The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutProject PacketMINUTES OF A REGULAR ORONO COUNCIL MEETING HELD JUNE 14, 1993 (#7) #1824 ERIC & SHELLY LILJEQUIST, 3490 BIRCH LANE -VARIANCE -RESOLUTION #3288 It was moved by Goe t ten, seconded by Ke I I ey, to adopt Reso I u ti on #3288 for Application #1824 Eric and Shelly Li ljequist, 3490 Birch Lane, approving a rear yard setback to permit the construction of a detached garage. Ayes 3 , nays 0. (#8) #1825 THOMAS L . MCCARTHY, 2490 OLD BEACH ROAD -PRELIMINARY SUBDIVISION Thomas McCarthy and Mark Gronberg were present. Mabusth explained this is a request for a 2 lot subdivision within the LR-18 1 acre zoning district. The applicant has proposed two options: 1) to create an easement through Lot 2 for access to Lot 1 which would reduce an area variance and would not be acceptable; and 2) access via a pla t ted corridor. She e x plained under the former ordinance , the lot width would have been measured at the 35' rear/street setback and 75' lakeshore setback and the property cou Id not have been deve I oped as a f I ag I ot due to the I ack of width at the 30' setback. The current ordinance a I I ows for the I ot width to be measured at the shore I ine and the 75' setback. She indicated the Planning Commission was asked to consider the combination of zones 75-250' and 250-500' with regard to hardcover to compensate for the excess hardcover within the platted corridor. The app I i cation . was denied based upon the excess of hardcover within the 250-500' zone. Gronberg suggested the recent Lund application was very similar in that there was an overage of hardcover within one zone and a shortage in another, and Counci I was asked to consider the property as a whole. He suggested the platted corridor be maintained at 27' wide , but the paved surf ace be reduced to 8' wide, thereby maintaining the al lowed 30% in that zone. However, this would create an undesirable looking lot. McCarthy noted the 2-way travel led road currently used in the Shore Hi I Is neighborhood is reduced to 10' wide in some areas. Goetten felt the subdiv i sion should meet the 1 acre standard exclusive of the roadway area. Kelley stated he is not in favor of the subdivision, but if it meets al I the standards, he would vote for it. Goetten felt if they were creating an unsafe drive, that would be grounds to deny the appl i cation . She stated the Lund application was dissimilar due to the size of the property. · 8 CITY OF ORONO P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 473-7357 APPLICATION NO. #1824 NOTICE OF COUNCIL ACTION Date of Notice: June 15, 1993 ------------------------------------------------------------------ TO: Mr. & Mrs. Eric Liljequist 3490 Birch Lane Orono, MN 55391 ------------------------------------------------------ TYPE OF APPLICATION: Variance ----------------------------------------------------------------- DATE OF MEETING: June 14, 1993 VOTE: 4 FOR 0 AGAINST ----------------------------------------------------------------- COUNCIL ACTION -MOTION: To approve per the findings and conditions of the resolution previously mailed to you. Variance approval is limited to the extent shown on approved plan and as noted in the approval resolution. Changes in approved plans are subject to further review by the City. Variance approval expires one year after date of approval. Permit application must be submitted no later than June 14, 1994. Please note that all persons with an interest in the property must sign off on the resolution. lsv TO: Mayor Callahan and Orono Council Members Ron Moorse, City Administrator FROM: Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator DATE: June 8, 1993 SUBJECT: #1824 Eric and Shelly Liljequist, 3490 Birch Lane -Variance -Resolution Additional Exhibits I -Gustafson Report 5/17 /93 J -1-3 Options for Consideration K -Gustafson Report 6/4/93 Brief Review of Application Applicants propose the removal of an existing single stall garage and replacement with a two stall 24'x24' detached garage. Staff noted in a recent inspection with the City Engineer that applicants had already obtained a demolition permit and removed the former garage. The former garage was located 20' from the street lot line. The proposed garage shall be located 15' and 10' from the side lot line where the former structure was 1 '2". Applicants note that the garage with doors facing onto the street could not meet the 30' setback without requiring the removal of several mature trees. The 10' separation could not be maintained from the principal structure and the proposal would result in excessive hardcover. If the garage was to be placed with doors facing away from the street lot line a mature maple tree would be lost and once again excessive hardcover would result. The major concern for the review was how to achieve safe access onto the adjacent public roadways as property is located at a intersection of three roadways. Birch Lane has a 20' wide right-of-way but measures no more than 14" in width. Applicants' lot is across the street from two homes who park vehicles or boats right at the edge of the roadway providing limited space to maneuver out onto the road. Applicants' original proposal, Exhibit H, proved to be the most efficient access alternative for the site. After a site inspection the City Engineer, review Exhibit K, concurred that three options presented in his report proved to be less functional than the garage and driveway layout presented by applicants. The Planning Commission recommended unanimous approval of the variance application for a street setback variance of 15' for a proposed 24'x24' detached garage and adopted the applicants' hardship statement and added the following: 1. Existing pattern of development along the severely restricted roadway presents unique access problems for placement of garage and driveway. 