HomeMy WebLinkAboutzoning ordinance complaint-1974 'rsq' "# ,. �� �g . '�
�}.µ,�}��ti�Cp�� � �,� �kv¢�•�� �::t �P'rf� >�.: A`�f,k k '§,.�„qr. Y�7� Y''� ' `�� ..�s.�'i.�� a� �i'"Y'� r "�a'`F� ',:��� � � ti�
� � ����SL�����' r� .' �c . �'+�� . � � r
9
$ ��...'�l,¢i��� �'r�' ��^�tl�a ,j� t 1��E '$� °�,1 i�s Y .• ._ �a t ��, A t�`�a"` k r'i,v��,�`'�� �`'-; j'�
��z 1 a s, a �a � � "� �`� �i 4 � a k� ��_: � r,��n�„� ? sY e. '"� � n':�,� U,
�'" � i a'�..•�-. � . � r;
;' '' �# J f $� 3 S f 5 '+ �' r i�' a�s'R' �'�>'�` .�r���. 3�g,..y.a s� U"" �
1 5 ; �y J y
^V' f )q' �'Y3�'T`�,�) A '�.
r
� rf H t ; . #5 � . .._ .._ . .W........ ... ...........a.,. .a..,�,.. :........� . .�x,.x... .'�'.'��t`r�"-�,.,p��w •��t�E� �.�
"�n ,�, �..._..-...:-5..,..�.u4wC.LL.�.a.d:.a ...:....,.r'�+ae�iJ.'.a.....,cW. �.. � }.�. a �IaFb I'Vi�i "��i7 ��?�.
i
' "� J� �l'r-�v.�r
� , � � � �, 5 � •'-
; � �'�- - '. � - ry ���e� -� �
�: . �j C ;(N G 1� ����- - • �
rJ .S.c\'- . ,. ,���;. �I�� 1 � �. . �
�` ►��-�� �t ��;,�-� �� �-� ,-�- �-� , �
'� �` i�,� �5 _ �� _ _--�.�- ';�`-`�-�� �
QL'070� i'it:I1C.'',o�7 �
Ilovember I. I974
1
4d�t the undresigned, reside� ts of C��co Foint, village of �
Orena, atrenuously ob�ect to :.ha_ we believe to be a flagrazt ',
vialatiiou af the zoniag ordinances of our villare.
� �he rssidence at 3510 I�y Flace is on � lot Luned for �ingZe
f��_.rQ�id�nce,. During ths� paEt ysar, xhile this pro�p�rty oraa
� lq�n� �%Richard Tyle:� a �truc��.u�a on ths back of the lat xas
` _ rtz�tt�d;,t� D. Ta�eaoa �o u.�sed it aa � resydencs. It �s our belief
t4iat. �#.�t,�3trt�etura f�ila tQ maet_thG.n�i�u,�t r,ec�uireaan* ���,�.�.•i.,.,
� ::;';. + � ��" . 'liv.ing iini'� in thia' ♦illage. Zt' is appar�nt ��� ` _
.,�'�':�.: : �etr`tictur� is far belo�rc the atandard tar tbe nQighboz'hoo�tfo ��_
�� , PQ2.Iaxing a fire in th� vrinclp�l structure on �hia 3et
aarlie�r this yeRrt th� atrcuture rre�g vacatdz '
Iti- 1.� a� berliof that the prot+�rty haa now bean aold 14►
g.�:c3ierc�: '1�x�; �a D. Jamsson who has mcvod i�to thc 2a�osr I�1 ��'
� `r*�� or�t�3te �inci�l struatura and 2ia+s ag:eed t� rent t� �r Ze�el
`� �,
� ' a� tlu: �c�sae b�x•uc turc. to th� Tylers, �akizg n �cta3 ot C�+s . 4 :.�- -* '',.
�� a ;3 �L;r,ytfi 2i�g ci:�tC or. a �.ot �.oned for =ringle ismilT- reaidenae. ,,•'. .
��� �:�:,�,�
� � ' � . . r�.,�.
��°�''�' �:.�,.canaid�r these c�ages, �.i true, tie bQ violstioaa o�' tb+�
vil:lagt crrdinanc�s s contreiry to tbe normaZ canaidera�ion� �en�d
{r ,� 3.a eases ai non-confors�ing uaa which mny have e�sted �ri�r tQ
� ;;:� `• � the sale af the g:ope��'ty� and a detrnction from th� vRlugs ot et:r
�'" '"`''' � si'n ze �a.rail renidencem.
°�M��`c�:� g- Y -
d ���'4� � ' � � .. �
��7itsk �'� " '� 1rd�Q therefare� respectit;lly requaet tha� rou re�eat � � ia
. _ . • �y.� �tHer l�ga1 and �us� kay, abe truc t t�,s iaauanc e oS 23.�anaea
' ca� p�x�xita that raould enable �orer t?:sn oae �aa�ily to legally occupg
tha lot��at 3s10 Ivy n].aee.
�fi •,� - ... .. ' , -c�?� . " .'.DDRr.SS � 'P$Z.. 1�`-�. `;
� �
,�. .� � �,��� ,;�%���r s�s,� r�; �° y�,i ��6y � . -
;A
';��c s�a..'C `��. �r..�-�,/v �`'''',.r� '` � �„^ '�7�— ���i� ^�
� , v : : � s,'�,. (.��,'-.�-�,�.c ��� s-°' '',�"� I'C. y T� - �c�y .
� � r.. •
*� �; •�r ;;��- ' ''� � . , - 3 a � i �,�.,�a �� �r � �_�.a�.3
'',�e����� ':.- _ �� a � � w • �.! %1 -7�' .2 �
�6 a7:. _ /, �� 3st�� Cd;uc Ccc . e/
�` � �,�c�G��z� a _'�..:-tc�-�"'.- , I , ,�(�"/ .
n �� 3 y'-7 C'a..�e �......� `
� ���...�-a.�-� • .J -��.G/ , � 4 1 1 ' 0 d S J
� � (+ 3 ">�j �..c:��:'o !.� �� �
� a� �.{����
.,
� � � i -?� '
; `� i�..f; r' � ?�' , -%.,��.�.o, -' �'�,' ��r.�.�' t� , �! ; � ° .
_".� �`: ,�`j ���s-s..b��. ' 3 '�° 7 1 .l� c�. '? ! — ��.�'� „
.
' i� 'i,(.c:,?��,"y�� :.' i�"t `�:.n:�r � ,t� . j !, ` , /C/`' . .
� �� .� ` . , . j�' ✓� , . . '>`/ .,�<<` , . . � �J .7 �•�
.�_ _ .._,... _.. .. __ .--• - . . . _ -
. . . .u.'f_ . c.�..�� �� . � ,. . ' �. � . . � .. �. . R . s��.�^��'� \ .. . . �S4�F�T'�'G�.
, _ ,. p. ,a �;r�
. ;:..�: , . _� ..�� _ _ , r . _, . :.
� r _,
_ . . .�.. . ... ..
,� , , . . _
�-� �� �
y`�/ �Lt .� J`_ i
� s
�
�
T0: Dick Benson, Village Administrator ;
FROM: Mike Scheller, Building Ins�ector
DATE: rovember 8, 1974
SUBJECT: Tyler-��:neson Property Complaint Progress Report - 3510 Ivy ?1,
Whe,1 I received information that r:r. Jameson bought the Tyler property
and were moving in the basement part af the house and another family
in the upper part, I sent them a letter, a ccpy in your possession. �
Mrs. Jameson called or. receipt of samc and wanted to know who i
ccmplained. I told her there was a complaint coming in on x
ilovember 7, 1974, witn a �ist of names. This is now in ouz possession.
To date, there has been no ca21 to obtain the final inspection or •
certificate of occupancy. In �hE event the�e is a double usage of
� the residence, they would be guilty of two viclations. I would say
that we should wait to see what the ultimate use of this property
is going to be. One cannot prosecute on hearsay. Jameson says "-
Tyler is still the owner of the property. We are not concerne3 with
ownership, only usage.
1
�
�:
;
� � f
�: �
,
�� , ���
.;
; ° .
. ...� . .,. , . . . •
:
. �, _ „�v;,r� .�� . ,.. . a� ,.�_ .>._... _
'� _ Y'f., �
� . .
