HomeMy WebLinkAboutre: zoning permit � °�
O O CITY of ORONO
�:, Municipal Offices
� ` L .:;�,, � Street Address: Mailing Address:
�
� ,�, 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O.Box 66
,�G Orono,MN 55356 Crystal Bay,MN 55323-0066
��kEs�Io4
6 June 2011
Peter&Susan Bazil
3535 Ivy Place
Wayzata, MN 55391
RE: Zoning Permit ATF Application 2010-01207
3535 Ivy Place/PID: 20-117-23-42-0035
On June 2, we received a photo with a sketch to illustrate how the lakeside deck will be converted to a compliant
4-foot wide walkway. Additionally, we received a sketch with a description of the plan for reduction of the take
access stair.Thank you for submitting this information.
In May, the CEty received a revised survey dated May 13, 2011 and a sketch modifying the existing fire ring area
within 75-feet of the lake and discussed this plan with your contractor Benjamin Schmid. Schmid was informed
that the City could not approve the plans for the modifications to the fire ring patio area as the existing fire ring
patio area is considered illegal/unpermitted hardcover within the 75-foot lake setback area. While you are allowed
a 4-foot wide lake access stair within the 75-foot setback no other hardcover is permitted in this area. The fire ring
,�,, itself may remain, however the stone patio surrounding the fire ring must be removed as it is considered illegal
hardcover.
Further, the survey and hardcover calculation worksheets submitted reflect improvements to the property within
the 0-75' zone resulting in 6% hardcover without the proper City approval. Hardcover levels in this zone which
exceed the allowed 4-foot wide stair(and walkway to the dock)are illegal and must be removed.
We understand that you continue to make unpermitted improvements to the property and most recently on May
25th our inspector observed work being conducted on a deck without permits. Please be advised permits are
required prior to commencing all construction projects, grading, or other activity.
We will issue the after-the-fact Zoning Permit 2010-01207 for the modification of the lakeside deck and lake
access stair according to the plans submitted by Auben Residential on June 2. No escrow will be required. In
conjunction with Zoning Permit 2010-01207 please remove all of the illegal hardcover from within the 0-75 foot
zone by or before July 1, 2011 in order to avoid further enforcement action by the City.
If you have any questions, you can contact me at mcurtis[a�ci.orono.mn.us or 952.249.4627.
Sincerely,
CITY OF ORONO
t
l���Gt����-�
Melanie Curtis
Planning and Zoning Coordinator
Telephone(952)249-4600 •Fax(952}249-4616
www.ci.orono.mn.us
Melanie Curtis
From: Pete Bazil [pbazil@earthlink.net]
Sent: Saturday, June 11, 2011 5:14 PM
To: Melanie Curtis
Subject: Letter/Permit
Melanie:
Today we received the permit from the city authorizing the modifications to the lakeside deck and stairway that were
required by the City as well as your cover letter. We thank you for that,as we have sought to be cooperative with the
City, dutifully undertaking to comply with the required modifications, and hiring licensed and reputable contractors with
orders to work with the city as required to assure work is done in a copasetic manner.
I am not clear on the basis for your allegation that we"continue to make unpermitted improvements to the property"
and this is the first I've heard that the May 25`h deck work was conducted without a permit(I was told the opposite).
We are happy to remove the material around the fire ring which was placed there informally by us using stone laying
around the house(hardly a patio).
As for the plastic around the pool equipment, I believe this has been there for as long as we've had the house and
certainly since the landscaping work that was done in 2007 for which we had to originally make amends to the City. Not
sure why this is an issue all of a sudden now. To the extent the City is insistent that this work be done and its due to the
75'setback rules, I note that the area appears to be partially within the 75' area. I assume that we would only be
required to remove the plastic that is within 75'. Please confirm.
I believe we have demonstrated our intent to be cooperative throughout this process. It is my hope that the city would
seek to maintain a similar cooperative tone. I would like to think the City of Orono seeks to be a partner with its
cooperative residents and not at odds with them.
Sincerely,
Pete Bazil
1
t..-- .� � y,.�<'
h C Kl
! 7� .' { l . �;F,���p �
�''+ �� � ,�, � . . 1, `� M'4Af` . .+�. � , ..
�� _��� ��..'� �������r�� F .� - s y.... L ' .�d4 ae?."� ' . ,. , /���� �O�
�, �' M
� R � �+k�a t a�f\�"r '���q,``�',$ ' �w-. ,. ��i� .+�'�.'^x. ���<� . . ' !^,�q
�' 4�, �"� � ` �S�7i'�;��. ,�.��i,� �� �»N r►... ♦ . H t
` .�s x .�(` .. '.,..+►
K •r �i+ �� � 1AEs�r�" fi a ..� #� s«+ - , ,
,'�.�''y �;'k� r,.,Ei r1 ��, � - .. . ., . . .
