HomeMy WebLinkAboutProject PacketCITY OF ORONO
P.O. Box 66
Crystal Bay, MN 55323
473-7357
APPLICATION NO. #1831
NOTICE OF COUNCIL ACTION
Date of Notice: July 2, 1993
-----------------------------------------------------------------
TO: Edward Engler
3450 Birch Lane
Wayzata, MN 55391
----------------------------------------------------
TYPE OF APPLICATION: Variances
----------------------------------------------------------------
DATE OF MEETING: June 28, 1993 VOTE: 3 FOR 1 AGAINST
1 ABSTENTION
---------------------------------------------------------------
COUNCIL ACTION -MOTION:
To approve per the findings and conditions of the resolution previously mailed to you.
Please make arrangements to sign the 3 original resolution copies at the City Offices
(Monday through Friday, 8:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.). All persons with an interest in the property
must sign the resolutions.
Variance approval is limited to the extent shown on approved plan and as noted in the
approval resolution. Changes in approved plans are subject to further review by the City.
Variance approval expires one year after date of approval. A building permit application must
be submitted no later than June 28, 1994.
Please contact Jeanne Mabusth (473-7357) if you have any further questions. Please be
advised that a building permit cannot be issued until the approval resolutions have been executed
by all parties with an interest in the property.
lsv
,.
MINUTES OF A REGULAR ORONO COUNCIL MEETING
HELD JUNE 28, 199a
ZONING FIL~ #1825 -CONT.
Gronberg asked if they would consider the application if the
developer upgraded the road.
McCarthy requested the application be tabled for 30 days.
' Hurr withdrew her motion, and Goetten withdrew her second.
It was moved by Hurr, seconded by Goetten, to continue App Ii cation
#1825 for Thomas L. McCarthy, 2490 Old Beach Road, to the July 26,
1993 meeting to a I I ow the app I i cant ti me to revise his proposa I .
Ayes 5, nays O.
(*#6) #1826 ROBERT & ANN HENSON,
2166 SHADYWOOD ROAD -VARIANCE -RESOLUTION #3295
It was moved by Jabbour, seconded by Ma_vor Ca I I ahan, to adopt
Resolution #3295 for Application #1826 for Robert and Ann Henson,
2166 Shadywood Road, approving variance for the construct io n of an
attached garage and lakeside deck. Ayes 5, nays O.
(#7) #1831 EDWARD ENGLER,
3450 BIRCH LANE -VARIANCE -RESOLUTION #3296
Mr. and Mrs. Engler were present.
Mabusth explained the applicants propose the addition of a 10x20'
lakeside addition to be placed over an existing patio, with the
remainder of patio to be removed, and a 16x24' addition to the east
side of the residence. Fourteen percent of the excessive hardcover
in the 75-250' zone is due to the aspha It drive which is used as
a turnaround for Birch Lane and used by the City for snow storage.
The Planning Commission requested an easement over the asphalt
area, but the applicants did not wish to encumber the property with
an easement. A condition of the approval resolution is that the
City be allowed continued usage of this area, and the applicants
have agreed to such.
Staunton noted the condition of the resolution will not be binding
to future owners.
Hurr felt if this is being considered as a hardship for the
granting of the variance, then they should require the easement.
Goetten objected as they have never required an easement in-the
past.
5
MINUTES OF A REGULAR ORONO COUNCIL MEETING
HELD JUNE 28, 1993
ZONING FILE #1831 -CONT.
Staunton noted the City could deny any subsequent owners future
improvements if the condition were not upheld.
Gerhardson noted the City has been using the asphalt area for 27+
years without a problem.
Ke I I ey di sag reed with the PI ann i ng Commission recommendation for
approval as they are exchanging non-structural hardcover for
structural hardcover.
Mabus th agreed, but noted according to the app Ii cants' contractor,
the foundation could not support a second story
Hurr noted one hardship stated is financial reasons.
Mabusth said State Statute al lows financial considerations as one
of the hardships.
It was moved by Jabbour, seconded by Mayor Ca I I ahan, to adopt
Reso I ut ion #3296 for App I i cation #1831 for Edward Eng I er, 3450
Birch Lane, for variances to construct additions to his residence.
Ayes 3, nays 1. Kelley voted nay and J-lurr abstained. •Motion
carried.
(*#8) #1832 SCOTT A. MABUSTH,
740 BROWN ROAD NORTH -VARIANCE -RESOLUTION #3297
It was moved by Jabbour, seconded by Mayor Ca I I ahan, to adopt
Resolution #3297 for Application #1832 for Scott Mabusth, 740 Brown
Road North, for a variance to construct a shed in front of the
front I ine of the principal residence. Ayes 5, nays 0.
(#9) #1838 ROBERT OWENS,
1700 SOHNS POINT ROAD -CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT -RESOLUTION #3298
Mr. Owens was present.
Hurr questioned the hardcover percentages for the site.
Mabus th responded that there w i I I be an add it i ona I 82 s. f. of
hardcover in the 0-75' zone because of the tiered wa I Is.
Hurr asked if this is the only way to repair the wal I.
6
To:
From:
Date:
Mayor Callahan and Orono Councihnembers
Ron Moorse, City Administrator
Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator
June 25, 1993
Subject: #1831 Edward Engler, 3450 Birch Lane -Variances -Public Hearing
Additional Exhibit
M -Applicant's Letter of May 24, 1993 Requesting to be Scheduled Before the
Council Meeting of June 28, 1993
The applicant proposes a 12' x 20' addition at lakeside of the existing residence located
out of the 0-75' setback area and will be placed over an existing concrete patio. To the
northeast side of the residence, applicant proposes a 16' x 24' addition meeting the required 10'
setback. Lakeside addition and portions of the side addition will encroach the average lakeshore
setback line. Applicant proposes the removal of existing non-structural improvements to offset
structural expansions. Structural coverage will be at 15. 06 % . Hardcover has been reduced and
is proposed within the 0-75' setback area at 2.93% and in the 75-250' setback area at 43.43%.
The Planning Commission unanimously approved the Engler application finding the
average lakeshore setback encroachment negligible as existing residence to west side is already
impacted by existing structure and residence to the east side of property is buffered by a 7-8'
high arborvitae hedge providing year round buffer. Members questioned the possible reduction
of the proposed addition so that lot coverage would not be exceeded by . 06 % . Applicant advises
that the proposed improvements were trimmed back considerably from the original proposal and
horizontal expansion was the only available option as the foundation of the existing house could
not sustain a second story. Hardcover was the major concern for the Planning Commission as
43 + % hardcover was deemed excessive on the 21,630 s.f. property. Staff advised members
that 1,960 s.f. or 13.9% of the hardcover within the 75-250' setback area was asphalt driveway
that serves as turnaround and snow storage area for the City. Birch Lane right-of-way stops at
the west lot line of the property. Vehicles that travel on Birch Lane use applicant's property as
a turnaround. Public Works Director has confirmed that the property is used for storage and
applicant reports that the City has replaced plantings that were damaged by snow maintenance
vehicles.
A member of the Planning Commission asked if an easement could be granted over the
property assuring the City that this area will be available and remain for City's use. Any other
applicant would have been asked to reduce the size of the paved area to offset hardcover
increases, the excessive hardcover on the site results from the extensive paving in the street yard
If the paved area was reduced, it would create major snow storage problems for City and
Zoning File #1831
June 25, 1993
Page 2
eliminate turnaround area. Applicant asked that encumbrance not be placed on property.
Planning Commission conditioned approval on applicant agreeing to allow paved area to remain
and to continue to allow property to be used for snow removal and storage purposes by City.
The Planning Commission conditioned approval on the following:
1. Applicant to provide a detailed grading and drainage plan specifically addressing
cuts into higher elevations for proposed construction along east side.
2. Upon the execution of this resolution that applicant agrees to retain asphalt drive
area as it currently serves City's needs for snow removal and storage.
The enclosed resolution has been drafted per the findings and conditions set forth on the
Planning Commission's recommendation. Please review the staff memo of June 16th for more
background on this review.
lsv
A RESOLUTION GRANTING VARIANCES
TO MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE
SECTION 10.03, SUBDIVISION 14 (C),
SECTION 10.22, SUBDIVISION 1 (B) AND SUBDIVISION 2
FILE NO. 1831
WHEREAS, Edward Engler (hereinafter "the applicant") is the owner of the
property located at 3450 Birch Lane within the City of Orono and legally described as follows:
refer to Exhibit A, attached (hereinafter "the property"); and
WHEREAS, the applicant has applied to the City for variances to Municipal
Zoning Code Section 10.03, Subdivision 14 (C) for structural improvements to the property that
will result in 3,383 s.f. or 15.6% structural coverage where only 15% is allowed, per Section
10.22, Subdivision 1 (B) where a 12' x 20' lakeside addition will encroach 21' beyond the
average lakeshore setback line and the east side 16' x 24' addition will encroach 12' beyond the
average lakeshore setback line where no such encroachment is allowed and proposed
improvements will result in 221 s.f. or 2.93% hardcover in the 0-75' setback area where 353
s.f. or 4.68% exists and where none is allowed and a hardcover variance within the 75-250'
setback area at 6,119 s.f. or 43.43% where 6,185 s.f. or 43.89% exists and where 3,522.5 s.f.
or 25 % is allowed.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono,
Minnesota:
FINDINGS
1. This application was reviewed as Zoning File #1831.
2. The property is located in the LR-1 C Lakeshore Residential Zoning District
requiring 21,780 s.f. or one-half acre in area. The property consists of 21,630
s.f. or .496 acres.
