HomeMy WebLinkAboutRe: notes. codes. etc regarding school-1997 r.
/ � � �/ `''� ��G'�-b-/ �o �
�� ur:sic�:v�i�Ki>,�cfifs 13—fi5
added to standpipe demand as determinrd h�c�m NFPA 14, thr. ltazarrl in h'i�ure �-2.3 or the rtrea ��rotected bv � sprin.klers,
iStan�lru�d for the/nslullation of Jtandpipe anrl Ho.se Systems. ruhicicez�er is �n-euter. Exlended coverage spnnklers shall Ge listed
Esc'eptioia ;Vo. 1: W7�ere lhe combi�ted .s�iri�ekler sti�stem devu�nd �2�h arul rlesigrnrcl for llte mirti�nu.m flow corresponding to che den-
and/�ose streu�n alloruuncr o Table �-2.�exceeds the re uiremen[s sity for the snu�lle.ct�irea of operation for the/u�zr�rd us s�ecifted in
of NFPA 14, Standarrl for the/nstallulio�t of Stan�lpipe and Hose Ftgure J-2.3.
Systenu, this higher rlenu�ttd s/anll be wed. 5-2.3.2.4 Where listed yuick-response spnn lers are used
Exception No.2: For�u:tinllc�h�7nklered hulldings,lhe sprinkler �hroughout, the system area of operation is permitted to be
demand, not including kose strea�n n.11orui��ace,as indicated in Table I•educed without revising the density as indicated in Figure
( � 5-2.3 shall be added lo the requireinents given in NFPA 14, Stan- j-2•3.2.4 when all of the following conditions are satisfied:
� dard for the/nstallntiat of Standpipe and Hose Systems. Wet pipe syste►n
(� Water allowance for outside hose shall be added to the Light hazard or ordinary hazard occupancy
sprinkler and inside hose requirement at the connection co 20-foot(9.0-m) maximum ceiling height.
the city water main,or a yard hydrant,whichever is closer to
the system riser. The number of sprinklers in the design area shail never
(g) The lower duration values in Table�-2.3 shall be per- be less than five.
� mitted where remote station or central station waterflow
alarm service is provided. ao •
(h) Where pumps,gravity tanks,or pressure tanks supply
sprinklers oniy, requirements for inside and outside hose m
need not be considered in determining the size of such � 3 Z,S
pumps or tanks. v, 30
.N
5-2.3.1.4 Total system water supply requirements shall be � .
detrrmined in accordance with the hydraulic calculation �
procedures of Section 6-4. ° 20
U
5-2.3.2 Area/Density Method. �
5-2.3.2.1 The water supply requirement for sprinklers c
only shall be calculated from the area/density curves in Fig- � �Q
ure 5-2.3. The calculations shaU satisfy any single point on a
the appropriate area/density curve as follows:
/\ (a) Light Hazard.�rea/Density Curve 1
(b) Ordinary Hazard (Group 1)Area/Density Curve 2
(c) Ordinary Hazard(Group 2)Area/Density Curve 3 '
i
(d) Extra Hazard (Group 1)rlrea/Density Curve 4 �0 ���-ti 20 30
� (e) Extra Hazard (Group 2)rlrea/Density Curve 5. Ceiling height,ft y( '': x-� = y�
It is not necessary to meet atl points on the selected curve. Note: +55
y=2x �
5-2.3.2.2 For protection of storage up to 1`L ft (3.6 m) in — - Z t s,_
height,the following shall be applicable: For ceiling height?10 ft and<_20 tt,y=�+55; -
For ceiling height<10 ft,y=40; * S S
Commodity Classes I through IV 3 Z,� '
For ceilin g hei ght>20,y=0.
For SI units: 1 ft=0.31 m.
Commodity Classification Palletized and Bin Box Rack
I OH-! OH-1 Figure5-2.3..4
� II up co 8 fc(2.4 m) OH-1 UH-1 5-2.3.2.5 The 'system area oF operation shall be increased
j � II over 8 ft(2.4�n) by 30 percent without revising the density when [he follow-
�. � up co I2 ft(3.6 m) OH-2 OH-2 �ng types of sprinklers are used on sloped ceilings with a
III OH-2 OH-2
IV up co 10 ft(3 m) OH-2 OH-2 p�tch exceeding 2 in.in 12 in. (50 mm in .3 m):
IV over 10 ft(3 m)�0 12 fc(3.6 m) OH-2 EH-1 Standard Spray Upright
5-2.32.3 The densides and areas provided in Figure 5-2.3 Standard Spray Yendent
are for use oniy with spray sprinklers. For use with other Sidewall Spray
� types of sprinklers,see Section 5-3. Large Drop.
�
Exception No. 1*: Qui�k-response sprinklers shall rtot be pennitlr;l 5-2.3.2.6 ' For dry pipe systems and double interlock preac-
for rue mith Curues 4 und 5(Extra H�izrerd). tiun systems, the area oF sprinkler operation shall be
Exref�tiou No. 2: SidewnU sprav sprinklers shul[he pennitted for increasrd by:SO prrcent withuut revising the density.
use mitle.9rea/Ueruity Cun�r 1 (Li{rhl H«u[rd)und, if sperif:call� 5-2.3.2.7 Whrre high temperature sprinklers are used for
listed, wilh Area/Density Cun�rs 2 ur 3((hdinary Hazarrl). Extra Hazard Occupancies, the area of sprinkler operation
l ExcepCintt No. 3: For exlendrd r.overage sprinklexc, lhr rainimum shall br permitted to be reduced by 25 percent without
� ( desigrt area s/uill be t/u�t correspondi�tg�o thr. rnu.ximum de�esity f or revising the dens�ty,b�u nut t<�less than 2000 sy ft(186 m=).
1996 Edition
13–tiF ivs�r:��.i.\'I'1();V()F'St'kl Vh[.P:f2 til'ti I h:�iti
5-2.3.3 Room Design Method. 5-3.2.4 Hose stream demand and water supply duration
5-2.3.3.1* The water supply requirements Ei>r sprinklers reyuirements shall be in accordance with those fi�r Ligh[ �
only shall be based upon the room that creates the greatest Hazard Occupancies in Table 5-2.:5. �
demand. The den�ity selected shall be that From Figure 5-3.3 Quick-Response Early Suppression (QRES) Sprin-
5-2.3 corresponding to the room size.To utilize this method, klers. (Reserved) (Sve 1--1.5?and.4-1--1.5.2.)
all rooms shall be enclosed with walls having a fire-resistance
rating equal to the water supply duracion indicated in Table 5-3.4* Large-Drop Sprinklers.
