Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout#555 Scanned FileTHIRD JEANNE A. MABUSTH ______________________ being duly sworn makes complaint to the abo~ named Court and says that he believes this i11formatwn and other pe~som from whom it is obtained to be reliable and that probable cause exists to tupport a waffant of arrest Jo, Cortlen G. Cloutier · · 2480 CASCO Point ROad, Wayzata, MN 55391 Jo, the Jollcwinf reasom: I am the Zoning Administrator for the City of Orono. I run. familiar with the facts conatituting these offenses through personal involvement and inspection and through a review of City record•, . • which include reE)("lrta and documents prepared by Building Inspector Thomu J. Jacobs and City Planner Al Olson. The defendant, Cort.an G. Cloutier, ia the owner of residential property located at 2480 ·.· · CUco Point Road, within the City of Orono. In May 1971 . the• datend~ ant obtained a building permit to allow construction .of a single:"'.'.-.. .. story boathouse on his property, estimated to cost approximately·:-• $500.00. Later that year Mike Scheller, then building inepector, visited the defendant's property, and, finding that a single-story . . boath.-:>use approximately 18' x 34' had been completed, he concluded that construction was finished. . On or about March 26, 1980, Building Inspector Thomas ·J. · · Jacobs received a report that construction was occurring on .defend---. ant'• property. Mr. Jacobs visited the property and observed.:-that the boathouse structure waa being renovated. By that. time, the : , ■tructure had been expanded to include a second story enclosed.·.: .. _ room approximately 18' x 20'. Additional construct.ion wu· being:· done on the remainder of the second stoey 1 it appeared that · a · ■creened porch wu being added. There also was a deck. around part . of the structure, making the total ground level dimensions approxi~,, ... mately 24 • x 35' • Mr. Jacobs issued a stop work C)rd,e,i:,-,t~-!? · '· ··,. · ·· building permit had l:>een obtained ,fo · · . -~l~r,IJ:gii•ci*hi=~.:~-~ . &•. ·· in ;,:~ni•-···· · · · , 9,.~": , ru~\\ s o.ry:,•truature approximately 20' .x 30 ,'.i•,an:•~,·, .. : non•conf ormin9 uae. . . . . .'.'· . ~) }Q ·;t,~{?~tc::::;e: .. tf.:.:i/:'~i:}t ·.-: 2 ~: ... ·. . .·· On or about November 4, 1980, Mr.:·Jaoob• receiv•4,ai~P9~/'.: ,'.,/ •·. that construction was occurring on the· roof of the''de,fendant~•!-j1i-c.~'1~; ??(: garage and houae. Mr. Jacob• viaited the defendant'a,Jprope.;ty)aijcf} Y:~ , , , found that· the roof of the garage and the roof;.of.:th•}~,•-~,4'~•::}1:,:'.· <::,:·.>:,, :both being repaired. Mr. Jacob• i••ued a' •top •worJt;-;"orM;J:;~uino/.'.';,'i:-ft ,(('. \:.building, permit had bean obtained tor thi•'construction:~i~t;y;::'fJ{;."f :;,;,_, •, · defendant applied for a building permit for•i-thi•r;con•:tr,ucf:!Qnit:~n -~,,;(t •' :. iwhich he acknowledged that the e•timated(consu-uctionJ~•l•~•••·:l\/~;~' ·u 00 •00 -. '.. . e , ;~-:-~·/'./~::_i~;-::/~ft{ft11~£:·~·~~-.iI; On or about January· 28, 1981, Hr:~·::Jacob•:,again~ii:~ived.a·",;j:•,r report that construction wu occurring on· defen~nt~.•~PrQPIIJ:~.-.: )•{..::~ .. - Mr. Jacobs vi ■ited the property and ob ■erved,~hat\,a~ct~al;t:,1:•~.':(>;:V~ vation wa• being conducted on the defendant!• gara9e.i/~1i.~~•1:,ntly.\:::::r.: the defendant was installing concrete slabs, ;,repairing<•,nftera:,:-j:o ·,ttJ . the garage, and replacing windows and-door•./ ~.;'~Jac.~•iJ;is.~cli'a-,;tt;t:fa. atop work order, a ■ no building permit hadlbeen".:o~taiu4ff9.~ft.his'':f{r\ . con ■truction. On or about February 2,·.1g-sl•/.i;he 'def•n~tfappl~ed.j~, . . . tor a, building . permit to .-allow; thia ·:renovation ;L1in;·lf.btch{J>..e:::~~f. :(t;, . ·. edged that the . ••timated value of, tbe(renoyati.on.,c ............ -1 · •:-.-. ~;t}~::;,:Jc:~~i~:.;,,,i''~,Ysf ,~~%~t~~if :;~;!'~·~.:: . . . .. O'Fl'ENSES count Ia Baaed upon the foregoing, your complainant states that .on or ibout March 26, 1980, within the corporate limits of.the -City of Orono, the defendant, Cortlen G. Cloutier; then.and there· did willfully, wrongfully, and unlawfully.violate oroni, City zoning Ordinance S31.881 by expanding, changing, enlarging, andaltering ft~~n-conforming •tructure in a way that increa•~• it• non-conform-- Count II1 Based upon the foregoing, your complainant •tat~• that on or al:iout March 26, 1980, within the corporate limit• of·the · City of Orono, the defendant, Cortlen G. Cloutier, then and there. did willfully, wrongfully, and unlawfully viola 4:e Orono City zoning . Ordinance 532.260, by altering a •tructure without ~irat obtaining a building permit indicating that the ald.•t.i.ng at;J:'uctau::•. oomplL~~:;, '.'''" .-:.r ff~Af~~z/~~\;~:,~~ing·. cod~~ ll!ld ·411-•.~~~~l;~{t):,,\1~tiltif" ,. .. 'f?•i·t."~~;~ '"• < :;f'i}J({Ji ,,)':;,count"'tII i<·.·sa ■e4 .upon· -the,iforego~1'9.l'~l'~-t~PIIP.~~. · ._.}l.i,i ':"-::~on or~.about·~Mardt::26, .,1,eo ,.~.w.ithin~~,~~~{l,.j, · ,-,~,- ··;\Cit.y:,of. Orono,,._the:;defendmit,-.;~rt.l4i1f.G~JC?l9u~f•~t~·-,. '-':,", ~.t;dJ.4,tvillf ully,. WJ:On9fully, ., anc!:7 un1Mfl~~Y~'i',1.ol~te_t@. -:;,'?,Code' 1301.(a) ,.:by, oon•truotin9,:.:enlu9.inq';'t'i&Jld!.~lte \:';:~,;;_wJ.thout .. fir•t obtainin9 a, t,uilcling penait~).:;;,;:.:·;,r/1:.• .... -.• c.·,,,,, •:.:::,-:·--::/: •' ~ , , r• ' ••• :, • ••• ; _ ••• , : --:_ • ~---•' • :-~-,'\;2~/oo_:;:-\~·:.-,-;:~~~t:f..';~--?~¾:;?t.~f~{~~{(,·;r:-\a;/~:9::;_~t£~~:~~-:~:·~.:3~-~-..:-1:., -t -;:--~:·\~i::- ~:::: ·::,: count ·tva:. Baaed upon the· .fore9oin9, ~_your·· complai~t'.~at.u;••;;~t:t&J~:;: ~::~: :. ¥i.~'.':~:on,.or. about -Howmber ,, 1980i withinJ:be~:.co,:porat&t;:i•J.~~{9f..:d:~~-~~t:~i~.~: ~~i: ;,;;:":.'t'"-. Cit. ;;of orono, .. he. defendant, ·Cortlen·=a;: Cloutier,.:,::than·111nd?the3,fr~--1;t ._c.;; ;;z.:r;-;:./'· willfully r wr0n9fully, and unlawfully violat.e,:Q%'ono:-~it.y'{fi/';.',~-:;,~'£'~: ..• l --· .,Jllfdi nee 132.260, by altering a •tructure without.•~~-~:t}~~ -~--;,~~:• \ . ;::;,.;..,.-:~;~-· ding permit. · -· ::.:..,>x.~;.:;.,·;_, ~:::,':""••'.:~•~-"---~- -._(, .,,,:,,_ ' ... ~.· ' ' ,.... . ... . .. . . . 0 ~ ; •~f\lf1'}'9rrt \('.,\( t v, Based upon the foregoing, your complainant·statea aif .. on or abOut November 4, 1980, within the corporate limits of e .city of Orono, th• defendant, Cortlen G. Cloutier, then and there did willfully, wrongfully, and unlawfully violate Str.te Building· Code f30l(a), by conatructing, enlarging, and altering a structure :without obtaining a. building permit. City-of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 1392 A RESOLUTION APPROVING AN AFTER-THE-FACT APPLICATION OF CORTLEN CLOUTIER FOR VARIANCES AND A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT TO PERMIT LAKESHORE IMPROVEMENTS OF A PROPERTY LOCATED AT 2480 CASCO POINT ROAD WHEREAS, the City of Orono is a municipal corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of Minnesota; and WHEREAS, pursuant to State Stat~te 412 et. seq., the City Council of the City of Orono has adopted zoning regulations for the protection of the public health, safety and welfare; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 31.700 of the Orono Zoning Code, Cortlen Cloutier, hereinafter referred to as the applicant, has been required to file an application for a conditional use permit for constructing a retaining wall along the lakeshore of his property legally described as Lots 1, 3 and 4, Block 1 and Outlot 1, Tillson's Villa Carman, hereinafter referred to as the property; and WHEREAS, pursuant to Section 31.831 of the Orono Zoning Code the applicant has been required to file a variance application for excavating, filling, construction of a retaining wall and for the proposed construction of an access stairs, all of the aforesaid improvements are located within 75 feet of the lakeshore; and WHEREAS, the City Council has reviewed· the application, the recommendations of the Planning Commission and the Orono Staff and the comments of the applicant. NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of the City of Orono hereby approves a conditional use perrni t and variances for the construction of a retaining wall, excavation, filling and for the proposed construction of an access stairs for Cortlen Cloutier based on one or more of the following findings of fact: 1) The applicant erected a retaining wall without the necessary permits along the outer edges of a sand beach to prevent erosion of the steep banks into the defined beach area. 2) The construction of said retaining wall required the excavation or cutting into of the bank and the placing of excess fill within 0-75' of the lakeshore. 3) The erection of the 30" high retaining wall will permit permanent plantings and seeding of the steep banks. 1 of 5 City of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 1392 4) The wall, constructed of timbers and limestone, will serve to support the disturbed bank and prevent further erosion. 5) The City Engineer has inspected the site and wall construction and recommends that the wooden timbers be continued approximately 8 feet at the east edge of the wall affording the neccessary support to the disturbed bank. 6) The applicant will erect a wall of limestone only along the remaining sand beach area and connect to rip rap along the shoreline. 7) To require the removal of the retaining wall in its present state would cause greater environmental harm. 8) The applicant will rip rap the entire shoreline of the property to prevent further erosion. 9) The property has no defined lakeshore access. 10) The approach to the lakeshore is inhibited by steep, irregular banks requiring an access structure for safe access. 11) The construction of the access structure will be supervised by the Orono staff to assure the construction is consistent with the environmental standards of the Orono Zoning Code and Comprehensive Land Use P~an. 12) The access structure will run from the top of the bank and stop at level grade approximately 25' from lakeshore. 13) Council finds no problem with the proposed grassed sitting area along the northeast side of the boat house as long as the improvement will not involve disturbance of the lakeshore banks or req~ire permanent or temporary hardcover. 14) The special conditions applying to this property are peculiar to such and do not apply generally to other land in the district in which this property is located. 15) The approved lakeshore improvement plan for the property is found to be consistent with the intent and objectives of the Lakeshore residential zoning district (LR-lC) and the environmental sections of the Orono Comprehensive Land Use Plan. 2 of 5 City of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. -~1~3~9~2~--- FURTHERMORE, BE IT RESOLVED that based on the aforesaid findings the City Council of the City of Orono hereby approves the variances and conditional use permit of Cortlen Cloutier subject to only the lakeshore improvements described on the site plan dated July 6, 1982, page 5 of this resolution and as specified below: 1) Access structure to be constructed from top of lakeshore bank and extend to level grade. Type of construction subject to staff review. 