HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolution 2894 r�,;� �!+� , -
�_ Clt� o� ORONO �
� �
. • � �RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL � `
. � �, NO. 2894 . . :
�
• - • •
A RSSOLDTION GRANTING
VARIANCES TO
1 MONICIPAL ZONING COD$
� SECTION 10.22, SDBDIVISION 2
� AND SECTION 10.23, SDBDIVISION 6 (B)
FILE #1594
� � WHER$AS, Duane Luke (hereinafter "the app].icant") is the
owner of the property Xocated at 2465 North Shore Drive within the
City of Orono (hereinafter "City") and Zegally described as fol.I.ows:
Exhibit A, attached (hereinafter "the property"); and
WHEREAS, the appl.icant has applied to the City for a
variance to MunicipaJ. Zoning Code Section 10.22, Subdivision 2 to
permit the construction of room additions to the existing residence,
such additions constituting hardcover in the 75-250' lakeshore setback
zone in excess of the 25$ hardcover normal Yy al.�.owed, and a variance
� to Section 10.23, Subdivision 6 (B) to a1.1.ow construction of an
entryway addition located 25' from the side I.ot line where a 30' side
setback is normaXly required.
1
NOW, THEREFOR$, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono,
Minnesota:
FINDINGS
l. This application was reviewed as Zoning Fi1:e #1594.
2. The property is I.ocated in the LR-lA Singl.e Famil.y Lakeshore
Residential Zoning District.
3. The Orono P1.anning Commission reviewed this appl.ication on
October 15, 1990 and recommended approval. of the proposed
variances based upon the folxowing findings: .
a) The orient�tion of the neighboring residence to the east
is such that the proposed 25' side setback f or the entry
wi�. l not tend to increase the visual density of tha
neighborhood nor wiZl it have significant effect on the
neighboring property.
b) AXthough hardcover on the property a�.ready exceeds the
25$ limitation, appXicants have demonstrated that they can
• easil.y remove equivalent amounts of hardcover in the 75-250!
Page 1 of 4
� C�ty o�� ORONO � �. �
� .
�� . . .
� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
� NO. 2894 .
' • - • •
�
� a
zone to yiel.d no net increase in hardcover above the
; existing 37.8� in that zone. A1so, Pl.anning Commission
; noted for the record that the hardcover caused by the
� existing detached barn and driveway, directs run-off to the.
1 north and general3.y away f rom the lake.
;
; 4. The City Counci�. has considered this appXication inc�uding
; the findings and recommendations of the P1.anning Commission,
reports by City staff, comments by the appl.icant and the effect
of the proposed variance on the heal.th, safety and wel.fare of the
community.
5. The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this
property are peculiar to it and do not appl.y genera�.l.y to other
property in this zoning district; that granting the variance
wouXd not adversel.y affect traffic conditions, light, air nor
pose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring property; woul.d
not merely serve as a convenience to the applicant, but is
• necessary to alXeviate a demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is
necessary to preserve a substantial. property right of the
applicant; and wouXd be in keeping with the spirit and intent of
� the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Pl.an of the City.
CONCLIISIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS
Based upon the above findings, the Orono City Counci� hereby
grants a variance to the MunicipaJ. Zoning Code Section 10.23,
Subdivision 6 (B) to permit the construction of an entryway addition
located 25' from the side 3.ot I.ine where a 30' setback is normal.I.y
required, and grants a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section
10.22, Subdivision 2 to al�.ow hardcover of 37.8g in the 75-250'
I.akeshore setback zone where only 25� hardcover is normalXy a1.Yowed,
subject to the foxl.owing conditions:
1. AppXicant is advised that hardcover on the property in the
0-75 ' and 75-250�' zones may not exceed the amounts and
percentages as shown on the survey and table attached as Exhibit
B. Any future proposaXs to increase hardcover on the property in
those zones wil1. not be alxowed, but might be approved only in
conjunction with concurrent removals of existing hardcover,
yielding no net hardcover increase.