� �
TO: Henry Muhich, Zoning ��ir.ector
FROM: Mike Scheller, IIuildinq Inspecror
DATE: November 18, 1974
SUBJECT: Ty1er Property - Final Inspec�:on - 3510 Ivy Place
I inspected the subject property at 10:00 n. M. today. The ttouse
is presently designed for two £amily occuF�ar�cy. The layout consist� of:
'� ' First floor - two bedrooms, two '�aths, livinyroom with L-ireplace,
•;'� . kitehen and utility room. Sec-ond f loor - onc� bedroom, one bath,
� ' livingroor+� with fireplace, c�ie kitchen, onc� utility room. There is
1'' ';' one electric service, one furnare, on� watc•r ��nd s�w�r billinq.
� ,
� The lower is Yresently �,ccupie�d hy Mr-. r� Mrti. D. .7<,mt�son, who stated
ttiey are only staying there until. the h�usc• nc�y ,�rc c�nstrurting
� Y in Minneapolis is fini�•hed.
i
� The upper is occup;�d �y the owner.
�
i<: e�
��^� The small �;ther house on the �roperty is v�c:int and is a non--conforming
�'� �� use.
,,.
� �.::.
� ,`",` Bruce Malkerson stated the Tylcrs havc ��ontncted him ancl are forwarding
•" 1 letter to him. He said wc shoul.d do r�o ta<�yin� until he s�ys we
+.� �, shou ld.
I issued no certificate of occLpaiicy.
1
1
;
i
�
; .;
, , ,
��
�i
:�
�
�
�
:;,:
:;�
. Richar-1 H. Tyler
• 3508 Ivy Placc
� Y �layza[a� Ninnesota
'�9
•�,�••
. � • November 19� 1974
• Mr. Bruce Malkereon
;' . � Attoroey for Village of Orono
. 4344 I.D,E. Center
- • Minneapolis, Kinnesota
• , Re: Property at 3508 and '3510 Ivy Place - Wayzeta - Oropo Village
' (par� of Taylors Sub Division)
��...�K• � �:
.� j-,
�ear Mr. Malkerson: �
{ , ,
• This is Sn reference to the peticion prepared t>y on^ of our nci�hbors, signed
`'�.,��,, • by others, dated November 1� 1974. Aiso in rcfezence co our rcquest for
, j�";', inspection of our home at 350$ Ivy Pluce for yurpose of occupancy pe:mit.
� i. First the Peti[ion
we have bcen advised this petitio� vas prepared by a Mrs. Bartakovaki� one �
� '� of our nei�hbors� snd that you have a copy of �l,is petition. Wc ask your e
'� .,���, consideration of the follovi�a in reference to the parag:apha contaiaed in �
f �?z r..J", the pe[ition: �
A�
��""' ' �. Para ra h 2 of the �
�Rr.,-: • . g p petition atatc: "The residence at 3510 Ivy Place is
'F- zoned for single family residence. . . ." This is correct, the house at
�' ;
� 3510 Ivy Plnce ie a single family residence ond hae nevcr been used f�r �
-� . • eny other purpose.
;� t ., �
f , This paragraph (2) siso �efers to a "structurc on the back of the lot", �
.. r r' ' �
,;� ,., As mentioncd, there is on2y one .�ouse sc 3510 lvy Plc�ce and St docs �
f r.iore th:tn mee[ the mininuai rcyvircr.,c•ncs for a s[andard of living unit fn t
�"' tnie village. The house has airendy been inapected by the Orono Insgec[or �
Y,�'��.:. "I,' .
• and approved, and I invite you to personally do so. � ' j
; .
'' `:� b. Paragragh 3 zefers to a firc at thc "
, .. pr'_ccipnl structurc". This "s[ructure"
`,,q�; ie at 3508' Ivy Plnce, �ot 3510. There �3s a fire abouc �tay 1, 1974, and
' . ve did nove ou[ ter.iporarily while rcpnirs vere being maJe. Hovever. ve
" uerc at L1�2iX��il�f the housc almost daily uhtle repairs Hcre bein}; n:adc, and
, � ' movcd back in as soon us vc could, so I doubt this vould be considcre�i a�
y'�' �. "vacaced" in [he legal sense.
,
' c. Paragraph 4 is almoet totally nonsense. ae havc not sold the houae co the
Jamesons, or anyone elae. ,
' (
• At preaent, the Ja�aesons are temporarily stayinR in the dovnstairs separa[e
apartment of our tvo family house located at 35Q8 Ivy Place. oot 35I0. �
, They have purchused a houae in Min�eapolis� buC for a numbcr of reason�, "
-' vill not be moving into i[ ImmediRtely. They will be staytng vith us �
�
. until their arrangementa are cornpl�ted. Iz is difficvlt for us to see hov
, anyone conld make a ca�e [o aupport the statement that thQ Jameson4, �
viaiCing vith us for a vhile wuld detrnct from tht value of chc housea ¢;
owned by tht pt[itionere� Mr and Hr.. Jamcson art co-ov�ers of e '
:
r� _.
� A,,,.. �.. ,_ .
�;:� _ _ >: . ._ _ ,
. . ; ,
, . , t
. � •
. " ,,
�- - thriving busineas in t��c Wa��r�ta sLo,�yt;i:: c�ntcr, r,nd Kr. Ja:,c�on i
' II
T6.;. . pre3ident elect �4 tf�e ti7ayzatA �I,nmber of C��.;,,�,-cc.
'; %�;�1 would be a much bettor neiShborhood uitn more familics l:key[he1Janc�o�s�
" �� d. Para�rr•ah S stateo "WQ consider [hcae char�;es, i ` tr�,� to b
.,:: .
5,,� • ' `�� t1i�Y nre n�t �r u e� I a s s u m e v e are noi in viola[1 o n�and requeat�the i on..,"
, - petitle:�ere be so advierl�
' �wy .
� >..¢ • e. Pnra�.re h 6
P requeets you [o re�ject or ob3cruce che issua�ce of Iicense or
`,.:,:.`
perQ.tts that Nould cn�ble more ti,�n one f.�mii• [�� occu
� , Ivy Place. Aa cbove wentioned �l;ere , �„ : ?Y the hou�c a[ 3510
• "• ' thi�hou�c. � � ncvcr .,,i.. ,ecn rrwr� tl�nn onc family Ln
2so, as [his tiou�c ��Zs not lnvolv•�.i i�i [hc :irc� n butlZln;;
, , p�rni[ F•ns no[ t.:kr� out und :C c,�;,� no[ awnrc CI.•�t
M a-�uld bc requircc Cor nn c>;1cCin^ x•�:icencc, lJ� i,.��;j_��`F� occu;.:ncy perml[
r .. .he ;hc�e of thr ]ot nt 3510, [he house iu exiniing unuerntnc � c bn�'�use oz
��,': of non-conforminL usc. 'ihc rirl�t co conttc,uc [;,,� 11�� ���$ ��_ Pro�•isions
f.,�-}`'t timc wc purchaacJ the prorert rif:ed �t the
�� contact m• �; Y• 'ror Lnforr,�.tio�� uci tiiia m�[tcr� plcase
;�.*-' �Iv�.� �` attorneY► � r. Tom it�(e��Lord nt Y���vc and Reicr:+�;ord, 6250 Wayza[a
� r:inneapolis _ 554I6.
• �. � .
t�;.,�. We would o��reciate you Ldvising us��s ;c,vn n:3
� • petttion Will have concernin,, tne �inLle family�Jwcll.�;;�at'�3510 I�ctpi�f any, [he
i .�`
? t - Y ce.
4. ' 2. Our Reaidence at 3508 Ivy Ylace:
.
