Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutProject Packet• g ,� 7S °° # 7 'Ira M, CITY OF ORONO - VARIANCE APPLICATION Initial Application Fee $150.00 ($50.00 per each additional variance) Renewal Variance Fee $75.00 (no change from original application) After -the -Fact Fees (Double application fee) --------------------------------------------------------------------------- PROPERTY LOCATION 9_�,Q Site Address Lot 2, Block 1 Kelley Green -Property Identif ication Number (P. I. D. _ Q 117 - a.� a j CIO s -Please check one - Is the property r/ abstract or torrens? Please attach legal description to application if not included on required survey. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- APPLICANT Name Colin Kelly b Lona Jane Shaughnessy Phone 475-1219 Mailing Address 285 S_ Rrnwn Rd 1,nnu LnkeFMn. 55356 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- OMNER D fr Name '��` _ Phone �[ ? �'� 3 Mailing Address An �' �{tn,7311-- • Date Property Acquired (month/year) I (d (do not) also own the adjacent pa.,,.-ls of land. ----------------------------------------------- ---------------------------- PRESENT USS OF PROPERTY Present Zoning District � k - / 4 ' Present Use of Property cResidential Other (specify) ------------------------------------- ------------------------------------- DRSCIRIPTION OF REQUEST Estimated Construction Cost $ 150,000 Describe request in detail: variance on the south side of lot of 12.7 ft. leaving a set back from private rd. of 37.3 ft. and on norEn s1de r Tot of 1T.5 ft. }esviea-� tee! - proper*T wa• ------------------------------------ VARIANCES REQUIRED Lot Area I.ot Width Hardcover Setback Variances ( X Front Side X Rear) Other --------------------------------------------------------------------------- KARDSHIP Describe undue hardship or practical difficulty resulting from strict enforcement of zoning regulations: Unusually short depth of lot makes it impossible to position our home on lot. ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- DESCRIPTION OF UNUSIIAT. PROPERTY CONDITIONS Describe unusual property conditions pre entcompliance with 'Zoning Code Requirements: Lot which was plotted inkJ" s very limited depth. This coupled with large set back requirements front and rear create ex rme cu y in — position ng of home. ►�buildable site is on western part of loton top of hill. - ____Requ met a o--=oar_o---------- REQUIRED SUBMITTALS ✓1. Completed Application Form Certified Property Owners List of owners within 150' (you can obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance-A-603 Govt Center 3 4 A - 3 2 71) . /3. Stamped, legal sized envelopes (410) pre -addressed to each of the names on the above list with no return address. ,/4. Certificate of survey including hardcover calculations as required. .//5. Plat Map. -----------------------------•------------------------------------------------ The Applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please remember that your variance application is not complete if the above Information has not been included. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE The applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay all fees and/or unusual expenses incurred in review of this application, and certifies that the information supplied is true V rrect to the best of his/her knowledge.' Applicant's Signature Date c OMNSRS SIGNATURE The owner hereby ackowledges and agrees to this application and further authorizes reasonable entry onto the property by City staff, consultants, agents, Commission members, and Council members for purposes of investiga- tion and verification of this request. Owner's Signature 1,/ Date 4A",/ Applicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 days before the Planning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission Meetings are held on the third Monday of each month. 210 1 211 /Id C 7- H 7 4: !tt !tt Uff"ie! 3.. —Z3c I ++G 7 �-( � CITY or oRa+o . Is••. � tr ---J, j to OF m 212p, LONG 4 IAII[ I,. 40•♦ Of 40 �t tai ONO----y •AS d-?,ILS �CITYs w000_. Z «� 200. o/ o0 0/ t • tI .tear at +✓ •s • . s 66YFFr �'11• r. l rAt y � . �► .. 6 ` ; 5• +• �. etc /T" 33: �c , G ••: 79vc SA O.L. d! Ltwx BROWN RO � � L. C ,, i s• rho `� ��` �.�' • /o- � n3 �'• • . 1. I h /J.