The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About#5483-Hardcover variance/CUP � o� o , o ��-, ,,� C ITY of ORONO � � bl� "�',� 8�� G'� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL i- -� � L�kESI3�4 NO. J � b .:: A RESOLUTION GRA.NTING A HARDCOVER VARIANCE FROM MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE SECTION 78-1288 AND A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR LAND ALTERATIONS WITHIN THE 0—75 FOOT SHORELAND ZONE PER SECTION 78-966 FILE NO. 06-3205 i�V�IEREAS, Mary J. Jundt and James R. Jundt, wife and husband, (hereinafter "the owners") are the owners of the property located at 1400 Bracketts Point Road within the City of Orono (hereinafter the "City") and legally described on Exhibit A attached to this resolution; and WHEREAS, the owners have made application to the City of Orono for a variance from Orono Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-1288 to allow replacement of the fourth set of lake access steps on the property; and WHEREAS, the owners have made application to the City of Urono for a conditional use permit per Orono Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-966 to allow grading within the 0-75 foot shoreland zone to create a path for a wheelchair adj acent to these steps; and WHEREAS, after due published notice and mailed notice in accordance with Minnesota Statutes and the City of Orono Zoning and P1aruling Codes, the Orono PlamZing Commission held a public hearing on June 19, 2006, at which tiine all persons desiring to be heard concerning this application were given the opportunity to spealc thereon. NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono, Minnesota: FINDINGS 1. This application was reviewed as Zonina File �06-3205. PaUe 1 of 5 � o� 0 0 � ��a.,-, � C ITY of ORONO � ' 3.�,�,, � n1 � ' `� RESOWTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL ti ��`�kESH�4�G NO. 5 � � � 2. The Plarulin� Commission reviewed this application at a public hearing held on Juue 19, 2006 and recommended approval of the variance based on the following findings: a. The proposed steps would replace a set of steps approved in Zoning File # 94-1867 that have deteriorated. An asphalt path to those steps approved in Zoning File # 95-1992 has already been removed. b. The hardcover associated with the new steps would be less than the hardcover associated with the existing steps. c. The proposed steps would have less visual in�pact than the existin� steps. 3. The Planning Commission also recommended approval of the conditional use permit for land alteration within the 0-75 foot shoreland zone based on the following findings: a. The grading will provide a path that will facilitate access to the dock Uy persons using wheel chairs and person who have difficulty negotiating stairs. b. There will be no hardcover associated with the path. 4. The City Council has considered this application including the findings and recommendations of the Planning Commission, reports by City staff, coinments by the owners and the public, and the effect of the proposed variance on the health, safety and welfare of the commtmity. 