Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutre erosion control-2014 MINNEHAHA CREEK WATERSHED DISTRICT QUALITY OF WATER QUALITY OF LIFE INSPECTION REPORT DATE: September 12`h,2014 Ihe idirrriehaha Creek TO: Matt Fritz Watershed Distnct is FROM: Lora Pohtilla committed to a RE: MCWD Permit#13-384:4055 Elm St, Orono leodership rofe in Dear Applicant, protecting, improving and managing the The Minnehaha Creek Watershed District(MCWD) has inspected your site for compliance with the MCWD permit requirements. Based on our inspection at the above mentioned location,the su,face waters and following was observed and recorded on September 11th, 2014: offiliated groundwate� • Insufficient final stabilization has been installed along the road side near the end of the driveway resources wrthin the Distrid, incfuding their MCWD requests that the following corrective actions are taken: relationships to the ecosystems of which they • Maintain perimeter control around site until final stabilization meets MCWD standards. are an integral pa�. We achieve ourmissior� To avoid formal enforcement action from the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District, please implement the above mentioned corrective actions. through regulation, capital projects, Thank you for your attention to MCWD permit requirements. If you have any questions, please educarion, cooperative contact me at (952) 641-4580 or by email at Lpohtilla@minnehahacreek.org endeavors, and ather programs based on sound science, innovative thinking, an ReSpeCtfully, infurmed and engaged constituency, and the cost effective use of public fun�s. Lora Pohtilla District Representative Melanie Curtis � �� � � ���� From: Melanie Curtis Sent: Thursday, September 04, 2014 10:30 AM To: 'Matt' Cc: Scott Oberaigner; permitting@minnehahacreek.org; Kristine Fritz; Robert Bean; Joe.Schreder; Kelly Hemp Subject: Erosion Control Violation - Letter 09/04/14 Attachments: letter.pdf; Riprap Detail.pdf; emailsphotosBW.PDF Matt Please see the attached letter and exhibits. The originals with color photos will go out in today's mail. Thank you — Melanie Melanie Curtis Direct 952.249.4627 Planning &Zoning Office 952.249.4620 Email: mcurtisCa�ci.orono.mn.us Website: www.ci.orono.mn.us Summer Office Hours: May 19 through August 29, 2014 Monday through Thursday: 7:30 am to 5 pm & Fridays: 7:30 am to 11:30 am t 1 1 �0��\ � �� C ITY OF ORONO � �, � � Street Address: Mailing Address: Telephone(952)249-4600 S' � 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 Fax (952)249-4616 F �,� �,�' Orono, MN 55356 Crystai Bay, MN 55323 www.ci.orono.mn.us KESHOEL 4 September 2014 Matthew & Kristine Fritz 4055 Elm Street Mound, MN 55356 RE: Erosion and Sediment Violation at 4055 Elm Street You have been notified via emails on July 22, August 6 & 7 and again on August 26 (enclosed) regarding corrective measures to address the erosion control issues resulting from your construction project at 4055 Elm Street. The August 26th email indicated that the City would resolve the issues using funds from the erosion control escrow associated with building permit #2013-00906 for your new home. The City performed a final inspection today; photos taken during this inspection are attached. It is our opinion that sediment deposited in the riprap at the beginning of the downstream channel is largely due to erosion from the property at 4055 Elm Street, and the restoration work should be the responsibility of the property owner. Therefore, please follow the direction below to resolve the erosion control violations within the next 72 hours, The City's Public Works staff will inspect the property on Monday, September 8tn for compliance. If not satisfactorily completed the Public Works crew will complete the work and draw down funds to do so from your escrow. 1. Completely remove sediment from riprap at the beginning of the downstream channel and restore riprap. The existing riprap and sediment should be removed down to the geofabric. The sediment should then be separated from the riprap, and the riprap salvaged. The salvaged riprap should then be reinstalled per the attached detail. Additional riprap may be necessary to complete restoration per detail. If sediment is to be separated from riprap on-site, measures must be taken to ensure sediment is not re-introduced to downstream channel. Sediment should be disposed off-site. 2. Repair erosion at driveway entrance and re-stabilize slopes to prevent additional migration of sediment. Additional biologs should be installed along the driveway edge as necessary to completely cover the flow path of runoff. Upslopes should be re-seeded and covered with erosion control blanket or mulch. City Public Works staff is available to meet you on site to observe and offer guidance if you have questions or require clarification on the direction given above. As you are aware the erosion control escrow has continued to be held until vegetation is established and there are no areas of bare soil or erosion risk from the property. Thank you for your cooperation. Please feel free to contact me or Scott Oberaigner (Orono Public Works) at 952.249.4680 with any questions; my direct dial is 952.249.4627. Sincerely, elanie Curtis Planner Encl Copies via email: Matt & Kristine Fritz (property owners), Brandon Wisner (MCWD), Kelly Hemp (Cornerstone) &Joe Schrader (Solid Ground) TABLE OF QUANTITIES RIPRAP AT RCP OUTLETS CLASS II CLASS III CLASS IV d50 - 6�� d50 = 9" d50 = 12" DIA. GRANULAR GRANULAR GRANULAR OF GEO- FILTER 12" GEO- FILTER 18" GEO- FILTER 24" ROUND L TEXTILE UNDER DEPTH TEXTILE UNDER DEPTH TEXTILE UNDER DEPTH PIPE FILTER APRON RIPRAP FILTER APRON RIPRAP FILTER APRON RIPRAP (IN. ) (FT. ) (SQ.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) (S�.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) (SQ.YD. ) (CU.YD. 1 (CU.YD. ) 12 8 16.9 0.2 3.0 19.6 0.3 4.4 22.6 0.3 5.9 15 8 18.0 0.2 3.2 20.8 0.3 4.6 23.9 0.4 6.4 18 10 22.4 0.3 4.3 25.6 0.4 6.4 29.0 0.5 8.5 21 10 24.1 0.4 4.7 27.4 0.6 7.1 30.9 0.7 9.4 24 12 29.7 0.5 6.2 33.4 0.8 9.2 37.3 1.0 12.3 27 12 31.4 0.6 6.6 35.2 0.9 9.9 39.2 1.2 13.2 30 14 37.4 0.8 8.2 41.6 1.1 12.3 46.0 1.5 16.4 36 16 45.9 1.1 10.6 50.5 1.6 15.8 55.4 2.1 21.1 42 18 52.8 1.2 12.5 57.8 1.7 18.7 63.0 2.3 24.9 48 20 61.1 1.5 14.8 66.5 2.2 22.2 72.0 2.9 29.6 TABLE OF QUANTITIES RIPRAP AT RCP-A OUTLETS CLASS II CLASS III CLASS IV d50 - 6�� d50 - 9�� d50 = 12" SPAN GRANUL GRANUL GRANUL OF GEO- FILTER 12" GEO- FILTER 18" GEO- FILTER 24" PIPE L TEXTILE UNDER DEPTH TEXTILE UNDER DEPTH TEXTILE UNDER DEPTH ARCH FILTER APRON RIPRAP FILTER APRON RIPRAP FILTER APRON RIPRAP (IN. ) (FT. ) (SQ.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) ICU.YD. ) (SQ.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) (SQ.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) (CU.YD. ) 22 10 22.4 0.3 4.1 25.6 0.4 6.1 29.0 0.5 8.1 28 12 29.5 0.5 5.7 33.2 0.7 8.5 37.1 0.9 11.3 36 14 37.3 0.8 7.5 41.5 1.1 11.2 45.8 1.5 14.9 43 16 45.9 1.1 9.5 50.5 1.6 14.3 55.3 2.1 19.0 51 18 52.5 1.2 11.3 57.5 1.7 16.9 62.7 2.3 22.5 58 20 59.9 1.3 13.2 65.2 1.9 19.8 70.7 2.5 26.4 B 4 1� 2' 1.0' � RIPRAP A � N Q � / � o Q . .. �, w � � - GEOTEXTILE FILTER 2 4 GRANULAR CUSHION SECTION B-B 2� 1�_ NOTES: q REOUIREMENTS FOR GEOTEXTILE TYPE,RIPRAP SIZE AND B THICKNESS WILL BE DESIGNATED IN THE PLANS. PIPE SIZES LARGER THAN THOSE SHOWN RE�UIRE A SPECIAL L DESIGN. O FOR PIPES GREATER THAN OR EOUAL TO 30". USE 1.5'. PLAN O GEOTEXTILE FILTER,SPEC.3733,SHALL COVER THE BOTTOM AND SIDES OF THE AREA EXCAVATED FOR THE RIPRAP, GRANULAR FILTER MATERIALS. Z RIPRAP O DIMENSION E IS GIVEN ON STANDARD PLATES 3100 AND 3110. O GRANULAR FILTER,SPEC.3601,MAY BE USED AS A 1.0' O CUSHION LAYER. PLACE FILTER PER SPEC.2511. THE CUSHION LAYER IS INCIDENTAL. I td� pp,��,�� OS GRANULAR FILTER OR RIPRAP,SPEC.3601.TO EXTEND I_ I �a d�a�a'a UNDER ENTIRE OPEN PORTION OF PIPE APRON. DEPTH OF r z�_� ' MATERIAL UNDER APRON SHALL MATCH RIPRAP DEPTH. GRANULAR FILTER � WHEN L15ING RIPRAP INCREASE RIPRAP �UANTITY GEOTEXTILE FILTER 2 q ACCORDINGLY AND PLACE A 3" LAYER OF 1.5" GRANULAR CUSHION CRUSHED ROCK UNDER THE APRON TO AID IN GRADING SECTION A-A FOR APRON PLACEMENT.CRUSHED ROCK IS INCIOENTAL. APPROVED DECEMBER 9, 2013 STATE OF MINNESOTA SPECIFICATION STANDARD - DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION REFERENCE PLATE 3100 N0. 