� � �• �i EW 2 �o .,,i ' �� T � KEG2 • V � - - C', $ r Q 7 I CJ�I S11444_cop n G 45243 Sd '27 ~w to 0.85 �It % qaEs,vtors -�'•'..' y�� a wCD � _ �a.f e t5� •4• r1 L-A RUN DATE 08/05/86 • BATCH 004 38 03-117-23 21 0003 A PROP ADDR 02145 WATERTOWN RD OWNER NAME R B SLOANE A M K W SLOANE TAXPAYER R D A M K W SLOANE NAME/ADDR 2145 WATERTOWN RD ORONO MN 55356 PROP ADDR 38 03-117-23 21 0011 OWNER NAME T A S MAJOR TAXPAYER THOMAS 5 A SUSAN 8 MAJOR NAME/ADDR t200 DEVIN LA ORONO MN 55356 38 03-117-23 21 0014 PROP ADDR 00085 BROWN RD S OWNER NAME J A M EGERDAL -� TAXPAYER JAMES A MARILYN EGERDAL NAME/ADDR l3t6 E AVON CIR ROCHESTER MN 48063 1 38 03-117-23 21 0017 PROP ADDR -ti OWNER NAME LLOYD 3 KELLEY TAXPAYER LLOYD S KELLEY NAME/ADDR 125 S BROWN RD LONG LAKE MN 55356 © PROP ADDR OWNER NAME TAXPAYER TOTAL BATCH NAME/ADDR 004 00012 HENNEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY OWNERS LIST 38 03-117-23 21 0004 02105 WATERTOWN RD H J OTTO ET AL HEINZ J OTTO 2185 WATERTCWN RD LONG LAVE MH 55356 38 03-117-23 21 0012 02225 DEVIN LA E W DOBSON JR A S S DOBSON EBEN W DOBSON JR AND SONIA S DOBSCN 2225 DEVIN LA ORONO MN 55356 38 03-117-23 21 0015 00125 BROWN RD S LLOYD S KELLEY LLOYD S KELLEY 125 S BROWN RD LONG LAKE MN 55356 38 03-117-23 21 0020 LLOYD S KELLEY ET AL LLOYD S KELLEY 125 S BROWN RD LONG LAKE MN 55356 REPCRT NO. PI435401 PAGE 7 38 03-117-23 21 0007 00145 01'0:01 RD S GLADYS STINSON GLADYS F STINSON 145 BROWN RD SO LONG LAKE MN 55356 38 03-117-23 21 0013 THE NURSERY HOMEOWNERS ASSOC NURSERY HOhE011NERS ASSOC 2280 DEVIN LANE LONG LAKE MH 55364 38 03-117-23 21 0016 00125 BROWN RD S L A M KELLEY LESTER S KELLEY 125 S BROWN RD LONG LAME MN 55356 38 03-117-23 21 0024 02075 WATERTOWN RD A A L PETERSON ALAN B A LOPRIE J PETERSON LONG WATERTOWN RD L LONG LAKE MN 55356 RUN DATE 06/05/86 BATCH 004 HENNEPIN COUNTY PPOPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY OWERS LIST REPORT NO. PI435401 PAGE 8 I CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTED ARE AN ACCURATE AND TRUE REPRESENTATION OF INFORMATION AS IT APPEARS THIS DATE W4 THE RECORDS OF THE HEWEPIN COUNTY DEPARTMEr OF PROPERTY TAXATIOW TO THE BEST OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND BELIEF.r (,\ / " /qf N w M4 u AUG - IV lot 70336-... Aladh 14e of WW4 Af P* 4 Of5dx 3-1174.1 Z&V/ 400, Ab Clim veWy 9;ec 3 -117 -Z3 t ' are 14755 L V 40P Perim l A 71 #1. SYSTEM DESIGN FOR KELLY SHAUGHNESSY OF LOT 2, BLOCK 1, KELLEY GREEN ORONO, MINNESOTA 1. Percolation Rate, TypE of System. 16.9 minutes per inch for the primary site(holes 1-4) and a shallow trench system. 20.7 MPI for the alternate site(holes 5-6) and a shallow trench with an interceptor, draintile. 2. Proposed Flow Rate. 5 possible bedrooms @ 150 G.P.D. = 750 G.P.D. 3. Soil Treatment Area Required. 1.67 percolation !actor x 750 G.P.D. = 1250 Sq. Ft. minimum. 4. Size and Number of Trenches. 5 trenches 3 feet wide and 83.3 feet long = 1250 Sq. Ft. These trenches would be no deeper than 1.0 feet deep in the natural and be spaced a minimum of 7.5 feet apart center to center. 5. Drainfield Rock Needed. 46.3 cubic yards of rock is needed to have 6 inches under and 4 inches over a 4 inch distribution pipe. 6. Septic Tanks. Two septic tanks of at least 1000 and 750 gallons each are needed. It appears that if the house is set high enough that gravity flow can be maintained, a third pumping tank and pump would not be needed. 7. Additional Information. All construction and materials must adhere to the provisions of the City of Orono. Both tiie primary and alternate sites must be kept free of grading and traffic. Runoff water is to be diverted from the drainfield area. if any other information is needed, please contact me. Sincerely, PERCOR, INC. Mark S. Gronberg PCA certified 1 KELLY SHAUO YIN LOT 2, BLOCK L, E LEY ORONO , M I NNESOTA s er'ys%a"c 720. /Y � I �r� � ` L t ,,� r� ItAlf '� . � � • / ( fL OUTLOT � 0&re r C Date : 8-14-86 Scale: 1" s 50' P-1 Percolation hole SB-1 Soil Boring LR�Lmia 1 TL57 DAT SHM Test hole location Isle nLaber Date test hole vas prepared I% Deptb of bole ►ottom,�(r inches. Diameter of hole, a inches. $oil data from test bole: Depth, inches Method of scratching sidewall Soil texture :,t,th o! ;as -sized gravel in botto= of hole, 2 inches. :+ate and he;:r of initial Later f!:ling j .:.- - Dep:h of i::itial water filling, /:: inches above hole bottom. Mc:ho! used to maintain at least 12 inches of water depth in hole for at least t hours Percolation test readings lade by on starting at `a.