Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
Project Packet
Jr/,,L& o /CITY OF ORONO - VARIANCE APPLICAT Initial Application Fee $150.00 ($50.00 per each additional variance) Renewal Variance Fee $75.0 (no change from original application) After -the -Fact Fees (Double application --------------------------------------- PROPRIM LOCATIoff f fee) ------------------- Site Address I L\ Z, Z ?> QL� Q \Lr i�,,\+'1Z JZ,0 0-9, Property Identification Number (P.I.D.) Please check one - Property abstract or torrens? Attach legal description to application if not included on CITY OF ORDNO FINANCE OFFICE 0 01 WN 150.00 1310200000 M 01 M 50, ,.• CHECK TL 200.00 RECEIPT -TAW' YOU #074' ?0 C001 R01 T08:37 V Li required survey. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- APPLICANT ` Phone ( home ) Name n v� v'� �y/,y \ Phone (work, FS A Address: 1431 '�a-��J ��,���x City: Zip:�, Cl �w•�) -------------------------------------------------------- OWNER (if different than applicant) Phone (home) Name C-LAI Phone (work) Address: City: Zip: Date Property Acquired t(A" (month/year) I (do) ( o n ) also own the adjacent parcels of land. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- PRESErT OSE OF PROPERTT Present Zoning District LIZL - \(., Present Use of Property Residential ) Other (specify) --------------------------------------------------------------------------- DESCRIPTIOr OF RDOURST Estimated Construction Cost $ Describe request in detail: 1L-mCGyC.-r � 1..4 --------------------------------------------------------------------------- VARIANCEd RRVIRED f "Lot Area Lot Width v Hardcover Setback Variances ( Front Side Other �� HARDSHIP Describe undue hardship or practical difficulty resulting rom strict enforcement of zoning regulations: --------------------------------------------------------------------------- DESCRIPTION OF UNUSUAL PROPERTY CONDITIONS Describe unusual property conditions preventing compliance with Zoning Code Requirements: v --------------------------------------------------------------------------- REQUIRED SUBMITTALS 1., Completed Application Form Certified Property Owners List of owners within 150' (you must obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Govt Center 348-3271). 3. Stamped, legal sized envelopes (A10) pre -addressed to each of thr- narres on the above list with no return address (use address labels obtained with property owners list). 4. Certificate of survey including hardcover calculations as required. -5: Topographic survey (existing and proposed elevations) if any changes in existing grade are proposed. �( Plat Map (obtained with property owners list). ,T'. As an addendum t(, this applicaticn, please attach a separate list of any other persons you wish notified of this application. ,B: Additional items as may be requested by City staff. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- The Applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please remember that your variance application is not complete if tle above information has not been included. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- Cer ification by Zoning Department that Variance Application is complete. Zoning Official's Signature Date --------------------------------------------------------------------------- APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE The applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay all fees and/or unusual expenses incurred in review of this application, and certifies that the information supplied' is true and orrect to the best of his/her knowledge. Applicant's Signature Date OWNERS SIGNATURE The owner hereby ackowledges and agrees to this applicat_on and further authorizes reasonable entry onto the property by City staff, consultants, agents, Commission mem rs, and Councilmembers for purpose, of investiga- tion and verification o th s request. u Owner's Signature Date I 1 ---------------------- ----- ----------------------------------------- Applicant must have alJ1 submits als into the City offices 25 days before the Planning Commission Meetinq. Planning Commission Meetings are held on the third Monday of each month. Applicants must be present at all scheduled review meetings of the Planning Commission and Council. If an applicant is unable to attend a scheduled meeting, pleaso make arrangements to have an authorized agent attend in your place and to advise the Building 6 Zoning Office of this change prior to the meeting. I k7 ��� of Z�.__• 0 DATA PlIVACY ADVISORY In accordance with M.S. 15..165, "Rights of subjects of data", we would like to inform yca that your request for a permit or license from the City of Orono or any of its departments may require you to furnish certain private or confidential inform- ation. You are notified that: 1. The information you furnish will be used to determine your qualification for the permit or license requested. 2. You may refuse to supply data, but refusal may require that the City deny the permit or license. 3. The information may be shared with other local, state or federal agencies to the extent necessary to process *he Permit or license. 4. 'F your requested permit or license reqires council action to approve, Some information may become public. 5. You have certian rights under N.S. 15.165 to review private data on yourself. 6. Your full. name, and date of birth are required to process this application or permit. / n�� I 1,3,,I /lJ rat Mic , e Tess Date of birth oes not apply to building/general permits) LA"?l-����tl Phone I un"at d my rights as s ated above. i� gna ttire . r Y Y „ f r li - 15 AP d*% 4 Ar iv Of 19 J p . Z gal tl +' • \ 'it16 zLL + S • I I co z Y ,.q e S r PleIf Of Lf 2.810:k 1, Cry"al say vie. 34 �w� tiAKE (r,p 11 RUN DATE 03/11/88 BATCH 006 38 08-117-23 34 0013 PROP ADD 01424 BALDUR PARK RD OWNER NAME CARP G YINGER TA' -PAYER GARY G rINGER NAME/ADDR 1424 BALDUR PARK ROAD ' WAYZATA M11 55391 38 08-117-23 34 0025 PPOP ADOP OW`,LR NAME EDWARD H SPIFIDLER TAXPAYER ESTATE OF EDWARD SPINDLEP ^, NAME/ADDR C.'O LARK.IN, HOFFMAN. DALY 7c00 XERXES AVE S SUITE 1500 BLOOMI►IGTON MN 55431 r, 38 7-23 34 0059 PROP ADDR 01ti, ALOUR PARK RD CMIER NAME G A H POTH ` TAXPAYER GUENTHER R ROTH I NAME/ADOR 4603 ELLERDALE RD MIY'NETOHKA MN 55343 1 '- 38 08-117-23 43 0005 PROP ADOR 01440 BALDUR PARK, RD OWNER NAME GOPOON W TANVE TAXPAYER MR GOP.DON W TANYF NAME/AOOR 1440 BALDUR PARK RD WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0008 ^ PROP ADOR 03510 NORTH SHOPE DR OWNER NAME D i J SIKY.A TAXPAYER DALJIT i JASWINDEP SIYKA HAME.'ADDA 3510 NORTH SHPE DR WAYZATA MH 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0011 PPOP ADDR ^35i0 NORTH SHOPE OR OWNER NAME JAMLS R PETTIPIECE ETAL TAXPAYER JAMES R PETTIPIECE NAME/AOOR 3540 NORTH SHOPE DRIVE WAYZATA MN 55391 HENNEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INEOPMATION SYSTEM PROPLRIY OWNEPS LIST 38 08-117-23 34 0^14 01420 BALDUR PAPK RD It R WITIVEP A S K WITTMER WALTER P A SNARON K WITTMER 1420 BALDUR PAPY. RD WAYZATA 1114 55391 38 08-117-23 34 0028 PUBLIC ACCOUNTI►IG SERVICES ESTATE OF EDWARD S"INDLER C/O LAPYIN, HOFFMAN. DALY 7900 XERXES AVE S SUITE 1500 BLOOMINGTON M11 �P5431 38 08-I17-23 43 0003 01448 BALDUR PARK RD CORAL H LALIT'LNCE CORAL H LAWPEFtCE 5120 1ATH AVE SO MPLS MN 55,417 38 08-117-23 43 0006 01416 BALDUR PARK RD W t P NELSON WALLACE E NELSON 6.21 WASHBU2N AVE S MPLS M4 55423 38 08-117-23 43 0009 13520 NORTH SHOPE DR DAVID A SI►IGER DAVID A SINGER 3520 NORTH SHVVE OR WAYZATA MN 55391 19TAL BATCH 006 00016 REPORT NO. PI435401 Pa,E 1Z 38 08-117-23 34 0015 01416 BALOUt PAP, PO J C ULY U J C UFLU 240 RUSSELL A,F SO MPLS ►lt1 551405 38 08-117-23 34 0029 PUBLIC ACCOU►1TIHG SERVICES ESTATE OF EDWARD SPI►DLER C/0 LARKIN, HOFFMAN, DALY 7ti00 XERXES AVE S SUITE 1500 BLOOMINGTON MN 55431 38 08-117-23 43 0004 01.44 BALDUR PAFK RD J F UE POSIA ETAL J E OEPCSIA 1444 BALDUR PARK RD WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0007 01412 BALOUP PARK RD J G & M R NYQU'IST JCHN G I MAUREEN R NYQUIST 1432 BALDUR PARK RD WAYZATA M11 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0010 03530 NORTH SHOPE Do AJ ACYEPMAtk4 ETAL A J ACr EPMAN+{ 3530 NcPTH SHOPE DR WAYZATA MN 55391 RUN OAT[ 03/11/88 BATCH 006 HEINEPIN COUNTY PQOPFRTY INFOPMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY ONNEPS LIST PEPORT 140. PI435401 PALE 13 I CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTED ARE AN ACCUPATE AND TPUE PEPRESENTATION OE INFOPMATION AS IT APPEARS THIS DATE ON THE PECORDS OF THE HENNEPIN COLPITV DEPAR''ENT OF PROPERTY TAXATION TO THE BEST OF Mi vNOMLEDGE AND BELIEF. • OAT&14:+-+. BY� CITY OF ORONO NOTICE The Planning Commission will hold public hearings in the Council Chambers at 1275 South Brown Road on Monday, April 18, 1988, at 7:00 p.m. on the matter of reviewing the following land use applications: 1. #1255 Orville Fisher, 1991.Fagerness Point Road, seeks hardct -• er and lakeshore setback variances within the 0-75' setback area to allow various additions to the existing residence. 