HomeMy WebLinkAboutResolution 2769 c��.`�� � .�'
��.:'�. ,..,. •
-..K .
^',���} y}r ��' ��� o� ORONO .
r:
A �I , . � '
°� *i�'��;�`�`• •
� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
�'A. ,.
� �f.� 2769
;., NO.
• - � i���
.�;,
1:4� '�:>t:'��.Z �
A RESOLDTION GRANTING
VARIANCES TO
MDNICIPAL ZONING CODE
SECTION 10.22, SUBDIVISIONS 1 & 2
FILE IaO. 1491
WHEREAS, Jack Rhode (hereinafter "the applicant") is owner of the
property located at 1690 Shadywood Road within the City of Orono
(hereinafter "City") and legally described as follows:
Lot 10 and that part of I,ot 11 described as follows: Beginning at the
Northwest corner of said Lot 11; thence SouthernZy along the Westerly
line thereof to the Southwest corner of the North 14' of said Lot 11;
thence South 87 degrees, 27 minutes East to the shore of Crystal Bay;
thence North along said shore to the North line of said Lot 11 ;
thence West along said lot line to the point of beginning, in
Shadywood, Hennepin County, Minnesota (hereinafter "the pro�erty") ;
• and
WAEREAS, the applicant has applied to the City for variances to
Municipal Zoning Code Section 10.22 , Subdivisions 1 & .2 to permit the
construction of a new principal structure using the existing foundation,
the proposed new construction would require approval of a lakeshore setback
at 61' instead of the required 75' and a hardcover variance within the 0-
75' setback area of 812 s.f. or 13.3� where none is allowed.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED �by the City Council of Orono,
Minnesota:
FINDINGS
1 . This renewal application was reviewer] as Zoning File #1491 .
2. The property is located in the LR-1C Single Family Lak°eshore
Residential Zoning District requiring a 1/2 acre or 21,780 s.f. The
property consists of 17,700 s.f. or .41 acres.
3. The Orono Planning Commission reviewed this renewal application on
February 20, 1990, and recommended approval of the requested variances
based upon the following findings:
A) N,ajor upgrading of the property will result in the following
changes to existing substandard conditions :
• Page 1 of 5
i ti • ��
.F•+.��..�,°' �-�F
. Ytn
.:��� c�t� o� oR,oNo .
• �����=�=_.-. ,
�`,�-�•" RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
y� 2769
• '#, NO.
��- � `,.�
:�...t,
.,�:�:�.
1) Lakeshore setback:
Required = 75 '
Existing Principal Structure = 55 '
Existing Accessory Structure = 10 '
Proposed Pri�cipal Structure = 61 '
Proposed Accessory Structure = 59 ' (second level deck
extends 2 ' beyond lakefront of principal
residence)
Variance:
Existing Principal Structure = 20 ' or 26$
Proposed Principal Structure = 14 ' or 18. 6�
Existing Accessory Structure = 65' or 86$
Proposed Accessory Structure = 16' or 21� (second story
upper level deck)
2 ) Hardcover within the 0-75 ' Setback Area:
Allowed = 0 s.f.
Existing = 926 s.f. or 15.8$
• Proposed = 812 s.f. or 13.5�
Total Reduction = 2.5�
B) The application involves no need for a hardcover variance
within the 75-250' setback area as applicant proposes removal of �
major portions of existing hardcover within the 75-250' setback
area.
C) The use of the existing foundation will provicle less of an
impact on the lakeshore property.
D) The original structure was placed on the property prior to
current standards for lakesliore development.
4. The City Council has considered this application including the
findings and recommendations of the Planning Commission, reports by
City staff, comments by the applicant and the effect of the proposed
variances on the health, safety and welfare of the community.
5. The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this
property are peculiar to it and do not ap�ly generally to other
progerty in this zoning district; that granting the variances would
not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor pose a fire
hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely serve
as a convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate a
demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is necessary to preserve a
• substantial property right of the applicant; and would be in keeping
with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan
of the City.
Page 2 of 5
1(' 1 ��
-`.' �-���� .