�. Maxie eater depth above hole bottom (date) during test, I&CM6- 'i=e .:tee I ;nrerval, Measurement. Drop in water K:r.utes inches level, inches Percolation rate, I REMirks minutes per inch I ;53 Z Cr 571116 1 1 53 cp -7 , /fo l.%2 /1 y 2 6, e 70 W` 021 . / / 5 Goa r ,. 5 '2a. yo ? �'Y >0 11 Y1J percolation rate 0 ? ,5•`r minutes per inch. Test hole location We number Date test hole was prepared j�• I-�'� De►tb of hole Totten, /" inches. Disaster of hole, 6 inches. fail data•fron test bole: Depth, inches V Method of sc:atct.ina sidawall 4'— % sell testure :,%pth of paa-si:*d gravel in botto= of hole. inches. ;gate and of :r.itial water f::lint :)@;i:h c` initial water filling, / inches above hole bottom. Mctho'- used to nalatain at least 12 inches of water depth in hole for at least t hours Percolation test readings sad* by � on starting at /:: ��• Maxism water depth above hole bottom •t� test , inches. -:=e ::tee :n- erval, Measurement, I Drop in water !.nutes inches level, inches i Percolation rate, minutes per inch Remarks ll l 7 30 1 I l 117 7 p•v 30 0 14 3 0 Percolation sate • tainutes par inch. fi?RCOLA? 4TL!ST'QATA Si Test hale loestles = A' -W Lela agog Date test hole was prepared �'-;' t'o" Deptb of bola bottom, inches. Diameter of hole, o ischas. foil data . free test bole: Depth, ischas Soil texture Method of scratchint a.dsvall '..4_ -Q-,V :m th of ;aa-si:ed gravel In botto: of hole. = inches. And h; -: c! :r.:-ia? eater :: li::E 1=� f I— S •P• Dep:` cf init:ai •.&ter fillir.E. / inches above hole bottom. !Sctha= used to maintain at least 12 inches of water depth in hole for at least 4 how's / • . • '/ Percolation t•st readings made b7 on �f starting at /j:.''� � '' . Ka:im water depth above hole bottom (date) lu::ng :ant, inches. _-__ --_- -__e 1 Percolation �-----_ !�:n.utes inches level, inches minutes per I L inch 1 1 i 33 7�, �"'b / Z ' SL i :? `-� ' r� 875 1, Z 3 1 Z 3 ib 3 yil 30 /z'li /� 3 -� 3.izs �, o 3315 85 Percolation rate eirutes for ic•ch. c D- 33 !ZRM.ATI01.TTStbDATt SIM �;, „ ' V l'�'�..�= Test hale location L = A' - , '• <t ` ` %�' `• /- Ulu number Date test hole was prepared d-1 - f'g Depth of halo 'bottom. /L` inches. Diameter of hole. jr Inches. inches. :ell date-froin test bole: Depth, inches tell texture Method of scratcElwt sidewall :e7th of paa-sized gravel In lotto= of hole, inches. Date and hcur of initial voter filling p » /'ice ; Dept` c' initial -dater filling. /� inches above hole bottom. ncthad used to maintain at least 12 inches of voter depth in hole for at least 4 hours <<- Forcolatior. test readings soda b,,• 44t:A' on 0 starting at ram: '' T Kaxia water depth above hole bottom (date) Percolati-e er. I I ..Ji .... G:.O�, ..GOO..•.........., �:nutes i inches I ✓-r ... .a►... level, inches .o.�, I ............a minutes per inch 10 .. fly a 0 — -�.0 -1.7 s 1 /9 31 5 2- roc, -J. ►Z.le 1 Z. yq 10. 91 _. 37 /o b -- 2.a 15'a0 _ y r /. O - J ti 30,a 6-7 - —, minutes per inch. Percolation rate � '- � �n t ' C0UT I ON T ' 94ATA 5 Test hole location Z -', A'- ' • (- : t•• - • ` • toll •ut►er J _ Date test hell was prepared ,i' -%d- Depth of he .e ►ottem inch... Diameter of hole. i_ Inches. teal date•frem test bole: Depth, Inches =oil texture L' r��i•i F•.i Iwf 4ethod of scratctine sidevell - ,o a "Pth of pas-si:ed gravel in botto= of hole, L- inches. Date and hour of !r.t:ial water fi:linx j'• ;,� eZit :)e;:h c' initial water filling, / : inches hole bottom. Method used to maintain at least 12 inches of water 1a hole for at least I. hours A'fri A Percolation test readings made by '61A „ -jt r ; on P•6-� : eta ing at qcx;j . Maximon water depth above hole bottom inches. _-c I Percolation .-see a ui lulu•, `=r„ces inches f ULUF au WOLCE level, inches rate, minutes per inch �.: 2 3 3 3 1'1. Zl !1 Srs a '� �, Z 5 /0. 5 Z2 3Z ID ;Vz L s%fo" 5 /z, O ►2 51 2 y 2 Y IJ.25 127,61 I Z 30 /y 9— 1 ys I I .S75 16.00 C) • sp p's/�_ � I • 1 1 �S Percolation rate 16• 16 minutes Per Loch. / 1- 35 PERCOLATION DATA Herr Test hole location Z Hole number V� Date test hole was prepared },- 1" ,�'< Depth of hole bottom, inches. Diameter of hole, 6 inches. Soil data.from test bole: Depth, inches Soil texture C -/c /c - IF Method of sc:atcrinQ sidew111 //9lr :�eTth of pea -sized gravel in bottoms of hole, 1 inches. Date and hc:. cf :.ni:ial water f::ling /�/N ' ',- G De-):h c` initial water filling, /S inches above hole bottom. Xc:ho- used to :aintain at least 12 inches of Later depth in hole for at least 4 hours /V" az ' Percolation test readings r-ade by 'Ve13' on _�-<-3.6 _ starr:.ng at /D:; p P.M. fl; Faxim-= water depth above hole bottom (sate) during :est, inches. j :ime _Me I :r,terval, `leasurement, Drop i_• water Minutes inches level, inches i I Percolation rate, minutes per inch Remarks 10 :yq ! z 9 2/ 3 z -7/6 315 p 7//6 1 `1375 _21. 