Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutRe: illegal shoreline work � o� 0 0 C ITY of ORONO �`,, , . � MunicipalOffices G Street Address: Mailing Address: �`9�fEgK04'� 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 July 8, 2009 Sandra Fenske Cole 2959 Lakeshore Avenue MEDINA MN 55359 Dear Ms Cole: In 2008 the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District issued you a permit to have Hawkins Tree and Landscape install riprap at 309� North Shore Drive. We have obtained a copy of the permit plans. Based on these plans and old photographs we have determined that the work Hawkins did went beyond the scope of the permit and violates City code: 1. An area was excavated for a"beach" and a retaining wall was placed at the back of this area. Any excavation within 75 feet of the lake requires a land alteration permit. If more than 10 cubic yards are excavated a conditional use permit is also required. A conditional use permit is required for retaining walls within 75 feet of the lake. Such permits are customarily granted only when the walls are necessary to maintain a steep slope or existing walls are failing and re-grading to eliminate the need for the walls is � unreasonable. ,�-' , � �r�� 2. Lakeshore stairs were installed. A permit is required for lakeshore stairs and the property �� U� is limited to one set no more than four feet wide. ,�� � 3. Riprap was placed at an elevation higher than 933.5. Because of the size of the rocks and `~^ , rt-,� • , �.:,. „,...}:�� _F�,_ , ..; • a a r � ' tt1:: �1��eiil;'� Ui ili�2i iliaicliizi `liii� Yvi�ivii vi Ut�, i;1iPa�'i i3 i,vii�lu�i�u i�i COVET 2i.� iS T'iGt permitted within 75 feet of the lake. By August 31, 2009, you need to bring the property into compliance with City Code by: 1. Either removing the retaining wall to the rear of the beach area and restoring the slope or obtaining a conditional use permit. More information about the conditional use permit application process can found under Permits and Licenses at the City's website (www.ci.orono.mn.us). A land alteration permit is required for either option. This is a general permit. Information about this permit can also be found under permits and licenses at the City's website. Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us Sandra Fenske Cole July 8, 2009 Page 2 2. Obtaining a permit for a set of lakeshore stairs and removing/altering the existing stairs to comply with the permit. This is a general permit. 3. Removing riprap placed higher than 933.5. If you have any questions about this feel free to contact me. At about this same time a new access from North Shore Drive was created for the property. Since North Shore Drive is a county road a permit is required from the Hennepin County Transportation Department. Tney indicate there were some preliminary ciiscussion but no permit was issued. You should contact them at 612-596-0300. Sincerely � Evelyn Turner City Planner 952-249-4623 eturner@ci.orono.mn.us Certified letter number 7002 0510 001 6306 0902 (also sent by regular mail) cc: Hawkins Tree and Landscaping Hennepin County Transportation Department ,-, --, n i��" ��� � �" i: ,, � ! + r /^� ` f ^ ,,��.� � , ��� 1 ��-� �-�=t� N�-�,��t��, ;�� - �` . � � �� -� ; ,r _ ; �;:, � .,,;��i - , � (� � :��:�� - _�.� c;�. ��., , , � � �l c: � � r�> -� , = �,� c Ew'` L �o� o ,, o � - CITY of ORONO ,r � �������<•�``; � � �� �:�� � ,.