HomeMy WebLinkAboutProject PacketCITY OF ORONO, MW "- A fi- `4
�i
Conditional Use and Variance Application
LOCATION OF PROPOSAL (or prope )
Address3W,�� am 14�lC • . k4N,
T
Legal Description 1-o c,4.2.2
APPLICANP
Name J A MCC K, AcC Ieq Phnne
Address I Z 33 T'v+11' W0j , , 146K►tU /l�H n3`l3
OWNER,
Name Sd vhc. q S *;Om- Phone I
Address
Present Zoning 19- Z- Present Use A ri n t,
Zoning Ordinance Section Relating to Request 31- 2Oo
Specify Ordinance Requirements ii% a/rC 4/ # ,j w�
Explain Request Relative to Requirements
Extent of Non -conformity
TYPE OF RBQLEM
Conditional Use
Variance
Wetlands Variance
Riprap
�e ?f"--77
FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY
Council Action
to
Denied
Hardships /to Property (Your reasons for requesting this Variance or Conditional Use Pemit
l� sir ? d Game .► 1 -101-rzed All 4 K Jt 1 ! eLtp
Sll/1 lr rt�t %Ol� �t14N[� ►W10U.11D� 1S Qi110KkT3 70 �{4�Nl�MKL
K oils 4t i2o dAIPJ o JSd�
�tSG �N P� 14h ac 0-e .,L�f,er,
MATERIAL NECESSATrMA COW= APPLICATION
(Must be submitted 1 week prior to Council Meeting)
1. Application completed
2. Plat Map Section
3. Survey (Sketch in proposal)
Date Ob-7
4. Certified Property Owner's List of
owners within (300 ft.) (150 ft.) -
from Hennepin County Registrar of
Deeds
S. $30.00 Fee
Signature --
' 1 Y77
se YeA4._
LAKE MINNETONKA CONSERVATION DISTRICT63
402 East Lake Street No. of boats
Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 Boat Density Index
473-7033 Can be reached at phone :
k 3l-16 l6
APPLICATION FOR NEW OR REVISED MULTIPLE DOCK AND OR MOORING LICENSE
ill ej t� y�C C(PQv
Print or type owner's name-
-7? 0?J 1_ rceblw �Vvltl i�Z ov
Owner's address -------------- ----------_----- Phone
the owner of land in the City of 0 Lulf a
Business name:-51k 4 kJ mAt,l,t,---------- --' —
If dif erent om owner
(Street address %- K�IliTM
rjg address if different from street address -
which is riparian to LMCD area(s) - , No(s) ,
Lake Minnetonka, applies pursuant to Chapter III, Section 3.08, LMCD Code, for a
new or revised Multiple Dock License, in accordance with all data, and other in-
formation submitted herewith and made a part hereof. The following must accompany
the application (see samples attached:
(a) Locator map H Site plan
(b) Survey (or plat) (a) Dock construction detail sheet
Permit or licenses may also be required from the municipality and from the
Minnesota Department of Natural Resources (for permanent docks.
Data: /
1. Type of application (check): Privat. , Commercial-y Multiple
Dwelling , Club , Other (explain)
2. The maximum number of boats stored in the water at docks is 43
3. The maximum number of boats stored in the water at moorings is O
4. The maximum number of motorized or sail boats drystored for Lake use is
5. Public liability insurance: Amo•,mt $ 3001DOip Company laelwe -ZkJ (+.
6. All required permits, licenses and approvals have been obtained from the City
in which the multiple dock is located, and the M.D.N.R. Yes t",/No
(Continued)
Page 2
Name s%Lt 4;j /✓ dl Gf/V
LAKE MINNETONKA CONSERVATION DISTRICT
Commercial and others, where applicable, provide the following additional
information:
7. Check the nature of services and parking provided:
a) Boat storage _ No. of parking spaces
b) Launching ramps___, _ "
c) Sales____ it
d) Service it
e) Boat rentals _ __— _ of
f) Restaurant__ ___^_ of
g) Other
h) Parking not required______ Total
Reason:_ _
8. Sanitary facilities are provided: Yes �NO_
9. Boat toilet pumping service is provided: Yes
_ I
number of units
No
I certify that the information provided herein and the attachments hereto are
true and correct statements and I understand that any license issued may be
revoked by the District for violation of the LMCD Code. I consent to permitting
officers and agents of the District to enter the premises at all reasonable
times to investigate and to determine whether the Code of the District is being
complied with.
Date ��/ �7 Authorized Signature
Title_ GC�
Relationship to ouner__ _ �—
W-221
Rev. 74
STATE OF MINNESOTA
DEPARTMENT of NATURAL RESOURCES
Division of Waters, Soils and Minerals
NOTIFICATION OF PERMIT APPLICATION
INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE APPLICANT
Minnesota Statutes, Section 105.44, Subdivision 1, requires you to supply a complete copy
and all supporting data of your water permit application to the following:
A) The chief executive officer of the city or township within which
the project is located.
B) The secretary of the Board of Managers of the watershed district,
if any, within which your project is located or which your project
may affect.
You MUST certify having served the complete application on the above in the box on the back
sideo7-the application form W-54.
IN ADDITION, if your project is NOT located in a city, a complete copy and all supporting
data of the application should be submitted to the Administrator of the Shoreland Manage-
ment Program for the affected county.
Complete this form for each notice served on a local government official.