���� :�W= Cit o� ORONO .
. �5�,� ��.;S,r.b�4ir> _ � ,
• ,,, �'�..��•. � .
�' `��� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
� �
`�"� -�? NO. 2769
,.rti
. �.-..:, � ,
,,�"::: '�a��
=�
CONCLDSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS
Based ugon one or more of the findings noted above, the Orono
City Council hereby grants variances to Municipal Zoning Code Section
10e22, Subdivisions 1 and 2 to permit the construction of a new residence
structure using the existing foundation subject to the following
� conditions :
1. All hardcover scheduled for removal must be completed pri�r t� the
final inspection by the Building staff for the new construction.
Please refer to Exhibit A of this resolution for hardcover areas
designated for removal .
2. Applicant to provic3e a Highway Department permit for the relocated
curb cut to the site.
• 3. Agplicant or aFplicant's architect shall provide the Building
staff with the engineering data or findings that confirm the existing
foundation can sustain the pro�osed 2-story structure at the time af
application for a building permit. Applicant is hereby advised that,
if for any reason unknown at this time, the existing foundation cannot
be used, variance apFlication #1491 shall be scheduled for further
consideration before both the Planning Commission and the Council.
4. Authorities granted by this resolution run with the property not
with the ag�licant, but are germissive only and must be exercised by
application for a building Fermit within one year of the date of
Council a�proval, or this resolution will expire on that date (March
�2 , 1991) .
5. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and
conditions of this variance shall constitute a violation of the zoning
code, shall automatically terminate any authority granted herein, and
shall be punishable as a misdemeanor.
6. The undersigned app licant has read, understood and hereby agrees
to the terms of this resolution and on behalf of himself, his heirs,
successors and assigns, hereby agrees to the recording of this
resolution in the chain of title of the property.
•
Page 3 of 5
�!� ' • U
i��,.': . � .
��� � ��`� Ci.t o� ORONO .
, t �'
• ' �� � �
;,�,,. ,.�
� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
�;;. • NO. 2769
. � ,.. ..
!�'r;-• k_, .
Adopted by the Orono City Council on this 12th day of March,
1990 .
AT EST: •
.
�
D othy M allin, City Clerk Jame R. Grabe'k, Mayor
P perty Owner(s) •
' STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
� The fo e oing instrument was acknowledged before me on this
day of ��Q�Y�,� , 19_�D � by James R. Grabek &
•Do-� M. Hallin, �Mayor & City Clerk of the City of Orono, a Minnesota
Y
• municipal corporation and said instrument was executed on behalf of the
City.
� �
Notary Public
NAAB � ��qa
• �ypTARE P�BU�"��INNES07A My Commi s s i on Ex�i re s
HENNEPIN C�g 9�Y9z .
��pmmisslon exp �
•
Page 4 of 5
� . . .
�: : .__......_. . .._ .. _.. . _ . .
. . .. .
.
♦� �... ;�
1 '
0;'S .f
tt �� �:: Ci.t o� ORONO
��p ��: y:�� � .
� 7 ii'Y.J�'e���i',t
• � So r r�,.�.w �
F�
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
. _ �} '
-_r�� � ;.:� NO. 2769
.,�_ • • ;
� �,,�1�.
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this ��� day •of �2���� . 199l�
before me a Notar Public w hin and for said county, personal3.y
appeared �Q(�� � ��o C/�
known to me to be the person(s) described in and who executed the
foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed
the same as his (their) free act and deed.
9'HERE3A L. NAAB l��-d-G� �� `"�`Gv`�
• �pTARY PUBLFO`1�l�NNESOTA
�HEN����Ny.�a-s2 NOTARY PUBLIC
• . : 9-�-9z
MY COMMISSION EXPIRES
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
)ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On thi s • day of , 19 9_, bef ore me a
Notary Public within and for said County, personal.Yy appeared
� known to
me to be the person.( s ) described in and who executed the
foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed
the same as his (their) free act and deed.