2. Proposal results in a reduction of hardcover within the 75-250' setback area. Zoning File #1824 June 8, 1993 Page 2 3. The former garage was located 1 '2" from the side lot line and the proposed garage will meet the required 10' setback. The enclosed approval resolution has been drafted per the findings and conditions set forth in the Planning Commission recommendation. Please review the enclosed information prepared for the Planning Commission review and minutes of May 17th meeting for more background and detail on the review. ch CITY OF ORONO P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 473-7357 ZONING FILE #1824 NOTICE OF PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION DATE OF NOTICE: 5/25/93 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- TO: Eric and Shelly Liljequist 3490 Birch Lane Wayzata, MN 55391 COPIES TO: ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- TYPE OF APPLICATION: Variance --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- DATE OF MEETING: 5/17/93 VOTE: 7 FOR 0 AGAINST Planning Commission recommends the following: The Planning Commission recommended approval of your variance application as proposed in your site plan. The Planning Commission concurs that options 1 and 3 create problems at Birch Lane because of the location of the backout apron and parked vehicles at the Carlson property. Option 2 would assure backing out onto Birch Lane but access to the site was deemed too difficult. It was unfortunate that the City Engineer could not be present to comment on his three options but he will be advised of the concerns expressed by both applicants and Planning Commission members and will respond to these concerns at the Council meeting. Applicant's next scheduled meeting is confirmed as: City Council June 14, 1993, meeting starts at 7:30 p.m. ch MINUTES OF .THE ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING HELD MAY 17, 1993 ZONING FILE #i823 -CONT. Rossing said she would I ike to commence with the addition as soon as possible , but noted she does not want to construct the berm at this time, -but would like perm •ission to place the fill from the addition where the berm would be located. Mabusth clarified that the Planning Commission would like to combine the landsca~rng with this request and that she could not stoc_k pi le fi 11 from construction w i thout a conditional use permit. It was moved by Rowlette, seconded by Peterson, to approve Application #1823 for Marge Rossing, 130 Cygnet Place, for rear and street setback variances to construct an addition to the existing residence, on the hardships that the lot is an unusual shape and the house was constructed prior to adoption of the existing ordinance, subject to the project being staged beginning with the completion of the e x isting detached garage, and second the proposed detached garage be completed prior to commencing with the addition, and a landscape plan to be presented to Council to be completed over the upcoming years, and the driveway boundaries identified .. Ayes 7, nays o. (#6) #1824 ERIC & SHELLY LILJEQUIST, 2490 BIRCH LANE - VARIANCES -PUBLIC HEARING 8:59 -9:18 P.M. The Affidavit of Publication and Certificate of Mai I ing were noted. Mr. and Mrs. Liljequist were present. Mabus th e x p I a i ned the app I i cants seek a street setback variance for a detached garage to be _ located in the street yard of the lakeshore lot. She noted that during the inspection of the property, staff found it necessary to back out onto Baldur Park at the three way intersection, and suggested they need to remedy this situation. The City Engineer has provided three options: 1. a Ii gn the garage and drive with the house; 2. construct the garage so the doors face away from Birch Lane and ang I e the garage a I i gn i ng it with the property boundary; or 3. directly angle the garage toward Birch Lane. Mabusth indicated the applicant has requested hardcover be ke~t t6 a minimum as he wishes to complete future improvements to the house. 9 MINUTES OF THE ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING HELD MAY 17, 1993 ZONING FILE #1824 -CONT. Li 1•jequist reviewed Options #1 and #3 aligning the driveway directly with the drive across the street and.said this is not viable and Option #2 provides for too sharp of a turn into the property. He said with their proposal they can back out onto Birch Lane. Peterson felt Option #2 was the most logical. Liljequist noted with their proposal they would be reducing hardcover to 20%. Mabusth questioned whether the Commission would sacrifice additional hardcover for safety concerns. Rowlette said she would be wi 11 ing to al low an overage of hardcover, but could not assure a future Planning Commission would feel the same way. Li ljequist indicated they· plan to remove the sidewalk and rocks on the property. Rowlette asked how many houses are on Birch Lane, and indicated the majority of the garages on Birch Lane are setback at similar setQacks. Mabusth stated the applicants are also attempting to ma tu re tree. She added she has not received comment neighbors. She indicated a preference to Option #2 hardcover would sti 11 remain below 25%. save the from the and said It was moved by Peterson, seconded by Berg, to recommend approval of Application #1824 for Eric and Shelly Liljequist, 3490 Birch Lane, approving a street setback variance for a detached garage, as presented by the applicants. Ayes 7, nays 0. (#7) #1826 ROBERT & ANN HENSON, 2166 SHADYWOOD ROAD - VARIANCES -PUBLIC HEARING 9:18 -9:54 P.M. The Affidavit of Pub I ication and Certificate of Mai I ing were noted. Mr. and Mrs. Henson and Mark from Triple D, bui Ider, were present. 10 To: From: Date: Mayor Callahan & Orono Councilmembers Orono Planning Commission Members Ron Moorse, City Administrator Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator May 12, 1993 Subject: #1824 Eric & Shelly Liljequist, 3490 Birch Lane -Variance -Public Hearing Zoning District: LR-lC, Lakeshore Residential Zoning District Applicants propose a detached garage within the street yard of their lakeshore property. If garage was placed such that doors faced away from street and a turnaround provided on site, garage could be located 10' from the street lot line. Applicants garage shall have doors facing onto street at a 15' setback. The minimum setback for such garages is 30'. The following ordinances are pertinent for this review: 1. Section 10.03, Subdivision 9 (B) -Detached garage structure. Street setback variance: Required = 30' Proposed = 15' Variance = 15' or 50% 2. Section 10.03, Subdivision 14 ' (C) -Lot coverage review required for all lots under 1. 99 acres. Total lot area = 13,894 s.f. (required = 21,780 s.f. or ½ acre) Allowed = 2,084 s.f. or 15% Existing = 1,162 s.f. or 8.3% Proposed = 1,434 s.f. or 10.3% 3. Section 10.22, Subdivision 2 -Review of hardcover. 0-75' setback area = 3,918 s.f. Existing = 0 % Proposed = 0 % 75-250' setback area = 9,976 s.f. Existing = 2,330 s.f. or 23.36% Proposed = 2,023 s.f. or 20.28% Zoning File #1824 May 12, 1993 Page 2 List of Exhibits A -Application B -Property Owners List C -Plat Map D -Neighbors' Acknowledgement Forms E -Existing Hardcover Fact Sheets F -Proposed Hardcover Fact Sheets G -Elevation/Floor Plans H -Survey Review of Application Applicants propose the removal of the existing single-stall garage and replacement with a two-stall 24' x 24' detached structure relocated 15' from the street line requiring a setback variance of 15'. The existing structure is located 20'. The proposed garage shall be 10' from the side lot line. The existing structure is 1.2'. The adjacent Birch Lane (20') and Baldur Park Road (30') are narrow at width. The existing garage located 20' from the street lot line requires backing out into the street for maneuvering a turnaround. At that specific point, cars can be coming in three different directions requiring special care