2. #1259 William C. Odden, 3450 North Shore Drive, seeks a hardcover variance in the 75' tn 250' setback area to allow construction of a three -car detached garage. 3. #1260 John Nyquist, 1432 Baldur Park (toad, seeks variances for side yard and street setback and a hardcover variance in the 75' to 250' set�ack area to allow construction of a two -car detached garage. 4. #12ul Joe and Sandy Rauschendorfer, 3895 Shoreline Drive, seek variances for side yard, street, and lakeshore setbacks, and hardcover variances in the 0-75' and 75'-250' setback area to allow replacement of basement and foundation walls, and construction of additions to the existing residence including an att-.ched two -car garage. 5. #1262 Curtis C. Hagfors, 1412 BP Idur Park Road, seeks variances for side setback and average lakeshore setback, and a hardcover variance in the 75' to 250' setback area to allow construction of additions to the existing residence. 6. #1263 JAmes Rivers, windward Marine, Inc., 1444 Shoreline Drive, seeks a conditional use pe*mit and variances for setbacks and hardcover required for the phased improvement of the marina property. 7. 01264 'om 6 Chris Smieja, 20 Cygnet Place, seek a lot area variance to allow construction of a single farily residence on a substAndard vacant lot. All persons wishinq to be heard will appear at this time. The meeting starts at 7:00 P.M. Written comments are solicited. Plans are available for review in the City offices, by appointment. By: Planninq Commission Michael P. Gaf ro , ast P anninq 6 7.oninq Administer rator To be published she week of April 4, 1988. CA Piro i -S - I C, - 117 —,? s i c UK I %j 4 IJ U :x ii L L AV' 14 1- L m:i i 14 L; s W,L 40 11061;NI 09/06/CC RETURN TO SENDER NO FORWARDING ORDER ON FILE. LINABL.E. TO FORWARD �ftr + CITY Of ORONO NOT tCf The rWMV;"CAPW"06lon a r-W Pwbac herags in we oard c hwnbw- at 12 76 9alh Brous %w an MonUay MH 16 19M. W 7 00 p m an it* nrsslal of review V " f0eawh0 *id me 21 SS orv�es ftelir, 1 � 1 f epaltigaa Ne11M Road memo ita►dravr grid lekedlog Mtaaeti w1ances wittw, to 0 76 s tbwh ores to Mow vwloirs sddlttorls to the o.airp r#rdallde 2 1 260 Waist" c 0~ 3450 Nor" SPWV Onve, sees a hrdoover verlrnde In the 76 to 260' eNbeos ova to AMar oorv"WitWn of a rtrNCar dewoeo 6w"pe 3 t 2W Jots Nyquiar. 14&e D&W ParU Road. seeks varrrloss to eras yard rid dike wMaice wd s hrdcovw vWW%0e in 110 76' to 260' s lbeck one to Now oorwrltclbn Of a 111W- oar aetgetr-some 4 1201 doe and wily RAM&W 00- 3996 316erodris Drive sees varurlose /r side yard. WSW rd W Wwry selbscss rW herd cover vartariose n We 0-76 grid 76 2W tail bees Yea M •e0hosnirir of 0gsarinWev founiftbor d oorrbwtion of Kklftu to eM anw.. noe ttictu*V an sttscA6d two -car crap A 1262 Ourm % mW ors 1412 9~ Pik now Mean vrierioM for am* setback rW evrwe errlwee argheok rW s trdwm Our ance in the 76 to 250 setback also to Mow ronetnrMan or *"acne to the eetat" rgedrx:e 6 + 263 jarrw Rivera wt,crrwd Atrtr» nc t 444 shorMne Drive seelu a Condiborir uee pa•*4r and vtllalw,ss 'a eetbedie OW rna/doarr it I& d tar Vw WWOMl rrytrovetriere of ft no ripe CPO"l 7 1204 'x. rx. :iw1s SWING0. 20 OOVW We gags a err alas rarsrice to Mow 7orirnrr to of a rip, tWV*f ree.onioe on a . 13~ dard veoril wr M preom wWWV to be "care itM Sama, N TAU tans ry woo" stem r 7 00 P m win t. coownents we W acned Piro Wo evalYtrla r r •e� me Cny offices by 64000,+me•,t 9y i. a..rruesion AAt:rigat P O,strat. Mel Plre1►ip A 2r" Adiriewelrg W 'Puns od in I've flier grid Plarneer A1,A 1666r _,_ Affidavit of Publication State of Minnesota. County of Hennepin / Bill Holm, being duly sworn on oath says that he is an authorized agent and Pmployee of the publisher of the newspaper known as THE LAKER. Mound. Min nesota and has full knowledge of the facts which are stated below A ) The newspaper has complied with all the require- ments constituting qualifications as a qualified newspaper as provided by Minnesota Statute 331 A 02. 331 A 07. and other applicable laws. as amended B ) The printed which is attached was cut from the columns ..,! sal f newspaper and was printed and published once each week for successive weeks It was first published Monday 1 I the G day of and was thereafter printed and published every Monday, to and including Monday the day of 19 Authorized Agent Subscribed and sworn o me on this 4 c>+ty of - ' 1. re HY � � • L ' A .Rt�R •anti r � � � t� lbh MAN OW04 t t t t '"4.1 Cleaait Ad tare Port Dy 00""W 40 uMr� ry conyla I" lWt.e 67 64 ;W1 ,ric" 1 kMairiivii •ate aittnr00 t)V i w 1,nr above -"Wtv N 54 err *w% S, Nara eC1WPV cnrpwil tar A@Ove A• !W $4 S4 PW f%k P% E ach A(%W, 1101e1 aria eea++e WOO& 63 [0 PW rw. ri CERTIFICATE OF MAILING STATE OF MINNESOTA ) COUNTY OF HENNEPIN CITY OF ORONO ) I, Jamie Bosma, of the City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota, do hereby certify that a Notice of Public Hearing concerning the matter of #1260, was mailed to the attached list of property owners . In Witness Whereof, I have hereunto Pet my hand and sea! this 4th day of April, 1988. Jam Bosma Y3, ) 1111V IILM 111h) OttR MICROFILMED •rtiflr"te c" .'urvev#487 "or John . N r ',I at, r` �A vd 1 ��NrMRlM "srt i� f•.^t �� I�, 1a 1 tr•:•• 9r"A InrrArf r'r_..•. ..r "«t' .. '. h turves. S..;T. ir:•: o' ,of 7, Oln«♦ 1, "wlAu^ •,.r�, .. rtr - t!- n� i •7t:t'.:r. .i 1-1r, a tr •.. r , It �^ t . mt. r ' .v..,tata ,,. ;,, n . ��,,,r.�.. fit« Suer*.Ovrp «me : • r 4-4 1c1 MICROFILMED # 87 I I 1 111, PLn-w t! m v ta P,ko 111. \f .1 1 1, t t. ri, mf !urv44 F-Al-lur Nr'e, Lt.N Ifir-s— tion of -til ex': tn C-1 I wAL* V,* ►I I I T I F O Al,VOTE 3 o N FMr►T10 TOTAL A, FF C-A • 16 si. S S • F pET ou I L-PA" �v-�A LMW40S ISO UX D ) siz3 S•F 3113 x . 2S 144 AS W Cw*o cari&) A►.t.4WA&a WS1444 4W%L • l o-7b S. F. florbSCo GAPNE * 1648 S-F 10TAL LoJOftf- : I l t4 5 F YAAI^t" 9EQuESIT EKkkPI v At"WAdUE AREA 6.4 11cils s.F. 0' TT R _I vy► 0 � z LLAi AAAMOFA[.ToF4 p 40; t2 3L'II.PINri AA S?A I IL W Alf �At Er. L D. HARDCOVER CALCULATION SUMQIARY A. B. C. D. E. F. Existing Final Lakeshore Existing Hardcover Proposed Hardcover Allowed Setback Lot Area Hardcover Percentage Hardcover Percentage Hardcover Zone In Zone In Lone (B/A)x100 In Zone (D/A)x100 Percentage ----------- ---------- ---------- ----------- ---------- ----------- --------------- 0-75' of 3�{+l4 a ��.� i t 1 '��- "of �' `� • 0 t 75-250' of �'1�� of ��� ,j • \�\1 a `� �\ t 25 t 250-500' _ if of • of t 30 t 500-1000' i tf of t of • 35 t HARDCOVER LIMITATIONS c P* r L, \\ 3Q 1, ROAD S. OTH".R LAKESHORE REGULATIONS HARDCOVER INCLUDES: - Structures with roofs - Decks, even if slatted - Sidewalks - Driveways (paved or gravel) - Decorative landscaping areas underlain by plastic sheeting - Tops of retaining walls, rock walls - Any other surface that does not allow direct absorption of rainfall into the ground SEC. 10.22, REGULATIONS FOR 'LR-IA', 'LR-IA-I*, 'LR-1B', •LR-IC* AND 'LR-IC-1. OWN FAMILT LARRSBORE RRSIDRRTIAL DISTRICT. Within any "LR-IA", LR-IA-1', "LR-18', "LA -IC, or "LR-IC-l" One Family Lakeshore Residential District the following regulations shall apply: Subd. 1. Lakeshore Set Back Regulations. The set back from the shoreline for lakeshore lots shall be at least 75 feet and no bu4lding ray be located closer to the shoreline than the average distance from the shoreline of existing residence buildings on adjacent and nearby lots. Subd. 2. Lakeshore Hard Cover Regulations. Within 75 feet of shoreline there shall be no excavating, filling, hard cover, temporary or permanent structures. Within 75 to 250 feet of the %horeline there shall be no greater than 15t hard cover. Within 250 to 500 feet of th,- shoreline there shal I be no greater •han 309 herd cover. Within 500 to 1,000 feet of the shoreline there shall be no greater th.. St hard cover. Sub,l. 1. Tree Removal Regulations. No trees within 71, feet of the shoreli is with the diameter of six (6) inches or more shall be removed without first obtaining a per^-'t from the Council. HARDCOVER RlD O( ATIOWS AM WORKSHEBT A A. HARDCOVER ORDINANCE - In 1975, the Orono City Council adopted an ordinance limiting the percentage of lot area that can be covered with impervious surfaces ("hardcover*) such as roofs, driveways, sidewalks, etc, on properties located wi'.hin 1,000 feet of a lake. Studies have shown that sediments, oils, and debris carried into the lake from highly urbanized areas have a detrimental impact on the quality of water in the lake. The intent of Orono's ordinance is to ensure that rainfall run-off will be cleansed by filtering through grassed or vegetated yard areas before entering the lake. B. HARDCOVER SETBACK ZONES - PERCENTAGE ALLOWED I. 0-751: in the area within 75' of the lakeshore, No