5-2.3. 5-3.4.1 Large-drop sprinklers shall be permitted to protect
5-2.3.3.2 If the room is smaller than the smallest area I ordinary hazard, miscellaneous storage, and other storage r
shown in the applicable curve in Figure 5-2.3,the provisions as specified by other NFPA standards.
of 5-2.3.1.3(a)shall appiy. 5-3.4.2 Number of Design Sprinklers.
5-2.3.3.3 Minimum protection of openings shall be as 5-3.4.2.1 Protection shall be provided as specified in Table
follows: A-5-3.� or appropriate NFPA standards in terms of mini-
(a) Ligh[Hazard—automatic or self-closing doors. mum operating pressure and the number of sprinklers to be
included in the design area.
Exception: Where openings are not protected, calculations shall �
include t/ae sprinklers in the roo�n plus truo sprinklers in the commu- 5-3.42.2 The minimum number of design sprinklers for
nic¢ting space nearest each such unfirotected opening unless the ordinary hazard and miscellaneous storage in accordance
coyremunicating space has only one sprinkler, in mhich case calcula- �'ith this standard shall be 15 for we[pipe and preaction sys-
tions shall be extended to the o-peration of that sprinkler. The selec- tems and 25 for double interlock preaction systems and dry
tion of the room and co�nmunicating space sprinklers to be calculated p�pe systems. For other storage configurations, the nurr.ber
shall be that mhich produces the gre¢lest hydr¢ulic demand. of design sprinklers shali be in accordance with the appro-
priate NFPA storage standard.
(b) Ordinary and Extra Hazard —�automatic or seif-
closing doors with appropriate fire=resistance ratings for the 5-3.4.3 Large-drop sprinkler systems shall be designed
enclosure. : such that the minimum operating pressure is not less [han
25 psi (170 kPa).
5-2.3.4 Special Design Methods.
5-3.4.4 For design purposes, 95 psi (650 kPa) shall be the
5-2.3.4.1 Where the design area consists of a building ser- maximum discharge pressure at the hydraulically most
vice chute supplied by a separate riser, the maximum num- remote sprinkler.
ber of sprinklers thac needs to be calculaced is 3.
5-3.4.5 The design area shall be a rectangular area having (
5-2.3.4.2 Where the room design method is used, and the a dimension parallel to the branch lines at least 1:2 times the
area under consideration is a conidor protected by one row yyuare root of the area procected by the number of sprin-
ofsprinklers,the maximum number ofsprinklers[hat needs klers to be included in the design area.,�ny fractional sprin-
to be calculated is 5. (See 5-2.3.1.) kler shail be included in the design area.
Exceplion: Where the area under consideration is a corridor pro- ' 5-3.4.6 The nominal diameter of branch line�ipes(includ-
lected by a single roru of sprinklers and the openings are not pro- �ng riser nipples)shall be not less than L!,��iri. (33 mm) nor
tected, the desigre area shall include ull spnnkler.s in the corridor to greater than 2 in. (51 mm). . �
a maximu.m of 7. � _
Excepeion No. /: Starter pieces shal! he permitted to 6e 2�/2 in.
5-3 Specia!Design Approaches. (6-I m�n) , . •.�
._:.� _
5-3.1 General. All special design approaches utilize�theY � �xce�it#on'�� �{i�r�;,�tancl� l:nes ar'e larger than 2 in.
hydraulic calculation procedures of Section 6-4, except as (51 mm), llae spnnkler shalCbe supplied by a riser nipple lo elevate
specified. �� lhe sprinkler 13 in. (330 mm)for 2�/�-rn. (6�F-�nm)pipe and I S in.
(380 rnm)for 3-in. (76-�nm)pipe. Tliese dimensions are measured
5-3.2 Residential Sprinklers. frnm the crnterline of tlte pipe lo the deflector. In lieu of this,sprin-
* kler.s may be off.set/eorizont�llv a minineum of 12 in. (305 mm). (
5-3.2.1 Sprinkler discharge rates shalt be provided in
accordance with minimum flow rates indicated in individual 5-3.4.7 Hose stream demand and water supply duration
residential sprinkler listings, both for the singlr sprinkler reyuiremrnts shall be in accordance with those for extra
discharge and the multipie sprinkler discharge of the design hazard occupancies in Table 5-2.3.
sprinklers.
5-3.5• Early Suppression Fast-Response(ESFR) Sprinklers.
5-3.2.2* The design area shall br that area that includes 5-3.5.1 ESFR sprinklers shall br permitted to protect ordi- j
the 4 hydraulically must demanding sprinklers.Calculations ���•y harard, miscellanrous storage, and other storage as �
shall be providrd to verify thr single(1)operating sprinkler �Prci6rd by othrr NFPA standards.
criteria and thr multiple(4)operating sprinkler criteria.
, 5-3.5.1.1' ESFR sprinklrrs shall be designed such that
5-3.2.3 �M1 herr areas such as attics, basements, or c>thrr thr minimum ��prrating pressure is not less than 50 psi
typrs of e�ccupancies are uutsiclr of dwrlling units hut within �,; �,�,� h��.ti)
thr sa�nr tiu�ucturr, these arras shall br prutrcted in accur-
dance with the��rovisicros uF this standard, including appr��- 5-3.5.2 ESFR sprinklers are suitahle fi�r use with thr haz- (
PI'18IC(�C51btl CI'I[C�'1:1 UI;)-`�..�. dP(Iti I15[C(I Itl�I:ible A-5-3.:i and shall be prrmitted to be used �
1996 Editlon
���
O-:��. V O
� �:�--� CITY of ORONO
� ,����� �
,y., : .: �ti M�;�,� ot���
� Y �r
�t �G Street Address: Maflin�Address:
�i'Egg04' 2750 Keltey Parkway P.O. Box 66
Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323•0066
October 9, 1997
Mr. Marty Schneider .
