The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About11-27-1978 Planning Packet1 AGENDA PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING OF NOVEMBER 27, 1978 COUNCIL CHAMBERS - 7:30 P.M. CALL TO ORDER X* Call to Order/Roll r Comprehensive Planning Comments PUBLIC HEARING - 7:30 P.M. #444 ACTION ITEMS #429 #43S X #441 /•#445 X #446 STREET VACATIONS John Noble, 1185 Fcmdale CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT & VARIANCE VARIANCE #441 John 0. Loughlin, 4215 Forest Lake Drive VARIANCE VARIANCE VARIANCE SKETCH PLAN REVIEW ^ #431 Gerald P. Mills, 1600 Shoreline Drive SUBDIVISION , #440 Louis B. Oberhauser, 200 Wayzata Boulevard SUBDIVISION 11. #442 Donald Scott, 2325 Longview Circle SUBDIVISION 12. #443 Robert Olson, 4665 Bayside Road SUBDIVISION APPROVAL OF MINUTES 13. Meeting of November 13, 1978 Pr VILLAGE (OF OMNO rV ».M» v:-t:"::rr^ iriLMAM T WrLLS V*kk«M li». Wt* 1 1 I TO;Planning Commission and Council FROM:Alan P. Olson, Village Planner DATE:November 16, 1978 SUBJECT: #444 - Road Vacation Hennepin County Park Reserve District - Big Island This application is made to vacate all of the public roads in an area of the west island which is now owned by the Park Reserve. The area is platted into ten (10) separated lots which are divided by the subject roads. The Park Reserve's intentions are to have the roads vacated to permit combination of the lots into one buildable/saleable loti In the past, Orono has declined to vacate any public property on the island pursuant to Resolution #446 calling for eventual public ownership. This application appears to be contrary to this intent with the Park District actvially divesting itself of land. Their intention appears to be a land trade between this parcel and another unidentified parcel on the west island. Perhaps a "trade" of access should be considered to justify any vacation.I As to the buildability of this "lot" after vacation, there is a small area of wetlands along the inlet but the remaining area would exceed two acres. Septic testing would be required prior to any building permit application. ^i\ m t jbdivision of I s.f Kitchels Subdivision Snd Lake Minnetonka/ ''’49Misc.393)*— Ptottt4 Short Um For dttoll of Kota aPlummoro SubS oot roeorS plot VllloU ol ORONO^HENM. CP. PARK RE^oeVH. APP’ROK. 2.5 AC WCL.Ra41>S I LAK£ MINNETONKA •• t 4 4r \*i • • m /I 4 \ . . .A..L.... §gfW ;«wi 'I A ) j i^na Use Application W>CATI0N of proposal (or property L MiAT&as'-West Island. Btq Island L^..4 PE OP REQUEST ibdivision $150+$5/ l*gal Description _P1at .42980. nsn toili^ «™®-SS"JSLl£Ut_ Tei Box 296. Haal. Pl.i- MS ct.c. OWNER Name Same Mailing Address Present Zoning LA-lA-1 Tel # ditional Use $50 _ _ Variance $50 _ _ Rezoning $250 ___ Riprap $15 ($65) VAC4sT»^ /A- pee MIIU Date Rec'd. By_______ % Present Use , Unimproved zoning Ordinance Section Relating to Request 92.200 a,............ Specify ordinance Requirements Platted road vacation raoulr... a , "■ajorlty of the land owners abuttlr.9 the property to be vacated. VARIANCE required _ _ lot Area __ _Width extent of nonconformity _ _ _ Setback Front Side Other, explain Rear Specify hardships to property SUBDIVISION application Residential Other, explain No. of Lots CONDITIONAL USE AND OTHER - explain proposed use of property in detail .Hennepin Coenty,l»ar4 R»erye Oiytrlrt intends tn dl„..t on the west Island of BI9 Island as per Board action on Harch 8 1978 MINIMm MATERIAL NECESSARY FOR COMPLETE APPLICATION (Must be submitted 10 days prior to Planning Commission meeting) Application completed Plat map section Certificate of survey of property sketch location and setbacks of proposal Construction plans, if applicable DATS 5. Certified Property Otmer's lis^ ovmers within (300*) (150*)- f; Hennepin Co. Dept, of Finance A-603 Government Center 6. Stamped, legal sized envelopes (] pre-addressed to each of the n on the above list. HATE Applicant's Signature Owner's Signature and Cbuncil necessarv to nro ^ City Attorney, Plaxming Gomaiss all fea. as L 1 EWIBIT A "1.tC Lots 1 - 10 inclusive of Kate B. Plunwner Subdivision, of Lot 2 Ketchel's Subdivision of Government Lots 5 and 6, Section 22, Township il7, Range 23, City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota. •■V \ r^' ! . C L 1 a:axc-R!■SOM'. ION /• .^. i30.1'TJON ’ /.Fprcr. *MG T!i) Cf'NCtf'T '.»! J IG I.>L\Ki) A i I'A'lr: L.: ]. vni* i"' ‘?;;3 ''ll.'.jc cl 0. ".no ’iriRt t is in ziM pnblic : uri.jM . o; 0-ov -.iift L sl ii.J Le:c’fe t oiiUit [••* ■ % 7 S ''.''•..•’i'-C -■iJ . ir 1 ii- j '■ •1 r ^ i .p *.• f : i '.' ‘ 1 Ml 'h «;c-.1 a »Kiaui .III tin. i-V? ri-. ic .-il ■ r •. 0 r b ? .I V: !• Jin - i S 1 i; :;».’:u w It ii f»t; J r.at l • j: i :. i i ii- -: olM:t-nan f.: <• . . t e t •rent ; .:vf ; •: t •••! rn:- r in ! »*:' r \ci -nl .•- i ■*: Ct » f-c c:. a;i;j :r T am?V i’Z...il’.' }.».-rs •j Tc •c fro. : r' t •IfK.f. •.:1i m: • • •• :m. - .. :. • ■ i 4 •• •“I ll K.-so: -.? ■; he : t c '’i..■:f ♦« 1. ri; 1. r-ja:•.'CiTCr .:ii !. -.la lOtf;i‘ -i?.*es -. a.’ 1 -. i ( j.i *:Iri p:J JtJTl r,c =i C - ? I •• 2 t U:V • ■! .o; .“ii ;:n‘i^e- M :-it t’.( f? »-Ic >u *1 I2 adrii j s > ?r j J b' f. i a:,...ic^' t.v.Uii./ i^de ann wnuM njjiove c f iti ru..t ny }]i a Cainty Ph‘n .itivirvc O: strlc't: A !oT "--1 •-■fK V. 1 .M-;o Coi: K'»'‘ cr rl^e ' c: Drear. ‘Ir’arasoi a ar ? 7. j« ?7.r ''':c ;inp In u! ;iay 2" *ii >2 !.cu j s *”*i H<r: r • WkS-. 1:. i pn TvT;r -7:..;?,’A.I.* ^ J I HENNEPIN COUNTY PARK RESERVE DISTRICT P.O. BOX 2B6 • MAPLE PLAIN. MINNESOTA 5S359 • TELEPHONE 4T3-4693 o 4 August 2A, 1978 BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS AJDITH 8. ANDERSON CHAIRMAN BLOOMINGTON CHARLE8R P»«. VCC CHAIRMAN ORONO WV.UAM BARBCAU GOLOCN VALUV AMEUAM D«MU8i MINNCAPOUS OAVD OURENBEROER MINNEAPOLIS ALAN K GREENE MOUND LAWRENCE F HAEO RoeeiNSOAU JUNEHEOSTROM MfNNEAPOLB UBAHDLLEND^ MiNNEAPOLB RAYMOND N. SEAQREN MINNEAPOLIS CLFTONE . FRENCH SUPCRINTENOCNT Mr. Walter R. Benson City Administrator City of Orono Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 rick: g@iovg i AUG 197a yiOAGG OB OBOUQ ★ As you know, the Hennepin County Park Reserve District currently owns a parcel of land located on the west Island of Big Island on Lake Minnetonka described as Lots I - 10 inclusive of Kate B. Plummer Subdivision, of Lot 2 Ketchcl's Subdivision of Government Lots 5 and 6, Section 22, Township 117, Range 23, City of Orono, Hennepin County, Minnesota. Enclosed Is a half section map identifying the above-described property. On March 8, 1978, the District's Board of Commissioners established boundaries for Big Island Regional Park. The proposed park will be located entirely on the eastern island. At the same time, tlie District's Board of Commissioners declared the existing land holding on the western island as surplus and authorized the Superintendent to petition the District Court for approval to sell this property. District Court approval has been obtained and we are proceeding to put together a transaction for the sale of this property. The sale of this parcel is tied directly to the District's purchase of a parcel located within the park acquisition boundaries. In order to combine Lots 1 through 10 of Kate B. Plummer Subdivision into a single marketable building site, the District hereby requests the City of Orono to vacate the platted roadswithin the subdivision. Enclosed is a completed land use application form, a map depicting the plat, a certified property owners list of owners within 300 feet, a petition of concurrence from the abutting land owner and stamped pre-addressed envelopes. We hope to be able to proceed with this vacation at your earliest convenience in order to meet a property closing date of on or before October i, 1978. Hr. Walter R. Benson - 2 -August 2^, 1978 I assume that, as in the past, fees associated with the processing of this request will be waived. Thank you for your attention to this matter. If you have any questions regarding this request, please give me a call at 473~^693> Sincerely, G^gor^3*^. Mack Administrative Assistant GAM:ghd End. •I •i 1 4^ C PETITION CONCURRING WITH THE PROPOSED VACATION OF ROADS WITHIN KATE B. PLUHHERS SUBDIVISION* CITY OF ORONO, HENNEPIN COUNTY* MINNESOTA. I (we)* the undersigned* owner (s) of property adjacent to Lots I through 10* Inclusive* Kate B. Plunmers Subdivision* of Lot 2 Ketchel's Subdivision of Government Lots 5 and 6 In Section 22* Township 117* Range 23* City of Orono* Hennepin County* Minnesota* do hereby concur with the Hennepin County Park Reserve Oistrict's request to vacate the platted roads within the Kate B. Plummer Subdivision. / /7g" (DaW L_ _ U d a HENNEPIN COUNTY PARK RESERVE DISTRICT P.O. BOX 2tl • MAPLE PLAIN, MINNESOTA SS3Sf • TELEPHONE 473*4693 BOARD OF COMMISSIONERS JUDITHS ANDERSON CHAIRMAN SLOOMINGTON CHARLESaPSC VICE CHAIRMAN ORONO mUAMBARBSAU ST LOUIS PARK 6HPUY A BOMNE MAPU PLAIN AMELIA M 0«MLI8E MINNEAPOL0 DA VC DURENBEROER MINNEAPOLM ALANK GREENE MOUND LAWRENCE F. HAEO RoeeiNSOAU JUNEHEOSTROM MINNEAPOL0 UBANOLLENO0I MINNEAPOUi RAVMOION MINNEAPOUi OLTrONE. FRENCH SUPERmTENOENT #444 October 6, 1978 MO® Hr. Walter R. Benson City Administrator City of Orono Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 XT i-) ORONO. Dear Dick: A short time ago, I spoke to you regarding the waiver of the City's