The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About02-07-1977 Planning PacketAGENDA PLANNING C(MfISSICW MEETING OF FEBRUARY 7, 1977 ORDNO CITY HALL - 7:30 P.M.B’f tir, • t I. CURRENT ITEMS A. Action Items 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. Call to Order Notice of Postpcxiement of February 21 Meeting to February 22 - 7:30 p.m. #220 - Public Hearing - 7:30 p.m. William Gregory - 1410 Shoreline Drive Vacation - Extension of Brackett Avenue #222 - Public Hearing - 7:45 p.m. Ruth Wear Estates - 2901 Watertown Road Subdivision (Preliminary) #192 - Navarre Area Rezoning Continuation of Ptiblie,.Hearing Minutes of Regular Meeting of January 17, 1977 #199 - Mrs. Robert Gasch - 1030\,Tonkawa Road Variance - Fence Setback (Structure) #200 - Victoria Grain Company - 500 North Arm Drive Subdivision (Preliminary) - Revised Plan #210 - Jack Rhode - 1410 Bohns Point.Road Variance - Lot Area and Width \ Conditional Use Permit #217 - Robert Birkeland - 1298 Wildhurist Trail Wetlands Variance - Dredging Permit #219 - Gary Peterson • 3545 Ivy Place Variance - Lot Area 8 Width \ Ri^t of Way and Lakeshore Setback #120 - James Sidwell - 1375 Park Drive Review Previous Proposal #225 - Good Shepherd Parsonage - 2466 Dunwoody A^nue Conditional Use Permit - Annual Review \ #227 - Rebecca Derry - Nursery and Child Developmeht Center Transfer of Ownership of Existing Non-Conforming Use Stewart Perry - Revised Proposal - Building InspectoKReport Ski Tonka - Second Phase - Conditional Use Permit 8 License - Building Inspectoi Marinas - License Status - Building Inspector Report ' Report Review Platting Ordinance Review Wetlands Dredging and Duck Ponds (Moratorium) Review Park Status (Moratorium) Review McCleary Resolution Review Duck Problem - Suggestions and Recomnendations ■i 'I B. Work Session Items 1. #223 - William D. Levering - 275 Willow Drive Subdivision (Preliminary) - Pifclic Hearing Scheduled for February 22, 1977, at 7:30 p.m. • Jdui H. Honour - 3560 Ivy Place Variance - Addition to Non-Confoming Lot ■ Williamson Construction Co. - 3779 Casco Avenue Vacation of unused alley or Variance on Lots 12 and 13 if vacation is denied 2. #224 3. #226 uary 22 - 7:30 p.m e Permit Center Jig Use ^Report .icwe ’ Building Inspector' Report leduled for at 7:30 p.m. Agenda - February 7, 1977 Page 2 4. #228 5. #229 6. # 21 le 12 and 13 C. Incomplete Items 1. #188 2. #202 3. #209 II. COMPLETED ITEMS FOR COUNCIL A. ComDleted Items Vincent Jolinson - 469 Tonkawa Road Variance - Lot Area and Widtli Joe Van Bockel - 2800 Shadywood Road Wetlands Variance - Dredge Existing Slip and Riprap Slioreline George Tonan (Mr. Schleich) 100 Orono Orchard Road Lot Rearrangement and Variance Steve Wallack (T.M.G. Corp). - 4100 Sixth Avenue N. Subdivision (Preliminary) Harrison Johnston - 925 Willow Drive Conditional Use Permit 5 Variance - Tabled - Moratorium Richard Ledstrom - 3465 Sixth Avenue North Wetlands Variance - Conditional Use Permit - Duck Pond Tabled - Moratoriun - Henry Skarp - 1045 W. Femdale Road Lot Rearrangement - Concurred - James McCIeary - 3445 Bayside Road Non-Conforming Use - Concurred - Boeye-Anderson - 500 North Arm Drive Subdivision (Final) - Concurred William Dickey - 2645 Watertown Road Subdivision and Proposed Land Grant - Concurred - James Sidwell - 1375 Park Drive Subdivision - Referred back to Planning Conmission - George Hanson - Big Island Variance - Lot Area § Lakeshore Setback - Concurred. irj 'Vn; WAV f4 I AM MOND A. MAIK HOO^^ W. SCtHNOf?*-* V •< DUNVCM KAUFMAN OAVIO S. DO TV ROHeiRT A. MINISH ROI ^ F A. WOWDK'N O. MARC WM‘TfHeAO * BRUCi: D. WK I IS FRLOeRtCK b. RlCHARi^ RONALD C. E.LMOUIST G. ROBERT JOHNSON GARY R.MACOMnr.R FREDERICK C. BROWN 0PUCE D. MALKERSCN JAMES R. STEILEN JAMES 0. LOCKHART AI.L.EN W. HINOERAKER CLIFFORD M. GREENE O.WILLIAM KAUFMAN Mr. H City P.O. Cryst Dear My cc util make engi a CO cons Reme affi to d thin PCPHAM. HAIK.SCHNOBRICH. KAUFMAN & DOTY. LTD VVAVr4t t'. RA iMONO a . maik ROO*'*» w. s<:HNon*^'»- *< OtNVCH KAUTMAN DAVID S. DOTY Roac'*'' A. minish MOI.»r. A.WORDKN O. MARC WH'TC MKAO * RRUCC O-WUl lS rmocRiCK t>. mcHAHus RONALD C. tUMOUIST G. ROBERT JOHNSON GARY R.MACOMnER FREDERICK C. BROWN BRUCE D.MALKERSON JAMES R. STEILEN JAMES B. LOCKHART allen W. HINOERAKER CLirrORD M. GREENE o.WILLIAM KAUTMAN ^ ^ A I r> S C L N ' E R MINNCAPOUIS. MN SBA02 February 2, 1977 \ 3 * ! B >4 • A I viLLAC;': c# 0. Mr. Henry Muhich City of Orono P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota 551 rfl7', ^ ‘ !j( > y V’ui-A iX; 0!v0NQ Vacation of Brackett Avenue as requested by William Gregory III Dear Hank: My comments on the vacation are as follows: 1. Please locate Brackett Avenue on the plat map. 2. Does it lead to the lake or does it provide for parking areas for people using the lake? 3. We need to insure the keeping of any public utility easements along the public road. 4 If we become involved in this in detail, we should „.ake sure the applicant pays all staff time, xncludxng engineering and legal. 5. As a condition of any vacation, s**®"!** a combination of any other lots and/or granting of wetlands conservation easements? to do so. In the past, we have used the following. A. It is being vacated as a quid pro quo for some- thing else. B. The vacated property will thereafter be taxable. Mr. Feb] Pag< Of the is eas we lot act ber eve BDM cc: ’•/■.wit-.- D. ei?- 33S-9 5^' V':. ..a ♦ t >. UAfit ^ c; Q a-*’ P T^'rp Ii. ;t» U; OixONQ e plat map, provide for y public tail# we should including )uld we force >f wetlands B must make E the public ng: quo for some- er be taxable• POPHAM. Ha IK. Sc HNOBRICH. KAUFMAN & DOTY. LTO Mr, Henry Muhich February 2, 1977 Page Two C, The city will no longer have liability for any public property which has now been vacated. Of the above, I feel that only the beneficial result Pitting the property on the tax rolls is that relevant since the city is usually not liable for any property over which it has an easement if the property is not being used by the ^ we are using that property for public use now, i;0., a parking lot, then we should make a determination of whether or not we actually need that property in the future for that use. emem ber, once the property is vacated, if the city determines it ever needs it in the future, then we will have to condemn same. Very truly yours. Bruce D. Malkerson BDM:ss cc; Walter R. Benson >r any putting le city IS an Lc, If parking not we . Remem- nes it emn same. McCOMBS-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES, INC. CONSULTING ENGINEIRS *• LAND SURVEYORS « SITE PLANNERS January 27, 1977 Mr. Henry Muhich Zoning Administrator City of Orono P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 Subject: Vacation of Brackett Avenue Dear Mr. Muhich: We have reviewed the proposed vacation of Brackett Avenue and have the following comments and recommendations. 1) oarkinq area and we would recommend that the City obtain a legal opinion as to whether or not Hennepin County has any rights to the property from this usage. Me recommend that if the vacation is approved that the City retain a 20 foot utility easement adjacent to the ciintrRoaS right-of-way for future ^^wer or waterma ns While the City has no plans at the present time for se water in this area, if these utilities are ever constructed placing them on the County would be very difficult. The Lake is close to the driven roadway on the South and the gas, telephone and electric lines are north of the driven roadway. In addition, the Orono-Long Lake also be placed in the right-of-way when constructed. The Hennepin County Highway Department should be added to the property owners list. I ^ J IjLT ' ' i J it i i!n1 ii;i.1 t VILLAtS OBONO 12805 OLSON MEMORIAL HIGHWAY. MINNEAPOLIS. MINNESOTA ',5441 TtLEPHONE (61?) 559-3700 22 NORTH MAIN STREET. HUTCHINSON. MINNESOTA 5'')350 TE LEPHONE (6121 897 8029 SOUTHWEST ENGINEERING DIVISION. MARSHALL. MINNESOTA 'j(>?58 TELEPHONE 1507) 532-5820 Mr. Henry Mi January 27, 4>age Two If you information with you at GF:jl »*] ■I r. iv J venue ion orner s our li s tyinepi n ; usage. that the to the itermains. i for sewer Bver P-way the hone dway. ill ucted. be added !> _.n ■ t ‘J • . ^'rt uAte 06 oaoNO if»9 3/00 129 i32 5820 Mr. Henry Muhich January 27, 1977 4»age Two If you have any questions on this or need additional information, we would be pleased to discuss this further with you at your convenience. Sincerely, Gregory/Frank, P.E. GF: jl McCO^BS-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES,INC. I m ■m r<- f-- ••—? ee:"-e%: i-: .r «- cS' m E.E..' r V.- . I H. * ^ <*■* •♦**’ Attached is ; this up for would not wi would review Items 1 thru Items with a All other it FROM: DATE: SUBJECT Planning CoiiBiissxon Brad Van Nest, Mayor February 3, 1977 Navarre Rezoning At«hed is a copy of our B-1 Items 1 thru 6 circled I feel should not be included in tlie new B-S. Items with a dash in front are ones that I feel could be included in the new B-S. All other items are now included in the B-5. IS in ^ conm*o< j iLO** in th< Shall ^0 saniti sha 1 1 ria.n.n: Sales except by the r j i * iToOf t I marked that we I wisii yew le new B-5. V- X- •' ■r**T. y • > vv -'■. • *■' •■B^v* , i ' ••, /v ^-JK. . ^ ' -f V>, ■ r / \• » ^0 ^ sanitary -.aO *^fwj •c ^T' .•^:T, ► V ' * « ^ ■ "• • -'C' :,,'•, » ‘ . t M • ^ * . . ^• • ».* * : ■ 1,^' ^ - . ■ < .■ ►,* ■■ « 35. ZONING: BUSINESS DISTRICTS (Amended Ordinance 172, 12-19-74, effective 1-1-7$) 35.000. B-1 Retail Sales Business District. 35.001. B-l; Purpose. The '*B-1*' Retail Sales Business is intended to provide a district for businesses that supply I ^ commodities or perform a service primarily for residents ^ the surrounding neighborhood. The district may adjoin A residential districts or other business districts which are subject to more restrictive controls. The district shall have immediate access to adequate highways and public sewer. ' 35.002. B-1: Application. All applications for a building permit in any "B-1" Retail Sales Business District shall be reviewed by the Council and may be referred to the riarning Commission for review. 35.010. B-1; Permitted Uses. Within any Retail Sales Business District, no structure or land shall be used except for one of the following uses or uses deemed similar by the Council: 35.011. Retail and Service Businesses. The fol1 <wing neighborhood retail saTes and servree businesses supj ly ing commodities or performing a service primarily * for residents in the surrounding neighborhood: Arts and school supplies store * Banks >md insurance companies ^ Barber and beauty shops 3icv. :lo sales and repair ^ooks, magazines, record shep , _ _ _ _ Drugs, candy,*"T(fe'“cre^, soff drinks, cornet..-s _ _and ^^th^ usual drug store merchandise Dry cleaning amT'laun^ry pick-up stTatiohs, ” . including incidental pressing and repair Garden supplies, florist shop antigue shops S-? ^'ilardware ~sT.oro, ^aint^^st^ep Hobby shops, camera and photographic supply i-' stores Jewelry shops and repair Laundromats Locksnvi^ e r Music', radio, TV, appliance sales and repair s tc.ires |;#r :-y'' Business supply nts join ch ct public r a strict to the Retai 1 e used imilar i' >w 1 supi ly- y >» ‘ * : • . fc.» - i ^rr«^* ' ' * *•) i • » I 35.025. nff-fihreet °“n in the saroe ownership as the «/!»*.ions as set forth in*38^U0*?f Ind'othe^^ucrcoSSitions a. found necessary by the City Council. 35.025. Public service^. ^“‘’^^®,ctrlc tr«n.mi.*ion including, but not telwhone exchange stations, line, and building. ““ “ISOated tanks, lift^t^urns^inrererjui-eru^ mSiSnj 4=sH^; .rLriS:“Sy"«~'‘S.'^'’‘”'- available and fenced. 35.028. Offices. Professional office and office, of a general .ature. 35.030. B;4i*||£2|^FTH5n^Sales Business District, the accessory uses:a w •. J- -- - 35.031. g.yf^°S[n|^pacp8rSs*r!gSlltcd in the Zoning parking and loading spac . Code.L,C»ut; • ^ ^ ciens as regulated In the Zoning Code. 35.032. Signs. Signs, as reg . __ _ __ « J5.03J -^.ror.ty f.rtm>.-s said cor.str ’ict ion. n«irorative landscape feat'uos 35.034. Landsc aping . Decorative ,« r^iaulated in the ^35.035. Fences . Fences, as 9 35.036. Tnctdent.a^. tted'^pHn^ipa 1 aso cessing neccssarv to ^ ^ shall not exceed 3'-» provided that the *V “*tpM building,of the floor spare of the princiF 35.037. Public Telep.h l2i}g-1122ll!i.- 35 ’.04o’. B^= . ‘ and Dos 19 n RetTi i ■■ a? ■ . ■ “ ■ i’i ■M ' .t : . ■ * 4 4 , m -1 ^^1 i.! i^ Is- V ,I rM:f bTi'. t^' '• I (fHoaeA'i SToAt. 3 <■ 1 CVetk'iiy) SlouL^ Retai used use p 4^. J ;■. 1 ^'■ K .i len on is rth cessary •s» on ttions. BSS I is Ratal 1 >«rmitted »et Soning ug Ct^ae 1 s»^s pl#?te :»iros . pd1 JSO# ed 30» IK Kfc(^u 1 1 ♦■r.« t«* » 0^1 i -______ HfiOoeA'i 3 itoA.c. CV»tlk\v5 JT7©4C -V, ■ . V*. / t » % Office^supply store, office machine store Pet shop Pioe and tobacco shops Z'l Plumbing, electrical, heating, housewares, furniture, carpet store Postal substation ^ and home supplied Sewing center and yardgoods Sporting goods store Tailor shops rp*>p«T **' temporary sales such as Christmas tree lots Travel bureau >2yarietv sior'~ Wearin appare fti2. Municipal Buildings. Municipal wh;°e the use cSnauctea is^ustomarily conaxdered to be an office use. 020. B-1: rnnditional Uses. Within the . * ■■ I *' *Kj ^4-"^a4^" r\t% or Xfiind shAll dc Ssef Lr*ine orthr?ollowing uses except by conditio^^ use permit: //,automobxlil^IaerJepa!r ’1unctjoL“re"^ta^ a • m min a building. , 35.022. r l-uol *^*^‘*^ pru'. i..ic..» set forth in Section 38.500 £f. . /2-1 ^oc F'ooci is .servedIS 0^3. Re.-;t dur (C lass ^ ^ , cukomer S^T.f n* rl thrrr:/uu^a„tVoer^ot serve^n,tcx. irreustoL^rwhUe’g:^ .xnd tuK..:. to a table for consumption. 35 024. Kcstauraucs ' Dr;ve-In,-^LT?u-r-sTr-vice slX'a ..... ^here a "rpackages prepared their food at a oc-.i.. o. *"/“ ’ ,irive-ln where m s’- customerrimsdmf the'.T'T! .^ in an -..rng ii,r.r'';..r-h^;e''^:-'‘:fc?tu:n^ —. — • •• • A i ««»•#« •♦•%sa* • f'U: i.-' - 3 V \ .«SM illinSJi m msernmmm:n 4i: y iifZQj^jLa i r Subdivision rape .s STAFF - Hoc Talked to r 1 wa.s infer filed as re trustees. FiA;;i:.r: i'n) I'abled - no STAFF • Jani Memo to Adm on this pro problems 11 PLANNI^i6 CO Mr. Wilensk issuing bui mitting rev Ihe Zoning revised pia the Soil Cc setbacks oi STAFF - Jar Jim Andersc we wanted v interested difficulty STAFF - Jar Several tin building pe him that th I haven't b for one bui Tract C con site plan s proposed si not consist STAFF - Jar Enclosed is issuing a b ’A *4 , -i- - . -r '■»>1 ^ * • * • 8 ngs ed to »-X" shall be Lonal r of lly enclosed rov IS i cr.s d L>-» C<vur;* • Jt cxi :ai : ti 5 S‘* . ♦ * • • • .jk*-:* Xnvenienct , rest -lux >.i;.' »rvoU 1 ; li*ra*. - ire rv ri*. L'l* 1* X i - .... V W m m •' V' ■' >• ty-> .1 5-i; ■'i;- V * k- '1 V- ti f . mr '"?i :• r.> ^ ■jivm f ''M ' 5 iA ^yictovla (-nun comjnanv Siibdi vi si on i, I’re 1 imtnarv') r '/ ■ 'X4 . I’afc :> STAFF - !»eccd)cr 1'.^^^' Talked to renresentative fixr’ torrens title records office with Hennepin County. 1 was inforred tbnt three narcels nrevioiisly oxxTied l>v Paul Poeyc (deceased) v«re filed as recentlv as Hccerl^er h, 197?>, listinp .Mii n. and Fern lezcl as trustees. PIA'iiT'.C (.•(ri’«!SSTO;; J.YINC - Januan’' .S, 1977 labled - no revised nlan. STAFF - January 17, 1977 Memo to Administrator regarding contractor. Mr. Lai*in, pressing for building ^nait on this property. We should be somewhat careful here to prevent possible future problems like we are now having with the Marge Gasch-Lorraine Pjirtcn project. PLANNING CCmSSICN JCETING - January 17, 1977 Mr. Wilensky from Brauer ^ Associates was present. We expressed our eweem over issuing building peiroit without completed plat, lie assu^ us he would be sub mitting revised plat shortly so platting procedures could continue. The Zoning Administrator informed the Planning Conmission ttot the sketch^ the revised plat included some changes on the marsh land perimeter as desIgnaty by the Soil Conservation District and, therefore, could result in a problem with setbacks or dry buildable lot areas. STAFF - January 18, 1977 Jim Anderson of Hennepin County Soil Conservation District called to we wanted wetlands designation reaffitmed for developer. I infoimed him that we were interested for building contractor benefit. His response was that he might find some difficulty getting to it for several months because of frozen conditions. STAFF - January 21, 1977 Several times during the week the contractor, Mr. Larnbin, has been in requesting a building peimit for lot »6 of "vised pr^al plat. I*ve to ^ t Sis is not permitted prior to filing of the plat - even by State statute, ’t been able to convince him so he changed his request by making application - ______8 ^__4-m.iT me tfico him that J hflVOfl ^ W -I 1 - - .4—m-ww ^ ___- _ for one building permit on the original single parcel - Tract C of #158. Tmct C contains all of lot 6 plus about half of lot 5 of the revised plat. The site plan submitted with the building plans, however, indicates only lot 6 as the proposed site. Therefore, his verbal request and data indicated on the plans are not consistent. STAFF - January 21, 1977 Enclosed is a copy of the report I prepared for Council regarding my concem about issuing a building pemit on properties which are not clearly defined. w Victoria tiraiu Ccampany ^jtdiVl.siort (Preliminary) ' r« r - ^ y y STAFF - January 24, 1977 ^ In tiyine to cowly oith Mr. ^i2er*fi*te»oclMw'pi^ted^*^S "* copy of this revised plan in the packet. Mr, Lanbin was somewhat irnt^. to get something together whereby we might ^ ^ revised plat, however, ^ineer followid tSou^ aiui siimitted a «vis^ plat included a indicated some changes of wW<* I !<rtl^s'and the failure to acknowWgeoutlet and a change in the boiai^ry line of tte wU^s^ c ^ Planning the Ha soil type as wetlands. I was changerto eliminate the outlet Comiission and Couicil would pos^bly Ig2“!!!i^b5uSies . Mr. Wilensky. wgineer and the questionable determination !Iu«nf„a in the wetlands line. Jim Anderson 'stoy’Sota... TOM: Dick Hank SUBJECT;Rohei Wet la Mr. Birkeland hs which was previc tion for complel pleted. There seems to 1 indicate a 50’ < channel. The proposed fi proposed grades drawn in free h In reviewing tli documentation t lands. At that evidence of any report). I am enclosing to the original ♦ • STAFF - Januar) I might suggesi action Planninj FLAWING Mr. Birkeland % content of ai. 50* channel suj stipulates 25* width came fra several years j After a length from applicant elevations and dredging mater plans. Mr. Birkeland Commission fel dredging or on first applicat Br. Birkeland other agencies s to speeu osing a ates to try . The however» eluded an I acknowledge lur Planning the outlet cy, engineer 1 Anderson 5 report ic enclosed steins.) .3*/' -• ,. ■ T_ .*•; f:.- :Vi it J K Dick Benson, City Administrator it '» A y-^k:.y DATE: SUBJECT; Hank Muhich, Zoning Administrator December 28, 1976 Robert Birkeland - 1298 Wildliurst Trail Wetlands Variance - Dredging Permit uirfof th™dreding which was previously approved and never com- pleted. ue. mipctinn here however. The current application and plans HSnatrTsS” ^har^ KraSucation approved in 1D73 denotes a 2S- channel. »-“2 ”■ dram in free liand in my office. m W co,r«tl«. .t thi. Vl.l.il» ("O report). I am enclosing copies of some of the corresj^nd^ce ».d doa-»ntation relating to the original application made in 1972, 19.3 and 1974. STAFF - January 12, 1977 1 mi*t suggest reports from some of tlie other dejartmOTts as sup^rting data for Ltin Flaming cSmission and Council might take on this proposal. FLAWING COMflSSlCN MEETING - January 17, 1977 Mr Rlrkeland was present. Flanning Coiimission very concerned over discr^an^ w ^tlit of^DDlteatim! Current awlicatio" requesting approval ^ dredging of a sJ'^chaiwl suimjsedly approved in 1973, yet old stinuu!^ zl^^mel. Birkeland stated that he did not know «*er^e • r™ Hirnlans are to finish the other half which was not completed :^raJ%S^go, MKt*Saie charnel any wider than p^ntly After a lengthy discussion the Cormission requested some ^ditioiwl plans. Ur RirVcaiand felt that engineered drawings and topogs would be too costly, but feirtMrmuW be necessary to determine ^ether project would ^ nw SSilni^r mint^ce of existing channel. Lack of proper plans with the first anolication of 1973 has resulted in the uncertainty of the proposal to BiA^lmf informed the Coamission that he tad sdxjitted plans to some of the Other agencies in 1973 and would present them if found. ilMlli .. iiiiiiiiiilll r . ^ t ; >.d- 4- “V M ■ - -ji ' * Roliert Birkeland • Wctlagds'Variance Fhge 2 1. - 1 Planning Comnission i of channel to be dre« advised that any eng; Later in the evening the Planning Coomiss dredging and filling with placement of th Birkeland proposal, was no longer presen the Cenmission would 1977, and not to inv make a site inspect! produce. STAFF - January 19, Called Mr. Birkeland STAFF - January 20, Mr. Birkeland returr sidering of proposal Planning Connission of moratorium on wet STAFF - January 25, I*m enclosing copie; has also given me t\ give us a better id< Mr. Birkeland was qi declared on dredginj f A project Dplica- com- and plans :isting and lap was >ome 5 of wet- find no engineering relating ng data for icrepancy in edging of a pproval re the 25* completed exists. formation d proposed It that the ated on the ;ostly, but would be new ins with the x>sal today, some of the -S' [ • r» 11 ■U I ^ ‘ \ n- Robert Bivkcland * Wctlands'Variance Piige 2 12 ‘)8 Wi laiuirst Trai 1 - Dredging Pennit I e •X. HSt:# Planning Conaission laoved to table until vie have drawings of charnel to be dredged, topogs and pl^ for disposing of fill. Applicant was advised that any engineering costs would be borne by bun. Uter in the evening, during discussion of the Upper Watershed Storage tiS wiSnSg Cca«islion shoSed extreme concern over the long range drtlging and filling of wetlands, marshes and shorelines. They wew also con^ was no longerpresent, so the Zoning Administrator was direct^ to inform 1^ that the Conation wuld reconsider the proposal at the next meeting of 1977, and not to invest in the engineering costs. T’?® make a site inspection and check any old plans Mr. Birkeland might be able to produce. STAFF - January 19, 1977 Called Mr. Birkeland at 2:45 p.m. Not in - left message with son to return call. STAFF - January 20, 1977 Mr. Birkeland returned call at 10:15 a.m. I explained Plaming Coomission rwon sidering of proposal and informed him not to invest in engineering Planning Conaission reconsiders proposal on February 7, 1977. Also informed him of moratorium on wetlands variances. STAFF - January 25, 1977 give us a better idea as to tlie projected fill and dredging. He They Mr. Birkeland was quite upset when I informed him of the moratorium recently declared on dredging and filling of wetlands. > m IP» -U. '. .=1 >.N ill i V" -IS m 1m m ^ m V r. i" 1 ’ v-n Pi fmmm i- wei: 1. inf' lem dec jr 1 detc edit ING i(hv< lisct for id l> ling Hie The apm ITVlt Two iti Pay Cit :CTI rov< rr ic. e itus lanc :ept -'c ’k ?ndr it cons > ** riptioa t was ect, from oncemed o the and iim that y 7, would to 1 call. recon - itil sd him t. He e. They ,V ■ ■ 1: ■ >: 'a A. : ■ I '• ■ ,* m > “'j m . i- mmH m' \ >'4 ■.-Va' ‘"I h-:* W- "■ M ■fer'= >1 . ■ Ttl: FROM: DATT; SUBJECT mck Benson, City Administrator llank Mohich, Zoning Administrator Deceifber 15, 1976 1T ►y• 4i' ^ I » .•«« •» •« •u«; „-rr sidwell - 157S Park nrive sSbdlvisi^ (Final Plat Approval) ^ ______1 esei-atck representative th "* , nifflAnsiens confoim toapproval. nn«nst«.s ^^sentative that I could I have informed both of the final plat.Riv-e them no assurance of approval or i _ should be included. or Planning Conroission lS?^t'fetS'should be included. Park Dedication Fee on this proposal would be SZ.OOO. PLA.’^JINC, CdNlSSl® IKirriMG - December 2P. 10-6 failed Vw 5 to *.. r—failed by 3 to 2. . ^ justification: Planninp. foamission then recommended approve y • wlar and hardsheUs as rcqiiireil. 3. Two sower unit charges. Conditions: , ______ i.-i in?? plans. 'TITINC - .Taimnn- 10, 1' " ■ . • , in^tific-itions and conditions.1 • *. 4^rs ri'inninn Connsfuon jUbtiTica 1\npnmH’. suliject to rinnninn ■* a * ST .ATT - .Tn:uiar>’ 11 > 107. cteck thirout i.V other department rccorns sue...................... r-,ar.'o on pronerty, T believe we could l^i^siyr^Ue^dfvisiSf o^^dd fa "cond .mit' ci,ar,-o. <' ft ’ r < '■r ?* uy'- '.'■ ‘•dJ '* ff f* Ii d M \ ■ i > •. 'A 15 % . 11 r> IV r I' A-.; 1 h fi*:.'* JfNes SiA«ell - ^lV»icn Pag» 2 STAFF - January House location STAFF - January After reviewinj was not assessc to the City Ad what the owner earlier applic; COUNCIL ^^ETINl Zoning Adminis misleading dat facts not exis recommendation i.*' : ^ ‘u*;' al plat >uld draft nnission ogni zing ,pally totion Lfication: liminarv’ ostly \s. :fc'- v'VC cnt rcp'icstirig Response frcc\ v.'hat it means i*ccl. ^ will 'lanninr. Conmission lieve we conl'J [•. f1. ti I ; \.'>y , i Jfpes jlAiell - 1375 Park Drive Page 2 ►.v;/‘I' 7 I I .:j V-» STAFF - January 13, 1977 Hoise location and drainage plan approval report received from engineer today. STAFF * January 14, 1977 After reviewing the sewer status, was not assessed for two sewer ^arge . * assessment situation as opposed to earlier application made in ?iarch 1974, CXXP4CIL r^ETING - January 24, 1977 Zoning Administrator pwsent^ ^^“?ev!^.r5^sion frawr^varwr~5rf?L recoranendation based on new information. Mr. Ha City c P.O. E Crystc Dear I have : subje' data f recom GF: sv ■ w >/ li v\ -i today. jie property )orts ii»de opposed to in his nn them of 5 made from mission for McCOMBS-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES, INC CONSUIIING ENGimillS ■ l»«0 SURVtYOBS ■ SITE flANNEaS January 12, 1977 , . <. t If t \JMr. Hank Muhich City of Orono p.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 James Sidwell’s Subdivision - 1375 Park DriveSubject: Dear Hank: As requested by the for^the^building on'thehave reviewed the proposed sites for the duix y subject project. Based on our review.of site and the to^graphio daca, either house location is acceptable, as sue reconunend approval. Very truly yours. Mc^MBS-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES,INC. Cr^eg Frank, P.E. GF; sw ' J Li I') J/V'* V1L1LAG6 oe, Obioico ,.805 OLSON MEMOS,OL H.OHWAV, M,NNEAS01,S. MINNESOTA 55A.T TELEPHONE ' •nv. vm\: mn: mTUCT: I*ve rev since wc property The reco property n«ip indi riE Klc Pic of Se /•I* # . raV-L. Council dioose JC. I f S’ c Drive we the hie we ^TES, INC. ' ‘k 1 :" ■ ■ -V i r:\' - *:3 ] * • 1 Ofc Ot^OKO E (612) 559-3700 . 879 8029 (507) 532 5820 •* h -V.. *n>: vm\: DA'n.: ;‘er.;-on, City Aibiinistrator llanK 'tiL'iicii, .'oiiinf .'Viministrator *v > • Jaivaarv' 12, 1)'?7 SUB.TlI(Tr; 5’i.lwcll Sewer (!hary,c Status property locatcvl at 137S Park nrl\x ‘. The recoil's reveal that nrior to t!v recent stil.diyision rexjuest, -■ijVoll property consisteJ of two parcels, cac!i one containms four lots (attachec! is a ruin indicating previous nnrccls). Plat 43120, Parcel 1065 is a conSination of lots 0, 10, 11 « 12 of Block 6 Snya ilill Addition. Plat 4312;>, Parcel 1510 is a con1>ination of lots 10, II, 12 and 13 of Block 7 Saon ;:ill '.ddition. Sewer Project - 1070 LSI lcv>^ «53S2 indicates tiie follavin?; server charges ; Plat 43120, Parcel 1065 1 I "nit Ciari’o 1 Connect ion 0\arf»e $1,.’70.00 Si 225.00 Plat 43120, Parcel 1310 ateral Pootacc Hiarye '• $7,h’0/ft. .>1 ..•o'^.O’'▼ Council piRlit want to reconsitler their recent apnroval of the nw siiVHvisinn or choose, to ah! t)ie necessar>* sower ch.arf.es for tlie seconi. mnldinR si e. *. V 1 ) •! ! I * !* . (I \\ -•f » }. • . 1 J-* .* lMwwhPi ' ■ m '’I W J i mmmm m?r m. 3 ->■ H y • d /i 4 i ; • ^ 1 t, . _ 1 / «. * iTour instniction the r.idwell ‘-ii ’wcll tacliod is a ihdivision or itr. Janui SUBJECT:ffl20 Scwe Attached is a c Sidwell pTopert It appears > charge as note< If we do appr< site, I waild and connect ia .Tamiary 19 tJ Called Mrs. > her that if J charge would $1,495 total She expresse sewer status 1977). iSMi '. • 'I j. ■i-.- !0 i- X Sv. * ^ 1\'>S'’^'7 rv F *: ^M\r u * f *W^I.l^' bimim MIMMII* •*. X. i* « » • •*' '^, >' 1 A.-I; |"-'.V I » . •« :' H )= f ^ #***^w-'« TO: FROM: Dick Benson, City Adadnlstrator llank MAich. Zoning Administrator #120 January 14, 1977 SUBJEa #120 - Sidwell Subdivision Sewer Qiarges Status w -1,. tMin^ of the sewer servicing the of the as-huilt naps oi wicAttached is a copy of part ot me Sidwell property.Sidwell property. , unit Sargi as noted in previous memos. Paixicl 106S was assessed; I Unit Charge 1 Connection Charge $1,270.00 $ 225.00 Parcel 1510 was assessed; A t*7 ftn/ ft * $1,560.00Uteral Footage Oiarge 9 *7.80/ ft. {The lateral charge must be based on a 200* line.) .. • j.^11 fe with a S (The lateral cnarj^c - - u 4i,i*;t„” sr. iss sus- and connection diarge of $225.00. ■Tmuarv 10* *077e4s%’&“Sses3S'S5?- $1,495 total charge due). _ . i— ♦$1,495 total charge due). u,i*band I told her the 1977). > . t f .• V ‘U, \ W • ^ 'I 1.1 ‘i.; m f I. .I # rj'-,-;- •n TCt;Dick 1 FROM:Hank 1 DATE:Janua SUBJECT: #120 Did a little moi I *m attaching cc sidxlivisian appl claim was made i 1974 applicatioi show that this i ■'CSV;';. , • > p. ■■ e unit illding 270.00 Explained to ^ 3ii<i connection 270 ♦ $225 • told her the (January 24, 1 { m i- 11 • I % f- ■ \ A -1 :r‘ BV C, mm: TCf:Pick Benson, City ' i ^ .vl w Hank Muhich, Zoni DATE:January 14, 1977 SUBJECT: 1120 - Sidwell Su Did a little more checking division application mad< claim was made that 2 sewer 1974 application definitely show that this was mentione " ;V- ri • .4- -{ / rr-rl' ■ ('■• ■■ .: :■: ■'- ■ ■■■'‘11 SiAiell »1< ina dx^ w (Kittinc buUdar, tte » ■iiMttanM to aocisting Ic •hewing tNO se**r Th» Pl«»i>«J5 ^ • new siWi •Ot of the me roQuired lot i vacation wasi stMiiaTd lot 1 CouiclUHin Vte d«ialtyof la has estiblist fii>st«ldard 1 precedanoe ■f^SwTrgr •. ,* After contin recoiBendati lot area mee ‘ lot wiposed lot w: Hake argued economic m the existini without a 9 IXnlap). ■ i I \i I: It Qiairwoman Orono Plana •t Hake moved riprap afpi larger sta other agen % Discussior this parci well as d Hike WWW the Hipli< adjacent < Nays (1) ' ;* ' lell \!kt • -’. s«7lot f««tmtas). «4 P«««t o« <(110 S6*®Jf *5S6SS*CWtS. ^ of the requitod lot Stwot TSI SS|i% to toeou««. Ait- and the ,.___-- . . 1 ■ ni^oft «n iuiu.t.A«iK the iHUOt of Ootoit^i v« :ciSssTtriTUT*^'• . ri V '.^ ■, w,f ■ •f i f,jwr caittawd di»o"^‘ffssxs s.’ff* «^»“irs.'sr- S 53T Dunlap). r/t/ >fr orwk <^fse Mf(. txjeissf ^ lUOV»-Otf*T ^<41^ HBU7t9VSJ> TtffS RjRl8pJ • A 4 c D IIt-hit CALL TO ORDER - 8:15 P.M. <3>.in«» D««1«P «ii«* “ “*Oiono Planning CcMission, Hake moved, SinTapproved^2 ^ or rtpwp to^ approval of U1 iSr/4^i /yos (S) - Nft (0) Discussion dewelojpto ^««t*p!^^ies as ^‘sssSd'p^.'s; “.«■«“ <« • N^ (1) (McDonald). JCE BRAUN ^ , 5020 CASCO POIOT I riprap pepmits : r.'» v.i» iiMi iMiMiliiiliiitt^^ I itiiiiiiiwt^^ ■viiytrmmm ^•i... .. .. . . j.. : • ■■<i.’- V/ ....• .i: ri9lS >44. seuJBA c fifi T« 0^ Zoning Diractic THiT*Mam< Add] rv ■HMBSiWMi • i.;; V. ' i • "* ■ . ■< ' V- ♦ ’ 4 • . • , ; V .* I M nr AT ruts orASACuTtse )j7t^^SP onCR - 8:1S P.M ICETING r.'»■bOUHANIsbo poiwr ttJN^soo POINT POM) pewits ite: V IHj I '■. ’ . t m V-7^ i.M' y. h ■4 . » if 7y ■*^-1 ii»:- r* ^/r r^ cac/A/c / UJiien^ Zoning variance Application reccions a. item number. b. Attach all supplementary material by paper clip. c.Pile duplicate applications and filing fee (3^ with Zoning Administrator. ) t:Name of Owner: V c^ V vir i-* - (Laatf (IMlrSn |V< lb<> .A (Phone r. Address of Owner: (No. and street i'v/‘'s /v»/!?k: l>t4U'e A'icuK-h 3. Street Address of Property involved: tS e li. Legal Description of Property Involved! Ptivr i:- r> -<, I<r, Aiut> t iv<r> h‘ioc(r7 e partially wlikin an b*'. r. t (c«» Does this property border on or adjoining municipality? KC- _ _ _ _ _ __ 7. Proposed tlse:6. Present Use: Present Zoning Vi'c-'^.u *L strict: It ('l-flCCt \ 0, Dat. Prop.rty Ae4ulr.d:v'r/(> 4 .ariance is rsQuested from the following sections of the Zoning Ordinance: . Z^Z 77^■ : ■• -- - -: lL \mat Item f ' 1 r 1 4C» •Sta^ prop 1 > % " •> - f , 15.lias beei mon' NOT®: ® fol befo eac L ✓ 'I I v'’ .V''• % r # Ir / \j£^ • «»OL 71 Lnting use >par ) ; rtijt....A- V ^ • . 'f- ) 1pnone ) ///€ < ,c t 7 U to,!^,170- [nan )ate Property lequlred: V v^r/( iiested fx*on tkV Dna of the Zoning •» f • I ' ^ \ ’ % h; I y lat are the requipemeniis o Item 10? • nc iCvt the orAlnanee sections iiawv< r4D t ' T iC^h\ H ______________ 3tate exactly wnat is intended aSsting^regulations : " ' " ^ M° U «. s« PT » 4‘Vr. <•-.: vS O Has an application lor JJJJiSgo’^Coincil witSn the last**si* months? If“C state tht date of the Vlllace Council • s action. >QC I , , „Ui I L. LH3' **«:rsSa?«erShe“in yS^p cas; confoms to the requirements ^.,14.4^a ttardship "to 0%mer7 Strict application o pifficulties oi feS'ning 6r5inance would result in the exceptional or ithe provisions ol the zoning ^uxu-..- —undue hardship upon the i«S imsIIv permissible such lot in a manner cu ^..hich said lot is located, within the soning ^a«-v for^the preservation E35>lain in detail. , , . . alij U iiv\ <»';•.« <*•“•4-Vx. iS •.< .auj »* "'j \Lr • 4<'. •'•A. a (c.V> Tttf. 5* j'' «:4 ■' ' • -- . f* s ^ 1 > i ( ^ ■ \ :\ \ • . • It . C- W C ‘ ^ Ls.^.c.k:. v. r.vV cA nvxfe ^ ^ . . V iU’ili r>C' i.*-- » c k ' I S i V> i% * ' 'or-. tvi.TH t i' »•;<.■ . I / I ‘ i K' AH'J t<T 1 ~ I.tAiiJi /» I ‘‘'-''it • I yL X r'*'.4\..xi li'^ .■■■' <■ I'• . /.y V . • '' I i \ ^*oO --' 'W.WF rs. bxc6 TTor tope exc« or 1 or i to G is 1 8 listed ix» ilatlons: Lv.i 'f V : ff ,* *^ -1’ Rc ^ T 8 property last six ncil*3 action. in the ibliahed lil after requirement 8. nation of" at in a or undue or using sible ocated* servation the appli- fflculty ) applicant. c * t *i ^ < Itti vii.j t i r ,.( kt \\ ^ ^ . I •| t *.*■• ^* i ^ I <• fr i K-» I ^ (Hun Lic k cr>. I T$. Exceptional Conditions of the f<ot: There are special condi tions (narrowness, shallowness or shape of a lot, exceptional topographic or water conditions or other extraordinary and exceptional conditions or such lot) applying to the structures or land in question that arc peculiar to the property Involved or inmediately 'idJoining property and do not apply generally to other land or structures in the district in which said land is located. Explain in detail. kirect on Welghi)orhood and Comprehensive Plan: Granting the variance will not iiiq)air an adequate supply of light and air to adjacent property, unreasonably increase the congestion in the public streets, increase the danger of fire, endanger the public safety, unreasonably diminish or impair established property values in the surrounding area, or in any other way impair health, safety, comfort, morals, or in any other respect be contrary to the intent of the Zoning Ordinance and any applicable comprehensive plan. Explain in detail. >v le rollowlng material must be attacked to this applicati^ A map or plat showing the property affected and all lands within 150 feet of the boundaries of the property affected by proposed change. ( copies) An abstractors certified property certificate listing the names and addresses of the owners of the land within 150 feet of the boundaries of the affected property as those names appear on the records of the County Auditor of Hennepin County. Acknowledgement yd Signature; Hie undersigned hereby repre sents upon all of the penalties of law, for the purpose of inducing the Village of Orono to take the action herein requested, that all statements herein are true and that all work herein mentioned will be done in accordance with the ordinances of the Vmage of Orono and the laws of the State of Minnesota. Date '^ i •(T' f * ^ Signature f^or Official Comments Only: i ,V - • i Vi 1! k„t E a y Ww'r>.*W» SUBJHCT: Plaiming Conmissiort and Council ^ f L- -• llank MiLhich, Zoninp Administrator January 31, 1977 ■f- •I* * % flood Shepherd Parsonaj^ - 2466 Diinwootiy Avenue Conditional Use Permit - Renewal The applicant is requesting a renewal of the original Conditional Use permit approved ^8us^ 25, 1975. At that time, the Council suggested this be retume*! for . renewal after a year's operation. Although this condition was not part of motion in the minutes, the Comcil was concerned because of the intended public use of a private access road. This application varies a little from the previoas one. The application approved in 1975 notes the proposed use as a Daytime Activity Center. The current application indicates the proposed use as eilucational facility and program for the developmental ^ eiKlos^ sketch shows a proposed parking area and driveway located on the churdi property witi access from the church parking lot. T!vis would eliminate excessive use of the private access road and hopefully eliminate tlie concern of other propertv owners using this private access. I am enclosing copies of the nei«r site plan shewing the proposed parking lot. Mso and^Suncirmimt” application made in l!)7)i alonn with the Plan’ninR Conmission .V...'. "7s % 5^ ’;i .•v„ !vil u I?'-/ rr:f. ■ V 4 :-k j. ■ f*, >4 4 I 'f! ■ - laOCATICN OF PRC Address 246( Legal Desciipti APPLICAhTT Name Good S Address 3 745 ONNER Name Good Address Present Zoning Zoning Ordinana Specify Ordinanc 34.530 Explain Request educational, for the chu is designed mental reta Extent of Non*c<x Hardships to Pro| The facility to city wate] programs c ments in th spaces and the property programs mv Applicati( Plat Map i Survey (SI % urmit approved i retumod for IS not part of :nded public i approved in ipplication level opmcntal >n the churdi excessive her property ]ot. .Mso ing Commission location of proposal cm OF ORONO, MINNESOTA Conditional Use and Variance i^plicatib^ {i %¥ TYPE OF REQUEST Address 2466 Dun woody Avenue, Wayzata, Mn, 55391 Legal Description Tract F ^ RLS ^ N l/Z Section 20 I'lat - 43iU2 - Parcel oOuu “ APPLICANT Name Good Shepherd Lutheran Church phone # 471-8433 Address 3745 Shoreline Drive, Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 ■■ ■ ■ - --------------------- -------------- ONNER Conditional Use Variance Wetlands Variance Riprap Name_ Address Good Shepherd Ltttheran Ghurp^j^^ m LR iC Resideipj^^nt Zoning Ordinance Section ^34.530 (Ref Specify Ordinance Requirements_ _ FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Council Action Date Approved Denied 34,530 (Ref 34,020) - Conditional Uses Permitted in IR-IC Zone; 34,021 Schools ' - 1-4; 022 oilurches explain Request Relative to Requirements This request is two-folcj both programs being request would be to use the facUity as an educational buildinc programs. The second program ia al50~g auCHtlOflal Ih il&tUra Shd j.8 designed to meet the needs of the children in the community in the areas of mental retardation and/or devel6pmentAl dei'Ay, ' ■ Extent of Non-confoimity Hardships to Property (Your reasons for requesting this Variance or Conditional Use PennitJ Jhe facility under consideration meets all conditions: it is sewered, and connected to city water; it tias two on grade exits/entrAnces; three resfroomff:—Wg~p3rt 6f the ^Q^rams could be construed as materially injurious to the properties or improve, ments in the vacinity. Our proposal would require a minimum number ol pAYkinc ,;paces and most of those will be provided in the church parking lot which adioins the property, r encing the property would not be required, SiiiOe-------- programs wiU t»j*rertMeNB!feSMi ‘W06MPt^ (^klst be submitted 1 week prior to Council Meeting) ^ ^ request for renewal of the use ^ 1' .< •> fortified Property amers within (f^^ft7]r from Hennepin Cbimf)rfegistrar of Deeds ''5. $30.00 Fee Survey (Sketch in proposal) Date / I '■/ • \ Signature I <:' t w ;?>•' -•'.V-v REQUEST tional Use Ace ids Variance ) CIAL USE ONLY il Action me; 34.021 Schools "■ ■ ■ 34:022^hurches ►roKTHms being itional building : TFf nature and e areas of onal Use Permi^ and connected No pare oi the es or improve- hber oi par King which adjoins Rg'feMlfe------- his a request for ewal of the use «5e.£fe.) - strar of mmmm aJZu o^to m €1 in •H ftt o otfl€) n>e g •H C §* o ••ccn V Idin N ^ X rt to 3C S 9 •O di jd to P« in «T o> in •d 9cn d cd d> 4^ •2 ^ ® o < ino t>o >s d "2 cI O •!-H ■u8* < § « S ° tJQ ra 0) <o H qC'O ^ < ^ rt OU (M 2 H —P -.1^ /i HHHP - . i-ia :<a6^S63^rj::3^SS • •# •••;.: !6"P ■ ' ■ .' v- V>i * a [;• .ii 'i'i PE?ICE GOOD SHEPHERD LUTHERAN CHURCH 3745 SHORELINE DRIVE. £1 j vr WAYZATA, MINN. 55391 PHONE: 471-8433 • » 1 f t «Ti r f -hi ^•V.- JaniiHiy 5, 1077 Mr, i.. 'radley Vnr.Koat llayoTf City of Orono 13‘J5 Hroim ’loju? t>, i-oiti; Laiie, I innorjoUt 55!*r>C leax Drail: Thanic you a ain fci* sto>>*'in<» iii to vi^ii vifli lae. I'lic conmion concern for the volfare of or.r c<*rnnuuity haa certainly been evidenced by botrti uood ohcj'lieid aud Uk* i rono adninisirators. tiiclo.sed vitli tliis letter aic: (l./ The ConditiuimJ Cse A]>)»ljcation 2,) Lur checU for tltirty doU.'ivp A letter .1 wailed out to the lesidcvite of Dunv'oody .'