Page 2 of 4
• ,
� �. . - • . � � 1 .
� .
���. s ._ C�t� o� ORONO
, �
• � � RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCI L .
� NO. 2894 .
� � � _ � � .
2. Authorities granted by this variance run with the property
not with the appl.icant, but are permissive only and must be
exercised by application for a buil.ding permit within one year of
the date of Council. approva�., or this variance wi1.1. expire on
that date (October 22, 1991).
3. VioXation of or non-comp3.iance with any of the terms and
conditions of this variance shal.� constitute a viol.ation of the
zoning code, shal.X automatical.ly terminate any authority granted
herein, and shall be punishabl.e as a misdemeanor.
4. The undersigned applicant has read, understood and hereby
agrees to the terms of this resolution and on behaXf of himseXf,
his heirs, successors and assigns, hereby agrees to the recording
of this reso�ution in the chain of tit3.e of the property.
Adopted by the City Council of the City of Orono, Minnesota
at a regul.ar meeting on the 22nd day of October, 1990.
• ATT T:
l � r
,
Dorothy M a3.lin, City Cl.erk Jam s R. Grabe`k, yo-
.
Property Owner(s)
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
The foregoing instrument was acknowXedged before me on this
22nd day of October, 1990, by James R. Grabek & Dorothy M. HaI.1.in,
Mayor & City Cl.erk of the City of Orono, a Minnesota municipal
corporation and said instrument was executed on behalf� of the City.
�
THERE3A L NAAB Notary Public
' NOTARY PUBUO-MINNESOTA
• HENNEPIN COUNTY .
��"��w'�� Page 3 of 4
�:. -�� -: ��; Cit� o� ORONO ,
�
• , � RESOWTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
� NO. 2894
• - � •
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this a� Y� day of C , 199�
before me a Notar Pub ic within and for said county, personal ly
appeared , � known to me to be
the person(s ) described i and w o executed the foregoing
instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as
his (their) free act and deed.
. , �
NOTAR
THERE8A L. NAAB
�,�pt{/�py pUgLIC• MINNESOTA
�E����eC�wNaas2
•
MY COMMISSION EXPIRES
1
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
)ss. .
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this day of � , 199 , before me
a Notary Public within and for said County, personally appeared
known to me to be the
person(s) described in and who executed the foregoing instrument,
and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his
(their) free act and deed. �
. . . .s
NOTARY PUBLIC �
MY COMMISSION EXPIRES �
•
, Page 4 of 4
I � • � . ' � �x�ia�T �
; ��,��-zd� l�a , z 89`�
;
�
� �; '^ ^ LEGAL DESCRiP7'ION:
� .
. .��
• .s 'That part of Govcrnmcn� Lol 5, Scction 9, Township 117, Rangc 23, dcscribed as follow�s: Commcncing at a
� ,�` �point in thc ccntcr line of County Road No.51,which point is 437.4 fcct duc Wcst o[a point in the East line of
saicl Scction 9, dLstant 1260 fcct south o[thc East quartcr corncr of said scction; thcnce Norlh 63 degrecs 08
' � minutes West along the center line of said County Road a distance of 50 feet; thenee North 61 degrees 17
'� minutcs West along the ccntcr linc o[said road 72.3 fcct; tl�cncc South �30 dcgrecs 07 minutcs West to thc
" shore of Lakc Minnctonka; thencc sc�uthcastcrly along said shorc linc to an inlerscction with a line bcaring
., � . Soulh 40 dcgrecs 07 minutes �Vcst from thc point of bcginnin�; thcncc North 40 degrecs 07 niinutes East to '
thc poin�of bcginning.
