The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About16628-TANAGER CREEK-ConservDesign-2-10-22Conservation Design Report TANAGER CREEK Orono, MN Project No. 16628 February 10, 2022 I hereby certify that this plan, speciation or report was prepared by me or under my direct supervision and that I am a duly Licensed Professional Engineer under the laws of the State of Minnesota. _____________________________________________ Adam M. Thiele, P.E. Reg. No. 51317 Prepared By: Prepared For: Anderson Engineering of MN, LLC Ethan DeNaray 13605 1st Avenue North, Suite 100 PO Box 192 Plymouth, MN 55441 Babbitt, MN 55706 Ph: 763.412.4000 Ph: 612-802-4052 Fax: 763.412.4090 Anderson Engineering of Minnesota, LLC ● 13605 1st Avenue North, Suite 100 ● Plymouth, Minnesota 55441 ● (763) 412-4000 Main ● (763) 412-4090 Fax ● www.ae-mn.com 1 | P a g e Table of Contents Existing Site Applicability Proposed Project Ecological and Aesthetic Character Review Rural Oasis Study Views from Brown Road Views from across Long Lake Creek Natural Resources Inventory Minnesota Land Cover Classification System Data Tree Survey Wetland Delineation Topographic Survey Conceptual Greenways and Open Space Corridors Conservation Design Master Plan Stormwater Master Plan Invasive Species Removal and Management Plans Tree Removal and Protection Plan Ecological Communities Discussion Views of the Property Landmark Preservation Plan Appendix – Exhibits and Calculations A – Project Location Map B – Preliminary Plat C – MLCCS Map D – Tree Survey and Preservation Plan E – Wetland Delineation Notice of Decision H – Topographic Survey Stormwater Narrative/Summary February 10, 2022 Tanager Creek Orono, MN 2 | P a g e Existing Site Tanager Creek is a proposed 3-lot residential development located at 860 Brown Road in Orono, MN. The site encompasses 14.06 acres. The subject property consists of a residential homesite, turf grass yard, woodland and wetlands. Applicability Per Article XII (Conservation Design) Section 78-1632 (Applicability) a conservation design plan for all proposed residential subdivisions or multi-unit residential developments greater than five acres in total area, or guided for urban density (greater than one unit per two acres), are required to complete a Conservation Design Master Plan. The subject parcel is 14.06 acres total. Proposed Project The proposed redevelopment will consist of 3 single-family residential lots served by a short private street with cul-de-sac. Each lot is proposed to be served by a paved driveway. Lots range in size from 3.51 acres to 5.14 acres. The proposed project does not include impacts to delineated wetlands and seeks to minimize tree removals via custom home designs. Wetland buffers are proposed to be maintained per City and Watershed regulations. Ecological and Aesthetic Character Review Rural Oasis Study The subject property is not adjacent to any of the corridors analyzed as part of the Rural Oasis Study. Anderson completed a field review of the Brown Road segment near the subject property on November 11, 2021. The observations from this field review are summarized below. Views from Brown Road There are no major landmarks coming from either the North or South along Brown Road. The road is aligned north-south and features rolling terrain as it traverses low areas and upland. The majority of the homes immediately north and south of the subject property are setback from the roadway and/or obscured by trees. Natural Resources Inventory Minnesota Land