.veimo [ :ve look foi%'ard to receivin?: o>.ir peruiit aovu;, Tf t'lero is a:iythiii(j 1 couH do to speed tliiu/.s uy, (.Icoia* contact rue. 1 send jtorsonal re.'raruf- foi’ a riroaperoua and ahbce.'safiil ne\.’ ve.ir! .iincerely, » K-'i.?.^ m • • dnci; k, '.'ierii i’astnr f .* v».J o)g@S0Vg .'Ali I i i3<. \ VILLAGE OE ORONO i.-ear I a? V fni ;i 1 I the j). As % CM Use ]’< procej One o! that ' 1 ass’ I P air.i oi:r c\ in fix as an If you EPHERD CHURCH WAYZATA, MINN. 55391 PHONE: 471-8433 PEJICE GOOD SHEPHERD LUTHERAN CHURCH 3745 SHORELINE DRIVE.WAYZATA, MINN. 55391 PHONE: 471-8433 **•f V Jnmini7 5, 1977 I aj,pic‘ci>ite verv much th« lelaliionsriu t>mt ry Iniiily ei.‘joyed \.^,A\c liuth, Teddy, da^on an«l ? vcro livin-; in ■the parsuna<;e :'t 24GG Duriwoody .Vvenue. As you laiow Good Shepherd apoHed Xor nnd received a Conditional Use J em.it foi lliat j roj'eity in June of 1075. e arc iiov in ilie process of renex/inyr that pcrn'.it. tne of goals as tl»o pastor cf .ood 'du;])!ierd is to continuo Mmt "hood .'•ei;;hhor'' rolic}’ v;i(.I*. yeo-. I :i.->sur(! you t’^nt v^c vill ;:ecp (•I;o traffic on CJjurci* I2oad to « r.nwi!:.:c.i. Cur vimrch Council ha.s aiprovod (.’'o pl.uis to *.iut in oi:r OVI.1 drivc’-ny usin*:: the entr nee frci» :;i,«(hvay 15 and* goiiif.; in front of our chui'ch building, r?»e i'arsonn.v'o vili be used aa an educational building for the church. If you have any questions, ])lcaso feel free to contact :.ne. ace rely, «)/iCh .1, iilOMX lastor pmg0 3 >p i-V'* 4 f ■' . v^ V i ^.1 h; 4 ’^1 ■ t- f-I i4 y r p m O liJ . ‘ • f i -i*- 9 iLtJ L>'• %m.4y->-; Ii -Sift*-*.' ‘Bk*- :.*q (f t>* ’ V- 9- ■ -i.' •-■ ••■ It-^*1 ::hurch VAYZATA, MINN. SS39I PHONE: 471-8433 . r. 1 e 3 f "i" s] -i- .S ' m }: »• *■ • *•* • t V* t* Ip; 4 I •' * \ ^ S U./z •W, » ^ V ..if *•.'f* 0Vi :r m • • 4* ^. • ■4. >:♦ .y.. •r . ,• • • ‘ -r .3'^ i: • •* •> *4 '.V r r- •- • vt • LV>»!( 3 A« t*rz^x ♦ 4, *•'' 2?«Si!5 ^4>.<1’ V mm ■n^.' •f/j ■iV I1^*f ••••*'•• ri M •feiv 'i'.v.A.;»v.* P* \ j.tt > » .'A.' i; ■ ''X! .= ; ‘*1** *1 *1- Jfji- ^i’-‘ '.... 1 :.. '/s * 'y ' ■/. . . • . # ^ " ♦.. •,. v'5i< 00^0m m '' I • 1 jk ' r .• • < «S).. . .•* •».%wr i*'.i'..w f •'> , S'^ # V j^-S' f.'r*' >. ■ i >' •4’^ *1- ^ •* ♦•• •• • • *4*iC-'5- .li ■».* 9* » » < •i.# . •• V i- i .% ^ m EX: " i^--'r ■•* ■ ‘ .- '-:> -•■ ; i f 4 -• •% '■ V ■i;:X.:X--c.j?W ;•> r « ►V •.'*■•■** . • • .nr; ^'t":£iv^5>b:: Sii^..,X't • • r ' :•: •Va'*> % .' . ...>.■■ ■ - --*-^ <% Vil Conditi Direction a. ] b. c. 1.iiaxne < GOOD S Addrei 0 0 3745 S 5.Street Parcel k*Leoal Tract 1 Plat - adjolr No Presen Residei for Go( Church Pre sen LR 1C 1/2 Aci ■saa ■r^SS^^T- Mm' f. f ■■• ■ r,.r-’ i^x (■ ■. > ■ im >V". .i 'H' '■.', •' - ,i :h- F •» Ip •.#34 eu ^ Villai^e of Orono Conditional Use Application For Official Use Only Name Case No. Directions to Applicant: a.Fill out this form in duplicate by typing or printing in ink. If the spaces provided are insufficient, use additional sheets, keying information to the proper item number. b. c. Attach all supplementary material by paper clip. Pile d\;^lioate applications and filing fee (g 30.00 ) with Zoning Administrator. 1 • Name of Owner: (Last) GCX)n SHEPHERD LUTHERAN CHURCH (First)(Middle) 2^Address of Owner: (No. and Street) (City and Zone) (Phonel . 3745 Shoreline Drive, Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 Street Address of Property Involved: Parcel-2466 Dunwoody Avenue Church - 3745 Shoreline Drive i|.« Legal Description of Property Involved: Tract F - RLS 660 - N 1/2 Section 20 Plat - 43102 - Parcel 6000 Does this property border on oi adjoining municipality? 6. Present Use: Residential - Parsonage for Good Shepherd Lutherin Daytime Activity Cente: Church I fapprox. 10 per day) 9. Present Zoning District: LR 1C 1/2 Acre - Residential - Sewered 7. Proposed Use:o. Date Property Acquired: 10. Requested conditional use is authorized under the following sections of Zoning Ordinance: 34.530 (Ref - 34.020 - 34.021 - 34.022 : 1^0 TE: I T c 11 m> ai a: O ) Middle) (Phone) an Property ired: nal use is tie following Ordinance: 34.021 - 34.022 K ' ■ f- ■- If] ■4 . <1 * , I L in' i r-~\ i ti ;■ •• • • •% TT7 Tsihat are tiie req uireroents of the ordinance sections listed in Item 10? 34.530 (REF 34.020) - Conditional Uses Permitted in LR-IC Zone 34.021 - Schools 34.022 - Churches For vdiat period of time is the conditional use requested? Until termination of Daytime Activity Center Has an application for a conditional use pemiit on the same property been acted upon by the Village Council within the last six months? If so, state the date of the Village Council*’s action. The law requires that the conditions set forth in the following three items Il|., 15, and 16 MUST be established before a conditional use can be granted. Explain in detail after each statement wherein your case conforms to the reqtiiirements. 1 :^c_p.rd with Purpose s of Zoning Code, ^e proposed location of the conditional use is in accord with the objectives of the Zoning Code and the pui*poses of the district in which the site is located. Explain: The major Inspiration comes from the people of the Good Shepherd congregation, and is considered part of their outreach program. It is important to note, however, that the Shoreline EArly CHildhood Develop ment Center is a separate, non-profit corporation. This corporation serves an an umbrella to include a Preschool and Child Care Center, both of which are housed in the Good Shepherd Church facilities, and a Daytime Activity LiCn uGT • . > iv- V c f . M- f > u'- If •'V ' i ••v'l 'it ■ ■■ m p'-'f- m 15. PubT the t woul< the ] to p: The fj and Cl three No pa; prope; Our p; those Pencil take ] 16. Comp] Zonii The pi the ne retard not on addres ns listed It aested? the same thin the Lage 1 the Lished Ln >rms •- ^ • V ;lves of I which the erd It is i Develop- oration serves >oth of which Line Activity ‘I *■1 -L - -y'.. r-*- 'It*', rif-r mm 16. 15. ^biic Health, Safety and i/elfare. The proposed location <:he conditional use and the proposed condition under which it would be operated or maintained would not be detrhnental to the public healthy safety or welfare or materially injurious to properties or irtiprovements in the vicinity. Explain. The facility under consideration meets all conditions: it is sewered, and connected to city water; it has two on grade exits/entrances; three restrooms. No part of our program could be construed as materially injurious to the properties or improvements in the vicinity. Our proposal would require a minimum number of parking spaces and most of those will be provided in the church parking lot which adjoins the property Fencing the property would not be required, since the entire program will take place within the confines of the facility. Cyapliance with Zoning; Code, proposed conditional use will comply with each of the applicable provisions of the Zonin3 Code. Explain. The proposed program is educational in nature and is designed to meet the needs of the children of the community in the areas of mental retardation and/or developmental delay. It is specifically structured not only to deal with the special needs of these children, but also addresses itself to related parental and family needs. 'f m-:- NOTE : The f 17.A map o within 18.An abst. names o: boundar; 19.Detaile* 20.Acknowlf • •upon ai: the Vii: all stai tioned t Village ^ Date location ox der ipdilch it iinental to y injurious xplain* is sewered, ranees; urious to the es and most of ins the property e program will tional use s of the ed to meet Rental structured but also & •j A i-. r. r ■I'- \ ' ♦ .i * i *• r,‘ ■% The following material roust be attached to this application; 17.A map or plat showing the property affected and all lands within 300 feet of the boundaries of the property affected. 18.An abstractors certified property certificate listing the names of the property owners within 300 feet of the outer boundary of the property in question. 19. Detailed plans and drawings showing the proposed development. 20. • • Acknowledgement and Signature; Ihe underatgnAd Via-nAhy penalties of law, for the purpose of inducing the Village of Orono to take the action herein requested, that au statements herein are true and that all work herein men- tioned will be done in accordance with the ordinances of the Village of Orono and the laws of the State of Minnesota. /7. /QTO" Date For Official Comments Only: w I t » mmIff f- i if:;:® f^ OHONO* COUN JT! *^varend j< Propose apj • Day Care Z*utheran Cl that Churcl residents r for public of tt using a pri Mho ma Who po Zt was reo to use Ch agreement to use ChuIm Butler __ conditions Lutheran C Bay Care A ffS-: to I Only f 10 cwiaP*r day or ... • ................. I ''•fy Every *reaao keep traffi activit Mg'VfA* aonths. •a I®VUUNCU, MEETIHG HEU) AUGUST 2S, 1975 Page 2 ^^M'^apptOMl the Council to • Day Care Active 2 conditional use permit for Lutheran ChS^eh^^7^c®Sw®^ Shepherdthat ChSrS^f^:.^^® Shoreline Drive, stating residents near^?K^' 2 private street acconunodating for public church, should be available owner McClordy, stated using a objected to a business9 private street for public purposes asking: Who maintains it? 2. lilho polices it? CONDITIONAL USE PERN 3745 Shoreline Drive IT ^ to use Chu2J3?*e?®^ that if the public is allowed m- alr^^Ln^^S harmless•vreement should be initiated. Paurus seconded, to grant a Lutheran^Church ^*^® ShepherdDav^c22 Shoreline Drive, for a tST ^ly for ®2® y®®^' ^ til S*??" *'^‘*'* • revlw aftersxx months. Motion. ava« r ft _ /a% CONDITIONAL USB PERMIT 3745 Shoreline Drive (Continued) *®**ths. Motion, Ayes (i) - Nays (0), * . • • •« •J' . » '• ■ I-• 9 • * ■ fSiSn a; * VV'".; >;; V ■ ifcisISK.l*'•• ■.. p* • I'vi;- , 4j V* . -V - '.and avo r^-.‘ and par fyir- 'H'J) •■■ ••■ ' .1. • * ' ■■ m F Brad ' dJvls; Brad 1 Sioj^ ftenry ceitif Pistor and th do. T an inf opporti retards Pat MbI S. U H, Hb fse] After I were 2b Brad Va 8:30. m : 'Iv .V •<■ t *'^ V* .' After It held and Van Nest we^. Indicati were bro able con woidd 11] usage In parscBiagi would be ^ nunbi and lacsi wt. Atbs (S), ■' ,y®r- ' *»/ t y*' * f f. P«9« 2 riONAL USB PERNIT Shoreline Drive fl >1 INAL USE PEENIT >reline Drive led) M ft€m t • m ft mmwmm&hm.sa f ■/•• pt'i# THF; R/iNfnNB On^SSmN A‘ t* $ tm ^ ^4.-4 J *» *’» waiminjf CotMiMi ao ihc?^^* ^ I^KPOund of wiiat thsjr »t«acd sm W CHDnCH* PUBLIC MBM09B. S/45 Shweiim jpr^ JUmiBKA? , y^LlC I 1/ S/4S9M • • #. I L •;x7rv<^,f J F / i'ii! ’,. J 1 J trM. ... <4.^it ip.-. «0*5hiS‘L^jL‘rt!r *»Ww of Tteet A,«! LeisXt th«; Ao Wriwte mvta« mmi. "STitofS gju?S“Sri2 2to tei ^ ;Good Shejdierd fe-rr >;• : ►iv't “•* ' ‘ ** ^■3l2*2Mte ‘’‘*®“***« «"»»*» Good Shop.r» I» m-' to SS5*5*c^dw- I22f }£?..!?_!®?-I^ !^ttld*#f snm CHDIIOHXND. Iwar AcrmiYt t-<9n% ShoMUw •• r ■■'" useage of the private iraed people m ?!4J a»|.» t:*< ^ Vmm:.' ..h: ^Vl'/' s. S«3d S Sr* Should be indicated vhat people fRrraiSLy^^ lot In excess of diirch pst^v M location on tho lot to aw it cmin); roquirawnts wm Ayna (S), Mbjts (O). ■ • 1^ * • V^oo*L lui, rnoiiSF MlNriEAPOLIS, MINN. 55415 PROPERTY OWNERS LIST NAME ADDRESS j CBooV-.I>a^t.oo. 3* J*..WptAtAE3 IISjo tx.'^>..r.c,oy AVC *5T. j vEkjio ET H. sec T(_fT -2“I I I 'W-Vfft.J.. KJoCS-^yscji ^S‘V) ^CTv_o^i pClo uO S^ijI LJ S~7'-i-5 ;iu.'«?n. lot" 'hpL “J' I'ATTICA „CU^C. Cc> I Mapioi-'JLJl »*t>|/^ -\Z'^?^0")LjO 'S')! -.2^ R.^A...Mci:mTy |i ijJAUDA 5‘CMc»eFP; t S VajOATAJA Lav-)<£>(-'|2. O'f^sxc 66511 «> l3 U)lV\ t • Pj:s.y L Ak^D jV) C..V i: • |(^T^T V)0 ‘'V3\0'0 tract a I • • I j t-DAEU L., PiCHAieOSCA-7o T)^mv.--ou ^ _ f7‘T'viU W’muVc. G>ooO Sniip LuTl-^ r.\;i I,.-O', .li ■•.•'i'j lf3 R iiA- 1A.C ilAtt V HJT-t.?- iXoRR C3 o ♦ H«»c C.>»'nvv.r 6a’5'i< SB •9f» F #• • •• «»* »• I . ■/I • I *r, 'm fir*'; h r -tr • *.; • r-2 r-.i f..p.• 1 •«« • It •r •• 'Hr ' : A *.• fJ". C r. T if '2« . • 1 uSt 0*KAu«i'.C(9 .. > ,f m. m. ^ AMr7£Vl_V, rU;7 ■ :•? _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ -rf j • %. '. t i 4’ FROM: DATt; SUBJECT: Ip 4?i i' Planning Conmission anil (Council i Hank Muhich, Zoning Administrator February 2, 1977 Rebecca Dcrrv' - .\iirscry ami Child ftevclopntent Center Rebecca Deny is considering purchasing this projTerty ami continuing the same use. I see no problem in tiiis, but 1 think wo sliouJd get some confirmation on the maximum number of students and teachers involved, I believe we should also inform the applicant lunv we might feel about any jwssible future expansion of the facility. We should also resolve parking rc«{uirements here so as to prevent any problem from excessive-on-strcet parking. Although this is an existing noii-conforming use, I think the Planning Cownission and Council should review all projected transfers if any conditions might be appropriate. 4 " ie same ition on mid also lion of :o ore vent .ommiss ion '.ht he > ! i f:-‘ ■ .i: •i '-■A W tm >:r 1 * t m .1; . i -■V: u 1i^r*. • r*^ ..eci .;(.c:.* • • * • * * t/ t V.X bw*.^ ^ .. i nri Januc.!-/ ic , XS77 f-.*o.io 7Ux..,.,^:. C:.i..ii:i.x f I -1 s 1^ <J 11/ V I ; w . .'.x'Ow-. V* « «V../1 Vrli liojA r ^ - ‘4;^-.' •-‘i-,/ .1' 7. 0 Wa;,i ..r- O..:0 . . iu :? icuK 1T-Oi. OC. V :i t. :;l;ti1 ■ \ # ’!7 '•.Ov’L .i . ^ ^n i«.CVO 1 . « • V i/Ui’J V. X i 1% V ..'Ll i « .*’..J‘i i. .i. i'i . 0 ; •• f « i • j. ■■ ■ i I. /•: u . ! ' 'JL - *■• • *• • t- / ,. I* * »* , ^..u .1 i.>^* ./U!;!: V ^ * X I »,/V..O I’l Oil • J .. I - ^ .> J »im j ^ 0./^0<?>TC ->4 £ « «w •*- J ^ • imn '*ta i> i;7i3-:<?!IF -4' *■ •% r4i <r ;-• FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Stc Sei This applicati authorization when Mr. Perry reluctantly ap correspondme 31.700 on 9>8* pre-trial hear lieu of remova with a new nor change the app or not this su be done (only the Court cale Couicil decisi Iteiuy F. Muhich and Walter R. Benson A. P. 01son» Asst. Zoning .Administrator Febniaiy 3, 1977 Stewart Perry - 2975 Casco Point Road Seawall and Riprap Ihis application is before the City to review woiic that was done without Council authorization as required by 31.700. The last action by Council was 6-14>76 when Mr. Peny was advised that the retaining wall portion of the work was reluctantly ^iproved, but that the seawall must be removed. The enclosed correspondoice followed, and then Mr. Perry was tagged for non-compliance to 31.700 on 9-8-76. The matter was before the Municipal Court on 1-18-77 for a pre-trial hearing at which time Mr. Perry suggested a compromise. Briefly, in If ‘ieu of removal of the treated wood seawall Nbr. Perry says he will cover the wall with a new mortared stone facing to prevent water from reaching the wood and to change the appearance of the wall. The question before the Council is whether or not this suggestion will be satisfactory, and to idiat extent the facing should be done (only part way up or coiq)letely covering tiie seawall). The matter is on the Court calendar for 2-15-77 for trial or continuance depending upon the Coincil decision. Mr. Fr Attorn' 4344 I Minnea Dear M I \ If tha entire Th« of lee< where : effect: Th: when wc I I propos€ Counci] SRP/bk c.c. Al Vi Be Cr Coifficil 1-76 IS 1 i to For a ly, in the wall and to lether ng should sr is on le fP& m t; m mmM-m Mr < >•.< ' ‘.;4 »S iiaAi&i&iiAi r- ^ •*■ ‘ ii Mi r 'i > -a i .#■ '1 ..V •f t-^r >■ ^^jg^aeffigw v.r^ ■ ■■<• t I. A\ { Jmw OffkU*i STKWAKT H. PEKKY Law C cntcr B uilding I62S Park Avknuc Minneapolis . Minn . SS404 Phonc 336*8611 » * February 2, 1977 Mr. Frederick C. Brown Attorney at Law 4344 IDS Center Minneapolis, Minnesota 55402 Re: State v.fOlseiw Dear Mr. Brown:Rrrw) Sorry about my misunderstanding. I submit herewith my proposal to effect a solution to our problem. I will put in pine log stone, two railroad ties high. If that does not look good, I would like to cover the entire retaining wall. The ties have been acri-guarded and there is no sign of leeching except in one high spot (about two feet long) where I missed the second coat. This spot shows the effectiveness of two coats. This work will be done commencing in late spring or when weather permits. I believe this sets forth our understanding as to the proposed solution, subject to Planning Commission and Council approval. If not, please let me know. Very truly yours, SRP/bk Stewart R. Perry c.c. Al Olson, Inspector Village of Orono Box 56 Crystal Bay, Minn. 55323 ffJ '7. -* fci I V/ VILLAGE :n* GROW COUNCIL M Notify m contribute and replac instmeted the City c Amy Corps Ihe Counci violation Jiaie 29, 1 >n to ligh. sign Long) or ) the > r \ I -in] ■ ! '-> 7 fit ;>T- ORONO •i-: mi \71 V , ;••' i j .• :■ v;u.^'.;L VviV'i . >««^BSSsailnMn fmtF' *fe. • *4. •• toi w. R. Benion FMNt n. F. Muhieh OMBi June 3# 1976 #131 SOftJBCTi Stewart Parry * 2975 Caseo Pt. Rd. Mr* Parry has already eoaplatad axtanslva grading and tarracing within 75* of Lake Ninnatonka. A "Stop Wort" order was issued isMdiataly after ws baciM aware of the project. All of the upper sections of the tie terracing haws been filled. The log tie seawall along the lakeshore has net bem filled# however. The ties used are treated and would definitely contribute to the pollution of the water in Lake Minnetonka. In the past we have# with the exeeption of the one eetal seawall# always insisted on 12" rort rip rap along the shoreline. The treated ties used for terracing would probhbly have less effect on the water quality but way contribute It to pollution through runoff. Nr. Perry had also proposed to do soee planting in and along the terraced Areas. X suggested he postpone tiiis until the terracing natter was resolved. PLMINING COMMISSION ICETING - June 8# 1976 nded following: 1) 2) 3) ISMdiate (within 30 days) renoval of the creoeoted tie seawall. Msplacensnt of the seawall with m>proved stone rip rap. Approval of the terracing subject to approval of the other agencies involved. (DOUNCIL fCETING - June 14# 1976 Notify applicant by nail that newly installed seawall of creosoted timber contributes to pollution of Lake Minnetonka and should therefore be removed ^ xeplaced with approved riprap material (boulders). He should also be instructed to follow procedures for subsiitting application for riprap with the City of Orono as %«ell as the D.N.R.# the Watershed District and the Amy Corps of Engineers. Ihe Council also instructed staff to withhold issuing a citation for violation of the ordinance if the application for riprap is submitted before Jine 29# 1976. mm ■ t r:- ^. V - Jr’ iiiL • t I'.i.viiiii.cj V.II •’•A* Dcnsm r.cv3d, (kith area variaxi CTntruction Ayes (5) - Mr. Sip.9 wa 'iiis after- tion of a c John Gethai wood was pr coo^laint a problem of Make moved# Conditional 1) Removal so as tc 2) Protecti interfei 3) Corbinat 4) Agreemen "hold-ha problems 5) Inv3stig Enqineei the int€ private Motion# Aye: Discussion < the-fact pr aftor the oi discussed ii treated (cr opposed. Pi of tlie tern 1) Lnmediat< tijiber si 2) ReplaceiK rap. 3) Approval ^>c^i^'all I Motion# Ayes This item ws to tlic Planr inlomation the Gonsnissi fXmmssion e stoim seivers west of Coun v'atw-r toward i:*!■: Ithin Ly after tia »ra has finitely :ha past ited on bsrracing ribute »rxacsd m arssolVsd. 1. tneiss timber i removed ilso be rap with I the )r ted before IS m I m m m-- ■'i f Jh 'ivA, #i .•„^ * [ ^ it ► '- :‘-V, : ;*v Ir J ll • y ‘ t ¥\: ( ■j;.? I -r>.- \y ' • •?)d ■iM V<i- A 1 tiLLk) «>U^ 6, tO - tMJi J ^!r. was present to describe his proposal. Hake r^cyM, C^thrie seconded, to recoMmd approval of a lot area variance and a 15 ft. side yard variance to allow cantxuction of an addition to his existing hoaie. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0). Mr. Sips was present to describe the circunstances of after-the fact proposal and to argue against installa tion of a catch basin in the drain line as requested by John Gethaidson, Road Supervisor. Glen Sauer of 4104 High- wood was present to say that he has had no problem or cooplaint about the dndnage thru this area since a plugging problem of the private tile line was corrected last year. moved, Ikmlap seconded, to reconnend approval of the Conditional Use Permit for filling subject to the following: 1) Rsmoval of excessive fill from around existing trees so as to prevent their destruction. 2) Protection of the graded banks to avoid erosion and interference with the sewer easement. 3) Corbination of lots 9 and 10 into one parcel. 4) Agreement of this and adjacent landowners to sign a "hold-harmless agreement" concerning any drainage problems or maintenance of the private tile line. 5) Jnv3stigation and recomnendations of the Village Engineer as concerns the need for a catch basin at the intersection of the Village culvert and the private tile line. i^otisn. Ayes (5) - Nays (0). D?.scussion developed concerning the history of this after- tlie-fact proposal including additional work being done axte^r the owner was notified to stop work. Intent was d5wscussed including access and erosion control. The use of treated (creosoted) timbers in the water was strenuously opposed. Pesek moved. Hake seconded, to reconnend approval of tlie terracing subject to the following: 1) Immediate (within 30 days) removal of the creosoted tiiiber seawall. 2) Replacement of the seawall with approved stone rip rap. 3} Approval of the other agencies involved of both the scffii'all and the terracing. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0). This item was acted upon by the Council without referral to t]ic Planning Gomnission and was discussed here for iiifoimation only. Councilli^ Welsh was present to ask for the Gonroission's conients cin this proposal. The Flaming Gummission expressed strong desire for investigation of stom severage of the roof and parking lot drainage to the west of County Road 19 instead of directing lOOt of the vzter toward Kelly Avenie. PHILUP JANS» loss S. BRONN P VARIANtZ WnjJiMSIME 4051 HIOiNOOD ROAD mONAL USBMCH, SIEMART FERlOr 297S CASCO POINT I OONDITIONAL USB F mm ocNsnucricN SUPERVALU 3333 SHORELINE DRIVE CONSTRUCTION PLAN !: I < > * i mm '‘A M .••• A' II' Itv.. If - - rvi; V ORONO council % Public*Hmarir Vhm Planning thm mubdivisJ Pmurus moved, •ubdivieion i ridge Lene, i being paid. Jmmes Sidwel] diecuse hie i hie property Wayne Peterec Commies ion hi and recommeni! Welsh moved, request for t 1375 Park Dri Mayor Searlee voting Nay. : Oiecueaion fo Butler moved, subdivision 1 per the Plann subject to th placement of fee. Notion, Neseengale an Naesengale me the rip rap p Point Road, a agencies. Me Massengale mov the rip rap pc Point Road, eu agencies. Mot Bsnry Muhich reviewed the Casco Point commenced ex Minnetonka w the neceeser Perry's exes' placament of line has vioi r *1 . .SI u «« mom 1976 • w — •:t' ^w- PUbllc*H«ariii9 * <7un« 8, 1976 Th« Planning Comisaion recomended approval of tha aubdiviaion. Paurua novad, Halah aaconded, to approve the aubdiviaion for Kam Hoppe, 2608 6 2610 Maple* ridge Lana, aubjact to one park dedication fee being paid. Motion, Ayea (5) - Nays (0)• Janaa Sidirall, 1375 Park Drive, was preaent to diaouaa hia requeat for a aubdiviaion to divide hia property into ti#o lota. Hia neighbor, Wayne Peteraon, vaa alao preaent. The Planning Coaniaaion held a public hearing on June 8, 1976 and reconmended approval of the aubdiviaion. Welah moved, Maaaengale aeconded, to deny the requeat for the aubdiviaion for Jamea Sidwell, 1375 Park Drive. Motion, Ayea (2) - Haya (3). Mayor Searlea, Councilmeiid>era Butler and Paurua voting Nay. Motion failed. Diacuaaion followed. Butler moved, Searlea aeconded, to approve the aubdiviaion for Jamea Sidwell, 1375 Park Drive, per the Planning Conmiaaion recommendationa, aubject to the engineer approving the drainage, placement of houae, and pay;jent of park dedication fee. Motion, Ayea (3) - Naya (2) •Councilmen8>era Maaaengale and Welah Nay. Motion paaaed. Maaaengale moved, Paurua aeconded, to approve the rip rap permit for Steve Plowman, 3024 Caaco Point Road, aubject to approval of other intereated agenciea. Motion, Ayea (5) - Naya (0)• Maaaengale moved, Paurua aeconded, to approve the rip rap permit for Joe Braun, 3020 Caaco Point Road, aubject to approval of other Intereated agenciea. Motion, Ayea (5) - Naya (0)• Page 3 SUBDIVISION 2608 6 2610 Mapleridge Lane (Continued) SUBDIVISION 1375 Park Drive RIP RAP PERMIT 3024 Caaco Point Road RIP RAP PERMIT 3020 Caaco Point Road L-' ^ ■ Henry Muhich, Building 6 Zoning Adminiatrai^, reviewed the application by Stewart Perry, Caaco Point Road. tfr. Muhich noted that Mr. Perry oonmenced extenaive grading within 75* of Lake Minnetonka without applying for or obtaining the neceaaary permita from the City of Orono. Perry'a excavation and grading, filling and placement of atructurea within 75* of the ahore- line haa violated aeveral proviaiona of the orlinancea. VARIANCE 6 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 2975 Caaco Point Road (Continued) Page 3 [ON 510 Mapleridge Id) :ON : Drive ERMIT o Point Road BRMlt o Point Road ft CONDITIONAL P D Point Road r- - 'Vs* Ivri' r: i-m m: Me l;’VviV;4 rv.=-i^^V: !<7V; m■A^gggs mB mm ORONO COUNCIL MEETING HELD JUNE 14, 1976 ^e dity issued a stop-work order inntediately after the staff becane aware of the violations, tir. Perry went ahead and filled additional Areas near the lake subsequent to the issuing of the stop-work order. Mr. Perry has used treated railroad ties for the terracing and at the water level on Lake Minnetonka. Nr. lluhich noted that in addition to the violations of the ordinances, the presence of the creosote logs will result in additional pollution to the lake. The engineer concurred that such pollution would take place because of the creosote logs. The City attorney noted that the City could tag Mr. Perry now and then ask him to file formal applications for the ripsaping of the shoreline or else the City could decide not to tag at this time and see whether or not Mr. Perry will work with the City to restore the area to its original condition. Mr. Muhich noted that Mr. Perry had not appeared before the Planning Commission or Council even though the matter was on the agenda. The City Council instructed the staff not to issue tags at this time but to inform Mr. Perry that he must apply immediately for a permit showing how he would remove the seawall next to the water made of creosote ties and would replace that with rip rap. That would be reviewed at the next Planning Commission and Council meeting and the City at that time would discuss whether or not additional action would be necessary by Mr. Perry. Searles moved, Massengale seconded, that the following recommendations be made to Mr. Perry, 2975 Casco Point Road: 1. The newly installed creosoted timber seawall contributes to pollution of Lake Minnetonka and should therefore be removed and replaced with approved stone rip rap. 2. He is instructed to follow standard procedures for submitting an application for rip rap with the City of Orono, the DNR, the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District, and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers. 3. Staff was instructed to withhold issuance of a citation for violation of the ordinance if the complete rip rap application is submitted on or before June 29, 1976. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0)• Page 4 VARIANCE 6 CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 2975 Casco Point Road (Continued) f d >4 4 4 * H i I i 'V y 4* W ■» .. rr ■: .1 * • • f ■ i wm. b VILLAGE OF ORONO Mr. StcMart 1 2975 Casco Nayzsta, Min r. Pany: Oh June 8, V. your in-plaa Goiaicil revii following: 1. The poi: ■ mid V > * • f • «•V.2. You . ► ♦ , . f 'idti the U.S. 3. StMi‘/#v • A vio: tin APO: be f age 4 ICE ft CONDITIONAL IRNIT lasco Point Road jiued)VILLAGE OF ORONO Mr« Stewart Perry 297S Casco Point Ri Niyzata» Mimesota S5391 Mr. Perry: .■ . - ,*-L :^£7 r Trlcphon* |7'r7lV Village of Orono post Ofrii'v Ho» <«H*('r>!ital Ray, Minnamta •’r>32.‘i*Muni«pal Ufftcc^ On the North Shore of Lake Minnetonka June 22, 1976 Qa June 8, 1976, the Orono Pluming Conmission wide reconaaindations co^eming your in*plaoe creosoted tiiiber seawall. Oft June 14, 1976, the Orono City Gouicil reviewed the Pluming Coimdssion reoonwndations and deterained the following: 1. The newly installed creosoted tiidwr seawall contributes to pollution of 1j >i» Minnetonka and should therefore be renoved aid replaced with approved stone rip rap. You are instructed to follow standard procedures for sub- idtting «i application for rip rap with the City of Orono, the TiR, the'Minnehaha Creek iteteirshed District, and the U.S. Arny Corps of Engineers. 3. Staff was instructed to withhold issuance of a citation for violation of the ordinance if the complete rip rap applica tion is subnitted on or before Jiiie 29, 1976. Ar P. Olson Building 8 Zoning Inspector . ^ Mr. A1 O: City Ins| Orono Ci- Crystal 1 Dear Mr. You so (I be' City act! I Wi meeting- witnesses I a: the next then, so I a{ meeting. 1. (Mr. Ben phone wii 2. a second 3. jurisdid 4. to use ri 5. lapped u| takes pli to boat n manufacti possible what couJ Trlcphont 17 v7‘jV Orono :)2-‘t*Muniapiil Ulfim ficeming ity d the m {ji •. ■•' -■V STBWAST R. PERRY t*' ' nt Anoarar at Law l«a8 PABS ATBNUS wsAPOuai. mmnaovA ssaoa TBuraoni June 29, 1976 Mr. A1 Olson City Inspector Orono City Offices Crystal Brty, MN 55323 Dear Mr. Olson: Thank you for your letter informing me of the Council's action. You may recall that I requested of you and Hank on June 14 or so (I believe the Council was meeting that evening) that before the City acted, I be allowed to go before the Commission. I was unable to go to the Council that night—or the Commission meeting—because the trial I was in was taking days and ni^ts (with witnesses, client, research). I also thought I was going to be in San Fransisco on June 21st, the next Commission meeting. As it turned out, I was still in trial then, so could not go. I again request permission to appear before the next Commission meeting. I wish to present certain facts, namely: 1. Literature on acri-guard, a paint used to prevent possible leaching. Oir. Bert Savltt, Savitt's Paints will be happy to discuss this by phone with you - 335-2187) i 2. The ties have been painted with the material and will receive a second coat. 3. I do not recognize the U. S, Corp. of Engineers as having jurisdiction and will not make application to them. 4, I question jurisdiction of anyone requiring me to make application to use rip rap. 5. The ties are npt in the water, but do, on rough days, get lapped upon. This has been since last October. Ihe leaching that takes place has to be miniscule (without paint-guard) at best. Compared to boat motor gasoline, (i§ there still discharges from lakeshore manufacturing plants?) and from other sources, the amount of any possible leaching has to be totally insignificant. I would guess that idiat could leach has done so already. V* I Mr. A1 June 2 Page t 6 retain requir know a of sev to the of $30 destru what c I if the and th consid remove I is den contes consci having SRPAk tion. or the ssion with 21st, trial ble leaching, by Mr. A1 Olson June 28, 1976 Page two 6, The ties act as a retaining wall, replacing an old, rotten wood retaining wall. 7. I do not want riprap on my land for aesthetic purposes, nor can I afford the cost of tearing out the ties and purchasing and installing riprap, and endangering my platform and the dirt under it. As you are aware, I did not get a permit—not knowing it was required. I did not intend to do terracing or a seawall. T did not know about creosote. What started out as a very minor levelling back of several feet, with ties four feet high in the bank to give some break to the ugliness of total wild brush and poison ivy (at an estimated cost of $300-$400) turned into a $4,100 expense due to the excavator’s destruction of the whole bank. I have done the best I could with what confronted me. I am aware that there has been a violation of the Ordinance, if the Ordinance is valid. However, I feel that under these circumstances, and the beautiful terracing that has resulted, together with the considerations listed above, an exercise of power to force me to remove the seawall would be unreasonable and work an extreme hardship. I again request an appearance before the Commission. If my request! is denied, then I have no alternative but to accept your citation and contest it. I know you have a job to do, and you have been doing it conscientiously in enforcing the law. I must also protect my interests, having found myself in a very uncomfortable situation. Stewart R. P^ry y SRPAk I ijSTA' ^COUT Stal V. Stew will atta< time i Way 2 c C •the O 'Si ll. Tl and Fc States !! I! j rights i jimposs. i;I power. 'i I •2. Dofe of the Th I present old, rotten wood urposes, nor sing and irt under it. ng it was T did net evel 1 i ng l5acK give some break n estimated cost cavator*8 OU.1 d w i th rdinance, hese circumstances, with the ce me to reme hardship. If my request citation and een doing it ct my interests. ur MlNrJESOTA I COUMTY OP HENNEPIN MUNICIPAL COURT third division - WAYZATA State of Minnesota, Plaintiff V. Stewart R. Perry, NOTICE OF MOTION and Defondant MOTION voo WILL PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the defendant above-named will bring on for hearing before the above-named Court the attached Motion, said Motion to be heard and submitted at the ta,me of trial on the 18th day of January, 1977, at the Courthouse, Wayzata, Minnesota, or as soon thereafter as counsel can be heard. MOTION TO DISMISS I comes now the defendant above-named and respectfully moves ' ■the Court for its Order dismissing the charge herein. Said Motion is based upon the following grounds: |1. The ordinance in question (31.700) is violative of the fifth and fourteenth Amendments to the Constitution of the Uni.ted, States in the following respects: i: I (a) It is an unwarranted intrusion into the property rights of defendant, (b) It is overbroad in its scope. I, (c) It is so unreasonable in its breadth that it is impossible of compliance and enforcement. t (d) It is an arbitrary and capricious exercise of r{'power. fI 2. Defendant was denied a reasonable regue-t ,r.cjucoc for a postponement of the hearing, thus depriving him of a fair hearing. I This Motion will be based upon the testimony and exhibits presented at trial. Respectfully submitted. I - WAYZATA ION fit above-named 3urt the :tc*d at the the Courthouse, fl can be heard. O DISMISS fully moves n. of the fifth iG United, -he property that it is rcise of nstponement 1 exhibits Ifenry F, ^Wlich, Zoning Administrator A, P, Olson, Asst, Zoning Administrator February 2, 1977 ! . Marina Licensing Status * ♦ Refer to individual marina memo, for detailed lnfon«,tion and compliance performance. Recap as of February 1, 1977, All 1976 licenses issued, 1077 /plications received, memo prepared; pTOhill Haaeomer's Association iiinnetonka Power Squadron Wayzata Yacht Club North Shore Union 76 North Star ^farina Faul*s Landing Windward Marina. Minnetonka Boat Works Stubbs Bay Marina 1977 ^^iplications expected: North Shore Drive Marina (owner Larrv fiork called 1 '»i 77 -.i illness had delaved his application ami thnt^i say that personal nayles Marina (no answer to^repeated callsproceeding wit»i it,) , -vw- • • V wm i - f’lK'sl. ■’^Kf'r ..'. -.r. • , • ts ^« ID: FROM: DATE: SUBJl-CT: Henr>' F. Muhich, !!oning Administrator A. P. Olson, Asst, Zoning Administrator February 3, 1977 Marina License - Stubbs Hay Marina, James McCleary 3445 Havsidc Road 1977 license application received on February 2, 1977 Annual Fee 72 Slips 120 Slides i 75.00 $208.00 $120.00 Total Fee $303,00 Due Facilities:One main dock, 180 ft. long with 3 amis (180 ft. total width) plus smaller docks along shoreline. Mo pontoon dock shown for 1077. Fuel Service; inside storage and l)oat repair. Qianges frcwi 1976: Boat and Pontoon rental discontinued. Aildition o^‘ 5 slips and 84 land storage slides. Previous restaurant and niarim imilding destroved bv fire 11-15-76. Council action 1-24-77 denieil re^iuost to reopen non-conforming restaurant. Application shows proposed plan for new 80 ft. x 200 ft. boat storage and repair building and stipulates removal of all existing stnictures. Proposed hours: 6 a.m. to 12 p.m. daily. 1976 landscaping completed: new trees and hedges. Prior landscaping not completed; none. Proposed 1977 landscaping:minor readjustment of green areas and landscaping around proposed new building; reisoval of existing main building and replacement with oiitsulc storage area. Percentage of completion - 4 year plan: lOO’o. Suggested area for attention: detailed access, parking, landscaping and appearance changes caused by new building construction (to be considered \dien building plans are submittcfl for review). t . m Vii , -AS . .-IT-i m • V" ' . ■■ {•■vi > ‘ 1 ■i. h) plus 077. I slips an<l l»lini> rwuobt% tjposcd ir.p and aping around ain building appearance an (to be ted for •.•>j ■V^ii'Mm iw ' <- mm t :. .» :■ i. .-.fc. » :.* m V’’ ■( •#. . r> T •■ ,1^' 5- ■■ m r> A. .*- j m- »%* •rtf' TO: > ’;l FRCM: DATE: Henry F. Muluch, Zoning Administrator A. P. Olson, Asst. Zoning Administrator January 31, 1977 SUBJECT: Marina License - Windward Marine, James Rivers 1442 Shoreline Drive 1977 license application received on Decen4>er 8, 1976 Annual Fee 89 Slips 30 Moorings $ 75.00 $133.50 $ 45.00 $253.50 nueTotal Fee Facilities* 2 docks with 40 slips on Tanager Lake, 2 docks with 49 slips plus Facilities. Application says dock locat on and length same as last year. Boat sales and service within building. Change from 1976: increase of one slip. Proposed hours: 9 a.m. to 9 p.in. daily. Prior landscaping not completed: original preen strip alOTg«P i, Bro»vn»s Bay, planter strip in front of sales building. Pwposed 1977 landscaping: concrete along house construction area. Percentage of con^letion * 4 year plan: 95t. Suggested areas for attention: continued parking and boat display on County riglit of way. '•'’1 fu. . d .V*-.1.SOA ' . - .V f • : I-’ t* ! i ■ w, -41 #V- TVl: FROM: DATE: lieni A. 1 Jam SUBJECT: Mari 1977 license f Annual fei 66 Slips Total Fee Facilities: 4 i Cliange from IS Proposed hour£ 1976 landscape Prior landscai: Proposed 1977 Percentage of Suggested area >s plus kI length Knil^s along ke, trees rent of sales • main sales ►val of :oimty rigjit la^ MlJ, .V»'j ' . Mm >« *v TO: : FROM: DATE: Menrv' F, Mu^tichy Zoning Administrator A. P. Olson, Asst. Zoning Administrator January 31, 1977 SUBJECT: Marina License - Minnetonka Boat Works, John Palmer 1449 Shoreline Drive 1977 license application received on January 27, 1977 Annual fee - S 75.00 66 Slips - $ 99.00 Total Fee $174.00 IXie Facilities: 47 slips on Brown's Bay, 19 slips on Tanager Lake, boat servicing inside building. Oiange from 1976: none. Proposed hours: 7 a.m. to 6 p.ni. daily. 1976 landsc£q)ing completed: row of shrubs along building and Brawn's Bay. Prior landscaping not completed: as below. Proposed 1977 landscaping: r^lace diseased hanlwood trees, add nw screening (6 trees shown) between building and Brown's Bay. Percentage of con^letion - 4 year plan: Suggested area for attention: none. 90"n. » , • * ■ , I 1977 licenf Annital 98 Sli| Total Facilities Change fro* Projiosed h< 1976 landsi Prior land: Proposed 1: Percentage Suggested i •,.,w4ii«i^: :..Jr ■es '^ * ■ . i-idiiiSfcV;.'':. TO:llonr\' r. Mihici», Zoning AJniinistrator ri?OM:A. P. Olson, Asst. Zoninj' Adninistrator DATi::.Janiian* 31, 1977 SlfH.li:cr: Marina License - North :-,tar Marina, Inc., Paul Keinpf 332*1 North Shore Prive 1977 license application and fee received on November 22, 1976. Anntuil Fee - S 75.00 98 Slips - $14".00 Total Fee $222.on Facilities: one dock with 3 side arms, anoroximatcly 300 ft. lengths, fuel sales, boat sales and service, rental of building’ to Perma-lop, Inc. for uj?holster>' repair and ruinufacturing. Change from 1976: addition of 3 slii>s (on Crystal I’.av) at old service dock. Pro|>osed hours: sales 8 a.n. to 6 p.m. daily; dock attendr..‘:t 24 hours per day from April 1.3 to October 31. 1976 landscaping completed: 'laxwcll 'day picnic area with grass, trees and. parking lot bumpers. Prior landscaping not completed: West side buffer area, replacement of f)lanting on cast side which has not survived. Proposed 1977 landscaping: none. Percentage of completion - 4 year plan: 80* (lacking front planting). Suggested areas for attention: Cooixjration witli County on drivesvay access,curl>ing and lajulscaping; lH*tter control of storage an«I parking on Comty right of way; control of west side sotb.'ick. »» ••vW SUBJI^: Mar 1977 license a Facilities: ^ Change from IS Proposed hour; Hen A. Jan Annual Fee 31 slips 40 slides 30 lifts 2.3 mooring Total Fee 1976 landscapi Prior landscaj Proposed 1977 Percentage of Suggested are: .1 V-T ■;' :. ; s. . . -:V*^ fuel sales, nc. for Jock. per day from and parking f planting, on zcss.curl'ing i rape an*4 r i| r- ' ^ f-'?. - ^ ifW'tsr .:■:i- ii ^V 'fl r.i’ \r i Td: FROM: DATE: Henry F. Muliich, Zoning Administrator A. P. Olson, .