SECTION I (TO BE COMPLETED BY APPLICANT)
TO: A) Chi f executive officer of the (check)
city, [Q township of e�ryNO
(print or type n=e)
y
B) Secretary of the board of managers of the ,�'l1#ifC 4 k6 watershed district.
(print or type n=e)
C) Administrator of the shoreland management program of 4WIfe lil county.
(print or type ncaw,
FROM: IA 7;9i1wovl 41 k� �r� %K 577-Y/ Date: k/ l0 19 �
(print or type naddress of applicant)
INSTRUCTIONS FOR THE LOCAL GOVERNMENT
This report from provides you an opportunity to submit input to the Department of :Natural
Resources to assist in deciding whether to grant, modify, or deny the requested permit.
It is NOT absolutely necessary for local agencies to officially approve or disapprove the
project or make any recommendation, although this may be done if desired. It is requested
that local agencies indicate the following, as applicable:
A. The relationship of the proposed project to local plans for the
affected water and related land.
B. The relationship of the project to local land use controls including
flood plain and/or shoreland regulations.
(continued on reverse side)
CONSTRUCTION DATA (also attach sketch or draping) w-54
Channelling Existing Proposed Alterations along shore Proposed
Total length (feet) - - - - _
Distance along shore (feet)- - - - - - VS-0
Length in lake/stress (fest)- - - _
Bottom width (feet) - - - - - - - Distance waterward (feet)- - - - - - -
Side slopes (ratio) - - - - - _ -
Average depth (feet)- - - - - - - Thickness of fiil material (feet)- - -
Gradient (Z)- - - - - - - - - _ _ Depth of excavation (feet) - - - - - - -�
1. Describe type of excavation equipment to be used, if known:
A.A oe
2. Describe /1ocation (include map) an char eri tics of spoil dis sal site pro osed:
14 ScfC ar 3riio T* y„ dG e. C .o u s
f row .t'J(i3 yoke o�/�
3. Moufl� intenanc excavation be ecessary? (check) YES
-74'o1 -- OW �7M�C 4 �, — E'&" .2o ca d v� NO Explain:
G/oje /0 SAOIC- e4.., 4, ore-&eo,./ d4.Gdyfh .fps„ bok•, e4TJS ssir3 /,�iei�
4. Volume of material to be removed initially (cubic yards): Muck or silt 9 7a-
Sand or gravel Rock or stone
ATTACFWNTS Lyi15.00 filing fee, ["<photog-aphs, L!�"-other (apeci.fy) t_.I�r�_ T/� yr /if � %D
Applicant declares that information submitted herewith and statements made herein are a true and correct ;6WtK4LI
representation of the facts, and that the filing of this application and information with the
Commissioner of Natural Resources is prima facie evidence of the correctness thereof.
COMPLETE APPLICATION SUBMITTED TO:
(1) Ovoito
Nam of city or tcL p
Cryj 4 l �Qy , I'! k, 3,? 3
Street
%s t office
(2) I N1 NeQV4
Narw f �atore sstrsc
et'�vUOYi, iMwt�►LLIM_
(3) 61
t•,s.cha .s.. t Na• s� 'CoRSwwTu�
of DL rIC County
State of Minneso a )
ss
County of I
on this IO "k- day of a<-ZG,
Dated this day of j! 19
Signed
(applicant)
/ % ,' erase
Address i� �3 �Kll( QAD9) �(/,
city
State Zip code
AFFIDAVIT
9?P— 0779 — /I
Phone 414 - W
18J 2 before me personnally appeared
2�e
who being first duly swo4 and to me known to be the person 01� who executed the foregoing
application, acknowledge(s) that ✓— executed the same as,-lLI� own free act and deed and
that the statements, maps, plans, documents, and other supporting data are true and correct according
to �, best knowledge and belief.
AA►AAA AA"U AA,UA#ALAAAAAWAAA►tc --- �-
MARILYN BOG/.CKI
NOTARY PUBLIC • MIN CSOTA Notary Publ i
DAKOTA COUNTY —�-- County
Val" My CoTmissMn (+;i+es Feb. ]. 198? MY commission expires _ 19
w-221
C. Any possible effects of the proposed project on the water resource,
navigation, fish and wildlife, conservation, pollution, and the
general public interest.
D. Any recommended modifications in the proposal or other alternative
way of achieving the desired objective which would reduce undesirable
effects.
E. Any pertinent factual data available concerning the water body or the
proposed project.
F. Reasons for any local objections.
Please complete this form and return to the address shown in the lower left corner of
this page within 15 days, if possible, or inform the department if additional time is
needed.
SECTION II (TO BE COMPLETED BY CITY, TOWNSHIP, WATERSHED DISTRICT OR COUNTY)
The applicant named on the opposite side of this form submitted a copy of his water permit
application on 19 It has been reviewed and the following comments
are submitted for consideration y the Department of Natural Resources.
