HomeMy WebLinkAbout#6425-variance-2014 , � ��� ��-s�- � o��-�.e—
Doc No T05207556
Certified, filed and/or recorded on
Oct 14, 2014 2:00 PM
Office of the Registrar of Titles
Hennepin County, Minnesota
Martin McCormick, Registrar of Titles
Mark Chapin, County Auditor and Treasurer
Deputy 97 Pkg ID 1164816M
Doc Name: Resolution
Document Recording Fee $46.00
Document Total $46.00
Existing Certs
1369675
This cover sheet is now a permanent part of the recorded document.
.�0��
C ITY OF ORONO
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
� �,: 6425 ,
ti�
NO.
t'�kESHo��
A RESOLUTION
GRANTING A VARIANCE TO
MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE
SECTIONS 78-78-1279(6)
FILE NO. 14-3655
✓
WHEREAS, Joseph R. Feidmann and Donelie L. Feldmann, a married couple
(hereinafter "the Applicants") are the owners of the property located at 805 Forest Arms Lane
within the City of Orono (hereinafter the "City") and legally described as Lot 1, Block 2, Forest
Arms, Hennepin County, Minnesota (hereinafter the "Property"); and '�
WHEREAS, the Appiicants have made application to the City of Orono for a
variance to Orono Municipai Zoning Code Section 78-1279(6) to ailow construction of screen
porch and deck additions ahead of the average lakeshore setback on the Property; and
WHEREAS, after due pubiished notice and mailed notice in accordance with
Minnesota Statutes and the Orono, Minnesota, City Code, the Orono Pianning Commission heid
a public hearing on July 21, 2014 at which times all persons desiring to be heard concerning this
application were given the opportunity to speak thereon.
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono,
Minnesota:
FINDINGS
1. This appfication was reviewed as Zoning File number 14-3655.
2. The Property is located in the LR-1 B One Family Lakeshore Residential Zoning
District which requires a minimum lot area of 1.0 acre and a minimum lot width of
140'.
3, The Pianning Commission reviewed this application at a public hearing held on
July 21, 2014 and voted 7 for and 0 against on a motion to recommend approval
of the average lakeshore setback variance based on the following findings:
a. The Property contains 48,665 square feet in area and has a defined width of
109-feet at the lake and 172-feet at the 75-foot setback.
b. The Property has a unique shape and is located at the northern most point of
the channel which extends to Forest Lake. Due to the nature of the
lakeshore the Property is somewhat disconnected from the lake proper.
Pa�e 1 of 4
�°�o
C ITY OF ORONO
I�ESOLUT'ION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
��'1 , ti�� N�. � 425
"�KFSHo�
c. The location of the Applicants' home is partially ahead of the average
lakeshore setback line. There is no conforming location lakeward of the home
to construct additions or a deck.
d. The proposed screen porch and deck will meet the 75-foot lake setback.
e. The Property wiil conform to the hardcover limitations of a Tier 1 property.
f. The Applicants' request is in harmony with the purpose and intent of the
ordinance.
g. The Appiicants have demonstrated that enforcing the provisions of the Zoning
Ordinance deprives the Applicants of the reasonable use of their Property.
h. The Applicants' proposed screen porch and deck will not alter the essential
character of the neighborhood and wili result in minimal or no negative impact
on adjacent properties.
i. The Applicants' proposal to construct the screen porch and deck ahead of the
average lakeshore setback will not adversely impact lake views enjoyed from
the adjacent home to the south.
4. The City Council has considered this application inciuding the findings and
recommendation of the Pianning Commission, reports by City staff, comments by
the Applicants and the public, and the effect of the proposed variance on the
health, safety and welfare of the community.
5. The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this Property are peculiar to
it and do not apply generaliy to other property in this zoning district; that granting
the variance would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor pose a fire
hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely serve as a
convenience to the Applicants, but is necessary to alleviate a practical difficulty;
is necessary to preserve a substantiai property right of the Applicants; and would
be in keeping with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive
Plan of the City.