� �ti M�,;�,� otr�� � i�������� G � � �,,�,� �;�� Street Address: Mailing Address: 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 Mike Hawkins Hawkins Tree and Landscaping 1776 Canterbury Road South Shakopee, MN 55379 Re: 3095 North Shore Drive— Illegal Shoreline Work Dear Mr. Hawkins: It has come to the attention of the City that you are responsible for work conducted near the lakeshore at 3095 North Shore Drive in Orono; work which was done without the necessary City approvals. Specifically, in relation to a rip-rap project permitted by the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District, a terraced "beach" area was excavated landward from the shoreline and a retaining wall was installed behind that area. Additionally, a stairway was installed in the rip-rap and two additional stairways were installed within the retaining wall system. The terracing, retaining wall, and the second and third stairways require City of Orono zoning approvals (conditional use and variance approvals) and are beyond the scope of the MCWD permitting authority. City Code allows only one stairway within the 0-75' lakeshore setback zone; permits are required to install stairways. Retaining walls in that zone require a conditional use permit. The retaining walls and extended rip-rap constitute hardcover in the 0-75' zone where no walls or hardcover are normally allowed. The property owner was notified of this issue in July 2009 per the attached letter, and you were copied on that letter. The owner has indicated that you have not responded to their phone calls, and has requested that the City contact you to encourage you to initiate the appropriate action to gain the necessary approvals, or bring the property back into compliance by removing the retaining walls and stairways and restoring the shoreline in those areas to match the remaining rip-rapped area. Please contact me at 952.249.4627 or by email at mcurtis@ci.orono.mn.us to discuss this • issue. We understand the property is being sold and this matter needs to be resolved as soon as possible. Sincerely, CITY OF ORONO Melanie Curtis Planning & Zoning Coordinator c: Randy Cole Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us � � � %� 0�\\\ � � 11�' �v �% O O�� '; � ,�,�� j�.� �,'I CITY of ORONO � �� `�,� �Ft�� ;�`���� �."� ,�,l� � Municipal Ot'fices � �' ' ����� .�e.� \� � ����, .ryG/ Street Address: � MailinQ Address: �\�EgHO�� 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box_66 ��=f� Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 July 8, 2009 Sandra Fenske Cole 2959 Lalceshore Avenue MEDINA MN 55359 Dear Ms Cole: In 2008 the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District issued you a permit to have Hawkins Tree and Landscape install riprap at 3095 North Shore Drive. We have obtained a copy of the permit plans. Based on these plans and old photographs we have determined that the work Hawkins did went beyond the scope of the permit and violates City code: 1. An area was excavated for a"beach"and a retaining wa11 was placed at the back of this area. Any excavation within 75 feet of the lake requires a land alteration permit. If more than 10 cubic yards are excavated a conditional use permit is also required. A conditional use permit is required for retaining walis within 75 feet of the lake. Such permits are customarily granted only when the walls are necessary to maintain a steep slope or existing walls are failing and re-grading to eliminate the need for the walls is unreasonable. 2. Lakeshore stairs were installed. A permit is required for lakeshore stairs and the property is limited to one set no more than four feet wide. 3. Riprap was placed at an elevation higher than 933.5. Because of the size of the rocks and the presence of filter material this portion of the riprap is considered hardcover and is not permitted within 75 feet of the lake. By August 31, 2009, you need to bring the property into compliance with City Code by: 1. Either removing the retaining wall to the rear of the beach area and restoring the slope or obta.ining a conditional use permit. More information about the conditional use permit application process can found under Permits and Licenses at the City's website (www.ci.orono.mn.us). A land alteration permit is required for either option. This is a general permit. Information about this permit can also be found under permits and licenses at the City's website. Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us �, . r ' Sandra Fenske Cole July 8, 2009 Page 2 2. Obtaining a permit for a set of lakeshor.e stairs and removing/altering the existing stairs to comply with the permit. This is a general permit. 3. Removing riprap placed higher than 933.5. If you have any questions about this feel free to contact me. At about this same time a new access from North Shore Drive was created for the property. Since North Shore Drive is a county road a permit is required from the Hennepin County Transportation Department. They indicate there were some preliminary discussion but no permit was issued. You should contact them at 612-596-0300. Sincerely � Evelyn Turner City Planner 952-249-4623 etumer@c i.orono.mn.us Certified letter number 7002 0510 001 6306 0902 � (also sent by regular mail) cc:Hawkins Tree and Landscaping Hennepin County Transportation Department FEB-25-2008 10�18 P.03iO3 . Permit# - 3� Sandbianket Permit and Sand Source Exhibit Form FAST TRACK PERMIT MINNEHAHA CREEK WATERSHED DISTRICT (MCWD� 18202 MINNETONKA 6LVD. Ph: 952-471-0590 DEEPHAVEN, MN 55391 Fax: 852-471-0682 . I, �Y1►'Yill/a �C�.2`�side at 3Qq� lUt�,-��•���r,�- �i- ,� (Pro�y�r� �a �i g� (Add�ess) (C tY) �Iv .� '�57 request approval to install a sandbianket on property described (State,Zip) hone) as .3c_'7�5 l�b���� � -� ���, �ocated i� _ Oron n , (SAeel eddless) (Wdhin the City bounderiee) (Caun on _ Lc�,�(t ��r,r�a�U - (Properly ID#[PIDt�J) (Lake) ( y) � hBVB Gpntr"dC�Wlth (Name of Compeny (Streetaddress) - to instalt clean sand from the (City, e,2i � (Phon foll�nring soun� M,� pPlier) i , � �„' �] � (Phone) I wil) install the sandblanket from the following source , (suppllen , , U (Address) (Clty,State,Zip) (Phona) My shoreline is�feet and the dimensions of the proposed sandblanket are: �_X ' -�� � (Length) �De�hj X�,. Sandblanket dimensions cannot exceed a length of 50' (or 50°�of shoreline), a width of 10' and a depth of 6'. If this project requires municipal approval or �eview, please attach dvcumenta�on of the municipal app�oval with this application. I understand that if this application is not completely filled out, or if I fail to submit the required exhibits, the application is incomplete and will be retumed. It will not be reviewed by MCWD staff until complete. By � signing this application, I agree and understand that the District may ent�r the property at reasonable hours to conduct an inspection to determine whether the terms of the pennit are being met. 1 further understand that if I violate the terms and conditions of the permit that is issued based upon this applicati�, the District shall conduct a field inspection of the project per MCWQ Rule J, provided with this application. I understand the District will charge fees to cove� the actual costs of field inspections, including investigation of the area affected by the v�rork, analysis of the work, including the services of legal counsel and enginee�s, and a�y subsec�uent monitoring of the work. The District's actual costs are deerned to begin accruing when the District issue�nakice of the tion to rmittee. I have read and understand the MCWD Technic2l Guidelines for sa la ' � ( ature of P rty bscribed and m to re me on this�_day of 20�. • �'� �,J ry �� � i� I`� , �'� � "�7 r� r-� i �� � �` ��• ' �1��_ � /i,, Approved by: . � � . TI"ITl11 D ri1T b g-o3to _ \ . i / , i � � � i % /� �, ;���,, / / , " : ,`� � �, / �� � �� , � /�/ � J��, , � �i , / � , �� � � �� / � / �'�� /�' ,','�,r�"�'sf' � � �,�' ;,' �i: �,�. \ �_ / �.� � , ', ..� . �� _,�� Q , �. �' ' i'�x � �, ,��, ,�� � � ..� .�'�, ;i.'/' o `�1. ' •' . '. �' .� ,/,�' �, ``` �M ; / ,�/j'��. ` " ---------*'°"_ ��,,�' . '� ! � / ��,,/;� '�� ���% / 1 �" ' , �' � I- ---------------=�--PROPOSED BEACH AND . TO OHW �v� �� �' � i' RIP—RAP AREA 13.3 �d� •� � �� � -�.t�r �' /,� 13.1 .-. / 13.2 ��/���� q,� '`aioau� unx�r 73.2 � '' �/ � /• . / 13.1 .