3. The Orono Planning Commission reviewed this application on June 21, 1993 and
recommended approval of the proposed variances based upon the following
findings:
Page 1 of 6
A. Applicant proposes the removal of 132 s.f. or 1.75% of hardcover within
the 0-75' setback area. Total hardcover will remain at 221 s.f. or 2.93%
B. Hardcover within the 75-250' setback area has been maintained at
43.43%. There already exists 43.89%.
C. 1,960 s.f. or 13.9% of the existing hardcover within the 75-250' setback
area shown as asphalt driveway serves as an additional area for snow
storage and turnaround for City vehicles.
D. The age and condition of foundation of existing residence structure will
not allow for an upward expansion.
4. The City Council has considered this application including the findings and
recommendations of the Planning Commission, reports by City staff, comments
by the applicant and the effect of the proposed variance on the health, safety and
welfare of the community.
5. The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this property are peculiar
to it and do not apply generally to other property in this zoning district; that
granting of the variances would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air
nor pose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely
serve as a convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate a
demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is necessary to preserve a substantial property
right of the applicant; and would be in keeping with the spirit and intent of the
Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan of the City.
CONCLUSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS
Based upon one or more of the findings noted above, the Orono City Council
hereby grants variances to the Municipal Zoning Code Sections noted above to permit the
construction of a 12' x 20' lakeside addition and a 16' x 24' east side addition to the existing
residence, subject to the following conditions:
Page 2 of 6
1. Applicant shall agree to continue to allow the City to use asphalt driveway area
as shown on survey dated March 19, 1993, revised May 21, 1993, for turnaround
use of snow plows and shall continue to allow the storage of snow during the
winter months on the areas defined on that same survey included as Page G:i of
this resolution.
2. Applicant shall provide a detailed grading and drainage plan with the application
information for building permit for new construction.
3. Authorities granted by this variance run with the property not with the applicant,
but are permissive only and must be exercised by application for a building
permit within one year of the date of Council approval, or this variance will
expire on that date (June 28, 1994).
4. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this
resolution shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically
terminate any authority granted herein, and shall be punishable as a misdemeanor.
5. The undersigned applicant has read, understood and hereby agrees to the terms
of this resolution and on behalf of himself, his heirs, successors and assigns,
hereby agrees to the recording of this resolution in the Chain of Title of the
property.
Page 3 of 6
Adopted by the City Council of the City of Orono, Minnesota at a regular meeting
held on the 28th day of June, 1993.
ATTEST:
Dorothy M. Hallin, City Clerk Edward J. Callahan, Jr., Mayor
Property Owner ( s)
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this 28th day of June,
1993 by Edward J. Callahan, Jr. and Dorothy M. Hallin, Mayor and City Clerk of the City of
Orono, a Minnesota municipal corporation and said instrument was executed on behalf of the
City.
Notary Public
Page 4 of 6
EXHIBIT "A"
That part of the northeasterly half of Lot 18, "Lydiard's Park" Lake Minnetonka, lying
northwesterly of a line parallel with and distant 197. 5 feet Northwesterly from that certain dotted
line shown on the plat of said "Lydiard's Park" Lake Minnetonka, which dotted line is drawn
at an angle of 88° to the northeasterly side line of said lot and intersects said side line at a point
distant 85 feet Northwesterly from the Southeasterly corner of said Lot; and that part of the
Southwesterly half of said Lot 18 lying Northwesterly of a line drawn parallel with and distant
222 feet Northwesterly from the base line as shown on the original plat of "Lydiard's Park"
Lake Minnetonka, Hennepin County, Minnesota.
CITY OF ORONO
P.O. Box 66
Crystal Bay, MN 55323
473-7357
ZONING FILE #1831
NOTICE OF PLANNING COMMISSION
ACTION
DATE OF NOTICE: June 23, 1993
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TO: Edward Engler
3450 Birch Lane
Wayzata, MN 55391
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
TYPE OF APPLICATION: Variances
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DATE OF MEETING: 6/21/93 VOTE: 6 FOR 0 AGAINST
The Planning Commission recommended approval of your variance application subject
to the findings and conditions set forth in the enclosed resolution. Please review the enclosed
resolution that shall be presented for Council's formal action at their meeting of June 28th.
Please contact Jeanne Mabusth (473-7357) if you have any questions.
lsv
, ..
MINUTES OF THE ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
HELD JUNE 21~ 1993
ZONING FILE #1830 -CONT.
It was moved by Peterson, seconded by Rowlette, to recommend
approval of Application #1830 for Richard F. ·oorlog, 1058 Loma
Linda Avenue, for I akeshore setback variance, average I akeshore
setback variance and hardcover variances to permit the construction
of an addition to the existing residence,· subject to all plastic
on the property being removed, and steps to the lake being
relocated out of the 0-75' setback area . Ayes 7 , nays 0.
(#3) #1831 EDWARD ENGLER,
3450 BIRCH LANE
VARIANCE -PUBLIC HEARING 7:47 -8:05 P.M.
The Affidavit of Publication and Certificate of Mai I ing were noted.
Mr. and Mrs. Engler were present.
Mabusth e x plained the applicants propose a famil y room addition
over an e x isting patio area, 16 x2 0', completely l ocated in fron t
of the average setbac k . She noted minimal impact on neighbors'
property by the encroachment into the average setback area. They
propose the removal of plastic under the landscape patio a ·rea,
reducing the hardcover in both the 0-75' and 75-250' zones. Most
of the excess hardcover in the 75-250' zone is due to the
bituminous area, which serves as a turn-around for Birch Lane and
is also used by the City to store snow.
Nolan asked how they plan to address drainage. He expressed concern
about trapping the drainage on the rear of the property.
The applicants' bui Ider s.:ated they intend to solve drainage
problems one of two ways by either allowing the drainage to flow
in its natural pattern or by instal.l ing a retaining wal I adajcent
to the addition on the west side.
Nolan felt it would be appropriate for the applicants to submit a
drainage plan.
Rowlette clarified that there wi 11 not be a walk around the house .
Engler stated that was correct.
Nolan asked if it would be appropriate to require an easement over
the bituminous area to ensure the City's use in the future.
5
MINUTES OF THE ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING
HELD JUNE 21, 1993
ZONING FILE #1831 -CONT.
Eng I e r s t at e d h e w o u I d I i k e to as k h i s at to r n e y p r i o r to co mm i t t i n g
to an easement. He noted the area has been used by the City for
many years without problems. He added they would prefer to remove
a portion of the bituminous instead of the plastic, however, they
realized the need to allow it to remain for City use.
Nolan asked if they would consider the easement if the legal
ramifications could be worked out.
Mrs. Eng I er stated they have worked we I I with the City in the past
and would prefer to leave things as they are.
Mr. Eng I er added they wou Id prefer not to encumber the property
with an easement.
Chair Schroeder asked if it would be possible to reduce the
proposal so a lot coverage variance would not be necessary.
Mrs. Engler stated they have already reduced the addition.
It was moved by Row I et te, seconded by Lindquist, to r·ecommend
approval of Application #1831 for Edward Engler, 3450 Birch Lane,
for variances to construct an addition to his existing residence,
subject to al I the hardcover removed as shown on the plan and with
the added condition that a drainage plan b:e submitted with th-e
bui I ding permit application. Ayes 7, nays O.
(#4) #1832 SCOTT A. MABUSTH,
740 NORTH BROWN ROAD -VARIANCE -PUBLIC HEARING 8:05 -8:10 P.M.
The Affidavit of Pub! ication and Certificate of Mai I ing were noted.
Scott Mabusth was present.
Weckman explained the applicant seeks a variance to construct a
10x16' shed in the front of his principal residence. An existing
shed w i I I be removed. The shed w i I I be set back 146' from the
street lot I ine. The hardship is the topography to the rear of the
residence, and the only flat area is used for the septic system.
Phi I Nelson, surveyor, added the net increase is 32 square feet,
no mature trees wi 11 be disturbed and very I ittle grading wi 11 be
required.