Pave 2 of 4
�o�o
C ITY OF ORONO
I�ESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
y��q �,G' No. b425
kEs H o�
CONCLUSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS
Based upon one or more of the above findings, the Orono City Council hereby grants
variances to Orono Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-1279(6) to allow construction of a screen
porch addition and deck ahead of the average lakeshore setback on the Property, subject to the
following conditions:
1. Council approval is based on the survey and construction plans submitted by the
Appiicants and annotated by City staff, attachecl to this Resolution as Exhibits A & B.
Any amendments to the plan which are not in conformity with City codes will require
further Planning Commission and City Council review.
2. Proposed hardcover levels are conforming to the Tier 1 standards and no hardcover
variances are granted.
3. Authorities granted by this resolution run with the Property not with the Applicants, but
are permissive on�y and must be exercised by obtaining a building permit for the screen
porch and deck and commencing construction of said project. A footing inspection must
be completed for the screen porch and deck within one year of the date of Council
approval, or the variances will expire on that date (July 28, 2015).
4. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this resolution
shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically terminate any authority
granted herein, and shall be punishable as a misdemeanor.
5. The undersigned Applicants have read, understand and hereby agree to the terms of
this resolution and on behalf of the Appiicants and the Appiicants' heirs, successors and
assigns, hereby agree to the recording of this resolution in the chain of title of the
Property.
Adopted by the Orono City Council on the 28th day of July, 2014.
ATTEST:
�
� �
�'� � i�.�: E ��Cr � l-'�
Rachel Dodge, City Clerk Lili Tod cMillan, Mayor
Page 3 of 4
�o�o
C ITY OF ORONO
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
y��,� �,G� N o. � 4 2 5
kESHO�
- � `� � ��
' ` '�
ro erty wner(s)
STATE OF MINNESOTA
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN
This instrument was acknowledged before me this �� day of�� , 2014, by
Joseph R. Feidmann, husband of Donelle L. Feldmann.
� , .
, ,�'
- �' �r.t�
N tao ry Public
STATE OF MINNESOTA SARAL.KASTENDICK
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN - ` NOTARYPUBUC-MINNESv>�
w,,,,,,:1 My Commission Expires Jzn 31 Z�i' <'
� ��'
This instrument was acknowledged before me this �day of� , 2014, by
Donelle L. Feldmann, wife of Joseph R. Feldmann.
,.����,�-,�����-
otary Pubfic
� u`�--_,::::�=�:�-.:.,.ti�::�
�� , SARA L.KASTENDICK
,�� NOTARY PUBLIC-MINNESOTA
�,�y Commission Expires Jan.31.2015
Paae 4 of 4
HARDCOVER CALCULATIONS
FOR
JOSEPH FELDMANN -
SHEET 1 OF 2 SHEETS
lSEE SHEET 2 OF 2 SHEETS FOR DETAILEO SITE/GRAOING PLANI .
-- ---------------C 0 U N T Y R 0 A D N 0. 1 5 1 -- ".�T_�_�_-
--xrv.-vei.i�i
s S I
Plat 5 BB'.79'00'E Msae.S BO's7'7E'E R��4.8J
—Plat J11.07 Meas.3I0.9F-- --71.56-' - i�'[MP
I —r+v.-ueZ.se
' \ ' 70 �y,.� �'' I ^..�. �.
�i',� �\ i �-_,i . ' t .0�1 �
� \ � ( �.1�✓ � w�c rt�a
\ \ � '�.�� (pJ � ' � LE�END
\ I O mw6sm ���w i ar,vrts) �' :e
---. =� � L 0 7 ���. �v�o . ��1e xr. oosiwc
' � i _-�,Rr.u+we reu I W � � wmairr�
.. ..�.. � . � } ;i��� �q J �i�s.r. 2 \
S
�. ,`���•1... �,J' � ___'�� ' �b o j 3 I ———ve]——— ExISTMc GROIrt+o CONfDUI+
�`. `b �. , '1. '� ,� _'_' -- S `0 1
�. �\0��'1 �. . � � � r . /:�.� �,ti . _'__^ze__""'_"^ 8 I� � .�oi.e Eonsm+e cao�mo nn'uwn
� >�\'L . � � I� '_ .l ' "' ry� I G`( G1FN'/a:1I
,, �---- � I 0 °
�— y9,�w, \��_� .�i re�sET� �,, k ��d@� . � , =--b�--'- �$ � Q 1. xu,.