. �,x
�..•.;' Aftrr �'eceiving the nbove me�zioncu pctztion, a rcj,rescn[a[ive o: Chc Villa�;e
;,,'_� .. tclephoncd :�r, Jameson ut t�is I:�y���n �torc nnd ;�dv;,��d �},�r� ��� n
'�y•'.�� � pera,t ty3uec: for .our houee st 3508 Ivy Ylace r.nd t1�a[ [he Jac��;eon��(hecd;dncy
�:�~ not men[ion the Tyleru uho own t}�c
�<,.;'�. and up to 9p daye in Jai1 for I�v:nrroperty) wi•rc 3U��CCC to a S300.00 fine
•'";�,�' - Thc buildir�, ,� in s hou;,c viu� no occu
� permit cor [li� r�-,airs Lo tt�r. Lo�,ac u,,� ��}_��i outnby �cot�tLCoastruc[ion
':!;.;. Co. w;io �ii_c: no[ proper.y close� ti�r. p�rm:t. Wi,cn ue leo.n�d of [his, I callec:
�� �• at the S'ill�,;e and requested thr. I1nzI ina,,cction, At thia
y�� ` eroat concernin� thc non-confonning u�c 1,�, point the question
��.z:� �•.• Wc submir the follow��� ;ar your consiJcrr:[iu11L�o-f:,nily usc at 350£3 Ivy Placc.
c ,
s. in :li.,� �:� t���•,:�;� 1.ou: :�, f u�• ' � -
lor �t;c s;�lr: vi tiie •. . .. ,t: .,� ... : ;i�• _.�:
::1',':1, I:n 1•C���iC-� [J 1iT1 .7t�
. . P'"�'���y' .:C 350S-1U Ivy I�lucc. One ot our bnsi¢ rc:;uirenen[s
ti'ns Chat thc house I�ave n sepr_rncc livin� u.cn bc�,:use I u :
'".�`.'�� •vith us, 24rs. Crnycc SIAck, uould . .
. a�y [hen Iivin�,
70 and Z c�xpccteu [��aL oi�c vr botL ofu[licrnlr;.;�i Lut.4�ofn�yiPa�iCtsu���n ovcr
not [co ciis[�nt futt,zr_ r,r.�t, 3� tJ},;:il aII �ul chil,l1•�:❑ u��v�d aWuy, [hc se;nra�c
�.: nrcn coul�! producc an incoinc for us,
,,:
. s:
�, . Wc wcre ��nr�lcularly i�it��r.c:.t�•c. in [hirt i�uu^,_• t,�•c.lu::c it �.•n� ort�:tnally I,ui::
� E a� a cluPlex. t,t Lhc ti�,ic we C�r::C in:;r�-ctr�,
� in the t�ou,^>e (Lot�r sdu][r ;,� - <<'`� ��'�"'��'. [hcrc �,rcrc Luo far.,ilica
, �). e clid n��[ };nve enou�,;, �n�h to m.ikc thc rcqucstcd
` ; cokn pn��«� �n� Lc�r,n i��rotia[ton:; fur rcr,[in,; �.,��I, an op�1on to buy, ieforc
we could completc Cheae negotiati.ur�s, Che owncr: Lol� the housc.
f
' We contiuucd to an;;ver ads r�bout 19'r.e housec, t:e ��;c:t uith � Mr. Jack Corl
r 'W�:o� it turned out, va8 ti�e buycr from tl�c previou:� ux,iers of this property.
;_ At that Cic�e� �Ir, Corl vs� in fieuZ lis�nCe� nnd also uwn-�1 the housc next �oor
�� . �° 3508 vherc he and his vifc Werc living, ile ua� u;terin�; bo�h houses for
` ,J aale and a�iviaed us he had hopcd the ott�cr hou:�c v�uld �_lI ii,st as lie and
�. ' hia vife were considerine living 6cre and rentiu�- �ut [i,o �ou�L_air8 Qpr,r�,pcnt,
;ir . ,
;<,. .
' ...j�'�. . .
�'
.�;�:�k�'��
�.
.y .,:. , u.... .. . . _ ..._:;. . ...
CTy .O
Y ., y. �w� �;` ^.� $r'�,'".�, �ti. �` . . _ .
>��= . ... � .
� �, _r, -3- ,
�`� . r� ' �
�;;� ��f�` �
� ,�, Mr. Corl then ahoved us what We had
; � ` ' previously becn awore of; that chc house h�d
j �, been buil[ as a duple�: - that chc d�wristnirs apartment included a co�ple[e kitchen,
" � bedroom, bath P
� livin room and diniii�; area, It �lso had sePArate furnace controls
; �� �.� and a separa[e ho[ vater heatcr. In othcr aords, � cor..plecely sc�arate and self-
�, � conteined apartment.
� Once again, ve dfa not have enough cash for the I
� f � in under n rentai purchase agreement and completedlthe�accual�ent so we moved
, �r�: � house in May of 1970, purchase of the
c�--.� � b. Icoed+acely up�n moving into the house, Mrs. Slack occupied the doxns[airs a artm
,, ar.d continced to do so for approximritely I8 month::. In the approximn[ely six ent
�.. ,
years vc have been here, I do noe bclieve thcrc havc bc
, ':��:
tha[ the dovnataizs aaar[n,ent has not been occupicJ. Eve��heniwendidXno[nparticulerl
�--� "- want othera to be livi�g here, ve feI[ it vns
'
standpoint Which I �rill explain in pnra�raph 3necessary fron n "care[eker" y
��;��- • c. Petitio� states that t�ao family use of ouz home at �;08 Ivy Pluce would cause
. reduction in neighborhood proper[y values. I do noc bciicve the facts bcnr this
«'�`: �.� out. Por one exAmplc, the house next door to us vas sotd for $5L,000,00 in 1970
•.� i, end W�a again sold last surrmcr for $76,OOO.UO. A vaLue incrense of more th�n
���-j, SOX in four yeara would not seem to me to be a losc in value. I pbin[ ou[ thac
this value f.ncrease occurred durin� [he period our house xus used as a ts�o-Eamily
. house.
3. �?ueationeble mo[ive behind this petition:
,;',� We have bcen advised that thc petition wus instigatcd by a Mrs. Partnkovski, a not
'.'� . too friendly neighbor. We have had consfderable
; i'�oving here. I believe an explanation of thesc problemmsWillhsuppor[3ourYfeeling that
''�-��er motives vere based more on vindictiveness and desire [o harrass [han any fear of
. ' loat property values as stated in thc pc[ition. �or the r.:ason of this explanation,
't ; ' t�e submit the follokin�:
- a• When we first moved here, two of Mrs, E3art�kowski� sons con[inually valked across
� :.;,„
our prop�r[y on their wliy to an� from u public hcuch are:�. As �+e entertained � lot
[his became an annoyance� and we askecl the�n to stop, Znsta:.d of sto in,>
�+ � increased their activity and beg:in tnrowinr rocics, �;I:,.;s ,���� other debris�inhour
yard and in thc uQtcr near our docic, (sy son's fo�t w�s b;:d:y cut by tt broken
�. boctle [hro�,m in the water), I callcd on Mrs, IIarcnl,owski to ex lain thc
'"'� and she adviued me hec sons would "no[ do such u [hin�", The boys continued�bIInd
`�' added ro thc harrassment by stnnding just off our pr���,crty und yelltng obacenities
a[ my vifc nnd our p,uests,
`°+ b. 'ine Bar[akowski doq camc into our ynrd ncarly evcry niy;ht and tippecl over our
;�.
Farba�;e c:ins. W,- complained ot;ai.n to Mrs, &nrtakuvski and received no cooperaticn,
to sny ti:e l��ast.
' �. �praren[ly no; likin� our com,laints, chc B fnmily rqczliuted by a nu:.iber of
harrassments which included filin� a claim a;;ain9t us under the leash ordinanee
boc.au;e our do� was not a2ways on a lcash ulien out of the y3rd (hc is now), Cae
or hoth of the boys have brolcen i�to our house on n; lcast cuo occasaions� scelcn
ornacr,ental fixture� off the exterior of our house� sec off fire crackers Ln our
mail box and have vindov peeped, Other annoyance4 vc i,�ve suffcrcd since Iiving
here (bot huve no proof the Bartakoti+aki boys were involvcd) tnclude more than a do�en
, e�bs thzoc+n on ary nev Buick, all Windous broken in roy Jcep snov plow� Theftof about
J 5200.00 in coins from our bedzoom� theft of liquor, capes and othcr items off our
boat� Our vuluable pet Peacock killed by a b.b. Run shoc in the neck� our pec ca�
injured by both a b,b, fiun ahot and bcirig hit by a roc«, Ovr re�;istered AKC German
Y =
�aA}t��:� ,}ti '..3 "�" �,f * � t r x..� : r t:,.;, �.;r`.« ,��` .
w � .�,,.�
. . .m,.t.r'r..a ... . . . , . ... . . . . . . ..
� ���
' ,I
V,�:
y� •
`',i` She erd do isoned vith ut chnine. I covld add cunsiderab?y more, but perhape
:k'1�: D K P� rS'
�:,,� ' thia will give you tt� idea.