�� � . � . �. �, . . 13.2 ' �'�o,d'���� ��a, . ' /� ��',��. . /. ------ ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------------------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------- ---------= TY I C A Ll S E C 10 N �P oF BA K-� SCALE 1�=1" ------ ---------- ---------- -----------I--------------------------------- ---------- --- - -- - -- ----�--- ----- ---------- ---- - -- - -- ----- --------------------------- ---------- ---—----- ---------- - � SLO NOT TO E CEED 3:1 � �` i -- - -------- ---------- ----- ---- ---------------------- - ----- --- ---------- ---------- -------- - --- GRANU AR FlLTER GEOTEXTILE FABRIC MATERI L MN OT MnDOT 37 OK EQUIV. 3801.6 OR � ON EXISTIN GRADE ( .) EQUIV. (TYP.) I � li'; � G :4 { i '. I f::5; , """ "'_'_"__ __'__"_"' "'___"'_ _'__"_"_i'_"_'____ '_'_______ '_"_"'__ "'_____'_"_'_'___i�. --g�9hr-r . 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 ``�` '` ,, ,. ,, . � � � . ` rj ` t�,.��� ;� ,� , � . � ' fL,: r � . g`i`� t� f., . � ; ,P �4 ,�.. � Y�� ,r �, 1 #y✓ `A I� 1 . �li � ��� ,.1� �'� � �Y ;'*,..Y� .�.. 1�.. ��a I "� � . n i�, K �. ���. �� tl'+;� r�1 �} � r . ' y � a ; . .� � � �: � �r � � r._ ,�;- 3 � '�'- " �',: /y�' }` ;� Qj � �y � �' 'R"�'�,� :1�, . / '✓,'b�.,f � i,j�', . ..X' 3?. '.k��'y ,7. . �i. , .�� .� �}t1:'� _ � �i, k��',� I MV �M�p'y' yy y� j f� I i `4 µ�y `U+` .. . . . . r���� ., � � . . i w J ` I�i'I fi P �-�:.y,,,,,es.x R"�� � , ���� /+'t ' � . � } � � . e,_ r'.g� ..� ��, �.+�e�t� ' t � ".^! 1-1' �n. �' �� � ��, f. # 4,d. � ' � ���.. � i .s'a � , . � � �� .� � �� o ; � _ Y�,A � `„ .� -� � , ,g', z ° ;�- � �` :� ��� � ` �: � � .� 3� �. + `;�' tia Y��+ �t •� a � ' ' � � ,. �� � �� 1 � � � � ,�, � � .,t• �, � 4 � M ' NI 4 � { A �� �,I ,�.�` � �i' � i' �- s�y x � � � ,�' - � i� . � , � � � . ., ,. . � r4 ' _t . 'r ., .. : �„. ' �. ' , �, "` _ k �:. y'— x �W� , . A:� ' f ����� �I �a. _ M+�„__�...r�.� ` � '� �r . �`� ��.�� �" ��x . , �, '+�t�"'�"'Sc � '" �, �` ��' ,� . �j• Q '4: �'71a -�,�_ �y ' .�' ','1 +� `'f»�„' ; ��� �� X� �; �JF � y��,�, �' ,� �..�;� '� . �$�4 �. � � V':y�r'? , , �t` �' rt t(-' �1 g �^,� , � � - � .� _ .,. �. . r � . , . . � ,� � � .�, �� �� � y ��� l�,� r`� �i1 Y� . � � { ' '�'. -Kr r � F . Y � �t -�``.ti.:- . �''. � � e4 .`j'�'�'�`y„1� 4a�,� • , � �` . ���A .�9 .. � �* ��a �� ��{��� y �r� y ,� +7, �� '� .� •.�s ' ' i � � ���` •,��'� f ` � it''�S:' , �� r � 1, i •"� y w..'.+<� rl':, rt' ,, r ",�- �. 1 � '. f�, ,� � �-' �' . . ., :., „ . ��i� � { ��. � ., � �",� . ; . '�� , �; i 'o� ��., .. . . r r, � � � ,� � . - , � ^ � I, ,r yµ �r. r, i� 1f�:. �.,.�Y ���.� � � ..� . �.A �# �� « ,i. �i . �• t '.�, i � ma. � � �3. � k . , :� � ,�• w.�k, Y;� , ,�. . �. � � � � j� t � � � I � � :, � � >'�j , ,�; �-�'� .fr ,� y -��,.. � � ,"�' � ��-,�;,,� '�c`� �� �. �'� �<'� , � �.., . .�. • -� � .�:. . � . �.. � -� , , , ` � �,.. ��» .�.�� . , �;; . , - , . c,: . ,, �z� x� . � '` �� �y�� £� � '4 � � ��, � r, ,U , ,� ��� � . � ' , � . . _ . � . ��"� � � � � �; �'. ,�' �f � �� �° u,�i } .. � �o� ,.� � , ,- �, t �� ,��� . *, ,t , h�, I s` *,� � � � �� ' �" , � r � �.• � �� � � �..,-'�� � � ��� �� <`�� ,`.� .r, �'��"�uo� I�� � ..g ._ • '� _q � :,. . � � r �q�, �}. ', . w�e � � y �,4.+� , 8�� ;.F � f�� . '� . �'!�'' r 1. 4 8` i .c�►� ��%`ur�v.� " .�w�•., �,�,. �' + z� � .... '"�7�.. ! _ .`y � ,��� �� � ; � � e '��� % � ��. � '� �«'"�G��` ���3 .��' , c � •� � ��+, ' ' �,µ^�" a� �I I . . t .+t�' ; �' {�ai.�.�.:,y'Y������ K � M �r -::;��r`� � �:���. �.�'M�'��I � � � ir _ p� T. �Mf .,�x:ss 4.. fy� ' � �'�"� ., .. ,� �"�.,,Y'� �, L + r' _ , M � � T � ; , _ ' y 1 �k � ��� r; ' � i �� n ' .�� . � q s� � � h^ [��`a '� ��r�' tl . 'y IIWih -y .41. ' �..f S 4� �t�r'�,+� i ..:� „f� �,d�� r� ,4 � si� ,�. 4�^ �'"I� irm�.'S+�, . . +� � ' s �e � ' i « f� ��T+f . . � . � ll�cy,�n � 4 �d� �': . \ � ,x�� i �5 �I �+�'o I I 'w2S�Y � Y • ��� ��I� ;I �..,�. �-�'�'#� . � �� �� ���.y�.. X. . i � ,i��"q���F�� . .