�/ �n ���i�` �\ FEIIYdNG I�LLS^. iOQ.PAi[K 4 � ! OGS�=pEIENA���, �1 I N � B e
OO
�.\\41` ; . �eSj. �, � i IiiiiF. a�� �bh -sl.V1s �\ �u �
o� '�"-�o.w...��0zpa,` I �_/._�I� « � �p � --� umx+e enurmrous sur+�nce
� ''-� � �
-----_, �•\ ,l �p�.,_`-� --7��..� ��= :�.e-� nerei�wr+o ireu m ��
�%�- nc*wwc�ws \i- . ia sr. I I e txnn+c cor+cacrr surrr�cr
�.�'-\��.� � ro isi s�r.� ' J� 7¢ �
��� �'` ` , I c�c . � � � i� :
A �� � \ � - "-�I vaanogo i ar,wmc w�u' �.,-� NSNw�� � �O
' J YISR1 PRt�A EJ �, �PV E C I
F"��d �� i 1_:�t''� . � I:o . � , ' ;
� � i.a:r. aR
� y i rodr.n.•'" �
., � - \ � --Plut 237.26 Meaa. 257.58--� � _ � I
�� �Pf . '-+,rr.e� I Pm�wesr uea.. s E9'S9'21'WG� �n�
'�� I � I I e�o � j I � ,, `U ,.
I " _' < .
I� � � � � �or 2 �'�` ' I
�
, rre-wa:
I' o I ' � ,7p 80 00
�, �"--------------I--�F-ne------'--------- esm, �
i mi I GR�PML SGL£M FEET
msn1c
� xasc �
� +v rno-sns 1 �c.n DESrR1pTI0N
II � Lot I, Block 2. FORESi ARMS,
i � Hennep(n Covnty, Minneaoto.
I LOi AREA�BOVE OHW� �.687 e./. \
� I hsnbr certHy Mot fhls �uny.Plan. a
Hordcover-Propoeed/eaturee and E�Iating lsature! RENSEp 7��7/�4:�DDm 51�1R5�ND IM�DINC, hpo��a�P�pored by m�or u�der my
�D lemaln (See drvw(ng (o�deecriptlone) NOOIIIm PA770,UPMIEU 70RLH/DECK DIMENSIONS �R�(��peMalon anC Nvt I om a Ucem+d
� 2.942 s./. Land Surveya undu Ue hw� (th�Stals
g J17 i.t. o/Minrn�afo.r
� I!0 e./. 0.7 OS 14
p z a�e .� ��y n�.o�d..btMo reo���s n.no+n oa�• / � ,�,om w�rsm.m
E B3 �.f. occoNinp to Ae-Bu1R SNe Pian by Mrysr-RoM1On Ueenes Na.b6d/
F 1.997�.(. {nM SeMn�.FlI�No. I1112-8. Ea/ed f0/46/12.
� 256 e.L _...... ....-. nevie�ors
H 137 s.L �..._�. .�.
i zse..r. _ . ����„ --. _.
. , s
ror�� e s�s a.r. c��e7-P'Z',�
8.4I3/�B98S � 17.Jx �LAfdD S£RMICES/�� n
NE131 03/03/
Hardrover- To be removed (See drawinq lor �,�ei.eeie�e "'
deacriptlons) or+wwHer 'FET=� 4��s
J 187�./. g,�_eneers
H.u.wva���.ux-a�rc�aee��.v�ewa�saou����.�»_�nx�,.bm,-e..a
rn �
� � �
0
�'' Q: c
N .'' '•�
� D �
LE�END SITE /GRADING PLAN
FOR
• swrcwr wn�ro�r .
JOSEPH FELDMAN
———9�1——— FXI5T��4 CAOIM�LGW/d�R
�9]x.0 Ln71TIM1C CROIMO El£V/1710N
, au,�,,, SHEET 2 OF 2 SHEETS
• NE7I. r� � i�t � e'o/x 4. � ia'•ou�
�� E70SIt�G EO'ilAlP/0U5 SUIffTCE ��" '1 I �
�T�-�� fX15IRAG COfIL'RE7E 5T/RFAfI \ � � '�I � \1 � \ .