�,y.•,� ,
. I fecl that if Mrs. BartakoNski uas erviy �onccrncd :•ho�rt loss in property values
�"'"�� sbe �.+ould have [aken [hc trouble .[o ascertain the ��� b�forc preparing l,cr
�`��tj'� petiti4n, IE the facca had b�en truly st::ted in ' .:titic n, I do not belicve
'{ � , [he other neighbora �+ovld have signed. Perhaps Mrs. B. vas n�.�nre of this and may
,;+'::�� � have choaen to ignore the f�c[s for thie renson. I du not, of coearac, knov this
''��y to bc so, but her paat a�:.iona r�+ould scpsr+ �^ avpporc this belief. ? do slncerely � •• "
t'~'�""'`� .r�gzet that the Village of Oroao had to become invoived in thia petty neighborhood
��''y . problew. ;
'i: .
I would appreciate yo� edvisin� us ds soon ns posaibla� ti�c dispoaition of the Pctition
_ and our request for occ�rn�ncy permit Qt 3508 Ivy Place. If you require additional
information, I Will av�pty it to you as qufckly as po^siblc.
"`�, . .
N?`'�, . . � .
:.'�.,
-t�etp truly youre�
� ' ���
� �
��� G ��_
•'.�K ' !i. 7'• er .
� �
y
.,��-�
:�a
�g ���,���. .. �
t'''�,F J. . .
��
••a,J..
%y. •
� ��� .
f'J
Y,P�3'Y
:�:�e..i r�e.. .
;u.� �sr= � . .
!4'`�"��t�.ti�. ,
.�i �µ
R'
�y< .
I .
ydn_
,�.�¢;►;.t-.� -
;
;..�.,
�f''"••
R
�'a'�iJ '
���f •
���
�
'�
�,.
�d[ Y:'� i ,,-5-� ''-.- ,",�. m' '* ��_.
_ ^`���5: ;%` `}.
i; ����
- � ;y�:.
,
, • I•i
, " �'y
• ,
� • ;f v"`
' .-�
. � ' ' d
.
_ ...
+�
•' Y
.r � .
� ��.
1
, • . • • � . y�i.
� /'..
r' _ - .
.� _._.... _. .._._ " __ _.._.�
;:� /{_"'"_'_" 'C . . _ ..''_.. _
"
I � �; / '
�F . ��C��y� �� ��,a T E �. (� ' �� ���
//` �//\ ����` .T_— , �..__��
/ //�.���1l��� �
//
- / '�..\.l.{ -r .. � / �
:� ;R � .�u`�-- � �
o i � ��� I
� � � �� � I
;M; , �.
B �i�_� �
t ' ` �' �----- I
� T� � � G�-� � I
�o, � - �
,
: ,
, --—
, _ - ----
, -- - ,
�-_____ _ _. __ __ ----- �f -� - -- -- - / ___ -.-
, � - //���
, �, . . .. .'_._. " ." � �
j��._'�_�- ���i��� " 1
C _ . - --- �Q _ J � `�l
+" , t �y �/ �
� ! o� _����,.._�-C._- .��f1 /�' ��� "
�M (� ..�':� / /""`� � C t �-� r
;E' ��CP�c�.T' ��C�v��� - _��
�S `� � � ��e'��-c� �-Of .
's' �� C��� ��� � �
,A J ._ �./
i�, /,� - ,� - �� �ct-c��--�-�.��� � - �
;E I
� ,
i I S'.C,NED
I �-
.�—`/i�� ,'J /J �.�7 �� �.
I /I/��7 ""' ./ J��A�'" �"�C!� .�C�1Z�c.-+ll �i/L LCG �-C L '/�IIy"L
�p. � � � %� � ��_{ /7 ���/ti� �
P i .�t'`"� -� GG��-�-�''-�"' -Ls�,�.-.-L.zd� --�":�ct ��, �'---��' _ I
� ,
�_ � E'� � �,�� � c�' ��z �-.'�+�-t.�'�/J o� ��� �.c.�����-�r
� � P I `y � �f � " �. ���! �`, i
'� �! C� t �� Lt� //�!L�-- ^ � � ��y---;...f-� s,_rL�..c �-tL
+'�. � /
� t �
` 1� Y� yyL /YI�Cr�l/ ' /J'l,{.Q-CL�-y�,c�C'�'LGt�s�� '/ - �-�j�.�ft��G�3�.' nc��Z,n,�
,'`�s;,a. + i r
} � ' SIGNED
�� a:��`-'e��------ ------- ------ - __ _.__ _____ - �
_ ---- ---- -------- -
. .
.o�w o� so•+zo SETdD PARTS 1•3 ti1'3T}i CARf30N 1(1TAC.`T--F'A:ZT 3 SHOULD 6E RF:TURNED\ViTH T.�P�Y i
:
� . . '._.._'_'"�.-.. . � �`�.;�,��t
.
�, � _.. ____�._ - -_
;�' ;�� �}`s '' Y �'`
I�IIIv�LTTES OI' A COUNCIL 2�1EETING fIELD DEC�t�iBER 2, 1974 pg�Q 6
, /'FYLER CObiPLAINx
Hir. Tyler was preser�t to discuss with the 1/ 3508 Ivy Place
City CounCil the violati�ns that have be�n
pe�itioned in reference to the property he
•owns at 350a Ivy Place. Several questions
were posed relating 'to t:�e condition o� the
property, the existina 3uplex, and the
; utility unit charge assessed against the
property. .
V�elsh moved,Paurus secondad, to table until �
the secor_d meeting in January, 1975 whc�n
i�ir. Tyler will respond to tne complaints
that have been raised. Motion, Ayes (4} -
• Nays (0) -
lY
�{ �zurus moved, Welsh seconded, to am�nd the FEE SCHEDULES
c::dinance and provide for a resolLtior. as
the foremat for establishing or changing
,:;t: fee schedules. Motion, Ayes t4) - Nays �0) .
`�. PUBLIC HEARING D?�TE
' �Iassengale moved, Paurus seconded, that � �exoning
public hearing on the rezoning for the City
of Orono on December 18, 1974,� at the Orono
High School Cafeteria, be ordered. biotion,
Ayes (4) - Nays (0) . _
VARIANCE
Paurus moved, Welsh seconded, that the 1331 North Arm Drive
��ariance request for Arthur Ah�_m, 1331 North
1�rm Drive, be deferred untiZ December 10,
1974, when more information will be available.
biotion, Ayes (4) - Nays (0) •
EgLpLOYME�IT
t•?�lsh mo��ed,Searles seconded, that James Li uor Store
G. La-rsen be employed part-time at the 4
Liquor Store at a salary of 52.�� per hour.
Hiotion, Ayes (4) - Nays (0) ,
EMPLOYMENT
Welsh moved, Searies seconded, tha� Howard Li uor Store
G. Ilanthei be enployed L art-time at the g
Liquor Store at a 5alary of $2.3� per hour.
Aiotion, Ayes (4) - Nays (0) .
,
� � SALARY INCREASE
;; t�%,assengal� moved, We1sh seconded, thaL the Li uor Store
salary of Tim Oglund, part-time employee �
R� � at tne Liquor Store, be �ncreased from
:�n 52.34 per hour t� $Z.60 per hour. tio!:ion,
,_� A��es (4) - Nays (0} .
,�
,,y
',,x;
'::�
t,;,
,-���
Y,,,,,;
«�'
��
,.r
._
. . . . � - ---------_.____. ...��es,.�.�.<�,.�:,�.,re�.,.�n:..r�c.m�ae.�ix�°.e.�., . . ,.._. . ,.,.
<
,i`tr {,, .� � � .e�" '�"d`�' t�„¢a `' ,,�;'.� "` �i'�Y `"u��":�+��i= %;.r �.r, � µ x,
=�.
','�Ap �
'`,�� �
''`�. ���' .
-r K-.
��.`
[
: TO: HJnry M�hich, Zoning Director ,
FRO:�� Mike Scheller, Building Inspector
,�
" � DA'�E: Novenbe r 2 7, 19 7�
i
SI;BJECT: Tyler Property - 3508 Ivy Place (Not tc be confused with
� 3510 Ivy Pl�ce)
: In order for a property to be a non-confor�,.ing use �t ihe present ,
it would have to be the followi��g:
,+� 1. Aetually and legally devoted to a non-conforninq use on Marc� 10,
: iI.
