HomeMy WebLinkAboutMCWD Permit r
MINNEHAHA CREEK � WATERSHED DISTRICT
QUALITY OF WATER "'^`- QUALITY OF LIFE
Pursuant to Minnesota Statutes Chapter 103D, and on the basis of statements and information
contained in the permit application, correspondence, plans, maps, and all other supporting data
submitted by the applicant, and made a part hereof by reference, PERMISSION IS HEREBY
GRANTED to the applicant named below for use and development of land in the Minnehaha
Creek Watershed District.
L��� "� �� 5�
Issued to: Timothv &Amv Sullivan Permit No: 16-521
Location: 440 Brown Road South, Orono
Purpose: Erosion Control- Buildina Addition
Date of Issuance: 10/6/2016 Date of Ex iration: 10/6/2017
By Order of the Board of Managers�
Rachel Workin - �
Permitting Technician
�_�- -
This permit is not transferable without District approval, and is valid to the date of expiration. No
activity is authorized beyond the expiration date. If the permittee requires more time to complete
the project, an application for renewal of the permit must be received by the District at least 30
days before expiration.
The applicant is responsible for compliance with all District Rules and for the action of their
representatives, contractors, and employees.
Conditions: Project to be completed as described in plans submitted to the
MCWD office on September 19th, 2016 according to the provisions of this permit.
• Properly install and maintain all required erosion control measures until the
disturbed areas are re-stabilized
• Notify MCWD in writing upon completing installation of perimeter and
sedimentation controls
• When the site is re-stabilized and the MCWD staff has performed a final
inspection, all perimeter control must be removed
(Statement concerning fees for inspections, violations, etc... on following page)
We collaborate with public and private partners to protecr and improve land and water for current and future generations.
15320 Minnetonka Boulevard,Minnetonka,MN 55345 • (952)471-0590 • Fax:(952)471-0682 • www.minnehahacreek.org
MINNEHAHA CREEK WATERSHED DISTRICT
QUALITY OF WATER QUALITY OF LIFE
Inspection/Analvsis/Monitorinq Fees
A site inspection and monitoring by District staff wilt be pertormed where the activity involves:
• a commercial/industrial/multi-family residential development
• a single family residential development greater than 5 acres or of any size if within the
Minnehaha Creek subwatershed
• any alteration of a floodplain or wetland
• dredging within the beds, banks or shores of any protected water or wetland
• a violation
• any project which in the judgment of the District staff should be inspected due to project
location, scope, or construction techniques
In these cases, the applicant shall pay to the District a fee equal to the actual costs of field ,
inspection of the work, including investigation of the area affected by the work, analysis of the 'i
work, and any subsequent monitoring of the work, which in the case of a violation shall be at
least $35.
Standard Fee Schedule
District professional staff $ 65.51*
District interns $ 40.35*
District clerical staff $ 46.69'`
Consulting Senior Engineer $ contracted rate
Consulting Engineer/Technician $ contracted rate
District Counsel $ contracted rate
Application fee $ 10.00
Copy costs $ .25 + actual staff time
Color copy costs $ 1.00 + actual staff time
* Hourly
We collaborate with public and private partners ro protecr and improve land and water for current and future generations.
15320 Minnetonka Boulevard,Minnetonka,MN 55345 • (952)471-0590 • fax:(952)471-0682 • www.minnehahacreek.org
Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act
Notice of Decision
Local Government Unit(LGLn Address
Minnehaha Creek Watershed District 15320 Minnetonka Blvd
Minnetonka,MN 55345
1. PROJECT INFORMATION
Applicant Name Project Name Date of Application
Tim Sullivan 440 Brown Rd,Orono Application Number
1/24/17 W 17-01
T e of Decision:
❑ Wetland Boundary or Type �No-Loss ❑ Exemption ❑ Sequencing
❑Replacement Plan ❑ Banking Plan
Technical Evaluation Panel Findin s and Recommendation if an :
❑ Approve ❑Approve with conditions ❑Deny
Summary(or attach):
2.LOCAL GOVERNMENT UNIT DECISION
Date of Decision: 1/26/17
� Approved ❑Approved with conditions(include below) ❑ Denied
LGU Findings and Conclusions (attach additional sheets as necessary):
Tim Sullivan has applied for a WCA No Loss Decision for proposed home repair and
excavation of sediment from a deepwater habitat at 440 Brown Rd in the City of Orono,
Hennepin County, Minnesota. Legal description: Sections 3, Township 117N, Range 23W.
A Level 1 wetland delineation was conducted by Kjolhaug Environmental Services on
January 9�', 2017. One deepwater waterbody with a Type 2, Fresh(Wet) Meadow fringe was
identified on site. A Level 1 wetland delineation was deemed appropriate because an on-site
review by Kjolhaug and MCWD on September 16�', 2016 identified an abrupt wetland-upland
transition zone.
MCWD finds that the proposed home repair meet the criteria of conditions of 8420.410 and
criteria of 8420.0415 Subp. A: "an activiTy that will not impact a wetland"as there is no
wetland within the home repair project area.
MCWD finds that the proposed excavation of material from the deepwater area meets the
criteria of conditions of 8420.410 and criteria of 8420.0415 Subp. A: "an activity that will not
impact a wetland" as the proposed removal of sediment is from a deepwater waterbody.
Excavation is not allowed within the area delineated as Type 2 Fresh(Wet) Meadow.
BWSR Forms 7-1-10 Page 1
of 3
This decision is valid for five years. Any proposed changes to the project that are outside of
the scope of this exemption and no-loss decision may not begin without approval from the
MCWD. These projects or a future project located on this property may require a permit from
the MCWD.
For Replacement Plans using credits from the State Wetland Bank:
Bank Account # Bank Service Area County Credits Approved for
N/A N/A N/A Withdrawal (sq. ft. or nearest
.01 acre)
Replacement Plan Approval Conditions. In addition to any conditions specified by the LGU, the
approval of a Wetland Replacement Plan is conditional upon the following:
❑ Financial Assurance: For project-specific replacement that is not in-advance,a financial assurance
specified by the LGU must be submitted to the LGU in accordance with MN Rule 8420.0522, Subp. 9
(List amount and type in LGU Findings).
❑ Deed Recording: For project-specific replacement, evidence must be provided to the LGU that the
BWSR "Declaration of Restrictions and Covenants" and "Consent to Replacement Wetland" farms
have been filed with the county recorder's office in which the replacement wetland is located.
❑ Credit Withdrawal: For replacement consisting of wetland bank credits, confirmation that BWSR
has withdrawn the credits from the state wetland bank as specified in the approved replacement plan.
Wetlands may not be impacted until all applicable conditions have been met!
LGU Authorized Si nature:
Signing and mailing of this completed form to the appropriate recipients in accordance with 8420.0255,
Subp. 5 provides notice that a decision was made by the LGU under the Wetland Conservation Act as
specified above. If additional details on the decision exist, they have been provided to the landowner
and are available from the LGU u on re uest.
Name Title
Rachel Workin Permitting Techncian
Signature Date Phone Number and E-mail
� ; 1/26/17 (952) 641-4518
rworkin@minnehahacreek.org
THIS DECISION ONLY APPLIES TO THE MINNESOTA WETLAND CONSERVATION ACT.
Additional approvals or permits from local, state, and federal agencies may be required. Check with all
appropriate authorities before commencing work in or near wetlands.
BWSR Forms 7-1-10 Page 2
of 3
Applicants proceed at their own risk if work authorized by this decision is started before the time period
for appeal (30 days) has expired. If this decision is reversed or revised under appeal, the applicant may be
responsible for restoring or replacing all wetland impacts.
This decision is valid for three years from the date of decision unless a longer period is advised by the TEP
and specified in this notice of decision.
3. APPEAL OF THIS DECISION
Pursuant to MN Rule 8420.0905, any appeal of this decision can only be commenced by mailing a petition
for appeal,including applicable fee,within thirty(30)calendar days of the date of the mailing of this Notice
to the following as indicated:
Check one:
� Appeal of an LGU staff decision. Send ❑ Appeal of LGU governing body decision.
petition and $0 fee(if applicable)to: Send petition and $500 filing fee to:
Minnehaha Creek Watershed District Executive Director
15320 Minnetonka Blvd Minnesota Board of Water and Soil Resources
Minnetonka,MN 55345 520 Lafayette Road North
St. Paul, MN 55155
4. LIST OF ADDRESSEES
� SWCD TEP member: Stacey Lijewski
� BWSR TEP member: Ben Meyer
❑ LGU TEP member(if different than LGU Contact):
� DNR TEP member: Becky Horton
❑ DNR Re�ional Office(if different than DNR TEP member):
❑ WD or WMO (if applicable):
� Applicant (notice only) and Landowner(if different): Tim Sullivan
� Members of the public who requested notice(notice only): Rob Bouta (Kjolhaug); Christine
Mattson (City of Orono);Melanie Curtis (City of Orono)
� Corps of Engineers Project Manager(notice only):Ryan Malterud
❑ BWSR Wetland Bank Coordinator(wetland bank plan applications only)
5. MAILING INFORMATION
➢For a list of BWSR TEP representatives: www.bwsr.state.mn.us/aboutbwsr/workareas/WCA_areas.pdf
➢For a list of DNR TEP representatives: www.bwsr.state.mn.us/wetlands/wca/DNR TEP_contacts.pdf
➢De artment of Natural Resources Re ional Offices:
NW Region: NE Reaion: Central Reeion: Southern Re ion:
Reg. Env. Assess. Ecol. Reg. Env. Assess. Ecol. Reg. Env. Assess. Reg. Env. Assess. Ecol.
Div. Ecol. Resources Div. Ecol. Resources Ecol. Div. Ecol. Resources
2115 Birchmont Beach Rd. 1201 E.Hwy. 2 Div.Ecol.Resources 261 Hwy. 15 South
NE Grand Rapids,MN 1200 Warner Road New Ulm,MN 56073
Bemidji,MN 56601 55744 St.Paul,MN 55106
For a map of DNR Administrative Regions, see: http://files.dnr.state.mn.us/aboutdnr/dnr re i�ons.pdf
➢For a list of Corps of Projeet Managers: ww��.mvp.usace.artny.miUregulatory/default.asp?pa�eid=6S7
or send to:
US Army Corps of Engineers
St. Paul District, ATTN: OP-R
BWSR Forms 7-1-10 Page 3
of 3
, • 180 Fifth St. East, Suite 700
St. Paul,MN 55101-1678
➢For Wetland Bank Plan applications,also send a copy of the application to:
Minnesota Board of Water and Soil Resources
Wetland Bank Coordinator
520 Lafayette Road North
St. Paul,M1V 55155
6.ATTACHMENTS
Level l Delineation and No-Loss Application
❑
BWSR Forms 7-1-10 Page 4
of 3
Sullivan Property
City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota
Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report
and No-Loss Application
Prepared for
Timothy Sullivan
440 Brown Road South
Orono, Minnesota
by
Kjolhaug Environmental Services Company, Inc.