Subjcc� to an cascmcnt for public road purposcs ovcr thc horthcastcrly 33 fcct thcrcoG Also subjcct to an
cascmcnt for drivcway purposcs ovcr a strip of land 12 fcct in��•idth,hcing G fcct on cach sidc of thc following
daSCribccl ccntcr linc, to �vit: Bcginning at a �oint in thc Northcastcrl�� linc of thc above dcscribcd tract of
. � IanJ,distant 34.8 f.cct southcastcrly of thc most Northcrly corncr thcrcof; thcncc South 33 dcgrccs 07 minutcs
Wcst 78 [cct; thcncc south���c.ticrly on a tangcntial cun•c tc� thc riSht «•ith a radius oC 180 fcct to an
•� intcrscction H�ith thc Northwcstcrl��linc of thc abo�•c dcscrihcd tract and thcrc tcnninating.
, Subjcct to rescrvation of cascmcnt R�r usc, main�cnancc, impm��cmcnt, rc��air and replaccmcnt o[garasc or _
barn building locatcd ui�on �hc follrnrinS cicscribccl parccl nf ihc foresc�ing tract: Commcncin5 at a point on
thc Northwcstcrly (NWIy) linc of thc Iract hcrcinabovc dcscribccl, ��•hich pc�int is distant t��•o hundred fifty-
scvcn (257) fcct Sout}i 40 dcgrccs 07 minutcs Wcst of thc North���cstcrly (NWIy) corncr of thc tract
' hcrcinabo��c dcscribccJ, thcncc a� a risht an�lc in a Southcastcrly (SEIy) dircction a distancc o[fifty-two (52)
tcct, thcncc at a right anSlc in a South��•cstcrly (SWIy) dircction a clistancc of Gfty-siY (56) Icct, thcncc at a
right anglc in a Nortti���cstcrly (N�VIy) dircction a distancc of fifty-t���o (52) [cct, thcncc along thc
Northwcstcrly(NWI��) linc of thc lract hcrcinahovc dcscribcd to thc Point c�f hcSinninS.
•
'"; �' M1 . : � � , ' . , ' � ,.�. , �, " W.'....'•\ ., ��
y,' ,!•.�.� � J h� i . , ,� � + ' � , a :k � :
'� �: � ,ir, �: � �' � s�ll � ( • _ • :c �I'„
n � .• . ' .�� I ?
.��. fi � , � � 1� , ' � � � 1 � . ,� �
� �; . . � . . . . �. , ' '.� . � � � � ,:I c, �
��`s 1: � .. � . , , y . . �) ' . . . , ;., ,' . . ,� i .
Y� - � ( t , !' , i� ��� , ' � ,Ii;I�7 i ' - � ' � � �
�1 1 � ' 4: � � � (�7. F: . � ' �� ' .
!t; , ��I� , :.� ij
, ' � � ' 4 . , � ';� .
;L��, � , . . .. . ....:_.. . : _.._. . � !. � �`��� ��,` �;
,� ,�_ i� , � � , a�+'� �------_..__. . f��I
:r j •� r� � < , . ` �� f . .
tr:. !.� f � � ' . ... • � Y .� ' } . . � . �T�' 1
.'�� � � � � ` � y r ' � � � . '1, . j . � < <!!1 �..,\
�� . ' . , ' • • � . . . . �� ��.
• �� � .� �� , �3 �. � ��! 4
cil { �� �1.. � I' � . . • .. �• �ti?�� � . .
_�. .a� e C '� I s:.
ri .�' r' --- . _' . ;•'. . , ',�i. .. � ' ; �O�p�• � � i�, .i�i ' .t;� C
wN' 45t � .... , � �k�' ;� : Si �.� �.i�T��;l�� �r �� '... •'; � j ;
';� �y � t r t + :��1 � � ,+•:: q �j.l��� t r .,'
��: ' � , C �.� "I a� �� i" � `1i- ��F. . � i ! .��.. 1�� �O O/'�O w�l'�t � .�?,�
:;st � ��� � � � , :.i, .,: � ,, , ;��.--436.00- ,,���' � ��'��'
�7 �:'� i 4 1'� ��) � .o � �l � , , . i :it ti i'�..