‘\sst. Zoning AJministrntor January 31, 1977 SUBJECT: Marina License - P.'iul's I.anJing, Paul Falilin 19SS Shorelinc Drive 1977 license application received on Januar>’ 11, 1977. Annual Fee 31 slips 40 slides 30 lifts 23 moorings $ 75.on $ 46.50 $ 40.00 $ 45.00 $ 37.50 Total Fee________ $244.00 Due Facilities: 4 docks to service pciirancnt and removable slips, slides and lifts; 30 permanent buoys: cvie rental tlock; liiel sale, bait and boat sales. j # Change from 1976: minor dock rearnmpement, chafigc from 50 slides to 40, :rom 62 slips to 61, increase from 20 iiKX>rings to 25. Net change 6 fo<er units. All !)oat service moved to Maple Plain. Proposed hours: 5 a.m. to 9 p.m. daily. 1976 landscaping completed: 'Taintcnance. Prior landscaping not completed: retention of nortlicast comer and south side as green areas, not fc»r summer storage. Proposed 1977 landscaping: none. Percentage of completion - 4 year plan: 991.. Suggested areas for attention:renewal of green areas and rcplacwient of hartiwood trees affected by disease. In June of l^'7f» a port able samhvich unit was installcil behir.d the min building, lliere has been no City authorization of this use. 'Iliere was also continued use of the Central Avenue property for boat storage. aMmuiff ■ es and lifts; nd boat sales. to 40, rroni Net change Plain. I south side as ine . ?nt of har«!wood of r’70 a port- jii\d the nain It nor i ration of use of t)ic iragc . ' ‘7- •••••■■>•:' llenry F. Mihich, Zoning A*lministrator I A. P, Olson, Asst. Zoning xXdministrator t • ► January 31, 1077 SUR.TF.cr; Marina License - North Shore Union 76, Arthur Omderson 3398 North Sliore Drive 1977 license application and fee received on Deceirber 13, 1976 Annual Fee 5 Slips $75.00 $ 4.50 Total Fee $79.50 Facilities: one T-dock, 80 ft. long, fuel sale, bait sales, minor boat service. Oiange from 1976; none. Proposed hours: 6 a.m. to 10:00 p.m. tlaily. 1976 landscaping completed; none Prior landscaping not completed; none Proposed 1977 landscaping; none. Percaitage of completion - 4 year plan: 99 Suggested areas for attention: 1) resolution of drainage problem in northeast comer. 2) completion of aiiiiing and landscaping along Tonkawa I’ooad. ■ ■ 4 ^: ‘I i*U \/:7 - «%. TO:• ?1 FROM; DATC; SUBJECT: 1977 licen Facilities Change fit '71 »at service. northeast comer, ping along . ....in-,...-., , Iiiii|ii>|ytiiiiirtt» ■ • i-fiiiMiiittiimriiiiniMi TO:Henry F. Hihidi, Zoning Administrator FROM;A. P. Olson, Asst. Zoning Administrator DAIT.; January 31, 1977 SUBJFCT; Joint Use Dock License Wayzata Yacht Club, Big Island 1977 license application and $10.00 fee received on January 6, 1977. Facilities: one dock, 200 ft. long, swinming beach, picnic and recreation areas (no permanent moorings). Oiange from 1976: none TO: ■ 7 ■1 FRCM: DATE: SUBJECT: 1977 licens Facilities: (3iange fron ^ / ■::vv-• :.^r- . .*% / IX): FROM: Henry F. Mnliich, loninp. AAninistrator A. P. Olson, Asst. Zoninp Administrator DATE:January SI, 1977 SimJECT: Joint Use Dock License Minnetonka Power Squadron, Big Island 1977 license application and $10.00 fee recciveil on Deceirber 8, 197(>. Facilities: 10 docks, each 40 ft, to SO ft. long (no permanent moorings). Qiange from 1976: none. f ■ 9 ^ . i'\ » . i - f 'W •■■>• fUi m»•;. ■ w- . o t ii: U:' ts. - •%. Id: FR11M: Hem A. DATE:Jan SUBJECT:Joi Foix: 180 1977 license a Joint Use 11 Slips Total Fc Facilities: < 1 Change from 1^ ■■••■r"'-.r^-:«>-:r ....i-ilii MiiiiWl A.. m*. '. .1 llenry F. Muhich, Zoning Administrator V\m: DATE: A. P. Olson. Asst. Zoning Administrator Jamiiry 31, 1977 SUBJECT: • ♦ Joint Use Dock License Foxhill Homeowner’s Association im Shoreline ^ivB (i nss Heritage l^e) 1977 license application and fee received on January J, 1977. Joint Use Fee 11 Slips $10.00 $16.50 Total Fee $26.50 Facilities: one dock complextotal length 144 ft., width I.'jZ ft. <Hange free. 1976: dock rearrengeeent (length and width reduced for rn-). one extra slip added. • ^7^ fi m:- \ -a ■> { 11 t ■■u .•. WtE- • » i • SUBJECT: Planning Conmission and Council Hank Muhich, Zoning Administrator February 2, 1977 Duck Problem I. Research Procedure 1-10-77 Received two petitions regarding complaints from neighbors of two Orono residents who have been feeding wild ducks. 1. 1-10-77 1-11-77 1-28-77 1-31-77 1-31-77 Petition #1 - 55 signatures (29 properties) Re: Howard White - 3908 Cherry Avenue in Petition concluded the feedinq of wild ducks s""* „hunsanitarv conditions of public beaches and private docks, lawns ana shorelines (health hazard). Winter de-icinq P^^for thewater area for water fowl but creates a dangerous public depending on adequate ice cover for access and use of the lake in the winter. 2. 2. Petition #2 - 45 signatures (24 properties) r/rx 'IS ri”:r unnatural habitat and migration pattern of said wildlife. Petitions presented to Council (Meeting of January 10, 1977) 1. Deferred decision for lack of time for review and staff reports. Felt initiating procedures for adopting ordinance forbidding feeding of wildlffe m?ght he over reaction. Ordinance be ,practical . and difficult enforcing - Orono is a nature area. (Feeding of wuld be common practice of tourists and residents without intent to disrupt natural patterns.) , 3 Directed Staff investigate and report on existing problem with suggestions and recomroendations for resolving said problem. Instructed A1 investigate problem ^or”as our health officer, P.C.A., Game and Wildlife, D.N.R., Game warden, or others that might be referenced by the preceding agencies. Havp not as vet received any report on subject so initiated project myself, clued Sarne rnd^rso^f P.C.A.'at (296-7326). Informed that State offices were closed for energy conservation purposes. Called Wayne Anderson of P.C.A. again. Again informed State offices closed for energy conservation purposes. Called Dr Larry Gallagher (Area Health Officer) at (472-1144). Was informed mIIJm w« his day off! When 1 asked if there might be anyone else «bo could hoin the receotionist inquired about the extent of emergency. When I explaine ♦•ho^nrnhlem to her She told me long range problems such as ours were conducted bTor^Jnarher! the%ppi?nte^ He^th §ff?cer of the district. Substitute .r- *. V* ri .i 4 ^ 1 w7Tr^-yi ) Orono i in ms and 5S open 3r the the lake I adopt >*ater an orts. ig feeding practical j of wildlife intent to (<ith gencies such Warden, or oject myself. State offices )ffices closed 0'i-'. m ;?rf' A' ■:‘i3 1 1 m Was informed else who could When I explained , were conducted Substitute ■•i 0.- 0- :x.. .^Duck Problem Page 2 officers could be contacted in cases of emergency only. 2-1-77 Called Dr. Larry Gallagher (Area Health Officer) again. Scheduled appointment to meet with him at a.m. on February 2, 1977. 2-2-77 2-2-77 Photographed subject properties. Hundreds of ducks in area - photos on file. Met with Dr. Gallagher (Health Officer) to discuss duck problem. He confirmed potential health hazard and danger from open water on ice cover of lake. Assured me he would send me a report relative to problems discussed. If I receive this report before the Planning Commission n»eetinq, I will have copies for you. II. Correspondence and Agency Reports Confirming Problem I would like to call your attention to enclosed copies of reports from the University of Minnesota (FWBI) dated 1-6-77 and 1-7-77, U.S. Dept, of Interior (Fish & Wildlife Service) dated 9-7-76 and 1-6-77, D.N.R. dated 1-7-77 and letters of complaint from Peggy O'Reilly dated 1-7-77 and 1-17-77, and notes regarding telephone conversations with various agencies dated 1-6-77. Also enclosed are copies of reports on swimmers itch and certification of treatment of same by Dr. Seifert of Excelsior, statutes pertaining to breeding of game birds and wildlife, and many other copies of numerous reports from D.N.R. and news clippings on the subject. I would like to call special attention to the following comments included in the enclosed reports, news clippings and letters. 1. Exhibit A 2. Exhibit B 3. Exhibit C 4. Exhibit D 5. Exhibit E 6. Exhibit F 7. Exhibit G 8. Exhibit H 9. Exhibit I 10. Exhibit J 11. Exhibit K 12. Exhibit L Paragraphs marked H and #2 of Swimmers Itch publication. Paragraph marked #1, Page 5, of State D.N.R. Commissioner's Order No. 1938 . Paragraph marked #1 of June 25, 1976 D.N.R. Ecological Services Report Paragraph marked #1 of D.N.R. office memo regarding Metro Duck Deaths Paragraph marked #1 of D.N.R. office memo regarding Pathology, Mallards, etc. Entire memo regarding Pathology report Paragraph marked #1 and H2 of Great Lakes Region News Paragraph marked ^*1 and #2 of news clipping from Phil Economon Paragraph marked #1 and #2 of news clipping from Minneapolis Star June 29, 1976 Entire news clipping from Phil Economon (Minneapolis Tribune 7-29-76) Statutes regarding game birds and wildlife Paragraph marked #Tand #2 and #3 of D.N.R. Division of Wildlife Report on Control of Swimmers Itch. < Outfk'Probleiv Page 3 13. Exhl 14. Exhi 15. Exh' 16. 17. 18. 19. Exh Exh Exh Exh 20. Exh 21. Exh 22. Exh 23. Exh Conclusi I belies It woulc would ha winters. of the c during v We coul( With sor basis O' bit of t i appointrnent tos on file. He confirmed f lake, ed. If I 1 have copies from the . of Interior -7-77 and , and notes -77. Also of treatment ing of game m b.N.R. and included in ication, lissioner's News Phil Minneapolis alis Tribune sion of Wildlife Duek'P*roi>lem Page 3 16. 17. 18. 19. m i'.. 13. Exhibit M - 14. Exhibit N 15. Exhibit 0 Exhibit P Exhibit Q Exhibit R Exhibit S 20. Exhibit T - 21. Exhibit U 22. Exhibit V 23. Exhibit W Peoav O'Reilly's letter to Dr. Jim Cooper and attached [jotes Letter to Mrs. O'Reilly from John Ellis of Fish and Wildlife Let^’er to City Council from Mrs. O'Reilly dated Utter to Dr.Vod of FWBI from Mrs. O'Reilly dated 1-17-77 Letter to O.N.R. from Mrs. O'Reilly dated 1-7-77 Paragraphs marked #1 of Professor James Cooper s letter to s'^letters^from^resi^ Johnson residence at 2056 Shadywood Letter to City Council from Neil Blesi dated . Letter to Mrs. Carlson from Mr. Schilling of P.C.A. dated 1-26-77 Conclusions S”isS! --during winters of hea/y snowfalls. We could consider distinguishing between private and public harboring of wildlife. With some direction from the legal department, I ® ^ ^ 3basis of a nuisance to the community and harm to wildlife. We do have guiie a bit of creditable documentation lending toward this conclusion. ’ i mm m 11^1^ '•rm •A • i:n u»i. *\'A IM Vl il tl u hu Mi 11 li td il i< A n il f •7' O />■ hed notes ger Holnies FWBI d Wildlife 7-77 1-17-77 itter to 156 Shadywood i 1-30-77 n . dated ance ordinance, animals as we *ing extreme ir, and some ild animals ng of wildlife ►roceed on the lave quite a / / V ♦ 1 TO WMOM rr mi coiiewi w. um nnnninitf rMldnta Of tiM Berth Arm tree of lako MlaMtoidM. of Orooo, do h*p*y 2! *5? fMl that thU id » hddXtb hasard la both tha aaaiw and ^ «a tWa faadliie of birda la doaa adJolBli« to a^ft^ **^5*4^***' it has baeotfiib dboot taig,"»y«^*yy aali^laB«bat thaaa bird7%ltb thalr aaoratoMot m dooka aad la tha aalilibomic aroa. 9/ aalii^iilaf tlJM it orMtoe • di«i*rais fv yomg dhlldr« 4sl^" M^^i^tte^idia^-aaAaHhta 11 *a»| dlfHoilt U aa* la^nartMa tia ha*a ao dbJaoUoa to a faabUfda, bat blada aoa to ^ —— o..«a.i^if «• fMl TOt this srss M Laka Wiaiata^ aaa ao^lataadad to ba a gw rafhca. Taaadlato aott— "" *“• ADnaKaa V- . ■■ - {I o' % % / *^S. L •/ V >/I \-*♦ \ \ *a • J t •' .H % *,^ -t h ^ • 9%\ ' \ ^ Vv.'. Vi' c \^ r ^ ^ i^yo CJU 'O /) ■*.y^ i ’'fl.'J ,y^. / P / / A tj /f { ^i'd'XL 11 • t u / ':r ol’HOvsTvv 0 J‘. W< 7^:■■■■ -;yV «' v'. : " ', ■ - '_ ‘ -r: • • .1- f i I • * tKVJSipA*J ./? • -J, -d./> - • ! -r'ii ^ “ -• lit’: iff.Tt- :!t, 1. i/dc r#- /'^//tViy-c.k# »F % " i:'?4. r" InnvtonlUt p of Orono, )t MindMoto ifroln »8. «• 10 wlntor* ling teaflihf 19^ ^O nljliMHr I and pabUo aMdbiko \< -'i? S®) it. J ^^/y>yy cto^^ (X aoajc' /^4 /A^. lC/fx.' V 1 / )*.. • y.O^y^Q Xc^ Ik. /V*/>u. . y/'-■ ( / > Out ! 9 ^h U.>.V/ #*• /y<7 A ^2^ P^- -............. ■rxc'’* *'•> ir-i.'i.':- j / t- ^ f t^Co ^ A.'-. fUsw) . ''.z I ’ ' V • "V y \ . -» • * -•% *• hci^ / I /(. i-4 /.iIC-M ' .-cvt'.c* ^ <L cT t*. t^* **-/< ft V# r '' y■ / u ^ i- *•- «•>• , , /--.V / / - > r‘ ■•^ • c ^ ^ • ^*— b /:? - ; t O O *1 4 a ✓ ^ ^ft • \ . • 7 11 •fc. t.^ i->-^.-> \ j',;^ ^h' 'i>'^''* /0^- /'/• j7 7/-/A 4 4c 'Ifi “ /V77 A)cA’T/, /#/ ^ /^ //t V ^ C/’L. /\U^i\t. Vs/ /7' /^' ^ ' •-; *■ V i- •;/«'n-/‘l /k- l/< ..lyj /V.;,' -^/A ^' f. ■ / .'• y5 #■. V^-^-.- V. A /t^-’ () :- 5 •'iJy » •>_!;} 'T' f''- Vv ft y * •-'1 ... hi- & ^ »^?TT.'7 “'3^r - i, # I-^4 •V > vvf6r. ^-.^ (TT IV» I *4t At ►-1' • >L i «• / Vu •V t *V n \ >> aM/^*'**11, ^ > .M « f 2 > / <>^ /t fl <V > . // /./V C/{\Uf%^ :/ if' •» /*• ^ <*% 7 />V • i <•/?/ • h “X y ■■. fL0.~£^iC i l> C i m' %m - / / < -' .«• / y tfj /vfe! c'x;>'/cv> /*'V> >!/ V k< i<V4. Mvr., ♦. -i 'jfo c A caa ^iG^ /k^*t„^/z). .t i %:l^/h*^Ui. >■ / . A ^ifLi i __________■'•■•_.•■■- ' • . 'j ^. ■ ■ ^* / . 4A • K VuW-.■.•■/e 7 4 «”»;:• V ,»* I"* •’,^** ‘ i*A X •, '7 n X i%-^7 0 v:*•».v i . *• >. f V t «!. •» ^ i • > ■ A-. 4 n } ,» •» • ..v' h* * • I N *%i' r •t> ^ • V '■i ' .i.,f •.{t '. \ »» V »•».•S^.i ■ ' 4* 1 I. 3^ 1 • • « * j. ■ - <■:, .'5 *• .-:f‘-];' 'i • tf'-- - »‘* *■>••: Ky^r■>,?''* r *'/- r :'■.:**• r* ■•:. \ ;^ V • i ■■■■ - 4v. ■f H- 'A -• * « 4 |i .1 .;•••- /' i i le of Ororio AL OKKICKS I MO.Sfc 473-7SS7 irouf^lit out ;s during 1 tiic Sumner. :hat near iso that 'idencv there. < f L^-.' '■ i - - tA, - t» -# ■ ■^ji I VV ^ * W*rr- ■ .._i. .c*. iv.1 •V ri /. •«> ss » y f "•S' 4* U i * y>: - f'V 'V'V V A 'u -•t I \ ' t -f* (■k ' *2 ■■■-—**^ ■ AW .t- mmmB rl'-'ii"A~ti fi CITY OF ORONO P O BOX 66 crystal bay . MINNESOTA 55323 BUILDING JOB REPORT ADDRESS _.<'3^' OWNE R ^I, ,, V C r.^ ’ •' •'■" > CONTRACTOR _ DATE 7 - ^ / DESCRIPTION A''.' C ^ x'’ t / PI RMII NO i) ^ Plu-S'U>-7i ;o -»i ;;*.<•'l ------z' y ^ /^'xr'n ' INSPECTION RECO'r D ___ „ Aj f) * % U^4yj) ___£/vC;V ^ f . P- ^Z" Js /a V /*^ /w'V' ^*7 ‘W '^y* UjCxtJSi X'^ ^ t-* X.9 ____?£n Hjl ^^ t V?Uf t <>2v .?/ ^ L>' W'i . 4i''4^ /i« #<4 '►* f vJiA^* / <./ ‘t *J T . ^ ^-»xc7Fxx\i^^^ f..u C%x*J/. ^..dfi-A^. A P^ 7 /• •4VJ.a^ (xLx'f.t^.. .1/ yjX • i.' *• It ^t? j}^^Oxy\ ‘ > INSPECTION : v. I S X -. i i <9^4.iL.«-j •I 'W: • • ^ Ci- ty * .R -?T-' I Midi ahargi pagant TBa ba inhabl adjaaa regard ba la aa la« ai Saballi Hinnaa^ CtfZialf aaiMr, ;r-R. i<r .- *\i u . :^'-i;.:iri..i 7i) ^.j^ /7W f/ ^L. * ' * Ll •■*,.- V •>. r- ' • ■ f- :f , :. .'I'-. ifer Li'-- -. ?-r*.-.' 'H' . Jun« lt» 1975 Mr* Gary Cnglund Fublle Haalth RnglMar DapartMBC af KaalMi Ihilvaralcy oC MlnMaeta Nlrniaapells, Nlnnasota Otar Mr* Cntlttdi I itidartttnd that ytii art piAllo htaith anginttr with Vattr Supply and In tlMTit of tha Mtlanal baching btaeb progran. Tha Vlllaga of^ono hat a ptCantlal prtblta ae on# of lt*t publlo twloBlng baaehta on Laka Mlnnatonka* Tha batch In gpaatlon la a aandy batch araa vhlch praaantiy la prater wall Inhabitad by daeka that aara fad throughout tha wlntar by a party llvina adjaoant ba tha aalaBlng baaah araa* Va art at a loaa aa to that to do ngwdlng tha baaah araa and tha dueka* Apparently tha party atataa that *®**i*^ faadlng tha dueka but* of aouraa^ thay art willing to atay aa long aa thara la wttar» ate* ^ ***** •• •• *• of eh* bMeh mm •mt *m* Mpro*rloeo ***fT"*?V,*“ ?• eh* VllUg. of Orono o«n do, vlMChM tlw b.«eh if ff "u**I*i.*f*i ‘^***** ***^ *o eontMt alelMr tfr.Hlkomailar or Hr* Hank Murlch* eA >f tha Orono City Hall, CTyatal Bay* Nlnnaaota* • { Sincaraly* Charlea W* Zina, M* D* Hat1th OffIear Village of Orono CHZinlf aailbr* Mika Sehallarw^ . - \ -'»0 i m' K 4| m' i - '1 ■ : ‘V ' h sjmmm mn6 In 0 hM • Itmntonkn. tty ««ll living tn do M thot to otoy I opprogrloto » booeh >Nlko »y# / •^ I / *A' V ■m ■&■ *M V . i « -i % ^ * m \ \ -i*. •*: \ nethods of controlling histosome dermatitis (swimmer’s itch) by chemical treatment of waters \ I^t WH Miditt Itbfjbb^ porofHn • .A ^ I I LOffetrio^., |U-5pijni|lo..*pyii»don.. I licola •; --V-t.- giiiau pblc^'; fed ^ op^d#* <# swamp ansflsi ^[®*J****5Eii^ *'*^ ^ sicols psisstris. bsVa idastifis^ as cercwise^pfodaeisg. Hm praaesca or abacaea of carcari aa- pratiaatag aaatlaia.watar aiplaiao ♦:s: •• .• •: .'• . -.5 • • ia \m€ wby awiaoBar* takaa and aot ia alUro. A afngla iafaatad anail ia eapabla ofpfodaaiag aavcral tboaaaad carcariaa daily for aavaral waaks. Gaaoially.i the carcariaa will aarfaca diraetly over or sear the snail ba^ llowavar, oatbraaka do occar far ramovad bam aaail bads bacoaaa the carcariaa ara aaaily dhiftad aboal by wind and water camaata. •^4" *’ . V"»*» rf** : *• •. .-*»v—•«-■ .L ^ ^ <1 ^ ■V‘-‘ ■.•:• : f» *■• •• •» Vierf* p» ifT-: 4*^^Pdap|aio:- dia^?lili illy did and. Jaly. t^Ra: i ^ >’ ?^iiaa0p jT?i 'v '^ ' ‘bir*p^tli.palbraaka ia la - . — dennatiiis (sw*ia«nar*a ^ -.^aaia 'aaaally ba aolaad ' ' ' Clone the baack si Paatany the cerci conditions provSdo bath tba oaaila. Ramoval of trol ibo aaail popalMioa Saoila can ba daotra i'- wf-y' V r « ■-W -. *>v li .r'". . .. ^ ■ ■ . • :■• :. •••.“ - ■j i- •t .I =r%/":-.-:.. H .-. f •.;.•*•■ ; . V-! L •! k-:' - I. ■ ■ >; .; '• ‘ II •a:I# ra-^r/ V. iMlK'«« I ^ .1 p*ji^ LSr^Urjk" >: f Y.WA: V. ^ % V* I »■ t • «. l4. • ;> 4 7 \ it.t: A. , ^f•^. - - At'.f^ V# V;. 'v; p«h£iOM i •• i^> J t V • > C-‘^,Ohd'iviaMce "tc^ ^revenl ca.»«. aw^ fffted:t«v9 of w;U hfe ahl toof €► fotol# •••♦* # ^ .r./K' % '*# *1 .4Kai~c reo.( t u^ natairal habi aw A m'l d raf'• ov\ paft« r». _..n ajrrv c ...... . CL Ad ir c s s ,*0 tm •-t. ^ 1 ►% S/M/W0»^ aJ >■0- r’-V'.*‘ •^>w’ 4 . * • D «• * T |r ili ■- .V ill"'*Wa ife /<r»tJ V K 1 A v> >A- ^ ------------------n*'-,ym ---* ^ « «r•-»•«■• - kMB •« «*<•••• • - •,.i; (<7 «• -«U ■•••««»• »if Pl^%«*’ '.*■ ...* »j..i •A w » -O.A-* t- i • ^ *# .• •• •— x> (i? . :a *1^1 --i iy)L e^'-0'''T'r^jAd. ~) J . U,> 0 ;>wc' £ ■£ */7 /.-• *€^' c* It^ f o u < 7I?•hV. 4« *• 4 V1 : ;/< *• c* ••; • '-i-TA ’* ■m-, A* *« • w ♦ • n «< »yyKiy "v.' r .>1* ^ \r bJ ■ '.‘•'v-i,'* • / ‘ «-• V »£ feA;* 7PfU4^ Hrf.: r:i # ?Tkn :<‘t f; >v}*,? I# i. .'U. J/ ^ IA X • // A , < \ ^■' * * Moca*vw c X ’ * '•' % ' ri- -;vhdy. •• •“ : ■5*’ f , \a *.<JL^ •I. • ‘V n "iT'. V i* •> ‘ »«. •' • h ^ >i^‘Vv li- • • • •• :':TT:q ; ■ > . ' ■ • / m ♦ * f > .> j ’7/t^'rvK .// C ^^:*yyi£<y /tfi^ VK v V ('. lo I l^^i'^fiuZ feu ^1 vT ife^ • « . !- # H4 i I L -V"- ‘j W •::!i <7« 'JT K*ivj; #»a f Hvt a V' U •\V.. ^ (.*: n '■TV v A^V \}P<tt ^ / ,v. ^ 'f 4C I **i c2^ ^ v^*" ^ . 7>« ' A' '• ^'• ’• ^ '' '•^■>«'., c^'<> U-f6cr ■ i f y i t') ?n, '>• 7-<c / |<'l. «.t.-n.- \i t?<^o •|»/^7 , A7 ^C^<*2A^ 5''' -f AVK '^/^ A .r ,-1 .. \ I i- *. • V •' itfl tSi • ■ V • W;.'V /U' ‘>7 ^/iv>-’-^ /V yV^ O ZU.'-^<-k y . ■( -.- ->} S„/>t M.y ». U-' *S-^ , / Uh9^ y *» j?‘:’ >.• ; *^7 A-'.' 3: .1 vWT ! 1^1 Fu-i. t 77 .a. :'1 V .':-' V r f ».- m E5-., ^■*;v'' f'. i pif*^ s V-, Dea ^HIUP T. CLAM PITT Associate Zoologist Cranbrook Institute of Science Ultmtftticns dy.Scff/ oe/« flukcs"aK iw *"*''*’ *alerfbwl, and bloodare interiwincd in the story of ‘•swimmers- I, . * technically as schistosome dermatitis ^jentific detective story which in *enerarwas In details remain to be discosered. Swimmers' itch is a problemTf STof hi f"'7“ becauseW of Its focal points is the upper Great Lakes region n Mich^an, at least, there is some evidence that n»^r the Itch has been spreading southward. Anyone with an interest in ecology, snails narasii- S'vimming, duck huntine, tourism o^^s. public health, pollution, or children m^y with sldir" ° ^ ron«rned-al least indirecily- o!l Pf "te Michigan Water Resources Tri: ^ ~ of Swimmers'Iteh in Nl,chig.m (1969), gives a useful perspective on the swimmers' itch problem as follows; “Al least as far back as the lumbering days penally developed following swimming in certain lieas. As recreational use of Micliigaa's lakes has HKreased. more people have encounicred this rash known popularly as swimmers' itch and medically ns schistosome cercarial derniaiiiis. Alihou.di it IS estimated that swimmers' itch has been reponed m the last tvveniy >ws from fewer than one percent "'0 ‘o'-eo. S V?if°'c"‘ P"” P""' often af- swimmers' itch have adversely air«ted the income of some resorts, inconvenienced llllrir.T™? operators, spoiled someprecious family vacations, and created temporary discomfort for affected bathers. To these Aople! the imimrtance of swimmers’ itch and its control cannot be overstated.” is‘ilso common ir Minnesota. Wisconsin. provinces of Canada, ofthltrid ” "“"f PP«‘ The rash associated with sivimmers* itch follows penetration of the skin by tiny water-borne la^ae" ^Icd cercariae^or certain parasitic flaiwornis. Small pustules appear on the skin after a few hours wherever the cercariac have penetrated, and are ac- mpanied by an intense itching sensation which may last for several days. Cercariac of about twenty dif- schistosome worms (blood flukes) arc known to penetrate the skin of man and produce a rash. These worms normally parasitize certain birds nH I. K‘rTn ; into host “accidental.”host. After the cercariac penetrate the human skin they die rather than developing further. In contrast to related species of blood flukes which iio mature in man but which do not normally-thcre « • « 11 4 "'r. s T he liv flukes a itch,*’ k It is A SI iolved $< to be di potenUal one of its Id Michi increased in nmge of the p. T ’ • ».Anyone with f ; * ^ology, water! ■economics, p f . < id:'have reason. ^ *. ‘. A with swimmei about it. A publicatt Commission,ii Itch in Michi: a on the swimm' ••At bather casioni areas, increas known as schi is estim ?/r ^ wcr than one percent is the large, recrea- are most often af- * itch have adversely orts, inconvenienced ’ators, spoiled some created temporary To these people, tch and its control nnesota, Wisconsin, evinces of Canada, i from many parts imers’ itch follows itcr-borne larvae — ic flatworms. Sn»all after a few hours rated, and are ac- nsation which may about twenty dif- (blood flukes) are an and produce a itize certain birds >riae mature into mal, “accidental, the human skin, her. lood flukes which l normally —there * % . •• THE BIOLOGT OF PHILIP T. CLAMPITT Associate Zoologist Cranbrook Institute of Science WetCraf/on* Odit The LIVES of people, snails, waterfowl, and blood fteh " x!" hi! . der»,aH,ls. P«*mial imerest to f rt h “Pf*' regionb Michigan, at least, there is some esidence tha le " "■* ho! the -S" rV"** *~S”Phic .K ^ '**" spreading southward. Olw latelwl P^resit-OlOfy, waterfowl, swimming, duck huniine tourism Iww reason tc be concerned-ai least indirectly- Whjwmniers itch, and may thus want to learn more htichigan Water Resources J^mmission, Ihe Cause and Control of Swimmers’ I«rt in hlichigan" (1969). gives a useful perspective on the swimmers itch problem as follows: lumbering days bathers have been aware that itching rashes oc- ttsiona ly developed following swimnnne in certain areas. As recreational u.se of .Michigan-; lakes has increased, more people have encountered this rash known popularly as swimmers' itch and medically as schistosome cercarial dermatitis. Alihouvh it IS eslimaicJ that swimmers' itch has been reported swimmers- itch have adversely aflwfcd the income of some resorts, inconvenienced cottage owners and camp operators, spoiled some precious family vacations, and created temporary discomfort for affected bathers. To these people the importance of swimmers’ itch and its control cannot be overstated.” ‘s also common in Minnesota. Wisconsin, northern Iowa, and the central prov inces of Canada. ofthr.!o!w The rash associated with swimmers’ itch follows peneyalion of the skin by tiny water-borne larvae- ^led cmar„if~or certain parasitic Baiwornis. Small ni pustules appear on the skin after a few hours wherever the ccrcariac have penetrated, and are ac companied by an inicnsc itching sensation which may Iasi for several days. Ccrcariac of about twenty J. k!!!Il!, . whisiosomc worms (blood flukes) are rash. These worms normally parasitize certain birds adultT?o1!d n'l "’“‘“re into hit Afi^? ft. - “•’"‘""’“I. "accidental."hmt. After the cercan.ic penetrate the. human skin they die rather tlian developing further. dbrn ''■‘l!’"'' 'P""'’ •’'"'X' "<<I‘CS whichdo mature tn man but which do not norinally-thcrc ■re exceptii penetrating tosomiosiSt disease infe Africa, and continental The life c typically inv times mamr Both snail a pletion of t intermediate parasite take host in whic adult flukes ^v'.' ‘Jir (about 1/5 of y most flatworr • *-• •.tissues of the adult female f -i ■■'reach the inte: feces. Each eg o . produces a vei • ’ ‘ of an inch lonj ‘ »swims and dri intermediate h< ■”* >If the miracidi species, it devel five tissues of t after several we V . ■ »•cercaria larvae. ■ V ”, all happens at tl ■m;'/ •without normal a parasite kills - ff parasite. A “goc V.point of view—1 •1 not until the pa ?•where its host i temperature and the snail and beg ‘ 1 oercaria’s turn r » «a water bird (or species of parasiti ■if the life cycle : Jk succeeds in flndin $ * •with the aid of 0 migrates through pf -•«vessels of the liver V and matures into; •After mating, the 1 f \ %begins again. wcr than one percent is the large, recrca- are most often af- ’ itch have adversely orts, inconvenienced ’ators, spoiled some created temporary f. To these people, tch and its control nncsoia, Wisconsin, evinces of Canada, 1 from many parts imers ’ itch follows Iter-borne larvae — ic flaiworms. Small after a few hours rated, and arc ac- nsation which may about twenty dif- (blood flukes) arc an and produce a itize certain birds iriae mature inio mal, “accidental,” the human skin, her. loud flukes which I normally^therc I 1 i. t r , * A •1^ In • •. H <** • . *" . f -*• • I ■jt I W ex c ept ions-produce a sijnificant dermatitis after These latter cause /«,»„ dta^Stain'r » parasitic Africa, and Latin America but not. fortunately in the coiilincntal United States. * The life cycle of a-swimmers-itch ” parasite (Fie h ^really involves certain species of water birdsUme- timM mammals) and a few species of aquatic snails. SStoilif are required for eom- parasite ’s life cycle-the snail as an n^n^iT * ***“' P™«<«sation of the C? hi ’’!“*• '"''hrate as a definitive tot in which the worms reach sexual maturity. The fatot"l “/s”r * “k "’"»<*'"<« worms^ut 1/5 of an inch long, male and female, unlike fiatworms, which are hermaphroditic) in the ISITf f " other vertebrate. Each adult female fluke produces hundreds of eegs which »^h the intestine of the bird and are voided in the ^ 'hal reaches the water and hatches rfV«"P”i.*i “"T swimming larva (1/250 ^ms'^VlT Y “ The miracidium i-ZlSLi. h- “"I" “ “"“"'ars a snail :; *■ penetrates a snail of the proper It dewlops in the digestive gland or reproduc- after ^ml***^ '^v ’PO'oc.vsis, whichato sneral weeks produce thousands of fork-tailed enwno larvae, each about 1/32 of an inch long. This all bppens at the expense of the snail, but apparently a SimlirkT"^ 1;'“"* “• ">i"S •Xaur ^siw A good parasite-even from the parasite s pmnt of view-does not usually kill its host, at least ^ un 1 the parasite itself has developed to a stage where its host is no longer needed.) Under certain Umpemture and light conditions the cercariae leavj the snail and begin swimming about actively, u is the TZTJrTI “ "** *-•- •his " me• Haler bird (or other vertebrate, depending on the ^ speciesIf tlw life cycle is to be completed. If the cercaria ‘‘ penetrates the skin with the aid of special glandular secretions, then migrates through the circulatory system to the blood ve^ls of the liver and intestinal tract, where it crows and maitures into an adult male or female blood fluke. After mating, the female worm lays eggs and the cycle DCfins again. Most cercariae do not And an appropriate host and IC within a day or two after emerging from a snail. Some may accidentally find a human host, penetrate the skin, and cause the rash known as swimmers* «ch. the fate of the cercaria is again death, however. That IS the nature of parasitism; it is a chancy busi ness. The chances that at least some individuals will complete the life cycle are greatly increased statistically by. the hundreds of eggs produced in a season by a single adult female blood fluke; and the fact that each miracidium which succeeds in penetrating an f potential of producing thousands ol cercariae by asexual reproduction. This hli ! ^ parasitic species is helped to succeed; by placing a premium on reproduc tion. Many other subtle structural, behavioral, and physiological adaptations also enhance the chances ^ success as does the timing of various events in the ^rasite s life cycle to coincide with appropriate tot" hosif' ” •''' “““ '"‘mmers ’ itch was first dis- ologist and professor in the School of Hygiene and Public Health of Johns Hopkins University. Dr. Corfi nntal investigations were made during the 1920s at ^ University of .Michigan Biological Station at e^remhvextremit) of Michigan s Lower Peninsula in close Mch has been a serious problem over the years Biologists at the Station, after working at a small pond adjacent to Douglas Lake known as the Sedge Pool frequently had come down with a rash which came ’ be known locally as the “Sedge Pool Itch.” Dr Cort demonstrated that “Sedge Pool Itch ” was caused by the penetration into the skin of certain schis- rnl^Hi'a ” parasitiae birds and After this pioneering discovery, reports of schis. tosome dermatitis, under various names, began'^to wme in from many parts of the world. All thal hale b«n investigated have implicated various species of Khistosome cercariae. aquatic snail intermediri^hos J nd bird and mammal dclmiiive hosts. Much has been learned over the years about the life histories of several 0 the cicrniatiiis-causing schistosome species about the snail species which serve as in,erm7diaie 2„ts which may be eiiher naturally or experimentally r r- infecte The snails, implici are giv within very si cercarii mnizat adults I snail in of the I breathin Both fai America a limitet nre comi emc*MU flNCTBAI ’ V* appropriate host and ncrging from a snail, iman host, penetrate nown as snimmers* gain death, however. ! it is a chancy bust- ome individuals will increased statistically iced in a season by and the fact that i in penetrating an tential of producing I reproduction. This parasitic species is imium on reproduc* al, behavioral, and thance the chances irious events in the with appropriate Mil and the verte- 5’ itch w'as first dis> rt, a noted parasit* ol of Hygiene and liversity. Dr. Cort’s tiring the 1920s at logical Sution at near the northern *eninsuia in close where swimmers* over the years, ng at a small pond 1$ the Sedge Pool, rash which came ►ol Itch.*’ Dr. Colt tch” was caused of certain schis- rasitize birds and reports of schis- nantes, began to 'Id. All that have arious species of itermediate hosts, i- M uch has been istories of several le species, about ermediate hosts, > and mammals experimentally VA H* ilj i i . i . I ■■iHn * « %• infected with the worms. ^ names of some of >he more common parasites •nails, and vertebrate hosts known or belieted to S unpliated with the disease in the Great Lakes reeion wain the common jenus TrichobilharzUi. tend to be »«'" i" appearance, both « M !, i "•* ‘ercariae shoiv rec- «^.»ble d,(Terences in behavior, and the ej of “e dtilts are in some instances strikingly dilTcrcnt The »«l .ntermediate hosts (Fig. 2) are members of [wo hreML L?”' freshwater pulmonate (air- •''‘•"•’“'ad in North Amewa, although some of the species have only III geographic distribution. Some of the snaiU «e common near sandy beach areas while others are characteristic of weedy, mud-bottomed areas in lakes orjonds. ___ __________ “ineTa^est gaps in our^ioinedgeorihnifccy^ these parasites pertain to the vertebrate dei.nitive hos s. As indicated in Table I, various species of ducks, passerine birds, and mammals have been iT 'r or «n be eaperimen- y infected with the parasites. Recent unpublished data suggest that most birds that come in contact ■ ' ^rnsKcs wiill act as natural hosts. What si^ics of birds are involved, where they pick up the infections, how serious the elfects are on the health of the birds, and w-hether the infections are parsed IZc L'lt' '*'* fr"- orspring all remain very incompletely known. It docs Mem, however, that ducks and other migratory water- fowl which are infected often pass thes: infetions- ft CnCMIA ffNtnATCS SKIN OF IWD C«CA«U FiNCniATCS SKIN OF MTHO •N WASM IKO, CFPCAdlAt MATUItt INTO AOOIT IIOOO FLUFFS DAUCHTTP SFOFOCVSTS P«C0UCf IHOUSANOS OF CfRCAIIIA LAFVAt CKCARIAC RfllASIO INTO AA»f»^^ SWIM AWAY IOCS OF FfMAir IIOOO FlUKR \ IfACH WATfl VIA FtCIS CF IMO too MATCHIS INTO MWAOOIU m' (CltlATfO LAPVA) WHICH FtNCTPATfS ipjAn I.,’™ iii-r*'”*'” '~'o "0'“» srcocvil.WHICH FFODUCIS NoMtkOuS OAoCHTtl SFCMtOCYi P5 Life cycle of typical ••swimmers itch parasite. 19 *! i ;.7 . t B • . ; i ■. V-? •-.'fe ..,v J, 8ii snail spec mediate hosts i (tch" in the Gri b. Physs gyrifu »t9gn*tis; e. Lyi ginst*. Table I. Paras dermatitiS’prodi region. * Phrasiie TriehoMharsia eeelhia Trkhobitharzia stagHico/ae Triehobilharzia physellae Cigantobilharzia hmoHensU Sekislosomatiiirn douthitti •After Cort 0950 unpublished info via eggs and these birds' fal With the wid and the migra definitive hosts mers* itch to ne C. Wall, in his the swimmers* evidence that i ward in that sta •he years 1939- problems to th mission; only o half of the Low periods betweer to 44 lakes repoi 14 were located St .1 /• r .. •' 4 • it, -•' kes reporting prob- 1960-63, of which t 1964-67 the total hese were from the nsula. Part of the sporting swimmers* tors as an increased owing numbers of ■ of more and more tendency for many e done ” about the worthy that during rtion of Michigan latitis problems— the southern part es in the populous suggest that the suthward in recent n these southern ; Michigan Water ( is a “minor nui- leriod at the very IS been obtained ich a person may -causing cercariae ted from infected rm sunny days— are most favored :>nd positively to dimming actively penetrate the skin reed—if he stays igcr—or after he n to become air- 1 strong on-shore here are beds of cercariae may be ‘onlimued on pagt JO) ( m a ’I .2. Pa V-. • 2 - * I / * •1“ * ; ' I %•' ■'il h'jliJJ '■•r-■ V ■ > \ ' • > t A . i Vv . FVW I - i y-V 1: 'ili. f* . r >«« a • .• • * SWIMMERS' ITCH (continued) carried passively to the very shallo\v waters adjacent *bore where children or adults w*ho are swimming or playing may contract bad infections of dermatitis, while swimmers remaining in deeper water farther from shore remain largely unaffected. ^ Some individuals are very sensitive to the penetra tion of schistosome cercariae, others contract only mild cases of the disease, and still others appear to be immune. The body of potentially sensitive individ- duals usually becomes more sensitive, rather than immune, with repeated exposure to the cercariae. Schistosome dermatitis is, in essence, an allergic reaction by the body to the presence of a foreign protein —the cercariae. In areas where swimmers* itch is prevalent, con- ^iticrable attention has been given to measures by which it may be prevented, treated, or controlled. Methods of prevention include avoiding cercaria- ■ infested waters, or wearing clothing with a tight weave, or wearing waterproof boots or waders when entering such waters. Swimmers who remain in deep water while swimming and dry their skin briskly with • *owel immediately after leaving the water can minimize penetration by the cercariae. Once the cer cariae have penetrated, there is relatively little that can be doiie by way of treatment, although itching may be relieved somewhat through the use' of some soothing lotion. Methods of control which have been advocated include prevention of snail infection and destruction of snail intermediate hosts. The former method would involve protecting bathing beaches with a schis tosome dermatitis problem from flocks of migrating or domestic ducks (or other definitive hosts). It is suggested that if this were done in the fall, it might reduce or eliminate the dermatitis for the following season. However, more needs to be learned about what species of birds are the normal definitive hosts of dermatitis-producing schistosome cercariae before this could become an effective control method. The usual method of control has been to kill the snails harboring infections by chemical means. Copper sulfate has been used for this purpose for a number of years, in Michigan under permit from the State Water Resources Commission. Combinations of cop per sulfate and copper carbonate, and more recently of copper sulfate with hydrated lime, were found to be most effective and economical when applied under suitable conditions at the rate of 2 pounds per 1,000 square feet of area. Specialized equipment has been designed and is used regularly for this purpose in heavily infested areas. Large numbers of snails are killed, but not .snail eggs or cercariae released from the dying snails. This treatment is relatively harmless to fish in unconfined areas. Between 1939 and 1967 nearly million pounds of copper sulfate were authorized by the .Michigan Water Resources Com mission for use in swimmers* itch control programs in Michigan lakes. In 1939, 3,500 pounds were author ized: in 1967 over 87,000 pounds. The effectiveness of this method of control —while apparently considered satisfactory by many—has been seriously questioned by some people. Swimmers’ itch outbreaks continue to recur in infested lakes, often during the same season after copper sulfate treatment has been in stituted. Furthermore, copper sulfate accumulates in the bottom sediments of treated lakes, and no one knows the long-range effects of this accumulation. New mollubcicidesfmollusk-killers) have been devel oped and tested, and some have been found to be more effective in killing carrier snails and schistosome cercariae than is copper sulfate. One of these is sodium pentachlorophcnate, which has the drawback of being highly toxic to fish. Another goes by the trade name of Niclosamide (Bayluscide). This material is more effective in killing snails (and other mollusks such as large mussels) than is copper sulfate, and also will kill snail eggs and schistosome cercariae. It does not harm aquatic in.scct larvae or most fish when used at recommended dosages in a 5', heavy gianular for mulation. It docs not accumulate in bottom sediments as docs copper sulfate. It has been licensed for use in ■’S-.Vt vs i 1 It r • ' •% Michigan, planes, un Bureau of Resources One*s V control sw used or pr by how se regard it n lem. Othei the situatk lem at leas in Michiga many are i days or e More recei and depen< not using incurring e< as an excej is being dar of the Mich whose jobs problems a and authoi grams to ki lem is a sei an importa swimmers’ i to control it Granting may take o learn all we to predict oi involved in < to live grac keep the us effecting cor one probler more serious tion of our approach w\ more effecti< and more r; their widesp waters. If thi effcciN as a n new tcchnoU those pnvbici vironmcntal Mr flocks of migrating initive hosts). It is in the fall, it might s for the following » be learned about mal definitive hosts ne cercariae before irol method, as been to kill the licat means. Copper pose for a number nit from the State mbinations of cop> and more recently e, were found to be hen applied under I pounds per l«000 luipment has been >r this purpose in ibers of snails are e released from the ttively harmless to n 1939 and 1967 pper sulfate were r Resources Com- >ntrol programs in unds were author* he effectiveness of iremly considered riously questioned utbreaks continue during the same lent has been in* le accumulates in tkes, and no one accumulation. >) have been devel* leen found to be i and schistosome of these is sodium rawback of being y the trade name material is more mollusks such as te, and also will iriae. It does not ish when used at ivy gianular for* lottom sediments censed for use in , ri; Ml i i ■ I [• » I I hi i I i Michigan, and has been applied from both boats and planes, under the supervision of biologists from the Bureau of Water Management of the State Water Resources Commission. One s view of the desirability of attempting to control swimmers* itch and of the various methods used or proposed for control will be influenced in part by how serious he regards the problem to be. Some tegard it merely as a nusiance and not really a prob lem. Others, including many who arc familiar with the situation in Michigan, regard it as a serious prob lem at least in that state. “Scores of lakes and beaches in Michigan arc so severely infected that every summer many are rendered practically useless for bathing for days or even weeks** according to one authority. More recently. Wall stated that: “Without effective and dependable control (of swimmers* itch) we are not using our lake resources efficiently, people arc incurring economic losses, and Michigan ’s reputation as an exceptionally fine area for a summer vacation b being damaged." The Bureau of Water Management of the Michigan Water Resources Commission, one of whose jobs is to receive complaints of swimmers* itch problems around the state, inspect bathing beaches, and authorize and supervise beach treatment pro grams to kill infested snails, also states that the prob lem is a serious one. All of this reffects the fact that an important segment of the Michigan public sees swimmers’ itch as a serious problem and wants action to control it. Granting that there is a problem, control measures may take one of iw'o contrasting forms. One is to learn all we can about the disease, learn how better to predict outbreaks, educate the public us to the risks involved in entering infested waters—and perhaps how to live gracefully with such risks—and attempt to keep the use of chemical poisons to a minintum in effecting control. This approach would .ivoid trading one problem, swimmers' itch, for another possibly more serious problem, further degradation and pollu tion of our priceless water resources, A contr.isting approach would be to continue to develop more and more effective and powerful snail-killing choinieals. and more rapid means, such as use of aircrali. for their widespread application to schistosomc-inl ’ccted waters. If there arc unexpected and undesirable sitle- cffccis us a result of using this approacli. m.i>be some new technological development will help us ile.il with those problems. L'nl'oruinately. this appro.ich to en vironmental problems has loo often characten/ed our past individual and collective behavior and has led us into many of our current environmental difficulties. While there is much disagreement about how best to deal with the swimmers* itch problem, those best informed on the subject arc likely to agree that wc need to learn much more about the problem in all of its various aspects, and to make our findings known to the public. There is a much more general question to which I believe, quite subjectively, we also need an answer: How can wc see ourselves, the human species, as members of a community of living things (including, among countless others, snails, waterfowl, and even blood ffukes), and not just as manipulators and dis rupters of every natural process that causes us even J d'^'.'iirnfort? If wc had a satisfactory answer, ti; JfVidually and collectively, to this general question, wc might begin to see more permanent solutions to some of our current environmental difficulties. Viewed in this perspective, swimmers’ itch is surely one of our more minor irritations. BIBLIOGRAPHY Bracked ’, Sterunc . 