application fee for processing the District's request ror vacation of roads within Kate B. Plummer's Subdivision located on the west Island, Big Island. As you know, this property was purchased by the District a few years ago when the intention was to eventually acquire the entire Big Island area as a regional park. On March 8, 1978, the District's Board of Commissioners officially established boundaries for Big Island Regional Park. These boundaries were established after considerable discussion and review, including a joint public InfonnatPon meeting held with the City of Orono in February of 1978. The proposed park will be located entirely on the eastern Island. Since the parcel located on the western island was no longer within the proposed boundary, the Board declared this land surplus and authorized the Superintendent to-petition District Court for approval to sell this property. Subsequently, an acquisition was negotiated whereby the District would trade its ownership on the west island for property located within the proposed park boundary on the east Island. Included In this negotiation was the stipulation that the District would attempt to have the roads vacated on the surplus property located on the west island. The District Board feels that in view of the heavy expenditures the District is making to acquire parkland on Big Island that Orono could show Its interest in this project by waiving the fee. Thanks for what you can do in getting this requested granted. Sincerely, (UU CEF:ghd Clifton E. French Superintendent and Secretary to the Board DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE A-603 GOVERNMENT CENTER MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55487 -Ff PROPERTY OWNERS LIST L ------------- y --------------------------------------------------- DESCRIPTION j IWU:ADDRESS LOT I BLK.PARCEL ;> SciBVNiSiOfi • 0"F Gov/fi^K niENl LOTS S' AND 5Z CTI6N Z2-//7-Z^ _ . ( AT ^zzvoo) ^------------------——# ^---------------— ■ ■■ ■■ -------------------------------------——- B. F. PfWSO’l T?MJUNo&nmsi U-tABiShS^/^-' _3l 1000 ■*—^--------------------------------------------------- — pMrviFf^S SUB- OlVfS/OK/ OP LOT 2. OP jUB'DlMlSlOKl (MSjr " 1 1^________________.#--------------------------------------------------------- r —si^—------------------------------------------------- ^assTsSS ! !00^ TRISTIU ae^ICKSt .HShi io. T^tasr; 1 MP‘S ^SIO £AmejitL<^AflEhlT OP LCrri KI TC -H-EL5 5i(^6DlV(5(6)«/ - JjA^T'^3000) ' hiCK U). le3rT)Rt: 7. U_____________1 ~dszo1HHlgili eorttfictit ••• gal^ rtpTMtnMton d Wan«d •tkMl it H iP^^ Wt oCTf 0.1 i*io MOPf* of tha MMiw Co. fHwnc* •aikoiif. HpfllV CP. »»*» I j ft. TO; FROM: DATE: Planning Connnlsslon and Council Jeanne Mabusth, Asst. Zoning Administrator November 20, 1978 SUBJECT: #429 - John Noble, 1185 Femdale Road Variances & Conditional Use Permit (Revised Plan) The second plan submitted by Mr. Noble Is basically the same as the original submittal minus the excess paving. The house and pool remain the same. The house has been turned around so that the garage is now on the east side of lot allowing for a more efficient entrance with less paving. The holding tank and well must be relocated because both fall within the Flood Fringe Area. In relocating the well, consideration must be given to the location of neighbor's septic dralnfleld to the east. The applicant should consult with staff's septic inspector before locating the new sight. Staff would recommend against the hardcover violation of 75' lakeshore setback in favor of moving the house further north. We would prefer granting a variance from the 26' wetland setback than waiver on the 75' lakeshore setback. Zoning District LR-IA - 2 Acres A. List of Variances Hardcover Variance:0-75' - 10,725 s.f. Allowed ■ 0 s.f. Proposed • 450 s.f. (4.5X of total) 100% Variance 75'-250' > Allowed < Proposed* Variance* 22,350 s.f. 5,588 s.f. (25%) 5,690 s.f. (house) 1,740 s.f. (pool) 1.613 s.f. (driveway) 9,043 s.f. (40.5% of total) 3,455 s.f. (15.5% more than permitted) m F November 20, 1978 John Noble 1185 Ferndale Road Variances 6e Conditional Use Permit Page 2 A. List of Variances (Cont.) I i Side Yard Variances (both sides) Required: 30' Proposed: 20' Variance: 10' ** 33-1/3% Lot Width Variance Required: Proposed: Variance: Buildlnix Site 200' 155' . 23% Along 200' 140' Lakeshore 45'60' » 30% Lot Area Variance Required: Proposed: Variance: 87,120 s.f. 45.980 s.f. (total area excluding pond) 41,140 s.f. - 47% Holding Tank Variance A holding tank is an approved alternate system but requires a variance as stated in the Septic Ordinance. B. Conditional Use Permit Conditional Use Permit required for filling and grading ''^^hin the Flood Fringe (Flood Plain Management Ordinance) and su^ect to DNR review. The Flood Fringe in the application would be the land between the 929.4 contour and the 931.5 contour line. Please note same setback rule applied for McDonald construction (site plan enclosed). u TO: FROM: Planning Commission and Council Jeanne Mabusth, Asst. Zoning Administrator DATE:November 20, 1978 SUBJECT: #438 - Paul Clabo, 1388 Park Drive Variance Mr. Clabo requests variance for lot area and lot width for Lot 18, Block 13, Saga Hill, to build a house. The lot has been assessed one hookup and one sewer unit charge. The surrounding lots have been combined and are not available for sale. Staff would like to call attention to the steep grade along- street access line. Applicant should consult with public works director concerning a curb cut for entrance. Mr. Clabo should be advised that once a variance is granted, the City will not consider future variances. Zoning District LR-IB Lot Area Variance - 34.452 Required: Existing: Variance: 43,560 s.f. 8.305 s.f. 35,255 s.f. - 80Z Lot Width Variance - 34.452 Required: Existing: Variance: 140' 55’ 85' (at building site) - 607. Lstrator lot width for Lot 18, .ot has been assessed irrounding lots have !ep grade along street public works director j should be advised that c consider future variances. ^wAicax:ion _ 1388 Park nr,vo Legal Description Block 13, Saea Hill “Kevxstid, Orono—-- -- - - -- applicant Name Paul C. Clabo Mailing -- - - Address 20th Avenue South St. Llond, MN—5 b3g l--------- (612) Tel #253-01^ OWNER Name Paul C. Claho Mailing ~ Address TYPE OF REQUEST ---- Subdivision $150+$5/to1 % __ Conditional Use $50 ^ Variance $50 _ Rezoning $250 Riprap $15 ($65) Tel # Present Zoning FEE ^^O.QC ^ Date Rec * d H yp Present Use vacant Zoning Ordinance Section Relating to Request Specify Ordinance Requirements Explain your request and reasons for same That I be allowed a v»rianr» upon the property. Purchased property In 1969, and at the time a __ _ _ -to. ten nr°hMil” cottage and now am in a position VARIANCE required X Lot Area Width extent of nonconformity . _ __ Setback Front_ _ _ __ Otbef,. explain Side Rear resilintiSf ^ SUBDIVISION application Residential Other, explain No. of Lots CONDITIONAL USE AND OTHER •• exolain .sca .. •expraxn proposed use of property in detail 1 2 3 MINIMUM MATERIAL NECESSARY FOR COMPLETE APPLICATION (Must be submitted 10 days prior to Planning commission meeting) s/certifled Property Oaner*s list ol owners within (150*)- from Hennepin Co. Dept, of Finance A-603 Government Center 6. g/Stamped, legal sized envelopes(#lf P^®"*®*^*Lressed to each of the namei on the 2d>ove list Application completed yPlat map section ^^Certificate of survey of property s^®bch location and setbacks of proposal ^.|yQc>»«»Lxuction pianwT—t-S-^appH , Applicant's Signature/^^^ (^ ^ DATE Offer's Signature Applicant hereby agrees to provide all infoiroation required or reouested bv * all fees as established ordinance. as^^ees ro pay i \ Pl.t of Sur\e;r' for rr.ui C. Ciabo of I«ot 1£, Plor< 13, oafu Hill Revised Her.r.opin Countv, Kinncsot* Certificate of Survey: I hsreb;,' certify that thie is a true and corrvrt representation of a to snow otncr inprovements or ercrr.bchr.ants. Scale: Cate : o : 1" = 50' IC-23-78 Iron virker Oordon R. Coffin Be/yUz.. 606064 ^Ivin ?..• herder Rat:, Co.13295 i^.nc Surve^. orr and Plannars iionr ^ ice, Kinnesota ' ►; • i;.! 1 J stj- 54^7 (H)' jp kj?3:Ct!: -K— ■ O.. « • iEE* mo •f msi i'Or' a cM* Ky*» #<f ^ MSSO* t“Sjf 0 *■ r > ■ rt^ r«t. l*raIsik^yite ^ h/4»jpa -Jr^ i i ^liLS i3ga H ,r"«U*EIIKl>lf * •.IJ-i^'y .WWARO IU*EI NCSS. DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE A-603 GOVERNMENT CENTER MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55487 so J-L PROPERTY OWNERS LIST • ^43‘S- NAME W /v-^ c^uW>? yF^<//e ^/TaqeyagVj^ ADDRESS ^Qg\ DESCRIPTION LOT [4ji{»«i^ S./irrftes/ifJ A y. >//MC£//r’ Johl^Soj/ l/9/y'£'_______ ^ Cz^gq X/3 ^citA/^sy^y /St'O- «• •• /ft / S^fji 62sr. • IQ^ a A6 _ BLK. PARCEL J3fa - Dtt ySSZ’/^/^/yf . A/.0 • V nW' I LiH- \ \% \^otolQ H- ^ <^;Am.vo\\ KAA, )uh^^ &.Nect/7ZPAf V\?