Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolution 5862 , , . �0 99 �,yG�oD� �?� , Doc No T4693233 Certified, filed and/or recorded on �`a-� ,.�;-�- , �, �'�� �� 10/6/09 4:30 PM Office of the Registrar of Titles Hennepin County, Minnesota Michael H. Cunniff, Registrar of Titles Jill L. Alverson, County Auditor and Treasurer Deputy 33 Pkg ID 574855 Doc Name: Resolution Document Recording Fee $46.00 Document Total $46.00 Existing Certs New Certs 857916 This cover sheet is now a permanent part of the recorded document. A RESOLUTION RENEWING VARIANCES TO MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE SECTIONS 78-330 78-1288 AND 78-1404 AND REVISING RESOLUTION NO. 3537 FILE NO. 09-3427 � o � 0 0 '�� - CITY of ORONO � a.=: ,� �' p,,, � ,bz''�' ti � Y�' `� ~' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL �L`�k'Es8�4�G NO. ; � � A RESOLUTION RENEWING VARIANCES TO MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE SECTI�NS 78-330 78-1288 AND 78-1404 AND REVISING RESOLUTION NO. 3537 FILE NO. 09-3427 WHEREAS, Alonzo B. Seran and Renee N. Seran, busband and wife, (hereinafter "Owners") are the owners of the property located at 4099 Highwood Road within the City of Orono (hereinafter "City") and legally described as: Lot 14, Highwood Lake Minnetonka, Hennepin County, Minnesota(hereinafter "the Property"); and WHEREAS, the Owners have made application to the City far renewal of a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-330 to construct an attached garage nine feet from the northwesterly property line when a 10 foot setback is required; and WHEREAS, the Owners have made application to the City for renewal of a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-1288 allowing 46.1 percent hardcover in the 75 to 250 foot zone when the normal maximum is 25 percent and 49.3 percent was previously approved to permit the construction of an attached garage and new driveway; and WHEREAS, the Owners have made application to the City for renewal of a variance to Municipal ?oning Code Se�±�nn 7R-14�4 �11���;-;r� i g.a p���P�� s��r+,;ral ccveraQe when the normal maximum is 15 percent to permit the existing detached garage/shed to be replaced by an attached barage/entry of the same foundation area; and WHEREAS, the Owners have made application to the City for renewal of a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-330 to construct an attached gara�e with three defined stories when the maximum is two and a half defined stories; and WHEREAS, after due published notice and mailed notice in accordance with Minnesota Statutes and the City of Orono Zonin� and Planning Codes, the Orono City Council waived the Planning Commission review and held a public hearing on September 14, 2009, at which times all persons desiring to be heard concerning this application were given the opportunity to speak thereon. Page 1 of� � o� 0 0 �'��a�� ;� CITY of ORONO � � �, �y;.�. ti ��L Y `� �G'�' RESOLUTION OF TH� C�IT�Y �OUNCIL `gkESH�4 NO. `' NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono, Minnesota: FINDINGS l. This application was reviewed as Zoning File 09-3427. 