2) 30" high limestone wall with timber structure supports may be continued 8' along eastern edge and limestone rip rap connected to ends of retaining wall until it connects with lakeshore rip rap. 3) Rip rapping of the entire shoreline per standards setforth by the DNR. 4) Grassed sitting area to east of boat house must not involve permanent or temporary hardcover nor additional disturbance of the lakeshore bank. 5) Prior to the commencing of improvement work, hay bales mn.st be placed along the shoreline. Any violation of this resolution or failure to comply with all conditions will be considered a violation of the zoning ordinances of the City subject to full prosectuion therefore. Adopted this 12th Orono City Council. ATTEST: C--d~{~ -~ l Alberta M. Strom, City Clerk 3 of 5 City of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 1392 I have read and understood the above resolution and agree on behalf of myself, successors and assigns that the use of the above described property may be so regulated by the City of Orono and agree to the filing of a copy of this resolution in the chain of title to my property. STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ss. The foregoing instrument was acknowledged byfore me this day of J .. 4 -<4 , 19 8 2 , by C PVTU:zcc./(°1de-&Zu.d 4 of 5 \ I \ l \ 5 of 5 . \ \ \ \ ' ) I I I I I I , I i I i l ! .• CLOUTlEH & Muis.i:;cu ATTOMNr:Ytt AT LAW CoMTL&M 0, CLOUTl,:M JA..ME• .~. J"-1U•£.cH TasOM.A.• J, lll••""" blC .\11uwz:i.T PLA:U. BUJLl)JN'O UOI N1coL.LJ:T ,"iAJ-L ,\ilNN'CAl'OL.llt, MINNl:IJOTJ\ 0040W City of Orono P.O. Box 66 Crys·:al Bay, MN 55323 A1"I'N: ,ln,rnno A. :--l<lbUsth July 9, 1982 Zoning Admini1:1trutor Dear Jeanne: Thank you for your letter of ,June JO, 1982, wherein you enclosed a copy of the oite plan as revised per your undcrstanJing of the di~ectivcs of the Council. It appears that you have added to the plan some additional "rip rap" on both sides ot the beach area and have set forth on the plan that the access stairs end at the ~rade level. I have no problem with tha stairs, but I am concerned about the possibility of endiny up with sonw further misunderstanding as to what is meant by "rip rap". lt has always be1ln my under:;t .. rndin<l that rip rappinq ffit:;><1ns a foundation or sustain1nq wall •.H' stones thr,;wn toq,~tlwr without. any specific order (as in deep w<1ter or on cJn <'.:mbankment sloµt~ to prevent erosion). lt has always been my desire to use lime­ stone for the decorat1vu Wdll around the beach area and that the limestone be laid in a somewhat orderly b~t random-appearing fashion 30" or less high from the area starti.iy where.y91.1 .have .. , designated "steps to beach" all the way aro.un<l. th~~·b§'.£lf~ia.rea(to .··.·· ... the shoreline on the east side of the beach~:~ The: U~~$tooe.;A:.pat.:,: __ ·:?: I have purchi"sed for that purpose could just{~.::i,, .. " · · ,,, · , ¢1<:},'.~'<>~''' rip rapping thd shoreline. It,.\l!A~i-· bQWiptj!l~' · · i;tz:J?:: . .'. as the rip;:rap for th&lJJho~eline./~~J;cjf:, , .. ,,,, 'Pe"\i? ,,;im•;t, . ..:;j~:;ti:;_~hat.J;;~ve · had on th9:~pr9,pe;-tY.;jJ~~~,¥~f4if' .. ~, . ,., ,·~:-J;'.-'i''-'#;}~;troet"•·of;,tbe two. types~,of:0 stone,,•,wi'1!':~e~nce.. . _ , ..... ~:t;;'.:~{<lakefront~;:.v.,~What I am· att':'mpting.to COllVey,:to y<.>u:;'i~;,t~.t:,\it:,' ; ::,,"'"{.~'./:1ffly; desire> tcr. have .. the ,_en tl.re · l~kesnore./.andt-be~«?:t:,_:~r,~/ ~!:P-~J;,~, {f );cit:.fromt,thei;land, with,,a .. borde~, of stone,0J:>ut~that\J..t;i~S;Jt\Y.~e:tJ.t ,;1;,,··· nlyf,~.r i P,:: rap"· ( wi ~h .'.•tone a;; thrown· together. 0 _wi th!?.~t\9~$J!it: "1,r0 • ak!S•h(>,re,;.<mly •. _-:; I woul,d . the Uineat~?t1(.~.a1;_,,,;..;._~_ ,}~4;l; . ·1~1;t:;·~.'.t:. •· : j;\t'5t{Ji':t;~tr . , . .Ji, ' . CLOUTIER & Musl':CH - Jeanne A, Mabusth July 9, 1982 page 2 separate the land from rhe sandy beach, in a morn 01derly appear­ ance. If I am not making myself clear 01, this, I will be happy to stop by your office and discuss it with you personally. • Cloutier CGC/ves . ; l !· TO: Walter R. Benson FROM: Jeanne A. Habusth DATE: June 9, 1982 SUBJECT: #674 Cortlen Cloutier, 2480 Casco Point Road - "After the Fact" Conditional Use Permit & Variance Area -3 acres Zoning District -LR-le Application a) Ordinance 31.831 Lakeshore Setback Variance reri_uired = 75' proposed stairs= ap~roximatelv 30' - variance of 40' or 53% proposed wall= 10' variance of 65 1 or 87% b) Ordinance 31.700 -~onditional Use Permit for construction of retainin~ wall and excavation and filling on nrooerty. List of Exhibits Exhibit A -Application Exhibit B -Property Owners List Exhibit C -Plat Map Exhibit D -Survey Exhibit E -Prosecuting Attorney's letter Exhibit F -Hennepin County Municinal Court Prosecution SUIM\ary Exhibit G -Engineer's letter of April 19, 1982 Exhibit H -Artist's Sketch Exhibit I -Site Plan Exhibit J -Planning Commission minutes of Hay 17, 1982 Background on Application On July 15, 1981, staff was advi~ed of excavation ~ork being done along the lakeshore of th~ Cloutier residence. Staff issued a stop work order advising nwner to contact staf.f immediately and obtain the necessary pe1mits. Cloutier had constructed a retaining wall approximately 30" high dividing a sandy beach and the grassed. area. A pile of fill was placed along .the lakesho+e•:o'"'",.pwne. · · explained the proposed work>was ,to protect an .exiJ.#iniitsa?,i.cf from the eroding grassed bank·· to. the i:mmediatec:;.rear_;\~?f~e( fill consisted of portions. of soil rel~as~.y·c:µtt -;; •:, ., , " bank .and,,; the, sand ,, from· the beach ,_rea •·1;tJJ;.'n1t~~· . · · ·:;{,-:::;: _and ha.y·bale•• inatalfed~1,t1~q119,;\:the;YJ.~esho;e_~; t:i .,~Il\, 'c,•,: ~-:: :::i~~il J~ -~~'.;,~-t~•c;,/~~~ ,;1~~•;_~t-,-•:: ~,~0:?:~'.:-tt:Ii:~1?~~:~fif;iJtli:· ,t}~~ · ;. .., ·. ·ptatf~.;,iaaud?a.caitat:ionr_the~,fp):1~,in9'i / 'Cl~i•~·'i•Jponditi?tal, · use ,~~~.t:7t~PP hA..t· .. ye;ar:.it,~Clouti,_'9~:·pl,e_adeflinot,'g,9\li:l .. :··•!Ill JJSJ.'i ·· · .¢/ar,t~,; . t674 Cortl~n Cloutier Page 2 Conditional Use & Variance During these many months of discussion, the resolution of the boat house and the pending "after the fact" application for the lakeshore improvements have been linked together. The attorney and staff had encourage this approach and we were certain that Cloutier clearlv understood this connection. At the first review meetinq of Application #674 in April, Mr. Cloutiec asked that the application be pulled from the agenda dfter reading my memo that placed as a condition of approval removal of the second story of the boat house. Review Exhibit r -In that court summary, it was aqreed that the two matters were to be r~solved separatelv. The Planning Commission was asked to omit any mention of the boat house in their review on May 17, 1982. The Prosecuting ~tcu:ney has advised the City staff. to proceed with the criminal tagging of Cloutier on the boat house violations as opposed to a civil action. Three tags were issued on June 2, 1982, one for building co~e violations and two on zonin~ code violations. Staff asr.s once again that we limit all discussion to the current "after the fact" application for lakeshore improvements. Review of Current Proposal The total improvement plan will consist of the followinq: (review exhibit 1) 1 -Rip rap of shoreline -rip rap to be continued up to each edge of the existing retaining wall. 2 -A 30" high timber and limestone retaininq wall dividinc, 21 1·andy beach area from the gras.st!d banks. St,. f. f recommends continuing the wall approxim~t~ly 8' alonq the north side of bank where the oriqin,11 b.i:1k had been cut into. 3 -Construction of access ~ta1rs -stairs to be built according to recommendations of Citv 8taff. Stairs will run to level ground not to shoreline as shown on site olan. The Planning Commisslon Recommendation·was as follows:_. . To approve an after the fact applicatie>l\;.for .~_rt;len,(;C~g}lt· ·· .. c:on•~,t,,!..»qt!i~;of;.'~iconditipnal use P~rnri,p1:an9 1~" · !fs"!~~.~~~-~;r.,~b.~~~~/~~;1-Jh,~ .:tet~!w~-~~{fi~~~~l-~,: f"'-t½ .. ;-:w ':5t~"I!-~~1-f:;,.;Ji!' ":•' ,-""~::,'.'.·1·.~~~•;,_~"',_,;'• \ ;·:~5:J.-,:,,, ;'{,-t-f_>:.'rj/,r]J~-.~• rf~·.•?~:~j:,r.:;:;';.~1~~~~-' .~ ,_ ,.t,.~,;,-~'f..:~:;ae·ta'.inlng 'wa11· may. reniain::because·,:of,;::the(great~~{eny. ro .. ;, .:t,, . .,,,,,.-: .. '.)::,::'haJ:'Jll done·· if ·removed. ,The north. section-·. ?£· ~e ,,,re~~ini; _;!;,,,,.,; '!. Jllay .. be :continued along. the· disturbed sect1on;,,:,c;>f,~;t. • , ,. ~~ti;;;;.to,,8"-providing-' the required eupport~': -,J,:c:"::::,xc;.£t;W,V:,\. ~ -~>~;·.·::-.·~ ,:~·:l~t -/,:·, , . 1• :_.•·>, ·· : , · ,,;: ,. . '." -": ,; ···i. ~ :-: ::_~· ;,~,c_:.7;:_:•·;:~i-~tt~~:\~;. _ .. : .... ;:'~••/•tair• :to. be: ·conetructed.~down_:,the:'1Akesho,.;~~~•-· -~•J;,t,Snot.}to··run.,to ,the lakeahore-but~-~:,.stop;· a1;~-i_,y~;:/:g~~ :/, 14~i~o ~•,+to~30' setback from lake snore •:ftC,i tyt~~Sf it:leei.,,, t~i''o. )~;~~MJi:3;:,ra.~~!iill !if ji~:;:{;~{4J~~ Cortlen Cloutier Page 3 Conditional Use, Varianco 3 -Applicant must obtain the necessary permits from the DNR and MCWO for rip rap of shoreline -rip rap may be placed along the outer edges of the sand beach until it connects to retaining wall. 4 -Approve the additional qrass sittinq area fin<linq the improvement will not i11volve further disturb~ncc of. the land and no additional hardcover within the 0-75' setb~ck area. 5 -Restoration of all disturbed areas and placing of hay bales along the shoreline prior to reconstruction. Approval of variance is based on the following hardships: l Steep lakeshore banks 2 -No defined lakeshore access. w ~Ii . !11 w l .. . . .r ,_.:./ ./i~~~ r-irr- . J " '.1 ·• Ill") <.': I ~i l... .. ~,.. ! l r_~ .. ! I o,, ~ z''" · .. :a I" ·-n I f ;;;.. ·◄ ~. ( .... ' ;I'-I -:!Jr' :;; bl":-,g !-! ~' Ll --.:-;,! l ,,, ~ I") ~+ oi ►v,rn ► ., ·, ,,. I ls_ <e .... ~·z·~ f'•i ~ I,. ~, (l .... ,,.► § ~-)-~ l'l\ ~~ l. ~Cl':; r' .... i ),, _, '" , ..... ... :S~~,. ! I C ~ =El _ ..... Ir:· h, ~! ;2J \.} ~ '=: •'. "' ► Z,: n I ,~ ► ),, ,..,.. I =o-,g "• ... .• l'. u-•' ~ ( "' "' '" / ,.::; ;,: ,.,g:;.. ' I• c~ .,,:;:,_: .... -1' >; I z f ,,.,.-o I' ,~•-. 0 0 0""' -,.. ' ., _., .-,,...~ I,"' I Ill .... ~o~.~ t· Y,~~ ... ' ~ ~t c z"'O .._: i:1 ~~r\ 1t•· '= ~) ~,z. ~-1-~ ~o;::I"\ -n, . ' 1•. ., j ,:, w;.' 0 0 ". I' .. oi~i~ • ;f -)JI. . ~ z ◄z.,' z;;;,:1;! J))--t_ . r (', o I. .. µ \J ..... Q:!rn---"' : z~ '.,t '. ;J ,, l ''"O 'h I c,,n '·· ;..,,. ..,~~:~ .. ~ , ..... ,..., "l2tl' .., Ir\ 1·{ \,,,J 1,- «: ;i r ,;. . ►f-----l I ' ~~ " 0--1,)\ ~~=! I ... ),N I ►.4 .,,.,.; !!?i~I ~ ,-.. I .t-· ,,:,- ~!