5 -1 3o % p'3/ib 1 : 1.0�75 -�y.",Z Percolation rate & ainu:es per ie:h. Loss of Soil Boring' 8-27 Location or Project laT 2� ifto(T h' l("Orl4FYfeP 6 Borings made by Date S _T6 _ Classification Sy ',.i: AAS1i0 USDA-SCS x ; Unified other _ Auger used (check t:wc,; : Hand �(, or Power F1i&E or Bucket 'X other .---- Depth, Boring number Depth, Boring number Z in Surface elevation W-57 in Surface elevation `�7.0 feet feet 0 0 &LAfk e64^1 P= 3 -- 4 — 5- 6 — 7- 8 -- End of boring at Ir• 0 feet. Standing Water table:• Present at feet of depth, hours after boring. Not present in boring hole ><_. Mottled soil: Observed at `� feet of depth. Not present in boring hole Observaticns and comments: 2 — 3 — 4 -- 5 «a,, L 6 — V� End of boring at L<. 0 feet. Standing water table: Present at feet of depth, hours after boring. Not present in boring hole Mottled soil: Observed at V.0 feet of depth. clot present in boring hole Observations and comments: Logs of Soil �eri�s tF-., 9 —� B Location or Project LOT Z t'-oje / kF• tor s- Borings made by AJAK_KT G(_F,,. Y)lr-, Date F-S -d'6 Classification System: AASI10 USDA-SCS i{ Unified other _ Auger used (check two): Hand or Power _; F1ighE or Bucket >; other Depth, Boring number .3 Depth, Boring number in feet Surface elevation 91•v feet in Surface elevation 0 0 dLACk [ e•i �ti^ 1 — 2 I I &":a' c!dr cOAr+ 3- 4 — s- 6 -- 7 — 8— End of boring at C.0 feet. Standing water table:. Present at feet of depth, hours after boring. Not present in boring hole X mottled soil: Observed at 3.'g feat of depth. Not present in boring hole Observations and cor.nents: 6 7 8 End of boring at __ feet. Standing: water table: Present at feet of depth, hours after boring. Not present in boring hole tiottled soil: Observed at feet of depth. clot present in boring hole I Observations znd coirsnents: CITY OF ORONO NOTICE The Planning Commission will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers a� 1275 South Brown Road on Monday, September 15, 1986, on the matter of the following Land Use Applications: 1. #1065 Larry Martineau, 4360 Chippewa Lane - Variance for temporary guest apartment within principal structure. 2. #1066 Ann L. Carson, 1317 North Arm Drive - Side setback variance to construct an addition to existing residence. 3. #1067 Herbert T. Olson, 3640 Bayside Road - Side setback variance to construct an addition to existing residence. 4. #1068 Dr. Glen Nelson, 500 Tonkawa Road - Variance for temporary guest apartment within principal structure. 5. #1069 Jim Williams, 2725 Ethel Avenue - Side setback variance to construct a 2nd story addition above residence with existing substandard setback. 6. #1070 Richard Rinehart, 985 Old Long Lake Road - side setback variance to construct an attached garage. 7? \\#1071 Colin Kelly/Lona Jane Shaughnessy, 95 South Brown Road'ront and rear setback variances to construct a new residence. 8. #1072 Fred Winston, 755 Spring Hill Road - Lot line setback for additiLn to existing animal barn. 9. #1073 James Deanovic, 2050 Shoreline Drive - Conditional use permit for land alteration. 10. #1074 Grace Baptist Church, 2830 Shadywood Road - Variance to sign ordinance height standard. 11. #1075 Joseph Durda, 3135 North Shore Drive - Hardcover and setback variances for deck within 75' of lakeshore. All persons wishing to be heard will appear at this time. Written comments are solicited. Please make an appointment with staff to review the plans. City of Orono By: Planning Commission CA • iri` JeanndWA. Mabusth, :u±ld ng i Zoning Adm n strator To be published the week of September 1, 1986 in the Laker and Pioneer Newspaper. C=TIFICATB OF NAILING STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) ss. ) CITY OF ORONO ) I, Jamie Bosma, of the City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota, do hereby certify that a Notice of Public Hearing concerning the matter of #1071, was mailed to the attached list of property owners . In Witness Whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and seal this 26th day of August, 1986. ,.ice,.