The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About06-17-1991 Planning Packetr«, Planning Cominiss: )n Council PUBLIC ATTENDANCE CITY OF ORONO MEETING DATE (p llN I PLEASE . :LL out THE INFORMATION REQUESTED BELOW FOR OUR CITY RECORDS. NAME (please print)ADDRESS NAME OR NUMBER PRESENT FOR (from agenda) 1.nr. " 1^1 St 1 1 n It i n i-m/viLivJ A'-d / i '6 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 1 0. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.1 9.1 • 0. ’ .V 1 CITY OP ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING MONDAY, June 17, 1991 7:00 P.M. 1275 BROWN ROAD SOUTH - COUNCIL CHAMBERS COUNCIL REPRESENTATIVE “ J. Diann Goetten ATTENDANCE SCHEDULED PUBLIC HEARING 1. 8:00 p.m. #1653 Jeffrey Johnson - 3825 Cherry Avenue - Vacation of an Unimproved Public Right-of-Way ACTION ITEMS u ^ ^Review of these items will commence prior to or between scheduled public hearings. . . . . . . r, .. / m 2.#1604 3.#1644 4.#1646 5.#1647 6.#1648 7.#1649 8.#1650 9.#1652 10.#1654 11.#1655 12.#1657 13. Variance - Continuation of Publi- Hearing Appeals - Public Hearing jL JL a. A i a. jr a. v*** —- - -- - - - - - - - Conditional Use Permit - Public Hearing Variances - Public Hearing Renewal Variance ~ Public Hearing Variances - Public Hearing Hennepin County Department, or Transporcacion - County Roads 15 S 51 - After-the-Fact Conditions 1 Use Permit/ Variance - Public Hearing Variances ~ Public Hearing Variances “ Public Hearing Variance - Public Hearing Driveway Request Proposed Ordinance Amendment ” Attached antennas Request for additional direction ADDITIONAL ITEMS 14. Planning Commission approval of minutes of May 20, 1991 meeting. 15. Planning Commission to select a representative to attend the July 8, 1991 Council Meeting. ADJOUR] r To:Chairman Kelley and Planning Commission Members Mayor Peterson and City Council City Administrator Bernhardson From Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator Date June 12, 1991 Subject: #1653 Jeffrey Johnson, 3825 Cherry Avenue - Vacation of Public Right-of-way - Public Hearing Pertinent Ordinance - Section 10.12 - Vacation of streets, alleys and public grounds. The application involves the partial vacation of a 14' wide alley within the Crystal Bayview plat. The alley is unimproved. There is no record of the City's making any public use of the dedicated alley. As required by both the Orono zoning code and State Statute, the hearing notice has been published twice in the local official paper the weeks of June 3rd and June 10th. As of this date, the City has received no comments from adjacent neighbors notified within the 350' radius of the subject property. List of Exhibits - A - Application B - Property Owners List C - Plat Map D - Legal Notice E - Wetlands Map P - Map/Key of Ownership and Pattern of Development Adjacent to Alley G - Survey of Applicant's Property Review of implication - Please review Exhibit G. The application fails to note the reason for the filing of the vacation petition. In reviewing the survey, applicant's building envelope is intersected by the 14' alley. Any attempt to add improvements to the rear or south side of the house would require setback variances to a rear lot line defined along the north side of the 14' alley and not to the more southern portions of the land holdings of the applicant. These parcels are all legally combined as one homestead. By vacating the alley, applicant's rear lot line would now be to the most southern lot line. Staff has reviewed the partial vacation petition with the Public Works Director. He notes that at a limited 14' width, the City has no plans to install a public roadway. The alley does not provide access to an existing residence (review Exhibit F). He recommends the vacation and asks that drainage and utility easements be provided over the vacated portion of the alley. Gerhardson notes that municipal water will be provided to this area and that the dedicated alley may serve as suitable area for the location of future water lines. Zoning File #1653 /. June 12, 1991 Page 2 of 2 Staff has reviewed the pattern of ownership (review Exhibit F). Staff can confirm that none of the existing residence achieve access via the alley. Two of the developed properties own parcels to the north and south of the alley which includes the subject property. Other lots defined on the key show separately owned undeveloped lots owned in common ownership that are located both to the north and south side. As already noted above, we have received no comments from interested property owners who wish to join in the vacation. Review Exhibit E, there is an extensive retention area designated as a wetland area on the map (review Exhibit E), major portions of which are currently owned by the City of Orono. The central location of the wetlands would also place severe limitations on the installation of a through road within the alley. City staff had originally considered a total vacation of the alley until the Public Works Director had expressed an interest in obtaining easements over the alley for future water lines. Gerhardson has also asked that the potential vacation be reviewed by the Park Commission to determine if the area is suitable for a bike trail. The application will be reviewed by the Park Commission at their meeting in July (July 2nd). If the Park Commission finds that the area is suitable for bike trail development, the City will ask for bike trail easements over the vacated alley. Options of Action - 1. Approval based on one or more of the findings noted below. Approval would be subject to applicant granting drainage and utility easements over the vacated portion of the 14' alley. It should be noted that applicant will receive only 7' of the vacated right-of-way within the west 50' of the vacated alley. Review Exhibit F, the City of Orono will receive the remaining 7' of vacated right-of-way. Review of the findings that would support the vacation; a. Width of right-of-way would not support development of roadway . b. Location of designated wetland within right-of-way of alley. c. Based on pattern of development and current ownership there is no use of right-of-way for access purposes. d. Public interest can be achieved with the granting of necessary easements. 2.Denial. Based on certain findings noted above that suggest a public use or interest in the undeveloped or unused right- of-way. I r /w -i' ^I I w CITY OP ORONO — GENERAL LAND USE APPL PROPERTY LOCATION JJ. “i / j> Cr »L-CATl^f^ ^ .r '£:>*r.;. Site Address Property Identification Number (P.X.D. ) Please attach legal description to application if not included on required survey. APPLICANT Address 'I I Phone (home) Phone (work) b» —> City __ Zip Z iiS OWNER (if different than applicant)Phone (home) Netme Phone Address City 7 ^ ^ Date Property Acquired (mcnth/year) I (do) (do not) also own the adjacent parcels of land. PEES - CONDITIONAL USB PERMITS - Renewal Fee - 1/2 Current Fee After-the-Fact Fee - Double Current Application Fee $ 50.00 For each variance request with CUP application $125.00 Residential accessory Use $150.00 Institutional (church, school, etc.) i-'.$150.00 Guest House/Guest Apartments $150.00 Duplex Credit/Bldg $250.00 Commercial/Industrial Use .--TV / $200.00 Land Alteration ex'irrrrc t Xf**’'" W" • tot. » ^ **•*••** r ?*• •*! »0.1. •• —e V v • r—.1 f-r VI * . • W • VV" ■•5rrr.''r-"''’4Av' you r*i* Grading and filling - designated wetland or floodplain Grading and filling - 101 cu. yd. or more Grading, seawall, retaining walls within 75’ of lakeshore ; 4vi Til •r • VW/ i.*?/ PRD/PID - sea fee schedule on APPLICATIONS _ _ _ $200.00 _ __ $250.00 $175.00 $ 50.00 $250.00 $100.00 Commercial Site Plan Review (+ consultant fees) Vacation Easement Vacation Easement Vacation With Subdivision Rezoning (PUD - refer to fee schedule) Appeals Other - see fee schedule r PRESENT OSB OP PROPERTY Present Zoning District Present Use of Property P.esidentia.l "ether (specify) DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST Describe request in detail: REQUIRED SUBMITTALS 2! Certified P^roVe^]^^^ List of owners within 35 0' (you can obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Government Center 348-3271). 3-4. 5. I Plat Map. Certificate of survey (signed by a licensed surveyor). . ^ , , Topographic survey (existing and proposed contours) xand alterations involve changes in elevation (grades). Construction plan, if applicable (see staff for requirements). ^ As an addendum to this application, please attach a separate xi any other persons you wish notified of this application. YOU ARB REQUIRED TO SUPPLY 30 COPIES OP LARGE DOCUMENTS OR___ A WORKING COPY (ll* X 17" OR SMALLER) FOR ALL DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED. list of The apolicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please remembe'r that your application is not complete if the above information has not been included. __________ Certification by Clerical Department that Land Use Application is complete. Initials of Clerical Staff:.________________________________ —____________ APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE ^ _____The applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay additional fees (staff time not covered by original fee payment) and/or unusual expenses incurred in review of this application, and certifies that the informatioii supplied is true and correct to »the bast 'pf^his/her knowledge. DateApplicant's signature ^ OWNBRS SIGNATURE —H ---------^ ^ The owner hereby acknowledges and agrees to this application and tx^tne investigation and ^Rerifiication ^pf request Owner's signature Date Applicant must h Planning Commission 1*1 ^ab^XaUs into the City offices 23 days before the AV?r?