The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutProject PacketCITY OF ORONO, MPMR)TA Conditional Use and Variance Applica# 3 6 LOCATION OF PROPOSAL (or property) TYPE OF MQMST Address , '`V-2 c t',0, 0-re f AE�4 �✓ xir l'u4''o /y; 4/✓ Conditional Use Legal Description :'C, 7 , v �, ; � ,� otif 6A� D y,� ,PA/�k el. Variance APPLICANT Wetlands Variance Nave r I /'._ *- Phone I r Address /?o 6 ,� yb b.!�Pd d��-E /'s+:�� (,,✓ Name !! 7,er e Phone I Address �}`cN ,`,y/4� �� (�0 PAti� /'1/ 4 4/ Present Zaning L K 1 C_ Present Use 'e c Zoning Ordinance Section Relating to Request 3-V S s 1. Riprap ss/f�-' c Fee re-e- c l uc U 3 i s-7 g FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Council Action to Approved Denied TJ Specify Ordinance Requirements Arc / _ t 6-77 5e1E -cj ieairit Lam+ i t k icry Lgl ClP� 4�k,Mac — 7s� FXplain Request Relative to Requiraaents Lc 75 i_57 5� I Le �L 41%i17'-- C1 T'iJI r.. 7 I Extent of NOn-coiforstity ` F 1 7 `7 5ILY N r I A T) T% K "Z Hardships to Property (Your reasons for requesting this Variance or Conditional Use Pent "A.✓�'(j icl 7A. ( ✓&JAX 7 .r, i 1,Hiwy r • � f1`.i &Flt/'q/^� MATERIAL WXXSSARY FOR CO14)LFM APPLICATION (Must be submitted 1 week prior to Council Meeting! 1. Application completed 4. Certified Property Owner's List of 2. Plat Map Section owners within ;NO-jk:;) (150 ft.) - 3• Survey (Sketch in proposal) from Deeds County Registrar of S. $30.00 Fee '►ate -�� !� .; ? •9 �E' Signature t+4-. c fe L 4KE (NORTH 4 R ,V) HC3S. DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE A-603 GOVERNMENT CENTER MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55487 momw #36-8 PROPERTY OWNERS LIST ��ronO DESCRIPTION NAME ADDRESS LOT BLK. PARCEL oq ct I hoc ) _ .� . � � C�,� U AI —r" d'• A✓O&NOt �/n i -��4i,.,ec .4✓. S'l � / .yti. s^1io,� ' lam' L Ad. 11112-eA�� ,��:: �. t boo �y� JAMES r. .vt.CA/F< 1\L I 1 � oo rQ�\�Pl c-,cyz,o-,/wofen Aej� nw.ss.�/✓ c;L 4C O rl y(� DU 1Wr� � � Q VL ♦ Y?il •ss . f tn+,E iDl� w'6 1.v f K � ,'fN. s _. , t- I C� L4� t/S1_ M t �� I ,4f/AV:'Vl ",'Of A C Of AUFffUI JVf W 111.'1i 4#"1 l 0t � • FA A PRO SEC T Of OM VAL LEYFAR DRIVE • SHAKOPEE MN SGM Af C 612-445- 7600 WALTER R WITTMER Vice President I CITY of ORONO float Office Box 660Crystal Bay, Minnesota 5."23•Municipal Offices Telephone 473 7357 Mr. Walter Wittmer 1806 Hubbard Avenue Saint Paul, Minnesota 55104 Control No. 368 XX Variance Conditional Use Permit Subdivision, Prelim. Subdivision, Final Date of Notice 5-22-78 NOTICE OF CITY COUNCIL ACTION Re: Walter Wittmer 1420 Baldur Park Road Date of Meeting:May 11, 1978 Votes: For Against Abstention. Action:____ Approval: As submitted subject to applicable ordinance requirements -ZX Approval: Subject to conditions noted Deferral: Pending receipt of information noted Referral: Review by others, as noted Denial: For reasons noted NOTES & SPECIAL CONDITIONS: Section 34.201 Variance to encroach 75 ft. Lakeshore setback by small corner of rebuilt porch. Rebuild or replace existing porch and extend flush with east and west sides of house. Delete proposed deck but replace steps in same location and extent as existing. Deadlines:,& Variance approval expires one year after the meeting date Contact building inspector for required permits —Conditional Use Approval Must be renewed annually Expires on _ Must be renewed upon change in ownership or use Prelim. Subdiv, approval expires after one year of mtg. date Contact Zoning Admin. for final plat requirements _;inal Subdivision approval expires 6 mos. after meeting date Contact Zoning Admin. for filing requirements and documentapprova —Deferred items may be declared formally withdrawn if applicant failed to provide information within u„e ,nonth of mtg. date or by date specified by Council If you desire certified copies of the official City Council Minutes, they are available from the Deputy City Clerk upon review and approval by the Council. TO: Planning Commission & Council FROM: A. P. Olson, Village Planner DATE: April 4, 1978 SUBJECT: Walter Wittmer - 1420 Baldur Park Road Variance #368 REQUEST: To remodel and add on to the existing home, particularly on the lake side in place of a former screened porch. Also shown is a large deck extending farther toward the lake. VARIANCES REQUIRED: 34.201 - One small corner of the porch addition encroaches on the 75 ft. lakeshore setback. The deck encroaches to within 64 ft. of the shore and well in front of the adjoining homes. SPECIAL NOTES: The home is a converted summer cottage on a 50' x 190' (9500 sf) lot