�t 'Iw 4 � . � p �' f �' � ,i . . f y�T .' ,. �:, �. . r g ,�F ' g�r�'.'!!N.{� _ ' t �. 4� � i�� • � ' 4 J�� �' ` + -� a. �`_� ,�.. , .. '" .e' i ;� � �� � ' 4: � _ :#� �,�.a�e��� f� w�p �� r��� � -. , " � , � `� '' M ,�. ,;'; . �; �s�� � � "� j{�, ( , tY ' �4, '�� •..���'R �[�'�, . � ry ,f,,:� ,.�>> ��" � �'� ��.+�� ���f4A. ��� . e�"; ,_� � � � „' ' '��� jf���� ,����.� _�.,. ¢ s� . � �, :.� . � J ,..�. d�,. � �s� a�', .� � ;-. ;� � �`° ,"r;:� �, �:� a�, � � '� �� �.�� ?"Y� �s � ���� �; :,� _y "� � "�~ ��,��`"�����1{y"1��.[�� �� � � � :.� ' ��� � -'.d �� •b� ,��� ��.. l �" SF,�x �., � '�rt�� .1 � �,�`! 9� ry���� £I I;I.+�1 � -� � � � r � 7 Y � • � r , I � y � � Y" � r . �y � � :i '`*S� ��s]�Y�. �� i�l+ ! ','� �'S� �'. ' ...` , .��'� � �.x.� � �" '`r`� � �� � �'� t' � rs 2 , �: ��� w ;,� r �� _ � � � � � , .G � � � .��: ' � ,�;� y ..-�,�" _ , . .r� � . ,� �� .. .. � . � -.� J,� � . . �, �, , .,�� �� �� y` . : : I� � � �. ,, �_ �- ( t� � , ' 't ' � ^�1..' �,��,;, �'t,��, � ` s� .� >� � �� t° �: .y,,, '�:;�"�.� . "'. ,_� a� � . , � � I � °�� � � y�'^,� �� �. tw�'„ - " ��• �� '� �fi ' �r � �i F " ��rs� ��,�, r� fi � ' �r� � , . ' ' �*a , 'f r�,. � ;:�� �� . � 4 � ' e��`� ����~r� :*3 +;F '� #��� { ,.r . ;' � „ y � ...,' �'���,a�� y��.. ' � .. � , . ! ` I Y� :�� i ' �� �� �� g t` '1'�. 1. •s �,F �'� '1 v.i �. 4 f �wtt ` y�.:i ` � ���. � l.�y���. .. C • �, � .. �. T� k , .T„ �. '8 C 1 {i. ;' d» � ic ti��riJ[��Y.� � f�i11:.... .�LL � _ 1 ..} s �5���.4 3 rl � y �'r.• g� { �._ ' ,?��- ��ia•E Is��' .�� �'� ��` j +�: � ' � , ��j� ��.. - :�, +� �� � . -� �� � .�,� ', � �F � h� `,� ' �,�', �i �` _ �:� � ,, '� . � _ �� I� L. F�,,# �.' �` � � •�'�'YYy `/ �I � ��1F *4 � `�` !'� � l� ' " F� { }'��'� �4 `� •�( T i '�` k 1 vi c���i �r , ;y � � $.'_�� � � � .,..: �. 1 I' ,i� �y,�y.�^�,�,��Y: , ���,� ...,�� ��+� t:�? M �} �mT \ I � � �� � � �} � ��M� �T`. �f, � ' �.�,'! 0. 9n ,wk` } � `` ° _ t`d .. � S .. .`� M i� • . '. Y ��, i� I : £ .. a 0. r. ��� ,� 1�a ��� ' }, �. t y �.t �I ,�; : �, ��r�t.,�,��, � , �, � �k '�,� � ' �'.�'^ .= ,�.��,, -; �,;. � �, `.;, ,,' + ; t `. :��,e � � •,, � 4� r �, �� �ir "°� ,�' �.. � ; . , ' „, p. , ;:,��" t y '��.`� %. . d'j .�'6yl� ,� 'r' '.�w ,+ y�. ."' + ..�, "`.' }' ,� � ��S iP� } �;� ',,a^�} " � •g , �►=,, ;, � , � � � , . � � -� r_-.� �' ' � � � y��"�{`+ '- M,��. `{�fp t °"'� � .+t� • , �3. �i i � , erti ',��a . . ��' I � � . - �� '� w �a�� '"�i, . ;. `"V;� y .�. ,% � � ,i ;,�,' ��` I, t"��,� .� "� � � � j �� 'f� i I t i a r- ����� sr4�,< -� • � ^ �� � ' �. , �`'''� /. -� a. . � V �t�� ��E' _j 1�.� �i ,,�.s,� a�;,. � l�,� �` - ; . � � - w ,� ' �'�ry y ` 1 . 1 r _ =�. , . : �y �t �w" ,�� �. �,� � ,�'���°r ��,..�. _ ��`� � f.. � � , ' �.. P .'9. i�_ �' .-�.,Y ' �. �..x ��� V " �. r i - �"{'�' 'Y`✓; i` �4� � :f� � �w.. '<�� ,ry -�,� ��,. y '{�,� �., � ,� � ,l�� ��j' �z I ���''r � �I } #• ii�l�.. . . 'a. � � � � ��'�'... r.at�, �' ,. �,+ - . �.�.' 1 I I � � �� � � � � �� �' '%�. �� �� y "'t�.�� .��"' ����� s�r� �y, ' ^.;,� . . ,�!� ►� �.� � ��� � ' .�' " � t }���Q�.,�'� P.'::. �•1 �� ` y �, � Y .� ,;� r ,��k, ' �f 4 Y � .;;,� � ` , •x Y� t� �}i " �. '�� # t"�j,rj p.�M�j fi � "� . ' � ���( . '"�� '�� ,� �'`� � Y t! �'�A . � _�.� • ��i r� F #! �� .`�{�5,.._ � ,Y 'x. t' ��yr � j )Y��� �. �� i �� �I .�.+���'� ���: � �� �� ���. ,��`i'. . r � S: �S • , 'n 1 � .-� .' : 4 � �� � � ��. , � �- �'' ' . �a�` . � � ` M � .� � � � ,��,,,�� - � �� .-:� . ^'t�,� ,�,,-� :s� '�} . :µ .,� �' • � '� � ��� t � .r i� � � � �i s .� I n •y.. ,.f . � �Y�:i. , ` i�; � I Yt.f�` r.� I �k�,l `t �*,�f. _ � � t ! Il�i�l 'tl i � � �14 * . . .. ' �� ,��t ���. ( f .� t / .:� ' ���� '� , '�}� � �(, .. i� � r� �� � � v��V.��f � �� } �. � r� �,� rH F �„ #. � ''�� � , i �. �;� t.�� +;"'" �x, �'� , 1 ' ,,��, x � I � IF� � r✓; +�� + �,,; 1 � �` �� � t i.,., y•��'' � � �' 1 �� �°�� i � � a' � �`` �,-, I. ` � :: , � �`, k a �t� f F d.. i . ,. �a�'..��',,: `� � �/ z � �@�,.t .