Hardcover is allowed (01). -- -- II. 75-250': in the portion of the lot located between 75' and 250' from the lake, 250 of that portion of the lot may be hardcovered. III. 250-5001t in the portion of the lot located between 250' and 500, feet from the lake 300 of that portion of the lot may be hardcovered. IV. S00-1,000': in the potion of the lot located between 500' and 1,000' feet from the lake 351 of that po tion of the lot may be hardcovered. NOTE: These regulations apply even if you have a lot that does not abut the lake but is within a lakeshore zoning district. C. ROW TO DETERMINE LOT AREA WITHIN EACH SETBACK ZONE (To be used as denominator in all hardcover percentage calculatioc:s) I. 0-75' Zone Area - 75' x Average width of lot in 0-75' zone measure parallel to shoreline 75' x ft. Zi r(/ (Avg width) Area of 0-75' zone II. 75-250' Zone Area - (175'or avg lot depth in zone) x(Avg width of lot in 75-250' zone) `` measure parallel to shoreline 17 5 ' x _ � 1. f t . W "�,x 6("F. s.f. (2) (Avg width) Area of 75-250' zone III. 250-500' Zone Area - (250' or avq lot depth in zone) x(Avg width of lot in 250-500' zone`, measure parallel to shoreline 250' x ft. - s.f. (3) (Avg width) Area of 250-500' zone IV. 500-1,000' Zene Area or avg lot depth in zone) x/Avg width of lot in 500-IC00' zonel (\ Measure parallel to shoreline SOO, x ft. _ s.f. i 41 (Avg width) Area of 500-1,000' zone HARDCOVER CALCULATION WORKSHEET Setback Zones (circle one) 0-751 7 r-25 250-5001 500-10009 Seistine 1ardcover in Zone a. Neuse x 1't O� i�"^�5�, . a. t . length width x s.f. x e.t. x s.t. Z'Z �� C1 �` b. Garage �, x • • . t . 2s' L c. Driveway x !�." • - .. [. • e.f. d. y sidewalk ��3 x �J • J I s.f. x • B.f. t x • s.f. e. Patio/ �_ x �� X �) s.f. Deck x • e.f. f. Landscape x 3 uAO- • 3 s.t. areas underlain x • e.f. by plastic sheeting x • , s.f. . x s.t. f . Other x • 9.f. x s.f. Existing Hardcover t • Total Existing Hardcover x 100 Lot Area Within Zone • x100 Additional Hardcover to be added in stones Itea Length x Width • TOTAL s.f. �-_ — x �S s e.t. Is x x . s.f. TOTAL B.P. TO OR ADDED l 31 (2 ) Existing Hardcover to be Removed, it anys It" Length x Width TOTAL a.f. vU-LU., -I Z x �. ', le s.f. ' x x TOTAL B.P. TO at REMOVED �� �� 131 Final Hardcover Proposals (Lino (1) • Line (2) -Line (3)) Existing To be Added To be Removed Final Proposed Hardcover % - Is a e.f. a.f. TOTAL ERIfTIMG HARDCOVER IN ZONE 0777 1s.t. (1) Line{ x 100 � Line tll s.f. -t � a . w � x100 • �.��• l HARDCOVER CALCULATION WORKSHEET Setback zones (circle on 50' 250-500' 500-1000' Existine Hardcover in zone a. House x 1Fi 1 s.t. length width X s.[. x • s.[. X s.l. x • s.f. Is. t� Garage J x �. �. . t 1� s.t. c. Driveway Z 5 x ` i (1 r s.t. x • s.f. d. sidew&110^ Z.tc x y). 1co s,f. -�-x 3 x • s.t. •. Patio/lK• 2lo x "21�14 s.t. Dock S1 to i k�_ •; _ X 9.f. t. Landscspeb,glS, ► x • �L �` s.t. areas und•slain 'tti x • �- s.f. by plastic shooting x • s.t. x s.f. ' t. Other x . s.f. x s.t. x ` s.f. TOTAL EXISTING HARDCOVER IN EONS - •'1y "1 a.f. (1) Existing Hardcover Total Existing Hardcover x too Lot Area Within Zone x 100 - s`I I Additional Hardcover to be added in Boner Item Length x Width • TOTAL s.t. x _ �-� - �yU s.t. r7 x x s.t. TOTAL S.P. TO BE ADDED (Y) Existing Hardcover to be Removed, if anyi Item Length x Width • TOTAL s.t. x s.f. �..+tCL •..' J x \J x a `1 •.t. TOTAL S.P. To BE REMOVED �'� (3) Final Hardcover Proposals (Line (1) ♦ Line (2) -Line (3)) - Existing To be Added To be Removed Fin Proposed Hardcover • - Line (41 xtoo - �L � sot• :100• �•L�z Line (1) _t*46 • f . z o ,7s7'p 011 w.w�y Lot I N F o F M it t I. rl 4- = Tot�►L � �1► � 3 s s.F AL't�FNktE # 3 w+�.�v _ I�t ,� sus N�► a y .- s+uR � �i�i3 s • F ' g „ As w lwW trwa) �Ib�bsto �d►I�it • 646 t • f %fAL, WWP*L = llt* Sf YAPlotb 9 ftm PI & AI�aWAii� 4R�A 614 1' sIs s.F, �-y �� T •! y i�) momiiioiimimmi Now J •zf y � � wklrwy . Let 1 N F e F IAA A 'T 1• �- � AI,�FhIk1E �3 wIL-Pjr 'fro. cri,LE' i��. z�� 371; rt .2S ! �S.ts sF ����� f7'•� �IM+� Lod*) srstIt s. F. rooftev S. Tdrg. CaWftg s 17 u Sf d H VOW" FEr4uts't � N UcPA Po*p MA&WAIKL AUA $1 1 1 S.Is S.F. 75*- Z50 I Ar f2e a re I jl LM w' "r'y Let 1 N • F N► A t • rl lbTAL- AoltmkTb Ulu c+ 2 O-W f t 307m zY. HA �1Ew�1�i1►'�• s gust �� No�tt • � o�� s. F. • i� s.t -c �Mt•�s� By YW)o c K� s �, s.F o K To R c . moo M.w^.,L AW w 44 11SIs S.F. U l', . of "ICON U .l Ulf L# It.) IL 66oCry►t d Ho). %Isnnr.,AA 5..%j t►%Iunrrip.,l Olfic•► Tr Itohonl 4737451 Mr. John Nyquist 1432 Baldur Park Road 'aayza to , Minnesota 55391 ",OTICE OF CITY COUNCIL ACTION Control No. 487 XX variance Conditional Use Permit Subdivision, Prelim. Subdivision, Final Date of Notice r7'f2_79 Date of Meeting: __ July 10. 1979 Votes: 3 For __Against Abstention Is Action: __ Approval: As submitted subject to applicable ordinance requirements X Approval: Subject to conditions noted Deferral: Pending receipt of information noted _ Referral: Review by others, as noted Denial: For reasons noted NO':'ES i SPECIAL CvNDITIONS: Council approved hardcover variaaca far — construction of addition per plans subject to the condition rec by the Planning Commission that new steps from dining area not encroach _ any closer than 43 feet from shoreline. Deadlines:&— Variance approval expires one year after the meeting date. Contact building inspector for required persits. Conditional Use Approva. Must be renewed annually. Expires on _ Must be renewed upon change in ownership or use. Preliminary Subdivision approval expires after one year of meeting date. Contact Zoning Administration for final plat requirements. Final Subdivision approval expires 6 months after meeting -date. Contact Zoning Administration for filing requirements and document approval. Deferred items may be declared formally withdrawn if applicant fails to provide information within one month of meeting date, or by date specified by Council. if you desire certified copies of the official City Council Minutes, they are available from the De pity City Clerk upon review and approval by the Council CITY OF OkONO U1ND USE PLANNING ZONING VARIANCE INVENTORY VARIANCES RVOU1 RED DENSITY- �... J11. 2t o 1 to.:L?_ ��3 - po EXHIBIT ii Zoning Use District SETBACKS C991JuCum j Y S / I *._a2� �41 H /a. 41 _ . _ _ 11 RPJ _11so u 101 L%G ►tOtldOi MAL lOf 1111ii MA1 UVU MA MOV011 MM/[OIIR� lttalArrO RAKDCOVER r•i •.j_ _ _ W.._ �.t.____1 aJ. _.iW - y s core>ue _ Olt 16 Ft. u AL —lei 314. no W• lfo - Soo It. MRS _ ----- lr.s f00 - 1000 ►t. 1fS -_ _.— _-�_. - OTHER SECTIONS•go tt111101rs dt oa�it� LA ND Cl. al lli rl.a ,,- 6" r .1 .taco • l01• t.••••1• /../ •Ml!•otls _L _— •.•1✓.ailTn� •a J•. eat lots/r,err.ls 1. 1 r .•. owt ✓1ra. qle• •tort wws.sM1• �••00•et0 t.e•er N/M Jswrery !, 191% 0►wlst tlll� _ + t/w01• s•rOrN• _. awl/wp• r/aM otAM partake tot /0 41b!• 0»lltsll� rt»tasarrr iwttroes, me_ ►ONeamwe arotloo" _-_ Mob 0.e•111/ _ 1eg1 poaol0 wllY+ ►t►•0 _ 0100v 01erwe of*^ Op.M -� 11ummebtr• ••0N IdQ,Ae•Ur •/lefttwo •l.. 4 . .� tMtti01 bO/ it OM0 _ .� vwr •.01 trll•ime late%bm lot .►t0/MorO, _ .N.�14 ___ 06r 010.oeom rit& rrlrntsItr�o 0s.s ►opown scCW. _ wo. .al.a." aw0 •1o,•6oV - w 010rwtr/stets __ pl.•t• Vr L►lr100, City •.rer 0rotipe/0 _� •0 •tMM0to0, city ouw owt�0Aw.rwta0 •• ., o, ease _ ram VvG'W..o _ •slot MO towfom"m NNO:/,� OrMeNd"d I.AND USE few).•% lot I• _ ."a" VoL 0•agtt0 talll0o. LAm r►t •twro•w• r tow►w, rM o/otlt•t+ z04111'e—fisO 1y _�_ •tlW0 0 -_r �. � +o •r.+.•.a •!I.r•• r11w•10e1 - ..•.•sMy twil•two r see • .. • Iw- K t a .ra0 • r waN .�00 Ott1. oMMYiO •le/ I.rtlew•• Ma0M0` .1 ,•.•.. ,o• ._. _.�._ ...__. _.ter.___.._. _.. -.. 1 r. ra.• r,It •.•u^I.•11�I tw•I Nts� o. .•. •... or •• tltt/ tart lltw• .r •.• West werot "a I•!•1 r1 ay tie 1 •a .I • • . • • . tows 1000 ti0•a 00t► •Ir11 1 . . . t..1 1 • , .t r .. • rLltpa� +r�rAle W I t • . - J ..�, .•11 �•1 eea.•. .. .. $boo 0411e00o01ha•o repo •tm0e ►o. CITY OF OAONU LAlt.tD l% UATE TIDE INSPECTION NOTICE ��- v PERMIT NO. _ _ _ CUMPIt Tt U ADDRESS J� � PAt.%. 2A OWNER _. _ _. CONTA.. TELEPHONE NO.- 0(JOY I%c :. PIUMblhr,041 SITE Ih3PtCT1Uh : �NA'.tt►.l, 464ECHANICA1 EJ►CAV E,NAJIhC,fIlClttVG INLULAT 1W. t►IAT( H ai,►jp UP ► 141tE54uMt wt TLAhOS .+ *All bU VE TEN SET TVNh U% t ,IEhS►%c (, iMAL .twEH14(A)KUP Ltj%WLAl%T /ao'.,NtS,. :APT►_ 4%:IALI FUltDou► .� Ot VOl 5t P1 ►i_ MA►•„ t St PT it f ►%AL { IRE Pk( ` wE It 'E '► �,MH COMMENTS. _ r .� ►�- ' - ��� .,A,� Ls1.,�... � /�h G tat Cx _ _ t� -�-s•-4_1 �.1'' � •'i1 ___ _. t. _ __ . -- --L� / ,ter- � ►'�. � � w �`�_ A11JNr ;'.TI;► •c IUwv ►Nu(ttu ' rNUTu VAX&% ,-ohN( t t ArUMK A P64Uc.t E O ,041.l(1 *004a (,A.. 1 va.'tI%ii tL1whrt1NNt CUVtasta" 'N{':► ►)%jA1 t Co%OlT►u'j w11N1% MckAll $%lif6Too WKL NtINM'M .lutNPtjyTtU CALL t%s tcTQN .jPt C►K.0h wl+iu4NE v CAl► TU A44I1IAh(d •Cttlb LAII Iu1 the nest tnfpomon 21 hours 1n gdvaAM. Ownw rCun1r on site In&p4Ktu► -- - a*7w e. , , .. ..,. 