1235 Hunter Drive
Medina, Minnesota. 55391
Re: Old Hill School
Dear Mr. Schneider:
This letter is to confirm our discussion of October 3, 1997. Work has been completed on the
building to allow the building to be used under the F-2 occupancy classification. It is my
understanding that the children's art school will be operating in the building for less than 12 hours
per week or 4 hours in any one day. It is also my understanding that the Minnetonka Environmental
School may be using the building for staff members but the children will not be using the building
until a certificate of occupancy has been issued for the E occupancy classification.
Please feel free to contact me if you have any questions.
Sincerely,
�y��
V
Lyle Oman
Building Official
LO/ch
cc: Bruce L. Vang, Field Inspector
Greg A. Gappa, Director of Public Services
Ronald J. Nlporse, City Administrator
Telephone (612) 473-7357 • FAX 473-0510
C O N s t r u c t A r c h i t e c t s
3750 Minnehaha AVC011O,Minneapolis,MN 55406,ph(612)724-9877,h�(612)724-1394 ■
� Richard C.Lundin II,AIA
� J�es LoRan Graham,AIA
� Ali Re�Heshmati
'J� _
26 September, 1997 ��b�f',��
. �,� �p �g�%
To. Mr. Lyle Oman
Building Official '
City of Orono •
2750 Kelly Parkway
Orono,MN 55356
RE: Lake Minnetonka Environmental School
The Old"Hill"School
2180 North Shore Drive
Wayzata,MN 55391
Dear Mr.Oman,
My client, the Lake Minnetonka Environmental School,has directed me to address the issue of Group B
Occupancy. The owner, Mr. Marty Schneider, intends to bring the current building to an existing Group
B Occupancy standard. From an abbreviated review,providing this is an existing facility and is not
under going a `change in use', the owner intends to install illuminated exit signs and smoke detectors as
required for a Group B Occupancy. This issue does not forgo my client's full intent to bring the cunent
building to Group E-1 Occupancy requirements.
Again, thank you for your time and attention on this matter. I will be arranging for an interim plan
review once we have prepared our construction drawings.
Sincerely,
��i��
James Logan Graham,AIA
Pazmer, CFO
Construct 1.to build,form,or devise by fitting parts or elements together systematically.2.to draw.3.a)an idea or perception
resulting from a sense,impressions etc.b)a concept or theory devised to integraie in an orderly way the diverse data of a phenomenon.
�?9;26!97 14:29 F�1' 612 i 24 �2K� STUI�IC� r�]Nstruct �J��
G O N s t r u C t A r c h r t e c t s
nso MrnoeeaDe AvCts+te,Mittveapolis,MN 55406,ph(612}724••9577,fit(f 12)724-1394 ■
� Rlchard C.Landh�lI,ALA
� Jnmts Lo�an Graham,AIA
■ �►ti ttem IIcsban4u
26 September, 1997
To: Mr.Lyle Oman
B�€Edi�4fficial
C�ty ot Oraao
275fl Kelly Parkway
Urcmo.MN 55356
RE: Lake Mlnnetonka�nvlronmental School
'I'hc Old"Hiil"School
218Q Norlh Sharc Dri�ve
Wayzata,MN 5539I
D�ar Mr.Uman,
Ivly clier►c, the I�ke Minnetonka Environmencal Schooi,has directed me to address tlie issue oC G'oup B
�ccugancy. Thc owner,Mr.Marty Schneider,intends to brinA the cucrent building to an existing Cir�up
B OcCupa.ncy 4tandard. From an$b6reviated review,provid'mg this is an existin$facility snci is not
under going a`change in use',the ovun�r intends io inst�ll illuminated exit signs and smoke detec;tors as
required far a Group B �ccnpancy. Tliis issue does not forgo my c1i��nt'c full intent ta hring rhe current
buiiding ro Group E-1 Occupancy reyuirements.
Again, thank yau far your time and attendon on this matter. I will be airanging f�r��1 itltetim plan
review onee ae have prepared our canstruction drawings.
Sincerely,
�
-�-� /
f ,.:� I _ -
f f
�� •� ��`
.Iames La�an Grraham,AIA
F'armer,CFO
Canrtrr[ct 1_to 6[rild,fonq ar devise by fitting parts ot elemcnLs togethcr ay�cmnticalty.2.to�aw.3,a)nn idea�perccp[ion
n�xulsiag fivm a�nnsz,im�sesvvu�c�c.b)�conce.gi ar thec�ry dnvisnd lo iawgr.uc in an�derly wsy�l�c di�rsn�ta of a pGruuineni�u.
119i26%97 1�#:�9 FAX d12 7�4 �29�# STUnIU �;C�Nstriu�t ���1
� d N S t T R C 1. �_ A r G 1i 1 t e c t s
s�su�Avct�c,Minneapolis,MN 55406,�(d12)7244871.fx(612)72�1•1394 ■
■ Blcbard c.Lwdm II.a,1�,
� Jalttes I�o�an Graham�AI�► Tl'QIlSIt1�l
� Ali He�Yicslonati
DATE: 26 5eptember, 1�97�--._,.....,.,._.
�
TO: MP.Lyle Oms+��,Attn.Rori Moorse ______,
� F�c.473-0510
PROJECI': Lalce Minnetonka Environmental sci�oot
E:_:�::3 ,.,..,., .._..__.
RE; Gronp B(by_c�rreat Qwnc�
�
COM1vtEN'I'5: .....,....r....,�.
I�'i Lyle,
rilqse revlew and oontact me at your convenienoe. This in no
way changes our intent to eae�ute the rroup E rzquir�ents.
Final oansuuction drawings are in process.
Thank You,
��:%' �-''
� �...r
James L.C�a�am, AIA
Pnrtner/CFO
PAGF: �
.......: .. ..:.. ..... ..:.:.... _ .._.... _..__. ..__..._._.---------------..__.----
oi: �
f��1hd E�LI:�t� i_��DE::� _ ;TI:��:= F,1.:::::f-,1��—�<i;—l�i;•' 1ii.r� 1^ `+� 1:l:a1 F' �_��';:;=i�
E , REQUfREMENTS FOR GROUP � OC�UPANCiES �``
� NOTE: Tables in Chapter 1� appear at the end of the Chapter. ��,
�; ;;
� Group F Dccupancies Defined ��;w
,.