`� P � � \ �ia o l I
�„„ vanwsm cwamn cor+rofm O � av.o��
�`Ja�o.,� 1 � aw osio ,,�d ?q� m•o��
.oezo vnowsm ue�anav � ` .
ar m+olo�w iv.v.w.�u � , �\\ ��'� ' 6 � � nr �w.o �aezo � � �k..e
iv
x mvm rro a Knwnc wu ,c
� PRapoSED STa.E RECNahC w.w. B�i.w.o
(m c aavm��! � \ �� 'L�� � \ I ,� . "�TN G920 '
p•rn+ � , / ^BM/320 1
�-� � .," G I I .��,��1�- Q�5
FROPOSFD MiIV \ �� � ��I KT C NNlf 0161 f�^2.9 },., i
' � I �e �9�5�� .o
`� I ' 'Tlw 0'�J2d
,�R ' \\ � �. �.�9N YIQE� �
%CMMD .C_\ \I I �D ' :.20.0 tl �EASIMC
e� I
_��Gmro � � n .�lid-=- -�.o �y � � noa+
\ a- � 's � � � � nv bdz! M k' '°o,`�z'
�r h �� ���.�.-. er wae � (�(�
c•cmxo �'\ /,� � \ � �\� � lJV
� �` � I � ��� 8� c�
v cm��ro; � I �
� � u
i� \ �� � N oy. � , � nr i�zs �-�� �
�\ ��` �� I S d� � es vM.e � oo� aa
\ � q, � � � �E �6 ��� 4 ^` � o ia m .w
� `(� � V `� �. vnaosm R
� 1�0. � 1 'I �-!Y 1 ` NI -
� }� 7N YJ7.0 . ` . vww [nzmc GRMi1C SGV.E M fFET
\ \� �'2,�\ \ ew��ee � � ,-�r.nmc',, .—aoo--=
� , _ , . izo - n r aan
\ \� � _~� \ ,i 7-� �. �ei�o�%n nr isz��. s�.d' � -`us��
� � .��� • 1 � � �.h
� 9w PN.E ogo RE115ED 7/17/14:ADUEO STNRS AN�IMIDINQ
� � �,\ ="` ' %��' .:y- �. �;: / P�no MOOIFlm GAT70.UPWIED PoRCH/UELK O�MENSiONS
\ � 4�a � �°g°. ' i ��b.e � � #� f�ae �� e�c z.i
\� \ \\ T� ` : \�cru� _ I �. . +�.� :i.e
\ \� 'J i; 1�" .� .:. 'r� . "� � ..,01�.� �� rw os�.
� � \ ,. � `,�y, o ,�e�.., ..! �
\ �J� o � .. m nv os�.i�-
\ - — 1 A
f
��. � .--o H.2 uie([L vzf.a).='''' '' _ ' 'IP es 1 ���I �� 7. M H27 /Q 'rnmoY� cr'.
\ >i ��pNM"" `� . I 1 a u.v�i rtir�Nc
, � � R,sET^�°� 1 I�� w,ui
,� ., �; '.:t—'' _�-_�S : � ;----
.. - \ % ie•oeK � � ,�. .. \ 1 F •� nFsr I
�,:' . . f»' w o�7.e �_ R PiION
�:-:�.___- \ � �--F-----f--�-----r-1 � �
� - Lot 1. Bloek 2, FORESi ARMS.
`—" � n•uev�r � � � � r�wt. � Hennepin County, Minneeoto.
' 1 \� � '�o. I � � � r oa.e f \
i
, ` � 1 / � � � � i f 1 i n.,.�r u.eiry�w�,.�rv.r.tlm�'m
,�� � � �,rt.�.c,�aa nr o
1 �� �I �;'�M»9 I j °�e•w.�c 8 � e�.�.�n,.r.m„ e u,�i i o u�.�s.e
I � —vnorwn urc Land 5wrsyo�u�w�bws el thr SteN
�� / o!Mlnnuotn. ///�����/jJ����
I � pati 0.1 03 14 .s�—�i.�'^s
� I I I •� � u":.r'�a"'�'eee�i
� I / I I � .___
� , � _ RE..,=�o,.,
� „>,�.