3110 RIPRAP AT RCP OUTLETS 3603 3133D STATE DESIGN ENGINEER 2511 . .�.y j .•f > �b�•�� :t. � s„� ���¢ . .� . � p�[!� .� � �� ��rd- � ., .�. �., . , f—'T I 1 �J L � . . ���s " , � . ,.. �- . (� �r, ~ ' R/ � � t1a�T;t u t��r'"�-� � ::;rf'� , + � �t ' ��'--���,f^� 4 t: 1�fi� �i ':a +�.�` Rt* �� � ... X � w�� _ C�'MX�• � t���`.,7�. ,� ��-.� -�l1FSs1 ; � Y'. �'� . �� . � �� s a. �T4' '� ` � � , .,,,4 yJ�� ,. � r 4�.�t. � �.r , x-rt'. � i. � ' ���s i q-�t ,�',�,. � x � �{ � �..�. ` .���%��.��� F r�! .����Ft�,' ._ . .:y„ � �,. . a .ti�.. �'� .�a t'RJ' .,.. ,�,n, �-� fe_.r,�'c�-'�, .';" "�.��..��^ -.-fi s'-. . s . ,,yi• m.�X n f A+�, M -�r..., � �eo''',�,�,�, — . �!°'.Yc .. .�,'"``` .__-<R�->" , t � _�`a�� xy� ��:a��� '"}.'��r � _ �� �. �C�� >a� an - .. � ' . =�•�E�"`h.t�.�; � ��'�. :.F ~�y'� wr �'" '�i►.:��� ,.. ..•: �3�`�Ynw..: c�'5..,7'r L�, . . ... . > � a:.: y�.. ..,(� �i �v 1 R -`��R � ' �°�°1t"' ..�"�at�;�.3 J t,: p} ' :! �,F ,��L�.��_;ir S��!'i��i�a91� .,��'�,�^+ _ '�.. �' .:'.-. �`x �� � �t ��^w „ �.,- ,f` � ;^-T �:Sc:t� i-, ��fE-,�: a�� t,�� '� � . � � S�` 5 �:� �� � �..i.� �� „sv�. "-'t 4.1.x -y�;,��' V� �� ,��� � ' p3 . '' �yl..,.. �;�Y�-- '�, y"� .. 4 �`+� �r. `=i'• "�`r�!' b- _ .. _ ..- ..y�y . y� �� �J � � � >-.., , _ . y - ,• ' . . � � �.>- —� ` � . �... . .t,-:,`�.e«� .. � �,�.: " .. . . � , �- . . , ti . . . � f * � y� _ :�� � ��y�tR f� .��.�y� � t :y � 1�Ci�p�S�Cy"' � .x.'".C: �s.= � - �§�; .;t"L?'. �,�r ; r �� �� ...ur . . i _ .s +9�+r"e,s ' •. • *�•��� p. -- • . .. � �`.�`,� `� ����� '�`��"��4���c:.�.� �.a'. � � � ya-�w�3`3�ea�r+s,�tr '�;. f� t ��� .'9'v.� :�':. �'� er . § �F � �, j�'� ,,� r� � -���=� x}. � ��. y F .:fi _.�. < c-�.�* ,r *-., M��Y , . , a _ � ��, :�„ . � ` ���. " .. . �,; - .; n' +� j �. ' - � � � �� � x Y-�� ^ � s� , , r , _ � �. ,�. � .Ix� w . : ���.• }t� .. _ _ � .� .� � � 9��;�5 ry� St.�l . . . MI L;"'l�"' � �.z rw_" • '�" tira� �� � i��1'/• .z.:�.-�:� .e � �� . � � / � �. :. i.`� A ��� ., . �... ' . .i+ . I - ;��� � ..1.. " ."1► �� ti�*• .} ��+�r �_ �.+--r a v t�' + 'Y t r.* . , �����.- �t ,� -: - .�c ^r ., t � � f�i�+. . fil.��... �,.�y d� ' � � ♦ xt �, }�`y. �^ � � �ti _ .p' ��� � t , .._ � » . ..._ . . . _ ...i�v l' � ' y ��',����:,�'�+� �1,.�. . .. t j ;;3,Y' �"'s �'.� ;�� �., a. .t�.�i, +r� a�t���*:� I X`.�.� � � zai-"-.:.�� , �� . � ��� ,� � � ��� ��W � � • S t _ ?4x #f�r' r9 � iF i � 1 . '''.: !'�d � �, ��� �� ; �.,..,„.;. 1 si t."- � ^r����s ' , , � �'�,,� ��` �� �-. � p�;.�` °� 't � t `����t�� s �jt� � �Yf.�'" ;11 .y l �v "OM.:.k�J; � ,�,T ^.�';. �� �,�:��_ } •�.`�� },t�...J.9i�k• IQ � . J~y � •� 75�� �?��'�: a � � �. ��. v �.tr � � A ,� , r �� �.�.. h 1 \. f� � `_ y � . • ' `�� a�4-��" �' -} � � �� u��� �� � �oi� q�2 � ���--� �- �� � � � � ���, �:�. ��� .��-,. �� : ��� � �'� . ���� �� ��� b`� _ �� � , �,. - :4�•y, ' � 7 �� . +. � , � �d� 1 --�s. f '� � ��' �r' ,�� Y i � �Xn � . '.Yr'x:, '1_.t: . . �.•. �:. �..`: .r— .,. �� Y ''v� .. � ��. .Y . � r. � `.� .. � $. �`,� . . .�; t■ � � � :• 1'��4� . �,c =. ' -- ' . {. l�cY p� � • �s 3;�,,,�„�<ak���� C� �< . . �i •�,�p,hc..�r... . �`:�=tis �' d,��:i � . . �" *"�'' � :` . . 1 i I I��� �:��. , �� �r��ll �� � ��' � .�'!,� �•a ; yv�. ��'.��� � .: a ~ ! ..yy l � �.'� '�� � � �Y' �`�i. �� ' � ���� 1��� ..��Y.. �Y � ' � ��`,���t� >�Z '. � 5 +��` . "F�R�`��,�,': .'I. �Iy �� Y. �l�?r'��;� y� - ���s.�.�k F. sF�i:, ,a�y' _ �Y ib!'•�y�a 1"�+�� T',e,y�� r+ .,i,. ° ..`�.+��� 'w � ..�.i.':3:7�s�....a.e:' a1%.a.. .�'+-. ,. Melanie Curtis From: Melanie Curtis Sent: Tuesday, August 26, 2014 2:06 PM To: 'Matt' Cc: Scott Oberaigner; permitting@minnehahacreek.org; Kristine Fritz; Robert Bean; Kelly Hemp; Joe.Schreder Subject: RE: 4055 Elm St-erosion control fence Today I spoke Vaith Scot� Ooera;gne� in o�.:r public �rorks dppartment. His eva'�uation �r" r�,-, ;�t� �;�;�_at�� :��} tn? level o` ��iork cor��!eted is insufficiert. Please complete the work as directed i�y or before Manday, September 1� or the City will complete the work and the charges to do so wil! be assessed to you/your property. As a r?mi�der the � recticn ��ias as fol�o��vs: The sedim�ent in the downstream channel (on the west side of the �rop�rty} nn�st be removed and th� ch�annel restored. MelanieCurtis � 952.249.4627 � � _�-��s�� �� ,��_���.��_ From: Matt [mailto:mattfritz2l@hotmail.com] Sent: Friday, August 15, 2014 9:31 AM To: Robert Bean; Kelly Hemp; Melanie Curtis; Joe.Schreder Cc: Scott Oberaigner; permitting@minnehahacreek.org; Kristine Fritz Subject: Re: 4055 Elm St - erosion control fence The log roles and silt fence have been removed from the ditch area. Some of the sediment has been removed from the channel area and some rip rap has been restored (as much as I can do mysel�. Please advise on when the city can complete ditch work. Thanks, Matt Fritz Exec Consulting Inc 612.802.6053 Sent from my iPhone On Aug 10, 2014, at 8:21 PM, "Matt" <ma�?t�ri?z�i :i ho!mai!.c��m> wrote: Hi Melanie, My understanding, the last time we spoke sometime around our closing date, was that the city was going to complete the ditch work. This discussion occurred at the beginning of July (we closed on luly 3). In the subsequent weeks had multiple instances of torrential rain that likely caused the sediment issue in the channel area (city property; not minel discussed here. 1 In my opinion, if the city had completed the ditch work in a timely fashion (beginning of July— after closing) there would be no sediment issue at all. Honestly, I've been waiting for the city to complete the ditch work and assumed we were on the schedule for the beginning of July based on our discussion, but obviously that hasn't happened. I can remove the logs and silt fence myself, but I believe that the city should do the rest of the ditch work, including cleanup of the channel area, as originally discussed and at no charge to me. Please let me kn;,�v vs,�he^ th;s v�orlc car be c�mp!eted this �veek. Thanks, Matt Matt Fritz Exec Consulting Inc. 612.802.6053 From: bub�iz�i�.bult�r�-niznk.��i�� To: khem�'cicornzrstoneccinc.com; �ICurtis�a�ci.orono.mn.us; Joe a�solidaroundhomes.corn; rlattfritz?1��hotmail.com CC: SOberai�,ner�a ci.orono.mn.us; permittin�J �i minnehahacreek.or�� Subject: RE: 4055 Elm St - erosion control fence Date: Thu, 7 Aug 2014 19:30:16 +0000 Kelly, Yes, please remove the siltfence and logs. The sediment adjacent to Elm Street can be graded into the right-of-way by the City when the catchbasins are lowered and erosion control blanket is installed. However, the sediment in the downstream channel (on the west side of the property) must be removed and the channel restored. Please let us know when this work will be completed so Scott can coordinate completion of the City's work. Thanks, Robert E. Bean, Jr, P.E. LEED Green Assoc. Bolton & Menk, Inc. P:(952) 448-8838, ext 2892 z Melanie Curtis From: Melanie Curtis Sent: Thursday, August 07, 2014 1:07 PM To: 'Kelly Hemp'; Joe.Schreder; mattfritz21 @hotmail.com Cc: Scott Oberaigner; 'Robert Bean'; 'permitting@minnehahacreek.org' Subject: FW: 4055 Elm St- erosion control fence Attachments: IMG_0810.JPG; IMG_0812.JPG; IMG_0813.JPG K:2iiy Pleas2 see th� res��.