� 5c'C_ I i�)1. (;rcri�E� f� f)�•�-1���+i3�c�ic`ti ti�1.�11 l>t': ",
�a � k�'';.
� Uivisic>ta !. C::isc�lit�c• sC�rvu•cr st.�tic>»s. sEc.�r:Fs,;c t.�;.�iu�c�•s ��l�vr�.� uc> rc._ ;�,
�; J
'� E:�;�ir �ti•c�rk is di3i�c• c'xc���t f��i�l��,ir�gc of p��rkS�ti�cl r���iintf.ri��inC��� T'Cc�il�rir��; ;�;i
•� n<> r���cri fi�tra-it<, \ti't:IC.�lI]L';, or tlic usF� �7f }3iF�;hl�' fiarnm�il:�ie ]iciui<�s. ;IS,
�JY.
I�iv�yion �. ��1'l��r,lesiile ancl rf�t�iil storc:s, U�I10E' �i111�CIE11�5, rlrinkin�
:ir�cl c3ii�iii� c�stal�lisll�»��r�ts }�:�vi�i� ari c��r•uE>ii��t li,:icl c�f lc�ss lha�� 1()(.), I��.
� r>>•i�,ri��� 1>1(U1tS, t71E]t11Clj�.l� [7f)11i��: �ti�i fir�: itit�EnilS, f1iCfOClf'S iilfC� \Vi>I"�- li;;
<, � �l-:r,}>s usint; t�t�atc�ri�l� n��t 1��;�1,3�� A.if17lTl�i}i�c'i�E� i:•cirnl;utitible.. stc�r,i.�c�unii ys:,
�: �
, sc�lc:•s rc>ucii�: f�<,r r,c�rnl,�3sti1->IE� �c3c�c�s, pair�it stores �t•it}�utit �itll�: h.Lnc�lir�t�. ,.���
(�cc �c�•l.icin �02 fcly df�finitic,,rz �>f Asser�tl�l�� 43c�ilc�irt,��.j ;3�'�
�� ; .r�:
; I,riilc3i�i�s cyr �>c>rtic»as of lyt�ilciiri,�s }t.�vir�s; rc>o«is izsec! f�c�r c��c�ii<<itir.-�sltil ��e
;�:�.
' �,tirF�c�s��1 1;�-��'i;tici tlie 12tEt gr�icic �vit}i lcs� thaii 5U <�cc��pu��tti in any ���,:,
(�:�.
�' i'OO[]l.
� �3�
F Divisic�ti 3. :�irt�r�tft i�a��r�gars ��•}ier� ���o rc:�air ���or�: is cic,nt' cxc�:pt ��;,
� e:��c}�an�<� of����3i-ts �tncl �ii�iititc�nance. r�yuirirzg nc� ci��ezi f�atii��, �ti•c�lc�irih, jr�
'; or thc us� o� �11L;��1�)' fI1tZ�Clt�i��t' liquit3s. r�'
�fi.
f_)pc�n E��irkiri,�; ���r<�Lc-t_ ��
� N�'li��i�rts. ?'
, �.
:>: �'UC UCCl.1j7�iL2C\' SEt]2!I'�lftOI75 Stt'. �.��i3�71t: Nc�. 5-�>. �;,
_�� h'c,c- c>ccti�l�tr�l lo<:c3 s�.e Srctir�rt �;()1. ;�
:� Construction, Neight, and Allowable Area ��;
'� G•s;
;;. S�c. 1102. (<ij C.>er�cral. 13,.iijr�i���s cn• ���irtti a-�{ i��uilcliti�s c•I<��•;c�tl in �;',
(yrc�zi�7 1�' hrcc�usc i�f !.�►�� usc cir ch�triiCter c�f thc c�c�c,��-,aElt•y 4hall ]�c �•Y
a ' d r;:
:� Ei�T�ite�l tc� the tti�pi:.4 uf�c�i�nstru{�ti��xi �[•k �c�rth ij� '!'al>1c�ti Nc�. 5-(; :����{ Nc�. ''�;.
1'1
� 5a1� anci s�i.�f] ►���t F\CEC'C�, in c�re3 c;r hei�ht, t}��t.� ]i��-�itti s���cifi�>d in ,�r
,", tiectic�t�s SE15, 5i)f�, a�icl SO7. ',`�'
�7,
' ()thi°r �_,rr,vi.sii;ns csf this (_:i�,c3c rz�>t�i�it}�iSt��r7clii�g> �i (_;r�.n�f� F�, T�t�isi�:�n `:
- �' j � �, hirl�5-
p 1 ()c�c��2 �ar1c•�' Ic�ctttc�c3 iri tt�:� 1-,as�ir�cr�t ar {i��st stc,r`- c>f s 1�,.�il<:3ir�<, �'
��,�; .i (;rc>>�r� 1�, 1?i��isi�7ti `� �:�r ci (,��-cn�}� I I ()c•c�fFia�-�c:�• tiiav h�� �•Ia,sc<� a� i.
�' a s��:;;�r<itc• �+�«� �isti<<c•t �.f+�ilc3i��� f�r�r t}�c� �:>>�i}�c�se t�f �►rc��� limit�iti��ri, ��
limitatiun i�f tiurf-,lxr r�f tilr.>ric.ti a�ic� Type of C:or�-;f-rtic:tickii, �i����:�x ti�l i>f ';',.
th�: f��ll<��t�it��� CUi1C�1�1C>[15 �3['l' Y[7Et: �-�
I_ 'I'hc C�r(yi�Fj I-', DivisiUn 1 ()c:c�ip.iti��ti• i:, o{ 'I')'E-,f: I (:c�t�titru�tiur�. ;��;.
". 'I'l��ere. is ii �I'I��ic•c�-���i�ur C)ec:uE�ar�c�y �ep�iratiur� h��t���c.�er� tlit: �'t'.
;i;.