1
(Attach additional sheets if necessary) Dated 19
RETURN TO:
DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES
Division of Waters, Soils 4 Minerals
Regulations Unit
Centennial Building
St. Paul, MN 55155
Gov't Official's name
print or type)
Signature
Title
Address
MINNES
TA
R SI STATE OF ATURALORE nD
Rev. 7 DE�ARTMENC of NATURAL RESOURCES
Division of Waters, Soils E Minerals
APPLICATION FOR PERMIT TO WORK IN PUBLIC WA
WJ
// , P JUL 20 1977
%Iles K ype a cQr/i the owner of land in Government lotjs)
�prs nL or type t�D f,. can nm� . � `.MR,W.AM 05 ,
quarter section(s) NF , ,��S township no.(s) ��-7 a3 range(s)
jcm- ,� .
dt�slcle o�p � lair i(.ol� �/ � ��• cam 7
I(fire no., box1no. or address) (lot, s oseson
County(ies) fyC4 y t/1K which is riparian to - /_ 4_
W@Wne of Lake or stretra)
applies pursuant to Minnesota Statute! .:F:;pter 105 and other applicable statutes for a permit to work in the
public water(s) named above, ir, accord.nce with all data, maps, plans, and other information submitted
herewith and made a part hereof.
PROPOSAL
IT IS PROPOSED -TO: excavate, 1_�7 fill, Q construct, U remove,
(check) Q install, Ll' abandon, or Q other(epecify)
THE FOLLOWING: Q dam, = shore -protection, [shoreline, [Q harbor, = channel, Q bridge,
(check) = culvert, Q wharf, L= obAtruction, or = other(specify) _
Explain why this p NJUSTIFICATION
project is eeded:
4ewtrCJ W92&v �PL4C/ /K K[6c� yews 4rLd �J4r�d�j' o s�`� /�Qvo-
yca`s Kf4t�A ,M►jress rb[G rKt a �d e9.�ss /Cnyxa�
ENVIRD, NTAL ,••,rxCf /--P4t-Str
1. Anticipated changes in water and related land sources:
UmAbl 49 �Vrwl 0 J-J ,
s4OIt 114c A AKlilll 46t CladR9C4 . - eft -. H w///
2. Unavoidable/ but anticipated detrimental effects:
��•Kor�l Of �r�J ��k� rl6W1i 1 iCsv�ee,,r[r
3. Alternatives to the action proposed:
Alaoe �ticCr/Gw(
PROJECT SITE DATA
I. Describe the type _and amount of aqu$tic 4getation present:
W*k
4404!
2. Describe the na ure o£ the material beneath the water:
s�4�je , Ned.
3. Describe the nature of the upland area: - /
tb 4k- /,f cseQJe aC T4 3 �"r
4404k;", clu 41;44eJu ,
r rr
Ar
.o
R'111
-,,,%1J
I
1. Describe type and amount of nearby shoreland development:
i� Pe . E���- C.4 � ANel,�
S. ENCLOSE SKETCH DESCRIBING WATER LEVEL FLUCTUATIONS.
(sea inetructiona) ATTACH EXTRA SHEETS IF NECESSARY
(eontinaed on ra:,erse side) — ---
OvIae /97Z
- API�uX.
eo
ply
Dyc l( (�, c uc STLAMS ry
94 y — � 1-3r �o'
�°' rr +r: � P
h 30 .
1� t+vive -gut«
IL
is
N 34-5y
ss. « 30
,
i
DOCK AREA n
3t u ! it 41, �r �` � �. t K U4 = 90
�1
gJECA
r• sr 47 4
I
olsr=r-oFF G�uE
[-, ,C IJ��E STD: EET'
4CCG s
ArC4
k41�G �t�f
6,1
�- Flow �Oav� - v 6 :v °� Xd "
ule. Kk+P-y ad..,,-
5+yln" — 61A c ea.C4 side. zx6 v
K4 0 47 (S, y l
u eQ (a c at-iU'A—
aX�''
�Gl(Lks
BO!%,1
Al `• ��y�a � �' �.•.. @tt ' r � �n1.1� ke �, �♦ '� •..�' , �''�._..`_.� � A � ;•'it
�LTZ-1 � �>s+, •T �`.►�._...� ,lif.JG... ti,' n•7• ...�.i'._ •s�..�• �r%��
. 1., '•� � ,t'A .. lobM D e•tt, � rM ell 4 , I rj-N,t'.. � � •+t .• ^.i i
r n '�t1 \ •�•• �• ° •10 6 S 1 ;��_ AN ` •/1'' �. 1: i• _ 1 ti �JeI
f r3 f O7 ;. .t'.�.t.,....• \ 6 01 streb. t , '' l '• t 1 In 3
�...1- r:.� '•f / V•s •• i ! u
Tt e.i1►�Jr. `` \- Ord •1. p� �, \ ►I. 0 Day .•!• •.f. •CAITIOc` � t���lr�•,• ,��.•+•� '._ •t� �� ����•`re�� �.a.-` 0
0 or
' Ave • � •!. •i'�,' 'NO;• ., •!. .,�°' �, r. •+ `t'•� ,y,� ! IVOyrete BAY 't
1r i• V
•% •, ' ^ . a'. y• Maratit r t �• I - D•eant
,v\•h rfN i. tl�t ,1 •1. .1( �S•R� L.R: � +�� �y ., 17• t 1 k•. le...t 1_ ,
,i/..-alv_ 1� ...�•.. •., 'a,i., •tlilf 9• 3 . �„ •t Gov
, Cryeal hay~ U• �; ... w t
1 J �/ „ r +re1w1�
.�'i \ r t 1 /•• 17 \:1 {•', :. 7' � 3 is j 1%,e r eolel►owl . \t
( �1 J c• aw 1 1 AI i
.�•sN trNr 1•� r . a• /' 7 \ ''.{' tH �.' 1 1' 1 ` ' �'� ' Isl.nd 4Cf�V+l.\•ce•ct An
N •1 • • Q.. •'I. •. ,Ltn NI AA nl ••J '�". rr f• .\�. 1:�• ,I
• �.� ees.we /' v tip
�ji }. •,''�/•q,t�J- �I -• t;j-1w + ,t •I:k..h + $
t
►itA de
nY�,�.e•ew@
O. ,[y��-/�. " 1 Sr)r► ve11� t ►slot r
+ 1 r•' o ��.1. T. t . r F•Itiit•�...1 aew..e /ie Y
C_ I L r • fn
�j)j� • r _ t • 1 t4 eh I . 1 tb ", re1w1 I
a
rTrr.`��` r•- �( /� '•'� a (;Tv" a Ultwr�l..i \ `S
it .elnt / 't\ •....