(KES Project No. 2016-148)
January 24, 2017
Sullivan Property
City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota
Modi�ed Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report and No-Loss Application
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page
l. WETLAND DELINEATION AND APPLICATION SUMMARY..................................1
1.1 Wetland Delineation.......................................................................................................... l
1.2 No-Loss Application......................................................................................................... l
2. OVERVIEW...........................................................................................................................2
3. METHODS.............................................................................................................................2
3.1 Wetland Delineation..........................................................................................................2
4. RESULTS...............................................................................................................................3
4.1 Review of NWI, Soils, Public Waters and NHD Information..........................................3
4.2 Wetland Delineation..........................................................................................................4
4.3 Historical Review of the Excavated Pond.........................................................................6
4.4 Request for Wetland Boundary and Jurisdictional Determination ...................................6
5. NO-LOSS APPLICATION...................................................................................................6
5.1 Minnehaha Creek Watershed District...............................................................................7
5.2 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers .........................................................................................7
6. CERTIFICATION OF DELINEATION.............................................................................7
TABLES
Table 1. Wetlands delineated on the Sullivan Property......................................................... 1
Table 2. Soil types mapped on the Sullivan property............................................................3
Table 3. Soil profile of the pond bottom................................................................................5
Table 4. Aerial photo history of pond location......................................................................6
FIGURES
1. 5ite Location
2. Existing Conditions
3. USGS Topography
4. National Wetlands Inventory
5. Soil Survey
6. Level 1 Wetland Delineation with Onsite Setback Measurement
APPENDICES
A. Joint Application Form for Activities Affecting Water Resources in Minnesota
B. Property Boundary Survey
C. Historical Aerial Photography
Sullivan Property
City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota
Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report and No-Loss Application
1. WETLAND DELINEATION AND APPLICATION SUMMARY
1.1 Wetland Delineation
• The 2.5-acre Sullivan Property was inspected on September 16, 2016 and January 9, 2017
for the presence and extent of wetland.
• The National Wetlands Inventory(NWI) shows one PUBGx(Palustrine unconsolidated
bottom, intermittently exposed, excavated) wetland located on the eastern part of the
property.
• The soil survey shows that soil types on the property are classified as predominantly non-
hydric.
• The DNR Public Waters Inventory shows no public waters onsite. DNR Public Waters
Wetland 27-858W is located about 300 feet east of the property boundary.
• The National Hydrography Dataset(NHD) shows no NHD waters or flowlines onsite.
The nearest NHD Waterbody is the DNR Wetland that is located about 300 feet east of
the property.
• One wetland/deepwater habitat was delineated on the site and is summarized below.
Table 1. Wetlands delineated on the Sullivan Property
ID Wetland T e Dominant Vegetation
Circular 39 Cowardin E ers and Reed
Type 2/ Wet meadow/Deep open water, Reed canary
1 Deepwater PEMB/L1UB4x excavated grass/Open water
Habitat
1.2 No-Loss Application
• The proposed sediment removal meets no-loss criteria listed under Minnesota Rules Part
8420.0415, A., because removal of sediment from a deepwater habitat is"an activity that
will not impact a wetland."
• The proposed sediment removal is not regulated under Section 404 of the Federal Clean
Water Act because the excavation will be conducted with an excavator or backhoe.
1
Sullivan Property Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report and No-Loss Application
2. OVERVIEW
The 2.5-acre Sullivan Property was inspected on September 16, 2016 and January 9, 2017 for the
presence and extent of wetland. The property is located in the NE '/ of the NE '/ of the SE '/ of
Section 3, Township 117 North, Range 23 West, City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota.
The site address is 440 Brown Road South, Orono, MN (Figure 1). The property corresponds to
� Hennepin County PID 03-117-23-42-0012.
The site includes mature woodland, a home, driveway, lawn, and an excavated pond. The
excavated pond straddles the eastern property boundary (Figure 2). Most of the Sullivan
Property drains toward the pond (Figure 3). The pond/wetland boundary roughly corresponds to
the 970 contour and most of the home is located above the 980 contour. The pond has no natural
or created outlet. The site falls within the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District (MCWD).
Surrounding land use includes a mix of woodland, wetland, lawn, and rural residential homes.
One wetland was delineated on the site.
Appendix A of this report includes a Joint Application Form for Activities Affecting Water
Resources in Minnesota, which is submitted in request for. (1) a wetland boundary and type
determination under the Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act (WCA), and (2) delineation
concurrence and an Approved Jurisdictional Determination (AJD) under Section 404 of the
Federal Clean Water Act.
3. METHODS
3.1 Wetland Delineation
Kjolhaug Environmental (KES) confirmed with MCWD staff on January 5, 2017 that a Level 1
Wetland Delineation would be acceptable for this project. The Level 1 routine method was
modified to include a field review for site inspection and building setback measurement.
Wetlands were identified using a hybrid Routine Determination method as discussed below.
Routine Determination methods are described in the Corps of Engineers Wetlands Delineation
Manual (Waterways Experiment Station, ]987) and the Regional Suppleinent to the Corps of
En�iileers Wetland Delineation Manual: Midwest Region (Version 2.0) as required under
Section 404 of the Clean Water Act and the Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act.
This Wetland Delineation was completed to allow setback measurement for a home remodeling
project. Whereas Routine Level 1 delineations do not require site inspections, Routine Leve12
delineations include field data collection and markin�of wetland boundaries. This delineation
involved a hybrid of the two methods. The wetland edge was reviewed in the field on September
16, 2016 and the setback was measured in the field on January 9, 2017. Approximate wetland
boundaries were mapped on aerial photography.
The Level 1 method and a site inspection was deemed an appropriate method for this project
because the location of most of the wetland boundary was not critical and because the wetland
2
Sullivan Property Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report and No-Loss Application
boundary in the area near the setback measurement was found to be quite abrupt during the
September 16, 2016 field review.
Wetland boundaries were identified as the upper-most extent of wetland that met criteria for
hydric soils, hydrophytic vegetation, and wetland hydrology. Because this delineation used a
modified Level 1 method and the ground was frozen during the January 9, 2017 site visit,
detailed data on soils, vegetation, and hydrology were not collected in the field.
The building setback from the wetland edge was measured in the field. The wetland boundary
was interpreted and mapped using 2016 aerial photography, field knowledge, soils mapping, and
Lidar topographic mapping.
4. RESULTS
4.1 Review of NWI, Soils, Public Waters and NHD Information
The National Wetlands Inventorv (NWI) (Minnesota Geospatial Commons 2009-2014 and U.S.
Fish and Wildlife Service) shows one PUBGx (Palustrine unconsolidated bottom, intermittently
exposed, excavated) wetland located on the eastern part of the property (Figure 4). This wetland
is more accurately classified as a PEMB/L 1 UB4x (Palustrine, emergent, saturated/Lacustrine,
limnetic, unconsolidated bottom, organic, excavated) basin.
The Soil Survev (USDA NRCS 2015) showed that soil types on the property ranged from
predominantly non-hydric to hydric. Soil types mapped on the property are shown on Figure 5
and listed in Table 2.
Table 2. Soil types mapped on the Sullivan property
S mbol Soil Name % H dric H dric Cate or
L41C2 Lester-Kilkenny complex, 6-12% slopes, eroded 5 Predominantly non-hydric
L41E Lester-Kilkenny complex, 18-25% slopes 5 Predominantly non-hydric
The Miimesota DNR Public Waters Inventorv (Minnesota Department of Natural Resources
2015) shows no public waters onsite. DNR Public Waters Wetland 27-858W is located about
300 feet east of the property boundary.
The Natioilal Hvdro�rapliy Dataset(U.S. Geological Survey 2015) shows no NHD waters or
flowlines onsite. The nearest NHD Waterbody is the DNR Wetland that is located about 300
feet east of the property.
3
Sullivan Property Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report and No-Loss Application
4.2 Wetland Delineation
The property was evaluated for wetlands during field observations on September 16, 2016 and
January 9, 2017. The landowner sampled soils from the pond bottom on October 3, 2016. One
wetland/deepwater habitat was identified and delineated on the property(Figure 6). The
following description reflects conditions observed at the times of the field visits. Herbaceous
vegetation was actively growing at the time of the field visit on September 16. A property
boundary survey prepared by Frank R. Cardarelle Land Survey is included in Appendix B.
The one delineated Wetland is a Deepwater habitat with a narrow Type 2 (PEMB) wet meadow
and boulder toe fringe. It is located in the eastern part of the property. The wetland/deepwater
habitat is classified as a PEMB/L1UB4x (Palustrine, emergent, saturated/Lacustrine, limnetic,
unconsolidated bottom, organic, excavated)basin. The L1UB4x part of the basin corresponds to
the deepwater habitat and covers about 15,140 square feet(0.3456 acre). The PEMB wet
meadow fringe covers about 3,350 square feet(0.0769 acre) and ranges from about 3 to 20 feet
wide.
The deepwater habitat consists of open water. The wet meadow fringe is dominated by reed
canary grass with boulders at the water's edge in some locations. The reed canary grass
transitions to open water with steep side slopes. The adjacent upland was dominated by
manicured lawn on the northwest and southwest sides of the wetland, and to mixed maple
woodland on northeast and southeast sides of the wetland. The wetland boundary corresponded
to a rise in elevation and a transition from reed canary grass and open water to upland plant
communities with 6 to 12% slopes. This wetland is an excavated depression with no visible
inlets or outlets.
No other areas with hydrophytic vegetation or wetland hydrology were observed on the site. No
other areas were shown as hydric soil on the soil survey or as wetland on the NWI map.
Most of the basin is classified as a deepwater habitat because the substrate sample from the
wetland center indicated it was excavated to a depth of more than 6.6 feet around the time the
house was constructed. T'he landowner, Tim Sullivan, sampled soils of the pond bottom on
October 3, 2016. The resulting soil profile is shown in Table 3. The sample was taken in the
central part of the pond. At that location, the pond contained about 4 feet of water, underlain by
approximately 6 feet of mucky/silty sediment. At a depth of approximately 6 feet, the
mucky/silty substrate abruptly transitioned to gleyed blue-gray clay loam.
4
Sullivan Property Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report and No-Loss Application
Table 3. Soil profile of the pond bottom
Depth Below General
Sample Photograph
Bottom Description
1 0-2 feet Black silty mucky
_ �►�� ��- �'-'
soil with lots of J
leaves and some _� �� £; ,�
fine sand � ��
�� .f �r� ���s� ��
r�` �`� �� .� e�
�' - �
.� -
-� - A`4 ' '
\
{,;, � � � � ^
2 2-6 feet Black silty mucky „'�
soil with few leaves ��"�"� -
s`�
,a �.
r
- .� �
��
` '� ��.
.
3 6 feet+ Abrupt transition to ° � � �
gleyed blue-gray � �: � , .:��
clay loam with �`��"�� �_ -
' �
some sand � '��; `"�
' : � ,�
, .
` �� �5 � A �F ..
� �"�'�' . . � ;
� .
•j���..-
. ���� �� �
J. %"
�''�.
��
�
. JCHA'� ��'
�� `� � �
F � ��Y� �
� �, �'�' «
,� � � ,
., t
..� � �K'�� .
� � .
R �� i �. ;�: ��} 4���w
, ��' '
�
� � .
� � , ,�,,
�
�
5
Sullivan Property Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report and No-Loss Application
4.3 Historical Review of the Excavated Pond
An anecdotal history, site conditions observed in the field, and historical aerial photography
indicate that the wetland basin was previously excavated. During an onsite pre-application
meeting with the MCWD on September 16, 2016, Tim Sullivan explained how the original
homeowner told him that the wetland previously existed as a grassy wet meadow containing
debris and old appliances. The previous owner removed the debris and excavated the wetland to
create the pond that exists today. Hennepin County property information shows that the home
was built in 1986. The wetland excavation likely occurred around that time. Evidence
supporting the excavated wetland determination includes:
1. NWI mapping, which is based on 1980s color infrared aerial photogaphy, shows the
wetland as a PUBGx, and"x" indicates excavated.