2. The Property is located in the LR-1B zoning district, where 1 acre is the minimum lot area and 140 feet is the minimum lot width. The Property is approximately 0.235 acre in area and 50 feet in width. 3. The Planning Commission reviewed the original application on May 19, 2008 and on a vote of 5 - 0 recommended approval of the variances, based on the following findings: a. An attached garage is a reasonable addition to the property. b. The new gara�e and parking arrangement will reduce hardcover and be more compatible with the surrounding area than the existing garage and parking arrangement. c. The new arrangement will allow the storm water runoff from Highwood Lane to be channeled toward the lake alon�the side property lines. d. The need for the side setback variance results from the side setback variance that allows the existing house to be 6.4 feet from the side property line. 4. The Plarming Commission carefully reviewed the variance to allow a three story addition and in addition to the findings noted above recommended approval based on: e. The topography of the lot. f. The need for the garage floor to be above street grade to avoid drainage problems. g. The mass of the addition being the same with or without the basement under the garage. Page ? of� � o� 0 0 ' � CITY of ORON� � ������ � � Y � ~' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCI L ��`9kESII�4'�G NO. ',1 �1 � f h. The peak height of the addition being less than 25 feet above the grade of Highwood Road adjacent to the property. i. There will be minimal impact on the view from the lake because the addition is on the road side of the house with the existing house between it and the lake. 5. The City Council has considered this application including the findings and recommendation of the Planning Commission in May of 2008, reports by City staff, comments by the applicants and the public, and the effect of the proposed variance on the health, safety and welfare of the community. 6. The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this property are peculiar to it and do not apply generally to other property in this zoning district; that granting the variance would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor pose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely serve as a convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate a demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is necessary to preserve a substantial property right of the applicants; and would be in keeping with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan of the City. CONCLUSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS Based upon one or more of t?�e above fin�ings, the �rnr.o City ro�ar:cil her�by grants a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-330 to construct an attached garage nine feet from the northwesterly property line when a 10 foot setback is required; and grants a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-1288 allowing 46.1 percent hardcover in the 75 to 250 foot zone when the normal maximum is 25 percent and 49.3 percent was previously approved to permit the construction of an attached garage and new driveway; and �rants a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-1404 