1941. Schi>tosoir.c dermatitis and its dis tribution. Symposium on Hutrohiotogy, pp. 3M-367. .NIadi- son: University of Wisconsin Press. CoRT, W. W. 1928a. Schistosome dermatitis in the United Stales (Michigan). Jour. Amer. Med. Asioc. 90: 1027-1029. 1928b, f urthcr observations on schisiosi>me dermaitiis in the United States (Michigan). Science 65: 388. 1950. Studies on schistosome dermatitis. XI. Status of knowledge after more than twenty years. Amer. Jour. Hyg. 52. 231-307. The most comprehensive summary available, from published and unpublished sources, on the schistosome dermatitis prob lem throughout the world as seen m 1950. includes a com plete bibliography as of 1950. Malik . E. A. 1961. The biology of mammalian and bird schistosomes. Bull. Tulwie i nn . Medical faculty 20: 181-207. Mc Moiun . D. II.. and P. S. Bfasir . 1945. Studies on schis tosome dermatitis. IX. The life c>cles of l’ ;e dermatitis- producing schistosomes from bird> and a discussion on '.he siibljmilv iSiiliurzu/litint* f FrciiKiiodvi : Swhl^tosor^alli!ac>. Amer. Jour. //»,e. 42: 128-154. KiV‘»'KCis CovMissios iBiology Si.itfl. I m'J. I he cause and conirtd of swimmers’ itch in .Muliie.m. MiciiiKMn Water HcMuirccN Corimiivsion. Dcparin'ciu ul Naliir.il Resources. Slate of S pp. and t iiis. I 2. IK’scribes Uic swimmers* iicfi pfi>hlem in n«)ii*leehniwal lani’uap.e, ^ises biol«i|*ical hawkitrotinj, atul iltvciisses re^i»m- mentled control pr«H:cdiires nneliiding prew.itiiionsi in some uclail. W \M , KfiiiiHr C. l‘>f)S. An analvsis of ilie eiirrenf slatiis of ific schisloNOfiie derm ititi> i'ri»h!cm in |*h I) Dix^rfa* lion, V niversM) ot Mulnean. .Ann \iUir pp. A an.il.^.N »i| iiu- pfs«h!eiii in NfiJi e.in as nclii by eoit.iite ovvnef*. reN*»ii «'pi.i .it«Ms, w-imp \tite^ii*tv. p;tk man.ipers Umijas dtc sk.iviiuiie hicraune up-to-vi.ite. ile'vid«es die .mil ii!v\tuencss o! current comrol ir.clluulx, and nukes fcwommendaiuMis. 0 -i: f-' i-u ! >afl ^ '1 XI 4 1^-' j Dear S1 E Permit Minnesa C situati include applica vegetat control the fon as soon of at 1< . 4* HFK: dn ivc behavior and has iirrcnt environmental ment about how best \ problem, those best cely to agree that we jt the problem in all ke our findings known al question to whieh also need an answer: e human species, as ing things (including, waterfowl, and even iianipulators and dis- » that causes us even 1 satisfactory answer, this general question, rmanent solutions to al difficulties. Viewed itch is surely one of ic dermatitis and its dis* pp. 360-367. .Madi- ermatitis in the United . 1027-1029. 1 schistosome dermatitis we 6s: 38H. Jermaiiiis. XI. Status of vears. Atner. Jour. Hyg. vailabic, from published aosome dermatitis prub- 1 1950. Includes a corn* F mrtmmalian and bird Vc<i//V/ri//fv 20: 181-207. 1945. Studies on schis- Ics of r ee dcrmjiitis- ind a discussion on the da . Schl^tosomalulac^ ISSItis (H«d«spy St.ilfi. micrs* itch in Miwhiean. i>su>n. Dcparimctu nf fi s pp. and I ij!\. I iV 2. ahicin in fuiii-tcchnual d, jikI iliNcii'*>es rcw»»m- ig rrcw.iiitionsl III some the current sl.iiiis itf ihc klnp..m. Vh l> DiNseiia- iU»f 21^ pp. i in Mivh e.iii a^i nss.ii bv nsp difc%ii*t V, aiu* t Ak lie up-ui-vi.iie, ile^vtiK's a comri l ir.elh*H!%, .itid ,» . A ■0 r I ■V STATf or ' ^DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES 390 CINTENNIAl OMICE BUIIOINC • ST. PAUl, MINNE^OM (612) 296-2835 I • (t f! Dear Sir: s1tu*tw^II2 f"? or.»quat1c plants can be done in some Of at least^en dayi uJSrre^ip?Tfa*ppl?cluon*"“''“ If there are additional questions, please write or call this office. Very truly yours, P 'J/ Howard F. Krosch, Coordinator Monitoring and Control Unit Ecological Services Oiv. of Fish and Wildlife HFK: dn '> i' • 1. 1 (We) ■i m •: < f ' XI. Hob0 address request fron (Check the a Liae A- Hoc Line B- Chei Line C- Cha Line D- Pla: XIX. in Lake located in Tot XV* The sise of ________ feet A channel ^ The whole la _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 1* Have you If answei 2* Is the ai 3* It is ini (Nane of ^* Describe 3« The follow; give brand 6* Sketch the direction ' dimensions owner. Inc possible ii V. JUSTIFICATION: VI. PERMIT FEES: Line A- the Line B* the Line C- the Line D- the If two or mor HOT SEND CA: VII PIC1/)3TJF.£3; Sk< I understand tl end aI{Tae, is i Applicant's sirnil *where this applic officer of the lak property holders r uous area adjacent holding property a owners and the dim additional sheet o CES ■ $SISS Jntrol ?s In 1 n the >ut the » cut ‘ use a itlon on 1 be mailed g period Is office. / .W*,. ■-V*- ^ _ IT *x - •% APPLICATION FOR AQUATIC NUISANCE CONTROL PERMIT I. I (W«) Bom* address _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ uL^^r:, ,r contra: Li~ B* JJochanical control of» sutaereed vogotntion___, energent vegoution LIm c” control ofs subaerged vegeUtion___. energont vegeUtion-----T MB* g- Chnm . filanentoun algae_ _. leeches , snails (ssiner's it^hT .Line D- Plankton algae III. in Lake loca ted ln Township No.Range No.Section(s) XV, The size of the area to be treated is; (Fill in where applicable) _ _along shore by feet lakeward out to a depth of c nnel long and -- - - - feet in width extending to open water. County. The lake is tThis oust be coapleted.) feet. The whole lake or bay of bay acres in area, (plankton algae only). Name of 1. &ve you ever applied for a permit to treat at this location? No If aMwer is Yes, give your permit number_ _ _ _, and the year Yes ?• Jf area to be treated used for drinking water or public water supply7 No (Nn« Applicant- -Co—rci.l .ppUctor 4. r Yes «cribe the type and amount of aquatic vegetation present: 5. The following method(s) and/or chemical(s) will be used: (If chemical is to be used,give brand name) dinensions of propossd trsstment area, names and total frontages of each oronertr owner. Include enough detail on the sketch so the property can be located for possible inspection. JUSTIFICATION; (Explain why this project is needed.) I f VI. P^IT lEES; (Refer to Section II above.) If you checked an item from: Line A- the fee is 15.00. Line B- the fee is $5.00 plus $0.10 per shoreline foot of the proposed treatment area. Line C- the fee is P«** 100 shoreline feet or portion thereof proposed to be treated. Line D- the fee is $5.00 plus $0.10 per acre proposed to be treated. If two or more lines are checked, only the largest fee shall apply (maximum fee is $50.00). DO NOT SEND CASH. Make checks payable to STATE TREASURER. Fee must accompany application VII. ENC|/>oJR^: sketch-, Signatures , Check/money order_ _, Amount_ _ , Other I understand that the control of aquatic nuisances, including destruction of water plants and algae, is subject to rules and regulations of the Commissioner of Natural Resources. Applicant's signature*Date*ehere this application is being made for the treatment of an entire lake or ba^ an officer of the lake improvement aeeoeiation or other official representing the sLreilna property holders must eign. Where this appiiction is being mad. for t^t^^t^” 1“tin- UOM area adjacent to tne shoreline property of more that one individual, all the oeraona holding property adjacent to the water area to be treated must sign. Signatures of Dronertv dimensions of the areas to be treated by each may be submitted on an additional sheet of paper. : .k i Wf h r 1 ,:\n , \ X -'-± I. 1 (w.) Borne addre request fr (Check the Line A- M Line B- c; Line C- c; Line D- P XXI. In Lake located inT XV. The size oi fei A channel^ The whole 1 bmy_ _ _ 1. Have If ai 2. Is tl 5* It if (Name k. D 5* The folic give bran 6. Sketch th direction dimension owner. I possible V. JUSTIFICATIOI VI. PERMIT lEES; Line A- thf Line B- the Line C- the Line D- the If two or mor MOT SEND C VII. ENCI/)3UF.£• «*^ • O I understand end algae, is Applicant's sig *i(here this app officer of the property holder uous area adjac holding propert; owners and the < additional shee •ip cod* D destroy or control: vegetation vegetation ' inner*8 itchT unty. The lake is is must be conpleted.) feet. water. tU.y). Nane of f Yes apply? No Yes il applicator inical is to be usedt licate: the conpass joint, bay, etc., of each property le located for ron: led treatnent area, oposed to be treated, d. jxinuafee is $50.00). accoapany application, t Other ction of water plants f Natural Resources. le or bay^, an ing the shoreline reatnent of a contin- L, all the persons Lgnalures of property lit ted on an U\ 1. 1 (U.) 4, .1' 4 XI. Bone address ^ ‘°'5e:*~VoV-oVt-r?U Um B* control ofj autaereed Y.getation ____, eaergent vegeution Liro cl vegetation___. emergent vegetation-----T ra , filanentous algae . leeches . snails (swinner's itch^Line D- Plankton algae XXI. in Lake Iocs tedl.n Township No.Range No.Section(s) County. The lake is XV. The siee of the area to be treated is: (Fill in where applicable) —^_ _along shore by_ _ _ _ _ _ _ feet lakeward out to a depth of channel long and __ _ _ _ feet in width extending to open water. (This must be conpleted. ) feet. The whole lake or bay of bay_ _ _ _ _ _ _ m -- - -— —u ^a • acres in area, (plankton algae only). Nane of 1. &ve you ever applied for a permit to treat at this location? No If a^wer is Yes, give your permit number______, and the year Yes 2. Is the area to be treated used for drinking water or public water supply? No (Ltm ^^5 ^be 'lork be done by: Applicant_ _, Commercial applicatoriName of commercial applicator) give^brand^nLer^^^*^ «nd/or chemical(s) will be used: (If chemical is to be used, fb«tch the proposed treatment area on the back of this form. Indicate: the conpass * irection North on the sketch, location on lake, which shore, point, bay, etc., dimensions of proposed treatment area, names and total frontages of each oropertv owner. Include enough detail on the sketch so the property can be located for possible inspection. J-V^TIFICATION: (Lxplain why this project is needed.) I VI. PgytlT (Refer to Section II above.) If you checked an item from: Line A» the fee is $5*00. Line the fee is $5.00 plus $0.10 per shoreline foot of the proposed treatment are*. Line C- the fee is $1.^ per 100 shoreline feet or portion thereof proposed to be treated, Line D- the fee is $5.00 plus $0.10 per acre proposed to be treated. If two or more lines are checked, only the largest fee shall apply (maximum fee is $50.00). DO NOT SEND CASH. Make checks pe.yable to STATE TREASURER. F'-e must accompany application PICl/>o tJF.g..j: oketcl ”, , Signatures , Check/raoney order __, Amount _ , OtherVII control of aquatic nuisances, including destructioi of water plants and ali^ae, is subject to rules and regulations of the Commissioner of Natural Resources. DateApplicant's sign'iture*iMIliisiSIfc <»^rB and the dimenaiona of th. aroaa to be treated by each may be autaiUeHn « ' •aaitional sheet of paper*._____________________________________________________ _________ i'1 L’i s •tudy Office ■ant o f' XXX. LAKE N townsh us loc raadin office XV. AREA as acc area n M Itei Xtem ^ or pen Item k you Wii vegetal be use< Xtem 6 VX. coming JVSTir IPS: how mu( nuiaanc to *»STI treatme Xxmmpli cuttini plua $1 only (a your mo DO NOT VXX« ENCLOSU items, the STA appropr On rece 1. Read Know alloi 3. Notil 4. Read and c Lp code destroy or control: regetstio n . vegetatio n . r*8 itch) • nty. The lake is 6 Dust be coDpleted.) feet. water. ly). Naae of , Yea pply? No Yes L applicator ____. oo: id treatment area* posed to be treated. unuD fee is 150.00). ccoapany application, Other tion of water plants Natural Resources. ^ Date t or bay, an ng the shoreline latoent of a contin- I all the persona Snatures of property Ltted on an ■li lical is to be used, Lcate: the compass ►int, bay, etc., »f each property > located for NOliiANCK nSMlf APPLYCAtY^ ^ ^orwitlon!^ Thla^i?r*aUo ?^ permit application and supply appropriate action. * •••♦€« your reoueat and taK m the name of tha roa^hy U’ .:.r Xmfb] TT* pTOuiI including ^IP CQIS. ^TATION or ga^AIK^ to ’T; ^n>Ued: Check cnlv the msasx m «.h to control. If ^ ‘'»- 7=^ coom in which the lake lies: It \m 4w**township number, ranae number and sect von that ypu placa accurate us locate your lot on the lake. TowniThui rana-# y"'**' *PP^ii'*tion. This will help yo.r p.op.rt, a.o<, n„..r l.«a a.i.V.p??.,; . M7ccur.t. .. area proposed to be treated. taees, are based on the aira of the Items 1 and ^ are self-explanatory. Wrso-n ILT. -- - -«‘’- you wish to^u..*fii control “'o.«^^„^'ir^l!luoi^^Ifl,^'’H!;'7 t*"h*?*‘r!! f.«j^lon. For .ff.ctir. control of v,*.tntion, th. pr;p.r‘;.JS^S o?•::n[^o^^•h^„^S'- «i-pi, t.ii u. ^ hou *uch'^o«*r.r!ill"bt ‘’ltch thir' 'l•«t■•nt H.nlr.a. To d.t.r.l«. nuisance that you wish to control with tha »»A«tation or to »»STATB TREASOHER” for the correct amount^ Make checks payable treatment, only the larger fee shall apply.* cutting on a 100-foot*br**ioo^o*^t*** *nd ask to use chemicals along with Pl« ffo.00 •'?/«. I5.<^ for ?H. :Sr.lt your money cannot be returned what hi'^»*y accurate.DO NOT iiF.ND CiU>Hl Permit js modified, denied, or accepted. iuJS!“5^r ^ «"y "f th.«. th. jSTATt TKEASUMai for th. correct •"'»• -ut to appropriate blanks completed. ’ ^ nppfopriata oignaturea, and all On receiving your permit: 1. Read and follow permit carefully :.TlTunij!“ “■ “** .r. I'. »Md M3^o!l^'yoir*heifca I proI^"riU^^''f*r ‘!l?n’'’t“**'and other important usage information. * on application rates iI i i-i KQfft It fiU raquai •iproprimt Zaformatlo ■hV. • ••^• J y WiiMn •tttdy ; Office] ■tat o: lake Mi towaahj ua loce reading offica* AREA to as accu araa pr Itams 1 Itam ^ . or pers< Itam k t you wisi ▼ogotati be used. Item 6 JPSTH ENCLOiS .:| .items, the ST approp On rec 1. Real Knot alL 3. Not: A. Reac and miff mm-.. jrcAtr^ *l^lic«tietii »ad yo^ ir#^u*ftt tkfuA t%lri» of VmtiUtfon or th* tyji^ of ¥Ofrttat\ott« p CoBsorTttioii r tha Hinnanota Da^rt* N\niiaoota. it you p\ara acmi^tt tton. Thl* aiU ha ip bars my ba fbund by b your county aaaaaaor's ■portant that you ara pd on tha aiea of tha da nano of tha coa|iany itlon and what aathod(a) p idantlfy tha prohlM *d of control ahould •• All •Dplicatioii \ rtcaifad.> rtcai»a( atad nulaanca. rad. To datartithi of aaaatatlon nr Ito chacko payahla • than ona typa of lea in ainnff with l5*00 for tha pamlt aak for cut ting P® •ccurata. •d, or aecaptad. I any on# of than# hack and# out to naturan, and «u tiiiaa you a## taant data, •ppiication nt«§ • .V, i*.g i v-i;--:%4 • • m XHSIBUCTIOIIS FOR lU ^ •aUZS ANC penit application and aupp •Wi«priata action. * “* *" -"""toly aaaoaa poi^ „,uoat ^ ^ Xafonation to bo auppli«i b, applicant (print or tn>o)< X« liAlJW XXI. ii•I >^«?iSl^ia!t ?SLrs:fl.r5,T'6 " Mr":* r: ^^s^diiauc. Officr. rogional or aroa ftSTwtSl Oonaorwtion us locata your loFon tha laka. Totmahio “ ^'*** application. Thin wiU help rjadinp ,„ur popart, doad uadar land jr. ■> %1 • I'’ .f. 5^ec*:.::.^^ibJ: b^:;:M.:r'ir.:L*c«**’‘ ** »»• -~araa propoaad toba traatad. ’ '*"•• <»» »»• oiaa of tho ^ ? *r* oolf>oxplaaatoi7. *“'* *“ **” ““ *'*• e«^«y jrou Oish to'*«oo for c*nt»i:"^oo^iBfoniI:UTO'Leanot*H^^ t**:!?***: “* *'“* JJdjUtioa. for offoctir. control of ro^tT^iot^iL* mine,: di.pi, boil „ ^ ^ indica^:!.. nuiaanc. that pou wiata to control with t:h. i..». / i -.|^ ^fpn of vopotntion or to "STATS TREMtnm"“or tto c^:: for ras. Hako cback. pnjablo traataant. only tha largtr fat ohnll app“.‘ ®“ *«* VXXm i’l5l.f::“riS!SIf: •«» »» en-ical. nlon, with Pl^ 110.00 (10.10 par JhomfrCt'aJS" »>“ DO MOf aim-a«§f “ -''•«'or your panut i. «,difi,d, dani«l. —^ccaptod. *V itana, your application will ba daU^d- ^our Mimlate L^tT****" *"*tho STATE TOEASmaB for tho correct iLiunt^!!fi conplota aketch, a cback nada out to appropriate blanka conplated. ’ •PP”P"»'» oignaturaa, aad all t On receiving your pemit: la Read and follow permit car#fully. '• 2T!r;iiS.r •■* ■*““ ~ ™ i KTi.SiXt.Jirr* •"■““• *“•and other important usage information. octructions on application ratea l A h *i! .. I./ * •'• f= I W« h ♦ rt i 1 id !1] ft,-! f Herbnl follov of aqi life i and or state Such V transp of Nat divisii such p« issuani tions < provide aquatic conditi boatinc of pubi snails, waters is reco to tlsc provide control use of wildlif the mea I iUV :J,\€w^m'- .i.. ATION KplicatioB Bad mipfXj IT raqiiBst •«yi taka * y»BBt«tion or tjpo of ▼•gotatioBf oeal CoBBorvatioa ba Niaaaaota Oa|Mrt» ittl, NiaaMota. fott placo accurato >a« This trill iMlp ra mj ba fouad by four couaty aaaaaaor* »rUat that you ara oa tha aisa of tha of tha coapaqy OB and vhat aathodCa) Idaatify tha problaa of eoatrol ahould ^ aaolicatioB icaivad, »d Bttiaaaca* U To datamiaa ▼agaUtioa or chacka payabla iioA oaa typa of la aloag with 00 for tha panit k for cuttiag • accuratw. • or aeeaptad. oy oaa of thaaa 5k aada out to turaa, aad all 14 i i* laa you ara »at data. »licatioB rataa i I.' ft : I # . • • STATE’ OF MINNESOTA eepartment of natural resources ; COrRIISSIO?;ER*S order >iO. 1933 destruction OR cmaTI'c^' oKOWrU OF AQUATIC PI,ANTS, ADGAE, f?p^ ?M AND OTHER INVERTEBRATE AQUATIC ' ' F0riScnA”rp^L''’f"'‘^”^' -^^CLUDIMG GUIDIXIEKE op” OP CRITERIA FOR ISSUANCE ?EF’^CHrr '„?"^:’^"-‘^' p«tab ':Jshin ^w:L.,itAom-P VoJ ^'-PP'fSEDING COMNISSIO.NER'S ORI3LR NO. 1850. Herbnt:, Coni7\issiorer°-^^Natura^ Robert L. life in public waters? ' ^ ' leeches, and other invertebrate Section 1. GENERAL. traLp!i:tod'°Sr"Ses?r?yod":x^io^:t"rplL?F^of miur.l St«MM sS?„; issuance or denial. ^tus, ana criteria for their tions and the pbTlcy^ofthe'“^^lrtment of those regula- provide maximum protection o‘ f?«h »n,! °f,Resources is to aquatic ecosystems while ® f "’pdlife populations and conditions whorrthese ce.T?? ^ control of aquatic nuisance boating, other water-based interfering with sv/imming. Of public waters Althourfi- other beneficial uses snails. anrieecAcs bv c Imic^T"^^ veget,ntion, waters is not promited bv °methods in public is recognized ?hTs^°rioL^":isanc"cSnd tions dfto the public to facilitate cont-rr^i occur. Service provided to the maximum oxtont of finf i nuisances will be usforpub ic‘w^t“rs Without -ther benofJc'af wildlif^ populations the meanings’noMf^a-|^ibod"to°thom ‘’e^^ regulations .have ■I : h 'I \k I * >;' iV. • I >&?'y itj- I wmm i^: Commissioner's Order No. 1938 - 2 1 eha" t>epart.-nent of^Naturei*'’pc^ofr" " on-site dotermina- Charactoristics of a proposed tfe^tl^n"^ on the status, progress''^orr ■' chocking by dnr oersor.nc-1 permit and observing control ope^==?LL^ S^^l^rli^y snails (swimmer's itch?'*^or'^or^^ft^'''^^" "“^^ns presence of leeches sSw'’ "«»bers or sSc^abunla^e aS a!gae swx^tng, or other aguatic --tio^^.ro^the^rb^nlf^l^c^^f some or all of the f^lowingr^'"® characterized by 9i^een algae.(aa) Algae population is dominated by blue- ^eet or less and in ^ Xated on the downwind “Lref°'‘“"^ ^Isae accumu- Ing a blue-green pigmeni a^°caS°rig"°n offens^fodor.®^®"® releas- considered to be^where the^veqotatlL°^ submerged vegetation is or more of sampling stationri^itM i occurs at ninety percent (904) has an average recovery of ?hree o? treatment area and ’ and average recovery are detorminr>^i when percent occurrence than 15 feet deep! ir.oans any part of a lake less narl^ regulations any other partf ‘-oodrvrsion thereof shall not invtulate (c) WIicn Poj'iui 1* 1 waters: -X—vb'iiid. .«o ijoruon shall in public allowed by Section (f)'^ or ■‘-Hi'i; tc vegetation, e;:cepc as . . ✓ i L./ i ;t;fcaP • .'■n It f It !!■ '} l.;^9 ;*r -W'kl 4 f 1 i ♦ •i m op si no dr w mmitiiiMr I c determina ‘■ilQvant personnel lorized by !r permit. f leeches, n and algae boating, iiil water ^terized by by blue- ly two nches. €! accumu- Igae releas- tion is 2rcent (90%) area and :currence lod described Minn, •fficc of o less I Illations lettered inva 1 idate ic Cl , . ✓ V •i .1 mM tv mr- .• ’'Ml‘K’^; ■ -' ' • < ‘I Cbnmlssionor’s Order No. 193B rr •• -T* • . » . , i . ♦ .. . «• (2) Apply herbicides or other chemicals; or plants or inveruLate'^lile nnrother'’Lanfr'''‘ from the Commissioner o^'^Natural nuisance control permit permit shall be made on fo™^^L^3^’'l:®®* APPUcation for such Department reijionel office '\e^^ Commissioner, to emy Division ot Fish and Wildlife l90*re Natural Resources,Mannesotc 35155. .390 Centennial Building, st. Paul, (f) Wien Permit Hot Required. (1) A permit is not. reguirod to: purpose of constructing’shSjtin™ aquatic plants for the sufficient for that pufpos^ ^ observation blinds in amounts. the shore Tine property’owr^er or hj“sSo2»®‘^‘' Plants, when done by nuisance control permit has previousld^i^n “9?"^, unless an aquatic l.ine for the same year, in order to: ^ issued for the same shore Peking which site shall not exceed“2"sSft®^'^® swimming or boat ^ich site shall not cxtenrmo^rtLMS «•«>lake frontage oi one—halt i ..i ^ feet along the owners* whichever is less? ‘'® ' ^"5*='’ ^his lake frontag^ less in width extendinn a boat channel 15 feet or in addition to shoreline <3istlncra!wrunder a?? ^ J M: areas posted by‘the ct^issionir’ls! *=® (aa) fish spawning areas; or (bb) scientific and natural areas; or operated cutters?’rakes*' pulling may be done with pc*er- slgnificantly a?ier th^c^o^s^seci" ®9uipment which does not*^ not be done with draglines !® public water. ^ dredges, or other power-oper?ted^» fu' jets, su‘ r operated earth-moving equipment. It shall uction i f V"' i■ ! « - Comissrfcm In the sajn permit has *: under the permanent1 required f< soil removf of Natural in accordai 2 order payab application •k the applica taken on th i tion is pen Commissione: * . * means: $5.( ment area. than 2,500 s plant parts. J • Minnesota pu: snails (swimi feet or port: of copper su] per acre to I F-^'. • "fsr. r' • :>r • •■ -.# »r.! (; or [uatic ol permit n for such ner, to any Ural Resourcesr St, Paul^ r the in amounts len done by iless an aquatic liG same shore ng or boat area, and otmer 8' je. feet or 11 not be r to US als ith pc>v*er* not • It shall action . n ■ i • ''V I ’ ’ ■■K'KI ; ^ . ' ri .*Co«»ii«l6rier's Order No. 1938 %- 4 .•r. ^ t i« the seune arei*Mch“5eM“*'iiiL^'.**“^^*"^."“^ conducted Permit has been obtain^ aithortzLra'SSSl under the authorltv Pulls aquatic plants o ^ r' required for thi*deateu«?y^»^f«"“^**I!f* Permit is not sSl removal or water re^^i f ?2“*J^®_,''*9etation incidental to of Natural ResourcL permit L? wS?k^lS^the bed^o?“o®M«®®*’“*®*"*' Section 2. PERMIT FEES. to Accompany Permit Applications. V‘.^order payable to^the*state^Treasnrar ^«h f?™ * check or money application when required by the fee'schedile!'”"*’*'’^ (4) Application Fee Schedule. ans: $5.00 plus SO^io ulr rooted vegetation by chemical .nt areL Lxlm^ $sj?oo! of the proposed treat- V 4 • ,•• than 2,500 square feit‘*by cutting ’^or pullingt°%S?00? “'®* Plant parts, other tlian’wild ttllV no Sh^rgl! e Minnesota public waters! no charge!^^*'^ aquatic plants into other r. snails (swimmer's itih?! and leeched‘’*'$r00^M?"lOO°“h«... or p„r..o„ „o,oiair^ iJE.SE-gS?So. of copper sulfate or *other’^aDDrOTed^,?^f®®.,‘’^ application per acre to bo treated MaK $fo?J?"'""‘^' Coiomis: or raore ing is providi potent! the app applied Resource lake-wi< permitt^ treatmer of new a larger i quired a be requi Section in most i beaches. interferii frequently weed, narj and Canadi ■■MppMhmmmvmiPIIIMiw >ntrol two ippiy. ■torinq. monitor- rged $15.00, ant of the to continue arge per al ienced :h ie in cases icre or io be re fed. shall not tatutes. most f pond dv;ccd % { S im* I • Ccwimissioner's Order Mo. 1938 •v^ere vegetation does not^fnlh^^s issued in most instance'- other aquatic recreationa/activltv boatxn^'"Sr ot considered acceptable reasons objections alonereasons for control of vegetation. f" the destruction ol™mergenJ^nd^?/"i"=tances be issued ''iW ricerbutrish vegetation -vegetation has a uniaue lily pads - because snch P^ZlgtlTe tltZeT^Ltl the"7i?f "-"'-nt^ot^rrflf satisfactory. ^ permit (see Section i (f)) should be preventing the growth of vegetation°bv^^i destroying or Plastic sheets or similar miterlats o^ ?hrio?t?m?"'='= development fi™f’or*’i^diWdual “wi°hino ^^’'^'Shore avoid to marked ^Thr ^PPearancepotential purchasers a famtent of this is to condition of the lake. ® impression of the natural instances for chemical™onLll^of !?? issued except in very rare other flov^ing waters. IhfonL ''‘^^^tation in rivirs o” is present in such abundance as ®*oeptions shall be where vegetat-o- flow of water is so slight the flow of waterand anprcciablc distance beyond the trlatmi:t"«e^!“ carried an is necessary! ara°espocUTrvT^k control of vegetation association°°"*^^°^ ■ P*^oposed by'’| 1 lake-wide removal will be encouraged ' Cutti with immediate ^cause this method of vegetit^^n ^ f®™?val is encouraged is not as destructive to fish and inmiediateiy effective hazard to non-target organisms habitat, involves ^^3^'nutrients. ’ yanisms, and (to some extent) removes and removal of vegltat^on^is°n?f"^^®^ Program of mechanical cutting littoral area, as^ouLfbo a rog^^ffref"program of chemical control. (c) Chemical Control. ; chemicaDy for thl con?rol°of •'"i)' h- trev establiL.h:jcl » ractirrit.: «-iLut*^5., ^loction tn s Conuii i s R i of the u por any : of the tc any indiv designate areas or shall be aquatic of the 1 extended inay abut t resorts, a beaches, a his deterrn. the potent: the develor vegetatii watershe< the like but be d: as spawni (gg) may lakes sue well-sepa S>ercentage for purpos usually 1C a principa urban rune tr ea tmen t or ono-hal shall be n for lake-w shall iricli treated. ^ permitted t >= . t instances Liting, or ions alone /egetation. ?s be issued station - rause such rross char- 'itat and allowed in ol of lily a wild that can should be stroying or mats or !-shore ' appearance his is to the natural in very rare rivers or tro vegetation iter and the 2 carried an station ( lake-wide •erty owners * ediate ouraged effective, Ives less □ves -al cutting ■int of ’ he trcaivd bo a n ^ t l-.b i '. -r<mmmmm :r % 4 * % Conuiiissionor *'^"‘-1 o Order No. 1933 - 7 m ^ the total littoral*area*^nd^^^ Development lakes: lo percent pet any individual owne^ ^ maximum of lOO feet of shorl unc m of the total ^^^^®3tion Development lakp«;. c; any individua^^^^I^f """" of ‘iSS'fe^t^^ore fln^per by Coi.«nisiilLr“rordL^r"°"“®"'= and lakesor wildlife management may abut their permitSd a^Lf individual property owners W'‘ v\ I resorts, apartments, beaches, and marinas his determination on tne potential amount the development been • In these cases ^hi swimming an individual basis!^ takilJo^f^?"'’'' of treatment that miqht havo^h*^° °°"®i^®^^ation spread out. requested had J ^rcentages shall not^ppiv''to^«?J^°°*' maximum and the littoral ar*.a a principal public value iping withir. cities which . «urs;-“ .™ «.M per ino: .dual property owner. treated. The amount of littoril a shov/ing cireas to ho Perhutted to treat will "K ;*.'r c. V \iiU ■ '■Mfct.Kv:.:'' ^ »k* • Coinnii s s lone r percent) por by such amou individual a %d\o are not and any appl tation must shore lines must be acco: owners on th chemical con after August letter of ju chemical tre first obtain Environmenta algicides an and approved Natural Reso tation or al for experima experimental and/or the M herbicide b] Resources s! area after < with signs J the permit i of treatmeni safely used the product differences recommendat: the Commissi Pesticide Ap Se (a firm shall a nuisance con License fro.^- a Custom Per 1-1- 0 percent shore line 5 percent ^1^6 line per lakes and resting e treated. oral area ast by plication shall be ty owners ^PPly to mming hall make sideration quested had apply to ssociations, lities, or U apply, JS, so long subsection ■ograms on distinct toral area t v/hich of water, ch have as wliich have 'lemical acres There* >wner . •ssociaticn ^cgc tation ■as to be ^i 11 be ' t en r* :| lp> U. ^ i ■ •S‘2j mm-:li.-, '.•< Commissioner’s Order No. 1938 - 8 percent) portion of the littoral area of the lake or bay, reduced by such amount as the Commissioner deems necessary to handle individual applications from riparians with aquatic nuisance problems who are not members of the association. This kind of application and any application for the chemical treatment of submerged vege tation must include the signatures of all property owners whose shore lines will be treated. (3) An application for lake-wide control of algae must be accompanied by evidence that a majority of the property owners on the lake are in favor of the proposed treatment. (4) Except in rare instances, no applications for chemical control of aquatic vegetation will be accepted for processing after August 1. Persons applying after August 1 must include a letter of justification. (5) The Commissioner shall not issue a permit for chemical treatment of waters used by humans for drinking unless he first obtains approval from the Minnesota Department of Health. (6) Only chemicals registered with the United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) as aquatic herbicides or algicides and registered with the Minnesota Department of Agriculture and approved for use in public waters by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources may be used for chemical control of aquatic vege tation or algae in public waters; except that permits may be granted for experimental use of unregistered chemicals in a bona-fide experimental program under an experimental use permit from the EPA and/or the Minnesota Department of Agriculture. (7) Instructions and precautions furnished with a herbicide by the manufacturer and by the Department of Natural Resources shall be followed when applying it or using the treated area after application. Chemically-treated areas shall be posted with signs furnished by the Department of Natural Resources bearing the permit number and name of chemical used and stating the date of treatment and dates at w'hich water from the tre<ited area may be safely used for swinmiing, fishing and other uses as specified on the product label or by the Department of Natural Resources. VJhcn differences in instructions exist. Department of Natural Resources recommendations shall be followed. ^ I (8) Any chemical deomca especially h.azcirdous by the Commissioner nay be applied only by a holder of a valid Custom Pesticide Applicator's License. Section 4. COiiilERCIAL APPLICATORS A^:I> OPi:i:ATOPr>. (a) Chemical Applicators. No })C?r;-.on, person;;, or_ _ _ — - — -- - - --— firm shall apply chemicals of any kind for hire for atjuatic nuisance control unless he first has a Custom Rmslicido ApplicaUt's License from the Minnesota DapartnenL of Agj* i cu ! tnro, issuance of a Custom Pesticide Applicator's Licc*i;:;c is contingent, iq.on deteji.ir.a- I ■] i wm ‘V.- ■ • i ' r ! • i Commissio i j adequate prescribe administc examinati Departmen 55155. T nuisance Natural P firm shal chemical Operator' Issuances tion by t and knov/1 This subd operated permits i work in t Section 1 Permit, C Control I report tc by him su may be re be ground Nuisance proposed permit, v work unde revocatic cation ie permit ur Aquatic C prior not the inter fish and permits c rules and Minnesott fc-'- ination urces and ion for such , Minnesota ul, Minnesota uatic tment of griculture. ms, or ;her non- I an Aquatic ‘sources, upon determina- ! equipment public waters, kg power- :erms of ‘sources for icsota Statutes, Operator * s ic Nuisance year, s furnished rations as eport shall atic of the n the eginning any grounds for . Notifi- n without a I any ormit witlout to protect or to protect tnditions of 5 of those Lficd in ti. il \\ y ■■ 'H-:. F.- ? •' *n lilfc.t j 11 <rf'’t--> • ---------— i-- . [i. k»i iL * Commissioner's Order No. 1938 - 10 (e) Liability of State. Any permit issued under tne provisions of this Order is permissive only and no liability shall be incurred by the State or by any of its officers, agents or employees by reason of the issuance of such permit or by reason of any acts or operations of the permittee. The permittee shall be solely responsible for any damage or injury to persons, domestic or wild animals, waters, or property, real or personal of any kind, resulting from the permittee's acts or operations, and at all times, the State of Minnesota, its officers, agents, and employees shall be held harmless from any liability for such damage or injury. (f) Disclaimer. The State of Minnesota does not- m A • • ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ _ _ _ _ guarantee the effe'etiveness of any particular chemical, endorse any chemical or formulation, or enter into any disputes between manu facturers and applicators of chemicals and persons who have financed aquatic nuisance control jobs. Section 6. REVIEW OF PERT4IT DECISIONS. If the permit is granted with conditions, or is denied, the applicant may, within 30 days after mailed notice thereof, file with the Commissioner of Natural Resources a demand for review of the application. If no demand for review is made within the 30 days, the permit decision becomes final. Section 7. Commissioner's Order No. 1850 is hereby superseded. Dated at Saint Paul, Minnesota, this ^-^day of t i97 ^ . ;??^ROBERT"L. HERBGT, Commissioner ^ Department of Natural Resources APPROVED AS TO FORM AND EXECUTION WARREN SPANNAUS Attorney General CP C. PAUJ. FARACI Deputy Attorney General Department of Natural Resources J" i ■ <1 i- - 'K y y- fart -Vvi! ;vk W: 1 I a ' Tt ‘X m'X:-:.:-- Aquatic a aquatic plants eaualag ewlnas aeurca of auia Aquatic a ■aintanaace of All aapocts of aaacoa will no or conflict wi Moat aqua Thaao are: (1) Mtabaeraed and ateaa. alt flowora and^ (2) Floatiag-l ■oat of their that float OB (3) ^eraeat havo leaves an There are shores or oa e grow to abunda Often several herbicide is u aU kinds. Of growth of othe Water pla grow froB root oventually for sad waterlilie wild rice are plants grow fr thst fora on t the next sprin eluding the tr » Most kind have a hard in it is eaten. -'t' nder the ility shall nts or y reason of shall be domestic or any kind, at all times, yecs shall be ury. not endorse any ween manu- have financed is denied, hereof, kd for made hereby r of )inmissioner il Resources >1 m j i. 4 ‘ 1 -TLZZZTLr •I s-i *.V^' r ' JvV * Infftmiational Leaflet 6 V .V MINNESOTA DEPAIOMENT OP NATUBAL RESOURCES nVIBOilHENT SECTION DIVISION OF FISH AMD VIIDLUZ CONTROL OF AQUATIC VEGETATION Aquatic auisaneta in Minnesota lakes nay be caused by excessive growths of rooted Aquatic plants and algae, by large numbers of snails of kinds that carry the organiaA swianer's itch or by leeches* Rooted aquatic plants are the greatest single Aource of nuisance complaints* • M •Aquatic nuisances usually can be controlled by necnoas vnav are ■aintenance of fish and wildlife populations and the protection of human health* aXl aspects of lake use must be considered by the Division* Control of aquatic nui«» sani*ve will not be approved if it is apt to be harmful to fish or wildlife populations or conflict with important lake uses and values* Types of Aquatic Vegetation Most aquatic plants, exclusive of algae, are of three general growth-forms. These are: (1) ifcihaerged plants that are usually attached to the bottom and have submerged leaves mmA stems, although some may also have leaves floating on the surface and may have flowers and^eeds borne on short stems extending above the water; (2) Floatins-leaf plants such as waterlilies which are rooted in the bottom but have most of th^r leaves floating on the surface and duckweeds which are minute plants that float on the surface; and . ^ w a (3) Urgent plants such as cattails and bulrushes which are rooted in the bottom and have leaves and stems extending out of the water* General Information There are about 150 kinds of larger plants in Minnesota that grow in water, along shores or on saturated soils* Of the aquatic plants, there are about 25 kinds that nay grow so abundantly they can interfere with ouch activities as swimming and boating* Often several unrelated kinds grow together* This complicates control, especially if a herbicide is used* There is no aquatic herbicide that is safe to use idiich will eliminate all kinds* Often a herbicide that eliminates one kind will improve conditions for growth of others* Water plants propagate by several methods* Many are long-lived perennials that grow from rootstalks in the soil* growth of rootstalks a single plant nay eventually form a large patch* Cattails, reeds, rushes, many pondweeds, water fliilfoil sad waterlilies have this kind of growth* Others, such as bushy pondweed (Najas) and wild rice are annuals that grow from seed each year* Many kinds of submerged aquatic plants grow from winter buds—really short thickened stems with many reduced leaves— that form on the plant in late summer and autumn* These fall to the bottom and grow the next spring* Canada waterweed, coontail, water milfoil, and many pondwveds, in cluding the troublesome curlyleaf pondweed, have such winter buds* Most kinds of aquatic plants also produce seeds or seed-like fruits* Often these have a hard interior portion that will pass through a duck or other water bird after it is eaten* In this way water plants are carried from lake to lake* Seeds, parts of *1 ’i I * »- * r i-‘i 1’^ . ■If 1 plants, ai tile foot I planted ii and cane, plants foj loose by % AU < native wi] the sane i C urlyleaf uabellatui from larg« are britt] As the nai margin ali Aqual growth son directly < food chaii other kin: Fish food* there are thrive in Fish shell bass and i in early i Water puri elements i plant nutx water weec water plan Water plaz oxygen and aquatic ar Frotection break the Food and e that are e are often for broodfl Esthetic v yellow lot all of whi mental as plants* 1 national Leaflot 6 ifths of rootfd the organiM ateat ain^e patible urith i health* aquatic nui- fe populationa h-foraa* ibnerged leavea id aay ha^e ;tOB but have lute planta he botton and A water, along > kinda that aay ind boating* eapeciallj if a lich will eXiainata litiona for renniala that It aagr , water milfoil »d (Hajaa) and serged aquatic luced leavea — tton and grow mdwaeda, in* 1* Often theaa ir bird after Seeda, parta of mi f. rl. r ■ -1 ’f . l!