«?t?rusViTp«fen"t l'’*3oh^ review meetings of the Planning Commission and Council. If an applicant is unable to attend a scheduled meeting, please make arrangements to have an authorized agent attend in your place and advise the Building fi Zoning Office of this change prior to the meeting. V f « DATE 05>^1/91 DATCN DOS T- •S? • HENNEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY OHT4ERS LIST PROP ADDR QNNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADDR ONNER NAME TAXPAYER NAHE/AOOR . I f f • / PROP ADDR C»t€R NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR (PROP ADDR. ONNER KANE TAXPAYER • NAME/ADDR PROP ADDR CMCR NAME iTAXPAYER * NANE/AODR V* ‘ V ^ * • }: ■ * « y S8 08-117-2S 33 0001 03820 CHERRY AVE CARL A BECK ETAL HRS CHRISTINA DECK * 3820 CHERRY AVE HOUND HN 55364 38 08-117-23 33 0006 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGT€D KATHRYN H EN6LUN0 ETAL K H NEVERS 9700 PORTLAND AVE S §324 BL00HIN6T0N MN 55420 38 08-117-23 33 0041' 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED KATHRYN H EN6LUND ETAL K H NEVERS 9700 PORTLAND AVE S §324 BLOOHINGOTN HN 55420 f 38 08-117-23 33 0080 03860 NORTH SHORE DR DANIEL J OHLANO DANIEL J OHLANO 3860 NORTH SHORE OR HOUND HN 55364 38 08-117-23 34 0040 03818 NORTH SHORE DR E 0 JOHNSON I P J JOHNSON EUGENE JQHNSON/PAUU JOHNSON 3818 NORTH SHORE DR NAYZATA HN ^ 55391 ' •f ] PROP ADDR ONNER NAME TAXPAYER NAHE/ADOR 38 08-117-23 34 0044 03818 . NORTH SHORE DR E D JOHNSON A P J JOHNSON « EUGENE JOHNSON/PAULA JOHNSON j 3818 NORTH SHORE DR . t NAYZATA HN 55391 • .1 . *1 , • ‘A • l‘ « VI I t «I r i ft ( i ^ < 4 . f 5 •-I » I *• I ^ .r i 38 08-117-23 33 0002 03826 CHERRY AVE R S E HANSON RICHARD E I ELIZABETH HANSON 3826 CHERRY AVE HOUND MN 55364 38 08-117-23 33 0007 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGT4ED KATHRYN M Et4GLUND ETAL K H NEVERS 9700 P0RTLAT40 AVE S §324 DLOOHir.GTON MN 55420 38 08-117-23 33 0042 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED KATHRYN H Er4GLUr4D ETAL K H NEVERS 9700 PORTLAND AVE S §324 BL00Hir4GT0N MN 55420 38 08-117-23 33 0088 ALLAN C A TERRI L LARSON ALLAN C A TERRI L LARSON 1665 HICKORY HILL DR EAGAN MN 55122 38 08-117-23 34 0042 03818 NORTH SHORE OR E D JOHNSON I P F JOH44SON EUGENE A PAULA J0H^4S0^4 3818 NORTH SHORE DR NAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 34 0057 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED JOHN T EIDEM ETAL JOHN T EIDEM 3768 NORTH SHORE DR NAYZATA MN 55391 REPORT NO. PI435401 PAGE 5 38 08-117-23 33 0005 03838 CHERRY AVE ARTHUR C BRAMDILLA TRUSTEE A C BRAMBILLA 3S38 CHERRY AVE MOUND HN 55364 38 08-117-23 33 0040 03843 CHERRY AVE C L ANOERSOta ETA*. N/LIFE EST CARL L ANDERSON 3643 CHERRY AVE M0U4D MN 55364 38 08-117-23 33 0059 03620 r40RTH SHORE DR DEBRA L CULLEN DEBRA L CULLEN 3820 NORTH SHORE DR NAYZATA MN 55391 38 08-117-23 33 0089 03625 CHERRY AVE JEFFREY J JOHNSON JEFFREY J JOH44SON 3625 CHERRY AVE MOUrm MN 55364 36 08-117-23 34 0043 03818 NORTH SHORE DR E D J0Ht4S0N A P J JOHNSON EUGEr4E J0H)4S0N/PAULA JOHNSON 3816 r40RTH SHORE DR NAYZATA m 55391 . 38 08-117-23 54 0058 03768 NORTH SHORE DR JOHN T EIDEM ETAL JOHN T EIDEM 3768 NORTH SHORE OR NAYZATA MT4 55391 - - -- t RUN DATE 05/31/91 '• ‘ ! : •f. 4‘* BATCH DOS HErtlEPIN COUKTY PROPERTY INFOmATION SYSTEM « PROPERTY OHNERS LIST • I PROP AODR QHNER NAME TAXPAYER NAHE/AOOR ) *• 38 17-117-23 21 0001 03605 NORTH SHORE DR JAMES A PONERS JAMES A PONERS 2475 DUNHOODY AVE HAYZATA MN 55391 PROP ADDR OlfCR NAME TAXPAYER NAME/AODR 38 17-117-23 22 0012 01635 SHAOYHOOD RD RALPH E MILLER ETAL RALPH E MILLER 1635 SHADYHOOO RO NAYZATA MN 55391 I • I 1: i" "« I I .y • « V I • » ‘ r-> ' • ■« .1 , ,V'iI i t I 38 17-117-23 22 0001 03845 NORTH SHORE DR LOREN R FRITZ ETAL LOREN FRITZ 3845 NORTH SHORE DR M0U»4D MN 55364 TOTAL BATCH 003 00022 HPT REPORT NO. PI435401 PAGE 6 ' 38 17-117-23 22 0002 03865 NORTH SHORE DR STATE LAND DEPT THOMAS R I COOKIE J SARENPA 1670 SHADYHOOn VU HAYZATA m T'^1 I CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTED ARE AI4 ACCURATE AND TRUE REPRESENTATION OF INFORMATIOf4 AS IT APPEARS THIS DATE ON THE RECORDS OF THE HErtlEPIN COUNTY DEPARTMENF OF PROPERTY TAXATIOT4, TO FHE BEST OF MY KNQ^ILEDGE AND BELIEF. DATE ' / > ‘4. tte ^-TT . I [t' EL- t - i CITY OP ORONO ~ NOTICE The Orono Planning Commissicn will hold a public hearing in the Council Chambers at 1275 South Brown Road at 8:00 p.m. on Monday, June 17, 1991 to consider the vacation of a portion of a dedicated right-of-way lege.lly described as follows; That portion of a 14' platted alley that abuts the south line of Lot 3 and the west half of Lot 2; Block 7, Crystal Bay View, Hennepin County, Minnesota (the South half of Section 08, Township 117, Range 23). All persons wishing to be heard will appear at this time. The meeting starts at 7:00 p.m. Written comments are solicited. Plans are available for review in the City offices by appointment. CITY OF ORONO by Its Planning Commission / //V ; , V.. a-V- Jeanner Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator JAM/tln To be published the week of June 3rd and June 10th, 1991. 11 ,• - 9iy CTl) fro flDI X ‘ i iUilm.1 i• t s ^ r \I >«.■ ii»•r r^ai;fiL p * •••* L • ^f» za_9[\ 11 •iM ifil CM) Tin lj"‘" 1**1 “I "fi “S B-l l« 1 I gS )•! B« .1 w ^ k A k \ \ \ \ -e 1/g/o/m e»C7*" b'«V« I 0f>40 ’-^d'€V« / 9p^P f/utxey tca//y c/<m<yii<t^o ^iJU^Oiilf Cen*>,6-lrt#5 p*-yt-c/4 I CcrKt/^ot^ L<>t — C> 6»ofietr>c4/jj ^0^*3 •* ^y^An-tfy r: i.«^«.( COixWinA'f/eW 1 \ \ - JLct“3 u-vs.J-fcv-C ft»*^ »^ • H o'JNe»-r4i|i -.. 5^ <Sft«iJK.^//#y d//iP (o Jl^S /Ji tV \ iTiriTtHCSAtH^O .19 . riAT- 5Q)if 9 ^ *J ja.£LSl riene ^.K5 Oft lUL- • / * ■ ,;y Minder. Enginzbring Co., Inc. ENGINEERS AND SURVEYORS lamo au(%ve.viMS CIVtVi MUAilClOAW tNOlMCCBINO C4I6-5C‘^“ AVENUE N. MlNMtAPOLlS ^T. VJIMN. K.C 7- 3G3T 90IU3 TESTINia LA.MO 5L-AMVIIN10 C « o*'i 5 IF i itife « «if It li iPTie '<r ^ ''7 .i. y ^ . . I3.<^ i • *N : f • n f *• . / /L .M. j 'i 5 N.A’* -••V • •' ; J V > m i.'i I ^ ^ • • * « T K4* V i Vi V. V. • I I • # /.d? •ii: ‘C • N 9 • « j3 •* • ••• • •• •w* • •*v • S 0 0 • f ''/ -V ■*•' ’>•1 HeaE5V CEttTIPY That this I5 a true ANO coawcr OCPReSENTATIOM op K SUttvey op the 60UMOAftlES op the •^9 A&OVE OCSCRIBEO ANO OP THE LOCATiOM OF ALL BUILDINGS, IP AXiV, THLREOM , AMD ALL VISIBLE ENCROACHMEMTS, »«'■,. .TO/, o»ON sND iANo. minder -EN61WEER1NQ CO., INC. :—tm - K-D / CMQitHCEQ.^ SUR.vcyo^S •/ '■ / OAflO Tbo^ — ■ . ’ ^ \ r Planning Commission Chairman Kelley Orono Planning Commission Members City Administrator Bernhardson 0 From:Michael P. Gaffron» Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator Date:June 13, 1991 Subject: #1604 Clair and Lynn Rood - 2215 Kenwood Way - Conditional Use Permit/Variance - Third Review Additional Detail List of Exhibits Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Exhibit F Revised Topographical Survey Showing Walls Revised Revegetation Plan Showing Pillars Construction Detail, Walls 6 Pillars City Engineer Letter 5/20/91 Planning Commission Action Notice 5/22/91 Memo & Exhibits of 5/15/91 Discussion This item was tabled at Planning Commission's May meeting in order for applicant to provide additional detail regarding the brick pillars and the proposed retaining walls. The additional information provided indicates (on the Revegetation Plan) the approximate location of pillars along "Hillside Place". The diagram doesn't indicate that pillars are also proposed (and in place) along Navarre Lane and along the northeast lot line back from Navarre Lane. Applicant has provided an elevation view of his proposed hedge between the pillars, with the pillars at both the Planning Commission's 3-1/2' recommended height and at applicants proposed pillar height of 4'-6". Regarding the retaining walls, two walls each of 100' length and 3'-8" height are proposed at the northwest and southwest quadrants of the lot respectively, apparently for the purpose of reducing the bank slope of spoils to be deposited. The Building Inspection Department has advised that at this height, these walls don't require a building permit, but will be included as part of the land alteration permit if approved. The Building Inspectors also note that no safety railing or barrier is required for these walls because they are not adjacent to the house. It is staff's understanding that the concrete wall blocks giZB a split~face stone design, more aesthetically pleasing than standard foundation blocks. The City Engineer has been asked to review the revised grading plan and retaining wall plan, however, we have no report from him as of this writing. No significant changes from his comments in the May 20th letter are anticipated. - ijynpupygilfywp Zoning File #1604 June 13, 1991 Page 2 Staff Recomiendation If Planning Commission determines that there will be no adverse impact on the natural environment qualities wetland area, a project approval recommendation would be appropriate on the basis that all storm water and flood plain management engineering requirements have been met so that there is no adverse impact on the quantity or quality of run-ott leaving this site. A further basis for approval would be that the area will be restored and maintained as a natural habitat rather than a "park-like" setting. Do the proposed retaining walls have any effect on the visual perception of 'naturalness of this pond? Certainly the walls decrease the spoils bank slopes, reducing the potential for erosion back into the pond. Any recommendation for approval should be conditioned on the following: 1.Applicant shall conform to all construction and site protection requirements recommended by the City Engineer and required by the Watershed District. 2.Silt fencing shall be maintained in place during the period of excavation and until revegetation is accomplished. 3.Applicant shall adhere to the revegetation plan as proposed. 4.Applicant shall grant a Flowage easement over the entire wetland elevation contour 931.5, plus a 15' to the 8" PVC culvert at Navarre description for such easement shall applicant's surveyor. and Conservation area defined by easement extending Lane. The legal be provided by the The Planning Commission is further requested to either reaffirm or revise your recommendation regarding the allowable height of boundary pillars. Isv 1 1/1 J Bones troo Rosene Anderlik & I Associates Engineers & Architects 0!tc G 3or.eirxc P£ Rooen W 9over<^ PE Jcieoh C Araer ’rtf pe KUr^n L Sor/au. P£ R<*'an3 E PE G’err ff Coo*f PE Tho^s £ P£ Rooert G krunic*'! ®£ SoMn M C PA A GofQcr PE w Pcuer PE OortKj C 9u«}J»Ct P6 j#rr/ A Bounjon PE KUrti A Hjrson PS >3 *i P£ Mcn^ f «jutm»nn PE Pcct*: ? «»E C^.KJ O PE Thcmii W Ptienor. PE \^tcn3& C L.fKh. ?£ •jfr« R .‘.rj’ire. PS Kenretn P Anderson PE Vyic 9 Piyti *>E 9tx>e^ C Ruvve« A . A •remas t Arqul ^6 HowanS A Sar^ PE j E^gerreo pe Vi'* A .PC Phao J Cai>^«A P£ »5maf ’ MjfTrc^^E Mar^ D Air Thc'^ii ? A/ieAtf Al A Pere C PH/ma^ A i A Agnei M R>n^ AlCP .ffrry Q PT'tTiCr P£ Ceew 0:fvef PE Rooe^ R PE Gary W Vcf>en. P£ <jfen L \A'*cr^ P£ <^ttn P -^iPC *»£ A Encuson L Pn'do Gra%-n^. Li C’ser May 20, 1991 May 2 8 10-)-.