6
TO: Planning Commission Members
Ron Moorse, City Administrator
FROM: Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator
DATE: June 14, 1993
SUBJECT: #1831 Edward Engler, 3450 Birch Lane -Variance -Public Hearing
The applicant proposes a 12'x20' addition to the lakeside of the existing residence to be
placed over an existing concrete patio area and a 16'x24' addition to the side meeting the
required side setback of 10'. The lakeside addition will be located in front of the average
lakeshore setback line as well as a small portion of the proposed side addition. The applicant
proposes removal of existing nonstructural improvements to offset structural expansions. The
improvements result in an excess of .06% structural coverage. Hardcover excesses exist within
the 75-250' setback and 4.68% hardcover exists within the 0-75' setback area.
The following ordinances are pertinent for this review:
Section 10.03, Subdivision 14 (C) -Structural coverage
Total lot area = 21,630 s.f.
Allowed = 3,244.5 s.f. or 15%
Existing = 2,748 s.f. or 12.7%
Proposed = 3,383 s.f. or 15.6%
Variance = . 06 %
Section 10.22, Subdivision 1 (B) -Average lakeshore setback, review Exhibit L
Staff has located the approximate locations of the residences on adjacent
properties. The lakeside addition is located completely in front of an average
lakeshore setback line and a small portion of the side addition encroaches the
average lakeshore setback.
Section 10.22, Subdivision 2 -Review of hardcover
A. 0-75' setback area = 7,540 s.f.
Allowed= 0
Existing = 353 s.f. or 4.68%
Proposed = 221 s.f. or 2.93%
B. 75-250' setback area = 14,090 s.f.
Allowed = 3,522.5 s.f. or 25%
Existing = 6,185 s.f. or 43.89%
Proposed = 6,119 s.f. or 43.43%
Zoning File #1831
June 14, 1993
Page 2
List of Exhibits
A -Application
B -Applicant's Addendum
C -Property Owners List
D -Plat Map
E -Neighbor's Acknowledgment Form
F -Lakeside Elevation
G -Proposed Floor Plan
H -Existing Floor Plan
I -Survey
J -Hardcover Fact Sheets
K -Olson Letter 9/6/81
L -Staff Sketch
Description of Request
Applicant proposes the installation of a 12 'x20' lakeside addition to be placed over an
existing patio. Portions of the existing patio are located within the 0-7 5' setback and shall be
removed. Some 72 s.f. of existing landscape area underlain with plastic shall be removed. The
entire addition shall be located in front of the average lakeshore setback line. The house to the
immediate west receives no impact because the existing residence is located in front of the
proposed addition. The house on the east side is shielded by year around arborvitae/ evergreen
plantings providing a solid screening from adjacent residence structures. The 16'x20' side
addition shall be 16' from the east side lot line easily meeting the 10' side setback. Applicant
has proposed removal of 701 s.f. of nonstructural hardcover and the addition of 635 s.f. of
structural hardcover.
There is an increase of 2.9% structural coverage on the property. The total coverage at
15.6% requires approval of a .06% variance.
The original structure was built prior to 1956. A building permit was issued for the
40'x24' garage in 1981. Based on 1981 reviews, the City did not require hardcover inventory
and structure's conformity was reaffirmed in a letter to an adjacent resident advising that the
detached structure met all required zoning regulations. Review Exhibit K.
Statement of Hardship
Applicant notes the following hardship: need to expand the existing single story structure
for growing family. It is doubtful that a structure of that age could support a second story.
Applicant also notes that extensive driveway area in front of garage serves as a turnaround for
City snow plows. Members will remember limitations of Birch Lane from the Liljequist review
Zoning File #1831
June 14, 1993
Page 3
of last month. The paved area at end of roadway is not located in road right-of-way but on
applicant's property. Review the plat map, Exhibit D. Note the road right-of-way ends right
at the west lot line of applicant's property. The City snow plows turnaround and store snow on
applicant's property. Review Exhibit I and the plat map, please note that the car parked in front
of garage is not parked at applicant's property but at property owner's to immediate south.
Issues for Consideration
ch
1. Should structural improvements be reduced so that 15 % lot coverage is not
exceeded?
2. Some 600 s.f. of landscape area underlain with plastic exists within the 75-250'
setback, refer to Exhibit L. Should additional areas be removed? Applicant has
shown a reduction over existing.
3. Does the fact that the applicant's property provides a turnaround and storage area
for snow removal have an impact on your determinations and final
recommendation?
CITY OF ORONO -VARIANCE APPLICATION
Initial Application Fee $175.00
($50.00 per each additional variance)
Renewal Variance Fee $100.00
(no change from original application)
Variance for non conforming use $200.00
After-the-Fact Fees (Double application
PROPERTY INFORMATION
Site Address ...5 LJ{ 0 J3 ; ;Q v /./ L;t;J S'
fee)
Property Identif. Number (P.I.D.) _________ _
Attach legal description to application if not
included on required survey.
Date Property Acquired J t.J N tJ J q g 6 (month/year)
I (do)(do not) also own the adjacent parcels of land.
I+
1
r · T TV nL tii:n1Mi1
L,,J. f r \.!I L 11\UltL'
r: !i-.i.-\iJr·C riCLT!-·C'
l J. I 'fMf'll'l.tL-t..!I I J. Lr!-
Present use of property: ~residential __ other(specify) ______ _
Zoning District: -----------
APPLICANT
Address: 3 fl-.5 0 8/JQ __ e,,//-L qv tf
Phone (home) ';-/ / -C} 9 'f 3
Phone (work) 3 ;I ) -c;73 Y-?
City: w ft V 2-AJ A
7 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------
OWNER (if different than applicant) Phone (home) ---------
Name Phone (work) ---------
Address: City: ________ Zip: _____ _
DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST Estimated Construction Cost$ ________ _
Describe request in detail:
VARIANCES REQUIRED
Lot Area Lot Width i_ Hardcover __ Lot Coverage
Setback: Front Side __ Rear __ Average Lakeshore
__ Other (specify) ___________________________ _
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
HARDSHIP/DESCRIPTION OF UNUSUAL PROPERTY CONDITIONS
Describe undue hardship or practical difficulty and unusual property
conditions preventing compliance with Zoning Code requirements: ___ _
-------------------
l
:\ 1
(attach additional sheets if necessary)
REQUIRED SUB MITTALS
Al 1 of the f cl lowing information must be submitted by the application
deadline date in order for your application to be considered complete:
1. __ Completed Application Form
2. Certified Property Owners List of owners within 150' (you must obtain
this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Govt Center
348-3271).
3. __ Plat Map (obtained with property owners list).
4. __ Certificate of survey (signed by a licensed surveyor) to include
hardcover calculations as required (provide one (1) copy 8½"xll" for
reproduction).
5. __ Topographic survey (existing and proposed elevations) if any changes
in existing grade are proposed (provide one copy 8½"xll").
6. __ Sketches or plans of floor & elevation views (provide 1 copy 8½"xll").
7. __ As an addendum to this application, please attach a separate list of
any other persons you wish notified of this application.
8. __ Additional items as may be requested by City staff.
The Applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please
remember that your variance application is not complete if the above
information has not been included.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE
The applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or
requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay additional fees (staff
time not covered by original fee payment) and/or consultant expenses
incurred in review of this applica i;i-on , and certifies that the information
supplied is true and cor 1ct o th~ best of his/her knowledge.
Date 1{/d-r I LJ
OWNERS SIGNATURE
The owner hereby ackowledges and agrees to this application and further
authorizes reasonable entry onto the property by City staff, consultants,
agents, Commission me)l)bers, and C ncil members for purposes of investiga-
tion and verificati n of
Date
Applicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 days before the
Planning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission Meetings are held on the
third Monday of each month. Applicants must be present at all scheduled
review meetings of the Planning Commission and Council. If an applicant is
unable to attend a scheduled meeting, please make arrangements to have an
authorized agent attend in your place and to advise the Building & Zoning
Office of this change prior to the meeting.
May 24, 1993
The City of Orono
Orono, MN
RE: Variance for
Mr. & Mrs. Ed Engler
3450 Birch Lane
Wayzata, MN 55391
To Whom It May Concern;
We are requesting this variance for the following reasons:
We are growing out of the house. We need the additional space
because of the increase in size of our family. We have looked at
going up, but it is financially prohibitive. In addition, we are
not sure the existing structure could support it. We also feel,
that because the City snowplows need our driveway to turn around in
and use it to store snow in, that we should be granted this
variance. We feel that it is unfair to ask us to give up
hardcover, when our family needs it, in order to provide a
turnaround for the public.
ciZ;ie
Ed Engler
-..