�n�z rrom our engineer. Please correct the issu2s as originally direct2d. Melanie Curtis � 952.249.4627 � r,;-�._,-*,s_ici o �^� T^, �, From: Robert Bean [mailto:bobbe@bolton-menk.com] Sent: Thursday, August 07, 2014 11:05 AM To: Melanie Curtis Cc: David P. Martini; Brian Simmons; 'permitting@minnehahacreek.org'; Scott Oberaigner Subject: RE: 4055 Elm St - erosion control fence Melanie, I inspected the site today to verify the extent of erosion and source of sediment in the ditch and downstream channel. It is apparent that the sediment in the downstream channel came from 4055 Elm Street. The silt fence has been overtopped in a couple of areas and was not trenched in properly in another area. These three areas allowed sediment to migrate off-site and into the downstream channel. The slope up-gradient from the siltfence has now been permanently stabilized with vegetation, so the siltfence and biologs should be removed and disposed off-site. The remaining sediment along the roadway could be graded into the right-of-way area when the City lowers the catchbasins and stabilizes this area with vegetation. However,the applicant should be required to remove the sediment from the downstream channel and restore the channel/riprap to original condition. My understanding is the Public Works department will complete work in the right-of-way as soon as the downstream channel is restored. I have attached some pictures for your information. If you have any questions or comments, please contact me to discuss. Thanks, Robert E. Bean,Jr, P.E. LEED Green Assoc. Bolton & Menk, Inc. P:(952) 448-8838, ext 2892 F:(952)448-8805 email: bobbe@bolton-menk.c;,,� From: Melanie Curtis [mailr�;��?Curtis�ci.orono.mn.us] Sent: Wednesday, August 06, 2014 2:42 PM To: Robert Bean; David Martini Cc: Scott Oberaigner; 'permitting@minnehahacreek.org' Subject: FW: 4055 Elm St - erosion control fence Da���e � Bob _����,-I nn:� n� ��n�; J's•?.9�2 f1C�'J f??�' 'Pllrfl d f25p011Se� MPlanie Curtis � 952.249.4627 � - 1 From: Kelly Hemp [ a'�'_� {� ^� `�='-,� ' — -=`� '� Sent: Wednesday, August 06, 2014 2:41 PM To: Melanie Curtis; �_,��ri'z%1�_�o`rn� i.rom. — - ___ - Cc: Scott Oberaigner; Lyle Oman; Joe.Schreder; 'bobbe@bolton-menk.com'; 'permitting@minnehahacreek.org'; Andrew Mack Subject: RE: 4055 Eim St - erosion control fence `.'-'id" _ Thi; is a rzquest ror ciarsfication. VVe have erosion control stuff in place right no�v-we can tip up the fence. Are you asking for the logs to be removed? -Tnere is only sediment build-up there because the rest of the ditch work has not been done, and the logs con only do so much for so long-if the logs ar2 removed now, when is the ditch work getting done? �1y understanding is tnat wnen tne City finishes tne required work on tne ditch, tnat this is no iono2r ne2ded. is that correct? �Ve can certainlv do what ever is clarified her and this has to be worked out with Matt, and cost is a factor. So the question her2 is: how much will you charge for this work? When is the work on the Ditch scheduled to be done? -Kelly From: Melanie Curtis [mailto:i�lCurtis aci.orono.mn.us] Sent: Wednesday, August 06, 2014 9:11 AM To: matt�ritzZi:a�hotmaii.com Cc: Scott Oberaigner; Lyle Oman; Joe.Schreder; 'bobbe@bolton-menk.com'; Kelly Hemp; 'permitting@minnehahacreek.org'; Andrew Mack Subject: RE: 4055 Elm St - erosion control fence )oe/Matt: I sent an email on July 22�d (below) requesting that you complete the sediment clean up in the ditch and riprap area so the City can proceed with the finalization of the storm drain and ditch work. I have attached photos taken on site yesterday which show that this work has not yet been done. Please reestablish the silt fencing on the property within 24 hours and remove the sediment and debris from the ditch and riprap area by Wednesday, August 12. The corrections must be addressed by August 12 or the City will take corrective action. Any work performed by the City will be billed directly to you. If no payment is received, all costs will be deducted from existing escrow funds and any remaining balance will be applied to your property as an assessment, Your cooperation is appreciated. Please contact me with any questions. Melanie Melanie Curtis Direct 952.249.4627 Planning & Zoning Office 952.249.4620 Email: ---s�- ----_ Website: ���:��1� � .or ;s Summer Offic� Hours: May 1Q �hrouy�. Auyus� ?9, 2014 11�nr;�y �h,-n��y!� Tti,;rS,-�a�. ' 3;� ?r., ��� S nm '� �rirl,��ij' 7'.�(? �,t'� t,., i 1 ��1 9r^� -----Original Message----- From: Melanie Curtis �ent: Tues�ay, J�a!y 22, 2Q14 10:44 AM To: Joe.Schreder 2 Cc: �Ma`�tn'��1 =��-+M- ,��-; Scott Oberaigner; Lyle Oman Subject: 4055 Elm St-erosion control fence Joe The silt fencing in the NW corner of the property needs to be fixed and the debris cleaned up. Also silbdebris on the ditch area should be cleaned out of the riprap are before the City finalizes the ditch work. Please address as soon as feasible. Melanie. Sent from my iPhone. This email has been scanned by the Symantec Email Security.cloud service. For more information please visit http: ���t��.���;n_in:�cci�>tid.cot7�i This email has been scanned by the Symantec Email Security.cloud service. For more information please visit http:i;��ti����.s��mantzccloud.corn 3 `'�,� �""� '�#g '�; � � =' � � .. �' r' _ . , a; �. .+� 'l..i � � «�c� .,y y , • � q�.k -�': : + /j � . � '*��'Q � "!'rfl� , . , �",, . � �,¢� '~ � ��Y.i ; `f d / '�.',� �t'.�, �x..� '} h_/'�'�-� . jy r._� ���L �.r,_ � 4"t�T� , y � ')• � �� 3 , I �-�h� ;C�a.r, _ . � ri�r3�, �� `� -�''. ,,�.,.. ,1 ` ' + �.' � ,r, . "F91�6�fi;� : � . � I '^•�+ �3 � .f , , 7 � " , . � t ` ,'` ��y'��c� l � s� ' E.' ? � `� x1 � v�' ,.- . f .+4�; y� � 3 ,��, �.���T �,� 'E r ���_, � ,� 6 , �'�'��i�� -• �°""� s ' C r �,� �.'. � ��;.�- ` � _ �•��1�! .�~S ��i ;j�� � '� �r�t n'�i'� � �. ,r :t y ��t►r � .. � ����A��,: 4���F� ]� ) x ` ..� " . i � �. � . ��i, :��'�- ,:�,�: �" �, ���'� ,, ,;±�• �■ Y -�s•� . .� .�tt +� � c� p a:•.�'� "i � . ;' Z* � �. " ti v l�� � �� i""'� I. ♦ ' f�} wy M _ �'� . � �,���g�����.� �{- M1 'K},��r '� �-�.'` ' f �1�Eg f ��'.:p y,#c�t'1'P?���� �—� .�RS ' ��� �a �' 1� .2' _�-� � �!+��'1t�E�e�A '}'1C�'� _.."1�iA..�_�" � ��._��_ ,F= �,� v� � . ��3`�p� � � ��. n T� ;a. s- tis� v�1� � r � . _ , �.-. r-�, �'�'s , y. ��i ti-. � . r "[: ��s'r}y',�,'�"-,-- ��.'} �,�. x � , ��,�" a� . �,� .i .3�= Y�` +i34;,�� i 1 S� ��-�*��1 '� � ��Y�. ���: � �. ;r *�y �t..'�� �¢..9 4�1`''�' ' �_�:..- (r ., „�r? ':y>.r, �s,ysrf�` _ � 'a.�y y �: '�'�y�x �f'��r +�iv�a��i��` . ���I� ■�I) Il��I�f��,r• �II'�� ��` ad ��! �� �� �} ••� - �.� w, � ��1-- -�''� � � ��������lli����l(���q II , �� � .�. �� y ,�,�,� � � '��l� r� , , � i a�,,fi ��' ���. � ��� '.. F � 'S�� ' ii4��l t� � �� ��i'�� �.�� .I�I �Illi,i �� - - ,/ :Y ��i. . a i"y'' . `x+� ��� � M -. . f I . �� ������I�I it� ���� a f ''t � � �s= �Z'-� Y. -r k a lil ��� � �I�H�`n1 '��± ' � �+p� ' :'i'"(r � �� I il �iil�I������lfl �$ �� . ,t�" � i �-- t��'� ��]i'���r�'s " �� I. , i" � � � �`� �' ' t � `a,+� �f�c�i a -, � e.y � t_ .+..�.�` '�'c �a. ��yj . 'fi: '�,�: .�..� �4�'4��,,` �'1�,�: � � �.. � �yF;� �'. '.�' � . �.. �� �. �t . L _ o-"'3'.ny-. ��'r {���'� q�4; ,." . .. •� , � .,��, ,^ .� . '�1�.,.,.'�^y ��t : ` �p.� �`� '' � 41 t�p � .+� ' '�:, . - � . ��� . i� ,,,t(��. y , . ,1 t a Fi�� „��r •ca— # � 'r��`. ,��..'a6W�vYl � .iti�..i Y ,^'-.�F 4 4ik:.:��raY:iniJ'litfi�J�i{M+k.` .�•... vrk s.� ... .Jpk �, a'S���. .1' l.- r.'�', ��� ' � , �t+�� �-c t r,�.y, 7 �a rar-v,�- _ � Zs.::. -�. . , � �•. ; � s,��'' 'r' c� a�!!r�� `» ¢��"y�►'. � ' " X ' ' � �� �.►�•�,f �, � i�!� k�'^.RiP i!r . �t i � �. v � t v"J� x � ^,1 '� 9. F Y' -�� ,����yti.r��` �.ti �' f 'x, m � �' u.���' - �� r �`,� .�S 4�c. � � � " � _ y.'� ' {,-�-� �#. !�. 4.� ,; a � . . • ,- ;. .�� �.-. �fi �-"'.:� �.. M.. , �� ���.�� ' �. ���r i .. ,'. . < ' . �� . .'�'�k .* s� ;/�^ -.t 1` 't i' yv` ; `� . ,� � 3 � � _-lj, i K-.. � , . ��di►Y. . ._ _ . . . �'`�' :*i G c u�Sr'.'��...�.":"..�.:�.'�i7=w, . �I�.��i',iGY�� � �c �rr•. z , �: � :� ; � = .f .,,,. a� < s°.41 } `t��l ��y� � �^_ 4' � � '` .. �'��1��t .� 4 �`... .J_,. `ib• r,� �it .,Y",}���C6J i`�i7 �� � ���"r . �'�`�i. �� ,�' G a": f� .i' t �'�� ;�a ��` 4." °�p�� r k�`i y � r K r'. t��r }�, ���'7 „ �, +�'�,�,�'�y�°,� -�:�' d'i, � ��� � �" S�� k<� �` �,a� r.����f�K4 e��.�:�,����LF�G.�r3�.�,'���'� � J��� Z� - � ��� +� ,i§*�v,�;,•�� t. ���v 3- '�' '`J� ',Je-4 - :;� :,�, ���:� � _ , ; -.n r �0`I ,,�,` �� '�: " ,..• �.� ' � ,_. ;.. � '�,� � �( �� y ' � ; �1" ,. � 1 _ � � �.��.� . .,. Y� � $ I � ,. � .� �, �..:�n ��y � � ��� a i . .�r� o�, y a �'r r' � ` "�'•_,-'� r�j r � ;���i V t`��+"`�� +ti�ys,��,j,�� • ` �` � `� T �ii`��'�''t.t � �� ���t f r �S'�� � M + � 9 S`� �� ,� . b`S' �J��� ���rj1°� k�-�1 J� �_ -tj _ .b'ti+ T3. � ` Y�} �` �1��: � y0 ^ 6�? Y�yt' �rr r ��. ti:•`��. '�` s,w �`�h �.:;. �A : � , a�,(+z �=��.3 `7 - � e � � nx �? ��y� t�k� �> ���-��} i1 �� a �,t-, . oR�,4:a : i� ? .:. A�i` .i-` .ti. f .i�. .a � 3� ,�� .,,� �. �` 3 � «�,, �r� ++� i{ �� � i!' � ,9��( �rt7 '��a�yd 'j+ 4`� ., �,, � ;�r�� , >�- �::,� � y � r . ��ti� �i= � ���', #x.. 1� �'.