2. The 1974 Hennepin County Soil Survey(based on field work in 1960s) shows the
wetland as a symbol that means"small depression,poor to very poorly drained."
3. Aerial photographs from 1937, 1945, 1956, 1960, 1962, 1967, 1971, and 1994 (8 years)
don't show the open water area until 1994 (Table 4,Appendix C).
Table 4. Aerial photo history of pond location
Aerial Photo Date Condition Observed at Pond Location
5-Ju1-1937 Scattered trees no o en water
Unknown-1945 Trees with o enin s, small area of otential wetland/seasonal floodin
7-Ma -1956 Mostl wooded,no o en water
8-Ma -1960 Mostl wooded, small de ression, ossibl with seasonal floodin
3-Ma -1962 Mostl wooded, small de ression, ossibl with seasonal floodin
4-Dec-1967 Wooded,no ice or o en water
9-Nov-1971 Wooded,no o en water
11-Oct-1994 Open water area covering an area about 4-6 times larger than the area of
ossible seasonal floodin observed durin 1960-62
4.4 Request for Wetland Boundary and Jurisdictional Determination
Appendix A of this report includes a Joint Application Form for Activities Affecting Water
Resources in Minnesota, which is submitted in request for: (1) a wetland boundary and type
determination under the Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act(WCA), and(2) delineation
concurrence and an Approved Jurisdictional Determination(AJD)under Section 404 of the
Federal Clean Water Act.
5. NO-LOSS APPLICATION
The landowner would like to remove accumulated sediment down to the blue-gray clay layer,
which corresponds to the depth of the original excavation. Excavation of sediment with an
excavator or backhoe will restore the deepwater habitat to the previous maximum pond depth of
approximately 10 feet, which existed following the original excavation.
6
Sullivan Property Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report and No-Loss Application
The only water resource to be affected by excavation will be the deepwater habitat. The narrow
Type 2 wetland fringe will be avoided. The excavation will be conducted during winter
conditions to minimize disturbance and sedimentation.
No-loss criteria and eligibility are discussed in the Joint Application Form for Activities
Affecting Water Resources in Minnesota(Appendiac A).
5.1 Minnehaha Creek Watershed District
Removal of accumulated sediment from the deepwater habitat is eligible for no-loss certification
under the Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act. Sediment removal was discussed with the
Minnehaha Creek Watershed District during an onsite pre-application meeting on September 16.
2016. Samples subsequently obtained from the pond bottom showed approximately 6 feet of
mucky/silty sediment. At a depth of approximately 6 feet,the pond substrate abruptly
transitioned to gleyed blue-gray clay loam.
The proposed sediment removal meets no-loss criteria listed under Minnesota Rules Part
8420.0415, A., because removal of sediment from a deepwater habitat is"an activity that will not
impact a wetland."
5.2 U.S. Army Corps of Engineers
The proposed sediment removal is not regulated under Section 404 of the Federal Clean Water
Act because the excavation will be conducted with an excavator or backhoe. The excavated
material will be loaded on trucks and hauled to a location where it can be deposited on upland
and used as black dirt. The activity will not result in a discharge of dredged or fill material into
waters of the United States.
6. CERTIFICATION OF DELINEATION
The procedures utilized in this delineation are based on the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers 1987
Wetlands Delineation Manual, as required under Section 404 of the Clean Water Act and the
Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act. This wetland delineation was prepared in compliance
with the regulatory standards in place at the time the work was performed.
Delineation completed by: Rob Bouta. Senior Environmental Scientist/Ecolo�st
Minnesota Certified Wetland Delineator No. 1081
Date: Januarv 24, 2017
7
Sullivan Property
Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report
and No-Loss Application
FIGURES
1. Site Location
2. Existing Conditions
3. USGS Topography
4. National Wetlands Inventory
5. Soil Survey
6. Level 1 Wetland Delineation with Onsite Setback Measurement
. �,. . � `'�,
�
:`;,;.� c .
�
. . .
«�•• ",'
� � �
t ,,, �=«-`
• ,..�.,,„
,
x
��'F
���
, �"- �- . _� -�� �
- - . Y _ '
__ - __ __ � .. �.
3
_-��_ ��__���-A'. � . .
_ - - ' � �
—_ � _ � � -_- � R
____ -_:-_ :_ Site Location �
-__- --__-_:_ � �
' - 3
� .
�
� , • �
' sw Lr«r � Im Snalt b.LrM .
N �
�
.. .
-�a,! .i. _ "� . �.M
� �,�.«;� .
�
�.�
. . �
Figure 1 - Site Location
N 0 1,000 Sullivan Property (KES 2016-148)
Orono, Minnesota
1 I � Feet � Project Boundary
2 - - ,� Note: Boundaries indicated
�(' TuAT r/-r on this figure are approximate
�-�,�
1lJ�J..17nVV ENVIRONMENT'AL SERVICES COMPANY and do not constitute an
^�y Source:ESRI Streets Basemap official survey product.
�. ,. ". t, " x ��y`�,a, � �: �i:,,'i'r'.�,. a `,.F4 . .�+� ,.r " �, • ^.�. '�... wF,�:w t
., '{
, u
. r�,p�. �q , � � ' � ...
.,� °' �t,r e ' „ � �` �" �� � \ '�sv� �,'��la. '4.` i�„'��.�'�. �R° �.. e .�� ,-t ..
�� _ . _ k � � ,. :_y'� `'F � R�t, a��`°'y ei.w� . p � { 4.,,�.�.° 'Z.,,..���� + ' r ..
,,
. . • � :
, , �
'��� �� �x���., ����. �1 i 9��'�•�� ,�� .&°"^� ,� ^aw+....� y��R�.�� ,� �°'+� � � ;I�.a�
� � i �� . ' '�. '2, ;""+t... � �4a 'I.,,"� i' _y:a . 'n . � * \^. M.k
��+ �. � � . -'-� '�i 1�yfpl"�'S �k'. � �i�. � � ��� .h� "'eyy
�.,�
� � 1�
,.. i . . .._.. ♦ � '�
p � ` �+'�q, �� �"�k '� �i s � � � ��� ` y� �'G �� :�`r�
} .
�,k.�;T � �,.,. , a`'` '� � ;� `.,'tL T .Y `LL�4* . '4� ..�`:.. 1,. "rr .� cyr� � �' � ."'�4 ���q� -
� ` �,.
�*$. `'#l. h')L . «' �,,
. _
n . .
, �� �; i `'� Y� �''S ., �, '*„ ' ' `,4 a,,: �4. � � ���i�,
w •
.
� �'1., � ;
, � ,,< .. _ , ,
° �• ,,. ��, , �'� s,w�y "t . ...4 ,� f !. . ��,
.''� „ "
,. , � c'
� �� �k .,,...�.E,i� . 3 t�., � .,.. �i ������ �.�_ e $'"!"5��,,, .•�°�,.. 't.. �� .�+��y. �,++�� . . 4
tg} �. . . ..`z� r�6t�` �� �y'l� �A� � �"1�. � �li�'y{ ���,.` �r � ' er��� �� �� � '�4������ �g'
� a
t 'v.'. "„ � ' N R R� � '� , y.•.�y . `'w � w� '
, , , ,` � � � .,�,�
. .� d� � �ir- � � , �� � . � » �
. � . . �� .
� " e '*� - — - ' . -.. " A ' . , �'�
,� � � , s w � �,.�.4 -�- "� `'� i � � -""w"�,� �Y-,'" �� �t� �
, '
,
�.s'.�� �` .�`�,:
�'"„ s. �- ',,,;.. � _� - .�µ ` e6 ' � ,4 �9 '�.,'v« '�^+R�`0�. . � a .x`� &y' ����ii. ;>,...�j* w'{..
� a
.
;... ,r�.::�,�.:. �h, .. "Tfe "�-.. � „ .�# �.�< Ys�,W .. ' ""Yh � •c� �� }, ��,� �� �� .
, '
. .� y
�4.. ,,''i ,� �. ' w`. � z�',t.. $� �� :1� #�l` �.x '! �r���h
tl
-
�'a. F . ` =t . . .., �'s' .! ,d . _ �i= ���+r. �� ,. `� y�.
, '
. a �.` a=, v � � ''�.� � . r' � �— A.
� � ��� a• :, � 4
�.. 4 ,� . .. ` ". _ �'r ._ .
„ - � � s ��y
.x . .
� . � .��~ .: ��� '4..� R ' M; * •� k'^'3 ,_^ � �� .,� b � � `��+
� �� k. .� � � 'h „ �,"^Y � :� � .. . . e * �' .�..
. a. �* ., .} a a�.
�^ c�+ t w�',�.�4 .�.,� "�};e., s� " ,�„-. �- ,i s t �,...:e"�z,,l�,� - *"°;k` ��! -
. �� �e� * �.�-�.
"+.'",��.��,.y� C- ' �:" , : Y�7/� � �� . F .
-.���"^a"v;,;q,�.4�c' �'-: r• '� ���. , � ���� '�'� � �.�` � �s � ``,�. � .. �,y,�_�,.
s
,z .
.
� :.. '�.� ; - "'
m �� � �� �� �
- e �• "e. , , -� " ¢
, :
�� .."M, �'�_ � �... , � t '�,?< �.,�e�,<�,y'°�� .� �' �� "�''���x�3z^` `'� e °V�'�
w �
E: �. `y... .�€.�g l; . � ey, �� . ���` .:.
�'i '� Iir�kY'' ` 4" �
, x
.- ' .f�+..� �. '� ��� k ��` '-.�g � . ' ,� _ ��` '� �"�N''w t '�a kr y.. � -i�.
, . , .� -
„ _
�` ,'y'y�,'y' �'�' '.�; � .�., �`" bs« ., a- .�y�.� ���� y� i�. `�'q,"'K �'�. �4� "'kr,
�- � y�� . ,,�
�++�-,«.� . 8+. \; . � , k,� 7' " :i
�ti" `"" 's ' . . � •s�� ` -''`�"
„� ' .
r.�• -- '.� ,� "�,�'��';` " ' v � ��. .� `a '' "'_ � � �� , ,a� �,q �
:_ '- " +R,. "�rv: 4'�,�. �^y"z� � „��r � '�«y� �. .p . ' , � � 4'� � `
F , • ��"': �„ �.
,
w.
. . . . , :
�. �+��r ,� ,�. •„���� �w;,: A, � �, �, �� t�
, . �,
� ��� . .,� � _ �r� �:. �:
:,��� w:� �, � � � � � � � - � � �� �� ' � ..�
� �
,
''��a��' # � ` � ����� � �
�� � ;��v._ ��" �'ti'i►,��;�`"� m, a�_ + 'i' Y� . �.:� - ^ _� ��: . ;�� �. a�'c_
1e' .'4' � '"Me°'..�. �r*'�h :�� ' ,�* ��� �������'+ �� y� __" "e ��'r.
�•' '� �" '
. .. � �.. ,.y � M� M. �a Nk . ' . !� ',� � ����� ,a _ ,� �� �
, � . �
�. ..,... .. w y.� "+� � � '..
r.� TMs -"�.�i '"� N., a . ,,.. .,,,._±��"y��,�, _ • . �.,,?hy �� _�y'",�.'�`:a,, #�� ���'-l�.. q �,At . � '�
ro .