6 ' CITY of ORONO N,..1 Offin Hon bb•C.yw1 Bay. mansome" 66= 0"asreasl oKlow On 011' Nurth Shure u/ Lake Minnetonka June 21, 1982 John Nyq ui s t 1432 Baldur Park Road Wayzata, MN 55391 Dear Mr. Nyquist: On a routine inspection of a property at Baldur Park Road, staff noted the brick patio constructed in your lakesbore jard. This improvement is in cOmplets violation of your variance application f487 approved by Council on July 10, 1979. Please contact my office at your earliest convenience to discuss this matter. Sincerely, ')4V%'1 G. ft Jeanne A. Mabusth Zoning Administrator DLILD#h(, A IU%Ih(, �T}1))T • \U111hy1�ATNlM • ilhAtrC! - �T}T • IKIsLX V _ �T)T>I6� A"* ►alhA, Ck, August 19, 1982 Joh.: Nyquist 1432 Baldur Park Road Wayzata, MN 55391 Dear Mr. Nyquist: CITY of URONO h,st office 11.,a bbeCryetal Hay. MinaawN 5&1*1eYwtnM1 Offset* On the Nurfh Shure o/ Lake Minnetonka Z apologize for the delay in responding as promised at the site inspection on July 29, 1982. At that inspection we discussed alternatives available to you that would correct the outstanding violations on your lakeshore property. We advised that the railroad tie portion of the structure could remain but that the brick portion of the patio must be removed and replaced with pervious, crushed rock over the existing sand bed. You may wish to intersperse larger, flat limestone rock within the crushed rock area. Please call my office if you have any questions concerning the above. Sincerely, Jeanne A. Mabusth 4 Zoning Administrator JAM/ps fatDIM,a4717157 0 AIMMISIt1A11U%A11!rA'Kf 47i1I14 0 ►nsLIC"to -4711Ino i Z3xz : y� E LY7 - IT Ao I �L 5 c.. -�. '-7 yv AS ' vA,c K --ew c 40 . .� .._- .... .......................--`. 571 f otj ��ft�►-�1c .� goo; ,�9 b L y wo &wool 6- S <-Lj rv� q.3 D t: 4 r .L RN i;�,�' =ors �"• �,� �"wr,o � -INN I1,E'v �S cfl Pr°p,;5.::� t _ -r-D7k - ���oPo��t> G 53. 8 yo w+�wy �01 dWM _ . TOT eCfLF- I,,_2D. A?eLIcA tirs QM(sINl1L- F"PorkLm- Rai Ll C)--73-'= y2 . (. %. • - i — W— r. r- • • — • � :� momm"-ft am A F OF► • ib 3'1.0 S • F LWO C" WS1INi tuffs ao IOTA1. G` YMI Io�� S.F• kid s. f iLlt4 S.F m' d TT a 'x 116. 3;/a o -7 S' • y2 OVAS46 t � 1 :wMA, I,o 1N�oFr1AT�er1 Toll F EA► • '16 . S S.F 1 s S F < r� t V .2 %& AS SF �wW tovi�) /►►�c�wl►sbs E�CI SMAJ G� e�ust N� • o,� S. f. HAPOCOVER ���o s.f i IOTAl, of IK.tt• 7 t4 S F d TT REV �SF� VAN mquevr AZAPIA& AI"WAt AREA 6y 11SIS F. G 7S- ZSOI sNo 6R�rrre � _75 � = 37.2 Vcp 1fIAN E1c�sri�u c, (yo.9 •.� 1 l.) 7ell • • • �� • i • •ice . � � �� I� r WA44NAl 7 Wr INFOFMATleV4 _ Aolf TOTAL. 0% F *At • '1b 37. S S . F 3 .2s s 148 As w aw13's COW AL4AW"L& 4F C , KCCDkV4FA)j> -- 6Mt I W4 PaLX L . , S.F. roobt6o fd►Fina * 646 s • t ka"Otj Oelm TV -Tvr#4L CA16FO*L I _ •tto' 14.C. IW• CALC . VARIAO" F ,Es1 E&U PIAv AL"WA" AREA 6.4 11sIs S.F. OP"1/E f ff*b O IDEA t N"I ff 3.s Yo 7s-Yy2so'='l y Np0AsE D-7S I +37.2 Woos May w+�-rwy �,0'i 111 • Ir► A e _I % 9.9 AffoLj C.Atu'T S wsT l"` mrosto �Evj,sewo J)topostrL -TorAt. VOI (1SH5ED oN lXWseu 7r- a rce 04.c - CAA-C) Iff "a AS sF �u�wna� • I o�� s. F. W,�. I�Z4 S.F PIWP AI"W a AREA 6y 1Z5.1S F. Z Cr►N+t�R Sfts�c.�� _ MCI PUIWA" 3IIIt3 S•F �CWW (o+Via) = 14i ,.ZS sG ?.7eMrj*L AUVrL REPWFIA" v lv� Mto Iold S.F. O 100 S.4 • LI MBE i 1 beo*A*LJc ?,4 a K N o- r!o'bsCO fd►�►ii, T b4a S• F i ® Rff ycv W itst, To t' x s:' 'Facia, C #W WaL =11 14 s.F O /D y . N � „�y/.9 � IT s �. ft�pwcn• S ZS - ` - I! I i _ I y A IO.f ►i V - - L ZV r-- --- -- I/ �y 1: u f u f i cl 3 O / � r \( :fARDCOVER CALCULATION WoRESHE•'ET R 1 Set_a:k 2cne: (circle ono) C-'So 75-250' 250-500' �-ICCO' E<ist'nT Hardeove- in tcne a. Hcuse !ength width -- x - s.l. x s.f. b. Garage X .�, C. Driveway x s.f. x s.f. d. sidewalk 1 X_ X e.f. X • s.f. e. Patio/ x �-• • s.l. Deck _ _ X • a . f . f. Landscape X • 1 ? s.f. areas underlain X . s.f. by plastic sheeting x • f, other -- X a s.f. - X a e..f. J x • _ s.f. \ s v/ TOTAL 9X1STIyG HARDCOVER IN 20N9 Existing Hardcover . Total ? 1� iar,__•.e. ' Lot Area Within :Qne v r. x ICO . [/ kdditionaI Hardcover to to added in =ore: T t em Lennth x Width . .: x s.f. TOTAL S.F. TO BE ADDED f21 Lxistinq Hardcover to be Removed, if any: Item Length x width � — TAL s.f. x . � i x • - s.f x !. f s.f. TOTAL S.r. TO OR REMOM (3) Final HstdcoverFinal Pr2M"l: JU " fll • Line (2) -Line Existing' /���s•f• ':i To be Added To be Removed Final t'roposed Mardcover I ine 141 x ICO 4 `a�' '.f 4 �� "P (1) _- 3.f x '_L_ t s'NMM�7 /q32 ew► Du.� Ft •, a� kARflcn'1 �'�� � 0 0 0 0 Oc G 7 Mi't /«'--ifS Posc l� 1 [a ; Hous E w , wets rACM w wy Lot 1NtF0E- AAII&P4 dam ja DAL � rat ��► s� S•F LWW cavity) AuftwntIU A?eLl CANT S WsTJN& DIU GIN A L Mew to-TorAt. CAW �.�► 13J6y S•F ►'°�'t �749 S.F. baa s.F A6E = 1 t4 S.f L' TT EQilES'f A1�WA AREA ff 1/t., 0 O D --7 1/ V. (. (gelotscl> W.,qo.gyp Pig sgAartlft I I t T �416 Al Mai 114 F o F N► I► 7 to 14 Tier^ AFC-/► • 16 . S S.F Cwo+ ta►�s) 6 xis HAS coup ' aTAL GF �2EV1SFfl Yet f' �e "e As sF • 1014D S.F. "a S.F Z4 S.F r -V rwwpvr%l 6y 115IS MLEA F. 0IT -745--2,SO I s No 60"A "AN EXfsrac.(y .9:) CA 37 z Vcp i way ... - T Lomr I N F o F A A Y I o r4 TOTAL s.F LMw0S 1t' sF.t 64 s1i3 S•F Iu4AWAS4 fO 001I44 Note ; Iola s.F rftftego �►FKE 64+b oN (rojop. To TorrAL CNOW-E _ 110 Sf 7 t 'Lr0 % N C• 9C' CALC • WIN" fEQUES"[ (o[,tvirk� Au&wAikL AREA by 11SIs S.F. �i 0n '"way LOT 114FaFMAor1 � Ai,��k1E �'3 1oTA1. F��► � � . s s-r- 1 i3 s•F �10*o cov") Au ►A& .E F,x1St INi. Nod • 101d S. F• PPy CAcN'f S rbrosep , �a s.F �S focoeorAL OrarAL Fw& 17t4 S.f gASE� ON C AWS NO V41 fEQu - p�v AW AREA 7t• itStb' H_C • CAI- ��v I�11SIS F. OE WA�,FMWI r12' IL M A t i 0 - � Oe r►k+tSU I LPJA " br�cPFfiA C slis s.F 3l1 s IlL . zs 14d .zs SF Pareuvrim. AbvrRemo MuCMS+ row) �,u.a ASLS © l00 SA. LAKE t 1 DEw�/F+ K " t20� P,X1StINi No�iG rftmsto "Fina * � �o�S.F. 44a S • F ® REDwtE +�j'jtS2.* TO Z%x S2' iGfOTAt, t#p*� = 1�Z4 ST • ill.'' IDY s;. REowcn•N .zV ww taw w� * Aotsme; *%-� �OA�s \ 0 n -�-1 1�12 = -?P-3 � z _ r pro sue( l3Zd � t I —1— 'LAIr INF•FMAdrIaA . dl� • dmmmmmmm� aw� s S"s S.iF le" i i 'IL %*&) s N&046 . AP sF �a�aLa IM1104 ftXL • ion. -a-F. ef6 tto GAF*4& * Ir44 s. f -WA. cowo" S.F -31 13 ti �o"� �•wAw� Ate► HARDCOVER Cr1LCi;I,A"1'ION WUI2KSii1 i:T 10�� _ O Setback Zone: (circle ono) C-'5' 75-250' 150-500' 5eJ-IC00' Lxisting Hardcover i Total Existinv Yard' -Over Existin3 Hardcover in ^one 5�.. C-QXGu�La��u•�o Lot Arca 6ithin zone f x a. House x • s.f. �.f. 100 R length widthVor,;, (.0_xN S,//��_. `�1, a.f. x - 8 x s.f. x s.f. b. Garage_ x -2.Z - �a�. s.f. c. Driveway Z� x ,720 . _�_ a. f. x _ ` s.[. d. Sidewalk �• L x -3 0 - l s.f. x W . x - s.f. a. ratio/ _� x LA Deck f. Landscape x • s.f. areas underlain x . s,f, by plastic sheeting x s.f. f. Other x x ----- s.f. TO'PAL EXISTING HARDCOVER IN ZCNL - s.f. (1) Additional Hardcover to tr aer+fd in zone: Item Length x width TO".'AL s.f. ---�_ x Lj x o s.f. TOTAL S.F. TO BE ADDED 14 (;% (2) Existing Hardcover to be Removed, if any, _Length x Width - TOTAL S.f. ZZ x 13gto s.f. Z S x Z% . 4 s.!. _ x _ - �� s.f. x - �� s.f. QTOTAL S.F. TO BE REMOVED 1-UPS; (3) Final Hardcover Proposal: (Line (1) ♦ Line (2) -Line (3)1 Existing To be Added To be Removed Final Proposed Hardcover 0 Line (4) x 100 - S.f' x 1C0 Line 41) s.f. I .. _ 1 ��� � . . ter, • � •ter. �+ �� Al zzt l - f 7? J 77 {.Olt 1N�oFMATto14 �� f �q -. • i • Ufa • ! • i • t•� G _Tod AF&P► • 1*37. S s•Fur J.cPos�O � �►��'1� �3 I�t rum ia•i � r � = »t3 S.F : 2. 01 3'f 13 . =s : 14a .IS w two &&VOW) omit" "MAIL • low. S.F. rooftop m" Vrp . lal�fl�f.E s 11L4 S•F d - %MFErQ O,! &MPWA& M"WANL AM " 11SIS S.F. .r 17 06 . y 4- ll t 6 4 $`% a , ton bo Q, PCB AX.3/: ti) + I /i \� l9 jacent props y ers' Acknowledgement Fora D I (we of /C FFFint. namatoil JpTint address) have reviewed the plans for the proposed improvement or proposed use of the property located at CJamk- also referred to as Land Use Application No. I (we) understand that in executing this acknowledgement, I (we) am (are) not asked to declare approval or disapproval of the property or use but merely to confirm for the City Council that I (we) am (are) aware of the improvement plans and that the proposed neighbor's project or use requires Council approval. Property Owner Date If you have any information that may assist the City in the review of this Land Use Application, please submit your comments to the Building Zoning Office at least 10 days prior to the scheduled meeting date. 1— : q*�1 Adjacent Property Anvers' Acknowledgement Form I (we) F of (,J ? 1 1►.�u��.ir�•,.rw �.