•• -/vV City of Orono Box 66 Crystal Bay, MI'i 55323 Aitn: Mr. Mike Gaffron Re: File No. 139 - 1604 Clair Rood Dear Mike: We have reviewed the grading plan for Clair Rood at 2215 Kenwood Way. The wetland boundary should include a 15 foot easement to Navarre Lane for drainage purposes. The proposed excavation in the wetland area will not impact the overall storage of the drainage basin. There is some minor filling proposed below the 931.5 contour in the southeast comer of the wetland. There is proposed to be an equal amount of excavation below the 931.5 contour in the northwest comer. The remaining excavation from the pond is proposed to be placed above the 931.5 contour. We would recommend approval of the grading plan. Please contact this office if you have any questions. Yours very truly, BONESTROO, ROSENE, ANDERLIK & ASSOCIATES, INC. Glenn R. Cook GRC:U 139.cor 2335 N»test Highway 36 • St. Paul, Minnesota 55113 • 612-636-4600 1 J il CITY OF ORONO P. O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 473-7357 ZONING FILE #1604 55323 NOTICE OF PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION Date of Notice: 5/22/91 TO:Clair i Lynn Rood 2215 Kenwood Way Wayzata, MN 55391 COPIES TO: TYPE OF APPLICATION: Variance Conditional Use Permit DATS OF TING: 5/20/91 VOTE; 7 For 0 Against Planning Coaonission recoamends the following: Tabled for reasons noted below. HOTBS AND SPECIAL CONDITIONS: 1. Add fence/pillars to landscape plan drawings, and indicate proposed intent for how this fence/hedge, etc. will be finished. Provide design plans and specs for any berms or retaining walls proposed, and show them on the landscape plan. Applicant's next scheduled meeting is dependent upon receipt of additional information. Deadline for the June 17th meeting is June 7th, or July 5th for the July 15th meeting. If you desire certified copies of the official Planning Commission minutes, they are available from the City Recorder after review and approval by the Planning Commission. Isv ^ r - • - ^ mn m • r- i ttMuuiiaAtaiiiiiiiiyi To;Planning Commission Chairman Kelley Orono Planning Commission Members City Administrator Bernhardson From: Date: Michael P. Gaffron, Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator May 15, 199< Subject: #1604 Clair and Lynn Rood - 2215 Kenwood Way - Conditional Use Permit/Variance - Second Review of Revised Request - New Planting Schedule for Restoration List of Exhibits Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Exhibit F Revegetaticv; Plan Grading Plan (no changes from previous) Notice of Planning Commission Action 1-24-91 Planning Commission Minutes 11-19-90/1-22/91 Memo & Exhibits of 1-17-91 Standard form Flowage & Conservation Easement (for applicant review) Discussion As Planning Commission requested in January, the applicant has provided a revegetation plan indicating locations, sizes and quantities of various trees and shrubs to be placed on the property. The areas expected to be disturbed are intended to be revegetated with a prairie grass seed mixture, to be seeded and mulched within one week of completion of the grading work, other plant materials to be installed within two weeks of the seeding operation. The applicant's proposed planting schedule suggests that the prairie grass mixture will allow for the natural character which Planning Commission recommended be maintained for this wetland area. Referring to the memo of January 17th, the City Engineer has recommended approval of the application subject to adequate erosion protection measures and adherence to Watershed District requirements. Watershed District approval was tabled pending approval by the City of Orono. It is staff's understanding that the Watershed District will issue a permit subject to City of Orono approval. Applicant was requested by Planning Commission in January to provide the details on a shelter island and any walls or berms proposed. The applicant is not proposing any walls, berm, or islands, and has not changed his grading plan since your last meeting . Please review the memo of January 17th for specifics on the pond request. I III ift Mil I iirin ntf iinfiitift ’Miftiiiiii-iiil ■K'- Zoning Pile #1604 May 15r 1991 Page 2 Staff RecoBonendation If Planning Commission determines that there will be no adverse Impact on the natural environment qualities of this wetland area, a project approval recommendation would be appropriate on the basis that all storm water and flood plain management engineering requirements have been met so that there is no adverse impact on the quantity or quality of run-off leaving this site. A further basis for approval would be that the area will be restored and maintained as a natural habitat rather than a "park-like" setting. Approval should be conditioned on meeting all construction and site protection requirements recommended by the City Engineer and required by the Watershed District, including properly constructed silt fencing and adherence to the proposed revegetation plan. A further condition of approval would be that applicant grant a Flowage and Conservation Easement over the entire wetland area (boundary to be defined by elevation contour^to be determined by City Engineer, legal description to then be provided by applicants surveyor). Isv 93/.5' CITY OP ORONO P. O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, NN 473-7357 ZONING PILE #1604 55323 NOTICE OP PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION Date of Notice: 01/24/91 TO: Clair Rood 2215 Kenwood Way Wayzata, MN 55391 COPIES TO: TYPE OP APPLICATION Variance Conditional Use Permit DATE OP MEETING: 01/22/91 VOTE: 6 For 0 Against Planning Commission reconmiends the following Tabled for reasons noted below NOTES AND SPECIAL CONDITIONS: Planning Commission requested applicant to provide detailed information regarding restoration of the wetland and surrounding area after grading is completed: 1. Provide a planting schedule for restoration i.e. -Time schedule - Plant materials listing and site plan - Detail on shelter island if proposed - Landscaping plan (walls, berms, etc. if proposed). 2.Planning Commission indicated that their intent for this area is to maintain the natural habitat quality (as opposed to a park- like manicured look). Staff suggests you contact the Hennepin Soil & Water Conservation District (544-8572) who will work with you regarding standards for wildlife ponds. Regarding the issue of the brick pillars. Planning Commission determined that they are to be considered as a fence, and because they are in yards adjacent to dedicated public streets, can be no higher than 3 1/2* per the non-encroachments sections of the Code. No permit is required, but the pillars must be cut back to 3 1/2' high above existing grade. Applicant's next scheduled meeting is dependent upon receipt of additional information. Deadline for the February 19, 1991 meeting is Monday, February 11, 1991, or Monday, March 11, 1991 for the March 18, 1991 meeting. If the applicant has trouble obtaining additional information, please contact the Zoning Department (473-7357). If you desire certified copies of the official Planning Commission minutes, they are available from the City Clerk after review and approval by the Planning Commission. Isv • I.''■1 ( • S' December 14,1990Permit Application No. 90-126 Applicant: QairRood 2215 Kenwood Way Wayzata, MN 55391 Location: City of Orono, Sec. 17DD Purpose: Digging to create an open water pond in a wetland and fill and excavation in a floodplain area. Applicable Rules: Rule C - Floodplain Alteradon Rule D - Wetland Alteration Rule E - Dredging Exhibits Reviewed: 1. 2. 3. Pennit Application 90-126 received October 8.1990. Grading plan received October 8,1990. frLetter fiom the District to the applicant dated Oaober 22,1990 informing him of the Board action on October 18,1990. 4. Revised ate plan received December 10,1990. 5. Hydiolo^c odculanoos received Deceoibcr 10,1990. 6. Map delineating subwatershed received December 10,1990. Staff Review Siimmflryr The project involves dredging to remove 2,774 cubic yards of material from a wedand to provide tm open water pond 5 feet deep with 4:1 side sieves. The project is located north of the intersection of Navatre Lane and Hillside Place in the Qty of Orono. The wetland is connected to Crystal Bay, Lake Minnetonka by a culven with an invert elevation of 927.93. Therefore, this wetland acts as part of the floodplain for Lake Minnetonka. Spoil is to be placed adjacent to the pond at a slope of approximately 3.5:1. Fill is to be placed within the wedand along the cast edge. Excavation is m be provided alcmg the west edge to compensate for storage capacity loss wit^ the floodplaita. It is unclear from the information submitted whether the proposed excavation is at the same elevation as the fill This project was reviewed and tabled at the regularly scheduled October meeting of the Board of Managers. The Orono Planning Commission has tabled this project. The next Planning Commi^on meeting is Janua^ 22, 1991. District rules specify that the Managers will review applications fOT permits iiwolving land development only after the applicant demonstrates that the plan has receive preliminary approval from the municipality indicating compliance with the municipal plans. Recommendation Table 1. ling recent of: Sta^e/storage relationship for the wedand for both existing and proposed conditions begmning at the runout elevation of Lake Minnetonka of 928.6 providmg no net decrease in stormwater storage capacity at various stages. 2. Revised plan providmg maximum spoil disposal slopes of 4:1 and revised silt fence installation detail providing wire mesh reinforcing for the rilt fence and posts spaced no grea^ than 4 feet apart 3. Review and q>proval by the Qty of Orono. Pro^ct Review Status hv Other fSnvcrnmcntal Units: of Orono is cunendy reviewing this project 8 of 19 iihiiniif r irmn * ‘t: A/ Lg<jal Descri pt ion :*’WALLACE'S ADDITION VILLAGE OF MINNETONKA UEACH".rO THE I hereby certify that this survey was prepared by me or under my direct super vision and th»it I am a duly regj stored land surveyor under the laws of the State of Minnesota. COFFIN « GRONBERG. INC. Ma rlT3'. (jroribe r g 'Tnin.TcTTnr.TZTE^ Lriyineers. Land Surveyors, Planners Long lake, Minnesota Date : Scale: 1" = 50' ^ : Iron marker Bearings shown are to an assumed datum. (t?o.z) ‘ bpot elevation Datum; Mean Sea Level Existing contour from drawing by others. ‘IC-/ • • ■ ' i I-41 WATCRSMfO I0UN0AHT MINNEHAHA CREEK WATERSHED DISTRICT P.P Box 3S7, Wayxata. Minnesota 55391 MRn»IIANMBIS:JaRMR.SpMslisPm.