� � 4"' �'4�R. "^..� 'iV b.-".- - ��Y Y*R'�,.� �.. ��'"'� i� . � q ;
` .
M1 "�
'*°,� ��,-6 n `�* "+��4 ,4v r, .. w ' f, � .�M'�� , a,"W �* �'�� ""�.� .r'�° ,�} ��
' ;.
. v �,
� i,4 a ��i t � , �� 's. � .' .r, , ". �
f�� .re s � � � �
.
. xN ,` ,L�"`�``. ��y,�. � , k � � 1 � �:� � `��; �"e �" ''
� ''_,_ .. .p
�,� �. � �" t_ . ° x_ai� �i4p,.., ,, .�� «�.i :: ,� ���. ::.; .. ��.�� e �.+%�..� �,je'�.�'tit� ��.'qA� �g �.'�k�
�� ,
�.. -
t�. �. .v. .z .
-�.g �,.�i�� 'p ' , ,, � y� , " � �, � �+�qKk �4 _;i � '�u"�
�' � *.
.
,�
. �'�. �� f�i� �A�,� ,
� � . , V
� � r � . �
e ' , � � L
u
µ I M �i�' � �'�� ^�,.
_� e y
:.:, .�-+�p '
'�F^r' ,.., .�z�� . : : '�' ws... �� :Kr� .. a .:. �'Ta,k"' ..�`. . , a �
+
_ �� M£ "�`�. ',�.;. ,�, st a ` h'�. �-° ���-,��. _�,"'_,'a��-"k', '1�_.,�`+�•'^aa,:�.�y���w�e u �'��F"
+ '� " "..�"k. ' �," � ,.z�" - �^"��"'` , �t� .- a� �-�' 'dn�a' �' �g�
x , � n
Yt .�- '�'' . L . , a.. "�n� - �' � €. `R_,� _'�n 1r�, .���� a ,r '-,�°�'i
, , .. ,w � , y... ..�'ti�. ..�
., .r��� 3� , ,.. =t..=-' �,y .. `__ • er 4�� ., ..�. , ' .�� �-#;�s '�' �-4 �♦s ��.,, ��'
�
+
. � n � � ���� i� ���
� � �` :� a �� �' `h �
".� � � "�'''�,' .. � � ,� ',� �� ,,, `�:,�� �i:
t , , � -
,
.�. " .- '� k �ti . �.
' ;, " ."! � '" ��"' AN ��
, ;
�'' �, � "�..
. .�: . �.�
. .
� � ���� :� �� '` � � �,�,�q �Y.r �'� , �
<
. '
� ,.. ,� � `; ' �#„,{ � -
� , ;
: . �:
k
_ M � _ ', '. .^ _
itr��+�, �* � .M' ,. " � 'T,�'".iCo *!g ��
A
; 'an F
, . ^� . ' .. - ,�. . .
� ,. , �. � a;�. .. ' vr.
,. :.� ti p < N . . �.y . ; � r- � �� ��.
�� 'r� •
dl� !UI�:.
. r , f�..�� "°
�"
, ��.
•' � � "�
p. :� �re " ,., t t �k� � k. � ', �. � - '.�v TM��: Q� `Y
s.� i +t
I
� z �� r . �, r
s
,�..�5 � . � -.:�
.s -., .. .� � , � � „
. .
. � -� � � ,. ._,
,.� -�, ; ,� ., _ _ .,,�.. �. �_ �. ..� �' -y
r ,
- e. . � s � �. , •��
Figure 2 - Existing Conditions
N 0 100 Sullivan Property (KES 2016-148)
� � � � � Orono, Minnesota
- Feet � Project Boundary
2 ,�, Note: Boundaries indicated
KJo�'n�VG ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES COMPANY on this figure are approximate
�,�� and do not constitute an
��� source:M�ooesora uNa(zo�3) ofticial survey product.
� � �'_ � , �`~�_r, '•` I~�� �4 � ` . � � � ��`�
� 'r 1 .�, ��
i=� � I� r�i,t �� ���ti` � � � � �� ._ �_ .,�J t�
�.� � �'� � ����� +l � � 1 ��L_.� � �._. �
� L�� :
1 • ,, � �� i+ 41�� T •�41■�
J ,�.•', ,1 J � ��I��� �' �j+ �aa� �T y � � _,f� -
� z rr� �5�� �( � � ai� �i�W �
� ti�� � ti�i� 1 � I�r - � - � , �
�� � '
� +
� � � �� ' � � �
� . � �' � yy������
�ti ,� �
.�.i�t�• .�:._ � � r� � �i� �5 ti_� ��-,�. ''-�. ��� �r"" ''��yy���� �''a. .'r � +
�• I � • � I � S � ',� �-�4 j� _�,~t�'�L� r � ' +{i r �r
I 4L• y �, ��� '�'�I ,���L ��'r'� h r y���'~ �� � ,Y' s r
4 '+L
s1 z� t,`� � � �� �` � �� i` �,!
S 1 �. t �L. �7 � J 1 J
L.�� �• '� � � =� ~�� ~ �. ��.�r ��a.' �I '� I f
'� _~L Z.� ~'i_ ►7 A � �, �
��!J � '�'~_�� ~'"�_��` �h y' � �' � � �y, '��:' �s�a��y I
r , � �
i � � ��� � � � r `7 � �' Lv 1 r �a � �
+�' •� — � � I : � � 1
i � �� � � � � •. � �
1!':: � 1- �� I �L� •���� �� _; � '�� —� .% �.-•� �t y� �� .�,4.
� � f• j'r• JI —z�.� 'L �' �{� �► � �I f yti ti�`�1
1 ,r �' {• � � I� `. rr�i, -fr �r, ,7 �V
. � � �.. �T�• � � � � 'a~��1 r' % 1 �4
� � �.'ti L � '�. �v- �-'ar��'s i 7 � i �.zr' (
�� � � � �� .r� ��.�� � •� � �1 � f,
.. • ��� � , � 4 �� •'� .�. I ���7� '� � t �� • � r'� '
`� �1 �+ � , J •
�S�? � �— �`"�` � �. ��� �T'��,�� ' �'t�." ' '` � r- �.
� � ` ` �1 �L 1� � i �, 1 � �� I .
jr J ■
-r1 V`� ' �. .�� � �1�—fi1 I r �� '�y�:� r '
,ti ' .i■� � � � � � � r r r����, �'� II
. I �� i ��* i� ti � � i f ��
. �� • /� � ' I � � � �i�= ♦�'f �� ��� I �� �
•� •� i[ • ( r i�i � (i •f �� i �•��+ r �-J
_ 1 � �, � � ,� _ - . � � � �r z , •�—�
� {z �
_. � � — �— -�'', "� �_ �
_::�� 1
' ' • � �� 0 �-� r �`r�`��� � I�'� � �� .
I �6 Iy ��, � r i�I''*� �''•�_*'.'•� � ��'•�'� -
I ! �� � • • .� � ��� _:� ~ k : • r--
� y � . �' �+� _�►'' ( ' I ' � — •''"'''-�.��� ,��: � r '
' �'-� �,.1'� •- 1 _`•'.,�'--�r "� � �—z (�1� ,.�L._
5 v I � ��` ti -����,z � ;i f �'•.�'` ~~�
'ti '� �_•t 4 ti 1 �' •__
Figure 3 - USGS Topography
N 0 400 Sullivan Properiy (KES 2016-148)
Orono Minnesota
, ,
� � Feet � Project Boundary
% ' � Note: Boundaries indicated
JOTu� on this tigure are approximate
LI111UG ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES COMPANY and do not constitute an
�w
+�,�ti sou�ce:nr�neso�a nNR official survey product.
�: aY :iY ,.,,.��? t� `• .,� �i, �Sr • , R .� A"X �`� �5 �: ..�3�.4'�.a` �, '`�w . �.,, � 'i�" � .s �A�-� �. �,�,.,:
-e > . � � ' '` y� r�''. �i,� �`_"� . '�< ���+ ,b1�+ .-�a� �, �, ,�: :�*.�
, .. _
. .
y�, ."�'�,����4�.�.Fy'�� . �♦* 'A.� „"�,.� � . :.,,y �, ., i'i� '��,.,,a;. q,� _ ��' rr�. -
�����.,, T4. N k p y ^ 'Y �y �.'. '�,��'" .��w.� � a„ ,.�;( 4 .�.y� 4'... ::'� ..� .
�e {'i if. � �� V �� '�!
i� „�. �'# R� � ,_ ���"'���h��� � ���.�. ��,L. �`,�`r�. 4 � � T �'��.`�.' � p,� �:"''. :�,� # :
�5. �r�V�,,� �
.. �t _�iy�,�
t '�, }�� �� .��M y�� ' ._ T��. �.. i« .�"�.' Td��'p'M X " 'A.:�,.,v
�' �'� �`4.Lt��� �F��, .4��`� ,�..�` � .
u, �
w,"h =� �dw j^� .F,: `- �. . � �! �
,�,.�� �,� � . i - `1- � .. ''� ^a*� . . � �"t.' A
�, �,: .`,�, 4' ` �,,. .��:�� k �� ��, ' ' _ PUBGx
�` �. � �'�,1.,a� -' �. �� i°"� ,y� ��.� ..,� � �r a.
'�� - '+ R'�'� +.*+��,y. �g#,' .L ,Y . �'{ yg � � '�
.' 1. ,��� �'�'�i �t � -T� �� s n"
�.`.. YA j���'''�,: . ��'k � *. ~` `�}�k - � � � �
. ,„ .
�%' ;'` �-'; 1 -+ti �.``�.
� �, ,�., k _ � , � � �.�91.�.
' _ . - -� �. �
t
.
, . } �, ,�• 'r - ' .. .� ...MN...� °.�� � ""�� • . ..
i..� � i` �� ' � �r� � a e� � �`d"�k�F•'��°�ti����. ;�.�'. . _ .,_._..
��� ' '�� ` . . ' -
' `
i ,�t
. '. :- , ��, .c.'~ _ ..
i ��� �
, . .
�a' M , . a R . .. � _ � _ 'a, . .. . `'e: �� �
'�., �, A
`";��'�Mt , �. ��.►.. , _.. � �C. � �:y � .c '� a��"�' � - .`w
., . .
. �. , �
�p 1r'� .+�� . � ,„s�^., - 't, .i�
` �Jt. • .. , _ , � ,
! ' f
.; ..�'4`� '"�*: .r�' '� � . . �,�,.. + ';�r� '� �� ° � * �.�. . .� ., -�.,
� !*. �'.� __
,� � a a,,' �" �`' . '�r!�" �'�. ,,� .� ' r.
� ._ ' ��.. '� "� ���� '""r, � '- '�t'�Fs. +t���.< M ,�.I .���~ . - � � Y § . :H.
�4 .� �. '��_� �'" yi..
. • .� i n
-� c' ,. � ' . '�.+�,,,y a� � ' ,. , �. ��..
', � - � . , �� - ,��
.
��I
x r,�u '* . , `#� , ` �.
��
-� a � �• ,��` m ���` ` �� �� �„
';�;� q�� �'; �c. �+ i' ;a . - r �" ,�,. . ' , .� .