for maneuvering in the right-of-way. The new garage and drive will provide no improvement in safety. Staff has asked the engineer to review the site plan for any other option that would provide more safety for the applicants who will use the garage and for the public who travel on the adjacent roadways. One may argue that these are low use roadways but during certain peak times, safety may become a major issue. Staff will include any sketches the engineer provides in your final packets to be delivered on Friday or staff will present them at your meeting. Statement of Hardships Please review Exhibit A. Applicant notes hardships as follows: If garage with doors facing onto road met the 30' setback, the 10' separation setback between principal structure and detached structure could not be met. If garage was placed parallel to the street meeting the 10' side setback and 10' street setback, a large tree would need to be removed within the street yard. Both proposals requiring extended drive and turnaround area on the site would result in increases in hardcover. Issues for Consideration 1. Would Planning Commission approve hardcover variances for the purpose of increasing safety? Zoning File #1824 May 12, 1993 Page 3 2. Would members consider granting a side setback variance for a garage with doors facing to the side and turnaround provided on site? Options of Action Approval as proposed, Or Approval as amended, Or Denial. Once again, please refer to Section 10.08, Subdivision 3 (A) (1-12) for the necessary findings for denial. lsv CITY OF ORONO -VARIANCE APPLICATION Initial Application Fee $175.00 ($50.00 per each additional variance) Renewal Variance Fee $100.00 (no change from original application) Variance for non conforming use $200.00 After-the-Fact Fees (Double application PROPERTY INFORMATION Site Address 3490 BIRCH LANE ~·. \, "?,-~.:ii' \ fee) !-. T IV r,r 1i.f..,lffl11! L,,.J, I ! Lll l., .. f\\-11\'L! Property Identif. Number ( P. I . D. ) 08-117-23 43 r:rn;..;.1,-·r: ,-.cn,--r: 1 J. nnrn . .-1-, u1 , .a. 1,..-1.. Attach legal description to application if not iJ~:0200000 # Date ~~~~:~:i ~~q~f;:!r8~8o/~vey. (month/year) CHECK {}i ~fi ~~~:: I (~) (do not) also own the.., adjacent parcels of land. HECEIPT-THA~;\ YQ1/.,-. • .:--:, Present use of property: A residential other ( specif,Jft>60() Co01 l,Vl_ /~~~~~';. Zoning District:___________ ..., . .,_,.,_.,,,,,:; APPLICANT Name ERIC & SHELLY lILJEQUIST Address: 3490 BIRCH LANE OWNER (if different than applicant) Name Address: Phone (home) 612/471-7255 Phone ( work ) 612/872-6500 City: ORONO., MN Zip: 55391 . Phone (home) -------- Phone (work) -------- City: Zip: -------------- DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST Estimated Construction Cost $ 4.,000 ,00 ~~=-'-'"-"'----- Describe request in detail: VARIANCE FOR THE REAR SETBACK AND FOR THE DETACHED GARAGE 30' MINIMLM SETBACK VARIANCES REQUIRED Lot Area X Setback: Lot Width Front Hardcover __ Lot Coverage Side _L Rear __ Average Lakeshore __ Other (specify) __________________________ _ HARDSHIP/DESCRIPTION OF UNUSUAL PROPERTY CONDITIONS Describe undue hardship or practical difficulty and unusual property conditions preventing compliance with Zoning Code requirements: IN ORDER TO ACCOMMODATE A DETACHED GARAGE AT THE 30' MINIMUM SETBACK., THE GA=-RA""""G=E...,..w=o:-:-:-LJLJ) ~&~~~~Nf 1 ~~~ruE A~~§U ~ ~~Ef ~~F~s~ ~~fup~6~c ~Tr ~6~1gE~~~2Ge~~Ty~Ei HrH7SD~ I 2~j~ v ZONE. IF THE GARAGE WAS PLACEDPARALLEL TO THE STREET(DOORS FACING SIDE)@ THE ·10'SETBACK., A I ARGF TRFF WOIII D NFF'D TO BE REMOVED AS WEIL -AS -TNrREASING THE NEED FOR F-17-\RlD[(i)VER :, (attach additional sheets if necessary) REQUIRED SUBMITTALS All of the following information must be submitted by the application deadline date in order for your application to be considered complete: l • ....:ic_Completed Application Form 2. __ X,certified Property Owners List of owners within 150' (you must obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Govt Center 348-3271). 3. X Plat Map (obtained with property owners list). 4._LCertificate of survey (signed by a licensed surveyor) to include hardcover calculations as required (provide one (1) copy 8½"xll" for reproduction) • 5._LTopographic survey (existing and proposed elevations) if any changes in existing grade are proposed (provide one copy 8½:"xll"). 6. X Sketches or plans of floor & elevation views (provide 1 copy 8½"xll"). 7. __ As an addendum to this application, please attach a separate list of any other persons you wish notified of this application. 8. Additional items as may be requested by City staff. The Applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please remember that your variance application is not complete if the above information has not been included. --------------------------------------------------------------------------- APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE The applicant hereby agrees to provide al 1 information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay additional fees (staff time not covered by original fee payment) and/or consultant expenses incurred in review of this application, and certifies that the information supplied is true and correct to the best of his/her knowledge. Applicant's Signature 5--;~---Date ...;;;0....;.4/a..a22='-/=93'--___ _ OWNERS SIGNATURE The owner hereby ackowledges and agrees to this application and further authorizes reasonable entry onto the property by City staff, consultants, agents, Commission members, and Council members for purposes of investiga- tion and verificatio~ of this req~Js/ _ Owner's Signature 5--, Q~~ Date _0_4/_2_2_/9_3 ____ _ Applicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 days before the Planning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission Meetings are held on the third Monday of each month. Applicants must be present at all scheduled review meetings of the Planning Commission and Council. If an applicant is unable to attend a scheduled meeting, please make arrangements to have an authorized agent attend in your place and to advise the Building & Zoning Office of this change prior to the meeting. -- RUN DATE 04/16/93 BATCH 001 PROP ADDR OHNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADDR ONNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADDR Ol'lNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADDR ONNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/AD DR PROP ADDR Ol'lNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADDR Ol'!NER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR 38 08-117-23 43 0001 03470 BIRCH LA .REX EUGENE BOLLINGER JR REX EUGENE BOLLINGER JR 3470 BIRCH L.A WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0004 01444 BALDUR PARK 'RD VIOLET.DEROSIA VIOLET DEROSIA 1444 BALDUR PARK RD WAYZATA MN 55391 38' 08-117-23 43 0008 03510 NORTH SHORE DR D & J SIKKA DALJIT & JASWINDER SIKKA 3510 NORTH SHRE DR WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0013 034.80 NORTH SHORE DR BRUCE A NUSBAUM BRUCE A NUSBAUM 3480 NORTH SHORE DR WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0023 03450 BIRCH LA ER ENGLER & B ENGLER EDWARD R & BONNIE ENGLER 3450 BIRCH LA WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0027 03460 BIRCH LA R WILLIAM TOl~ARD ETAL R WILLIAM TOWARD 3460 BIRCH LA .WAYZATA MN 55391 HENNEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY.OWNERS LIST 38 08-117-23 43 0002 03490 BIRCH LA E LILJEQUIST & S LILJEQUIST ERIC J & SHELLY.R LILJEQUIST 3490 BIRCH LA WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0005 01440 BALDUR PARK RD RE ENGEBRETSON ET AL RICHARD E ENGEBRETSON A JEAN ENGEBRETSON 1440 BALDUR PARK RD WAYZATA MN 55391 3,8 08-'-117-23 43 0009 03520 NORTH SHORE DR DAVID A SINGER DAVID A SINGER 3520 NORTH SHORE DR WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0014 03490 NORTH SHORE DR KENTON H CARLSON ETAL KENTON H CARLSON 3498 NORTH SHORE DRIVE WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0025 03458 NORTH SHORE DR PE BOWMAN & B D BLADER PAUL BOl'IMAN/BARBARA D BLADER 3458 NORTH SHORE DR WAYZATA MN 55391 TOTAL BATCH 001 00016 REPORT NO. PI435401 38 08-117-23 43 0003 01448 BALDUR PARK RD CORAL H LAWRENCE CORAL H LA•~RENCE 5120 10TH AVE SO MPLS MN 55417 38 08-117-23 43 0006 01436 BALDUR PARK RD W & P NELSON WALLACE E NELSON 6221 WASHBURN AVES MPLS MN 55423 38 08-117-23 43 0012 03470 NORTH SHORE DR HAROLD J BROUELLETTE HAROLD J BROUELLETTE 3470 NORTH SHORE DR WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0015 03498 NORTH SHORE DR K & D CARLSON KENTON H CARLSON 3498 NORTH SHORE DR WAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 43 0026 03460 NORTH SHORE DR JOHN G NELSON ETAL JOHN NELSON 3460 NO SHORE DR WAYZATA MN 55391 PAGE 1 - -- m RUN DATE 04/16/93 BATCH 001 HENNEPIN COUNTY PROPERT~ INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY OWNERS LIST REPORT NO. PI435401 PAGE 2 I CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTED ARE AN ACCURATE AND TRUE REPRESENTATION OF INFORMATION AS IT APPEARS THIS DATE ON THE RECORDS OF THE HENNEPIN COUNTY DEP~R ~N OF PROPEIJ:!'¥,-l'AXATION, TO ..J't;lE BEST OF MY KNO~LEDGE AND BELIEF. DATE@f#WeY t',.,/;D , · , .... I/ A<<" ;q ~•(1 \ \ ) :;·' i ' \: •• ,-1:'-·• ,.-·· ~'f"'J:, ;. \'.. -:J' .,.\ ., /. ..... ··,,,- (3) \\ ------,-~~---, 12 a:, I ~·I: ( 2 ) , .. · i I I I (we) Adjacent Property OWners' JA y fJ, L1r<AJu~ C6,- Acknowledgement Form _12- of ( </C/8 -/5frt..t}a,;e ~ j}r.YJ::} [print name(s)] [print address] have reviewed the plans for the proposed improvement or proposed use of the property located at 349) BIRCH LANE al so ref erred to as Land Use Application No. I (we) understand that in executing this acknowledgement, I (we) am (are) not asked to declare approval or disapproval of the property or use but merely to confirm for the City Council that I (we) am (are) aware of the improvement plans and that the proposed neighbor's project or use requires Council approval. Date / ·Property Owner / Yk c2-faJ Date / / ************************************** r ( we I._ €Jfllffe!_;l, flt mtA; /.._ ~ of 3'ff&' !Jf!lff 9'-b/2E /Xw .Ii= [print rlame(s)] [print address] have reviewed the plans for the proposed improvement or proposed use of the property located at 3490 BIRCH LANE also referred to as Land Use Application No. . ' I (we) understand that in executing this acknowledgement, I (we) am (are) not asked to declare-approval or disapproval of the property or use but merely to confirm for the City Council that I (we) am (are) aware of the improvement plans and that the proposed neighbor's project or use requires Council approval. I Property Owner Date If you have any information that may assist the City in the review of this Land Use Application, please submit your comments to the :euilding & Zoning Office at least 10 days prior to the scheduled meeting date. r-..Jt' f t..J/IAC f;v 1 HARDCOVER CALCULATION WORl<SHEET 7 7 , .• ... "-6) .... .,., .:. SE.1"SACK ZONE: (c IR CLE· ONE) @ 75-250 1 250--500 1 500-1000 1 EXISTlNG HARDCOVER 1H ZoNE WWM~•~-WMW~~-•ww~w•~~----~ t• ~ IJII' ' •~. t • A,· House::_ .. __ ··_·· __ x ....... , ..... _,, .......... i:: _____ s,F, . ' ' LENGTH WlDTH ,.":, X -----,;, -----S,F, ____ ......._. ·X -------" _____ ,S,F, 'I -----x· ______ = _____ s,r-, - ---~-X ______ = ______ SF I I I • •~ J f 11 11 B, GA~AGI! -----X -----= ______ S,F, 1 • ' •1 "'tr• C, DRIVEWAY;__,_ ......... ___ X _____ ~ _______ S,F, · . -----X _____ = _____ s,r:, ~ I •til . 0,. SIDEWALK_.----X -----= ----.-----l'l! ' . ...,.. S,r, ------X -----= _____ S,P, I I ,-4 • E, PATIO/-------X -----= -----S,F, De:cK , . ... ,. "1, ..... . ------X _____ a;:; ..... _____ S,F, ... F,lANOSCAPE _.;_ ____ X ______ , = SF AReAS -----' ' UNO!!RU. 1N BY ', , X = '.'":":""!'-------_____ -----S,F1 PLASTt'C' ......... ' IWlt ' • ' SHEET ING .. I ••• ___ , ................. ,.,. .......... ----. X -----= ------s IF I _____ X _____ =i= _____ s.i::, ' , , G, OTHER -------X -------= _____ S,F, ..... _.,. _____ ...... ._ ... .. ,, 'I tf. fl• ToTAL HAnocovEn IN ZoN~ ' ' TOTAl. P.noP1;~TY Am!A lit ZoNG: __ .....,;C)~_S,F, [I] 3 '~f IF ':t s. r-, [il . r;;i 0/0 0' ~ + L.!..J-. J '713' X · 100 = __ , _0 __ /C t 1•11 ,.,, I,. n 1.-•1HU1 I ' I ---.... .... ·~ .. ,i ,1a•. ',I oll I >l,o t 7 .. 3 "" .,C:~lr~ u) ,/I/It,~ r,/ .. <.. ""'"12 ---- HARDCOVER CALCUL.ATIOM \'IOR!<SHEET SETBACK ZON~: (c tRCLE' OME) 0•75'~ 250-500' SQQ .. 1000' EXISTING HARDCOVER IN ZONE w---•------~~~~•Mw•~~----~ ' I' 1 ••ll ' •~ t 1 ., 30·;,Z 23/,.'35 A, · House X = 7JS s.F, L!:NCiTH \•I I Oi"H I 2. .. l, :; , X /0, 7-= '/.Z.3' s Ir: I I • .. ··X = ,S, FI ,;. " x· = S,F, X == S,F1 I ,,,, 11,· ff t!. GARAGE: 1,¥. '3 X I?.. 5 = 30o/ S,F. ,, ' ' ,, '" C, ORI 1/&:VIJ\Y X = 3.30 s Ii-I . X = S,F, l"ll'W'l "'doiil ....... I •1•1 I DI' s I DE\~AL.K LJ..t.:4.!. 51/0 ' X = s Ir-1° C.o.-vr. J'"4A8 1/. 0 ')(, 2,2 9 .,,.. ('tJ1.1r. r..rf,; r X = So ' S,r1 · c~u,/ '·t):.,1/t.1< · ' '?O X = S,F, 1 ttll11111t I X ? .. '1 = . (§ 1 s Ii= I"' /"tt;>J ' -'I.~ >'-z; ?. II F,U.NOSCAPe: --:....----X --------~---.. ~---= -----S1F, AREAS UNDE.RLAIM llY . I -~--...... X -----= ___ ..,..,....._ s I I" I PLASTlC''_,., ... ,,~, .. ' I SHee.T lNCi -' ., .. ' _____ x ______ = ____ _ S,r, 76 s Ir I ; .• 5 X _____ = __ ___,;./._..__ ~,F, ,.__,_._._.WW•M ... __ _ '· '• • 4 I.II Li. TOTAL HARDCOVER IN ZONE w Tor A'-P,ROP ernv ArH!A rn Zo~lt~ Z3Jo s,r:,·m · ?97( s.r-. W ' _z. r, 0 '_,.: 7 ITJ . 9 9 7 ({ x 100 • I , t,t l,111 I\ , •t !