Cover Classification System (MLCCS) Data The Minnesota Land Cover Classification System map indicates that the site consists of emergent and open water wetland, forest, and areas of 11-25% Impervious cover. The M-34X modifiers indicate the majority of the site rated C or lower. AM-34X modifier has not been assigned for approximately 47% of the site. Stormwater Narrative/Summary February 10, 2022 Tanager Creek Orono, MN 3 | P a g e MLCCS M_34X Acres % Area Wetland Open Water Not Rated 1.08 8% Wetland Emergent Veg.D 7.50 53% 11-25% Impervious Not Rated 0.92 7% Forest Not Rated 3.50 25% Tree Survey A tree survey was completed as part of the planning process for the proposed development. All significant trees and stands of trees were identified for species, size and location. The site consists of primarily Green Ash, Box Elder, Red Oak, and Blue Spruce (landscaped). Existing trees are shown on the Existing Conditions plan. Wetland Delineation A wetland delineation of the subject property was completed in September 2021. The wetland delineation identified 5 wetlands on the subject property. The wetlands are identified as Wetland 1-1 through 1-5 in the Wetland Investigation report dated September 10, 2021. The various wetlands include Type 1, 2 and 3 wetlands. The wetland boundaries were reviewed by Minnehaha Creek Watershed District during a TEP meeting on October 18, 2021. Please see attached Notice of Decision for the approved wetland boundaries. Topographic Survey A topographic survey of the project area was completed by Anderson. The survey shows that the property consists of an area of upland adjacent Brown Road and a large portion of wetland that is contiguous with Long Lake Creek and Lake Minnetonka. The proposed project is limited to the area of upland. Conceptual Greenways and Open Space Corridors The Conceptual Greenway Corridor map from the 2008-2030 City of Orono Community Management Plan identifies the subject property as part of the “conceptual greenway corridor”. The subject property includes wetland areas that are contiguous with Long Lake Creek and Lake Minnetonka. The areas surrounding these features are protected by 40-75 foot buffers. Existence of Rare Plant Communities \No rare plant communities were observed on the site and are not identified on the Hennepin County Natural Resource Inventory Map. Most of the areas onsite are dominated by turf grasses and common buckthorn. These areas are of low quality and do not warrant special protection. Stormwater Narrative/Summary February 10, 2022 Tanager Creek Orono, MN 4 | P a g e Conservation Design Master Plan Stormwater Master Plan The existing and proposed topography directs surface water towards the wetlands north and east of the project area. Runoff from the proposed site conditions will be treated prior to discharge into the wetland complex. Invasive Species Removal and Management Plans There are no known invasive species that exist outside of wetland and lakeshore buffer areas. Tree Removal and Protection Plan Significant tree impacts will be reduced as much as possible and have been avoided to the extent practical during the design process. Individual home construction will use custom home designs to limit tree removals as practical. Ecological Communities Discussion The goal of the project is to create a residential development that fits into the existing site and maintains the rural feel of the area. The proposed private street will follow the existing driveway and turf yard area to minimize