• � y�''1�� � `, •_ � - 'a`�l' �`i+q� a_iR`���1`` Yie°. t��" .��.',' �rt .. a- : ,. r .-• � � `� . � � . i� ' at�.� , ..... • ��!Ir -. . t� '�►,�"N k��i1�iRi', � �. . ` �k� �,�'.,�-��"��s .: �'-�`' �+;-. l.,s: � t tuC• � �i, . p � r . . . � —:t.- , �� ��� .. '.,yr we�,s -,,,� s �; i �� ��}r������ �,,. ,.�.,.:.K.s,z; _. �._� s:..` ,-=_,.n Melanie Curtis From: Melanie Curtis Sent: Wednesday, August 06, 2014 9:11 AM To: mattfritz21 @hotmail.com Cc: Scott Oberaigner; Lyle Oman; Joe.Schreder; 'bobbe@bolton-menk.com'; 'Kelly Hemp'; 'permitting@minnehahacreek.org'; Andrew Mack Subject: RE: 4055 Elm St- erosion control fence Attachments: 080514_photo1.jpg; 080514_photo2.jpg; 080514_photo3.jpg Joe/Matt: I sent an email on July 22�d (below) requesting that you complete the sediment clean up in the ditch and riprap area so the City can proceed with the finalization of the storm drain and ditch work. I have attached photos taken on site yesterday which show that this work has not yet been done. Please reestablish the silt fencing on the property within 24 hours and remove the sediment and debris from the ditch and riprap area by Wednesday, August 12. The corrections must be addressed by August 12 or the City will take corrective action. Any work performed by the City will be billed directly to you. If no payment is received, all costs will be deducted from existing escrow funds and any remaining balance will be applied to your property as an assessment. Your cooperation is appreciated. Please contact me with any questions. Melanie Melanie Curtis Direct 952.249.4627 Planning &Zoning Office 952.249.4620 Email: msart,s�c7i ci.orono.mn.us Website: r��,�w.ci.orono.�;�r.us Summer Office Haurs: May 19 through August 29, 2014 Monday throug"� Thursdav: 7:30 am to 5 �m & Fridays: 7:3^ a�� to :1:30 a�r -----Original Message----- From: Melanie Curtis Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2014 10:44 AM To: Joe.Schreder Cc: mat*fr�tz21'c�notmm�,!.�cm; Scott Oberaigner; Lyle Oman Subject: 4055 Elm St- erosion control fence Joe The silt fencing in the NW corner of the property needs to be fixed and the debris cleaned up. Also silt/debris on the ditch area should be cleaned out of the riprap are before the City finalizes the ditch work. Please address as soon as feasible. Melanie. Sent from my iPhone. 1 • w .. ... i �,j�� . N'^��J�� �yG1'lY[� {'�j� '3 :M 1i rf4if�1Y Ri.to� �y ],�,�y.}�' '~ ,y y� � ��� � ��•� �� � e�r y. �!` M. � �.�f'� ... . � �� �N�',�f� ✓ ('f t ,; - 1 , � ' , J`, yl�+� . � ;; '� •'� _` � 1�. .� '. .� � �� . - �',i� r' r��� .r - s 1� . - .�u.'�F' . � ,Y1� �l� .k, ti��. � ti ' � "�� " ;,�;� �� m� � «+�- "� �W"> � 1 7 `�y ± x �n- �,.. , ��, ` . I�= �'; ! i:" ` `:9c ;�� �� � .. r + , ... 1 .b .�'.4 ��` 1 ' p��F,�'^� ��'t :_��y�( i a•���;;`'� r� f,¢ i: ,i ��./�� �r: . ��4� �,�R+, 1�'. • 1X 1Ai��}:f i �i"..':. H � �. 'I j �V ��� {� � �j �q� ��.�. �� \1 e ��_i r4f� . �`, t L:._ �<}• � ?' �,��+� •�,�,! Jc'� 3 '�� �;.�h.r U'��, i� t�'� �� �� � � � � ���� � ��� � � � � � ,.� � [��ei� .1 . }� � <�r �� ,� � .�� ���a .i' 4 . • , S. 9. . �i� {�T�f�A / �ry �! g ^;r �Q ' %' . �j .,,,��. /, i� . r� t' xiA • � h; �.ijyi.�.ar 1' ".+ � �rCi . . Is � � ! 2 .��,�.. ,�r,,y+�. � �. �' ��i y w ya;.t � � � ;,T f;. *- ,r�.�- . .F j,wiww9W . � c�a � yrt� �tY,i* z� i'�. � �.��r� ';�i� . � . o - j�. . !•�7 �,"{+i+ t l^f� `� ��l �t��P�=' r1Jf�` '.�' �. �0�t.d` � �� �� �� t .� ��i } ��I r�. r��4,� ,��, � _. . r - .� , : ��, ;�y�i1�t� , ,�,� ��i x� - �� ��' ;— "�; f, ti� r� f� $ � � �.'�'�;� '�i ,�?�• i; s v�''•.,� , `��. , }z i.' �'a .�1: .�Yy : ��c�` �_ � �y w.� , � � f'�r . � !' ��`;! .�'+?-+.�#., y �' �'wf;� �( ����� � � .. � _�! ��i. ,f �� ���. � "�� � ' �� �i -,S,S� . '• � � �r •�� • � '.!}� � ! �:{� � ��. ; `�i, t �h -�... .� .� � �. i,� : x ,;v. S� � ���� -� } , . . 1� � ... �` ��•,� �_�.�i. � �`Y �,� �t � ,_� �.{ tt "rfe_.rt�� ;� ^� � �r '. S. {P l.6�i s� 4 ^ ' ' J� (P �.� t � a ! ,.j. �. r ,_ _ J; ��` #'; J ',j�;� �,«. �,"7 & ` �'� s; ,��� t`�iT�yf '. �''� ' �°b. �'-�;, ?'' 'I � �L�„�'�Ti `i . `' . � �.N"A( � '�' ��'�j �° ti 9 V S -� � r ' y ' �! � ,�� `���J` ;. �' '� �_.s s ;r� �„ ,; �'�'r t z , ti� �r '. �r�R`�*t�r_ � .���f;}Y�F la�,. ��.�� .b�r � � �,i� �t�� ,�''{` �p .. � , 4'. ��p! �i `i:,'"�a+.�' 'T+i�p4':�• k � � _; �` • ���t� ��a. ff� �':. r �st. .s� >� �it#�t a� •' ,,r ��� .`� :s i^�,.. a .t /:�':, � : , � � ��-� i ii � g f �. ,� . � . . ��t�� �t Y � " =� . `�` �,;, ,' � � �:` 's � r���`� r�'� i � .��� }�as�� 'r � .�� �V"�"^�� "r r�4 �, 1 �a ` � . � '`i. y ! �M `�� �a .� �� j� �.l ��„ '. .��,.i�r ._—< �:j,. `'� � ��gl.C't� R �s��;�r}�w:il + �����*��'�' � ` � _{'sht �J`4,F . A � , !!V, � �r�� f't ' ��'h� � ��r �.� �'+��+t�+, :, F� '���� .�,''� ,t ��1 t l�.' { �i�:•'. .����, �' �- ,1 �+ � '4 � t � �.� 's. . y�:..s �R.- �': , , k ,`�w�+„ . `i ; � ` �` �:, F � .• . a '',�,.lp �j�, ! 1� `�p-/ i ,"���+��,.i� /a r"t/•y/� } i^r; � �•' � t- d��• �.:�ibL 4 I .Z l� ��rk @� Y, .�T�t��.�M�.ld ��� . . .{'.�•/�7 '.L` ;. i�y w�� ���. .�C, (./�,�; ,,+t�'-- t*r�'��' •' Y'?'� �'� . Yf-*, r �.. �'v. �-' r�� 4� � , .:�� - r�� �. � �.. d� .. ? _.� . ' � x��` t �`ti"� -!� t,� i ~ � � ►' .�i w.�, . ! .� �g j y+M1: � ����>�,:. �r�� ��'i...1'��.`" 3 t _�w __ _ +� . '�� � I� ; : 5 : � .. . ��� � r^'A���� r _ y,�y,K•+�.u�, � � •' � a� � �� r �" � �� � �� �� ��, _} 'r���,�.;r�tY_,.s. ...7i+ w�►r { ��{� � �_ ^ �.` � {/� .:�_r.r�C��,'..y�' .. •� 3+. �� 4^'7 - - .f�^ b .II'vXk°.. � sy� - '����v i � �f�fi��_ K �`b�N�A'd����� „`� . �.. �,� y.� �'4'..�"'3�^. �yi`,^a s3� i`. �� f Y f., � �.:ffi� ��k''/�9�4=��: �� � ,� � Y ��,S. ��I�: �?'.,,S,t���. , � • f . ��Z '. 4 �",jF L� �� .a� ..„}. !� .�t r �� a.. � Y'� �•��J9�� `�/• � �J.�+�..r�� �.��Y+?l'a�� r al � � �+ .. - '°v ��� � � j. �� � v . .,y� P���- �_ �������:- .. � � �.� �:. - ,� • ;� ., N ry, . ,� �,`'�'�J','_ ._ �'�`'..��Y�.� •�j y(�{Y/�l � I � ,.`� .A4� �a�r. `�:� A 1 �� • 75�ia�.A�1�'Ai�'-'"fCa� �11� ;'��f�' ..r �� 4 CITY OF ORONO �.�� PO Box 66 � Crystal Bay MN 55323 Phone: 952.249.4600 � � �. G� INVOICE `�kFs H��� Date Number Page MATT FRITZ 09/11/2014 20140185 � 4055 E R Customer No. 105482 ORONO MN 55356 PAY BY: 10/11/2014 Quantity Description Unit Price Net Amount 11 3 Maintenance workers 30.71 337.81 4 Bakhoe 95.00 380.00 8 2 Dump trucks 75.00 600.00 1.5 Wheelloader 110.00 165.00 1 Erosion btanket 12.50 12.50 1 Fabric underlay 23.60 23.60 1 Rip Rap 264.00 264.00 Balance Due 1,782.91 PLEASE NOTE: In accodance with Orono City code (Chapter 14, Section 14-110, paragraphs A and B) at the end of each calendar year the City of Orono can assess all unpaid invoices to the property taxes of the property associated with said invoice. Invoices not paid by the due date are subject to a late fee equal to 10% of the invoice total. MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO: CInOFORONO IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII Po eoX ss Crystal Bay MN 55323 CITY OF ORONO �0-� PO Box 66 0 Crystal Bay MN 55323 Phone: 952.249.4600 y�.� �: INVOICE �kFS H 0�� Date Number Page MATT FRITZ 01/15/2014 20140005 1 4055 ELM STREET Customer No. 105482 ORONO MN 55356 PAY BY: 02/14/2014 Quantity Description Unit Price Net Amount 1 Elm Street Ditch repair 3,500.00 3,500.00 Balance Due 3,500.00 PLEASE NOTE: In accodance with Orono City code (Chapter 14, Section 14-110, paragraphs A and B) at the end of each calendar year the City of Orono can assess all unpaid invoices to the property taxes of the property associated with said invoice. Invoices not paid by the due date are subject to a late fee equal to 10% of the invoice total. MAKE CHECK PAYABLE TO: CInOFORONO IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII PO Box 66 Crystal Bay MN 55323 � , Melanie Curtis From: Robert Bean [bobbe@bolton-menk.com] Sent: Tuesday, September 02, 2014 12:11 PM To: Melanie Curtis Cc: Andrew Mack; Christine Mattson; Scott Oberaigner; David P. Martini; Brian Simmons Subject: 4055 Elm Street Attachments: 2014-09-02 10.39.50-1.jpg; 2014-09-02 10.41.44.jpg; 2014-09-02 10.42.12.jpg Melanie, I met with Scott this morning on site to review erosion and restoration required. I have attached some pictures for your information and following are my comments for your consideration. 