\ I . .. • r •• HARDCOVER CALCULATION WORKSHEET SETBACK ZONE: (c I~ClE' ONE!) @) 75-250 1 EXISTING HAROCOVEn tM Zo~n~ PROPOSED 250-500' 500-1000 1 • ·~---~-~-~~~~----~-~~-----.,.' .. ... . . A, ·House:_._. __ ... _. __ x _____ = _____ s,r, LENGTH 1'/tOTH I I ,, ,;,:, X = -----------S,F, ,, . . . ____ __;._ ·X ....;.,,.. ____ = ------s l FI ,,, ------x• ------1:;; -----St r-I ____ __;._ S,r, x ______ = _____ _ t I '\• I'• i w. B, GARAG€ ------X -----= ______ ,S,F, ... ' ·t • ,,.. C, DRIVEWAY,·-------X --------= ------s IF I ' . • -------X -----= -----S,P, . D,. SIO=.WALK _. ______ X ______ :::: ______ s F · I I X -----; -----S1F, . . . E, PATIO/ ------X ------= -----$,F, DECK . I ,,, tt ....... ► I ______ X _____ -_. _____ S,F, .. F,lANoscAPe ~----x _____ = _____ s,F, M~EAS UNDERLAIN BY '· , X ------------= -----S,F, P L:AST re ... · ·~·· · ..... . . SHEETtNG ______ X -----= -----S,F1 ______ X _____ :::=: -----s,r-, ' G, OiHER ------X _____ ~ _____ S,F, . ..... ------............ ... . . . .. '' TOT/\!. HMOCOV!!n IN ZONE ___ 0 ____ S,F,. m w '. To'l"Al. P.noPcRTY ArutA rn Zom:: GJ.,...__0_' -•-~ ~ .. OJ , : !./? , X 100 • ___ Qi:;___% 'I I '' • • •• _,.;._ I I ,_, ....__ ........... --·-· ', ' ' • ,I HARDCOVER CALCULATIOM HORKSHEET SETBACK zmte: (C!RCt.:· ON!!) 0-75 1 0-75-.:.2_5_§) 250 .. 500' 500-1000' Ext STt MG HAROCOVEn HI ZoN~ . ______ ...... ,.._.. .. ;,--,;""'."----:--.. ":"--~ .. -- A, · House · 30·;"2 .. : :< __ z_l,_1._3;...S __ = 1JS S,F, LENGTH \'It OTII _--"-/_.'2_._l_, :.i_: _ x ___ /_O..;..., _'L __ = . /2.3' ' tbi::...,.....,. .... wa1.11rsL , .. SI Ft .. ·•X ,., = ____ ...;_. ...,;,,.._____ -----S,F, ' '" .. -----X· ------= -----S,F, . ' ~ ______ x .... _____ = ______ s F • I l J .... ,ft,• • s. GARAGE •.. -, -•• ~ ... 2.=-~.;....;~=-0-x -=z. l{._. _o_ = __ ..... ~+:....;:l,=-. _ s. i: , . C, 01\ l VE'rlAY t.L ·P~ x ____:2;;.....2:_· •...:i:Q~•-· _ = -.:....4;...;..~.::::::;.1. _ s , F, . -----X _____ = _____ S,i-, . .... D,. StO~HAL.K ,:JL'AO X ' ~----= -...,...:.·--.:.•...;-=---s IF,· cm,..,('. ./'~A& ~. CtJu('. .r._r(t'r X = So · s .:! -----__ _,;..:;_,_ "' · c t;,..1c: '"t.UjlK. . ' . X ~.~. . ,,. " E ' 7. 'f X _____ :::: _____ S,F, , ....... . j' .. ' / --------· --~'..;! __ s IF I,. /'tli'.J . . ~-~ >< z.-f'. II V F,lANOSCA?E X -----= -----StF • G, ... AR!:AS UNOi:.R1:-)-[H !3Y I :< -----= -----s,r-, PL.ASiic·-, .... '·~·: s!iES.i ma . I 'flt t X -----lo: -----s IF I ('(JM~~ d'(t!l(l(f ' X _______ S,F,:. .r~,,.'( """ 17'J1(tl,: >< OrHer-1/"'"""',,,..., ",,. ,~,k, ' X -----;: --------$IF I t .... -......... -.......... ' ' '. . ' .. . . TOTAL HAnocove~ tN ZoNE .. TorAt.. P.nOi'ERTY Attt::i\ UL Zou~ ... Zoz/3 • S,F,. [Ij .· 7' 9 7i . s: r-, [i} 0 §:01.} ·..: ~ m . 9 '7 7=-x 100 • 20. 2.5s _ % ' .... ,.... ' ... ' ..... _. ·-· PROPOSED V • ,, ,, e«-o z.4'-o'' • I j a''~ I s'-4 F S-4 f , f . 1 'I< 1\.411 s'-4'1 d' s'-◄' 5L4 11 1'-411 5 1--l 5L,l ·.2 =si _, IT) ... _, "' :.r =o ~I ·m l\l I -II\ L ii . I I,, It- !..11" sd) _, "' "" tt-'S.~Fz• BOLT.3 (TYPICAL) TOP OF SLAB ELEVATION--o'-o'' UN EXCAVATED 4"GRAV'EL 6A5E W/ 4•c0Nc. SLAB W/b";<"-''41-10',/,WH r-J'(TYP.) FO~ .;,,.Ne::~ l!IOLT LOCATION = .. dl 4 iii ~ (J I- ii: ., 2 ( " .... o. gz ~ :r:i '" o'" :i ., .. .. {i ~ GL .,o -~ .GU ToP/eLAe CJ...IN ""1" --•EU,V..-c;l-z'1 No-n:H ~•Fo,r POOR A.!10\lli lc,}-z!1 • 5 1-11'' =~ "' "' J In I +II ;. -· Ill i- ) Ill -0 _, " "' i 01 -· t 1-w,;" t + + 1" -21 I GARAGE FLOOR _, l'l <$!1 GCt-.JC:, ~L.A.& INI c..xc:..it" IO i,.J, i--J,M, W/ TURNED DONN !] I FOOTIN<!lt AT EDGE-5 f,,j/ _,:1-• GRAVEL l!>A~E ~A"-JCHC>" eo.t.."'l"~ llit11 41 l< IZ 11 -,r ::;!: TEMPO~A"Y t P'0""'1 :!>TAI(~ -~ I -· II) :=-0 . ~ :.f 11-l~kr,-,., ..... 1...) l'OR ;o,.NC:Holl. &OLT 1...oc:.flo"-1 ~EMOVE l"'ORM ESoA&tP,5 Al"l'Elt COt,lc:Re,'11! ~ No-re.: SHIM it_. 0>RoUT UNDE'.R WAL.L PA.NE.i-~ ,.a..LoNC:, ~,ce-, ~NO Fle:C>NJ WA.1....1...S AS Re.au11ce.c, 2'1,'-0" 1" ·11 4' 4 1-o" "l,11"-4' 81-0C!<.lN'-•-r i:i,-:2." .::,.~. J t;..<I 011 ! -- -,,-1•,._G-11 R'AKe,. 6a70_.,....ZS. /'' " f11~e," Soffl7 ~/ l/"J.11 R~F 'Sr+-'T'a, 2",c8' GAeiLC. ENi:> fl.4-F'TEJi!' FOUNDATION PLAN ¢.AULi(' .____------ ( formed concrete) ALTERNATE ,.,p,""" ---.. "!1"41 ,A,j '"°H c:,.;:., GAe1-E EklP ~TUPS FOUNDATION PLAN {turned down slab} :'5,c.ALE V411~1•-a• (SEE ~ION 413) z-,,eir ~ELF-iEA..'-. / .C,..,~fHA.1..T ~HINoLe.s i5 ME,AL.. ROOF 'VE.NT(Of'TIONA.L} i• 11• !j: IZ .....j",caA,.L.C_.U4U.,.:t!-c," (SU.." $&C;gQN 4,..;) SECTION 2A ,sc.c.~E. IV-:&.I': 11 • .::,11 ROOF DESIGN LOADS ':!>O 16s. -L1VE Lo.o.o 10 I 1:,e.-DEAD I..OAD St...tp ,...to..o 1:Ctt.1'2""'«il5.. SA.SM 12..o t 11-101 ._ ,.._.,'I&" I I I ;bJJ I ~ I SLIPHe...c...O G.-.E',,.._,,,E SA.'51-1 11 R_ .o. 1'-1011 ,._2:1-71/e, IGD' -0 11 X '1'--0• SE~TIONA.L O ooQ.., I•, i '1 1 11:U• I ·I ,, 1· ... I T i;,u.oL = .. -· 1/) t -, =-v _, :I~ 0 _, ,. " -I --,r -' 1/\ :'r' 1/\ 1"~411 C:QRNEfi' i:IOARDS s;e,' PL.YWOOC F'A.Ne:I... SIDIN6W/ GROOVE':> @e11 o.c . -"" ..._,.___::,============------L-- RIGHT SIDE ELEV. REAR ELEV. SCALE 11a•-11-o• LEFT SIDE ELEVATION FRONT ELEVATION SCAL.f! V◄•al 1 -o11 P-2026 SHEET 2 TOTAL 4 \, --l- 4.1.' ,.J) N "' Certificate of Survey for Pave Whnlen of Lot 2, □lo~k 1, Daldur Park IJcnncpin County, Minnc1iota # 1 P.xistinq teqnl Description Lot 2, Block 1, "Baldur ParkN. I '!'his survey shown the location of all existing buildings and visible "hard- cover in·relntion to the boundaries of the above describnd property. rt does not purport to show any other improvements or encroachments. o : Iron marker ·1~arinqs shown nre based on an assumed datum. / I hereby certify that this survey was p.rcpared by me or under my din,d super• vision, and that I am a duly rcgislercd'Civil Engineer and land Surveyor under the bws of the Stale of Minru.'SOta. • Mark S. Gronberi; Minn<'SUla Uccnse Numb,,r 12755 N DATli j -I~ • '3 Z JORNO. '3Z· zs,;,. I-+ r I ~ --1\11 Bonestroo Rosene Anderlik & Associates Engineers & Architects May 17, 1993 Ms. Jeanne A. Mabusth Otto G . Bonestroo. P.E. Robert W. Rosene. P.E .* Joseph C. Anderlik . P.E. Marvin L. Sorvala. P.E. Richard E. Turner. P.E . Glenn R. Cook. P.E . Thomas E. Noyes. P.E. Robert G . Schunicht, P.E . Susan M. Eberlin, C.P.A . *Senior Consultant Building and Zoning Administrator City of Orono Post Office Bo x 66 crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 Re: Liljequist Variance File No. 139-1824 Dear Jeanne, Howard A. Sanford. P.E . Keith A. Gordon. P.E. Robert R. Pfefferle. P.E . Richard W. Foster. P.E . David 0 . Loskota. P.E . Robert C. Russek. A.I.A. Jerry A. Bourdon. P.E. Mark A . Hanson. P.E. Michael T. Rautmann, P.E. Ted K. Field, P.E. Thomas R. Anderson. A.I.A. Donald C. Burgardt. P.E. Th omas E. Angus. P.E . Ismael Martinez. P.E. Michael P. Rau . P.E . Ph ilip J. Py ne. P.E . Agnes M . Ring. A.I.C.P. Thomas W. Peterson. P.E . Michael C. Ly nch. P.E . James R. Maland, P.E . Jerry D . Pertzsch, P.E. Kenneth P. Anderson. P.E. Mark R. Rolfs. P.E . Mark D . Wallis. P.E . Miles B. Jensen. P.E. L. Phillip Gravel Ill, P.E . Karen L. Wiemeri. P.E. Gary D . KristoFrtz. P.E . F. Todd Foster. P.E . Keith R. Yapp. P.E . Douglas J. Benoit, P.E . Shawn D . Gustafson. P.E. Mark A. Seip. P.E . Cecilio Olivier. P.E . Gary W. Marien. P.E. Charles A . Erickson Daniel J. Edgerton. P.E . Leo M. Pawelsky Allan Rick Schmidt. P.E. Harlan M . Olson Pm e sweli . PT,.::, ,. r.