(�rc>>:��� F', 17ivi�icin 1 l)cc�.,�aancy �uzd.ill porti<�ns oi�thc (:r�up ��, ;%
1)i,,i�ir�r� '.'. c�r (�ro���> Ii f)ccu�aaiic>�. '','�.
3. '1'}��� C;rnizx� r', I�i�.�isic7ri 1 ()CCu��anc�1' is i{t.vC�tE�c] ti> tlic stc�r�t�;�� c�f' :ij:'
�i �)iiti$t�xa��r• vcl�icic�s (}7ti�'[fl� 'cl C2S[3.1C1��' O� [7(1t Ill{)IC.' C�l::ill T'1[I]t'- j:��-
��zrso�is }�cr �•c.hi�le}, l�ut ���3}� c�nt:►ir� l;iurEclry rcx�ms and Er�e- ?'-
�.�,:.
cliiiIlfC:i� ��cXuipm�'rtt r��nii�s inc�ident�}1 tU the c�E�c'I'2it1(?I1 Uf t�-�E'
�: r:
� }»tiltlit��;. '��
�,
� 75
i;,"
I,`;�
=__ . . ..,:__.�... �
/---_ �
.� 0,�.�
Q O�
'' CITY of ORONO
i''�,� �������� ,` �
6 , � "� r� �!� Municipal Offices
� f����� �.
�.� ' '�����"�,��1�`�'.�G Street Address: Mailing Address:
9 `�'� '��'` 4�
jf�gg0� 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66
��--_�' Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066
July 16, 1997
Tom Joachin
Division of Building Codes and Standards
408 Metro Square Building
St. Paul, MN 55101
RE: Orono Building Code Board of Appeals
Dear Mr. Joachin:
Enclosed are minutes and supporting documents from an Orono Building Code Board of Appeals
Hearing, submitted for your review.
If you have any questions, please feel free to contact me at my office.
Sincerely,
Lyle Oman
Building Official
LO/lsv
Enc.
Telephone (612) 473-7357 • FAX 473-0510
�.1�I ��
• ;
ii.�
' �
:;,.�,i I I �r f I� .
'1 i..��e •, �77 1i
"'� I I i:J rJ �d �' � �C� �
a�, �� � 1 ��,� � ;
I ���rn I� �
�' I J
r� i _
,4;I _–_ i-- — —_TII .-� -- n..�� � I
'�,� IJ � _ � l „ � 7 l I _ _ . I
�.},� �' � I = ' � � � — �
;"� ' _ _ ' = � ..� I ��
�,I � , , I �� �,� i � n,,,,�
`I'� ., � r I ; i ,T � r� � ,
t'1' , = i � I � a � '' � O '� '
���_ ,� � .r I ^ � ' N `1 r�J �'; �
I�� �� il - -�� I � �� I ,�^r C~ �v .
�L II ,.� I — i � I i. '_ L"'� '�
•I � t:� 'A
ty{;I ��, � ry II - �I •� I y �vn.1 ��
`I� � I - J � �^ �I II •!I; f J ��
�tiii y . I Ji = I ~ il ���' I�
7� �c ' _ - I� � i J r I c '1
E�r = � � �7, ^ � ^ _ � I,i � �
.�1.' . ' � , . :c �I - � �A � � '�
.�,jl � _ I � � `�., . � � r'
�a'�'' � - � ; , � i, _ '1
;� , - = I � , . = r, _ � o � o
,i� , - - ; , � I - _ ; � � q.
;;I -� - �' �
-!,., �T �I f G I ^n � ; �
.����I'i ' � �. i , I � i � ��- - ' e ! �q.
�j I ' �__ , �I' '�� �' � v
N �
�,, _ ' ,I.— i I „ I ,� 10" � ; F
.�.i!,� C�� t� ►. j W � I lo � �,�; t.p r w �� � � If.G t5 mm Q "i
.I I � i __ � '�� .. �--r`—
'.Gi �— '�-' .— � - ( � i '-- ( ,
,i ��).-. I..l_,� �-. I .-� I� y� �'t�' � �f
�',�; ric�%��'" y-y - —�' �. '�� � _ � i.�
.� �, c � � � � � I= , ��; � �_ _ � i �
�t 7'�� i ,. � � � � _ i - ~ �,�
.�,�, _ _ ;T"� � �i . � J,y � i^ v) ... i , y I�J i 7 =� =t y r*+ 1
��'��I� C I� � '1° ` n , r Ir� I�tNn I l. � il •� I `N rAT i
.�1� _ I� I�'� � ? y , �� �� � w '� �N ��
,�� �a ...��� � ._.� =.�� � - --�;�N �
,�F y �^ � .."? i ��� ' a - M� � � v
` r� u.- � �� •; ~�+ ~ � I`+ 7 i �•� � � - = � ��+
.� �' y " ~� c,;, ry r�lu� 'r�l �, � ^ ,:: �1I ' �ilrC.,
�. '�C�I�r'III, v� � � O n ��'^I ,,,,�I � � � ^ ' � N T ,�
� � ;,I�,, '! '•'.G. n.^'.� �I !s I � •��'*, ,r,.'., ."rt �1
•'1�1�. '7 � 7 .I � -ui 5'�F, I T I �^ _ � I y T I I . �
�� ;`, �. � � r-- �^TI�� •. �� 1 •I-� .�� � '�/.�'"�.i !
;i, n � ' � ' � �' �J" � J 4� � �
i r J I � � � � » ., V rt G I�� rt K v� O
:,� ;� � ^ ^ �.., . � � _ � R� ; � ��1 ; 1
� � � � � �y �:� iry r I()
��,! I" � '� �` � �_..J C1.`��� .� r � I�'.I�'� � � �M.� �- �
�.;:!�+. :�q r 4 T:.I ;��,�� ; '� u "I n - v �n -�,I;� ^�N n �y ,� r
��I I.,. I"-� - - �� p„ v� �=1� _.I G ' .^•.� ;�_ !