t. r 1 ���a t.t� � ` ! � � ' t � ,;; � �'r�� 'z +4 ;� . , . �a.
l�' l'� „ r , ' i �ti F I�� i ;r � i '_ .� ! •� , , �i� + '•�P,`; �
s ���, • "�3� � `r � , ' �i � • � �1 � ' � ��'�
� 0 �I ,•ii• ��'I +'d �l �:�; i �� :r �� I r OCK SURFA E. . 'I' ~�: Oy: �' � � '+� I � ..
:'�i� i . �`CC i �' �r,. ��1.,,.� ��' ,. .. °. . . Z. �� I • .
;yi ;' � � . .'r• �,�w».., ; .. :•• i�� .► t .p�s p {?; � c u1 , . i'��.,,
'+? ' ��,i , �,� , � ;�. � . � 250 .• " — lin •i� ; . .
���, �{,. 1 i � (� . ' �t � ,it� tt'I� ' '� . . . � , ' � •'(�' � p n - R:. N� � ' `, ' t,+ �'• I.F�, N ' ; � -
, �. N1 S '� * . "` �• ► 'x'' R o �r; i X o :I� �� _ �� � '
�,n '.�: �S 5 75 ' '' : :� �. x,-. � ol �� ; � o,.:z,�; '�; i
o � � :�n• �/, ' , t '�:Y:.
� � � �;� x � �
;�i i �p ' =a- . �..� ' �•►'.;�:.• � C� n . 'r 7 I ,A },O,t� ti,, ! t
''(�,: + A N jo � _° . �•� •D. �. E1�— W /►1 ; 9 0 '� Q �� ,; ;
Y�'f3 #� ^ 'a p • . �� _. , ''_'�. � �"1 D / R ,, �° , `� (l� oi ' •�
;�T �t.'�i• '�N' � �, x � ��ti, n' �, , � ;o•, m o m`� � � _. � n �,�: ; ; , ,
i; � u► 3°, , _ :� , � I ,: �,�v.� #r7� . � .
:� ; D � �o � ;.� , ro �- � ',.. �. .. ,r; ;, i r. .
�� � '�C o �'. p� m . y,F; J . � Z 'n . :;. :co �
,�� ' N N• n � � IJ � •w•:.' ',r::' ONC::. •�. ' ,�
fi" � " N � �/ m . ' ���g, N .:�:. � ' . � . i : :
�r� ` • -r ,p� o�� � � ° � �. '�1 , . . , N� �
.�b;� �"O ! i� � m , ..'':� �'• , cr � �`•': .� . � ;.
,, •� �, N r n � Sta rs� � a � 22•0 'f. - �n� ;� . o � �
k �' � � � �` '�� �'�` � ►' ' • • � . 'N � �
�ks l� N � 3, IrC �2C ;�: ' rl., � . x � : .. ` � �.
x-� ` � j v � . r D�U ° .• CONC:VJALK�►' / `� . ^ � � ..�. .
i � y';!D � 0 7� � p � d 70 I '6.5� / i •, ;+ , � `i .
h' t. � .•_ .� .c � � , (p Q p � DA `.\ . i•'. ,� v. . � ' S t� + ., n '�=�'I � .
�+ ', � 'p�� I :'
6�� , �•; ' � � � �� I "'�ol`l J�1 � � r . � � �
'f ;! t rti t. �(qv � p ,� J r �
.+,.F1' . • 1, e' , i ; . . . Z� N _ . . , r t !;, ' •. � � �` � .
i-� � ! • Z� . . a.1�' � , 7 '� i i
� ;.�; � .. 31� -- •, v � , � k s , � �� � :� � , .
,� t }i r ;'� , 1: , i. --. . � �' .�t` � : ,, :, � ,.
'�� E 'I}u' . i ' . , � I .�t 1�,, , �r , . � .