*JoimETtNnas*nctanlR. MHl«r RdM 0. Ertckaan • C. tftadrew Lm • Cliiliaon Lindtoy * Thotnas Mapto, Jr. UKC MINNCTONXA t* & December 14,1990 Permit Application No. 90-126 Applicant: Clair Rood 2215 Kenwood Way Wayzata,MN 55391 City of Orono, Sec. 17DD Digging to create an open water pond in a wetland and fill and excavation in a floodplain area. Location: Purpose: Enclo^ please find the Engineer's report and recommendation for your rermit application. The permirwiU be reviewed by the Board of Managers on December 20,1990. The meeting will be held at the Wavzata Qty Hall and bedn at 7:30 PM.at the Wayzata Qty Hall and begin at 7:30 PM. If you have any questions concerning this report or recommendation, please call Ron Quanbeck at • • t ^ • • • I ^raniifcf i»ti irar ii 11 ^it ~iiiinii»ii > ■ 31VfO O'- Mii D ^ ^ V M m '.. T ■:• b ItXt MINNITONIIk yy r f. - ic - ;• • *^T« % ,4 t0 ■^ J a. J • ^ P.O. Box 387, Wayzata. Minnesota 55391 MMO OF MANAGERS: Janies R Spensley. Pres • John E Thomas • Ru:nard R Miiier Roden 0. EhcKson • C Woodrow Love • Cla/Kson Unoiey • Ihoiiias Mapie. Jr December 26,1990Permit Application No. 90-126 Applicant; Clair Rood 2215 Kenwood Way Wayzata, MN 55391 Location; City of Orono, Sec. 17DD Purpose: Dredging to create an open water pond in a wetland and fill and excavation in a floodplain area. Dear Mr. Rood: At the regularly scheduled December 20,1990 meeting of the Board of Managers, the subject permit application was tabled pending receipt of; 1 . Review and approval by the City of Orono. This item should be received no later than Jar.uary 7, 1991 to ensure your pennit application will be on the agenda for die next meeting of the Board of Managers scheduled for January 17, 1991. Should you have any questions regarding this matter, plea.ce contact me at 473-4224. Sincerely, lAMES M. MONTGOMERY, CONSULTING ENGINEERS, INC Engineers for the District Ronald S. Quanbeck, P.E. cc: BqardTile zCiiy of Orono Mark Gronberg i ■ m Bones troo Rosene Anderllk & Associates 0*T5 G 9c'*fsr-rc Roceft A/ fjienr PB jOSfOn C Anoen^ PB Marw.n L Siyva-^ P<"‘-»n3 E V''?' PB •jr^S C 3"lC'' ®£ G«nn R Ccw PE ">c^as € Nov^ ®E G ^c•*ur'<rt PB Jjiin M £tc' n CP* Engineers & Architects r^-n A GorJon »E A/ Boner PE Cora-0 C SufV^ra P£ ^erry A BOortXJn PE Van A Hanson PE “-J k Sens PE V<rjei T Sjut'Tijrn PE PcceT R PE O LOs*tctj P£ T*'cn'j$ O' PE V<*-a<r< C ^E jjmes -R PE P ^ricefion PS \U'« R Rs^ PE Room C RuiiW. A t A 'N:rr.3s E Anguv P£ >-<?wv3«0 A SAn^OAl PE j Ecgentn PE Var* A Sec PE 0 J ®£ v'naet Ma-'tmex pe Vane D PE T*»(3*«3^ R An-f^cn. A f A Ga^ P R>'*arK3ef p£ Maps B jprsen P£ L p*wt<) Grav^ « PE •pf'p C P’uma/T. AI A. V“ps *.* Rir^ A IC P i-rry D Permcn PE Citao Oviet PE Rocm R CmncMT pe Gar* ,v storm PE Chjnes A trillion Leo M PawefUry Manan m Qtson January 16,1991 City of Orono Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 JAN 1 3 1991 Attn; Mike Gaffron Re: Clair Rood Our File No. 139-1604 Dear Mike; We have reviewed the hydraulics information submitted on the Clair Rood property. The proposal calls for constructing a 5 fr/ .eep pond within the wetland area. The material excavated from the pond will be placed si)uih ot the pond near Navarre Tane. The storm water calculations indicate that the high water elevation will be below 931.5 which is acceptable for the ponding area. The excavation will not reduce the storage capacity in the watershed. We would recommend approval of the application provided adequate silt fence is installed and watershed requirements are followed. Please contact this otfice if you have any questions. Yours very truly. BONESTROO, ROSENE, ANDERLIK & ASSOCIATES, INC. jt Glenn R. Cook GRCdh Enel. 2335 Wiest Highway 36 • St. Paul, Minnesota 55113 • 612-636-4600 c I Ks'.MXiMiydKH Zoning File #1604 January 17, 1991 Page 3 of 3 As a separate but related issue, staff requests the Planning Commission's direction regarding the brick pillars. Should they be considered as a fence, or as accessory structures? Based on that determination and given the relationship to surrounding street lot lines, should the pillars be allowed at the existing 5-6' height, or should their height be reduced? Do they need to be relocated? Should they be subject to a building permit or variance application? Ii-fur • Zoning Pile #1604 January 16, 1991 Page 2 of 3 Discussion - The City Engineer has reviewed the application from a storm water management standpoint and has recommended approval conditioned on adequate silt fencing and compliance with Watershed District requirements. The Minnehaha Creek Watershed District has preliminarily reviewed and tabled the application until preliminary approval from Orono (Planning Commission approval) is granted. The applicant's engineer has made the plan revisions requested by the Watershed District and has provided the engineering and hydraulics data necessary to show no adverse storm water/flood plain management impact. Remaining Issues - As noted in the memo of November 15th, absent any zoning code directive that su pond construction is strictly prohibited under any circumstances, if all hydrolog5.c/engineering concerns are satisfied, then the only other question ir. the granting of this conditional use permit is rather subjective: will construction of this pond and proposed grading work at its perimeter be compatible with the policies expressed in Section 10.55, Subdivision i, i.e. will such work have no adverse effect on the natural environment qualities of this wetland area? While there has been some neighborhood opposition to the proposed changes to the wetland, the applicant has reiterated his goals are to create a better wildlife habitat while cleaning up the debris and trash dumped on the property over many years. Finally, please again review Page 4 of the November 15th memo regarding the issue of the brick pillars constructed around the perimeter of th2j property. Please direct staff and applicant as to whether the pillars in question are allowed^ "as-is" as a fence, or whether they should be subject to a building permit or variance application. Staff Reco—nendation If the Planning Commxssion agrees that the proposed work vill have no adverse impact on the natural environment qualities of this wetland area, a recommendation for project approval could be appropriate on the basis that all storm water and flood plaxn management engineering requirements have been met so that there is no adverse impact on the quantity or quality of run-off leaving the site. Approval would be conditioned on meeting all construction and site protection requirements recoi^ended by the City Engineer and required by the Watershed District, including properly constructed silt fencing and timely revegetation of disturbed areas. To;Planning Conunission Chairman Kelley Orono Planning Commission Members City Administrator Bernhardson From: Date: Michael P. Gaffron, Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator January 17, 1991 Subject:#1604 Clair Rood, 2215 Kenwood Way Conditional Use Permit/Variance - Continuation of Public Hearing Zoning District - LR-IC, Single family lakeshore residential, % acre, sewered Application - Revised request for conditional use permit and variance to create a pond within a designated wetland. List of Exhibits Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Exhibit F Exhibit G City Engineer's Letter 1/16/91 M.C.W.D. Letter 12/26/90 M.C.W.D. Application Review 12/14/90 Revised Grading Plan Hydraulic Calculations by Applicant's Engineer Planning Commission Minutes 11/19/90 Memo & Exhibits of 11/15/90 Revisions/Additional Information - jj|r Applicant has slightly revised his proposal and provided additional information as required by the Watershed District and the City Engineer; 1. The pond is now proposed at a depth of 5' rather than 12' . 2. The pond side slopes have been flattened to a 4:1 grade, enhancing both the stability and safety of those slopes. 3. The pond surface area dimensions remain the same as before, i.e. approximately 1/2 acre open water within the 1.5 acre designated wetland. 4. The volume of dredge spoils is estimated at 2,774 cubic yards. The dredge spoils are now proposed to remain on site, generally along the south end of the site (see plan). 5. Excavation is proposed at the northwest end of the wetland to provide equivalent storm water storage to that which will be lost by filling at the east side of the pond. ,«r (7) '' “'a- f o . t i; ORONO PIAiraiNG COMMISSION MEETING JANUARY 22, 1991 ZONING FILE #1604-ROOD CONTINUED four feet." Bellows suggested that it may be in Mr. Rood's best interest to entirely forego the pi-lars. Mr. Rood asked wher.der he could apply for a Variance to have the pillars five feet high. Kelley informed Mr. ^ rK^""nan^'’fnr Cc^issicn been fairly consistent in recommending that fences along public roadways be no no-e 3.5 feet high." #1605 DR. RICHARD LINDSTROM 1065 WEST FERNDALE ROAD VARIANCES CONTINUATION OF PUBLIC HEARING and Paul Bedke^*,Charles Lindstrom, the c-tpl^canfs brother, ' ^rni%^1^o7e^^i^narreSns-i^ ^^tr^Vrle^-tndJ “T ^^ould abstain from the discussion and voting on tnis matter. Kelley opened the Public Hearing at 8:45 p.m. raff-nn distributed a sketvck showing the revis-?d root heich?r a;d floor elevatinns. He said. '•The applicants for the ' havp rev’’sed their olan to keep harccover ou- of the 0-75* ^setback area.* The only encroachment in that setback \"re”a There mus\ ‘be a aV' oool* s'etb'ack from the side lot !!:e aSd ! a; concern^rabout the elevation of the bcser.ent floor in relation to the flood plain. Mr- R.-.f^ker referred the Planning Commission to the sketch tha*. Ga‘-4of had dVsVri^^ He said, "You can see that the existing basement is below the flood plain elevation. 2^q to construct the first level of t.ie garage at tne 932^6 elevation. The second level of garage woula be at '39.11, ^hicn is approximately two feet above the second floor addition would even out across -ha garage a..dition a^r the existing structure. We are proposing to construct a Srtek‘planter, dif f el^an'ce"".(n g"arS ilevation^.^"'‘The"°drive^ will slope up that additional two feet along the planter up to the garage." Bellows asked Mr. Bedker what the slope is coming out of the lower garage. Mr. Bedker replied, "We are proposing a 5% slope - 10 - Z•o r ilf' \ _M ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING OANDARY 22, 1991 on his plans he area around the pond. Hr. Rood 7. “??“was ^ "'hfve'conlidllad just let it come back ^s On the side near my sanctuary/island in the ^ into* mv'yard. On the other side, yard, the we,—and ;]usw - ou*-* There is an exoosea gas there is a ^ to do somethirc to divert t.oe water so ihat erosion will not continue. Perhaps put in some rock walls. Hoiiowc? seconded bv Cohen ^ to table this It was moved by o. a iomorehensive plan and aoplication p.ending that will maintain the planting diagram /f.^te as wetland in as natu-a- • - , aeiav the monument issue. She tabling the pone issue woui- “®"®-.,at issue seoarately. It stated that "lanninc SLmission to' act on the WAS t.he consensus or the . - :^ves-6, Mavs-0. Motionmonument issue separately. Motio... -iyes », carried. 1 - M- Rood should make a separateKelley askea whe_h - the Planning Commissionapolication for the monume.nts. He asxe-. how they view the monuments. monuments”%%nlt%.u”rrrence7n^'’\hoi?rh:^er:^^^^^^^^^ 3 5 f0Sti • Hr. Rood stated that H® ' c"reni" growrto "a J,”;:?:rreigt: O^hree « -Id 7e ^if leirhtrh rn°"’a"‘’:ackjar^?’ n,\" rerUce"' there was a dedicated right-of-way there." Bellows asked i£ the plantings between the pillars had to be restricted to a certain height. , i.1,0 ri ®-v Code does not address theMabusth stated t.hat .he Ci.y sight distance is aheight for plantings except in cases whe.e sight a factor." .. >3 a-Hat- -if the Citv Ordinances are followed in this "Vasr VomVthing very' hideJ.s in appearance may be constructed. Mr. Rood explained that he had St'-rlel pillars to be five feet high. He ® around them to ?ight now. but 1 would be three to achieve a uniform rive loow - 9 - i iittftliii 11 ...11 ifmitffMfiVr-BBau iAHBai _J ^ V»^- ***»l^V - 4 i; s. ‘-S.