RUN.DATE 05/11/93
BATCH 008
PROP ADDR
Ol'lNER NAME
TAXPAYER
NAME/ADDR
PROP ADDR
OWNER NAME
TAXPAYER
NAME/ADDR
PROP ADDR
ONNER NAME
TAXPAYER
NAME/AD DR
PROP ADDR
ONNER NAME
TAXPAYER
NAME/ADDR
PROP ADDR
01-lNER NAME
TAXPAYER
NAME/AD.DR
38 08-117-23 42 0005
03430 NORTH SHORE DR
LUCILLE M OFFERMAN TRUSTEE-
LUCILLE M OFFERMAN TRUSTEE
1669 NORTH FARM RD
LONG LAKE MN 55356
. 38 08-117-23 43 0012
03470 .NORTH SHORE DR
HAROLD J BROUELLETTE
HAROLD J BROUELLETTE
3470 NORTH SHORE OR
WAYZATA MN 55391
38 08-117-23 43 0020
03442 NORTH SHORE DR
GERALD J RAV ETAL
GERALD J RAV
3442 NORTH SHORE DR
WAYZATA MN 55391
38 08-111~23 43 0023
03450 BIRCH. LA
ER ENGLER & B ENGLER
EDWARD R & BONNIE ENGLER
3450 BIRCH LA
•iAVZATA MN 55391
38 08-117-23 43 0026
03460 NORTH SHORE DR
JOHN G NELSON ETAL
JOHN NELSON
3460 NO SHORE DR
WAYZATA MN 55391
HENNEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM
PROPERTY OWNERS LIST
38 08-117-23 43 0001
03470 BIRCH LA
REX EUGENE BOLLINGER JR
REX EUGENE BOLLINGER JR
3470 BIRCH LA
WAYZATA MN 55391
38 08-117-23 43 0013
03480 NORTH SHORE DR
BRUCE A NUSBAUM
BRUCE A NUSBAUM
3480 NORTH SHORE DR
WAYZATA MN 55391
38 08-117-23 43 0021
03450 .NORTH SHORE DR
WILLIAM C OOOEN
WILLIAM C OOOEN
3450 NO SHORE DR
WAYZATA MN 55391
38 08-117-23 43 0024
03448 NORTH SHORE DR
J & M ERLER
JAMES & MARV ERLER
3448 NORTH SHORE DR
· WAYZATA MN 55391.
38 08-117-23 43 0027
03460 BIRCH LA
R WILLIAM TONARD ETAL
R WILLIAM TONARD
3460 BIRCH LA
WAYZATA MN 55391
REPORT NO. PI43540l
PAGE 21
38 08-117-23 43 0002
03490 BIRCH LA
E LILJEQUIST & S LILJEQUIST
ERIC J & SHELLY R LILJEQUIST
3490 BIRCH LA
WAYZATA MN 55391
38 08-117-23 43 0019
03440 NORTH SHORE DR
DAVID J LINDBE~G
DAVID J LINDBERG
3440 NORTH SHORE DR
1 WAYZATA MN 55391
38 08-117-23 43 0022
03444 NORTH SHOR.E DR
WILLIAM D ROBINSON ,
W D ROBINSON
. 3444 NORTH SHORE DR
WAYZATA MN 55391
38 08-117-23 43 0025
03458 NORTH SHORE DR
P .E BONMAN & B D BLADER
PAUL BONMAN/BARBARA D BLADER
3458 NORTH SHORE DR
WAYZATA MN 55391
TOTAL BATCH 008 00014
-..
RUN DATE 05/11/'13
BATCH 008
HENNEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM
. PROPERTY OWNERS LIST
REPORT NO. PI435401
PAGE 22
I CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTED ARE AN ACCURATE AND TRUE
REPRESENTATION OF INFORMATION AS.IT APPEARS THIS DATE ON THE RECORDS
·oF THE HENNEPIN COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PROPERTY TAXATION, TO THE BEST
OF MY KNOWLEDGE AND BELIE~ . &
DATE /~13 BY 1aa l,W
# t~~ ~1 W
"""' L"'<'¼,
'i . .
00-111--Jo-
AUD SU!ID
180 ~73
( 3 )
------W--~
12
( 2)
...
Adjacent Property OWners' Acknowledgement Form
I (we) ,,d;, // -~ /fe (:C,,.__J (ell)..)/+-~
[print name(s)J
of s1/ G Cl & I tee f( ,c.../}A}~
[print address)
have reviewed the plans for the proposed improvement or proposed use of the
property located at .7f<SV /;/R.ctf t,_.ft-p)E_ also referred to as Land Use
Application No.
I (we) understand that in executing this acknowledgement, I (we) am
(are) not asked to declare approval or disapproval of the property or use
but merely to confirm for the City Council that I (we) am (are) aware of
the improvement plans and that the proposed neighbor's project or use
requires Council approval.
Property Owner
~zl\~~w\
·Property Owner
Dat11¥
Date \
**************************************
I (we) (jg,r Alf) g A '--(
[print name(s)J /
of 3 Y y...2 /vo1t 1J.J 5/k u..r dJ/2 ,
[print address)
have reviewed the plans for the proposed improvement or proposed use of the
property located at ..f Y e;-o EJ ~/l c./4,L L J.J also ref erred to as Land Use
Application No.
I (we) understand that in executing this acknowledgement, I (we) am
(are) not asked to declare-approval or disapproval of the property or use
but merely to confirm for the City Council that I (we) am (are) aware of
the improvement plans and that the proposed neighbor's project or use
requires Council approval.
Date
If you have any information that may assist the City in the review
this Land Use Application, please submit your comments to the :euilding
Zoning Office at least 10 days prior to the scheduled meeting date.
/:-='~ ·~.· t;;;) ;;p -;
mt:@;, r u 1 i,
of
&
(/) :r:
-rr,
fTl
-l
r
)>
7' m
CJ)
0 m
m r m < )>
-I
0 z
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
LAKE ELEVATION
SCALE 1/8" = l'-0"
MAY 19, 1993
(
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
PLAN FOR: ~FAZENDIN BROTHERS INC. ED t BONNIE ENGLER 1421 E. WAYZATA BLVD. 3450 BIRCH LANE WAYZATA, MN 55391 WAYZATA. MN 55391 (612) 476-2311
' ;,;
? ;,
' ;.,
;.,
.:.
" ' !'l
~
io
...
:.
~~ ;j
:::<> ".:
Iii
t-
:,:
EXISTING WALLS
NEW WALLS
@WcWZW&Zd
"'-o·
3'-r 12·-u·
:2"f"f-f-112
WITH TEMP. GLASS ov--~
()
\i ":;l!C\
'\_)
MASTER
BEDROOM
't' ATRIUM DOOR
8'-3 11:::i· 1'-8 112·
"'-0"
lil
t-
-( u g
w
°'
BATH'□
BEDROOM
HALL
KITCHEN
END OF WALL WT\ EETROCK t TA
NEW HEADER d; (2) I 3/"f" X 1-1" MICRO LAM
EXISTINC,
BEDROOM
EXISTINC,
BEDROOM
= == =,========L "--REMOVE EXISTING SIDING
IXIO R.5. CEDAR LAP SIDING SHEETROCK AND TAPE WALL PATCH SHEETROCK
:25/32 BIL TRrTE SHEATHIN.G I ABOVE s·-o· HEIGHT 2x, STUDS --1,• O.C.
S 1/2" FIBERGLASS BATTS
2 MIL POLY VAPOR BARRIER
112• CiYPSUN BOARD
WIT~E~~~S~I~~ FF~'b~~ I LINE OF EXISTINC:. FLOOR
I
2XIO FLOOR JOISTS 1,· o.c.
~/<f" TONGUE t GROOVE
WAFERBOARO
GLUED t NAILED WITH RING
SHAN.K NAILS
TRUSSF!S
DESIUNED BY MANUFACTURER
,112 PITCH ON ROOF
3/12 PITCH ON INTERIOR YAUL T
NEW CEILING
S/8" SHEETROCK
IX, T t G CEDAR:
R •H INSULATION
~PATCH WALL AS NEEDED
12' ATRIUM DOOR WI
CUSTOM WINDOW ABOVE
SEE ELEVATION
.EXISTING WINDOW
3•--1~ 1'-s· 8'-11" u·-, 11:2~ 11'-3~
19'-S" 2''-"t 112·
"f:2'-5 1/2"
(.). zo -> (/) _J;;
a:: CD n
w <( l() :r: I--l() I--_,. ...-0....... ...-
a::~ z n
CD<(:;EN I z3: .f.D
-<( I' 0 . I---'-z W <"
W..-Nr-..
NN>-N
<( ,tj-<(.,...
LL..-S:~
Ck'. <, w t<)
_J l..fl
IJWl..fl zZ
w<C -lz
!!! Ir:: zu .
Z(k'.<(
a::: 0-1-
0 !OCO<(
LL-()~
~ 0*<(
..J W (<)3
0...
z
()
i=" _()
01 o::....
<( II
o·~ wooo-"-(J)-
Ow c<i
Q__j-
O<C>--
Ck'. 0 <(
Q_ (J) r::
SHEET
3
:i
~
' '>!
r--4
J>()
l\ rn
C/)
~~
-I
1,•-3 1/2"
/
m
()~
0(/l
;z::!
