HomeMy WebLinkAbout#5064-CUP-2003 - ��� .
O .��.�:> � O
�.;,�A .� C ITY of ORONO
�, �1������ ti �
�: �
, , U,,.�
� � �'� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNC L
� G
��� �� � �'� N O. `� ,(�;' „�� �=
kES80
A RESOLUTIO\ GR<�.�TING
� CONDITIOti�I. USE PER.itiIIT
FOR PLUt�IBING Lti :�r �CCESSORY' STRUCTliRE
PER NIli\ZCIP_-�L ZONI�G CODE
SECTIO\ 78-303, SLBDI��ISION (17)
FILE �03-?929
`VHEREAS, Jeffrey L. �iartineau and �Tzlissa L. Ottin�er, husband and w-ife,
(hereinafter "the applicants") are owners of the p�operty located at 2565 I�ortn Shore Drive�.�thin
the City of Orono (hereinafter "City") ar�d leQally described as:
Attached "EYhibit:�" (hereinafter "the property"); and
�VI-�EREAS,the applican�s have aYplied to the City for a condi«onal use permit per
Municipal Zonin�Code Section 7�-303, Subdi��i�ion(17)to allow plumbinQ i:lcluding a toilet,sink
and sho�ver to be installed in a proposed accessor� structure; and
`VHEREAS, after due pu�lished notice and mailed notice in accordance w-ith
Minnesota Statutes and the City of Orono Zoain� and Planning Codes, thz Orono Planning
Commission held a public hearing on Sepi�mber 1�,2003, at which times all persons desirina to be
heard cor.cerning this application�vere ���en the opportunity to speak thereon. y
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT' RESOL�"ED by the Citti,- Council of Orono,
Mir,nesota:
FI`DI\GS
l. This application�vas revie�.��ed as Zoning File �03-2929.
2. The property is located in t�e LR-1�ZoninQ District,where 2 u--res is the min�um
lot area. The properiy is approxirrately 1.47 acres in�oss area includinQ wetiands.
3. The Planning Commission revie�t-ed this application on September 1�, 2003 and on
a vote of 7-0 recommended approval of a CUP for plumbin� in the accessory
structure, based on the follo«�ina 5ndings:
Page 1 of 6
. ��1V'
O ��
0
»� CITY of OR4N0
� - �
������� ti
� � � ~' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
�L`9kEsil�g'�G NO. �' �s � �.
a. The proposed use of the accessory structure with p:�.�=nb:�� will not be
detrimzntal to the residential character of the neighbor'=ooc_
b. The plumbing fixtures proposed are in keepin�with t�: inr_uded use of the
accessory structure.
c. The property size and building location are sufficient to::Io�.=.�the conditional
use permit to be granted.
d. The CUP should be subj ect to the standard"Plumbinj in�cccssc�ry Structure"
conditions.
e. The installation of a kitchenette in the structure would��t b= appropriate as
that�vould make the building easily functional as a gue_.noL�e for which the
the property does not qualify.
f. The property can remain in compliance with the hardco�,-:;re�-.?irements ifthe
concurrent removals of driveway are completed as prc�:�sz�.
4. The City Council has considered this application includiLa tr� findings and
recommendations of the Planning Conunission,repons by Cir. �ta�. comments by
the applicants and the effect of the proposed conditional use ��rr�: on the health,
safety and welfare of the community.
5. The City Council finds that granting a conditional use permit :� al:��.;-plumbing in
the accessory structure will not be detrimental to the health,saf�.�or_eneral welfare
of the public, would not adversely affect light, air nor pose � �re :azard or other
danger to neighboring properties, nor w•ill its use depreciate :_rro�-�ding property
values and that the proposed level of use of the property will b= in���ping with the
intent and objectives of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive?:an �f the City.
Page 2 of 6
- �°�
0 0
���- CITY of ORONO
� : `�
•y�'`• l�
�� ' �� �'�' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
L�kESII�4'� NO. � � !� �
CONCLUSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS
Based upon one or more of the findings noted above,the Orono City Council hereby
�ants a conditional use permit per Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-303, Subdivision (17) to
allow plumbin�including a toilet,sink and shower to be installed in a proposed accessory structure,
per the site and building plans attached to this Resolution as Exhibit B and as annotated by City staff,
subject to the follotiving conditions:
l. The applicants by executing this resolution agree and covenant that the property will be
bound by the following conditions:
A) the accessory building will not be used for a home occupation unless specifically
approved by City or if allo�ved by City code;
B) the accessory building will not be used as a d�velling unless a guest house CUP is
obtained(site is not large enough to qualify);
C) the accessory building will not be rented, leased or otherwise provided for use as a
dwelling under any circumstances; and
D) the accessory building shall not be fitted with a kitchenette (kitchen sink, range or
refrigerator); and installation of such fiYtures in the future shall be considered a
violation of this approval.