� . . . � (; d�; � • � '�«� *, '� � N k. . . , . . , y ,� :; �, , . " ,��� � # a. ' �t.. � � � a' � � 'f� 'F� 't��' � �- � �� -?"� �`�� � � � r . �y,.t ' �. k , �� �' �l �' � y. - I .�' ��� .�, ,�� �`�._ �°f'�. � . , r . �.�� '� �� ... .. *� � ('�`�� rr` .. ,. 4 •� •�'1� �'"1�i' � ��� �� � . +�11. ` k: ' .��� .r �'f, . '� :a .� , 4 �*C° �,.1� f.Y� f I"�`� 3. � `4,�;x� � . t i � � � •� f� ��� ,` �t #^� . ,��. '��� s��...�„ r� : '.;� .y . .�� �... � � ,� { :: „ �' ' ., ,_ �k: tt� �� Y ��_ .. .� �.� ai : . ��r : . . , . rt...�;. ' . - � ., �� . . ' ' ..«,.,,�.:» � r .�i .. .. �� . . �'� . '� �N 3�"" ;,. � ������ a �k.��� - � � .�• `K-'�-r �� �3� ' ���. _�, •. . �� ,r,_::.. � M , , � a' * . ..x .,. , , � .. .r�� J ._. �.. r *� + � . � � ,3� �' � �� r�:. r . ' , 4_�� � •,` t S (' + i .. �`i"-. �•✓ � \� ,�' � � � k ;�;. p.'. n i Z.r k'.. � .� � � .,,�'. g- ��� .� � � . . � � �� ;F !t F 1� - + '- � + .. � . :P4�. r . u J, y . � , __ _ � t k -^ w, , . � ��1 . , � � � � ��'�,r,. � .�'. � ;. .� ;a� � , , ,3._ �� ��'� � �����i�� � �� � � ��, a�� ��` "f�itl � '`� �,��.� �- �,i � �� �, �� �� j� t' �,� �= i , � � y � �� .,�� � �r ; ,� � , '�4 �" _ +�' + I�1' . E a°� . �,r r��� ..� �- �, .. 6*'� 'r � 1" � ; ,x+ � , �'' .. � .' - � ��k�� �.�,, ._..�, .... � , > �4� a. �.�,"�, _ CI� � � MP� �'"'�'r� �' � ;� W } .�i � 4 ,�� � � ,�` � � ���• �R �� �._ ' �� '. ,� �,.. } '!" �"�4a` �xF �T.�,',1 f .-f �yaF, '�.- }�� � 6t � N� Fi - Y $t r' . ^,�^ , ,s.1,� ,� . ,,�—..:Y � � � . � � '� i, t � , � ��a " .,,��� ,, i � .' � ��°� '� �, .�«��� � � �� t' � �� '�� � .. A �� 1 :� �k, � � �.� :, � . �� � � � 4 w, _ � :�'` , . �'° _ ., �" . �� : .. k� ����� � ��, �,, . �, . � � � t . ��� " yqw� „�. ,,,, � .� '�,�c'7F ������N�j� 'x"� +�r ?.t'.. ��� 1 f y4��`'{� �T� ��" �., .:r- �'t I�y y A F '� "k.� J� �'��` -g�.!� '' � Y � ..� pu' +t. � �,� '�v,�' a� , ,s " .1 : '� �.,4 � '�' ,r,� � t � .�. l , �� ..� � �` � .� ` . ; � ,„! r � t���� . �! . � � � .. ±� .. x . `�;_� . �F"' y * ::t' t V� �...�. . .�` `+ ^�� `r�., . 4� .�, . ..,� .. � ., �� _.�� j., ... �: ` � �* <� }� +'� �'A�i� ✓ �,,. fiv� f � �� "`�1 ;�, t� � ,� .' � � t' � ,�;y �• .� � E ��,t�vi�"'�'y<.� �� ��: �' t"� ��� '�L<.� � �.� :r��- � '�` �" z�.:, . � ' � t� • � � h�; _ .+_t`�` +�. � � n � ,� �� �...; � � ^ , 3 ln � � �t � Fi` .� '; � "yy;.. � p� �,..i ti� � „�.��y� . �.g9'�' � �,, p� ��Y ! ..�.�' �--� rt.. .. . , :, ,.�_ M ?�' a�S`.�� ' � .. �,,,i . •� < ��" �� � f , Y;* — .� � � ��. _� . rw � �F . � , �� ..! ♦ :� � ,:�. �"S. ` _ y' � '�, n,L�N� �+�°'� Vl°s�`�'.j". Y�4. " - _. v. �� � �` �, :,ac.,' �r} � _ _. . Y -----�-... s�m�,v ., � 1. . � .._ . ...�. ..�..r . , `��+as;._���-� � � � ' - � :�OM'�.-� � �#-"^.Afw"'" , .,g, .�s ya � '^4�`'. +,*�,r,;��..'?"'u�. �'�� �`�„�..1' �#.�isl�c�i,w✓ �� ' ��.'l �.��,. 1` � �4� ��.._._. . i.� �'�-.��"' ! ._, -�.�'„%�"�,,,� �.-V.",�!`�`.:_ Y��-.t � y"`. '`��"„'S. - � r...'�.. " ;�_. i� `k... . -_..o.� . �y 'f . � -�.j` ��.,,, x �� �_ , � ' ; . - �' �. � . : _v -t F.: t o- ► �. �;,� ! } �, tt ���. � . 1 " ---_ .. . _ . � M 1 � _--.... . _..__� - „'��_ � .... _" . . . . � i �� �yz:--,���+-'-----'.,.- _....„.., . . .' r � �N�-. �'__ �_ �rh:...i�. .. . . . �.. �`��.f{t ` ��f,9���� ''.�`�. � - . _ -. � �� - �. - .� .. a���� . '<�� ...:5(n..�yrt) � . _ _.� �� - �..,.. _ � '�m.. ... . � ---"' �.. . ' �'�"�'..� �.1�+4ri� ' h Y' .,'�"u Y�Y��.2'�n� �.- _ �_ _'�--_ ��� �_ �� � �R ��.�.�':#7' �f_ ' as. .... :v#+.c: �.. ...- TAPfrx�� "�' "�+nlri��_' �__ .. --'�_. �i�" �� -^X SMR� .... � ...�.-+_ _ _,.... - _. _ . . .�.. R .. ...._ _ � y_ _._ — ' ��. �.�;, ...�... _ �� 4. . .�.� �.�^n�-•-'-_. ��r�-��r .�� '.1 ,_..._ x . . ._ �— :' � f _ ..�.-�1 � . _ .�1�► a . . Ys . • . ,_ _ �� ...�. �a �.. � r -- j.,.. '�i w ', . . "_-i-n �' .. . � � �y �� , � �r'dl� _. _. K_ _. _ � �'' - �. _ _*�s.._:�" _ -= ,� � � - �. =,3 '_'__ .�-c. _ . . ". , - . � -- � � . -; ,„. � t � . '� �r.� � �' �._ . .-� • ..� - .., _, s :;�r .. I _�-- , r. .