^\r- A? A^0U0j}S%'. /S^S' - ' \ iCSLa^^U-^ ial-?.6on isssas .ISlISCpO Irsl^CoAO ISJiTlO \ laepo 1 Ronn I C€rm tht fi V on ot^ Bfe a^'d tfj«» reJ eser.tMi U'n ft /YBrea^s tf'K fe:ords of the Hann. besi Of n y iQUira rep'e ei an ac:urkta I TO: FROM: DATE: f Planning Conmission and Council Jeanne Mabusth, Asst. Zoning Administrator November 20, 1978 SUBJECT: #441 - John 0. Loughlin, 4215 Forest Lake Drive Variance Mr. Loughlin requests a front yard setback variance for a proposed addition to his home. The addition involves adding an additional stall to the garage and a study to the west side of the existing house, "niere exists now a 29.31'setback at the northeast corner, house was constructed before 35' setback was established. The addition would be 27.8' from the northeast comer and gradually increase to 35' at a midway point of the total width of the structure. The setback distance increases to 43.9' at the northwest comer. Hardship claim - existing house location on the lot. Zoning District LR-IA Variance: Front Yard Setback Required: Proposed: Variance: 35' 27.8' 7.2'20.5% S-- ■* a tor 3ke Drive ice for a proposed Lng an additional of the existing northeast comer, ablished. The r and gradually idth of the .9' at the northwest lot. I t ■’ ■ Land Use Application • (d^^roperty) Thr-^€T Ul:^ 0/7/ ^ ^ . ioT^V - QLoO. 3 Legal Description Te^^jT Ar m< c^u^Tr^ eiuL TYPE OF REQUEST Subdivision $1504$S/tofc % Conditional Use $50 : n Variance $50 _ _ Rezoning $250 Address —7b Xal^e. Qn^ ~ Hound- ^_ _ Riprap $15 ($65) FEE 1^0. 06 applicant Name,-loll>7 O. loua^iL.^ Tel Mailing OWNER Name Mailing Address Tel # Present Zoning — I Date Rec ®y Present Use i?g s ,J m.r>l~tcx.t- Zoning Ordinance Section Relating to Request QBD Specify Ordinance Requirements s<£rhac.)b }iXoJL “Tin 'T'fyg^ JLA/t_^'T7At Explain your request and reasons for same “TJvucJLj ~ru VARIANCE required — extent of nonconformity _ _ Lot Area V Setback Front ><' Side _ _ Width- Rear Other, e9q>lain Specify hardships to property ~fLu ^ • yy-'-O^ Sy:>A-r€^ —> "TJua/) TUsi-/jiJ. j a:^ SUBDIVISION application Residential Other, explain NO. of Lots CONDITIONAL .USE AND OTHER — explain proposed use of property in detail MINIMUM MATERIAL NECESSARY FOR COMPLETE APPLICATION (Must be submitted 10 days prior to Planning Commission meeting) 1.Application completed Plat map section Certificate of survey of property •hetch location and setbacks of proposal Construction plans, if applicad>le 5. Certified Property CVner*s list of owners within (300*) (150*)- from Hennepin Co. Dept, of Finzmce A-603 Government Center 6. Stamped, legal sized envelopes(#10! pre-addressed to each of the nauaes on the above list. /5 ^ /^yP' Applicant's Signature j pate /-S' /^7/" Owner's Signature ^ ^f\ i * Applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or reqwstsdi^ the Zoning Administrator, City Engineer, City Attorney, Planning Commission and Council necessary to process this application and further agrees to pay all fees as established .by ordinance. 5/78 M- ^-Zd.ZCt-c-nJ irrv-tZ^ u-^Ovt^ y\JU^ 0-'V</2^ ~7l^Je^ j2yyZi<x^ 'Tlsjt. ”7^ ^j2/UAC^fZZ 3 J CZ: 1%JL^ N B <Lff-r?\xy>z^ s 7y^<-<Zoc/tjc^ UrM^ J27. P/ .^4^ 7^ A/. B . Cl^<rTO’'^t/U , ~y%je-^ ^ TTut, <2->— TI jl . c^ t Ll . dyziL. ~tm :> TIjL. 9 5 HZ’ ykjt. M. OiJ CLo'T''>'^‘C/Zy^ 'yt^ y^'Cyr^ 0<r'>\^^-rn'>xxZ<^ Ov-K^iiL. ^ ^ I ! Jt. . I HOWARD MTPERKINSV . mM mm TIiTtHlI* TT^tTtlTIiriJ mrr.FTK ‘^•£‘‘5*-». >c<.4*>fc- •- mm bk» TO: FROM: Planning Commission and Council Jeanne Mabusth, Asst. Zoning Administrator #445 DATE:November 20, 1978 SUBJECT: #445 - Patrick C. Baxter, 4120 Oak Street Variance Mr, Baxter has submitted an application for an area and width variance on a four lot combination in the Minnetonka Summit Park plat. The applicant has submitted a site plan for the proposed house showing a right side yard of 35' and a left side yard of 10'. Staff requests that he reverse the side yard setbacks. The left side yard abutts an improved public access, whereas the right side yard abutts an unimproved alley access. ZonlnK District LR-lB Lot Area Variance: Required: 43,560 s.f. Proposed: 34.404 s.f. Variance: 9,156 s.f.2U Lot Width Variance: Required: Proposed: Variance: 140' 105' 35' - 25Z 'i C..:.iJr—H .s rator reet area and width tonka Svunmlt plan for the and a left se the side proved public nImproved Land Use ^wlication • ^TICN OP PROPOSAL (or property) Address Legal Description LnlS I 7^ y 4fyVAtrc?(UkL4- Klocjz ^ Variance $50 ^OF REQUEST ^ision $150 ’f$5Aot m Ifioiial Use $50 r Tel # Address / '^oaxsMi^-> Tn_ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ __ Rezoning $250 Riprap $15 ($65) CWNER Name^ ^dL /Lrr^.,^ a Mailing Address Tel #FEE ■3' ^ , CC^ Date Rec'd By Present Zoning (i'^ \ (K Present Use Zoning Ordinance Section Relating to Request 3 ~ Specify Ordinance Requirements ) /✓<) Explain your request and reasons for same k t^,’ (J ^iJl^ VARIANT required - extent of nonconformity w ^Lot Area y/^ Width Setback Front Other, e3q>lain Side Rear Specify hardships to property SUmiviSlON application Residential explain No. of Lots CONDITIONAL USE AND OTEIER proposed use of property in detail MINIMUM MATERIAL NECESSARY FOR COMPLETE APPLICATION (Must be submitted 10 days prior to Planning Commission meeting) Application completed Plat map section Certificate of survey of property ®^t®tch location and setbacks of proposal Construction plans, if applicable Certified Property Owner's list of owners within (9M^) (150*)- from Hennepin Go, Dept, of Finance A-603 Government Center Stamped, legal sized envelopes (#10) pre-addressed to each of the on the/above list. DATE DATE (Xmer's Signature and Council necessary to process this application and further agrees to pay all fees a« established.!^ ordinance. - - Ok- .. • . I ^ v» X fflmH O ■n $ I 0 rm 5 cn 1C CO m > >oo 0 s1 zo 3mcn 5mzom O•n O' f o > Hm ■c #445 1^*0^ S fj f| tl H \(j>t>.0^ m m H imMm^t 7/a f7\il 'WL ^ M • A \ C\p<VS' DEPARTMENT OF FINANCE A-603 GOVERNMENT-&LER MINNEAPOLIS. Ml£®^ \3Sn^4-PROPERTY OWNERS LIST ADDRESS -C2SZ31 l5d DESCRIPTION o O rnnf LOT BLK. PARCEL 'gr'o 6.S/>L'^.O Sloo y uJ. /ou 5;tJ~ ■ fhfl>5 ‘SV3 7 V^£X/CZ6 J. F/eAffT^r cjaataja fMA^ELLT.m/UAAi /S7df Scccm CAAJt ’ /hTAr/l ■ jsyj 7 BCT/fAtiy ^€LLo USfAtP ✓------------------------------------------------- mp/s , bSJLC Accrv e.ccLT~ejr. tiJC. /.g. 6ehnpeTTt\^^]M'^°,'^^J^ ssV3t '6mA ny Feuttisui, y/^ DfkyllD f. m/S(JL THtnAS o^fttfAnu THM)AS K. UtLLiAny. 'AMi$ HAVeS J^£JI3L3 >^ tvAtLD .'n^. / DAMtC> P. /DAlSL£j d. CcAyAooL^, i U. fh. * yJbHiiJ <T- ^4LZlJ^jflc^ 3tHh) kT. Pe-tri V9f /^/eAT AfiAf^ LAKt SS^yrL <3-_U^Q i^oo I b I lupn 3 [.3 I non ^ p ia‘=>g~^ iL^Ti^oo i^tso L5 ]^on yjis' To'yUKAt*^A £.7T. 6aAf6 CA/^ty Vsts- 7liA//('y1iiJA s7tL jL6a >£ c/t/rA. \<t. /Lf I 777 AAAA' LA a S Zj>a /6> LA a CL. £AKiyLA/7t. I bnon A. IvS ^7# i^nnjz^ i .1:^ l<^\(/>0 ^/a. HoAH iAys SS3^3 V/// OAKSr. APTA SS33Cf Th/nf)S fi. UJtLt/Ams V/// CAKST. SS3S-6> / 7 ft/ oAKsr. J-H7A ^727 ^LO Au. /35/2ZJL, s^voy Si SsSlOO I -343300 K<ar:5l 7e>^ To/J^AWA ad . I, ^ ' I----------------- 723" TCA)/^AcJ7i723" TCA)/CAUf f^o76 LAKL SS33i,Xy^cjcJ44 .i?SCO 400^ OftMsct t*i« f«4 rnspr Ohf^ to tha boat of n y Iuk>»i« ii Honiij Co. Divisic i> I M n #446 TO: FROM: DATE: Planning Commission and Council Jeanne Mabusth, Asst. Zoning Administrator November 22, 1978 SUBJECT: #446 John A, Worre, 1270 Arbor Street VARIANCE Mr. Worre requests a 7’ front yard and a 10' side yard setback variance for the purpose of constructing a 36' X 26' attached garage. There Is a single car detached garage on the north side of the house with a 1.8' setback from the neighbor's lot line. He plans to retain this building and use It for storage. The house Is located within a two-acre minimum lot zone (RR-IB). Applicant's lot Is a little over 1/3 acre (14,700 s.f.), the Arbor Street neighborhood consists of similar sized lots (review plat map). Zoning District - RR-lB Front Yard Variance - 34.840 Required:50' Proposed:43' Variance:7' - Side Yard Variance -34.840 Required:30' Proposed:20' Variance:10' - : U% 33-1/3Z 1 ff: ■2 j; 4 H trator de yard setback X 26* attached on the north neighbor's lot ! it for storage. lot zone (RR-IB), 00 s.f.), the ized lots (review Land Use Application • .locaiiob of proposal (or prop^f A /I /I . request Address A MRLICAN t HameJ. ZZ \ «*' ^ -^I-------:--------------Rezonlng $250 CWNER Ncune Mailing Address Present Zoning Mailing Lk~i / Riprap $15 ($65) PEE Present Use 0<T- zonin, ordinance Section Relating to Request Specify Ordinance Requirements Explain your request and reasons for same ■6/ - VARlAN^ re^^ed - exteny,f nonconformity — Wdtf'“ • Front'Setback Front___ side Other, e9q>lain Rear -------------— — r JLii ________ Specify hardships to property ** ^ ^Lf ^ ZL^ ^ ^ Vm ^ ^ ^ ^ /A-f^4C2. SUBDIVISION application Residential Other, explain No, of Lots CONDITIONAL USE AND OTHER - explain proposed use of property in detail (Must be“s^S:“’'M“ay3 ““o^/°J ‘"°f APPLICATIONays prior to Planning Commission meeting) Application completed Plat map section Certificate of survey of property sketch location and setbacks of proposal Construction plans, if applicable 6. OATS DATE A-603 Government Center Stamped, legal sized envelopes(#10) <■ Applicant's Signature <X#ner's Signatur, the ^ning Administrator, City Engineer ^i^*Att” *^®^^*^®** requ^^~^ «d ^uncll necessary to pro«ss mn^pUc^tlo^ “S'; all fees as established by ordinance. rcatlon and further agrees to pay % i r- n #1 1 • I A ^ CALVIN H. HEDLUND 1*1*4 D.tl ti*|in*«#446 ^1t Owloofc ta^f ClfcN tloommfto#\. Minn^ota SMS? •sa ?oso Sumtfors Certificate 'I XDI NO. > SUtviY foil John Worre DESCriCD AS) Lots 9 and 10, Block • 1, CRYSTAL BAY HINN7:TOh ’KA, City of Orono, Hennopin County, Minn- tota, snd reserving the drainage* and utility car.