HomeMy WebLinkAboutCourt OrderPI�N�EPI:r CULL! TT�.� -
:t-1�.�'=_: ill•`.(.. �G'ni �?t1 � ': ,7 tv C..ii:.t 1�'1 �13 s_.
irgerd,
Plaintiffs,
VS.
13�0 Ba1Gur, LL.C, a �. �ii.nesot:� Limited
Liability company, anal Frederick Puzak,
Deferdants.
bISTRIc:r caul�T
?;I1r. I ri i DIt'T_;-kI:IyI`�l&11.i1:.I
ORD;�`�2:4ND 1Y1;✓'��O��rDui�I
This martyr came on for a hearing before the rxo:rorable Cara Lee l;e�:lie on Januar,� 13,
2009, upon Def ndant's vlotion for Partial Summary Judgment. Adam W. Heaton, Esq,,
appeared on behalf of Plaintiff. Joseph <. Lawder, Esq,, appeared on behalf of Defendant.
based upor= all the files, records and. proceedings herein, and the arwtiments of cotinsel, the Count
hereby makes the following ORDER:
l . Defend�ast's Motion for Partial St;.tn:nary Jttd2r,ent is GR4NTED.
2. The Court Declares a current and legally valid appurtenant easerttcnt for t1',c lreneht of
Lots ?! ')3, and burdening Lot 20, Block 1, Baldu: Park. Hennepin Coity.. minneso:a,
with the d'mensi.ons defined in the Deed to title of May 24, 1948, recorded with the
Hennepin County Cleric and Recorder as Document?\'o. 251998, and attached herein.
Coart hereby' enjoins Plaintiff's :.Heir aGerts, and assig_.s, tram inter ring witl3
Det'endants' use of the Driveway Easemertt to a.ct-jess and enjoy the properties be:aefted
oy such easemant.
�. The attached memorandutn is itzcorporater= herein by refereice.
L£'T JUDGMENT BE E'rTEREI7 ACCL?22DINGLY
TT US :SC) URIL►ERET)
Dai:ed
It
The Honorab'.e Cara Lee Neti�il.le
Jud�;a of District Court
The Court hereby enjoins IGi tiffs) tileIY aeilt5; 8:t17 aSSioi1S, from InteIC?rinv \t'It?7
Defendants' use of the Driveway Easement to access and en.o%'tile properties beneMt
by suc.. eas�mert.
!. Tt 1letror�r�L') 1 3ttac; �d to this Caur-'S Order datepr i 1 2C��9 is herzb j ane ded
an "1 �-!
Cr r,.tiect the cerr..-�t recoruin� ;lamb,..M i�r �h., )
LET J>vAG�ZE�T �EE:"�TEil2ED :�.CCUF.AI:�G�k'
DateG
BY i'�-IE GOli�2T:
The s Honorable C`xa Lz21�e��ille
isDscutaitrit
STATE OF M UNINESOTA
IIIuR\ErFLWN CO I1T1'
DIS I Mu l COOKY
FOI:RTPI KIDICIAL DISTRICT
22 V. 2
Court File tio. i7-c��-OS-�_�.,--�.
�X' in herd,
PIaintiffs,
4�.
A1IE\YDED ORDER
1�54 Baid:zr; i_.LC. a �-linnesota Limited
Liability company, and Frederick Puzak,
DefQndants.
This ina�er car_-,e or for a E�zarin� before t;�e I��onorab`e Cara Lee l�iE��ii:e on January 13,
?QQ9, upe� Dafzndar_t's ?.rlotien for Parial Surrtnar�� Jad�trent. Adam, ���. Heaian, Esa.;
appeared on b�hal_f oT Plaintiff. Toseph S. La�i'dEr, Est., appeared on behalf of Defendant.
)3V Iett4r dated :gpri' 15, 20�9, Arorne;= Patrick Compto.i 0ndic2ted that the Cot:it's
Order m'isstated the recording nu:r_ber for the i� S8 Deed. There were no other submissions to
the Court. I3aseC upor: all the i;;les, reco=ds a7d preceedinas he:zin, and the argun�enis of
counsel, the Court hereby snakes the $in� A�IEND)~D ORDER:
i. Defendant's �loi=.'on for Partial Sumrla_:' Jadgr:�ert is GR�'�"TED.