()Z
,oC,
m
-l m
7]
)>
-I
~
RELOCATED 20,0-"1/J.
rn
X
Cui
<::! -z f;e>
iU
0
0
:I
''-1"
EXISTING CONDS.
SCALE 1/8" = 1'-0"
MAY 12, 1993
2-1·-,~
~'-5" ,,_,,,
0: B rn
X
7'iii
=i::!
()Z
IC' 0: rn ;z
g
z z
C,
m
X
arui m-1 Oz:
~c,
0
:I
1·-1~ l"l'-3"
50'-!!"
PLAN FOR:
ED t BONNIE ENGLER
3450 BIRCH LANE
WAYZATA. MN 55391
10'-0" 2·-,·
rn ! X ~ ::Icii
l>-1 (/)-
-lz me,
iU
(Jl m ~ 0 ,-
iU -.
0
:I
"' 1s·-o·
--!
(JI
)>
-I
I
( o]
m
X
arui m-1 q (JI Oz: )> ~" ~ -I
I 0
:I
1-1'-1 112· •l'-10 1/2"
~FAZENDIN BROTHERS INC.
1421 E. WAYZATA BLVD.
WAYZATA, MN 55391
(612) 476-2311
'""'
4·
I lF.slGNEO RY
IIHAWN KT
I I ,(~.
1 CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY FOR
ED ENGLER
.,
IN LOT 18, LYDIARD'S PARK
HENNEPIN COUNTY, MINNESOTA
Luke.
Minnetonka.
41&,,/
'\~ \ // A/
-&J/ \ 4_.,,,, \ . --~--· v-•··· /~'/ \
/
/
/
~.,.,~ ~'+-·/.,,, .\
·,ut.,,, o..!! \ .-,
'-.)/ f ·.. ~·,-: , -• ' "<·
\ \
"<:--~.
/
/
/, /'
/ ... ~ ......
\~
t
I
\ /
• I'\ /.
··~ V
, :' . , ... ~. ·-
]<"<• ··:•
BxistiM ~l Oescr!ption
''•;
That part. of th~ no»tiheaaterfy half c.,f . _a:At;; . )&tc •tydiard! • Park•
Lake Ninnet:onu. •. lying ~t~,ty .o(i♦•·t~ ~•l,tel with and
distant , 97 ~ 5 feet Northweat.er:ly frqa 1:¥.t · •t~i~ lllat;ted li~• .
shown on the_ p14at of ■aid •Lydia~•-. ~'·::t.alte 1Unnetonka, Which
dotted liM ia. drawn at. u an,1.e·:ot·o10: to ti., northea•"rly. ll.ide
line of said lot and interMOta •~d.!:I •~•-·lilMt at a Point distant
8~ feet Noirtllwesterly frOlll the Southe_astely, qorner of· add Lot;
and that part of the South~ter,1.y .balf Qf. •aid ~t l$lying
Northwesterly of a line drawn pa~Uel w1tll uc1·dhtaiit 222 feet
Northwesterly fi:-0111 the base line ae··•hown on the origilial plat!
of •Lydiard'• Park• Laite Minnetonka.· · · · ·
0 I Iron IIUU'ker
Bearings shown are baaed on an a••~ «..tall•
;f'·
'
j, ... /
·. / \ .... / -·~ \ v
\ \-,,..✓
\ \ ,,..✓
\ ·:,,, \ B /· sbn on ,,
' ?q \ ~ "'~ rlrl?,LW· J· d·s Rrk -. ,...-···· kt o Yo"" ·. / .. p ... / \\ \ /
\ / 'j.,/ \ /
\ ,,..✓
/
\ //
V
/
/
REVISIO'-I DA TE I DESCRll'rt< lN
@ )s-11-11 I :;_;;;J"::P~ ,~,,.,~,T;, ~,,..,vAo $ COFFIN & GRONBERG INC.
•. (.· •. ,. 'IL••.l •• t·lt 111·,·•·-· /.11,,111,·,·,, 1.111/d )l<l'i'l'lltl! ,, Silt' 1'/,111111'1' I --··--·:·•-•·-·I.--···•--·...:----•-·---··•----------.a..-,···-------~-----
.1~ 2 l.1111,1r,1<l .-\n IHI\' • l.1>11g L1k /\1\: '1'is~i,
/,12-171-1111
I ht•rt+.\ 1 l'rhfy th.ll th,, "iUr\ ,·y w,,, pnip.ut>d \1\· mt• or undl'r m.\ dirt•d ... upt.•r·
vision, and that I am a duly registered Civil Engineer and Land Surveyor under
the laws of thr Stat,, ,,f Minnr,ut.a
?b ,.,./ .,.,, , . _______ L~:L_ ~-,::&!·~1~:5f~-
Mark S Cronb.•rK \tinne,ot,1 L,renst• .\J11mbt>r .f!'755
SCALF
I"= 20'
DATE
3-lq .q3
IOB NO.
93-85
/. -C £J €° IV C:. .l f" I~
HARDCOVER CALCULATION WORKSHEET
SETBACK ZONE: (c IR CLE· ONE) @ 75-250' 250-500' 500-1000'
EXISTING HARDCOVER IN ZoNE
. ·,:.. ..... .. -~.':' •·
A , · Hou s E __ 2_2._~·...;.-s__ x __ s....;...;. o;._.1_t/....:c:_ = __ ....;/;..../___;.1/__ s , F,
LENGTH WIDTH
X ______ = SF
------O· I
8'. o · . -X 5. 7 = 1/ b s F ...;.___..::~------~=---·''
-----'--x· ______ = _____ _ S,F,
______ X ______ = ______ SF
' '
B, GARAGE ______ x _____ _ = ------S,F,
I ~ ,,.,
C, DRIVEWAY _____ X ______ = _____ _ S,F,
------X ------= ------s IF I
D,. SIDEWALK _____ X ______ = ---,-----_,, S,F,
------X ------= ------s IF I ...
~./7'/t::> '2.v, I x
E, PATIO/-. __ _.;;..;~;...._-
3. o ✓vC = 60 ___ ...:;__;;__ S,F,
DEcK · l ....
------X --------· --------s IF'
FI LANDSCAPE
AREAS
UNDERLAIN
21 X ___ 3_._o __ = ____ 7_2..~-s , F,
BY ______ X ______ = ______ s, F,
P LAST I'C-.• ··-.. ·~··
SHEETING ''
_____ ....;.;.·· X ______ = ______ S, F,
<ftc<'k wAlL //. '/ . )( 0. ( 7 ~
/--a ;:f Ft:1tV'€ X ------____ S__;;;;.3 __ S • F •
G, OTHER X ------= ------s ,FI
,,,
TOTAL HARDCOVER IN ZONE __ ___..;.J'_.5_"3_ S, F, . m
ToTAL ~ROPERTY AREA lK ZONE 7S'(O t S, F ,· [il
0 S 53 ·-;-m 751/o X 100 = _..:.4-"..;.-~6"...;;;8~-%
..........
1) /(f1t1C,~·( ,f'P<'K //t,.Af"rJC = 72. 35.f-/32 -:: 2 21 .-! .. ~S''(t),:: 2, ~.9 ';I,:, ···-········' . _ .. •·-, ..• ,-1-·
Y-JJ-93 ·--....__
2) /<(M(lV€ C'tJ/4/C. /J,(rl() : <(0 ....... ···-·------------------------/32.
A.r,'1.::
HARDCOVER CALCULATION WORKSHEET
SETBACK ZONE: (CIRCLE· ONE) 0-75' ~ 250-500' 500-1000'
EXISTING ·HARDCOVER I~ ZONE
. ·.: ~ .... -::.1:' .
A I • HOUSE
0 -75
_ /N ,,; . .
51. 0 · X ---=2_2~-__.f'----
LENGTH WIDTH
/01/<j S,F,
(.3 x· /.3 .... .. ·g. ___ __;;__ S,F, /S-97
/0./ -x ··,· 1/. <J = ---~1/~?_.S,F,
. 2. l/. C x· /9, 9 5 l(IIC = '-I '7 I -,---~-S,F,
---~-X ______ = ______ SF ••
•;, Ii, t,••
B, GARAGE 1/th 6' X ---=-2_;_7'.,;._;. 'It..--_ = , 9 9 I · s --~:__:_-,F,
C, DRIVEWAY _____ X ______ = ___ l_?.:;_o'..;;:..O_ S ,F, ·
C~I(,/('. JJ,tl) X = 7 ------------______ S,F,
D,. SIDEWALK _____ ·X -,...-----= 71/2-S,F,·
------X -----= _____ S,F,
. . •
b / ------X _____ = _____ S,F,
E, ATIO . ECK . , .. "
------X ______ -.... · _____ S,F,
. -
F,lANDSCAPE _.;.. ____ X, _ ___,.; ___ = ______ ?_s_o_ S,F,
AREAS
UNDERLAIN
BY •. I -,----_..;..-X -----= ------s. F, PLASTI'C" -·•-.. · ·~" . .