� � �' ..,� ��~�aMi�l��������. � I
t L # k3�� ti. �j 1 ���. ,y..Z�i . � i� 7 E
( � ati".. .l1 . �. .Y.'_S >` � , '
,4 � ,�'';1-` 7 4'dr. �'¢ � . ► �F '•i� ,. ' :� �y��� .
� Y` �� Ls� �'`,,a . s ' . .. • '�K r'. ���y�":"'�C'4�-� ,.��.i.
, • � ._<
.` } t . .� ; �l �1
r4s . , } ,� �� �. - �I _ �c'�'.�.
� r�fi�."`t�?�- a�' _
.... �. � �. t A �, , c � �
�
, { . ,,��. , , � �,� .
. . y,,
�
`'4 1f%� � d'. e ru� "'�;,� t • � �,.,_\�4'.. •�� . �--.C-R.T . �y`�.`'t�� +. } _s . .
.:_
, . ,
,:. r -- �' w �I 1 ., .." 4• � .
: _ � � � � S
,;45 •, a. .�.sa . .��.}s.,. .. . . .�'- ` � ,�n �� �•.:! � � . . � . �
\ . . «. ...�;
. . , " .. .t .f: .- � ��T1�:Ks^�w.. 4�.r.f. ��.�
,
�;.. . � .. ,.: y: `. ,_. ., � .. � _1: :.' . . .�+.^ �'�-+. �r � .
1 �
,,, +t wF , �.,�iin ��.�`,�:'�'t,` .'�`��-' .�,. � . .
. �. ,
{.. 1 "r{- �j�: . '�' -$ . . , . .
�.. ' �. '� .� y ,�yl'"``;.� l��S�C.� }G� ��' � �
�' ' •: .
�
.�, , _
, �, � `�,.
,� �� ' r _�,�- . .,. �� j '�"�a�L"�,`' . �: �w. I' C �-r`�r �ry../�� 2.. .
k
a ��, , � if���-"�"� 'a.'' ��'�} � .�_
�,'�,' :r r � `� ;�t � � � •. -` i a q� '�. .. �
i � � .. y �� �r t q�s;,f� ;..� �� Y .:.tiY+,.y C�ys.`.�,� , . -� . - .
.n1 '�<",G i.�+v.�'� ; 4 d" 4 L,� �y ; �.�, ±�, 'T7' �y.� • '
• -^ 0 �'+�5 N'C�'i '�' '^��u /�_'�.. a- 'Y �P)'�3 F^'..t 3. f �7'k ,�f 4.�X},�� . � `, '
) '�' e't�.� � arr r... . � w+rS�s.IK� � ..r � ` �`'�'Jc>s n �1[ r '.�' �T�,y}. � - , � . . . ,
. t� , "t ��� "��'�" i.�:ti;t Y st � ��€tA^"�yx I �.3,� , S �'..rtM� . ��''� `4 ,�i� . . ` �i' .
n \ _ . :
� . . *.� ,�5� * `,�.K � . �ir� f 5�"�, .a. .. �. ,".�.
. d�"s�'1'4 �.� 1p� . �:w.y� e, �'w 1,��(„ «!R n ��'f:.►Kt ^v'k. �
� �� .. ' S'�Y `' � �7�';'A�i�$ � , �S` ,��,4b .e�r.`.��lY �
c �
.__,.. '^' ..
�
� -
� � F} 4 ,� � .k�` �r."� . � ,� ' t"-�µ,�`��.�� � 4����v�k���''"; . . �r":ti.� �',£"'+4's'�``:a s�,'+�C �".� x�._�
k . �.a L 'iV j,. . �Szt:4Y � S _ d; }
�. F � � �a.. . . � _ �{'BY �����r�M'�f^^a,�i" '�y ���f��µ/-x ( �,.A F 1q- � ;,t � `�
� v � ,,g_ �-=1
? ��¢�.. i y�j, �::�.'�. .�� � .. � �' . '.3��"'^��.�2� x��kis '�'�i° � � »+`+.'P�.'t�e. `.:� ,�.+^..,
..��
K �. : ... a �.. .� � -�. . y9 Vry.p ."'�E� �ieY;�t �
r i - . �:�'�r r''�:. ; � : *�';d�'�F' ��5.�►+�y+�� �'� r" MPx� F� � t�:r' � •' �•t��
y-� ` {� ,,. � a
���'._' t t��i+ f� K� A S� �y� �+... `(7� .1+ � :'t +4 . . ' .. . . � � t,..F, '�1 °`h. ...: .p '£ h�GT....J!