,�. � --4., , ��"! ��;���_,-' �r� �' P U B G x , � . ,� ♦,� '�� � �'-
...,, `� ,�+a p '.�- _ ..� 5e V '� ���� v�"R,�,"%i,'� �+w��"• � :�� rt, .,'k- � ,.'� �.A`. �` �F�
P E M 1 C „�� � �'�,� �.�, � . � , " :_"�; `` 'w , .,�.�r ��'�,_,�-��. . "��• ��-,� � �.�. .
�`: .,� "',��„ � '�'+..,��. �'� ���i.���y,,��`°��'vC�:� .,+`� �- {,� � ,�,.r' >,�p`+ �� -..
, , .
; ; s.
� . , -� . � , , -.� .,
. f . ''�;�,.� .., �� ��y ; ,�„� "�.,�..yA�'°� "�t"�,' � 2 ' "✓� li , �.,.
� �� y i!:� � �,.
��k �� �.1��, � �. ��-0i�� �"`W' �.R .�.;�d�.� , !.�'`^`�R►�: � � a ��9.i��w k"�.4 '��' `� � � �y `i.
.`nv � J� . '_,2d ' .. $ �. " s('�. � i t ��`�'4 "�5�hq*� �=' `-�k Q,�� ""�,,. .,�. �.. ,� �4; ^,,� � 4 �.�� # ,
a°.^��` ^ ,�' x4 " i �• - ` t.;r , �* .i�' ' �a z ax�. f 's.�. 3' "` .rA '� ,[- �
.�y,�.3 �, � �.�', -��+. �'� �`x a�,y�, ��+'� "�� �.�- s� �, ' y � -','� �,�.^e ��
,...,: . ,.. .,,
� ' � �, �
,
�`� "4. �+ � b y��� '`�.. �, �`-j a �F- - �'��y. ''�' ' ` � � "°'
_ � . +�, . . 'k �- �,
.sr�p "��.: a +t.s �Slqe°' . , � � :1r �=a +vw', "`�°
� s ,
C' � '3" �'�c'�„ �� ;�, � ;w. � ` � � �� „� •� � � ;, , '-, ` �' 'w��
� � ;��� � a , .. ��� s�. *`�� ,4 �;�" ••"�c�`- � -"� _ ��� � ,,� ' � �,� ' � v " y .
g
.,� �,.� �s �, ,�., tw�.;�r . g
�-
�
, -.
. . . � `..�, r " . �"',
ti
•. - � , - �- -' ', •� ���.� ��� �'k
.
^� ' � 'k _ �' ����� � '.,: * ��',...
� . . .. ;' P,� .'b";Y„�`ly� '#" �9:
. ' ., � _ . '. .
.
.
' 1. .:a .- ' . t•,�sd+ ��„ . t � .
~ ��
_ � � � � � ��. '� `�'r, '�:w�� '♦ - y�� .
. � . � �� � �, , wr. 'wi��� ��`� � �-�9�"�S
r 1 =, �
� � r� �� a ,",�,� `« � � �� �t'�
7
_ y,
..:. . �- _ � ..� .. � .- _
,. _ y . , .. � .
�yy� �r .-. � . r.. �f, ..: .- .,: m�`��s
_ t. •
�` .
�y .
�` � �, �� Y �,��.`: � PUBGx
. . � �.� �� t�� � 4., .ir •.� ' - �. �' %��� �.i ,z�",`` �... �s
�r � � , .., , . �.x �,.. "' .:
�
.
, +i�'� e -� T .. -. • �. : „ ,*�'' $,��� t.
:sF.. !�, <.' :k�. 4 F������� .t4,';k,'� � ���'"�.'s�,5 r ���.,.w+�'` -
. .� �_ ��,� H^.
,.� � �
PEM1C��` `� PEM1C � �_
PUB .+ �,
Figure 4 - National Wetlands Inventory
N 0 150 Sullivan Property (KES 2016-148)
, � Orono, Minnesota
� � Feet
2 � � Note: Boundarics indicated
KJo�uG on this figure are approximate
�-�.+
ENVIRONMENT'AL SERVICES COMPANY and do not constitute an
�� Source:�tinnesota DNR(2013),USFWS OftlCla�SUNey pl'OCjUCY.
ti
L41 C2
L41E
W
�."w,.
��, .�,�
49!°'
L41 C2
I .19,A
L41 C 2
t
} f
`L23A���� -
: � �
�i
L37B °
� L36A
� �,,y�,
� � � . W
a �;� e'' �.r
* "� ' L41 C 2 L41 E
L16A� i
` � k� See narrative for.soil series information.
Figure 5 - Soil Survey
N 0 150 Sullivan Property (KES 2016-148)
. � I I Hydric/Predominantly Hydric Orono, Minnesota
Feet
-" ` � Non-Hydric/Predominantly Non-Hydric Note: [3oundarics indicated
�u� KJTu� �� on this figure arc approximatc
OLIlI'1UG ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES COMPANY Paftlally HydflC and do not constitutc an
���v so�rce:us�n,nRCs official survey product.
� - .,
z k �`""'' � �
" ,
� � . � � �. � S. x�.'��m ' � �+:-,.� , ..
�� � � °.������ Footing to Wetland Edge � � � � �� �� �� �� "�
4 r � "�.,;
�, ' 36 Fee?
a4�� ^` �� ' �� �
`� �{ f ^� . � � ,i = ����" �J�p�
- . ��� , '.��! '�� .^�, yA : a d�. �� Of
�
,q
��� . . .. s, .. . � .
�
' . . �' ` . ,. '`�d�#�: ffi: , �;;� � ..s. ' ^�9 . , .�.- �t0
. � �A^:m^';�. �". _.�. , �tQp � i ,t� � Or1
�,� �,.�� "'= t "� �'�
980 �,�� u �;� y �'` �e� �� �? i- � �a,=p �� F
. �
� ' � t�
.� .. � ,,� , s . " . z �
�.
, _,., .
k ,za
9k} �� �:. ;�;�`�`�`�`'.. �� �� � ' ,i '� - xyq��. �
� , .
f �" ➢ �.�^ a[ 7
� . � ��.. j . " . . ' . . �
� k�"i�, �� �4 .�s " �� .F ����,I�������� y ��� ��� k
:
� �{ e
�� • �r r k � i�
�
. . �` ��
�
� r � � ^ry � ���� �I'�� � � �« ��
�,:� _
��+.^ � � .�' :,, , �l ,r �- � � �� � � :
+,a�''" �.��, r. �
Footing to 6
`� °"�- `�' ��� ' � � �� ���� �` �
Wetland Edge a� �j �� �; g ,� �tt ;� ,
�
35 Feet f •
, � r '` " ��e"_ "�k,- �.
. � � � ����' �� ���, ��Narrow Type 2 PEMB � � � '
� , �,�,� ti Wetland Fringe with , � '�"�. _
� _. - , " d
. ;«,.,� :
� , � , Boul er Toe �; „
. � �a �� ^�' � ° _ �: ,� � �` ,.�"":,,,�
:,�� a s� � ,�ii;� � ���:-.. ;,� ' z� ",�. �.
2
� , ,��` :�
� m
,� � � �°'� �°���� '��� -�.'� .,
ii��� ",..�. � .r � � �'w,s.� 1�'= � � �"�� � �"
`�: ''���� . .�` .. ��.� : ,��� ?'�" - - � �.w��I� � �� . . �� . � ��� ��a� ' .g �... � - .
.. .. w�... . - ,��$ .:_ , •�g_ ,� � � ,c�'�'�`".. .._. ,�'q�:.�'� ' . �#�'- � t z�
�:w " ��� #' �, ��j` 96a ����� +4.� . fi� rn� `��� s� �N�
� 4 �.�� ,� .. �� � ,J � ��� , ..'/�� ������I{�F�.' ,��� .4�..
� „F
.. ,
� • tA � r
�� r � � l � �-a"_'r�`,�, °� � � � �
� r �`,{�'��� �A�A�/�. '� �" .� ���-� ,{ p� g�,,, �,
w x:;. ;� ,�y��.i+;� '��7�� .x'n y :5
�'� , � '..9�,�rg�N r°'i �a � �.:.� ��. ��� � �. � .
�: �� �,r. "''s , .. �:
il ._r . .�,P' . .. � �� �{ 'i,�� .
., ' . . ..- �.�� -
�, A ';� ,�. ,t $� � *a'' Deepwater Habitat L1 UBHx t . 'N
"""�:. " " (Non-Wetland) � '�` `
� . ,
, :. , m
�. : , F
, -s: � , �3
�
��;
t :�- �,,��, � ,,x � �' . , , �
� . � ��'
.- .�. ���. �} � �i `sv.. .., y8O
Figure 6 - Level 1 Wetland Delineation with Onsite Setback Measurement
N 0 40 Sullivan Property(KES 2016-148)
� �Feet �Project Boundary H Onsite Setback Measurement Orono,Minnesota
`` � Deepwater Habitat Hennepin County Lidar Note:Boundaries indicated
1lJOLL711UG ENVIRONMENTAL SERVICES COMPANY on this figurc arc approximate
�.w Wetland Fringe and do not constitute an
+���/ Suurce:l!SGS official survey product.
Sullivan Property
Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report
and No-Loss Application
APPENDIX A
Joint Application Form for Activities
Affecting Water Resources in Minnesota
Project Name and/or Number: SWlivan Property
Joint Application Form for Activities Affecting Water Resources in Minnesota
PART ONE: Applicant Information
If applicant is an entity(company,government entity, partnership, etc.),an authorized contact person must be identified. If the
applicant is using an agent(consultant, lawyer,or other third party) and has authorized them to act on their behalf,the agent's
contact information must also be provided.
Project Name: Sullivan Property
Applicant/Landowner Name: Timothy Sullivan
Mailing Address: 440 Brown Road South,Orono,MN 55391
Phone: (507)202-5363
E-mail Address: tmsullivann�d(a;gmail.com
Authorized Contact(do not complete if same as above): Rob Bouta,Kjolhaug Environmental Services Co.
Mailing Address: 26105 Wild Rose Lane, Shorewood,MN 55331
Phone: (612)581-0546
E-mail Address: RobB(n kjoll�au�env.com
Agent Name: Rob Bouta,Kjolhaug Environmental Services Co.
Mailing Address: 26105 Wild Rose Lane,Shorewood,MN 55331
Phone: (612) 581-0546
E-mail Address: KobB(n;kjolhaugenv.com
PART TWO: Site Location Information
County: Hennepin City/Township: Orono
Parcel ID and/or Address: PID: 03-117-23-42-0012/Address: 440 Brown Road South,Orono,MN 55391
Legal Description(Section,Township,Range): NE '/ of NE '/ of SE Y of Section 3,T117N,R23W
Lat/Long(decimal degrees): 44.970664,-93.568578
Attach a map showing the location of the site in relation to local streets,roads, highways. See Figure 1
Approximate size of site(acres)or if a linear project, length(feet): 2.5 acres
If you know that your proposal will require an individual Permit from the U.S.Army Corps of Engineers,you must provide the
names and addresses of all property owners adjacent to the project site. This information may be provided by attaching a list to
your application or by using block 25 of the Application for Department of the Army permit which can be obtained at:
http://www.mvp.usace.army.mil/Portals/57/docs/re�ulatory/Regulator�Docs/en�form 4345 2012oct.pdf
PART THREE: General Project/Site Information
If this application is related to a delineation approval,exemption determination,jurisdictional determination, or other
correspondence submitted prior to this application then describe that here and provide the Corps of Engineers project number.