�. S' [print name s Tprint address have reviewed the plans for the proposed improvement or proposed use of the property located at �L\"3(e ��A ,r (� also referzed to as Land Use Application No. I (we) understand that in executing this acknowl< ..t, I (we) am (are) not asked to declare approval or disapproval of the property or use but merely to confirm for the City Council that I (we) am (are) aware of tre improvement plans and that the proposed neighbor's project or use requires Council approval. Property Owner Date Property Owner Date If you have any information that may assist the City in the review of this Land Use Application, please submit your comments to the Building & Zoning Office at least 10 days prior to the scheduled meeting date. Tot Proms: Date: Planning Commission Michael P. Gaffron, Assistant Zoning Administrator April - 3, 1988 Subject: 11260 John Nyquist, 1432 Haldur Park Road - Variance - Public Hearing Zoning District: LR-lC, Sewered Lakeshore, Half Acre Minimum. Application: Side setback, street setback, and hardcover variances to allow construction of a detached garage. List of B:hibits: A.) Application S.) Plat Maps C.) Property owners List D.) Neighbor Acknowledgement forms E.) Survey F.) Site Plan G.) Garage Plans H.) Applicants Hardcover Calculations I.) Staff Hardcover Calculations n S,) Dt.�urpn�n�:� ,-C -- n�orovo.�s Pertinent Pacts 1. Lot area/width, hardcover, lakeshore setback variances granted in 1979 for room additions. Those variances allowed 636.4 square feet hardcover in the 0-75' zone (17.0%) and 962 square feet in the 75-250' zone (25.48), or a total of 1,598.4 square feet total on the property, where only 948.25 square feet would normally be allowed. Staff calcuations of todays existing and proposed hardcover are as follows: Existing Proposed 0-75' Zone: 1,512 s.f. (42.6%) No Change 75-250' Zone: 1,670 s.f. (40.9%) 2,199 s.f. (53.8%) Net Increase: 529 s.f. Total Existing: 3,182 s.f. (41.7% of entire lot) Total Proposed: 3,711 s.f. (48.6% of entire lot) 2. Garage Side Setback: Required 10' Existing 2.0' Proposed 5' Garage to Street Setback: Required 30' Existing 3.8' Proposed 20' 3. Traffic on the street is minimal. There is adaquate site distance both directions for vehicles to safely back out. The 20' setback with recessed door area will allow for adaquate space to park guest cars on the property. Zoning File 1126C Page 2 Discussion This property is classic example of creeping hardcover syndrome. While there is no question that the lot is very small for a lakeshore lot (0.175 acres), the additions that have occurred over the years and which are currently proposed result in an overall hardcover on the property of nearly 50%, with more than 50% of the 0-75' zone already in hardcover. Staff would note for the record, that the variances granted in 1979 reflected a less rigorous method of hardcover calculation in use at that time, hence the percentages of hardcover allowed in 1979 should not be compared directly with the existing and proposed percentages. However, there have been additions of structure and hard surface in the 0-75' zone that were certainly not anticipated by the Council in 1979, including a raised patio using tie -walls and a sand -base brick system, as well as landscape areas underlain by plastic sheeting. The brick sidewalk leading from the patio to the lakeshore also was never mentioned in any of the previous approvals. I would note *mat in 1982, the applicant, without approval, constructed the currently e) ting patio, with after -the -fact direction from staff as to how it would nave to be reconstructed in order to •emain. This occurred prior to the current policy under which staff has limited authority for dealing with hardcover, and prior to the more strictly detailed determinations as to what is and what isn't hardcover. Although as of this writing, Zoning Administrator, Jeanne Mabusth is not available to confirm whether the current patio area and sidewalk meets the standards she set forth in 1982, for purposes of this review, staff has considered that the patio, sidewalk and plastic underlain areas are definitely existinq hardcover. Regarding the variances currently requested, the applicant proposes to construct a two car garage with storage both to the side and above, with total floor spare less than 1000 square feet. This proposed garage will replace an existing garage located 2' f-om the side lot line and 3.8' from the street. The new garage is proposed to be located 5' from the side lot line with doors facing the street and being approximately 20, from the street lot line, leaving approximately 22' to 24' of parking depth adjacent to Baldur Park Road. Because the houses in this neighborhood do not have basements due to the low elevation, it is reasonable to ask for the garage, plus excess storage space. It is also reasonable to locate that garage facinq the street so that parking area +r made available while using the least amount of hardcover. Site distance and traffic flow on Baldur Park Road are such that we would not anticipate any problems caused by this proposed configuration. ?oning File #1260 .jage 3 Regarding the side setback for the garage, staff does not see an obvious hardship to allow less than a 10' side setback, the only rationale for the request being that it leaves a larger area of lawn to the ripen side of the garage. Staff would question the need for the extensive woos pallet walkways proposed and suggests that a narrow walkway would suff'_-e. Staff Recom er-Oation Given the nei-I for storage space and vehicle enclosure, the proposal to construct a two car garage with storage and a driveway apron would appear reasonable, however the extent of the driveway apron should be reduced to maximum width of 20' in order to conserve hardcover. The wr,�,,a pa 1 tet walkway should be reduced to as narrow a sidewalk as is tunctional. All of the landscape areas ,nd—lain by plastic should have plastic rAmov. and be reverted back to vLasn area. Planning Commission may wise to consider whether it is appropriate for applicant to keep the patio ,nd lakeshore sidewalk as they exist, taking into consideration the intent of the City Council in 1979 and the intent and substance of what was approve-i by Jeanne in 1982. Presumirg that the plastic areas are removed, the sidewalk is cut down to a minimal 2' width, and the driveway is cut down to a minimal 20' width, the resultant hardcover is 1,320 square feet or 37.2t in the 0-75' zone, and will be reduced by approximately 450 square feet in the 75-2501 zone for a final 75-250' hardcover of 1,749 square feet or 42.8%. %3Z0� 17N� �t19 `,� of 4f. !-� MINUTES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING HELD APRIL 16, 1988 i1259 WILLIAM C. ODDEN 3450 NORTH SHORE DRIVE VARIANCE PUBLIC HEARING 7:50-7:52 William Odden was present fr): this matter. The Affidavit of Publication and Certificate of Mailing were noted. Gaffron explained the request for hardcover variance to construct a three stall detached garage. He noted that in 1977, the City Council appL ,ved the proposed garage and-;J1:itie ,s subject co the driveway being gravel, w�,.ich t that time was not considered hardcover. A vo ianc is required due to the extreme length of driveway hardcover in order to serve the proposed garage. There were no comments from the public regarding this matter and the public hearing was closed. It was moved by Cohen, seconded by Johnson, to recommend -i;Nproval p r staff recommendation including the condition that no additional future hardcover be approved for this property. Motion, Ayes 5, Nays 0. #1260 JOHN NYQUIST Y432 BALDUR PARK ROAD VARIANCE PUBLIC HEARING 7:53-8:09 The Affidavit of Publication and Certificate of Mailing were noted. Gaffron explained request to tsdr dowr.an existing detached 'e a onstruct a new detached garage requirin: ^es _ follows: Hard. 0-75' No change 75-250' Existing 4J.91 Proposed 53.8% Side Setback - Regvired 10' Existing 2' (existing garage) Proposed 5' (pro.