Cn•.1nC� a •1 O r•u �� �S'�•r-�'
•es >� r.AT.w•Ts '� mot. Ili i r. `45 (O1
►. I, !c'.[� ��/ .'L r°:1I r':K !!aY • velvet .t:'!:: �•; MinneWnka ; /t� ! jJi.
•r�.f '�11 ,� I C:•,^e Spring 1•�/1'1) \ .�� 4. a i(i' .i• :,..
1• 6. !' 1 alt :- +�, i., , : Y 9r..,rq: it, w, ' ' Yr :.i� d.. `::
Park i((t' "!+L .r t ! +' • ( V •!� a i ' i:D t i - t
•f for •_,••*..rr•�•`i% +wa. .\ LRJayette (� i)'.1-41
fA ! �• 1 v+:A ��••'t:�.�•w..� '��'•..
•; 01 •,. w 'i / ''�i • - - -• - - B ,� I �` s �� �•IV j{ •t�V�-- 1.. I11•
' I ,.), 't t• Vawtld°` OUn \ N+•.1•`: _A 'v, \,170 l�- , ey wvwtlwt e s t x '�: i�� <� Deephadenil'r�
�} 1•. `
(,ak li; .1•.'� vi( t e .T. 1 1 �1 - _ ►elwt ` �.'�rt 1S ,l ?� 6.In n i� • J! • t'"�: J
f� iI r...• —ry1,� " '1� • V.`�h J : G l t+e 1� �j'' . ,7► 1 1' f AI 1 +% �9� ,= 1.;. ••
\ •�—�':tir �` t •�_ •►t +'+ O •�d,M g/-,p►'�r�}I�1�1 L'S •�' r, `i _
`, '^ �• •t � 1 ,.,I ITT PI :1 •_f,`t t 11 �' t4 aS0['1 K�.+rye �Lt .lyra A 1 <,t••1� 't t;It••��- j . �.-�i4%T.--+ I
I�••'' �. t e ..lrt� •_ a �� .`.' I! p•au.ew �. )•`: y s._... • I , t /� < 7.
i 'w5 Cnok. �1 .19
't t) 1. ll i h• t+° t t,, :`�cc=
Ph I 4..�L.r'Jr.nc.wt ` �• \�?r .:.�'I ffi'' ..IY i \'L;KG" �;�.`�
w\ -!L�• �.; �n if� DRY e Ds velvet . AY+ ', �� \ i flt3p_.:p • �y'y �; AC ^ v
1 0, •:.: ti. f It lend Goose A i� •` C.see / �V 1 �•t �/'�h
velws, Loeb@ e)�1 OEM /,%)_ •/° '. ►.� .' �i��-tt
r1W L �,.�-• �,f. /...,.:.. (•.t�welwl .. Tonke Bay •�IN@we Tj-?nf�•�t..o=.�it/•..Y1..
• t t t w@.d@c.@bble t i� / _ _ �f .T . r t f• ..M r . i• 41 ,
..Iwt : r�' .:• W �laland Park " I\ 1•.ti , - ,Z) .• i, F,ch. Bay ' • 0 '''! �l4 i►1i�c d�.� 1 a
�. t• ry eye oll .041 + •� l p ( C, i:' {"' r t� �_\ V.t Y a• .. • • �. ° "
e `� ``, Wral Day @.we C•r.n-Ill..dyl.tt/
.�• i ''"►�: 6 •`' ielnf P L ��%� �1 Greenwood
Cots I. \O.Wtsweer+elewe tf �i Y 1 >I.. �''la ` .J 1 ►r,.
f e • r ^� a �• "teY Me.rerd, . // Cr••t•'. �•;� (i idenn tiny a�; ml M �''� e `' .J�� !• I,. -)1�-_� •�` 1
�, I � � tt�O baw `s1t; ` �' oelwt . 79 /-•:; J 7! ^wNN ,�. �� � + � �!t h \. � •! �+' j � .