= James i'.\ E-,,ardt lfliL We have reviewed the certificate of survey submitted with the variance application for the proposed garage on Eric & Shelly Liljequist's property. The survey shows the proposed garage 15 feet from the twenty foot wide right-of-way for Birch Lane, aligned with the west property line. There is some concern that the irregular alignment of the driveway will create a problem with vehicle access onto Birch Lane. We have attached three options that should be considered to improve the situation. OPTION 1 OPTION 2 OPTION 3 Align the garage and driveway with the house. most common procedure to align a garage. The the driveway at Birch Lane will be improved. This is the orientation of Align the garage with the house such that the doors face away from the street. The driveway would curve to intersect Birch Lane at an improved alignment. Align the garage and driveway at right angles to Birch Lane. This is the most common procedure to align a driveway. The orientation of the driveway at Birch Lane will be optimized. It should be noted that the standard right-of-way for local residential streets (private or public) is 50 feet wide . The proposed garage is shown 25 feet from the centerline of Birch Lane for all options except OPTION 2. OPTION 2 shows the garage 20 feet from centerline. Please contact me at this office if you have any ~uestions. Yours very truly, BONESTROO, ROSENE, ANDERLIK & ASSOCIATES, INC. Shawn D. Gustafson, P.E. 2335 West Highway 36 •St.Paul, MN 55113 • 612-636-4600 --. ,) If) LI• u' N 0 • 0 7 ,a ... \· ~ ~- lt::,: l ':, THE ( IT',· OF OF'CII 10 t:, l .?--173-73':,7 Cn,t..lt.l<:l\t.O nf />urv.-.y £or l"Qyo Wholul\ uC Lot .:. lllocr. l, 1\:\1,lur l',Hk llcnt\Opin l:o,•nty, t1lnn("'•l'>"•" #1 ,:11.1 ,1,-.:~ ,,,·· ··._: f-. ,.:,·. •., Ta) I EMJntinn r.~on\ Oc~c~i[>liu,, t..o~ 2., Hlock '• .. Un1.Uti..u-l•nr,•. 'l'hi.tt e:svrvcy "lhowu t.h-..; lu1t..Dt ion nf .,Ii 4,111.l•tinq LJui ld4n,1n au,1 vLn1blc •n.o.r.d- covc:r ln 1,·111,,l. lou tu t.lu• Uuu1H.1,,r IL•.~ gf t.hn Hh')V•.,• (lcacr1L•,~J f••'-".,...,11 Lt, lL .:Jo"'' 0(• ... t)"''Pu,-t. t.u '\how nny ot.hc, iPtip.:nv,:,nc:ntn ru· c;f\Cl IHl'-,.lu-,cuL::&. n I lrno th..'l<~• .... r ~ . UOb.t in,pi ,~ho...,n l$C"' O..;\aCU on An AAAum•d datu~. OPTION I N I lw-u.·b7 u·11Uy 11\.)1 lhh tMN""Y \W'&I p•t1'tan...J l•1 fhC {If v•..J\.·1 tU) J~n,I h•t"''I• vt,.On, al\4 $l.).l I .:a.n ~ d\.11) •t)'.U-Lc(NL .u Lnt;~Mn •nJ, Lind s\,1('11'\·,vt '""'""h,.,. llloC' L\n,1 ul tl1\ Su,,.'--' Mirnt\wl.. • UA.t I 1 ,.. I \, ~ 'f' {. .. _ "/ I :;i;.w: \ ·-~ :~ -, ,.) • 0 7 //J ...\: 'I'- lt.:.: l ':, Coct..lCic:nt.n nf />urv,.y £or l'ayc Wholon v( Lot ;:, lilac~. 1, "·•••• .. , 1',l<k Ucono1>in l:ounty, Min1u~,,,,r.,., #1 ,,I.. • '--•:·. ·., '1"4 I ExJnttn..-. J.c-onl Ot.~4cL·i.ptiun Lot. 2. hlock , ... lllll&.h.1, ,~n,,•. 1 l'hlat ~vrvcy -i,howu t.h1,,1 l,u ... •t ion n( .,1 l \fr.ietJ.n9 l,ui ld1.n~a 01u\ ·..r1.01.bl~ •t,ord- cov\!'t' io t'•1l•&\.lun lu Llu• L>,1u1H.1dr ic.•:-. uf r.hn tll,,,,.v,,: tlcocr tL~.--d r••(,.,..,,)11,,. .... t t. ,,h>"•i nut, ~"'cpur-1. to '\how nny oi..hc, J.p,pJ"t.V,~l"Cl\tn ,.,.~ ~,,c, ,,o\.o.lh•~•IL:i,. / o , I ..-on 1 .... :,,:)u:-c · Uohr in,p, ,~hn.""n "'~ h~:,cd on 01\ llAAumed datu~. OPTION z N ~ I IK"h·by (C'ftUy 1h..1t &hla tu.tvry ,~•• pn:1••rnJ l•7 n.c: {lit \,,IH..!ti.·t •u) J~n, • •wt"·•· vh..00. •Ni lh.ll I .)m .1 t.1vl) •rtlalcfrJ"L •U Ult;,~ft<"C'f ~nJ Lhui Su, ... ,·,vt u,"1n ,t"" l.l, ... u/ ,,.,. £.uh.· ~-1 Mi1~1"'-Wl~. • .. -/ I :.(.:.\LL \ ~ .. ~ 3ra ~...e£---k;E- h\.u~ ~. Cu.1ol""·1 ti Mu1H\,")ul.1 u""'u"· N~ull"\.t ll'}~ • ; • , • ti oJ t,J\ • 0 -;,, I ... ••••• 1,._--•· ... ?.?~ 0 c.l ... 1. \ 1!>1 .. k, '-<is I ~ ~ .. ,.1, .... ,. ·• "'·. . ·'" ••. , ,,.,.,,. Cl . ,, .. (') I r ,o li::,: 15 Cn~t1t1cA~II nf fiurvpy !or l'A)'Q Wh11la11 <.>( Lot Z, Ill oc~. 1 , I\:\ 1,1,., l',IC k UCJH\Oitln \.:ount: y, 1'11 """'\Qt;f\ #1 ,;11,l .tr !:1 F.:xintinn l.flnn\ nc..•11c1:i.pt.ion LOL 2, (\lOCk I, •u~ldyc rnr~•. I ,:~;:·. ::;;'"4 ~ 'l'hi.tt tH•rvcy ;howu t.hl..i Lur....•t i.on of .... 1 l YKi•tinq UuildLU'f:t ouc1 vlo1ble ·t,Ard- cav'-!&' iu Pil,,Liou tu t..lu· lJpu1u.1.,rlt.•.-.. u t r.hn tth,oy.._ .. 4lc-0.c c l& .... ,~d (•• 1;,., .... ,H I,. v. l t. Jo"o nt,r, •lu.cpurt.. tu "lho..,, C\ny ol.hcl"' it•p,o,·,:tnc:ntn n,· c;;nc1 (Hh .. Jtt••cuL:a • o I I rnn 11L.,,:)i.ec . lhlbt' in,,,, ,~hn....,n I\Cr t">..l:tC<.l on al\ AAAtJmad datu~. OPTION N I IK"11.·b7 (c:-11Uy ll~t ,hh '"'"'"l •wa1 pn:1'•n-J t-7 nw; Pf '°"'"""' hi) J;u, I ,h•P'·•· vl'-"ln. 11\d Uu.1 I lu\ ~ dut) •l'l,ibLtlNl: •U (n.~~IK"C"r inJ l...ind s ... ,..,,.,Vf """'"'T ,lw: Ll,,.. ul ,I,,· t\.Al,; l-4 ~fow, "WW, , UAII 1 ., \ l. • Y l. ~..,e(---kr, M.u~ 5. Ctu11l""'ti M11m,·>ul, LI,:"'""' N ... wl""• Ul~ . ; . 1 .•• ~ --1\]1 Bonestroo Rosene Anderlik & Associates Engineers & Architects June 4, 1993 Ms. Jeanne A Mabus th, Building and Zoning Administrator City of Orono Post Office Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 Re: Liljequist Variance File No. 139-1824 Dear Jeanne, Otto G. Bonestroo, P.E. Robert W. Rosene. P.E.* Joseph C. Anderlik, P.E . MaNin L. SoNala. P.E. Richard E. Turner, P.E. Glenn R. Cook, P.E . Thomas E. N oyes. P.E . Robert G . Schun icht. P.E . Su san M . Eberlin . C.P.A. *Senior Consultant Howard A. Sanford, P.E . Keith A. Gordon. P.E . Robert R. Pfefferle, P.E. Richard W. Foster. P.E . David 0. Loskota, P.E . Robert C. Russek , A .I.A. Jerry A. Bourdon. P.E . Mark A . Hanson. P.E . M ichael T. Rautmann. P.E . Ted K. Field, P.E. Thomas R. Anderson, A.I.A . Donald C. Burgardt. P.E. Thomas E. Angus, P.E . Ismael Martinez. P.E . Michael P. Rau , P.E . Philip J. Pyne, P.E . Agnes M. Ring, A .I.C.P. Thom as W . Peterson , P.E. Michael C. Ly n ch, P.E. James R. Maland, P.E. Jerry D. Pertzsch , P.E. Kenneth P. Anderson. P.E. Mark R. Rolfs, P.E . Mark A . Seip. P.E . Gary W. Marien. P.E. Daniel J. Edgerton. P.E. Allan Rick Schmidt, P.E . Philip J. Caswell, P.E . Mark D . W allis, P.E . Miles 8. Jensen. P.E . L. Phillip Gravel Ill, P.E. Ka ren L . Wiemeri, P.E. Gary D . Kristofitz, P.E. F. Todd Foster. P.E . Ke ith R. Yapp. P.E . Douglas J. Beno it, P.E. Shawn D . Gustafson, P.E. Cecilio Oliv ier, P.E. Charles A. Erickson Leo M . Pawelsky H arlan M. Olson James F. Engelhardt Subsequent to our inspection today, we have prepared this letter regarding the proposed garage on Eric & Shelly Liljequist's property. The existing flat topography, closely situated structures and narrow width of Birch Lane pose a difficult arrangement for street access. The applicant has requested that the proposed garage and driveway be aligned with the west property line. The garage is proposed to be 24' x 24' with a 22 foot wide bituminous driveway. There is some concern that