- I>'T- ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING JANUARY 22, 1991 ZONING FILE #1604-ROOD CON’flNUED . , wild^i^o -s in the Hanson stated ,, Htracted'^'t^o the area once the alterations have been made. He attracted ^ -oneso **^'a** issue is subjective. In my opinion, cleaning‘\p‘t.he wetland’isthe more significant issue and enables me to view this favorably.” disturb them." She asked Mr. Rood what he intends to ao with the rushes and stated that is where the ducks ana geese hiae. Mr. Rood stated that most of the rushes would remain jusv. as they are. „ ansrs j may appropriate to table this matter until summer. to thir^cle\\\e.''^’'she"sVid!"^'If''lt''i^^ necessary area, that is one thing. I do not agree with e.xcavating, filling and changinc the nature of the wetland. Moos stated that she had no objections to Mr. Rood's pond proposal. Bellows concurred with Moos. She said, problem with altering the wetland in this manner. Rowlette said, "I am concern ad that it will antiseptic looking." be very Bellows suggested, given the delicate nature of this land, that Mr. Rood submit a landscape plan showing She said, "That may provide us with a means of assuring t neighbors that the wetland will be left as natural as possi e, while accommodating a reasonable request rrom the nomeowner. - 8 - o ^4^®' xf 'tr \ \ \ \ Mm M4^Af«iWiCC« K'-rw- >*.rt. ^ ■ i* ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING JAITOARY 22, 1991 #1604 CLAIR ROOD 2215 KENWOOD WAY CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT CONTINUATION OF PUBLIC HEARING . . . Mr. Rood was present, as was Mrs. Lorraxne Moss, a neignoor interested in this application. askedKelley re~opened the Public Hearing at 6:15 p.it. Gaffron to briefly review Mr. Rood's proposal. ana Ga-fron stated that Mr. Rood had revised his proposal since chanced, but the slopes are now snown at a ..ou.. one -a. o, as ODDOsed to one tc one. Mr. Rood is still requesting approval ^o convert approximately one-third of the watlanas into pond ^-ej. He is also proposing to fill and excavate portions of ^he wetland " Gaffron showed the Planning Commission wnere the spoils 'would be deposited and stated that it would be necessary for the acplicant tc nrovide silt fencing and erosion con^^ol measures. ' Ha reviewed the additional issues involved witn this aoplication as noted in his January 17, 1991 me.mo. Cohen asked if the monuments were still an issue. Gaffron reolied, "The monuments may be a separate issue. T.here is an undeveloped public right-of-way to the rear and side If tney^ are an accessory structure, snould they meet a 10 toot setback, if they can exist at all in a siae yara or rear yar^ without a Conditional Use Permit. Thera are many issues. Rowlette asked whether Mr. Rood had a specific reason, other than aesthetics, for altering the wetiaid. Gaffron stated that the applicant's ma^or intent is to clean up the wetlandr, which have been used as a dumping ground for years. He said, "Mr. Rood also wants to aesthetically the appearance of the wetland in addition to creating some different characteristics for wildlife." Mr. Rood stated that he has not seen a great deal of wildlife in the wetland. He said, "I thought if additional area of open water, it may ^ would like to install some wood duck houses and I unde-s^and that the ducks must land in water. It is not my intention to es^... , the wildlife." I f 'lliit rmairiifi * w ORONO PUUINING COMMISSION MEETING NOVEMBER 19, 1990 u.. <1.. 1... -;■« • "habitat I startad oleaniag out the debris and found thaf there IS V 4" gas line exposed near the culvert under Navarra Lane." T’here were no further comments from the public regarding this matter and the Public- Hearing was continuea. Motion, Ayes-6, Nays-0. Motion carried. #1605 DR. RICHARD LINDSTROM - 1065 WEST FERNDALE ROAD VARIANCES a ao r, 14- PUBLIC^HE^INGa8:43J.M.^ Certificate of Mailing were duly noted. Mr Pau’ Bedker, Dr. Lindstrom's Architect, and Mr. Charles Lindstroa.f «e« present. Cohan indicated that it w°u .o be necessary for him to abstain from discussion ana voting on this matter Vcauae of his professronal relationshrp to the applicant's representative. Gaffron reviewed the information partaining to * linds^omT application (see Michael Gaffron's memo dated November 1.5, 1990). Bellows said, "Before we get too involved ^ would li’-e to say that I see absolutely no hardship for the Lees requested. I find it hard to b.slieve that such requests have been brought before us. .... point, because I cannot consider the other aspects of thi application." proposed additions. Mr. Bcidker replied, "The plans before you represent the ideas of Dr. Lindstrom." Kelley said, "From mv point of view, I may vote favorably for the second story addition. If you wish to submit a new - 13 - L ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING NOVEMBER 19. 1990 ZONING FILE #1603-JACOBS CONTINUED , Lnson said, "Tha City is in possession or a letter i-ica?in- Hr. Jacobs' willincr.eas to legally comoiae _ tne paJ^elL I would be willing to recom-tend approval basea on that." It was moved by Cohen, seconded by Johnson, to withdraw the motion to table this application. Motion, Ayes-w, Conen. Nay. Motion carried. PiS as oversized ^accessory structures; and (2) a Variance to allowed total ar^a for accessory structure on a property. The allow_d is 6 000 sf!, proposed is 10,795 s.f. Tne hardship is the size on this parcel in relation to t.he zoning district in which is located It is further recommended that the applicant provide comprehensive plan of the combined parcels for Council review and that covenants be filed on the chain of title accessory structures and future suodividing or '-h-s parcel. Motion, Ayes-'l, Bellows and Cohen, Nays. Motion carried. believed that the application was forced anead and preterred to see a comprehensive plan before maKing a recommenaation. B..llows concurred with Cohen aid reiterated her comments regarding the commercial appearance of this greenhouse structure. #1604 CLAIR ROOD - 2215 KENWOOD ViAY CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT PUBLIC HEARING 8:30 P.M. TO 3:40 P.M. Mr. Rood was present. The Affidavit of Publication and Certificate of Mailing were duly noted. Gaffron summarized the information contained in his November 15, 1990 memo. Ms. Lorraine Moss. 3.335 Crystal Bay Road, e,xpressed concern A.n.-’uf Mr. Rood's proposal destroying the characteristic of the wetU.d. She stated that the wetland is a wildlife habitat and that she would hate to see anything happen to change lu. boucht this property, the house was unfinished. The bo y • p the corner dumped all of their trash in the * I have changed my proposal and no longer intend --o ig a to a twelve foot depth. The Army Corp o,f Engineers sent me a letter indicating the ramifications of doing that. My surveyor - 12 - 'ks^iiks.'ri.r I'v H> ■ .lA-uw t uXkcvrs^T^ a i" 7 ■ , • . * . . « • f • • t t • . / .. • * L^iiik ,'r_ ( rrifum iilMitflt r »•••*. # • . sryi.(rf - r.ra/iA(t^ . jFaA \ ex/sTy/t/e. iuercA^^p-s. • • i • •• £££jL^. : . C€i/f‘L. . AR^A z/yc/f^AifAyrAL i/ol. A ccum . t/di^ • • i ■ . L; ?i.a J-... fi(.|/ fJ!/i 51.. •••• • • * • o; i.H ^.y 2.,?; FT.200 Je.rr. 3Z^.2 00 HO.O ^7y /O O " >6 ^ Cu.Ar. ^%s7o ;// ’77, ooo >/ ’fs/SAO" ■ r. 0 CU.A C920 .^€,030 " /3J, 030 " I r • :.. .;, i ! • • • • • • . >•• ..• ••• •• • f- * t •• ■•»• •• I • • ••w-f « »•■•••••< t. ; : • » •• • •*# . . JTA.<?F ^ JTaAA(?F ; A^oFOS^^a cUfTiAA^OS ^CF!/.{So, ft ) /AyCAf/nfx^AL i/Ai.. ACta/^. IAO l. •• • # > • • • yi/ 1.._• • •• • • -r ./V? .. O.i • • • • • • Ay 2.i«* . 2-? •• *. • • • • ••• •- • • ••• ■ • • • . ’2.0.0 JA.fr^ 3.F,^oo . **. . 72, oo.d // 37, S2>27 " . 300 ". •71^0 ^t4 rFr. 53', yso • 79; 7SO' f ySy^OO'*^' . 0 c</. 7 /*fO FO, 390 " /9o,0^o '' \ ■ •. *# • •• % .« ' . «f « s i« • • 7^€f^roAAO^ yocuAF MAS ActaAuy A€.f^ /sFCAeArro \foo^r a 4t .p/F'^JOA/AHS . STA06JI. MAxOfF 77^0. AAPFO^FO:MOA a A. { i 4 .U I • • ■ • • I • • • •• •• I *• « - «••• • i* »•••«•••• «•« •••• • « »••••»•.• • • . a. •« •«• •«• •• MW ■• .. . ••••«• « • •• * • • • • . » • • * « I 1 J !.•« ••••« • • *. 1 *• • • * ^•••■••* • ad *^k I .*• 4. • • • m • • • •• • • ♦ • mm «•• • <« • • COA/ryy^]^ OAAAA^FAO,, i.•* t •• • • •• • ■ --:^/ cc^t:^/ t^2t this-plai, speclflcatlcrf* '“r/rcri y.cs’prepared by rtJe or under'my, • .. E'ipirvic cn and-that I am a duly Rcois* ’ .; r.ercosionel.Enjjineer under lha laws ot 2 z 'i>. of Minne^ta. ' > | Ui;e /Z Rr^. No> /Z7jy :' aasi>M \ » I I' i . /^ooD u:;r. - ZJ.7i A<k€S \ \ ^ ' ‘ . •* * ' - ../(i4Mah:F. Aacto/l ^ C.= o,*io i- . ... \.7yti£...oi^.:Cauc.. Sa ./^jaa .^. -r 3,Z .DEC 2 1' :v!>;i LJ^^-JZ JTA ^. Q.yo (J.2) Zi*. 7<r -i S<?, y/. C/TJ 900 » y 57T • ; 1 «f 1 Jll-\lk:4.^€^rS.rP.(^^.C’e. ^/s^e. ^rrAckfO. . * • < 1 -•~}--H—•• - ' £l€l/U/XTf/^ .Cfi/€L ais.v'nHM.^.. '?£oL-i ,LJ....; ?ji/ •♦*•- - f 92^ . -?J5 . fP... . /; C . Zi6 ./.. /T.. I k'✓cr /-T^g ■ >gy:) *f?,sao\ . ^.C^.9oa . . Z7, /oo \ zoo . ■ 6~oo . /AACje^/y\€A.^AL uat • 3 % ^2.0 c,/^: • 77, Ooo ** • • J-^,€50 // • J/o, *)oo •' ACru/^ i/^i-. . ^7 (T. 910 / /n,9io •' 2oZa ^70 " J/.9. 4.. ArrAC/tfa (T aaaa) •.. I J>/fCJ/AAO^. Jl"CA^P AT auTLfr y L=Zoo y S - .ooZSS, . . cz/rfcr Ca^tac HtA. fc-- /A't/. S ; 1* ~ iX -• 72</ 929.V ^.930.0 927.93 /J /A^U. r —^; Mi ha -I So I- i ! :. • 'j 917. 9S • «• t0 ‘ i ./y = ^OJ •£o 4^LS a \ . . . .., <>■ ■ ~' ru/^Vo'^'Lti • 0 • m - • • • ' ’ acA^sM ^ * • ! i^oio ___.UiH.___ 1 ..^,-y7L o. £\ . Q.7 • «I-t ! 1. :<fp!u7.... -^‘>7 //✓c. €. \ %5 •V *T‘N ruz . . - // • • •____Z.£. \ . z.r • • • •1 AC .9Z9.H .?Jjak^..5;.f // .« « • *««i ... 3.£.": . 2.5. 1 .. .fl£l/.....A/2a2 rtp/^Ao -7 Jo :.... j±^. . ^ • « #• %• • • .2*07.... .ZoS9. ...O. Y7 O.. ; . 0 • ■ • • • • m . m « . [SJ/^—2a 07 _ ////. 7-P./aL • • •Uf/r/f rco .922oO 9.07 . . ..ft •2a O /,?AC 930.0 • .9U 0 ..:S^o7. ' ^ • -T ////* • • * #« « 1 ... 2.Q • • «. anJUMj* • —• W • •■• • •• «..-»••• TrAPf-jTojtjff 0A/TO T0A jtr • • . Y^atOL . . • * A ^ . ____ • « • • m ^ • • •••• • • • AfCJiA'». UOf ,^A 72P.uO. .:..c. : A-<? 92Z.. O. . 2.Q ^ . My^oo. sa.fy:, .....?7, ^oo. . ; . /a C, 2 jOO . 1 . /fS, 6po 77,000- €SO rfo, 9oo . O 77,000. " /7f, £SO 27% SSO // it Aik. r HT,. .yMtiaU/ /S ^ Srf/> /r^r'Cr/a,iy ,. . - 50/^jfy. - ^o. y/ /fy'^feox *y*'/A r/a,^ T’a T//£ /?ecA^i*tAr,JAyy^ £>€Sf-Sf I '^/f>>! '^/Aa iO^ ^ CPI O..L\ O,. t. : OiS \ 0.7 ■ 0-2 O, 7: A. <2 . A t.: A ^u ? • \.01H ^9is i . ,1 / !. IS 1. So .ss . *7S \A o \ Af ./.po . J2 Ac * % 5 to ts• • io. I i^X: so ss. VO. vs So ss CO 0.73 . Z,27 CAl iO» a /S.70. n.n zv.oz. 17,37 29.10 So,i/. ZJ. 70 27.37. fSA A3 A y s 7.C A 7* A S' A ? 1^0 2./ Z. ^ 1.3 Z.9 AS .7i .a. AS A2 ,n. AC. .37 .27 AH. Ao, AI /fOj»T/A^c: TAOLC 2DJ.• « ' T/Atf A mm^) /AAPCOOy CcPS) < Ohi4 ^ CP r O, CPS cs is.cs.2.5 as .75 *i.SC 7o 12. SO 2.C /Jo • 2, HS .75 /?. H6 2,7 .fjs AZ 3.CS So ACA3,2.S ./.Po • 70 3.OH SC /H.60 ..lA :/vs .OJ 2.7H /2.77 .A.o ./So..AS 2.V3 is /OAS ..3. / ./ST • 07 2A3 iOO 9-V3 3.1 ./Co a C /.a 1 fos S.