��-.•�._. ���� ,),, t {4.: '-•�t%`l .� _.e..�t� FiXCCl31Y'l t e \ .�� 'v�� S' AJ' llee@. •J�A• �;:
1.r' ' - ''r, r ,►y-a`)nT'\ . �i •i j� ill !�• • �-�t • »�
silo
,� 1,• .i�,� / wet r•(•TCk./l \`► Al �� "° �• •t' ( b �C �piw•a ••`'-
1• j , •lr., C•ew@�' 1 ewo •J '{, iwMariehle .,y ,. C .1�r.L �'fl. '�• Ss �t �, •1 �•� ` -�rA tsl a
n mot•{ ` •` • t
JN
)ArJ 36ffI • `'JI,�
1j • •, V` 'tog-*la.wd �1 .,.,•�1 / f i / I�. l •; j�5'LrL�a •��' • �5.3 a •a, • i
\ , . SCALE 162500
° �1 1 I o 1 __ ► • �,
.•fit( 1'�.� ''1 _�. •q 'j �_
-ice )°� ° 11ea t01t TnuD HOLD 1%" .Rai' ..• •It•
14 y / +' .LION` * ,1 ' °" f VL't3L-r'1. 1 'Lt� .r 1 ::1: •.n»':1 . • 1:= 1,-:;_:� _� _r?,.1.'_•7v .1. t t_=1,t: - t
.i3 l.akt `Z ii Y 1 n 1
D �! a, �+• e • li , . 4� •. AO _ ty. HI-1•LTL"t.1 JJ' . ?•_ 3rii@.L= -=---- .=L•i1l-ri
G �t . - v : ' C• •+ 6�A , • , / 6 i (� .„ I « ..af COM IO MR S .IuNVAL LEVEL0ET
AI I
too.
i + �• •t S L
� I^• r '� `e rof A.."
aw .MM a, re r�0 tI-Co %-II +�t•� � �. � �r� f
tAniel n11S ItAr CUNruIS wuN NAuaNAI MA• ACC ACT Seep l Y
• ( , �• .;; Loki IOR SALE BY U S GEOtOGICAt SUOIWY DENVER COLORADO 60775. OR WASNINGIrN 0 C
1 t`v[ A \', •{I •���1 �' 1 _. i %. 1 �^ t� ` �tyy%i A IOLII(H 0(%$;RIRING 11114XIM141R• 41 AND STYIOI IS AWANAVAJ W N1%1N•4
it @. � • Via• � 4 • • ' �1 • � t7! •
N �« 112
SEC. 51 T // 7 R.,3'
•I r
SEC 32. T• i( 84
• 3
�oMp ' y ISTERED LAN I
,� �� I .• �ti •. » _ 'y �� I � D SURVEY N
Aiat
JA
94
_ �'•� _! \w , r�r/ � �✓i � SJ, �� •� ..0 t , w � � 1 \ u � �••'� I '��� ' • 1 M' � ' o-` �, i
� r . i r i ��� � I .I,r, s .'•1 r 1
:� 1 L A KE MINNETON
Z
D C
off
- DS
i
% �; N i" r CS •� ['IG \�J J-tr
° o. m31A153W:)
_ `
N m in 1 ao ; r+ O 2•�'•.
M • O
az ccL
N ►'� N
l a, ;O " ' 'C ! n4 a\ �� FF� • I o'+w w
^ dANol lip
05 for.
— J t► t r`41Dfy
Z N r rn2i r ;, A w
(rc: ti.. • j% ,•`o_ N �,� �
rib N
OD
Wv
bV
o
•oJ. 0 C
a w Zf• .
N Q t
p
00 �' ^• __ - t
I I N
f �
�iTL
v • /$� ,J MOM
_o-•_ CZf1 __ J S I -uses
z 3 - S'rvis as BOW
_ c Zft --, r 16 i
Ncli
•1
` .NC1101
IA.M' r aO
LAND Stil M.
vff R'GISTERED
c/ -73
loso,
N0
(I E!
lid
18
32 33
2q
44 -4
71
(1110)
H P- L
i.�pp1�C
►V� f NIUE'�DUK�
Bout
Ael
a,p=JcN klum
• Ser--off' 1-4uc '07
�s s.\\
L t v
�y N
a
3t
.y7 ✓P
79
•
(, i UE
30'
C-R�jjc 4ccas
{
'
t46uSE
k4u0C N
Doc�cuc,
1 .2o'
?-1 ir''
9- t7 Jo'
lY--3f ao'
3`-54 �S
Ss= C3; 30 `
jaCK A&A
D.uC
kvA
1-4KE s-rofEe-r-
■11
Spa
vlew
Ykgrr w kr•
sL rlKq
Wit re✓
t�,a�e(—i---•.....,..--,..-.-...�.,.-.,. ter,,..
7
I 30'
f
f
olstoj't /
1si sc& -
it .• -
_ •� \,. .-..�1.�._
S 14-
1'►^',•� •� {.fit
.. p z •e
,
I
d�a cep
r%r6rt, a "�
UwNe� �y q jplra�
J
COUQTY
s�
I O
to
14
4.
�UII.OI►JG 1
N 1 La
w ,
f� AI
1
/ LAKE.
SIT IZ E. ET
r -
MINNEHAHA CREEK WATERSHED DISTRICT BOARD OF
D
P. O. BOX, 387 WAYZATA, MINNESOTA 55391 AUG 1971
PERMIT APPLICATION - PROPERTY IMPROVEMENT VILLAGE 05 ORONO
DNR PA NO.
DATE RECEIVED
APPROVAL YES
DATE NO DATE INSPECTED
APPLICANT NAME
ADDRESS
�Mltj t &-c/ew
APPLIED TO [city, village, town)
PROPOSES THE FOLLOWING:
1. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION
2. BODY OF WATER Shy l
Q ev Ko
3v,/S- Ay-jlcle
TEL . 6 3l l6 K
DATE /
W - " '4
ON 4,6
3. DESCRIBE WORK & OBJECTIVES
* Fo'r dredgir.-• permits describe proposed method of excavation
and erosior_;.,iltation control and proposed location of spoil
disposal.