NOTARY PUBLIC
MY COMMISSION EXPIRES
Page 5 of. 5
•
� �.d.1.I..l.�i'.4.:".�rn;i6 4i{� t�Q61[�1 ' � �•.
�� .� .. • .; -.-.. ... . ... . M d, ; � .,. •::;...o.
,, � , !. s 55 '1. i7':•.ICi'L' . . '��I� 11��'
�%i�..L- . ' � l, '. . ' ' .. ,;j�����1. �}'��1@��•;'
j., ���.:,�� i�:.
'r; � r• . � . - ..�i•���+I,� ���'(,�':
�s ' :' !� � , i: ,.�:.� ''7 •': •J1,7.
�it .� � J ` .i'�` �� ��'�'';3�
� . ._ �q � � . ;: � ,.
� ;;.' ��'v ;;'� ► � � �����:
,� .::,_..,ra . . ,.�� �1 s �� �` � � ,4���.
, + �� ' .'� '''. � }�:;.
. ��� . " y7j' yt�;} i :��.1 't'
� � U V � �.. • .�,��; .:�: ,
. , ..,G, � � . , ` ':i,�, ,��;,
• ;��. , v �� � : RESOLUTION #2769 ' �;�;�{�?•'� �,; �
, �''--;i �:r, .',� '��� •lI ,w � ; �! �'f: i�`�?� �.;�:',
j llr� � ;�r:. .�. I .��.. .�-� �f.. .� . 11i��.'.����''�'� �`.
''�� � � � ., � ��y�:!':. �� `� � �� � . �I':l::s..��.:.'.�
) f �t:�''�'• �;:'y... , .F�f'.,. '
��t• � / .`,,;,: �, �....�. • �:,:. . , , ,. . ;. :� .< •t�. , •
� • .1, I�.Ir 1' . ��T ' ��� I'^� � , . '� • 'I� .�I,� ji..i�:�� t.
.1 I., P
,, �{ '�!, ,,�i . .. ; '���'�� . . ' � � �i'� i; �ii" ��:.
� . ,� . � ; , �;�:.�,�� �, ;. . ; ;,,.; � �
� �,.� ,{. � ���� ;�; , ����:� ,
� �, �. , � � :.� . �i'. � ' �,;1�•, �r�;:
: ► , �r• � . ? '�,, ,�.:..i��; '.
l ; ', . , , ��� ..� . � �• :�.,.., �;�_ ;�
'� �� .;� �i�. �' �' �� � , , , , � � ����� .
. . .:..� � . . �� .�+. ,. � . ; �. �,,,.:��:�
' � � . , � � � / r , �...� , ,�,,, ,:
' ..: ' ��._.:. ---_..__.. �..,. .=.7: � • . �' . . : � � i . �' ;
`;I� ,�,�� / 1� . �,�:, ,:�,i I,
..�{ ..� �� (_t? 1 %• ' , : i �ii r ;..
I a . .� �' . : : �. .I
, .� � w , �1�,I� a
r. !' i ,t:
� � ' � / . . . k . : `• 'f:.rlY:,;.
� ' .. . .� 1 � .�..j•:i�•�'i�'' I•
i � �' � '''
� � ;9 �J . �� : ;� � '��'�. �f
A � i � d: �.' •r i"� .�
z � • � x �{ • . • • n�• '�' I:�' ��! •
I �y G 1/ 'r'1 . . . g '1 . . �•.', • � ,;.
f` '� 1 ,� . I, � '' i i
� / •� . � . I• . il•i I
. � ` ,
;� �, �� . !� r�,� . � ; �'i;. i
• � � � �i ��_�Y� . ; � . . .i `�. :i
i .� �j ' • . : h . �''' i_
� ���, �' �_ M ,y ° �� . : �' �. �f�,: `.,: ,
� , • • �;. j !�.
t;• . r.l.� ��:
. <�F. V l' � � . . , . � . '� .. ..�.
j f'0:t 1 ,�.,/ � � t,� �v,� 'f. . • , .. � ' , ' �� .j •�� �
� r'�� ' ,� � ly � �. .. ., . ;. �j; �i
. � x�,�r `p . � , , �,� � � ., '� �� ' �.� ''
� ' �D,�-� � .� rr,� � t ►-' • ;: I'r. �. "! :i i�,
. �J.� .. r : o . ;r� s �:; ,� �.�. ,ti:,,i�.