2. The Court Dec:ar.:s a cu:ren: a�ad'egall �° vzli� app'artenant easement for tl:e benefit cf
Lots
"1-�3, and bt"rderain� Lot 2t�; Block Baldt"r Park. Hennepin County, ti�iinriesca,
c=ith the dtrl4rsitns de:ned i;1.eha Dezd to :itlz or" �=1G�.=. 24, 194 8, reoorded vtit. the
r�e�aeptn Courry Cle.k and t2ecorder as Docarncnt No. ?5I3998, and attached rerein.
E
D o�°moo City cif Orono
..
AUG 0 $ oil 1ifebmie Curtis
t"kesuo?g Plannmg & Zoning Coordinator
"ITY OF ORONO
Mailing Address; Office Address:
Po_c Office Box 66 2 5o Kellev Pada.ay
Cr .scal Bad, t1; I 55323 Orono. MN 55356
Office (953; 249AO2' F2x (952) 2494616
NO PAR \ Now
AID
akx�' Saba
' ` sp �` ``w 7
0 IF ar to
,a.
f
1''• s .�
, q L�oO
I It
r bar ,.0 to
vSIS
����
lt \ /
•� 1� .4 1.�Q �-
4 It
IF��:.' 1 1�t: /f
PO `f—.t
`t at '
.Q
f
AN to
if m
book Ir
at
'Ato
-&7' • f j
n \a` ,. �how !
Sqr4 I lip SO
i %! i .
�L `
% fall
\ �- V , ,
0 •
It
.,�
�
'
III A
\
So
to
IS. So
IS
to
Sbb
da.0 So Of pNbat
''\� :`
i
JIL
Wife �ttDcrtttare r4fa t
1e.4a ,
Arnold Re Boxrud -Rsd magl}elle S. $o7Crud, buaband and wiles
off; sdram,and Jephiz Fa rin.and rla?.fie busban .�ii�,.'niA 4214 partiP
- _.,.. ,... __...._. •__
_ IlAptneoin _. at _.._ .and Stasoft... . }iin-t aobsL" _... - j . --- prxtier of iF.e :wend par[,
15lfltttt�ftt(l, Tlest the tall par Li a 8 0/ tlu ,forts For t3 lts aonafrier`<ction aj t,nz turn a/
4 fit be 9 014f F, .GMAL•"114 •«:tD..X1MR..''Lr? AITA TaC...^uR'+{4.Xi2�r 81�.Q1iS'z =..
. 60LLd:IS,
ibs to hares pa!d bJ the tafd;xsrtftr aj tho Rcand ps+t, !ha rocalpt whereof it hertby acL»arol-
adged, do iurrhy Grant, Bmu•Cel.'s, Sell, and Convey unto fhe t[dd parfiat of Ma mmnd par: ar joint
tenons and not a•t tenants sac Common, •lhatr atrta,te, thi turoklpr it/ mt:l p.;ritu, and the h4'3rt and
auiffn W the t:r n ;vr, Fore vr, all t'hr. traelAt or pareCl. _A o/ laid Iglnwf and belnO In r• the ounly of
., {`it4 # a 0 _r , , and fitnlc of Jrinnotctn, *aotiF as foliau,'s, tawft; •
i.rL �ventr {2Q), !!leek CmA {1), in 6sldtSr Yarkr Stab�nOt to end rRg^rVfnc
in the Rrsntors hnrnin, their essitrna, bhA K; rvivnr nt• said psrtinb,
and th>' nir9 erd a:?:ale'p.'s of Lhn onrvivorr an easement Vor drive^xe.