* For ground water withdrawal give number, location and depth
of proposed /wellls and estimated gallons annual use.
/XdM_rc+rgNCC a�cdai�w ab afxe- At
4. EARTHWORK DIMENSIONS (FEET) .D X asv /► 0-3
5. EARTHWORK VOLUME (CUBIC YARDS) 97
6. ATTACH DRAWINGS SHOWING PRESENT CONDITIONS & P OPOSED CHANGES
All maps must show: Q [ ,f DA14 // p„
* scale
* goverrunent land lines and property boundaries
* topography (two -foot contour intervals) using sea level
* a plan of proposed improvements datum
* locations of soundings and soil borings
Cross sections must show:
* water and land profile showing highest known water level
* soil types
* constr io details Q
SIGNED DATE U /�
Mr. Rutford
Page 2
6. The City and State DNR have no record of any previous dredging at
this location.
7. The City feels that riparian access is not endangered because the
property owner can extend docks to navigable water within the
authorized dock use area, and has in fact more than 30 goats
currently docked at the existing facilities.
8. 'I"ne City finds no evidence of any previous attempt to control
runoff and siltation which may have contributed to the applicant's
current desire to dredge.
9. The City questions the need to dredge the entire shoreline if a
lesser amount can be dredged to provide access to a launching
area.
10. The City questions the applicant's desire to indiscriminantly
dredge the clock use area when boat storage can be more environ-
mentally provided by some onland storage system.
11. The City questions the permanent need to dredge when the applica-
tion comes in a low water vcar.
12. The City questions the very operation of a commercial marina on
this site. 'llie area was zoned for this use because of a long
existing fishing boat rental operation on the site. I"he support-
ing structures were destroyed by fire in January 1977, and the
only current land use is the non -conforming slip rental of water
space not supported by any public facilities or services.
13. The City feels tl,at this site is unsuited to any expanded,
commercial use because of the limited traffic access to the area,
the surrounding residential land use, the extremely low level of
the land, the lack of any sanitary sewer or projected construction
of same, the questionable on -site sewage treatment capability,
and the naturally shallow�eutrophic and remote nature of Stubbs
Bay.
14. The City has not yet received any information regarding fish and
wildlife habitat affects anticipated by this proposal.
15. The City is adamantly opposed to any improper dredging method
and to any on -site spoils disposal within the Lake Minnetonka
watershed.
16. The City feels that any dredging allowed mist be contingent upon
proper riprapping and runoff filtration system installation to
forestall additional dredging in the future.
Mr. Rutford
Page 3
16. Above all, the City feels that there are many alternatives
available for exploration that will have less permanent or
adverse environmental impact on the Lake, the shore and
the neighborhood, and that these alternatives should be
documented and weighed against the personal benefits to
be gained by allowing this dredging to proceed as proposed.
Sincerely,
A. Olson
Asst. Zoning Administrator
APO: be
cc: District Engineer, Corps of Engineers
Minnehaha Creek Watershed District
Minnesota 94R - Division of Waters
James !McCleary, Stubbs Bay 'Marina
Telephone 473-7357
CITY of ORONO
Post Office Box 66 • Crystal Bay, Minnesota tiS323 • Munici;.cl Offices
On the North Shore of Lake Minnetonka
August 10, 1977
Mr. James McCleary
1233 Trailuvod Drive
Hopkins, Minnesota S5343
Re: Stubbs Bay Marina - Dredging Permit Application
Mr. McCleary:
This letter is to confirm comments made by Council at their meeting this past
Monday evening. Your application will be on the Planning Commission agenda for
work session on Monday, August 1S, 1977. Major areas of concern were the
location and method of spoils disposal and provision for reducing futu:-e silta-
tion causes. There is reluctance to approve any spoils disposal within 1,000
feet of the shoreline, or any dredging near the shore without riprapping or
other siltation control measures.
If you have any additional information or wish to address these concerns, please
have something to me before Monday's meeting.
Sincerely,
24 T�k���
A. P. Olson
Asst. Zoning Administrator
APO: be
P.S. Marina license resolution approved by Council August 8, 1977. License
will be issued upon receipt of the $169.50 annual fee. Also, enclosed
is the agreement copy you requested Monday night.
eo.Ro ✓!Mof As
l norms S WpM. Jr Cha�•rnan
GeeLha•en
ROtfrls Ma[Namata Y,te Cr.��man
rrat:au
A"W Cta•. Sevetary
,J m" t on. a &eac h
Robert l 5'..n 1'.esuter
G"e—oo0
F ova•[ G 6auman
1 on., Bay
R JonFnrman
M,nneiryta
0-&tA Fenstad
Mound
Frana R Mvnt, Jr.