1. The riprap at the beginning of the downstream channel located on the northwest side of the property stili requires cleaning and restoration. It is my opinion that sediment deposited in this riprap is largely due to erosion from the property at 4055 Elm Street, and the restoration work should be the responsibility of that property owner. 2. Additional erosion/sedimentation is occurring at the driveway entrance to 4055 Elm Street. Additional erosion control measures (biologs)should be installed to prevent migration of sediment downstream, and the upslopes may need to be re-seeded to ensure vegetation is established. If you have any questions or comments, please contact me to discuss. Also, Scott may be able to provide additional comments regarding potential for the City to perform the work against the escrow. Thanks, Robert E. Bean,Jr, P.E. LEED Green Assoc. Water Resources Engineer Bolton & Menk, Inc. Consulting Engineers&Surveyors 2638 Shadow Lane, Suite 200 Chaska, MN 55318 P:(952)448-8838, ext 2892 F:(952)448-8805 email: bobbe@bolton-menk.com www.bolton-menk.com This email has been scanned by the Symantec Email Security.cloud service. For more information please visit http://www.svmanteccloud.com i � '' `���w rv��>,� 1 f� tw� . "����`;�.r..Ir•� '� T C�� � y�� `J,~ � .i i4�' ��V^� (. r �`.# t. � ��� �i ;. ` . ., t� `3 � �� ;� �: � � ��_ �i..y �".� �, ..+ � �•�' t �'�� '_. . . l� . . - ► `;, . 'f .. , " � �°Y^t=w . . \' . � A �� t � �- � � �� �;- .- �j r �� - �� � '�\��� {�' .;4�� . . 1�.^ • .t ,� .:'. ` fQ�� :M � �r�, �'r„ it ,��a ,rt �,�'.�� ,``%t� „�,�i� l � R �'` •4`"�`4�'�. �•.t �� �yyh »�. �y1'" � 'L� :�.R S ��'�,_� .�.`� 1Jr r ��" � ,� ��� � .. � y _ ` � �, � � :�� ./,.� �,� ,.�.'� `, �.: � � 4Y.k '.r� v �,� � '�� -Z ir_•`��. . -.•�. +efx::r a _.._. .we. +�i � '�`+.�•- ,'Yy�,��� -� ti'%ti_` � i 'FY �... `� 3:., t.� •Z +i .�..• i �.. �^1�_ .� i � �. _� �. � ����� -- ' �� '�' � k Yt,�°`,� �' ,� .� �. � � . ��, ., '� `.'�.�, � �� ,, "'s� '�� .^ o . ` ' �S . 'C�.� �� ."! '7 . _ i P :-G_ �.� �.�,�3 '�h.; 7 �t'yi�•r '�t � �r .��:;:: �i ' �� , ,,?„ �C .� .. p :�� � ' _�. .. I _r. '. . , . � �.. �... . .; . F.- � � . �'°`` "_ ' , . '� '�r^�''�'ari r ,,,,t;_ •?i. . . � _ .�'� �cr?�..► �:..,- �. „y':� . . � � �. ir:�,g � ..._. T. , � �� �a;'� �� _.' 'a'' .y > .� � ... t��,P• �.'.. "' fi-� ��a. `w"�e�^ ... •4'�� ��.! ,:'"`,. ..Y �,. ° '+°'q�� � - , � f:� +Y�ww+�~ „ f 'y�A����••I � , ��2,n -r`� :y,: ,� �:2 "•'�'4�`y'' ~4 ' a-.��' ,s a+�._';+*'+'Rl►' +'+ .,,a�.* ''�� ��.�"' � � " '�.}� ^Y,� �e�tw�,.�.. ��C ._ $,i z e "�w:.� . '���1`b"�^�:.:. �' �r�.. .f'`" �"" '"' � .xl� �-� , �w�"�ti• r Y` :-: .. - �..,�:1� , : �' --.� +^c 11.��;i ,.r � a!T' 1� ,.}�.1.a/`9�� . � . _ # _�.�+'_:. �„�aR aJ�►.�Z .. tti's'v.✓4,. ..�x.�.. �- .�,w� �. Z.^ .7'=i$ �aT .�� L�� . '�,'1'r.e ` .s_:'i� � • ' y �' it,yr•- ,� k ' '..`:.� . � ��1. ...; ��;�~ ..�;"��.... ��.e,,r���„�,.���MM 'J►/�,� `�T ;� 4�� _..t,�' � 't'+ �'ISE'"'1C.�" ���� ,,. r ,i + / �„ ' 1.�-�... x ...�a � 'Yr .lv� / 3�FT� .�` .:cs ,�wy,"�'�! ,� 'Cy9�.�� 9�1 � , �sn - �_...�'ww �.�, a•�a'i_.' `�.. .- ' �.���. . �,� - ��• +r'�- �c M +� �, +P { � . ,.. '��' .� . � "' ':.'��„'�'a-.g:.�'-y 'L��" � � T`� _ �...e` � �i,�,ilV�� � �. � � ,�r �+s"� �s� � •:��. �`'�. Y i.. .� ��s.t-`� .��.�,,'�„�M� . _ . - .+� !� �lr- . . .c'-� •-,i�y�..�... ♦� � •� _ ,���.. :... y�� .,�`� � d � � + _ � _ J&' ". E .� �' ''� f r .� >L�X' � .- . ° ,:-• .; �f^ r - t� +a� �" '. ��.`s �x�Ib�,�.. r r ;.'- - `T +��` r, �t �..�,.�.�, .�,i�.+ s �� .� :� �`�� rf � _ y .� . n � +.� ,. , - +W:t� � .... . - , � n: .��. �: ` ,�: �3'*���.V R�, .♦. eun . ���,`'µ'�!�A�yM��: � � ��✓���=- a -a-nc.`.� � �.�; �.� _ : '�', . � 'IG� .�. . . . . .�Nra- �� '.4y .�e. ���^W�fw"�M4 y g', � 4 14:��`��r y".— " ,�. s`;� �-x p ... . , . _ . ' ++ .�'�' : �-_ � ;" .r'. .�`r �a''*�- � ..�v.. r � �" ' 1,` .,. t"''� �` �-`�s'� A,'' `' r: M .. �• `��j .. x t, �, : �+2' . � �,a , ,- � ,., . � ,_ � �a �� � �=� 51� ..:��.. � .. � .. � �.�r � ��.. �iy " t � . _ � : � S: � Y� ������' �.� ,,,4 . , .. ., : � _�` �'�p1� _ .. p��� � { � I�s n► T� �...7.w'G� �. ..LF�. �^'� �. �� ,'� - � - � 5� T� ` $� � � �; \ �'�-.,..'""y a— '^L.r . �'�.'. ,: " . .._ � --atr` a+,�,�� �� " ... ' ..�`� a �. ' `" . . . _ . . - a _ .� �� ��� .- _ . ' � .�- • . -- " _ !F' � . -��� _ . ;��MY� .,�..-. ,_.�l�'. `a.�` ��„_.w �'4 �•: � . • �-.< . , «�s.� •.,. Y , -: � . . . . . .. .r._ �... ,tt� �yil,.... ..,.. � a.�-. .. . _� .,. -� � �-I,. ^� ' "�" 'x ..�r r .. �'i�' `\ �. " .,j s' "� \Ti ..,� ,� �.z�.."'.a° .. � ._ �.. at��['?��� , �..4 Y y.� ' ..,.+5 ' M�4`,�\' . \.. _ !�y'l. . ����' y/`� )�:. � �"`� ` i�LiY !3� . ..... `. a ��{!�l` #T.T"'n:. 'Y , ) J!y, ' �q 1 . \�� �'... fi Mv�[e,Y'�S.\ � �\.. O ti� •f X � ' ,,,. - ,'+e,'' ���[ ., �W ae-. �� j, .� 3," Yw p�e . , �" '�:i .`> ` t�'�4 �a�n��� ` �`�� �'�� ���� ��� � _ t /L��~-S�� �~ � . .u� �_, �L�.�. -y' # 5 _��,� �""', A'� 1�`" , "�'.�, ��n'- 3 �•�.�.<4��� � � .. 'w' `he�", . � �:� �.�,,.- � ,��.','v a''�C�% _1 _-_va ,.}' ��v%���i.a.."�+r..' *�.:,�' ` ~{� � '�'�.> a- .-^ ,;:, ,� . a. ... .. . k y�. aw.�f ,,y,. '�`"t�" � � � +3.rA�,;;a.ix�r ��.!, '�. { x ��.y"�' c., . � . t . . • . +y�, \��. ��M. iM ` � sr•�� .�" Y � I ` .�... a . i r � � 1 .. .� a . ' 4 � �ew. �RF1+ ♦ .. • � � , .. -0�'... a„r'_� .>.. ;. 4 . '�. �'i Y`,�, �y �`_ a l '�A". T'` .,- �; . _ I _ � . .. . T �. . � � , r3fi� t. �w, / _ 'I'I �.' - �. � 1'Aa. _ .':✓ �.f��� '+ � ��..� ,..yA,_;.i;, ` � y� � . .� , �,.y � � _ wi�f' "'tR�r + _t .�l,;b .,�. ��` -. �,� I t M �'• • �SN •,p..� i" &,6t ' � ..Lw� . . � � . � I . . �,. ' � ',�� . y ` ^� ---' . ��.. �.. ".'•� . 1 ' � 1 • � . ..:� �R +W ' .. . ' ::�. . l i A �_ * ay.' � rF �Y..` .r..w �,.��� . . I �i �M�, :^" , � . . .- �.. ,' .' . b" i ... �� F . '�A � o. ' "� ,, . "`''� '� �� . �.�� _- . , •. , ., .. � .. .,.. ,� , .' �`M ' ��, \ ,�:W �a �.,�' ,";�: -^r� r�c n.+k"�'`"�w �` ~'"'� -. . ;, � �"�a'±§I�.A�4i'•,..- T ,�, ' " ' _ �t�,FM'� Cze �r . • .. ' _�e`�� ' � .. �'�' ``e 1. � -� .:,r��� ���, M � � x ' ' � � R'�r ' < �� �'k .YA`�:. �iB'. .. , . .. ' . ,. - � r� � x r.. �:7'� '�-' {:* �"�f%:,,.� "o ' '^�b ; F,,� vU � � � � � w�'��� �� � ,s� . � a ^ ��. '�n• .�� .#,a�,,a ' T;` Y�'y k•�,,.f' ..LV" 4:?''"�.�f 3 ,k+iay . � A G � 7 . � �.�..� . }a'n� � ,��,,r, ^ ,.��� T,�'g,�' ., '" _ �,+1`'H !� � , .+- +i�. a+'` Y ' ` �' . x� � � � "' ��# � , � , . •- a • j►� 'r `` a : �" ''t� n.'�< ^•� . , , r. � `" a �+. � � � ti . . . . '� y yti , b: r' . �.� �" � -��a �y 9�: •. ,Y �� '�i:�� # �: ! . . . e�iF-� ��f9 '� �z.�' '�eq�, � . 1�' � 4g,q±�`yy �..f . � ��. �:. .�y ��t.�.`. � �� ��4 'y ��' I k_ .:�1rPsi ' �' 4s 6.' - . -i �9x�" ���'. - c,.�°q.« .. ,�,.'$N`' FM ��tY �= �'$'�;� � . - i�'` � ,�. � �' >�A �� � r a�l��� ,� �t�,�,� ��!' ',' Wf���_� ti' . , ,� +� ��'f� , ' ��, `� t � � ; �5 i � , � �1 ` �\� ����� �"'a 'L/"'��� Y.4�,\^�,°r,�ri!' �'`,,).,,;t,'� ' '!,� t. 1 ` . `'S - ,�� � .r �- �:E��,�� �� ,� t�` '���. a C � : °� \�� d, �� � � ti: ° ��� �`�, i �. � � � �1 ��y�� ,�y.A;Y�� �,�1 � a� s.� � s �.'� +1 4< ^ �� t5 ��' � 1 � � � �a� ��i� ��+� ,,�.,�4t i� .� \� .- �, 'jt� �� � . � t�j" p�h��', ��i�l,�� \�1� �``1i�ti.� y' ��',, �, '�..` .. �� �,. � � ���� . . ���� � � � '��}�����. � � - � � �� � ,;- 1_. ,� n.}. +s fi�l r' + � �` �1i � �, ��,. � l i�� ��� � �� �@ �� ' �':' �� ♦.tn� ,1 '"� � '� � � i•� . •.��,� �y6alb[����.. �1. 4��4 � ����a�����i�.�� ��. ,�,_�T i�,j,i���� � � ��� t�� �.' . �� -{� > � � g *' �f �t � ' a ���,x� � ����#�� , „� ��qjR ! a��'; 3 �� , � �` � �_�� , � � �ti � �'�� '{ 1 .t �!� � ��� o � �� �� ` .t � '°r���*r if�{.}�. ,'�� ����'1��5; � �t^"11 �y�, � � ,� •�,•�y', ��.� .��'4: � � �i ., ',i�,� ,f�iM ��� �`. � i t � �i 4' � , f � �f .�� "+� . - ' �oi, a .-����'� r;.a�i� ��,2 ��,� t.y, �t's�"����` t(`�1��'a � +'i �, . �. �" �� - : �, A' 1C1� .� ��i1"!'k..� ,! ���,i}T ,��� 1t � � � �. .'.' ++� �� j'�3, � t"�};��r �'� �i�f�� � �� 1��- ,'��� "� � . '��� . � � � w.1 �; ��; �� �`,�r� , : ,,� ,'� '• ,�" � ��� _ �.. -..:.: r.r"� \��,{ �.,� �� p�"� �'�` � ��� q #� �: ; 3 s :A� ,`.�+��a. ��"k �.2�".