ur;:ore over t`:a,t vortirn oi. saia lot dancrlbRd as lnitot:•9; 4os.^rn^ine:
aL the ^(+uthsnstorly corner or said LoL 1w)0, thantte ldorthwesrprly on
thA ;,at+titt:Psc^rl,l' lirrP. oY said Lot 2O, dlstart 45.0 1s,:t thanen
`:nrt:+oaotarly to a ;point on the NorLhwaScerlyr ling of 014 Lot 20 diat6bt
#, .C+ 1^et l:c±rthpnsterl,V belts the S0Uthwt?sL9rl7 corner 01• Said IreL• '"n
LnnncP ':orthnshcqrly on Lha ttorthvfencarly 11ne of said Lot ?Ct disLsn't
%_^.^ �^r'v; Gh^nce scuthwestjl^ly to Li;41 pZr:ae a1' beginning as now l:+id
cu c, anG
rant part of Lot Warty -ore (21), nlaok Ent► (1) in SaXdur Park deaoribed
nn 1-nZlowse C;ttn.Anair,l; at he 7;yande" line on the Northearstr;rlr cornea
nl afcid I*t :31; cltrtnoca :.orth'xr,sLarly cn suid ling digtunC 50 0 NA to
sh^ hr: Lhtr^ocorly ccrrrt of said Lot 21; thAncfi SoutlraeaCr�rl;c ar. Lhn
^rt;t:t^9L^rl•I lire oI' ^:r:? .t+L 21 %AiyLtrnt 23.' 1'or:tj eha t nee dir+UG,1^r,nL^�l :
,tnlr.t nn L^q SnutlrenstAqr?� Iir,P GC�5 SEat Southwesterly irmm 14
:: r+• I,i•n:,�C,, ry•. rC.,:.n:.� L�;;n':. l:br tl'.9RFt[t: 1�; nn the SO L:;P.RS Lr•rly ling
r,:S i'AAL Ln t;r p2ao^ �1' b^r.ir:r.'nf.,. r":i i6
�jalb tfje tk�amC, 1'ueiefhrr tr�ifh al[ the 7seredi[arnenW nxr� upper; dlttd.t +ru+r..
ease Leknri;:ae ur i„ ,(II,,/,J'rp,: ,etll,CP[ainLhf?, tV <Ae sett! partlu c{ fhe deGOltd pe:rb, [hrir nns[rn�, tkr errr-
rdrorof 4alel;artier, and thz hrirs arty[ ,:rri6n of the na,vloor, borzver, rite told purlier of Mr tarand IM,:[
tukb%Q ai f0.'vt leacrrlx ^od not a.r (cnntef.e to Porrmom
fed thergfd ru Ilali. {. ip G1 tr'� ;,rid..l.a}rhe..11a ;S4xrL'G:
fvrrt !reef the frrrc pr:r[, fur L,tcvLsel.e-5,11L3iCir bests, exeCrrlon Heel nrinriniafrr,to'ra,In
rcunrtnt rCtfh rhr ,raid rynrtiu of tlrc tuond part, fTceir otai finrr, iha turr'irtar of rvrirl pc+yle.•, r:nri lhr hrir,•
anrd ntrigna o! the rrnrvbtor, that .Chet' are u:dI tel:e3 in fta of ehd 112hdA and Irren?JM* ,r joreaeiel r;nrf
Ire ve tnnrl righ, to rrTl and convey the mrre in manner and jorin rferrvt+rl, amri ll,ut tht Arrrefr nr*
frra jn:r.r ell iueumLrr,nn�a,
.,'r ,rr thR Rl.,re hartrained ant! lrranls,f it:.^.� red Artrri.rts, ii thA grt[tf- and Trnrrr.rl.lr f>.�e.cr,.,r�a:t of fi:r
fabl partfta eJ the tuand party thrir asrdQrt.t, l7rC m:ra✓,Car of eafd partre;r. and !hr hrfrt ntr,i rr,eeigrr.<,;f thr
tin:;ir•nr, nFalntt rdl prrwna lan•juif�r rrinriny or fa clalni tF.o a=hadr or retry "Ito lhrreej• a;rhyrf:
inrurnbr,,r, rr, i/ rcy, hrn•inLr/ern n;entlonrd, time radd part lea o! the finel hurl rcill 11'armni and
j+r! end,
PRO �tt;tlmor;p �jcttgf, rr� ar:irt ,aartie s
lr r;,u)9 OW, day r, nrl �Crtr fi•xt ahurr varitfrn
,
t1r
Tn feeenca of
/ r
a/lhe 1$ral A4rt Ire Val „Tterravrfo art :
. / -a&AIr