--� _ -. -- . �--_- '�' ._..c- - -��_. ,. .._- .. _ r . �-, � .�- -• - � � Y���_- ;s _,c4,�.-'�_ � Dv' � �T,t�ly- ♦ i +� ��.. y ��"��,�,��u..� - +�V 'i. Y �" . %(�` r +... '$r. �' �. :� �A �n���,� il �1�� �� ..� ' (�, . 4 � µ � � � �.�„�..� .»� � � lY-/.�. �"jy�f3 °^' �?t`�`� •. �,A _r � '� ����`u' p '' ��,� �;t � r � . � 4 t � ' �i ' py'��,*,, � +;�C� ��,� ���p�.%. '�� rt ��,. �, J;� ,r V�� r��"l��� ..�5 ":r a '`���n r� �/`'!7i+- ds�.. ,� A.s Y 1�, r - „1Y sf�:. .� .�', t j� . . � . ` -" �� ,4� �.v �� � ��.:: -� ' �� � ...v^;�,� � � t . , � ....: � ���Y � �,�%�,ar `� . ,y , _ , � �S ..:+�'` S � ��' y^s.��Jd���"� _�.�� .r. yW� ��_ r�.. � `� .� ��r.. '6 t�� �.�1 ��.}�__��,�h _ � .'�, rs�. ,�� s, +__� >- �rm� f � .£8 �e!r . _. „ � � � '.g-'3_�'� '�3 � ', ,,r �.�'� �,a��_sw �, - � w� , ` �. -- �� �t'� �,� e - _,... �`�t ' ,� � .. � ! :,.� _ ,�.� - � �� �. � _ t ' .`, �.,� � . '—� . � ,. � . _.. __ ,�.s, . . . . -- �—.,��.. , --- ' �t '�— �.- . ,�� y.;:��, ., � 5, _.� � ��. __' '_ ""-� ' ... .. .� ,�■ � / `: . Dl-'- . �r� .,:y,��, �. . , , a .;:�_ �?W,, I�� — �� --..;.�.,��i1�-� �.-�d�� Y � � ,� �..,,, - _ � � . . - � ,rs �`: �..: � �' �.�.,.�, r;: _ �. ,, .y.�' , �,,,-. , ,:,� ,. _ ,. . $� w.- �.n?.A:.+';�� �f' , .�+:, • � �i.Tt'1!'k'wi .... __ — ", ,-.. y n _ �, . t � �`, . �,j . � . l ,� . _� - - � � �. _ :� ..�, �--.� .�=r= . .� -- . , _ �, , . , . _ � �'.�». ♦. _�� ; „r :� � � � � -� , _y,,{�� � _a � � !^' . �r� , �i �. . , , _ - � �'--� �. `y, i,� _ :- '- ' �_:__ - _ ��'itJ� { �� ��� � , r ��s - _.�.' � _ � - s'q _ �.��' ��, - ..... — � ,�,, ��,.. _ _ �.. _ ��o �� � .� . d- - -- - , �-,'.. - _.._ � ...�-: .._,,,,,,� - __ � :_� - l � . _.� �_ � � - � s _,, � _ --- _ r-� _ e � — _� - +�� � - - - = : - - �... ��,,.�.. - ----�_., z �. Y.� _ ';� -�,�„ _ �__ _ �_ y��`. -� �', � � i —e.�. ..-- �.__� �v_; ' -� _ -..�. .� ' �� , .�...�.��. I ,�I� ,� . a/.�� _ .. -- . ._. _ ., ��- .:�.-'_�"-5.�� — � =sir.w�.:.r..�- �'�`_�_ _-- __ �' '�f ��t- "�� "- - '-. `�=�—_. __. )� ' -- � __. ^ - � t`�,`.�,.._ �� 1�2 V �� No��r� � � , � ,, � �,r � A � . �w �'"�'�. 3,Y:P.;;,r.- - .:^""* a�.r ._�-�-il`.,��'"., � - � • _ � • � ; y� `. -v. . . � �'� ' ��, � r f � � �� - '� '� ��`� ;�; li -�. l�'�� _ ���' ,� � � r. .. `� '���� �- � , . . . _ ; . _ _ �- ` � s_-� � `� � � :, . .� . , _ _ .: , .,. , ; �.� . :�. _ � � . ,. �..� . . , , �: - - z , . _ _, . ,;_ _._ . ; . ;� - _ . �. . � ��. i��-�n��! ..� '. .*..: . ' k��im - . � � '- . - _ _)� �F _ � ». I " - � .�— --_. , `- ,. .. _ v„"_ -�"'_ _ ;� - -�- sF_- _ _ j � __ _ _ ,, � - "F—— � - ,._� �, --... � L= �►' -�-- - ?x: � ' �'�: y � � �•-a — ` . . ':�,t '. I�II, -� � � wu Y� �- � � �� . � '� , , .-� � x" , i� ,� ; .. . .. . . ..s��+�'d,� ",t+zur� t E�.i,+e .'. � �:,-q � LL.:.. 4 � 4�Ff� . � _ .w . � "�""w�''�'(' ,tw � .�� g ar . ) t ���"naynz- � � >oQ_ . � �..'rk..� ^�, ����}��-�y "�`1� `w�,.� ;�`�`�'�`,.µ �'o . �'-' � 'a � . .... .,_ .r.. ��'��*�.;,,,, ��Xe;` +uw M� �.�'i��"'' Z v � `,� �.rr ��. ��` . � Y +s�. v�k 9'S _..� s. . ` •�y,'ySK.:_: � ..,�,. � �..oV� �" � �,..'�+�i .. � , '��� �s�+.� .a..� -. ��V-���Y ..� ca ' . �, �`' �`�'�, . y :,.".9" .... ...= ` ��t_ � wR�. / ,y . : r' � � . _\��. .. '�. .���� � .. . � , . .�. ��'� -V�����_ ` .�`� �' . . . �. ... � � . --� ..,.�� �,.. �� . �.i ....,���� , ' #t' ` � :fi ✓ �F;� . . �+ , �. `� y i� .��.v � � 'r�- 9t'�. � � , -:,. .:t ..� . . .Y n . .y � � .. ..� . ' , .�..-� ..�.�� .. . �:-+� .. ,�..�„ � � . . '°`vK` + +.� , � �n �..a 3� . ,� •,°� .�..,��t�a�.. -. -—- ` _ _� , . ,,' �* � �',Y�"`'`� : , . � _ � ���� � . y � . - . ,;� ��� � t,] ��� � = `� �' ' _..� w;... tr. ti...;,�,� � � T ' 'vrrw,.. . . � , . . .. _� _.. ar�t6' . ,` � -.. .. ,�` � `_�"�"..... -. ��: � .. �� � .. �t�'S.,� �_, ' .:.za�o. . <� . . .. - ._ -�:�" �� � � ° . . -� c yr '-_ --�� . . . �.` � .. � , __ ._ . . -- - , _ i� _.ac,�... � .. . � ��� w..., - � .--�._ ..� _ _a,._ _ - . �; "'�, . '"y��. �.. ' _�.s.