allowing 18.4 percent structural coverage when the normal maximum is 15 percent to permit the existin� detached �arage/shed to be replaced by an attached garage/entry of the same foundation area; and grants a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-330 to construct an attached garage with three defined stories when the maximum is two and a half defined stories, subject to the following conditions: 1. Council approval is based on the site and building plans submitted by the Owners and annotated by City staff, attached to this Resolution as Exhibits A and B. Any amendments to these plans may require further Planning Commission and City Council review. PaQe 3 of� � o� o ,� o �,�, CITY of ORONO � �-� � � . �� ' `� G~' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL L�kESH04� NO. � ��j i� ?. Hardcover in the 0-7�' zone shall be limited to 0 s.f. or 0 %. Hardcover in the 75- 250' zone shall be limited to 3096. s.f. or 46.5% per the proposed site plan and hardcover allowance summary as depicted on Exhibit B. The Owners are advised that any future requests to increase hardcover or change the nature of existing/approved hardcover shall require City approval, and increases in hardcover will not likely be approved without concurrent reduction in existing hardcover. This condition revises the 49.3 % hardcover allowed in the 75 to 250 foot zone by Resolution No. 3537. 3. ADDITIONAL SURVEYS REQUIRED: a. Per City Code 86-68, a foundation survey is required to be submitted prior to commencement of framing; and b. An as-built grading plan verifying compliance with the building permit, stormwater mana�ement, grading and drainage plans shall be submitted priar to the issuance of a Certificate of Occupancy for the residence. 4. The Certificate of Occupancy shall not be issued until the Owners have �ranted the City a drainage easement over the swale along the southwesterly property line that carries the runoff from Highwood Road. �. Owners shall not place any plastic or fabric liner material under any landscaping on the property to ensure their perme�bility as non-har�c�ver surf�ces. 6. Authorities granted by this resolution run with the Property not with the owners, but are permissive only and must be exercised by obtaining a building permit for the new garage before September 14, 2010 or the variances will expire on that date. 7. Once a building permit has been obtained for the new garage the setback variances granted in zoning file #178 for the existing detached garage are void. 8. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this resolution shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically terminate any authority granted herein, and shall be punishable as a misdemeanor. Page4of5 � o� 0 0 ��� CITY of ORONO ,� ��� � 3 � �., '�,� y p�"� �~ RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL � O � NO. � S l G `9kESH 4 9. The undersigned Owners have read, understand and hereby agree to the terms of this resolution and on behalf of their heirs, successors and assigns, hereby agree to the recording of this resolution in the chain of title of the Property. .