-'T.i''’nta as sho}*Ti_j3n the record plat thf-rcof, ^ --------------—"iqi_2i3.. XkjM Fi»j % X«50 > .. *7- 1/1 4.C' / Z*.^Z "7 ^.C’/" 0 > ; 1.1 * %i.e'—^ • L Zo7' // ^ ♦ • / i? MtAS. )t.4 - IW.0-.X R <*• sj P t sj _______ Lq.ng. CIITIFICATI of SUKVIY 1976 *nd th« thribLrjuri.”Torr«t dt.crlbtd Abovt 7 I jT •wifcv«jr« Calvin H. Hcdlund, Minn. Reg. No. 5942 _ _ _ A H • m • ---V— ■ Mi lUVJ. nr, it ] • l m I • ■ i*’''•ju-*' • -^1 ii-r" j- ■ '-i'^ ?fJ.-FSa, ■;«jrfii ■mM *f :^Jv .^alr*^- -V^i DESCRIPTION x:Lye^Vc=^\1?v=:4> T6a)J tf ^/*i?/ijjfl Ttu)t) 6F r)P/itJ6 LOT BLK. PARCEL VfLCAGi} 6f^ /)iPA ViLLfibb bf d>/^£AjQ ^s-jA Lr>^<sJl:^i.!gL__ 5-.^. FAA^eu.jje. JhAXSMAf FAK^ rtc^jjl^./ASH AKStJ< jr. €CA4Jf^ A ^€TtASofJ __^jC£f06 /^// A^6d^ ST, V-otfe 14 a ^JM£LJ^Uo_eLtc \ Q2QQl 5iOQ OfcOO_ ljQ'g<9Ci ' IIQOQ ao n I ^ 1 li^nn^ /a ^QjQC) I laiiQO ■-3ior> :0O c <-4-$5io? b o^ \ob:^ 4 aj65ca_ CVj^sA Mas 40)4/C^ T, TfifTcMStL ^ AsP^f ^0HlJ Pi. 60L0lNiff CM£-01 &T^iAEt3£r Sii4^a isr^ fuAil of OF^dfJo L&lAfJkfPO fio, aaypj jSAysTflk SAy^sss ^ A^okXc,<\ r-l\r)->l'^-A=^ V_pb& 44-^ (-0 C-?Wt Sox/AS" ^ ^AysjRLj^Ay^ss Aj L.J 0*4^0 2J I certify thj t the fac 00 V^s cei ficate ar<an peculate and true reb^esentattn of Ir.f irma. lion as tt appears thi records of Otv., to Xhi •od beQtf Hem X)etejy^ .he Henn 4 0 in S(cCO hOOO represehted daic online Co. Fmafce r iy knowMuge Tn^ &l # A ________CJvO r>o DESCRIPTION LOT BLK. PARCEL J 5 LIq2QQ. 1 V s (d iiDQ_ |06 pOO_ j 1 IQOQ .L2=PO LJiUaO. I !Al .1 la<AOC^ ^lAlOO py 4 tSIQO m. ^'UUJ HC8S4 department of finance A-603 GOVERNMENT CENTER MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55487 PROPERTY OWNERS LIST L—tz > T NAME ADDRESS DESCRIPTION LOT BLK. PARCEL 4 Mtz ^^ 7^a)J bf e>fj)f^6 (LeysmL s/tv Se)(3¥ ^I JqqojC) *40 a TbuJi) t)f /)/f./)/J» V/l CA60 6/^ yiLtnkb bf ^£^AJt) P.g. Ke^SUA/A- 'OL ~ ~ * “ ^ PGpOQ \Q^O_ IDOO- 66X7 ’jaojQ d^si3L6e}Lst. fUcScLlJ - , PAK^cic. f <6, iL£3^L^/y/S3A63\ -Uot£>95ilO I (n^C ^ I i^nry^ /ASm AKBoC^f.LA sQ^QcXD f • w r ^ 9 r’- A AertASo/J \j3yy37A.^J3Ay SS3X ^6/ AB6dA sr KA < /n.A. ScoAnSc/J^ \2l M/ ABi OBotOo rc3.2^ /A7/ AKBdA. ST.Up\z,t^ I IP- —^AysTtLL_sAy MVa «i -^JtalQO if-ris i, lot.4ft0 Mc^Vcfri- ■-3IOO) ^-kS5-QC> L/C 6 r. TAircAeu. ^^£M^£sJiT!UAUj3A ^tlMcLSms. Al l Ly \avt >\56L^ 6 }?)A/C4(Jb£TTt I . sisyfd ... OM/J A). QoLOIf^iH 'MeA e. -__n. -V-CA-S> ncji___0tP.66V yLBXSTfikMy, SS3^3 ^jg.c4:-top> ouo-in-c^.^ U?\esfc ‘V\?>\6'\ AasV/^cT / iuAU or 6oX /AS~ J^y^ysML J$AX^ SS3 23 etif thppfj vo no DESCRIPTION I ctfUfy thi T lot BLK.1 PARCEL — ' ■' 1 ■■ Ij 1 jQi2QC —J J-Jo4oQ --------—---------------------...V OfoOO. •A ----------jV-X, ^ l-JlQOO —1 ^-Ljj^i-O.Q. s..1 1 3 1 (900^ Jl._ l \^aoC> -------------------—~-^Lk'iaQL -------------------— ■■■ —-------------3-UlOO Lo¥ 4 J:^5lOCL J-4drLcfr;5. ...^ 15*^00) t \ob0 D__ ^ j—------------ > Ql^O —Ls>\ OG=OC> s>_• ( ——----------- Z14010 S(cOO kOOO the feet. rep^esehte# Oil tMs cen ifkate ^ri ind true re >resentut Hon as ft a records of ^ars thi he Hann. t - ?. Gerald Mills 1600 Shoreline Drive Subdivision Page 2 #43^ PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING - OnTORFR 23. 1978 that the following Ite™ be noted L“‘rte p^eltZirrpLtr"""*" 1. 30' easement through Lot C be removed. '■ "'ie JUdlcaMd?''’ 3. A minimum of 200' of lakeshore for each lot. 4. Existing access is questionable. It will be reviewed after the County Highway Department makes their recornnenda t ion • 5. A, B, and C lakes access on Tanager Lake, access on Smith Bay.D and E lake SKETCH PLAN REVIEW 50-'ea%:^en?‘* designated as an outlet Lot areas - Lot 2's area is questionable since a 50’ road easement will eastern edge of the lot. The surveyor have to re-estimate the two acres of dry buildable for lots confideLwonf takei^nlo ”building“site?‘ ““ ■^®'=°’'ded elong lakeshore and at the Riparian rights - The easement through Lot 5 has been removed and e ch lot now has single lakeshore access. Existing buildings - Planning Commission should address the isau*» III Trl 'Within the 75' lakeshorrseJ^crand Thev intersected by Lots 3 and 4's mutual lot line either be removed before final approval or before resoliaSn.*’®”” issued. This should be stated in the final 1 J V i < ( TO: w Planning Commission and Council FROM:Jeanne Mabusth, Asst, Zoning Administrator DATE: November 20, 1978 SUBJECT:#440 - Louis B. Oberhauser, 200 Wayzata Boulevard Subdivision, Conditional Use Permit, Rezonlng & Variance Mr. Oberhauser has submitted a plan for a 12-unit condominixim ^ and four units in the Wayzata district. The project has also been submitted to the City of Wayzata for review. The entire parcel to be sewered by Wayzata, unite with a PRD development. Items for consideration: 1. Condominium ownership - structures owned by occupants but Country Club to own common space and underlying property \^t about the underground garage? 2. Four condominium units will have legal description involving two municipalities. 3. How to handle split authority: a) building code; b) police; c) taxes? 4. Femdale Green lot - should be platted as a single dwelling lot and division line drawn. 5, Access road to Orono units only through Wayzata. strator eata Boulevard , Rezonlng & Variance mit condominium * Orono and 4 acres 1 on the Orono side >roject has also been The entire parcel applicant requests Lim, density ratio 1 developer must also B detached dwelling wned by occupants but erlying property - al description involving ilding code; b) police; ed as a single dwelling ugh Wayzata. E OP REQUEST ivis i^j^^ 2 50+$ 5/Lot nditional Use $50 ./^PLICANT Eamel^U/5 Tel Mailing /yi/ £. lA^Ayz/trA sv/re Address U)aY7/I t ^ ^ ■ r$~3y/____________ Variance $50 1^'^^zoninq $250 Riprap $15 i/cWNER Name uJa/ZATA CovAiTKy CLU£ Tel Mailing Address UlAy7^7/t. . S'r3^/____________________ FEE Present Zoning AA-/3 Date Rec By *d • /.jtrr.77/g? 0 Present Use Soning Ordinance Section Relating to Request Specify Ordinance Recpiirements Explain your request and reasons for scune VARIANCE req;iired _ _ _ Lot Area Width extent of nonconformity _ _ _ Setback Front_ _ _ _ Other, explain _ Side Rear Specify hardships to property SUBDIVISION application ^^Residential Other, explain No. of Lots ^ t^'^d^DITIONAL USE AND OTHER - explain proposed use of property in detail PAD y _ _ _ MINIMUM MATERIAL NECESSARY FOR COMPLETE APPLICATICW (Must be submitted 10 days prior tc Planning Commission meeting) 1. 2. 4. Application completed Plat map section Certificate of survey of property sketch location and setbacks of proposal Construction plans, if applicable 5. DATE /l L uJzs. Certified Property Owner's list of owners within (300*) (ISO*)- from Hennepin Co. Dept, of Finance A-603 Government Center Stamped, legal sized envelopes(#10 pre-addressed to each of the namei on the zd>ove list. Applicant's Signature' S ^ <•! J <Mi Q Li! C 0- \ « >» •»•♦»• V GORDON R. COFFIN SUWVtVOW ^NO PLANNtW 1021 ¥^ATt»TO^AN «OAO long UAKC. MINN lllll A71A11I 9-1;-72 • • • Ir!3crirtion ^or \'’f^®’",4.n=-23of osrt of ft.'- r-outl.criFt 1/4 of .->vi tior , - - - ^ That part cf ths 8.,,t qoirU.r cr i^-,;,-a':;i-T-l-;;3r., l/in- Eoul--.?rl.- '''■'^'■M"lS''-i.t''’34‘'«et o<- Vh^ 994 f«c ‘ <■■!■And th^ .. r.^,.4v,.R* ru'rt"r of 5«'crtlon 3o, of the Soulhcsst quarter S^VV-inclr-*^ I-erliitr..Township 118 i:orth, Mrfc 23 .*cc-t o. t,.^ 5-r. .-ir^c- , A •-e 1-JL ___ Li i i3 [M: c C J) Grathwol , Ploetz, Oberhauser a Thompson attorneys and counselors at law MSI t.WAVZATA OOULtVAWO-SUITE SlO o’NtiLcu. oaatmw C. WAYZATA, MINNESOTA BS3SI WAVMONO C. PLOKTZ JAMCS M.OPATMWOC LOUIS s. OSCPMAUSKW OAPT A. THOMPSON HOBCPT m, PANOAUC M Jf—r:.-.:;r:r # November 2, 1978 mm (eicl «7»>c«oi % • City of Orono P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota Re:Roger Fazendln Realtors Development of Wayzata Country Club Our File 2198-37 Th. underBlgn«J .ppllcnt 1. .J.ulta.e<«..ly filing nn nPPlJn*!*” development of a piece of property pursuant to the sketch In ^ Wavzata In the City of Orono. At* previously explained to you the property In^questlon is intersected by the common boundary by the City of Orono and City of Wayzata. The location of the structure on the property is four units will be located in the City of Wayzata and eight units will be located in the City of Orono. It is contemplated that the applicant will request the rezoning of eight acres in the City of Orono from two acre to one acre patlble with the adjacent zoning in Femdale Green. The property Se^vS by sewer from the City of Wayzata and so this application should not create any problems. It is suggested that the development of this property be handled « contractural basis with the City of Orono, The developer would agree to. 1. Grant open spaces over the unused portion of the property to be Included in the eight acre rezoning application. 2 Would agree to install access roads from the west pursuant to Pla“s submlt;ed a^d in!"ll sewer at developer cost to be connected with the Wayzata seWge system. 3. Provide for a homeowner’s association to cover the maintenance of the common space and the ingress and egress roads. 