• '� • . 4'�w—1� � , .; • - � : .��•:'` �.f , �E�;
'". ' , ���n" / i �l ' ` . ' �,',, "�� ';'•��i�`�i:��si',��!t
� ^ . . . J. ri• �; � , , , ,j.,,l,!• � � '� ;
r �� ',�ri � ',`'7� ', . " , � i:',' :'' : �: ;:if'��I,�'�{�t i'!
s� � z � �I � , . � �;��: �i, 't •.i:� r'; :��� ,t .1:
� � ' ; q r" � '' ' 1 I , .' � • , ��': '+� � ' fd�;, ; ��•s .�
, .o � ��� " . � � . .'�� l��; �k:l:� ' '�iF-''� �� •��
� ' � , i; , �' r���i l�i s.
; . : 1�,� : �� ;:':5:�� ' . � : . . . ;,;.: ��', i`.�f�. � . •,.i:;;��� a;;; �
� � s.
. . . � � .i� G � • . � � ' �� �: � ,�I�1��i1 q�i�:i '!'
. , : � �.f � `� , : ,� ; � �; ��. ;.' ':. :it;,�l��?��lE'�'! ;;'
: , � , . ' } � � ` ' � ' ,� , ! � S #'�k � I
�' i �'� •.r,,.,�..." . J � � • .. 1 �.i [� �:' ��, � �� i,r .i /l
' ' ' : • � �' ' `'� a: •, . p- j� . f� .I ,.�,..a', , ,,: ; ��,� i'+i..
� r . .�..'t� ' � ', .��j�' � i `-� �r�� .7, . . � t ; � �. �I :t' ': !•� �. ��kr; �s(�1�4 �;y r;
��� �• � ,,{,�.1�•�'i,,t �I`��.• •.>r ��� NI �' 1 i ` � • 'i .� I.�•�I�nl 1 i��{• ��1, i� fr��if�.
I 1 .�'J 4�`.,i..��7C1.re �� V�/.��!,,� � F�F�1° ,� ��, lJl ��' ':i. , ••�'•� � :;, �F�.,'�,1 ' �il� i��i; .��i i.; Py' i �I.i �
• 9 • • • -.�;,�,;i,,, .�'1;. �.G; ;r;� �. � i i., ti�� � , .Z�K' ''�.{� '� �F;"'�i�;F i'�� i 1' 11 'ul� ��,:i r`!� j,,
• � 1� � Y :��'�: /'� �'I�.� 1, ,• i.. '.V �1 .��'y �. .�. 1:� I.t 1 ..r!
, �( •�.'�;��: ��:it�+,��°M�'�r. ��i,9{ �;,ZFi�'��Y, � ��� C � �'��R {t��f �.�• ' 1' `�'•:1•iI •1����i!7•N�
,�j-l5 ' �:�ir�r�lY .1...) i :r�, "[) ' •i�� • � �j � ir��`i;i,11 7,;� .�'I�� � �'�.i �
' , , � �� �J F�. )� _�� �+�/IN ,'•:,� •1 I '� . � j� i� `n � ���� i i� �01�� t!i �
� �/.+ �r��.�. 1� � � 4� rI, Jt ���' '; ���
- . ', ' • �i��:���i i ���,� ;f�;� i .�•1'�: � ; . �� � � . f ' I'".S i'� � �. ;i, � �:�. �.�.1t+.��, ',
� . � •t � �� a i :.�' � � :V� � �,, I 1 , .� l•��,�: I r •�' '� 1'' 1 �I'i,'^ ,t
I Y �;f� J d k�.
M � , �;1 �,�;f�,� ��� � �_�� � ;I:: .i;�.
, . . .,. � �: :, ,.:
� ---------._ __�_._...._�.._ r �,,, t +' ti .. 3� 'j ,. ?�r..�,�~ �° :'I: � . ')',;'3�:�:y, '����,�.