^i •,S. 3 /CS . OS . /.sz fio 7.7c? .. ?. y /^o ■A.H //r C.oS 7--5-/7S 7.ZZ tio SA7 ,AA iSO..03 o. 9/ -Oi) » • ( S • • ru/^r 929. V STOSAC^ CCiA, trr.1 . ..OC/T^lra£.^ Ac.!^ 11 A.J. :..... 5. . ..0.73 . .• • .« . ^ , , KJ• • • • • ; . o ■ ll '' 70 . 2A9 . .• o yL±.__./j . i C.3H /OS6• • ' . • • •o s 10 JO.CV .. .: .. .....o.A ;4 « f « « m f.I...,_..i_? .. ,„ .JSAO , ,. :. . .... <7./5. . • • *7_.._i_ Ja ... .: ..J1A2.......... S'^'.V/o.ifa . ;..... . C7AS\ )s . .. .ZV^uOZ . .... /S, SJ.S \. ..: 0.}S\ 7 Ho 27.J7 .. .^'••/zs,*37 :■■: ;C7.S5\ 70 Hs IH.SO . .; ^^‘/f/,£g3 : : .. . o.c . a__ .^. .. . .3o.HA . .'’‘“/vo. -iys . . .. . 0.7 s 71 S5«•••«•• • ^ • • • •29Ao. ... .. . . OA . tJ A. Ao. .............27.37 . .;■'. <7.77. /H1.A. ..C5. : . .2SA5 *. ... - . . ./. ^75 7S.......7o........... .21«5<? .’’’'''5^7X37/ . .A /2 • • • /C A....7J-..- ... ..« •/9A6 i.. f'y?7.7/.5 ... .. i /. Z . 77 fo /C.73 . .. ; ts, 2(3. . . .: . V.2.? >f...\. tz. . .7A..CO . .. : A3 n 7» • - . I ■■ •m.m^ ^ • ••■ • - •Z2..77. .: .. /.35-. lo\ 9T 70,15 .. ^**^YH7A23 . . .. .; A37 2/ /Oct 9A^7""y'/^./97.. ..A 37 • •# • • • • 21 70S 2.2./. ./oz^cos . .AT' . iMiir irifci^nrtliyiifiiMi laiiiniminiififc'i iffTn Y^■l wHif^rtiiiMiuntrhrTuritiartiimai jfc' .. .. Trc^dg:f ^f>tj rr) „ iOc/r^t.£tr.^ ^r/^- I .. 1. :.JLI.L... \..^X-^... " is ' %:c Izi.lJ 1 I * f _i-.-.i \I^ J.J IJf.XJ . i * 2} '‘ . j> ' '— ♦ ■ #•« «*• .. /JO. . /iS. :. Lla \ /2S • • . • . ^ .■ /2c ■ ...; /2S.1 /*fa- I •? i /Vy^ i • • « • /ss •. , /Sc ■ « • • • /OS ■ • • • /"*o• • • /7S ....... . 7^30 . , .. .: .. 0^,a2 i .J : J?:y7 : ;. : : : . 9^ i’.r5- ?.o</ ” ■? I * • . A , ,Z7r % • 4» 2 22 /S2 /* 2 2 •• : • 1• • *• •«••««« . »« rcy AT 9^0^ . .. /Ay^i*e^ (CPS), . ,i ! I ? . ..:2..:... A ■ - ■ /! ! ! - O .. s . /c T n 71. ._!^_.o. I //; f *'•«■• iti »•« ««•• 4 /i, % *1 ■■ ■ ■ . /A__ 7H 20 : IS.. • - Js . . . Yo ... vr . So ,-Tx. .:• . • •« »* « • • • 4 •-•••• • • • .L. • • • • • • # • • « m m • « « . - d-73 . ?7 ;V. j? /o.6^ '.tSr^O t% 77• • • • • • Z%. .Z7.S7. 29.20 30.*ft. 27. i 7 , - -•\_____70 • .....27 sc. • »<»- • • • m t • /S '■ :..7S .........-..2.9.76 1 • f — • - • /? i • ; « •1.. . 26.73.i • -‘— • I/r ! • • • •:-px : :. .. . 29.60 ! .rf._L._L :fc . ./Z.77 « 4. « •»•• !t•‘X• i7 -.■• • ■ . .^ • •.«»• « « /C. 9S • . «*«• • 2L.I, ':./oy?• <« • « *•?. V3••-«•«# •« • •• /ox : .■ 2.-ZI• • • • •• • •• • ^ • • /to• • •7.30• • - • ♦ «» iliy^ /7?Oy y^. <fZZ. . /C7,?20, . /o%o2i... /o%jS5 V/0,721.... ///^so6 .. \ ///.23V ; //Z,.160 . ; /./z,y25 , i ^^^/ //2, 07Y. "^y//2,770 "■ y//i77s : : '^V//.Z,.C91 :...; iTOdedfi^ Crc.rK) .: .0. . , V2/?: , '^•Vsooi .^'"'.Vmo. '^*\*/23^7n , ^**V3i,g3^ .. ^V%S7S : ^ys7,^oz.. yy^<C255 lJ 7-r>6/yjyj, ^‘'‘*V?o,.ns.... "‘‘VT5,.£77:...i ^‘*VH 33J - . 4 "^‘y/^f/sss. j. ^y^97,:gcf : ^'^^/’/oa.i7te. .. /OS. Z/.9 . . t -r / y /.vz AY3 /. Y5 /.Y< /.Y7 A "72 /. .5^ /•f- /.5 X5- AS '. <y. 1 '// /•s . s^. • 4 • • • • I t • • »^ 4 •••« — • • • • O ^ Q : O. : O : 0.5 0,7s 10-3S. \O^H2 .OrS :P.7Z 'p.?6 O.J2 /.OZ /.'2. /./^ . /.22 . /. 25* . A 3,2 . A 3 A 3/ . A33 m • • • I Mdck t.^1 -.1-■AitlM.Vijrmj .............. * > *• 0 • • /A/p ‘cocy C cy^^) • • • * SraAA(^f Cci/.rr.)OcATyioc^^CcA ; « mm-m • ♦- • ■ • • .2Y 0 • 0 • . . /'^ . • -0 0 • • ♦ ' ^'^^y/oy.oyo /, 3 7 '^X • • - ^ • —i# • •................ . . J ./cyZ,9i3 A 7? .i,.^< :. /2 5 . . y. : 27 • 0« < « i^.95 ^77//. y/ .1?. .. .. f3S . . 3. CS .//y,3s 7 • 00 ^ \n .. . I'iO y. ov . ;./49 ;/H5 2. 79 00 • //2,SO^ yn, Z99 A /.H5 .:3<. : /i . . /7<? /Jr • 9 0 0 0 0 . . 2,'S t^H5 . • <« • . « 3i • ' • • y6o • • • • • A /. 95 • • •• • • /J5 A ^2....... ' ^*y/yy,soS' « • • • •- • 0 . • /7^» 0 0 /. 2 i '^'///3^52^CJT95 AfA ..•l^ • . \iC: .: • *0 « /7J # • • 0 0 0. • 0 0* 0 . /. 22. • 0 > • 0 • 0 0 /yy,v6<7 • . . 0 • * -0 0 0 • /.9S 0 « • r*//r^ • 0 . 2 f Tja. /tvt ec^uAT/j>y . *729. y.y^J' 4 . ^ .r//f j~a 7? KO /aU yf* /^o yfi< ^ C^J/^<^ vf . ^yc?.o S’T/47/a-'<^ ^a,.x^ 7?yf ^auc^ y^/ff TC^ 9j7,ys Sf/^fiA€ r//(^ iJJtf /e.ase ro 9J/,S £t/fA^ru^ctr , • AIA^ /^C> T'fAA ^i-Cty/tT~/ /7/6- C*yfCL AJ ‘ £A/^f /AA/y^ ry>iAA-A^ c<a /r// /uo ^^i\r JW><y^.r t/OliA/A^ Attau^Aa SfCaCs^ 9S/.S" r/a/y. . . . • « . *• • « • • <« • • • • • •• ' ^ • • « • • • •*• • » • • • • • / C^etAAS€/^C^ • • • • • •• • • • ♦ I I'.orc^y ccriify i!iat tirs pl-n, specificafcnv or r::^'ort v.'os prepared, by. mo or under n<y ’ •'-'‘ ^•'.■’-r'.^^-cn and that I am a duly Rcr-5- ' . ;c.*c3Sional Engineer undar the laws of J 'JIM:. Cf IvUnnoscia. » % 0 «« C'.Cti /Z Rr.3. No. yz Trs-' • • • • • • i» C LA//< ^QOO . /^.oos • • •» /gy^4 •■ //t/ .CP^£>P la//i^ . ejsTifjtkr s/i^e..a.f ^^/-vc) . ;.....: 3^100^ JJt/.S c^/^rau^ . <f^ /=/U O. ^r.l /. 5" '' /f >0^/</yUry(>rAtfr._.~^i L/aL^ . 7,?^^> /<? .-/■. ^ 5.^^^ . '■^ ZOoo cu./sr. • • m • ^ 3lOQ . . ^<^0 . . Arr£/M.. ysitiA/jf. . . .0. CAt. ex^. ?i?S. /'___ ^• "-COM^^AJS^r/Ayyji ^ycAUATJ/n^ /^ y^caa/y/>iji^j^ ..... /AyCj^fM f^rA L uai . . . .0. 4jr c&tr ' ‘ • ! ^ t‘^^' r •• f...../ft.^33 J<^»./V’., ■ ry^-y^-'p^ C^'.P/'.' .............. ~G.. —C£^.^3.ZL.. A 5“ ; -,. .3^33 .''. ... ' ,\ ...*.. 1 . /3,^?s. .y.<.._. : ■^ • • r* * * 4»- • ■• • »-...• • » ,■•■•.».. , .« » , .. sz, . ^?9^ •■ • T‘/3/S./s. AJa 3€c/if ASf /a/ /^(oaa STa/uy f <fV/V#. ____r • • i f • • • l/^^CAMf yfyr\'jir'^A'jL/'/-r/yifL,‘ yji^*. ^oa^3. ^/L €a . . . i/^L.P^Ar/i ; , m ^a Fr. / 3 s. p* /i // • 2J, Coo sa.fr. u foo cu.^r . /«, 000 ; // ' ., / , . thioo : /' : 4700 .'■. >. ", 2IT. /V5g4 OF SF^/aS . CA^P^e 93/aSj V »• #» :L .AAPP ai' [;■ • PPATJ/Aaaa 0 /er.. Z3oo. k Z ••Sooommy /.9 coo C •,2 Zoo S ••■ 3o0 • • Iaaluaa a > /3f3oo 3^00 ^ */zao ,;• ^ • /S00 V // /• Q. Fr • •Z y .". C '• ? - Z7^aap Ci*,^r. /f cr^A}.. L/otUiVi f . - -.L . . O c^. Fri. .. P30 . S/, S’.ao. /' '. 7% 9oa. '* I = Zy7.y . ci/, TPSl *• ** * • • I • ^ f • • • I I * : f : »•**-■• ? L . A AAA 7T Aaaa^; f i/acutA A, 4i /2, *oo 'y ^Q. 900 ?2oo. f y /%/ao ?Zoo : 900. >r V 7, chp T otal 7%f^o CttaFr. = Z7€S ccf,rc/s. ^ uj^a js Tyc4u>prfAAy ; CpAySrAi4<rfpify ’TCMiToAtLA k /^€6, AAAfL . 1*29p I ; ........................ ; . . . . . r ............................................................................... 'AA^APCSf^ ^^CAfAAa^ Fi^C4iAM-r/AfLA y CAT r^/ffz*yA>(S, . . . ‘ • * * I \ m^ • • • I \ i • • ••.»••••.0»«-• •• < iiyiiliiiil ll<^--M t thac covenanrs b.® filed on rhe cr.ain of oiila perrair.ing co one his oarcei.accessory shrucrures and fur-ore subdividing o Mo-ion Aves-'!» Bellows and Cohen, Ways. .•lorion ca- -e-. C- believed than t.he applicarion was forced ahead ana _ preierrec^o se« a comorehensive plan before making a recou.uenda..-w... _B- -ows concurred* with Cohen and reiteratsd her comments regarcing ....e commercial appearance of this greennouse structure. #1604 CLAIR ROOD - 2215 KEIIWOOD WAY CONDITIONAL OSE PERMIT „ ^ PUBLIC HEARING 8:30 P.M. TO 8:40 P.M Mr. Rood was present. o r //./« The Affidavit of Publication and Certificate of Mailing were duly noted. Gaffron summarized the information contained in his November 15, 1990 memo. Ms. Lorraine Moss, 3.335 Crystal Bay Road, expressec concern about Mr. Rood's proposal destroying t.he cnaracteristic ot u.he Se?^and She stated 'that the wetland is a wildlife haoitat ana that she would hate to see anything hapoen to cnange iw. Mr. Rood said, *’I nave lived on t.he property for two years and h“e seen little wildlife in the wetland. The culvert that extends across Navarre Lane has been there for some ti.me. When I hnnflht this orooe-tY, the house was unfinished. The bocy shop on ?Krfei d^uLp"ed-Yil of their trash in the “"4^00^ T have chanaed^my proposal and no longer intend ^o dig uhe pond L r twelve® foot Ifpth. The A-tmy Corp of Ensineers sent me a Jetter indicating the ramifications of doing that. My surveyor has re-drawn the pond and it will now be rive -aet dee- m f _ _ _ _ __ _ — — r> ^ ^ C wir Gradual slooa on the sides. I want to e.xcavate the pone so C-here is some water in there. I do not inte.nd to destroy any of the wildlife habitat. I started cleaning cut the debris and ,.ound that there is a 4" gas line exposed near che culvert under Navarre Lane." There were no further comments from the public regarding tiiis matter and the Public Hearing was continued. It was moved by Cohen, seconded by Moos, to table this application until further, necessary information is receivea. Motion, Ayes—5, Nays—0. Motion carried. #1605 DR. RICHARD LIHDSTROM - 1065 WEST FERNDALE ROAD VARXANCES PUBLIC HEARING 8:43 P.M. TO 8:49 P.M. The Affidavit of Publication and Certificate of Mailing were duly noted. Mr. Paul Bedker, Dr. Lindstrom's ;y:chitect, and Mr. Charles Lindstrom, were present. Cohen indicated that it would be necessary for him to abstain from discussion and voting on this matter because of his professional relationship to t.he applicant's representative. Gaffron reviewed the information pertaining to Dr. Lindstrom's application (see Michael Gaffron's memo date November 13, 1990). iratinniiliiii J r' To:Planning Commission Chairman Kelley Orono Planning Commission Members City Administrator Bernhardson Prom: Michael P. Gaffron, Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator Date:November 15, 1990 Subject: #1604 Clair and Lynn Rood - 2215 Kenwood Way - Conditional Use Permit/Variance - Public Hearing Zoning District - LR-IC, Single family lakeshore residential, 1/2 acre, sewered Application - Request for conditional use permit and variance to create a pond within a designated wetland List of Exhibits Exhibit A - Exhibit B - Exhibit C - Exhibit D - Exhibit S - Exhibit F - Exhibit G - Exhibit H - Exhibit I - Exhibit J - Application Plat Map Property Owners List Survey Cross Section Letter of Request Notice of Tabling from Watershed District Staff Letter to Applicant 9/27/90 Wetland Air Photo Code Sections re: Pillar Discussion Pertinent Pacts - 1.The applicant is proposing to excavate a pond approximately 1/2 acre in area within this 1.5 acre designated wetland. 2.Applicant has applied to the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District where his application was tabled pending submittal ^ of additional information. As of this writing, applicant'^qjt f* has not provided that information to the Watershed District. ^ 3.Applicant notes he has discussed the project with the Army Corp of Engineers, but has not indicated whether they have issued a permit for the project. This is not a DNR— protected wetland. 4. Applicant notes that approximately 1500 cubic yards of v excess fill will be removed. Staff calculates that a 12 ^ ^excess fill will be removed. Staff calculates tnat ^ A deep pond 1/2 acre in area would yield approximately 10,000^^ cubic yards of fill, hence 8500 cubic yards apparently are ^ unaccounted for in applicant's proposal. 