.e" 1 p1� .ti `t /� a . " �' 7
� � y'.��4f�i�„�`�x*� �,.�{ � f��yy�.., ,?�� �v(( � �r . a •..y� q� ti� � � .. }� ° � ":3�� ���� s�_, �
r�'.k 5 a+`i,�b � �,'S�i.+ ,p+,r� �N... a� . �% � , . �- � •�.c �.. xx "' `
� �,1A ',�{� t�
� a� 4
a �"F "� ��f`' �,,��'�rhp �tCE - � t'4 ti� 1: J �A 6 . a� f+t*.�i �\v , ��`�'�'ra`�,� "" �
r '�.at y�vr�.: y �"e ���+„.�c� ti_+� �g�� � . '� c, . {��� .r�' s3 _•;�,:� .,�. . -y� d �+ �,i �, .:�
�;� r J� ,�.y ] � �i"r' . )ix+'If..« ,� �' :T,r�.,� a �?..�'. � �'::�,3i�R���'` r .. t�.i�.+��y+�+�� � T'y � v�i:. ����'�
� - •nM- -..,ce `�.,�°.,} �'i x. �'�s s�.xj�y'y; _ . k+. - ,� ��� 4^,;F+. 3��'", .l'��1. � �Y� Y+�. .p y ri� r � '��g.%ni''
���j . .� � * � � � i,�q. rtri'("� -'.�" +"' . r � .1 t R �14 .y r.f- �7 1 1;` . . ..
: .�:.. k ; � a .. 9,.'z: 'ro :.�r�""+► t '4�� K� -Y.���`+ f -.s+k .°i-. ',''�^ -tR t,.�� 1
.; rdw ... roa . .� �._r'�t --_ : �'.. :.- oe.r� '- .Tps. 1 *'e'�., ., 7ri F r���, _ �, �?.t *k�.�.y.�
y^ f ��'
}''Sia �-- „;£ y* ' .; ., .s r . ¢.�'l�ii. � . ''�F .. a�:r1'.yu rz f �k r1 y�jc-;'�r-' s�+Y�����. . c-:Ts�'. . i ....,::y��, . ..��7
.y 4..6 K�F ��q k � � 'q� 4 .Y, "nl y,� -�.`' ,�'r'Y .'6f � � j� �;'� �.n5i1,X'S¢,].� cdpyw.:�'+. . ,.y..� 1 S • •. +�,
� s��'an � �x r'�{ � �` 7` i'i.�f �_:•3 �aS�..y's t s s-�}�` sr�+t-�'F;i '1'�> _'�,,..�Qid,tLF'`�3+P.,� � .at,4 i �-.ana4�uaw�'"' ,�„�'3r�
i�:' f � ° -ec. A.�1t. _.i;iarb i+�� �ke4 . cn ar�s a5� -. i ,. ' ��•
� a -'~`""n 'r ;. 1�...#�,y .. �y �k.,���a3 r��`Fr�;�'A2��;7�'�r3�t � � . '1.�� #r'..ti ,z '„� ��,�;rD{"-T�. `. �?�k,��(��+u�M A'�-�,�, x r/ ���
���� `yt +"' YS�.'�:.�SA p.ti.,4 6 ,:a � ' c, .�yy ..tf A r r_�y. (t�,. ..�,w. .¢�.'rshY�O, , ��St,��� �� �`M' .
.i:�'�' �,rr.. a :: �.�y"(:t ; . ;� t r�k ..ii..�^v . ::.� �.�.��r� � �1��a �, �^�_'� -,. r 5,�., � ra�.^t+ 3r�`-�.�''�t�y.�o7�f♦ �4�r�c,�.'.h��"; n �' A,.�`{����+t G�r/�a.�2�
�s .� ''..�� �y�'..�_��' .i 4a ;'j.a� �'^�`,Y �+•Y *�1 � �, �jk�t'�y� ^��� l `e�,.,��� �'d�T�� 4.� 'i....>�`,3�-st� '�4,:�i,'�'� yt�
M,�� �4 .sm ;:�.�}�'� ,g ;rxn�t. •.�� � , �! .:•/�,� t �'�'"e,:��$...� ` �'Sy}f��,"�'#47.�`xr'1 ���r.�.�4kJ"�.�Yf�+�l�f;�;,y 1�'c��,�`�.�Py yv� .. �,tt..,T � '�'�.'�,;^�N�'�`,.:y{
r.,.. ' � >.�,�Y ..� 4 f"v a�°`�i„h"� �y��E��k�W� �. 1 �-�" t ,':..) 2 ..\ ' t"�`��: �"�'1}f' �`i ��'V^ fyY�.��',w .,�...K•J'�..�s �; .`�* '. 1.