the irregular alignment of the driveway will create a problem with vehicle access onto Birch Lane. However, the applicant's requested alignment may be the best option due to the configuration of the other driveways in the vicinity. We have looked at the feasibility of aligning the garage such that the doors face away from the street. The driveway would be constructed in a curve to meet the street. To provide adequate room for a passenger vehicle 's 22.5 foot radius outside wheel tracks would require that the garage be located approximately 12 feet further from the property line than proposed. Also, the alignment of the driveway would require that a large evergreen tree on the property be removed. This alignment is shown on the attached sketch. The fact that the proposed driveway is twice the width of the existing driveway will improve access onto the street. Both Birch Lane and Baldur Park Road have relatively low traffic volumes and adequate sight distance . Due to these existing circumsta nces we would recommend approval of the applicant 's proposed garage and driveway with respect to an engineering standpoint. Pl e ase contact me at this office if you have any questions regarding this matter. Yours very truly , BONESTROO, ROSENE, ANDERLIK & ASSOCIATES, INC. JL.rn :t>. /~ Shawn D. Gustafson, P .E. 2335 West Highway 36 • St. Paul, MN 55113 • 612-636-4600 CITY OF ORONO 7. ---/t '.~--. ;~,.;·;-~~TICE--':·:._ :.,:;;.,,j .. ·•·" The Planning Com.mission will ' hold . public hearings. in the Council_ Chambers at ·:· 278Ci .Kelley. Paskway ~ oi:i Monday, May 17 . · , 1993 on the mane(of reviewing the following · . lari_d_ use·applications: .. ,: .. :-' .,.\. ,.: •" ·•:•l'•'::"'. r·' -. : ,: -' 1. :f 1820, Hennepin County Oepartm~nl . of' ·Environmental · Manageme·nt 'se!!ks · approval of a ·conditional use permit for _repairs . to an existing'sea wall adjacent to the ramp at Hennepin County's North Arm access . -· · · .. · .. :2 . ·#1822 Mark Prueter of 3215 Crystal . Bay Road seeks approval o( hardcqver and s ide setback variances for ·_a second story addition to the rear and for the replacement of a .deck at the lakes ide of the house . • · ._;'.3 . #1823 Marge Rossing _of 130·Cygnet Place.1seeks approval of _a _. rear -setback variance· for a proposed two story addition to the existing residence . -~ii':•·:J'., • ... ·. · ., · ·--4 . #1824 Eric .and Shelly Liliequist of 3490 Birch Lane seek approva of hardcover and a street setback variance· for a pro·posed · detached garage. __ · \ .-: 0 ~ \'~s-· ·--, •· . -1 s. #1826 Robert and Ann Henson of 2166 . Shadywood Roa·d seek appro\'.al of a ·. , hardcover . variance fo( the installation of a I detached garage with in the street yard and .an i average lakeshore se,tback variance and lakeshoce .setback variance for a proposed deck at the lake side of the ex isti ng residence . . -, 6 . #1827 Richard Henry Nelson of 3908 Cherry Avenue seeks approval of hardcover and lakeshore setback variances for structural improvements to an existing residence· . involving an expanded · roof .design and .· redesign of exterior windows :.,;_. : .•.• , · , 1 ... ,-·i""-,7: #1828 Christopher Tully of 1,355 North _ I · AnT)'Orrve seeks approval of a con·drtronal u~e 1 · permit ·to ,, allow •·the construction of ,an , ; accessory 'structure in the streeVrea( yard of th e ~';,Yg~~~;~~-t:is';,~-~\t~ -~~: \e~~;-lfi;j ! / appear at the meetrng . Wrrnen comments are 1 solicited . Plans are availab le rn the City Offices for review by appointment. • . City brorono . : . -' ·--, --. -' By : Planning Commrss1on , • _ , ;' . : .. _ ' ·,. · --. ' -·--· :-,:--Jeanne A. Mabustti , . , .· , Bl!ildir:i~.&_lp_n ing.A_dministrator _ · (Publishe~ in The ·La ke~ a~d· Pi~n~e r M~y -3,,:.: 1993) ~ . . . :-~-. _-' . " • Affidavit of Publication State of Minnesota, County of Hennepin. Bill Holm, being duly sworn· on oath, says that he is an authorized agent and employee of the publisher of the newspaper known as THE LAKER, Mound, Minnesota, and has full knowledge of the facts which are stated below: A.) The newspaper has complied with all the requirements constituting qualifications as a qualified newspaper, as provided by Minnesota Statute 331 A.02, 331A.07, and other applicable laws, as amended . B.) The printed /m ,IJ /l of/ ,rfrco l;;,~4./ which is attached was cut from the columns of said newspaper, and was prin_ted and published once each week for ___ successive weeks: It was first published Monday, the >-2 id day of_.,,__,_,.....,,_ __ _ 19.u_, and was thereafter print and published every Monday, to and including Monday, I the---day of _______ 19 __ ; 1~--"""'"'..._..,.__,""""""""'----Autl:lorized Agent By: KRISTI HOLM § NOTARY PUBLIC • MINNESOTI\ 1 HENNEPIN COUNTY f d Mydcommlssio[l exoires 7-10,-_97 an sworn lO me on mis . .... __ ...,..,......._. Notary Public Rate Information (1) Lowest classified rate paid by commercial users for comparable space: $10.76 per inch. (2)·Maximum rate allowed by law for above matter: $10.76. (3) Rate actually charged for above matter: $5.98 per inch. Each additional successive week: $4.12. CERTIFICATE OF MAILING STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ss. CITY OF ORONO I, Jamie Bosma, of the City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota, do hereby certify that a Notice of Public Hearing concerning the matter of #1824, was mailed to the attached list of property owners . In Witness Whereof, I have hereunto set my hand and seal this 27th day of April, 1993. ~-------- CITY OF ORONO NOTICE The Planning Commission will hold public hearings in the Council Chambers at 2780 Kelley Parkway on Monday, May 17, 1993 on the matter of reviewing the following land use applications: 1. #1820 Hennepin County Department of Environmental Management seeks approval of a conditional use permit for repairs to an existing sea wall adjacent to the ramp at Hennepin County's North Arm access. 2. #1822 Mark Prueter of 3215 Crystal Bay Road seeks approval of hardcover and side setback variances for a second story addition to the rear and for the replacement of a deck at the lakeside of the house. 3. #1823 Marge Rossing of 130 Cygnet Place seeks approval of a rear setback variance for a proposed two story addition to the existing residence. 4. #1824 Eric and Shelly Liljequist of 3490 Birch Lane seek approval of hardcover and a street setback variance for a proposed detached garage . 5 . #1826 Robert and Ann Henson of 2166 Shadywood Road seek approval of a hardcover variance for the installation of a detached garage within the street yard and an average lakeshore setback variance and lakeshore setback variance for a proposed deck at the lake side of the existing residence. 6. #1827 Richard Henry Nelson of 3908 Cherry Avenue seeks approval of hardcover and lakeshore setback variances for structural improvements to an existing residence involving an expanded roof design and redesign of exterior windows. 