�AP-�10 S'LPIM��SA�
p�ry Iinu and u��0��uru on��n e�rr��.�+Nasais^ M o^rE o3ioeii<
oeeo.dfnq ta M-9ultt Sit�Plan Dy Meysr-RohRn ea.t�e�+��+w ^ �� 2 oF
(und Snvtta.Fi��No. 1I211-B.dalsd t0/28/12. ap �:eo� �E�—
g z a
N:\ufe vnlem\���lt�aune.nAe iz.�naaoe�Mv�s�e ran\���11 l d i mecnd�bd�w
� �
� �� V
�
� � i ��� � � —
o I�J I I Resolution
� II ,
Q , I ; Exhib�t B� _
LL � ; !, 6 4 2 �
� � I '
0
w '�
�
Q � �,_- ,
� _
� � nD � __ __ :
o ��,��-,:
I � ,
�
�,o-,L� � 4 2 5
��O-,LI L I
,� „o-,oi Q ,�o-,z
�,t�-,z ,�u-,z ��u-,z �,n-,z o
� -
h.' '.
S1S d bx� N WG"3fl 6 �Z c�+ _ _ -_
€ :_=�=�-'`T`_T='_==_:_�_�;��
-- - - -- -- - - -' � W�'38 HS(11d "1'd Olxl°£ �.w; ,� �I
I
� � i I "�"� ��`�� w ��� � I
=I N N S1SIG' '1'd OIXZ (0 m I
� Q ;;;a Q
V/�/ Z N �- � W ,,,p ,� �
IL� N x Q I �I � ��� W �
QIW ,� U V i � I =a, Q•"�� �
c�
,�' Q..U � O Z ldi � ' � ��� �
� - ) I
�
W Q �ry W � � I � J �
i
IL'Q l0 (V � ���Q Za �
� I N �i�0
U n _ r u
> i
� � O 'i 't� �W"
; � wvaa�sm3 �rd oixs��-';" �, �
i, �, - - - - �i_�e�=_�e�=:".�-..r�
- - -- - � I ";1
i
x, � -
I •�-p ��g� �„�
� �S1SIOf"1"d OIXL^�j
iiL � w p I 4���
�Q-�Z - � I W�iil
'\7 w � m ����
�
�a�8 � � � tt N"'�
W � I 'U J����
Qr � � LL��
� d � � r���
� `n � `� ° � a �;;,1
U � � ° �;;;1
W a = � r,,,
Q X � �j �����
� W I Z
M Q 0 I ����
o O ��°-�£ ' :
� p � � ,�0-,9 i;ii '
� � � - - ��� - -
� � ___________ ____ _
' va9 hsm� •1•a oiXs�s
I „6-,8
� O
I O-,6
� •�'o „9i
�
slsior �rd oiXz
�
'wv�e r+sn7� �l�a oiXz��
-- ----------- ----_----_�
- I - - .� _._ - �
i --- ---- y�} -=z_= "` �
� - � -
---- ---- '
� ---— ----
� ----- ----
---—�----- _____ ____
I (� k_x___ -c_`_
� -i--- O-,6 � z '— -----
- -- -- - �
- - — R Z � � ----�-----
---- ---- p � d
--- -----
---- —- a O � ----- ----
---- ��----- � O Z '? -=__ _=_`��`\
u.l t- 0 ;';'
l'I � o Q O k;� ys��,
z d u � ,�; y'���,.
p p (Y O `r ; �-`'',.
Q ~ � � '�5%SigJo � +
Q �o z�.
p - W R' 'i O E�W '���`ys���"� 8+\
O w p Z= u ��.�� � z ;�
3 Z > z u_ �z� �� ��,, 0�8 ;r'
o W d „� `\°,., +� -,;s %�
_ �m w "\ ��ry tyl�
� ° __��
_ ,��,m
xoQ .
�� � �
� � �:�,
� �
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
The undersigned, being duly qualified and appointed City Clerk of the City of
Orono, Minnesota, certifies that I compared the foregoing resolution adopted at the
meeting of the Orono City Council on July 28, 2014, with the original thereof on file in
my office, and the same is a correct transcription thereof.
` � ='WITNESS my hand officially as such City Clerk and the corporate seal of the
Ci�ty this ��l`�.day of ��,�,�,� , 2014.
- _ - �s�-�--c ��--�_(' l�,c��
City Clerk
� =�;���,
--,