Describe the project that is being proposed,the project purpose and need, and schedule for implementation and completion.The
project description must fully describe the nature and scope of the proposed activity including a description of all project elements
that effect aquatic resources(wetland, lake,tributary,etc.)and must also include plans and cross section or profile drawings
showing the location, character,and dimensions of all proposed activities and aquatic resource impacts.
The home on the property is being repaired and the garage is being remodeled. The wetland delineation was completed to
demonstrate compliance with municipal setback requirements. The wetland/deepwater habitat has a narrow wetland fringe and
the landowner is also proposing to remove accumulated sediment from the isolated deepwater habitat.
Minnesota Interagency Water Resource Application Form February 2014 Page 1 of 4
Project Name and/or Number: Sullivan Property
PART FOUR: Aquatic Resource Impact15ummary
If your proposed project involves a direct or indirect impact to an aquatic resource (wetland, lake, tributary, etc.) identify each
impact in the table below. Include all anticipated impacts,including those expected to be temporary.Attach an overhead view map,
aerial photo, and/or drawing showing all of the aquatic resources in the project area and the location(s) of the proposed impacts.
Label each aquatic resource on the map with a reference number or letter and identify the impacts in the following table.
Aquatic Aquatic Type of Duration of Overall Size County,Major
Impact(f��i, Size of Watershed#,
Resource ID Resource Type Impact z of Aquatic Existing Plant Community
excavate,drain,or Impact a T e s in Im act Area° and Bank
(as noted on (wetland,lake, Permanent(P)or Resource YP ( � P
remove (square feet) Service Area#
overhead view) tributary etc.) Temporary(T)' (square feet)
vegetation) of Impact Areas
Wetland/ Hennepin Co.
Excavated Fresh wet meadow/ Mississippi
Wetland 1 Deepwater Excavate Permanent 15,140 18,490 Deepwater habitat �ver Metro
Habitat (20)Bank
Service Area 7
Total 15,140 18,490
llf impacts are temporary;enter the duration of the impacts in days next to the"T". For example,a project with a temporary access till that
would be removed after 220 days would be entered"T(220)".
zlmpacts less than 0.01 acre should be reported in square feet. Impacts 0.01 acre or greater should be reported as acres and rounded to the
nearest 0.01 acre. Tributary impacts must be reported in linear feet of impact and an area of impact by indicating first the linear feet of impact
along the flowline of the stream followed by the area impact in parentheses). For example,a project that impacts 50 feet of a stream that is 6
feet wide would be reported as 50 ft(300 square feet).
3This is generally only applicable if you are applying for a de minimis exemption under MN Rules 8420.0420 Subp.8,otherwise enter"N/A".
°Use Wetland Plants and Plant Community Types of Minnesota and Wisconsin 3�d Ed.as modified in MN Rules 8420.0405 Subp.2.
SRefer to Major Watershed and Bank Service Area maps in MN Rules 8420.0522 Subp.7.
If any of the above identified impacts have already occurred, identify which impacts they are and the circumstances associated
with each: No impacts have alreadv occurred.
PART FIVE: Applicant Signature
❑ Check here if you are requesting a pre-application consultation with the Corps and LGU based on the information you have
provided. Regulatory entities will not initiate a formal application review if this box is checked.
By signature below, I attest that the information in this application is complete and accurate. I further attest that I possess the
authority to undertake the work described herein.
�� .
� '�_____��f
Signature: Date: Z Z Sp�( �p ��.
I hereby authori � olhaug Environmental Services to act on my behalf as my agent in the processing of this application and to
furnish,upon request,supplemental information in support of this application.
1 The term"impact"as used in this joint application form is a generic term used for disclosure purposes to identify
activities that may require approval from one or more regulatory agencies. For purposes of this form it is not meant to
indicate whether or not those activities may require mitigation/replacement.
Minnesota Interagency Water Resource Application Form February 2014 Page 2 of 4
Project Name and/or Number: Sullivan Property
Attachment A
Request for Delineation Review, Wetland Type Determination, or Jurisdictional
Determination
By submission of the enclosed wetland delineation report, I am requesting that the U.S.Army Corps of Engineers,St. Paul District
(Corps)and/or the Wetland Conservation Act Local Government Unit(LGU) provide me with the following(check all that apply):
�Wetland Type Confirmation
� Delineation Concurrence. Concurrence with a delineation is a written notification from the Corps and a decision from the LGU
concurring, not concurring, or commenting on the boundaries of the aquatic resources delineated on the property. Delineation
concurrences are generally valid for five years unless site conditions change. Under this request alone,the Corps will not address
the jurisdictional status of the aquatic resources on the property,only the boundaries of the resources within the review area
(including wetlands,tributaries, lakes,etc.).
❑ Preliminary Jurisdictional Determination.A preliminary jurisdictional determination (PJD) is a non-binding written indication
from the Corps that waters,including wetlands, identified on a parcel may be waters of the United States. For purposes of
computation of impacts and compensatory mitigation requirements,a permit decision made on the basis of a PJD will treat all
waters and wetlands in the review area as if they are jurisdictional waters of the U.S. PJDs are advisory in nature and may not be
appealed.
�Approved Jurisdictional Determination.An approved jurisdictional determination(AJD) is an official Corps determination that
jurisdictional waters of the United States are either present or absent on the property.AJDs can generally be relied upon by the
affected party for five years.An AJD may be appealed through the Corps administrative appeal process.
In order for the Corps and LGU to process your request,the wetland delineation must be prepared in accordance with the 1987
Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual,any approved Regional Supplements to the 1987 Manual,and the Guidelines for
Submitting Wetland Delineations in Minnesota(2013).
http://www.mvp.usace.army.mil/Missions/Re�ulatorv/DelineationJDGuidance.aspx
Minnesota Interagency Water Resource Application Form February 2014 Page 3 of 4
Project Name and/or Number: Sullivan Property
Attachment B
Supporting Information for Applications Involving Exemptions, No Loss
Determinations, and Activities Not Requiring Mitigation
Complete this part if you maintain that the identified aquatic resource impacts in Part Four do not require wetland
replacement/compensatory mitigation OR if you are seeking verification that the proposed water resource impacts are either
exempt from replacement or are not under CWA/WCA jurisdiction.
Identify the specific exemption or no-loss provision for which you believe your project or site qualifies:
The proposed sediment removal is eligible for no-loss certification under the Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act.
Specifically,the proposed sediment removal is eligible under the No-Loss Criterion set forth under Minnesota Rules Part
8420.0415,A,"an activity that will not impact a wetland."
The proposed sediment removal is not regulated under Section 404 of the Federal Clean Water Act because the excavation
will be conducted with an excavator or backhoe. The excavated material will be loaded on trucks and hauled to a location
where it can be deposited on upland and used as black dirt. The activity will not result in a discharge of dredged or fill
material into waters of the United States.
Provide a detailed explanation of how your project or site qualifies for the above. Be specific and provide and refer to attachments
and exhibits that support your contention.Applicants should refer to rules(e.g.WCA rules),guidance documents(e.g. BWSR
guidance,Corps guidance letters/public notices),and permit conditions(e.g.Corps General Permit conditions)to determine the
necessary information to support the application.Applicants are strongly encouraged to contact the WCA LGU and Corps Project
Manager prior to submitting an application if they are unsure of what type of information to provide:
Removal of accumulated sediment from the deepwater habitat is eligible for no-loss certification under the Minnesota
Wetland Conservation Act. Sediment removal was discussed with the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District during an
onsite pre-application meeting on September 16.2016. Samples subsequently obtained from the pond bottom showed
approximately 6 feet of mucky/silty sediment. At a depth of approximately 6 feet,the pond substrate abruptly transitioned
to gleyed blue-gray clay loam.
The proposed sediment removal meets no-loss criteria listed under Minnesota Rules Part 8420.0415,A.,because removal of
sediment from a deepwater habitat is"an activity that will not impact a wetland."
The only water resource to be affected by excavation will be the deepwater habitat. The narrow Type 2 wetland fi-inge will
be avoided. The excavation will be conducted during winter conditions to minimize disturbance and sedimentation.
The landowner would like to remove accumulated sediment down to the blue-gray clay layer,which corresponds to the
depth of the original excavation. Excavation of sediment with an excavator or backhoe will restore the deepwater habitat to
the previous maximum pond depth of approximately 10 feet,which existed following the original excavation.
T'he proposed sediment removal is not regulated by the U.S.Army Corps of Engineers under Section 404 of the Clean Water
Act because it will not involve the discharge of dredged or fill material into waters of the United States. Sediment removal
will be accomplished using an excavator or backhoe with a sealed bucket. The excavator will load the bottom sediment
onto trucks and it will be hauled to a site where it can be used and deposited on upland. The black soils from the bottom
sediments will likely be used as top dressing on fill or m'viced with topsoil.
Minnesota Interagency Water Resource Application Form February 2014 Page 4 of 4
Sullivan Property
Modified Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report
and No-Loss Application
APPENDIX B
Property Boundary Survey
Mewse•T?•w lntr__.'.•�r. �,,, ;: ..-
r
__.
,n
� .'" x'f !9 -�.^�,a't ..• , �
–___–_'__________'� "________^____'– '. �`�i,� 'lm .
\ _____ _,-- --__� ___– ___._ _
� A� I!'. -�^.�". F`R� ,
` ,.n^ , . , ���l �.� �� _,
� ,�, .� .p� �i—'.�'` ,
`1\ � 4� • ,,'^n � . �/��v�j�� .
\ • � `.a F 4 I , XnFDCOVER
E%ISTNG
\x. /� yp h� /�f� .°�'3l ���.25C ST
y- OEG�f� SO SF
`\ - n .�� �s�� �rr..ae.�..c-orz �� �p•� � 19��. OPovpEw.9ESs9'
\
/ I flW�LLS.�00 3
\ , -_ y` . k d � . .`° TOi,LL�10p10 SF/9.lfi
\ Q`p � o. _-'�`� 1�.
\ �} s:.� ��i
.
{i� s
\ �,,,\ +~ �� �- � �F'��
` ` ;
\ '��� �� � \ � � � �// �
\ i � 4r '/�s I
�:sr�w '^ A .���.. �j�e I
. �.3: � � \ � � I � `� `� ,A'.i rJ.�'�.l �
� ! � �s i
8 � ��i ��'� j/ .
\ \ �' ��`, ^ /� �/ .,�� w
�� � � � � �� �� I
o � =t-�� ;i � R
� � o" � � �
\ ; �� ��. � .r%� � e
� �
i i
`\ ,.�� �s I , i�.,+ / � J/ QO� I �
��� �� �: ��.��d �-'r�'" �� ri� I � ��
� � __ \ I
� ;� . ; �
1 - -� /'f �� . � / � \� I
o xo �o so � ' �,, / ,.+' � V�
i
� � - . .__.-- .� .� �� 'y �� �� �
SCALE IN FEET , �--- --, ' .
d' . � . _ � _ __ �/ ',
�,��.�.,�, � A � � � --. — �r� a
,,\
• _ .,;,,� _ � �; � s
.rva�m ��.a�.,A» �� - �- .� , ,, �
..\ . �, i �a�"s
�.R� � ..
� _�„��.� , _� 6 �
w .w�.o�.�� �' � � � ---� �'
.�...����.,� � -- •„- -
. ---—
-;� �. .