- Z ICIUNTTI, r .�.. . a�raiotto�to NOTICE hoe" h the C&Ad orwan an Ch•mbars at 127. South an Nte Collette: ertlwr w M,a f l,r�id7UlaEi 14o�ott V 10N Larry mm"r"rr 4M Cfrlppewe 2. 100 Am L. Carbon, 1317 Narfh Arm orh►a-MOa 0011100di 0 In we b owatnxt an 3. 087 Nrharl T. Olaw. 3@40 ti0y01ua 140100-41101e solbaok varbrloe to oanatrvct an to" Dr. 0AM1 N•001, 5W Twaawo � tar vimavrun.nc 6. 100 AM 1MriaeN. 2725 Ethel Avanw— sld0 aettleob vaterroo to oor%&W a 2nd efory ettlr. ►—ante VAh oft" edetan. E. 1070l WWd ft'r~. M5 ON Loco Latre p•e'ft =*@* verterroo 10 oorwntO +,art ol- "VI ' ")Lam Jeri@ twinnoteto oorrfnrot as now rosiderve •. 1072 Fred wYroton, 755 &V" HM a1Mtbboth." eetttaclr fora . . - to ewlet� O. 1073 Jaen. 0orrovlep,if. 2060 Sf rdna 10. f WN p Gtxd for � W&W, wood Rood -varlet" to OW orsr� �� .f.terrd. 1 I. 1075 JoOafW Ord.. 3135 North &WM M**—+tardOMW and eatbeck varlrroae for dk* w4M1 75' of 1eA WWO. AN parum WWOIg to be hose we appear.of ~ PbOW plerre ft" am e0oo1'Ar with staff to MjW the Ofty of Cro" sr: No Co"ft"" w zJ-- .. Meath, one+p AbrrYyOtralor (Pibl;rhad in The Laker w4 prom, sop. 2 j -L = .; r r- I'. SrV Affidavit of Publication State of Minnesota. County of Hennepin. Bill Holm, being duly sworn, on oath says that he is an authorized agent and employee of the publisher of the newspaper known as THE t.AKER, Mound. Min- nesota, and has full knowledge of the facts which are stated below: A.) The newspaper has complied with all the re- quirements constituting qualifications as a qualified newspaper, as provided by Minnesota Statute 331 A.02. 331 A.07, and other applicable laws, as amended. B.) The printed which is attached was cut from the columns of said newspaper, and was printed and published once each week for ! successive weeks. It was first published Tuesday. the _ _ y day of - - , 19 �// b . and was thereafter printed and published every Tuesday, to and including Tuesday. the day of .19 Authorized Agent Subscribed and sworn to me on this / b /'�'day of - 19 . By�N ary Public 1 Rate Information (1) Lowest classified rate Laid by commercial users for comparable space: $7 84 per inch. (2) Maximum rate •Rowed by low for above matter =4 54 per Inch (3) Rate actually charged for above matter $4 54 per inch Each additional succeaarve week t3 03 per kxh To: Mayor Butler Mark E. Bernhardson, City Administrator Orono Council Members Orono Planning Commission Members From: Michael P. Gaffron, Assistant Planning & Zoning Administrator Date: September 9, 1986 Subject: 11071 Colin Kelly & Lona Shaughnessy, (Lot 2, Block 1 Kelley Green) - Variance - Public Hearing Zoning District - RR-1B, 2-acre Application - Front and rear setback variances to construct a new residence. List of Exhibits Exhibit A - Application Exhibit B - Plat Map Exhibit C - Property Owners List Exhibit D - Survey Exhibit E - Neighboring Residence Layout Pertinent Facts: Lot width: 720' Lot Depth: 144' Front Setback - Required: 50' Proposed: 37.3' Variance: 12.7' or 25% Rear Setback - Required: 50' Proposed: 33.9' Variance: 16.1' or 32% Discussion: Applicants request front and rear setback variances to construct a residence on this long but relatively narrow lot created as part of Kelley Green in 1978. Because the usable lot depth after required 50' front and rear setbacks '.s only 44', the shape of the lot is a hardship in that it leaves little flexibility in designing the house to fit the landscape. Note that a new house is expected to be started soon on the opposite lot south of the cul-de-sac. The topography of the site seems to suggest that the proposed house and drainfield are located in the most logical site on the lot. However, this dies place the house directly south of the Heinz Otto residence (which accesses off Watertown Road). Staff has received no comments from Mr. Otto as of this writing. Zoning File #1071 September 9, 1986 Page 2 of 2 Given that a side setback standard of 30' is required in the RR- 1B district to provi,?e open spat- and maintenance of a rural character, it follows hat a new residence, which has at least some degree of flexibility in siting, should maintain at least a 60' separation from any adjacent residence. This