~1~-.... I o, ' -"' ~1 ~r:: a0-1 -:-" \i\11' -"' . HENNEPIN COUNTY MUNICIPAL COURT PROSECUTION SUMMARY CITY OF ORONO TO: City Administrator -c'ity Planner FROM: Prosecuting Attorney DATE: May 17, 1982 .E .. ·- ------------------------------------------------------------ Defendant: Cortlen Cloutier (0) Offense: Construct Retaining Wall Without Proper Permit Summary of Proceedings: This was set for a jury trial on May 11, 1982. At that time, it appeaLed that the defendant and the city could resolve the dispute regarding the con­ struction of the retaining wall and excavatiori and filling on the property. The matter which could not be resolved is the second story on the boat house. Therefore, it was the city attorney's recommendation that the two issues be handled separately. The matter set for trial was the issue of th~ retaining wall and excavation, and an agreement was entered before the judge that the defendant would complete the necessary administrative procedures and construction of the work by September 30, 1982. It was agreed that this disposition solely related to the retaining wall and excavation and did not include the issue of the second story on the boat house. The defendant was inform~d that that issue would be subject to further litigation. Disposition: Judge Hart accepted this disposition. TO: Planning Commission FROMa Jeanne A. Mabusth DATEa May 13, 1982 SUBJECT: #674 Cortlon Cloutier, 2480 Casco Point Road - ttAfter the Facttt conditional Uso Permit & Variance Update -Since April 19, 1982 moeti1,'} At the trial on May 11, 1982, the court directed Cloutier to proceed with his original land use application with the City of Orono. lie was given until S£.ptember, 1982, to complete the application process and until May ll, 1983, to complete all approved lakeshore improvements. We ask that you refrain from any discussion of the removal of the second story of the boat house during the review of application #674. Staff has asked that a formal compla1nt be filed against Mr. Cloutier for failing to respond to the Council directive of Resolution 1254. It was the inclusion of the ~oat house issue in my review memo that caused Cloutier to withdraw the application at our last meeting. The original packet has been recopied for your convenience. In the staff memo dated April 12, 1982, please remove condition 3 of my recommendation (pdge J) and please no discussion of the boat house. The City Engineer's report has been enclosed for your review - .::.t dppears to be in complct:o ,.lccord v,i th my recommendation • . ~' .:' .~a:,-. > .. X'.;~;k .. :r/~}{~-~:' ';.;·,t·' -~:~,;.., ....... . *l *l CONFIDENTIAL MA'l'TER TO; Desyl Peterson FROM: DATE: Jeanne A. Habusth May 6, 1982 SUBJECT: #555 Cortlen Cloutier -Formal Complaint 5-7-71 12-6-71 1-2-77 3-26-80 5-5-80 5-6-80 6-4-80 6-9-80 6-10-80 6-16-80 6-18-80 6-19-80 6-23-80 6-24-80 6-25-80 7-24-80 Chronology of Events Building Permit issued for boat house. Request for combination -combined all of his properties within Tillsons Villa Carman. Field sheet -assessor Stop work order issued by Jacobs for work being done on lakeshore structure Cloutier letter -filing of applicat~on Application filed (variance -conditional use permit} Zoning Administrator's memo for 6-9-80 Planning Cow.mission meeting. Planning Commission minutes -work session Notificatio~ of Planning Commission action Inspection by Tom Jacobs by Planr.ing Commission Follow up inspection -determine size of existing structure Zoning Administrator's memo for S-23-80 Planning Commission meeting Plonning Commission minutes Affidavit -Mr. and Mrs Anderson neighbors of Cortlen Cloutier Affidavit -Mike Scheller -Orono Building Inspector *l *1 ~#555 Cortlen Cloutier Page 2 Chronology of Events 11-12-80 11-25-80 12-1-80 12-3-80 1-13-81 1-19-81 1-20-81 1-28-81 2-2-81 2-2-81 2-2-81 2-11-81 2-12-81 2-23-81 2-24-81 3-9-81 3-9-81 3-10-81 Zoning Administrator's letter notifying Cloutier of deadline for scheduled action meeting of Planning Commission Zoning Adm.inistrator' s memo to Planning Comr.iii;sion for w~eting of 12-1-80 Planning Commission minutes -Planning commission tabled application until meeting of 1-19-81 Notice of Planning Commission action Zoning Administrator's memo to Planning commission Planning Commission minutes of 1-19-81 -Planning Commission denied application (4) Ayes, (1) Nay. In1:1pection notice -stop work posted work done without permit on Cloutier's ;~rage Inspection n6tice -stop work posted work done without permic on Cloutier's garage Planning Commission renotification Permit #4420 ispued for structural repair of garage Zoning Administrator's memo to Council for meeting of 2-11-81 Council minutes Notice of Council action Council minutes -tabled at request of applicant NuLification of Council action Council minutes -formal denial of conditional use permit and variance (4) to ) -Resolution #1254 Resolution #1254 Notification of Council action 7-13-81 Zoning Administrator's letter renotifying Cloutier of deadline date for removal of second'.,story of;•boat hcrnse ·'.ii .··. 7-15-81 . Police report involving unauthorized work alon~ shm:~lin~·':·:~c';.Qr:::} :\~ ':":, 7;.,17-81 . Citation 33 581438 issued '!~;~',. .. -.. ~-~;,c. " •• ; , ·• . . • -, ··•2-,·\~;7~17;..81 ·; · Lettor hand delivered with citation advising appli~a.nt;, · .. ... :l.r?•':' .... ; that he would be allowed to restore 1 lakeahore.bt1U1k-and.;'" ~i,g'J~Jj}J:)t;\;;::need: tor placing of ,hay balea· alo~CJ::11~~5~~in,!t:\};{_}·,<::::;·;,:x;\}?'. :z··:.:7.;.17-n · ''lnapecti,::,n notice -. Stop work order<had been: r~ved<· 1 : . /\\.:~ ·•, .; "-,,~ ·",;J, .• >,, -and additional' work· porformed·.witbi'r(:2•F~ur.:ipt1u·1.Qd.;:·,.;;,;:;•/.:~::t• :-·>,~'=~::\~·1\:"';•:•ri. ·J~::·""-:~ \5·.:: ;.._ .... \~,' 'i t :.,_ . -•.~--' '·,\•,' ·-~ "~'"-' L ... t,:~r-·<~~-r;.-' l ;,r:~~; :.i:.:.r.;;.,' ·-~~"''.~·~\'i i_i,:.:•.,. ~-.:•:~~ .. :-~:<:,' -~-~·~·~·./(}~~::·-~, <.~::-:. ~-ii;1,•17.;.:zo..;s1 rl:. Inepac~ion. notJ.c• ,~, advised .Cl®t. ei;:Lwo"l.4:~«P.P••l0 ,·the ,, :: :,::, •.r·:?i>t ... ~r . , .. ''\;~itatiosi:}1:,: ,:,,J-J:i~i\}':ilf':~~fr?; . ;~;,~;:;;',is ·. . ;\b~Jtlf1t1W/;i ~.:,'-'.--'.' .l?J"t•i>t . . JSSS Cortlen Cloutier Page 3 Chronology of Events 8-21-81 9/81 12/81 1/82 2-2-82 2-25-82 3/82 4-12-82 4-19-82 4-2a-82 4-30-82 Bruce D. Malkerson mcmorandur.. Site inspection with Bruce Hall,erson, AJ.an 01s,,,., and Jeanne Mab~sth with Clouli~r -He advised &hat he would prob?,bly file an .1fter the fact apr1'.catio·., with the Ci t'l (or the pro po sect lake~h,.)re ir.,provemr.nt:s. Cloutier v~sited City officas to di~cuss ap~lic~tion. Called o~fice to dis·.;uss filing a:tc. SC"11edult:! Peterson letter Application 1674 fil1:?d Cl0utier visited the office to iiscuss with "vm Jacobs and Jeanne Mabusth the plans ;ccsenteJ with the application ~nd stated that the plan~ wo~e not ~xactl~ what he had in mind and that he was op~~ to suJgestj )OS from staff which is exactly what we ~ave. ~e ask•·J that the application be poscponec'J frvm s..:heduJ r~.,;1 March 15, 1982 meeting t.o the April lt;, 1982 PL .. mn~~,g Commission meeting. Zoning Administrator's me-..mo and i:-~;::ket for Planning Commii:;sion meeting of Afd :t. 19, J.:182. Planning Commission mirmtes -Applicant asked co withdraw application Notification Inspection notice -Cl~~t~er plans to re~tore disturbed area to origin,,l s:tat~. Advises staff of his intention concerning seco~d stor~. *l -Tom Jacobs -detailed chronology 3-26-80 -2-2-81 *2 -Jeanne Mabu$th -· detailed chronology 7-ls-ai,.,,:-::,, .. }-:-2 " ' ; ,'·. ' 'ti;/~·J> :c, J~1~1:r~u:tt•• ;°.;;~;;;d~:1~::~:g is conficmd m . -1~t:@1:~,~~pplic:ant •s'2 next r-·scheduled meeting is deponde:i.~_:YFOn r.ece~ EW-~-­ ':; , ".,, . \.;;•ddi t iona l . information. .--:Ptra.d Un1Sc:,,£9r .::t~'it?."" .uc:,; :,:,,;, ::~•;•r"-'''c~::1: --~':'i•?;;,;, . ··. ·, · "' ~;;,,~~i~.±~~#i't.~}!~§;•l,~~1ttt~t~r1~13:~~i'i'.'~!":11;)f.~;r~"f ~::i:}?t ·'.~', ,, ... '• ---~ . · Area. -. 3. acres /;:_zoning,Diatrict-LR-le ·.· ·"'/Application· a) ordinance 31.831 ,required • 75 1 . .-.. . <proposed ataira • O • variance. 75 1 or; 1001 ·:: ... > ,., •·'/'propoaed,wall •-10'. ,rar!.v,.e, ot.· 1s•.9r,1_~?.''';.~>; . b). ordinance .31. 700 -Conditional Use P.el:llit.. tor:>' construction of reta.ining wall and· excavation .· and tilling on property · · List of·Exhibits Exhibit A -Application . . Exhibit B -'Property OWnera Li•t ... Exhibit ·c -Plat Map · ,.Exhibit o -,survey . :Exhibit Er-Attorney•• letter Exhibit P' --Resolution 1254 ··Exhibit G -Site Plan Exhibit H --Artiat'a aketch '/1 :· Background, of Proposed·.· Aeplication On July: l5r 1981,. ataff was advised of excavation work being done.along the lak.eshore of the Cloutier residence. , Staff issued a stop work order .. advising owner to contact staff •· immediately and obtain the necessary permits. Cloutier had constructed a retaining wall approximately 30• high dividing a sandy beach and the graaaed area. A pile of fill was placed along, the -lakeshore. ._Qwll~r.,.~~pJ,ained the .propoae4,,work~1~~•c;:;,,,,.,c"\ _ to protect. an existing sand beach from the eroding grasaed.: ; ;r: :-: ~ i,; ba:~; i:-~a• T~:i~iirif 1* c~iifi~!~ti1~t0'.iitf. . 49e, ~,~:_;,,.·.~/~·:;::,.,,· ;,, -~~~:·f;·:::/··.-~-·;::.="':~~,--,:;-,.:,,. J,f/~~f'~~o~al ;.'U1e;:.PermJ.t ', 'Narianoe . i. ' . : ·~\'':.~':'.-·•.~:;.i.-~ .. '._}:':.-.; .• ·.t·~.~.;-.; .. ::._i._,:,'.·•.·.·.-_·.·.•.r~ 1 ··,:,•_:,.:'··.·•.;·,··~,~.-.i .. :, .. _".· •.. ~ .. ·•,·,.•.·.·:·,"'·:'··,'· .. ··'":·.·.••.;.-,:.'.:.;;.•_,·_·._:·•.:··:•·:.:;·.:.,· ..••. ,,_.Jt}iJ;~t\\?/\i:'/ .... : .. -: .. · _.:-·\~- ;1,,:/}i_.:'.;Ith&vo '.encloud ·a copy of the denial resolutionitor. tfuat :::., · ·~, .. -:r:: •. .,. ;,,~c:. f·iearliar application (Exhibit P). Briefly, Cloutier. filed:-,-··/ \:f:~,;i:?;"' _; · ·.•.·.··an -After the tact application with the City to pei,nit·;.4C.;-·\·,i.,;·,•,:(t/{f;,,,:':: ,.;gueat. home uae of a non confor,ainq boat hoWHJ •true~ . .that ;i,;;'.";,f?);]f;::{~ · had ••uatained "ever.al improvement.a without the· benefit. .of< :·;.;::,,·r::c:r)tl;/ . . buildin9 perJlli ta. A• the reaolution at.ate.a, C1o--.it.ie,r<)IA•, to . . · ·, 1 " 0'·::,<c • ,remove, the aecond atory of the boat houae by Sep~b41r'·9~·-. · . . ·. ·,1981, and cap it off with an originally Autboriz_e.4::dec:$~ :: . . : 'Cloutier ha• pleaded ·not guilty. to the citat~n:.·i~;~~.~\:}\{\~;if;.ztf .. · July_ 17,.,],982 and & _trial baa been. scbedµlacf. •f?r/~)''.''41,·>:f':'.':::;:;~r.:f:J/; · .. 1982 •. DUJ:ing tbeae many month• of diacusaion, '·t~•""&'tlfO~\l~iop.,;;:'":'ff;:".':;;r3:: of the boat hou•• and the pending appli04t:ion..,for,,,theil~•.#()a\,/ .. ,,:,~.:.': improvement• have . ~•n linked together. 'l'he attorney and}: :: '.07 Yi~<(; . ataf f have encouraged thi• cour•• of· action .. (Jxhi.bit E) ', /· )./-?'?fit)//t1i Review of Current Pro29aa1 ..• •, U2,; ·i;.r;;J:@ . Cloutier ha• adviaed that the pla.na enclosed , ~or·· :this z:~y~ t:,il ("'1:~ttt •.wei-e.drafted .. by an owr uabitio1.1• draftPWUt, · I bave d.-ign4~•i,.,.,;:.y~ , . the propoaed improv81Unta on Exhibit GJ Cloutier review• .~a!l·'f; as follows 1 · l Removal.of aecond atory of boat house structure and capping with deck. 2 -Rip i-ap of ahorelin• -rip·rap to be continued up to each.edge of the ••i•ting retaining wall. · 3 -Construction of access stairs -stairs to be built .according to recommendations of City staff not as · .. ,sketched on site plan. Stairs need not run to the ... ahoreline but PY stop 20' to 30' from the shoreline. · 4 -·.Grass sitting area -applicant claims this will -involve cutting into a oank and may require some physical 1tructure to prevent the bank from eroding to the rear and along the front. The sketch shows retaining walls. ·.·· If·iranning Comiasi.on appr'oves this 'additional· ataff will require ~dditional inforution . '"" 1~~l~t1~r t~c$i;;.1{;~~~~~ ··• 5 -. D6ny the additional grass sitting area finding adeqwi~ level areas for sitting at the beach area, second · ·· ·. · story deck and top of lakeshore bank.· De'tl.ial will . < , .. prevent additional disturbance wi.thin O -75' setback area. 6 -Restoration of all disturbed areas and placing of hay bAles along the shoreline prior to reconstruction. Review of Hardship• -required for approval of ; =~~-.:~•i:/~/ J~(~:~•1 ~. ~ • l ~i <\ ',: :.~ ?. f~ ~; ~ • .. _> .·>· .. \_~ ~·.