2. The applicants shall remove excess driveway hardcover per the site plan attached as Exhibit
B so that the property remains in hardcover compliance.
3. Authorities granted by this resolution run with the property not with the applicants, but are
permissive only and must be esercised by obtaining a building permit for the new
construction within one year of the date of Council approval, or the variance�vill expire on
that date (October 27, 2004).
4. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this resolution shall
constitute a violation of the Zoning Code,shall automatically terminate any authority granted
herein, and shall be punishable as a misdemeanor.
5. The undersigned applicants have read, understood and hereby a�ee to the terms of this
resolution and on behalf of themselves, their heirs, successors and assi�s, hereby a�ee to
the recordin� of this resolution in the chain of title of the property.
Page 3 of 6
. �°� �
o �� �
� CITY of ORONO
,� .�. �
ti
��� �G~' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
�kESI30g' NO. � � � �
Adopted by the Orono City Council on this 27th day of October, 20��3.
ATTEST:
� , .. >
_� • / �(� ' ��
f�'/ '%�-- ,;I� f/� 4_L_.... �Ll.�lc'��.+i�.�'�{1...�,�-`�+C�„�:G��:fr.y�^,�j�i.
Linda S. Vee, City Clerk Barbaza A. Peterson, Afayor
//
./ ,! �,�/ . ; 1 �
�'`..�.-�-------' ' �-���C�l�" ..: ,�.� �I/�a t��._
= r p Dwner(s) -
i
\ I ` -'
`' . .�
Pa�e 4 of 6
- �°� .
0 0
� CITY of ORONO
� g • ,c\� �
N
��L �` �p~' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
`9kESI�Og' N0. � � `�'�' ��•
STATE OF 1��IIl�NESOTA
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN
�i
The fore�oing instrument was acknowled�ed before me on this 2�"lth day of October, 2003
by Barbara A. Peterson, Nlayor of the City of Orono, a Minnesota municipal corporation and said
instrument was executed on behalf of the City.
.� �. . � _.:< , ; ; .
�r� . -�,'i..c: l�_ �. ( � �- �' c .__-
f` : �� RACFiEL DQI?�'� ; �. , �" , �—
+, ; NOTARY PU6L,c-��„ - �-�, Notary Public �
a�f ca�,,;�„o�,rX,;,_..._ .
STATE OF i�iINNESOTA
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN
,:--j�:.. �
r ,
The fore�oinJ instrument was acknowledged before me on this-'��day of�_ r'��''A=`A' "-2003
by Linda S. Vee, City Clerk of the City of Orono, a Miruiesota municipal corporation and said
instrument was executed on behalf of the City.
�
, � . /. , '
:...
�:-�'" r l^r7" � \ ' .L..1. l�...- c_ . / i ,/
. �. '-����.a'��� ��. ��� '� �� ......�4 ,�''.� (
. � .. ? /�..._...--.
� ��1'��-���'�:� ' Notary Public \.
F!C`l.F�y I�U�:.IG-P:9;,,. -n
;,ip r_,�mmist;i:,r,Expires.1:�r, ...
Page 5 of 6
- �°�
o � o
CITY of ORON4
� ������ ti
��L � �� �G~' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
�kEs�I�4 NO. � `�i � �
STATE OF MINNESOTA
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN
This instrument was acicnowledged before me this ��F'r day ot � r�/,�;,._,; ,200 L�
by Jeffrey L. Martineau, husband of Melissa L. Ottinger. `' �
--.-._,._. _,..rt . ,..�.
_ ,,,
., ;
, Rp,�}dcL(�QI?�'� : .
��,�-���. :._ �.. �_ 1�c-��_;: � ,�.__.
� NOTARY PU^uLlC-N;" i^OTA
�.7yCc;�missio�F�cpireSJa;�.:;t,'�;;� TTOtaly PubI1C
. ....�.,..........w'�4.v�. .^�^r^�.--.�..