� 1967.
�+� 2. It �oul� not be �iscontinued for ovcr a year at anytim��.
i� �
"� 3. Extended in area.
.:i
�r
' tiow, as this relates to the Tyler propert�• :
�. .. .
, The property on March 10, 19G7 was owned by Dr. Subby. From alI
' the information I can get fro^� neighbors, it was not a duplex. .
� In fact, when the Subbys sold the propert�• to �� r�rty namPd Stevenson,
� :.'k.�y explicitly specified they did not w.ish to nave i t .3 duplex.
� • Stevenson subseque�itly sold to Jack Cor? in 1969 , wh�, �3id not use
� it for a duplex. In fact, thc i'�•lers rcnt��r. it trom Corl the se:�en
' months he owned it a:�d then sol j ir� 1�7U to T.yl�r, rh,� present o�nc�rs.
;�. . There is no record until this t:me th�ar i t ��as �sed .� .i duplex.
�{s � From the mere fact t.hat it was i�o� a •:c::-cc�nforminq u ,�� on N.arch iG ,
1 967 When the Subbys ow:1�d i t , ��ould ,:i sq�,.,1 i fy it :�r .� lc.ta; nv�.-
,f, , conforr,�ing duplex at the �resen t .
From a11 the information I can •,�t •ai �h �ic� c1,�c-u�tcnt.+t �.�n, tl���
;� ,iamesons, who resic� ir. th�� i��w _ ;�<�r�., h,i���� t.��en st •E>:; `.o c>urcha� .
Sr HC' �:J::�t"`
:y � _
Fegarding the secoad hcu_e, �ili !-h� r�•c�or.iti k•c� hav�, ••'�o�w� � :ontinl:�us
usag_- prior to b�arc!i 10, 19f.� t � ;u�il ; f�_• i r f�r iec;.�i r,c�ti-r��•�Fc�rr,�i:: :
use. i�ur engineer' s s}:etch shc�,:�; r.t�c r:�-r�•�•n F„�r.-h r:, 'h�• ':' t il��;•• .
right-of-wa}' bY aF�roxim��tely i ' . 'I';�: ,���t i.rf. .,rot.� c • • �;.:� -wo
uate: and sewer as:sessmer:tG . I . �.t��>> �• w,� < .� 1�� :.�1 t i� � c�-f �t: . l;� .� ;e
� indi.atcd, there sho,ild ha��� bu� n c�r�•. .
;� � � �
�';�`
t
i
J
i . �
. `� ,
: W McCOMF3S-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES, I(VC.
LONSU!il.':G FYGIi.:ERS C �%+�iD S13Y:10RS 3 SITE PLAN"1�95
�
i
Novem��er 26 , 1974 �
Mr. Dick Benson
Orono City Administrator
P.O. �ox 66
Crystal Bay , t?innesota 55323
r~ Re: Jameson - Tyler residence Casco Point
i
�
Dear Dick :
Enclosed is a sketch of the parcel ef land which includes
Lot 183 and the southeasterly half of. Lot 182 , Taylors Subdivision a�
of Spring Park Lots .
� As shoH-n on the sketch, the on1, existing property corners '
we could find in this area were the �esterly corner of Lot 181 and
the block corner on the south side of Lvy Lane.
Using these two iro_^.s and two n:ore on the west side of Ivy
Lane, we reconstructed the lot lines as best w� �:o�ild. The plat
of Taylors SuLdivisioi� doe�n't have an,.• angles frun front corners
to rear corners nor any i:formation on ttle c�r�.��:� w��:.=h torms the
front of Lots 182 and 1E3.
Because of this lack of inforr„atior. on the plat �nd k�i�at
:-`�,� i ot corners we found in tne f ield , i t will tnke a cons iu'eraLl�.
a:�ou-�t of additional ti:ne to cio � cosi�let� L�Ol1Ill��lry survey �or
t`�is narcel .
�oL�-s very sincerel�, ,
MC:C���:BS-KNUTS�N PSSOCFaTF.S , INC.
� i , '�
:,.� ,;� T�� � -
��, . :��,. .
- >
Thor.ia� S. Berqquist
.�
,g T�B/kr..
�
°�, E;c.
:d05 OLS��ti h1EMOHIAL NIGH:"�4Y 1,11tiNE�1Pl?L��; S1��V�i`�:l�i�� '_:-t11 `_LF�'riONc ,�•.1; 5-�.�,�:.�
�'�� t�� KO'riTH MAIN ST�ifFT NUTCNINSCI^.. 1,!INVESnIs\ '_,_ r`'.f�'HQ'.E '.Eil�'� ,. ' F03;
;�,
' • _
`,� Si)UT`i1\'FST ENGINEERiNG DIVI�i�)N MAH�N�LL � i:!�c`;11i,; -.� _'_ iE�EPH��NE ;`�J? o3i.5S_��
;�. \
�.,
,
, . . �„ �., ,,;. �,;_ ,, � �:z;... � s---= -
� �
;:a
�
�: ���
! � \� �-�
��
��
� ��
� ,; \� �
.- � \�,"�;o
�f / ��-
",�;: \�, -�
_ . ��� ���
. , .., , �` j \
i ' � `�J� " \
e ;�'
� ' N�s �
, �- �
�
: bp 3, �
� s �
. . � B,b� •- � O �
"r• �
�,
���- �NE
L
_ f ..
M,"- _
1*•" , - _� b'r�'1`
SKETCH OF:
Lo� 183 and rne �outheasrerly hal°
of Lot 182 , Tay�ars Subdivision of
Spring Park Lots, Henn. Co. , Minn.
'::;� .
:�
`-�'� '��5� PREPARED FOR:
ac .w e
McCOMBS-KNU7SON ASSOC�ATES, IyC• �� ��
r��winrc e�w�ua�w+w++nT�+�+�pT�Fwpsn ,K�,.o: City O f OrOt1C
` Yr,Al.�IOl10.wUTC1�WOM W M�tM►LL Yl�M W TA
�
,
.�
io-� ,'�'=.'s�''« ,.4. ..'f' . ,;: �4, '�:'_ e';..v -
+,k'"
! �
;;�
.�.., o-�� •
;:, »
^=i�_ � POPHAM. HAIK, SCHNOBRtCH. KAUFMAN b DOTY. L7D.
�i ' Wa• �E G ='J.•- ia.. � . . r i . �.
, c�
�, AAv.•'�1�.. 4 ..l..r
�'' , .. aCGfu .. ',��.,c,pn..... MINNEAPOIfS 55402 , .• • . ��
'•�,+y,. OENV£4 �
- 7.�v-J 5 ;C'•
'_i' o7D<o7 .. v. . ..
•j t U�_ r :. �... _ =r+
c.. r.i.:aC w..�'��[a�..
'af't` 9PVCE O �: . *t L (� e .
FRL'JCq1C� 5 .�, nnL� IVO��C'.i:J)C�I ..� � �.>7
"`,Y.^ . aGI1alO C �lMr:.:`.'
Gaor o .in� '.i _ _
� SA�AVCI P 4< ,
. . ,. rqf.GEu�_. � . .v,•.
;�, LO^`CI� T:IC•�t�+
�` B[f1.:=L p • a..f.4,�.' ,
'��?� � JANiS R t�� .e .
, t ir. ,:aa}: t9ut:i ch
- . �it�• o� Orono
,,�;�„�.,. Y.O. oox 66
. Crystal Bay, bSinn.
r- ;;ii,��. � . S 5 3 2 3
�.''� 'y
� • �Y ' Re: Property at 'S0II an<1 ,;10 Ivy rlacc -
ar�"e�{ Slayzata - Oronu Villr�c;c�
.�,. .:
��•„�� Our File T1ur�iber 3C43
, . —
.-,
Dear Fiank:
�` ' Enclosed £ind a co��y o£ tl�� tctter from Tyler
. re his property. �ick wi�1 probat�l�; o:an t to sencl copies
�f�-'' to all council members. I have askc��! '1'yler to investigate
f�;�, r. the status of his proper�y ciuring th�� ycars of. 1957, 1��G8
��•���Y,�;_,., and 1964. He uici not own tlie t�ropert�.• at chat ".ime. tac
_.� ` necc? to knok-:
�:�r`
:` ��''' �
'.,,�� . 1 . The zoning of this ;�ro,�r/ rt�, prior to 1967-
';t• 1`�' �8 a�.TlE'21C:IilE.'11t. ��•,� IC. .-J-�',rr.il.j 1'f b� ��l'�t T 4 �
-s, i
r
{ . �
� ; Z. Ir � : �+�e_�• a legal �iuE>I.cx or lcgal non-
�.•:;n���.,�:�y �:�� pricr t �� 1�67-.1968 �t:zen�:�i�cn:..