��� '� , f , � ; . , rth . . :. '�;�• ; ' � .--- 468.3a
r�, " . . : - No west line of' �DI�CON'ADDITION N40°07bt
; i . 1 ; . . � � � i� i }'�l " . � '�#��I , ,
i1 ' . i � . ' . . � . . . � • . �FI,�,'i � .7�c-� � .� � i � . •i � ''�Rf}� '�
• �i :{ . , • ., � .. . . � • , , �1,� Y !z �rt;.i ' � ` � �ij.i
� ;' ♦ ; • j . R ',• � . , � ,
,� , � •� . , . i,� � rL i ; � * + ..
! '� ' �' '� .I �� 1� y� � � p='-pti7moY �'ci tl . =' °" ' � Sc �^'j . ��' . 1 � '� ` 1 ? . �1. ��', .��_ .. ' 4 `y�' ;� .
�� j��. [i� '1 �ii , ���x � � 1 G bY�Utl AY N C1 . Y i!. . ' '� ] 'i � .���� . �,'1i'� ��. � � .
� � : � � � .. Sla° .� ' �M' �ia°° ' X.: v ' � b I -. � a p':.' . : � + '� � t���'• ' • ' ( ' � �
� i, . t�-�� o t '' .. 'Qn �� �' � � , �c y . . Z x :>; ,. .� �r 1��`r�� ,. •`i!� � '
- ,y • . � ' X D . � Ll , S� � 1 . . }! f 1 '
j • 'r:.� ' � �' r . . , �/• m n -AC w ' . N/� � rn t1 F1', . . • • �I�.i;•Y1�� • ' .�� • �� , .
� ' . (� ��°.�_ �.� . ' � . . � 1 � .. o tf, i � �.o •4� � � � i �
� ' �:k s ! � ' � • � x � i �' , ; � ' ' ;' '. ' :1 ( � ,
� ��. .�. �� ���. � : � . c�1 N � � ��t--'•- t:; � . ,, : : , , '' '� I
r ' .i � ' . . • y� n 1� . . , , I
• � m ; Z J��C:�. X X x x N O ��.�.� i n � .Q ii. �
! x•` N .1 x x x � x X JC M � ' ��. 7�' ' ' . . . . +:��.
t7-�� x �I
�' .I �! +� t9. ► �' '�" '� i; ' " x x '� " _ �i ' ' ' ~': 4' ' 1'
' :� �i,''�: � ': �;,�. j: �� �;1� � � (!1 • x � o 's ..____.��--- .... _ .:.;; ... :� .
; � J ; .� . , � N • O n ,�,' . f. . � ;i .
: .} 'x� , � . N � � ' � , � �`,�, � ,'�� I%: � . ; � ;�
` t 1�1;. i' _ • t j � , ���!� � . i; i, .
I I ,:� � � , " � � 11 a d o t :� , � �
! 1 i�� .��� ol.� � : ' r n � � � , i ; .. . � ;� .
`� � p { f � , � . , . �� � , .
� , i�i =: � � N �1 --' N ,- . � � : , �
( ; �
�i �( `.� � �1��' (� � - � , ° �. • .� ` , . . . • ' .� . . , ; � .
�� ''t . . . , . . , �
� i t . , i.�. �. • � �� . . .
.` t ' � � • ,! ��� 1 � , � � � � ' , '�
1 � '"' a I �, ��
:' N p y •
-j +� t ll � [� y � VI I{ . . . .
� . �• f . ,} �� � ' � � ,n ,7� . ;� y y� q b U N '� d i' �. . . � . .. . . . . . .
,. .j� . \• + � ' . � � 17�' yl 1j � N y V N � . , . . �
. . ;! q a �-7 � _ " " ". :� „ ��::� . . . � �.. ; ,
• .' ' � � u , . :' ' � :i � � , ;U� �' . :
�,�. ; ' i � � :..__";,..:.`. . .. • �- ��.� , ��, ; � 'J �� � , I� �.. .