tree removal and other impacts. Houses will be constructed in upland areas and utilize custom designs to further minimize tree impacts. The natural corridors located along the property boundaries will be maintained. View of the Property Views of the property from Brown Road, as well as from across the wetland and Long Lake Creek, will remain primarily as is. Proposed tree removals are situated within the interior of the subject property, thus maintaining the screened views from outside the parcel. Landmark Preservation Plan No landmarks exist on the subject property. ^_ Legend ^_Project Location SOURCE: MN DNR, USDA, ESRI, TIGER, Bing , Hen nepin C o., Anderso n Engineering Project Location City of OronoHennepin Cou nty, MN13605 1st Ave N #100, Plymouth, MN 55441P 763.412.4000 F 763.412.4090 ae-mn.com De Naray PropertyOrono, Minnesota Figure AProject Location I1 inch = 1,00 0 feet01,000 2,000500 Feet Address: 860 Brown Rd. SouthOrono, MN 55391Lat/Long: 44.9629, -93.5729PID: 1011723120001Project No: 16628Date: 12.6.2021 860 Bro wn Rd. SouthOrono, MN 55 391 9 3 0 93 5 940940940 94594592 9 9 3 1 9 3 2 93 3 93 4 9 3 6 93 7 93 8 93 9 941941942942943943944944946946947 947948948945 950 944 94 6 947 948 949 935940945945931932933934936937938939941942943944946946947947 9 3 0 935 931 932 933 934 936 937 938 939941942 800 BROWN ROAD 920 BROWN ROAD 930 BROWN ROAD 760 BROWN ROAD DELINEATED WETLAND BOUNDARY OHWL 929.4 30'BROWN ROAD (CO RD 146)40' LOT 1 3.63 AC 0.62 AC UPLAND R50R45 LOT 2 5.02 AC 0.78 AC UPLAND LOT 3 5.13 AC 1.06 AC UPLAND 30'DELINEATED WETLAND BOUNDARY 75'OUTLOT A 24'N 0 40'80'PROPERTY INFO - 860 BROWN ROAD CURRENT ZONING: RR-1B UPLAND ACREAGE:3.92 AC WETLAND ACREAGE:10.14 AC TOTAL ACREAGE:14.06 AC 30' LONG LAKE CREEK D&U EASEMENT 10'10'10'10'10'15'15' BUILDING SETBACK BUILDING SETBACKWETLANDBUFFER &SETBACKLAKESHO RE SETBACK 40'WETLANDBUFFER &SETBACKAREA WITHIN WETLAND AND LAKESHORE SETBACK ENTIRELY WITHIN DRAINAGE & UTILITY EASEMENT DRAINAGE & UTILITY EASEMENT FILTR A TI O N B A SI N 0.28 AC PLOTTED:COMM. NO. DRAWING NO. ----16628 TANAGER CREEK 1 3 6 0 5 1 s t A v e n u e N . #1 0 0 P l y m o u t h , M N 5 5 4 4 1 | a e -m n .c o m P 7 6 3 .4 1 2 .4 0 0 0 | F 7 6 3 .4 1 2 .4 0 9 0 A n d e r s o n E n g i n e e r i n g o f M i n n e s o t a , L L C DRAWING TITLE CHECKED BY:DRAWN:DESIGNED: ATJRAT 01/14/2022 REVISION LOG DESCRIPTION OF REVISIONSNO.DATE 860 BROWN ROAD ORONO, MN ETHAN DE NARAY PRELIMINARY PLAT 1 01/14/22 PRELIMINARY PLAT SUBMITTAL PRINT NAME: SIGNATURE: I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS PLAN, SPECIFICATION, OR REPORT WAS PREPARED BY ME OR UNDER MY DIRECT SUPERVISION AND THAT I AM A DULY LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER UNDER THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA. DATE:LICENSE NO.01/14/2022 ADAM THIELE, PE 2 02/10/22 REVISED PER CITY COMMENTS AREA WITHIN OUTLOT A ENTIRELY WITHIN DRAINAGE & UTILITY EASEMENT D&U EASEMENT 30' 3 0 ' PRELIMINARY PLAT OF TANAGER CREEK 2 0 0 ' 2 2 3 '200' 2 2 5 ' 2 5 6 '238'40'WET L A N D BUF F E R & SET B A C K 75' LAKESHORE SETBACK 50'50'50'75'LA K E S H O R E SE T B A C K 189' 141' 99' RESIDENCE TO NORTH (OFF-PLAN) APPROX. 