SHEETING /-v<"(.~.dl.l . ...,__ _____ X _____ = _____ S,F,
------X -----
_____ S,F,
1--cA CFrtP;V<c'
G, OTHER
s~ _____ X _____ = _____ 9,F,
'· ...
ToTAL HARDCOVER IN ZoNE
ToTAL. PROPERTY AREA Ht ZoNE
0 6:t ? c;' .. : m / 1// () ?a
...... ,,.. . '··'
6/<f.5' S,F, [I]
/'ttt:)9~ S,F, [il
X 100 =
. . ·l,11~
(JJ'5 f 6.r.5 -·70/:: 6tl
••·•-·······. . .
1-,{ 3 5
I
I
I
h.
/CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY
, ,·
\
' >'. 1...-.......... -r-,,. .,..... \
\
' "' 0 :...-
\
' \
\
.. ·•-;'
J ft ti-~ ~.rj k f,
nt ~~ --· ~,1(,....,,
t!Jfft-Z..)
~f i' ':,~'><.,_.,./ ti' ·~~ \:) [Ii,
:t.;}~.il'
Q ~· ~,·,,.
I .· 0 ' . .
' ·.
€1<ur.
H1111,,.,,-
.,
>.-fc•"'c WALk°
,.,.1tf!,,, ,,...-
,C. ._r:,,-
;'Of'~,,,,,
....... ✓
LEGAL PESCRJPTION
LOT ~ LOMA LINPA1 Hl!Hlll!'!'IN C"VNTf;
MtllAllf;oTA.
AREA
,1 9S0! S~-FT
p -------R , Eo~ C J t
SURVEYS
I NC. --\
~ 1r , \
/
-i.. t'"=zo 1
,
I
I
IJ.S±l.._ .... ....
Lil /{g
. /"'11#' .#lii"tvKA
WA7''1'tf Et.~V/IT!IN 'JZ 9-7?.-
' S-Jb·9.3
e ltfo ,v r"vfeJJ
KIM A. REAUME
REGISTERED
LAND SURVEYOR
612-542-9559
413 HOPKINS CROSSROAD
MINNETONKA, MINNESOTA
55343
BOOK PAGE
le -, ' WER\:"RY <"ERTTf:'V "'H'.,.. ..-µre:; c-r·R··::-\· ' l . 4 'L ~ \_. l 1 ... ~ ~ -~ l • ' ... ._ .) -l ' •..• ,
PLA~. OR REPORT WAS PRE?ARED BY ~E
PROJECT NO. SHEET OR UNDER MY DIRECT .Sl'PER\'JSIO'.'J A'.'JC
■ ':},3042.C... THAT I A:vt A DULY REGISTEPF.D !"A'.\/D
• SCRVEYOR UNDER THE LAWS OF ~HE
REVISIONS STATE OF ~INNESOTA.
A:C:..,.~
DATE f"-11-,3 REG. NO. 19522
•··-c•, , •. ., ... ...,. .... ,.-1c • ~ ........ 1 ·~,··· ~ .... ••v • ,~.,,. ... ~,-,,~..-•A'<l"'•'!---r,r,-•~-:. •',!If'!":' '.-;,~,·--1·-n <r·Tr.;rnt'l~1'"~·-;·; .-,·,:r-··-;;~_-: :·-~:-:-•,_":"'';-.. -..T,;::·;·.1:,1•·· ,·,·•:,·~·-... ~-:;.-.;,~r•--r.~ ;· :;-:··..., .. "
~
September 16, 1981
Hr. Kenton Carlson
3498 North Shore Drive
Wayzata, MN 55391
CITY
o,, th,· .V,irth Short' of l,akt' Mmnc-tonka
Re: 3450 Birch Lane -Complaint
Dear Hr. Carlson:
This letter is to acknowledge receipt of your complaint letter
dated September 15, 1981.
)N()I
I met with Mr. Paul Kempf at the site of the garage construction
this morning. I provided him a copy of your letter. We discussed
your concerns. He said that you had also visited him yesterday
about the matter.
It is our opinion that the nature and direction of drainage has
not been altered by this project. I agree that somewhat more
runoff may occur because of increased hardcover. However, Kr.
Kempf's project is within the allowable hardcover regulations of
the zoning code. I have no way to deny him thia construction.
There is no local ordinance or statute requiring redirection of
the water. The lay of the land is such that the natural flow from
the east side ot Kempf's lot is toward Birch Lane.
As I said to you yesterday, I feel that my office has properly
reviewed this construction for hardcover and drain4qe. A valid
permit has been issued. I have told Mr. Kempf thac he may proceed
with construction including replacement of the pavi,i'J in ft:oAt of
the garage doors.
I understand your very real problem wi.th flooding and excaaa runoff.
I do sympathize with you and l do want to help you and yow: ~ually
effected neighbors. However, Mr. Kempf'• project ia not the aole
cause of your problem and he can not be expected to defer pet'fflitt.ed
improvements because of a neighborhood-wide problem.
tat:IU>l""AilU!lilWi ,nun •
,i.st~'W.
\
!
t
' l ,,
;;:
H u
!II
$
;
' <
f
(
I
Kenton ClU"hOn
Page 2
Mr. carl1on, aa I aaid to you yoaterday, y~ur •~lution is to
requeat and initiate a atorm-sewor/drainaga i~provement project.
Only in thi• way can the City help you aolve the neighborhood
flooding. A proper engineering review ia required, followed
by any necea1ary phyaical conatruction or alteration. The coat
of this improvement would be aaaesaed to all the propartiea
contributing to tho runoff, not juat tho•• affected by the
flooding.
Please understand, this is not a way for me or the City to
dodge any responsibility. A formal improvement project is
the onlfui mechanism we have for h~lping to correct the problem.
Let me ow if and when you wish to get thi• underway.
Sinc;~rely, /I ,•1· ~ ,c,:.:._
, P. """'olaon
y ~1a.nner
cc: W~lter R. Benson
John R. Gerhardson
City Council
Paul Kempf
,··,,
'i,'
~.·
_.•'\
>-.:
t
I
\~
/
\ /
•I\ / ~ V Jv/
6 of6 ~Q.1
Page #lt:50
Appraisal/Consultation
Valuation
Litigation Testimony
Market Reports
Feasibility Studies
Tax Analysis
Finance
Mortgage Loans
Institutional Sales
Portfolio Review
Mortgage Servicing
· Prop erty Ma nagem ent
Marketing/Leasing,
Tenant Relations,
Accounting/Budgeting and
Operations/Engineering
Asset Management
Receiver Capabili/ies
Construction Management
Research
Market Inventory
Vacancy and Absorption
Construc tion Updates
Sales and Le as ing
Brokerage Services:
Office, Retail, Apartment
Land and Industrial
Tenant Representation
REO Disposition
Investment Sales
Sale/Leasebacks
Exchanges
May 24, 1993
Ms. Jeanne Mabusth
Building and Zoning Administrator
City of Orono
P.O. Box 66
Crystal Bay, MN 55323 If, t:T.
Dear Jeanne:
Writer's Direct Dial Number
(612) 347-9347
Thanks for your courtesy in discussing my variance request for 3450 Birch Lane this
past Monday, I enjoyed our conversation.
As per our conversation, this letter is to request, that barring any unforseen problems
that you and/or the planning commission may find, we would appreciate it very much
if we could be placed on the June 28 council agenda for the following reason. My wife
and I are expecting our third child in September, and we would like at least the
opportunity and/or possibility to complete this work by that time.
Consequently, it is imperative that we begin working on our project no later than the
first week of July.
Once again I enjoyed our conversation and look forward to both meeting and working
with you in the near future to bring my request to a successful conclusion for both
myself and the City of Orono.
-;
l C '--;_-_ )
~~~
Ed and Bonnie Engler
ERE:dkp
i:mabusth.ere
Towle Real Estate Company
330 Second Avenue South, Suite 800
Minneapolis, MN 55401
Telephone (612) 341-4444
Facsimile (612) 347-9389
Owner/Member
Colliers International
Property Consultants
~_A/1'}1 -. ()
~ l}j l..~ I".-,. -/J
r
.-' . 1--/?_.'
' --_, I /5. ~
I ,
1il ~ {2~~. ~ I
I
r,, ! h.---1 -__ . C.i
6--,,_
0 ~ .-r---!/_. & b ~v~ <
"'1,--~co
n~.--J-'13. £-'j ~ ¥3 . ¥.3
.
I
I
I
:
I
I
/ ./
'\~ /
\ Q.C\_.: .. , / \ // \/
,,/ \
\
\
\
. ..,. . \ .
/
/
f, .. 0.. . \c~.
o I\', . ' -. .. ·, .