< V • ^ . --vV MM -2- pXaata, and even whole planta, in the caae of duckweed, nay alao be tranaported on kha feat and feathara of waterfowl* Becauae of thia, auitabla areaa are aoon ra- lAantad if the planta growing in then are deatrojed* Some kinda, auch aa cattaila and cane, have aeeda carried by the wind* The atena of nany kinda of aubnerged planta form roota and grow if they drift into ahallow water after being cut or tom looaa by wave action* A^l our aquatic planta, with the exception of two introduced European kinda, are native wild planta* They are the natural vegetation of our watera and not weeda in the ease aenae that nany imported upland planta are weeda* The two European kinda are l-urlyleaf pondweed (Potamogeton criapua) and the rare Flowering ruah (ftitonua unbellatua)* - ^Curlyleaf pondweed ia troubleaone in many lakea becauae it propagatea l^om large winter buda and makea rapid growth in i^ring and early aiumDer* The atema are brittle and, after reaching full growth, nay break off in a atorm and drift aahore* Aa the name impliea, the leavea of Curlyleaf pondweed are wavy or criaped* The leaf OMurgin alao haa many fine teeth* Value of Aquatic Plante Aquatic planta have many vailuee to man, fieh, and wildlife even though their growth aometimee reaulta in nuiaance conditiona* All aquatic life ie dependent, directly or indirectly, on water planta* They are the primary producera in the aquatic food chain and convert basic chemical nutrients in the water and soil into food for other kinds of life* Other important values of aquatic plants are: Fish food—Much more food for fish of all kinds is produced in weedy areas than where there are no submerged plants* Insect larvae live on the plants* Freshwater shrimp thrive in plant beds* Sunfish, our commonest game fish, eat some plant material* Hah shelter—Submerged plants provide shelter for young fish and usually nests of bass and sunfishes are located in weedy areas* Northern pike spam in marshy areas in early spring* Fishing is often best on the edge of weed beds* Water purification»«»Submerged plants absorb phosphate, nitrates and other nutrient elements from water and soil as they grow* They compote with the tiny algae for the plant nutrients that cause water to become green in summer* Frequently if too many water weeds are destroyed, a heavy growth or "bloom” of algae follows* Some kinds of water plants, such as rushes, can even absorb and break down polluting chemicals* Water plants, both the large kinds such as water weeds and the tiny algae, give off oxygen and thereby aerate waters* This oxygen is necessary for all fish and other aquatic animal life* Rrotection of shorelines—Aquatic plants, especially kinds such as rushes and reeds, break the force of waves and help prevent erosion of shorelines* Food and shelter of waterfowl—Many of the submerged plants produce seeds and tubers that are eaten by wild ducks* Bulrushes and sago pondweed are especiedly valuable and are often planted for this purpose* Bulrushes and reeds also provide excellent shelter for broods of ducklings* Esthetic values—Several kinds of water plmts have flowers that people enjoy* The yellow lotus is a protected wild flower* There are six kinds of native waterlilies, all of which have beautiful flowers* Arrowhead and pickerelweed are both as oma* mental as many garden plants* The "natural look" of a lakeshore should include aquatic plants* They are part of the ecology of the lake* r’t ; »IS'*: II. ' \'\ V ■ 0 Economic val Are hand har of Minnesota 1100 millioo Excessi aquatic plan need a suits The kin the abundanc necessary fo cium, etc* the surround through the ground water as southern than are wat trients accu The pat the nutrient Ikiring perio creased runo little rainf plant* growth growth by mai of water pla Activit vation and f of aquatic pi ceive* Nutr: drainage froi and livested these reasoni may sometimei Water d< require ligh1 grow well in bid or colors than 15 feet, that are comj laay become sc submerged aqi trients conti soil in shall up of the bot Rooted p quite specifi soil and sand accumulates o V. ■ i. .vw nsporttd on • aoon ro- no eattaila ubaargod cut or torn man kinda, are not weeda in opean kinda are lutoonia t propagatea ir* The ateno jid drift aaliore* ied« The leaf Dugh their ependent• B in the aquatic Bto food for *eaa than where ihwater ahrinp ; naterial* ly nests of narshy areas ler nutrient algae for the r if too aany Some kinds of chenicals. (ae, give off ih and other les and reeds« Ids and tubers Lly valuable and ixcellent shelter I enjoy* The » waterliliest >th as oma* 1 include aquatic i r-- I. V; 'i: I*- -■ I) it I < it.' ^mi/?,-//. ; 1 Bconewic values—Wild rice, which is an emergent aquatic plant, produces seeds that dre hand harvested* This local industry is worth at least €2 million to the economy of Minnesota* Aquatic plants are the basis of much of the fishing on which more than 1100 million per year is spent in Minnesota* Factors Influencing Plant Abundance Excessive growths of aquatic plants are caused by a combination of factors* All aquatic plants require suishine, water, and chemical nutrients* Rooted forras also need a suitable substrate or soil* The kinds and concentrations of plant nutrients are very important in determining the abundance of aquatic plants* The nutrients needed are the same general types necessary for the growth of land plants; such as phosphate, nitrate, potassium, cal* cium, etc* The source of these nutrients, under natural conditions, is the soil of the surrounding watershed* Nutrients are dissolved as water flows over or percolates throu^ the soil and they reach a body of water in surface runoff and in the flow of ground water* For this reason lakes and ponds in areas of high soil fertility, such as southern Minnesota, are more apt to develop excessive growths of aquatic plants than are waters in less fertile northern forest areas* In lakes and ponds these nu* trients accumulate in the water and in bottom soils* The pattern and amount of rainfall and surface runoff in a given year influences the nutrient supply to a lake or pond and the availability of stored nutrients* During periods of heavy riinfall nutrient supplies tend to be greater because of in creased runoff and because nutrients may be released from flooded soils* If there is little rainfall and water levels are normal, nutrient levels are not increased and plant*growth is stabilized* Conversely, continued low water levels can promote plant growth by making more shallow water areas and submerged soil available for the growth of water plants* Activities of man also influence the growth of aquatic plants* Intense culti vation and fertilization of land surrounding a body of water can increase the growth of aquatic plants by providing them with more nutrients than they would normally re ceive* Nutrients in wastes such as effluent liquids from sewage treatment plants and drainage from septic tanks can also promote pleuit growth* Drainage from barayards and livestock feed lots likewise can add to the fertility of a body of water* For these reasons lakes and ponds that had no serious weed problems in their natural state may sometimes develop problems because of human activities* Water depth and clarity have a strong influence on plant growth* All green plants require light to manufacture food* Rooted submerged aquatic plants therefore will letot grow well in water too deep for light to penetrate or in water that is excessively tur bid or colored* In most Minnesota lakes vegetation does not grow at depths greater than 15 feet. Lakes and ponds with clear water and shallow basins often have bottoms that are completely covered by vegetation* In some lak<^<> free-floating plankton algae may become so abundant that they create a "bloom" that ol^ds the water and shades out submerged aquatic plants. Growth of plankton algae r^noted and sustained by nu trients continually being added to the water* Such nut> ^ents can come from the bottom soil in shallow water, from runoff from adjacent lands, fr^m wastes, and from stirring up of the bottom by such fi rhes as carp and bullhead'll>• Rooted plants require a suitable soil to grow on* Certaxn species of plants are quite specific as to type of bottom but most kinds prefer a mixture of mucky organic soil and sand or gravel. Generally, as a lake or pond ages and organic material accumulates on the bottom, conditions become more suitable for the growth of rooted S'/,’;'-"" , .i I slow process n The kinda water chemistr mota, others g auch as are fo The facto are related no also to the na Under Min property of tfe Natural Resoui Order on aquat Applicati condition or 1 partment of Na on forms provj 390 Centennial automatic* A] for evaluatioB area to valuat other lakeshoi Once a pe fore control c be notified aa signs fumishc of the treatec required to rc amount of chea area after the The Depai control of aqi: provides genei of Natiiral Rea or arbitrate x work rests v .t The costa property oimei villages, bore General infom There ara controlled: bi usuadly suit at such as cuttin u4_WTL 6 seeds that 0 the economy hich more than faciors. All foriua also in determining eral types tasaium, cal* the soil of or percolates n the flow of rtility, such Stic plants nds these nu* ear influences trients. ecause of in* • If there is creased and promote plant for the growth tense culti* se the gro%rth normally re* ent plants and m hamyards water. For r natural state All green plants refore will sot excessieely tur* pths greater n have bottoms plankton algae and shades out tained by nu* from the bottom d from stirring of plants are mucky organic material th of rooted i \ J % •* ’ ^4* i i * . a • • 'slow process normally requiring thousands of years. The kinds of plants that grow in any body of water are determined by the water chemistry. Some prefer soft waters such as those found in northeastern Minne* sots, others grow in hard waters, and some thrive beet in alkali (sulfate; waters such as are found in some of our prairie lakes. The factors, then, that cause nuisance growths of aquatic plants are complex and are related not only to pliyeical and biological conditions occurring in the water out also to the nature of the surrounding land and use of it by man. State Regulations Under Minnesota statutes the aquatic plants growing in public waters are the property of the State and may be destroyed only as authorized by the ® , Hatural Resources. Details on regulations are set forth in the current Commissioner s Order on aquatic nuisance control. Application of any chemical to public waters for control of an aquatic condition or large scale cutting and pulling of plants requires a permit ™ partment of Natural Hesoui'ces. Application for a permit must be made to the depwtment on forms provided by the Technical Services Section of the Division of Game and ^sh, 390 Centennial Building, St. Paul, Minnesota, 55155. Issuance of a ^mit automatic* All applications are reviewed and often referred to depax^nt field sti^f for evaluation. Applications are sometimes denied because of proximity of ^ area to valuable fish and wildlife habitat, protection of human health, objections of other lakeshore property owners or lake users, or protection of valuable natural areas* Once a permit is obtained there are certain other steps that must be taken. Be fore control operations begin, certain Department of Natural Resources personnel be notified as specified on the permit. Chemically treated areas must be posted with signs Aimished with the permit. Such posting is necessary to restrict certain uses of the treated area until the area has detoxified. The holder of a permit is also required to report to the department the actual size of the area treated wd the amount of chemical used. A state licensed commercial sprayer nay be hired to treat an area after the proper permit has been obtained. The Department of Natural Resources also evaluates chemicals and procedures for control of aquatic nuisances, provides information on aquatic nuisance control and provides general guidance to lakeshore property owners associations. The Depart^nt of Natural Rasources does not endorse specific chemicalSf productSf or spraying or arbitrate results of control work. Liability for damage resulting from control work rests v'^.th the permittee or his agent. The costs of aquatic nuisance control projects must be paid by the benefited property owners. However, Minnesota Statutes 1961* Section 111.81 authorizes cities, villages, boroughs and towns to levy taxes for this purpose. Control Methods General information There are three general methods whereby nuisance growths of aquatic weeds can be controlled: biological, hand or mechanical, and chemical. Biological methods are not usually suitable for private control measures. Hand or mechanical control methods, such as cutting or pulling by hand or machine, can be effective and are advised where ___________________________________________________________________________COIBIlIKI&Xv _UBUdii _____________________________ i II lit >1 I ***' Cost of ch< •qiiipment used, bo boot ootimat< moreial). oprayo: otbroo and firmi Control of vigorously, and oooding stage, ropooted each y succossfUl if c Mechanical or h Mechanical in most situati pulled vegetati grows the veget boat channels b that are now co several times a of plants be re through their s if left in the off and propaga ditions on beac (^mmonly-u has a submerged scythe, and dra tangle vegetati submerged forma weed cutting eq Chemical contra Before a c must have prope specifically aj: ducts registerc public waters i for a particula Department of ^ intended for ue ^ :"v ■in JK>'w. ;r". r- if ‘ ., '’: • . r’-.SW ¥ •«>--6- ChMiioal control of aquatic plants with liarbicldas is tanporaiy and control ■ensures usually must be repeated each year. Before chenlcal control is initiatedf proper identification of the nuisance regetation is necessary. Most aquatic herbi cides are selective as to the kinds of plants on which they are nost effective and the proper herbicide should be used for the plants at hand. The plants that a particular herbicide will control are listed on the label, ibcact species identification nay not be required but it is necessary to nake distinctions between major types of plants and often to identify the genus or general group of plants. The pictures of plants at the end of this publicaticn will aid in the identification of species oonaon in Minne sota. Belp in the identification of plants can be obtained fron the Minnesota Division of Game and Fish, 390 Centennial Building, St. Paul, Minnesota. Plants sent in for identification should be dried between sheets of newspaper or paper towelling. Care should be taken when applying herbicides for aquatic plant control so that the chemical or drift (spray or dust) from its application does not come in contact with adjacent upland vegetation. Shoreline areas should not be treated during periods of heavy wave action or the chemical may drift out of the treatment area or become so dilute that control will not be achieved. Cans or other containers of chemicals ehould be disposed of with care. Instructions on the label should always be read carefully. Chemicals listed herein are safe for fish when used according to label instructions. Label instructions should be followed in detail to avoid harm to per sons handling the chemical, harm to shrubs, lawns and gardens through irrigation and ham to humans, wildlife, livestock and pets that might use a treated area. Be- strictions on use of a treated area ehould be adhered to for the period of time specified on the label, or by the Department of Natural Resources. ✓ Chemical control of submerged and floating-leaved plants Organic herbicide commonly used for control of submerged and floating-leaved plants contain formulations of endothall, diquat, silvex, and 2,4*D. These are all biodegradable organic compounds. They eventually disappear from the water because they break down into simpler substances, they are tied up in bottom soils, and are absorbed by plants. I There is no single approved chemical that will give satisfactory control of all submerged and floating-leaved plants. The plants that a given herbicide will control are listed on the product label. Qidothall and diquat formulations should be applied early in the growing sea when the plants are actively growing but before they are in flower and fruit. This is commonly during late Nay and June. Diquat should not be used in muddy water be cause it is deactivated by silt particles. Following treatment with these compounds, plants usually turn brown in a few days and eventually settle to the bottom. Formulations of 2,4-D and silvex are slower acting growth-regulator tyi>es of killers and therefore should be applied earlier in the growing season. Granular 2,4-D products cw be applied as soon as the ice goes out in the spring. When liquid 2,4-D or silvex is used on floating-leaved plants, a wetting agent should be added to the spray solution. It may take from 4 to 6 weeks to show results when using 2,4-D or silvex. Wind and wave action sometimes cause chemically-killed plants to accumulate on shore. Water in a treated area may turn brown temporarily due to decay of plants and in some instances an algal bloom nay be fostered by nutrients released when the chemically killed vegetation decays. A large mass of decaying vegetation can also lower oxygen levels and cause a fish kill. For this reason, large scale chemical re moval of vegetation is usually undesirible. f *1 •. - ■•V A:: . V: r and control \1 is initiatod* ( aquatic herbi- ; offoctivo and the that a particular Ification nay not ;jpoa of planta tturea of planta at >a ooanon in Ninno« ) Ninnoaota Diriaion into aont in for towoUing* control ao that cone in contact ted during perioda area or becone so of chenicals wavs be read rding to label oid ham to per- h irrigation and d area. Re* iod of tine oating*leaved Iheae are all water because Boilst and are f control of all cide will control e growing season Bd fruit. This ■uddy water be* these conpounda, botton. itor types of season. Granular Lng. When liquid lould be added to sen using 2,4*0 or > accuaulate on ;ay of plants and »d when the ition can also rale chenical re* V4. ■J '■ i rf .'•V ■i; - .7- Liquid endothall and diquat hare been Used with sons success on duckweeds but the ability of these tiny plants to reproduce rapidly and their tendency to accumulate in layers due to wind and wave action hinder control neasures. Oudc%reeds are small elliptical plants that float on the surface of quiet waters, eifpeCially small fertile ponds, where they may completely cover the water surface. lemical control of emergent plants The most common emergent plants causing nuisance conditions in Minnesota are cattail and bulrush. Occasionally growths of broad*leaved emergents such as arrow* head and grassy plants like reed»conary grass cause nuisance conditions. Woody plants such as willow may also sometimes become abundant in damp low areas next to the shore of a lake or pond. Cattails can usually be controlled by the use of formulations of dalapon. This chemical is applied as foliar spray. Spraying should be done early in the season when the plants are ? to 3 feet tall. Any successive regrowth should be sprayed as it re* appears. Spraying is effective throughout the season and con continue until shortly before the first frost. Bulrush is extremely difficult to control chemically. There is no one herbicide that has given consistent r<*sults in Minnesota. Mechanical control by cutting and pulling has usually proven to be the best method. Because of the unique value of bulrush, few permits are granted for large scale removal on public waters. Excessive growths of emergent monocotyledonous plants (those with parallel*veined leaves, like grasses) can usually be controlled by the some chemicals used for cattails, and emergent dicotyledonous plants (those with net«veined leaves, like a dandelion) controlled by use of liquid 2,4*D. Woody plantr like willows may be sprayed with 2,4-D or ammonium sulfamate. Complete wetting of all plants with the spray solution is important for effective control of emergent plants, lifhen a water base solution is used, the addition of house* hold detergent (any of the common liquid kinds) as a wetting agent will increase the effectiveness of the herbicide. Commonly 1/4 cup of liquid detergent per 25 gallons of ^ray solution is used. There are also commercial wetting agents available. Spray drift can be minimized by directing the spray downward and VM of Imt pressure which produces large droplets. Spraying should not be done on ^ays. Illustrations of some common aquatic plants On the following pages are illustrations of some common aquatic plants occurring in Minnesota. The kinds that have the names starred are especially valuable as water* fowl food and cover plants and this should be taken into consideration when control of them is contemplated. The yellow lotus (Nelumbo lutea) is a protected wild flower and the waterlilies and pickerelweed, while not protected wild flowers, have considerable ornamental value. A ri j'v' "vd f a 1 • :w»ed8 but th8 kccufflulatt ia >e snail mall fertila aota are i as arrow- Woody plants to the shore apon* This e season when ed as it re- til shortly ne herbicide tting and value of rallel-veined d for B, like a nay be for effective tion of house- icrease the 25 gallons of Le. aays. ^6 occurring >le as water- m control of Ld flower and ionsiderable r wii - " 77 lik« y» ■•1 HHHH m/m ■ N LI iV. i C' ' W a »' • 7'I ^ 'A "A ♦AT.-': A k iIlU^ u Id tD ..V-- •-■ ■ - M I f { « « Alfa* ara i atreana. Like < l^iotoayntheaia ' off oxjsan whici growth OMy uae i life* Thara ara t ^hay ara aoticac growth aay bacon water* Such exc Chaaical control Niiisancc gr fliauta, mostly n and may produce aoaa<^e tuft& o and (3) the musk lima encrusted p Tiny ellipt wida« gras6*like Traatme: larger water wee< Nuisance gi water in proper from the Commiss can be obtained Fisht D-partment 55155* Chemical without first ha Resources* The costs ol However, Minnesot and to«ms to levy Plankton alg blue*green algae, become overabunda green or greenish flakes or dots, appearance of a b! accumulated in th< GcnTal Inforwation .•• AX(a# ar6 sinipla and oftan microscopic plants that grow in lakao* ponds and straaaa. Like tha largar graan plants or "waads" of watara thay aanufactura by photogynthasis tha basic foods on which all aquatic lifa dapands* Algaa also giva off oxygon which halps to aarate tha water, but under conditions of unusually heavy growth may use up oxygen in water, especially at night, to tha detriment of aquatic life* I . • Thera are hundreds of kinds of algae but only a few aver become so abundant bhay are noticed by tha casual observer. Occasionally the kinds producing noticeable growth may become abundant enough to create a nuisance and interfere with use of the water* Such excessive growths are commonly called "blooms", "scums", and "moss". Chemical control of such algal growths is sometimes desirable. Nuisance growths of algae are of three general forms; (1) plankton alrae are minute, mostly microscopic, free-floating plants that cause water to become green and m^ produce blooms and scums; (2) filamentous algae appear as finely divided mosa<%ike tufts on the bottom or as floating masses or scums of hair-like strands, and (3) the muskgrasses typified by Chara which is a coarse, much branched, and often lime encrusted plant with a musky or fishy odor and which grows attached to the bottom* Tiny elliptical floating green pads are not algae but are duckweed. Plants with wide, grass-like or dissected leaves arc not algae but are higher plants or "water weeds". Treatment recommended for algae will usually have no effect on duckweeds and larger water weeds. Use of Chemicals in Water Nuisance growths of algae can usually be controlled by adding chemicals to the water in proper concentrations but such applications may be made only under pexmiit from the Commissioner of Natural Resources. An application form for such a permit cm be obtained by writing to the Technical Services Section, Division of Game and Fish, Department of Natural Resources, 390 Centennial Building, St. Paul, Minnesota, 55155* Chemicals for algae control should not be purchased for use on public waters without first having obtained a permit or consulting with the Department of Natural Resources* The costs of algae control projects muj»t be paid by the benefited property owners. However, Minnesota Statutes 1')d1, Section lll.ol authorizes cities, villages, boroughs and towns to levy taxes for this purpose. Control of Plankton Al»ie Plankton algae are ol many kinds’but those causing blooms in summer are usually blue-green algae. Blue-greens arc a natural growth of fertile waters but sometimes become overabundant because of man*s activities. These may impart a uniform blue- green or greenish color to the water or appear scattered through it as tiny green flakes or dots. Guch flakes or dots are colonics of microscopic algae. The sudden appearance of a bloom means that algal cells have risen to the lake surface and accumulated in the upper iew foet of water. If very abundant, blue-green alrac may f- ' meeurnttlmte Growth tho wator. from adjace carp and bv Lorgoi i^ore weed algae may i Plank’ for not mo: sulphate d Amounts us treated* is greatoe of copper where the used in wc per acre « upon the li The coppei ctable affli copper ca: adkaline possible. Ther method it Commercia scatterin smaller 1 use the \ (1) (2) (3) (4! il Uantt No. 7 I and I by to give Ly heavy aquatic idant toticeable « of the loss" a are green idcd ends, and often the bottom* ants with "water weeds and to the permit permit ne and rmesota, e waters Natural fty owners* I boroughs usually Retimes blue- jreen sudden ind •ae may i ^ ' il i ' j i’i 4 f ; u Th« «iw h**« • «»«•'«« ***'*’''•ce»»a.te .. • »cu- *1«W ahor«s. Thv *y . _ ,dd.d 0^..1.- carp and bullheads*and buiineaas* wi«dv«i* occur Urt*r •«t#r weeds S’sTe rrSTl‘AI.‘luy result in an incw *......... for not nope than a month) by grade copper sulphate xs Zpl^U dissolved fron “T^d fvenly dio "buted o ’" *•“ ^Sis dIS«er Amounts used must be fish if concentrations are too -• c pounds U «iaUat in soft waters, such as control of blu-green al^t of copper ®^P^®^*/®^y^®^g*^ten ^e^t or more* Proportionately 2*5 pounds -IT. rrs-ir.« “ Upper esrbonsu. espeemUy f “s best to treat as early in the noming as SSSine St night than during the d.j. it « ^ poBSible* Ths're are e.veral methods for applying .othod it ie important that ‘^^/^^‘'U.^Urtedln boats or have Jeviees for Uattoring email crystals. ^7"Uha?e by the boat-and-burlap-bag method. To ««aier lakes commonly apply «PP" ^ use the boat-and-burlap-bag method. in guiaing v«tp war . r - pM X 2" (2) Construct for each boat Uough '?o*^UtUf tUosHhe boat and Hi »“Send of the frame to .orn a oounre fastened*tascenea. (3) Nail a burlap bag to “effU cU U“its e -r -uomi-nl V - I— cipplied to the lake (this (4) Distribute the total -xmount isi^^ACipating boats* At the is specified in tne permit) equally .julphate should be placed In burlap bag can bo f^dju^aei es n 1 1 1 (5) Space b of boat tributi moving* since c Initial tre must bs suparvifl Sffectivenc formity of appll season gives sat treataents durin effect on algae success when mad viously stated* neon* It is al£ algal cells to I must be treated bay can readily to give only ver A principle correct dosage. Plan early for t decay of a large of fish and othe along shore* Tr water should not If other cc be applied accor by the Minnesota Filamentous form blankets, s will usually gi>< cations of coppe chamical per mil of copper sulpha The copper burlap bag methc dissolving powde the shoreline fi out of the area the water should Muskgrncses Chara, the attached to the they decay elng added to ter, fro* ruaoft y aueh fiahes aa ally bloona occur 1 of plankton ily (uaually eually copper ia uaed* the area to be ;h and thia danger ‘usually 5 pounda ie*green algae imical ahould be ieept 2*5 pounda justed depending i other factora. he water in appre- the water aa re usually less n the morning aa . it with each Ily ns poaaible ices for i residenta on { method* To 1 (motora of at to be used of 2” X 2” the boat and )iece near each •lap bag can be t >ttom will drag in r its equivalent a lake (this ts* At the d be placed in he amount in the istribution of i' t (5) Space boata equipped for application about 100 feet apart and move the liiM of boats in even rank over the entire area of the lake to obtain even di^ tribution of chemical* Remove bags from the water when the boat ia not moving* Boats should be washed carefully when the treatment is finished since copper sulphate is corrosive* Initial treatments by a new group first using the boat-and-burlap-bag method must bo supervised by personnel of the Division of Game and Fish* Effectiveness of plankton algae treatments vary with weather conditions« uni* formity of application and other factors* On some lakes a single treatment per season gives satisfactory nuisance control* Other lakes may require three or more treatments during a sumier* Treatment of algae one year will have no suppressive effect on algae the next year* In general, treatments have greatest chance for success when made in clear weather with light wind to aid mixing of the water as pre* viously stated* Early morning treatments are preferable to those made in the after noon* It is also desirable to have a day with calm weather before treatment to allow cells to float up into the upper few feet of water* Usually an entire lake must be treated for effective control of plankton algae since local areas such as a bay can readily become reinfected* Treating a bay or marginal area should be expected to give only very temporary relief* A principle precaution in treatment of plankton algaei other than application of correct dosage, is to make the treat*^ent before the growth becomes extremely heavy* Flan early for the treatment* If treatment is made when n heavy bloom is present, decay of a large amount of dead algae may deplete oxygen in the water causing a kill of fish and other aquatic animals* Do not wait to treat until there are heavy scums along shore* Treat while the algao .are still dispersed throughout the water* The niitsr should not be used for swimming for 24 hours niter treatment* If other copper compounds or formulations are used for algnc control, these should |)C applied according to directions on the label and instructions for their use provided by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources* Control of filamentous Algae Filamentous algae may become excessively abundant in localised shore areas and form blankets, scums, or moss-like growths on rocks* localized chemical treatment^ \igually give adequTte control* An effective treatment consists of three appli cations of copper sulphate at weekly intervals at a concentration of 1*0 pound of chemical per million po'inds of water or 2*7 pounds per acre-foot of water* The amount of copper sulphate to be used in each situation will be specified in the permit. The copper sulphate c-rfi be applied by hand scattering line crystals, by the burlap bag method using large crystals, or by spraying* A spray solution is made by dissolving powdered cop'-er sulphate in water* The chemical should be applied along the shoreline first and then into rrogresnively deeper water so that fish will move out of the area to be t/e it' '^* niter t.re .ting filum-.;ntoao algae with copper sulphate, the water should not be used for swimmitir for P.'* hours. Control of Muokrrasn (Ch«ai*a) Muskgracses are la-ge algae that lo'-k much like other large aquatic plonts* Chars, the most conmon of the muskgrasses, is a coarse bushy alga that ^owa attached to the bottom* The plant may grow from 6 inches to 4 feet tall and has 1 4 ■ it whorled bra crusted wit the branche. (?hara usual treat pounda of w by the boat phate to be sulphate, tl Certain controlling instructions the treated of Natural R Chemica boating and encroachment If in d< Technical Sei 390 Centennii ov« th« liiM n tv»n dis* t l8 not finiahtd )Bg ntthod lone, uni- mnt p9T «• or more ppressive nee for water as pro* n the after* ment to allow itire lake iS such as a lid be expected ipplication of »nely heavy. La present, luaing a kill i heavy scums tfater. The ol, these should eir use provided re areas and I tre.^vment three appli* 0 pound of er. The amount e permit. a, by the on ia made by pplied along sh will move opper sulphate. c plants. that grows 1 and has m »>d with lime, hi^a flshv or ^ Pl«nts art often en* Mch... ’ “* *“»• »*nr aMll r.ddi.h qior.. on * IiT* kreati9en?iJ four'^appUcations of coiner sulphate. The of water at weekiv pounds of copper sulplMte per million bojit^d-burlap-bi!g ..thod “»• er o b. UMd wiU b. 8D.eifi.d ti.. -SLI' *S?!_ ™* ??*""* •«1-JO be used will be specified in the ner»ifc ?tr* * copper sul- ». th. wiur ehould not b. ua.d ferTi^Li, Jorab'toJJS? Cdpper-containing and organic compounds are also effeotiv* tions"f^*the S^pa^Jmw? Jf SStiJu ral w2r?il.*^?2es2 Department in doubt as to the identification of water plants send « a Services Section, Division of Game and Fish Oeiartment^If n ^***tennial Building, St. Paul, Minnesota,%155 * ^ P**'tment of Natural Resources, \ i ■i 1 . ^ : *11 'h V > y* . ‘1 r' i -F r Aquatic Horbic piil'lic waters Endothall Com: ./r { i e. Aquathol K Potassium Endc Aquathol Plus (endothall & t Other Conpoun •Aydrothol 4? Oiquat Omlapon (Dowp< Watrol lasergent Plan (much as catt. tebmerred Plai (much as pond yioatlngleaf 1 (much, as wate: Others - Cana< Alga< Char^ Ducki Leecl ysMi: *te be applie< fhis list of • interdded to s< based on fede. available. Aj Departr.ont of St. Paul, Mir.) - V , . ^ ■ -L:'— - --• . -f itiii- • r U86 in Minncsotft nw#r Co!t>nounds ler sulfate ine iystem M mycin PLL-C le-Chek iysten A mm ifatrol nly product and is year 197^ and is els currently ccted to the uilding. tv »JQj 1976 AqUAtlC BEDBICIOE COSTS PER SOViOt ACRE TO INSlVintAL: CHEMICAL 2« Granules Aquathol Plus Liquid Aquathol Plus Granular Aquathol K Aqua-Vex Aqua-Vex Hovpotf H Cowpow C Huron Vatrol UNIT COST (♦) .5?At> 26.2S/e«i •70/lb 17.25/sal 'iT.SO/ cal 37.75/63X l.ASAb X.70Abs 1.57Ab8 22»11/ gal NANIIFACIORER'S RBCOMMENDED APFUCATION RATE 173 lbs/ Surface Acre 13.55/eal k gal/ Surface Acre 200 lbs/ Surface Acre 4 gal/Surface Acre 2 gel/ Surface Acre 4 gal/ Surface Acre 100 lbs/ Surface Acre 30 lbs/ Surface Acre 30 lbs/ Surface Acre 3 gal/ Surface Acre 48 gal/ Surface Acre C08T/SURFACE ACRE I 99.75 105*00 140.00 69.00 95.00 151.00 145.00 51.00 47.00 110.55 650.40 II t IVT. Chaaieai Vydrolthol 47 Cutrine (F.A.) Cutrine (chara) ^ Copper Sulfate ^ (filauentous algai Copper Sulfate Cohara) j Algluycin (P Uf-C ' -Cham1, •filaaentous algae Aquasine Plankton algae j filaaentous algae e • baaed on 4 fo< 4 - Manufacturer's CP.A.) filamentoui i.. I 99.75 105.00 1^.00 69*00 95.00 151.00 1<I5.00 51.00 47.00 110.55 650.40 Copper Sulfate (filaaentous algae) *50Ab 11 Ibfi/ Surface Acre Copper Sulfate (obara) .50Ab l6 Iba/ Surface Acre 8.00 Algiapein (P LL.C) Chara filaaentous algae 2.75Abs 2.7? ^bs 40 lbs/ Surface Acre 80 lbs/ Surface Acre 109.20 218.40 Aquasine Plankton algae filamentous algae 3.72Ab 3.72/lb l4 lbs/ Surface Acre 17 lbs/ Surface Acre 52.08 63.24 based on 4 foot average depth Manufacturer's suggested retail price Mechanical Cutting Without Surface Weed Removal % 40/ Acre ‘j (F.A.) filamentous algae Weed Weed Removal 1170/ Surface Acre 0-' • ■ > s • ( 4 i > i I CoapaiiK in 1975 • V* - / This 1 produc only t equips Resour Hinnes t/Surfac« Aer« 52.16 66.52 8.00 109.20 218.60 52.08 65.26 1 I- if ■-.V 4 CoBpanits Manufacturing aquxpmTOv in 1975. (exclusive of dredging equipoent) Besenrch & DeveXopnent 608 Virginia Dr. p.O. Box 6081-C Orlando, Florida 32o03 * I. ' . A .. •f % r 2. Air-Lec Industries, Inc. 3306 Commercial Avenue Madison. WI 55716 3, The Hockney Company 913 Cogswell Drive Silver Lake, WI 53170 Phone (414) 889-4581 or 862-2628 4. Aquamarine Corporation 1116 Adams Street Waukesha, WI 53X86 Phone (4l4) 542-9491 I I 5, Water Weed Saw Co. l402 21st Avenue North Minneapolis, Mn. 55411 Phone (612) 522-7090 Thi. list of couple, does not constitute product and is intended to serve only as a gu • ^j^cjujiical only to clendnr yeer 1975. oSSJ^taent of 5ltoi»leouipMnt in public waters should be directed to tte Deparw« RSsoSrces. Environ^nt Section. 390 Centennial Building. St. Paul. Minnesota 55155- ^hone (612) 296-2835- •.*■.'.•-■ Inforuational iMifiet No» 102 STATE 0? MINHESOTA nVIBONHEin SBCnON DIVISION OF FISH AND VILDUR WATER PLANTS —> THEY ARE VALUABLE AND NECESSARY Water plants nay be troublesone along svilnnlng beaches and in boat channels* Fbr this reaedn permits are issued by the Conservation Department Tor destroying or limit ing excessive growths by use of chemicals or by cutting or pulling* Water plants, how ever, are a valuable part of our lakes and streams* They are the naturcCL plant growth of waters, just as grass is in meadows or trees in forests* Fish, ducks and other aquatic life depend on them for food and shelter* Requests, therefore, to destroy aquatic plants should be limited to areas vrtiere they are seriously Interfering frt.th recreatioxial use of waters* Remember that these plants are not ”weede** in the same sense as garden weeds and they are not ’’pollution'*—although fertilization of waters can increase their growth* Here are some of the vcdues of aquatic plants: Pish food— Much more fish food for fish of all kinds is produced in weedy areas than fdiere there are no submerged plants* Insect larvae live on the plants* Sunfish, our commonest game fish, eat some plant material* Pish shelter— Submerged plants provide shelter for young fish and usually nests of bass and sunfishes are located in weedy areas* Northern pike spawn in marshy areas in early spring* Pishing is often best on the edge of weed beds* cation— Submerged plants absorb phosphate, nitrates and other nutrient ele» ments from water and soil as they grow* They compete with the tiny algae for the plant nutrients that cause water to become green in sunmer* Frequently if too many water weeds are destroyed, a heavy growth or "bloom” of algae follows* Some kinds of water plaints, such as rushes, can even absorb and break down polluting chemicals* Water plants, ooth the large kinds such as water weeds and the tiny algae, give off oxygen and thereby aerate waters* This oxygen is necessary for all fish and other aquatic animal life* Protection of ahorelfnes— Aquatic plants, especially kinds such as rushes and reeds, break the force of waves and help prevent erosion of shorelines* ft)od and shelter of waterfovl— Many of the submerged plants produce seeds and tubers that are eaten by wild ducks* Bulrushes and sago pondweed are especially valuable and are often planted for this purpose. Bulrushes and reeds also provide excellent shelter for broods of ducklings* Esthetic values— Several kinds of water plants have flowers that many enjoy* The yel^. low lotus is a protected wild flower* There are six kinds of native waterlilies all of vdilch have beautiful flowers* Arrowhead and pickerel"’^ri are both as ornamental as me jy garden plants* The "natural look" of a lakeshore should Include aquatic plants* They are part of the ecology of the lake* Bcon«v^c values— Wild rice, which is an emergent aquatic plant, produces seeds that are hand harvested* This local industry is worth at least $2 million to the economy of Minne sota* Aquatic plants are the basis of fishing on vdiich more than 1100 million is spent each year in Minnesota.- In recognition of these values the Minnesota Legislature has made SM^uatic plants grow ing in public waters legally the property of the State so they can be protected for the benefit of all the people* Permits issued to destroy them must take the values of these plants into account* Shoreline property owners can help by limiting requests for control permits to areas udiere control is really necessary* In turn we will be glad to help by advising as to best and safest methods* In general cutting and pulling of water weeds with removal is preferable from the point of view of lake ecology to use of chemicals. "Tiis can be done in limited eu:*eas without a permit. In some cases, fiOwever, only herbi cides are feasible* Any use of these requires a permit from the Conservation Department* J.. B .M. I Ik . 