55' SETBACK FROM OHWL OHWL 929.4 Forest Wetland Open Water W etla n d E m erg e nt V e g. WetlandEmergentVeg. Forest WetlandEmergentVeg. WetlandForest 11-25% Impervious11-25% ImperviousWetland Emergent Veg.Forest76-100% ImperviousForestForest 51-75%Impervious LegendProject ParcelHennepin Co. Parcels SOURCE: MN DNR, USDA, ESRI, TIGER, Bing , Hen nepin C o., Anderso n Engineering Project Location City of OronoHennepin Cou nty, MN13605 1st Ave N #100, Plymouth, MN 55441P 763.412.4000 F 763.412.4090 ae-mn.com De Naray PropertyOrono, Minnesota Figure CMLCCS I1 inch = 20 0 feet0200 400100 Feet Address: 860 Brown Rd. SouthOrono, MN 55391Lat/Long: 44.9629, -93.5729PID: 1011723120001Project No: 16628Date: 12.6.2021 MLCCS Type Acreage Perce nt Cove rWetland Open Wate r 1.08 8%We tl and Emerge nt V e g.7.50 53%11-25% Impervi ous 0.92 7%Fore st 3.50 25% 800 BROWN ROAD 920 BROWN ROAD 930 BROWN ROAD DELINEATED WETLAND BOUNDARY OHWL 929.4 BROWN ROAD (CO RD 146)DELINEATED WETLAND BOUNDARY N 0 20'40' APPROX. VIEW SETBACK (VARIANCE REQUESTED) REMOVE EXISTING UTILITY SERVICES COORDINATE WITH UTILITY OWNERS DEMOLISH EX. HOUSE AND GARAGE REMOVE EX. BITUMINOUS DRIVEWAY LEGEND EX BITUMINOUS PAVEMENT EX UNGD GAS EX UNGD COMM EX OVH ELEC EX CONIFEROUS TREE EX DECIDUOUS TREE REMOVE BITUMINOUS REMOVE BUILDING REMOVE TREE GENERAL NOTES 1.EROSION AND SEDIMENT CONTROL BMPS SHALL BE INSTALLED PRIOR TO ANY EARTH DISTURBING ACTIVITIES INCLUDED TREE CLEARING, DEMOLITION, AND GRADING. 2.CONTRACTOR SHALL PROTECT TREES NOT SCHEDULED FOR REMOVAL. INSTALL SNOW FENCE OR OTHER PERIMETER CONTROL MEASURE TO PROTECT AREA WITHIN DRIPLINE OF TREES TO REMAIN. 3.COMPLETELY REMOVE STRUCTURES AND OTHER IMPROVEMENTS SCHEDULED FOR REMOVAL. REMOVE ALL STRUCTURE, FOUNDATION, UTILITIES, AND APPURTENANCES TO PROVIDE CLEAN SITE FOR GRADING ACTIVITIES. 4.CONTRACTOR SHALL PROMPTLY REMOVE DEMOTION DEBRIS FROM THE SITE AND DISPOSE OF ACCORDING TO LOCAL, STATE, AND FEDERAL REGULATIONS. 5.TREES AND BRUSH NOTED FOR REMOVAL SHALL BE COMPLETELY REMOVED INCLUDING STUMPS AND ROOTS 3" IN DIAMETER AND LARGER. 6.WORK WITHIN THE RIGHT-OF-WAY OF BROWN ROAD WILL REQUIRE PERMIT FROM HENNEPIN COUNTY. CONTRACTOR SHALL ACQUIRE NECESSARY PERMITS PRIOR TO COMMENCING WORK. PLOTTED:COMM. NO. DRAWING NO. ----16628 TANAGER CREEK 1 3 6 0 5 1 s t A v e n u e N . #1 0 0 P l y m o u t h , M N 5 5 4 4 1 | a e -m n .c o m P 7 6 3 .4 1 2 .4 0 0 0 | F 7 6 3 .4 1 2 .4 0 9 0 A n d e r s o n E n g i n e e r i n g o f M i n n e s o t a , L L C DRAWING TITLE CHECKED BY:DRAWN:DESIGNED: ATJRAT 01/14/2022 REVISION LOG DESCRIPTION OF REVISIONSNO.DATE 860 BROWN ROAD ORONO, MN ETHAN DE NARAY PRELIMINARY PLAT 1 01/14/22 PRELIMINARY PLAT SUBMITTAL PRINT NAME: SIGNATURE: I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT THIS PLAN, SPECIFICATION, OR REPORT WAS PREPARED BY ME OR UNDER MY DIRECT SUPERVISION AND THAT I AM A DULY LICENSED PROFESSIONAL ENGINEER UNDER THE LAWS OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA. DATE:LICENSE NO.01/14/2022 ADAM THIELE, PE 2 02/10/22 REVISED PER CITY COMMENTS Tree Survey 810 Brown Road S, Orono, MN TANAGER CREEK October 12, 2021 Tree #Description Size Remove Tree #Description Size Remove Tree #Description Size Remove Tree #Description Size Remove 1 Blue Spruce 6 N 31 Blue Spruce 10 Y 61 Box Elder 10 N 91 American Elm 10 N 2 Cedar 12 N 32 Blue Spruce 12 Y 62 American Elm 8 Y 92 American Elm 6 N 3 Cedar 10 N 33 Blue Spruce 8 Y 63 Box Elder 14 Y 93 Green Ash 8 N 4 Cedar 6 N 34 Blue Spruce 8 Y 64 Green Ash 8 N 94 American Elm 14 N 5 Cedar 8 N 35 Blue Spruce 8 Y 65 Box Elder 12 N 95 White Pine 14 N 6 Cedar 12 N 36 Blue Spruce 6 Y 66 American Elm 6 N 96 Box Elder 16 N 7 Cedar 14 Y 37 White Pine 8 Y 67 American Elm 6 N 97 Box Elder 16 N 8 Cedar 6 Y 38 Blue Spruce 8 Y 68 Box Elder 6 N 98 Box Elder 12 N 9 Cedar 10 Y 39 American Elm 6 Y 69 