7. · #1828 Christopher Tully of 1355 North Arm Drive seeks approval of a conditional use permit to allow the construction of an accessory structure in the street/rear yard of the through lot. All persons wishing to be heard will appear at the meeting. Written comments are solicited . Plans are available in the City Offices for review by appointment. City of Orono By: Planning Commission JJ:cn=Jc~ ,&,,,--Ou J e A. Mabusth · ~ ~ Building & Zoning Admini.strator To be published the week of May 3, 1993. APR-27-•,;;,3 TUE 11 :24 2831 ALDRlCH AVENUE SOUTH TELEPHONE; (6J2) 87:l-6500 FAX: (612) 872-6946 FAX TRARSMtSSION FORK P. 0 1 DATE: 27 APRIL 1993 1125Nv1 TXM!1 ________ ,__ .. _._ ____ _ TOTAL NUMBER OF PAGES ___ 5 __ ClHCLUDlNG THIS SHEET) TO: JEANNE MA.BUSTH FAX NO. i 612/473-0510 ------------- COMP AMY i CI TY OF ORONO _.......................... :a.: ..... - REGARDINGs SURVE~~-~~RP.£~ER S~C~Jd'TIO~§. FOR YARIAN_C;~ APfLI~ATIO~ .. - COl'lttEHTs 1 PLEASE FINO FAXED TO YOU THE REQUESTED HARDCOVER CALCULATIONS THAT I INADVERTENTLY FORGOT TO INCLlIDE WITH THE APPLICATION, l HAVE ALSO INCLUDED OUR PROPOSED HARDCOVER CHANGES, I Nil UNSURE AS TO WHETHER OR NOT THIS INFORMATION WAS NEEDED BLIT I TI-OUGI-IT IT BEST TO INCLUDE IT, IF YOU NEED ANY FURTHER INFORMATION OR CLARIFICATION., PLEASE DO NOT HESITATE TO CALL ME AT THE /iOOVE NLMBER BE~EEN THE HOURS OF 730/iM TO 330PM flbN -FRI, THANK YOU! ·······••************·•·····•~**************············••** :::::~sl·r1~·l1;;:ii:·=:·············u·~·~ SHELLY LIW UIST 3400 BIRCH LANE ORONO, M'l 55391 if 11,T,irr,d ,,. ,;i rlr: nn,J rem .. p,r•jhlP, 1! rli111,..,n<= j,)n~ · inward at top 1 ··• ; l 'H '\JI ,l e. ,b. Using wire Ce. Q straight board lending flush with ition of bolt x4 plate over 1 been done for CA HST GARAGE I E AREA ...,-; i ,., ~-1 /•·-f.;~; \ "" 19. Cutting rafters is simplified by following the rafter dlogrom provided on the pion. I ,..,Hru1t ,.,,,,..f r11f-h...,,..._ rnfJr.n,:c h-, ,:?,-c, , .. nrl 'r.c,J-h, ..... 1,...-.o. f.,-. rl~o.-1, f,...,,r ,...,..,..._.,,...,...., IRA~"'"'""' 21. Add 2x4 gable studs, gable end blocking and any other froming.nec.e55ary, as sho,y, I ,,t ,, , ,/i \ i ,: "'',;''~dW~llf--= n -. ' DATA PRIVACY ADVISORY In accordance with M.S. 13.04, Subd. 2, "Rights of subjects of data", we would like to inform you that your request for a permit or license from the City of Orono or any of its departments may require you to furnish certain private or confidential information. -~ou are notified that: e7-,;::..s-,: •• 1. The information you furnish will be used to determine your qualification for the permit or license requested. 2. You may refuse to supply data, but refusal may require that the City deny the permit or license. 3. The information may be shared with other local, state or federal agencies to the extent necessary to process the permit or license. 4. If your requested permit or license requires Council action to approve, some information may become public. 5. You have certain rights under M.S. 13.04 to review private data on yourself. 6. Your full name is required to process this application or permit. ERIC JAMES First 3490 BIRCH LANE Address ORONO City 612/471-7255 Phone LIi, lEQI IISI Middle Last MN State 553~1 Zip I understand my rights as stated above. 2-: ~- S1gnatur~-= ~----.. -----~-----··-_. __ _ RIGHTS OF SUBJECTS OF DATA Subdivision L Type of data. The rights of individuals on whom the data is stored or to be stored shall be as set forth in this section. Subd. 2. Information required to be given individuaL An. individual asked to · supply private or confidential data concerning himself shall be informed of: (a) the purpose and intended use of the requested data within the collecting state agency, political subdivision, or statewide system; (b) whether he may refuse or is legally required to supply the requested data; (c) any known consequence arising from his supplying or refusing to supply private or confidential data; and (d) the identity of other persons or entities authorized by state or federal law to receive the data. This. requirement shall not apply when an individual is asked to supply investigative data, pursuar,it to section 13.82, subdivision 5, to a law enforcement officer. The commissioner of revenue ma lace the notice re uired under this subdivision in the individual income tax or orooertv tax re und instructions instead o on those forms. · Subd. 3 •. ··· Aceess to data by·· individual. Upon request to a responsible authority, an individual shall be informed whether he is the subject of stored data on individuals; and whether it is classified as public, private or confidential. Upon his . further request, an individual who is the subject of stored private or public data on individuals shall be shown the data without any charge to him and, if he desires, shall Se informed of the content and meaning of that data. After an individual has been . shown the private data and informed of its meaning, the data need not be disclosed to him for six months thereafter unless a dispute or action pursuant to this section is pending or additional data on the individual has been collected or created. The responsible authority shall provide copies of the private or public data upon request by the individual subject of the data. The responsible authority may require the requesting person to pay the actual costs of making, certifying, and compiling the copies. - The responsible authority shall comply immediately, if possible, with any request made pursuant to this subdivision, or within five days of the date of the request, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and legal holidays, if· immediate compliance is not possible. If he cannot comply with the request within that time, he shall so inform the individual, and may have an additional five days within which to comply with the request, excluding Saturdays, Sundays and legal holidays. - Subd. 4. Procedure when data. is not aeeurate or complete. An individual may contest the accuracy or completeness ·of public or private data concerning himself. To exercise this right, an individual shall notify in writing the responsible authority describing the nature of the disagreement. The responsible authority shall within 30 days either: (a) correct the data found to be inaccurate or incomplete and attempt to notify past recipients of inaccurate or incomplete data, including recipients named by the individual; or (b) notify the individual that he believes the data. to be correct. Data. in dispute shall be disclosed only if the individual's statement of disagreement is included with the disclosed data. . The determination of the responsible authority may be appealed pursuant to the provisions ?f the administrative procedure act relating to contested cases. . ~ ·7, -;-, 1.: . . t.-_ t ·~ -..- \. \. '" ,-