4. Develop with staff and City Attorney approval proper legal documentation S! I i 1-^ % IM: c N fei" i L! City of Orono Noveaber 2, 1978 Page 2 to provide for ownership of the structure with a lease for the common space* The development conteuqilates that the occupants of the Individual structures would own the bricks and mortar comprising their structure, but would lease from the Wayzata Country Club, l.e., the owner of the property the common space and underlying property and by the terms of the lease the Wayzata Country Club would maintain the common space, the Ingress egress road and sewer lines and water lines to the anmlclpal system. It Is suggested that because of the unique nature of the property and the fact that clustering of the units and the use of common walls would be produce a more aesthetically pleasing and envlommentally sound structure, that the necessary variances from the existing zoning laws of the City of Orono could be granted under contractural rezoning so as not to create any precedent for future development. Tour preliminary views are solicited prior to submission of formal plans because of the enormous expense associated with the development of preliminary plans. Any questions that the City or the Council has concerning this development would be cooperatively answered on request. Thank you very much for your consideration In this matter. ■ - - - - - - - -- U I ^ #440 . S\.) Ji ELMER Jl PETI CoMrtf Survey* Cewify, UHI f(ets "Y i :4 CHASe “Kisii * onive \ X/. >. ^ntpr* / I* • 9' S. iit*) I ill ELMER JL PCTI C**»I. S«mi« CMatK, 1; V . HC9B4 • • \* 3<on department of finance A-603 GOVERNMENT CENTER MINNEAPOLI.S, MN, 55487 PROPERTY OWNERS LIST NAME / tf // iSlT/9r/e oA /^AJ a/_____OAxA) ^ot ADDRESS 5e.c, ?>c p.a. Btn(7( W<^YZ/VTA MK/, 5539/ i i a I / ^-O. iS! Way^ArA? Cou^r/ Cj m_ W/9Y^trr^ maI. , DESCRIPTION LOT BLK.I PARCEl A»c.^o— D'AVf S'cAfcui£iOoe4L _Oo^A/ Buffet.rviuAJ J^/n. ^yA I* -^<aagiSEg ^<g>ev ,So//A/ fatA/^jp<. jJA/«g/>T7i» C2>c^fOr^}/ CiM 9 UJA^/Qr^rtif. £539/ AL10-g»Ae ~ra<»PAr.f: lozo.' 34(Or 3031 Pn^T -4/3-7<;3 Fe«A>DO<^ g-««^a / u/^Y2ft,rA./nA/. ssyi^^f zyaa i■I IIIII //’C?/ f. (^t/>7Y. &U/0. w»ygAnA ■ AW. 3539/ / / 5 5 K^AAJCfiie U/gg^/Q-r/O^ /^a J. SS3^/ 45 lrl/<LC"0- /^/^A/njp> P^/^-r 42^ JO ^ I Av CAA/fuy i^>7j2r7S< Y^/9yAAT/9 , g,S39/ \aJ^ ^ / I -yAJeL^cJ I cerftfy that the facts fpp/esent^ Ofl UllS L,'biUflwclr iiN aw.Uf Jt9 -i-^ •»Hf true representation cf r.^orma* ~On d»~t; j^y^edts t*it5 da*;* ; n -------- -<5__/yzioo /S//0 /SlZO --/a /^<DC>C> //42OCD --Z:/'~ --------/4oo f— records of the Henn. Co. finance xotne 0€Si of my kiw?.ieAJge “ Hinif. Co. 151 (uamjp^ye >«, r.* TO:Planning Commission and Council #442 FROM:Jeanne A. Mabusth, Asst. Zoning Administrator DATE:November 20, 1978 SUBJECT: #442 - Subdivision Donald J. Scott, 2300 tiongvlew Circle SKETCH PLAN REVIEW Mr. Scott, the developer of the Longview plat, proposes subdividing a four acre lot (Lot 2, Block 1, Tongview) into two lots. Both lots meet the zoning requirements for the RR-IB District. 1 have checked the files on the original Longview plat (#270) and find Mr. Scott has fulfilled all items sited in the final resolution. There was nothing in the records that would prohibit the platting of Lot 2, Block 1. Please review the septic Inspector's comments regarding the septic reports submitted with the application. Staff would appreciate a recommendation concerning this matter. • ♦CITY OF ORONO, MINNESOTA Land Use Application •.0' lOCATION OF PROPOSAL (or property) Address ^ 3 .5* I«gal Description \L (or property) . - O 9 I SKiac APPLICANT Name Donald J. Scott Hailing 2300 Longview Circle Address Long Lake, MN 55356 Tel #332-2303 OWNER Name Donald J. and Constance M. ^*^Tel #473-1941 Mailing 2300 Longview Circle Address Long Lake. MN 55356 Present Zoning Resident R R 1 B TYPE OF REQUEST Subdivision $150*1-$5/Lot (^n^tional Use $50 ince $50 Rezoning $250 Riprap $15 ($65) FEE Da By / ^ 0 . OO Date Rec' d Present Use Residential Zoning Ordinance Section Relating to Request Specify Ordinance Requirements Es^lain your request and reasons for seune S 1 I VARIANCE required ____ Lot Area Width extent of nonconformity Setback Front Side Rear Other, e3q>lain Specify hardships to property SUBDIVISION application __/ Residential Other, e3q>lain NO. of Lots ^ CONDITKSIAL USE AND OTHER - e3q>lain proposed use of property in detail ? « I MINIMUM MATERIAL NECESSARY FOR COMPLETE APPLICATION (Must be submitted 10 days prior to Planning Commission meeting) 1. -^ Application completed 2. y Plat map section 3. ^Certificate of survey of property sketch location and setbacks of proposal 4. Construction plans, if applicable DATE^^*^. ^ 197 /Applicant*8 Signature 5. y Certified Property Odmer's list of owners within (300*) (JSG^)-> frcm Hennepin Co. Dept, of Finance A-603 Government Center 6. y Steunped, legal sized envelopes (#10) pre-addressed to each of the names on the,^bove list DATB^tv /T Ovner's Signature Applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, City Engineer, City Attorney, Planning Comission and Council necessary to process this application and further agrees to pay all fees as established .by ordinance. 5/78 1 RESERVED #442 BINDINO— \ t SOUTH SOUTH I y. lit cTHt mitt oTStv.a ______— 7w».a—« •^JA‘/LLOW WILLOW DRn^'. \if-y. i - -t'^V ?* V.*'*#r w -e . » it ' '4■ H MVa.: ■ ;. * ? i, wwr— •I Vv \\\ j , \A \-<\ ^SSF-^--------# \ .3 N^p i see 3 ,\ C #/ <r /fi/^tS9r. ^.a4Ac. «* ~CE^1 X ^*444f/4kt *tfjie. -£Jtu.__: .Z J$€ \y >5^4r.ir^4R Ooodr/ei • < '*• w // Tiorre ^/of I ' \ ------tt.*4rk4.S NCB94 3d^ ^DEPARTMENT OP FINANCE PROPERTY OWNERS LIST y- f(0li^Y DiK/l S/cW rpLff-r Y/zS^ ~CKo N c!) DESCRIPTION LOT BLK. W/ti X^ajTT // lice c./lvJcT/^ • - - f* n / T' t ( '/ f IC_‘ PARCEL / / I r/< f *F6 Yi Y-c Yfii/^ J-tH ^iCV y-^ gTT ; 2m 6d06 ^^CkiTZ^H-A V/)A(^d y/)/)d 'iS %•i£arttfkLtMJ|^JacU reprtstfite# ofi tMi ctrtificale are an «>cciifate nnd fiut Uprjg^ntatlon of lnforma> lion as It appears this data on the records off the Henru Co. finance Oiv., to tne best of my knowMg^ and belef. Henri. Co.'S^onAWfeL (i .V2 3 #4 • I jsl t_s •a TO:Jeanne Mabusth, Asst. Zoning Administrator FROM:Michael P. Gaffron, Septic System Inspector DATE: SUBJECT: November 16, 1978 Septic System Soil Testing Donald Scott, Longview Second Addition Soil testing data for this s .* division has been reviewed. Orono code requirements for testing have not been totally met. Three (3) borings per lot are required to show the depth to existing and seasonal water table. Only one boring was taken per lot, and in both cases data shows the water table at a 10* depth; the boring logs Indicate no soil mottling; and my Inspection on November !6, 1978 revealed water table at a depth of 3'*6" on lot 1 and 9* on lot 2. Additional borings showing depth to mottling will be required. Orono soli testing requirements and methods are enumerated on the subdivision application forms. The applicant has only to read the Information contained therein to find out what Is required. i e 4 ^ » ••.7 / ^#v# hissi^L-.: TO:Planning Corrmission and Council ^ — a FROM:Jeanne Mabusth, Asst. Zoning Administrator DATE:November 21, 1978 SUBJECT: #443 Robert Olson, 4645 Bayside Road SUBDIVISION SKETCH PLAN REVIEW Mr. Olson has submitted an application for a ^o lot subdivision originally submitted and approved by Council (May 28, 1974) by Harold Anderson, 4665 Bayside Road. The original application was never finalized because Mr. Anderson did not complete specific obligations to the City. The two lot subdivision now involves a 1.9 acre lot and a 17.3 ®cre lot. Mr. Olson requests an area variance for the 1.9 acre lot and a setback variance for the pole bam. Hardships following code requirements to the letter would result in an unusual and odd shaped lot. The pole bam is 8' from Anderson's south property line (IW required for a bam - 10' required for an accessory building). The pole bam is 2,400 s.f., the State Building Code Requires 10 setback from the lot line or the building must be structurally altered to meet code. A one hour fire wall is required and all openings within the wall enclosed. The lot line could be moved 2 to the north along building line and a compensatory southern shift in line could give the necessary two acres. The septic inspector will inspect the existing systems. Park fee to be determined. Items for consideration:1. 2. Determine use of pole bam. Can Planning Conmission determine a more feasible division line? m -us U) trator VW7/I mi:: •T7SI fTOI ^o lot subdivision toy 28, 1974) by lal application )t complete specific * lot and a 17.3 acre Jie 1.9 acre lot and >8 following code inusual and odd shaped i property line (150' isory building). The le requires 10* setback iturally altered to id all openings within I 2* to the north along : in line could give will inspect the pole bam. lission determine a more i line? N 1/2m .1' -i •»• Si 3 -• .1 - ^ ^ ■? ■ . * <2 ■ t'' v' \v^ltf5> ■;ife V--X■>><, • ‘ \ I fk ArmMtrm^ IV Ac : ••»• 'J > .• '* .C . .*..r , .-‘/VI ' «?•> '^N^-±- • '»»,vi • % ^Wl4 >r .fcJ' (r>f») fWArni/r^ tUTM 9 &> '". ' "ti- i/>W /» 1^ 1*9 A, {oiSiD *) ^C h^P€fi ^ ii Ac -POAO I, ,‘t:i> ja: :n*n' fir^>'m t^4 - V'i. . VC •r\ = ,«4!»; *r.,.,^|T*V ?^NORTH ARM'ESI TM ft SECOND , ADC 'f .#> -6.% ‘#/7W- fiTt §279$- I -17755- •a 1 • a.