Box Elder 12 N 99 Blue Spruce 8 Y 10 Cedar 12 Y 40 Box Elder 10 N 70 Box Elder 6 N 11 Cedar 6 Y 41 Box Elder 10 N 71 Box Elder 14 N 12 Cedar 12 Y 42 Box Elder 8 N 72 Box Elder 14 N 13 Cedar 12 Y 43 Box Elder 8 N 73 Cedar 6 N 14 Cedar 6 Y 44 American Elm 10 Y 74 Cedar 8 N 15 Cedar 12 Y 45 Box Elder 10 Y 75 Cedar 8 N 16 Cedar 10 Y 46 Blue Spruce 16 Y 76 Cedar 8 N 17 Maple 22 N 47 Blue Spruce 8 Y 77 American Elm 8 N 18 White Pine 16 Y 48 Blue Spruce 12 Y 78 White Pine 6 N 19 Blue Spruce 8 Y 49 Box Elder 8 Y 79 White Pine 12 N 20 Blue Spruce 8 Y 50 Box Elder 8 Y 80 White Pine 6 N 21 American Elm 30 Y 51 Blue Spruce 10 Y 81 Box Elder 18 N 22 American Elm 34 Y 52 Blue Spruce 10 Y 82 American Elm 8 N 23 Basswood 36 Y 53 Box Elder 6 Y 83 Green Ash 12 N 24 Willow 60 Y 54 Box Elder 10 Y 84 Box Elder 8 N 25 Blue Spruce 14 Y 55 Box Elder 14 Y 85 White Pine 14 N 26 Blue Spruce 18 Y 56 Blue Spruce 8 Y 86 White Pine 6 N 27 Basswood 10 N 57 Blue Spruce 10 Y 87 Box Elder 14 N 28 Basswood 6 N 58 Red Oak 10 Y 88 Red Oak 10 N 29 Blue Spruce 10 Y 59 Box Elder 8 Y 89 Red Oak 48 N 30 Blue Spruce 14 Y 60 Box Elder 14 N 90 American Elm 8 N BWSR NOD Form – November 12, 2019 1 Minnesota Wetland Conservation Act Notice of Decision Local Government Unit: Minnehaha Creek Watershed District County: Hennepin Applicant Name: Ethan De Naray Applicant Representative: Anderson Engineering – Alex Yellick Project Name: 860 Brown Road South, Orono LGU Project No. (if any): W21-058 Date Complete Application Received by LGU: 09/13/2021 Date of LGU Decision: 10/18/2021 Date this Notice was Sent: 10/18/2021 WCA Decision Type - check all that apply ☒ Wetland Boundary/Type ☐ Sequencing ☐ Replacement Plan ☐ Bank Plan (not credit purchase) ☐ No-Loss (8420.0415) ☐ Exemption (8420.0420) Part: ☐ A ☐ B ☐ C ☐ D ☐ E ☐ F ☐ G ☐ H Subpart: ☐ 2 ☐ 3 ☐ 4 ☐ 5 ☐ 6 ☐ 7 ☐ 8 ☐ 9 Replacement Plan Impacts (replacement plan decisions only) Total WCA Wetland Impact Area: Wetland Replacement Type: ☐ Project Specific Credits: ☐ Bank Credits: Bank Account Number(s): Technical Evaluation Panel Findings and Recommendations (attach if any) ☒ Approve ☐ Approve w/Conditions ☐ Deny ☐ No TEP Recommendation LGU Decision ☐ Approved with Conditions (specify below)1 ☒ Approved1 ☐ Denied List Conditions: Decision-Maker for this Application: ☒ Staff ☐ Governing Board/Council ☐ Other: Decision is valid for: ☒ 5 years (default) ☐ Other (specify): 1 Wetland Replacement Plan approval is not valid until BWSR confirms the withdrawal of any required wetland bank credits. For project- specific replacement a financial assurance per MN Rule 8420.0522, Subp. 9 and evidence that all required forms have been recorded on the title of the property on which the replacement wetland is located must be provided to the LGU for the approval to be valid. LGU Findings – Attach document(s) and/or insert narrative providing the basis for the LGU decision1. ☐ Attachment(s) (specify): ☒ Summary: Site was field reviewed by Anderson Engineering (Alex Yellick), Board of Water & Soil Resources (Ben Carlson), and the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District (Cole Thompson). The boundaries and types identified in the delineation report for this property were reviewed and verified. The TEP has no comments based on the information provided, and approves the Boundary and Type of the wetlands noted. 