; � . _r.� r � T -.. ... ._.. . • � .� / �' �+'� '�' ''�� j• • .e.� �1�
,. �• ' � �.
' '` i i� '.��'t' , ,�,i�;�: :`�.1;�:k�.
----•_._, ' ;� ,�.�; i � � � .: , • ' �� t���� i f'r S; �;' I
, � - .b� � . � ,,� . . . . y ,��• �.��i i ��,;. ? ',t�.�.�� .t�� ��
R ; i� :�.: � ,;��:�,;:.
. . �' �r!� " ;1: �_..'� � , , • : � •�s�',;,h'tii �(;i.i�'a. ;. `•�; '} '•
I P .Y.`1. i . '� �i''j n �L"j•;;'
! , nqr'� � , d� ' ; - .... ...,. I.. .� �•� �J;,l.({j:li: � ,+,�'�_ ';;r• �' ��i' `{�� ,f'`;
'` � � � . - . � f , ��t� ;�.'(�3 ��'.
w ;;� ,• .
',. • ' ��J � I, ,_ �" M1. • !. . �.1` ! t•( :? �(i-,i;'I)�'���...
'i i •x. ,_ �'�'.. n :� S i, i ;. i n,::c.f f�
i � �Z . � iy : � : .. • _..1�,� �i�.�i)� �: ,.i !��. ;;;9;;.�.5
� o C' -7� � 3 . . s, , � S'.,:'t ''t;�, :, ��;��;t 'A :i�.�: .
� �� i' ��,�� �� �
, • i p , ..,,., �s...l "' . _. . ' , ' r: :�,� �:�' ,�,;�`�,�; .�
i �•,, , y� rn � :�i: • ;� ? , ;�,.,�� . ��; . :; ' ;,. 'j•� �; ';
' •', !;� , �{S7�i; i ,.' ,�'• .'I•' �� ,k,.,��'`.
f ,- � { , . , , . �� ,: .I: ,;� I;� �.:,:.��;;:�.:::��,•
.i � ��" � . P �, . �. . ; � �I, ;• . << .,�; ,�f:� �''�'���!,t.
1 - ��rj. �t`� Z ,'.' ;��•;'•i;;,;`•; �, i!':''i!i t�.i.'�:.
� � � �� � ,�.,; �it.;l.
� .. . .._ .�.�, x_ _..__—•F.—r'�,__.�.5 ^ �,' ' ' � �°;-,�C .. ; � ���: -: . � :+
i • �. ; -.�.._.._.__. � ., �r . . ' _�:= 3'•,-�,.
,:, ...__ ,.. ,.,�. .�.
;�: .� � � r, ---� • . i ! :::'t•� . ! i!: �: �
ii � •`'` � .�`.�} ��'�x�;:1.; 3'� .�.
N r 1 . .! c .� �; ' •
� � ' . . .. .i':}�. �.I. _ . . �i�'• r: �) ':' • '•
� �.'-`._ � ' p • , i� � •.��.I•� '�� I''��i,�`•:k i' i.r
� � "�--�__• • ' l� ' ' : �• ''�i. •� `i�'�.f1�!•+,!j, 'i.�'(I{.
� $H i� ��� i',� ; • � ' '�'; 1j;;•��`�F. ; :
�R� �.111kr �2_ --��-.v�'�"� �.�-_•�-- . . ' . : '.�•� �.I� �� � :' ,. �::
.'�. �1 �(' ✓`.�—�_ � • • , i : • ., ;, �:e i,.�l:��:;
I, A �. y . t '!.i t ��,
k.� � �� r,
�' �� 'v\ (�� � , ;•�'�•` I,�, t;�,�
r '.
� �= ro N � . .� � „'..�;:�-::i .
�- .�� � :.;
i; • , , �; : �: �� :i,.
. . . . . ., . ��` ; 4';j. '
• , . ' • F` . � • � .�i�"��'c.
' , , . � ., . . ,' I :����i'.
.. . ' . . . . .