STATE OF MINNESOTA
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN
{�r
This instrument was acknowledaed before me this `�Ir�day ef .�-�_s�-� 2003
by Melissa L. Ottinger, wife of Jeffrey L. Martineau. �
-.;.r,,��::.' ,..1
,t. �ChiEL DOD�� '; f ' �{� �, ;,
NOTARYPUBUC-NUvh�iOTA ��� Cx.:-'`---t '" ` ��C��%'�'f�---''
� My Commission ExP��aD'`��''�`' Notary Public
_:... . - . _-�--�-----"""""':'�� .<-- .
Paje 6 of 6
EXHIBIT A � � � �
_ RESOLUTION NO.
LEGAL DESCRIPTION
IN GOVERNMENT LOTS 4 & 5, SECTION 9--117-23
HENNEPIN COUNTY, MINNESOTA :
DESCRIPTIO�I OF PP. ��4ISES
T r a c t_I: Thc Nortl:wcsterly 50 fect, troiil• and reas, of that part of
Govcrnme�it Lot 5, Section 9, Townsltip 117, Nor:li Fa:tge 23, �Yest oL the
Fifth Principal Meridian, descriUecl as follovis: Co�n�nencing zt a point
i:i the centcr line of County Road No. 51, �vhich point is 437.�} Iec: 1•'lest ut
a point in l•he Easl• line of Governmen! Lot 5, disl•ant 1, 260 fcet Sou:h of LhE
East 1/4 corner of said Section; thence Norlh�vesterly alang khe center 7.ine
o! said road a distancc of 53h.6 feet to thc t:uc point of bceinning of thc+
property beiu� descrit�ed; thence continuing [.'orl•hwesterly along the ce;lte:r-
line of said road to a poi»t 265.ZS faet Southaastcrly measured along thv
centerline of said roa'd from ite interscction .vitll tlte �Vest line of Gover:�r.�en!
Lot 5; tl�ence Soul•hwesterly witli an interior z1ig1C of 90° 41', a clistanc�: o!
435.7 feet, more or less, to a point�in the ti�lcst line oi said Covernment Lot
5, said poinE•bei�is 507 lee.t Soutlt o! thc isitcr::ection of said West linc with
the centerline•at saicl County Road, said poin: also Uein� on thc shore o(
Crystal Bay,�La]ce Minnetonl;a; thence Soutl�easterly alono said sho�eline to
its iutersection with a line drawii through l•h�; point of Ue�inning anci :orr.ning
an�(nterior angle of 8�k' 2q' with thc centcrlinc o( said road; thencc Nor:h-
CZste1•1y alotig last clescribeJ lino a di�taitee af 435 feet, inore or loss, to
thc truc point ot beginning.
Page 1 of 3
� ~ o � �
T r a c t_I I: That part of Governincnt Lot S, Secl•ion 9, To�inship 117,
Nortli Ra�i�e 23, �Vest ot the I'ifll� Priiicipal ��[cridian, described as totlows:
Boginning at a poinL in tlie centerline of CoLu�t� Road No. 51 running across
said G�vc:3:I11Cnt Lol• 5, ,:!:icli i,o:nt is 2Q^ .__. So�_:'::c=s`_=r?y r_:ezsu:�d alc:io
the centerline of said road Crom its intcrsecl•ion witii the ti4'est line cf sa.id
Govcrnment Lot 5, said point o[ begii�ning Ucin� tlic Nortlteastcrly corncr of
that ccrtain tract of land dceded to Anna H. ��chulcr by Anna and Titus
Mareck by Deed in Boolc 551 of Deeds, page :4R �( Heru�epin County, v:inn-
esota; theiicc Soul•l�easterly along tlie cciitcrl:nc of said road, 65.25 fcc:;
thence Southwesterly malci�i� an angle of g0• 11' l•o tlic right from sai<l
centerline, a distance o! �35.7 feel•, more or less, to a point in the �Yes! line
of said Covernment Lot 5, said point bein� SC"1 feet South of the intersecliun •
of ssid `Ycst line witlt th�e ccntcrlinc of said Cotmty Road and �vhieh ;.oint is
also the most S�utherly coi•ner of the aba�e rtia;ltioned rice:l to Aana Ii.