··.:~•:~:;-~~-j2::•:~:~±::--j~•·~1·:•~,~~~~({;~•:, lain~~YQ~'r-zueetiandlr•a~•ff,~0%:'?,;e ~;i:~1:~{r~!iti,~~i~:i;1Jtt:~t1~~ . i February 2, 1982 Cortlan Cloutier .: 2480 caaco Point Road Wayzata, MN 55391 Dear Mr. Cloutier: On the' North Shore of Lake Minnetonka l have just completed a monthly review of applications with Bruce MAlxeraon and he asked if I had heard any further-from you concerning your filing an application with the City for l.Akeahore -improvements on your property. I had previously· · advised him of your visit to the office in early December and your intention to file an •after the tact" condi.tional use permit application with the City sometime after the first of · the year. In conaideration of the date, I must once again ask for confirmation of your current intention. 'If it i• still your plan to proceed and to assume completion of the total package of lakeshore improvements on your property by this spring then I would advise that you consider the March 15, 1982, .meeting of the Planning Commission. The deadline dace for the tiling of all applications for the March 15th meeting is March 1, 1982. ·-1 bave,encloaed another·conditional use permit · ~"".:your convenience. Please contact my 'office it qu.ation•~ ' .· :_ P.oPHAM, · HAIK, .sc~~!~:!cc:": ~~~,~~~,.-f 1."Q;~;;~;.~;~:::t~~if:~~~~fi:)~l~-~\;: MIHN&A,.o~•·· MINHl:&OTA ·••o•. . •. · ... ,: '· . ,. r..,,, " ..... _,; llHO u~,c-•CII . ·:;.,:::; : ~0,:"??:· "/·.~:..-· ........ ., .... 00 , ~ ..... ·~ ·{;::~.<;~_-~-> ....... ,.. .... ""'··. •••NOIIIO A. HMll ..... C:HIIO.IIICH ......... """"-" -0 .. DOTY 0 •• ,., .. ,.. ........ . 1,f'S·&.WOIIOSlol · •.-ltc; "'"''CHUO ,l\1CS D. W 11,.1,1 ■ HOCIIU.•· ._ IIIC:H•IIO ■ e. ltO•Cll'Y JOHNaON ..... y II.· N4c:ON•IUI ao•sllT -.■u1111 , , 'rlUDCIIIC:• i:., ■IIOWH, .:{,No .. •• 11. •c11a ,•£•111,1,:,;. P. NAIACIISOlol 'l-<W'""'• II. SHll,CII .. _,,.,JANCII a. I.OCIKHAIIT {';c'At.l,CH•W. "IHOCIIA•CII <;;;jc:1,,rF-O N,OIICClolC 0-w, .... , ......... l,/ .. "41l .. cu;a• .. I,, ltCTCll ■ON HIC:H•Ca. 0. ,11c&wA .. i THON•■ C. O'AOUll,4 1.AIIIIY 0. C ■PII, : .1•1oc ■, WAYCIIOH ' PAVIO A, JONC ■ . SAl.t.Y ..... o .. HaOH . &.er &. ... Cl:NY -1.cai.tc 011,1,CTTc HIC:HACI. T. NII.AH "OaCIIT ,:, WOll.4,.CN o•v10 .i. coou,aT CATHCIIIHC A, "01.A ■KY STCV&N 0. NCIKCNS ,JOHH lt,Wll.(.011 IIAfHI.CC .. W. 14Ul0C" . H•HCY J. TUltlJAIC JOHlol C:, C:NII.O ■ ,.,.,,.,ac ,. ... ,11,■110 \ Mr. Cortlen. Cloutier ,2480.Caaco-Point aoad Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 February 2, 1982 Res State vs. Cartlen Cloutier· Dear Mr. Cloutiers -i-·' ,~ • .• ~; f¼"' .-.:./-,·· ·:-,:· :.t::!~ _ Pursuant to our. discussion at court on Janu,u-,; 27 1 -~1982 1 youJ: matter ha• been scheduled for a trial on May ll, , 1982. My understanding is that matters are proceeding smoot...J.ily · :through the City Administrator processes, and that the matter .can be resolved by the time of this trial date. Sincerely, Desyl L. Peterson Prosecuting Attorney City of Orono · -~ -f~: •'.-~·.:~:~-:""' -·· ~ . :-·, ,.,,,,·:,-·, .-· .. ,.:_City.of Orono . ~}j;~~1}1}1;~~~~,~~::Naik~~~;n :_'. : . . t''",?::::.=;:,.,,:._'' ·"'-c.,.'-ri~}~,'.~sl.f> _.,•~.Jc.,,,,.;,.~.·--=~ • .. ~!.·~· -~· --"·"_~. _.-..._.•,:,.-,. .• ; ":,"-" •. ·~:":.:·~~·~·a~jt:~~f~o••c~~~io,~ :;_~rtlen '.ti,,A,UU~.LJ';•t';,,::~~; ;:_i'~~-'(~,, :.;1,,,.~:~; :f;!'.\::.~., ~ ._:j;:· _j _~r;;;:/~::-:::t:;;,.~1--.-:-;; :'.~: :t-~->~~~"-~---~~-;;:Ji:~~-~~1~~~·,::~.::~· "1•,~0n)1'quat 112 ~~;1911·,::_,.Jettena.4 ':~.tbe::;itt•' :~~-, ~ ·i.co~~n ·,Clou.tj,er ~'.;f-Be:,.Pl-4,ir-not:it,VYP.. · · t,:Pc~trial• .11&•.2·aet';{for'·;lfoy~.;:;_4·.~1Jt, not,;;,r4191••t.:·•;;jpiy;tru1yor",,~,,c,c,..1,,;,:10 .. , . ,F:f-t,iae'4, will ·',have •r• tfunk\'di~u••io.nc:.i_J't 1::·';'~-conoerni~cJfh•t ·a.•~J.ntendaitto;~~r.yJto'j~Q4_ .. =-. -~i ·.-~:>·?Utter •. •;It,:J• our•,jnt9nt.x:to\•i:9or~l,..: ,M· KIE• f:.;;".t;•r;of :,~ .. -.ordinanoe,,a•,,•,Ao::1-.:~t.be\' .. rvJ.01flt.ion.;£c,_JnJtlie~!•.-..~::3~;;. 4 ak~~w:theriact;4~n~n:;,~l'ffl1, · · Wo~-'--~,ao,'"tbat,"'!• ''9:!•·0 ;;:si~f~~~lt!~~~~tJJ}~f;4 .• .2 , •. ,., .. :,;;J;t~On;.tWedne9day;;:•ftar:,-oon:t;'%:~anec1t~~., . . . . "' . ·+ :fL:J.What:i-,~i• ::pl&n•t~ff~,J.p:i1:ega,;d:.,\:to'-t~i11 :~~~-. . ::::/!)'.ti-to ~-tbe cboathoUN.'¥:a._;:1-tec .. ;>J4tt:""°'"'41;.~j {_;P;~·<;.uny,~thinga~.•bout:the~ld.atoty"atl4,'.tb,e;.;p~, .. ,, . . . . . ..· ... \f,/:~:,;.;;atated:,tbat'ihe;di4,1JJOt,:knovJtllat:there,,).te~•;·•·nys-oJ.'di¥~J[:~.t;:.{itt~ · itf'i,t/~O~ibiud2;the5'..,nc:avat.~9n.i,a~c1 :.i-e11"rang:fng~c,f:;:~t.e.r,~,•~•~'~14l.~)'ff~:-;i,~~-:­ ~)i:i;i!lfibi•·:il:•k••b01:e,\:\le ,1lu••rtr••~ ;-Section .:,.1. 70Q,r.9£;,~eiord i~t• . · "' ·· "at•~fithat-:;-he,,;think1,:th•t•<:i t:'.':ifi;t.oo.:. P1bi9uoua:;.,in'.~tha~fit',~ . ]{notfi~.afinetwh•#-~:lak••~e>re~\prop•rty;4•";:,:tx 0,indicatitd/to{hi1ii}~~!~t~11~~'~::t:,;% ~1/:!"B~•~'"'tn9~i.1ion.· .. t•t••,-,nQt,~nly that: it·•.a~.J.llegal,to:·al.~,,:-.:;',t~1?tS':Y,:,'c"'~' ,ii(,~tcepaii.?.¾pri;c,han9ft/,the,.9rade,;of;itr·abore}of;;:3.akeahore.pr.op,e,.:ty::..tcJ?~:t;:';:-?.::. ~~J":'/2.;witllou~1.a:Ojper:aitt-but.7also.:that>;it,'was,,il.legal··:to.••excavate;~:':7f';."?i:?;/'.".'\f~ 7?:~;~~trc.ocka,:..,aanc1,':9u~el,::· d1tttQr .. )•imilar;,.mater1al,anywhere\within·.::\.;;,,,.i;1:.t; l;t•;t~:·.'-:the,::iJ.aits·,of •·the',,City~ot.:·orono~' I indicated.~to .. -bim.;tnerefor.e;l·.:·,,;/'0 > ~•\;,;.,~that.'l_ • ., •.. n '.if ':,ther0lak••.b.Q~ .• :,wer:.•;.nq. t} .. 4•C·i. ~.-.··_?J..· .td· .. · • -.~l~;::*.b. •· .. , .. ,,:...'·~-,•.·,'!', ~-, ·. -~-b~~l9.l\.~tit~ffltl~~~~tt~l.'eJrie~~: .;fZ41MOU:•;-lor:~rctin•n9·•,,p(.s,t~,;;.~~~~;?\AAltt~1 ~~..-,2~uJ,4,qp.1:•.,.~JnA. f P,~~-:~ , , . . . . .I Hf=/·~· OW ICIATllf'ACT ~rRocilo-.,-~-. · 0 <X>l'RICT WOflK • l'fllOCll!O 0 CORMECT W0l'IK. CALL f0R RE INSPECTION 8Ef0RE CCVEfllN(, O>ORRECT UNSAFE CONDITION WITHIN HOURS. 1NSf'ECT0R WH..L HfTVfilll . . IJlil'fTOP ORDER POSHO CALI. IN!WfC10PI O INSl'ECTION HlOVIRED. CALL TO AHRANGE ACCU! .· c1H for the next lntpection 24 houri in advance.-·------- ~v;:; .. ,:;--FT~~-. .. . . " l' . ~ r~~.':i-·.::ii: ]~=~==-_: J:.':'.;...:".'. ,_, . . _ _ J ":':"_~~ .... '\i:b;i,., .,. .•. -,. . J"' .. ~i>~~-~~-:'.:r_~!Jlt~1fJ~~((~~.;,C4~4, .. ,m_Ch,t.._,d.2d~..sE'rlt'. .:j;~{{JJ:fii/::Ii~'-.~~'.~:~@i • ,,c ~~-<.,: • : • ' • -''-4~~h;• >a.,.t-;-•-, -• -.-: ,1 . ~-~~~i-'Lw,J..A~A~~c.:.c~,'--.<;~~-~-1:.J.nt.beL:&.'l.!!~i2ui,a;j;_:::' '.. -_-.·. · __ <~ t.. ·?·) :· . ',·· . ,--. -:·, ,: . -... :· .·, . , -, -. . '.' ; ...., .. ,,, ; ·. -_~ .. -r~ • -~,:" ~:--.~·--•f :"· ~~:'G,c;,~~'lrlJ '''.·C ,~~r~:~,..~ ;J if 'j'O <~~~--~.JU_~ t!i .. ·-C> '-:t ~~:~~--. . -.. : ~-& :.~• . ,;..;:.,,._,...,L1, .... ~~1,.,,,,,,r;_ ·..--. · .. ·• .•• } : . • .• ~~ ,~:-· -~tf./~t !!ul~./!J.~r.Ou/4/J. lf1A ~.C.Lou7J er:.~ Y:..£.f!Jl..U~d ... ~··: .:, •'}( ··if ; ''::·~~4yt:~!'S~~;~~:~~·· .. _. _,~~t~m~::;2,~:~;;.:, ____ _ 1·._;;,;:,0?t;:?fOR';JAOON, BUJ.l~M19 :,off ici&l _;?:,.il[t,'?}Na;~:l0,'.1981< . . . ·. f1fi:su~;::.<2480Caaco Point Roa4 stf~-~t,.~,;_,l\L:·,:~~c;~' ·. ._· . . . . . . , . . . . . . > ., ' --~--~<-' ;:: t03•2f•IO •/Wa• •infon1ed by unknown caller ·that. •~-~ .. 1;,,:~:,. ·_--• ·" ·< .. . /:~by lake at. 2480 C&aco Point J&oa4 ·u4.•"1UtdJ~f~ · ~ · if pend t waa iaaued. l eheclud rtbe · :ftie;_ . '¥ ;,•,r,--·,.--I,r .. ~\\:penait,w•• i•~4 ••. , ,_ · ·•,"·./t,./t~lJt\f~FJii~~t ',};.03"'26'-80 2:""7. .• site·inapection:wa•:~ •i 1.1,•:, · · · 1!~¥'-;;,%1~;'{'%~=~=-~=~ '"... · · · . · fr-,_at the -~-{tiM -~ t.hoUfbt./1~;-~· ·.'ft::;:>.-_.,::. l:~: ·:·· :A: •. •tol', .. ,or4."~-r--.:~tad_-_(5.i~i~~i,"~:~~~f*?~~~f~i~~ .,;"-'<\.2::;-/ ci-:06•16-80-;-.. l"WU . infm:aa4 ·by.:,Jeane· ........ :,tbld:•l,P:u· ~~ . ~---· ,~;1:.,;>>· . ,.·11•04-80-. •·Again when· checking the ·site I found-· that two: l:'09fer:a .. ,,,·. ):/ . ·;1'.:'.;:t~;;:_:::·> ~"··· ...•.• /'.were, reroofing the main: atructure, -clay tile roof~ . :::·:c\;_} "f ~Y1-tt;p;I:;~}1i./'.~~~~t.~.:i~!•:e:;..1t~~1~ed.~1ou~;:·u(~~~. {;:t,:i!;\,.-·:,'.11~0f.-80'\Mr'.·:Cloutier•• father came in picked up ·a-·permit:'for.!;;'':-'ii(,f,, 1f()~J.'.\:\~''·\s:{r-<~:::~;·_.=th~::· ,;~.i~~a!e~ '·. The estimated con-,:·.:l,\i}E~\c'~~- \',-'-C::-t ,-,_. · .Ol-28-81, . Wa• told by a resident of the City that more· vcrk .,,_ ... <: '\: ' . . ·._ ·• wa• done on the. property. I went out to inspttc:t the : /. '.-);:\ · ;:, ~.,;: .. , i>::; ~•·• , .. _ -;:PJ:'ope&-t.y,-and found. that ,~ •,9U:A9•_·:,,....,hay~~J;~~~1W;::;A;,;:~ 1~.~,-;,;,t:•~',"·J~ .. /';;;,:;~i;t,'.,;,,;,:epeir•:,.t,etng · done"' to•:•1 t ::wich·) the 'previous~,~ . t'f~\';,~ .. :~;,:t\;; ;,::., •~ _ -•··. · . ,,. 414 :.~~ _:'~o~~; ';th~~,_9onsi-.,;!e,'. ~}':;~~ "~ollow,tngi,~~f~ . t#,~T1~15i~ffe!r~~;:::~~*!~f~~~1~· • . ,, .. ,,,. ,:, uly"l.5th ,.-:•veninq · -rmived call notifyiJi9, .. ·:9ff };.:,,>· '"' .... Cc c:. :and filling withing 75 •. of.·· l&ka"a.t'!,2480;'.._ .. , ·. ·~. . :~~ •t··1 •> , · > · •• · .. · Road ... •· Police wre · a ■ked to. advJ.H 10VMJ:,:~of'.:.,'tfte~· t~Ji;~r?:;~:'.;:(·:~~:~• .. ;_:for.• . .,.~~-· and to conuot:~d·~~;!:~,.;.~i\{~·-. · · . · :·~§July '16th ':".· AM • i••ued,.,a •top .. work orderc and:'lett:,~~-.• ~ ... -~c .: , .. ~('\ .. ,. s,, · · •lip advi•inq owner of need for pemitA1,,,l0~1.~.a, ··,;;:~ . • • fillinq, 9radinq within . 75 •, of' 1"M•bo~;':l'an4.:f · .•:c.;:.. . .. of retaining wall within O .~ -?,.~_rot{ ...... · ·••,·;-;· · , .. ,.•.addition ero ■ion control ,wa ■,•ne~:;;•ncl pl.Aoinq of hay bal•• along .lakellboni~;:: "'F§g ~ ,.~·,y.Ju1y·,16th .: PM•• owner, :cloutiu, cai~;;;~~~~~i'~;~ ... 4•+:~• ••'. . ,f!.J atate he waa not. awaus tut . needed~~t(~ _ .-, . •·. -doe• tut do at t.hi• point.. ,11e,waa1ad~;i"43'· . . · · for· uo ■ion · cont.roJ. and advi ■ed":%'4:901:2; .. : ••• he·had arran9 ... nt» .for·a ~"CM'"'}w.····· · .. Saturday to ooaplete the pz:oj~J•~it;,\J't · -< ;. • • ,-'' .". "{: ;' \l;~::J::.;,,~/\,.tf~:~~.: '· ... ~. · : .Tuly• 1. 7th -'PM -A taq aD4 'letter· .were, .~<'.~W ·.-. ' ,111 . : -by unident.ifie4 woman;;.;· Sbe;._...:;:-~~·:i!. Cl' ·• · · :· wa ■ part .of our-. noaui.,,p,:-00.SUr,e · . . -. that. owner·. would. bav• to•~!;. • . · .-···.to-it.a ori«Jinal · atate :an4 aay~".:~""'-: -•··DI ·:;:. '. .. _ . ··: •~i~;....'4!3tt;~::?:;l~1t'..,,..·. , 1!!1,1! •.. ;~'{•:·.;July· 19th ~-::.PK -· a.port.a•· fr<a:fD9iCJbbor•~~ve.,'1: l\>-: < c .•.. on -.applicant. •• 4dviaed -to}~••toz•it '.,·., •-.: . . rl ,original •t&t.e over ~ ·yee,keM;~:..;.,;;;·t '( if ".;tfsJ;\:.·, .,;; . . . :-·~: : : .. , · ,,; : ..... :i · · r • ·> ~ ,<; · ;. · . • · · · -"; · ~-i· ·: : · . i·'/::<ttt;.,U#,::~)/:•:::-";?!t/ ;:,.:,~~:..;',July ··20th .--:·An in•pection '. wa• made of. the site· '."'! ax-ea .Ji~cE~o~~~t~ :},,. · ... 'fJ· • ._:_:/returned to •original .·state ,-,.retaining•.w~l 'i•tl:-l.1-•.Jia.:;.-,;,,-:'.;:;,~ ..... ·· · . : ' , ••place .. -owne~• · fath~r informed· WI that h.1.s ,:.son," p,ianne~,,.ccf/;: '',! ··.,,.;~::~··''.'~.· •,~~~.~n:1 ~=~o~f~e=n~e,,tc. ~~:0~~;;~\~·,.· }\ ' .·· . ::.•~ .~..i·--. '-:-.~' ~,--: .. ~.:w:,,~,.:c. • •. :•y· •· ·•""' ~-:'.'~"::{·:j:.,:,J•••M!<si.-:;.;;~,..,,,~,,••"1,.~,--..,~ .... ,...,y*r"""'"'~,,i;:.,.,"'1w1:,,i(--:,. .• '::r~~ ,•.f~~-: .. ·, :-.-. ·.-...:,;,...;·.-. $: ... ·: :_: .:·:.:.~ .. ::~-~~.~:~'.'.~,.