��,��4z ��: ����,; Adopted by the Orono City Council on the 14`h day of September, 2009. ^�' ` .. �,:� 2 , . , � 4 ;;y� �� I�T�`���T<: �. f� t,p x S> �� s p'� r �T �� . a ���-' ��Yi�'i yl � �"3 . r r r '..� , `/+ �--- �Y t�r ���,y;#.�jiy s�t���y+�,+n`�.' ���r `=-X't--. �7 (�/�"�-'�" _. '��� ^;,���,�"���ee, City Clerk � Ja s M. White, Mayor ,�. �ru.�._�, ;��'.� l Ju«c! r . . . Y + �p}�'`+ '�„�� / �"�� : L� l�/. Property wner STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIi� This instrument was acknowledged before me this /6 _day of 2G09 by Alonzo B. SPran, husband of Renee N. Seran. r BARBARA G. SILUS f _ NOTARY PUBLIC-MINNESOTA � ,�}/y� �j � . My Commiseion 6xpires Jan.31,2013 � Y►-�""'�"'�'Q a Notary Public STATE OF MIN?�"ESOTA COLTNTY OF HENNEPIN This instrument was acknowledQed before me this /(� day of_t���,, ?009 by Renee N. Seran, wife of Alonzo B. Seran. ��� � �;�,I - ���" BARBARA G. SILUS �-R �'V '� '' NOTARY PUBUC-MINNESOTA NOtal'y PUbI1C ;; :,;,:» My Commissicui Expires Jan.31,2013 ,�.� Page � of� �— ---- - _�„ ---__-- ------ a. - --: : --- ,,- ---�--- �b--- �- , � - ---- ,- Q -:., � �.,.. - -- --- � - --- _- , -- �-------�„ --. --- � --.��,�� ,,- ' - -- -- , r � � .S1 __ - _ - ' __-- I ��- - � ' �1/:""`L��y '-� �/T�' .i 77 �'�-�y — � , X __ ' _- � � I: i I�� .� , . s ' ' _ ' ____ ...' .{:�� � ; W ,�.u,"n"s� ' ' u -'__�eie a,rv ` I , �a ; - s ,w. ,. �. •-;—sE E.�—,� �,�.,. „ s—�-: _ , � � � _. �� � �« � �y, �.,,�E,, I i - ' s«.-- �. i - E�,,,,,,, .T ------ , --- , -- �Eal]TI��GB.>SF.l.IEVT'' I. -py -- I r . _., ' ._ '�• — __. __- _._ _ T �- Fsi�ti �� --� �o�.°�`i«.�»�.:e� � '� � E,� �c��„o ��, �, — -- _ : .EXISTIrG Ba5[�I[V _ �'r.ivo.�. .,e- ��.� . �._�I �r'_ i " -- . . _ .. 4 _`�j� .''Sj.�.�».�i,�e �� � o�ai�ncw�n�x � � w .. . r�vc . ¢, .. � �_,�,.,E.�a�.r�,. ,��. E�E,., �, . -n ���s�� ��.,,,. — -- �.,, .�t�.,,, fi� = .w_,�— �� s sE E �E°� :�;� e� I��� ' s�� , „�un��.,� �Ej � ' w.,s:S% - r � i � � � ` � -- ^-- � � __� �.�, .--. ----- v;"ri'�� ,7.'�r5,t7`��3'l„T li� �Tr__ _ w,a . ---�- . � W �� : . �. .�_.:_ ._-� �-' —. --- ��- �'- .. t -- _- `-�.. . `_ .--- -------- --- -------- -- __-._ r __. _ .. _,_ ..---- - � -� . . . .. --. .. -_ .:_ -------_-- � � . a�K. . . . .�_�. � .. - ���S � «�� "l`� I�PPFR FOUND4TION(n GARAGE SLAB � � ;.--s,��� �wo ,�, �}.7?�__ ._._ .._-_ _ . ___.. _ ___. .. � .._ -- •_ _ . ei.[�w�fm ,.. x'S1'aVCRE'fEl-l.)t)NW,�J'1'OPYI.VG IIJ.-I.U.. ^� LOWER FOUNDATION F l ---------- ---- i'..CUUCRE�fEBI.UCK I���'=1'.il.• � �, ,. .. _ � _"'_'_ " - _'_ y�__"" - " � " -" _` , '__ ____ j ...._.._ ii� . .. 1 '._-- " —__-_ .._"_ —_._ .. .�____.-_ '.e'-..-_ i ./ .. -. I I �I --___ --p--- -___ ' �� - I . . _I ' _.' . i, I II . .� I ' . I , � . 'I ' i I "--t- i ___— _..___`� 'i. I '_.._ I L i —_ — — --- — - 1 G- � � � � _ , _ , :_ , —� _�_,� � ---�— , -'� ; i , �--- i� r. �� _ � ,.k�= ' .�—� �--1 '�� i � ' � �� 1= , �� � !� � � � , � � - : _ - - � ' I �i . s �-�. � _ , _ , _ , - -- �_. � - . , - - � � ,, , � �'� �.__ _ �� . �� � --- — -��eaisnNc�aizi�.00k u I _ _ .�I � I �, .Z - --- ---- -- �. .� - � . . ' _?' - -� {,�- �G --- -- ,-� _ � � � .�.. � - - �-- � , � �ri� ��— � _ -- � :. �� �� �_, ' i � �� ,� --��— , _��— -� --� _��yp � d ' � _� �� _�:� I I-�I I� �I��i ^ s _ � i �` EXISTING UPPEN FLOOIt�. ' � � ' �. . _. � I I — ° �. _ -_ C � I . / = I '. � ' I -___� __.'