� , 3. If it ���ere � lcg��l u�,c <>� legtl i�on-conforr.i-
ing use in 1957 , cli<: nn•.�onc aF�ply f�r ttte
conditional use �>cr��:i ; rr.c�� i; becar�,c or
continuer. to b�� a nc;�,-�:<�;i`orming usc in 196�.
4 . I?as Tvler or � nrc�vic�it; owner ever ec:<zs. ci
• using� thc prorcrty ��:. .� �:u��lcx , if so, when,
� � and for wilat ]�r.gth u t t iinc.
�
, , I woul� appreciat� }�our r�:vi�wing thc� city rccorcis
• to obtain the answers t� the above ��ucstions.
Ve.ry trti ly ��c;urs ,
�
--� Bruce L). �ialk�rson
BD:�1:rrp
F:nclosure
,;;i� "X,�.� - _ ,�'"' .., .
�, .
.. .. '.... ... ..W ,• .�.;'r� � _-.x-. .
. .. :, ..� ., . ...., ,,'., , .
. : i���761YM1'�Ytc '�".�4".'.,a. ' r,:�.: , .. ;. �... :,:.--
a°"
i�-
�{ .
F
;�
OFt�1� COU�tCIL MEL-'fiV(;, FI'BP.UARl' 11, 1��75 I�t1r,E 3
ltielsh �r�cved, Paurus secondecl, to extend conditional use SiUBBS BAY 'tARIW1 (cont.)
. for soup and sanciwis�.�s and not full course mcais tmtil
the rr�eetinR of February ZS, 19i5. Atotion, AyLs f4) , Vay ((1) .
It was st{�SZeste�l tltiat the menu as presentccl to Caunc:il
� _ . defineci muc•e satisfactorily.
1•tuhich sLateci the Proposeci Antenna Gridance will he ' i'P.�P�SED A�"I�.�;tir1 •
diacu.ssF�ci at the Public }learin� rebruarv Z;, 1�75, at �RI�rL�'CF: '
8:3C r.�n. � .
.icrry. Kcberts, a representative of t}ie f;��ne Pro�erty GACLtE PROPLT.Tl' - f('i+JY.1Z
d^veiopment, rec{uested a sequence of d�+i�s for their F, OLP CRYSiA1. (��1Y RD.
proposal. Ile was infc�red that a�lication for cezoning
to be made after Plannin� Ce�trnission and Council 5as
establisheci standards for new rr�itiple zone as Prescribe�i
in the Comprehensive Gliide Plan and adopt a irz:ltiplc
dwelling zone within the ZoainA Caic. Plannin� C�ission
to discuss a time t�ble for these standar.is.
Paunu suggested Council review w}iat �ype of r���na�ement
andJor ownership wouid oe establishcd to insure welfarc
of inhabitants. •
• Council reviek•eci our participation in the SouthHrst S(UIT{WF:SI' SI'..VITAJtY S�YdEk "
Y
. Sar�itary Sewer District and thc ��lue for Oreno. �iasscn�ale DISI72ICT - APPOI'�fI?��.YI'
suggest� we obtain a copy of their Charter or Iiylaws ;or
';; Council inforrna�ion. Tabled until ;�L3rch 11 mectin�.
�
;�; ' " Paurus moved, A'elsh seconded, adoption of Lake Use I.�UQ: USE F'OLICY
:;�� Statement. D4ot ion, Ayes (4), Vay (0) .
' J•lassengale moveci, h'elsh seconded, waiving pcnalty for K'qI1�T p�-�ALiy _
' Clarence Anderscm. t�Sotion, Ayes (4) , Nay (0) . �L,�`,� ������
�
Welsh moved, Butler seconded, zcceF�tance of 1974 1974 FI'V.4VCL�1L STAT�3�;YI'
; fir_ancial statement, bSotio�, Aves (4) , Nay (0) .
City Attorney reporteci the Tyl er's }iave 1 isted th i s ,'�'YI.E;� CCt�iPL4I,�T STATUS
property For sale. Thr:y acimit t}icre is no l�asis fc.�r =' 3810 Iti'�' PL4CE
leAal non-confonning use to u�e as a duplEx. The Jameson's �
stated thc,y have entereci int% a rental agreement and wili
be �oving �tarch 31. Thev will send our Attorney a copy
of the rental ar;reemrnt. Tne Tyler's will rcrrbvc the cai--
port on the srnall cottage. Status of cottafie is i�rcertain
at this point. It appears not to be a le�al nen-ccnfonnii�R
use.
• Co�cil requesteci Dave Ophev,�, Ciiaizman of tt�e "ark Cor�- �I�I ic�;tiA �`i:t�1.1S
' _ mission, be pre�ent�at next Council r.�eeti�lg to �iiscz,•s '
his activities regarding pur�hase of Ski Tonka.
:�
..�
,w
,�'
- i
�''�: :
. � ._
+�,.� }2 S N T. r S 4... .�. ��:f "F� .
� : ..
�;,
'�I(YYI. 'yi� 'If'L'�I 5�1ib � '!t•' ",� bi!'T ,a`�(yy� �ifi^k,..
' I I �� 1
�
<� � ' ,
�
1
T0: Bruce '�talkcrson
I-�2(i"�i: I iank '��}t i.:h
D.aT'E: .January 22, 19'S
RE: :b.blc t�ccupancy Statu� of 'fvler tik'C11171R at i
�� � _ 3510 Ivy Place . � ` '
,
�N
>�
, �1s per your request ��c sent }�ou tl:e ent irc f i;e re�ardiri� t�;�
Tyler pro�rty at �510 Iw F'lace by certified mail on .lan. �1 ,
`'`� 1�75.
In it you w;ll �inci all tne recorcl� w•e could ciig up �lus two
short nores rc�arding the dout�ic occupancy status o: tt:c ch.•cllinfi.
The first r�ote si�;ncd hv sevcral nciFi�hor<; in the arez in�3i�ates
their }:nowledge as to the ycars tne s,-����:ure H•as not usec3 for
double occupancy.
T!te seconci letter was submitteci by Jack Corl, the fee owner of
the property statinp, his Y-ecollection� of ti�e status of the
_ buildin�.
i
;a
.:
�"
,✓��"�".1� �
��i �
YS.A"�.`,_qrJ
�yf'r '91
.S:p
�4�%°�
S :ti,.
. , u ^ � •
,,. ., •
, � ��
�_ �, �� v ..,
a �
eqe � 7�y ^=�� �.a�x ¢�, , . �i, s�r.� � +.
�. _ . �.@ww+w��'ar. . _..�-«.r _...a _ . .. ._ . . . . . _
� �4 .r.,'� t : i^k {' ��+�Sx'� "-y �� #r�' 'Y a ,ra:�x 2.Ux�.k .L,.�..�.,,� ��af„r,..,.
xt�.. �i'�.. _ '��,� � „�
'£..
j+��^:
F��� ,..,.: ...:. . �` � � � .,...,i:._.
y .f
� ��
�.,� � ' ... . .... ..... .
-'E.� .:«.-,� ... .. . _._"-... .
e.
{
�
t
� 'I'p: W. R. B�nson, Administrator
�
� rRpM: i;. F. �uhich, Zoning /1dm.
t
i
.j
�AT'E: January 23, 1975
' RE: Tyler property double occupancy at 3510 Iv}• Place
; (Tabled from Coincil Mtg. of 12-2-74)
The rrcorcis �f the property loc�ted at 35L0 Iw Place have been sent
by certifi.ed mail to th� Vill�ge Attorney for revicw.
They include the history of the property ,ileng with sevc�al more
recent rcports an�' correspor.c?ence as to tze past and prese:�t status
of the property.
'Ihe fol�awing are the most recen� additiols to o�ir .ecords.