—sed garage' Street Set hark - Required 30' Existing 3.8' (existing garo ve) Proposed 20' tproposed garay-) Gaffron noted that in 1982, the applicant, wi0 out approval, constructed the currently existing patio, % th after -the -fact direction from staf' )is to how it would have to be reconstructed in order t. -ain. 4 MINUTES OF THE PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING HELD APRIL 18, 1988 i1260 NYQUIST CONTINUED John Nyquist was present for this matter and stated he has owned the property for 11 years including during the period in 1979 when variances were granted for other changes *o the Droperty. Chairman Kelley questioned what has occurred on the property since that time. Gaffron reviewed the changes made on the property since that time, noting that the variance granted in 1979 reflected a less rigorous method of hardcover calculation in use at that time. Staff recommendation for this application, per memo, is that the plastic under the landscaping areas be removed, the sidewalk be cut down to a 2' width, and driveway cut down to 20' width resulting in a final 75-250' hardcover of 42.8%. in addition, staff dues not see an obvious hardship to allow less than a 10' side setback for the garage. Mr. Nyquist stated he is agreeable to staff's recommendation except to maintain the 10' setback. He noted that many of the neighboring properties have a garage setback comparable to the proposed 5' setback. He also noted that if a 10' setback is maintained he would have problems gaining access to the well on the property. He stated he is agreeable to removing the plastic around the house and is open to suggestions for its replacement in conjunction with solving the drainage problem into the house crawl space. Chairman Kelley felt the garage size 6vd driveway could be cut down to reduce the hardcover an additional 2% so there would be no increase in 75-250' hardcover from what currently exists. There were no comments from the pi, blic regarding this matter and the public hearing was closed. It was moved by Chairman Kel ley, seconded by Cohen, to recommend approval of the side and street setback variances as proposed, subject to removal of plastic within 0-75' that is not necessary protect foundation/crawl space, and 75-250' hardc er not to exceed existing 40.9%. Motion, Ayes 5, Nays 0. ZONING FILE NO. 1260 CITY OF ORONO NOTICE OF PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 473-7357 Date of Notice: 4/19/88 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- TO: John Nyquist COPIES TO: 1432 Baldur Park Road Wayzata, MN 55391 TYPE OF APPLICATION: Variance ----------------------------------------------------------- DATE OF MEETING: 4/18/88 VOTE: 5 For 0 Against Planning Commission recommends the following: Approval subject to conditions noted below NOTES AND SPECIAL CONDITIONS: 1. 0-75' hardcover - remove plastic that is not necessary to protect foundation/crawl space. 2. 75-250' hardcover - must not exceed existing 40.9% per staff calculations (1,670 s.f.). 3. 5' side setback variance, 10' street setback variance approved for garage locatio>> . Applicant's noxt scheduled meetiny is confirmed as: City Council May 9, 1988; meeting starts at 7:00 p.m. If you desire cert'_:ied copies of the official Planning Commission minutes, they are available from the City Recorder after review and approval by the Planning Commission. M To: Mayor Grabek City Council Members City Administrator Bernhardso- From: Michael P. Gaffron, Assistant Zoning Administrator Date: May 5, 1988 Subject: #1260 John Nyquist, 1432 Baldur Park Road - Variance - Resolution Zoning District: LR-lC, Single Family Lakeshore Residential Half Acre. Application: Side setback, street setback, and hardcover variances to allow construction of a detached garage. List of Exhibits: A.) Planning Commission Minutes of 4/1^/88 B.) Planning Commission Action Notice of 4/19/88 C.) Revised Existing Hardcover Calculations by Staff D.) Memo and Exhibits of 4/13/88 E.) Resolution Discussion Please review the memo and exhibits of 4/13/88. The applicant is requesting variances in order to remove his existing garage and construct a new detached garage. Planning Commission reviewed this application at their April 18 meeting, and generally felt that the project as proposed was excessive in hardcover. Planning Commission then voted 5 to 0 to recommend approval of the requested variances subject to a substantial reduction in overall hardcover. The Planning Commission recommended as follows: A. 0-75' hardcover - remove plastic that is not necessary to protect the foundation and crawl space. This translates to a reduction from the existing 1,512 s.f. (42.6%) to 1,320 s.f. (37.2%) resultant hardcover in the 0-75' zone. B. 75-250' hardcover - Planning Commission recommended that in this zone no hardcover increase should be allowed. Note that staff had done a preliminary estimate of 75-250' hardcover at 1,670 s.f. or 40.9%. Upon applicant's request, the 75-250' hardcover was recalculated in detail and found to be approximately 1,893 s.f. or 46.3%. Staff would interpret the Planning Commission recommendation to mean that no increase over the existing hardcover in the 75-250' zone would be allowed, whatever that existinq percent is, hence 1,893 s.f. would be the maximum allowed. C. Planning Commission recommended approval of the setback variance of 5', and recommended approval of a garage se, of 20' instead of the 30' normally required. Zoning File i1260 Page 2 The applicant has reviewed the Planning Commission recommendation and feels that he can comply by removing plastic landscape beds in the 0-75' zone, and can in fact, remove landscape beds and redefine his sidewalk and driveway areas to a maximum of 1,815 s.f. or 44.4% in the 75-250' zone. This will result in a net hardcover decrease on the property from 3,405 s.f. to 3,135 s.f. Staff Recommendation In light of Planning Commissions recommendation for a net decrease in hardcover on the property, the applicants current proposal accomplishes that purpose. A resolution reflecting the Planning Commission recommendation and the applicants revised hardcover proposal is attached for Council review. 54 u-31?fi5 City of ORONO RESOLUTION Of THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 2431 A RESOLUTION GRANTING VARIANCES TO MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE SECTION 10.03, SUBDIVISION 13, SECTION 10.22, SUBDIVISION 2, SECTION 10.03, SUBDIVISION 15(P), AND SECTION 10.25, SUBDIVISION 6(B)- FILE #1260 WHEREAS, John Nyquist (hereinafter "the applicant") is the owner of the property located at 1432 Baldur Park Road within the City of Orono (hereinafter "City") and legally described as follows: Lot 7, Block 1, Baldur Park, Hennepin County, Minnesota (hereinafter "the property"); and WHEREAS, the applicant has applied to the City for a variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 10.03, Subdivision 13 and 10.03, Subdivision 15(F) to allow construction of a detached garage to be located 5' from the side lot 1 ine and 20' from the street lot line where a side setback of 10' and a street setback of 30' are normally required, and for a variance to Section 10.22, Subdivision 2 to allow hardcover in excess of the 25% hardcover normally allowed in the 75-250' lakeshore setback zone. Minnesota: NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono, FINDINGS . This application was reviewed as Zoninq File 01260. 2. The property is located in the LR-lC Single Famil} Lakeshore Residential Zoning District. 3. The Orono Planning Commission reviewed this application on April 18, 1988 and recommended approval of the proposed variance based upon the following findings: A) The existing garage located 2' from the side lot line will be replaced with a new, larger gr.cage located 5' from the lot 1 ine. The 5' side setback variance is justified by the need to maintain an adequate corridor to the riqht side of the garage for future well maintenance access, and will provide a more useful yard area than if the garage was centered on the property. Page 1 of 5 TRANSFER ENTERED 44 . • E k ., .« .... 4W JUL 16 M City of ORONO RESOLUTION Oc THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 2431 B) The existing garage is 3.8' from the street lot line. The proposed 20' street setback for the garage will allow parking of vehicles in the garage and in the driveway without encroaching into the traveled right-of-way. Baldur Park Road is a lightly traveled residential street, and site distance is adequate in both directions so that the proposed garage location will not create a hazard in the neighborhood. C) The applicant can reduce the percentage of hardcover on the property by removing certain landscaped areas underlaid by plastic, and by reducing the magnitude of the sidewalk and driveway apron. The Planning Commission finds that the proposed garage with storage above it is a reasonable request since the existing house has no basement due to its elevation above the lake level, and in conjunction with hardcover removals the net amount of hardcover on the property can be reduced. 4. The City Council has considered this arrlication including the findings and recommendations of the Planning Commission, reports by City staff, comments by the applicant and the effect of the proposed variance on the health, safety and welfare of the community. 