- I ' TO:Council FROM:Hank Miihich, Zoning Administrator 'A A O DATE:April 20, 1977 Ji SUBJECT:Harold Anderson - 4665 Bayside Road 1974 Subdivision * Never Recorded Mr. Anderson was in my office recently inquiring why his plat was denied recording at the County. I explained to him that when I received the County*s request to confim the subdivision approval, I found he had never paid his Park Dedication Fee so I informed the County that all conditions were not met for plat aj^roval. In reviewing his plat, I discovered several irregularities: 1. The split of 10 acres into 2 sites in a 2-acre zone - one of the lots does not meet the 2 acres. 2. No final plat on record. 3. The bade 8 acres appears landlocked. 4. Accessory building (pole bam) on large lot without main structure. 5. Bam does not meet required ISO* lot line setback. 6. No Park Dedication Fee paid. . When I found this I suggested he submit a new plan. He was quite tq>set and refused, so I took the material to the Planning Cormission for reconanendation to Council for some direction. The Planning Comnission reconmended this proposal be resubmitted. I'm enclosing copies of the Planning Conroission and Council ininutes from 1973 and 1974 when this prcq;)Osal was originally made. COUNCIL MEETINS - April 27, 1977 Directed Staff to inform Mr. Anderson to resubmit subdivision application. New proposal must meet zoning requirements and eliminate landlocked area tc the rear. Current park dedication fee and ^jplication fee. STAFF - May S, 1977 Letter to Mr. Anderson informing him a new sid>division proposal wAuld be required. The original af^lication from 1974 had eDqpired (statute of limitations). CONTINUED MEETING OF THE ORONO COUNCIL APRIL 27, 1977 Page 14 Mayor Brad Van Nest noted that these structures would require a variance, as well as a building permit in that this would create more than one permanent structure on one lot, again, expanding storage areas at marinas which would seem to be unreasonable. Mayor Van Nest concluded that there appears to be many questions that remain unanswere and staff will require additional time to research all the information required to justify Mr. Hork*s request. Mayor Van Nest moved, Welsh seconded, to table the request of the North Shore Marina for a structure with boat racks until the May 9, 1977 Council meeting. Motion, Ayes <3) - Nays (0). Mr. George Johnson, 835 Partenwood Road, addressed the City Council stating that there are some concerns that the Council should address themselves 1. 2. The City Council cannot grant permits 'for temporary construction. If the City of Orono should allow Mr. Hork to install the racks, the City is inviting a lawsuit. Mr. George Johnson felt that there was much public concern in allowing the marinas to expand their operation at this time. Mayor Van Nest moved, Butler seconded, to table the request of Dan Oas, 3297 Casco Circle, to waive special assessments, until the Council meeting of May 9, 1977 for further information. Motion, Ayes (3) - Nays (0). SPECIAL ASSESSMENTS 3297 Casco Circle Mayor Van Nest moved, Welsh seconded, to refer to the Planning Commission the subdivision request of Harold Anderson, 4665 Bayside Road, for their review and comments. Motion, Ayes (3) - Nays (0) • UBDIVISION 4665 Bayside Road Henry Muhich, Building & Zoning Administrator, presented a report by Gordon Coffin, surveyor, explaining the advantages and disadvantages of s\ibdivision plats vs. Registered Land Surveys. SUBDIVISION vs. RLS i MlNUltS OF A PLANNING CQinSSICN KEbTING HELD APRIL 4, 1977 - PAGE 6 rhe Zoning Administrator stated that althni^ this item was not cn tlic agenda he would like to bring this ratter to their attention. Mr, Anderson has been into the office <md inquired about the amount of Park Dedication ^e due on his sii>divlsion \diich was approved in 1973. The Zoning Administrator felt this proposal should be reviewed by the Conmission. After a brief discussion, Hassel moved, Hannah seconded, that this subdivision proposal be resubmitted. Motion - Ayes (S), Nays (0). There was some discussion to consider denying any duck pond proposals. The Planning Comission felt that removal of aquatic vegetation in any marsh area would destroy the filtration of storm water provided by marshes. The CcHnmission considered setting up standards and clarification of parks. The Conmission determined that (parks) as a permitted use in residential districts is too broad a term. Ordinance should be amended. After a brief discussion, the Cccinission determined this was definitely a commercial operation, and there are commercial zones for an operation such as this in Orono. Hannah moved, Dunlap seconded, to recommend against amending the ordinance for dog boarding or kennels in any residential zone. Motion - Ayes (5), Nays (0). Menber Dunlap submitted her comnents to the Zoning Administrator. Other members stated that their comments would be forwarded soon. Richard TiJthill and Richard Hassel presented a preliminary plan and model of the 21 unit PRD concept over 21 acres of land in Minnetonica Beach and Orono. This location is north of County Road #15 and east of the Texaco Station at the intersection of County Road #19 and #15. The proposed density would not exceed the zoning requirements. The preliminary model indicated that there would be approximately 3-5 inits in Orono. The ^jplicants presented the proposal in order to get some direction from the Planning Commission, Other than determining the actual location of the structures, the Coninission indicated general approval of the concept. The proposal would require platting, detailed plans for PRD approval and joint agreement with the City of Minnetonka Beach. HAROLD ANDERSON • 4665 BAYSIDE ROAD 1974 SUBDIVISION WETLANDS DREDGING Q DUCK PONDS (M3RAT0RHJM) PARK STAHiS (MORATORIUM) USES IN 5-ACRE RESIDENTIAL ZONES - VETERINARIAN « DOG BO.ARDING SITE, TRAFFIC § ENVIRON MENTAL REPORTS ON FUTURE MEDINA VO-TEOI SOCOL PROluSAL RICHARD TUTHILL 21-UNIT PRD CONCEPT iril . A.. •IINUTES OF A REGULAR IlEETING HELD HAY 28, 1974 Page 2 Paurus moved, Scarlcs seconded, to grant a varinace to Richard Hollander, 680 North Arm Drive, for the construction of a garage 22' from the road right-of-way, since it is an improvement over the existing situation, but * variance from the 75* lake setback ordinance can only be given preliminary approval subject to the Hinnehaha Creek !7atershed District giving its approval* This variance was deemed reasonable since it is a narrow lot and the variance is only a need for a deck supported by poles. As soon as the Watershed District approves it, then a written copy of that approval must be submitted to Dexter Marston, and if it meets Mr. Marston's approval, then the staff is authorized to grant a variance. Motion, Ayes (3) - Nays (0). VARIANCE 680 North Arm Drive 41685 - 1020 Lot 1 The variance for John Zimmer 6 Melvin Dale on County Road #6 and Watertown Road is tabled until June 11, 1974. The variance for Albert Burkhalter and Gerben Korthius, 1066 Loraa Linda, is also tabled until June 11, 1974. Butler moved Paurus seconded', to grant the variance and sttbdivision for Harold Anderson, 4665 Bayside Road, and that a 5% park fee is to be charged to the two- acre.. parcel. Motion, Ayes (3) - Nays (0). Searles moved, Paurus seconded, to grant the subdivision to Hugh Harrison and that a 50' access to the lake be provided and that a 5% park fee be charged for this subdivision. Motion, Ayes (3) - Nays (0). Paurus moved, Butler seconded, to deny the street vacation of Dale Matson, 2200 Bayview Place. But the Council did feel that perhaps consideration should be given in the future for the variances needed for construction of a garage. Motion, Ayes (3) - Nays (0). Paurus moved, Butler seconded, to approve the conditional use permit of Edward Zubov, 1940^Shoreline Drive, under the conditions as specified by Mr. Marstoa in his memo. Motion, Ayes (3) - Nays (0). # if /I o VARIANCE Watertown Road & #6 VARIANCE 1066 Loma Linda VARIANCE 6 SUBDIVISION 4665 Bayside Road 42460 - 1412 SUBDIVISION 41620 - 3000 STREET VACATION Wallace Avenue CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT 1940 Shoreline Drive 41880 - 5000 1 MINUTES OF THE REGULAR PLAMNtl'IG COMMISSION MEETING, MONDAY, HAY 20, 1974, 7:30 P.M. Ths mooTInQ wa$ callod to ordor by Chairman VanNest at 7:40 R4. All members present with exception of Kallestad and Elliott. Fred Curtis moved, Paul Pesek seconded, that the Minutes of t April 15, 1974, Planning Commission meeting be approved. Ayes Nays (0). Chairman VanNest opened the Public Hearing at 7:42 P.M. regard ing a subdivision of 2 acres off from a 10 acre tract legally described as Plat 41560, Parcel 1412. The Zoning Administrator presented the Notice of Public Hearing, the Certificate of Hall' Ing, and the Affidavit of Publication. The Planning Commission agreed that a simple subdivision with a variance for the setback of the barn and for a 1.9 acre lot Is justified and all future property owners will buy the property with full knowledge of the location of this barn. If Hr. Ander son were to comply with the strict letter of the law, he would create a lot with an unusual and undesirable shape. After all persons were afforded an opportunity to be heard, the Public Hearing was closed at 7:45 P.M. Kullberg moved, Curtis seconded, that the simple subdivision with a variance for allowing a 1.9 acre lot and a variance from required 150* setback fc>* a stable be granted conditioned