/
/
/
/
~ ,·'•, , ' , ' ' \
.'. :
' I .,
/·'.
,.
~//\
' \
·\~
·\
l-;
\h,·
' ~
½ ~ ·15:
t
N
\ .\
_,,/
/
\ ·!\ / ~ v,....,,
jv/
\ v '\-// . \ / \ /
"''\'" ;,, \ / B /· shown on 11 ,:·. , ·:. '?" . \ ""· .,e '"' .. L"' d. J, R,.k
I • ✓ ·----j t of v lur S ,, / p~ /
' \ //
\ )-"/
' "Lydiiu:d'~ ,4rt·11 1
pataftel wftifr , ~nd . .,
.i;lin ~<it.'t~4 1'.l'ne , ": .' <
> • ' 4 ' ' '~ ' ~ I • . ' '' ' ' ' ?1i nn~tonlt,-, . whl•c:l\: :i , · · .,_. ·1,. •
n6~1;1l~a'st~frly ···-.i:ae ·.-, :·.. .· '.· ....
'at ~ p9int .'-<;1iitant /t 1;. :• r
ner of(sa;lcr ~ti :·· ',;; , , . : .. ·,
Lot i&: l¥~n,{' ~-, ·' : _:.; ·. _:/ ~:...
di._sta~t 22~ .·~e•~ :-.V/ / :::·'it.: . :[" i"' l ' ·ii' .. .,~. r!:,,. 'I}., or g "'" ,,.:Ji>,&:a,.'"', ,. ' ,·\ •f,!l''· ;,(,.,u;i.;''' ,. ' ' ' ' ' ;, ·:{:·}\ ~7 '.
I ,, I, . •
' I
. . ' : ~ ',1 ',M,/.{, _; , .. _''
r : ·, '' 11 ;,t ·,~~•1,,. 1 1 , 1
.. i ·.· . .-, ··: .. : .. :1.-::-:/. ;~~;1~;~:: .. :H~.:-.,··
\\ /
\ ,,,..,✓
\ /
\ /
V
/
/
/
#
p~ Q rr r
·i· ~:\,,i","'', . -~-;i it~,-'4:.~ ~ -~~ .. ,
{ ~ t ~
( .. JI.-.
,t•~oyo.;-~•1•"·.
u•1n
.4'
DESK;NE[) RY
IIHAWNB'r
~ f !'( ~-
CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY FOR
ED ENGLER
'
IN LOT 18, LYDIARD'S PARK
HENNEPIN COUNTY, MINNESOTA
L"ke.
Mi~t;nk~
41&,,."' a.'\;, \ /'
),__"'
,d;J/ \
<$ / \ ,_.-e J\,, ~,:,.,-, \ \t;' \(-0 . /,
/
/
/
~ .. ~ ~~-/ \ /ilJ ,,,.. / . \ ·",tu,,,,, t)~
"Ill ,,.l~/ \ -,
: / f • . \\,P
; \
.. : .. -~
/
/
/
/
/
, -.. ~
\~
t
I
\ .... / ''z-\\ )✓'
\ /
• I'\ /' •~ V . j.,.✓
• .. :;{~-.,!!;·::-
Bxiating 1'!1 Description
•.•,.
That part of the. no»tib.aaterl.y half of. r4t;;. J&1-•,i.ydiard! • Park•
Lake Ninnet:cmlca, lying ncnt~Jl' .ol,:••U.-~at1,1e1 with and
distant 197.:5 feet Northweste.r:l.y frqm ~~'..-~i~ ~t;ted li~e
shown on the plJat of aaid •~diaJ.)t.,.•. ~"~tab JU.nnei;oi'llca, Which
dotted line la. drawn at. U anfla''of• ·••: .to t .. nortuasterly. aide
line of said lot atid int:erffClt:a a,i!.1 •U•-·li-. at a p0int distant
85 feet Nol'tbweaterly froa the Southe_aatei:r, corner of said Lot;
and that part of the South~ter:i,y .half e>t,,aaidL9t l&.1¥ing
Northwesterly of .-line drawn pa~ll•l wiU. ud diataiit 222 feet
Northwesterly from the base line ••·· e!,own on th• origiAaI plat!
of "Lydiard'a Park" Lake Minnetonka. ' ·
01 Iron marker
Bearings ■hown are baaed on an•••~ «.t1211
~·
' Jc-.:.·
·. /
\ /
' \ \ // -
, ~q \ ,,-,( B..,e lrirll!,Las· f-=;,
5
Rrk" , v .... l.t o yc,tar \ / ~
\ ·.. ✓-✓
\... ' / \ \j.,/ \ /
\ ,,,,✓
\ /
\ /
V
/
/
/
REVIS!Ot,; DATE iJESCRll'Tl<lN
@ f,Yl-t,,., ,t,J', ,~_,".,._~/ , ,(("l"f#l/14(,J
S·/l· 1J I ,.,,,,,,,..H>! ($-COFFIN & GRONBERG INC. •· 1.:,,,,.,,11,,,, I,,.,,,,,.,.,_, I"'"/ ;,,,.,.,,,,,, Sit,· !'/,,,,,,,.,, --· ·-•·.•-•·---~---···--...:----.--.-..-, --·-·----·-·--~--•·•-·-----------
.\S~ l.1111.1r,11k .•\1·,·m1t• • l.,,ng L1k,,, \I\:'>;~:,,,
1,12. i:·1 .. 1111
I hl'rl+~ \ l'rt1iy th.1t thi, sun t·~· w,1., f*TMt•d t,~· mt• or unJt•r m~ din•(f ,uper·
~ision. and lhal I dm a July regi~lerl'd Civil E_ngineer and Land Surveyor under
the laws of 1hr State of MinnPsola
. .»-..,,,/ '"'/. ---.----L~_L4.._~,a..,. ~.e.--~·
Mark S Gmnllt'rl( Minnesol,, Licenst" N1,1mbt'r ffl55
5CAl.f
I"= 20' -DATE
3·1'i-q3
IOBNO.
93-8!>
Luke
Mnw,tonl<a.
Bxbttnq wpl Oeacrf:ption
CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY FOR
ED ENGLER
IN LDT 18, LYDIARD'S PARK
HENNEPIN COUNTY, MINNESOTA
'l'hat pan of the na6tl:beaate.rl.y half of ~ .,a. •.t.yd.iard~• .P•~k•
wk• Ni-, lyin9 -ly _oi ►t"'4i panllol vith and
dbt..nt ) 97. 5 f .. t Hiortln,,esit.er1y trqa ta.1:t 'oat.ia 1¥1:tted line ■bovn oo tbe plat of Mid •Lydiai,t•• ~":1-a)ta llinnetonka, Vhicb
4ott .. line 'ia drawn •~ u -,-1.e·Of-el• to t~ nGrtlMtaeterly. aide
line of NMI lot and intarMcrt:• ••i~ 1U.. li .. at a Point dista.nt
15 t .. t Nottbweaterly frGa the So11thean.ely. corner of aaid Lot 1
:~e!!~i; :: !h11!:u:::t;!!!1~f w%f... 9:fi: ~!t!ft 1 J~29 feet
llortb-..aaterly froa tb.e b.a•• line u · allolm OIi thtl ori9i~I plat' ot •t,ydiard'• Park'" Lake Minnet0D.ka. ·
oi Iron aark•r
Bearings shown are baa--2 on.· fin ■HWlliltd U'cc:a
., .. ,-.,,,,.,.,,.' ~ ,,, ... .,,,
.f·/1,,J ---;~ _ fl!;:-~ ~?.1~1~0•~~9.~?,~.~~~~~,,: I~~~: w-,(, l11n,11t1\ \111Hh. l,1ngl,1kt ~1'\i-,~,f;
til.2 l 1 11 ll
t
i
1*~:1~20·
DA11"
3•1i-qJ
""'"' 'l:l-85"
CITY OF ORONO -NOTICE
The Planning Commission will hold public hearings in the Council Chambers at 2780 Kelley
• Parkway on Monday, June 21, 1993 for the purpose of reviewing the following land use
applications:
1. #1830 Richard F. Oorlog of 1058 Laina Linda Avenue , seeks approval of hardcover
variances for improvements proposed within the 0-75 ' and 250-500' setback area and an
average lakeshore setback and lakeshore setback variances for proposed additions to the
lakeside of the existing residence.
2 . #1831 Edward Engler of 3450 Birch Lane seeks approval of a hardcover variance within
the 75-250 ' setback zone for structural additions to the existing residence.
3. #1832 Scott A. Mabusth of 740 North Brown Road seeks approval of a setback variance
to allow an accessory structure to be placed in front of the front line of the existing
principal residence .
4. #1833 Laurence Elsen of 2879 Casco Point Road seeks approval of hardcover and street
setback variances for a proposed addition to the existing residence .
5 . #1834 Mary K. McCarty seeks approval of lot width and area variances for the purpose
of constructing a new residence on the property located at 245 Tonka Avenue .