5, The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this property are peculiar to it and do not apply generally to other property in this zoning district; that g-ranting the variances would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor pose a fire hazard or other dan�er to neighborin� property; would not merely serve as a convenience to the o��ners, but is necessary to alleviate a demonstrable hardship or difriculty; is nEcessary to preserve a substantial Pa�e ? of� � o� o _��, _., o �,,�� CITY of ORONO ��-� � � � �5�,�� ,� �'' � G'� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL r �`�kEST�I04��' N0. J � � .5 property right of the owners; and would be in keeping with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan of the City. CONCLUSIONS, OR.DER AND CONDITIONS Based upon one or more of the above findings, the Orono City Council hereby grants variances to Orono Municipal Zoning Code Sections 78-350 and 78-1288 to allow replacement of the fourth set of lake access steps on the property, subject to the following conditions: 1. Cotmcil approval is based on the site plan submitted by the owners and aru-iotated by City staff, attached to this Resolution as Exhibit B. Any amendments to the site plan which are not in confonnity with City codes will require further Planning Commission and City Council review. 2. Hardcover associated with these stairs shall be limited to 167 square feet. Owners are advised that any firture requests to increase hardcover or change the nature of existing/approved hardcover shall require City approval, and increases in hardcover will not likely be approved without concurrent reduction i�� existing hardcover. 3. Once the existin� steps have been removed the variances granted in Zoning File # 94- 1867 for the steps and in Zoning File # 95 -1992 for an asphalt path to these steps shall tenninate. 4. Authorities granted by this resolution nm with the property not with the owners, but are permissive only and must be exercised by obtaining a building pennit for the new construction within one year of the date of Council approval, or the variance will expire on that date (June 26, 2007). 5. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this resolution shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically terminate any authority granted herein, and shall be punishable as a misdemeanor. 6. The undersigned owners have read, understand and hereby agree to the ternis of this resolution and on behalf of the owners and the owners' heirs, successors and assigns, hereby a�ree to the recordin; of this resolution in the chain of title of the property. Page 3 of� � O � p �, O �� .�-,, ^, � CITY of ORONO � � da j �',� `� G'�' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL �`�kEsK��'� No. 5 4 8 � Based upon one or more of the findings noted above, the Orono City Council hereby grants a conditional use pennit per Municipal Zoning Code Section 78-966 to allow grading within the 0-75 shoreland zone per the grading plan attached to this Resolution as Exhibit B and as annotated by City staff, subject to inclusion of erosion and sediment control details on the final plans. Adopted by the Orono City Council on the 26t�' day of June, 2006. ATTEST: � ,� �� _. ; ��! �,�' ��„/�, � � �,1��(:��%E..��,(`' :..,�!-�((.�..�G-��`;��-; '� � � Linda S.�Vee, City�Clerk Barbara A. Peterson, Mayor i � I�� , i"� �,w �,�� '��41.r.. , � �,.�,.�.t_j,.��.t: L%r/r Mary J:,,und� • James R. Jundt STATE OF MIN1vESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN The foregoing instnlment was acknowledged before me on this,�;xi, day of'��!,�, - �. , 2006 by Barbara A. Peterson, Mayor of the City of Orono, a Minnesota municipal cozporation and said instrument was executed on behalf of the City. �� i, ��:�� r ! <�:,f;/ , I��otaiy P�iblic' '. � , /i . c,a�r.y'�`�r,..'..�.,F..p,..=.:�n..,.c��,7..'J'�,a�..I Ah�'d�iV�I1IiA �. p�� -�� , � �;;; �;��UNG ,� : �' ;;ir��fecota a �� ,;: , f s.:ur�31,2C10 :,!`'k`:,f2;�itj�d.,a�..^y�:�d'v'�f"!w'��iv'dvV'b'�lLr�`�yl�.�'. Page � of� � o� o ,, o ��>�i-:�� CITY of ORONO � ��, � � �'�" ti .�� G RESOLUTION OF TH j�T� C��OUNCIL `9kESI3�4 N 0. STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HEi�NEPIN The foregoing instrument was acicnowledged before me on this �_'day of � � . ; � 2006 by Linda S. Vee, City Clerk of the City of Orono, a Miiuiesota municipal corporation and said instniment was executed on behalf of the City. �<;>•�m.�_._ . ' `� RACHEL DODGE � - ,. �, <F , ;l,1"ARY PUBLIC-MINNESOTA NOtaTy PUbI1C �� ,:,mm�ssion Expires Jan.31,2010 STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN This instrument was acknowledged before me this�day of l� , 2006 by James R. Jundt, husband of iVlary J. Jundt. .��n��., BARBARA G. SiLUS �� '��'` NOTARY PUBLIC-MINNESOTA �;�:`� My Commission Ezpires Jan.31,2008 Notary Public _�.� STATE OF MNNESOTA COLNTY OF HENNEPIN This instrument was acknowledged before me this_day of - , 2006 by Mary J. Jundt, wife of James R. Jundt. -.;:!�::�:�,.�'.�'"' ` �„ � �y;�:� ��ACHEL DGDGE _. ' �� 3'-�, NUTARYPUBLIC-MINNESOTA ,.�,,,�r Notary Ptlblic ` `�'i'��;.`�' !,F;Ccmmission Expires Jan.31,2010 � .... :.�>->;�,�,��--� , Pa�� of� 54 � � E�hibit A ��,a,f L�ES�'RI�7'I�I� �� PRFI�ISES Si1R�YR1�: (r�te 5 er�.d t�, khnrrnn,?w,ment u� Orqr�a P��inL; Also• thn,t �x�, r�i. Ir��,s 5 �.nc� 14, Rr�nxr�ar�emr,nt ��i �ranr� �r,int �nd , � � � �� S�SLi�r;��1y �.r�cl Gaat�r�.� ,�f t�.+s f�ll�u Lu� bu�.i�a1:i�:.rt+� t��.r.Li� 1'�tu� in� dear,rik��d linN: CcsmmyncinE �.t a ��1rit in �hy c�ntFrlinF af C,�ntFr AT�fnuF �',�P,95 fr,ct narthcrlY fram th�: Nr�rthwceterlY ��nEr of [tat ''�, EtF�xrrdr,�emr,nt t,f Oronq ��int; �hrr.r,��; eputtl�r�1Y aZan� �nid aer�tr.rliz�e � rlist�.ncc a� J fFH'C� tltr.n�e e4uths��t�r1Y uri a ' tif,x�?e'nti�.l r�urv� tr� the rlght wit�'� n� radit�e r�f ��1, 17 fFFt h. d�e- tn.ncp r,t 169.3� iFyt; thEnr,F squthw9eth�'ly t�t�et�t tr� �h,id l�..e� dh8r�rib�f� aurvF n. diatr�z�cr. r�f � f��t; :th�nc:e er�uthwc�th��.Y �n b, tnn�pntihl r.urvr, t�� tti�p rig.ht n rihrliuc q: 44��.7� fr,�t, �, ��iet�4f-" pf 119.!� �nFt; thence ��uthw�etrrly tfinBFY�t 'tU ea1��.1 1�st d.F- � scriYx�d �surv�: n r�iatb.ncc uf iQ7.� fE�t; thanr;F �r,o�t�r1Y a�sk�.nE � �1r af �4 d�:¢rr.r:s 42 tni'nutbs to thy ri�r�t r� ��i$�tyr�r,�F pf 79.3 feet t�� thF gYwre af L�ke MinnCt��rikb, �d '�hFrF tr,zmin�.tinE; eu��- 3eoL ti�� &,�dcr Avcn�.c e� o�n�d �ry U�x,via�:nt ru�, 2�}92��8; Alao thgt �crt uf v�.c�tad C�nter AvenuF �u s�1r� C,�ntpr Avrnue w�. dhdi��tcd tc� 'tri� �ublfa �.ri thc vl�.t �if kr�.rr�sx�eF��ttt r,,f r�r��ri� � pr,int, lYi'n� �outhrr].y af tt� wgatr.rly'�ex��neiun r�f ,tY�ti r��rtnrrlY linp r�f t��t. 4. eai�l Et�xrr�rYBcmcnt o� �nr� Pair�t, nr:d n��rt�h9r?.Y �f n, lir�e r3�r�fs.wn u��tierly i�rW�'nf�ir�ul�.r ta t,Y�; W�et l�nnr�rtf,t'l�rlY t�f,w4 fY�am h, T��i'�it r�rt ��.id Neat li.r1E diatnnti 18...