on the payment of a 5J» park foe on the 2 acre site, and that the remaining 8.1 acres be combined with the property to the east. Ayes (7) Nays (0). Chairman VanNest opened the Public Hearing at 7:45 P.M. for the property legally described as Plat 41620, Parcel -3000. The Zoning Administrator presented the Affidavit of Publication, the Notice of Public Hearing, and the Certificate of Mailing. The Zoning Administrator explained to the Planning Commission that the staff felt that it was essential that a public right- of-way be provided to the proposed 2.5 acre parcel, and that the narrow strip of land which provides lake access should be widened from 30* to 50*. Mr. Lahti - V/hat would bo the purpose of extc.idlng Long Lake Dlvd. as a public road, and bow would It be done since the pro posed lot Is separated from the public road right-of-way at the present time by a private easement? >1 Harold Anderson Subdivision ; Hugh Harrison Subdivision Mr. Harrison - Sluce I do not anticipate subdividing my property Id the future, ! see no need for providing a public road. In add ition, I would be willing to widen the 30* strip, but I would like to keep It as narrow as possible. Cormissloner Gasch - Although the property to the east of this Is marsh, establishing a standard of 50* of iakeshore as being the minimum allowed seems reasonable. Since the marsh Iakeshore property to the east of the 30* strip cannot be that valuable. It would seem approp riate that we require Mr. Harrison to provide 50* of Iakeshore. I I eir^J MINUTES OF A REGULAR flEETING HELD OCTOBER 24, 1973 Page 2 1 Oberhauser moved, Butler seconded, to table the request of Kermit Knutson for a division concerning 3640 Bayside Road until the comprehensive plan has been approved. After approval of the comprehensive plan, this request will be sent back to the Planning Commission and the Park Commission for their comments and review, after which it will be forwarded to the Council again for consideration. Motion, Ayes (4) - Nays (Oj. Councilman Dorn abstained. DIVISION 3640 Bayside Road Butler moved, Welsh seconded, to table the division of Harold Anderson, 4665 Bayside Road, until after the comprehensive plan has been approved. Upon approval of tiie comprehensive plan, tliis request will be sent back to the Planning Commission for their comments and review and then forwarded to the Council for further consideration. Motion, Ayes (4) - Nays (1). Councilman Dorn Nay. Butler moved, Welsh seconded, to approve the variance for Diamond Construction Co., 1120 North Shore Drive, The variance is granted for the lot size and a variance IS also granted for the building moratorium. The hardship that was recognized is the fact that there is no more available land to bring the lot up to the proper size. Motion. Ayes (5) - Nays (0). ' Massengale moved, Butler seconded, to approve the division and variance of Bryne Ghostley, 3133 Casco Point Road, subject to the following conditions: 1. That the applicant provide the Village Attorney, Mr. Marc Wiitehead, with the recordable ingress and egress on the property, 2, That the applicant grant to the Village a utility easement if the driveway was found not to be big enough for a utility easement. 3. The conditions of the Planning Commission must be complied with concerning this division and variance. 4. That the proper setback and drainage requirements be complied with. The Council felt that the hardship in this particular case was tliat originally two lots •®*isted in this area and that it appears an accidential combination took place sometime in the past. Motion, Ayes (5j - Nays (0). DIVISION 4665 Bayside Road VARIANCE 1120 North Shore Drive DIVISION 6 VARIANCE 3133 Casco Point Road < j I I I '! ■r I • 1 ?IINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING HELD OCTOBER 15, 1973 Page 2 It was the opinion of the Planning Commission members that minimum lot size in areas that do not have public utilities will not be more than two acres per lot. In addition, it was felt that the ISO* setback for stables did not apnly in this situation. The interpretation was that the 150’ setback requirement was passed^ to prevent one property owner from infringing on t«ie rights of another, and not to limit someone from dividing their property when the setback is acceptable to all affected property owners. DIVISION 4665 Bayside Road Q Searles moved, Elliott seconded, that the division of 1.9 acres from Parcel 1412, Sec. 6, be approved, subject to a variance from the moratorium and tne Village Attorney’s interpretation of the set- cack requirement for the stable. Motion, A,yes (7) - Nays (0). Elliott moved, Guthrie seconded, that a variance of 0.15 acres and 40' be granted from the size and width requirement as well as a variance from Ordinance No. 149 for Parcel 2630, Sec. 7, because the area was platted before the existing zoning ordinance, and sewer is available. VARIANCE 1120 North Shore Drive Searles moved, Guthrie seconded, that the division of Lots 42-44 and parts of 45 and 64 of Spring Park, into two building sites, a variance of S' from the width requirement of the westerly lot and a variance from Ordinance No. 149, be approved, with the following conditions: 1. A lake setback that is compatible with the homes to the east must be maintained. DIVISION § VARIANCE 3133 Casco Point Road 2. A drainage plan must be provided to avoid the possibility of disturbing existing drainage. Motion, Ayes (7) - Nays (0). The Kvalstens have submitted an application for a conditional use permit for the construction of a duplex on Lot 2, Block 1, of Apple Hill. Van Nest recalled that this property was originally zoned commercial and when it was rezoned to lialf- acre lots, the understanding was duplexes could be constructed there. Despite the fact that tne^ Navarre Task Force has recommended the reclassification of the commercial property to the north of Lot 2, it was determined that another duplex would certainly fit in with the character of the area. CONDITIONAL USE PER?4IT 2595 Lydiard Circle Searles moved, Gasch seconded, that the conditional use permit be approved, subject to the Council's approval of a variance to Ordinance No. 149. I?otion, Ayes (7) - Nays (0), I ML ^ O Hr; O £S‘i;.-...—™ „™ „ .I'ss.r.'AXr^sra, acre^o?**'^?"''*''”? If* '‘e'5 “®ste<f paralsslon to divide 2 cribed is Plaretjol ?irii|°M?2'°*Kin°\'H Wlas .or lU1or?S;i?’ _ * • quirement Is 35' In this area and setback re- +o keep the addition In IlnfilJhV^'n^r fli fnovedm Hsko sArnnrio/i -fk 4» p^Gsent home. Gasch the “icatfiaTtii eifiiiio''i;i^r°.'* »♦•wn OT rne existing home. Ayes (7) Nays (0). • • •• r4 ‘ • ■ • • • /M ^,r'-j •—• * r*i *%. ***' Iv. stHi iin“4'’?ii‘'?eir,„!ahl ” """® a i r'^.♦» ■« structure 120- Um tU priiir7^M„i'’'*„i° 1^? *'’'* • variance. The petitioner claL« +Kl* ?J' needssibj. to put the bui d iriso- ir» ■* '"""*- outVarovlag a great number of tr«. seconded, ttot a varirn^nL^ ^ Posek trator can determine that there^u*? Zoning Admlnls- elther the torr^I^nVi^Iertn P"®*’’®" '''♦*» from the property line If structure 150* plication should come ^fore the PllJjifnnV'"*?®"!' *^® ®P" Ayes (7) Nays (0). Planning Commission In May. iiel »fTH^'"Tb- T.lt Pesek moved, Curtis seconded +h«+ requirement Is 10' sia» tb. niigbiiii eiii«:id ji’oM::; ®„"®® ®pr»«« a basement under a structure th*+ constructing .on. to tb. setbfKk requirements. Aye%'1'7)"~aJi”S;i'’' subirjiiTo"::' ^s"fi'2 ’”""‘'’r ♦"® <>"• time met the I acre zoning requlrlri^nt "“"a? I? * the petitioner owns 5 lots and iil ^^® P''®^®®^’ +1''®, ‘'MI be granted to aTlo^^^Sstr't^on '' ®•puwrion Of homes on each of the 4 • . •-2- k Roy Starkey David Slavik A Donald Schultz Variance Harold Anderson//^ Subdivision John Anderson Variance Frederick RIebel Variance Larry Berk Iand Variance John Ztnmer & Melvin Dale Variance •1 '-A November 3, 1978 Alexander Holzer 2677 Casco Point Road Sge^4^°"*^ Permit & Variance planning commission meeting - NOVe-IBER 13, 1978 would be to^^^^^ou^^^nr^clearty^'de^^^ °f ®eeting attorney and the city engineer by the city Council, whlfh request w?nT®“ *’* ®PP«''e‘i November 28. 1978 Council P«aented at the ^v^er^iriwl. Conm.lsalon meeting of Planning Coranlsslon’s request of the City attorney: 1. 2. 3. 4. on recent Supreme Court ‘I Hr xri ’s-- Planning Commission's request of the City engineer: J* of fill involved. f: so?