. .�n. f. �� .i' � Q ;,�e. : . . . • ii � � . � (�� � .
. :� . I ' ,,f; , ,. ;,: ".q ' M ty ('►� •12.} - � � . !,� � .
l � O �' �•A �S�"CZ'�Y ..t�p. .Y ^. . � , i� X �Ni} ;. w '� . . �, V . . . � .�... .i . ..
• : �a� ; a S '1�� � .��1� ' �'� .fi��":a:, . XM _... .__� � y - ' _ _ X - ; i , + .. �� � f; , , .
A � ,. ��
. �� o .� � � . - � �
, i J° � ° � � a . [y!' � o ° . � ,. (�+�
� .��' �..U�'°: A • z m '� p n� : C z o � • v O � /� • � " 1
1 1� '• '�.O � � K • n{ n z ' ' �
�� ' i't �i "D� - � .! ' � _, E.� W � ' m n [* ry ; ' '' �, ' �„ , ,T�
� � � € 1 �,` �� O � W � 6� J �• m N � � J -" n �' '':� , Q � , � , � � .
;� � ,�U �1� .����(r � ; � , . N ' � � r � ;��. . ; ""�;;. � `� i —1
� ,' l:' , :z : �x � x x' • xX x x � S' � � �i;' �;/�. ;J,' � : .O, .;�•.
`� 1 r�. , e, , •.;z � •x. x o .
.•1 0� �C� i) f, Sj q�1 � . ' , x x X x x x m " "" i `. . . . � "' �. . '� " � m
� ���i�� i N.� MI.•,r! ia !. � �� — x , x o � � CA '� - ;Z ;iIW
,�� i S,n�� i a � .�.,�� N— .�, u, N ,! �b � � �� � � � ' , '� � . � ;
,•�:�1' .�, � :,� ' tn J �� a° N N � €^: ' � .� �0
��'`� x �: '�i, i ;�i� r ' � : � � �� , � . , � , �
••,.9 •.,p r a ■ � � � r � :o !. ( '
.!i .� : �� ri ' N n q r � q � � d .... �' , � ' � N• '
�s o�51 U� - , , � . . M � i� . . � �
''� ,���� � ,� ��- ':� N o ,. _ ; � f : � � �(`� , .. � :� .
� f ' a .. ' i v �
t � � t : Q W _ , , , , ,� �.
! �i `��• i � » Q � p W N � � � ' � i o i ;, ,
'f •� I i• a 6` ! — �
, ,.� ` 'f� ' � � ' � �y N W w !: .p, ; . � ;' , 1 . �. ; , _,
��;W: S I ���N` i.4 b i��q p � � � � j � t � � '� ��
` { 'V' 2 !.,?I .'� ���t•i..r ; :M u :' a � :U u b i a : i
�.; 1 •'.�. � � • �,... �•�,, ( ��.� I� '�n �:� .n � . �, ,n ,� . I t �. ' . . . ' • Z .
't�,\j I�\' � Q � . O •1t�.T, �'`�J �� � �7\� � �7 tl T .n u .� . � ! O , (� ; � . � . . .
i \v •� A
�� p''I � � � t ���i • ' V ,� R� O O O r�� � . . ; i
�� �,� � . , �f � , , .I�i �;,, : , .�"� . .o -b ;, U�, b:;; �
. �•� i:�I � . � ' �'t' ' • � •� °""•• .. 4 F' i . 3� , • . :i .
�� Y � t,�• ,�,� , . ��� E� t �� •� -o • .. i
t ; � , `: I t ...r" ��'� h � U ' 1 S, . '- t ��i
: G �., � .! , , a.�� . ��a 1.� ' . . • - � , 4' .
� t, � '�� '.� !:fc . . � . . , • ��N � . - , . . , . . , � , . �• . . . ' � . � . , ..� . ..
��.