__- � i ' ' _�_ _ �?� I ° . z � 5'. � _.___ .___ j i � �' Y— � � I , :. , ' . �� .-. . . ._.___— ___�.—._. k _._._. •., . --_. -____. _ t� , . . -�--� .�__�.-___ .-".—_-_','�. i I \ 1 _I -- _I __-.___ '�—_ i i - .� L , . I ,. I I „ -. � .,..- .__ . . - ��.,�z -_-____._._____.. � �.d--•-_-.w ��;��Y- �r _.,�,.�- ...__.___ ���+-_—" ' -__I.. .Y.I- -- C�" � �_ _— . _—_ ;o e�._ ._ � ,.- ___-• __ �IAIN FLOOR PLAN � Y ,n,�(._._._____.____._- . _ ._-.__ __.. ._��. UT'PFR R_UUR PL.4N r.o. U,�___._. _. _ ______- ._. ..._ �., v�'=i.Q.. n.�nFaen.n %//�\\ \\� r�_n��.0 . . ��j . . --..'�'"'.. _�� �-- :��----K "- I __— ,�.. . .v- _ - f — . . .xn> //��_ _� =1 _ -. . . � / '_ ' �.wo� �.�/ / . —_�—.____. _-_. _._—_"____��.., . .. �m� �Jr _— I�.fi� I�I 'C'' --I''! I i a� i�' !� � __ I ��--_ If;i . ---- ��EI�RONTGL6VA_f'ION --..---- ------- I/J'=1�-U' _.__ -_ -__-_"....-____--. --_- ____-.__ ' -_ _..__--.-_ -_-_--__ � _ .___._ . -_--____ ___ I ' i.._. . .... '�. i ,-. -_-_. _- -_..___- ___'__.._'_____---_� .. i �__-..-_-..-___.___._'--_.__--_--- -_. , ....__---_ '. ; ��. _.-____ - -T__.____--_ 'i . -__ .-_.- --� ___- . , , � _-- I i I"""'..."_.._________ _____".___. __._ ._' : ' : ',' ___........_____..._.._-_ _.___ ...._ I II II I I I � II __- � i � .. � I i � '�..-_�' i : .;� i ..__"__..__.._.__-_'__-.-_--_ . : I _ I i .._ _.-'_ _ _.._ ...___ .. . _ _ ___ .__ ..-_._ �_-,. ' ; ' '- - _- - _ .,-.--_,- I ____�. _-_____�" ' . �.__.. . : . r.. I--_ . . . .._..__ I� �', I,' '� � �� . � � _""_: I� , '=�, �'I I ,� i _i I L' �. . . � , '� I ��i , � � i : I � � '____�1__ '.__""___"""_" . . , . � � .--�,___.._.'.___"_____ _-_ __y" . ' "� . �_—�__ ___._—.._ . . � �"���. SIDG[LEVATION �� � SIDE ELFVA'f10N � — ---- � ��----�---- — — �E2,— ---- v�_r.o. _, vr_i-u- r a Ti� ' I� �= el� � ° ��9 - mim � tla �i� I6 '� ;. � g '�IG ��i� yI� ,t ' =1k� I" ylj :I� � ��m � � �7 �� � y�; . i ,'��� � i _ ._ _ , - ' I � I�� �['_L11L�" --- a� r�; �— I - ,. i � , __-� �oK � - I_ �, _:� � � _ ,E_ ; -�--� ��; ._ r., ��,,'I� € ,:y� ; __.__.� I� - ..� ,m � _ I � l i'I I I __ r2 �i; r.= � i i .--, Z s `�c I'I� ���' I __l € Illllll i,l c il � ; � � _ _ � _�--�; '' ' � 1�111_J� i ' {, � � ��y��` �_. I - --`-� � i� � � ^� � d ' 1 „ , � _ i m s;' ''�;-:%� � '; ; _--; , �� -- � — -- '' � 1 - ��__ .��_rrrn, _ _ __ , . LL— £ � ��� �c j k � � i �- -_� n ,� , � ' - - � x ; =— W I � I � ,._ ._, � a . n.„ G . —� 7- � � c _""_ y. N j I �. ..-�vxm • .��¢u � " " .�.,�-�:-r .� ;� e.i-. .__. �iY."-.. . _ . ;- _____ �I � Y � � � __.-._—� i ' � �� � ,�, y `� a = �I= � '�; _ - _ � .',I� I � c� i �� �s �E 5�e c �I� I- Io la a.a �� :B _ ' k^_ � 'Ih�� [� �t,�' �i'c��i- �'`4 ul� r{. ; ' � .� i. � ., '�, � � � r� � � I w �I ,�I�L_L, �!{� � �d �_ �i �1�7T7��L —__- —py-_ � '�' �i �i f i ._— . 'n�-- ,� I� _ �� E �I 1 Im ,}2 _ - I I i ��`'� `a _.. ,� �, I I I \ , n . . I s:JI lO II` _ I� I %m \� �� II :I II. I \ �� I4 . � � — _ ,k I � \ - �� � \I �;��Z �'..i r��' �,�� �e �1 i�i - .y I � ``rJ4�i� J __- __ �:� I �,Iz JII i� X I'�� 1 �\� + h ^ ,I. � : J � I � I � i � II I r / I 4 . - I� � � � � �� �111 LI1111��_, - -� , , � _ , il'� �m� / % �, ��, �' 'I I2 � _ � - 's� _ - eu� � ,.., - �� _- � „ ,� � , „ �� , ii; � , �I �,tir,r�f��l�r�f � � � � � I r��-� , ��i���_ � � .i _ 4�_ ; /� zJR S/TF � SUR1iEY �,OR: A/� Rcn�e �5'erA f � � yo 99 �r9tiwooa Rd � � � Q '° / `b°'� ���"j ��\\ L°� �5�� fliyliwo� LQke M�nn�fcnf(ct . I � 24P�� , � % ��i t. 2 / �N�nn'�P��r Co.