� I���I 1�Y;'J 7� n �'yp Cr, = n ;.: � Sn���t�x I
�1j�. N v �. Y w �� - �I? v, J �• ��I� ,n�� ; y m 1
� �� � .n <F� N 1 . � �� '� '^ wl r -�.-
.f�.. I V. .'�'_. J t.-'J� ,Y. I..w Y �ti1 v �. y�+ ��� .: Y�I t�� � I�
;���' � � �� �nN � �-"� �+a� - � �.� � �y 1�� O
� �L i.� r�n (� �Gi W � W T i: _ T (r ., i., ' 'r,T W I T� �: � :.�
^t+. '"�n ,.� "!ti r� � '� ^ ��?
i�'�r{I �. !c' - 5 r� �? .z I � r� ^ '�i
._.'�II rr rt -r K �rt T n rt ^� �7
�.���I - '� ��.
::�1�� �
j'� �'(j �
St_i,'Si_� '�:� 'b�bT ,'�:�. �T �-���i ��i-,T—:?f=,�—�T'_i: :�'� _;:(IlS � =:;�[ICI:_� �i[I��3 t'•ll�d
, ;: , ..
�., � ,� x...;,;.. . _ . , . _ ,: .
. , � -;,- <
� . ., , r ., ,>;,, ,.,;:_� �.._:� �b�,;.v
�6�lOgS'TAX�CAPACITY QUALIFYING AHT .00 OZVIS20N NO 80032 . , ,
� ;..NET'TAX CAPACZTY FD SNARED TC DZVISION DATE 04/80 �
RENTAL TAX FD AREA RATE 00000000 SEE ID S 10-117-23 31 0009
� ,��'• �F 'PROJ �r�+�ti 1 r µ � IF PROJECT N0. . 10-117-23 31 0010 • , ,� � �x+;'• c k i��'�'`''r».'
� { �� .-r r'+ �" P � . . �c&�1 r�. � �"'s�', ��' i�
S ar".x�� k��'y�'j�.���.J #��tiCr r� �.� ..S�F `?�.S'. °il �r;.. ,. - , �� . � � . . . , . . � �-i' .x . {`�� �'R�4 w������ "'���.� u.
�1` t , , 1• ; 10-117-23 �31 0011 �' , ,� :�.� r �r�� , ;;"� ,M3.,; �� ;�:�
. MORE THAN 3 ID S . �.�� .
TAX LEVY/DESCRIPTION HMSTDPRTYP ' RATE AMOUNT • � LAND BLDG � MACH OWN% BASE1 BASE2 NHBASE NON—HMST
EXEMPT . N LC ` .
�;r„�; TOTAL TAX .00 . �
TOTAL PAID .00 .
�;�.;. . •..,�}.
OWNER.• • MORT CODE/LOAN � ADDITION NAME LOT BLK PLAT PARCEL PROPERTY I.D.
TAXPAYER NAMEIADpRESS ESCROW NAME/ADDRESS ACREAGE SCH WTR SEW PROPERTY ADDRESS • SN TWP RG QQ SUFX
� METES AND BOIAJDS_ DST SHD DST ,�.
MARTIN & ANDREA`SCHNEIDER MARKVILLE . p03 42520 10-117-23 31 0098
ATELTER LESUEUR 3NC • 000:00 278 3 2180 NORTH SHORE DR
� ` 2180 NORTH SHORE DR STATUS: CURRENT' �'' '4���:
..�WAY TA p�1-`.:<,:55.391 :,_• . ; ' . ,
� s ;__,,.� , . , .,_ . . �,. .: '' ; , , . � , �; " • CONSTRIJ�TION YEAR,�930;',�'��Y,�•'"`*,�`.f r':' ,�'3��t� a�,r',;
.,... r . ..�':. .�:. �,. , . � x. �t ' i, - t .�3�;�i're�i��i , : ��n�vi .,y'.�R'' ��` ��.
'LOT..5�AND THA?,iPART.�F: LOTS�4 ANQ .b LYII�',.E_OF.W 69 FT THOF . . +. ;, y ' � ��,,.t� ,,< ;��,< ��;�.�4�:�, ,�,�.c�!`,;s,k..�;
;TAXABLE MARKET :� ,r w r F.,��' ,�r,� ,�.,,, �
y,�,� ` GROSS TAX CAPACITY QUACIFYING AMT � .00 . DIVISION NO , .89103 EARLIEST DELQ YR - 1995 ' � . ,��
- NET`TAX CAPACITY ' FD SHARED.TC DIVISION DATE . 12/89 �• ' '
RENTAL TAX . „ FD"AREA.RATE OOOOOU00 SEE ID S 10-117-23 31 0059 ' � � . "
IF PROJ AMT. '� IF PROJECT t�: � ' 10-117-23 31 0060 ;
:� . _ � ' - . •
_ 10-117=23 31 0061 .. +�'
- � MORE THAN 3 ID S _
TAX LEVY/DESCRIPTTON' HMS7DPRTYP RATE AMOI�(T . LAND BLDG MACH OV�J% BASE1 BASE2 NHBASE NON-HMST .
�,y� EXEMPT, N 'CC . , . �
13882 1996 DELINQUENT UTIL 344.77 .
� , TOTAL TAX " 344.77
. TOTAL PAID. , .00 . AMT UNPAID 344.77 . .
'�.w� : _ .�.
;� OWNEIt • MORT COOE/LOAN # ' ADDITION NAME ' LOT BLK . PLA]' PARCEL PROPERTY I.D. �
TAXPAYER NAME/ADDRESS ESCROW NAME/ADDRESS ACREAGE SCH WTR SEW PROPERTY ADDRESS SN TWP RG QQ SUFX
:�' MEtES AND BOUNOS r DST SHD DST . .
. _ •
� . . ',
4�} , L S KENNEN & J M KELLAR "MAXWELL'S ADDITIOPI" TO CRYSTAL BAY 001 42540 10-117-23 31 0099 �
, LEONARD S KENNEN 000.00 278 3 1240 ARBOR ST
,
`" �� t r. � . . . � i.- ;;'�fV,2�a�`.'��`rutf t sa�?�,5y�
:.} �' Ls 1<, " .ti..�� ri' F. .e '
y \ .,., "Lk y��,t `�'f� � ��,,•., ,�37'�'^^{��'1
y, v + ,i^; y. ...� ..�. ,�}.� .�:. ..� .S. y.