proposal meets that criteria, with the hardship being the narrowness of the lot. Secondly, regarding the front setback, note that this is the end of a cul-de-sac road with an outlot for a future through road to the west. If the road ever was connected through to Devin Lane, a logical realignment of the cul-de-sac area to connect Out 1 of B to Out lot C would result in the house meeting the 5n' setback (see survey). Staff Recommendation: Staff would recommend approval. based on the following findings: 1. The narrowness of this recently created lot is a hardship in that it leaves little flexibility in locating the house to fit the landscape. Under code requirements, the allowable building envelope without variances is only 44' deep. 2. The proposed house location maintains at least a 60' separation distance to the nearest adjacent residence, which is the minimum residential side yard separation distance allowed in the RR-lB zone. 3. Topography and existing low lands on the property, and the necessity of providing a septic system on the property, are factors that make the proposed house locations and orientation the most feasible for this property. TO: Mayor Butler Mark Bernhardson, City Administrator Orono Council Members FRW: Michael P. Gaffron, As.,istant Zoning Administrator DATE: September 16, 1986 SOBJ: #1071 Kelly/Shaughnessy, 95 Brown Road South - (Lot Block 1, Kelley Green) - Variance - Resolution This is a request for front and rear setback variances for construction of a new residence in the Kelley Green Subdivision west of Brown Road South. Please review the memo and xhibits of 9-9-86. Planning Commission voted 6-0 to approve based on the findings as stated in the attached resolution of approval. Note that the neighbor to the north, Mr. Otto, was contacted by the applicants, and he prefers the house configuration as proposed because it actually provides him more privacy than if the house was constructed parallel with the roadway. Staff recommends approval per the attached resolution. SOWING PILE NO. 1071 CITY OF ORONO NOTICE OF PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 473-7357 Date of Notice: 9/16/86 ----------------------------------------------------------------- TO: Colin Kelly/Long Shaughnessy COPIES TO: Les Kelley 285 S. Brown Rord 125 S. Brown Road Long Lake, MN 55356 Long Lake, MN 55356 ----------------------------------------------------------------- TYPE OF APPLICATION: XX Variance ----------------------------------------------------------------- DATE OF MEETING: 9/15/86 VOTE: 6 For 0 Against Planning Commission recommmends the following: XX Approval: As Submitted NOTES AND SPECIAL CONDITIONS: This item will appear before the City Council for Final action on Monday, September 22, 1986. Please review the attached draft resolution which will be presented for approval. ----------------------------------------------------------------- Applicant's next scheduled meeting is confirmed as: Council Monday September ; _ 1986 --7 ; oc:> rb.— M-1,1%. If you desire certified copies of the official Planning Commission minutes, they are available from the City Recorder after review and approval by the Planning Commission. City of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 2048 A RESOLUTION GRANTING A VARIANCE TO MUNICIPAL &OWING CODE SECTION 10.25, SUBDIVISION 5 (B) FILM i1071 N9ERNAS, Colin Kelly and Lona Jane Shaughnessy (hereinafter 'the applicants') are the owners of the property located at 95 Brown Road South within the City of Orono (hereinafter "City•) and legally described as followsc Lot 2, Block 1, Kelley Green, Hennepin County, Minnesota (hereinafter 'the property"): and WNRRMS& the applicants have applied to the City for a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 10.28, Subdivision 5 (B) to permit the construction of a single family residence to be located 37.3 feet from the front lot line and 33.9 feet from the rear lot line where front and rear yard setbacks of 50 feet are normally required. NOW,, TeRaRFORR, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono, Minnesota: FINDINGS 1. This application was reviewed as Zoning File f1071. 2. The property is located in the RR-lB Single Family Rural Residential Zoning District. 