�
v"`c :�o�.r°`n ao`°�°�oa�.w""°" j .a� ` i ior��'vM wu+r�ip�s�Han. ��2
� BROWN ROAO � �0 I , �i via�0-a�2 a�o s �e�
\�PRIVATEI .. } . _ _ . .. . I�..�., �%r�n�m�o�i�� ����
i .
� , :
"----i `'� /' /�� ` I SURVEY 5 SUB.ECT TO CIMNGE PER 4 O 1�
-'... �- ,-' �� \
%=
" ./ ' +`�` \ 1 TITIF OP E�SEIEM fsORYATqN �
'�.� � � , \__�L - �m��I1�
, �`� / .,• : rF� • . �� vERsr 1LL aQ1�lA NO J�
A�. ....d'' ,__.__L—�-��t:______"_r____________________________ ELEV/.TqIEWI1MPRfY05EDR�NS �Q��
__... ....."_.' - i
___.�
------------- VERIFY,VL SETB�CKS M9TM Giv � �'
� 'N G9'SS'ST E PD2JJ
�A
�
2
R
�
�
Sullivan Property
Modi�ed Level 1 Wetland Delineation Report
and No-Loss Application
APPENDIX C
Historical Aeri�l Photographs
r
M
O�
�
�
�
�
..
�
�
��:
/!. V ��
"i
,��~ *,�
� � �, ,,,.
!
�. �
�. �
"` � II
. � ���� .
,.
�
: ., , •,�F =
� �. '�,•+� -
� ,, �, .
� ..._ �f �
1 � s
. a `,f � �
'� , �"'"j
* �� I ���le� `�,.�
� �i
� �r � • . : * �
�4 � '1� � ,,�, � -�►
• � �
c
. . ,� � ,� , `
.
� ' �� * � 4� ` � "� ',� � —
- � �, . �
�
, .�
y .�,,, � „ � � �.� �. �. ,.,M,,
� ° ti ': �' r,
� � � � ` � Ir`��,
s .� � �
R � �
• �, ,�, "
� • � �..,, �
� � r
M � � ��:
l ' �
; � �
„ k 4
# . �
� . ; , « y� �..
� �
� �� �
► � +� a
, �I� �- � �
� � , ' �
. � a
, °,, � �� � ,, i� .
., + � s
1 � * � �` $
� � � � " ` •��� � � , , .. 'k
� � .
i '� � �� ��Y • �� •_• j , t .a ` „ �.
� T � �� x� � 1!
� � t� p �
4 i i
�� . �* � � e � x � ., Q r , 7
c. .� � � � « ,�
� sl� .. , . •
�
.. �:: n'. ��: H��' ,f��
� ���.� °�'}�Ga
� ��
�
� [
qW" '....,.
� �
� �
` � y
P � .v
��:
�
� �. P
��y �.
�
. }�� � � � ,� �;��.':
^"' . ��, %. .
��� �
� �
X4.� t
�
k
Y �
Y
mm�:�: �
� ���u� �� � + � � � �� � �_- E ` �U _ � _��� ���
�
, � � °
.
�
<" �.r �a �� �� � �+ ` '*w• ' ,e a ��� ,����
.
I i��, �� ��
� �� +" � . gM^ � . �' e �, I� ,� � ��.
. c
r � '�' * ,' a.�'�, � '�' � " . .ae� ':�'3Sec ���a.=+�r.,. ,
_ � _ x
- # �, ' .�� . - �� �� y
_- # . � - . " .. .� ���:� �a
� ��� � . . F 2��� #4�$ �� _
!
�.. }d% �fi
r � T �Y"�}•��� '� ~g, , � . � �''..�
� ���p�Y
� . ^s�
. . . , . - �c .�r "�^a . '.
j i �i
. ,.,, y: " �. ,- illp���l!�If��lj�'45�I�i��y1Vj��{�v��� ..,M � ;. . a
r� �'1
- -- � I� j� � aR
� :"�:•:� �;
. . . . � ��� `� "' _. * . .�,� . �`"�� . �*� . �ce'�� .. $j . . �.. � ��:« �e.._
�� � �+ ����'4��,� �s,� ' 4� g },� . . y,.
�N
.t . ,
, r
� ,r. � .�
« ,� , . . ,. � � � . �,Y�.:: ...
,: � `� � . . .�a �� a��"�"�
�, �� , .,.:,. � ,.�,�� � .... �� �,�� , . � . �. . �_ . .. . .
. ,�., : , � .: . ,. � .. .�, .,, . � ;_ ....� 3R' � � �'".. -�
` .y" � °; w.'k' �� a+' �
� � �„., ,�t
�`
- �M."�+.
,t z�'4, �
.
� , a �" �.
�.
.
,
,,,��' � _ . �
��`�' � • "
,� �� ,� :� ��^� F �
�� .�� ,,�", � . _
r.� �' '� �,� '�A � � �� � � �� � � y a ""F``�"�� �
� ,�f �,''� ; . �+�k �••�:�� w ,
� � �.
a� *' �� � ` ���� ��� .
• • s #
,.; .,.
.. ,
: �,��,� .. " �
�a� ��� ,�.
�aa� i+�'. f: . s
�,.x« �� ��t� �3� � � . � • ar #
�� :. �;,. � �� • s �
, �`� �� „� _ �! �
-� �� � � ,� � . �
�y� � ��
: ,
�P�
�
,� � � �.�: �� y'� � " ' • � .
, �. �� � �
rE
,. -
� �, � � . � ° . m� �
. �� , . �
=r �'�` �� . �. ��
� �� � { .. - �
� '��' � � � �
.. � �#_+�� ���' � ��, ���` � . .
s
; � �� � T�
.
, - , .. ..,; �
,. �' ,�� - - " � '� .
� ���- � ��,�p� w .�.r.� � � �
��� ;`'"'"'i � ' � "'r ' , � ��
� � +� '!�
.
� �: �� � � , �
, ��_ �
"'s
.�
.
.
'�� � ,�� ���; � � �� , ' �
M ay 8, 1960
� �,.. �
� ', ;�;,�.-..
� .3 ` �''. . ��=r _ e-., � �.:�„ �
� �, � :�� - . • i ,
. . .. . . .� '3
� �
.. �, r , ,�. s , .. � —
�,+w: '..Y �` :��....��,..
r �, v�
�:: .. ' 2 ..- .i... " , n.. ..� ...'..
� �. ..�. . . _.� �
. 1
� . - . �.: : . . ' .
_ � . �N � � .�� .
; ..�, �n -� t, ,,. .,
±.. ,5&:." x ',;. , � , " :.
... . , ,.� `t . : ... _.
�„ �,. ,� . . . �� �
�- . . � ,�.. »
. � ��
.�,
� � . ._ _ o � , - ..
, �:. .� . � w � .��- �
z � �� F �
�+ s 2' ."�k-
- a
. ' qa ' v . , . �
.� - . ��.� .:. ,{" - .
„ ... . . . - � _
>.: ' �, .,, . &`^, . s
� � ..' . �. . �, �
-, �. . �.: `,r ..�a :, a ,.�,� „�.. ,� . .. � �.� . �,� �.
_*.
,
. �,.� °. Q. „�
, 4 '
.: .. .«. . � �,c..�; � �����
- �,.. , � . .. . _ .�. ._'. ;:,
,, r ;� . . . . t�:
i�� � � ' �� ��. �� ' � �_,
, �
�.. g'�M. �w,`� - _
. , '� .,, ' d ' -' � � , ,."
_'
.. . M .: s�' . , .'r `' . . 'y���.
� �.�` . � .alFt"��' :'�ak„� ��. �u
�.' �::. � �" � �` � �9 �, _ �� '* ���'.
:.w �-� ��� , . ,'^,-��� .'�*k �.m�- �a �:,� �" ,r ~ .
'�„ .-t � �� t
;.. *$��� �� �'. �.� �� : ��: �P - .
�
a.
� � � �� ��� � F � ; s Y¢� �
� ,
�� �.a �fF = _ ' _. .
�v. "��. �'� �� �,-�b.^ �.�: -:.� m� �` �'�,,. _. � . .
�.,
.. v� �' �" n': � � �p,� ��YL?, �
r .
.
,tiF P"` 'P 1� •. � .�wh'3 F �:.� _,qP.
u ♦ �;.� vF � `" � _
� � II I
M
, :- . �.a�k � i 4 >��i �#s.�` . ; . � �„
..� , w. ,� �M.:_.�.. .. . � ' �� ...
,Y
.
II
- .we '� r � 1_� .
�w .
„ '� ` `K"
. �
�
_,
s
, ,� �..'. � y :_ . . - �`. m �y,
� ' �-
T. , c'�
' � � ' +�;,M,`" �{ ' .. . ':y ` e �' `T'
�y i ,
:
:. , -:: , �r.< �p,� . .. . � ,.
` ' +
- . �.,,;� , '. ": •. * ` .. �+ ..
., . �` . , k" �. y
, �, ,�: ° e .� �. "' ' _ �
-i ., !�s � . :
��'Y � 0 . .�:: ���� a,.� ;t�k`� +S `Y.
� 3 .: � R , ��� � '�� $� � � � s '�
�'� � _ _ .�.. 1 �c `"2.� ��
+�p , .« , p. �� � . �a�� r�k
_ .
t
. .
� � ` �
, `
: . .
. ': v �
a
� �
w_ _ ;f M
�z.i �
k�� .� , �'�Is,.., sa
«
.
r�
. . �; .. , . .� i
,4 , ��� . .. ` �� _ . ...,.�.°` ,�
� ==8 -- , ��. �:�" �
; "«, � �.,, � "�
� �_ ..' , ,.� . .� .r
� , - v'p, � �re -. � � ��
,� . '� ;,, z �
` $ ���
�. �
�� � Y� ��. �''• r ��" �� �� �y - �� ��� +�"'.w, r
��. �� �_ �'s�Fx".'� s ��� C:�* .. }� IR� s�u
_` �t �. �
, � . .
'� W , . .". � ... �' ,.,. ,,: .�: �
�
a
�x� -�. ;
fl � �
� -�Re c . � �.:.�„
A
.'.
� � ,.. .. , r..
�
°' �a � a�,
Y y .
'I '
• .. �� �� •, �.� �:�F � r": .s� 4. ay�,�,r
m
�;"�.��•'� "` ^`' . , -
AF . � � . � . ,4� -
„ �L °y�'' M � f .
�' .� � , y � �` ae�� . .
I� r�
� "'frt ,. :} . �g:, .. Ap�x �+i a,V. �'
�. �'�. � 4 . �,.. � �..:� - "� .r
.
. .
;
'� ' - � �,:� � �'
,,
. �. .,;� � .. , . .
„ . i�� ,. ` �.
�"'�� . ro,� ,� >:=s$��_ � � " ,, , � g„ _ �r `+I f
, _ � � � � �
,
,
. , „�. . . �
� .:4,. �� w �$. Y . 4Y�,
�'
. � ���;. �" -�,. �. _ � __ q
May 3, 1962
's� � • '� ,�" ".R � �,,� �q ��"� � � ,�4�'��
�"� �' � � Y � � � �� �
� � ��. � � „,.
�,��� �� �� �� h
�. .
.w
� ��.
r . � � " '§�, " .
� �^ • ' � �
s ., � "� � ��� � a� �'��� K�+- � �k�".
�
, t � � � � � ' . � <.
,
, �. �
:�
� . � - t � - � .� ���
#� � ,� `` �; ,�. �,,.� � � f� �''�` 4`�w ,,
� ��� `�. ��� � :w
a ��
� �.