- ,. . _._ ..�:.,,�� .�ax..� ..� " '-a� .� . �- �. % , ... � . � . `-�� . _. _�. �, „e,-..�y.._"�t�. �. -. . ".„"'°'ce "G:• P.,,a�i..c�a- 74��+r'- . �--�-�rr . T_ ,_. .. . . _.e. � -�.-. -�.,�, . `.,. „ '��- ry � -:�Y144+uL..._... .--r..-x..c .K..aF�. -�.r ._..'_,_,,.m� �"^,�P . 'r S -T^---'�. '.�o,..� ,.:��. ,_ �� ��� � . ..... :- -„�. .'?c y �su�x.,... . _ �a.-,,,�.�..+T - .. . •�- , � ._ - . �- . -.d.kr'__:.."'�A"---'. "54�._�n. .�. � �-.z'`^' .,w+�c,u.�. .___�- --�— S� _ " �.�`... -.._.,"'�-�-:.'a.�,�-" ..�.nd-.......... • ---�""- "'�' . , ` ,.....�_ _ ....,,.:� ,. '..,, � __ ......�x _, .> ..._�-..� . . ._ -. �--.�. --.,..,.. -�__ . ... . . .�,�..,.. . ... .. , ... . '_'-n+..-.�.,..�,.,s .... .._ . _., - ,� - � -.. .. � .,... . ,.-.,,..'_. .- ...�_.-ar, �. . .,k.�.. .,.b„��� . _. _ -. ..� ..v..�' :�'_ , w _ ' ..� . �. ��� _„� . .:� �,..�.«�._. _._.'�--......�, .. :.-. _... e� ... �, ic.... '.,�� �.... _ . ._., „g ` - _ '« _ .�,-�+.�r,�rra., - .. . � .. ...._,,.-�. _ � ...-�.��. ;-.,.�v��., �...._ -:. � _, .. _.. . .�..,_: . . . -.. ___.-.--_m__._. ._:.�.�iiN.xa�-,� __-..�.......,: � - _.'_.___ ..,. ___.._-_. ���.._ ..�-"..'�,e. . S �.:._ ._ _ _ '._ .�. _.. .. ....... - . . . "' . . ._� -_',.. ... . _ M � - �Pw..�....�,. .' _.' ..,.__-�..�.. ^�.i, ��-�-�+�-.."_, � . , .� _.._ �_ '� . -+�..� �4"`^*'�-. ` __. - .« - � ._..-«_ . ��_. - -•--...... „� ����;?�'-=��rYl '� �� .._ '�m�..,+...w.r..rrT _ _...�.. --.�..�.�...,.._.__--.. . .. ... �c�/V 1.�� �O, '" \��„/• w��� �V1 I � � �` `�' ,� � j . � .. .._ < � : ,,,4:�. 'e : �:�.'!'a=.�a � � __ � _. , �"k �" ay''�+«'"�; _ . _ � p �? . '� � y ��� � �3' ' .. �,u �� � q��� � *" . A .� .aL.+� '_`� �f Tt.'Y�r';a; ' . ��k���� Rk8 �. .� � �V } S �.. ? '. YtS � ` ��� � � -� g �1 ��1' . . �.e�'.*sJ�"' tiu'•�'� ���-..�` p� . ,w.., �'aw�, �v � �_��- +`� ��„� � ,�^ � ~ � y r � ; \ _ ��.7j .��,a"- "a' . _ 's' �' '+�°���z�^d� � . . � �u _ �f E, t� - � . :�F� . � � ��'�F � a �, � > i�`,: _-� � �' '�� �� . �> ���it,. = a ; „ _ . �' � > , '_ -"'� � . i rry- ' � � � _ . . �t� - �,' R`�i .�- .... �.'�s Y..'i 'i►'�. 1 ' ,. h.� , W i�- 4. o- ».yl y ���.' ^•. ..a� '�►!'� .. � �y^wd+ � .. �r - � � i . = 'D� ' • Ls-- ib,� `s . `�.. ,� - �F' , � � � i , � r� �.r �;-::�..,,�,_�.c�.. -,.�, - : -- .__ � �- 4 .� �,` �-yr. � �� ., � . � ' �Y A� �� _ _ ` y�, •� y r~ . ... � -�,,.�„�`� _ �, ... _ . �y s. .. . ."' _ . y " . . y ,.�... .... ( _ .. .. _ J�'-�.�":1. ��"' `g�:� �� �:- "�}Yi" � r.. �... � . lg �a �'�� � �" ,�w'r. ��.�" ., . � �. 4 _ . .� .. j e�..�. W��Y.�7 Y� , ' ��'�. `� "�+� � . � _�ys .. . , �;, � a �'`r. - ' ' z; \ 11,Y ��� _ ,3 � � .s''It ` .�7""'. � `:' ' , � ' `_ -. ' . ,} _ � '�' `,�y ��� ' r! ` '- --� �— -� .. -_ , - .�,. --- 'E r ` ' - � --�—� � `= - � -.s - � _ � � �� � �� , � �. � � ,,,,._ � _ ` , ..."�„g'�"���' i . - �� - � ��. � ,-- . ' -;' --�--;� � - �.� :>�� - �c+r�: `�'��"��:- ""� —'� �� _ �„P -.� .�. ,�„�„ - ---� "' a��: ' � `-_"�"" �.�. ,=""'� - _- .+ �� �..,�s, +�. �.�. ---�.,.. --� _ , y ' � �.: �.::.._. :T - i „ �-_.� ,` � ----- �.�+,�.< _ .� r - - + _, �_ -� ,:�.. . —---� '�,,,,�„..r._ uaw.i► � _ --�'- - �'".:�"�>„_ _: „_��.. r �A, ��_ ,,.« � -+; ... � — . _ .__ -_... _ -' _. �,_ .�,..__.�_ .: - a; , ' , __ -.,....--,_--�-.xac -^-+....-m.�as. - . ��._. . _..:.. ,A.jF. '-,� �-:.. , -,�,ryu ...._ _.� „ , __. ..«:.._;:.,:�. . ..���.. �,.:�_,_�,...n.,,rc, -. . _ .. ;. ,�� '"T -- � . _ � � .. ��L. .. .-_....� ., ` . . . ,.-_-- . "'----^--._. •a : , -_ „t._r �_ . . _ , __ . c., _ ' _:.. ..�_ �- - ..-�.� r... H.. —�._. ._—.._.,�_._ � '—_. .. --- � .,.t., - ."'. �.: G.bw�,e.,;L ,Y,,. .._ -�.�. _--.�_ ' _'_'. . ...._._- .. . —�_ ..-�--•-.• ,u,•,:,.. '- __. ,�Ml'�i : ...A, _.__:.::-. -_"' 9kknP+�.r i�N��. - �tt .vr.� - � � � � _ � , q �w � ._.... -._ _ ,..,. ..�..�__ ._ �� .��. -_�. . , —.�.. - .., ;� ���.��„,;• �. ... ,...._._:.._. ... �.-„a__ .�_. _ ._ ...""�°"' -- _ ..�.. .... �n d. ""�... , . ��� I�Ot����� ��