-,.,~"'i~""::~· :.::;;.:':~:~·-·· .... -:t·.,,.. .. ,-. ·. WHEREAS, the City 'ot OrollQ .. ;aJa,( organized . and exiating: w,de;-,,ctbe law•;c:. ,,. / Ji;l,:y'~ki;t.:~1::St~~?itt!i~tti1toa ,. ·:·lc, r: _. . ;,:zoning,. regulation• , for · the ~;,protection 'i"P.~t~ " and 9 ~.,.:~l~::~riwiit !11i;:;::: . ~ .· permit· and.variance• to tbe?non'!"confo~t!i,.1¾a,,;i · ...... • ... . . hardcover · regulations.·; for"; lueahore property,:. to. pe.tmi t:•':~h_e':l. C ' :;~ •• • '• • • • :\: ..... i•••~~ r .. "•.:i.~ 0,~•,::•••••••.:~ .. ;:t;.~~-~·:?ff;}J:¾:~~- 1.: To ,convert:::the; second story: or an,:existing ::b()~~ •/ • house to a ~(e~~-:~.o~~/.~;,~~~~-_: · _·. :, :i(/:;i~ ]J};H[;iJ:f} . · 'l'o aad:a three-seasoned porch~:.13'6-#: x.·:.l8F6~)/it · · · .. · · aecond ,'story .of, ._the, existing~ boat. ·house .. o,ii~,J, cc· •• ~''.·> . .-~~~<::·:: : .. t~ · -··'-"·_i :~. _ -~--:· /-·:--:~~: \-/~-~::<.,_~ :~/ ~ -· _·:--~--:~-~.:?i/d~--~~;~r;·~j(-.~.-..~:-/, ~.i.::•:_·(i·~f4.;)j;:-~lt{~~Yf{ffi .-,,:i,-·,.-;-·'.:-;,;·· -= ,~._:-~,WHEREAS·,• the City::council·.ha•-}~·eviewed,;tbei~applic•ttCln/-v,. ,· :~··>..·->recommendation• of: •taf f and the P lanning:Commission 1 c'.Af ~~;'a¾{__., ,, /r; , ~' Sc:heller, · Maurine :and>Wilbur Andera.nJ:c:omments\by\n,_e, .. e>+ · • ) /-).:· ·· .·citizen•, · 1pd .totter, 1ml c::ol'l\IMn ts by ·tm,,.applw~t-.,,~.1;4~·,; · ···~~;t.:i~~-:.;·~:.,,_:~,;{:JA;~i:~f~;~i~~~~~if~~~~~~t~;~~t~- ·• . :,city of : Orono hereby., .. denie.•~4;11~ -~ · ··-· · · , • ~-1· _; • ..,.• ·• --• .· ,~,~~"~*{~~FJi~~t~~ff/*1 ,,2. ·'!he exiatin9 boat houae -~•~~~-c,:~· ~ ·e: ;.,,~c;:'' _ . ,. ::-;~ ~~i~~,~-·*~,1:1!;t~,~~f..&~~;l~~~~,. 3. Building permit No. 2495 waa·,w.ittait,~to,1' . , ., oonatruotion of a •ingl•-•tory"'boat;,~_itp · .. with deck, approximate ,eiae·::.20'·<X:JO!tflttt\:t~'i~ . . . . ' ':' . ·, ; .'~[,~;; ~-·· . );,:"'.?.~, :'!.ftt '4. Building permit: No. ,2,~Ss:.11t.u,.,4•-.4tpn,t .. ·. ~;2 t ... of. $5.00• wa• b4od-oni,~•14&Ucmtol"'. ·. suterial at f500 ,0O,-.,.all ~.ktto-~bef-' .•,.' .. ~r. . . . . v;:~·:·<f}t};{~:.;fl;t~l · 5. · 'fhe · affidavit•· of'Mike·JScbeller~ ::.~#' inapec:tor, and' Maurine ,:&Dd~·lfil.J;m~t . -~,:, · re ■iding at 3555 Fredr.i.c:k:::S~:t,,~·a or!ginal permit-waa:to~~-~:.a.),. ·-~-··:. ;;, capped ,with. a· deck.· 'No~~on4~~n'.~. . . . . by permit .and the inspector•a·'1:affidavit·;sta:t:.es.· ..... in•peoted a atructur.e as•umed · to be coa:iplete'ij;ii.~~/di'.4-',r· not contain any second story. · •.· ·:?\J~:)L\-<r.M,:' ".,; ·-.;\ 6. · Following receipt of 11 complain·t by an ~~~;:~~igtibo;: on June 19, 1980, an inspection. ·was made by--tbe,~,U,~µ1g · . in ■pector and the zoning administrator. of:,the,:.ix>at.::\t(;,.·:,,;;;,> houae. The following was noted: . '" .. '·'·:::z··. "\}(,'.;::~::/'::·· .. a) A two-atory boat house not of recent. ~onstruation.>· -,'.: b) A 14 ' · X 18 ' incomplete addition cit~d;,J'}~~~~,~i _ of .aecond ,atory, inc.luding.,,.tud,,waU•;:,~," , 1: · • ·.· ._ larglil•'window area• in,walls. , · "·;{k~'-l§I'~;; L..LIC.>Uw.~~~t ;;;,~;;• F , ,, , •·. , , C ; ',i\\'.£,.,\.};'.:t;;:;~S&:,;,(]1)t .·a ~:}ff!ba ::city ... • filae c:uv•,'tno·rrect.)~djl'f f . .a';i ... - ; , · '•j bein9 .. islSIMiMI fo,:,:.tmn~.-~-~ :t->:;~:-:.Section 32 260'of•'-tbfF&On"~~ · :.,.,,rs~~f~~ 1!~05ft12i-~~t . ·· · bein9 iuued. · for partial ,1f0rk-~'cc,nj~ . : boat houN. . . : . ': :,(;f/}lf{f"J~f\:,: ' 10. · The City file• have no. reoord..of .. a;;plu111td.i:J9,~_ being iaaued for partial plUM1Ding.,wo:k1i.dolMriifor;:iJ:,c:,Jl. houH1 including underground MWer:,~'••~Jj · · .. inatAlled. . .... -.,'./i;~{};Vtf\C,,:~. _,, __ ... . 11. ffie,boat ·house,· looated'.30 ;feet: froafabor.eline;i;oi~~ ca.raan • • . B&y, baa. been . a -non-conforming/uN,1;..Q/oJ'fr:t January 1, 1975 per Section•: l<1.201:;an<1t3_4zio~-;:,::}~1t~;• ::. . . . -.-•-.. · ". ·.,-~ -:-·;_.-·~;:,:~Jl~~.z:?~~;\~;{-\~.?z:J~~~:~;t ::12. '!'he City ~ilea have. no record ·c;,fq1':,0tr~if~~~9~t. ·•Occupancy.being i•aued for tbe 0::non,.,~~:L ... house atructura. per· Section:'232-;250 /·,• r,:.""·'""'~";fc;;J1,:~11:"': .. 13. The City files have no record of a conditional: u'~/'.;},;;;:·; .. peniit being. issued for the non-conforming boat:. . ;,,"·.:;.:-;::;,;,' house use per Section 34. 480. · · . ·,(,.'illt ·-14. :. ·. ~~-?~-iAJ;r Conatruction or occupancy of guest houses have . . .. _ . ~;_,•", ·. required prior .. City Council app:roval of a conditiQnalJ<J.tt: uae permit •inc• the adoption ot t.b<; first Co.l'l:lpr~iJ,,:,ft\ · Zonin9 eode, Ordinanc-~ NO, 93 in li67. · ,.,'.·rt?)){. :,:. ~~-~~:f:i · 15 .. · The City. files have no record of any application by -. Cloutier or any othei-peJ:son to have "· gu.eat.,.ho..._:· _,, ,:, on this ·property ;-·until · thia application~wa;.\jii._4,(f. 1980. · ·-;,., ·.· There are no specia1 · conditions applying'"to , the land in question which a.re peculiar, to ,. · the land or immediately adjoining property~ ··• . . . ·; .. ., ·, ',. -. ; !· . :::{:, .. --_.NO.------- -'~(,-t:: •t:·, · .. to. the. Dltputaaat ot · 11uua1 .. Jle. ·_ . · ;tii:"'w;::t25D:j::!qt-::;:~7 ~~· e.;~•;,,,s,i,r ,c-' -,:-,c:·', .. ' ,to any of tbe aboN finding-• ot..,f~,g-, .,, ·1~"'iY::"o: .. ,.\,;_:,,:·c, .. <that:,be=:hat:· .. penai.t:.IIQ•,::a,,o.;_ :;~~~:::;{'.}::;:1:;;§+fr~?~E~-=,-~~-t.~--~.-::~~.c::~~~~~--:,.:;•"'.,..,-;.,_ .. , .. ,::· •,,,:,_·.,."_..,,. ■uape""-4 · fO&' a1: ·-1eut·'nine~•~,, ·.~i:~~~:}1;1{!Et!::~1E1~«t· . :::::'::t:~==t:=:1:s:~~~-=i~'-_, ~~~,ont.A9,~;Code, -·~•City;.,C'.Olmqil~:baru,;~:m~~ , :.~-.. ;~_•at.ue ,.WDH4:-.4t0:r:Y.,~;of.,,_;,tbe•, boat '.·bouN-1'.M::i<a.tfW-E. Q~t~tlle~1tow~ -~~~~ ~,i/~:~~:\,~J:t:i/~/i/hif~fJ;~i~r' ' . . c'·-· ' :, _ " --.. :;1-;. -., . '!bat "'appliou~" obtain the· neeeaaary: building-;pentit• . : ·· ~ .. to make the .requir.S ·structural change ■ ·to l:>e.-·aompl.eted--'!,\ .: > ;_ ·: ,'._;:no .. later than .-•ix 1110ntha after, adoption of -1:hia~re;.ohl,'t, .:;._.~-....-._ .... :, .. -'./,:.:f:>i~~:/<~,:}_'. .. ~·t·~J_:/_:/.~ · '.--,\~ ·\.;" _-::·.:.:\·-·~· , ;,. , , ·. '.;·'.,. :, .~· . -~, ,• ··.'.·;~.) :·~::-.:·\_. ·<.:__.~ ·.: <;~-~/~·:~~:~l\;{:1:~?/{{~i~· )';:;:-:{; :;.''{/C; 2 .;_FJJpon :ruioval -:of the second story, the remaining'<s.truc:tur" '/.<·:,~· .. :\;lf.<:.·•\'~aay-.. be·•.aapped with a deck pursuant·•to· obtaininq.·a .. l:)\lil4~~ . ,,;,:,:'·\ .. '\;?:,::r;tng·.pemit:.therefore •. · . . . . . . '-' =:i-:t:L~~c~idc.j.cC\l ff ·~\~!i: of O,,ono, Minnesota to draft Cloutier'• letter of 9-22-89 . Assessor'• Field sheet: l-2-77·,. :. · -·.~~;:~~/:> ., , . . ·.. . . ~ .. -_:-{.:_.-.·_· .. ·.·.·.·.~._--~··.·~-:'._:.··t•,···.·.~~.:~-.· .. ·_.:._:·.•.~:-.~--·•.··: .. _:~•.·,.·•.:: ... ,.:''·. __ ~-·._·:;-;_.: __ ;_}_.-'"·•·-.•.'·.:':·•:·•, _ ~ f}-~~,'.~J~~;.•t;~~~/!'>:.:~i~}~:!~)J~~:i:_'o. ; < ·•-.... ~ ·. ·. . . :. . .. ' . ;--:·~ -~--~~--i~' .:wo\lld·rapenc:t'f'on;;.'.applicant.. · Cloutier· sent copie• of· ordi~~'~ ... , :.:!=i ,.!:~=: t•:f>8ck (34,201) and aet.back~ ·for · ~';J.C,!-~.£~,st" ,~:;,;-1~1., · · ,,.2,,~~;;;;l~~\ f'.Apy,licant withdrew new gueat ho·u•e propoaal ■ince ·rt::quired:;iakuhor~;:_,;. setback for new gueat houae would interfer with future plan•~:f,;>r: ~-,1/"• addition to. th• main houae, PlaMing Commi-■ion revte.wed :thai.'oricji,p&l? application .. and made their recommendation. Please .re-view.: &ldlibitJ;0 ~/>"1 7 ~ 8 for.background discussion and recommendation., . -,,_~t:··:c:<"o~;t;'.,::.::,:S;;;'~-· '-·'!. ' ~ . . . : --~"::-:·.··~:',°.})~~-::/:tttt;f:f/f;j:J#· In :·reaponae to Clolitier' • letter of 9-22;..eo. The Plami:ing ,.CCiaa J«coepted hi• report a ■ part of the official record but;>\;ba~i · realb• the City'• record• show no penuts for the additiona -.: done out8ide of original building permit. · ; -' .,j' ::··',·,-/~::,;,-c,t0;];: ' . ·.' . : ' •, . '· ·--,._:. :·:,•,"· --:--~-;~~\5t=~~,;~:,:::.-;~:~ :In•-the 'Planning Comrni••ion'• recoaMtndation, the 'aingle;; storyJ hou•• wa• allowed to remain because, the _following.,,Cindi. •';.~ . ·::,.:=:=:~:::u::1::·~~Sf ~l,!~1~~ .... · 4) ',fair urket·value aa of 1•2~77 ·wa~ $2,500~~0-,·: is,:,::;,i/~if{~iiQ:f(i:{t#.~7 CClld.••ion: iieiab.ra :-·rec~lled the. City I s position on the V~n 'l'assel . > -conditional U•• Permit. 'l'he fair market.value of that structure was.)\ ,.900.00 but-•taff in•pection deemed the boat house sound and· in good ·}\ .repair:1' The·City,iapproved conatruction of a deck on top of the boa.t,>j,.';·',';, hou•••·· · . < :-:, . · ' ,.· . -· .-,.',,:_,-:~ :·,,,_ ..1.'·:. ~-.:_~~:_;;::~-~:.,_; :;-'· ,· . ·, 'lf.a;.•inql•X•to.ry·boat.houae capped with a deck.is allowed to remain,::\:;· . Cloutier, must: \obtain a;: building permit to make all necessary change• ·->·?}:, ia exiatincJ,•.•tructure. · · .·.· ... ·· .. ;.;~:;.,,,,.".:.;;7;t -\i;:~~,:~ ;below 'thar.PlannerJ e/option••~~fri;acticm,,not:ed-:,di11~>='; .. ' :ot .. 1-2,-so,. . ' . ·,, ·' ,; .. ,,,,•c•>·-' .,.,, •. ,,,~---, 1 "i• .. _·,;..;,:,,, .. ,,-..')";•,~ 'DEPTH IFlrml 8L0G,SIZE. i .. ... .. CITY OF ORONO CALLEO-IN DATE TIME INSPECTION NOTICE SCHEDULED PERMIT NO.-----COMPLETED / -cJf-f/ ADDRESS cJq.fb dwt!!> Pf-tJ OWNER CONTR. ____ _ TELEPHONE NO. ---------._ Vs1TE INSPECTION □ FOOTING D FRAMING □ INSULATION □ WALL BO. 0 FINAL □ PROGRESS □ DEMOL □ FIRE PAt:V, COMMENTS: ~L~ ~ ., • • .. • ... . . □ PLUMBING Al □ MECHANICAL □ WATER HOOKUP □ METER SET/TUAN ON 0 SEWER HOOKUP D SEPTIC INSTALL. □ SEPTIC MAINT. D WELL TEST PUMP !la.'! . .. . .. • .. . • I • /d' EXCAV.JGRADINO/FILLING □ LAKESHORE/WETLANOS □ LICENSING □ COMPLAINT □ FOLLOW-UP □ SEPTIC FINAL D 1-19-81 · .. '. 4 Ac;Jainst ; ... : ·:~:~~- . ~-,: ·, ___ , ,Approval. a.·. As submitted -· ___ Approval a '';;, :---App,:ovala · Additional infonaation required._:.:1,eforei~il'f: ( .. ,, ---\:-.:~!:,_.::!a~~::.~pt~f ... a~ii~f;.:'.~~~~~;j~~~!il;,14~~:;,~~~- ---· ·~ Tabled 1 :_> Pl9nding-:. review by, other•,_ .or.·:.furt:her:~,Planning?,; , .. • .sion1;'=~; ~:•~~~~ baoe4-~:'2~¢¥i~~ii~Eii~\~~f~ ,iit~ ,, fi~iJt{:t:X~ft:/;i:::r::))}:t~{f:#{';,. _.J,,q,,:·~~J ?;:;~,PEMNINQ· COMMISSIOM'?MIHtJ'fJIS :OP'.:'JJUl,UU,Y",'.·l . ,. . u~;;ig:~iiwr ~r■-h Ot ~555 Fra::1~bJ;E~f'~~!~w~Q•; • .,·,;-t::;:,Japplicant were present. St.Aff reviewed tbe eite,,,,;; ,.-;i24JQfc.ias~ f;,:•c.; ·.: plan for the propoaed guest houae >notin9:·t.b&t:· ;t.h• ;,•-~1. }({: ·"" '> aver&9e ,lake-•bore ••tba..:.k · required ~uld · be; •~ ;'. r·;C~l~ .. Ji·/, > proximately 130 Pt. and the aite plan ·de•ic;nated ., ···• PBRMiffJ;?fi ...... . ?;'.lf?·\~/75 ft. .Cloutier withdrew hi• application for a.·:', '·',C,555):/,_,;{f:\:._,g '""'!>,c . . ·, '.MW· gueat house becauae, required lakeahore Ntback ·• ·. . .. :· .· \ /?:.;t ;ii,fi .-,:::~. would interfere with a future addition planned. for ... •. , '. ,>.:·)~\;:~ };if'·i· -:,,;-'.·the main house. Cloutier reat.Ated hia poaition &JS. · ·/TD ::f;,. :: 11 ~~::::::::r::~PP:::•:: ~-==•porchO ·· ,~;.)jl~¾ 3. 'l'o remove all plumbing improvmunt• done without permit. 4 • 'l'o obtain permit for installation ot furnace. . 5. 'l'o .liJllit all work on _· repair. . :..:· · .. ,,,.,':. ..... t·/.:·,2 ,;: : •· valued -1:>ov• 3,000.00. . Jabbour noted::tbe:'aWlarJ..ty':> ·~:. ./f'"-:·,J$.,,1'• r';.~:.,:L .\:_ .. ; to the Van 'l'••••l conditional uae,.penu.t·application. · · , l~t,.:o: • , · :,.:'.,'l'he boat hoUH, a non conforming structure, was valued .,·,.·::-. s-""'.llc . . , .::,;: ... at.l•••·:than 3,000.00 but because of the excellent . ; ~-~,_~ .. -.