Schuler by Anna and Titus Mai•eck; thencc No:thcasterly along the Easterl•;
1'inc of said Scl�ulcr tract, 4h0. 11 feet to th� point of beginning.
Page 2 of 3
_ � 0 � ��
T r a c t_I I I: That part of Lots 4 and 5, ;iection 9, Township 117, Nr,rth
Range Z3, �'/est ot thc r'ifth Princigal Mcridian, dcscribed as follows:
Dcainnin� at a point on tlte centerline o: tlic :�n�in Gounty Road; zunning
�astcrly and Wcsterly thrnugh said Lot ��, 3C�0 fcce Eastcrly trom thc puint
wtticre s�id ccntcrli�ic intcr.ecl•� tlic ce�itr.i•linc o( a sidc road r�uiniiio
So�ithcrly frat� said main road lo L•hc sliorc of J.a}:c ivtinnc.onl:a, saiu point
of beginnina l�cing l•he Nortlieast�:ly cor�ier .^.f a tr.c� oI land convey:d by
Ann� H. Scllulei• and husUand to IiaL•I:ie ivt. I3i•id;c:ttan b}• Decd i�t Bo�l: 579
� of Dccds, page �k23; tlience r�uininG SouthvicsCcrl�� alo:i� l•hc �asterly line of
thc traet of lan� so Jcedcd �,vhicli l:ne is parallcl to and 300 tcec dis:.z:�t s.rnm
tlic ccntci•linc of s�id :•oar.l to �o�.v walci• i:�ai•l: o�: t!:c slin:•c o: said lake; :rom
thence Eastcrly alon� L•hc li�te of lo�v .vatcr �:�ar;: about �00 feet to ti�e Dinrf:n
and South Covcr�unent line bcl•wcen the aforc:�aid LuCs �} and 5, and fruiii
tlicnce about at i•ight anglcs Norl•li.:astc3•ly C:troa��li said iot 5, and along th�:
�as:crly li�ic af l•l�c ti•act uf land convcycd hy :\:via an:l Titus Iv(arecl: to l�nna
F-I. Schuler by deed in Bool: 551 ot Deccls, pa�e 3�:5, to a point in the cer.terline
ot•said mairi r�ad, 300 tect �astcrly of the poi�:� aC bc�innin� and trom thence
\'/cstcrly alono said ccntcrline L•o said point c� E�r,�-i:i;ii^�„ �"kCL• PT l.�nd
descriUed as follo�vs: Coinmencing at a poi:�! n:i the sl:ore o( Lakc Mintteton1ta,
said point bcing 300 fect \Vestcrly al�n� said .:horc tron: Soul•hwesterly corner
of Lot 5, Section 9, Tov�nsliip 117, Range 23, saicl poii�t <.lso being Southeast-
erly cornci• of land no�v ov�ned Uy Dr. W. A. I�atCen; titcnce Northcasterty
along linc of said Pal•ten ;and, 370 icet, mor�. or lcss, to cc�itcr of C,ou.��ty
Road, :;aid poii�t bcing 100 fect, morc or ics:., i�'orlhwestcrly trorn intex.�e�:tion
of ssicl ccntcrlinc ot said road, .vil•h linc bct�vccn Lol•s h and 5, said Section;
thence Soutlteasterly along saicl centerline to interscction �vitli center ot e.
private driveway extendecl and thencc South�vesterly alona said centerlinc ot
saicl r]rivewa,y to sitore ot Lal:c Iv[inneto:ll:a; tltc�uc \ort:t.vest�rly alo�tg said
shorc to bcginniiig, •
Page 3 of 3
ii��,..� EX� �� T � � ,,.b. �� �
Y y�� ��+� M•N
( �r.✓a�� ��,�. � YI�t/r �.N.a/i MtC �
• i � . — CO2�U T. '
�t��
�---r---- a'"'°' a ccawl I __ I � � I I.• �' I,a
I ' ,, •, r• i-mt . -� � ------� �
� ;�I A�� � �._„. a .'� . ,, �- ,� �; � �� a'
ii a�d I•rrtii[oa: �'. � I _ i.�_ ' yf_i._v�v.iLroa� ,{ i .•'� �� � +i �y,
, �.r.�_�.F: � o �
�.. -rt — ` - - �� �.•r����,� !
i i' w in u..�«r;� {' �r'�'g � , .