3. The Orono Planning Commission reviewed this application on September 15, 1986, and recommended approval of 'he proposed variances based upon the following findings: A) The narrowness of this recently created lot is a hardship in that it leaves little flexibility in locating the house to fit the landscape. Under code requirements the allowable building envelope without variances is only 44' deep. Page 1 of 4 City of OR ONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL Z193 2048 B) The proposed house location maintains at least a 60' separation distance to the nearest adjacent residence, which is the minimal residential sl'de yTrd separation distance allowed in the RR-113 zone. The orientation of the house is such that the windowless north wall will face the neighboring property to the north, affording both applicant and neighbor a greater degree of privacy. C) Topography and existing low lands on the property, and the necessity of provid.,ng a septic system on the property, are factors that make the proposed house locations and orientation the most feasible for this property. 4. The City Council has considered this application including the findings and recommendations of the Planning Commission, reports by City staff, comments by the applicant and the effect of the proposed variance on the c,-alth, safety and welfare of the community. 5. The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this property are peculiar to it and do not apply generally to other property in this zoning district; that granting the variance would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor pose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely serve as a convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate a demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is necessary to pre- serve a substantial property right of the applicant; and would be in keeping with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan of the City. CONCLUSIONS, ORDER AND C ADITIONS Based upon the above findings, the Orono City Council hereby grants a variance to the Municipal Zoning Code Section 10.28, Subdivision 5 (B) to permit the construction of a single family residence in a location 37.3 feet from the front lot line and 33.9 feet from the rear lot line, subject to the following conditions: Page 2 of 4 Sep City of ORONd RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNL,, NO. 2048 1. Authorities granted by this variance run with the property not with the applicant, but are permissive only and must be exercised by application for a building permit within one year of the date of Council approval, or this variance will expire on that date (September 22, 1987). 2. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this variance shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically terminate any authority granted herein, and shall be punishable as a misdemeanor. 3. The undersigned applicant has read, understood and here- by agrees to the terms of this resolution and on behalf of himself, his heirs, successors and assigns, hereby agrees to the recording of this resolution in the chain of title of the property. Adopted by the Orono City Council on this 22nd day of Mary C. 9ut er, Mayor Timottfy Adams, Acting mayor Page 3 of 4 ` Page 3 of 4 City of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 2048 STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ss. COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) On this �'-~' day of 1 . / , 1986 before me a Notary Public within and for'said county, personally appeared ' -/ / a 11,«4 1 known to me to be the person a described in atid whb executed the foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free act and deed. WILLIAM J. SMETANA ;j NOTAPY F )BLOC • MINNESOTA "[ iI HENNEPIN COUNTY MY Commission Expires May 31. 