and is located 4.23 ft. from the west lot line. There is no foundation under the existing porch and questionable foundation under the remainder. Remodeling in excess of 50% of the market value ($14,600 * 2 = $7,300) would also require variances to 34.552, lot area and lot width. PLANNING COMMISSION - April 10, 1978 WORK SESSION Planning Commission expressed approval of addition but not deck as it extends too far into lakeshore setback zone. Also expressed approval of repairing existing porch and steps which encroach lakeshore setback. PLANNING COMMISSION - April 24, 1978 AC;ION The Planning Commission approved the variance contingent upon maintaining the steps and omitting the deck. MINUfES OF A PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING HELD ON APRIL 10, 1978 PAGE 3 The Village Planner introduced the subdivision. Mr. Kelly was presert_. The Village Planner stated the size of Parcel A, which is 6 acres, should be addressed as to where it will be redivided and where there will be access. Jim Olson concurred that it would be in the best interests of the applicant and the City of Orono to address the access at this time -regarding private or public. The Village Planner stated the Council is in the process of preparing guidelines for the Planning Commission regarding this issue. The Planning Commission indicated that they did not have any problems with this subdivision plan as submitted. The Commission informed Mr. Kelly that any wetlands would be subtracted from the total dry buildable area and that any roads would also be subtracted. The Village Planner noted the wetlands area had not been located and that a survey would have to be submitted indicating the designated wetlands area. WORK SESSION ITEMS Mr. Wittmer was present. The Zoning Administrator stated this is a variance to add onto the existing home on the lake side. He added that this area is sewered. The Planning Commission indicated that they were not in favor of the deck encroaching within 75 ft. lakeshore setback, but that they did not have problems with the small portion of the porch or the existing steps encroaching. Mr. Grimes and Mr. Dahl were present. It was noted this is an existing non -conforming situation that the addition needs no variances, but that the existing house encroaches into the front yard setback. The Village Planner stated that the Ordinance states that if the addition is over 507. of the value of the existing structure it is considered a new structure and requires a variance. Hannah moved, McDonald seconded, a motion that given the fact that this property has been before the Commission and the Council for subdivision and that they are aware of the existing structure and have previously Approved the lot lines, the variance should be approved subject to no new variance being required to add onto the existing structure. Motion: Ayes (6), Nays (0), motion passed. LLOYD KELLY 85 South Brown Rd. SUBDIVISION' (#3- 2) WALTER WITTMER 1420 Baldur Park Rd. VARIANCE (#368) ORVILLE GRIMES Emtsrtain�t ,, C*miR '%. T o One ValWair Drive • Shakopee. MN 55379.612 445-76(l0 11: 6�. April 13, 1978 J �„ Mr. Al Olson Building Inspector 'lanning Commission % City of Orono P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 Dear Mr. Olson: Enclosed is the letter to the Planning Commission as suggested by you covering my variance application for the property at 1420 Boulder Park Road. If this letter does not meet with your expectations or convey to the Planning Commission what you think it ought to, please advise. Sincerely, N n L;- mot' Walter R. Wittmer Vice —President /j Enclosure Eetertttm�t I Cewter IVA. r.W One Valleyfair Drive • Shakopee. MN 55379.612 445-7600 April 13, 1978 Planning Commission City of Orono P.U. Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 Members of the Planning Commission: In accordance with your wishes verbally given to me at the Planning Commission meeting on April 10, 1978. I am, by this letter, reapplying for a variance in accordance with the plans that you reviewed at the April 10 meeting. The property is at 1420 Boulder Park Road. However, in resubmitting I herewith agree to delete the front deck from the lakeside of the home and further agree that the steps that I. reconstruct will be no larger in length, width or height than those presently existing. Since the April 10 meeting, I have spoken with Mr. Al Olson from the building inspector's office who indicated to me that this was a proper method to resubmit for variance, and I herewith request that action