^:%l:;sion problem with neS g “de? problems for neighboring properties ^4:3 3 1 L TO;Coimcll t i FROM:Alan P. Olson, Village Planner DATE:November 8, 1978 SUBJECT; #319 - West Shore Lafayette Bay Dredging Project The Freshwater Biological Research Foiindation has submitted the final report conducted by the Gray Freshwater Biological Institute concerning the monitoring of water qxiality during the West Shore Lafayette Bay dredging project. The enclosed letter states that the project is complete, the required leveling and seeding has been done. The City hold a letter of credit for $3,000 that the foundation requests be released. Staff inspected the site on Noveirf>er 7, 1973. We found the leveling to be satisfactory, but it was inq>ossible to determine whether the required seeding had been done. The DNR permit had required mulching along with the reseeding, but we found no sign o." mulching. i Our recommendation would be to hold off on the release of the letter of credit until spring. At this point, an adequate determination cannot be made of the original reseeding or if additional seeding may be required. COUNCIL MEETING - NOVEMBER 14, 1978 Council reviewed the FWBI report and commented on the grading. Council took no action to release the letter of credit preferring to wait until formal written request for release is received and until the required reseeding proves to be acceptable next spring. Officm: R*c;wd G Gray. St. Chattman Dr Rchard S Caldecott. Vtct Cf^sirman Raymond 0 Black. Secfetary Henry Doerr Treasuref Dlrtdort: SewaH D Andrews. Jr lirxisay G Arthur. Jr Roger I baker WMtam M Baker Raymor.J D Black Wii»am M Bracken Russell 0 Brackett Earle G Brooks Mrs Herbert Busher Dr Richard S Caldecott Mrs Benton J Case Herwy Doerr Kirrgsiey Foster Gilbert P Goeti Richard G Gray Sr James I Hetland, Jr O' Joseph T Ltftg Charles M Moos Earl H Mosiman George T Pemtock Dr DeanK Raer Robert L Seartes Thomas L Warner Dr John M Wood FRESHWATER biological RESEARCH FOUNDATION 2500 Shadywood Road. P. O. Box 90 Navarre. Minrtetofm. U.S A 55392 (612) 471-6407 October 30, 1978 ^IeIS NOV 1970 7 Mr. Al Olson City Planner Orono City Hall P. 0. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN Dear Mr. Olson: CITIC OE OROKQ 55323 Here is the report submitted by the Gray Freshwater Biological Institute regarding the monitoring of water quality during the West Shore Lafayette Bay Dredging Project. Dr Joseph P RossrHoaflecuiiv*orecior As you Can See: 1. Suction dredging apparently has less of a disruptive effect on the lake. 2. The primary disruption ceune from stirring carbon and nitrogen from t;he lake sediment. 3. No consistent or long lasting change occurred in the marsh. The dredging project is now completed. The land has been leveled and re-seeded with pasture grass. The spoils area has been seeded with clover to facilitate the drying process. It should be dried out and st2d>le by next August. If you desire additional information or clarification, please call me at 471-8407 or Dr. John Wood at 471-8476. Sincerely, rosepn Rossillon ;xecutive Director JPR/n cc: Mr. Earl Sween A PUBLIC NON-PROFIT FOUNDATION • CONTRIBUTIONS ARE TAX-DLDUCTIBLE November 1978 KEPORT TO THE ORONO CITY COUNCIL West Shore Lafayette Bay Dredging Project From July 7th to August 29th a dredging project was monitored on the West shoreJ.ine of Lafayette Bay, Lake Miinetonka. Approximately 16,000 cubic yavda of silt was dredged from the existing boat channel using a suction dredging technique operated by Dewey Lindsey, UAWAPADCO. The spoils were retained in two dans which were prepared adjacent to the wetlands on Freshwtaer Biological Research Foundation property at Navarre. A report on the Engineering part of the project has already been submitted by Mr. Lindsey. This report deals with a study of water quality in Lafayette Bay and in the Wetlands. This study was conducted before. during and after the dredging project was completed. The effect of both suction dredging and traditional dredging on the water quality of Lafayette Bay is compared. Analyses were conducted during the period for total phosphorus, total carbon, and total nitrogen. In addition, turbidity. chlorophyll levels, and secchi disk measurei.'ents were made throughout the summer season. The results of this study are presented in Table 1 (Lafayette ^ • * Bay), II (Foundation Marsh) and III (Seascout Survey of Lake Minnetonka, 1978). The detailed technical methodology used in this study can be obtained from the Freshwater Biological Research Foundafion upon request. Conclusions Suction dredging caused very little change in Lafayette Bay during the Entire project. At all times the nutrient balance was seen to be significantly better than the natural conditions in the bay reported in 1972 by R.O. Megard, Journal of Limaology and Ocenaography, Volume 17, p. 68-87. However, in the Report to the Orono City Council first week in August Bill Niccum was employed to dredge part of the 1934 boat channel using the traditional dredging approach. Immediately we observed a doubling in total carbon in the water column, and a significant increase In total nitrogen (see data in Table I from August 1st onwards). Clearly, suction dredging for channel maintenance is much less deleterious to the body of water than traditional dredging practices. The dams which were constructed to hold the spoils from Lafayette Bay were so well constructed that the water pumped with the spoils was mostly lost through evaporation as Mr. Lindsey predicted. Most of the changes in the marsh could be accounted for by rainfall causing increased urban run off, except on July 28th when a visiting student from Harvard who was studying crawfish In the wetlands Inadvertently stirred up sediments in the wetland close to our sampling points (Table II). Measurements taken by the Seascout Project on Lafayette Bay (Table III) show the results of a typical season of algal succession, except that this year Lafayette Bay was much cleaner than last year, and is showing a great improvement in terms of nutrient loading. This could be due to two reasons: (1) the removal of sewage effluent from the bay and (2) closure of the boat access at the comer of County Road IS and Old Beach Road. It is clear that high powered boats entering shallow bays, ^such as Lafayette Bay, stir up a large amount of sediment whi^h increases the concentrations of soluble nutrients in the water column. 1 TABLE I Dredging Project DATE WEATHER WIND - RAIN TURBIDITY LAFAYETTE BAY 1978 SECCHI DISK CHLOROPHYLL P S M T T F S M W T S S July July July July July July July July July July July July 7 8 10 11 13 lA 16 17 19 20 22 23 Off On Calm On Calm Calm On On Calm Calm On S Off 5.31" (ftl yes yes .05" yes yes 1.27" 30 30 30 20 25 24 20 20 23 45 32 27 4 5+ 4.5 4.5 5.5+ 5+ 5+ 4 4 4 5 (ug/1) 9.2 15.5 16.6 17.1 13.6 10.7 7.1 5.7 9.7 21.6 18.2 39.5 On ■ On Shore Off - Off Shore On S ■ Strong On Shore yes ■ trace of rain + ■ Secchi disk visible on the bottom TOTAL P04 (ugTT) 58 68 68 64 44 36 32 32 42 62 38 68 TOTAL CARBON (mg/1) 11 T July 25 Calm yes 20 5+8.3 32 W July 26 Off yes 20 5+8.4 40 — F July 28 On yes 38 4 19.1 70 12S July 29 On S -21 4.5 14.7 46 T Aug 1 On -20 5 8.2 2f. F Aug 4 Calm -27 5 9.7 42 25M Aug 7 On -19 5+7.7 34 W Aug 9 Off -21 5+10.0 36 F Aug 11 On -18 5+11.0 40 25N Aug 14 Calm -31 5+22.4 44 T Aug 15 Calm yea 27 5+17.3 44 24T Aug 22 On S -19 4.5+11.5 48 '26T Aug 24 On yes 22 5+12.7 24T Aug 29 Off 3.0"23 5+11.8 34 26 TOTAL NITROGEN (mg/1) .98 .93 1.23 1.17 1.66 2.28 3.06 1.79 2.28 ‘^anp j I TABLE II Dredging Project DATE WEATHER WIND - RAIN Marsh 1978 TURBIDITY CHLOROPHYLL TOTAL P04 TOTAL CARBON TOTAL NITROGEN P S M T T F S M W T S S T July 7 July 8 July 10 July July July July July July July July July July 11 13 lA 16 17 19 20 22 23 25 Off On Calm On Calm Calm On On Calm Calm On S Off Calm 5.31" yes yes .05" yes yes 1.27" yes W July 26 Off yes F July 28 On yes S July 29 On S - T Aug 1 On — F Aug 4 Calm - M Aug 7 On - W Aug 9 Off F Aug 11 On - M Aug 14 Calm - T Aug 15 Calm yes T Aug 22 On S - T Aug 24 On yes T Aug 29 Off 3.0* On •On • Shore 75 A5 30 20 24 22 17 17 15 20 20 20 15 15 18 15 15 18 19 15 16 13 14 17 19 16 (ug/1) 15.9 17.1 8.8 34.4 6.3 7.0 4.3 4.8 1.5 10.6 13.1 7.2 7.5 7.2 28.1 7.4 5.6 5.5 11.5 4.8 5.9 <9.9 6.3 10.0 23.5 4.3 (ug/l)< 144 120 94 126 60 68 52 62 72 114 104 98 76 60 132 66 o2 72 72 52 60 56 68 80 100 74 (mg/1) 10 (mg/1) 1.03 .98 .88 1.31 1.49 2.63 33 27 1.82 1.65 2.10 Off ■ Off Shore On S ■ Strong On Shore yes ■ trace of rain W > 1^^1 I TABLE III LAFAYETTE BAY DATA FOR THE SEASCOLT PROJECT Procedure: A sample was taken for Chlorophyll analysis and a Secchi Disk reading was taken at a point equal distance from ali shore lines of Lafayette Bay, near the deep hole. Date June June July July July July July Aug Aug *ug 17 24 1 8 16 23 29 6 12 20 mssm ■5 Secchi Disk Secchi Disk (m) 1.98 1.65 1.83 1.57 2.44 2.03 2.26 1.83 1.52 1.65 (ft) Chlorophyll (ug/1) 6.5 5.5 6 5 8 6.5 7.5 6.0 9.6 10.3 10.6 3.4 12.1 18.2 6 5 5.5 20.3 11.2 nf ivj. j yrKK,':r-um roi joutr Kurua. or HKLiJTiJmj tJkt.L no. iO90 NMiwptB Omaitr, maoMoU /#430 V- 7^*.j c^.-^ dIs.;»«prlptlon! Trvrts t •nd B, togl*t«r«4 i«nd Sunr«x Mo. UW, Ml** of Itoflatrar of Tltlo^ Count/ of Monnopln. ATMi AppraalnaUt/ 16.7 orrM 1 horofajr rortlf/ that tM* •unro/, pioo, '>r roport uo* proparoB bf m or lUar dlrooi •Mporvlslon and t6a% I aa a dul/ raflataiwd iants sur*a/or undar tM Lava of tfw Staia of Maaasota. STr iMod SamroYor and Planer t^Mg •aaa, WInaaaota lirmlmi I’ • 100* SkU t T-U'-'-? ro^craptv/ addad <f-1^7B Oat<»> Maao aaa Ua«I, lake WJNNETOM k A 4 4)io-t>V t Me-, mm' #429 UW UmniTf. CM) !!«• « fr««t tin* I In • • • p«i • «A Ml •‘■?L‘~'::=:rE rers-n •*>1».r.4 V«,., » . 1*;, ^ ,... MU trlMtM Iln» lr.« tk» liM •nr ,* II.! .. .mm. ' -------------- ' **• »» M < M* |. (Ml I, m IM Ml. Md !«•. MM i ,m •) MU J A M. M..I.M M IM MM-.M • IrMI • I MM Mruy ■•. M .. r«MrvM ,. ann !k mm. •.. V>u»«, r.u. f ll.>i.t'ar I '.i ... 1..U . Ml .. M. 1.1. I. .MW'.I I. *« ..r.MMI Md * -|»1L‘ —li t .1?*: «trr.": r.; “‘rHS? ■t:.- ' .I*, ,o<-, y y ..‘V A re*9"y. Z9a Sf A/. i im ussft.au ---------------?» M, mW .W .'^'1 X’-l ^ ci-FOR . e • mr *.v !• il 44 JOHN C NOBLE /' «r' t ; '->• "'. ■ , - —■ • .-w MM- **«m