� /yjy . � � d j S p� C ',�� �/ ` j ��e/ �u�d 94'"���0. !� I ,��' / O,fO.Y` ` `-L ,�� //I�� ��� I � �{_ ' �a��,r� / ! �1 r.,�� �`. � � � ��� � \ � � �t:q��/+54'o,,�. /'�'' Z`` � � �,. , �� \V \� � � / � � qSo.� t , � I � � P"'P�sea� � � � �� ��y����\ y+er` � �� �� , � ,`',n� V `� /� � ��� � 2'�°� � t� � 9 ,y� � ( � � � � / /\ � / �/ � � / �, �5b � drivc b o Z2 y� �� \` �� // 4 / q�'�� ,,! ! q'f�� I � - r �b �`��j�5� �� �q� M1,ti' �S� ��O .k � �� � I �� q� � M i � I .�,Y ��� 5n ti;Sf' Yr'� �1° g• / 'r v' 1'�5 y � � _' � � � ' / `� h .• G -y 'a � ,� ', N`I-� ,4`' /p�^ S�� '�b e i � � `�ii`6R r : hu 1�QO q�,l' � �X ,�V � "`J i / � � S� _ 5#, y .sy� z � / q S q,}�l 9 x -� � 9syeJ� �e+ `/ � fraR��'�� �i5-�"` 9y5� � ,�1' � -� I � h Ex;,t�f'�y�y � , �°° � ��099 � �`i 4��� / 133�9 e�° / � tc / 3 o D.;.,� �� � � �� �K ati y���° g�• � / f �� � �q Er.J�, � `�Vb� � , �' , V� 5 �j� � q'� / / �„_`6`� � � � � Gq�� � .1� � 4s* '"� I,EGEND � � ,�f/ � [� 1 \ �/ \ /� E',Fir\\\� � l0 9 ,��y / L-0.�eshL+i�_ Q Denotea Set Rebor R1S No. 19162 ` � �Fq,.�'` /�' qti �� ��a� � � D�notef�ourW Iron Pips \ � ,cY/ P/�%.9_ �/ ,� , � � I A D�nafu PK Nai/ tn BlfMminsus \\`\�✓a/,�ek f e e�/af�fi / � / q� / 9 � � DESCRIPTIQN q � � Lof /S�� ff�"yfiwi00%Ca�e \�. 3� •�. e9-ro � /`� � � °�ti� . �G�� I �/ � �� , i � a ,y� *A � -- eEx��� Co�fur I /YJ;nne to.,Ka�H�r►rnp�n Co.� q� � _. � � �M1 � '"I C Mi r�/�e.rs to� qa� / / ' / �/ G 1`` Pre�cvi�e�('o�fwr I � f � � , _�B1'IFICATION / � / 4 xX—l�nn�s Ex•s�S� � � �� �z � � E/cvafiart � i n��ey��e��y tnac tni� �y.pio� a \ � b � `� � l �Du�n�ts1.7�*Perrd I ��pa�'�Oi O�ava�0 by me or under my A Ab �93� P�opoud E/��Q�j�pxs �XXX dkeot aupmfslm and lhot 1 wn e duly / , / E�fI�Q/�OYI ReybterW L�d��ra undm lhe lawa \ � �OWC{� v3.0 �-►- Dtne ' ol lh�Slala ef uhneypto. i�12 in� f/oe�= 9 f�s�' f' � � � 9�L f �rqrp e F/ea.= 9SB.S °/��'/aw efSpi-�qtp � e<<e f y-ZooB Re✓•,s=3/-1ooB�A• / /� Tp�ffew�daf:on= d�4�i�q9e. ao�«, c. �u,�tl,: � ! 4N Rp_Ne. 19162 JCG.Sr�VPw, 3-/2�200s \ � I �� �i � �� � S�if/e���i i �" �GO� �'- �'�'�'-�1/�� — C._�5� Z��� =C� . �� ��`--Z��� � �Z�� - ��%�� ��=- /����,/a STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) The undersigned, being duly qualified and appointed City Clerk of the City of Orono, Minnesota, certifies that I compared the foregoing resolution adopted at the meeting of the Orono City Council on September 14, 2009, with the original thereof on file in my office, and the same is a correct transcription thereof. WITNESS my hand officially as such City Clerk and the Corporate seal of the City this 16`h day of Se�tember , 2009. 's y ;:: L�,y�C.� _ ���-�.� �'�� �� '` -; City Clerk �.;� , ��� =�'�(se��l) ���� ;"* a� ." � ' s�D �, �<� � �.,� i: �r � .� �y;y, 6 ."� ry�r;P t �.i„�� �� r:� a'��.r�j � �x � ,. r; -Ai fl:;,,y t rF' r a a� ,P�� ,.�6,��,�Awt r':�;7� �"+ ='.f ° � k r`t. j `':k�`' YA.�i;'��' r �. s,� . (�;. +-: