HomeMy WebLinkAbout2009-00529-PERMIT VOIDED " � ` � �-� �a�,c ed
City of Orono I����✓� ����-���� zdag �asa9
Building Permit Application
for New Structures or Additions
Mailing Address: Permit number: �Z��J �l�J
�j,O,�.O PO Box 66
O 4 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 Date received: r� v�� � G
��'� Received b � �
� ��� ���� � StreetAddress:' Y�
ti 2750 Kelley Parkway Plan r�. ' : '� J d,j. �
�l � ����G Orono, MN 55356
9kESHo4
- Total Fee:
Main: 952-249-4600 Fax: 952-249-4616 www.ci.orona.mn.us
This application form must be completed in full and �ll'required information must be submitted.
Incomplete applications will b�returned. (Please print)
GENERAL INFORMATION: �
Job Site Address: 3 31 S Cii2,a�f��-� �,���,�.i�
Will this be a Parade of Homes, Remodelers Showcase Home o o#her Display Home? Yes ❑ No
If yes, a special event permit is required with Police Department and City Council approval 0 c�'ays�prior to the event. Shuttle bus service will e
required unless applicant demonstrates sufficient on-site parking is available. Non-permitted vents 'll not be allowed.
CONTRACTOR/APPLICANT INFORMATION:
Name: �;ti-�iZL.�� C�iD� (_c� �
State License# ` �, '3S Z S E iration ate: 3 -- I- Z�f D
Phone: �a� Z- �S�]- 7� office) - `�c� � /4 Z cell)
Mailing Address: 5 U�O " 3 /z� i�v�. N� Cit : ' � � � �"" ZIP: SS 7
Contact Person: 5�� L.,�cr��7- Applica is: Contract / Homeowner (Circle One)
Email and/or Fax: - Z c�
_ �
PROPERTY OWNER INFORMA�fi�N:
Name: L 1-�t��ze-�"� ,,-rn C� �
Phone (day): �, Z- 3 3 - �3� 'Zt�
Address: �p �3 f2' /�UE; �/� Cit : Y����?fl ZIP: .S� �/ � �
Emailand/orFax -5� cl� � C�' Cr-f��lzit�Czi��J � r�f'�
ARCHITECT/ ENGINEER IN RM�TION:
Name: j�� � p '� �ILC.�-(/�C"-�
Phone (day): Z- 3 Z�-- 7�(�
f��lress: �'� � T 3� 'U"E , ; Cit : P� vL!%7f ZIP: 5S¢�7
Emaif'�r�d/or Fax: �J./U Vvv -t1�G i���-j 5 � �i2
,_.-�
�
PROJECT IN MATION: '
1. Type of Project �\ . Propose 3.Structure Type 4.Sewage Disposal &
Water Supply
�,New Construction � ingle Family with �,Residence
❑ Addition �� ktached garage ❑ Garage/Accessory Bldg. ❑ Public Sewer
❑ Accessory Building ❑ Siilgle Family with ❑ Deck
❑ Relocation detached garage ❑ Office/Commercial �Private Sewer
❑ Other: (specify) ultipl Family/Condo ❑Warehouse
❑ P�c ❑ Storage ❑ Public Water
**Any earth movement may require ❑ Comm ial ❑ Other(specify)
MCWD review&permits. ❑ Industrial �Private Well
Minnehaha Creek Watershed District(MCWD) ❑ Other: (specify)
18202 Minnetonka Blvd
Deephaven,MN 55391
Phone: 952-471-0590
Fax: 952-471-0682
www.minnehahacreek.or
Estimated Construction Valuation (excluding land) $ f � ��J� � pp p ,d
Last Updated: 6/22/2009
- 19 -
r
/ � �
STRUCTURE INFORMATION:
1. Structure Dimensions 1. Structure Dimensions (continued) 2. Type of Construction
a. Length (ft.)= �Z.—O �� Number of bedrooms= 5 �Wood/Frame
�� ❑ Masonry
b.Width (ft.)= �OO-O Number of garage stalls: ❑ Metal
Attached =�_ ❑ Pole Bldg.
Areas in square feet Detached =�_ ❑ ICF
❑ On-site Prefab
c. Basement= Z�� ❑ Off-site Prefab
d. 1S�Story - Z9 fo S ❑ Other(please specify):
e.2"d Story= 313 4
f. �Yt�� = 1��to
g.Total Area= ��
REQUIRED SUBMITTALS:
All of the information must be submitted in order for your application to be processed:
Not
Enclosed A licable
❑ Permit A lication
❑ Pro osed Buildin Plans
❑ MN State Ener Code Calculations and Mechanical Code Requirements Form
❑ urve meetin` all re uiremen s
❑ Stormwater Pollution Prevention Plan_���
'� ❑ ard
❑ Se tic S stem Site Evaluation Re ort
❑ Access Permit
❑ � W rovement an
❑ ineered Plans for Retainin Walls 4 feet or above
❑ Plan Review Fee .___�.�..�•-�---------
❑ ❑ er
APPLICANT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT:
• Agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Building Department;
• Agrees to pay the City of Orono for engineering consultant review costs in excess of$500;
• Certifies that the information supplied is true and correct to the best of his/her knowledge. The applicant recognizes that they
are solely responsible for submitting a complete application being aware that upon failure to do so, the staff has no alternative
but to reject it until it is complete;
• Acknowledges the Escrow Agreement is completed and signed;
• Some or all of the information that you are asked to provide on this application is classified by State law as either private or
confidential. Private data is information which generally cannot be given to the public but can be given to the subject of the data.
Confidential data is information which generally cannot be given to either the public or the subject of the data. Our purpose and
intended use of this information is to annually update our records and records of other governmental agencies required by law.
If you refuse to supply the information,the application may not be issued.
S-rEv� Lt c!-�T — C�/Zc.� Cud,t� CO •
a� � ,�q_. p
ApplicanYs Signature: � -- �G.�Cili� Date: 8 — Z I— (� 7
Last Updated: 6/22/2009
-20 -
� o�
O t�,r O CITY of ORONO
�',� \a,
Municipal Offices
r� �� � %• _ �, Street Address: Mailing Address:
,� �.>�,
"�� � :�� �,�,�' 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66
a�
,� Orono,MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066
�kESH�g'
June 30, 2011
Steve Licht
Charles Cudd Co
15050 23�d Ave N
Plymouth, MN 55447
RE: Building Permit Application 2009-00529
3315 Graham Hill Road; Orono, MN
On August 26, 2009 the City of Orono received a building permit for the construction of a new
home at 3315 Graham Hill Road. Our last correspondence, an email, on September 3, 2009
included the City's engineer report and identified issues regarding the number of stories
proposed for the home, which have yet to be resolved. This application has been inactive for
665 days, therefore it has been voided and enclosed you will find the submitted plans.
You paid an advanced plan review fee of $5,405.89. You paid the engineering review charges
and as the plans were never reviewed by the building official, we will be issuing a refund. As a
matter of formality, the check will be presented to the council with the next accounts payable
expenditures and mailed after approval.
If you have any questions, I can be reached at cmattson(a�ci.orono.mn.us or at 952-249-4620.
Sincerely,
CITY OF ORONO
I�1�JU�(��l'�--
Christine Mattson
Planning Assistant
Enclosure
Telephone (952)249-4600 • Fax (952)249-4616
www.ci.orono.mn.us
' � CITY OF ORONO PERMIT NO.: 2009-00529
2750 KELLEY PARKWAY
ORONO, MN 55356- DATE ISSUED: 08/26/2009
952 249-4600 FAX: 952 249-4616
ADDRESS : 3315 GRAHAM HILL RD �
P[N : OS-117-23-I1-0007 �
.
LEGAL DESC : GRAHAM H[LL PRESERVE �
: LOT 000 BLOCK 000 '
PERMIT TYPE . ADVANCED PLAN REVIEW ��'`~ ` --
19N `w;r'.� .��-� ��:;i:
PROPERTY TYPE : RESIDENT[AL �t r�'�: :;�C�3t:�`�s ti�:4 c;:, cC�%) I
CONSTRUCTION TYPE : ADVANCED PLAN REVIEW
JJC
. . iOi�lf � �I
�"r�E�kl:,:tz Exr�a Fees
___..�_.__.,..�_._ ;
J,4l'�;.�i9 �
;�-1; cl�s C���7r4.aF? ;,=�;Ya.�� i
��r:
-;`�RS u11f�0 ��_� ',
�;�7L'I 1:i� �.�'.�i.?�� i
. .. �i�. - '-- -__.. �.�V
..r: .����� �
APPLICAI�T ADVANCED PLAN REVIEW 5,405.89
CHARLES CUDD LLC TOTAL 5,405.89
15050 23RD AVENUE N
PLYMOUTH, MN 55447-
�)
Minnesota State License#: 20635245
OWNER
JMA Builders LLC
,JMA BUILDERS LLC
6065 EUREKA RD
SHOREWOOD, MN 55331-
AGREEMENT AND SWORN STATEMENT
The work for which this permit is issued shall be performed according to
the approved plans and specifications,applicable City approvals,and the
State Building Code. This permit is for only the work described and does
not grant permission for additional or related work which requires separate
permits. All provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work
shall be compied with whether or not specified herein.'Chis permit will
expire and become null and void if construction authorized is not
commenced within 180 days of the date of issuance,or if construction is
suspended for a period of 180 days at any time after work has commenced.
The applicant is responsible for assuring all required inspections are
requested in contormance with the State Building Code.This permit may be
revoked at any time for due cause.
/ / / /
Applicant Permitee Signature Date Issued By Signature Date
SEPARATE PERMITS REQUIRED FOR WORK OTHER THAN DESCRIBED ABOVE.
Melanie Curtis
Fram: Melanie Curtis
Sent: Thursday, September 03, 2009 10:19 AM
To: 'Steve LichY
Subject: 3315 Graham Hill Rd - Basement
Attachments: admin ci orono mn us 20090903_103556.pdf; 2009-0529 3315 Graham Hill Road
9-3-09.pdf; building_height.pdf
Steve
Attached are the most recent comments from the City's Engineer.
I am through with the zoning review of the building permit for 3315 Graham Hill Road and only one concern comes up
(from a zoning perspective).... The number of stories. Orono allows 2 % stories max, and in order for your basement not
to count as a story it must meet our definition of basement. I believe the top floor is defined as a full story, resulting in 3
stories &therefore the house does not meet code.
As I calculate, the first floor elevation is 1025', our definition states that the first floor may be no more than 6' above
existing grade for 50%of the perimeter. Based on the first floor elevation the 6'grade point is 1019'. I have attached
my highlighted analysis of the perimeter where I believe 1019' exists and where it meets the 6' standard. This appears
to be significantly less than 50%of the perimeter.
In order to resolve this, the home must either be lowered into the grade more to meet the basement definition or the
top floor must be modified to conform to the half-story definition.
I have also included the basement and story definitions below for your review.
Basement means that portion of a building that is partly or completely below the existing ground level.
A basement shall be considered as a story for purposes of determining the number of stories in a building, when
the finished surface of the floor above the basement is more than six feet above the existing ground level for
more than 50 percent of the basement's perimeter. The perimeter of the basement does not include portions of
the house or garage that do not have a lower level but are merely "unexcavated". Artificially raising the grade
adjacent to the foundation of a structure (by filling or by a combination of filling and retaining walls) above the
surrounding natural terrain shall not be allowed as a method for converting a defined story to a defined
basement, regardless of any other benefits to the property of such action. Finished grade that increases more
than one foot from existing ground level shall be considered as artificially raising the grade. However,
artificially raising the grade when such action merely restores a previously excavated site to its original natural
grade may used as a method for converting a defined story to a defined basement.
Basement, ��alkout, means a basement having an entrance at grade level.
Building height means the vertical distance between the highest adjoining ground level at the building or
ten feet above the lowest ground level, whichever is lower, and the top of the cornice of a flat roof, or the deck
line of a mansard roof, or the uppermost point on a round or other arch-type roof, or the median height of the
highest gable of a pitched or hipped roof. Topographic changes which elevate the adjoining ground level above
the existing terrain shall not be considered in determininb building height. For a pitched or hipped roof
situation, regardless whether the highest living space in a building is a half-story or full story, if the highest
living space contains windows (excluding skylights) the upper measuring point far defining building height
shall be the median height of the top of the highest window and the highest peak of the roof.
i
Half story means the uppermost floor of a building in which (i) the intersection of the exterior wall and
the roof is not more than three feet above the floor elevation, and (ii) not more than 60 percent of the floor area
within the exterior walls of the uppermost floor exceeds five feet in height as measured from the floor to the
rafters. Floors exceeding these parameters shall be deemed a full story.
Story means that portion of a building included between the upper surface of a floor and the upper
surface of the floor or roof next above. It is measured as the vertical distance from top to top of two successive
tiers of beams or finished floor surfaces and, for the topmost story, from the top of the floor finish to the top of
the ceiling joists or, where there is not a ceiling, to the top of the roof rafters. A story that meets the definition of
a "basement" shall be considered as a basement and not as a story for purposes of determining the number of
stories in a building.
Melanie Curtis
Planning & Zoning Coordinator
City of Orono
2750 Kelley Parkway
Orono, MN 55356
Direct Dial: 952.249.4627
Fax: 952.249.4616
Planning &2oning Office 952.249.4620
Email: mcurtisCa�ci.orono.mn.us
Website: www.ci.orono.mn.us
2
EXISTING HARDCOVER IN ZONE �,SQ FT PROPOSED SQ FT �X
HOUSE WEST ! 744; 1231 i 1�_ 1231
HOUSE EAST � 340 340� 340, 340
SHED 202 202� 202', 202
FLAGSTONE SY SHED 108'.75 81 81I 40
STONE BY WATERWAY 27*J5 20i 20T 0
SIDEWALK TO GRAVEL �- 126 1261 275
FLAGSTONE 55`.75 41'� 0 0
FLAGSTONE BY SHED 86'.75 65 65� 55 55
STONE WALK 75� 75 0+
COVERED +OPEN 551+152 703; 703, 703
WOOD WALKWAY& DECK 1042, 0'
BRICK PATIO EAST HOUSE 482I 482 382�- 376
BRICK PATIO WEST HOUSE 275' 39'� 0 51
BRICK PATIO BY SHED 565 565' 375' 265
BOULDER WATERWAY 132� 132 75
RANDOM ROCKS 370 370� 0�
BOULDER WALLS RETAINING WALL 220 126�_ 82' 77
STONE BORDER 51i�5! 0
STREET SIDE I 78
TOTAL HARDCOVER IN ZONE 4659� 4562 3661 i 3575
HARDCOVER IN ZONE 104861 10486; 10486 10486
% HARDCOVER 44.43 43.51� 34.91 I 34.09
GRONBERG SAYS i i '� 34.89
04`'��o BUILDING HEIGHT
�,t��: .��' www.ci.orono.mn.us
''���°� 952-249-4620
ALL BUILDINGS IN ORONQ MUST HAVE A DEFINED BUILDlNG HEIGHT OF 30 FEET OR
LESS AND MUST HAVE NO MORE THAN TWO STORIES PLUS A HALF STORY.
HOW TO DETERMINE 7FtE DEFINED HEIGFtT OF A BUILDING:
FOR A BUILDlNG WITH A BASEMENT OR CRAWL SPACE:
START WITH the distance between the basement floorlcrawl space floor and
the highest roof peak, the top af the cornice of a flat roof, the
deck line of a mansard roof, or the uppermost point on a round
or other arch-type roof
SUBTRACT half the distance be#ween the highest window and highest roof
peak of a pitched roof
SUBTRACT the distance between the basement floor/crawl space filoor and
the highest existing grade within the faundation or 10 feet,
wftichever is less.
EQUALS Defined building height
FOR A BUILDING ON A SLAB FOUNDATION:
START W1TH the distance between the slab and the highest roof peak, the
top of the cornice of a flat roof, the deck line of a mansard roof,
or the u permost oint an a round or other arch-type roof
SUBTRACT half the distance between the highest window and highest roof
eak of a pitched roof
ADD the distance between the slab and the highest existing grade
within the fo��nda#ion
EQUALS Defined buildin height
HOW TO DETERMINE THE NUMBER OF STORIES:
For the basement or lower (evel to not be considered a story the elevation of the floor above it
must be no more than six feet above existing grade for at least 50 percent �f th�perimeter
of the basement or lower level. �I �- � �U� I -" 1 '�2�� ! (% �
A half story is defined as the uppermost floor of a building in which the intersection of the
exterior wafl and the raof is not more than three #eet above the floor elevation and not more
than 60 percent of the floor area within the exterior walls of the uppermost floor exceeds five
feet in height as measured from the floor to the rafters.
�OR MORE INFORMATION
Contact the Planning and Zoning Department at 952-249-4620 or planninqCa�ci.orono.mn.us.
Reference: City Code Section 78-1. Definitions.
February,2008
This is an information sheet. Every effort has been made to insure the accuracy of the information contained herein;
however,if any information is not consisfent wrth provisions of fhe Cify Code, the Code provisions will prevail.
Plan Review Checklist for New Structures / Additions
Address/ PID/ Legal: __ � .� � � ���� I-( �� �—, i 1 j
Description of work: JVF't�u �f�?�YY��-�
Septic review by: (�% - < <�� �1����5 Date Approved: � ���^ t% �
Zoning review by: �/����'t��� {���� Date Approved:
Building review by: Date Approved:
Grading review by: Date Approved:
Zoning File # Resolution #: Resolution Date:
Zoning District Fire Department Post Office ', School District
� I i I
�
Zoning: Lot Area: ��_ SF /AC Width: 7—��� Depth:
Survey Submitted: �es ❑ No Date of Survey: � Z �
/\
Proposed Setbacks:
Fron Lake) Rear Street) ' ( N S E W ) i ( N `S E W ) �i Other Buildings � Wetland
Side �i ide i
�� !'�'�-� '
Building Defined Hei ht: g i� /7i
9 u din Peak Hei ht:
9 9
FOR A BUILDING WITH A BASEMENT OR CRAWL SPACE: FOR A BUILDING ON A SLAB FOUNDATION:
START the distance between the basement floor/ ; START I the distance between the slab and the
WITH crawl space floor and the highest roof peak, j WITH ' highest roof peak, the top of the cornice
��� � the top of the comice of a flat roof, the deck ' � of a flat roof, the deck line of a mansard
, line of a mansard roof, or the uppermost roof, or the uppermost point on a round or I
� �, point on a round or other arch-rype roof � il other arch-type roof ��
, SUBTRACT ' half the distance between the highest i SUBTRACT I half the distance between the highest I
i � window and highest roof peak of a pitched I window and highest roof peak of a I
i roof !� I ; itched roof ,
`U22 ' SUBTRACT i the distance between the basement flooN i ADD , the distance between the slab and the
U��' � � crawl space floor and the highest existing , ,I highest existing grade within the ,
� ; ( � grade within the foundation or 10 feet. i ' foundation
i � whichever is less. � EQUALS ' Defined buildin hei ht
EQUALS I Defined buildin hei ht �
Lot Coverage: l��f` SF %
Shoreland District MCWD Permit Received Avera e Lakeshore Setback Blu
❑ Yes No I � �es ❑ No ❑ N/A ' ❑ Yes No �
Permit Number: � ❑ Yes ❑ No ��A i Setback: j
Hardcover Zones '�, Existin ' Proposed i Varian equired CUP eq 'red
0-75' I ❑ Yes No ❑ Yes No �
75-250' � Type(s): i Type(s):
250-500' ' ; ; I
' 500-1000' � , j
REMARKS (in-house):
Updated: 07/01/2009
z:\forms\plan review checklist.docx
Fees to be Charged YES NO
Perm it
Plan Review
Sfiate Surchar e
Investigation Fee
SAC— Number of SAC Units
Sewer Connection
Water Connection
Park Fee
Site Inspection
Other(specify)
Miscellaneous Fees
Calculated By:
UBC: Construction Type:
' ! Square Foota e $ er S uare Foota e ' '� J
�
rBasement � � X i i = I $ I
1 S Floor � X I ' _ ! $
; 2� FloOr � X I = i $ I
' Gara e '� X ' _ ' $ ;
i
Estimated Construction Value: $
Orono Inspections Required Work Requirinq Separate Permits Required State Permits
� Site ❑ Plumbing ❑ Grading / Fit!ing ❑ Well
❑ Hardcover Removal ❑ Mechanical ❑ Fire ❑ Electrical
❑ Footing ❑ Septic ❑ Water Connection
oundation Survey ❑ Fireplace ❑ Sewer Connection
❑ Framing ❑ Masonry ❑ Lawn Irrigation
❑ Insulation 0 Mfg.
❑ Wall Board ❑ Other(specify)
s-Built Survey
� Final
0 Other (specif )
REMARKS (in-house):
Other Review: Reviewed by: Date Approved:
Access:Existing: ❑ YES ❑ NO New: ❑ YES ❑ NO
REMARKS (TO BE NOTED ON PERMIT AND INITIALLED BY PERSON PULLING PERMIT)
Updated: 07/01/2009
z:\forms\plan review checklist.docx
2335 Highway 36 W
St Paul,MN 55113
Te1651-636-4600
Fax 651-636-1311
www.banestroo com
September 1, 2009 # Bonestroo
Ms. Melanie Curtis
Planning and Zoning Coordinator
City of Orono
Post Office Box 66
Crystal Bay, MN 55323
Re: 3315 Graham Hill Road
File No. 000139-09000-1
File No. 2009-0529
Dear Melanie:
We have reviewed the plans for a proposed new home construction at 3315 Graham Hill Road.
The plans are dated 8-25-09. We have the following comments with regards to engineering
matters:
• It appears that the proposed retaining wall on the south side of the house and driveway
is approximately 8 feet high. Engineered design and details should be submitted for
review and approval for all retaining walls over four in height, and for all tiered walls with
a separation of less than two times the wall height.
• The plans must show existing contours at least 50 feet on to the surrounding properties.
• The 1024 through 1014 design contours simply do not tie into the existing contours
along the north lot line and must be revised. When doing so, please note that any part
of a retaining wail is not allowed in drainage and utility easements.
• The grading plan should show the ditch and drainage patterns along Graham Hill Road.
The current plan shows this area draining to the 3285 Graham Hill Road driveway.
• This project will disturb more than 100 CY of material. Sediment and erosion control
information meeting the requirements of Orono's City Code 79-7(c)(2) must be
submitted. The minimum $2000 sediment and erosion control financial security should
be required of the applicant for this permit.
If you have any questions, please call me at(651) 604-4894.
Yours very truly,
f—�. ;��1��
Darren Amundsen
Cc: Tom Kellogg
Melanie Curtis
From: Melanie Curtis
Sent: Tuesday, September 01, 2009 10:10 AM
To: 'Steve Licht'
Subject: City Engineer Comments - 3315 Graham Hill Road
Attachments: 2009-0529 3315 Graham Hill Road 9-1-09.pdf; Escrow Agreement- Building Permit w Erosion
Control.pdf
City Engineer comments are attached and must be addressed.
I should complete the zoning review today and will let you know if there are any zoning issues. Please see the attached
escrow agreement. The owner should sign the agreement and submit a check for the amount of the escrow.
Let me know if you have any questions.
Melanie
Melanie Curtis
Planning & Zoning Coordinator
City of Orono
2750 Kelley Parkway
Orono, MN 55356
Direct Dial: 952.249.4627
Fax: 952.249.4616
Planning &Zoning Office 952.249.4620
Email: mcurtisCa)ci.orono.mn.us
Website: www.ci.orono.mn.us
1
Melanie Curtis
From: Melanie Curtis
Sent: Wednesday, August 26, 2009 12:21 PM
To: 'slicht@charlescudd.com'
Subject: 3315 Graham Hill - Permit#2009-00530
I am in the process of reviewing the building permit for 3315 Graham Hill Road. I need you to email me a copy of the
building plans so that I can email them to our Engineer for their review.
Thankyou
Melanie
Melanie Curtis
Planning & Zoning Coordinator
City of Orono
2750 Kelley Parkway
Orono, MN 55356
Direct Dial: 952.249.4627
Fax: 952.249.4616
Planning &2oning Office 952.249.4620
Email: mcurtisCa�ci.orono.mn.us
Website: www.ci.orono.mn.us
1
REScheck Software Version 4.2.2
Compliance Certificate
Project Title: 2010 Graham Hill Spring Preview /Job #9407
Energy Code: 2000 Minnesota Energy Code
Location: Hennepin County, Minnesota
Construction Type: Single Family
Glazing Area Percentage: 3%
Climate Zone: 2
Construction Site: Owner/Agent: Designer/Contractor:
3315 Graham Hill Road Steve Licht
Orono,MN 55356 Charles Cudd Company LLC
Permit Date:8-21-09 15050 23rd Ave.N.
Plymouth,MN 55447
612-359-1709
slicht@charlescudd.com
. .
Compliance:36.3°/a Better Than Code Maximum UA:10606 Your UA:6754
. . .
. . � . .
.
Attic:Raised or Energy Truss 3620 44.0 0.0 80
Upper Level Walls:Wood Frame, 16"o.c. 26570 19.0 0.0 1523
Upper Level Windows:Above-Grade:Above Grade,Wood Frame, 755 0.330 249
Double Pane with Low-E
Upper Level Bays:All-Wood Joist/Truss,Over Outside Air 877 38.0 7.5 19
Upper Level Rim:Wood Frame, 16"o.c. 2960 0.0 9.4 323
Upper Level Doors:Glass 24 0.330 8
Main Level Framed Walls:Wood Frame, 16"o.c. 30599 19.0 0.0 1754
Main Level Windows:Above-Grade:Above Grade,Wood Frame, 719 0.330 237
Double Pane with Low-E
Main Level Doors:Solid 87 0.070 6
Main Level Doors:Glass 68 0.330 22
Main Level Rim:Wood Frame, 16"o.c. 2988 0.0 9.4 329
Lower Level Framed Walls:Wood Frame, 16"o.c. 11268 19.0 0.0 628
Lower Level Windows:Above-Grade:Above Grade,Wood Frame, 599 0.330 198
Double Pane with Low-E
Lower Level Doors:Glass 21 0.330 7
Full Height Foundation:Solid Concrete or Masonry 3023 0.0 5.0 245
Wall height:8.7'
Depth below grade:8.2'
Insulation depth:8.7'
Walk-out Foundation:Slab-On-Grade:Unheated 1511 5.0 1126
Insulation depth:4.0'
Furnace 1:Forced Hot Air 92 AFUE
Air Conditioner 1:Electric Central Air 13 SEER
Compliance Statement: The proposed building design described here is consistent with the building plans,specifications,and other
calculations submitted with the permit application.The proposed building has been designed to meet the 2000 Minnesota Energy Code
requirements in REScheck Version 4.2.2 and to comply with the mandatory requirements listed in the REScheck Inspection Checklist.
��E-V�= L.�c id i— Dat���i�z��ra��I" _/_-�__�-_, �uc� �`� - "L!-U 1
Name-Title Signature Date
Project Title: 2010 Graham Hill Spring Preview/Job#9407 Report date: 08/21/09
Data filename:F:\Drafting\Signature Developments\Graham Hill\94XX-2010 Spring PreviewWrchive Info\heat loss calc-9407-Graham Hill
. R � -
;ob Site Address: � 3 (s ���'���� � ��"�` �d��
``�ATEGORY 1" ALTERNA'I'E FOR
ONE & TWO FAMILY DWELLINGS
INSTRUCTIONS: This alternative may bc used for one- and rivo-family dw�cllings built to meet the Category 1 requirements of
Minnesota Rules,Chapter 7670. Complete Parts A, B, and C. Clearly mark plans with: insulation R-values; window and skylight U-
values; size and type of equipment; equipment controls; and location of vapor retarder and ���indwash barriers. More detailed
i�iformation can be found in tl�e Nlii�rresotn E��er,,��Code summaiy slleets available from tlle Min�lesota Depai-tment of Con�mei•ce.
Part A. BUILDING ENVELOPE
,�. _n __,. �___. � _.._. . . , _ ._ _,_ . R . z ._: _.... - . T .
Clieck proposed envelope joint sealing option -� ❑ Prescript�ve(caulkmg gaskets,etc.) ❑ Perfoi�nance(test per 7670.0470 subp.7.C.)
Check tllermal energy calculation option used-� ❑ "Cookbook" (co�nplete worksheet below) � MnCheck method(attacli report)
- : ❑ Perfomiance (attach U-value calcu]ations) ❑ Systems Analysis metliod(attacl�analysis)
MINIMUM REQUIRENIENTS
��Cookbook�� Worksheet �for"Cool<book"o tion onl}�)
❑ Ceiling Insulation: Minimum R-38 with 7%z"energy heel; or
INsrttucr�oNs Minimum R-44 with]ow truss heel; or
Step l. Check ite�u(s)that design meets on Minimimi Reqtriremeiits list Minin�um R-38 with R-5 sheathin when no attic.
to the right.Must meet all items to use"Cookbook"option. ❑ Ent Doors: Max.U-value of 0.30 or 1'/4"solid wood with stonn
Step 2. Indicate proposed wall type on table below. ❑ Rim Joist Insulation: Minimum R-19
Step 3. Indicate Window U-va]ue and source. ❑ Floors over unconditioned s aces: Minimum R-24
Step 4. Verify total window(including area of all foundation windows) ❑ Foundation Insulation: Mininmm R-10
and door area is equal or less than allowable percentage. ❑ Foundation windows: %z"insulated glass,wood or vinyl fi�ame
: TABLE FOR DETERMINING MA.X11�7UM WINDOV►'AND DOOR AREA _-
Maximum Allowable Total Window and Door Aiea as - ' _ '
aPerceniage ofEx osed Wall - 12%- 14% 16%0 ]8% '-20% - 22% 24% 26% 28°/a
Wa]1 T e`.(Stapdard Framin ): -'. Maximum Avera e Window U-value(exce t foundation windows): .; '
❑ 2x4,R-13 insulation, R-7 sheathing 0.55:=; 0.47` 0.41 ,-036 :� 033 0.30 0:27 0.25 -0.23 :
❑ 2x4,R-15 insulation, R-5 sheathing ` 0.52 > 0.45 - <0;39 =0.35 ` 0.31 ' 0.28 ;0:26 0:24 :0.22 `
❑ 2x6,R-19 insulation,<R-5 sheathin `i 0.48 -: 0.41- 0.36 0.32 0.29 : 0.26•' 0.24 0:22 0.21 -
❑ 2x6,R-l9 insulation, R-5 sheathing > 0.56 ;' . 0.48 0:42 037 . ' 0_34 '_' 0.31 -. 0.28 0:26 0.24
❑ 2x6,R-21 insulation,<R-5 sheathin 0.51`__ 0.43- 0:38 `034 0.30 '. 0.28`' -0:25 0:23 0.22 .=
❑ 2x6,R-21 insulation, R-S sheathing = 0.58 0:50' 0.44 0.39 0.35''`. 0.32 ' 0:29 027 0.25 :;
Wali T 'e (Advaiiced Framii� ): = Maximwn Avera e Window U value(exce t foundation���indows): `
❑ 2x6,R-]9 insulation,<R-5 sheathing ` 0.52 0.45: . 039 035 031 ' 0.2$- 0:26 0:24 `0.22 -
❑ 2x6,R-]9 insulation, R-5 sheathing � , 0.58 1 0.50` OA.4 0.39 < 035 032- = 0.29 0.27 0.25 ,:'
❑ �x6,R-21 insulation,<R-5 sheathin 0.55. - 0.47 0:41 036 0.33 -- 0.30 ' 0:27 0:25 0 23-
❑ 2x6,R-21 insulation, R-5 sheathing - 0.60 ' 0.52 0.46 0.41 . 0.36, 0:33_: 0.30 0.28 '- 0.26 :s:
_ ---- -- -
Window.0 value; ' Source:-� ❑NFRC 0 ASHRAE 1993 Handbook� ;
,; �. __ -
� 10� � � -� - C� = C--�1°� < �� °�4 :
��indow&door area gross exposed wall area DES]GN ALLOWABLE (from table aboye)
���P�i'�'�JQi�'i �r"�"��c�5 i� ���� - �i►�F1iCf�i �iE1�C� �i,4►0 ��€ �
TYPE OF.RES.IDENTIAL BUILDIIVG APPLICABLE RULES -
Betached R-3 occapancy 1-'and 2-family dwelGsigs " ; Cha�iter 7672; or ' , i _ � .
Exa�»ples: single family;twin homes,duj�lexes Chapter 7670"Category 1" with stafutory depressurization a�d ventilation requirenients '-
Attached R-3 occupancy d}��ellings- Cliapter 7674; or '. '
", :Exam les:, tri lex townliouses and row houses ' Cha ter 7670 witfi either"Cate ory 1" or "Cate o 2" rovisions
R-1 occuPancy buildings of 3 stories or less Chapter 7674; or ='
Exain les: condominiums or apartments Chapter 7670-w�th either `Category]" or "Cate ory 2" rovisions._.
_
R-1 occupancy buildings o>'er 3 stories high;. Chapter 7676 _ � -
,-
.�Bxam les: hi h rise condos or a�artments` �5�=� - -
.
�=Part �. DEPRESSlJRIZATION Pl�OTECTIOIiT
Cl;eck option used: � Puel btu-ning equipment (complete schedules below) ❑ No fuel burning equipment
INsrRucrioNs EXHAUST/MAKG-UP AIR SCHEDULE*
Step 1. Complete the Combustron L'quipment Schedule below. Only equipment Exhaust devices over 300 cfin Flow -
with a Y (Yes)may be selected under the"Category 1"alternate. cfrn
Step 2. Complete Exlaaust/Mnl:e-up Air Schedule on tl�e right if direct or power cfni
vented or solid fuel atmospheric vent space heating equipment is cfiii
selected.
COMBUSTION.EQUIPMENT SCHEDULE
' - (check all types proposed)
Space heatiiig—noiisolid fue] Sea]ed combustion—Z Y Heai•th = nonsolid fuel � Sealed combustion
❑ Direct or po��er vented L�- ❑ Direct or power vented Y'_'
- Y�;
` Atmos herically veirfed N - Atmos liei�ically vented N
Water heating noiisolid fuel ❑ Sealed combustion Y Space heating-solid fuel ❑ Atmospherically vented
_ I,*.,
Direct �power vented Watei heatin -solid fuel ❑ Atmos herically vented Y
` ;Atmo§phenca y,vented N. Hearth-solid fiiel ❑ Atmospherica]ly vented ' Y
* If atinospherically vented solid fuel or,d'u•ect'or power vented nonsolid,fuel Space heating is installed, then make-up`air to ii�atcli
f3ow is required for each individual exl�aust device which exceeds 300 cuUic feet per minute.
Part C1. VENTILATION
V_ENTLLATION QUANTITY: - -
(IvIechanical ventilation must be provided per the larger quantity`calculated Ue]ow) -
�SO Z� 'cubic feef s 0.00583/minute = � cfm ('Cs x 15 cfm/bedroom)+15 cftn= �17� cfm`
volume of habifable rooms - number of bedrooms
- . 'VENTILATIONFAN_SCI3EDULE
Check method(s)proposed 3 _[_0 Exhaust only Balanced (heat iecoveiy ventilator,air exchanger, etc.)
Fan descri tion or location '� p� Z. .�.4- AT� S TCI��L'�l TOTALS . <
VENTILATION Intake cfin . cfni, cfin QO cfm` (of� ; cfm`
AS DESIGNED- Exliaust p :cfin' ZID cfni �p cfm' cfiri` 'cfrii.
St?t�mCP_t of Corr�nli�nc.e: The proposed building design represented in these documents is consistent with the building plans,
specifications, and other calculations submitted with the permit application. The proposed building has been designed to meet tl�e
requirements of the Minnesota Energy Code. o
S�vE L�cN� �u�� B-ZI-6� G/Z- 3S%-/7O9
Applicant(print natne) Signature Date Telephone i�tunber
Part C2. VENTILATION (Submit Part C2 upon completion of system verification�)
4/
�� ------------------------------ ------ -------------------------
Job Site Address: Pernlit Number
Fan`descri tiori or location _ TOTALS
IVIEASURED ', Intake: cfin cfni cfin cfm cfin
PERFORMANCE-� Ezhausf cfm cfiu : cfm cfin`� cfni
-� : Ventilation rate must_be �neasured and verified wlien the performance option is used in lieu of the prescriptive option for the
sealing of joints in the biiilding conditioiied envelope(from Part A). '
Compliance Statement: Installed ventilation system is in compliance with MN Energy Code and is sized to provide the design air
fl ow.
Applicant(print name) Signature Date Telephone number
Date: 8/21/2009 Revision Date: 8/21/2009 New Construction
Site Information
Address 1: 3315 Graham Hill Road Project#: 9407
Address 2: Lot: 6 Block: 1
City: Orono, MN County: Hennepin Subdivision: Graham Hill Preserve
Application Information
Business Name: Charles Cudd Co. MN Contractor License#:20635245
Contact Person: Steve Licht
Office Ph: 612-359-1709 Fax: 612-604-1209 Cell Ph: 612-490-7142
Address 1: 15050 23rd Ave. N.
City: Plymouth State: MN Zip Code: 55447
House Details
Square Feet: 8817 sq. ft. Avg. Ceiling Ht: 9.75 Number of Bedrooms: 5
ft.
Ventilation : Balanced
Total Ventilation Capacity : 376 cfm.
Minimum Continuous Ventilation :90cfm.
Intermittent Ventilation: 286 cfm.
Combustion Appliance
Water Heater 1: Power Vent Input BTUs: 75,000 Independently Vented Combustion Zone 1
Water Heater 2: Power Vent Input BTUs: 75,000 Independently Vented Combustion Zone 1
Furnace/Boiler 1: Direct Vent/Sealed Combustion Input BTUs: 125,000 Independently Vented
Combustion Zone 1
Furnace/Boiler 2: Direct Vent/Sealed Combustion Input BTUs: 125,000 Independently Vented
Combustion Zone 2
Other Combustion Appliances
Gas Fired Direct Vent Fireplace(s): Yes Gas Fired Power Vent Fireplace(s): No
Gas Fired Natural Draft Fireplace(s): No Solid Fuel Appliance(s): Two or more
Exhaust Equipment
Continuous Exhaust Ventilation Capacity (cfm): NA Clothes Dryer (cfm): 135
Exhaust Fan Rating (cfm): 600 Next Exhaust Fan Rating(cfm): 120
Make-Up Air
Total Make-Up Air Required (cfm): 446
Minimum Power Make-Up Air Required (cfm): 267
Passive Make-Up Required: Round Rigid: 11 inches or Insulated Flex: 12 inches.
Motorized damper shall be interlocked with largest exhaust system.
Combustion Air
Combustion Zone One Round Rigid Required: 7 inches or Insulated Flex: 8 inches
OO 2004 CenterPoint Energy Minnegasco. 2004 Mechanical Code Guidelines. Page 1
Combustion Zone Two: Minimum Combustion Air Requirements Met.
Applicant Name (print): SZ�� Lttl-(T Signature/Date• �� p�u-r/j�' �� Z�'d 9
Code Official (print): Signature/Date:
�O 2004 CenterPoint Energy Minnegasco. 2004 Mechanical Code Guidelines. Page 2
}lennepin County Property Map Print Page 1 of 1
Hennepin County Property Map - Tax Year: 2009
The data contained on this page is derived from a compilation of records and maps antl may contain dlscrepancies that can only be disdosed bY an accurate survey performed by a licensed
land surveyor.The Derimeter and area(square footage antl acres)are approximates and may mntain discrepancies.The mformatlon on[his page should be used for reference purposes only.
He��ep�c County does not guaranCee fhe accuracy of matenal herein contained and is not responslble for any misuse or m�srepresen[aUon of[his�nformation or its derlvat�ves.
�`��.y^y'4 t� 6�. ' h` � " �
;G . ' '�.� � . .:, . �
�
,
� ,'V e, �a �� �.Y## •a`��� ' .
r , -
� . � �
��- "� '�n�. - °� �' .�'s� ,."� ;
� E �..�"� �` t��='� r.� t Y � +. , �e
.; .� � -y. .:r.. '
' 4 � � T .
. . , , . . . i�.. . * ..
_.k �. .�,r, 3}u' - ' • " �1
¢ �� � ���i' •A* i� �� � � � .��,
� . . , .�+`i � :� '�, �'' ?' 4` �," .
�' . •; .. � � #�Y� vr'r r __� `�,.
-"'� "�� ��. ,�� ��_� � � �. .�G �; �
3"'+ ��''G.�� � { , w !fi
.�
'�� � • � ' � A�� ` � � � 7� .se.
` _ �� � ,� �
r er- ,7�� , ,�:'
y~+h. .�. .;.�..�` '.�+ ', _..
�r i t;^
r-,��,, - � '��-�::
� � .
� t 32ti0
•� �c��� ,���y{ � � I 3��
�- ��. ;� .,�,�"�.' �
...
.:� � ��` w �
,.
��� � , ��� �
. ,�
fYe �`'� ,� �`� � � � � �'�,
�. �
`�:�1 �"���r: *:" �'„�. ..�
�� ��`�u'" : . �:►` `� � � ` :,.
�� � �h' j �A^ . �
,yy`,�. i#��"�* i � l
_�� ' � 6 ��� � �. � �. J
' � .� .��.,,� ' .,_�_
s y�
w��,y i.�Y` A�.�.
�`��v'`.� . � . . ',�.��4 '� ��ID�S �' f '�'
�G , , 5.- _ . -
"• ``'� - _' . � �� S`�
�d� �,M1� �F tf�F l � � �. ,� .� � f .
R
'� ... �r..`... � . t� ,,. � .`. ..'�.a Yr.i�.�. 1l ��
Selected Parcel Data Date Printed: 9/3/2009 9:24:06 AM
�• Parcel ID: OS-117-23-11-0007 Current Parcel Date: 8/4/2009
Owner Name: BPS PROPERTIES LLC
Parcel Address: 3315 GRAHAM HILL RD,ORONO, MN 55356
Property Type:VACANT LAND-RES Sale Price: $0.00
Homestead: NON-HOMESTEAD Sale Date: /
Area (sqft): 132060 Sale Code:
Area (acres): 3.03
A-T-B:TORRENS
Market Total: $341,000.00
Tax Total: $3,852.14
http://gis.co.hennepin.mn.us/HCPropertyMap/Locator.aspx?PID=0511723110007 9/3/2009
. ; • .
1 •
emo
To: Finance Department
From: Christine Mattson, Planning Assistant
CC: Street File
Date: 6/30/2011
Re: Building Permit Advanced Plan Review Fee Refund
Building Permit Application #2009-00529 pertaining to 3315 Graham Hill Road has been
inactive for 665 days. The Planning &Zoning Department is voiding the application, retuming
the building plans and refunding the advanced plan review fee of $5,405.89, because no
building plan review was performed.
The following is attached:
• Letter to Charles Cudd
• Copy of Advanced Plan Review fee receipt
• Copy showing all engineering fees paid
Mail check to:
Charles Cudd Co.
15050 23`�Ave N
Plymouth, MN 55447
w:�street files\graham hill road�3315�advanced plan review fee refund memo.doc