5.The applicant is absolutely correct in the statement that the area has been used as a dumping site over many years. Staff inspection in October revealed debris along the north. iiiVi rtfranmiiiniiT rsi .1 my•t '\. .f V- • Zoning Pile #1604 November 15, 1990 Page 2 east and south ends of the property. Applicant had gone ahead with a bulldozer to remove some of that debris, and when this was brought to staff’s attention, applicant was stopped and was advised of the necessary procedures to gain approval for continuing that work. Applicant had taken one or two swipes at the very perimeter of the wetland, however, it appears that very little if any wetland vegetation had been destroyed. This designated wetland receiv^es drainage through a culvert from the south side of Navarre Lane. The outlet of this wetland is via a 16" clay tile that heads northward underneath the railroad tracks, underneath a portion of the house located at 3329 Crystal Bay Road, continues underneath Crystal Bay Road to outlet at the shoreline of Crystal Bay. This tile was likely installed a century ago when the railroad was built. With the invert of this tile approximately 1.5' below normal lake level, there would appear to be a direct connection of this wetland with Lake Minnetonka. While the Orono Comprehensive Plan mentions wildlife habitat as a wetland benefit, the Zoning Code basis for review and approval of wetland alterations, is primarily for controlling the quantity, rate, and quality of run-off entering the lake. The City Engineer has reviewed the applicant's proposal ana has walked the site, and has requested the same information as was requested by the Watershed District, in order to determine whether the proposal meets the required flood plain management engineering characteristics. As noted above, approximately 1/3 of the wetland will be opened up to create a 12' deep pond. This may have a number of ramifications, both from a wildlife standpoint and from a flood plain management standpoint: a. Providing an area of open water surrounded by a cattail marsh will likely increase the diversity of wildlife attracted to the site. Aeration of the pond as proposed will tend to reduce the algae growth, as noted by the applicant. Depending on fluctuations of the water table, excavation of the pond could tend to dry up the fringes of the wetland during low water years, hence changes in the nature of wetland vegetation might occur. IS I”*' >• it-:'-' l4 * >■ mm: ". •• '■ • j . • - 5’»r ^ Zoning File #1604 November 15, 1990 Page 3 9.The City Engineer stated he would not recommend that the City approve a pond excavation with 2:1 side slopes. While this slope would leave a greater proportion of the pond at full 12* depth, from a safety standpoint, it would be nearly impossible for a child or adult to walk up the bank and out of the pond should they fall in. Most of the City's lakeshore is at a 6:1 or flatter slope near the shoreline. Staff would agree with the Watershed District requirement that the slopes be no steeper than 4:1. /V A' V -V In addition to providing the information requested by the Watershed District, applicant should be required to have his surveyor locate the 15" clay tile outlet at the lake and verify the invert elevation. Because this only pond outlet is underneath a neighboring property owner's residence (probably without benefit of a drainage easement), the engineering data will be critical in determining whether construction of this pond and the general clean-up of this area will have an adverse effect in increasing flows through the neighbor's property. /Iifo ,<y 4,- a -*■ W i Applicant has constructed a number of concrete/brick pillars along the perimeter of the property, with the intent that bushes would be planted between them to act as a fence-like barrier. Note from the staff letter of 9/27/90 that these pillars were constructed without a permit, and staff intended to advise applicant regarding interpretation of the Code regarding this issue. Planning Commission is requested as part of the current application, to review the Code Sections regarding fences and interpret whether or not these pillars meet the fence requirements. Staff R ndation Staff would recommend tabling the request pending submittal to the City all of the information requested by the Watershed District, and additionally, information regarding the elevation and nature of the clay tile outlet at tne shoreline of Crystal Bay. Absent any Zoning Code directive that such pond construction is strictly prohibited under any circumstances, if all hyrologic/engineeri.ng concerns are satisified, then the only other question in the granting of this conditional use permit is rather subjective: will construction of this pond and the proposed grading work at it's perimeter be compatible with the policies expressed in Section 10.55, Subdivision 1 i.e. will such work have an adverse effect on the natural environment qualities of this wetland area? ;-A*: f =-. .... J Zoning File #1604 November 15/ 1990 Page 4 kU;?k- The final issue for the Planning Connnission to review is with regard to the pillars constructed approximately every 20-30* oi the perimeter of the property. This interpretation is requested by staff/ since the Code is somewhat unclear cn this. 1.The pillars in questions are approximately 18"-24" on a side/ and range from 3'-6* in height above grade. Are these pillars considered as a fence, or are they considered as accessory structures? Zoning Code does not define a fence. Pillars are intended to have bushes between them, with the intent of providing a barrier at the property line. 2. 1. Is the side yard adjacent to the street considered a side yard for fence purposes? If so, a 6* fence would be allowed along Navarre Lane. On the other hand, if for fence purposes the Navarre Lane side yard is considered as a second front yard, the maximum fence height a^ ov ,*d would be 3 1/2*. 3.Because the Code does not address nonencroachments for a side yard adjacent to a street, and because only the principal structure setbacks are defined for a side yard adjacent to a street, the Code gives no direction as to whether accessory buildings would be allowed within the required side yard adjacent to a street. In the past, staff has taken a conservative approach and generally allowed no accessory structures within the required side yard adjacent to a street. 4.Does the fact thct the wetland parcel is not legally combined with homestead parcel, have any bearing on your view of this property? 5.If this property is considered a'through lot, then do you agree that a 6* high fence would have to be at least 30* from the rear lot line? Attached in Exhibit J are excerpts from the Code which may help in your interpretation of the above questions. Please direct staff and applicant as to whether the pillars in question are allowed as is as a fence, or whether they should be subject to a building permit or variance application. Isv 1 ji }iso1 CITY OP ORONO - GENERAL LAND USE APPLICATION PROPERTY LOCATION Site Adr^ress (’ **7v *r ■WA I » to*/ w/'U'tfW rL^z/kJj /I- *, . ^ • • i- • : to V» t toCU 4 to*k/V'» VWV r » • h*$V' a JUt i ^ L'V Property Identificati n Number (P.I.D.) /7//?:^l ‘/V^o - S~ •• .1 wv'Vi f’v^ • ji. o • a i{?.*'2*i»/? Please attach legal description to application if not included APPLICANT Name ... Phone (home)¥71- Phone (work)HU- ?f y/ / Address City CJ^h'iA-TAr Zip OWNER (if different than applicant) Name Phone (home) Phone Address City Zip Date Property Acauired (month/year) - , I (do) (do not) also own the adjacent parcels of land. FEES - CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS - Renewal Fee - 1/2 Current Fee After-the-Fact Fee - Double Current Application Fee $ 50.00 For each variance request with CUP application $125.00 Residential accessory Use $150.00 Institutional (church, school, etc.) V,' J J _ $150.00 Guest House/Guest Apartments _ $150.00 Duplex Credit/Bldg _ $250.00 Commercial/Industrial Use _ $200.00 Land Alteration X 1 Grading and filling - designated wetland or floodplain Gradi.ng and filling - 101 cu. yd. or more Grading, seawall, retaining walls within 75' of lakeshore PRD/PID - see fee schedule OTHER APPLICATIONS _ _ _ _ $200.00 $250.00 ~ $175.00 $ 50.00 $250.00 $100.00 Commercial Site Plan Review (+ consultant fees) Vacation Easement Vacation Easement Vacation With Subdivision Rezoning (PUD - refer to fee schedule) Appeals Other - see fee schedule liSKldHblyAASMiii riiTiiiiM PRESENT OSE OF PROPERTY Present Zoning District Present Use of Property Residential Other (specify) DESCRIPTION OP REQOBST Describe request in detail: .^REQUIRED SUBMITTALS * ‘ 1. Completed Application Form. . 2. Certified Property Owners List of owners withxn o50 (you can obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Government Center 348-3271). 3. Plat Map. 4. Certificate of survey (signed by a licensed surveyor). ^ 5. Topographic survey (existing and proposed contours) if land alterations involve changes in elevation (grades). Construction plan/ if applicable (see staff for requirements). As an addendum to this application^ please attach a separate list of any other persons you wish notified of this application. YOU ARE REQUIRED TO SUPPLY 30 COPIES OF LARGE DOCUMENTS OR A WORKING COPY (ll* X 17* OR SMALLER) FOR ALL DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED The applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please remember that your application is not complete if the above information has not been included. Certification by Clerical Department that Land Use Application is complete. Initials of Clerical Staff; __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Date- - - - - - - - - APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE The applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay additional fees (staff time not covered by original fee payment) and/or unusual expenses incurred in review of this application, and certifies that the information supplied is true and correct to the. best of his/her )yiowledge. Applicant's signature Date ONNBRS SIGNATURE , ^ ^ *.uThe owner hereby acknowledges and agrees to this application and further authorized reasonable entry onto the property by City staff, consultants. agents, commission members, and Council members for purposes of investigation and verification of this revest. Owner's signature _______ Date ________________ Applicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 days before Planning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission Meetings are held ^ ® third Monday of each month. Applicants must be present at all scheduled review meetings of the Planning Commission and Council. If an applicant is unable to attend a scheduled meeting, please make arrangements to have an authorized agent attend in your place and advise the Building & Zoning Office of this change prior to the meeting. rtr ^ r * • • ..il. . '^. ' ' • ■ .r • '. . • V- " I ' ' . • • ■*. •.