5. the City Council finds that the conditions existing on this rroperty are peculiar to it and do not apply generally to )ther property in this zoning district; that granting the variance would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor rose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring rrorerty; would not merely serve as a convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate a demon- strable hardsh-r or c'.ifficulty; is necessary to preserve a substantial property right of Ln, applicant; and would be in keening with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code and Comrrehensive Plan of the City. CONCLUSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS Based upon one or more of the findings noted above, the Orono City Council hereby grants a variance to Municiral Zoning Code Section 10.03, Subdivision 13 and Subdivision 15(F) to permit the construction of a detached garage to be located 5' from the side lot line and 20' from the strec' lot line where a 10' side setback and 30' street setback are norm required, and grants a variance to Municiral ?.oninq Code Section 10.22, 2 to al low additional structural hardcover in the 75- 2`•0' setback zone where they pre-existing hardcover already exceeds th< 250, hardcover normally allowed. subject to the following conditions: Paqe 2 of City of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 24 i1 1. Hardcover A. 0-75' aone. the only hardcover allowed on the property in the 0-75' zone includes the following: House 860 s.f. Patio area 360 s.f. Total (zone area = 3550 s.f.) 1,220 s.f. or 34.4• The applicant shall remove the plastic -underlaid landscape areas to the north and south sides of the house. B. 75-250' zone Existing house Existing torch Existing porch New garage Revised driveway Revised sidewalk Total (zone area Hardcover allowed area from garage to house = 4087.5 s.f.) is as follows: 2-3 s.f. 96 s.f. 84 s.f. 784 s.f. 170 s.f. 120 s.f. _ 1,727 s.f or 42.3% The applicant is required to complete the hardcover removals and revisions prior to final inspection of the new garage structure. See exhibit "A" attached for illustration of approved hardcover. 2. Applicant is advised that no additional hardcover will be allowed can this property, and arty future proposals to increase hardcover on the property might be approved only in conjunction with concurrent removals of existing hardcover, resulting in no net increase in hard•over on the property. 3. The Frorerty owner shall not block the existing culvert leading from his property across Baldur Park Road, nor shall he cause the flow through such culvert to be impeded in any way. 4. Authorities granted with this resolution run with the property not with the applicants, but are permissive only and must be exercised by application for a building permit within one year of the date of Council approval, or this variance will expire on that date (May 9, 1989). `). Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terns and conditions of this resolution shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically terminate any authority granted herein, and shall be punishable as a misdemeanor. Page ? of 5 + city of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 2431 6. The undersigned applicant has read, understood and hereby agrees to the terms of this resolution and on behalf of himself, his heirs, successors and assigns, hereby agrees to the recording of this resolution in the chain of title of the property. flp�n3 by the Orono City Council on this 9th day of May, PagP 4 of 5 1988. City of ORONO STATE OF MINNESOTA ss. COUNTY OF HENNEPIN RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 1 On this ��'� day of JCA-tje- 198? before me a Notary Public within and for said county, personally appeared �pnr) (a c t-j MGu-reed k. Aj)jfdkrSt known to me to be the person(s) described in and who efecuted the foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free act and deed. NOTARY PUBLIC NOTARY PUBLIC MINNE`:! a HENNEPIN C('uN' My commroaron expires r 1-. 4. /�-15 13 MY COMMISSION EXPIRES STATE OF MINNES,07A ) )ss. COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) On this day of , 198 , before me a Notary Public within and for said County, personally appeared known to me to be the person(s) described in and who executed the foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free act and deed. NOTARY PUBLIC MY COMMISSION i:XPIRES Fage 5 of 5 ?f socN T►oN l c. 2q 3 l �r�VfL . NP,ct�CfJVE le ► JN3Z I 1 r /4 H. S r LOi? r PAT O ZO E!- LDv re R�IROA L, ("AKar_s L. 2$k 28=781 S�- Df'` iEway M 370 J S rDEwAtr� o Q L:' ► ` z �. 120 r JN :1 _S Ll'xy ic, _� J / 20 La JK E -TOTALS l2 U s� —)r-?;D' 2?3 e� 37� ►moo 1727 s Resolution a2431 STATE OF MINNESOTA ) COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) CITY OF ORONO ) I Dorothy M. Hallin, City Clerk of the City of Orono. Hennepin County, Minnesota, do hereby certify that I have compared the foregoing copy of a resolution of the City Counflil of the City of Orono with the original record of r.ch resolution .n the Minutes of the proceedings of said City Council at a meeting of said City Council held on May 9 , 1988 , and that the some is a true and correct copy of said resolution was duly adopted by said City Council at said meeting. In Witness Whereof. I have hereunto set ■y hand and seal this 6th . day of June , 1988 Dorothy M. j16111n, City Cler A, MINUTES OP THE RBCULAR ORONO COUNCIL MEETING HELD MAY 9, 1988 11256 Ml/CC CONTINUED Zoning Administrator Mabusth explained that the project must be started within one year of the date of approval, the project does not have to be completed within the one year time period. It was moved by Councilmember Sime, secon '--�d by Mayor Grabek, to adopt Resolution #2425 granting a conditional use permit and variance. to the Metropolitan Waste Control Commission pez staff recommendation. Motion, Ayes 5, Nays 0. #1259 WILLIAM ODDEN 3450 NORTH SHORE DRIVE VARIANCE RBSOLUT-#2426 William Odden was present for this matter. City Administrator Bernhardson explained the request for a 75-250' hardcover variance t-) construct a 3-stall detached garage. The construction and propose hardcover removals result in a decreaac from the existing 38.8% 75-250' hardcover to 37.3%. It was moved by Councilmember Callahan, seconded by Councilmember Peterson, to adopt Resolution i2426 approving the hardcover variance as presented. Motion, Ayes 5, Nays 0. '�I1260 09N NYQUIST 2 R PARR ROAD V IANCE RESOLUTION 12431 John Nyquist was iresent for this matter. City Administrator Bernhardson explained t? •-pquest for side setback, street setback, and hardcovez -iances to allow construction of a _.etached garage Planning Commission recommended approval of the regiiested variances subject to a substantial reduction in the mall hardcover. He noted that a number of years ago k.ve hardcove-- riles were such that plastic covered rock bft4s were not considered hardcover as they are now. He also noted the after -the -fact patio constructed or, the property in 1982. Assistant Zoning Administrator Gaffron explained that the hardcover ns it exists, the original proposal, and the 'evised hardcover roposal aci-o1rplishin- th*s re. .en::.*ion of the Planning Commssion. He noter: that t .c & lan;iino Commission recommended no hsrdr;jver increase from the existing 40.9%, however, since the Planning Commission review, recr:culation of the 10 MINUTES OF THE REGULAR ORONO COUNCIL NP.ETING HELD NAY 9, 1988 #1260 NYQUIST CONTINUED existing hardcover has been determined as 46.3%. Staff drafted a resolution based on Planning Commission's recommendation of no increase over the existing hardcover. Councilmember Goetten felt that 46% hardcover is excessi.e and suggested that the application be sent back to the Planning Commission for reconsideration of their recommendation based on this revised existing hardcover calculation. Mr. Nyquist explained how he discovered the hardcover discrepency and brought it to sta:f's attention. He stated that he interpreted Planning Commission's recommendation to mean no increase over the existing hardcover irregardless o: the change in actual existing hardcover amounts. Assistant Zoning Administrator Gaffron reviewed the revised proposal which decreases the 75-250' hardcover to 14.4%. He noted a few other options to decrease the hardcover in the 75-250' to 41.9• and 34.3% within the 0-75' area. Councilmember Goetten felt that the lower hardcover amounts were more acceptable to her. She also noted the proposed loft area in the garage and felt the resolution should note the prohibited rental use of this area. Mr. Nyquist stated that he intended to use this area fcr a workshop and storage. Staff stated they would amend the resolution tc ref lect the proh ttcd rental use of this area. Councilmember Callahan felt that the walkway around the garage to the house and brick walkway to 'akc should by eliminated to reduce the hardcover. It was moved ►,y Counci Ix+ember Goetten, seconded by Councilmember Callahan, to approve the variances subject to removing the brick walkway within the 0-75' to the lake and the 75-250' hardcover not to exceed 40%. Mayor Grabek felt that the walkway around the garage wAs necessary because there was no other way, except to walk through the garage, to qet fr(,r the driveway to the house. I MINUTRS OF THE REGULAR ORONO COUNCIL MEETING HELD MAY 9, 1988 #1260 NYQUIST CONTINUED Councilmember Sime concurred with Mayor Grabek and felt that the walkway to the lake should also be allowed to remain noting that