~_:_i_~_;:;_;_~,~--::. ~·;;'::/:;~;condition of. the atructure Council approved the con-~ ·•. /';t~'.;.j·•b:uction.ol a .deck on the .ilat roof. The Planning k, · {., . , COlllll\iasion once again advised Cloutier that recent in-· , , )J;/(\tonustion aubmi tted by. the previous building inspe<?tor. and·. f:l, ,~t•).·/ .a .nei9hbor revt;1al. that. the original building permit did · k•i ~::(;~}:\inot cover .a 2 atory structure. The permit covered a · " ·: ;"':-:a:i;)? ~:/iaingle. atory boat house capped with a deck. -.:.,~r:<~,.,_ .. ,:-... :.:-~·:,.:!: . . . ·. \';-i~_ "'..< , :,,;.·~,:.-:;: . . . i(\,:\,/},,,;J&bbour .moved .first, .,te> .. 41eny,ithe .. original,a}Jplication ··of·. t{/;_"::~\Veortlen' Cloutier involving aeveral improvements to the:: ·: ~i~r{ '.; 2 atory, confo.rming, .-strµ_c~ure;;~eguµ:illg:~J~h¢·t · · ~·• . ,,-.,~ . -·~ "'·· . . . :.::~~:~-' .. .. . . r-4'1~'- ~~,?ai~n~i;J:}t[f??'.:\Dif':\/\)\;_}I'?tf~~ ,. . .. ,-. .. '\(~~\}:;;i:·;PLA'NNING _COMMISSION. MINUTES OP "7ANU~y·,,:19}.Jl;?,~-}.;~ -ffi}ftttSt;_,.;: . -~ -·. · , . ,,· __ ,,,_, >::~:,:/(~?tf0t~~~-~ -~".::,,: -:) : H&1111erel: found it ·difficult· to concur with. thlllll:,,.../j,..~J..f:~!~ ;f;,:c~::5; __ .r:,;:,: r41queat to remove .th• ••cond atory., •inc•itbe·••t,~iai'~;. ~;: 1;:J, i '>·th&• been ,in exiatence for 10 years, with .. tv fair marut;:;we (;>r.•,::; 1 :;_over $10,000 and in consideration of.buil4i.ng'.per:nai;~'iprQi, _:,:··_;;·· ,_) :''cedure• in those day•. . ·/:;;:-,;-c ).,};~;/J!::tis~it ' Hr. Harvey was not preNnt. · Sta.ff aHur~-the:.:::L:~~s~un::· . Planning C0111Jnission that the applicant:;~er•to~i'i'ii~J,ft358Qt;, ... ··.the ordinance• a, requirement that all cropa,• sold:_-4:t :;.;.lr<:ON~J. ·:hi• roadaide atand 111u•t be grown on the site. · -'.?:;:i'f"',PEltMlfJ.', · ·: • ·c".'s ·,•:.: ·( f 57ca ' ~·-. ,,::: ,_. ' : .. . ' . ··t"; ... ~ Frahm moved to approve the Conditional t:ae Permit and'\'.·.>"'·: · Variance application of Fred s. Harvey baaed on the ~_.-y,;/; following finding• r · ... • • .. '/ :::':,~-c .... ,:;~~.,;ilf',:'.::• _ .. . . · . · ·_-· ·.: --; :.:: . .:.._,.~-:~-~ .. _? ~-.. ~~\\·-~:~r;/t}~*+i l. 'l'he. atAte· highway department ha ■· approved: the '\.<,:,~-,~::.~t:,, acceu olf Hiqhway 12 for exiating house and'. tem.,;·.--::,.•:-;;p3\\: porary roadaide stand. . · ::·._-::a;::;\}/:2-i{~f;:l -· . .-. -.. •-. .-.~-~--~---;-• -<:~-:,f?~)~~~::~:\\·~:t~)~1tr~ } 2. . Only crop•· grown on the subject property; w~l.1:-.bft~1;~iff ·· . aold, at Harvey• a roadaide. atand in .Orono.·;}'~ ·,,0,<:--'~• i , .. •··•·1 •• ,__ .. ·:. . :_ ~; .. > . _: . } ·~ .::;_·,:;::~::-'.~?'p~·:<fii}~}~\·.~ti~::: .. 3. _.·. 'l'o approve-the··variance -for·"'-h•·•ize of''.exi•#i ·_ ;~,,,. -.. barn •• a road aide stand baaed on: the following:::/~.::, f indi~g,• s. :\.~~-• .... ,, : ··-: . , :, ,_· :./ · { : : ;,, · ·;:{.i.:::.:Jt~{{,~;g';j}\~?{f,,~, 'A~.•· To .allow: uae.of · exiating atructure-:,tbat-';i~,v ir(t-\::\~f. ./, ··. .. . . . good. condition and .in excellent::loca~iQ~;-\(::f;i.\'.ttJ/f,fa\,, · ; · B. · , sti:uc:tur•. c:;onfoJ:11\8 •· to ·-setback·/ standard• .eq:;i;~:ft'e~:,JJ,'!'l'¼ic')t .. '·. · .. c •. ,Large enough to.·require .. that 'all' sales.'produce';('.11[!i:I . . , '. · will be stored inside the building. · · .. ·.. · .. ; ' . · ':f >0 ..'.; 1-'-1·.,r ", '. Jf()~~~: HCO~~~ci';.-b/ Hammer el . Vote: Ayes ( 5) , N:ys ( 0 "·: . ('"?-J\ntt\fi · , Mott.~n ,~~--•ed. unanimously. ; ,; . ', _ .· · . . _ , . ·;,,,~r<>~fitiJ,._;.,{i/irit,'.f'·· .. Robert White • __ wa• ·, preaent--.~-t,:c,:'htt:-J'lanning, Commisaion'"""":·~.';'.::\'t:''·'· f·,acknowledged' a receipt of a letter dated. -12-5-80_:· .. : ' ;,:7/:;, · from the Woodhill Country.~lltb1• • . ,•· . ".> ·: .-:"· -:;;_; ~';;". ,,ijfl . ;5;.~~;tz:::·u~j~,<\'. "?iJIUIJICTa:~'' IS55 . Cortlen :Cloutier, 2480 Caeco Point load .. t~~if,I.t".;. :.::: bcu .. , ::{~tot:racu .· ..... ~.,>OJ:clinance .,34~027 ~ Gmat · Bou,e • Standard• ):~\.·,i.: 1., · . .AccaHory UN to principal. ,}:'.i•\/2. ·. loa.,pa,-nt far its UH 0 ::':iH·''{3~·:·StructUN1·im•t.meet all area and ·eetback 1tandard••: .. i~i!J¢'t:Ct-:t:-a~~tG;··.: ...... . ,. .. ,,.~-·' · ; · PropoHd • Total area 3 acre• J/~:~; .. ! :·t,'/~/ Mr;fCOrtlen•c1outier 2480 Caaco Point Road Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 ,, ,· . IIOUC:S,:OI' .-PIMIBDTG CONMISS IOU, AC'nOl( •. . ~ -,, Dat~)of Mlleting • __ o_e_c_em=be-=r_....l_, _1::.9;;..8.0 __ _ Votea 1 . . 6 l'Or O Againat P~ cominia ■ion reconaerua the following: ___ 'A~1a Aa ■ubdtted Date of Nbtic•=--:::.::::....-::;....;.~~ EXHIBIT ---:$k;,~ ___ Appr:ova1a Subj~ to condition• noted . . ., ---·'Appr:ova1a. .Additional information required before Counci1 ,. · ·· . -Yv--Denial.a. -· l'Or reuons noted ,,. . _ . ._ .•. ___ · ... : ____ .:''l'ableds. ·Pending receipt of r.aditional ~ormation from).1pp.l.i ___ 'bbl.eds-'Pendincj•'review by o'.;her ■, or further Planning,~~•• . . . -·•tudy . . ___ so:·act:ion required. b) . f • PXJ\.NNING COMMISSION MINUTES OF D~CEMBER 1, 1980 PAGE 2 3. Park Dedication Pee of $200. 00 ($100 each lot). GARY LINDGREM '.;{;'~\~;: · 4. Dedication of additional right of way for west 4505 Wea t Bran<:Jf: .· Branch Road -total of 40 • from centerline. SUBDIVISION .~::.;c;:;/::;,'; Public;; lnfo/{Meet 5. Dedication of drainage and utility easements. (f588) ,;,·cont:/'',·· '~~:::~::~:~::::~~:~~~~~::;::::~~~~~~.1~~~~J,~;1 ' .. he never received a written. follow. up adviaing;;.him ., . :coNDITIOilAI;lu · >of his options of action. The Zoning· Administrator:: . :.vARIAHC£~~:;';}fJi · noted for the record the letter of 11-12-80 and copy .. •;·(t555)::;0 ::i~::('( · of Planning Commission minutes of 9-22-80 sent to · '·" the applicant reviewing the alternatives •. Cloutier stated he must have misplaced the notification. The alternatives were once agai~ reviewed for the . applicant. They advised that if· he chose, to go with . the original proposal, the Planning.Commission would not change their original recomJDendation to deny. A new proposal for a releicated·guest house and retention of one level boat house would require a · new review. Rovegno questioned if appli~ant would have to apply for a new conditional use p~rmit. Staff advised that this would be considered another variation of the original application. Mr. Anderson was concerned that Planning Commission would have to delay action again. He asked for : 0 a••urance that the lakeshore setback for· the propot,ed ·· 'guest house would be determined by· the existing · . •tructures in .. the neighborho9'1.-... .ar@ ~•-1" "~· t;;\,tlµ•¥~••rpart:;of~ithe§_no .. . · · · · llcanti!WO\JJ.d ., alsojbe~ into i nt · ·· 0 OF DECEMBER l, 1980 -PAGE 3 _ P14n -for aingle story boat house -showing final altered atructure to be reviewed by staff. Pair market value of boat house as of 1-1-75 if leas ._than $3,000 than structure may have to 90. )/}··Motion seconded by Hammerel. Vote: Ayes (6), '<.:/ Nays (0). Motion passed unanimously. t-•:'L.; t:f.·•The applicant was not present. New members \r,certain conditions of the Stubbs Bay Marina Rezoning <~>AgreeMnt. Most of the concerns dealt with the ,).::extent of_ the variances necessary in an LR-lA zoning 0}\~:district.: 'l'he Chairman advised that these were - f'minimal c0111pared to the violations cited against 'f ~th• marina. operation. Thia agreement was -the result .:-;.;·_ of -many, compromises on the part of -the property · owner · i/;and:the-City and that concerns raised by this body '. ·will· never change conditions of that agreement. f~;!Stj~f, advised that the Cosnmission should ~eview the ,propo•ed-plan to see if additional information is needed-to complete review. Staff will ,:equire· septic. ': testing .. for. gray water system. Access road should .:;tJ::Na·deaignated for three residential units to be r~1con•i•tent _with City's policy. A public hearing is -__ - \f•cheduled. for January 19, 1981 at 7:30 P.M. '<··. CORTL.ES CLOUTIElt 2480 Cas.co Point CONDITIONAL USE ro, ......... VAIUANCB-. · , Cf 555) Cont.~ ·-· __ ,_ f r;•t:-J);}z~ applicant was not present. Staff advised that JAMES_'.P. ,RIVBRS/:!t applicants were .r~guired. by a rezoning agreement 1440 Shorel~-/p~ •;to coaaplete a subdivision for the subject property •. , · StJBDIVIS.IO!F'''\,<'/? ·+i'J."he unapproved division occurred when the original •· _(1590)_ WorJ,t._S"e.11u1" •old a portion of the ,lot .wi~~\½t;-;,,.~p~-1.~Jl!J"1:ifed,.;"1.,).;,,;~· · · · ... ' .. , ,t?,V¥:!i1~;r:~;_~:=~~~~,r;~t~i~tirohffl~~~1~;,it}t 'DEPTH PROIIO&O SETBACKS . FRONT . A.SID£ REAR· L.SIDE LAKE·· WETLANDS.·· NEW :'.:0\:iEXlSTING AGENCY•IJIPROV. DATE· CJTY ', STATE · REMARKS: CONST. TYPE ILOO.IIU L> 10ftM$/F UI · SEPTIC ATT, An, DAT• DIT. DOCK NON,RESI0, PROPOSED use occ. CLASI, STORIES COUNCIL APP. DATE TOTAL DUE lL:\~0;/ ':, ,,'•-~-:·,ef-~ -·\·:~~~~~~~,~·., . ;:·. .;;ito_t[C,.-> .. 1t.t.: ~ --' ' -. ·. d,; .':!:{'.:\ C/.. '. .. ,: ./£;;-, .,·.::j;,/· .·I ~· , ·:: ,. ' :,+,.':.,' ' ' t/k4~'-:l:-~ ~t) .:~~,lt;,~~-~.-~ ~-_ :· ·;::,·.·,:,=·::~-.:. iffl~;]1/~~i~: iJ4 keC &«l:fX'? ~tO&f~y ~;~tff 7;!/"~iw.i".!,ii.U~:;,, ,;_;r,¥.W,-,»w:,,~~~~ J,PiiliI~\\~t{IJi]¼;f ;r~}~i[;{,~ ,~;ij;~f J!l~,;1'.]Jif !l~!i':~, ,.;-,,-, ,,::ca,,:<v .s--',Ci.otrn•~• Mt1&.BQJ1;,l)~19,,;:&~.JQ1D1$1"0Jr.v ·;.'.,..:: ·• :.:,.:·1;, .<··:,,•·-•:•;;. ··;:'i./;' :)i]t} ··1iii!1}t[!f ~;~ !i~{~;J{Q2 "'-~,JY.-Y' ll ,~J;97l ,"'.~<•t~,,r~,-Mz:',:?.; ..... . · 11.~~1NJtlo::~a\pemit;'.\·t•%'~4o•inot::r~lli~ . letta~any.,;,kind · ·of i, app1ioa tion/; ,no~·i4qj.f'f:' ntQned;s~t iU.),ttnei:-e~,wa• .any.ir•l•~JJ, .. ee~1:fiqQ••t:e4,t&D44',trull:expeot,ed;.cost.~o · •t.nct:1,u:e,.to,•,bo,-,c:onatnotctd, ,: or!(2) \ ~::'.!~r!tJ~f;~~;:~~t0 .~ 1 '.,Pt1r~-)-.,,?!:itiJl~i-... . · ... ····.~•··· ... ,, .. ,?t::~::t· ncaoo2:da,confirm,the· foll<>winq 'evsnta.·oocu~"'®·;~,i.c:s:,:✓..p~;·r;"\,.•••10 \n:;~/·;,,vc-10/07/71, ., ~i:q •. '"' $0Ux,4e-livered· ~i?~~:Ef:~f i~i~~~~~~~.~tt; , ,{}t,l?i!~t16/1J AitG• .:, z,.,,{~~nqao,1?,ing,:;:.~~ ,i7 ~{~:?~r~~,,~~~f::::~.:YX/:~~:q,~i_ayl.~·~.'°~~the·,;,~ei-,~ ... ,, r-.: . >:· ! .. ,;,,,_,.,., r .,,,,~· .. -line, •h•lect~,,~,r,.il~·,. ,,_J'.fU{{0t}}f;ttr:f4\lin~_tt:ttt;f{!~ff j~[: . .. ... . ." . . . . . h~~li;~~J.,~4/ti, f;:t~;••t~l0t~?/411.'-'.:i~Yi:Pe~r~n;,plJ,Unber~. ·.installed ,th~.~li11e~:{:".'.:':/:iii:' ' . itW:1.:.):~.1~:.r_;,:~.~ '.·;,·:;:;;'•:< "·:._, _ .. , .·-···. . . · ... ·;,;t\~;~·<t'f:t.;;r? · · ~t'i:(/,f,i,ll/l,:l/7l,/. Dennis. Carlson, and: his helper., .Ed~ard~~uglt,~,/ @if{ifi{f[li}i~/,i>}+A_~"C?~~:,blocks·.f?r·.the walls .. · ., , : :;,:,J~:\' -;JY/Jito:1'12/1(,/11 >: Carpenter ,;Helmex-.:_:Johnson, constructed '.;:Itirt1';t~:/;,;,1,t~:;: ;:~~~=:r2f ~v:12~~ •·• :~~o~t~:;.:~ ,>.,_,,,,:;tiest;l2/l0/7l 'The concrete floor was poured. ·• .. · ...... '"·' ~~-~r·~:.);i;·. ·_., .' _,_.:.;; ~.:· / -. -· ··:_:_ .· , :;·• .>, : __ ·. · .. · ... _• .... :··· _· -.. ,. :-·-_-:-: '.-_ -. . ~. --.... _--._::-~.>. //~~t;~:,_::i-:i.1.i:;;~~~, ~ :,F k,~{14ed. ;,,t}le'tl',ollow~iw ;~~~1;•·r-i~ ~CQ,nn~ti~n!.',jit!J:{(~n~L,. .· •tnc1:ion,.•.ot:•,t.h~.boat/,9µe!,t· po~e, . .'.~!:.·,tl:l~L.t9i1Qw.i.11g1,. :-'-' , .--;, ., .•. , )·, -~ ,, ~,~, ~JJJ{i!;tf /$/ci•tf ~~ ;j1'.:'.i~; .. . : , '" SJiOE~1}PWNING?COMMISSlON' MEETING'.7°1iELD:ON"S~ ~~t;J;t';. • . .. . · .. ··· .. ··.•·• · · · ;,;:m;;:,,;;i~ltl\" __ rt.len·~cl,obtier ,. Wilbur Anderson (3555. Pred-erick)_,.1:'-•;\;:.:.C9 4,r"ichael)::Wallman. (3565. Frederick) were, preaent~\.