1 Findings must consider any TEP recommendations. Attached Project Documents ☒ Site Location Map ☐ Project Plan(s)/Descriptions/Reports (specify): BWSR NOD Form – November 12, 2019 2 Appeals of LGU Decisions If you wish to appeal this decision, you must provide a written request within 30 calendar days of the date you received the notice. All appeals must be submitted to the Board of Water and Soil Resources Executive Director along with a check payable to BWSR for $500 unless the LGU has adopted a local appeal process as identified below. The check must be sent by mail and the written request to appeal can be submitted by mail or e-mail. The appeal should include a copy of this notice, name and contact information of appellant(s) and their representatives (if applicable), a statement clarifying the intent to appeal and supporting information as to why the decision is in error. Send to: Appeals & Regulatory Compliance Coordinator Minnesota Board of Water & Soils Resources 520 Lafayette Road North St. Paul, MN 55155 travis.germundson@state.mn.us Does the LGU have a local appeal process applicable to this decision? ☒ Yes1 ☐ No 1If yes, all appeals must first be considered via the local appeals process. Local Appeals Submittal Requirements (LGU must describe how to appeal, submittal requirements, fees, etc. as applicable) Please submit written appeal request, along with a $100 check to 15320 Minnetonka Blvd., Minnetonka 55345, ATTN: Cole Thompson Notice Distribution (include name) Required on all notices: ☒ SWCD TEP Member: Stacey Lijewski – Stacey.lijewski@hennepin.us ☒ BWSR TEP Member: Ben Carlson – bencarlson@state.mn.us ☐ LGU TEP Member (if different than LGU contact): ☒ DNR Representative: Melissa Collins – melissa.collins@state.mn.us ☐ Watershed District or Watershed Mgmt. Org.: ☒ Applicant: ethan.denaray@gmail.com☒ Agent/Consultant: Anderson Engineering, Alex Yellick – ayellick@ae- mn.com Optional or As Applicable: ☒ Corps of Engineers: usace_requests_mil@usace.army.mil ☐ BWSR Wetland Mitigation Coordinator (required for bank plan applications only): ☐ Members of the Public (notice only): ☒ Other: City of Orono, Melanie Curtis – mcurtis@ci.orono.mn.us; Signature: Date: 10/18/2021 This notice and accompanying application materials may be sent electronically or by mail. The LGU may opt to send a summary of the application to members of the public upon request per 8420.0255, Subp. 3. D C A B 1-3 Long Lake Creek M-056-007 1-4 1-2 1-1 1-5 Lo n g L a k e C r e e k (M-056-007) Legend Project Parcel Hennepin Co. Parcels Wetland Tributary Sample Point Culvert SOURCE: MN DNR, USDA, ESRI, TIGER, Bing, Hennepin Co., Anderson Engineering Project Location City of Orono Hennepin County, MN 13605 1st Ave N #100, Plymouth, MN 55441 P 763.412.4000 F 763.412.4090 ae-mn.com De Naray Property Orono, Minnesota Figure 5 Delineation I1 inch = 200 feet 0 200 400100 Feet Address: 860 Brown Rd. South Orono, MN 55391 Lat/Long: 44.9629, -93.5729 PID: 1011723120001 Project No: 16628 Date: 9.7.2021 Circular 39 Classification Cowardin Classification Eggers and Reed Classification 1-1 Wetland 0.04 1,671 N/A Type 1 PEM1Ad Seasonally Flooded Basin 1-2 Wetland 0.11 4,783 N/A Type 2 PEM1B Fresh Wet Meadow 1-3 Wetland 7.83 340,898 N/A Type 3 PEM1C Shallow Marsh 1-4 Wetland 1.02 44,292 N/A Type 3 PEM1C Shallow Marsh 1-5 Wetland 0.00 107 N/A Type 2 PEM1B Fresh Wet Meadow Long Lake Creek (M-056-007)Tributary 1.14 49,868 457 Type 90 R2UBG Riverine Resource ID Wetland Type ClassificationApproximate Length (Lineal Feet) within Project Parcel Approximate Size (Square Feet) within Project Parcel Approximate Size (Acres) within Project Parcel Resource Type