the applicant has agreed to remove a tremendous amount of hardcover already. Councilmember Goetten stressed that this severely limited lot consisted of 40% hardcover and strongly felt that applicant must give up a little in exchange for his request. Motion, Ayes 2, Nays 3. Mayor Grabek and Councilmembers Sime and Peterson voted nay. !lotion fails. It was moved by Councilmember Sime to alprov- the the variances with the hardcover removals as indicated and allowing a 2' wide sidewalk around the garage and the brick walkway to *he lake. Mayor Grabek asked if Councilmember Sime would consider amending his motion to require removal of the brick walkway to the lake? In order to pass this varlance, Councilmember Sime agreed to amend his motion to require the remove l of th brick walkway within the 0-75' to th- lake. Motion seconded by Councilmember Peterson. Motion, Ayes Nays 2. Councilmembers Ca 1 1 ahan and Goetten voted nay. Attorney Barrett &toted that the granting of a variance requires a 4/5ths majority vote. Therefore, motion fails. Based on this fact, Councilmember Callahan st:?gPsted that Council send this application back to ilar.r.ing Commission for consideration of a revised proposal from the applicant. It was moved by Mayor Grabek, seconded by Councilmember Sime, to submit this application back to the planning Commission to review a redesign. Motion, Ayes `, N&ys 0. ADDENDUM% On May 11, 1488, City Attorney Barrett reversed his position regarding the need for a 4/Sth vote to approve the variance. Barrett noted that his research indicates the statutes do not require a 4/5ths vote for a var ance, but merely a simple majority (3-2) vote is required, hence the motion receiving a 3-2 vote is considered as approved by adoption of Resolution 42411 and the action to table has no validity. 12 WAIN( O.IOP«AM :ATMo10 A A. w00[w w !C «NOsw�c l• OeNV(R wAV+MAN Rose*? A M.N,s. ROLrt A.WowO[W e. MARC WN,TCM(AD GwVCIS O WILLos ►wt of RlC■ ! O.CMANOS G. Moe(RT JONNl OM GAR? w rACOMOICa ROGt RTS SURK MVO. V. rl u Nw[TT.,II 1 w(Ot*1cK a fwowN TMOWAS K. f[*O JAW[• w, f7(IL(N JAW (f *. LOC"MANY ALL(" CLIr/Owp W sw(t.c O. W, LL, AM KAu/MAN YICMA(L O./*[(MAN MOWARO SAN MY(we.,,1 LAOwT C, tf►tl JAM'[ S. MAT(RON T.0W As J. SAOPtn POPHAM. HAIK,SCHNOBRICH & KAUFMAN, LTD. 3300 PIPES JA//RAY TOY"" MINNEA►OLIS. MINNESOTA SS402 JAMS A PAINE Tel[PMOM[ D AANDALL SOT[R GAVIO A. JON[! 0I8-31a-4a 00 00, AN N. JOMNlON L[e It•WEENY T[L[COII(R • ••OT"T w wvcw GAMOL O-eWAN6ON ALA,N /RtCON Lt SLIt O,LLerT[ Iasi Olt-SS4-8112 ISA PtT[POON M-CWAt I. T. MILAN Iasi Olt-$34-ave. JLLI(♦ ew[.TE[R ROS[RT M. LYNN TMOMC.M.tLtNMAVftN IS TNOMA9 M. (,PKIN! tall elt-aaA-tsoa MKMACL D_CM*IeT[WSO" wfw� C MO,LAMEN O J. YIC MA(l fC"WART( 7MOY[As / N9LSO,+ IODD ., JOWI.sON TMOYAS J. RADIO Su.19 8400 J[rr RtT P CA1wNs DAVID I. MAe MMALL 1t00 ![VENTEENTM STREET LOWS P. fMITW RATML[EN M MARTIN 0SNV[R, COLORADO OOROS sRuct N. L'TTLt JOMN C C—LO! T(LEP-ON[ 30t 4783-1800 A PA/MA :'A%."L S. POw[OfA DOUGLAS P ![ATON T.OMA! E SAN MEN T(LECOP't- 303-063-8104 fRYAN L.CI.♦w►OI.O RICMARD A_ KAPLAN MATT.(W [. DAMON ewuCt f M.PM(eTew! Bu-T( 200 soul" JONM W PROVO aeon ( w,C«TER 000 M l+wttT, N. M. [LLt" Out PAOR(P PAVL J L,NlTwOrM WAGNINOTON, O. C. 00030 OREGON, O fRoOKtw 11 1 A. •WIT. T[LEP.ONe tOt-sas-sa00 w'LL�AM M OOWALO M. 1'TM T[LtCOP'[R tOt-SaS -la'O TEIIRANC[ A. COSTELLO t •IIAf ET. ♦ TMOMPSON JOlEP« O VAS• w [,T. J. MALL[uN0 DIRECT DIAL NUMBER fw,A" w O.M MARK S.P[TtwlcN STEVEN A. C.CL[GYIIE May 11, 1988 Mr . Jr)hri Ny•1') i St 1432 11a1 1 ft Park Road Wayzath, MN 55-391 Re: 11260; Variance Request 0.9000, a SCOTT ROSANNE O 1-06NWE0e111 wOetOT c CA9TLC. 1•[wtle M .AWK9L JUL'[ •L[MIWO-wr-/( Oe GO111AN A. OTOON SAGER? " JONES f ENOON K. W.,TN(T w ATMwTN Y. W"Mce O[OwOe J. SOCNA l MAN( w, wt LL[T lUfAN M. Wels MARK /. Te,. ETC■ OVAN[ R. NOECKEw er .w"St, ►Rte L.YowwlsoM •Ae"ITTq 1..0WA .AornTe! IN IWoose Dear Mr. Nyquist: After the meeting on Monday, May 9, 1988, I "eviewe'l my legal advice to the counsel with respect to the number of votes required to grant a variance. I was wrong at the meeting. Only three votes, not four are required for a variance. The potion to table which would have sent the matter back to the Planning Commission is moot, and your request for vartance final. The terse of the variance which has been granted will be sent to you by the City staff. I apologize for any problems which my error created Sincerely Thomar'J. Barrett I i sus/ai 4? bj set WSW fernhardson Members of City Council APPLICATION NO. 1260 CITY OF ORONO NOTICE OF COUNCILACTIOA P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 473-7357 Dr - of Notice: 5/19/88 --------------------------------------------- ---------------------------- TO: John Nyquist 1432 Baldur Park -'oad Wayzata, MN 55391 TYPE OF APPLICATION: Variance ------------------------------------------------------------ DATE OF MR19TIlOG: 5/9/86 VOTES 3 For 2 Against COUNCIL ACTION - MOTION: To approve per the resolution E.reviously mailed to you, with the following revisions: 1. Rr.(:k pathway in 0-75' lakeshore setback zone shall be removed. 2. Sidewalks in the house and garage area shall he constructed at a width no greater than 2'. The resolution has been revised to reflect these changes. A revised copy is attached. Please arrange to sign the 3 original. resolution copies at the City Offices (Monday through Friday, 8:00 to 4:30). All persons with an interest in the property must sign the resolutions. Variance Approval is limited to the extent shown on approved plan and ap noted in the approval resolution. Changes in approved plans are subject to further review by the City. Variance approval expires one year after bate of approval. Permit application must he submitted no later than May 9, 1989. if you desire certified copies of the official Council minutes, they are available from the City Recorder or City Clerk after review and aplroval by the City Council. You must apply for and obtain a building permit prior to commer.c emE nt {,f construction. (':he building permit application is a separate applicaticn from the zoning variance jr conditional use application.i POPHAM, HAIK,SCHNOORICH 6 KAUFMAN, LTO. 3300 PI►CO JArFNAT TOWER MINNEAPOLIS. MINNESOTA 96402 w•.Ne O.►O.NAM JAMB* A.►A.Ne TtLt►NONE 0.RANDALL SO.[w wAvMoNO A MAIM DAVID A JONes slt-313e-4000 *-AN N. JO NNsoN *coca W. SCMNoesICM L[[ [.sNe[M. TCLCCO.Iew fIMOf N. W RUCK n[NVe'► A..J•MAN AL^IN IatCON CAwOL s *WANeON woetw♦ A MINIsN Les L1e $1LL[Tf[ 1321*It-»A-*71' soUCa A.•t7eaeON a0l•e A. WOAOLN MICM AtL T. MILAN 1*111048-334-8761 JVLIe A.swtlTtew q...AwC WNrt[N[AO .Ostwl N. ;.NN TNOMA* C.MItL[NMAUStN sayCt D WILLIS TNOMAS M, el►ItINs 1*II0I*-334-8002 MICNAtL D.CNwIST[NSON /s[O[wIC■ s• wIC NAND* 000e*1 C MOILAN[N J. MICNACL SCNWAATt s.wo*taTJoMNsow TMOMAe7.Ne/sOh 1000 M. JONNSOM O^A♦ A .t^COMs[s TMOMAS J. AADIO SUIT[ 2000 Jerra[... CA14016 AOs[wT s. SUNK DAVID L NASNMALL I'0o st V[NTec NTN *vote, LOUIS P. *„ITN NUeN V.►LUNALTT,all AATML[tN M MANTIN DENVER. COLORADO •O*O* SAUC[ M.11flle /wtotwlcw c $wowN Jo«N C cNlto$ let's.MONt f0'-es*-1*00 MAw11 /..ALMA NOMAs 1t. *too JAMB* s. sT [$Lam OaUSLAs ►'[ATOM TNOM..0 t '^Nimes TeL[C011to 303-60e-e1*4 ayS se lL e_.ONte$A ew.AN L. C*AW,OI,s JAMcs e. LOC^NANI w1CN•s0 A RA.LAV MATTNeW t. DAMON ALL[N w. MINOt*All[* swUCt s.I.•►Metftas sU1Te 300 SOU/N JONN W..wovo CLOFF. M. OweeNe SCOfT t. sI CMTes $*OO M STweet. N. W. [L►Lim sUt .AA11[s D. WILLIAM ■AUFMAN .AUL J. LaNSTSOfN WASHINGTON. D. C. *00*6 SatsOs. e. 8000091111 "ICMAtL O. ♦we9M^,1 $Calf A. sMIT,I Tt Le►MoNt tot-e8e-8*00 WILLIAM M. OJIL2. JA. MOWAAD SAM M-[A*.uI DONA►D M. Lewis T[LtCo►Leo *Ot-ee*-SSIS Tt1,wANCt A. COST[LLO LAAST O es►aL a►IZAS[TM A TNOM.Suw J06e.04 0. WASS JANIS $.MAVCOON 14e11/4 J. MAI L[LAND DIRECT DIAL NUMSEA solAN W. 01110 TMaMAs J. SAwse TT MAww •.pelt**ON STtV[N A. cNeLt*NI• (612) 334-2549 August 1, 1988 Ms. Jeanne Mabusth CITY OF ORONO P. O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 Dear Jeanne: 00900*. e. SCOTT wOSANNe e. tAIDeNW[sts aOstwT C CASIL[• IN[wtse M. MANatL JV Lit TL[.IINs-vv0Lrt De SON AN A. DYSON t ACNta. M. JoNts se"SON II. WNtTNtT AATNSVN M. WALetw OeOwst J. SOCN♦ *N^Ne w. AtLLtT SUSAN M. We.$ MAa" F. Tod tTCM D1/ANt A. NO LC11tw N SSVNsc♦ pass L. MOAAI$ON .•SNITTes IN Ielw •AsMITTes IN ILL11100 Enclosed and listed below are documents which have been filed in abstract property with the County Recorder and returned. Name Reams Doc . NO. Date Filed Rollin i Sharon Lacy 2434 5430769 July 13, 1988 Kathryn i Andrew Duncansun 2379 5431263 July 14, 1988 John Nyquist 2431 5431265 July 14, 1988 Thomas R. Williams 2387 5431266 July 14, 1988 Orville Fisher 2424 5431267 July 14, 1989 It ;you have any q -estions, please feel tree to call either se or my secret&ry, Pau!4 Van De Laarschot (334-2656). ✓Very truly yours, & Nancy E. Husnik Legal Assistant PLY/4992j Enc s .