1989 STATE OF MINNESOT# ) )ss. COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) VA MY COMMISSION EXPIRES On this 7' day of 1986, before me a Notary Public-igfWn and for said County, personally appeared L- ON4 JQ 0j l ._a,<,- 1, known to me to be the persons described n and wh1b executed the foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free act and deed. �c� WILLIAM J SMLTANA NOTARY kNONOTAPYPUA.n: MINNESOTA HENNEPIN COUNTY MY (nmm st cn f R'W"% UMW �1 1950 MY COMMISSION EXPIRES Page 4 of 4 STATE OF MINNESOTA ) COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) CITY OF ORONO ) I Dorothy M. Hallin, City Clerk of the City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy of a resolution of the City Council of the City of Orono with the original record of such resolution in the Minutes of the proceedings of said City Council at a meeting of said City Council held on September 22 , 19 86 , and that the same is a true and correct copy of said resolution was duly adopted by said City Council at said meeting. In Witness Whereof, I have hereunto set ■y hand and seal this 26th , day of September , 1986 . thy M. a in, City Clerk (SEAL) September 23, 1986 To City of Orono Subject: Lot 2, Block 1, Kelley Green Variance 1071 Dear Sirs: We have reviewed the variance requested by the Shaughnessys' and Les Kelley and have no objections to your approval of said variance. Yours truly, Heinz Otto Elliabeth OttoA-4j.�u/ APPLICATION NO. 1071 CITY OF ORONO NOTICE OF COUNCIL ACTION P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 473-7357 Date of Notice: 9/26/86 -------------------------------------- ------------------------ TO: Colin Kelly/Lona Shaughnessy COi.Lds: 285 Brown Road South Les Kelley Lonq Lake, MN 55356 125 Brown Road South Long Lake, MN 55356 TYPE OF APPLICATION: XX Variance ----------------------------------------------------- DATE OF MEETING: 9/22/86 VOTE: 4 For 0 Against COUNCIL ACTION - MOTION: To approve per the resolution which you have been previously sent, subject to letter of approval from Mr. i Mrs. Otto (neighbors directly north), which we now have on file. Please return the signed resolution originals as soon as possible. The building code review of your plans is underway I should be completed the week of September 29, 1986. X WORK PERMITS ARE REQUIRED - contact Building Inspector before beginning work X VARIANCE APPROVAL is limited to the extent shown on approved plans. Do not change plans. Variance authority expires one year after approval. If you desire certified copies of the official Council minutes, they are available from the City Recorder or City Cierk after review and approval by the City Council. WAIN[ O.POPMAM RAYMOND A. -AIM ROGER W. SCHNOSRICM DENVER KAU rMAN ROS[RT A. MINISM ROLFE A-WOROEN ().MARC WHITEHEAD SRUC[ D. WILLIS FREDERICK S. RICMARDS O. ROS[RT JOHNSON DARY R. MACOMSER ROS[RT S.SURK MUCH V. PLUNKETT. III r REDERICK C.SROWN THOMAS IL. S[RO JAMES R.STEILEN JAMES S. LOCKNART ALLEN W. HINOEMAKER CLIrFORD-.OPEEN[ O. WILLIAM KAUFMAN MICHA[L O. FREEMAN POPHAM, HAIK. SCHNOEIRICH 6 KAUFMAN. LTD. 3300 PIPER JA«RAY TOWER MINNEAPOLIS, MINNESOTA 55402 TELEPHONE 012.333-4800 TELECOPIER HOWARD SAM MY[RS,III RIC HARD A. KAPLAN 512-33A-2713 cPN[[f ERS LARK♦ O.ESP[L JANIE S.MAYEROM THOMAS J.SARRETT JAMES A. PAINE DAVID A.JON[S LEE E.SH[E— ALAIN FRECON PATRICIA A. JENSEN LESLIE GILLETTE MICHAEL T. NILAN ROSERT M, LYNN THOMAS M. SIPMINS ROSERf C.MOILANEN THOMAS F. NELSON THOMAS J. RADIO DAVID L.MASNMALL KATHLEEN M.MARTIN JOHN C.CMILDS DOUGLAS P. SEATON THOMAS E.SANN[R Ms. Jeanne Mabusth City of Orono P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 Dear Jeanne: ■RVC[ S. M DART O. BLACKFORD SUITE 2400 SCOTT E. RICHTER Ii00 SEVENTEENTH STREET PAUL J. LINSTROTH OCN AOO-69 500 SCOTT A. SMITH LEPH NE 30 TELEPHONE 303-SS3•ISOO ELIZAS[TM A.THOMPSON KITH J. HAI LELAND TELECOPIER 303 003-2194 MARK •. PETERSON SUITE 300 SOUTH D. RANDALL SOYER ISOO M STREET, N. W. SRIAN N. JOHNSON WASNINOTON. O. C. 20036 TIMOTHY W. MUCK TELEPHONE 2J2 828-6300 CAROL t. SWANSON TELECOPIER 202-S2S-531S RRUCE A. PETERSON DIRECT DIAL NUMBER JULIE A. SWEITEER T HOMASC.MIELENNAUSEN KATVILE[N A.SLAIF 334-2549 MIC HAIL O. CHRIS' ANSON J. MICHAEL SCHWARTZ LARAY[ M.OSSORNE September 2, 1987 TDDD..JOHNSON JEFFRET P. CAIRNS LOUIS P. SMITH FRANCIS J. CONNOLLPY SRUCE H. LITfL[ MARK F. PALMA RUSSELLS.PONESSA SRYAN L.CRAW rryRO DAVID K.RYOEN MATTHEW E.OAMON JOHN W. PROVO GREGORY O. SROOK[R WILLIAM M. OJILE. JR. TERRANCE A. COSTELLO JOSEPH O. VASS SRIAN W. OMM STEVEN A. CMELCSNIK OREOORV O. SCOTT SHARON N. /ULLMER 0. COVMSEL FRED L.MORRISON Er, sed and listed below are variances which cannot be filed in a chain of title because they are registered as torrens properties. Name Resolution No. Smith's Bay Marina, Inc. 2194 Waters, T. 2172 Kelly/Shaughnessy 2048 If you have any questions, please feel free to call either me or my secretary, Joyce Pedersen at 334-2736. Very truly yours, �LZ-S/4^ IkIk4 ° Nancy E. Husnik Legal Assistant EH/jlp/3328 Enclosures