�9 f�;F. thp ec�uT,h�rF�� F•r�rnF�� a� s�siri Lnt 4; hlar� thr�t �rt, pf th� W�stcrlY hv.l� �f var�r�trr� �.rntwr Avcnuti lYin3 sauthF:'1y ai e�id. r�Yx�v� ��e- �criy.rLta ��rr��ir:U1�r l�.n�; br�d ai5�1 ti'cvrt Y:;��:t nf tY.e wNat�t•d.Y t�lf af vn.r,�r�.,�,ect C�n��;r Avw,nu� �Y�-� r1e,rthFr>>I a� the t7�eterlY �X- taz�ior► af th�; north�rily Linr: af �slcl L,r�t �4 e�::nd lYihR $��utYuSY'lY of �. lir�� d.x�nwn �netcrlv �.t ri�ht �l�s l�tr� th.b wh�tht`1Y �lin+� vf shid va�at�d CFnt�r Av�,nup fr�um thF �int o� ir.t�rawrti.f�n �f b�.id wwst- crLy Xin� wit�� a line dr�wr� ?0 ieht �r�st�rlv. s�f t'r�p followi,�8 dF- acri'r�d 1in�: C�bn�in�c at ti W�int in the cen�prlirie af �aid �sr.-- ter Av�r,�e diatnnt 588.�E�. �g�t northcrlY �:�� th� nort��w�atc�r1Y r.orinrr �f s�1.d �t 5: thbnch eouth,�rly �.lon.� e�iid renterl�r� a tli�try.ncp of � f�et to th� p�int af Y�ginnin� af t,"�� 1.inP b�i':� de- scrfberl; th�nc� aauthueetcrly g1r�n� a t�nEenti�.1 �ui'vF to tha right WiLh a radi�s r�� 221.i7 fcet a dist�*:�e �f 1�9,38 fett, br.d said lir�H thhr� ending. ' 5 � S :� A1.�� 'I'r,�t F�art uf vacated Sord�r Avenue a� laid aut and dedicatad ovdc �nd aaraea �art of i.�t 9 in said RearrBnge��:n�, 4f Qrona Poitlt which l��e bctween the weaterly lin� af a�id C'�nt�r Avr.nu� and a �� .a� c�,��m ecroes said Sor�dar Av�nue at ri�ht at�les co the eide Iinee af egid Border Avertue from thP ��nt at int�rt�eetion of � t�@ c�nterli.Y:� of e�id Bo:der Avent�e s�ith n line dcacribud aa fal�- lowa; �e�innit�.B at � �o3nt �n t'heh oor�tarlinm o! o�id Cant.�z� A�rw enue dietant 558.95 feet northtrlY af the nnrthrreat cor�taz' o� as�.� �,p�t 5; thcnce southerly along th� cent�erlin� ot �ai,d C.�nter Ayo�s�e ' a d;.stance of 5 feet; thence s�uthar7�Y and s�uthwasterlY g�Qn6 g tan�anti.al curv� to the right �ai�.h a radi�zs of �L1.17 feet a dic- tancc af 1fi9.38 fees; th�ncc SouthWeet9K'1Y t�s.nBerit ta �nst aaid cutwvc a diet8nce of 5 feet; th�tsc� �authuesterly alone a tan�en- �ti�l cuz�ve to the rl�hy �ith a r�di�e of 445.7� foo� e d�,ataz�ca of 119.� fo�t; th�nae sauthW�oterly �an�ent to laat eaid eurve a diatance of 147.30 feet; �hence �outhwe�terlY �?otzB a �$nti�1, curvc to th� left with t� radtitzn d� 56 fe�et a dietance oi 14.7 _ ' f��t, ther.ca south�rlY ta�ent to la�t �&id curvc a digtance oi 6,$ fcet; �hence aoutherlY alonB � tanBenLial cu�'e to the left With a radiu� of Y69.7 feet a dietenae of 53.8 feet; t�anc� ecuth- er1Y t��nt to last deacrib�d curva a distance af 20,�� teet; thence eou�herly an a tan�ential ctirve to thc left with s z'adiue of 78. �. feet to it� intereection with the c�t�Lerl�.z�e of aa�d BorY dr,r AvrnuP, �nd eai�� linr tlterf endin�.. , �� - 10.0 -- ' Jundt _ —� � � 1400 Bracketts Point -----� 167 sq ft treads �= Chilton Treads with landings �2 sq ft control box 179 sq ft total �941.5 23 sq ft � � . �.- � ,:� 941 I 18 sg ft: �" �`\ �,="� •',� ,�..-'. .'r,'l:�a�.:::�ti�i::�.;�;: I �r�:;;\ 939 _%`� _ .-_. . - ,. . _: - _ � ,= � -. . _- -- `.:\ . -. 938�_ - � �. �•' � . . �19.5 sq ft � ;_;�;:>,: ��"_ - -- . O r�� ss7 937 _ —' " d' — _ �- N 937 937 —_ ,�—'` s _�—� 935 SOd _ _=' �� 936 -- � Handicap Path to dock �—� � 935 �� %� --'— 934.5 � g34(-�) 934.5 % � 21.8 sq. ft: __ '� 934.5 � � I 933 1 I I l�� m � � � � � � � __r�—�' e.-t i—� side view of stair system � 1— --J- _J— CJ 1 1,.L I —____�______________ � ...'___— _ "___.__ �