^ {w.�'� �ii� '��+.� �,} .\j t'� �,1F1'• ' ir r �BFa°'r 4 . _ µ � � �' � ;� � � s �� ��� � � ' �i , � ��� t ` ` • . �* �° -_ °.���i ��_ � .w�L�.� ��}""� �'�.. . � +,�C�,}s:`F'�,��C �� ti t���+�� .. `,,` ' 'il�� �4 � . ��� t ���x �� 1Y . . .,, �` t,�.. �.�, ��'*4 ' � ►s.'`+f\��,��. � ����aer� ���� �.����� � 1 'l� r A , :. � �. ��� 'g�,� �` �w w�� � � 1 � ��!.z a 1 , � ��x jE". : �, ' 7 � "�` -•� -� 4-; . a-p�,�v i�3�� tt � � ���� ( . t � :1 y . +. ,h ,:� . ' -. : ,W�:� ,.�1 ���!�' � ��� � i!X . . t« ' , �� C "`� .. . + p � . 't�'��� �-., {�.�� ��n. �j x,� Y';.o+f 1 `� �.� . C �+� ,f ��+, }j,* � � } � - " � � �+`',�,: � � 1 � Y. � . .. .� - - r!f �"s,����-` ..:.� � �1 � �. ����� ,; �.k� C'. e�.� ,� � � ., .- � ,Y ` . .. a .:�k` � �` ... . � p•�� }� r4 �.� ,����� ,��i �s�t! �• � a � �`� � ,r.. '�. vk �;� ^ �� ��"� , � �`�� c'l � � _�� �-- ��" `�' ,�,:;�� , , !, ;r 1 ; ,,; Y .� . .,���,�'���, �- _ ��� �� ,� � �:a� '� � . `� �t c�- t . . ' ( ��.� ' o,�. .�M� y � . � .rM�. '!� � 1�.. . �.. � �� � �. � K � e � . � � � x � t,�• � �� a�� � t� ., �d� �� a R �-� t � �; ���� ,���������� ; ' ` `�v �� e�g ��.�� � ` ` �{��j' �. +�, ��:,,�y�ra �� � � � � �'^»: �:,� � .� .. c. r i ,� .�� . � � �+�" .�r h ��u�`�,4�.'i�;� ...._ .. �.1 . a . �-14�... a . ,� �y cy� ,�'��yt t �� '�` � x . � , � r. • '� '�t � it u 35 YS �i.1 .r.3. f,�����i� �4� ,t\\\\\ \�� �'�; ''� ;�y. ;� ,., 4 ' �,�� �� �l��� 1`.��r����,..,¢ � 4;,,} , y� ' .��� � � ���� � � -.. �� . � `. . � :�,E� � �`i � ,.v=-a ' . � �� �;..yt ae ��. . <->'�y�,°g� `,� 'ty�. ������� ����',�', �"'� �� � `�% pr °�S�''}�.�r �'�:s�1 �t��la# �� �� ��.a,� \ � � g �Sh'�; � - `,�E' � r� � �� ��F � �1� \���'`,>,� ��, --- , ������ � _ �'� `, � �\\�` \� a i�,_� �;� :,' ' '�`; I�', r o +����°� _ , �, ' � , , � 7� ,�- �� , ,+~ \'�'�` •�,t`. P:,�;' �`3r `3� �it. � �#,�,. . � � - ... n,+pp,i •�� !a� p .�.�' Ii . ` .S t i 1�r ,� ... ^E` . =t S�a�i� ��{�5t_• > p e+���',t � :. ' , �l���n C, �s 3�... � r4� r` �i ��, � ,�'�'�- � �� �.�'T�' � '� , l. ° . +�. , . � � Ct� � . � � . �:;,��� r �,r�- .��^� �� � � '1.,< ,, ri; X � � � s . � �ti„i+ d"`,�,..i � � �� , � �' � �'� � , �y�,e,�[ ?` ic� , � � �, . � . , ��`� �� - �--w'`_'�„ _ . . _�;� r) -.c a ��E+�; \, ��� t ���' �- ��+� "�"F%'�` AR �`; i�.t`� - �;r � f 1 _ �1��°� • �.�t � e �� �� ' �1.��. ����. . '�`�'+'t�`� �' � ,� ,p����•i �� ` �,�"�J� .. �F'3 � �.� �. �, $ `.�`���a SZ!�.�,4 , , ,.�}Y�-� ,' ,, �. *-v.+s g a,��` �!'� «.. :.�,��! � ��'� ` �`'��. ; '�a`.. � ,�� a. z � 'y '` � � wv.`� f �.�� � � �-���. ���"s'x t���� �� ���. �1�_�y� i 1� rt�,�� l: f� �,C,,,��} L. �SaR+��C�: ..� F �ta.^y�;r'". �+�,. � fe"�l�t. !� `� ..:; ' ,S ,..� + .'..t L �+��`p,� •� � , t ` iP"�+c � ti� � �4' � ` �e a� ��l 4r2ti".��' � �:�� � r� �, ,� 9..I4� ��7 �� '.4 l�'� � '' �1 C r � r �� f�� ���lr � kt�"I�lA �� �� ,� �-'� ` � vv'�`s$".t..� .�. �3f :��Tjt S. •�.��r, p.� y,....y:cy� ` ,r �; ��� t :�, �lY� ��E� j��.�M) � �. : �' r t. � '�.� 1 ''� i 1:'1::�"� � '�..�.^T i sti` d�'� a `_ � 4 �, • �f. 4a �M``.s .v ��i� � _ � 1 ��, -a•�; y �}��• d , � ,,y,aG �� R�':, � � i ¢ yj� S't�9 d ?R, M14.�. ' ��'+� }.,` ��.t*�d�.�'^S ;� � ���4 � 3 �l �. �����kra� A t�� . ,c �^ �A H - � � 'L� � �,.,, 3en i�E. �'°���'*'.l.. �{�4 � ,w / �'K,� ���'�` ���1�� n�r ��„a '�, '( 1�'. �1 Yr�'0.�� ' t� q �'.� ��2 �,`�i �°� .p � � :,� '� � ,� � . � +c. 3 � `�' !fi�t � ° i� �i i' J�'.' ~� � � �:i � `��� .. �'. �� fr�, ���tT . 1� '��?. �i���. •r.n--0 w�� �� '�'" '��� . � �w�� , � .� v �G �' �'_'R .�• S, t. � ��.c F2' a �'M :t.�,•. t, ".y�`,, ?' � �� �yq��..♦.p.�.. �, � ��. �� � ;,, ,p�w�ik � �.; �t`� �}��""►� �'qti]�. '4�1'y �*`� •�'��9t .4. � ���� ��7'.�r-• �,i���, . ,� ! � . . ���G�',�'v s�,.�.'^.. ?. �," .� " „�q ,. ��.� —..+!� , . 1 t t. � �%� �i ���u;� A.� ! ��� ���..� N� 1. ���•��� � k��, ` �, ;. �.. y��rv.•'� �� Fv- �"\'` �.�t 1�-y�� I����R��l�'S� t.: . } :T�� )� . . in �,�l ev r�., .x �t:r'�1t 1 .�i �. ,.$'`���` ���Z ��� � � �'r `? . � � - t,d', ..�"r,r _� �'.e'' ��. .i�'��\�v���,ii��l .\',�� . ,�. �^t���r.:�` . � ti � . . . ��,. , ' . . . x. � ..4� -� y,�r •• �`Ie(,d�1� 1 R�. A�y : t. . \�' 1. .��. .t+ .,a�!.,�. �.:P y f* . ..Y. �,. � jyL�� 7 '�•A.�t �.. i�� . ... 7R.. _ +,. � w �� ��� � �. 'il � ,6� � ,��,y�� � ° �,:���j, ti _. � � y� �n. �i�l,t �.'` . . .E� . � . 6� �'�t! k� � 1�! ?� '��{�'� � � � t , ����t`�1�����������v=;a� x �i��'. � . i�'l �'�',; `� ,��'��,�'y '�� � , ; .,�� � ':"� �"�� _ - �. ,� ,V �„ a��.�, , t �`. ,, ,c. t ♦ �� �j{��'�M���+���it^ "T?.kp ��y1�f��x 11�� .. � `�i��.`�`� .;= T, l� 1 � �,�� � i.� r.>. � �� �M!f�,��'� ` �.�� ��� � � . , �� y �. '.e, � .��y, _h„� ..�,.� �, 4"` ��l� � � . �,e �-� � 'i ��,,,�y �:',�* ''- `' ,a e P�, \,y�+�aeH� ^r�.� w.� ,� �'� � : j N� �i� . � . � �. - �=�'� �� ����,�� � �� �.���� �� , ` � � , �,. ["-"�*'�'� �.. •`\l�4. 'F ��� # . . ., � . _ . ���� . � . . �, . . , . . �. , ��_ . ,� �� . . � ,� +. .. .` � � � '�j'+�!�����m�!-7�'+' ��� d �' �.:.. �Y r y,C h tia�':5" � #�44 r� r 4 x � ' � F ' ' `'} ��`�:�E�t � "�'��c i�j,��' ;� �7'Itul�g II��� f,)n�� � y�'� 4� �'�,��}� � . ,�nt ' � ��.��� '\ i �`�'�Z#r�0�'�r.9/'.tP+��+s.i� t��..r,�l � � ¢f �f ti ,�'S�'�� '�4 a,�� . � � �� ,� 9����''�_��.�,"�'.fi�-ti�. .i 4 4 f�,�j'.i �!r � ,;1'� 5� I 7 YY ' � � -4�7.e F:.�� r.t�'��C�11�,�*��'��Sf'r. +� �'�,:.5.^� r� ��.:'iY #„'�.�-t�^:.�� t . 4'-e�' t �f - .�� . � * C�� J��i� � � A�, .1 .''. y�,,� ������t� f..�,� r �F `�F. �M :.?} �;.-� ����'��f�1� � � ,yt�1.'v .: � !'� °i�I'�,C �9c� ��tsJ�+ �C . `" �` � �> �. ", '� �•4,'���� tl r E.y V/ '�Y�'� , i �"'-r�{rr�. �L�d'.) �f�},yay� ���' �� 'r��`��s` . �" + _ l '�,�c.`� - � �d �-� "� ��� �?r , � 5�:: 't i �; xy �✓v H ��t ��i, ,a i� a. .' . � �� � �A. � � 3 � , v ��`. h �' �•ri �+ '�.�1�{,',��]��.� ' t�` � �n. x1.. �-��<,, ' ��::�'' k�, r xk.� ra7�t r t,�,�j�fi 1' 4��krf ,i �`.� 4' r`� . 1 14 ,.. � . y..µ �4a d .; ��it�1"l r 1 `�� 4 0.7:� 4 "'�C' -' i ��n, � '.. ! ,�p^!� 'i k > ,� � % �"e� ��fn+ �� �> _� �a t �'�`�i( �t�,F '�1��C{'�la * �1` `�b\ i[�`e: !.. . y � y �� , .� , i �� � .�(i,' (,�� Y��` x �y�.1�p ��' ��)L,1rti�..'�� t.,y�;.�� 1 �'fj.� l�y���,. � . i, +-y- t �� Z,.E a: ! ; a � iiV irt�'ih!.:rt.: '� f#� � ! ' :7 � 4� }.� . .. r '.4 a� O�,� ` 4'+ I' / '°� ��, � �f'�r j`e7 " 1d 'J `L'/' �'�� , . ;� :# ti�� ��iy. •, � 15* J Y�,t� ��" ,/s��4A� wF� � I��� , ��f`� f Y �4 � a.�`'�� , ���" ,. � _, ... � t�..` R �,E � � j�k�` t� {r�.;� .'i�� i �`.. �� • � , �/ �y.��t�C�s` ` � °1�I�, � p A" '�H}y �. � y��. 1 J, � � i : �_ . ,. . � _.�.-'.�-' ' . �r � .� � °�'�� . .y . c�:. r . � , � • ���� d..*,h����* ' ;-r � ' �"y'^ i f�l.ta# j���,. �d�� '�y�'� .�� � , - �'�� �+ +� a ��,� y.f �, r t -t }i �{t��r.ir, ��: +,. S + � �r ' � : ."-�+� x y � �.+ �y 1�1`d. t �• 14 � � �v ." � �� lh � � � y� � � .a ; ...� , wr ,�;;,�> �•� , { _ F� t*,� ,� r, ,� � /�. . \ _. �.,+»��a ��4-;^36aR. q� � '� . ?� � ��� ti/ F#�t.�R'�''Of� `, ��iA �. ��� . ` , t�� _I--- . � . t `F t�i t � �'� . � , , • � _�. f�'�;�.; `z r= -a. `kfi�ya �� �zhk"` � , a:l . -.n., .. <') �f :� . � r t � �,« .-�'�^�r, � � � � �n✓�`ao-,�r '6f �� 4 p �i'L�� � 1''�.. � .. � . . � '�� ^�3''^ �`' .Y `� �s�p' ` 4 � '`'�� — . . � � ���,�� ��.d.�'x � �� . �-,�. � ���i �n���, t i� t�`���` '�� „ . a .� ��"' f � �����'` y � . �`?���Yy�l evr , 1, .� � . /� . k�a.� T �,������ �F� ' .. �� ��5 1� ', '� � . �, r� „�.. i S�. � �3 �`,��� � ;, �i{k�,'�� f w���� �� . '�y(�" � Y , . . �_^v 6 °�' � :x'�" „�. � . o '47` r °�k. � 1 � __._�__ � y ����� ���e,�,� e � ; �� `w��' � f R : v 4 �-�r� ��.i:.v '. � m . � � ., s�, ��. �CF* '+ +S • � ' ,.� ,� ' �Y � A �14u I :�"��`' �` x� d. , •➢� q}r;�y+,� �t..rrs � , �,fi� `''` �{ �ro ��'+�%� ��� "i��T`� h.4L.Yi, ' �i{. � ��.,. r i� , . �t i^,�c! '�1� �� t� � .��.��.;,�'.. '"" .� � �.�3� t�v�` '� � ��- �n a�`, t �, �� , � . �i ... , �`��`� '� � �,��*; �� — �d ��� ��.�fi��� �'��� + ,.�^��' �� �.3 i� r ���� tr:�,,x d��f{ �w�.'�i. ` ' � t°� v, a� , �,y�, a �+�_¢,+.°�, y ��:` ' '� . , i..(" y � t �e'— S . � 7 . _ iiix!''� �y sY `R .Y.. A ' �� .`..x g ��rF ,y3��y3 y � �� ��J�y �/'~ f?� r��`' �,, � A L � . ; . k y..��� '� { �{B➢{ � Y. , ` [ p�i, ag t 'YF f�+ ,�.�A'$1 A1 � 1 �. ' . ����i . . . - �.t� .�i. r �; _ � � �" -� '?.w'i F�i1qiP� !