�'?`,� >f t' r� rT�. "..��' � �,_ y f Ca " Y` +� xr`�tr`��: yl'A�f �_�;,Gi' ��S 4 tiy �t .�•Y ,j,s, � �": A
� . . � ' I �.., 6t� ..� �� �,'� � � �J�. lr�.t�b::.. �hy�i�j's`'i < '`� `��'� :y,,'��,Rt� . _ Z ,,:r,
kf� i� t ..i'�.y,
"`� , �^^����'��t +��vy.,� `,�.I,� � ��.��t ,�,.*•'���,� �jt �`"�a�#��?s:.�t+�� ,T•!�'�.�•jt,���.`_f �,�k'`1�. �l. `k;� � ' ,
.�`j�� �.F.�. . �.�°{t4� x, �t 3.: i 4 . #� il }7j f�. +;S""-���1 1 'r ,� t,�` ���rJ"�,�t�� �,µrUi"�t���1-�,�,�,,,5' +.. . .. . . .R.
�- ''atJ � �t ���� d !i x ��;'. ,y� �:;�i �'�'�. �,' .c � ����1„u R ti����:1„r'� %"'�a: �t � .� sv
�.�`;� d r a :_��p�.-�e�,'�,,,�{ / �y�`� .:< k�. '� T, � `�1�,. ."3 r�,,.. 'v ►' > 1�`L��' .h) s'�' �ri/5`� �i+
s• �, v ^T-sT.�4S17•�y ^�i�r�?`+���.���� i�}�ay'1� p'»+..�'Y �`�w� �`; ... ",�a"Y "S�` ", y,�+c�r,�t� � ��;��'.F�'�l�y`t�,�l�{t,3`��y�i�ayX���.�. .
V 3 a N � ��//`14.� uf�c I f �� K� � aFJ�j�� s [� ,;+�'� �,3f`'(�s, k r�'�" Y J� �� ��.1� �� #�i f'�t�l,���i 1 s .���� /�
YH �� i. : �Y' E . t�u4� !" \, r�T �f V>1 �. '��' Y ` -
r; 7�';;�,c� �� .M� .'y?r�r�.'��� '�,rf..;�y� ::�� "` �'�;. `+�4�.'�Y&� .,y,.�a� �f�». `a{�,,'��4,.�.a�� '��, �"w`:`}.�"� �"�►•�_",;f,ti��'''7` RE�E�vE�
r�.� '�. ,..�� �:Y�n y . ..JY� -t���� ����r','�r .i�� � .^+y �� YN;_ �e4,'y�,{�4s.�';�t"#-1}+'�� � ����:y�,���-.*'` - .
� �� tk' � ,� 3� Y ,�� 11' �� ''`��� ��'1 .� w . aa �ry i t�y �,N� M r 7+f�.a��'M � +i.
{� !' l :. .. � 1�, �b�� 'b f .. 3`{ � Y I��t f � T ..
< ..� . ' ��„ �„�,'`�,`J�M� �sih�°i"r�r""Fw�!��� �_�i=��a r^ d�,"'y.r`1;•�1„e �j�' � t�..��`- ��o� .lr��;�����,,� ,"�'��al�, ,}y �".Y'•Y'.r j V 1, � �
� ,,,_ '� ' ���
. c .'�� St '` ,,�,�� .'r,g Y:dr «.sy" �.' t s ., k i .6,:,.4 k r i3 F,'f jte' - �:.a,�� . �w�►':�-,` _ ��. t-?
�i i �' 'RfSr- 'rA ��{ � 5 �.t ..� � ����?� s. 4',�� S; �' f'j,.S}d'C�
��� - � T;3,r �7 . i r .vk s ax; 4. ��} � ,. � . .F �'r a.�1,�{!� l S'*
: ��,._. ._ ,s... :. � ,& ;'��. r ,.r a -x:.. >�'.z:- e : :.� _�'� �' "!. �'�l+�� ro '"��,,+ytiEacs. 1.�
�s.�'�."0�'4�,J: �. .�`.�,'� .v �' �ti�4"�#'1��>�'S�� *.. � r �',' °E..�t .. � �� z �" 3�)�..�!'��'�!' �%���t �.��ti��w.,��-i'�,`, '� ��TY 0� O�ONO
:Sk+ ..{ i 1*`•:�� ',,,,��`'4Y`'�;-��'���:��3�yhf,�,��.<�.r�. �.ix ,� 6�+1.Y i '�1 �± y���y�i.�' �t, 'F y',�i . , . ,'J������ �i�'^�rs�d;�'_t'.'� ��,.,�¢,���',� .
,
�S' � ,,;:� �' �: � . .�..° s :-. r t '�^]�'� ..t.� ' � p ' . ' �.<, ._ . �F` ., ..`�,,.� �t�I'."^1 y3....r+�.,RrJ��!t.;.�,.4.�' ,.a� r�..,^a. nan�t�': ..'�+: �,'
,_ _ . ,.a:. . , , . ., . . . . .