4 >4 4-: f' ) h OF NATU David B Aqua tic Ecologi Phil U Fish ar Ecol ogi Adi emai The f1< avian at the 6u(Cjc7 of thi botuTT The gr shrink on whl carcas feed1r shwn amount Duckli quanti Accorc destre In or: shore' PPE:V cc: < ..-ii LMfiet No. 102 X channels. FOr troylng or limit- fa ter plants, hovK ural plant growth icks and other e» to destroy iterferlng with a” in the same lation of waters L weedy areas than ;s. Sunfishy our lually nests of .n marshy areas in other nutrient ele- ilgae for the plant too many water weeds Is of water plants. Water plants, ooth sen and thereby bic animal life. rushes and reeds. seeds and tubers Lally valuable and i excellent shelter ay enjoy. The yel- waterlilies all of Eis ornamental as e aquatic plants. duces seeds that are the economy of Minn< OO million ia spent e aquatic plants grow- e protected for the the values of these requests for control be glad to help by ling of water weeds use of chemicGds. however, only herbi- servation Department. . 'I A .>■ I. •* I . ^ *■: i. r'i- i f \ k w W* * * * OF HATURAL RESOURCES David B. Zacpetlllo Aquatic Blolonist Ecological Services Section wune 25# 1^75 Phil Econoron ‘ . ^ Fish and v;ildlife Pathologist Ecological Services Section Adleman Pond, Bloomington, Minnesota The field and laboratory data supports Ivian botullsa as the cause of the recent duck norUllty at the above location. ISiicRs tbaiL-acanf »M< <nr» are parti^^ serisi.vive. JtO-Diu^eaKS- or t)tuns5lEn3aieiLicMer£^':^r^ er^ncerby ’Tia> grovSiTof oovui.ir.un U aUo * shrinki.-.o water levels vmi^xpose rore sh^ Oh whi S. wr anaer^- ^ay,‘ carcass“S*<:Sves%o cerpetuatc fcctulinun poisoning. fMd^r,^0p■^he” r-:-ains ingest the toxin an-i ^avc bat as few as one or tvo naggots »" arolint of batulinun toxin lethal for an Dwklinss and other srall birds ray die froo the ninute quantities of toxin released in tne water. a,.-nrJinrlv i* is cruclal that all dead and dying ducks be Keyed when "outbreaks of totulisr. occur .at these ocation, K to prevent additional poisoning of waterfowl and « • I • ^ . V V V ^ W ^ i shoreline birds. PPE:lls cci Oliver Jarvanpa UiIlian Lcr.gley iK. w» » QiPA^fyiENTT:^ *; -i V; r rnoM SUaiECT:M< Pursuant June 25, laborator din Minnea The most Health La botulism Laborator In July vj died. Si to botuli • # The botui Bloomingt are, be inf Higi*- temr tdilch the resulting coupled V proliferc of toxin, toxin pre ies } ^the magge Ducklings of toxin all dead lime-pit prevent i There is rences o Many peoj concentr magnitud' at this * wune ZSi 1^75 c ids ents gots VO be itions id I >-•'■ 'ft •r i] Ptf*ARTiyffMTT!^lQ]r NATURAL RtiSOURCES % '■!J I » t V: V i ( f Roger Holmes* Chief Wildlife Section DATE:August 24, 197: [4L FROM Phil Economon Fish and Wildlife Pathologist Ecological Services Section SUBJECT:Metro Duck Deaths from Avian Botulism Pursuant to my ®J'3“heen'*corroborated*^y**two”add^{r.:UriU‘i.*5ii: as:°s 'sx,irii srsrfoju .m. . in Minneapo'.is area lakes Tha most recent ”Msconsin^ earlier^verification cf by ?»e^s!rof Minnesota Veterinary Diagnostxc Laboratories. ■4 died?^^in=r?Senrat*$tLrilo^atSxfionffdLrdeat^^^ to botulism have occurred. ■ j • •M?gt o?! 11^ f le iriridinl being ’ in'/es$j.gfl^.ed. and reading _shbrel^_esi^ult^rtlgh temperatures and levels•Shlch the. bacteria of avxan botsli.|m,^ti-y^^er^ ,yg_^^^which the. bacteria or avian_octy^x,|u. - iSsunlKT^-onr^ “LS IdH! conditions for theresulting_ from UK'decomposition conditions for the ^liferation of the °!®tucks’and eialorltion of the .outbreakbf toxin. The rapid oecomposi^ion oi u.au ^ outbreak. toxin produced in these carcasses P®j;P®e toxin and Mag§9ts feeding on thebe duck^remains * ooisoned from stud!xuc?ll hlvf sLSn tStfheaUhy dScks ’may^^become poisoned from eating ha maggots from dead ducks a and in turn die^ - - --- -- Ducklings and other small birds may die from the minute qu _ of toxin released in the water. Accordingly, it is all dead and dying ducks be promptly destroyed by incineration or lime-pit burial v;henever outbreaks of botulism occur, in order to prevent secondary poisoning of waterfowl. There is no human health threat known or postulated from the occu rences oi avian. Type C bCculism in v/ateriOv<l« ^ A r* ' t ■ F«g€ Two Roger Holm August 24, i H ^»i-. ♦•iV> A • ♦ • * V' k, t*- V--.' (*■ if ^ ii • 'f- m Wb ere con have upon their fall have large in contact The latter transmitte PPE:ll8 ee: Mike Olive Rober Rober Attachment morandum August 24, 197: tttfQiT ^ mr •: A’- .4 • fcr ■■"V. w id memo of ^ two additiondl id this summer Fish and Wildlife verification cf^ *inary Diagnostic nown to have hs attributable I Minneapolis, ■rom Lake Minnetonka cqiulil^pn.^n “o^scygen levels n in mud flats > tions for the its production elaboration of e the outbreak, e toxin and oned from eating nute quantities crucial that ncineration or r* in order to ■I < from the occur- ch may tend to t, increasing the given handouts he most plentiful tf: W« mr* concerned about the effect this local botulism outbre^ mght have upon the health and safety of incoming ducks and geese during their fall migration. The factors promoting avian botulism will have largely subsided by that time, but migrant birds will be coming in contact with and be exposed to the weakened survivors of botulism Tha latter are prone to develop other duck illness ess which could transmitted to healthy waterfowl. PPEills V cot Mike Casey Oliver Jarvenpa Robert Jessen Robert Benson Attachment y • • 4 - • ^ -X •r r « » ' 1A ■ •... it break might lese during Lism will ill be coming I of botulism, lich could be ♦ # \ %: 1 . »I ’.r 'O ; r‘ ■ ’i ..jger Johnson Regional Wildlife Manager Region VI DATE: October 4. 1976 . 7 i V ' I FROM Philip P. EconoiRon Fish and Wildlife Pathologist Ecological Services Section 6t.£■ SUBJECT: m Pathology Report/Hallards/Srass Lake and Lake Harvey—S.U. Minneapolis The examination of^ , t above locations ruled out duck viral enteritis, fowl cholera. , Nsalmonellosis. toxic algae, and lead poisoning. 11 t. * ■ i •If. J •’ '* ■■ V 1 { 11 . V -. r 1 • % . • 2Ll!r: «:’S «.’2S3R3,?S.S’S^Ssr Kith the onset of cooler weather and reduc^ oxygen demand, the temperature and anaerobic conditions Sileh have promoted the growth of Type C. cZoatwitum totuHnam. ttls summer will end. The toxin that had been formed also degrades more rapidly under these circumstances. Natural and Induced restoration of water levels at these offected lakes and ponds will do much to prevent similar g^(ijpi*ances of avian botulism in the future. . »PPEtlls ■■if A. 4< •** f* R. Holmes R. Jessen R. Benson 0. Jarvenpa ? •’h ->• •.> I •• V- •.» • *■ A . • ’% ;w,-t •« ♦ * *9 1 m I: 1 mrnl • ‘ •• s 1 t •i randum ctober 4» 1976 fr £ Minneapolis the I ’U an Is Unms ^0 f r - -- —’ ^ — Office Memorandum •i’s V ., : ■ 1. ■ *■ ‘ ’ * '• •>. % SUBJECT; •* Roger Johnson Regional Wildlife Manager Region VI DATE: October 4, 1976 Philip P. Econoiron Fish and Wildlife Pathologist Ecological Services Section m Pathology Report/Mallards/Grass Lake and Lake Harvey—S.W. Minneapolis The examination of several moribund and dead Mil above locations ruled out duck viral enteritis* fowl cholera. The largest body of field and laboratory data points to avian botulism as the cause of these mortalities which . about three weeks ago. No recent mortalities have been reported at these or other locations since then. mth the onset of cooler weather and reduced biochemical oxygen demand, the temperature and anaerobic conditions which have promoted the growth of Type C, ctoatndvm hotuUnms this summer win end. The toxin that had been formed also degrades more rapidly under these circumstances. Hatwal and Induced restoration of wateraffected lakes and ponds will do much to prevent similar occurrences of avian botulism In the future* PPE:lls cc: R. Holmes R. Jessen R. Benson 0. Jarvenpa i ■ I’ ! :* I* * ^ V •a.; a Sr ; r f • • • ••1 t k k ‘ 1• S f t ’ • _________ ■ ^ ^!___________________________ ,s t .11 DEPAfm/ieMr.:!^! *dki V ‘ >- TO FROM SUBJECT; R R P F I 1 % a 1 I lU indum Dber 4, 1976 ^ £ nneapolls tMRj m^.Mi ’"■■■ m_____ mmfir"*>» s«■ ''> i# . V V:’. . • X ^ ll *,oc^AftmeNr: STATE Of- MtNNtSOiA Office Memorandum f • FROM . ♦ Roger Johnson Regional Wildlife Manager DATE: November 19, 1976 ^4 Phil Economon , . ^ Fish and Wildlife Pathologist Ecological Services Section SUBJECT: Pathology Report Duck deaths at Birchcrest and i?J^s"*were investigated last month. About 30 mallar were involved in what appeared to be the culmi nation of the avian botulism outbreak of last summer. These ducks appeared to be late victims of botulism with chronic symptoms related to weakness and minimum exposure to the botulinum toxin. The necropsy bn the five mallards eliminated fowl cholera, salmonellosis, duck plagu , aspergillosis, and lead poisoning.. Idiopathic anemia and atrophy are a diagnosis of tertiary avian botulism in these ‘instances. PPE:lls cc:Gordon Gust Oliver Jarvenpa Dave Zappetillo For Immed ^ % 1’“ ; randum trvT,.: f-vK' November 19, 1976 u/0/r /= Lsm gue. m \k % =• ^1! { i ■} * :r- v'.-t.? ■r^d t .- - 7 ' 0,1 ■ k »• * ^-'^7 C\; ■ Tf ▼'■*'*■»• a- /■ '.Vv r^'-^v GRHT UKES lEtlON UNS A r For Immediate Release Dffpartmcnt of the Interior U S. Fish and \^il(JHie Service Federal Bldg fort Sneihng Twin Cdnys. Minn bbW Larson <612i ;?5-3519 FriEiPd Jc*'-.' ''LOSSES FROM AVIAN BOTULISM WIDESPREAD Losses of waterfowl and other water birds from avian botulism nr/<- been widespread throughout the United States this summer, according u, U, r U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service's National Fish and Wildlife Health i „o-,r,. v :•>, Madison, Wise. (rT Mil ton Friend, director of the laboratory, said positive dit<'j»to*'es of type C botulism have been established by the UFWIIL for the folio,<ing areas: Sand Lake NUR near Aberdeen, S.D.; various locations within ‘.ne St. Paul-Minneapolis area; Park Ridge, IL; Bowl imjbrook, IL; O’Hare !nt:.r national Airport in Chicago; Green Bay, Wl; lloricon NWR in Wisconsin. u./J Ul-Bend-Bowdoin NWR ir northeastern Montana^ Several other botulism suspect areas are still under investiqatj .m, <z? he said. "The greatest losses have occurred at O'llare Int'l airport v.ne,e more than 1000 waterfowl and shore birds died from this disease and in Montana where several hundred ducks—mostly blue-winged teal-diod." The laboratory director disclosed that Horicon National Wildlife has been under intensive surveillance due to recently initiated changes in the management of the refuge. "Aerial flights and repeated surveys h, air boats have only disclosed a small number of sick and dead birds, " ... sau. “A total of 13 birds-all that could be picked up-have been examinoj, .>igni (more) -K . -0II 1J P--- 5 : « • % r7 *'- "-V t I .LOSSES' FRO of which h represent monitored several th Dr. U Station, B an infecti bacterium, most deadl He pc through F, attacking dose is li It is year in tt usually t> "In c dead aqual rnents and, eat these feeding or and, if Ic birds, a s related tc years hav< Dnsidered to 1 be continually 1972 when iver Research isoning, not ed with a es one of the gnated A hers but al I , if the 20 cases a botulism is ory. bodies of ent reauire- irds that riy maggots lighly toxic. :onsumed by )t necessarily Is in recent »nsen says. ■s < ^V-fy •.« kt. ^ . :*‘V '•Iv i'. ‘'t )v ‘;! f .* ■.} ■ i’- LOSSES FROM AVIAN BOTULISM WIDESPREAD -3- Low water conditions become important only when they result in the death of large numbers of invertebrates or fish; these rotting carcasses may then provide a suitable medium for toxin production. Dr. Friend added. Daily clean-up of infected carcasses and their proper disposal is essential for preventing a rapid build-up of botulism and other diseases, « reports John Ellis, A FWS biologist in Minneapolis. Waterfowl die-offs « should be reported to the nearest office of the Fish and Wildlife Service or State Conservation Department as soon as they are observed, Ellis suggests. Wildlife disease specialists at the Fish and Wildlife Service’s National Fish and Wildlife Health Laboratory are available to provide identification and control of these disease problems through the FWS regional office in Minneapolis. 9/7/76 -FWS- 5t :i ' "4 -T.. hi 1 ; r, -• i H I ' -•V I ! •; • >1 * ■ •r «* ^PDuck 5noh< Assoeiah ' The d« ducks on .Uiis sum ^ botulism, 'humans. Resource said Wed ' The bo lakes an Blooming na. The firmed b; WUdlife Madison, The bai botuUsbi lures and ceding sh summeric Phil Ec< pathologh mans fee summer \ centrate t there is be *lDucks handouts: their natu plentiful." >Conom< needed to disease is i and dispo! tion or Iini ducks cont ing magg birds. • e^ .1 : - ^ iiSiMV- ^ mmm----------— ^ the death lay Chen :e in r>/,v-- if ‘ i m \d • ‘^«-4 •»1 r ^ k .. •;■ I V»i s>. 1^ A.,^ -^.WL.«L:a;. . Jt., .1^ «.»-v';?> -:i V-:i-i. ;:»i <:■ '. 1 H V- ‘ ■- ♦ >• .*1 »> ■t ■ 1 / ll «r hi f Duck-death c *a. ^ no harm to humans • H . Associated Press ' The death of several hundred ducks on T:\’in Cities area lakes »this summer was caused by avian botulism, which is not harmful to 'humans, the Minnesota Natural /• Resources Department (DNR) said Wednesday. ' The botulism problem has hit lakes and ponds in Minneapolis, Bloomington, Richfield and Edi na. The precise disease was con firmed by the National Fish and Vnidlife Health Lal)Oratory in Madison, Wis.. The bacteria which cause avian botulishi thrive in high tempera tures and mud flats created by re ceding shbrelines. a result of the summerlong drought. * • Phil Economon. fish and w ildlife pathologist for ‘he DNR. said hu mans feeding uucks during the summer may be helping to con centrate the birds :»i areas where there is botulism. ''Ducks do not have to be given handouts at this time <>lye?r whe.n their natural foods are the most plentiful." he said. __________ Economon said the man action BMded to prevent spread of the disease is to p’ck up all dead ducks and dispose of them by »ncine."a- tion or hme-pit burial. He said iive ducks contract the disease by eat ing maggots growing on 'dead birds. # \ Botulism spawned by drought blamed for death of ducks f . • Avian botulism has caused the death of several hundred ducks in • ' Minneapolis-area lakes this sum- mer, the Minnesota Department of ^ Natural Resources says. 1^ The agency said yesterday that . the botulism, w'hich is n >t harmful tc people, has infested lakes and ponds in MinneafKjlis, Bloomington. Richfield and Edina. Bacteria that cause avian botul ism thrive in high temperatures and mud flats created when shore lines recede during droughts. Phil Economon. the agency's fish and wildlife pathologist, said dead ducks should be picked up and dis posed of by incineration or lime-pit •burial to prevent the disease from He also said people may be con tributing to the duck deaths by feeding the birds, thus encouraging them to concentrate in areas where there is botulism. • *-4- • ^ .2 • j r; -11 ‘1 4 i . I * % . i ■pff •'•■Svi'v: i I'm K • \ f i >■ >.v: U‘ v- / > u»<-, I Vi i ^ ” ■1 1 j i.. pis id ned cks (d the cks in sum- ent t*f f that rmfut s and '.gton. botul- itures shore 's fish dead id dis- ne-pit from ecoH' ;s by ■aging ivhere y .#•• :| r f i. « Ml i rM hu I MIL in / )( By JOE HENNESSY I,- No shore birds were affected b^^i^id there is no danger to humans liMnaeapolis Star Outdoor Writer I the outbreak. He said that when the\ from the outbreak. water is foul, shore birds move to undreds_ of wild ducks- erell^ither feeding grounds, but the dyinf. on Twia_Dtics gtsii £onii$ and lakes, and part of the reason is that the juhfic h'as~Been feeding thm, a state p^Qiogis t sald'yes- lerday,__ Many deaths are caused by bo tulism. contracted by the birds in gesting the toxin with contamina ted food. Concentrating t.*:e ducks greases the cfiances ot infection. ks sru f f eT I n g from botulism, show neck paralysis and flop around helole^^lv. _ ucks remain because of the artifi tal feeding. Economon said he *>uld stop short of saying the Li.Js never \ should be fed. But he said the abundance of ducks on smaller lakes, v/hich now are quitewarni. definitely is a factor in the death.s. He said that without the feeding — thTTfu^s would seek .cleaier.wa- "Unless humans were to eat the same insects and vegetation or drink the \s*ater, they would not get the same type of botulism." Krosch said. Samples of blood from the birds also were sent to the Nat:or.al Fish and Wildlife Labratory in Maryland and to the University of Wisconsin. Severe outbreaks of b*3luI*s.Ti in the North Dakota arid South Dnko- ta and on ther west coast in recent Howard Krosen, ‘^nheaeparP yers resulted in t.he deaths of t«.n$ ment's ecological services section of thousands of duck.s. ilism was confirmed this week In at least some of the birds ^ ^ , the Minneapolis Minnesota veterinary diagnostic thurs., July 29, 1976 | Biateratories.51/TD THE FIRST outbreak about 3 weeks ago was at Adelman Pond in Bloomington, where 110 dead or dying ducks were picked up. Since then, ducks have been coJiected at Washburn Pond, in Bloomington and at Lake Cainoun. Weed-cutting crews have been picking up ducks elsewhere in the metropolitan area. Dead ducks not taken to the lab oratories for testing have been burned at Bloomington ’s diseased elm-tree site. / •• / VL J * ' . V / "High temperatures and reced ing shorelines result in a conditicn in which the o.-gar:;;ms (of botul ism) thrive," said Econom on. DNR fish and wiidlii'e patnoioVTJT "Low oxygen and hea*.y vegetation cause exiri’me pro!::er.ii:cri (of bo tulism) when the t c .m p e r a i u r e reaches 03 degrees. "The study sho'Acd that one or two imyjtots fccdii.'.» on the dead ducks concentrate th« toxin enough to kill a healthy adult duvk." he f said. » • s 4 \ t I i i ) "Concentrating the ducks by fecdTng ThbW ha-»-aan:.jkcit&!y7H:i- cciit^ on ■the cutbrmrttt^ -EccTrmaon X, V ♦ • ‘V 5.^ said. "It uTTrac’s iV.rrn !ro:n ’o*b.?r pla<:»-s. I rihew •?.:• i- >! iriVwitl.'jl i.’-ui5“ic inr*n:. iiui-’w/.'; •hor.-cir- cuits n'tlVii.aJ i ■• •• 4. • 1. ■* . R ’ hi. 4 it.f / i i V- /' I r * #' % 9i f ' 4 • ^ iT'* • ' . ■ It ^ • ‘i. f ^‘.1 ' : 'r- t * ‘i r t /• * * 4* 0 ' • /y- ‘m: • •. •d ♦ I f f :» - -. V . f - •.* i I * i •I • .- / ^ ‘' >*v I: Vvir'A;,.? • ^ ' *. 1* : •* • •,*> *f. . ^ • •.. • . -a ' X • ♦ ' • ••• " ' ^ I - ■ f' f ..‘.-it ^ J ^ i I •• .r . ■ I-'f i. ;'iV- ^ V 4 . <%■.' • ' * • % ■■ ■i ; f ■ i. ».a.# « tt::*v A. ' V • V t. V f • • • II n»_SS £11® jurea there is no danger to humans the outbreak. nlcss humans were to cat the insects and vegetation or the water, they would not get ime type of botulism," Krosch ipics of blood from the birds were sent to the Nat:onal and Wildlife Labratory in and and to the University of nsin. ere outbreaks of botu!-s.*a in orth Dakota and South Dako> I on ther west coast in rc;;en: esulted in t.ne deaths of uns isands of ducks. 5TAM .. r ‘V t ■k _______W;' : & / • ' ; • 4-. .a,r .* / f ■ / • ■ If t T:'*'«<e r» ■ 0Wf 4 *" > •. . A i TD Mi ^e --8« XJ 3 - --i c* it .2 S>-s'£'^3^ X ' '•'l- ► • I- f A : .. ■ ., ••' .• ' ■ i' • « ■ ■■• ' •< ' Twi ^ •' • .: A \/ •vV"> •*■•••■• *•..*■ ■• ’. - ■ J.v" uV/ •' ■ i ' '• 3“C'0|'S*.2 SZ • 21 2 s §^.5 £3f% 6» ^0/ 21 <0 <s .. <v J' ni* V ** v t. • nV->,ifv i ! -.f V '■■.; 'i ■ . 4 — ‘ ■ -• ■; . ^ . * f :y^' aliipjl n e !S'S fi<os ':X> .'.; • j *»• * •• my If;t C- ^ tr -f • * ,f ; /» ■: •. ■ .••• .••'. ■.“•., Vi- •*% • •;■•. ' ■ * •■ ■•*■■ •. -. •■ *. I V , . t t • > .. •. .. • - #' ^ • V ' • . £ ^ > C J?>S1s a ® n ®I %*2 n 2^ • Cl c ^ S V - t . r* -7 * V k-?*- 1.1 • «B * • Pl^V ■’* *Al'>- .>.l-". '*-** - •* ; -..^v I I tit t ** .)n ■ .1' ‘ JMi •■••■‘A V V ' ■ v'vA /■ i • •r sk 1 ■ • •;)f V / $** . i: :• ■•’,- f .a ' » k . • •.' ^ V • / ,i-.. 7 t .• ..' ••• ‘' . < ' S .>s k .• *■ ••■..•< ;'S * ;;l . * 4 ' t F . ' 'iV- V i A.F ^ :■ ■ V . .. • * • * * * "V, ' '*f • I 1 <''•■ >*K»* t * *i pi:- If ■*1* j' N'.j • ■;t .if* GLESNE SALES INC. Manufacturers Representatives Suite 112 7300 Gallagher Drive Minneapolis, Mn. 55435 \ I ^^U>4S>' ’ I K:i^:f S INC. fasentaiives r ^ J0Pb^ f/ <LXxr/'^^ jk I* I t •V T1 A!- t-. /is. tt 4 t '■* h • h '.' ■ M; V-.;.J'..‘ ,:i*;.V1 Vy»^¥.^S-; ? -Vv ‘:'iiSBMsdm ■ \r^rc :-laaii • •-'...».' j.-i' 4 <?7- f :t - (jL^eA/“^ .!'• ii ‘ * ••*••*• I . • . • • • • 1. •. • • I .♦>v ;:^ 3 ,. awimmers* Itch Swimmers * ti^et may Be act organTsk TS" a~l aqufitlL birds i f tinyT^ee-ewimf f The presejfCF tr I tration s^flrewhi I sonetines confi I physician. A Th3 lii'e : '' ndult stage is and mammals, o: eggs in the sm* into the intesi into tiny free- Four species o: snail the orgai minute fork-ta: naked eye. Cfl each day for a ^ about seeking i ''t this time rr Because control or allt with^ppor su] Large cf^sTals snails or place For best result or to the outei often been sati Where pos£ shore or extend of drift of irt should be made area and v;hich oince th»* that water in t »5ome coatz masse^^ of weed: A permit i to public lake: .iection of T»ch sources, 390 Cc W^m . •- . .. . ■ .. *\ZnfomatioB LaafLtt No* 8 MINNESOTA DEPARTMENT OF NATURAL RESOURCES mVIRONHENT SECTION DIVISKRI or FISH AND WIlJ>liIIS f CONTROL OP SWIMMERS* ITCH AND liTiCHBS awimners* Itch L ■? ' .' Swiaiffl«r^ (schistosome dermatitis) is a temporal^ but annoying skin infection 1 t)|^ may be acqun'^d~By bathe^^^ lakes, usually in'June euid July* i^e causative J oreaHrs?ir ts u liny puraMte that lives part of its life in snails and matures in aquatic birds and maiasaJs,"'usually Waterfowl* Humans are not the normal host and the tinyT^eo"Swimming"~pairasiies (schistosome cercariae) die when they enter the human skin* The ^eseffev of this Toreign body in the skin causes severe itching at the site of pene tration somewhat siMl^ to a mosquito bits* A heavy infection may produce a rash sometimes confused with ivy poisoning* nny such skin condition should be seen by a physician Thestory of the organisms causing swimmers' itch is quite complicated adult stage is e tiny f]uke (trematode)^hnt lives in the blood vessels of aquatic bird) and mammals, often wild ducks* When the flukes are mature they mate and the females lay eggs in the smilTerT^intestinnl veins of the host animal. From here the eggs migrate r into the intestine from which they leave the animal in the droppings* These eggs hatch into tiny free-swimming animals (miracidia) which burrow into certain kinds of snails* Four species of snails h.ve been found to carry swimmers* itch in Minnesota* In the snail the organism further develops and multiplies, finally emerging in warm weather as minute fork-tailed free-swimming animals (cercariae) that are barely visible to the naked eye. Often many thousands of the cercariae are released from an infected snail each day for a period of a week or more. On release from the snail they swim and drift about seeking r. suitable bird or mammal host* Accidental penetration of skin of bathers •’t this time results in swimmers* itch. I a .1 Because the causative organisms are harbored by snails it is usually possible to control or alleviate swimmers* itch oubreaks by killing the snails along a beach area with copper sulphate (blue vitriol) at the rate of 3 pounds per liPOO square feet* Large cfysfalsof copper sulphate may be scattered over the shallow water area harboring snails or placed in a burlap bag and towed about the area to be treated until dissolved* For best resultc treatment should extend from the water*s edge outward to the drop-off or to the outer edge of heavy weed growth. However, treatment to a depth of 4 feet has often been satisfactory. Where possible, treated areas should be continuous for 500 to 500 feet along the shore or extend 100 feet on either side of the bathing area to reduce the possibility of drift of infective organisms from untreated areas. Application of copper sulphate should be made from the shoreline outward to repel any small fish that might be in the area and v.hich might be killed by the high concentrations used. oince th»* concentration of copper sulphate used is quite high, it is recommended that water in treated areas not be used for 4S hours after treatment* oome control of swimmers* itch may be accomplished by keeping beaches clean of masser of weeds and other debris that provide protection for snails* A permit is required for application of copper sulphate (or any other chemical) to public lakes and streams. Application for such a permit should be made to the section of T3chnical Services, Division of Game and Fish, Department of Natural Re sources, 39C' Centennial Building, dt* Paul, Minnesota, 531S5. m »1I1^> 1 '.i OFFICE PHONE • 4744167 January 7, TO WHOM IT RE: Swlmmc I treated Donald 0*R< swimners ll The above i Derma Cort Sincerely, MilCoh H. MHS:ckg \ \ \: L ob Looflot Ho« 8 fffT i- I akin infection > the causative itures in L host and the r the hunan skin* the site of pene- iuce a rash be seen by a Bonplicatcd. ?1 of a»^uatic bin i the fenales eggs siigrate rhcse eggs hatch inds of snails* sota. In the warn wenthcr as Bible to the infected snail Y strfim and drift f skin of bathers ly possible to g a beach area quare feet* er area harboring until dissolved* to the drop*off th of 4 feet has feet along the he possibility opper sulphate might be in the tl ♦ is reconmended bes clean of I iher chemical) lade to the r Natural He- ' 1} ! li t fi- f i'M * mmmm rty-'. MILTON H. SEIFERT. JR.. M.D AND ASSOCIATES. Lrn b '? WATER STREET EXCELSIOR. MINNESOTA 55331 OFFtCC t’HONE 474 4107 24 HOUR Stl^VICE 922 OOOO y January 7, 1977 TO WHOM IT MAY CONCERN: RE: Swimmers Itch LMiro^temraS*“so°Patrick^o ’lte were also treated for 8wlmn6rs Itch in July of 1976e The above named individuals were treated for this condition with Deirma Cort creme* ! Sincerely, ' ^ MiltSiTH^ Seifert, Jr., M.D. MHS:ckg \ \ \ \n X ; ■ ■ ' f * f > ..w ** f L I. r, ■ 1 yK / i • t * . . .. . •■•r:.; '* le - ■ it A . Ur* Jim \ Dept* of Ihiiversli St* Paul Dear It. Ve, Reaii feeding < health h< / hcac!> • i have bcc< V,e !.ave i the twin cernlng i CCi Vll] a ^ *.en .A • - a . . . A**. i. . 4 > - ’a * . ' lOUR SERVICE 922 0000 '"t K i .-j. ifi«K.i--#^A-''i--'i.' i1S;'vyi-‘^Ji^«. ^-rfHiil ^ .11^^*' **i /•V K--V V ^''lA I if-. ^ f- / ’» } to fe- ♦.-/ > •V Dr* Jim Cpopmr Dept* of Betonolerya Fleh & Wildlife University of Minnesota, St* Paul Campus St* Paul, Minnesota 55108 3926 Cherry Avenue Mound, Minnesota, 55364 January 7, 1977 Ejctfiffir Re| Feeding A Ralslnc of hfallart-s Dear lar* Coopers we, Vlesidents of the Village of (>rono, are conccnied vith the feeding and raising of mallards by ncinbcrs of our community* %ve health hasard for adjoining property owners am! in one cane, a public '/ beach* We, also, feel these ducks are ciota do^iicstic t)>an wild and have becoma domesticated becntiac of the feeding* We have been informed of your knowledge and work with waterfowl In tlie twin City area anJ would appreciate your cotnnents and advice con* cerning this isatter* Sincerely, Pegg^ O'Reilly (Mrs* Donald R*) CCi Village of Orono Council t ‘■'^k t-.' 5W64 • 4 ^ •»ti-'i tr A7 ire :hls >iic :on» E-‘7^ •'V li ^4\ * * j* (»* i;^4 •• - 4. •'<*. • \ * %v /• •. • \ • • V * V..>• % * ’■'.*■- -f'V- ' ■ :i ..'I «• •»■ < 'V** V •>^ •r )i i*. »p fV'-' -, tZ-L-v-A^ V-/V 7 j. V ' . ‘ • Ji/iOr j ; '.y . f*/yvi,‘^ih-'4' tiqj}. # UiJdLpj :!X ' ■ ss/^f V aU'^Ar,^-' ’■''' TTtf. vJU^ Jb/jfliO " * lIwUMjLuut. MJ iamha A'C V'(kOMUlU 'to A/9tJS/i ^ v/iu' <w/iMJ Jv 9 ^ ^/k4^ VUli ____________-cx» Jk»4i')ai ir » 1 t 1 J>L it. ,4^ ■> ^vcL^Uuo f£)f^ (duuMM fS Fv ■:;s: •*s- vf?K- ’'!>• % t % I ‘ \i/.j' \j * • • d I i;-^^ » *■ * *. • * V • ♦ t/ •' » V ^r;-- • -V f t t- i A': '?■ T'^ V -. • • t* h. ; • '■ •»►» . •• ‘ ' -‘^ * > • ''W 1.^, . • « . /• • ! ’ ' •> y ^ C •- :'■ ''A-' • ■ i'.- .7 '■ ■ V. .-* , :-'v . V* - •..' 'X^‘ r , ''■" a--:. -S; * > •■, ■ :■' f-‘ .*,- *I r : . :;.. -i y'’'' i'- ■ '■ : 1 :]!-/■•■■■■= /} .1* \ t I /'vv7 7 /. ^<^Li: f 14))^ 3- /7iti. b: 4i<4^ ri tf %‘V. ^ iF'l \ [ > I Ut^ >s >v /*i -r •V I "V C ;^ a; ; .'vv ■ » J'■■ I-.j‘7 , ; .*' i*' .'’ '- '•“ . v. >» /’ • > • ^ ;r ■4 ....i t •r I . . '■'I*,. . ’• .♦‘v t i.- > . \ }.' <• |i • .1 t* V. ■'I S ' .i' .-1 i.'--i:';-.y-asm-:-; \-'mi^ ' ^wm-: - 'i^■i'iI-:- n 1^•». ‘. ,.i **m4 .*• » , A'" /f. 1. ♦*.’V,> / • IMaiUaJ /Wfi”mW..4. rf^' L V/ET *« iifjm/tiMiulj I mJj/ii ^ JktAn^f c » ♦'« fllUJ4V I : V » • liUZ-l -U : .-I, P’j •'• i>f-'I k’i'. i ii.^i f / '/lit' ■ Mnu.o, ¥-<r^^ /ou^u-ia^L ■'ntfi<-- /fl'tC^ Cu'' icttlA^ LfKlAJ^ 'j^fLtAJ -. M •t »0tr*4^ m ■ > UN TWI Janu Mrs. 3928 Moun Dear 1 su the foil itck cons a dc ducl< lake the feec suim boti fec( lin< siti I s YAu: \ . /J./ 1 I Dir wrnmmm • ■ . • -l-'j'k-Vi.; ;■ ■■ *■ /sn. \ja^ Jl y hull y f 77 , /TiLfi c l.-v-’l- UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA Freshwater Biological Iristitute TWIN CITIES College of Biological Sciences P.O. Box 100 County Roads 15 and 19 Navarre. Minnesota 55392 January 18, 1977 Mrs. Peggy O'Reilly 3928 Cherry Avenue Mound, MN 55364 Dear Mrs. O'Reilly: 1 support the passage of an ordinance to discourage the feeding of ducks on Lake Minnetonka for the following reasons: » ' 1) Ducks are primary causes of the swimmers itch parasite on our beaches. 2) Ducks have a very active metabolism and consequently defecate about half their own body weight a day. Therefore encouraging large populations of ducks adds substantially to organic pollution of the lake. 3) Organic pollution has been shown to encourage the growth of toxic "blue-green algae**. 4) With the water level being low, ducks have been feeding in areas rich in their own excrement. Last summer many ducks died as a result of poisoning by a botulisum toxin produced by anaerobic bacteria in the feces-rich sediment. Therefore feeding ducks in shore line areas is not even kind to the ducks in drought situations. People are killing the ducks with kindness. I support your actions and hope that common sense prevails. urs sincerely. / /J./ M. Wood id/:rector r // eight f the murage ive been ist >y a \ the shore- Jht Lndness. 5 prevails ■t ; •1 I • w 1*^ r ' ' is : ' . i iJis.'j fs. / t r' .i f V'1:v^* i United States Department of the Interior FISH AND WILDUFt SI RVICF Federal Building, For( Snelling Twin Cities, Minnesota 5*' 11 1 iM BteLV urta to; MIM January 6, 1977 Mrs. Donald OVeilly 3928 Chary Ave. Mound, MN 35364 Dear Mrs. OVeilly: ss'S?.Kr™^si.r»‘:i.::isrursis:: r;!“. Fish and Wildlife Service: «&Dos»estlc and semi-domestic A«cl^s raised under confined conditions have been rTpeate^ljFsfi^^n to be serious disease reservoirs. When they are releaseirsinriiitx with wild ducks they can transmit diseases to wild birds. We view the potential for the introduction and spread of Duck Viral Enteritis (DVE) from captive-raised ducks released to the wild for wild ducks by the Fish and Wildlife Service. / /'liftflllfSf /North under these conditions are severely taxed to maintain normal body f functions and become very susceptible to disease which can be easily V introduced under conditions found at artificial feeding and watering sites. \/ ‘Last sunner during our hot dry weather we saw a high Incidence of Type C i Sotulism in ducks in the TWin Cities area. Here again the combination \of feeding captive-reared ducks at waters Infected with Botulism and /decoying wild ducks to these areas no doubt caused a greater loss o w ducks than if the birds dispersed naturally throughout suitable habitat in this area. In short, wild ducks which are held captive and are then allowed to mix with wild ducks pose an unhealthy potential for both themselves and the wild birds which come in contact with them. /■ I mII Sinc«irely yours, P ^ I xiv.f-1AL JohWH^. Ellis Senior Staff Wildlife Biologist Migratory Birds and Haomals and Non-Mlgratory Birds 7 :■> ; 'N'n.- f ■4 a « i - • #V- % I AFFUCAT In accardano the followin eubDitted to is unlawful in Lake Minn (l) Maoe:^ (2) Addxeaa (3) Locatlo (a) Sis (b) Nus (c) Are (4) Purpose (3} Se>iciE (6) Municii Before a spe the followir (a)1 I (b)a d 1 (o) 1 f *£ a (d) 5 (e) 1 c c I ♦S LV MVBA to: BH nestle e U. S. have are d uck Id d us nanaged ficialLy lited :s for >e very >ther 1 the L body lly ing Type C nat Ion and of abttat to nix nd the it Mi ......I ift'TT rMMiiiMHffflniTii' f’ '4- it' 'i, ^ -• «Vt t Lake Minnetonke CoDservation District / to . AFFLICATIQN iND SI^IAL IBBMIT FOR DB-IC1N6 EQUIIMBNT INSTALLATION In accordance with Chapter III of the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District Code, the following special pomit application shall be conpleted in all respects and suboitted to the District Office, 402 East Lake Street, Vayzata, Minnesota. It is unlawful for any person to instil, operate, maintain or use de—icin^ equipoent in Lake Minnetonka without a special permit issued in aooordanoe with this Chapter. Date:-(l) Name: bU CA^<Jl4l^UA/£? AfAJ (5) Location and description of de-icing equipment: (a) Size of unit used: (b) Number of units used: h g. p.m. h. p. (4) (c) Area capability of unit(s): O sq. ft. Purtx)ae: (5) De-icing period (dates unit will be in use): from C, (6) Municipal Permit: to 1^1^ • I Before a special permit may be issued by the Lake Minnetonka Conservation District, the following statements must be checked: 0>) (o) w That the proposed installation will not be detrimental to the public , health, safety, order and convenience; That the area to be de-iced be no greater than is necessary to prevent damage to the instillation and does not extend nor affect areas beyond the dock use area for which the permit is issued; That adequate safety precautions will be followed in its installation and operation, including providing a enow fence four feet ^ hei^t; *a minimum of six reflectorized signs; de-icing occur only in the i»r- mitted area; and all other requirements as specified in the permit; That the installation will be properly enclosed and adequately marked and lighted to protect the public; That the applicant has taken apprepriate steps, either by the obtaining of insurance or otherwise to hold the District and its officers and emplcyees harmless tsom any damage or injury arising out of the oper ation of the equipment; (Continued on Page 2) *Bee sheet attached ¥Bmm- Application ar Page 2 ^ (f) Thi buj (g) Thi I certify tha*! true and com of my knowled^ consent to pei at all reasoni District is b< Can be reaohe or Special De-Ic: of Directors < In no ( which \ Dated: Approve Inspect Issued to brict CodOt pecte and iota« It ig equipnent bhia Chapter. ~7C ^ U' ion Pistrlot* he public to prevent reas beyond istallatioD jQ height; J9 the per- I permit; iely marked the obtaining .oera and r the oper- Applioatloh and Special Bsrmit for Pe-loing Equipsent Inatallation Page 2 That the inatallation will be made in accordance with applicable building, electrical and other construction codes; and (g) That the installation will be maintained in a safe, neat and orderly condition and be completely removed from the Lake by April 20 • I certify that the information provided herein and the attachments hereto are true ax>d correct statements as to the conditions of the application to the best of my knowledge. I agree to the provisions of the special permit if granted, ai consent to permitting officers and agents of the Pistriot to enter the premises at all reasonable times to investigate and to determine whether the Code of the District is being complied with. Signature of Applicant:__ Can be reached at phone number: ^ Special Pe-Icing* Bsrmit approved by the LcJce Minnetonka Conservation Pistrict Board of Pirectora as above, subject to the following requirements: • A ' V able ’ I . orderly 0*. to axe the best antedf asd preDiaea le of the Latxict Board use area for t-*'' >-S -v' ■ V • 4>‘ ? ■.3^' ;/ = :H A I ‘••■4 • "■ vvT-:'--•■ « ■I'^.-■ ;/:■' V., - V V •'k *'•' .• . f .*• i.V--/.rt ...mV V' '.'■ *• •. •. ' * :. .. .' • * >Vv'r' \.r:: ’‘^ ■. . I . h* *. I : * . I I;»v . . » » , *v’.‘ \-0, ■ Ky>yj V Jv-sly... ; V ^ ‘•■1 •fi.' twit 4 » • J)2>3 Cherry Avenue ! l!ir.n'"3ot'» Jnnu'^ry 17 > ^T/7 ^xff'fOf'r f* Villepe Council Orono* Minnesota To l!hoin It Concerns Our »arhai?e cans are enclosed ty a wood ntruot.ire on poUo tiles. Test sutmer and fall »*en ploitinr un "artare s-ter visits fpoB r.aocoons» 1 saw rat dro'-pincs around the cans. ■/a stray cat walked dlrietly in front of t» near the '^area oarryint' a rat. I called the village and ?' ■>«' J ”rrat^i “on out but decided a.r.ainat it b. cauac of the raccoons. V hr'*»ieve the duck feed nnd duck epRS ore hrlncinp these ^ roSeirtrwo!2d. T conal ’or this a definite health h.,sard and ^problem. Sincerely» Fc"py 0*Heilly (rro. Donf»id) : y :- Vli ,Sh ;,a- ». -a* . .4 • ♦! ' 'f.’l t -r .• ,1 . i-' h. ^ ‘A* I : Dr. .To*ri \ r*yK? ; ■ •ly'!'t>^ 9 1 Doer Dr. Vi5> ro‘iti-> n M i V'*v?c;rr-m: fyrn < nMi!i?e *?otVa*i*-y hcolt*' Vc Ti.t; durko e::r.'«..)tr.or ■rVLr.v.or ’c is 'ny s? 'i 1 ‘r.T, ?on •'rnrottoT r.f:-: JO s oi? t Orrr* ' •*’y*!*' tn» 1" iniWMot*! Dcwr Oi", ’ co:i| ■■»>?■ -Irorry /’.vcriiK- T.I «» i ^ T f *1 V ** J/ p i f t ( Dr*. V.otkI 7V(*.;b V av CT I it.lciricnl TniUV.iU ''•VK* •*■•% £lf(//0/r '«Tih«i o'* t’-'■'ll'’-«>•? vor,o» ^v': v**M: *;:.o - •.•■ 1 li. v-M or. •.-’•.c !■ iny.- ’-y tM.^rrr <-T.~ :>orr-B>‘.'.y ‘. ' o o*.!!. o-u- 'm.,: ' ■ ;'2 /’ in,,,-e or to ■•>■'. 0!i ".n -...iri or’'.!.C!’.iw o ■■’••oo. w -t 0itu-ir.y IK 'ool ’uo : i v.>^,r.vln ■• _; u; :o lios’r*’ *’or vro-f'i-ty o’^rtf-r i -)r o\ ' . ^ «• ^Tia: c\irr<n ,nnr*. >j •'.r r. .la.i.or 3 • - ^ f,.i f.j'i -• -onr;<*ij*a*'t'^‘x’1'', '•IC' .TT^-.OOl* ici 5:U'..>n; a. - ‘ ** ^ ^ 'UT;^ ?an '-o }r^>m i:r- bov 'sho .'-,.0^ »rvo -iTo inv o-. 1 O'’* ,.f i • ;0 'Ivlvtac* ^. ro;r./ 0> '« ^?TClK> Vll*i *' f • • H :#• s . ♦. • mMmi\' >t. i •=1 VI ■.'■'•ri i w. ! .1 b fr ST^INlMd ^DEPi CENTENI Mrs. Don O'Rel 3928 Cherry A\ Mound, Minnesc Dear Mrs. 0'R< This Is • feeding and n the phone, th< feeding of ma' from our view| )(While feeding not cause pro from migratin' outbreaks and ■1 The pi ac cause problem This leads to We also public beache /The most obvi deposit. Thi boats and sar Regardir this is not r / Department o1 considered tc does not app1 mallards are I think yesterday. RMH:pmt *- STATE OF Ldepartment of natural resources CENTENNIAL OFFICE »UI10ING • ST. PAUL, MINNESOTA • 55155 January 7, 1977 ONR information (612) 296-6157 Mrs. Don O'Reilly 3928 Cherry Avenue Mound, Minnesota 55364 Dear Mrs. O'Reilly: Th<c In resDonse to vour phone call of January 6, regarding the feeding and raising of mallards on Lake Minnetonka. As Mir:.”™™" .... outbreaks and actual freezing into the ice# boats and sandy beaches as loafing sites. I think this summarizes the comments I made yesterday. If you have any additional questions, please call Yours truly, ■) ROGER HOLMES, Chief Section of Wildlife RMH: pmt AN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY EMPLOYER • -/m; A ^ ♦ i- 1^ ««■ •■ iin UNIVERSITY OF MINNESOTA Department of h'nlomology, fistienes. aruj V(/ii J!ify TWIN CITIES St. Paul. Minnesota 55101 January 7, 1977 Orono Village Council Orono, MN Dear Council; Mrs. Donald O'Reilly contacted me on 6 January 1977 and asked for my opinion on waterfowl concentrations and artificial feeding. As I understand t, your village has had some difficulty with a specific population of ducks First let me briefly describe my background and experiences with waterfowl. am an Assistant Professor of Wildlife Ecology/Management In the Department of Entomology, Fisheries and Wildlife at the University of Minnesota. 1 have both a M.S. and Ph.D. in Wildlife Ecology and have been engaged in waterfowl research for the past 10 years. For the past 4 winters. Graduate student Mike Johnson and I have surveyed wintering waterfowl in the Twin Cities ^fetropoiitan Area, and conducted studies of the winter ecology of waterfwl populations. The results of these activities are now being prepared for publlrafiyn o -- - - - - - - - - - - - 8 preparea Your probUm. described to me by Mrs. O’Reilly, Is fairly common In Che TVln Cities. When mallard ducks and to a lesser extent Canada geese have a Murce of open water and food, they chose to winter here rather than migrate. These winter waterfwl concentratlons—there are at least 37 in the Metropolitan area--provlde our citizens the opportunity to view the colorful birds V at close range. However, when the concentration occurs in the backyards pain'^^'^*^^ howee what may be one person's pride becomes his or her neighbors between neighbors is complex, the problem of :h%r:t*r ;:nh^ Bay where private homes do not border the open water. -ayzaca /My recommendations for ordinances regarding waterfowl are: 1.To prohibit the artificial feeding of waterfowl from 1 November to 1 April except where allowed by special permit. 2.To prohibit the maintenance of open waters specifically for ducks geese and swans except where allowed hy special permit. "III iiiiiiiMiiiiliiiisaeaiaMII^^Mia ■ - brontf'Village i 'January 7, 197 Page Two These regulatl where no or on from attractln; neighbors. If you have qui Sincerely youri W A.Jailed A. Coop^ Assistant Profi JAC/sjr cc: C. Madsen, R. Johnson. 