�i't��` �'� �,�_t . . • ' i . . � � �y ��.. � � f�� r � Y Melanie Curtis From: Melanie Curtis Sent: Wednesday, September 10, 2014 3:32 PM To: Brandon Wisner Cc: Bob Bean; permitting@minnehahacreek.org; David P. Martini; Andrew Mack Subject: 4055 Elm Street Attachments: letter.pdf; emailsphotosBW.PDF; IMG956407.jpg; IMG955698.jpg Brandon On 9-8-2014 Orono Public Works responded to the erosion control violation at 4055 Elm Street. After adequate notice to the properly owners, attached, Public Works staff cleaned the ditch which had sediment accumulated within the riprap. Public Works removed all sediment and riprap at outlet of culvert down to fabric and replaced fabric, 6 tons of rip rap and erosion blanket on South side of Elm Street. The attached photos were taken today, September lOth and in my opinion are indicative of the properry owners'lack of responsiveness to their own erosion control responsibilities. Please visit the site and address if you determine appropriate. We are billing the properry owners for the work conducted by the City's Public Works staff on Monday. Melanie Melanie Curtis Direct 952.249.4627 Planning &Zoning Office 952.249.4620 Email: mcurtisCa�ci.orono.mn.us Website: www.ci.orono.mn.us 1 t.�� ��-�-� • �j/�r - � �_ ,,�..�� ; _ ��!'1�!"�VI1 ��✓v(/Y1 • `� �iI I � ��.i. �;- .t > s � air� � � , - ' �� � _I � / . r � �: 1'� .i; 1 ��T'�t. �, _ � t f�� j � ,I�S�k: ! ' ��,� ^ � .�` �*���� r �� �Y�" . _ c f � �' � �'� � ; , �, = i � � . � � �� � �'. �+�� � �: � � ��i������i i������i�i�� ` � � � ��4 .���1� �1 I II 1 �la. .�1 . � 1 i� 1 2 ♦ � . YX, i �� � II I � � �'�• �1�`'�F'►: rhy��` . i� � r-Y' �` . , II ����ti��;i t+.. 1 1�* i Y�' ���4 • f',. .�t�1E i t 1 r4 } • ti ♦ y� ; F-, y��14.��' � t(l�+' '� ; j, � ��,,,� �. t+. -�:� (I �1 � 11 .� �'jt ~`• i�t - r� �. �, r>i.. i � � � �h .r �i t ;r � s � � ' �'� � �li� i}aL"��� � �',!�ti �d��y�` ��.r-:i � " � f +:! � .`� . Yi.i�C,i 1�. f' _• . .� '.¢� t . ��?' ' .. .. . t �. . ' � • ��I'�' , j` � 's'r ! ��� F f� . . � �N •'+i��'W ' � ''"'�,� :� L � � 4 �°'-�. ' �� _ . .. . �� � . .,.�!7 �Y c '.�{,, .�Q"�'�J,� .!�x �L �"..# �- . _ C�'.. '. . i. ..;. �' , y� ' , � h�� x , .�� �►�'4,-�j S `� !� t \/ 7_t` k, � i _` � i.� � } +� r`,,-,�,i� , . ��' �i� i. .t• ,� + � �.., R .r �y ..� � ��a �f �,, ��e.� " . +�.� ••.� t, . . _ R' .t r� �.F��� Ya .,�,y,,i �' .� � t �',.�:,. p.� �. ,�;� 4 ;,� ��^ -, X ..ti � • � � `�^ ,�; ;*, ��s �'. . , � ,€x " ��{ , t���#G t,�`� ; � .t �i r �t. h ti' tL � r�� �. ;R i �' . ��r� ,tr ` .�.+" Ar�'� {��t ,r $, � }� . � � �� � � s �`� � {� �Y:�: �� � :I�1�lI� 'S �3.� �r�+ � � �'��r '*�' �-�1J','� � �'�,: �+�` �. i�� ��" ���� �I r't, .� i } , ' . Y �,}}},,, a.t "*Z �# . �A, �, t. �i#`�, � ��f?� ' �� , '� ' v itti, ��`��� :t� ' ' �1 �'� 2 ''Y ����t'S�i�}A.� . .:f,• . , ' '. � '; b.�. . ,�\ . `` � � f T ' �"�-:, . . . � '..' � i. ,T .� .` �.` a � .���i 1, � ���i� �,c . . , . L� t � �� i � ° •r.. �- }ti.`ty.e ` �, � � ��. ,•i$�o- ��. .�i � •'�I� � , 4 t� � ' ' ! � 11 i�1 � � . .. �� Ir � s � y �1,i+1 � � , v�. . Z _ � •� � ;�� � , � � ' a,y� �f �. � � � � `� � i�':' '• ► . l,+, � y I;�i� } ,� � �' s� �,' {. `` r � , .+�` �;t ��. � ! � # � � c�"?�d �,�� .�, � ,<< . � ,�y� ti ��'4- l,. . . 'a t •.�a � ... �•'"4�',� °:�.,i �� - '+ha � l��'"t •+`°��X � �kj �'S,?►+��ii,�, -�� ,,`i A �,��"�_.� . :�����t ( � ��.�7��'t���!.r` ar..-7 � � . q 1 �,�f i#Y ei. �+t�` 4��r}�`r"4t'. . {� k i�.i�'.f�� f' � y�L- ���� , .,�, � � C'k�,'� �..�t� ��..' � ' :. r����' t+�'� `b�' i .�'� � , . .4 r��'M i- �',- 't �. �! y: } r K � 3r : �.- _ 4� ��� �i, , .4.`, '��dz�� f'' i ! ,. irt�,',.,`wr"`i t� tie�; '*,3 ' : ti �-:• ��'r�`�: •itis �,g, �� �i,- �•, t`� , �,, . �,t�_'�� -r�T , �y.n,�', ��-',�ti . 't �t'f 1 . ♦� .�; ' � � '�'ti � t'l�,�,�#. �!� ��,:, �, ' .. � _ �✓r r , t.' ' . �.^ ��..� . '�t ) ii " . . + t� „a,�, t , •4t.. !� .. - ��- A, � . , ' �� [.� � �46;� . .'� - .i � ' ." . • : M � y i�=� .� �. . , � ._ -' '4*r ��ty. er �' T *� eiy{� � t' �t ,�1 j' g ♦xA �}' � +a 'y.�t� •� i r '�i -r��N1' � . ,.�, ' s1�]�.^ ` ''K'°s`. . �, t''�. . . Y`�' �.s'� .��C .��� �.W�! �P' `r.. I`' � _�� _ ..4� .,f'.. '�, "v'�1� .T�'\7 4T/ ' ' -`s. � ��V 1�, t 't L���u_ s y.3' r, .► r<ti� f � • ° F j�,r.z,u�x.�,�4,,,� a�. ',���� 1, .2��'�: �y : t.��, ..;��y� �� �}f� - a;. � t,�.� �;.g�w^ �-p-: ;.� �j���:� �. �r t ~�� ��� �1+. �:��•�S.�' «���"4` I�' �' ' - ��+�'j:^� ,I��rr L.i��"r _� �'"'i�. ` y -,� . ,�r'�[ �. :ti� ` �,"'� *4 � � +' ' �'€ x `;�r^ 3- .. �'::r .�.f '.��.,����1 ...��1 - r i r t e � 6� � �, '�ti+e � "e°'A'�r��' t���� �� �; � �- ���'�� i�x ��� �: �'� ~ ��' �;-` � $y� t� �.1 .. � r � F v=.,� 4. ' '�f� 11� ' .,'3 .,� `*t� 'i� ..���� i,r'�.a :r.0 1i. �.. �.. y: .�'� r ,"p$y�,�� .� iZKpt�S� 3, �+� ,� �,.r, `.��� ��_' s'1 �� _ a� - s� � � �'f� �,� �,�' �, '� �'t ` e}. �� .e .. � .. '�.� r �.: .�' �,�! ,�.-_.:� - q '4 rr�'. '�,_ ..y.- � -t r �i t�, : �x� �` � .i .,, . �. R�� t_ '� ��� ��,�i ��;j ,��� �� �'� �� ,`�i ' l; ,� '��.'- 't�kk�.�Y^ � i• � , �"� �, � `'�.a`�-C'�-� .aq R . ..' �•' � �'��,. f- .`� , ... , �'��� ,�.. i.� 'y. � -Y �s.� . ,'; ly'`��t:�_�� ^�l�y,,�;�..��'i� 1 -, '�' . '� _ � �a�� `.,.1 �,�,f �,. � � _ ���� �,e. � i' � � �? f". ., ��`` �1�' ' �i'� �'�e��`' 'ra�T���''� � y�� '��, �� +�ti. �t f' � � .��'x I�M��f� '�,'�,{.��, ����i�+ � � �4`���N��R 2 � �.1� " `+'�. �} ��G� �k /�� zx,���� � .�,� - ���� - �, .. � �.'. '�T�� /��"►r . . 3��-.,.�` �. ' �'�'' e ^'i�i }� '�-��� . � � \ . � �y... ���, � Ai�.t' v '� r''. . �. i4:��xr y��- i�'t` , T� . �r �� �"r+�f 1 � j. -' �, t „r'`� +�� �y ' � , �. � ,�� � �� �Sr', e� :. � �.� ��. S� 4 n�4�� . . .R r , i `'': ,' � ��. �s il.�'6t�.. '....5'. + ���y..tt. �,.�.� � �. .( . �, �f,a- � tt � ,��� �{�„�. . � �.�'$•' i .� � '� � � � `. � '� '$�.' T'' 1 $t'�°� ,� ^e;�' _ �" ��. �� ���. `+1`J �2 � �_ � � � �� .1� 4 '" ����'_'��.�� 1'`,, *.. "��::- �'��^�r; ��r x�'a;s .� ,i 1,�'� �:���� ,� �,,, ,,y ���± . � �+T� ; 1 = :.�'t �. �'t ��r_ �...r' �`,�,�{�r��'�,*�S `. . :k... �,�;�(.,S�d f� •'y � .. ,���. r . . ,� ,� , �;. � ...�„�, ,a t Fj_M� r* 1 E4� t t� ,� *j s „ � , �� t r � f _P?' k j� J�`3 3 �5�, I a 'r�;r� ,'�+ '" i � X�,�("` T ' i �t{h: .t �' 4 '`�*y.�ti'� , 'k , t •r.} • '� r�•T' ;p� �' � k ?�. w y� � �,w �;, � �1�� ilf � ,� 1 -�� � .� r �w«�!h r .c.. y� �� � S. ._ . � .: "�••u'iA i� �M�l q'.F } I .: � . � ,. -•v.f�, g yry � �yy�y � � �!�� � .7-�+ 7 { ,',�"+" � R�j y�.r., ..c�� ♦r¢~ �� lr.A �14�Ri�' _,'e.l. ,:{' 3�eiy� t�'�,5�•� :�, 1.5.�'��r+`�.+��"{ +k'"'l ��; �� �y;ti:k h �: ti j-y," 1� `� +' � e • �� " 1S�f-��•�T���� �, � ��°F`�t�}� i4,.��,� �k�'��,��R `,{ �"� ; � , . ; �g .*�i.�, ���i� ., _. 4f��. .7 r �.Pk ��x . •�Nir�'��"J" '. ���•rt�.t��".� .`�!��. . • r�y�'s.�j7}� �-Y�� �.: �� �. n .{�� F�x sr,�"�'< a. 'in �e_t,';r.� , �zie�l y"" ' �a , ��- � T�lK T�'La.''¢" '`r� � f`x <- ��5�r.'*�`„�,�r���,C'�•��•`�,�t,.�_: "`'CS."` `��« { ,;;'` �..�t i, ,,r ;� ,t��r � T'.�', -c n,� _ J �'°'Y� .A.�'�.�y1 � �. ';� �s. {�r�f''�. ,F ..� 9 r^/•�,���� {! .-� �,� �}{- - t'4 .{'fy�R ��Yx: � . 'Y i � _ . 1F i I � � � � "r � j R����.�M y,L'��� �; � � . � ' �� � t��� {� hr, "�ri��. I�� �.,r.f,�`} i'ftS % . � "d.. .y _ . ��Cl ,,�, .qy :'�#� � -" �L ��} - ♦� � �.' Y �.^�,' 4'� 1. . �.7Al�m. . `+,... �f�+ �/ r .r a .t�"g'"�1�,' -'Y. �l'� �'�� 1 �f���'1 � � _ . . + " r� . y�f,,�'�j'�'��.�k ..��1� _�'!H�� F\ �+ � 1 ��.. ..�1� �����e'���} Ar . �,� � '�e f����l'} ,t`cF '� T� � A f"�.i 4 +�t '�wJ'� Vl � . t . � � `�•� ♦«� ° y�'.: -'{ .r:, P` ; e:+-, �.j�t I�+�, , ,�,��1„'^". .y,���� � v x ♦ � t r,S+4vA ' � e y! � �15�; ` ��,t � A� s���;.'r���. , b * � �'��� y $ ,.t. - R !y� ���, � �, � 7.�� • ��'�a},� ,=�'i� P '"�� •� x.'�i g�i� �t 4.���� . . . � .y�`:� ,,; t ��.�� r�� �. .•� ��:c�'t.o- �•,� ,�t'�Yit' I ; .,� ' �. . 4 � ,'�"'�. � � c' �,�q;r�h y� .{. .:� �r ' .. � � . � „ �� ��t� ''t . �E�'+�,�� ��'�r+�r"i��.:. f . �,3�.. � �� � '•� w-•leL� ,�4 w,. r(�'t] „^" ! � / s �, s � ��.+ ��i �'�17,y'4 4 P' " C'k" f i�'1�,::�-� � ,M y..; ,y.+.{a A 'l YL1b��YY�r1��i.'"L::�."s*;1iy41..�+s` - -� r . , ... . . . , �.'. g� ��1 x .�f _ _ .�*..J.ah+�." �►`� - � '�'.�ac�- � �`. 1�s,�����//� �� � �I I6-; ' Y �yY„_ � r.�- �_ - y_ -`..,.,� r ���� � �"` �i�- -.�r r � ��`1' � �.- � �'� � ��� r�r: �.