{�"' 't �. a?. 1� ;�1.. , a .� ,.�:} �t�. .l>�� ':i�F.,s :a�,a,
��ti '�'a�.'. :<�, �r .�F ES ,��*�`f-� a�b�i,.y�e }�.y�- .4a
�'. . w � 3 it�r J'"p�I�r
,�'�I � ' if ! �7 t } �' �f��.: 5i1�5^d M.�"�.C.
,"� _ _ _ _ ' _ _ _ �'� ..�� ; :.� ..�.� �ti.
y �. �-- �. �� : . -� . .
.s . . . -� �. �
'.'��*i _.� ' ' ; . _ ... � - � .. � �.. __. ._. . . _ . _._. - -_.tc�.._�,x.,•,�-.�-.o�i�s:a.,
:.�li . ..-�.�. ._.., �.'... . : - . � . . ` ...,, •�. '-
. �.: � .. . �- � , Y:Le#�s�zG
_ .
..., r`a�•t ': : __,. ,.., ,. . _ , , . . . . . . lnMAbC�aiiwwarM�LVr�hy�
- . .r
_ " _
,. . _ • � �� -rc
_ .
S - _:. .�.�........'� . ��, ��',�
. .
`
. .
...._ ..,.
.., .—,- .�.. r...w.w
� �:.,. i .�..- .. . _^ . .. . . . . . . _ . ., . . ..
.,» .. ..- "}-.'� . . . . . "�i'� , t�,•� �ron.
ii.�.',�.s. �'y��� ".* a... .. .�, ._ -i . . ... . . .. • _ , s,t _ ;r. ���t�t'�_�.+ �'.A&'
t�_
t
7
� O�
� O O 2
CITYo� p `
A RONO �
b._
� ,�
�� ���
l' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
�kESH�g'� NO. � � � �
�PPOINTMENT/DESIGNATION
1997
�uburban Rate Authority
Greg Gappa
Jest Tonka Senior Citizens Ronald J. Moorse (Alternate)
epresentative to Long Lake Fire Dept. Gabriel Jabbour
uilding Code Board of Appeals Charles Kelley
�Loren Kohnen, West Metro Services y�9-»�
�`Tom Anderson, Hopkins Building Official y3S'-gy��r
�Maureen Bellows, AIA Architect
�''Kenneth Roelofs, Building contrac or� g�so
�nnepin Emergency Communications Organization y7! -f��`��D
Ronald J. Moorse✓�i h.µ���,�, ,��s, ��3,�
�rt h Tonka Crime Prevention GarY Cheswick (Alternate)
Gary Cheswick
ghway 12 Appointments: Barbara Peterson
'olicy Committee
Gabriel Jabbour
'echnical Committee J. Diann Goetten (Alternate)
Greg Gappa
Gabriel Jabbour
itizens Committee Charles Kelley
George Johnson
Eleanor Winston
�sing and Redevelopment Authority J�� Massopust (Altemate)
Gabriel Jabbour, Chair
Charles M. Kelley, Secretary
J. Diann Goetten
Barbara Peterson
� Minnetonka Cable Communication Commission
Timothy Pattrin
: Use Committee Gabriel Jabbour
J. Diann Goetten, Chair
Charles Kelley
Charles Schroeder
�,
i
i
�J�tJ�� V�+�-�'1, �t•�-1rJ�t �z� �� �l l �1.��' .
-� '. G l-C1� D F o 2.w�c�
t
�� : Z l f:b e� • S 4-�0� D�►v4._ ,
� ��czv�� /� l���0�2� v�/tr- w��'N `t� 3��(r . Ca D�.
4�v A23� c�F ,��,e�1.S ��CrA�e i�1 J�(r- A cKr�-v tr� t t�
U CC.vP��►Cv� G�/,SS1 F�G�i w� �_ TI�... ��V�- ��.� .
�31�vt-O��Jtr-� � �S:tStNv �t'S �lS��1 g U� ,
�sv�,��',,—, .
� .
��/� �tih�u•Fi''p��.
l 2 3� �����L �L...
: �iv�EQl rv� Un� �53� ,
� ` _ _
�
� _ : . ._
� , _
� _
I . _ ..._
_ _ ,. _.
,
I
,
;
, .
_ . {�
1
. .... i 4 /'_ ' � .
.� .. � - » r. . ...' : �z...
,r , . ..... e �d � � a ... . ' �. .
. . . . .. . . ,.. . _ ..._. .. . . . .� . .-w `i....} .. � .. . ... ' .'^. . ... . . �.
. , .. . � . ..y . ._� .. «.. P ...._+.� � . .
. � . .. .... �-a .� . � '� ... "f .
; - .� . _ . w. . 1 < . i , . .
. r .. I t. ,.� .a,
, . . " . . . > . ' '. :. .._ .'. �.i � y.�.:'_... ..,..... d.. .._ .._. . ._.... �
.
�
, . �,. . _, - ; , .� .. I . . �
.. �' r
:
"' l
�. . .i : .. 'i , �._.. - . -,
�;
.... . .. . . _.. .. . �. �, ,.J....1 a ... �..._ ��.1��.. .-..r: . x ,._ �.,» . .... .�.._ •. . . - � . `-� .. � .. . . .
- 7
.. .� . -._ p ..
�' E « �ds '� !t." .. '•°. t . ,�}i`'h y� !...`�Ft � .;+.�.
� +
' �`� � �._.....� ....rCi.'-. ,_ _j
_ ._.___.__.... __._ _.. _ _ _.. a_.._�_.___ _ . _ __ _ _ _ _
-,- -�. - ._. __ _ _
e ;�._
. . _. .. _ _. ...._ ._.. . ..... _.. .._ .__.___—_'_--'- -_ _.. ..... .. _ . . ..... . .. _. _ r.._ . ._ _ ... _... .. .�. ._.___ .... _�,.._ . _.. . ..._^__
.. - . if� r�~� . f �. � .
•
A /.
", .:.� v�a. •� .e.J.
. _�.. ..,..�,... ... ... ._i.........�................. . _... ._.... _ .,.�.... � ._..� t. ... J " .
_�1 � �.'. .f ,y ".` ...f�r .l.�',' �' �.
a
�... .�.....�. .. . . ._. _._ _. .___ . . _._. _ . .. _ ..._...._..._._.. __ ........_
.. ..� �...,f. 1 � ... ... . . . .