1^: - :N bron(t village Council *January 7, 1977 Page Two These regulations would allow the flexabllity to permit feeding at locations where no or only one private owner Is Involved, yet prohibit an Individual from attracting a 1000 or so birds to his/her backyard and those of the neighbors. If you have questions or wish further details, please contact me at 373-1722. Sincerely yours. James A.Coopu^:._ _ _' Assistant Professor JAC/sjr cc: C. Madsen, U.S.F. & W.S. R. Johnson, Minnesota DNR . •'4' iii S * , ^cations ridual ;he 173-1722. niir ) *' ••.» I iiwi •»,.■ .n-- \ 9\- January 31• 1977 Orono City Council Crystal Bay Box 66 Minnesota 55323 \/A, Dear City Councili We wish to call to your attention the public "“j*®"®* ducks and aeese have become on Crystal Bay. to the fact that Mr. Lloyd Nehrin^. 1972 Shadywood Road. Wayzata. Mn., has been providing them with food and also keeping the ice open for them for J-®®^ nollution^’ Each year the flock increases and also the pollution. We have had swimmers itch and sore throats water. It is almost impossible to keep our dock, dock seats, and boat clean due to the duck droppings. We feel it is wronsc for one person to be allowed the privilege of feeding the ducks and geese to the extent lent to a great deal of raw sewage going into the lake each day. This must surely have an effect on the fish also* We request that the Council take action to prevent Mr. Nehring from maintaining the the ducks and protect the health of the residents of our area. VerV truly.) ^ d '-fl ^ . /I /-S ‘ Harold W. Johnson Dorothy V. Johnson 2056 Shadywood Road Wayzata, Minnesota / ’ -y / ' 55391 ■fO IS ff 3 j V C.J HB I VILLAGE OF OROMO 4^ v-i! fei 1 ■•■11 Januar; Orono Crysta Minnes Dear C As a c wish t to sto from s a bubt The ek causir as boa imposs (insic is im; My fri sore 1 on Crj years is all own s< use t) le e I P [| rp r—>2 51 •'T ; n ■ ii Vi . ' Of ORONC - » • • t* January 31* 1977 Orono City Council Crystal Bay Box 66 Minnesota 55323 Dear Councili As a concerned citizen and a resident ol crystal wish to request that the Orono City Council take action to stop Mr? Lloyd Nehrin?, 1972 Shadywood frofsSppl^in-- the ducks and ^eese with food and providing a bubbler to keep the ice open. (inside and outside). The excrements leave a stain that is impossible to remove. Enii;rs!rJ?« S';.,;:..":"/!:: use the lake. Yours truly, ✓ jt. ! A - y' A ■ Stephen R. Johnson 20^6 Shadywood Road Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 i- \ } i‘ •I 4 . VIlLAOa L•:^v■‘{^0 I. M' I 1 4^ I- . . 6V Ir r. ill Itl-if r:,£- Mi ft2\: -'i fill f-' . a. ». - «%• • i J anuary Orono Ci Crjrstal Minnesot Dear Cou The duck years on For this 1972 She providir the duck and it i like to the duck I have c the lake become a Please 1 becommir for reel pollutec .!/n. in£T only r such ft alation ist few rinsr 7 his ant to r- * • . ,fc \ ‘{t ■ rii ; ■•. • I f 4 •ii. r ii 1- * 4. « January 31» 1977 Orono City Council Crystal Bay Minnesota 553^3 Dear Councils The duck population has increased so rapidly the last few 1972 Shadywood Road, Wayzata, Minn., be prohibited from providlnf^ food for them the year around. It is unkind to the ducks to keep them here in the cold Minnesota winters and it is ruining the lake for the human population who like to swim etc. in the summertime. The excrements from the ducks on the dock and in the boat has become neuseatine. I have contracted swimmers itch and sore throats from usinc the lake to swim and ski. The excrements in the lake have become a health hazzard. Please take the proper action to keep Crystal Bay from becommin^ so polluted that the human race cannot use it for recreational purpose and also so it will remain un polluted and beautiful always. Sincerely, Wendy Lynn Johnson 2056 Shadywood Road Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 r''\ fn'ft: r 7/MV i n'Xoj '' ..y i=.i [1!n • : u VILLAGE Of. ORONO % f 7 t p ur qt ta dr 8a thi ini afr mmm ew Laance . Lnff » n to iTB ) rom iiaing ^sve rn- ft; r ?/? f'l..■' -7 i=;i P Orono, Minnesota 30 January, 1977 Orono Village Council Orono, Minnesota Hear Council, la.e fit rioe. „r an. ,aasa at hi. He la O 1 ‘•Hrouohout the year.applying the ducks ujith Food x nr^ the lake ooen. ,h k nr«-«<1inQ a bubbler to keep pen, thereby, causing ever incroa^inn r. k to remain in the i™,aoiata area on a ^Ih. .. ^ ® veer around hasla. creetin, ^llTo"rlnllll ^ “> - the eater in »Hichl I:!?:; r::;—» ^ U Has reached the point ehere they are - I: thri:: ;:; nuisance and most likely a health « safVtv fai ’ ” The number of cases of . ^ (slippery docks) haiard. problem over the iae»f ®, ' s t ten or more years uhen eo did not heue '’*Te*"IorgTl»o"°“"'’’ nopulatioo. unusable to theT^nt'’" ‘’7'”’'""* ''irtuaJly quit putting them in at all In so token out or the eater t e ‘-> -troopings, .a had to gi e ooilboat because the '"'t tt-ot it eas impossible to keep them clean. insure that^tl^ “tl-’" to •-cted area is pr;;::."^ SincereJy yours, T- c. c X. • (.. Wrs. Joan L. Carlson 2080 Shadywood Road U/ayzata, Winn. 5fi39i * > ..% mmm f Minnesota r>unry, 1977 6/ inn, 55391 ^ at his » yoar. * to keep ducks area is roppinqs ^d boats, s t •• a 0 h8^a^d• latior % 2064 Shadywood Rd* Wayzata, Wn. 55391 3anuary 31, 1977 Orono Village Council Oronof Minnesota £mBJT \/ Dear Councils b.c j;:g"*jrco™:rne2^r/H“frflbck of enromolv larg, our area of Crystal^.! T '""“"‘rated in bohrina. Of 1972 Shadyiioi Rd Strata ’’* "alntainlng the ducka for years .ith'^fnJJ'’” *’** ‘“®" until the flock has qro«n ao ^nLi “‘"‘"r. b«Jo«a a continuing public nuisa^“ ’' property damage, a^Thaalth j: four neighbors. hazard to us and to for too large front nearly impossible ?o keep Sn.''our dock, our swim raff ^ clean. They roost on Of droppings uLe b^h?„n oway daily. The rit.« i have to be scrubbed the dock and the warnish^and*c*aM Point on Ute bought new cushions and boat. covors for our boat canopy to trv*to‘d *™* from making a complete mess of the boal!'"""^® f become a year-rouM^Dol**rf'*”'*'* *’“* “‘®® of dropcings depomw da!?, h^fn*"' ImmadiM. area ««*?» ! *' ‘'’® "®'"» ‘b® action to protect*^the^h^”?*i appropriateOf the Paop^elrtrafrt^^^ Sincerely, U f'. Utn Neil Re Blesi • ) ; r. nu*'..--::■ -x ^Ir" ;._j S i: i 4 • <■»% V Hrse Jot 2080 Shi Wayzata, Dear Mri Thank y harbor! the use due to ever, r have an Mlnnetoi have a < Of mor K dltlon Becausi adult : latlon the oui the In- aulfatc permltt respect Due to ' affected toxic to as a sol a wild p nuisance Regie ^me/r 1/ . '1 :l ' -'J yt v: . i - 7 i mmy• kik! imm^€^ m a y. :f •'■■• .., , >;-L -i-i^ Sr'-j'-'' » 4r4 ''•wescta PoMion Control y^oency (612) 296-7256 January 26, 1977 Mrs. Joan L. Carlson 2080 Shadyvood Road Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 EmBf 7 (A/ Dear Mrs. Carlson: Thank you for your letter of January 21 197 tarboring a flock of either done“u and/or i ] the use of aeration devices. There Is no douhf * Minnetonka through due to the harboring of ducks In rtls coLfn^^^^'““““°'' »°»e degrM ever, relatively small numbers of ducks and their'*/'®® 1 ’' '’® “''"ring. Ho»- have an Insignificant Impact on th/overa?? "®®f““''« excretions would '' ^®^*® '<»«»«etL^rff^at«fo„rf^^ ?f “®y« >•-''« short term negative Impact with respect to water ”aUty ®'® X dft“n* f«ortog^rte occuJrence of /i'"® eon- Because waterfowl are one of the ^ dermatitis (swimmer’s itch). tault form of shlstosom“. thf^ZrJn: oTa H®® ‘"“i' ®®"® ®® ® *»®‘ ‘he lation of waterfowl in a littoral zone of « « non-domestic popu- the outbreak of this follicular Lrmatltis! anif Stage host, can be accomolisharf rh ° snail, which becomessulfate treatments in the affectarf L! through the use of cooper permitted and in compliance with Denari* ‘=*'s®ical treatments must be respect to the control o?“gHatlc ^Sisa:::,'/' '*®®°“"®®® °®'*®" ' ^f«ted''':rea“o‘^\®:r tas“t“n"^Us‘'*^® ‘®®®‘"®« to an toxic to aquatic species, the Agencv staff*^/?/.'/' “PPer compounds aretoxic to aquatic species, the Agencv staff ^ copper compounds aic as a solution to this problem *Ratha/?5^ Pt™ote this measure a wild population of waterfowl could be Ln/ ?, “S"®®' *''** “*® tarboring of nuisance and heilth related effects a/w!?? “/ P®®''®"‘ f*® cause Ifeffects as well as the degree of pollution Impact. Regional “'""esofa 55113 ''•-tas.e,/ .. "1'ff* ii tf i Ml •-'/ f ••«<1 r, ♦ W *' ''iIs »> Mrs. Jo Page 2 January Ml 'A.. Please '.A'; •> I JGS:lib cc; Mr , .-V - *:■.:■'iV, igency loyd Nehrlng netonka through to 8one degree irring. How- :lons would ‘1 Bay, Lake waters do on of con— 8 Itch). Bt for the tic popu- to promote »hich becomes f copper must be lers with tc an nds are asure orlng of use of t>n Impact. mm* %n Mrs. Joan L. Carlson Page 2 January 26, 1977 Please feel free to contact us if we can be of further help. Sincerely, (IJoel G. Schilling Lake Studies Unit Section of Surface & Groundwaters Division of Water Quality JGS:llb cc: Nr. Howard Krosch - MDNR / • V- ir^ 1M K.p-1 s V •' ♦ ' '7^/1 • ^ r A- t.-v7 f ^c. mdwaters . % .5 ■' “'i' '* '■ ’ ) / '//■ ' ■ /C/. t t <. ii. C^' C/'V -C u: A I •(: %' . t"*- / /J /l CL^^s^h .jc t y •^~‘- V /tj, t‘L '^-^.i-.^\,'L. J: C J /C'^rr^ tj, t cl C.- \.^ • .,-^*^-<—t^ ^j ^' ' y y ' . . . . ~yr)^. -c .,f > 4 ■ ' / J ^'C^.jL.^7 i V- / ^ /l C^.^/ ~< <<- <:l. «•<. < (7 (f^LC 1 *f." /; (/- V A- c C a . "/ u < > <</c /u /■'■' n ¥ ' > /^. /k* <-•' I- 7 .-■^r Ci./ T" 7 d QL <* ^ tK W*'V>.^-» V 7... "'r^ ■ C4--0-^ V V-'C.*?. ’V /I. .Til /u'- C^ ..c Vc Uw* • . c. 7-/ iy , ♦ . c fyy^ -7 V i.< ^ ^'''4- * / 7 <' y i: X - / -»~7^t' ,.( X i 4 (' i ><• '<• •> Ao - < 4» A. <A-- <- c •■//7<..A -4P 7c. .C L T "‘4 C C i I. > — — —--^ t. • 1. -/-y'*'‘^ <» . 4 rt ^ ,, u C'L* .V y/)y-v-ryA^>.‘A .^4 -..u ./1> ®iraiTn Z iii’/ VILLAGE Of ORONO •>. \ FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: I*ve resean had some otl found in soi itfed as a SI it to the pi \y \J^'.v.. TO: -* ’Planning Commission and Council FROM: DATE: Hank Miihich, Zoning Administrator February 3, 1977 SUBJECT: Delayed Followup on Duck Problem - 3908 Cherry Av’enue I w researched the subject property further and discovered that this location had sons other problems in the past. I am enclosing copies of the documents found in some old files. The dates do confirm that this shoreline has been med as a swiimiing area at least since 1968. If i find any more, I will add It to the packet. •. r u Wi -i * * mimm mi ms l.i Si*.- ' JJ-Viv; ir.-' N-“ si':.- '- ■ r1 ■ JS-V;*QB * j I ‘ • . ■ . ,4*. - I .^4 ’ ; V / v-^i' ! t 1» Hi s /V ^ I-•'-k'''’-' ■'■.••• To: Adn FTom: C He s Par Date: J "^.-A • ■>• .-i" LLvi''-..' V ‘ . *i\ y In check up with ? .•1’/ ‘ ■ • Che "no Che no ••' “k Map "no f: b * ;\ ' y.i: * .* iT'.’f ■‘•v* A-;^' • **•■ ' «• I believ problem V' [^V •y-’-.A.- hi A f . •’V** ^ . i :, -A-ir" ■.- *r ,.■•*■ ■» -i ■ '**>**• *7 ' ■ a' .- ,. >• •*' .•■ ' > • , \ |r >\ ■• > 'S'VJ* V, ■•*. A , -A.'': ; .‘Aij; V.“K, V'AAt W, .*.’4.'•*•.•■ .-i.•« Vk’.*'' .i .u ‘ wr>«Ata ■ ■: •' v-'*. Kration tents ►een . add ' ^ •• *■ #*' 4 •V ’'" '\1‘'^ ' . Vr i ♦ ‘.J. ■ • *#., • JV # ■'>:■-:. \; V \ I h . it':/; To: Administrator From: Chief of Police He: Harking on Cherry Avenue & Maple Place Sate: July 22, 1968 ’ r ' ' T/rV^ • In checking over this area for parking problems, I have come /X-; XLp with the following recommendations: i • *! *. » ■ • ‘ » ,2 ' ' • - I -• 'v •; Cherry Avenue west of Maple Place should be posted **no parking** on both sides of the roade I*-..:'M'■ • • Cherry Avdxnie east of Maple Place should be posted **no parking" on the north side of the road* 'V : 4 Maple Place south of Cherry^Avenue should be posted **no parking** on the west side of the road* •: •• t believe posting it in this manner would take care of the problem in this area* f f n.i • 4 */ N vH i i-1. •'/ .'tv* I f- ♦ ; ‘ r J », -.1^ •■ : .' -fi/ .y ^ A **♦ ’ • t 4.r • »* JjtvVjvA' ; ;n*. * ‘ * • y't A ' • ' J Gerald boss ..*.'.X' V • • i . * VA r.*.'•• .4".. ♦“ . <■ \. a * t • V II ’ Jf.- Si-’., mj§ i >• « •i« The Regular Park Commis Hall on Jul The foiUwi Messrs. Dor Mrs* Lehman T’le Meeting tuur of the to the Mapl Golf Course aUry \acat Kcei e Avenui Appro /•*<! va< Oicken*fv*n S - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -f Hcron"*.tnded signs >n Mai f urf ew. It is rccomi be given foi come the ' rm , r-avvf^-^; ■* '• w'-l TK i In•SE^J • 1 ^ ^ 1 A it^- ■:,K^ 'F>- r > iv'-as-^i • -• *-'^f \ 1J2. #*^ jm». .? ,; /^- .V * *. *♦’. i V * ... -*"':i‘?:^ '“j. - '. ? .U'.. . • *. ,- . j'; < ^ ' *4 ; . Jyjp V’ V •■ V. . ■ i%‘f X- i '.*■: n. ;v".': V 19 t' f..' : -V >. ^ • L. ■ ^'• >>' r '” n ft •<* .'»^i*IRONO PARK COf.tfqsSlON The Rei{ular Monthly Meotinc of the Orono Park Commission was held at the Village Hall on July 17, 1968 The £oiUwim; r'embers were present* Messrs. Oorrul, Mix**, Otto, and White. Mrs. Lehman and Dr. PanusKj absent. The Meeting consisted of an inspection tour of the swimming beach and lake access to the ^laple Avenue Beach, the Orono Golf Course, and the site of the proposed alloy vacation at Russell Avenue and Kcei e Avenue. Appro/<‘<! vacation of the Alley nf Oicken«!v'n Street. r 4. Hecon’ntnded placement of "No Parking" signs in Maple Av*****? access area and a urfew. It is recommended that serious consideration be given for a new golf course club house. ’ \ 8:00 V. f\ CALL TO ORJER ALLEY V.ACATION MAPLE AVENUE GOLF COURSE CLUB HOUS; Respectfully submittov Heinz J. Ottc Secretary m ■•If * •' *TOi Vlll;’.(;c rmgordi Qentlfln I have been behalf. As IIP. basic ::rlncl 2 Uve on til had some of Tba retltlon general c<r. a: Point iw It in Ta place i’n end rriv rt-ht I’o rectdor.t to tlie rl drimro:.' ba".;x:nc • -.ro: orty even ro. wo ’l' nc Ihc lil 'll Iwt t!i' (6 reel .Iti. the for the Part rrric!er.t I b;^*. he o: t’li.- 13 it in o ' 1. i:: OR.^ER CATION . N I r lOt • I # • •VUlapo of Oromn»(?rreing a petition to be ottbnlttod at tl-.o :^tlng of the Council thi e] -’ * •* * • Oentlcmon: I bAve boon asked hf the slcnere of thlr; ctitiun to act as e;iOk©aian in Iheir behalf. As a noe resident of their nelr^'horhood, I at first r€liict?ijt to bewtio InvlTod. Bat, after hearing the naiv/ con:»laints, aia^ a*grooliw: with the basic ;rii»ciplo involvod^ I decided to asolst in aiy way posslblo. I^y idfo ant- I llWon the property I'mdlately Bant of the aoeuns la ——'*—< "*»*• had none of these problens set forth in the petatlon. fbe T«titlon is not really as elaborate as It ehoul;’ be, so I*ro jreparod oone general covsxnits on the joints nentlonod In Iti point mnber one donls with the general disturbance caused by this access. It in our feeling the the nlu!lo of a i«sldonlial area is f»t the ;:ropor place f nr a Pablie iloaeh. Owners of iTlvatc iTpoporty have*TKn riflrt to pc-'co rnA rrivaey, and the Villas of Crono has the resi«nsi)>ility to nroteot that right i*c;thcr than to ds2rtro.^r it hy ''j.^^ninr- a iub'ic Iteach. Tl'e lf..ct t>»' t residents ar f:!.r ns tr.io b}oc!cs a..*sy bavo signed tliin rotition is to.iti?r>ny to tlie flc:ree of miscnco that cyi -.ts fpo**^ nolne ♦•»lono. flie oti’ects and drlwraj's in tV o area rro oct>r i 'r.ontl./ bloeko •: tr/- care parkec' ’.ihorovor it ha".'x;nr. to be convoniont. Per u ilk and rl-le blc/cljos across ririv.te .roiorty \d.th no rogard for V rights of the <:wner. T^ieoe ncople r.rc not evon rn. idonts c.x tiK area, bu’ cone ftr>n ao v> dlnta nen to use the ‘censs. 'It.an, ’r. one i.'ci.lent ;:horr; a v:\ rd light 'rnri 1>rokr.n Ir; jwl r^ers :»o that the:* •1 ’ not tjothci'cd \r/ the li- ht. The hl h tax levels ;rovalc-.l In lliio ainoa w.r .u’ indicr.to high ;.roj orty v?il»iec, Iwt the codstence of this *\ihlic Aecoso ha;-, a.c: had tho of foot cf '*e.ro-si:.: ’>rcoorty values and ifoulU Tia.-co it ^^iificult to riarkct .TO»ei*ty in tVr- '*rea. .it foel that ti:o ViH''.;:e h*is no: hoc Lot) to :;i*ov ’..;'c t)io j'O'j v’cnts zT this the facilities, rogulntlon-T. .•»nd eaforccnont tl:at should’* lie • ;u;d-.tor for the activities a!P-cr.;od by -bo Village. Part t%*o of tl'O :'otltl'*n do.* Is ;Uh. tliO Deodod right to access that riajv roriderts '..'cre lot’ to bclloYo a::i-lcHji ;:Vcr. IW ' 'nrch.vjed t. clr ro* <', t/. I )vf*. >o.-iod tliat tliO invorti ■'ti)!: f tlvVo A w Ijc CO iete o ' ueetiu-', Ixil as yot ’;t' ^'o not Iv.ve '•H of ..l:o -biforr.-'tlon. Ar 'oon '13 it is corr^leto, *»c irif':.li.o ’^i.Tl'vc e*' -iVio cxi:jto;icc or n-oo-ind-oto'co o*' 1. it: rirl.t. H’!C t!. fart 01* t!ic petition 1 *’S Jo o ti;c •vltKiwiC'/ •uni rojpil ti:»n <^f t'f.ls :\roa as n ’.ub'ic '-..’iir v. - h -Uitel, -'idUi of Ihl:: .•irea Ir f'O foot, 3o:;3 th-’t ^JO foci of it .-u-o ui-> I - b ct.i:;..-: of n dratnago -‘i.eh r.7oY)f: ono ::iOe. 7 I *, cenn.-'t l>.' ha-o .-»!o *v'.r ler the .'wio'.int cf eci 11 *t t:as 'loco there. - iPT:?r.r^-x::mm 4,l! V* . • ■ . &S&1 the urea in not sipervlsed exoept when sninnlnf; lr;asons ore ;;lven. If it is tfitendeii to be » Pttbllc Haadii es it in bcirv' used, then it elimilc! bnvo tlic fheUlties atd naperrlsion that othor iXiblie t^aehon rust Theso 10 ineliide tho fsHo^rlnf t 1, A reaflo»ble oi»ni!:g tii» in tho ncimn/*. has 3t*>ii;od ;r; oar 3. 'Lr? ^:00 A.K* In this area* a3ont; ^lith its Inevitable aol':c. 2* A reasonable closinif tiJ» In the ovenlnf. times tho jioino *rr.^ activity has ooiitimed untl3 tho oarly :»rriln,<? hv>urs* 3*Cr.^erieneed eapervislon durln;: evoxy hour the beach is o^jen. T!iln ir intended to Uoep the peace* and rroteet tho livoj of those usin' the boaeh. 4*Frcner 5artJ.tation faellitioo* 'ilds does not only r»,in ^coe"/irir the area clean, but also rteane adcc'ui.to toilet frcilitiea for U\o users. Irivato business of nost tyxis are rer|uired i::Qr las' to x^novide tlieso facllltioa, and ue do not ttilh^ t)ie V131.\:o slionld <x« an exception. There h.-v/e ^oon occasions uhon the residents h:.ve beon as!;o<! by ohilcUtni to uao t)\e hathroott. 5.Adecuate off •street parkinc;. Private huainoesos are rec^irod by lob* to provide off •street pyoportionato to Uie ex.x^eted tr:\ffiet and MB do not the ViUar^e should bo an excovtion, Tho roads ard driwrays are virtually bloclc^ to noxmal trrfnc flotr wlion t3:ls area* is in use. It is vor/ obvious that tlie a rca in r^iestion is not adoou^ito arv3 never /ill be adecuate for the aetivitlos conductet* thore. *n»e •'rca hr*.s not been oontrollod, and ir bcoorAnfj rx>i« lun^or! trolled ever/ year. 4,Tlio fewrth point I'as to do ’.rith the efforts of Uie ViD-j 'o tc provide the necenr^ciy faeilitiori for a IMblic loach. I*m ::ure tho voters did not Initiate the idea that Crono purchase and operate a ?u!.;lie Golx* Coui*oo. Thexeforo, in its apparent concern to provide pulilic recreational facilities for tiie reellests of Orono, wo suc'^.cst the the Villaf^ initiate proceor-iri/^s to find an aderaato Puhlie Dcachi ono t* at is not a c;>r:8tant cause for con laiet and n:U.sanee to the residonln of the area. 5.Port nun-jcr five of t’lis petition rentions May as beinj* Cleon«Up I'ofith. 'ie think that this is an exee31er.t idea# and feel tliat tho Village co«?.d have set a noro inspirat .onal. oxr..nj:.2.c by clcanln,:: up :inc3 beauttiytnc its lublic riecch. This MC‘1 not done, hoifever, and v/hon it bocaro unbearable for ricarby x'Q'jidonts, it fell c*n their nhoiildero to do so.net ’. dnij. llvl-a is vhat t?^ey vild: They plantod Tr.rnac (iKiss aXonp one side to co'.»er up a noddy an ’ rutty M)l;jk’o; they buried retting flsli throi.n on tlie ippoixn * \xs fishemon to p.ot i-ld of tho spiells t!xsy out nnt* voisoned tl)e i -raiy clun-. r* of ;oison l-.y ir*i: on th*' axea; they plc’ted up tra.f)h' *' ■*. r r. either t'ur?i/n the crcuric’ <;r 0'/crr’/R»tng,. from une-;ptled trash barrels. T ir. uas « .-.l.''rt, '.j\t there .arc sons t‘fl‘v:s that K:-/■ . ^ ■ ii ' ll ‘. i - it the rcsii'ei'.ti the drainsre uvipeeraiiec • ; pools . .*nd \ Susnaty: in-'..# Xn eonelusioi net voiced only \ be ei*5!ii*h for a vl-lurJa* itspre.-^w this ’icirr res tiny area tb '.t i: that use t!ie sect .1- / ^ Hie area in < It is ni>t S-; It t3 fi !Ub? ; It i.v a cx-'^ept 05'. It l3 not I::; The ym-ape : xUt^latio; the rosi ’ent it is not CJ am the situation i attenpt to «*alnt oan only get '.;cr legal aupoT.-lato' Been tho Vlllae:a of the iiartieula: residents havo a pursue and finr' beoone s'acb sn v. coanlderation to to the ;:eneral p be alloi/ed tc \\r- nei-Wiorhoo* ‘ : eo and the a-;ce s *.* \ ' » tnrim is c IC. r oai ’l*' n 1! tho lo /im iTivato lti03• VS '<oon Jie lai ie, A and crna- 13 be nod. the not .nwi" r COT lalet havo set I r«ceh« e'iidonts, her/ Ji«*e; of tho rr’/«*ing.. i ’V:3 hh?.t > \ • t. »T JUtl ,1 /5I . r '■• r H;.': y HIM ..■■ :.» Il V lUXv MW VU».w JL^ ^—.------------------- A lliet tioe tl^ sccess» anti the;'' hr.vo si^^nod In XUIX cn^w .odrje of \.)»,7t it « •jrs. -V-M f'/ iif Hk! area 5.n qae tion is not oafo for rntXmin^ Jjoc'ju.jo of Incdo-'raito Tu xji-violor. It Is not o^fo boccjise of ;*oor s-nitrry oonclittojuj. It l3 a !\ib?lc Kalcm>ce \rx»aao of u^.cens noise :uid activity. It is a ?\Jblic Hiis-nco bocaure thc:n is no pL'soe for ooonle to ptr*'; their oars cxrspt i'n the otreot and in rrivntc drivways. It is l:j?gc enott-^h Tor the x'r of pcoplo t'.-it use It. The 7ln^l:c h&s nade HtUe atierpt to rer'slatc tho aroa or to c-nforeo trie copulations tltr.t r.***' ojCist. , *1, x the rosi’ente of tho -.xoa ;ni:v.ld r.ot be eqjoctod to heap u>: thi.*: access ::o .hat it is not an eyesore In the ncirh'jorhooJ. f? ' • ‘ . .-.m the situation is out of eo:itrol, evor; for the unfortu * .te i'ounn rooplo rvAlce ari rtttnrt to raint?ln order ’./hllc .tivin' swijrdr\<; lesc*.:>s. Tlrls uncontroll'Ki vitii «: aan only get ’.;orse. Aij tho -.rord sprcr<^s * ;it>nc those ioo>.inn for a place free ^ron legal yuxJor*'lston or onforcoficntf *ic can soo untold pi'cblocts aheod. V . ■ Svwi tho Villa^:® Cffleers c'uuiot soon tc acroo on the o n'rsV.ii: or roc^icnsi'^lllty of the ;>articular parcel of rround. I it a I^lro l.-no or is it nott Do so o trsa wsidonts hnvo access rlifr.ts or do th8y not'/ tTieso ai-o ouc'^lons t!mt •«> l;»tonC to pniigii0 and finc^ **jm5wors to. There is so r:iich conAisior. around tho access aiv! ▲t Vios heeorg :Tach sn unbe.rirablc nulscnce thr.t we are aslrln" the oouncil to give V'.-ny s^^rljus eoaalderatton to our pot:ltion. Tho - nli' solution wc can acceiit is that it Ikj clo.-.od to the nonoral public, clOwU'-.l for r..i:.Trlnr: les.vjns, ;aid th.^t tho ir!n£3dl''.te reside*.ts bo aUoi'i ’cd tc use It for t’.C'.r bouts and cV *'r lalcosi ;o activi-tlcn. At least tho noi-hborhoo*’ poople anjl- have soisw cnnsldoration for our ricJits to rx5.ucc -n' rivacy, and the aone r :.’o*ild arr-'in iK'cono a ;'}“'/i.xt place 'ci* 0.1 cuncemod. ■•<1. ^ ./ / / • *-.1 '< »/ Ji fj /.. 4.. * 4L.I i .. * • •. .;2r.«■m > ' t t i * i::'.w. : •xi. * 9* ; • f * \ i 1I ' .*?'V : '■ y i ■ fy. iAy f^r P' hr :x ^ V V 1 r V 4 > :/■'I'-X w>il •:i,- i L '■■■.ff . r I 1 JI-. ■> vX; # i /o / ■ / \\ /•? Hh il lar*. r :n b.T-'T 51 ?.alnt is !in ..'O'jlI/* . Ijx'i- •Crttc ♦hat L-ilvoly chiWpon s. xiiVi'Aor, lOlr cars tl-ic n ::o that PJ4 u tion rec f rofn I V JL lUV 0 o i.'itsne to it has V' i7 r.'^ri'MS !x*5 clo..od 1 rcstflo -.tr: fa.;t tho •nr' rlvncy. .1 . f \. • ♦ ■ t ■^F■' % ■f '1*. :•/ \ % K t \ f i I : IX i S ts • \ •i % ‘ < / i\ . < ipT I —r T' ;rv I I ^is tV 'AI ^ k ■ 1 m F>:' / !1 ^?v k Hr ii ? .• , i.; f . > r .'"v ♦ * • » ‘2'd!X/7V / ^ / /■' • ^ “■‘ I r ^-1/ 1 ri C< T r. If. >9 B X . r v y H e t Lt .V' .•* - t ll..-'-A^ > / * ✓ / -----C'l-iC*/'\'U •Sy' 1.^ / ‘J /i / i ' A • • I •.♦< ( ‘i. /^•; .. ( .7); Ct'ii4rJ'' Lc-U u/ \ r,. • / « r- r: ,r . A i ;‘-t B f* V i ..< V' ■i-Ar'n V-. 'rC'*'<91 4 . • .*, . _*• Ir t » *..., ■ MS I- ■ -♦J ’ -r >7 V# »#. '•■<10 Mf ^ .* '/■ A f ^ I V' irt t- J>i .*• I -X 2 ’ w':' •• J •3' 3 H'. Cl I 7 i '/ : I'- 7 ^ UT’^iu 7 ,/ •i I / I •* , 1 P* y >- , .• . ■* ■a- Ml » f « I 7 ‘ I; ■ M ‘ :’’;M r- d "f ■i- r U » .. : [ i I f ru ^ • ;r :r . j ■’^ i >y *1^1 t " >* 1 V^ L> ' V f JT T -i • >> • t * V. ).*. # 1 .. lA C-• /* ' * • .N ' ^ 1 >■ t s-c" .vM- ,. "P /:>[ •jk !> »/ w ■) 'V** / ”'.j ,/ f.y •^^■/' ' . •/ . ‘'V-'',A- r.l'V/7>Y *' • r . • -'•<>' ^ I / '^ •• ■' I - 1 ^7 ci / *?/(A i cci Ot / v<^ V' /.. ’^<?G V-01-.xjL^^a { . ./>»*• ■/^.^€'^- •- i."''/,.< -;4 / •' ^ r , ✓ ('. Y « ^►r’-^o'Vj *. ? • . fUi., ^ ‘•’ /.MV ^-y.. • ^V 1 ‘/ /y 7. / i / / ••Uj*J^Oci'r^^ /:■' " ' K ';. j; c /* / ' * j / /.‘Jx f-A / J J>//■V' ;#■•• /I'M^ <'/‘l-f /^/vti trs^«x. ^ V^f Q/)A 5/- t fc.l<:*A1 *3 ‘ / /^LA' /• ^' . X. ♦ # ( , ( , t) .V ^ 70 « f * / / ^ '. ■: ■'•<: ^ / / / M’. j9-U('7 rlvt/- > : '.. 'l4 MArt.■I ^1'-/ - ' / ^ f I il J < rj Ocy^- *'f'-^yuiyxy■it rnmuammamsm. * * 'h f . I 53-'' ■c ■■*, .i'-'i-: : i*. I . '^1 <}^^iw mmm '% •A ^=•>1O-' ;. \JLl * i •p '•^.s ;-^:3 •«1 ->=*-r ■•* m is. ^ ■*» • 4 \ ♦ *** s *«W .• «•• I.1J »• m:i li •*’ tM #: 'i » • • 1^' [«•* «» . '^i **•«». ^4? r ' At'•'•'/fcs.j r^j t/ ^ %;f Vx tl> >'T'L. ■ I ^ • ••’ >)^y s/:-s/y'^- ^v^ ?Al. 7/<At', li'U',:/t‘ ^ 4: o DC cif\L f «. .« cHr .'/ '//. ^ l^i^j2/^-rt\d jti A (lO «y.v c*- \\va-. fecsv. ^>Vt',.X ^'7' m-i(li*,j! ■/S-I V. s t SU • - ? . f t *'*ir ■?v* —NilIII «r» w fi#U t< tom alBo •FM to 1 W» OTO pi ••rtaln x ma to the PubUe, block it to autoMbllo traffic,,and wiforoo Its •. .' tfboro protMtii^ ^ public use of this aroa on iho grounds that it has donrlaad iiasir-s^iir; sarX«.%&sia.sssiir“. ' i r pretest is based on the foUoMLngt - . v* jJJ® attau^.it'jpg to entertain chests, the noise and aotlvUgr dostroy ansr ^4?!^ Pritato^pe^aJl^at tolK. J? area we are entitled to the sane degree of peaee andprivacy enjoyed by other residents of Lake 14innetonka. ^ Certain Pfjparty de^ in the area specifically grant lake access in this area, and the Village of Orono Is deiirlvlng then of tliia privUeee. * there ever will be a repilar lifeguard on duty evecy dav to nrovide this. ^ ^ provide an excellent Public Beach th Is i£t In a resltotial area if the Village of Orono can afford to purchase and operate a Public Golf Course. iwtosc #• ‘ ? aptM>.ar3nrufc shoxc by fishorsttn, and the general unkempt residents iranodiately adjacent to tfas Stei^^*^ JS ^ regularly since the yillage iis nade little ^/UXvi^ 1^- > ^^Jia fCo\ i/V-t. ^4'**’ ■‘I S.fi- ), r ♦ ‘ 4 r ✓m « '/■ 7^ucl^ 'rfLuuuM/ ^. 1.• !••4 t * I I. # ___4_ w m^^aU •mi V- -r-mm-, \ m >■ % />■H- •^,A; 4> A, * TO: FROM: DATE; SUBJE The P. fill . area : a pari We ha’ We ha’ inforr to a I and pj years. The b€ swimmj suinmei childi area. V/ '•** h .• Ub • -X; ’ Mf« MiiOMd losing* iM dtpilTid Biblie »• >37 hammd Ihe nolso i th« rMldrad peace and in this re ground. There is tion that e this* Eeadi that purchase 'Clean4lp (rest that lestion is ind» the . unkeqpt • to the b little oL i » 6md-> UM 0 ^ ■^v-. V 4 n f 2 V. ^ ' .• .--r 1*^f . n-"- i ? r: ;.:• rf^ Villaqo Council Dick Denson, Villaqe Administrator August 23, 1974 Cost Estimate *• Sandy Beach Area The Park Commission has requested a cost estimate to place a culvert, A gravel at the Sandy Beach swim area to provide a parking area for cars that use the beach area. The estimated cost to provide a parking area would be $1,295.00. We have received many calls from residents living in the area we have received input from the Planning Commission. All the information that has reached this office indicates a positive NO to a parking lot that would only generate more cars, people, and problems to a beach area that has become over crowded the past years. ^ The beach area is used by the Upper Tonka Council to provide swimming lessons to approximately 30-40 children during the summer months. One solution to the problem would be to bus the children to the beach rather than cars transporting to the 5 Augu< Dear Di The Par of the to the form a mately would 1 bea:h a We appr senedul DGOphel :e a culvert, I parking it to provide area. . the tive NO >le, the past ide he us the o the fm - - v " lU ' • n 5 August 1974 To:Dick Benson From:Park Comnlsslon Subject: Cost Estimate - S<indy Beach Parking Dear Dick: The Park Comnission requests that you provide us with an estimate of the cost to place a culvert in what is now the ditch adjacent to the fire lane road on Sandy Beach, fill over the culvert to form a parking area for angle parking from the road to approxi mately two-thirds of the way to the beach. At this point, we would like to locate a barrier and provide additional recreation/ bea:h area from the barrier to the current beach. We appreciate this estimate for the next meeting, which is currently scheduled for August 1974. DGOpheim:bjs J a..m. i ^% - • ' ^ . I- H:i?ort to: .>U'r'ir.g 197 Cfevelopmer Various c< Th3 fol l( u.'.i/or ui Hr.C;3£RR CnSCO PC HlC.iwAKl ’) J.tW Cl ChSCO mmm '. ■ ■ * *43 i . ViUage of Orono _., r\-'ii”i*v' «« Iht Sulll ’ March 6,1972 ..cbrt to: The Village Council, Planning Co„B.ission ar.d Park Coir^^nssion.and ParK uoi^inbi .. , OT OUUIWM -------------- Of additional Park lands.1. ACQUISITION. . . . . . 2. DEVELOPMENT......................existing2, DEVELOrWtNi............ 3 ’ ........................f^oUbrifUl^elit'trreSonar activities, etc. ia,5'aM.io™"'« »“ s“ rt,C".3£FtRV PARK for baseball, swings, etc. C:,SC0 POINT PARK ;‘rrS‘ u 'iS ««•*winter skating rink, is i p and graded. •:g..wAno park foot paths, trails, etc. ... ^ J.\\j golf course •n ho oaid off in full this year and The course ^ L a qood source of revenue in the future -^o^otion, have engaged a for the Village. assist the golf coun- '«le ’in"Lillizln9 recreational use and revenue. kSCO point circle Acquired during 1971 will^b^^^sed ':!fural°p?rygrrnd for children and residents .n the area. AjjITIONAL .-RiVATE FAC WIT.-ilN ORON Future plan ” . : .'iPK CO:T C.Vj Vlll p‘jc.ygrot ci--cis^on . c- increasi : exit /.'•,* no X, a 1 ^ i .'.u ;7oSt yea ruat deal rn:- Grono Pa 1. V . ».O':! and, ma' • .mmiw >f Orono K*KS PHONE 473-7357 in consnunUy 11age Council i ranging from *ecreational presently ov^ned led and seeded lent, backstop exceliant for s of being villed oped and used [ds a parking lot, this year and e of revenue ve engaged a e golf cor*«a“ and revenue. .-oTURE PLANS 4. •* .. ►j*v Sw:/;y,iNG BLAwiiLS r.A.\c>Y lii/u.jl: (ii.\ivy stnM..:er swiiiiiiring activity, ;iave nuw Crepcuu docks (purchased in 197i) ready to install this spring. Couid use a satelite. Kill.LY AV£. PHLASANi LAWN: good swiiniiiing area, could use a new dock. Crepeau proffered for safety, ease of ••lainlenance and appearance. CASCO POINT: new barrels installed last year, used for swiinii.il,g instruction quite a bit last year. CRYSTAL UAY: needs a swiinnjing platform if it is to be used, (not used last year) AjjITIONAL PUBLIC OR rkiVATE FACILITIES within ORONO GOLF COURSES: Wayzata, Woodhill a.id Lakeview. Wi.nter skiing i’acilities at Ski Tonka. BOAT LAUNCnlAO; public facility located on North Ann, .niaintained by he.i.iepin County. PLAY6R0U.N0: at Elizabeth Gardner grace school. FRENCH LAKE: possible use of sewer plane prc/erty in part for a coiiuiunity skating rink and open space. TRAILS: the possibility exists of using the Luce Line Railroaci right of way as a multiple use trail system. This could tie in with a County or State system and could be a great linear park. It is under study now. NEIGHMORHOOO PARKS: additional small parks ere needed in some area of tne Village. Example: Navarre, Eager ness Point, etc. These would be one acre sites to be used by tne children from inaiiedidte vicinity. RECREATIO.NAL PROGRAMS: winter skating, sliding and ski ing programs and facilities should be provicac. Sumner programs of swimming instruction, uoac^tc* uC.e fishing facilities should be considered. Many alliec. programs could and should be tied in with our Golf cc..rse funds and personnel. Maintenance equip.nent ci.ei st,.ff could be used through out the total Parks anc Recreatioinal program. .'*crK Coiumission is charged witn establishing a sound park and playgrou.'jo system tne Vi Hare of Orono. This job includes deteriiiining what type and mixture of parks playgrounds would best suit tlie present ano future resicents of tne ci_*cisions we make directly affect the quality of our lives arid the i.T.,joyi.;ent of .0 increasing number of recreational hours that each of us has to spoind. .*.ust exibit financial responsibility a.nC at the same time make recomendations that //. .1 not always be easy and will sometimes be controversial. T..e past year has been a fruitful and productive one in which we have accoruplished •: 'rcat deal. 7n:. Orono Park Commission O'rland, Chairman ' 0.1 ' \ % Or lla SUBJECT; Wi Sul Mr. Levering, back in Deceni 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. Sche< Notil Hold to C( Counc Ifai Planr Counc Counc Certi I also infoime 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Appli Fae C Preli List Porti I also explain 1. ^Vlar 2. Plat a. b. c. d. e. f. g- h. d ai n ei d: t( di c< Final a. a b. c. Ci Ci d. e. f. Ad Co Ce act wily, ;iave ^]) ready to install ¥.iing area, could 'or Safety, ease of last year, used for St year. orm if it is to be Lakeview. Winter T LAu.\CiiIi\u; public tained by Kennepin rdner grace school. plane prc/crty in P.d open space. sing the Luce Line use trail sysceir.. State system and under study now. 1 parks arc- needed e: Navarre, Fager- acre sites to be vicinity. pluygrcu.'io systen and rr.ixtcre of parks f wt *e c. i C.A. the *.T.^oyi.;e.it of spend. recomencations that ave accoa.pl i shed V. 4 r?- t| ( • I. / ng, sliding and ski- be proviuac. Sumner oacit-g u.ia fishing ny alliec. programs r Golf co..rse funds t ci.ei st..ff could be Q Recreational program. w -.V 'I ■is ■V 1 J'I * % r y*-% m ; • V. * . .n , i • . “S % ^• 1 < TO: A Opono Planning Comnission ■ikc FROM:Hank Muhich, Zoning Administrator ^ tVkTE:January 26, 1977 SUBJECT:William D. Levering - 275 Willow Drive Subdivision (Preliminary) 1. Pliblic Hearing for preliminaiy with Planning Comnission.2. Notify neighbors. 3. Hold Pi4)lic Hearing for preliminary plat and make recomnendation to Co^il. 4. Council action on preliminary plat. 5. If approved, applicant submits final plat. 6. Flaming Cdimission review of final plat with leconmendation to Goincil. 7. Council review and action on final plat. 8. Certification by Mayor and Administrator. I also informed him that the following data was required with the application: 1. Application form. 2. Fee ($100 plus $2 per lot). 3. Prelinimxy plan of propos^ plat (topog) (roads - preferrably private) 4. List of owner's within 300* of property. 5. Portion of 1/2 section map. I also explained to him the information and material necessary with the final plat: 1. ^Vlar and hardshells. 2. Plat to include: a. b. c. d. e. f. h. dimensions angles road details easements (public utilities, drainage, access) drainage plan topography map description of properties certification record form 3. Final would also require following: a. b. c. d. e. f. City Treasurer approval (Special assessments paid. Park Dedication Fee paid. Approved Bond or Irrevocable Letter of Credit) City Engineer approval City Attorney approval (which includes property title opinim addressed to the City) Administrator approval Council apprtr^l Certification by Mayor and City Administrator I' ■' •r-'- a-amse. .•1 Wllllim'toiar Siibdi^ion (1 8 4. Tot { - 5 ;leg . #He was also n* • - '• t area and widt »r,.- • ■ 'f •xegulations w Ti ^ ■excluded from showed him ou He was skepti 1 i- k'' f only 20,000 s Willow Drive. I would like ; *Conservation '■ ■freezing cond k. ^ . ♦line of the w the wetlands We will be sc »'• ' «• r • ) ^ii-} procedures on. on cation: private). final plat: lication Fee i Letter of Lon addressed vtW'^ 9‘ toivring Subdl^ion (Pre: g. Filing of plat within 6 months. / ■ .i •' fi•r ' *•• .' 4. Total procedure time excluding applicant's delay in preparing necessary legal and engineering data. He was also notified of the zoning regulations in this district ii^lud^g minintiii lot area and wid^ requirements and setback requirements, *nie wetlands and marsh regulations were also bra^gh^* to his attention. Wet and manh arew and roaw are eoGcluded from lot areas in calculating dry buildable areas for individual lots, i ^owed him our wetlands map which indicates an area of 156,800 sq. ft. as mairehland. He was skeptical of this detemiination. The preliminary plat as submitted d^ucts only 20,000 sq. ft. as unbuildable wetlands and nothing for the 33* designated as Willow Drive. I would like to obtain a soils type map and report from the Hennepin Coimty Soils Conservation District, but I'm afraid they mi^t not be able to getWisvrvttbxuil VAabAXWfc, trww «. m «.—/ -0-—- -~ freezing conditions. This would be the only way we could detetinine the act^l line of the wetlands. If we don't get this report, I would reconmnd we follow the wetlands determination as indicated on our wetlands map in the office. We will be scheduling a Pdblic Hearing for February 22, 1977 at 7:30 p.m. wayWc o. popham MAVMONO a. HAIK nOOKM W. SCHNOBPK OCNVCn NAUPMAN OAviu s. oorv MOSCMT A. MINISH NOLPC A.WOMDCN O. MAMC WHtTCHCAO •nucc o. wiLus rncoentCK s. pichap nONALO C. ELMOUtST O. POBCPT JOHNSON OApv n. MAcoMsen PNCOCPICN c. BROWN BRUCC O. MALKCRSON JAMCB R. STCILCN JAMCB a. LOCKHART ALLCN W. HINOCRAKCP CLirPORD M. ORCCNC O. WILLIAM KAUPMAN Mr. H< Zoning City < P. O. Crysti Dear 1 is to ment? road any p the w Drive tern. sides to th city appea fashi polic the C A nininun lot rsh oads are lots. I marshland, deducts ated as y Soils in these ;tual :ollcM POI^HAM. H a IK. SCHNOBRICH. KAUFMAN & DOTY. LTD WAVI#C G. POPHAM MAVMONO a . HAIK MOOCW W. GCMNOSRiCH OCNVCM HAUPMAN OAvip B. oorv NOBCRT A. MINIBH NOLPC A.WORDCN O. MARC WHITCHCAO •RUCC O. WILLIS rRCOCRICR S. RICHARDS MONALO C. ELMOUIST a. ROBERT JOHNSON GARY R. MACOMBCR PRCOCRICK C. BROWN BRUCE O. MALKCRSON JAMES R. STEILEN JAMES B. LOCKHART ALLEN W. HINDCRAKER CLIPPORO M. GREENE O. WILLIAM KAUPMAN tos CCNTCR MINNCAFOLIS. MN 8S40S eiP-T35-933l February 1, 1977 : O ■q) i r« \i I ?» \ J t'iVWjJ • I village of 0i;0.;!0 ' *.• Mr, Henry F, Muhich Zoning Administrator City of Orono P, O, Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 RE: Levering Plat Our File Number 3643-047 Dear Hank: My comments on the Levering plat are as follows: 1. Is this to be a public or a private road, and if it is to be a private road, do we want an underlying public ease ment? 2. Do we want to extend the public and/or private road to the western boundary of the plat for future access to any property on the west? 3, Do we want an open space-conservation easement over the wetlemds, if they are at all substantial? 4. Do we want sanitary and water easements along Willow Drive for any future expansion of the sanitary and water sys tem* in the immediate or far distant future? 5, Do we want sanitary and water easements on both sides of the private road in the pla t extending all the way to the western boundary of the plat? 6, Do we wish to have the developer pave the road to city standards even- though we will not accept same, since it Appears that the City of Orono will develop in this sort of fashion the two acre zones in the future? This is a major policy guestion to be -discussed by the Planning Commission and the Council, ^ ‘V. ^ % Mr. H( Febru2 Page 1 straci public Agreei your < BDM/m< cc: • IP-335-9331 V * ilM □f OUO.iO ind if it Lie ease- /ate ccess to inent over Dng Willow ter sys- both the way road to ince it ort of major ssion and t . .i ■ • f w: • r I' pm m.1 k I ?^ r * • r m ■: ■ • r V r .*• *-*^ ■'■V. •i '.- ••-i C, '•’ V* * \ * It f ' '» . k r ■ 1 .«» •«%» •-. •' ^OPHAM. Haik . Schnobrich . K aufman & D oty. Ltd . Mr. Henry F. Muhich February 1# 1977 Page Two 7, We will need a title opinion from an up-to-date ab stract addressed to the City of Orono. your office using the forms previously supplied. Very truly yours, 9 I9.O0^-^k Bruce D. Malkerson BDM/mcr cc: Walter R. Benson Y. t.-. • ■r .-.‘V t «I'. .:Ya * ; •• <-i.y L^/U c w‘,*- /. ^ McCOMBS-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES, INC. CONSULTING (NGINHRS ■ LAND SUHVLYORS ■ SITE PLANNERS January 27, 1977 Mr. Henry Muhich Zoning Administrator City of Orono P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 Subject: Wm. Levering ; Dear Mr. Muhich: - Subdivision Application We are unable to complete our review of the William Levering Subdivision, because the submittals do not Include a street profile or storm water disposal plan as required by Section 7, paragraph 39.300 of the Zoning Code. When this material Is submitted, we will complete our review. SIncerely, McCOMBS-KNUTSON ASSOCIATES. INC. ./ Gregory/Frank , P.E. GF:jl l«j * u a ■•5 n N O LTj 1 ' VILLAGE Ofi ORGNO VMAft OICOMIJUCA^^ __UI rVUJlAi A V__Aa INI M CADni 1C __AAIMMCCrVT>^(UjR.4Af_JTCI ‘ I ' i' a \ i rTjt-'.'' w • ^ • ...L- VILLAGE OF ORONO ■'X" ■ .J V !