~L;;Jt248 ~t•PPliicant --~•viewed the mew material •ubmit'ted;;;f'\j\.,,~., t:.:-t.ne·=,meeting .•.. ~,>tn summary of hia writtenJ11tatement,_~;.:i,:.::t. ?ch..Uengea"the-,dat••· :referring ·to scope; of.,t_tJ:)~ :,;",J~;;flii:1tt,. ri9inal:. permit·Jand _period o: ,oonstruction,"cited·,;f!-.;-'/';':':;;;f};;'. chellerr,,.._Anderaon affidavita .. ·r It :is Cloutiertst::~--•A:\t:,:rJ .•i~on).that the.:original: permit., cove.;ed ·the}~9~~k;y\tJ1l-"'·"" to~i•c1',i~t:ructure:,,j ust, Jn. review\of '.th,e .~,~ f8~1\~1t1,,\-~ ''.J~~d~ ... ~:~:~~~~Jl:7.~9 ?~~·,'.:,,,, ~:··.";' \,:·_'f,~-\::,S::~'>?·)£;;~::?~ffi{;,:;.;c•,:;,:\;:J;;~; '.~, . 01Y1,~CC.:~~•tn~iolaiuia,;1:-h•~~~ig~n•!/~-?-i _ .. . .. ~4·/a.,,■ingle,:,story-,boathouse', to =be" ~.e_d•:¥,~ ... · k~;;,-,,The-;.date ■,t1referenced. .: in; 41-t t,ia.,vi: · eWt.i~/ · ~'.ei~~it~~~~~~.~~'.~~-~~;~E!?~~i~~;-::~~~~:r~tri~~z{}:~ . .. . .. -;~~~¾~/ IlJUnt:que ■t.ioned: the .•t• tu, ·.o_f:11:h~~\C!~J~P-9.~~~il.~: ;, ~etJ.~$?5.•~"'•etbaok :; ar.a~.;d::;Jft;f.Q~;JecpJJ4:j;;~,~1r~~ , q~~d:ioutc.~of,:l,th•i~qc,pe4 cf-~bui1cJin,.g.~rpermi_t,\.then:'•·· · · )ij:.hat_,,poxtionJ:ie"allowed .to re~n ].::. >, ,. •.r .· · .. ;u>n:'Of.tha.,"legal non ... c:onforming:,'sectionsof ' ::·~};:,,~:~fft?.::i,,:,\rc;,:·_ .·. '.·.' . :·: : •·. ': '{:_;; :'' _: ' ' ·. ,~~:que ■t;~one-\ .the-assessed valuation.:of·•$1,200.00 A~he 1aubjecti,structure •. It,, is .obvious .that the boat · ~ •. ·· ~iiJ•1worth)JnOre :than $1,200 and· how does the City ff..1SOLveV~i•0;lnu•~:.>,staft advised that with an· •pplic:ation·:qf ~his.;~ype,. an inspection of the non-· , . oontondng.,,:•1;ruct\lra:.is part of the normal rev.iew. staff)://·· •· ., ' ' ' '.j<Anr•V~l~tion·:.Ji• tQ.r,t.he.>,<condit.ion.·of ··t.he·istnictuie'~;' · iSOJlll':"°inatancea, applications have been .denied_ . ··:-:::ft uae;,,of the_:·f,µnd~"-f .: · Planning Commission ·-,Alan P. Olson, Village Pl.Inner . t.: -·: . ~ .• :.: '>'":• . August 13 1 1980 . C i.··,'.i,,:/',;.,., · •.. ': 1_: __ f; · ,r,1· :,_,~_' _:c·.-· r: ~\StJBJBCTi · 1555 Cortlen Cloutior, 2480 Casco Point Road ;~,yu~~.:j}/(· it'" • • . .. • Conditional Uae Pemit ... ··•· .· • • • • ~~~,;~~~J~~~&ftt;i;~~- t ·on/June ,23 ~• .1980, the Planning Commission rec~dd.nW\of't:a'c;J~t: ;:L:. \:fhouM oonditional use peX'JIUt for the Cloutier boathouse-,Tamt,}..-.iaJ.;•?o,f::" :}·'.: ti•. variance-.r•queated to permit expansion of the exist±ngc,::. .• ~~n4~:·.-.~o~/fr ... :.;,: 1=::::·.b-in9 Comi-■ioo -ting, the city re~iz;~if~}/~ ·~neighbor , Wilbur Anderson and from foxmer,. buil.4in9: iin•~~ . . ,1.~'ler;-:-i'.~ · Tbe&e, wer•, reviewed .at .the council meetinq.o~;.July;,,39::,:1~19. · . Ji ~,.file. waa,: ref erred. baa~·: to . the. Pl~ning'./C.-1,,,iqn~: .. :=;:;h~~ ·:~t~·-· ·· :, ,_ · . · · :· .. ;:.1~:·:·;.~~~•::?::::·:r,~~:;~:~>::~4::~~~ utJ.er:;verbally -contend•, tha.t~:thei:~xiatinq.,•~;!~~ . . s;" .. , aa::previously: . .authorized. · .. 'l'he •cityifiles·_-eo.nt.-iin;af~~~~f'::,, ,., •30\X,:20.,bo&thouM" ,only.,,,,'l'here ·hu,been no:pendt,ti•~1P~ :aez:v!Qe::•·to the building or.for plumbing·or:cbeating;;(.~..,,_~~•r · · or::uything .. other. than,t.he main houee. \.:.In:~ipn,:,'l,;~f.,,-"'• t•tat.•1:oleuly,tha~Jw :'issued the pe.mit 'and inspect;ed:,:~ .; .. ~_;1a /~;,!~f,.~~.~ boatho_use • : . , ' . . ; .. .· . . . . . . .. ':):Z;:;f?~J?:(;~t~{-~;t}f~}'.(\: 1Qning t COlllllliaa.$.on is·, asked• by the Council to review: the ·i~e,r.son\a.nd.' : chellei-tletqra,. the· attached. Minnesota Supreme court. case,/,~d tj),e'-· · · . 1~er•11·.memo:of July 24, 1980.. . .: ·. ·.· , ·· . • . :-;•(i};};;/.,;t//: }M~.4";\cJ.outieriwaa asked to present any new information he ~y)1¥t;::::-to ;docwaent;;,hia·poaition. · .If he does so, Planning commission .should.con_a~r, \that, .. aa.it compares to the.official City .... .,. · ·~ 'f;--~ . ,· :,, ·:;-:J::'t. '.:~+'.;~ <~i:; ... _,:.:' .--. '. : -·. ·_,_~:·: ~,· ;-. '{'::-:.,_i~ ,-; .:--., ~~-'.:; . '': . iifi:enew;of''al1''new·"'infoz:mation, ,,additional.finding•--,~"J;',•c:c,~;rQr;wa , ' . -. ; ·~·.-, .. -: ·-· ;• _1,. For J2._ Against thia application --·.-- · to allow you time to review the City tile• (a copy of; ataff,'•':'Jj;lY:/~ . . INIIO, letter• froaa Anderaon and Scheller, and a 1978 ~~;t~~i·•· . . Court C&ae report are 'attached for. your ,inforaation) time to make a mor~ detailed review. you about performing another inside ,-> · .. :~ .._ -.'~;.~···-., J/'?;{·,,:_ . . . ' . . . : . . . .. ' '4,r·:_•DGOLM··.MU'l'ING 01' '1"JlB OROIIIO ;COUJ!ICIL,,.JtrLy:· is /::1980 ·'. "<-:..~. ,, ': ·. , ' . . -~. ~. -·. ·- '!. : • .,, :-• .': • • ' ' '!,. • • ;:-•<. Mr. Cloutier ude hi• application and conte~ .that cau>tTION,i }:',c·} tbe work undorway wa• mroly coapletin9 ~.k _, • . ·.• · · 2480 Case( 1\:,<)•tu't.ad in 1971 .but never C0111plated.. '?be, PlanninCJ : . '(Continu.ei ;_;:'!~:/. COlllli ••ion reviewd tbe application, on.· thi• ba•i•,. . ~i'.'t.'::~).1'he Plannin9 Colaia•ion denied the CJWl•t ;:hou,m • · ·. }{ :::. ~clit.ional UN pendt. and vari&nca for work within ,·?.': .'75 feet of the aboreline, find,i.nq no b&r~ip ·to -,c~ .. --=:fy caxpuaion of a non-conforain9 UN •.ad ",'··. • llty to 9rant a variance ·to Section 31.101 •:;~~~-;ao .that one non-oonforain9 UN (boat. holule) •COG14 ~;:;::~:{be, cbanpd to another non!""OOAtonai.ng •UM_. (9Mat. · tI(>.'<bouN). T.be Ht reault. of thia ~indill9, ·u.vp-.ld. ~~,,'.;,-:\:by• the .Ccnmoil,. vould. .be to cauae re.11110v-1,\of ,.i:M .new \;:~;;·:>fraaing _AIMS HW·-furaace a.n4 to. prohibit.;naw -water . • '''.·/·.<and .NWJ: .. oODMct.ion•, but -to:allow ,t.N ui•t.in9, · .. • /Yttwo-•tory. •true~•. to reu.1n •. "._-: i .. .. ·:·. : . ,-~ . \(\,After: the.,, Planninf coaai••ion Meting .. however, new · · : /i: ·.'information va• received· vhioh .uy be aaUM for total ~~;::·:,_;-,reaoval of the ,auucture becau• of a hi•tory of. ~:.> cont:imd.119 · aiailar 'violatiou. . : . · .. · · . ·;~t~~i~.\~tter• war.--~r-~ived 'trom,:ne~· .. · .. . ,~:~,-Wilbm:--A:ll&uMA ud··froa retired. bui~ i..Mpactor ;-t"~'f'Jliu,_SCMller. · .. _'!Ny. •t.ata1 · -t:}:·1//4--ori9iual-~t bou~·-wu at.u~ without. -" .. · .. _: · c(::, .. :<)pemita, w••--~ted.-impl:'operiy,.-and·in .. tac:t, .. . , ... · .. , l'.. ,. .... _f . "-~"-...., .. .,.__ e-1.-1,--. . ... · _:;.>-=·'.;"::•,.·co ...-J)Nu::-O&'e. · ..... spe,:~.-.-.· .,_, ~-,,~ -·•::s.,·.;·~~--:<;i:i, : ... J}~;r ~,?f:~~~li: :~ < ~ •: /.~ 7; .. ~.\; '' .: .. _,. • • ,.'> ~·;,',:,/J;~') >;;; l~~~:-".:','C~/~.~•'(\:, _,~:;.,.~ ~ •:·'.'.'' • •. • , .~ : . • . • .': '. • ·:~ ~>:~. fZ2~ 1_.t!~~pa:,u.1:i ,; ianed · in 1971 wa• never intended t.o - · ',aover anything .except, a one-story 20' X 30' boat :,,.?i•'';'. hov.H-capped with an open deck. All aecond story .. work n• therefore been clone without authority aoaetime between Mr. ·Scheller' s final inapection and March, 1980. :.',In addition, the 1980 aaMased fair market value of .. :the total building is $1,200. Section 31.106 requires .. · reJ10val of any non-conforming structure with an ; . ••MaNd value of $3,000 or l••• vi thin 36 month• · of '/:,~;January -1,· 1975 or no lat.car than Januuy l, 1978_. . . 1-.~,,•-~- .,,11oa.-;& ... l4 .. P ~::nNlll,n,.. ,., ·"'"' ... _ -·:':,c~ . ; ::. ., ·, 5i~ 01':'l'U OaollO 'COUWCIL, -JOLY 28; 1980 .. '?)iii~?~:/~f:~::.> .. >~~--··; -.-• . -. - ftJOC-~:11Ca1°·}~aon, there ia &b.otffl to be caUN.·for low.f.At:DOM.:work to remain, tbs Councsil would have ·~;,-.Jca,,the;,followi119 .. f ind~g•· and approval•, · Of:vbiob .have ·l:Hton Udoi }~~~;i:~'.-~:;a: •infl• •tcxy boathouu· only a -'5 1 7:--::r:..::·. ;-:..~:-_ . - \,{t/•rtt ~1n4:. that value exoee4-d f3, 000 aa of ''.\"~:;',J~ 1, 1975, and notify IHH ■,aor of cba.nt]e. :~~;:r~1~-;•_·-::~--<;·;'. :;_ .:··· ·,, .. - .,,,.'.}\t'/b)>:'fapp.rove conditional UN permit for • non­ {:;;~~:t~,:i,.~/09ft!o.nain9 UN •• Of January 1, 1975, Section 32.480 :;.h·;;~:_:~·:;.:~/· ··->-· .:.'~:; ·._ . ~.-;>'!'o:'uep;Qy Ncon4 story ehel.l, witbo\lt dwelling /c: foapabilitya . ·;_:~-~{it·•1...t.. :-· ~ • • - ·t'il .. ,\tin4·.'.that. it exJ.ata4 before Januuy 1, 1975 ,+?.~'b)5)find :f:h&t it ext.tad before OJ:diruance i.e • .1S5, .... c ;l'ebnuy _l.4, 197'. (7!5' Htback) . . -ofk:tincl ::t;bat. .J.t '.waa ·never an unpenu.tted · expanaion · : oti;j non.;.gonfonaiA9. UM . · .·· ·•· · · • · , ... · . . , ·,: ·.4) , ,authorize building perait approval after 'the. ', .. ,/i;:,fact, Abjeot to lull code COlllpli&nc:e and. payment. ".:.'\·::· :;of·:.-11·.fM•··ancl penal.ti.ea · · t~tt?~:\:/:_'•:•,,~::~~ . ~ -:,~::,-• •::• C ''-,. :.,.. ·,.•r,:•····/•._·_a11 -,-•at &a-•--. ua .all f 4 ... A 4 .. -• ·"'--pl11 •. s. · ~~-w,.~•--..~ .. 6V_ ..,.,., __ ,y-~ I .........., -.UVYV ...., :.~, ·:-:find :it •• ao uaed before January 1, 1975 .·. '1 --.:·.~--'.-.-,,.;-<: :-,·. ' ,':".-.0:. •• -. • ; :\);;i;'.b)":~appl:Oft :91,1eat. .. bouu conditional use peJ:mit, \t~:tl\·'Seotion "34.027 Md. variance•. to lot area, aide :i,:,:"'';;,,Nt:bacJc''and lake Ntback . . ?:X·ttr~r-,. ->~-,\. -.i: ... : . . ~-· t:.:<.:;>o) .·;,require.,inatallation of s411itary facilities .\Jrj~.:-~;~~/ ,c'·:L~.f(-·;.;, •. ~--·:,r·.,~,--:,~--/ -. . .· ~ . . .,;,:?:;,';,1:d)1 •~require payment of additional SAC, sewer t:· .':L;,unit. P4 ··water unit charge• ~~,F~t~, -Jvly 28, 1980. . • ·. ,n~tiaJ; ;WU preNDt .. ~• W!:11, 9i:Y!Jh~ ·:'1:. -~~ . . . Mill!n• ·; · . h Pffld,t had bun b•~'.ld by the iMpector at thi41 t1-. · · Wba·· ·I&ffind at the ,on, tJi. blocJC',rork had al.req~· oollapNd c:tu. to DIDS urly back till, rain the night· before · and non oontcmd.ng (8) •iiht inch block•• When I tallold to ._. Cl.out14'r atY.,ut. the colla.p~ structure ~. tail.UN to get a buUduag pel'lldt, he stated to * ,that.'it .waa 4 ,F', l1'0UM level. boatboun, and th.t.t the 111ateritl tsoo.oo( •·1... hundrea Dollars). I Jl'el!t to NVeral. ot the neighbors, among them Wilbur 11.r.d .Ma.urine .· . . -~ . . - · ~NC •t j.55.5· FNC!.erick st., and they said they .'"'~ have JJt ,,eir~i(,':.>:_.::___,_:<_ .. _,:~·7 ~\' ;~>···:\·.:. ·.·· ; -._?,: .. ---··-. . -· . Jr,._·.J::c;'/:::,;:,:?;';,.:;1no· objeotion"to a ·grCltlM level boat houH. Jr;4jf::ct:'"~~--:->·~~!<-.<\(·-~-· ·-:>>:!-~<· ... -_-,' -~--"·: . ., . . ---. 1 ·.? >: {,' , . With thi• I issued a jwn,d.t # 2495 tor $,500.00 ( Five hundNd Doll.a.rs) -in uteJoi&l.s at. a r .. of $5.00( five dolla.r.s). -~~~ -,,,i~,m~;:r~::~;y _-,~-".~;tf;ti. ',:i,"t~·c••~ s'.:'·, • MNtwiJlabQ.th;,; -: .. , . .. 1:;;,_ ·.··.•.· ... ~.~.~-;:.{,E.·.;:_·_:.:.:.~.,.: .. ,:•··.'.· .. :~.~ .•.. , ... ~--,·.:.·.:.:.'.,;.:··=~~. &~·. . -· :--... ~~.~,~-: .--__ -·-': 11114 "" .. __ -~.. :.:_ ... '.-i:::~T"/irf~:;.,. ·, •. :•:,:,lr ·.:.."'~'·1 f ~ -.~.. ,sJ)1 ... · · ,., _ .. ~.·, 1 .,·.·.~, .. I.;.:.·.i_••···"'.·.:_'.'.-.t.~.•.•.i; .. ;=.: ... :.:.·:·:··• .. ~.:.,.·.,. .. ·.·.·.~.\ •. ;·~ .•. ·.·.:.•.i:·.····•·•· .. ' .. :,·:.·.L,·.'l'be .. \,.·o.ou. ·. ·.;;, .. · · ~ 4-~•,in., -..· er, M1lce ::icm.ller··· ato........A. ·.· ·.,·• .·•. t_·_ •·O\lr·'·'··· .··•.h·\··•':•.A•::\~/i~;c,;,,, ~t::i;;;{;,, . .--.• ~--" 1, 197l. ·· ~~~:=·:u. ot a ~t hw: •. g~~ ca'.:~.'-::;; \{{)jtj~ ·:;;1f?)1~'~)t\•\, .. ,-. ~-_· '~-~~ •, . ; -_·. :."'•-,,·, · ... · /e';!Y'. r·~ 'm.it'iff J)J"OJ)erl)" at· &bout 24e0 C..IIOOl'Jtt,.id. Be at.at.cl that it ••.. 't' fl". ~·''. t.o•~ ..r•oamit block oCll'lstruotion a.nd to be mde.rg~ and capped off ¥1th & deok. He &1ked 1! we wow.d.baft any objectun to a istrucrt_.;-, nob •• th1•• 'J".