sprrnp Par►
M,ron (J*") Johnson
E.cetaror
WJt•ame KeW#
Shoe -ow
A,,.., Ma ... so-
W ow,and
Norman W ►aurus
O•ono
Robert K Prnsbury
m—wonaa
RictvrdJ SoOeroerp
v.ctau
Dared F Nnon
LAketo.m 1 o.rns nrp
LAKE MINNETONKA CONSERVATION DISTRICT
402 EAST LAKE STREET WAYZATA• MINNFSOTA 55391 1ELEPHONE 612i 473-703`
t,R 0 �NK u ECt/ltvF [PRECIOR
r•ua-ust 15, 1977 D
AUu 2 K-7:
VILLAGE OF ORONO
Stubbs Bay :•i?^ina
c/o J,-es R. I'icCie--y
777 Old Excelsior Blvd., 'rJ204
-�acelsior 1•111 55331
Subject: 1977 Dock License
The District ha-- reviewed ,aotir annlication for a
1977 dock license and finds that under c=rent
District resulations. setbacks r ovided 4~e
i n a.de cuate .
he ?iiCD Code noii prondE'S that %:nn e claps ODD
toward the side site lines e=enced in to the
the setback: provided must equal the length of the
slip, or be at least a riinirmm of 20 fest.
if you bane f=ther questions, please cob,,ac: uS.
Sincerely,
executive D* ector
mac: Y. R. paricL-
City of Orono 8-23-77
t'—ro on tvpe, Maoe r•n.$—c -e.'t KM•}
/ P� #� V4���
August 18, 1977
Page Four
James R. McCleary; Stubbs Bay Marina; Dredging
Application; Orono; Application No. •77-98 \
The engineer advised the managers that he had had no
communication from the officials of the City of Orono with re-
spect to acting on this application in advance of review by the
City of Orono in the customary manner. It was moved by Lehman,
seconded by Williams, that the application be tabled. Upon vote,
,die motion carried
Marc W. Arneson; Minnetonka Motel; 15818 Wayzaua Boulevard;
rrinnctonka; Wetlands Fill; Renewal of Permit No.,7b _20
The engineer reviewed the application to renew an exist-
ing fill permit originally issued by the district in 1976. The
engineer recommended approval. Following discussion, it was moved
by Lehman, seconded by Palmatier, that the application be approved
as recommended by the engineer. Upon vote, the motion carried.
Grading at "Stone Ridge Trace"; Minnetonka
Doug Goriesky, consulting engineer on behalf of the dev-
eloper of Stone Ridge Trace, appeared before the managers and ad-
vised the managers that grading had been undertaken by the devel-
oper outside the right-of-way for road construction prior to sub-
mission of a permit application to the district. Mr. Goriesky
stated that he had contacted the district's engineer as soon as
he became aware of this situation, and was proceeding to insti-
tute interim measures at the request of the district's engineer.
Mr. Goriesky further indicated that the developer would submit a
permit application pzomptly.
Hennepin County Well - Lake Minnetonka Association
The engineer reviewed the history and present status of
the groundwater wells previously or -rated by Hennepin County and
later transferred to the district. Stan Kinghorn of the Lake
Minnetonka Association indicated r iew that additional informa-
tion regarding the possible utili. on of the existing wells
should be secured by an appropriate public body. President Cochran
expressed the general interest of the Board of Managers in explor-
ing the matter to determine what would be involved in evaluating
the possibility of utilizing the existing wells. President
Cochran expressed the appreciation of the managers for the report
made by Mr. Kinghorn.
Treasurer's Report
Manager Palmatier distributed the treasurer's monthly
administrative fund report, a copy of which is attached hereto.
Following discussion, it was moved by Palmati(,, seconded by
Cochran that the report be approved and the bills paid as set
���� � wa�E aSMEO �L`UM JaAf
/ J
A
f ED
MIPJPJEHAHA CREEK r ?`
LAKE MINNEIONIU
WATERSHED DISTRICT
P.O. Box 387, Wayzata, Minnesota 55391
M IMM ESOTA 0I►ER
DOM O► MANAGERS:
Devil N_ Cochran. Pr". • N Dale Palmal,M • Alyorl L. Lehman • lam" S Fu++ell • loan 1• n v 1
August 19, 1977
Li D
1977
Mr. J a,�,K_1. M c p a r y
1233 Trailwood North
Hopkins, Minnesota 55331
VILLAGE 05 OBOR(I
Re: Permit Application No. 77-98
Location: 3445 Bayside Road, Orono
Purpose: Maintenance Dredging, Stubbs Bay of
Lake Minnetonka
Dear Mr. McCleary:
At its meeting on August 18, 1977 the Board of Managers of
the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District reviewed Lhe subject
permit application.
They have tabled the permit application pending receipt
of information from the City of Orono.
You will be placed on the agenda for the Board of Managers
meeting September 15, 1977.
If you have any questions please call 473-4224.
Sincerely,
EUGENE A. HICKOK AND ASSOCIATES
Engineers f the District
CZ.a.
E. A. Hickok, P.E.
EAH/cml
cc: D. Cochran - MCWD
G. Macomber - MCWD
V111e Muhich - Orono
r
MCCOMBS-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS ■ LAND SURVEYORS ■ SITE PLANNERS
# t'e2 9
August 29, 1977
Al Olson
City of Orono
P.O. Box 66
Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323
Subject: Stubbs Bay Marina - 3445 Bayside Road
Dredging Application
Dear Al:
As requested, I have reviewed the subject dredging
application. I recondend approval subject to the following
conditions:
1) The shoreline be protected from future erosion
problems by riprapping.
2) If the spoils are to be disposed in site, the
applicant should provide a cleans to insure that
the spoils are not subjected to erosion, thus re-
turning them to the lake.