6. #1835 David and Ellen Phelps of 1950 Fox Ridge Road seek approval of a front/street
setback variance for a proposed garage addition .
7. #1836 Ronald D. Lauer seeks approval of an average lakeshore setback, lakeshore
setback and hardcover variances within the 0-7 5' setback zone for a second story
bedroom addition to be installed over the existing residence of the property located at
1180 Tonkawa Road.
8. #1837 Cindy Fredrickson of 1516 Long Lake Boulevard seeks approval of rear , side
and hardcover variances to permit installation of a new detached garage. The detached
garage will also require a structural separation setback variance. The structure will be
placed less than 10' from existing residence .
9. #1838 Robert H. Owens of 1700 Bohn's Point Road seeks approval of land alterations
within the 0-75' setback zone of his property that would involve the installation of two
tiers of retaining wall to restore and retain eroding bank.
10. #1839 Robert H . Owens of 1700 Bo'1n 's Point Road seeks approval of hardcover
variances in the 75-250 ' setback area for structural additions to the existing residence.
All persons wishing to be heard will appear at this time. Written comments are solicited. Plans
are available in the City offices for review, by appointment.
City of Orono
By: Planning Commission
Jeaphe A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator
To be published the week of June 7, 1993.
Affidavit of Publication
State of Minnesota, County of Hennepin.
Bill Holm, being duly sworn· on oath, says thal he is
an authorized agent and employee of the publisher
of the newspaper known as THE LAKER, Mound,
Minnesota, and has lull knowledge of the facts
which are stated below:
~·-· · ' I \ I • -
,
i :A.) The newspaper has complied with all the
requirements constituting qualifications as a
qualified newspaper, as provided by Minnesota
Statute 331A.02, 331A.07, and other applicable
laws, as amended .
f 11 ;··1: ,l ; : '!' '1 •.J
.
CITY _OF _ORONO-NOTIC_E .. ' , .,,,·, approval of an 11verage lakeshore setback , B) Tile prlntod
lakeshore setback and hardcover variances •
The
0
Planning :Corpmis.slon --wili 'fioic/ .. . with in' .the 0-75 ' setback ione for a second
public hearings in the ·council Chambers al, : · story bedroom addition to be installed over the·'.
. bill w ri!u~J
2780 .Kelley Parkway .on . Monday, ,June 2h , existing residence of the property located at __________________ .;__ ___ _
1993 for the purpose of ·reviewing ·· the 1180 Tonkawa Road.· '• · ' I ' · • ~ · ·
fo llowing land use applications :~i; ) ·,' ·!,,· ,,)·1 '. :· . 8 ,,.#1837 ,Cindy Fredrickson ·of , 1516 " which is attached was cut from the columns of said
1 . # 1830 Richard . F. ,Oorlog of 1058 Long Lake Boulevard seeks approval of rear,
Loma Linda Avenue,,'seeks approval of side · ahd hardcover variances :_10 permit newspaper, and was printed and published once
hardcover 1/var iance si; fol ·· improvements 1nstallat1on of a new detached garage. The /
proposed within the 0-75' and 250_-500' detached garage will also require a structural. each week for _ __, ____ successive weeks:
setback ', area and • an average ·· Iakeshore' separatio n setback ·variance :The $tn.icture will '
setback and lake shore ,setback• variances · for . be . placed , less I tpan 1 O'.,. frnm , ~xi sting
pr<;>p osed , add i tions '"-lCJ r t_tJq d a~~~i _de .o,f 1 ~h-~; .residence.. •., 1 ; , ;-.,I . . , ,: ,,. , •
exIstIn g res idenc e. 'I\· .. •. · · i , · · · 9 . #1838 Robert" H. Owens of 1700
2 . #1831 Edw ard '·Engler 'of" 3450 Birch' Bohn's Po in t Rciad ,.seeks 'apprbval of land I
Lane seeks approva l of" a hardcover variance alterations with in the 0-75' setback zone of his
within the 75-250' setback zone for structural property that would , involve.,.the In stallation of .
addi tions to the existing residence . . two tier_s of ,retai_ning ','/BIi , to restore. arid ret<!in)
3. #1832 Scott -A, Mabustt) of 74Q No"hh i;;roding bahk . 1; 1!" '-· t,~ •i, '-•.rr,( ,\·,.w· :"H ·.-: •:: '
Brown Road · seeks approval of • a setback ~-!:': 1q:•#J839 ;Fjober f ,H (civie~iV of i1oo .
variance to allo:,v an accessory structure to be Bohn's 1 Point•'; Abad X,seeks ' ·.approval : of
placed in front bf the fron,t ,line: of the ,existing , hardcover ' .variarices in the', 75-250:· setback .
principal residence. , . ,: , . . · ,' , 1 ,, , are.a· for S_l(~CJ_~ral: ??di!i~ns;i,to ,th_f :existing ,
4. #1833 Laurence Elsen of 2879 ·Casco re~1~ence ,-,· .. J! .. •:•, ;: .. ·. · .. ·,, .·. Ji :: .. ..-J. : ·-'. ,
Point Road seeks apprQval , of hardcover and ll('~i:-All ,persons wishing to ,be ,:,heard Will .
street setback var iances Jo(. a proposed, appear · at" this t_ime. Written ·: comments a're
addition to the exi st ing residence. '· '·:,':-''•' ··,:. solicited ; Plans are available In the City olllces ·
· 5 . #1 834 Mary , K. McCarty ,,:seeks' .. fcir.re.viewr,by. appoin\ment. ·· {: }!\',' ii•, 'f. ·.
approval of lot width ,and area ,variances ,for . ii:.:'.f•'rl /', :N'.I (,:. -~;~;1,';~C~,('.\,_:::'.:/i'. '. 1:. ' , :
the purpose of consiructing a ·new reslqence '. C1tyiof9(or:\o _:.-;"i'i 1~ •. : _li:;4:. :,:,/.\'' ;: 1: • 1• . ·. ,
on the property located ·_at 245 Tonka Avenue'.(~. By ~_8.l11n.~ing ~op1mi~,si<:>r.,t:.~,1;-,1-;.·:_'.'-l•,, , ,,: ..
. 6. #1835 David arid Ellen Phelps of 1950 ,. t'= v-1~·~-1.,\k ,.r,l.1•i' ,r:.'r •. ,;,:,, '. -.,. , ·
Fox Ridge '; Road · seek , fapproval,: .of :a 1 .,•t~·1 .. 1~ 1 'i'., ,i'.-•'";1.:JeanneA. Mabusth ,,
fronVstreet setback variance for a prop·osed -~\\ . · Building _8,Zon jhg Adminis _trator. I
garage addition .. , -~ •. ,:~ ·,. H ,,~-, ; i ''.· :, , : (Publ ished in Th~ Laker and Pioneer June 1,
7. ,#1836 Ronald D . Lauer!(seeks
. •1 "' r' I ; ' rl I
II was first published Monday,
the · J 1/z day of_~~--19173 I
and was thereafter pri led and published every
Monday, to and Including Monday,
the ___ day of · 19 __ ,
&Jtj{c;
Authorized Agent
Subscribed and sworn to me on this
By:
. ' KRISTI HOLM.
NOTARY PUBLIC • MINNESOTA
HENNEPIN COUNTY
• M:mmrmrefflf!ittori 0-91
~
-r,,~ oo-• ~la(Y.lPublic
( 1} ~ W1lmlassll~'Rlt8' paid •by-comrrierc:i:il users
for comparable space: $10.76 per Inch.
(2) Maximum rate allowed by law for above matter: $10.76.
(3) Rate actually charged for above matter: $5.98 per Inch.
Each additional successive week: $4.12.
CERTIFICATE OF MAILING
STATE OF MINNESOTA
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ss.
CITY OF ORONO
I, Jamie Bosma, of the City of Orono, Hennepin County,
Minnesota, do hereby certify that a Notice of Public Hearing
concerning the matter of #1831, was mailed to the attached
list of property owners.
In Witness Whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and seal
this 4th day of June, 1993.
Jam~
,.
1
DATA PRIVACY ADVISORY
In accordance with M.S. 13.04, Subd. 2, "Rights of subjects of
data", we would like to inform you that your request for a permit or
license from the City of Orono or any of its departments may require
you to furnish certain private or confidential information.
-~ou are notified that: .. ~ ..... .-_.
1. The information you furnish will be used to determine your
qualification for the permit or license requested.
2. You may refuse to supply data, but refusal may require that
the City deny the permit or license.
3. The information may be shared with other local, state or
federal agencies to the extent necessary to process the permit or
license.
4. If your requested permit or license requires Council action
to approve, some information may become public .
5. You have certain rights under M.S. 13.04 to review private
data on yourself.
6. Your full name is required to process this application or
permit.
First Middle Last
Address
City ' State
Phone
I understand my righ s as stated above .
l t