· .; 1:.··',· . • . Mb Jlluriae and I qu.sti.,_ hi.a abcNt tti. toraer attempt· at 't..bM oi:nst.Mtim t not ha vine bl.Nb up to o«te and the failure t• obtda,a peNtt. Mr. Scheller .tat.ed that tbe new cccstruct1~ voald ·' · be·. brolacht up to oode and that a 1>9rmit ooal.4 be ia.u.i it theN :wa9;,-.; •J.'•''..' .'; '.·_, ~ .>.· ,:ir.--' . wld.Gh vaeito .. bi. ian.d tor tin hundred dollars. , .. , -W.. .. t.u·oeaant blocks were CAw,,d off at ground 1n-el.a.nd t.ho-· •· •• · ·. 'd~'.(~.;~"~)~ftl• 'lleN n&iled d01o-n, J/f'/ und-,rst&tding was tut '·.' it •• ow.pl.et. a,· pe:r agreament with )!r. Scheller and withill the ,-.•_-,·. H~;aove4~=:~l"4'0Cr 11114 · approval ·of th•-two lot , •· · "(Jomt · . . Ul\9ent:~1,upon·-tu tollowin91 -., -~ . .. , .•. _,,.,:. ~1,sh. --:. , ·~;-~~~J~i,,:~t.r;::i._·;)·~~-~~> ···: .· ,::~~ ._· ':>¥ .->-_{-./~ > -. . .. \~:~:;~:~:-~:JUBD l/ . •~'4cxm•ez:vat:ion· •••--t t:aken:~er .. r:t:,2:(f.5~~): .. "1 t~•l.9Ut414:."t.1•nd••-··_~-· · ,~: :~:_:,.;~-h~~·;:~·1!~qt<'i;" ~ ~i,1:0~9rant,,a,private-driveway and utility_ : • :;~·:_.::::~·ii·,·,<;:~:' ~to,Lot-,1. ', •' .. . . ' ' ' • •',; :~'.O· .. ,>.•••~\:~•• 114R1g.g,•;.t.Ju1tallation ••hall.,contom-to the 0n:-Site·· ·.-,··:·•·;(,:•>.,.;.tl' ")-P-_. . ' • ·,> .'• ~. .'--_;._·',:; _:·. ~~ .. ~~_::~:;{•t~-- ~i;Naa9c •-~report and, Mptic, daaign .:to• . .<< / .':.,:,;~1 fom~vitb .. the.·· conaultant • •. recosmnend&tion .·:·• .:/:: '·;. ).r''t!t:r -:~g~f_,~;1JMU."t::~~• for Lot. 2 ot $200~ <-?' ._:·~';);;,\/(ii'.'f{;)J~-­ II01t:SG. R'~ed'.'by':Jabbour •. _Votes, Ayes (7)~·r1tays>(0):.::;:\;;\t¥,;>fh;;., Notlon''J)Nllfld 0unaniaoualy ' ;hv'.·.:·~--;-J~~~r~ ~ ~-t. · 11. --91~.aC0PY 0i,_;;7:~fj~~ •Aft~..., ~to .. -read . before any 4i•cu••icm: c::olllfD8Aced •. ·. . :~ .2,a.o~,ca-~:~ JIO~publ,i.c. c::a•enta 0'1Hlre heard.. Mab\ast.h atatec!: the . . -: V'A1UMtCSi," · appl~t ;i.•:.;.not .raque ■tinCJ Additional. deck, but :'"' :·~ ~B':~ .. , . onl.y~;;9er•flin,g •. , :u. ... rel aaked tbe · app.licant · 1.t · ·.>:. ;. · ~ f 5~Snt;, he vu,awu•::tbat:his.buildin9 pendt bu expiredr , · , •. -·:::t~;t:/~°Tf\ Mr. -Cloutier'·••id~tbat-wu what he Jut.,. been-informed.: ·,0-c\/•Ji:;•;;;1?1. B..-Bel ·furtber brought 1:o Mr •. Clou~•• attention · _. .,:-•.::,:.~:~·;}~J,;:'.i~1~E. -that1~iPlmmin9\Collmduion ~Y not. leg-1,ly 9r~t< c " ··,::}/f::;:t~:}!~ a .vutance ,to ,the standards Ht .forth. in the non .•, . ; :_•-c:,··;,;.':-;''•,. confoi:aiag u .. ,.aectiona of the code •.. McDonald· stated. .. ~:::·/'.:?',,tI,;,,,( Bhe-,felt· thu >application· va• not inc,:eaaing. the · . : , :· :, u:J";,f,,, '?fif~ ba:dcover.which alrady_exista and that.adding a roof, vu not. expuding the.-usage. . During, further· diacnaa8ion, ~it ~wu · •tatod that use, .. not hardcover,. wu:1:.he iaaue.,. ,At;.tbat.time, Mr •. Cloutier stated · be •lleYer--intanded.to UM the-•t.ructure .aa a guesthouse; · he'::waa 110re interested in fini•hing the .screened porch .. -··· ~ Jf .. ·· u~l;,=Jioted;.tb.at ,he :felt : an 1nterpretation . of. the .. - non-oonfonain9,:,u ■e· section• of the·-zoning code by the - City :Attorney. ,i•, necee•aq before the Planning. commission can,aake<a.sn;oper recoaaendation. . -,, ,-_. / _, ••···At our June 9, 1980 meeting, •uff wa• ••ked to ,reapond•"to:f. -following a · ·--• · ;_ :: {S/·f ~!· . A) Legaliti~• ot hookup to main house utilities{_ , .. :r._..·~0:-.iff}<?J{j:_ . . . . .··_:;:~~> ;:\•·~<-~·-:/.~!?it\8:f-1{;: All such·.work would have requir.d ••epuate'permits:that.t:i . guest houn or apartment had received offic:ial~i•PPJ.'~f~ . . -. conditional., uae penut. · There .. i•• no.· record ,of .. ;~:;;pepa:t;,~ .. ; . : _.-· iaaued for the connactin9 _ •ewer • and --water lin~.;t#t~i•. · ,'. , .. : . --· . and SAC. charge would have~'bNA ,,:equil:ed alao!.•r~~­ ••ter in•talled and watcr;unit::chuge ... tJ, ,wlit · · ··? :· . .' . . . . .: ' -.-,--.. •'· ; . .-. ·•"'-··--''.; -. - · B) _ Bow i• .the. aubjeot proputy, ... •••Md?i'.-.'. ,', .. :)_'';::;;- .-• • • < * •. ·:, ~:-~-~ • :->. > .. 4 -:,".>::?~t,t<f:~~~t~~~.~-- . The applicant appliod for ·• ··COlll>inat.ion of;' hi•.~~ . · . lot• and road ·outlot ,on-.Decenmer 6, 1911. ,r.'fhe-:;_:~rty~va._:, _ u••••ed · tor one . ..wer. unit. Th• -••••saor",valuea'A-tbe ,boa thou .. ·c,·:::::::joft,0; ,n~,.c;-t~;".;\;~;,,~&;~1~}~~,i~f J~t!~t~i!~ . .. ::. 'l'he · 1:>uilclin9/inapectcn:, 1."detemined all,. new_,)construct;on :invol!ed . ; '':' ,'only· _the .,acreened • porch ,.area. ;_ . 'l'he :. conetructioi. .. wur noted ,tq_f). : /,;~~:1DOat·,,recent ,by the condition· of" the ·wood.,: Photographs we~e'7~ •• :t;:-:':for review at the Planning :Coani ■sion, Meeting of:June. 23rd.:?;:~fj' ·: :t~\';·::,. : . . ·. ... . -. '•,,; ". --~:-=; >: ._. CITY OF ORONO INSPECTION NOTICE PERMIT NO. ____ _ CALLEO-IN SCHEDULED COMPLETED ADDRESS )., H: 5: a ~ Y1 QI DATE TIME . OWNER _____________ CONTR. ____ _ TELEPHONE NO. ________ _ COMMENTS: I l l - ~-t .. ~ ~ O PLUMBING RI O MECHANICAL O WATER HOOKUP O METER SETfTUAN ON 0 SEWER HOOKUP 0 SEPTIC INSTALL. □ SEPTIC MAINT, □ WELL TEST PUMP ,.,, l~ -,., .:. -'I I I I~ -1 ':" ---' 1":. I ,~ ---- it~ ~ \:i) - c-':. 1, □ SITE INSPECTION □ EXCAV./0AADIN0/FILLIN0 □ LAKESHORE/WETLANDS □ LICENSING □ COMPLAINT □ FOLLOW-UP C SEPTIC FINAL □ .:?J1I t_, I/ ':,/ ·-.. □ PHOTO TAKEN CATI TIMI' -------------·CONTR·--.. -.. ---,.-.... ·, I g ~=L.~~~ .. t · 0 LMUHOIIIIMTI.MIOI. · .. , 1· 0 LJCa.,NQ · . ; • 1. 2. 3. C.L'.i:~ 0.f ORONO P.O. lo ■ U, c..,,u.-1 a.,, tu ....... u HJU OJ-1l57 PROPERTY ADDRESS 2480 Casco Point Road, Orono, Minn. wad .. ecrt,cs-eh.all i.. •'-oa •t"9ch•d l\ln,ey, Ea.hU,tc 3. APPLICANT ,... Cortlen G. Cloutier ,,_.. 336-3641 ------------• Hot Una .A.UnH __ 2...;4...;a_o_c_a_s_c_o __ P_o_i_r_, t_·.....;Ro.;;....a_d __ ,:.._o_r...;o_n_o...;':__MN;...;.;_1 If Appltunt b -t -r, upl.S.a _____________ _ Same ,.. _____________ ,,_ ___________ _ HdU",1 Addr ■H ____________________ _ Date Property Acquired August, 196 5 (Honc.h/Y ... r) ' I (do) ~~ also own other adjacent parcels of land ' AGENT ""-__ N_o_n_e ____________ ,,,_. _______ _ ,, .. ----------------------·------ LIST OF EXHIBI' t pu9rtpt19D Other Io(ea,Ue:o l ; &.-~--<'-----------------------© NOTICES Should ... •-t btl 7 • ' ll) ,-2._ AP,Uunt __ ,...c CE:) PRESENT ZONING USE DISTRICT _L;;;.;R;.;.,_-__;;;;l_C _______ _ /11 12 PRESENT USE 1ut4-ct.al ~ COcMr> ______________ _ YHHC ~ _ Y.auat luU4laa(•) _ Occupt.d .._,Udlaa(•) __ DESCRIBE RF.QUEST ESTIMATED CONSTRUCTION COST $ 2,000.00 Deacribe request in detail: on May 7, 1971, a permit was applied tor aM a combination boathouse/guesthouse on Lot 3, Carmen Addition. t V.ARIANCE(S) REQUIRED t• .i.. CM r....-ec•d IJorlu apptovea rot the construction of Block 1, Tillson's Villa, Lot Ar.,. completed except ror ro '? of completing Loe. VlAa. _L 1.c1teck <JL rroat _Ilda--. llear) Oclwr Conditional Use Permit .. ::.,: .. ·,.-.... l I 'l ; J . l ,.<-~.\:;,i•:,010 ,UdWIHJt . .Pl.u& Bl.de• ;~;i:zt :;::· ~ 55402 . . . . • .. ·,;~i';y·. :,I' h.t.V• Y~·letter ot Apd,l._,0 replyin.g mine.ot.Apr.11.22 . , ..... ,._, , ·z,•:.: ~,, •. ·~ ot ... OOYera&e · Oil the. property . .at 2480. ea.eco Roa4 •. ·,. You,·.~ l+~t~~;,\'l,:~toriuUclD•:'t.bt 110•t-appi-opri&te .way of HOertainin,:tbe,corr•c#I, ,. _ ··:l;;;_;~.:f:,:;,.,ot OOMftP 1.b&t-tbe bale abould I>. ina\.u-ed · to,t'.·J 0a. ;a -1'1"0~.t,y''I'~!: ¥-W'.:•c.•-;;:ove.-,, 10 7un:old it i• val")' dit1'1cw.t tor ua. •• asente to ;-40)110.N-:,: ")j/i,:.' '· n-c.cmrQd ~ uaount ot iAlurance which ~ould co indic:ated .~#4,~:--'ef:~•.:" ·.,·: , .. _ .. -. in!J.atios:lary. 'tNsKl of buildillg replaceunt cost.a •.. -'the 'Clllll-. .,f,~e: . :/;·:,·:< to-~;uaatly what a pro~rty should b1' in.sured·t'or"1s to obtain ... , - ;j?-;,. ·th4t Mrvic .. ot·an independent. .o.ppr&iaal cocnpa.ny .t.:, ),en"orm bot.ti a marl(.et,.'}}\>l~' /~1\~?. ev.iua~ and. NP].aaement. co•t-evaluation &prraiaal of the properey. ,::_ /i:-}:· :?,' :?}.:{"~{{~:~_:•~ '.;::~, • r-• •J •• • •: • :• • • -,, • ~,:~·?, • V :};:t?.·;;,·.J'A:',lune ot 1971 we eat.im&ted Ule replacement cost. o! your home at &58,000. • :'.C\):;{lt;wow.d ti.: OOlllei'Vat.ive 1.o a,.y that. replacement cost-s have increufK! 35% ·;\'~\:t\,in.,tlw ia.t·,t~·1ea.r• '4licb WCW-4 indicat. a ~placemen~ v&lue.01· merely .. },,jff'1},t'80,000,,toda)' which I have & teelin& i• on the low side. The· houae is • ·, ·\\\r'.)Y·Pl'••entlyinau.red·tor.$6()9 000. and I wst look to you for aome direct.ion . ·.·. ?)) to .upplaaent our own·_ rec~nd.a.tio~. ·. .,. ,:. , : ·~ , ''. -. ,: . , April:;30, 1975 · ·· '. • .' '. ( ~ t, ~}iz~~t~?2:~¼~~g:\;it~~j~l~i@·:., , ... ",;;},,.~~?=:!::.·~ · ... ' . . . ·"}~)} : , ,J~:-':X~Ra, ;,•.•Jla1:■0111Mr• . Xm m:anca -2480 . casco Point:: .Road~ :W&i~;i3:;;&• ><;. . .. . · <. . ... ·. ;i: . >I'-" ;:;;,'ff •\::":'~~aaf--=--·,,J.•,made to your letter of .Ap,t'il 22 .. <;~975ii:,\,, . ·"'/~·,:el.attn .to . .renatiDQ the Hcaeowner• inaurance.·at :24'-Q. : I-'caaoo:Point<liced. '. . •·· .· .·· :/t.:f!0t)i;J~ ·x ·8111· ·1n at;1roc.ment vith your auggast:l.on!that. the<cover~ge. > -· : be increaaed. Whet• yould you recCftnend aa the most appeoprt,at: . . .. :/ l!la)' .at .,aaceJ:tainino· euctly ~het coverage ··should be .. placed?'.?a'::.: •f/_,·on the 1)£"operty to insure that.the propeJ:ty -~•··.not:_?Jni~•~?} '·\;·,:\1~\--.~:'. ,. \~-:~:~' .. ){, >,.,,,{ .,;; ._; .-~-;':,i·:· ;._ ~-_,<·: .. .' -< ,::.:.,.,<\;/\ .·<·· ,: . ,.:~:/.:}/:-~.,•::,:-·;-_\::~~~::·~:/.:-·;: t'.•}:½~~·!:_;:f~~:;:<~-Y'\ •\'ft.·/% ,~~-:'.IIMIJlticnlld, to' you · alao thi$t: ;I,, cccatructedC:a tc9CD,biµt ·:. ::s',baatbowl•.tanc:S -~thcu.M•.OR the p.optrty·ju.at,,t.fo.r-oitbe~.f~U . . . ::>~~,.i'l'hat• ■tructure ia ,not· fully ccwpletecf 0111.t.be"j,na'tda::1} . -:2('yet •. ,,;,t:J1.av• .about $20,000 investad in 'the structure. ·•rhe pr~y: /·{/;ia loca~ed Jipon Lot 3, 'l'Uaoo• s Villa Cl!)rmen Addi ti en,· wher~~ ... ;:?~?/i · .:·/:·.,the Min .bcw.e 1• actually located upon Lot 4 cf the -same ad.di; •, ·:' .. 'I ...auld like to be .•ur• that :both at.ruct~ea or•_~COVOJ;~~ ,·:.,, mim•owur• ·, pol.icy ed; i 'ttu.Qk·, we; t&lka4 f e~t,· that!:J;)efore~;~bu~<i'.X' /~, ... ,_Dot·••u.re.1~·would"'YOU mind ,Ch.ecking··that f~.. :;"'''"·'-::·~-"",,.,. " . ·;· :: . ~ ,:, . , -., . .. " . " . .• ', ,-, ,'},;' ·~Q: •• • l?t· • . ::: : • ~~ .. · • • ~ z. OWNlll ADDIISI PHONI NO. Sec. No, Parcel No. 6.iP" t) y,fl I) I ~D tJ LAND DISCIIPTION Size of Lot Land Sq. F1. Elevation CONSTRUCTION Fram• Shlcco Stone POOTINOS O.pth Width FOUNDATION· Conatructlon LUEMINT Ground Oral~• Bearing Pa.ts Beams CHIMNIYI No. Fovndotion He!Qht Above Roof VILLAGI OF ORONO IUILDING PIRMIT Lot Block i..-J,,,· I I IUW>INO LOCATION Dis. From Rood Ola, Sides· Dia, Bade Drainage Brick, Solid Brick VenHt Cement Block Least Depth Below Grade Floor Size Sh:• Size Spadng Span NO, OF FIREPLACES __ Type Addition o, Sl.ibdlvltion ___.. /,1 tlMJ--,t(} VENTILATION AND UGHT Percentage of Floor Area Vent. Percentage of light to Floor Area IJNTII.S Size location WELL TYPI Conatruction Location Span SEPTIC TANKS OR MUNICIPAL HOOKUP 0 Size Distance From Well Construction DRAJNflBJ> Depth Width length Pl.UM&ING FlXTUW G•rbag• Dispoul Sinka laundry Bath Tub Dlatance From Well Dlatance From Lot lines Dish Washer Shower Toilet Lavatory Smoke Pl,,_Dlatance From Jolat• PLOOU Sub Flooring Joist• lpadno 1eartno ,ffllDDIHOI -.lpaclno -~·. ,tote. Size Bridging Span 2495