� —IL ij .:,,,��«..uM� �. ; �
r4 � i .=o.� I
� 5 I �O Ct8 :I I 11 I�.:;�''iereo ae _ _! p� I �' y '
{ 4� "------+M'--- =• �e � ` � } . p
�Q • ' �'y,�ti_'--'--�'+'---�i E � '� j �:F�? �N a �
� i !I II��. . „II ��� ° ~ i R:�3 ,`g:l �,
I �5� � S } �� • : I
� : '.,� _s•uieeooe;II- � '�', �Ira•uiaeroaeJ!�_ 5_ • v � �� � I
{ � �� Ci— ��• -' eR--.��_ _ a�� —re'-i•' v�" �1 {
I � � A � II� ' . F i I I � I I •!'grw �+ � �
i ? �'41{• il s I � ir� �I � �,. �ai' j'i
.
'"� �y II � �I1 . , I I :� I 3p.� +
� I I9 ab rl � ���� • ��.1�:-� ' 1r'""""'__"" I� 1 j i �� --_-_- � �: �Fv I
` Z" � xaeeao°°a�a;`0�1 k �' ��tLr�`1y wov�m �I�� fY �X I �� ��y � e+ II•I
� I M.NI���KO��!— �'y� L-� ��=t11/3�41M � 14 I4 � x; �4' Yy_ ! —$— Ml� � � I� I I
� X x'y ''�,i:3! ���"i n'eT,i'i�r•r.A�S:r. F' i+roT . I � �� • -rr_y' `�
}t„ 1.,•' ~�ti ' � ' \�'� mur.N.a ievrra+�r•�airri i I
N � � �,. fi' �� � I I .`•Y 1 r•r - � � r _ �i " i
.ts�IPK �\� 1 I 9 \ i '•� � ��S
�� �
� I ii�' ri. —W. � I � �Y/� ♦ ��a a�'.I ISa I
L _ 5 : .� 9 I � „� "4'a R�s �a�
I ; II L'I i
+�b I- I � �� �4 ; � ;�"�°.���ii k� ` � � Y(a >�� :� ,� _��i�a3 �
I� `i ! --- '��i�r� a ai� �,,,. _„ ��p: ¢ � � "s�e� �I � I : I°"'°" ���
�vr .� :� wyr� I � �
I� [n+M I 1 I ? I z+i rH'
�: a � �j � I I IS - ,c a�l I i t �'uo.uiee
� I ¢v � ; ��, j V � . � '� '^-'' � ' �-
u�e �
l�. � r.e I S � :i n b rt w � il 11 � � an.:Jt w.s.irc' I
�V � - I icr.l rt.a r�..+ra
� � � • .�cxm eurrn.� 11• �� � � �S1 � I w. I n, � I
� ra� �rd ao• i �
i � �� I I 4 I Y4 I sC4 I t'.M i
� � ia�a� �A i d�a' �-�- � e.�.a �
�� �7w'! ia.a•RM ;�,�, .
As� �� 1 "•,'. p�7 � ���F�a
���� � �5� sr A
"a £ga �0 r�a�� '
a3� g v�� D
F'� g ��� Z
��� �
' � TSO ft.weDed br_-_� �--��- � - - _-�__��
.; � - - x
�. � � � $
\ m ~ . , �
n`� 1 s
\ W� 1 • ��' ��' .
� 1 . � o
\ $�, �•� �: O
N � 1 _
� 1'- : L�, IIME � ���'��.�'���L.. /N1
'=` '1I�� y�` N
� _ �' c�°_� �
\ y `
� �' f' f'
P'
. ,.D.
�°tl� p�p�pOSED
� e�•���°. �.
^^ 'f'' ' o ;��°.�� ` �,V 1�p� N�i /
'/�/�VGW/.{� I �ACNT'V V:F.'MAY . ' 4 ]f0 � _I]D, `AI 1 �� .�/�II�I
Tr� . �
To f3� - � o , , �. , �-
o ; ��
�EMovtl� � �� - �
, �
, ,
� iu �
__ S rt �Y __ _ ' - �
` ��$ rn
g � ` - �.+�' `°� �►
sf � , "
�
' \
o-� �:' ��
'-v
�.,:.,., , ,�
���
� N 53•28'S W�57.71� � — — ;�
— 923.t eontwr pne �— _. —
�
�
LAKE MlNNET�QNKA