* '-YV' v'v ■ I"*. •’ ' f'i im r i‘. .-V Pi; ' ^ if Mr. Jim Anderson Hennepin County I 250 N. Central A Wayzata, Minneso^ Dear Jim: Gould you please property now beii I also wish to tl other properties Sincerely, -•»» Vv y Henpr F. Muhich Zoning Adhiinistn HFM: be Enclosure -4r'-"■fc . .^ ’ - / ='• rr *■^1 4? ✓ r ■ m - '“4? iNtL * ^i:i^ ‘ «r I :v r* . ‘/'J/ r-r- yia I S' fit ss « > ^ ,1 I VI I ■ ■•• > I'il'i •V'- 3 » *i ^ Hi r. «ai t' -Stf. " k •'■■ ' , 1 i’ fv *' -n ikl^! 4^'' ^ ^00^ * € I s. f' m *% •-m I I. n to1___e!? •>: < 1 • i1 •# . JV • i <« ' xjams *M.--------1 ------- « *• ?l • ■ •• # ‘•ly C > <# j NAME O’Sl ?)'3;fcOAat u). Mpte -SSMiO CSk m«i> X) u\man SWU<\U?x"o I il^£ Li \ V *^an'v''a\K^AC. Co, V..^'^ > 11 l^.^'X^w'7r\Ci<T>£ (jeori^tiLO o/ r^ ■-di^. N\e^>r Bc^ii.v'l:. h docif < iiC'U^ -L r. yo . Ke. w 6n Sfe • ,5^U '-• M U-U35^te. sw ^vjCt- n?>4-- Pr<prjc >v>\r X^M-NWiads-l^ E^s*Ja» A ^.U3Hir^e^ ^ ) 1^‘^t~>Ql-c^ ^ ri. i" ^ I (^) h\ Crt->t HaTTe'N \|llWo<2/ otO\'C iU W^ \^ • C'i\c <£¥oC Ti R.VJ.U-A'rvA . _____ Oi •"T" T"^ U.nie-te.rJL rO^/'^-»K uTiKt v lA/>;n 0^ OrOvAO !hC) Um^ ftV: * ‘Bc^5•5^ U t o > 5 rc r>0' LOT U 'h BLK.PARCEL iOOO I'^10 I '.' a C «. .4 yoc •?>'v Io — O^-'ic- lO ^ yy V jy^C Ci;' ; €' 7 I / t i ‘ f s- y' ^ <, C T C ‘ <-^ 09Cc; 1^00 * *> i £ ' "'!/‘-)C cc:•■?,.' v;>-•inv<- ■ 1-.s Tr-' ■ '■■ ' " m I, j, :.pv ^11 '■ aW'-; 1 ■w a- h: Bk mjL*.,. f *- i^myym0 I / ■»'«4 }■ ■TOi ‘ FRCIM: Dick IkMison, City Aitainistrator Hank Muhich, Zoning Administrator / < ' .^v-V DATE:January 25, 1977 SUBJECT: John H. Honour - 3560 Ivy Place Variance request for addition to non-conforming lot and dwelling location. Required Area Width Side Setback (Existing) 21,780 sq. ft. 100 ft. 7.95 ft. Lake Setback Lake Setback for Addition The property is sewered. Existing 16,000 sq. ft. 50 ft. 10 ft. V'ariance 5,780 sq. ft. 50 ft. ■<* ‘j ■..' :■ •■ u *V ;v- } t ,/ fv i j k il i location op PS Address Legal Descript APPLICANT Name Address OWNER Name Address } Present Zoning Zoning Ordinan< Specify Ordinal XV/<^/ yt'/^v4 Explain Reques’ Extent of Non-< SrtSt - Hardships to Pi w* ,•.•*, .r*y<y 1. Applicatioi 2. Plat Map S< 3. Survey (Sk< LL/ '' »4 ‘‘ -A"' '/ ^ IV,*V '• * *'^ ition. Variance 5,780 sq. ft. 50 ft. ■ * tit w£' r 1 I Pli t , •> M --------' ■ c 1. ' cm OF ORONO, MlitCSOfTA Ccnditioml Use and Variance Applleatftif eV' •’ i (or propertjr)It', >■. UXXTION OP PI I "' : Address SSA'O T,- v 'T^'/a-c^ __________ ^ A^' r^/ f^*y ^y/ »» y PheneJf 7 / < .7 Legal Description^ j. s^ujlv at:' /a-r APPLICANT Name v^r»y^x ^ ./' ' Addxess _^f>6cO "/ /I.- aVNER ^JoLlL^o < Phone t ^7 ' TYPE OF REQUEST Conditional Use X. Variance Wetlands Variance Riprap Nane Addxess Present Zoning lM- fC^Present Use /ii v Request Specify Ordinance Requirements 30-- F6e f^Zh77 FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY Council Action Approved Denied jfit^, /r /(z4r Explain Request Relative to Requirements _f A A s/> Extent of Ncn-confonaity UL, /ffdt f*dL4 * 7A 's fifdOOtf- f?90 /Uf»n/f^ » Sb/ts _____^jfe * i i| T. 1 Hardships to Property (Your reasons for requesting this Variance or Conditional Use Permit) /./y.J.:) /T.-^ /-> ^ ■/ ^ -v' ** v /S / ^ ’/T ' V/' ^ MATERIAL NECESSARY FOR COMPLETE V??! ICATION (Must be submitted 1 week prior to Meeting) 1. Application conpleted 2. Plat Map Section 5. Survey (Sketch in proposal) 4.Certified Property (Ximer*s List of owners within (150 ft.) from Hennepin County Registrar of Deeds $30.00 Fee Date Signature :ja2.i '<.i \ V i I 1 : 7 li\ %» • U -.r i l5oVfc NAME Wfb U'l ^icVia^ V^vrf J\ H 'SriuJc'-bt OClC<T>< OvCA^ ISdr\n^ K'y^ Ji )ds Variance } [CIAL USE ONLY :il Action ^ • 7.9 r y « i. tional Use PeTnit) ^ 'ey r*s List of (150 ft.) - gistrar of i: ■t 14 m i" .'v ^ .t t U,%t I DtPARTMEN! OF FINANCE A-6'03 GOVERNMENT CENTER MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55487 /- \\ U i5oVfc PROPERTY OWNERS LIST c NAME ADDRESS WcIsj 1- DESCRIPTION iC\r, ^idna^ O. l'Lrf^,\jy.)^w»V]f (\ vi -<r 1®^** ^'>'i ( A Vi I I Ij).m\or »AjetwJ.’feds'o «s \\on(ro( •SSH'^W Oi'CiC.'C-- *sS3<^i Stdbi TV?.<a5 W^a-A^Ic '-'O CPte U50<S ‘.^ •;>\)i\iQd'' isiiCl W'rsii'Y;^ WtHr/o r7 ‘:;>Tn(j; Q, -■•^\/J,(V<A ft- LOT BLK. ^ 5^rtr Ivj, WG \\j H'S t" t \ \<-ac_'c \j • V ’('p\c^t 4'60^Vc K^^y''xi|oal4^aAS5af»' iCci!d211 ITV \rac t O fvv»a VVjtvxV: l\'jl\ (rlql:-5<5^ u> er I n\-L :■ li v' . .‘j!vv ■3^:"■5’i'^;::. -sit li;m iisfes -LKj.- - o A. 'K'h • PARCEL orx:‘Q lOo:':) juoC^ U>c:>CyQ k I*. •'' f'ilii r.n. .’3 • *- - I 'ycii ObOO.. ‘-tC^CTO. j %C^iC S-.S? .^4 ■ f .■t; i: I ••V ■ s-l ■■'■!■ it I f»«My eif# (te r«p(«.« ; aru i !=■ ,i» 0(1 •’■/It eri' Jflost ? afu an ac*.u •nd fn»e «|».'astnt^t on of In.'i rr»i^ Hon as It flOfT^ois t^l s d-»ti> cn fOCOfd? of lh«i Hert.'v Co ^ • 1.M ■>., ■ ’• _wvlJvcii_?fJ __ FRn*1: DATE:Ji SUBJEa: Applicant own alley. His p bining Lots 1 1/2 acre • 10 January 31, li option we migl If we do not on the combi 100 ft. lot area requirei It*s been ou benefit to tl the applicam general publi If the vacat the result w< wide and 7,6i If we wish to i to be schedulec Public Hearing V ■j . LOT BU.PARCEL 1 10?) ♦ - •* a — -«K« • • • - or^Tj lOOC^ _ )c^-oCl 0)C:><00 1 -t .'ycilA C-’C^.O- ‘-^CX^'O.. I i 1 » 4 1-» -j * ‘ 1 'fj f ■;.•■• M I Npma an ac».u oa ^ tn dtte cn Cj- N 4^ V' ttt-t'n ..;v A •\ ■ f Planning Commission 5 Coimcil /< Henxy F. fWiich, Zoning Administrator January 31, 1977 I ' ♦ * i? " Vari^e’'<;S"^S"?! a«l 13 V i^fo^TO^al ” divided by platted unused billing Lots 11, n n Mr»?L I ^ vacating existing alley and cooi- 1/2 aire - 100 f«i lot^r^tinJi L!” >«>‘dd ineet our January 31, 1977. I waived the ^PP^^^ation was submitted option we might favor. required survey until we determine exactly what « the‘‘^Lj§P ”;^erof7,^s^r i® r^uesting a lot atea variancerir^sS^nrvT ^firto*^’^«al*’nSlic*^**l»rdo*^* property on the basis of the res^iJSd”^*5TO*r^li1inp'^”tf^d^*’f ?'J,P"^!f**es is not approved, wide and 7,600 sq. ft“^^2! il) which is only 50 ft! to be scheduled, ^'^believe^thc anol^cMt**! ■'' J'd’iic Hearing Kill have Public Hearing in thr^tror! i^e right to request a • f 'Xk Sr ». Ir f'.i i. . 1.'- f . ^■n ‘t ^ t«4|.-xr ■ ■■ * ' ; cj 1 i h MM»>•> > -i. v- rS’'i ;u ’ H \ -i/' '.‘i-» ■*. I t. LOCATION OF R Address Legal Descrip APPLICANT Mane WUlla Address 14912 •.?iv'ia I Nw Same Address Present Zonini Zoning Ordinal %)ecify Ordinj Explain Reques ^ Extent of Non r/-/2 i Hardships to F Requeal three ! struot: 1. Applicatic 2. Plat Map S ✓3. Survey (Sk Date B f P m )F REQUEST litional Use Lance Lands Variance rap (,/^r ,tc.t FFICIAL USE GNLY mcil Action Vv-;^ ) - >j ^ ^'k'- *.f w - ■ ^ ■ :»i!^ •■(• Ltiohal Use Peini^ 80 that all ’•fW4() poses of con- /■ # nar's List of .) Registrar of T-------------- -,«!■■ ^ . ■- !T v^y <■ i I’l'' ■ ;•;. •Ai /’I i,- •‘^a^.-. :.A- .;■ '^i.:,<-vv AJV kiV. Planning Comnission and Council if FROM: DATE; SUIUECT: Hank Ntihich, Zoning Administrator a ,-fc" February 3, 1977 Vincent .Johnson - 469 Tonkawa Road Variance - Lot Area and Width Application submitted on February 2, 1977. Request for lot area and width variance Lot Area I..ot Width Required Existing Conditions Variance 43.560 sq. ft. 25,000 sq. ft. 18.560 sq. ft. 140* 100* 40* The applicant has agreed to coinbine Lots 1, 2, 15 and 16 as one parcel if the variance is approved. Mthough the combined parcel lacks required area and width, each one of the individual lots has been assessed for 1/4 sewer unit for a total of one sewer unit for the complete corbination. The engineer evidently considered the combination of the four lots as one complete building site. The property (all four lots) has been assessed one uiit charge of $3,859.04 and 100 ft. of lateral, charge of $1,830.00 for a total of $5,689.04. The proposed location of the dwelling would meet all setback requirements. We should make certain a garage is included in the plan so no variances would be requested for any future garages or other structures. The original proposal also indicated a driveway toivani the north half of the parcel. After informing the applicant the County would have to approve access onto a County Road he has reversed tlie house plan in order to locate the drive way further toward the south to improve the problem of sight distance as indicat^ in the enclosed County Highway report. We might consider noting an exact dimension for locating the driveway to assure us of the safety suggestion by the County Highvay Department. After reviewing the proposal and County Highway Department suggestions, I believe we should require a contour map of the property indicating existing and proposed elevations so tlie County can review the proposed drainage pattern before any building peimit might be issued. We could defer preparation of the topograp!)ical map until sucli time we determine whether we should approve the variances. i1 w I -r . •t-i 1 i V Mm !. -i < ¥ 1^ '•* ivi r1 -'m UCKnON 0 Addms_ Ugy Desc APPUCANT 'S-. k&! « m l.v.-v , ' •> ' ...»: ‘.. * Address :■ Present Zon Zoning Ordi cify Ord M Explain Reqi Vf fr »:.. y Extent of Nc ■a- ,i ' Hardships tc 1. Applicat 2. Plat Map 3* Survey (j ^ . ».l»te ‘J,/. IgCTWgy y '.C\,,. \ v» iridth variance I if the )f the le sewer the jrty (all of lateral. mts. We rould he of the re access :he drive- as >ting an suggestion i, I believe id proposes! >re any ipographical :es. ^11 <%'.■ CJ^ . ,-A t.i- UCKTION OF FI Addnss <• cm OP Qttk), MDMESOTA Conditional Uae and Variance Ap|d.icati ^ (or property) Tt3M«.f w'.\ n%•• vW- ^v>' if r' U|il Oeactiptim Mt ^u APPUCAKT Hn» i i-Vv; ic n »n ‘ a Phone # Address \Pr t V) O i r .*'»;■ t \ I h. . V '1' • rfOiy; Phone « • r,i ^ 4 ' s'V- * »^tJc/ - r. |J;f 24- ¥.1 ■h. .;>' i **e ‘ ■■ “•. '4. Present Zoning Present Use 7 * Z^ing Ordinance Section Relating to Rec Specify Ordinance Requirements lot TYPE OF RBQUESr Conditional Use *♦ FOR (VFICIAL USE (MLY Coiaicil Action Date Approved enied >„yCdbbv I Bcplain Raquest Relative to Requinaente « •a c*-rLAf <9 W%jCZi^ •■■’M . Extent of Non-confor»dty ~ /$■ 'iCo ^ r- Hardships to Property (Your reasons for requesting this Varian __ iJO L«ik'P V u n* ^r/y ^ ^y^ar. <» T i />/^C //f4fiffL(c4^r Lt^iLL. CcM^/^U£ i.er*- r-«/?7-fA?£ MA3ERIAL NBCBSSARy FOR OQMI^IE APPLICATION (Mist be subnitted 1 week prior to Coiaicil Meeting) Vj /.otS 'P/Jal^p ‘.»T 1« Application coapleted 2. Plat Meqf) Section 3e Survey (Sketch in proposal) 4. Certified Property Owner's List of owners with^ (3W ft.) (150 ft.) - from Hennepin County Registrar of Deeds <5<^ 5. $30.00 I^e "r - 79 Signature /llv. . i »j • • 1(6/ f -^"u? ■■ ^ / E OF nquEsr •.V” V Sonditional Ibe ariance ” ^Sc ■.-- OFFICIAL US ONUr Coincil Action ’ . 1 t>’.n^L.&f <|» M •r- «^o \\- nditional Use Pendt} KAiiP ■|f 4 ’)» r H JLoT^ /p/7ci^P wner's List of t.) (150 ft.) . Registrar of :i^-V ^V i '/ t-. * v-v v - V ■. V , - •. •*» - '- r- 'i ' ; v.J /1. A iw, j.^ \U ' t 1 •^. ; jflSSHtf-i * ■ ■ ir-' '.;. '.< :■_■ ■ Ai>^‘ . it. ;■ .• ■*' • .-• • ( ♦ ^ V* •• 'll• ' .• 'Sio'-'r W A . • ;■■ ‘*i-it. f.^ r;irv<='*.'' ■'ey .'inront Johnpor r I, r, I'), m;v5 p.loo’< 1, I'ti r r . *. h'' i ”urr.jni t (’•• r.i fivnnornn A • nt.y, J-'jruv^ro tn 7icn 66' .V ; i^on . > Ort.l«'-i«Mto o'' Snn'ov: I ^•■i^eby certi'y V:nt t'V< * t-v. ^ a rA:r^r.ry f»^,. ^ ^ ' „, . !* -^.n-on.inl • r 1 .n of ton<a .V.incitt. ?Mr>, •- i ••>0 In^rtir.n all. .v-m-:r,jn,^%..jxvin * ' ’'■-"••'-'r.'-..''or ;’.r.v.^h-’ 1» --. 50* <i-%76 Iron narker (■:. rot'f’ir "^-T:H‘*«*' ^ ■ i-' S' / u>nr l'inri''Gr,-.r, m-’mis®. -A • - •'•r‘. 'I'—v • ••». /■ ,' >\v'..tv.' - i," • ^ !,. '.'••■•' ■ ■ ■ ■ ' . I ,i^ • ^ •. 4* • ^ . ‘V I * • • '• • TT^i. f . .t /4^ /W • ■» • -'V* ■ “ • !V V* hT* 1. i‘/ ofr f A‘.' •*. ■• ‘‘-t' ■> ■' • ^,. ' f V ■ ii ' ■ . “ ■• f •..• 'I •■•. k 'V-. .• ■■ a ■■•. /• \ 7* > " iSI mm * 'i-t' Ut ’. .» .•■ -Jf. ;•■?. ?.-i'/:' 'V- ’ v-r -.7 . y - :,3^: [fw }kimoo •« V f^T t SpS 30N3AW a I il m ^4ym.f'L 6 ■ V’*'? O’ Vif-* , v>' .'iP fv* i • .‘r. V > i >:<■ : ■ 2 i' '7- ’A «. •. .■ ’ »- vir- ^'-fcV; >4.r. f^TV 7 \‘v ' • '•■ ^,. ■*..* . i'j,. ’> ; r'‘ »I ■ *: •# J, ,•.'•.•*» ;• ‘ 1^' ^^4 ■ ’4 Sr - * • • • . M,'i t,i V - ; * . f . . • t'.;. « - * .. '■ .'. mm • ■ ^ - -1.. ■•j'- ■ ■ ' ■■ . ' ;>; k f PoMic Works Dean Bailey 2380 Island Spring Park, Dear Mr. Bdi Rc I have revic 1) Your dr Orono I Henry ^ 2) As dis( locatic A speec distam moving 450+ ft 3) Any fi' characi Hennep* 4) No worl permit I will be h( permit have Sincerely, I mf Donald C. Mt Traffic Eng 0CM:pj Attachment cc: Henry Mi fv *• ® t V- i9HfSf,72 HnoQ # ;v> ^__IZA .T’.' .1 ■*» % « fW.' 4. <- > •4 fe biSi^VbYr ■* pi*'‘'>.>' ■W-'^ . - ■; . •w '.T-^ss;' -.' « •, .V I'' • U M HI. V i[.:iL--^ - l-r ' -m:'i'‘:mE :-v-^‘v/K-.:’ Public WorKs Phone 935-3381 320 Washington Av South. Hopkins. Minnesota 55 J4.i f ir^ PI- ••r ‘^v * HeNNGRN CXiUNTY January 28, 1977 Dean Bailey 2380 Island Drive Spring Park, Minnesota 55384 Dear til'. Bciiiey: Re; Proposed Access to Co. Rd. 135 - 469 Tonkawa Road I have reviewed the above noted site in the field and have the following cotnments: 1) Your driveway permit application will not be approved until the City of Orono has acted upon your building permit and related matters. Contact Henry Muhich at 473-7357 if you have any questions. 2) As discussed in our telephone conversation of 1/28/77, the proposed driveway location is undesirable because of the limited sight distance to the south. A speed limit of 35 mph requires a sight distance of 350 feet. The sight distance from your proposed driveway location is approximately 285 feet. By moving the driveway to the south edge of your property a sight distance of 450+ feet results. 3) Any filling in the northeast corner of your property will effect the drainage characteristics of the area. Recommendations on drainage will be made by Hennepin County in the spring. 4) No work is to begin within county right of way u.itil an approved driveway permit has been issued. I will be holding the driveway permit until the questions regarding the building permit have been resolved. If you have any questions call me at 935-3381, Ext. 225. Sincerely, if Ivp^y.Vv.IV • Donald C. Murphy Traffic Engineering DCM:pj Attachment cc; Henry Muhich, Orono Zoning Administrator Minorities Women and Otner Pfoto'Ued Chis:.es .I'l- f i:i.ouio>tvC to afjpiy -rr n 4 W: - h !r it#' u liil'■■r ■■ •I ‘4^ i ] tic ui,-i Name of applicr,:U _Z] Atid.css_^.3.' -H_! Name of Propcity Owvi 1. Contractor performing 2. Application is hereby i 3. Building to be construi 4. Driveway or streol will 5. Islhe properly: PI. 6. Building Permit acquit 7. Type of pro|)osed entr 8. Location 9. Location, i1 ruri;t:..JV Dated __L To help the inspcctoi vegetation. APPLICANT'S OIAGI q . __1 1— m /^> / () vmLi •^ \* IL ‘ |i'*''-V LOT BLK.PARCEL ,::^r OO^jO C'l oo fc:'- on^O 0^<>OC] C^'iSO O^iCA r. ^ /.0'75 • ■ f 4 = x aOCjiZ L£CC ai :l.lu.**.* %r<8 •. n*i # • 7 ♦ 'i • It'.i; ’. ^ i ©i i; ^ >! k-A I ’ -<1 i 4 W/ ^>*vt§;.:;:o :■'m Ij SV’ I*. •' • .■.>•.■•' ' r,^ V ■'. ■ ■*v - .t \ V '' . > ‘‘a *-■ '?•• (- .' V .4J*-;.. * ' ■'■ i v‘‘ *«•.;..*V „,v ■ Ij. .«■ ' . V ‘..* ' -i. ' r - . -.•n ' ‘ ■If'' ■ f •-,r‘ , /f .■..r^‘ »V7> » . . * . l.K'Tt V 1 I I X- *f’ V • '• •. ■ ‘ '. r.; *, t ■,» «'■ .S;. . '* ■ > yr . .'•■ - >■;. *• Vy .? ; V*. f < af*'#, ’V Planning Ccnnission and Couicil Hank Muhich, Zoning Administrator Febniary 3, 1977 % r SUBJECT:Joe Van Bockel > 2800 Shadywood Road Wetlands Variance - Dredge Existing Slip and Riprap Shoreline This iqipllcation was submitted 2*3-77. The subject slip already exists on the property. It is currently covered by a boathouse (hardcover) badly in need of repair. The shoreline within the slip is not pro|ierly protected (creosote piling and metal sheathing). The applicant was considering repairing the existing structure and riprap. After consulting with me, he considered suggestions and returned with the enclm^ application consisting of removal of the existing l^thouse and metal retaining wall and dredging of the silt whidi has eroded into the existing slip. The proposal includes replacing the metal retaining wall with minimum 12*' rock ripi^ to coeplete fisting riprap along shoreline of his property. He would also replace the existing boathouse with a metal pipe and canvas cover boat cover. The stone riprap would be a great improvement to the sheet metal retaining wall and prevent continuous erosion. The substitute structure would also eliminate the existing hardcover conditions. The Council has declared a moratoriim on any permits pertaining to wetlands. Therefore, if we do consider approving this r^uest, we would have to grant a variance to the moratoriun also. • a : tA •, -r iiVV-. •• Tm .V K i f ■ \ * 4 4 A ; !l location op pi 4 •ness i Legal Oescripl APPLICAOT Name CMNER N mb ness Present Zoning Zoning Ordin Sjpecify Ordinar Explain Request A t ^ C. »•< U‘ L. L ^ Extent of Nda*o ilardships to Pn 1. Arolication 2. Pl|t Mq[> Sec 3. survey (Sket Date -2^ line sts on the in need of eosote iprap. with the and netal isting slip, m 12** rock !ie would er boat aining wall eliminate etlands, o grant a 4 .1 - • .1 '<f V- m t!*T ilfil Ifl#r;.- •• 5>=fP I'B ISk. cm <» OROn, MMCSOTA JJ^ h- Conditional Use and Variance Ai^icatioi^'* ' I'flCAnON OP FRCmiSAL (or pn| ^**«»ss S4it</y Ugal Description /» / ^ applicant Address CMNER ^ /t/ / Wwne » AddressjLlCdd Present Zoiing U Present Use Zoning Ordinance Section Relating to Rec|uest //•> Specify Ordinance Requirenents 3L7^C >'/■ 7/4 "^A/olCl PhcnT «t/7J. __CiSAiuiY TYPE OF REQUEST _ Conditional Use Variance Ifetlands Variance *^.vV KXl OFFICIAL USE ONLY COuicil Action Approved Denied Ir ' *v-#: < ^ «. /. 7~.• f /V - /: oA wf m. i /: (3 Explain Request Relative to Requirennts V •* ' • • • #•P yl , - y > ,# y *• t ^ *•• 't J. * J L ( i C ■*- J ^ L (:-• / <?-C ^( Extent of Non-confoneity -/ /i ( 1 . : ■> ■ (w-^ -k' k‘ If. Isi Hardships to Property (Your reasons for requesting this / ^ , / ------------- ■■.■■...</ / MMERIAL NECESSARY R« OOM>LETC APPL7.CATICN viJst be subnitted 1 week prior to Couicil Meeting) • I d•'t Ji. /. \of * ll 1. Anlication conleted 2. Plft Map Section 3. &tivey (Sketch in proposal) 4.tertified Property Owner's List o owners within fBBMc) (150 ft.) from Hennepin County tegistrar of Deeds $30.00 ■‘5^^ !-k‘ 4 Signatu:m M #.> - - • .»• >d,* - .'J '• ■’• * ‘ * ■ V. ' w # ' V •'« V-' . ' e * .tT'O-'r '- ^-f. • .-5 •'i- r • >. ^, v; ■'•4 ■/ri*,..••■.C 5 SS&Av" ■■ ■ 7’: V ‘•r ■' yn,,01.r . VyJ ^ , ».. *;• % •• 1 ‘ 53 -./Ml'if • •L-Vv-v. f4 ., •. ;f ■ ':v ’ V ■ : ■' '* » < ■. >* i* i> !; ■ ■ • ^ ot, • * • . • .r. V ^ . a, • .:.; f.‘ • =• ; kM Atm : - :-7 ^f ivTt /' y ^ V S'J* 4 ' • ^ ..■ . A f'‘*7 * ^ ' • 1'X . ♦ ‘ ' **'J ^ i ..A 7t;j: • S • t f ><* • 1 ■ :■..•■ W-' f ■■ ' ^/■ * *■, • • ■ ■ ..J/ V .♦ ,i • ::^•I -H . J ! ■ •!. 1 - y-‘- i': ’• i _ I J,‘! j. 1 •i ^ • . "'V: *K. i /• 1 »■, .1,. 4 ‘ •*4 •'■• M ‘•r I ♦.. r‘.^ .V’l-I 4 *,Ai ‘ t * f • \ ' \ r'~n< .4 1«». •* .• J -.4.. » < FT-Vs,'/' »•» * 9 4 ♦ -. •%. DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE A-603 GOVERNMENT CENTER MINNEAPOLIS. MN 55487 if !-1 PROPERTY OWNERS LIST ^rono NAME «■. samm ^(Wvam k.j\«vW:a: NUc^ve 1 ^ ADDRESS n^^aior 4^(0 5Vvaii^V4>o»4. Otooo ^SepK'iao'r^e-l<< DESCRIPTION I19L; AMMi*i«flkr-«ni \vcnct l\ VcXX \\'0(it Ci- jcn \'AV.'- 3K*id^u)0dd. I I ^i\ Lo.xi^ HeiTO 1^ 1 \ Ae. a-51 57?^»»a6.nj«0*«i. e»«•l•^le^ \r 2ictl A \Ainnij^n Cct^ Tb4 I lnWr\ aA>ojA / \cact'-.E 5 G f^o^.-.j^Nr■ <;\n ci( ' oi \\tei 'feao U tr> >51-'!>4 Uct;^ ^^ rLy, 4 «» LOT BLK. t “• PARCEL ■dOOO.. LiCiOC: %oo^ 1 • i H *: hn 1M» r it^:'..**. ; »r«; .vi . 4.«..«- •A *• •ndtn-*! t.p.*. ’.* •on rs ttlrrT-” * i»:cr.l*. ---------«4V.r(^l il« • :• «f • 4 ♦ .;•?*•:•■■ "I V^i . Cr. J Kt tfOttei txj Knew i.Ciiv:.U% k.COktU ■■>£’; '-• V ^ ‘ ‘ ‘ V**-. f •« 4 ^Vr- bT/il’' .-f^ # A-' i-.A 6-16-75 4a: y-: DAT RE: Lot <Orono BLK.PARCEL aa?o ..... 4 U'K^O t :«ti .VI i .•u: •. •; ••• •m t• • 4 Is/. W r-nsi 07 nnuJk^cgtr. riiii'i'jy I <11 6-16-75 =»9»' S ■* ' ■■ '. ■ '■’"' #21 TO: W. R. Uenson, -Administrator FROM: Hank ^kdlich, Z 5 B Administrator DATE: June 12, 1975 RB: George Tomnn, 100 Orono Orchard Rd. and Ricliard Backstrom, 95 Smith Avenue - Request for Ixjt Split and Combination Lots 61 and 74 are presently combined and owned by Mr. Toman. Mr. Backstrom owns lot 62. The current proposal by these parties is to split all but the south 15' of lot 61 and combine the remaining 139.4' of the lot with lot 62 as one parcel. The Backstroms are interested in combining this property so as to prevent any possible future subdivision and development. This area is currently zoned LR-IB (1 acre minimum area). The combined part of lot 61 and lot 62 would consist of only 31,480.8 sq. ft., but would definitely insure us of less density. If approved the applicants should be instructed to submit a survey of the new properties for recording and files. Planning Conwission recommends approval of this lot split and combination. CtWNCIL ICETING - June 24, 1975 Approved sid>ject to filing final plat. This proposed lot rearrangement was never resubmitted properly for final approval. We never received tlie necessary iwlar and hardshells, and the*lerefore the changes were never reconled. Since that time, Nfrs. § Mrs. Schleich liave purchased the one revised parcel located at 100 Orono Orchard Road. In April 1976 he requested a building permit for an addition. The lot was substandard so variances were required. Upon review of tlie status of the property, we found the final plat was never approved. Tlie .'ipplicant submittetl an application for the variances, but was informed Comcil could not act on the matter unless we had a lot of record to deal with. Mr. Schleich was unable to contact the original applicants to complete the original lot rearrange ment transaction, so he has sidimitted the necessary mylar and hardshells himself. rnmmw George Toman Page 2 Ihe proposal final plat ai The necessary we begin wid The dimensioi preliminary ] was approved. Lot 61 would been made. I requesting tl the applicant the unsigned plat conditic Re: The foil issued i Required Dine Existing Cone Variances Nec ^ - •-'v-:'v,-r4 - ■ '•■’ S^21 Strom, ion n. arties ! remaining I as to liis ;ombined |. ft.. i survey md srly for final [lells, and ac revised e requested a so variances we found the application on the matter was unable to ot rearrange- and hardshells ■fr *•w ¥■ k1 :'l, 'H :' .yJm * *< ^ r • • f -K0 i \> ; I • ?•»' a • • ;•■ ^ '<3 • u 'i. t; . u'.v' m i. v: i' . .% '^ j., . Geoi^e Toman Pige 2 V • The proposal here consists of two separate requests - one for approval of the final plat and the second for the necessary variances on the proposed addition The necessary mylar and hardshells were submitted 2-3-76. Mr. Schleich requested we begin with the procedures for final plat approval and variances. The dimensions indicated on the final plat coincide with those on the proposed preliminary plat (copies of both enclosed). At the time the preliminary plat was approve, we indicated that a conbination of Lot 62 and the remainder of V _ A ^ M « « « .. ^ ^ _ _ __lx>t 61 would be a condition of the approval. The conbination has not as yet been made. Mr. Backstrom did call the Assessing Department on January 11, 1977 requesting the conbination, but the assessor cannot record the conbination until the applicant signs the application for combination. I am enclosing a copy of . the unsigned application for combination. I believe we could approve the final plat conditioned on this combination. Re: The following variances require approval before a building permit can be issued for the proposed addition: Lot Area Lot Width Required Dimensions Existing Conditions Variances Necessary 87,120 sq. ft. 22,720 sq. ft. 64,400 sq. ft. 200* 145* 55* - g. Street Locat Legal Descri Owner: Type of Reqii Description Please draw 1. Indicate 2. Location 3. Adjacent 4. Location 5. Distance] property Exhibit Subm ^Map or plat 1 boundaries 01 ^Abstractors 1 owners of t!i( the change 01 Auditor of H< PeflrioiT'-showt varjiajice. jchronolojpy Inspection hep Mministratny Council Engineer planning Comm. ouncil ^Plicant ReciMiiniAn^lo*. L of the addition. di requested proposed iry plat ider of as yet r 11, 1977 ition until i copy of . the final : can be • I I t ■■T.rifiWr r.'y _qwr.ef.ni... - fi- ‘.''i Cas Fee - . O . r f; VILLAGi: OF ORONO Land fisc Application Street Location of Property; _ _ _ _A/ Hate -eg.! uescrxption of Proporty:_^:f- ^ Owier: <, ?>>.,.,, ... ’ ' „ Type of Request:nezoninf» :• X Conditional Use Pernit _____________Other Subdivision Approval 7 c c‘ 2*.></ •/, ^ Variance ***SwI.*V**" °5----A- /r,f-rc^ ^:;r. //«>•’ Ktlc.ti a.''A V. 77a.>/cj -c.' < ____ A »riiApplicant)CChvner) ^ structure shov/ing the following ■>. I ‘;; Please draw or attach a sketcli of I: E-HH s":E ^ SisJancL'^f’*''' .-“IjaccAt existing ■ pJope??r P'°P°sed structures and structures on adjacent Exhibit Submitted: It *1 P«trtIbn~»itCTrtn); Sffrof -nropei WiiUice. iicantJJjtificd Reconunendations: 21 C D j./»r 74^ (»*honej ffse Permit C' "/1 fJ/ MAAi 7i ‘ F the following: ?tl structure us area >n adjacent ^00» of the pies) ddress of the ty requesting tiie County kW: Pimmmm ■ V ^5'I 4 u- '♦11 ■m-,- . • . . .* V. V. ‘ fiy7*''*‘W - c ♦ /It-JUU:/ * (W —Y / 'i CTO OP ORQNO, MlItGSCia ---- cxnoltional Use and variance Application OP PACPQSAL (or property)V LO^rc^rd SWLY 15 Feet of Lot 61« Orono acquired Also ^VPB OF BEQUIESr CSonditicnal Use laid J. Snhi «<>.>.work; 372-6188 Phone # 475-1176 Variance # Hetlapd^Varlanoe fibb j^OO Orono Orchard Roada* Wayzata^ Minn. 55391 a Schlelch •v Phena * 47^-1176 POR OiFICZAL USE ( Oouncil action Date Ut ISO Orono Orchard Road, Wayzata. Minn. |flpp*oved Present Use ^ £It Zoning *Bning (ktUnmoa Seetioi RaUting to S^foUjr <Minanoa Raguljnaattta Denied IB^hlain Riqpest; BBlatlvci tao R bju Is 1 11 «tant of NDn-confoailty ✓^tedshipe to Property See attached sheet TOR ootPieiE AHUCamOM<»iat be aubnlttad 1 waek prior to OouncU ^toet: ^IP^^Lcetion ocnpletad Meeting) Plat Nep Section ®ffvey (Sketch in proposal)5e $30e00 Fbs /J^€ f - Signature Vc^ettL *• i V- >. A- 9<-'M •:'.v • • . f 4 ) i- r 1 I i • Li-. h » 'V The p] garag€ The pi single leaves etc., our ca The pi the ms These sizes, room, of ths The pi a hall a sewi The up highes would Upon c more t would Bluepi inspec ....p,S'- A •T 9r I; \ HARDSHIPS OF PROPERTY The plans for improving this house involve adding a two car garage and three bedrooms to the existing structure. The present garage is unsuitable for our needs as it is a single car unit, large enough only for a compact car. This leaves us with no storage space for lawnmowers, bicycles and etc., as well as the inconvenience of having to keep one of our cars outside. The present bedrooms of this house are two small rooms on the main floor. One is 9*6' X D.8' and the other is 9.7' X 11.8*. These measurements Include closet space. Because of the small sizes, we are unable to fit all of our bedroom set in either room. And many of our clothes must be kept upstairs because of the inadequate closet space. The plans for these existing bedrooms would convert one into a hallway and closet space, while the other would be used as a sewing room. The upstairs area is 11.2* X 15.6* but is gabled, with the highest point of the ceiling being only 6.6*. This space ‘ would be used as an attic for storage space. • Upon completion of construction, the new addition would be more than 45* from the property line. The outside appearance would coinside with the architecture of the existing house. Blueprints for this proposed addition are available for inspection. ik two car is a This cles and one of Ris on 9.7' X 11.8*. the small n either because one into used as th the space uld be ppearance house. Iv.;n ^ ■'2-*'.: a-MS \ \ \ \ \ \ Av < Xs \ \ V ^ **t. 1\ X V<* N < t • [>f 5*.urv'.*yt tify th?,t i:c .uiul "Of-. rjn of a rica Ci’: liv.jf; ?.«rLy mrO-jif r;r.‘l t’ly l^> fr ot ;torly 315 . rH.;, f*.u V !• li :r t to or.or-..i»oh- '>r/,4 i!f) BEfORE IT WAS iresT 0? T/yr 6i If- ■V- '"■fiV&i-: ' # ‘I V. ;. V .' . .=:r;.b .• .< X--.- » >: .f ^ K. ■ i "V » 4«M)» >. fc.*■ a . •DEPAK.;*£N. »v. •% OF FINANCE ROOM'116, '.OLIRTHOUSE MINNEAPOLIS, MINN. 55415 PROPERTY OWNERS LIST NAME ICfTV oP ORfjtsiQ ADDRESS \ Bf gCle hJD-<LiO |jg>c.wftfti:> P. 6/CKS~ ■ P-1*.;VCPA^IAFg v\x k\Jil. RdNS.‘^el_>kviv)^ a VC DESCRIPTION z- \n' ( Pan wo OROKi O _ORChV/^ LOT ( pvM vx) ) 40 - .2 C. lA£tt.CVAMbt>- Alfi.J2SttiaCi-.-0i£iVkav «1> ll l.yA. D. ME\V-^QtJ Ipm.1 \. Vj^ieiicH r': r 4 Uwjg lCv-, 'tCjQ ^ft-Oioo Vs 3 I c«rtHy thal tha l.vM fopfes«ntctf on thW ccitWic.'te sre an accurate and true rcprc'.ai''''''**®*' jr.orni» lion ar. ll np. co'« ini'-* "*•* recuiUt^ ot Henti. Co. i Irn .ce U.V.. lo l»e Uft.-. OJ mv Kr....r.^Cdo anJ tMilcf. Hdnn. Co. Ftnanco Diviswn /J r..-»i.^CC3-76 BLK. r' PARCEL 4^^O0 ♦ I - 'tfe. : .>• .....♦ '" ¥ l|■W M ."■!*■ :i?tv. .....'Jyim. » I ■... ■ i: V i Z'' i ..4 ■V.i • • #w :^-j± :ii^.^,^;.....:... ::vi; ::a: •-r* LOT BLK. PARCEL K'V-# ' :k I ; 45.00 •*■'■' '.vlL'iiJ!!''' * ft •j i :■ • -V : -'••-T ’SB .rvsJkUbiiji .^•1 l n c . > ||V<- % \ •%. V" » H. GORDON tAYLOR ATTOIINSV 304 MtOWCBT BLAZA BUILDINt; ■01 NICOULCT MALI. MINNCABOLIB. MINNESOTA 55402 A U'^J VILLAGE 01: ORONQ .June 7, 1976 City of Orono 1335 Brown Road South Long lake, Mlnnnscta 55356 Attention: V/alter Penson Pear Mr. Penson: I represent Paul Schloich who owns the property at 100 Orono Orchard Road and T understand he has made a reouest for a permit for a new addition to the property but that some difficulty has arisen relative to the division of Lot 6l. In lookinp at the survey it appears to me that the orifinal tract of Lo*- 7li and the Southeasterly feet of Lot 75 is sufficient land for the present dwelling and the proposed addition and that the questionable tract, the Southwesterly 15 foet of T'^t 6l is not needed. Can*t this strip be removed from the arrlieation and the application printed as to Lot 7|| and the !-,outheasterly 35 feet of Lot 7C^ Yours very truly, x" X . X' > ^ /H/ r«ordj^ Tnylor HOT:CO ir--'.n--. -:r^ % i ’-X'' :.i. A A ■V i ’t "v *' I :■ :Sj- V -.y; i tiMANoa* ^ laginMf V®H*g* % ! : ( » ' )\ \ « . . I . ♦ • I^>- -i i Of. OKONQ b.i IRJ.;, m \ . i , Mmig.-,- '1 hJ^ •>,. 'W ■~i: ■ "* .- *m ' -i ’IP r?- "Sk tat,. 9, i:.\.:-sC?s;x'm vVy v-^*;r>- ^ •• V i.« «• 4 t«• * # I f-’ ^1 V c loc«tio«Jl_^t-.->r‘ ^ . .Ok C-hf t- •.» Architect 'f K C/rOC^.w/j P— J_OT‘~ ^1 Mf -iP XaUaiUlv ^4 j C' 'U:^£l'm.M:\rn y.C < O ' j 41 .j j t jfrr; _ L-O- r 1 TC _. V-.’ •, r fteq f . .mV.. LO'- Cm *n»i ^ • SiWM«Ww*»f« 'w V* f%vfr ^ • * V COPY of P^on>s£P car J^PPPYYS-£M£*'f y \# «► ^ M-I • \ \ » \ 'A \ X..'•y \ .-' r .r \ >• i \ \ \ A \ V"^. ‘l Vw \ \ll t 7 A- .\\ K f i \ \ \ V ‘A A ' V.jf'\/ !• \.f' i ‘ \ « k HONEYWELL A5 :i. •f ■| ■^l-v : *• .■••;. !•■'■■■. ip- '* 4*'' ^ j • ‘ list* .1/^1 ck;*- V Tv5Lf -7 V i^:.; E ■* i r ‘ w •; ^ •V. I {«•', T^;.; ■•:■• t • 4 Vi'’ l> *•. ■♦: . V.. . 'T *l<*. . V- • ’'• :»■ * • ‘ t mi...' 4v'^ * V» V *1 4^,'V- • '- ; ■’S il M' i * . ^ f > i! '! *1 y s Hv .V- li m ! ' -4 r V,.)v. A' ^*4 ' ■?S'r| i r/ ■ ct MM • ■ ■ I I P ■\. JT *t> i \ • • • • • t y* r*—*• • • t s :r*”“s : f—*v* : .* xf I .••—I i » W ‘fii. h',. .1: :v^ Rv^;v>: ^jpr-iwr'iilMrtaiihii ■■■iwtoafciii 1 Ti Y «k V ^ ■■ L . / vb, ifi; *... ■, ^ .« .^v ,--------.I.'"'--- .: • P"^' . MV 4y^£/c/fr/^Aj {jUsectf^P /* A ’ U •* 1. ^ : • r* I -'#1* »•’•' ' < ’ * k .< • ■■■.•■* |>« ,;/ ,i '{ .--7. •. . ..Tf'/.v-j-.- ’ ?)^v-W r/••' • , .•■■;'‘J: 1:4, ;■•'••■. • . *'• » '-/* :*• ■ ., \ w ' January 11 « 19 77 .^•i; :*U' I-’■’ % 1^;: 7 i‘y' • . • •, . • •■'■ , .*^ - I. 1 )■•XV,C-,o-..4 ‘.- VOINQNT. HOm nMANeC DIVISION URfCTOt r.£;^~o» >»» ie.’iMt Sit; Iv' » -'? •T : *■ ■( I RBtSBy Him KDUIST Wt A CSnMSIOI» CCMBIHSD) ASSSSMItt fOtUMINB OISGRIBBD LANDS !;,iC: - ■ \y\.‘ -‘SV Ir f P ■1 s \ *• l> -;,■ ‘A'tr H ’i > V •-/T ;f. V . ^ • • • ♦'.*•. , S ■mf' . ■ ’ 'S. *• ' A TOUN» VIUA6S at DISTRICT 38 ■ Orono ^ * A V TT It SIGNATURS OP PS£ OtfNOt *ifVf ’ . M, 1978 TAX YSAR NiMB OP TAX PAYR ;7>. r’y.•/.,77 /♦;•TAX PAYR’S ADDRBSS U •; • *f ^ v>'; ■ Ot N.H.LAND f. BUILDING MACHINB ' / • *Y f -.r^ i Mi :•• * 'I?'/’ V-t: ,1' % . ‘i ■ T4 .'i: f , .'■'«*•ir v\A -:yi: 1 ' lul .“Vt Regular Meet ? Mr. Conpton A' * ti.mw •f'f *i- * l*^^; ■v-r'-'. • side setbad his aninals. allCM IS ani ■#: "■ ’t1 I ‘1.^ i#i Van Nest mm for approval lot and cone Conditional to contimiec Ayes (7), Ns (M *> Ms. Overby 1 a variance i -V ” ’ <-V^ nonavails % > setback to tr/4r r*-i '^JS^ .'A 7 w i;v (7). M “ I II ISif vMr. Toman, I Real Estate, Ci. > 7 request for : moved, liake aniroval of Mrs, r%'j£ ■ 'iA^ , :;;V ! Mdiich expls ppi size varianc tes^'Van Nest moi SVL>^;Lots 4, S, (Sfe"; be granted.;IKv • • *VV'^ - • fTA , I Dr. Ifoellnei ■■- ,:=• *>>»f . •*: to operate s ^perty leasee Vbn Nest mm ^“1;.-v;. Coiaicil grai lease with 1 be erected» > toilet, no I either sail fefe'f.,'. Mho has the (7), Nay (0] m -'si; i * :n 1f.-i V *■ M. / • '« mr^ The Plannini made forthei tion Study i following cc :. ISfi'-'* V-"- - ►, 1. .. i. r'~ i ‘-^ '• ^ i 77 Orono \ I ‘P [.;-v f* ■iI' A'i K JL^. *' 4.. 4' • . *»> > !l*r- «.’ • *9 * ’' ’Li\r,'V ., .. • jr I. ‘ r : ., >» ‘V#*V •‘* ■rf*- -V,.uT . :/:v./r ;»\i y';^, VK 4?^ Wr |l«g.1 |fr tlMtilli! Of th» «-16-7S i • • * ' V- lA K • / 'v I sfS®SasM £T„ allow 15 «nii»l units bn his land. i**-' ‘ - . -^ ' \ .V fc .*» «»♦* VARIAMZ « USE PEBMIT Robert CoHpton 4S4S Watertown Rd. mCNMrS • V* s 'sr„’ss'«i?^«s.“ “s; .lot and concuirenc© of wirf^bofs ai|4^app:w of the Conditional Use>i?Skm r-M / ».‘W w continued concurrence by the nei|^itere.o ^totion, ^ '.-• Ayes C7), Nsy (0). • , •• .’•> • . ^v''v ' »• «» * V i' ngdh^^ her iwjM^st for' ^ sue. ^ Ibhe moved. Hannah seconded ’,> 4 recoemendation VAiOAHas Audrey Overby 567 Park Lane .•. ; A .. .-i ' * ' •• i”: * of nonavailability of laM on either side m if#^^^;betbadc to be conf6n^>with heifl^flKirihg homes Ayes (7)^ Nay (OK :t;a ‘ ^ 1 > •• / 'll k t Tomaju Ihdce Schneider r>'-: Estate» and Mrs. Baekstrom presented their v» rv i > i -- “ip ;v V ie<|uest for lot split and. combination. Van Nest --^^m Hake seconM reobemendation to Council f< ’: - • V Vi SPLIT 6 ODINATIOH in $ Baekstrom 95 smith Ave. 100 Orono Orchard Rd. \a froval of this request.. Motion, Ayes (7), Nay (0) vV. v^v I" - k Mr. and Mrs. Nright laade : their request i^r-variance .. Hdiich explained the background for the for •*» * •» “• V' •4V. ••U.J |»;M: site variance. y v ' iVan Nest moved, Hake secoiiii ... Luts 4, 5, 6 be combined into one and no otlier variance VARIANCE . Richard Wright 4045 Elm St. .•. * '•, ^V < ' «■ 4 * ' * • ' ■ *• 'A ’ ■ ’ f > ■ ■’tf V. » V t »r r- f't" , be granted. Motion, Ayes (7), Nay (0), hi:**:, * ^ .<• # Dr. Woellner and Mr. Stone explained the request by 1^-Jtvv--; •.* the Nayzata Yacht Club for a conditional use permit g-rsy siTiStf ‘ CONDITIONAL HSU Wayzata Yacht Club Big Island 1 * :m •.Vi; '. j' ■ !. .. -V • SIS i •;■ ^ T j ■ . >1 t V Nest moved. McDonald^bonded recoenendation thatfIs f Vnmrihu #^>25: !••»• wit** •'“"'•1 ' y T "V Conditional Use for the life of the review, that no pernanent structure e exeantion of a portable chemical toilet, no pernanent mooring or docking of boats . sail or motor with the exception of the owner, uho has the right to his own dockage. Motion, Ayes "^»P^(7)r Nay (0). i . -I •v; - # • >' V.« f. •y’,'1*; ■^ Planning Commission, upon recomneiidatioh of Council wde further corment on the-Itennepin Codnty Transporta- SlTT-h : > ...e_______________________________________________________-.U •«__tion Study in relation to nopnlation and growth. The HENNEPIN CaOTY TRANSPOfTiATION STlIf»Y following cosnents were made: Vs' U# »• ‘ ••s' V «. m r- k jrin S' . . .Mis-Sv' V . . viv i . '1'' -m^wed, Pc North Shore Mai nsnhing Commii Ayms (5) - Nayi I It Paurus moved, f Shore Drive mai Motion,Ayes (SJ Paucua moved, V Star Marina lie Ayes (5) - Nays P-rurus Tioved, •i Marina license Ayes (5) - Mays Mr. Henry Muhic presented a sta street right-of Park Road. Welsh moved, Bi for a front anb Petrin, 1520 Lc Ayes (5) - Mays Welsh moved, Bu conditional use Compton, 4545 W hobby farro^ Mot Paurus moved, B\ variance for lot Overby, 567 Pari 1. Submitting i 2 • Removing exj Motion, Ayes (5) Butler moved. We split of Lot 61 Lot 61 and Lot 6 Chapter 39 and 1 to; Survey being fil Motion, Ayes (5) h ^ - ■ . *;^^ . V .• .A? *• ' / V ' •^* t • V. • ' mCHNL T ■pton »rtown Rd« . V i V * * ^ I •. • • fwby Une i .'. . N . '\ . • •.; .1 •>. ’ * 4% /«*• ‘ , - {rrh.y t i •« . •.* *: r (oYDiNMriol tackstron Ave. ) Orchard ■• #> Viv ' St. ' iif. - (• . > . m USE k'acht Club nd • t Cni!\TY lATm snif»Y mm I •V ‘'H‘ ^ 4 m i “1 .'•, * • v»U»*Nv' V • ^ viv a .4.4^ lltvj Li' ^:i; .. Sr. ..i i •. J Paurus seconded, toLefer the North Shore Marina buildincj permit to the Pfinhing Commission for study* notion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0)• NORTH SHORr: MARINA Building Perru*. Paurus moved, Welsh seconded, to extend North Shore Drive marina license to July 8, 1975* Motion,Ayes (5) - Nays (0). MARINA LICENSE North Shore Drive Paucus moved, V?elsh seconded, to extend North Star Marina license to July a, .^9'5. .Moti<Mi, Ayes (5) - Nays (0). MARINA LICENSE • North Star Manna Paurus rioved, Welsh secondee, to extend c.ayle*.- Marina license to July 8, 1975. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (C). IlARl'IA LICENSE Gaylt?*s i4arina ‘f . Mr. Henry Nuhich, Zoning and Building Administratfr, STREET VACATION presented a status report regarding vacation of 505 Orchard Park Road street right-of-way for Robert Eckert, 505 Orchar* Park Road. Welsh moved, Butler seconded, to approve a variance for a front and side yard setbacks for Richarti Petrin, 1520 Long Lake Boulevard. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0). VARIANCE 1520 Long Lake Boulevard Welsh moved, Butler seconded, to approve a conditional use permit and variance for Robert Compton, 4545 Watertown Road, for a stable and hobby farro^ Motion, Ayes (5'; - Ntiy:; (0) . CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT & VARIANCE 4545 Watertown Road Paurus moved, Butler seconded, to apt rovt a variance for lot arevi and wiJth for Audrey Overby, 567 Park Lane, subject to VARIANC i; 56 7 Jark L.^ncj 1. Submitting a survey. 2. Removing existing structure. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0)., Putler moved, Welsh seconded, to approve a lot Bplit of Lot 61 and ccxnbination of remaining Lot 61 and Lot 62 as one parcel and waiving Chapter 39 and 10% park dedication fees, subject to: LOT SPLIT 6 COMBINATION lOp^Orono Orchard Rd. & ,95 Smith Ave. Survey being filed. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0). U'v • J vt'j V*- ;< 1 m mM v: ? m f : I iti V. .V . ' • * • ♦%,. a*. Henry F, FROM A. P. 0] DATE:February SUBJECT: 1976 Bui Orono Building Feiv New Residences Residential Remod Residential Garag Conmercial Industrial (Addit Institutional (Ad ^4- Orono General Perni Sewer Connections Water Connections Well Installation Septic Installati Other Receipts (P i 4\(jontract Services ;:o New Residences Residential Remod Residential Garag< (ksnaercial Industrial ■ i r i r: r\AI?INA errur. \ ♦ e:nse B Drive SJSE Mar Ina • MvSE :ina iTION I Park Road «ake Boulevard . USE PERMIT & ;own :<oad no COHBINATIO:; rchard Rd. & 1 •4 ' A »; s '■■*;...v.v.---l tmtm M m- ,r:r: I •V < • ■ • FROM: DA3E: llenry F. Mlhich, Zoning Adninistrator a: P. Olson, Asst. Zoning Administrator February 1, 1977 SUBJECT: 1976' Building Inspection Services Orono Building Peimits 'ji- ‘mi i-:. •> 1: Nar Residences Residential Remodeling $ Additions Residential Garages Cosnercial Industrial (Addition) Institutional (Addition) 1976 Total (1975 Total Orono General Peimits Sei#er Connections Water Connections Well Installations Septic Installations Other Receipts (Plumbing, SAC, etc.) V'^aluation $2,559,532 988,245 130,100 1,000,000 25,000 259,000 $4,961,877 $2,229,700) (Super Valu Wayzata Country Club) (Van Dale, Inc.) (Orono School - Athletic Field) 1976 Total (1975 Total 411 239) Contract Services Lonf» Lake Minnetonka Reach New Residences Residential Remodeling fi Additions Residential Garages Gomnercial Industrial Sui) Total 39 Total Contract Projects: 53 i§ ■ ■ t S' § #226 \ ^ #229 *** r TO Bf SCNVCOV mmn m...mmm.r“ffv^(5 I m w.■^ii’*Tt1i;^iiyfitlilMl:p*^' -^1^; "-^V ' j»>' 3 WH449. 'v^' PARK Kmjiii k£ '- * \1t^ \*0* 0- •' »£? \„ V4CAM Bio> Ha iM,H.443 "”\\ wrr I9I.I.A ItCA --.. V JitT or M H i LtMo \ c*a? AtV MHM8 \ \ AH j;‘A“ A j ......A* !! :I 1 i .......... ; i ;__ i k*MR*if:T;rrr.ij zsz-:!::'► —-*A-................. s^iii . \\n- f('8'7 |S SI p2|,£3 Hi i'i- i J llii'HH'; a :i i r I. ■ * ■ j 7 U.. <• „ ./. /> ,. V ■ -> ,:^*^:'L:-'.xi- U: ~.Ux-;-:i..i•as&-< ■ ■;'r<4 W^m...^•■V;.•* ^ * Tys^-^-^j* X< • • * • f V;-,-* ;v,‘‘^-^‘*'*'V t*w* j4 '-• ‘ '•'%'’vr V *• f;^' ^ - - V' ■' -'Si •• - ''A .» V.