be taken on this variance at your next regularly scheduled meeting on April 24, 1979. Thank you for your attention in this matter. Sincerely, Walter R. Wittmer Vice -President MINUTES OF A PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING HELD ON APRIL 24, 1978 Chairman Hassel announced this was the time and place for a Public Hearing on the petition of American Rebuilders. The City Planner presented the Notice of Public Meeting and the Affidavit of Publication. The applicant Mr. Herfurth was present as well as the following neighbors: Fred Keller and Jack Rosengren, a representative for Elmer Ties. Al Olson read into the record a recommendation of the County Engineer regarding access and right-of-way on this property - Basically, the County would request an additional 10' of right-of-way along County Rd. 6 as has been standard procedure along this highway and that no more thin two new access points to County Rd. 6 be granted. This last request would require at least one common access point along the three lots abutting County Rd. 6. The Public Hearing was closed at 7:58 P.M. Most of the Planning Commission discussion centered cn the Highway Department's recommendation - they were not ready to limit access to two access points until the staff had reviewed it further. Jim Olson, city engineer, noted for the record that Lots 2, 3, and 4 were just under 4 acres each and that due to the 2-acre zoning requirement they would not be further subdividable. The Planning Commission thereafter recommended approval of the preliminary plat as shown on the drawings dated 2-9-78, subject to septic system testing prior to final, plat approval, park dedication fee payment, conservation and flowage easements over the wetlands, and to the 10' additional right-of-way dedication along County Rd. 6 as shown on the preliminary drawings. Motion by Frahm, seconded by Hanunerel, Ayes (6), Nays (0), motion carried. Mr. Wittmer was present. It was noted that a letter had been received from Mr. Wittmer revising the application. Frahm moved, Hassel seconded approval of the variance contingent upon maintaining the steps and omitting the deck. Motion, Ayes (6), Nays (0), motion carried. PUBLIC HFARING 7:51 P.M. (FRED HERFURTH) SUBDIVISION 2400 6th Avenue No. (#363) WALTER W I TTMER 1420 Baldur Park Rd. VARIANCE (#368) REGULAR MEETING OF THE ORONO COUNCIL, fAY 11, 1978 Page 8 Tom Jacobs, Bldg. Tnspector, entered into the record the following request of Walter Wittmer, 1420 Raldur Park Road, for a variance, dated April 4, 1978, which states: Mr. Walter Wittmer, 1420•Baldur Park Road, is request- ing a variance to remodel an.` add on to his existing home, particularly on the lake side in place of a former screened porch. Also shown is a large deck extending farther toward the lake. A variance to 34.201 is .required. One small corner of the porch addition encroaches on the 75 ft. lakeshore setback. The deck encroaches to within 64 ft. of the shore and well in front of the adjoining homes. The home is converted simmer cottage on a 50' X 190' (9500 sq. ft.) lot and is located 4.23 ft. from the west lot line. There is no foundation under the existing porch and questionable foundation under the remainder. Remodeling in excess of 50% of the market value ($14,600 divided by 2 = $7,300) would also require variances to 34.552, lot area and lot width. Planning Commission - April 10, 1978 Work Session Planning Commission expressed approval of addition but not deck as it extends too far into lakeshore setback zone. Also expressed approval of repairing existing porch and steps %-hich encroach lakeshore setback. Planning Commission - April 24, 1978 The Planning Commission approved the variance contingent upon maintaining the steps and omitting the deck. Council Meeting - May 11, 1978 Mayor Van Nest moved, Butler seconded, to approve the variance request of Walter Wittmer, 1420 Baldur Park Road, per the Planning Commission recommendations of April 24, 1978. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0). Tom Jacobs, Bldg. Innpector, entered into the record the request of Hennepin County Vo-Tech, 2950 Sixth Avenue North, for a conditional use permit renewal, datf-d April 24, 1978 which states: The Planning C)runission recommended rent.-wal of the conditional use permit with the same- conditions as Resolution #781 adopted last year. VARIANCE 1420 Aaldur Park Road # 3 6 8 Walter Wittmer CONDITIONAL USE Vo-Tech School # 376 rERMI- i (Continued) • r Survey for WALT WITTMER � 0+4 ! + •bi ` !r �� ;. ,.uo�r..S•