}� t :�,,, ' � :�. "� � 'N,� 4 t � � �� �
> ,
° n�e
b � �� ��� � ���w � ��
� . • '� T �s"# o � '°6 af
� .�p� a �
q - �. M��`Jl�`', �, a ,f Y�`. "�F �.� �F�� 7�� '* ��_ Y � �ki
.g � �� � � �
} u £i* � �g4 ¢ `�
� �� �� � �� �� � � � � �� ���
���� �'$ ���� ' '"x* �.��.. �i ,� o- � j� � �. � � �� �� „�
� " , t �- . _
'�: ¢`s �' � i� s'� �v � d� w�^ ��. a -:�' � �.a:
i � " ` �-� � g� �� �
�' � i � «� �
� ;� � " u� � � �� � �.� • � x
�:. '��_ ��'�� m.,�� � F", ��� � �'� u.,;'�,�'
y
, k � �
. �
' . ..�. , : �, ��.�`��i � - � �`.. '�, c �a�.
f � � � � n
�.'� �S i�'� ` s� `� '��,�, w �rt ,» x �� 4 � '�,r =g�� � ..��y a�
��'�i s� ;:,; %v � �' � � � '� b ' �� `� � � ����� x a �i �" � . �.
.�� � �F � t� � �,� y ��'�� � , ' ..
�re � Lar *4a .. � ��.� S� `��J& #c ��.w �W, �&� . ._ .
� � �*_�S'� a: e
��_ �� � .
k � _ ,�
� � � , � � :
� . �: � ��� �': a "� � g $
4 ! K���� '���� � tl X.
<, �
�
�� ' �� '"rs» � � � .a � x
;�° �� l �� ' "�t «aw
e � �`' _� �.,
�� �. � �� . , - � _ � .
,� � � �I' �
� .
, _ , '•
�� ,� � � a- E w ' ,
� ` �
. � _ ,. �
. .a
� `�, ` � �
r� � � `� a �` �-
'` �. . :
:� P-� , ��_ � � �,
..
���..�' - � � �, ,� �� � � �� �
�. -'
.
.. , : ,� . , ,�
.. . ,
,
�
# . � � ,,f
�, , b . � � .
� .�
,.
� � �, � �'�
� � �
, �� .. .. :. v ^ P� ,� ..
$ _ � � �� �� �� nL Y` _•�, . �
s � _ € � � k � �y_
� �" # �� ' z.
^ . �4
��'� t�„ „� � ,�r �ai ��� � �
�k � � a � , � �. ����=� � '6
.
, ,
- _ ... ar�.-�..:�. ..w,-N . . „=_ . i� s ys.:*�` � ,,.� , �.. �.
� , . � , ��. , � �� k :��a.i
�� "�
->
J'F `
a .� . < . .' . �
.
�
,s � _$ . '� �,
,
=4 .
� s. �a `.:a ..«, � «�" .�'
�
� � `' .�� �� � .. .y� . ���-. � �` .. �� � � � ` �R:
. � . . . . �F . . . , ���y�� � ... �R,.. . ���
Dec 4, 1967
� w�� �� ��� ��
6� � � �.- ,
,�` c� �r'�a�v� ���� ,� �� ���;..t�. Yk� r
x Y§� �,'�, �n a .'�p"" �,+
� �k� � �_ ���x d � .�4� ��t„
�: µ� 'y it � r#�a � +� �, �
� . ,. }� � �� j �,..:x . �D� �-
,
M ' 'r �.
. �
4.y
, « , , —�- � "°
� �
� � ,,. �.
-,� � ,. . �2 �'- {� , ,
, �
E^ t s �
, �����+� €���� ���; r� �i(Xs, �. '� �:: f � .
di� � III{� 1(I 11 I R�:'#a4d+'W i�T'' h . � �I Ylk • .
r
�� ��h�i c w' � s+�ri aa u�. ,
M78l� �,.. ���.� �w`,��I �,�,a� � ye�;r:. �.,.�, �.a�'.""� ..i �
9� �Wr
�' � . . «�°" x; .
�' r _ ,
�' � , : . ,
yr+�� ,� � � � �"�� .. , .
� � e
,
�-,� ��
+r+�, p
� ��� u���++�I ���'�i�
� ' � ` "� ro
�' ��. �rJ��' Ivs ��' ���� " �
.. .� 4�-��r� �, r�t `;�� �,
� .. � .
�, • �_ ���� ,�r•- �.. x
�„� �,���� � �.. � � "` !,. �,, �.
, �� , , � <
w � � -
� ,u � �
. . ,.. �
� , ,
. .a i� . n�'e"` ��y'.« �'f .
w
,. �Y� ,. �~ w. F .� :''W` ,�lY `$= � ' v�.u�� 9 :. .
z
1 .
� � a �
.,, .,;.. - r �s ' x�. . � � � iA�'"il�' �
,m �. ��� y� � � �x�,y� �r"'
. Y �..� ',�' � #
s . ' . * �,� . .� :�
� � �p ,: �� � �..LL. �
„`��:.s � 3+
� � •.. a-�;. «• ' „ ` � .wy� , . _ . .
,� ,.' ✓ w#i1N� , ._ � %�n .
, yk" ` � � , ' �.�� "^ � _.+dE..
� • '
..� ,aw"^�s;,N""�'�Ap' � �„ . �� i s•� �:. ., � '` A" ,a. . . �'i .
;' . � A ....,�- , .. . .
�� ���: ��•fi . �<f . . q �a*'-��.:
. .. .r,-. �. N
! R
�Y* -a �
� . .. . .,-"' .. � ,t ... � /�
��' ��. �i1f�. +. �#�� � � :� �� v`
, � �4�'" �,k ���. • � ..•
.. :
. � .. _
,� �'" � .� �. � � �aw ��� � �
� �`" � �' `��•.:�� *� •�� � - . - " � o
� '�X,.w x� �n�� .. ;... �� �..,. .M �W� ������ ,. 4 Z
.ti� `��� "�►` "�' '' t''-�� _ � � „�' 'e""� �
�'�. ��t . ✓., . �...�„" . .�`" r-.; .., � � ��f�� -
�.d � �`~ , .{ d ..±Y < -'�,^ ,� . ,�:. %� - . ..
~�' "', +�R'5 F,.r`� .. .
,...
" • j
`�y ,� '�'G ,'�• � ����� ��. ��,� .. tt . 'o�;����.. ` .. ;,�.w .,.
� �.. n 3
, c � - r
# ,f
.. �..r . , e . - <�. f���:.
. �
.
..
� . w
, ..° .r' ,±`�Ifi .� �. ' pt - ,
s':, .
x �'
^�' 4
.. . .. �„ , . . �
, ,x. .
w
,,
; st� ,
a, � .. �. � . ' ,
x
- Y '� � ...�" '..P � lar''�' _,,{
• +° -
� LL
;.• f
� T s#
' Y , � ,�►� ' . . '� '"',> .�.; �.,.:: �
,..
� a w ..>. ,,. , � ��,.�.
.. .. 'T�,. . �.
.a ��-' a ." :
g.,�* 3 y 4����iP'F �r #�•.v .��,.. � ,��t � .. .
� � � t
�
�� '� �� � � �� � X ~�� �.� ..
. �,. �y dl�' � �, '�� "�
i ,+��"•� e "y..�.
.../ .. `b "` ' ,
.
. , �`• '�g��d '� � �"�s .. . �. �+a y�,
�r.. . i :„e'^'w�: �,+Xn . '.�"�� � � .. • . ��„ �" . �
j
�Xn
��. Ca„.
�+c
�
� � . ��
. �_ ..Y }
�' � «.s� L4 3 � .a�° ' 'i,
n. L �
� ' � " +�v r
�F' v. �"�.r'� �§^�'�' y� +^"
,x
. �
. . �
e� .• Ye��. ++x °' ��..�. .t� ,s}� � f� •�� €KK fi. ����r
:
� � � ' '._::f7 .����� y� �n,�r .. � s.9'�.. ""'.".� .,
, . ,
, . °' ,.. �"'..- � :. ' � ,w+ �I,,, .
�
.. �.� :�b- �. 5+�" .. .}" � ,+ .'� ���l
.. _
,., -.r > .y�'.� �.� ida, U, ' a• ..�`
� .. .; �M•d' � ; T .sf: . ,�U
� yy
,
.. ; � � �.. ���. �,.� �� � '4 s''�''.�w�,:� �e W � �:
A,� .�., �' �3�..� ..A.°,: � M � � . > �..�
x.,,z
� �.
a ���
i,�.+ _ . w , , .
� .
� �
s � #�.�
r _
. � ;
..
�� ,(
y � �
' �_��� � ��fi ..:: . "' „� �S M1 r �...R^ �1t �� � �
` ` �
x ' ^
M+" ,x � +. . „,' .
,� . �, r �. N � -. ,,. �;�*
� ,
.�� '�.� .�,_ »'`� ° r n_ .
� .�.�^� . - .. �.�
��� • � .�f � ,. �, �..�
� r � � ��
� 9� , .# � � r .♦r �1> ,�.' �, '
' � .� • • ,
)�• � r - � K
� � � • ` �� . k `�►-.
l � ~ ; �'� i� �
k�� 't ��' .i• �� , ' . •,.
4 :. • ( �,�. .. : i ,. � •�
. �r • �� �' .
� r r/r` �`�; + . . Y�il�� � ,� ' " �'
. �
s ,�/�'*� ��C �� � �_� � r. '� ' '�I ,,
� ` z � �
:� +� 1 �
;� '� �• .`; . �
f
�
� ' .
`
# 1 � ' � ' I' . r� «. •
A �'�,� �� " / -.r �.� s.
.
•�:' f-, � ,�. ` �" ",�.�► ���,�{ `Z- ..
+`` . .ti�.' ,+� -��. ,1� ,,r � • •
�� t . .� +�s 'q a�f Y ,t ._ „T' r i. ,.
;- r
T'
��,� , +� ,;�� a r. s !,R w �; ` �' r ,,�X�, •
• , �+ . ,� - � �„���E � t � � P �• i
7Rj
►�, � � 1 " j � t . �' • � t`'
, -�� ��
- C��f-� � �.r� ' ` � � �� r
°�. . '"'r'. �,r
. � . ,'�' w� 7 .�t , � ��/. i �'
i �
..� � ► �' �� "
� n'r' � • :Je
�.1 � „r.�. . � .,T �" +�� f
� • ' .
�' �, ♦.
� h - +�' ��
�� : '� �4� ` � !-� �� ,�y �.
� 'i1"''I.� �, -i T �� . '
� ,�
f t ,�, � i ,�1 " `�.�'� � � .. � �' . �.
`. + ♦ f .� Lr'
V.{ � ��r ..f� a - V ' •�r
� ♦ � � . . 1. ��'�!
d w ' V
I �� . . � i
� } � F.
,�° .�. f ♦: � ,� t
t ��'�.�! � r . \ A r
�" t � � '�
. •�
5i. _
' �, * � ;{ ��; ! � � ';\� e
�� . RI.��k � f iP. . �} ` . $..
+�'� �, i✓�4�Y¢� r, � • !�� �G � S '�F'
� +��yw � s�:.`t�+�✓ • ` * • • �l � .� .;�► �f,
. J�r�'ts�:� .•� , .h► r '� � .�, .
Oct 11, 1994 CIR Aerial