1. A sketch of the site 3s d:awn up by tiie engineers noting
approximate locations c:: lot lines ar_d struct�tres.
; 2. f, stater�ent signed by neig,��crs �: ��e �roperty noting
past dates as to ��iien the structsre r��as not used for
dauble occupancy.
3. A letter frora J�_ck Co:l, tiic fee c�mer of the p:aperty
' giving t�ie histo:-y of the pr�F�:��ty� :s 1�� re.�embers.
�
'�
, �
',.
. �
n, r�.. ,� ,� �• .# t � r;� ��x „»-� � �. �, r� :^t.
,���., . 'a*.
{'4
:i;
I
�
I
A •
Soring Par�t, ti�ir.r.. �
��.c 6, 14?4
b�r. 17er:ry ',:t.kicr.,
Orono �oning Director,
Village of oror.o, '
Crystal Bay, N:inr.esota
Dear Sir:
To t} b�s� of rr� k::owl :d�, ; ir r. �argavei bu:l* ti:e i�o�,.:s•_ �i.
esrly 1940. �i� sold it in Iq56 to Gsibers,wY:o �oved in i.
1957 , usir.� it as sir�gle family dwelling for approximately
two years. , "�
They sold to Dr. Skbbay. ;e uscd it as sii:gle family dwrilizig
also, from 1g60 to 1�67 , wher. ha sold to oeppl.: by r.am� �f
Steverisor,.
Steverisons lived trere: approximately two years. Tr.ey wer� �
nctifi�d by t�e Viliagc_ it could :,ot bp �.sed as a dupiex.
And it w�s r,ot us�.d as such.
I bou�;nt th�: housc• about 1g6G and sold to Tyi:,r about 1970.
�;� As far as I �r�ow, they have used it F:� � sir.ol� fasily c3welling.
;� � �
k ���'
i i
• i
!
�
'�.
`i
��
�'l .3wys �r" � 1 �'4�3 � `4. fi l - � � �� I
� �� �� ��
t ,�r '?k'� P,, i YrX' .� i
;�'
.'!'.
' � � , i
. �
�
'.h�
�� :�: }�?Jl}: '•�1Lti11C}]
FR�}*t: '•tike Scheller
D,AT'F.: Decanber 6, 197�
KE: Tvler Infonnation
1�+r. Quentin Johnson �ave me the follo�oin�; information a.nd stated
,�� he �tiuld set information from otner �eo�;e in the area.
The house was huilt by �tr. I�r�avel in the �arly 1940's and sold
in 1956 to t�ir. Geber, who in tt�rn sold it to I1r. Su��; :.� 1957.
The usage of the entirc nroperty by the Subbvs w-�s as fol?.cws:
they iived i.n the main house and had the in-laws in the snall
hause. T;�ey owned tne house in �ctoher, l�ti7, so that ►,,:,_.ld have
made the small hc�se a le�al non-conforming use anci the main
house a single family at that time of adoption of our present
ordinance. In late '68 or early 'G9 the Subbys sold to �lr. Stevenson.
1•tr. Stevenson ran an ad to rent the lower part of the house, whi�L
was detected by a neigi:�or, who reported it to *he .illage w�o
inforned him that this kas i11eRa1. `�tr. Stevenson, in 1969, then
sold to John Corl kfio rented it to Ric}lard Tyler, the present oa�ner,
until 1970 when it was nurcti�ased by >tr. Tyler.
;` i�fr. Joh.�isnn states he car. never recall w}ien the princi�al builc3irig
Has useci as a duplex including the Tylers. Since the Subhys i.ere
using the small house in 1967 �hen the ordinance was adopted, it
�uld he a leRal non-cor.rormin� use.
,z
�:.
'��
:;�:
;�
''��
;�
�
��
�
'�
r.
� :
_.. � I�I /,,
�►'. �^ _ �� t, ,
� ,.
,�,. � r. ., . ,. �,�,�. .�;, .�,� ° -�,. �,..� ,
�
,;, •
�
�
T�: Pick Be�son, .4dmin:scrator
Ft'ta!: Iiank 'fuhich, � F, i3 :�dninistrator
� �/1T1;: June 4, 1975
1.F:: ivler }'i-c,�-�'��, 351:� I��y Place - F'z-ot>Iems and status of
}�ro;,ert`• con�•eyed to ��u-e��aser }•tr. 3r.� �`rs. Cht:ck Faber
:�� � -
.:-� .
��liiie :oll�titiing the cvsto,�ar}� p:ocecaL�res o: ins�zuctin� the �:�r>n��,-
o,•.ners of rer�oving ;l�bris, we Iearned a r,cw ;�,1rtv t.-2s consi�.a.�;in.^ �
" the purc;l::se of the above nropertv. After aa extensiti•e research �
"i �ce �iiscovered the Fabers 'riad alreadv a�reed to term� to purct-�ase
the propert}•. I infor,;�ed t}:e;.: t;�e detiris ��a�Id }�zve to be rc;�^o�•ed
from t}�c nrope;t�•. T7iev re��uestcd I ulstruct t::e rresent owr.er
,� �T�•ler) ��hich w�e dica by letter.
�' I also inforric�c: t�ie �ahers t}�at thi� pronert�• wa� �oned sin�le
� fa-nil�� resicential. `tr. Faber exnressc�i�no :nterest of :iouble
- ccc�a}�ancy o� the m�in strvcture. E'.e did, �:owever, rec��iest Ls�e
accessorv structur�� �e used :or reside;�ce; of the c�irrent occunant
`� until their new ho,:�e unde: censtraction ti;e�;ld he ccxTplete;i. I
sugk�es`e� he set � d.�tc �nd �a�:c this reqae�t in n-:-itin,� k�it� a '�
condition tNat �., nl ic�.tion far a Conc�i;ional lise r emit be made. �
�1 r �^� �1 7�1-' �l
I info*-�ed him the anplication could he r�de *or either second
residence or �sest hotL�e but indicateci t;�e difficuitv in o':t�inin�-
?nproval For ;� second residence on n;z� �rcel. �
'•irs. Faber ca^?e �e �-:v o~f:ce on .;��n� _�, i�?�. �he �ic}:ecl i:a a
�onditional ilse ?'ermit ap;�l icatierl �-�:1 �r��^ised to retura t:�e
' anPlicatiol; si�o:tl�� aler.� witi; c_ lct�.�r rccuestin� tem?�ra:�•
"� xeunancv o{ tne secor,d s�r,ict!�re fo:• � l i:�itecl tir,�e onlv. ;he
�` �resent occun�J?t �,:oui� T.o�:e into a r.��� 'r.��c airre^t�v c�der con-
-�` st:aetion. Co�^nletion is �.�ue ��r?�tu-;e LhI� fali.
'5
�'�
{u
:+� ,
"�if
rf���
�s�.
��y;,
'f1�
�'�:�
_�,
4P'
S',
Y.T. � 'h.. :f
��:
$o . .. . . . . .,, .
.{
TO: l�i�•E; �3c�r.son, Vi ; 1,���r �1�3,�ini�tr,:<��r�
F'ROM• :tii:�� Sclz��llc�r , 3ui ic?incJ ItisF���ct�r .
��
UA'I'f;. tieptc�tr.ht,r ? ti , 1�;�i
�r . _
� �UB,:I:C�: FZ;�n.�rd Ty1F•r I.�,;���� 1 3�10 I•�}' }'1<tce
Aftc�r ;� �•<�uvl� doz�n �:ips tc> thc-. �;'t.c,•.��• sit�• , I got t� inspect thc above
resid��r�r.c.. T h.ive �i l lec] out ,� foi�a >>= �'�1 �-��' r�'=idz nt ial inspe:t ion _or
'� hazarc3��us b�ilciings usLd �.+h��n uc wi�'.� �_o fo;c�� repair �r removal.
This buildinq has been contr�jversi,,I �ver sifice I beq�n here in 196F.
; First it was thought therc wi�re twc� resi<icnc�•s on one lot. :he tax
� r2eor�'s sho� it as DC1T.g on c� �����1rat�- iot, distinct from the m�in
reside��c��. Aiso, uh.i?e checkin�l Lr�' ����'�. � found it haC been ust�d as
a rental as f3r b�ci: as any�c�c�y hcre c�n rcc�ilect. I did all this
befoi•c I allowcd a sewcr tio��:��p, fc�c�l i �� i f i t w�zs not � legal bui.l�inq,
I cou?d r�fLse th� ho��kup. I coutd in �:.r.� start proceedinqs on ,r��unds
�,f it beiny a ::ealth 1,.12ar�:. ti�vi.ny ro ���To��nds, I had no choice but to
allow the hc�evup a�d they ure bc�inq eharr,��c: Eor usage.