Very truly yours,
McCO S-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES, INC.
1
Gr ry rank, P.E.
GF:ts
12805 OLSON MEMORIAL HIGHWAY, MINNEAPOLIS. MINNESOTA 55441 TELEPHONE 16121 559-3700
22 NORTH MAIN STREET, HUTCHINSON. MINNESOTA 55350 TELEPHONE (612) 879-8029
SOUTHWEST ENGINEERING DIVISION, MARSHALL, MINNESOTA 56258 TELEPHONE 1507) 532-5820
printed on recycled paper
TOrphone 473-7.357
.. t CITY of ORON o
`.y }'ust Office Rog GG•Cr%stal Bay, ALnne�ota 55323•Municipa) Offices
`s'.
t� On the North Sf,ur<• of Lake lfinr;ct. Mika
September 20, 1977
Mr. Larry Seymour
Regional Administrator
Department of Natural Re,.ources
1200 Warner Road
St. Paul, "innesota S5106
Dear Larry:
- a
As you know, numerous dredging proposals for Lake Minnetonka have been made this
past year. Dredging of La):e Minnetonka has been of great concern to the City of
Orono.
We've been unable to find any data supporting a dredging project as a benefit to
the general public. We feel dredging is not necessary along shorelines of
properties where lake access is not obstructed and lean toward denial of all such
proposals unless the riparian property Qwner has lost all means of lake access.
The term "maintenance dredging" as used by the D\'R has always been a concern in
Orono.
We are currently consideving the Stubbs Bay *farina dredging proposal. Ince again
we are faced with a problem. lie have found no records indicating any previous
dredging, so I would assume the term 'Yointenance dredging" would not apply here.
We suggested to Mr. McCleary he consider some alternatives such as onland storage.
He was not too happy with this suggestion indicating the cost would be prohibi-
co
tive.
The Orono staff reviews and prepares reports on all proposals before consideration
by the Planning Commission and Council. Our staff is somewhat limited, however.
1* do lac}, the expertise in fish and wildlife as well as many other natural aspects.
Before we do prepare a report, I would appreciate any dita that the various D,\'R
experts might be able to provide to include in this report. I would life to pre-
pare a document I could substantiate.
Than), you for the interest and cooperation we're received from the II\1R to date.
If you have any questions, please don't hesitate to giie is a call.
Sincerely,
' Henry F. ]ktihi ch
4.-ing .�•z:i.n;st.-.`car
i-h �;: be
I L: cc: Mr. Ron Harnack
4ov tao
I�� r
"WIN ct'Ttab
s 70C /3-s 134y
300 Metro Square Building, 7th Street and Robert Street, Saint Paul, Minnesota S5101 Area 612. 291-63359
September 23, 1977
Walter R. Benson, Manager
City of Orono
Box 66
Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323
RE: Department of the Army/James K. McCleary
Permit Application for Maintenance Dredging
in Stubbs Bay of Lake Minnetonka, Orono
Metropolitan Council Referral File No. 4939
Dear Mr. Benson:
On September 15, 1977, the Metropolitan Council received the above Department
of the Army permit application for Maintenance Dredging in Stubbs Bay.
The Council will be reviewing this in the next few weeks and would welcome any
comments you may wish to make. Any comments should be received within one
week.
Sincerely,
METROPO AN COUNCIL
JAn Rutford
Referral Coordinator
u
JR:sc
cc: M. James Daly, Metropolitan Council District 16
An Agency Created to Coordinate the Planning and Ilevelnprnent of the Twin Cities Metropolitan Area Comprising:
Anoka County o Carver County O Dakota County o Hennepin County c- Ramsey County 0 Scott County 0 Washington County
Telephone 4 7 3-7357
CITY of ORONO
Post Office )ivx 660Crysta) Bay, Minnesota &5323•1%lunicipal Offic"
On the North Shore of Lake Minnetonka
September 28, 1977
Mr. John Rutford
Referral Coordinator
Metropolitan Council
300 Metro Square
St. Paul, Minnesota SS101
Re: Referral File 4919
Stubbs Pay i,larin; Dredging Application
Mr. Rutford:
In response to your refferal of the U.S. Army Corps of Fngineers permit application
notice received September 26, 1977, the City of Orono wishes to enter the following
in the record:
1. 7be ^ity received a request for dredging and on -site spoils disposal
In ,_gust 8, 1977. We have also r:-ceived copies of applications
made to the Minnesota TVR on July 18, 1977, the Minnehaha Creek
Watershed District on August 3, 1977, and the Corps of Fatgineers on
August 11, 1977.
2. Discussion with personnel from the DNR indicates that the permit request
made to them was after a DNR conservation officer tagged an operator for
dredging the shoreline with a backhoe.
3. The City of Orono Planning Commission has reviewed this application at
their meetings on September 6 and September 19 and have not passed on
the request due to insufficient information regarding need, detrimen-
tal aspects, and possible alternatives.
4. The City of Orono has extensively reviewed the environmental conditions
of Lake Minnetonka and is intimately aware of the delicate balances
affecting water quality and shoreline protection. The City has found
that many previous dredgings in other areasof the Lake have caused
serious and permanent damage to the environment.
S. The City has previously, if reluctantly, approved maintenance dredging
of certain areas which had been dredged in the past or which were
required to maintain any navigable access to historically riparian
property owners.