�- . _ .. ..l � �'�-��"'�"'"'�•-�. - -� ' -_r 4' '-�- �^ -_� • ��� � `� � ^��-a���` �� �`��^ � u r��-� . ,,,�,� .�"3^ . � - ... : �, - .. .� r ._ ` . �. •:,. .. ... �-..._ .: - ,, ..,,�"-�� � � '. R. . .. �..' .�.'1 �:�i'.., zn �_- .� .. ��- ...> �.::�-�-�t.._. �� :.- � +`�'� �:.. � �"'�"a...` + �,� +" ""'^e`^^-�-�,�,,..,�-.�._. ""- `'�r •- . . . --�.._.� � .� _ _ _ :., .�. �,.__� � :". �-�,'-.'._.�.� n'. _ � �f�..�"""--� L_ '-1 ' -Y < � �� �=-��. - _"'-�.+er - � -.= .i.,y� ±e+�a> - -" -�-"Y.'T"' -- '1� � � �"'� - :;1.- �~_� �v.-. `.-^--, . _°-�. y� P �..----�-' '� .�,�" ...cs. .�.�� � �•... . ... . .. .... . ..` -�►�.�.�w�-�- __�_��-- -�`~ 1 .- - -�____� - ------ - .. ., ��� � � � �OSS , . �, �. , r . . �'� ". : .:.,�. � � . r� � � ,A�'.��' . �`� __ �,,, . � � - . ,�,� . -� - + '►:•,; '�' .re-.:�-.,�.�.r 2 -� " •ft `+ .-��h: ; '•yy�� _„�,.� �P•,�;- , �,a ♦ -�� t �� l x��' � ._"k. yR'� '"� x7���6;.� Y��`�'��� 1 = ' � a • '.:1 ..,�.i� a• ty, µ�., ',,� 9.> Ps✓.� .�. L�c� 6'..�., r"L�� �" h�.�. »L�t� . • .� ..�t •`�.� tti 4_ .. �.,� .. . .,�.i,'}P,y, .l��,�� ..�`'. ��� -t �� � �`- 4 r yr *�i:. Y'��' �,�, k,��r ' _.:st r Y "��� "� 4 v�i, r ♦ "�.`�� � ��s ` �:i7 h.`� �{'p '�.� ti:f" "+f a- .` �-�.. r � �C. *1M -^r' `���2 r�,,.3 � �,�.'� qu:' 4�� `AC" . 't'. . . � .,f•~�r .. � � .`Jt - � w '�� ��""` 't. '�Ict` -". x����.r '�"a'.t_.. � � ','�� �?�"`' -s'= � �� - f '���.e '���i' ':'i' r.�kd y'�,. � � e 3' Of��� r � . �j�'�` i �::.. •_ '�: 1'�'�� � i :.'d �'�-�,'�''i�'�rj'W'.;��^ ''�-.�l�� ��-..� Y`.' � . � • .� K t � � � , }.�� .�.�^Mli�^ ' �i,(�}� . � !'� 4 '.R'�.� _.�. ��t�..s.1 �e^'� r ..:. _ ��i ` y�,: °� . i.c '°�.Y� �� c_� ��i�i, _ _ �-ei '�� ,s'.r�*.���� � 1�. �,��� �� '�� �it�'�:y: •�-� � .a�' .. r.� ��r�ax:g� �+�a�r i "��,y`d , ., +-y4�a.�'�-.' �/c,t�-.�,� . ... 1 �-*�� �"+.4� �s�,�'3'�"�. � ',� �y ..'` &*. .}''"` a.. .�- ._ �,. . _ . �I'Rg�+,ltis.• . w� .� �'.µt� . rr� _ �4� • � ''� ��Pa�"'��'W f�.X ��'M� ` � . 1, . _ . .'3:. ., • � � � ���� ��'�� � �-�`` �"���``` .,�-' 6 r "' . � "��� .�: _ � ' � . .�•_ .�`y ,. `��. � �, . . �' - � a -iT.� � `• `�"'��� - - -+.,� - y"�`�`s . . � ' `-' '�i i '-N � ''� i:<� � � �v . ,,.�„ . ' � „� ,R�`�'`'�,� *w � � �..� `,'r. , �p �. , . `- -�:_ � ' y"'�4 �;`�'4ti5 e,�""`- .,.�tr" " , - � ,`„`r" �t�.. ' - - �"_ . ' _�;> �}.:. .� �- Ax.. ��'►. .,a ,:�y�1,,.\` - �' , ,�,P w��..�� 'ti.. �1� • � �!�.w "'-i "'+ ti.t.�'�a"�� f ;y. - , . , .. . Y 1►- a4 .r� w i,, ` , ..�.�,�r .� ' a ��q''�,�..- ; • /�rr r,; „�.. „_�<,�„� �n ' , i, <x; ��� •T �r, . " " !'fo' �� - ti► " '�� ��ai'+; �r- +'� � s_:.-: ,, ;c � .'� ,� �rr.i�. . . �'�" �.'x "�,� - - � ��;f `�'���'+.r'v . - '� �v .. `- �t - _ 7�„•�'/��-�- :r { '1 1��� l _.*. �. . `��.k��r�� .♦�k ' .� 1 . w` �•CK',�__ y -�.. . �--Y_ ��,��r.^-�c.�-_ +•• '�--+r �. e,r '. ""t '^ ': �.. +- +w��,`r�r.a'� �,' ~'�� e :,`�• r ��� �"�`� `�.1��h_�.�•+?'.���M�#ia.. ��',"� ��� :.� ,'^ t� : ' �--^�'"� y�": `a i. _ -.. .� �..'Ta �'{.�'Z..S - � . '�,`�sf"�,...�. . . � . �'.. + , �� � q_ ' _ __ �...-, ._ ... ,, ,., . ,, �,,....�.,. . , � i���.'� i.�"�fi.f= .. � ;;n.. . . 1 k�i,�`�- ��. � �' - '_�4.��� ^."�rF .{��,". i. � � .. . � ,-.-..r"" '' '�'-r'�'.�"���`�^i�-+�r. .:.,��. r:� tt - _� ' '�. " +'�� . _ �.. . . , ...,�. ,,� +. t��L'' �• -► `t i �. "R�„'r , . 7 , . -, �..�-.`� '"` >r' �Y's 's"' ��,F-•�-++.,�:���' ��"Sr��„1�r- , _ t.e� ��,�'' .,. �'.ttti:`,Y` ..� � .•� ,�,�,-.,t�,�4 - - � . ; 1 �'4 io���ti�Y i'�hp.: �j ��, �, �,�.,�-.' - .f� -r V'� .�'f,a"`-�. �- ��".+.=� . . _ �_ �.>> 'N�-�,� e4, r �lrn. _ . v .�' r '�t� � . _ .. ... ' . ' � _i:;i � „r, ^'y, a- . , . tf��4l{"f �� tf`"�����Y��fr -� �-+'�* �(�L��y~��� . - r g _-: ti,:. s } .. -,tie ik.,�'' 4�t�.� ,`�.�"1' +��-yk �'�r= `�+e' � �. , , -`l` . k �4 �[ ��k �.' R �.� i ... y � ti. 1� ,�.J '� � a�� Y �� �. � ���t'y�`i 1 a�. Jr� t�Y�F�f�S�f*�,�tr�'��`%i-�, "�- ��- �. - ` � �� . � �,� .. . _ _ r . Si<.,._ .�r,� �� `'.`�r'"�, . . , _ . . �µ,� . . , , ` , E ... '' .°« �x ,�.,. �., ,- � ' + f`'°< 4 +r�i. '��t ;� ��" ' _ . . � .'�` ♦ ..}Y ��r1'��� ����'r_+�'" i �''-a . . . " , . . � '_ � 1 1,4£ .�f.•.i V'i•hyt�, - j. ; �1! ,k! _M...yi� :I.. . . ' , ' "-rv���� � ' fi��� �'c�,T�'����'� � �, »1 ���� � , � �� �� � �� _ � �r� � � -� � � e4��M�;n,+,�\6j �\ '����; F. � � ' . ��.� •�� � ` t,� 1• � ��•Y}�ym y4}����h�� �. � �+,.' �'�• . � ��� . . , , 1 y, . . , +..� ,. �- x.��...,,s .,a 4.aY[ntit1.L`.ar�... 1�y�.�,ia�-3L-v,a.i.rt�. .,, .. :.:>-..._. . . _.: ..._.� . �. ...� ..... - _ .,. -,.,..�, -. . ,ti . . � +. . ���:, �� t r � ,1.� � -w�., , �; ��Y � f' : "'��� � � � ;t rl3�., ±ka� _ 1 �'. , � �,. ����x:, �I 1 �T �� �� ,�� ,� Y � n A� �¢ A� � . r � � y ,� ,'�� ��' �- r�� °�' , ,� � ��% �'+ � 'y�,t a �_; �'_ -a^} � ��. � y�I y .' • , ` �` ti!� '-�' ,�" ;,� + , ,�.�� _���� �. ° ",X ����� -"'{— ` " . � � 'ti�:.";�,, �, i Y'�' • � � �, r..."� '�G� � �` ► �. ;'- � , , �. �.��'��� � '�'� .'� �::� r .`-�, � � s� .,� -� �' � � { ;. �- , � i r � J � , , 1�� . - r � ,. ," ,�� � # ,�,� '� � <:� ' ,���, � y �' i. ;;, . w`�u�.\ � �,aY +�x.�V �, f� � t �- �� � ��4...����� .,� i .'` ' �J. 't� �•s ,. -. ` � .. �.�� ��`� -�� �.�� :� �.� :�� !"�� - ' , '`� ^ � , ,., ,.,�.- ` ��y ` ��� t A, � r '��`J I � � Y �� . `'.`�+ n t t%i�l Zl ,_, �S. 'J 1 '� � `i V '� , k ����@ �� ` �' r t�( '� j�r, `` ��C, .�`� � . ��. .� � �r� � �� i,�� � � � , . r' � � �� -'^ .,Z ° '� y '". ii �, w. � ,, f y� 'y� r� ' "��� 11;.�� �P•�'. . �� ��r � ... y�� .r,, �+►� `.`� ,��:; .� _ � � � 1 �; �./ x°�' � 4i� f .' .F� �� � '� �� �� '+ P' � 1 � . ' .'i� �*�-A .� '� '��^ ��' �� ��Y �� .. t ' I- . ' '�l'� O � " . � ' .� r ` �`, „r � , ,,, .��. 3�� � � �,.� �� �,. �� ��„� ` '<�, �i_ �� �; �\ ,�y,��,�9 a �! � 1� i � 4 �^ `A. j � • �? ��` ��.�` .. ,�. `�jl�� �r� �: � �T' <<. � v+�`^ aj.f -� +, 'r 7y � 1 i � . O � �� ::� m. \ �r P v, 1 { +i"� ��'� ..V,4�_�,L.,}'Y .tl �}�Y'�} •~ �i`,`� `�• ��- �'� �V.'�� f�� � � y:dy ��. lti . Li.�'. 'd a '�' `z ��? y'w`i..; ., r�` ';�;� , ;`: ;i l z�.. L �.�.�i i�� �'� 4� s. � * �'� � ��' �, �.� � ��f�y � �s�� `,� a; � . i� ' z� "� , � .., � � ,� `(� ,i� ' �, i ��; �,�. '�' \�*ti r' •� h.� J� `�•. � �p� :t��'��.: tr�' ��,�7 11'� i .! a'r^.: �. ,. "�� r-y;, ' ��i � �� '� Gc `"���� ' A.`' t�'�`.1�1��� ?" � r• ��� t t�,` � �i' , i y��„ �� � ' , `/ i �+, ' , t � ` i ). f" 7i �..,i:� �r '�►�►, : r� ,� . � ,� ,�� � i�+ ��..; `"� ;, i � f � �'�; , •���� � %' � —i ,,; � . �l+ ` . ���',��� �.. ' r�.�'� ��i �.,� 'i� Y f'�,�� . x`:;��,°� '`�-,,;�;'`.� t ,-{.,�� ` �'s�",.�L�, �' � ". �'� Y, .;:. •� .r ,�.-..;t.�� . j^:.s :�+• �t�� 1�. ��� o- .< '�.., .� •r � �� . � "" �' 3��i{� ��g�s�� � ��r � � '� '� »�����7� -:� �}��, ` #'`n �..�`. _ 7� ,d''' �. � , � .'- . �,� �•' ,�� O V�"'q�`'� w 'JrA�i� � ��" �, K� °'� � � a. J� f� "=���M�+t,. �QY..�, � �' yv ,�'9 , ,;y_, :., � y E' �' "�l � "�: � Y ��f��� ,� n �.. f y { , "'? . -"t �' a S a. r '�l. a"e < a a.\ ' ��.� l��.. � �'� �.;� �� t - a�a r ?�}��+?��^�t4y��'`'t�,V''� � i�� t •�f::�. � 4i J � � A . .. � �N ' Ys l i r l, ; ,� � �, � � J � t� �',�;�F�/t?�1 .r .'L�� `5 7{` .3 4r +t� ^l�,'{ <,�, . i('� � _ .i `� + '�:\, .�. .,d^ �� � � a µ�'� � .^ a � ;t . .�4, , , • .�,, �^ • ��}• ."�, �. � )�' � � t ���F � ,.� ? r� 1 � .. , � " f�'��������� y �r��., ,��, �,` '' - � � '.� .,��jy..� .t�3:; � i v ►�.!?�`t��` � ' t' s.� ' � ��� ! � ;: . , � � '+i s ej:' � !' ; ��'tf 5,��'1�'►�j ''�,�'���+>'� ``• ' c�;;�,� y 3 + `� �,p". . f/ "� . ;�• r : � �( �.; 'h�t _�� ���`-, ;�i ..��"yl��j�s.�� � i4 .t1�°,, f �r t��'* +j����` ?n �' ' �4� �1P°��' �r`:t�. �`,d '� . .a -.�ll • t+ I " � x���`� � - �a � � � i .. i n�= �'' ,.,. 'r i �, �1iF �.�i a.�, ��� T ��'' i � *�' � � ��� i, , �,k�t p �r +<. ��.n '!� r��, j � � .� �,�., � ' s �' . f��„�, � : �1 � ��; ,� 1 ;1 ` 7: 1°� 1't+�`16*�` ����`�"." '�` , � � ti' ,�'�. .i , . ,��ry�' � , ,�� � . �_� � S/�S�tt'J�x � �.�e .��� � \ I• � � ,,. ,,�) �. ri.'b; �fV�, +�, �'Xy j� ��'�� „;!� � , 7 ,.�1' ,� i � ' � t �l �r � !7'` � ' � a�p• � . � yy �� � � �'�: f � j�; � .♦ ` ' , �' ' `, �� 1 �'y,j,� ,� � ' r���. i �{�f .j.�y,��� J��'� �� , , � �� �a' � . �. E ' � t � � .� � �� � i h� ' � �; r � ; �Y �` �,5,,' � �� � .�,�i .��� � 5� (��� ��� � � �r.��j.���� � f k: < � � � '�y ' � �,s��� � ��`f �'.�3�`��' *s� ��`.� ��� l'�: , k. �i'�. '�'h'��1�1