'lbout a ye��r :►go, I received <� com;�laint they werr_ closing in the screen�� '
porch. On inspectinq it, I !c.�.�rned the�v had setup a few pieces of this
plywor�d ~o scrcen Lh+� porch frc�m t}Zc� v.:�w of t�a�sing cars. ] <:���sl:) no�
consi.dcr �nis a viol�:,tic�:�. 1 h��v�, issu��d th�� Ty�lers orders to c-1e:a��
up a fc�� timns. ".'hcy cor..ply wit:h�!�F� m�.�or itcros, hut aqain, I c�me� into
the grcy �r�_a wher� I yues�ion i f i �� ius: i f���c'. to proceed t�nd�r �'�e
��rdinar.���s w�� h��ve. Thc p�o�lc� i.r� `f�� �r��a �hould be r��de ��wai� i hav�
G''.'en ::�li��u E�I'lt2 I�rGwn� til(_' j)rOSC'�'tlLlilt: ��ttC�C)l�'}'� .li1Cj 1Sr:EC� �IOW ii]!� �
could qn in f�rcinq c1e��nu�� <<�<i��ily. I w�s in:c�::nec3 w�� ha-.c r,� ��CIE'•3:'1
�. yard" arr.lin�nce.
My inspection ' oda}• rev�:�led th� :��_�ic3��nc�• is i�o mencic� to heait`�, ::•:�s
�i icy.�t l,ath leq�.�lly hoc�:ed t�> scwer. It .i1:,-� ha� acl�quate liaht ind
V�:Rtl l��`. 10(1. i� 1�� R:J� C�f?E'fl tc> C}�ilcir�r,. 1�t1�7�1f•St1Ji11I)LV, 1F r�UJ :t � "
� FiJ(�d�� � COCj�'� 1 : CU'.11C� fiGt D:' CC)RStL�lli.tFC� 5U�'}1 <lS 15� SO lt 1S :10"�
; � ^Unforming as to s��tbcick ancl <.on�trt�cric�n. If 1 wcrre tc� enforce tiuch
� stan;3�rcis fairly all c�ver. th�.� Vil��tgc, [ rould re�movc a lot of nor�-
i c:�r:forming ila���s, if we wo�li: :�ut .::'o��t � liqht h�>usiny ordinanc:� .�nc3
�
! h�•v�_ ir.sF��c'tors bianke�t any �r��:� to �_•af��rr�� i � anc3 �1.1V�� the ensuinq
court cases to k�ack i.t: up. I tt�in}: ��c�F�lc� t,:kinq m��tt�rs such as the�e
? � to c�urt ��I tc�rr+a: cc,mr�l•:�i ��r �; .•ccc�mrlish mu�•h mc�r•• th�n insE����-tc�r�_ ,
� as j ud�3�'� louY more f Zv��r.il;l�• ��n �;t� t v.�' �• �•<�m:>l n lnrs th�►n t hc��t�� „F
:`; � ins���-r�,r� �mr,loyr_c] k�y a m�n ��-i;,ril i . .
,
1
;�;
• �
�;qr �
i
f
�
� �
�:V: 3
�
� ,
;�
'�1'illag� of Orono
.
�'�,:; 1)1fi.�• }i.,r M;•(�t�•ytal Ray�. �icnr r+oL.t .-,��.i�l:t��Suntcipei �)ffirry
i
On th�' :�nrfh Short�nf l,ak�• .tifinnet,»ika
• ' i f
i�tar:�i 23, 1976 �
�
hfr. (harles Faber
3510 Ivy Place
lVeyzata, ldirutesota, 553Q1
Dear I�r. FsL�er:
It has caae to our attentim that your property is aRain ic�r s�ie. Due to
previous probleas cancerning occ�ancv of ynur outbuilding, � feel t�at �n�
m�.t�t go an record again 5tmsing that your lot is Iocated in a s;ngle fami:y
residential zoRe. Occupancy of yflur au*�building is prohibited Frith�ut th�
express cansent of the City Camcil throug}� a Co�ndition.al Use Pezmit. If
'' you hav�e any qutstiau� please call.
Sincerel
.�'C°-�—i
ffi1 P. �15Q1
Buil.�iing $ ZcxYing Ins�ector
APo1rd .
ec: G�orge Jacksai F Assc�ciates [Lerlty
P'
M
w -
�illage of �ronc�
p.0. I30X 66, f'Dl'STAI. 1 �11'. Mlti`. Si323 ��L%N3C1PA1,OF'FTCFS i'H9"(F.: a73-i73i
�
� On tb� ;tiurth S{r�rt I_u�Ee :Ninntlnrt.Ea
� - s •
3
' .July 9, 7.975
.,
_
;,
*�
;�
��
'�`r. Charles fiaher
3510 Ivy Placc
Wayzata� ;�liruiesota
near '�1r. raher:
�'t�en I learned nf �•our con�icier�.nr rxi:chasinr the propertV
on ivy T'lace, I infoz,nec� timi� of t}�e restriction on maltinle
occupancy on sinRle fariilv residrntial zonec3 are�s and the
nroblem we r�rere cuncntiv� clealin� with on this Pro;�erty. J
. At that time you assu�red r.�e wu �ould send me a statement
that �rou had no intention of u.sinF the main �tructure for d�uble
> oceu}xir►cy and were considerin� oc.-�rt1znc�• of t�� secc:�d SLTUCLUTC
� � only �til the new residence ef the rre5en:. occupant was coa�-
�leLeci. I have not recieveci this state:xnt as vet.
On Junc i, 1975, voz►r wifr. ric�ecl tr, the ne�esszry forc�s fo:
a conditional use permit s+•hic.- :iaven't as vet b�en su�nitteci for
, processinF by the Villane. �
If vQu have any c�uestinny �ou can ��ntac: r�e :�t [he th'ona
�'i11aRe }�11-4?5-735'.
�inccrcly tirours,
:
!(anh �h�hich
;
; �onin� Ac6ninistrator
:
� cc: Dick Benson
;.
�
}���p�,.
;=;�;
."'
;:
:�
j;,
;'�-� ,
{ (
f
Y
� �
. �i. 3 .`. � ��,.
. . .. . ._ , ?���. _ .. . . ..o. ., �+�t .. . . . .��.:.:t .. .. . .� . . . ... . . ... . . . _ . . •
�,.1., ;e': 1
:�
�.
::��e'
t ,
�.s �.t..r:....,. ...";.,.. . . ,
�'� . ... ..... . . .....-a .... - ,.._. > , . . . , .. . . . . .. •.��.�
♦'
e
:9 �.
i�e, ttie ur.dcr�igr.cd, state tha� the house at 35d8 Ivy �;
. �
�lac e, r.o� occupi ed by Tyl ers, l:as :,ot b�en us ed as a �'
�
duplex a2+er: �
,
! �� � 1 — �x�t�c, �'����'�� ' `� r7 i �"�i !`. { r � <_ �
/1�_��� ^ ���� �,t,�' ��..�. G-�-`�' �"
N'��"�� G�-- a �
. t;
.— � , • - : .� - e�-
/ �/ ! � - % � 'h.� > f -�: t ,_<<, ', . . �-'" ,. ."' _ . ��.
( �� ! � 1 � � , �� _ :' ,`\��; '�.
:� � �- 4� ,� i f:" ( %;-!/(-�,--„• •:��^ %-� ;��- ;��.� � ��.��, . ;�
, � � !f �
^
�.�% � .. � � �. �.
� �1�: L- -�i 1�� ;�� �: ��.�JL���.� � _.;�.�_ ��, , �=: � � z.�. �� . ,. _, � :�:
� � = �'!`��Cu� '.- J`'i., :�'.S �: : :���-.� ,�-��t..=r' �
� J G�. - C- . f `� � -
�
�
�
�
�
�
,,
:�
�
;3 � �
.�; r'
;�. .
:;
� r
�
�
`S�
�;r
�
�
l':.
�
t
'� • ;,.
k�
�
.�"
,