, . _ � ..� .. . . � � .� � .. . . _. ..
.. - . . , { .�:'�L -rl.. i �J, ..� '3��'� . . . . � .
' . . . . _ _ , �.' .. . .
.
' ., ,. � � ' i . ' . . . .
- . . �_. .. 1._ ,.. ..,,� - _..___
__.._._ _ _ _...._. ._...._.__ ._.._. __ ..__......>_..._.._ � . . . . ._- _ .__. .. _. .. _._ _ . � __
_..._-.-...a..�._......._� .._.. . . .. ___.. _ _. . . . .. _. .. _ ._ .
. .. "_. . ._ ._ . .. �.-�_.r�� . .. . ..�-
Y
._ ._..._..�.___,.___._._.�._..... _._�._.... ___�.. ._:__.r.-_. .:.�:_-:. '_....___._... ..._._. . . .. . . _ . _. . . .. . . . . . . .�. .. ._.... _,_.... _.. .__.. .
a
i`
June 1997
To whom it may concern:
Following is brief description of my background and present qualifications relating to my
chosen profession as a Building and Fire Codes Consultant.
Presently I am 68 years of age. I am married, have two grown children, whom are both
married, and we have five grandchildren. We live at this time in Vadnais Heights,
Minnesota and spend our winters in our home in Alamo, Texas to escape the Minnesota
winters, and while there continue our consulting with architects, cities, attorneys etc.
I grew up in a family that ran a logging and lumbering business, so learned many lessons
about lumber as a construction material, the grading of lumber and about the various types
of species of wood and types of lumber at a rather young age.
As my father passed away while I was still in high school, and I was too young at that time
to continue in his business,the balance of the family started a retail lumber business with
lumber that had been cut and sawed in our logging operations.
I completed college, U of M at Duluth, MN., was married and served a two year hitch in
the Marine Corp., returned to my home town of Barnum, and ran the family lumber and
construction business for approximately five years. I have spent a total of 13 years in the
retail lumber sales industry.
I had by this time moved to the twin city area, and began my own construction business in
this local. I did this for 10 years, and in 1970 was asked by the City of Oakdale to
become its building inspector. I served this city,which is a second ring suburb of Saint
Paul, as its building official unti11979, acting also as its fire marshal for the last 7 years.
During this time the Minnesota State Building Code, became effective throughout the
state. I was invited to and did accept a position on the State Building Codes and
Standards Division staff as a consultant in June of 1979 and served in that position until I
left to follow this independent consulting business of mine full time in the fall of 1985.
My clients are primarily the design professian. for whom I act as an consultant on design
matters, cities and counties, for whom I do plan review and act as a consultant to their
building inspection staffs, some contractors, the legal profession for whom I act as both
consultant and expert witness, and in some special cases an individual home or business
owner with building code problems.
I graduated from the U. of Minnesota, Duluth, with a BS. degree in Industrial Education
in 1951. Since that time I have taken numerous courses from various colleges offering
correspondence courses in Millwork,Lumber, Paint etc.. I have earned a total of 27
credits in"Building Inspection Technology" from our two local community colleges of
Inver Hills and North Hennepin.
February 1996
Page 2 of 2 pages.
Re: Resume - Duane C. Grace continued.
I now teach some of these same classes along with some classes for the construction
management people. I ha.ve for some 12 years been putting on various seminars each year
for the design profession through the MN. A.I.A., for building officials at their various
cha.pter organizations of I.C.B.O., and for such organizations as CSI, schools teaching
architecture, the Univ., of Minnesota Long Term Health Caze Division etc. All on various
aspects of the Minnesota State Building Code.
I am certified by the State of Minnesota as a Building Official, #0556
Have been certified by Council of American Building Officials as a building oi�cial. #472.
As a building inspector, by the International Conference of Building Officials and as a plan
reviewer. Certificates#1923 and#9793 respectively.
I currently belong to all three of the Model Code Groups, The Internationa.l Conference of
Building Officials, (ICBO.) Southern Building Code Congress International, Inc.,
(SBCCI.) and the Building Officials and Code Administrators International, (BOCA)
I also am a member of the National Fire Protection Association, (NFPA.),
The Construction Specification Institute. (CSI)
I am presently serving as the building official for 3 smaller communities in Minnesota, until
they find a certified building official to take my place and also for the Minnesota State
Fairgrounds. The above list will vary each year. In some cases I may serve as a building
official for a city for just one project, whenever their building official is not qualified or
certified to perform the function of plan review and inspection for that t�pe of structure.
I do the plan review for some 40 various cities in Minnesota, and work will over 50
different architectural firms during the course of a construction season.
Have in the past few years been hired as a consultant by�different firms of attorneys from 6
to a 12 times during the course of a year.
Respectively submitted,
�
Duane C. Grace
iiu%'li�-'�7 ii�:3d FA1 61�491►i�1�� UUANE c,Wai:E C�iinlii)ii1
Duane C. C�raee
Building and Fire Codes Cvnsultants
4375 Mclvlenemy Street
Vac�nais Hei�hts, MN �5127-60U3
Ph ne 612/490-0142 Fa�c b12,490-7869
. Lyle Qrnan- Building Official
A eals Board Members
Ci of Orono, Minn�sota
Re Requ�St for appeal by Mr. M.'�rtir�SchnBider—Hill School..
T request by Mr. Schneider is to detern�iu� the correct, an ea�asting c�ccupancy
c sificatian, pe.r the Min.nesota State Build'vng Cc�de, for the structure th�t,he owns, t}3at
is �vt�as the�Id"Hili Scho��". He is contesting your interpretativn of the catY records
an the bu�ding code�s an "B" occupancy. I
IIi cantention is that this structure has been used as, and should remain classifi�d as an
"�,' occupancy.
If I�ere are questions that I might help resalve prior ta tivs hearing, please feel free to call
an me_
pectively submitted, �
�����
D e C. Grace
B - din� Godes Consultant.
R r�senti.n� Mr. Schneider.
cc - Gity Aministxatox - Mr. Ranald Mvorse.
5
��
. �