*. -► . ^ ^ V . ~ .t:'a* - ./T *T' !<’* »/ 1-1^ W ** j •■»•.'■ IS p{ «3) i '• 'i» I V ~ I* //7- 2 3 / X'-i#: '”.x .4 -V ,(J4I ; .* ' 't. ; < HOTf I • ^lM4>ai€NT <?. 57.^^59 . 69. i 71 9iuACE*^^ntf^ to t^^ VlUACfc^ Wr»#C»0MA 86ACH. (fSTil bit to \niki PMOTO t956) ;p I9)\ xa/V'2 \' ^ '<f» i I •• •■'1 ‘f 16)xi^'<k'^\ J 'SC. » SSI) ll\<n> ^■Vrv»4& * V ^-^^ •••••••• • ^*\*^ * "'** f:TA ,A !5\ r \06^“ - ^ /A'« •?! (24) ftVr- SS— / -ci IM / ti ■» OLD M a /■•s /\ .> 12" / ✓ / .f'/ »V*-v^ •••• ' 4il X. (->81/ / / /y^- 8 3 LAJATS: c^,^u) a -- /(to3.y^XA^t?5rv 6^^ 9?,: (12) >y /'v( JSI/ *\/ ' ”/'• '"•X\'* / ^.'/V- y/t, sy •9’^ 36 O'” •• /\, y/ i (57),(96)/„ ^y X,'/ .%• ( 59) S >o:, WX'o) ./•.t ’0 3 O) %V»’ / *•. y'• «• • • • •mjTo Vir5, ..V V/> TI c"//-5 .1 CUTLCT c 134) t L’ 9'<^^s<^^^ •T’ 6 T t i- >.I i -1 RUN DATE 10/26/90 1 i V'’••It: 1:1^ 'irl r! • : OATCH 001 1^1 « ; PROP AOOR i’'OHNER NAHE I TAXPAYER NAME/AOOR SS 17-117-23 41 0002 02140 KEIMXMI NAY CARL S JOHNSON DONNA E KABANUK 6931 DALLAS RO HPLS MN 55430 {.* •* ' • i . .*»• PROP ADDR OHNER NAME TAXPAYER NAHE/ADDR 30 17-117-23 41 0005 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIONED PAUL R HOLNBERO PAUL R HOLNBERO 17961 9TH AVE N E P0ULS80 HA 96370 { [PROP ADOR ^lONNiFR NAHE TA/^AYER ’/ NAHE/ADDR 1: 38 17-117-23 41 0013 03295 CRYSTAL BAY RD HARK C ZA6ARIA . HARK C ZAGARIA 1526 21ST AVE N E ROCHESTER HN 55904 «< {•4 ‘ i 38 17-117-23 41 0017 03315 CRYSTAL BAY RD J A TRUDEAU A J B TRUDEAU J A TRUDEAU I J B TRUDEAU NAHE/ADDR | 3315 CRYSTAL BAY RO HAYZATA m 55391 ji PROP AOOR (l.ONNER NAHE « TAXPAYER it !5 I : PROP ADOR 'CMCR NAHE TAXPAYER i NAHE/ADDR :rif I .V-V • ^ I 38 17-117-23 41 0020 03335 CRYSTAL BAY RD A LORRAINE HOSS A LORRAINE HOSS 3335 CRYSTAL BAY RO . NAYZATA m 55391 i # TN. I ir i:PROP AOOR > ^OIpCR NAHE TAXPAYER NAHE/AODR >■J. ' .• ... • • ^\ t • I a. !. •i 38 17-117-23 41 0023 03349 CRYSTAL BAY RD NARREN L PASCHKE ) HARREN L PASCHKE 14441 VILLAGE HOODS DR . EDEN PRAIRIE HN 55347 \ i K. IJ i» fct? -* m-’1 t « f : ti i . fi', !(a !• /!■ HENNEPIN * * »0 i ft ♦ COUNTY PROPERTY INFORHATION SYSTEH PROPERTY ONNERS LIST 38 17-117-23 41 0003 02150 KErJHOOD HAY H L A J H PAASCH JAYNE H PAASCH 2150 KENI'IOOO NAY HAYZATA HN 55391 38 17-117-23 41 0006 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED PAUL R HOLIBERG PAUL R HOLMBERG 17961 9TH AVE N E POULSBO HA 98370 38 17-117-23 41 0015 03285 CRYSTAL DAY RO THOMAS r HC HUE ETAL THOHAS E HCCUE 3285 CRYSTAL BAY RO HAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 41 0018 03325 CRYSTAL BAY RD RICHARD J STAKEL RICHARD J SIAKEL 3325 CRYSTAL BAY RD HAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 41 0021 03339 CRYSTAL DAY RO PATRICK 0 0*FLANAGAN PATRICK D O'FLANAGAN 3339 CRYSTAL BAY RO HAYZATA HN 55391 38 17-117-23 41 0024 03355 CRYSTAL DAY RO JOHN E KliST JOHN KUST 3355 CRYSTAL BAY ROAD HAYZATA MN 55391 REPORT NO. PI435401 PAGE 1 38 17-117-23 41 0004 02160 KENHOOD HAY S P DIHMICK I B. DIHHICK STAR 6 TRIBUNE EMP CREDIT UN 425 PORTLAND AVE MPLS MN 55488 38 17-117-23 41 0007 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED PAUL R HOLMBERG PAUL R HOLMBERG 17881 9TH AVE N E POULSBO HA 98370 38 17-117-23 41 0016 03309 CRYSTAL DAY RD PIP GUSTAFSON ROBERT HEGERHAN 3309 CRYSTAL BAY RD HAYZATA MfJ 55391 38 17-117-23 41 0019 03329 CRYSTAL BAY RD TERRYL A PEDERSEN DIXIE LEE HEEKS 3329 CRYSTAL BAY RD . HAYZATA HN 55391 38 17-117-23 41 0022 03345 CRYSTAL BAY RD ALINE K OGLANO ALINE K OGLAND 3345 CRYSTAL BAY RD HAYZATA MN 55391 . 38 17-117-23 41 0025 03359 CRYSTAL BAY RO GREGORY H LONG 6 HIFE GREGORY H LONG 3359 CRYSTAL BAY RD HAYZATA MN 55391 » CD I rv- . i.* ; ‘T • . • ■ RUN DAT6 10/26/90 BATCH Ooi i f •Hi:rt4EPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATIOT< SYSTEM OROPERTY OFtXRS LIST ' t* PROP AODR (HCR NAME »•»TAXPAYER C: NAME/AODR ; ZB lif-117-25 41 0027 i 03210 NAVARRE LA ' CLARENCE 0 SCHRAPP ETAL ELBERT OINKEL 3210 NAVARRE LANE HAYZATA HH 55391 • ■ ’ . 'V *]!'• *PROP ADOR ^ ONNER NAHE ( 00036 t I 36 17-117-23 41 0030 AOORESS UNASSIGNED . KABANUK . . TAXPAYER J DONNA KABANUK i iNAHE/ADDR ^ 6931 DALLAS RD * ^ j BROOKLYN CENTER HN 55430 • . ‘ I • . • •' * *• ^ * •'* FV ' I ! 6 . i * * u . i-' ■ i!I'. f I I I- ’ PROP ADOR i * ONNER NAHE TAXPAYER f .NANE/ADDR • .'1 !*•■ ‘ .( ii: ’ ! '' i ; ’ ,1. i * I' ! » ’ 36 17-117-23 44 0016 03365 CRYSTAL BAY RD J R LOFRANO ETAL J R LO FRANO 3365 CRYSTAL BAY RD ^ HAYZATA HN 55391 . Y. • • PROP ADDR 9 ONNER*NAHE : TAXPAYER NAHE/AODR ..*:jv- 1 1 SB 17-117-2S 64 00S2 • 0003B . AOORESS UNASSI6NE0 6ENE AND SHERYLL BLOCK GENE AND SHERYLL .BLOCK 2305 BAYVlEH PLACE HAYZATA m 55S91 ►^<•1 •. t;‘ i !* ('I 1* . • I* 'r PROP AOOR ONNER NAME • I I ♦ < ir. , . ii,: 38 17-117-23440040 02240 : BAYVIEH PL JACRUELYm J ZONTELLI ET At JACCI SEGNER NAHE/AOOR A 2260 BAYVIEH PLACE * HAYZATA HN 55391 i( ft• » ' * TAXPAYER S . \ ! ‘.V‘ • « *•*. i I I , r V- ' 1 »• •, ' . - PROP AOOR ■f. 0»tCR NAME , TAXPAYER inNANE/AOOR IM; f * i \ t 36 17*117-23 44 0044 00036 f AOORESS UNASSIGNED C H PA.^iCR A B J PALHER . CNRIS A BARBARA PALHER ! 2710 CASCO PT RO ORONO m 55391 r.6. •I ^ i i I'M i-i ?. r. i :r;V * • ': ♦ ♦ £ V* I i> >1* • •J ‘ .fc i i 4 fii .4' f : Ik’ Ih 17-117-23 41 0028 J2160 KENHOOD NAY C A H HEINICK CONRAO J A HAUREEN L HELNICK 2160 KEftMXM) HAY HAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 41 0031 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNEO DONNA E KUDANUK DONNA E KUDANUK 6931 DALLAS ROAD BROOKLYN CENTER MN 55430 38 17-117-23 44 0017 03369 CRYSTAL BAY RD J B DAHLHAN AHA DAHLHAN JON N PAPAS 3369 CRYSTAL DAY RD HAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 44 0033 02305 BAYVIEH PL R M STELLING ETAL GENE H BLOCK 2305 BAYVIEH PLACE HAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 44 0041 02250 BAYVIEH PL CATHY JO TURNER CATHY JO TURNER 5016 ENCHANTED RD HOUND MN 55364 38 17-117-23 44 0045 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED C H PALMER A B J PALMER CHRIS A BARBARA PALMER 2710 CASCO PT RD ORONO MN 55391 REPORT NO. Pr;35401 PAGE t 36 17-117-23 41 0029 02170 KENHOOD NAY DONNA E KABANUK DONNA E KABANUK 6931 DALLAS RD BROOKLYN CENTER m 55430 38 17-1)7-23 .41 0033 EDH STEARNS DONNA HUNTSBERGER 3128 OLD COUNTRY RD 15 HAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 44 0D18 D3375 CRYSTAL BAY RD JAY B KEISER ETAL JAY B KEISER 3375 CRYSTAL BAY RD HAYZATA MN 55391 CO38 17-117-23 44 0039 02260 BAYVIEH PL JACQUELYNN J ZONTELLI ET AL JACCI SEGNER 2260 BAYVIEH PLACE HAYZATA MN 55391 (|E22aei^ 38 17-117-23 44 0042 02240 BAYVIEH PL O S HILLIAHSON ETAL 0 S HILLIAHSON 2240 BAYVIEH PL HAYZATA HN 55391 38 17-117-23 44 0046 00038 AOORESS UNASSIGNEC C H PA>MER A B J PALHER CHRIS A BARBARA PALHER 2710 CASCO PT RD ORONO HN 55391 ! £■I— III m I I J ' • « fc •i :!:i |i .: MM DATE 10/26/90 DATCN 001 t .» f ♦* •i •> ^1;'t.'HErtCPIN :.'i , 5* ^ •*. I •4* •i PROP ADOR ONNER NANE TAXPAYER NAHE/AODR I • «■*. I r . 'p I •‘V \ I . ' f ^ • f i\ : I 'ik .A V . PROP AOOR { ONNER NAHE : TAXPAYER { .NANE/AOOR :?» • ( V «r PROP AOOR ONNER NANE TAXPAYER . ' NANE/AODR ?! % SO 17-117-2S 44 0047 : 000S8 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED j C H PALNER A 0 J PALNER ' CHRIS A BARBARA PALNER ; 2710 CASCO PT RO i ORONO NN , 55S91 i - r ? ?i I < r ; ) so 17-117-25 44 0055 * OOOSB ADDRESS UNASSIGNED j C T rood a L D ROOD , CLAIR T A LYNN D ROOD 2215 KENNOOO HAY NAYZATA NN 55591 iV- ; I T- r ‘j * ’■'K M 17-U7-2S 44 0056 } 01220 . NAVARRE I.A ( RICHARD A PROUDFZT : ROBERT J RITCHIE t 1901 BEACH LA NAYZATA HN 55391 ' ^'1. i 'PKOP-AOOR •;.ONCR NANE > ' TAXPAYER I I ■fi. i SB 17-117>23 44 0068 03215 UFAYETTE RI06E CT CHEYENNE LAND CO- ns H A JANE 0 BUR6ES6 *^! NAHE/AOOR ? 3215 UFAYETTE RI06E CT NAYZATA i 55391 I 1* tv 5 !■' V • • PROP AOOR 'ONNER NAHE ) 36 17-117>2S 44 0091' ^ 03245 UFAYETTE R1D6E I CT i CHEYEIME LAND CO TAXPAYER ,I STUART A A HILDA J mOBERO INAHE/AOOR i 3245 UFAYETTE RZ06E COURT !.■ “i t'. i NAYZATA NN 55591 V I 4* 'i: CM4ER NAHE {,ITAXPAYER if{NAHE/AIN i t .V i-n 30 17-117-23 44. 0094 00036 AOORESS UNASSIGNED UFAYETTE RI06E HOHEOMNERS LAFAYE1TE RIDGE HOHEOIMERS 1709 N FARH ROAD i » LONG LAKE HN 65354 ' t'r. .* • H r! i - < I \ I • M COUNTY PROPERTY INFORHATION SYSTEN PROPERTY OHNERS LIST 50 17-117-25 44 0048 00058 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED JACQUELYNN J ZONTELLI JACCI SEGNER 2260 BAYVIEH PLACE NAYZATA HN 55391 58 17-117-25 44 0056 00056 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED C T ROOD A L D ROOD CLAIR T A LYNN D ROOD 2215 KEFtlOOD HAY NAYZATA HN 55391 58 17-117-23 44 0082 *02200 BAYVIFN PL DALE MATSON ETAL DALE MATSON ETAL 2200 BAYVIEH PLACE NAYZATA MN 55391 58 17-117-23 44 0089 03225 LAFAYETTE RIDGE CT JAB LARSON JOHN T A BETTE J LARSON 5225 LAFAYETTE RIDGE CT NAYZATA MN 55391 58 17-117-23 44 0092 03245 LAFAYETTE RIDGE CT CHEYENNE LAND CO DAVID F A SUSAN J BRIGGS 3245 LAFAYETTE RIDGE CT NAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 44 0095 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED LAFAYETTE RIDGE HOMEOHNERS LAFAYETTE RIDGE HOMEOHNERS 1709 N FARH ROAD LONG LAKE MN 55356 REPORT NO. PI435401 PAGE 3 38 17-117-23 44 0054 00038 AOORESS UNASSIGNED C T ROOD A L D ROOD CLAIR T A LYNN D ROOD 2215 KENHOOD HAY NAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 44 0057 02215 KENHI C T ROOD A L CLAIR ROOD 2215 KEN NAYZATA MN 100 HAY D ROOD 9 : • •»HAY 55391 58 17-117-25 44 0085 02250 BAYVIEH PL J L SCHNECK A P H SCHNECK J L • • V 58 17-117-25 44 0090 05285 LAFAYETTE RIOGE CT SALLY J HCCABE SALLY J HCCABE 5285 LAFAYETTE RIDGE CT HAYZATA HN 65591 I 58 17-117-25 44 0093 00058 ADDRESS UNASSIGNEO LAFAYETTE RIDGE HOHEOHNERS LAFAYETTE RIDGE HO»CO»MERS 1709 N FARM ROAD LONG LAKE iti 55556 58 17-117-25 44 0096 02500 BAYVIEH PL JACQUELYW J ZONTELLI ET AL DANIEL J SEGNER 2260 BAYVIEH PLACE HAYZATA HN 55391 .! ihtilihl i'! —- 7 i I • RUN DATE 10/24/M J* ■ •. * \ f N -1 • u* ‘ ®l*i ■ nnp l(c ,M ^ ' ' . . »S • r *.. .»1. RATCN 001 I'r ■ , •i i;' l: V- -J: HEItCPXN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY OMNERS LIST ' 1. > ; It X7-117-2J 44 0096 i ‘ »! r i PROP AINW . j OSSOO . NAVARRE LA . , - -.1 OHNER NAME I JAC6UELYNN J SEGNER ; . ) TAXPAYER ! ^ JACRUELYMIJ 8E6NER 'i ! NAME/ADOR * 2EM 6AYVIEH PL '' - ' NAYZATA MN 55391 . » ! . I ■ ! ’:• ill' !•. i * ;•b j'.' r-: ?I* ”4 ' . t t ' • U-117-ES 33 0003 ' i. ( PROP ADDR • i 03171 UFAYETTE RI06E RO ONNER NAME T C J OUILAP AMO DUNLAP V T/lXPAYER ‘ ; i‘.i f.C J A H 0 DUNLAP t ^ NAHE/AODR ;j: 3171 UFAYETTE RXD6E RO . j, ’■H; I .4 ■’ J NAYZATA W 55391 . ' : ; 'i i >i f.. I; n at 14-117-23 33 0004 <,;.i;-.pROP AOOR l OMCR NAME ,;.!TAXPAYER NAME/ADOR •ft? L , . i NAYZATA H4. 'xi -IS CHi'.’U i .4 • -1 ?»■•' 03159 LAFAYETTE RX06E RO E P A H L OHEN . ‘ . , ERIC P OMEN 'I- : ' , 3159 UFAYETTE = RI06E RO h . 55391 V ' ’'•I*-, >• :- « t ; 1', ,fc' i'.‘ . ! ■;; 4r bi ’T •! L PROP ADDR I ' ' AliAJBB klAM < V (rl* NAIC/ADDR i !*/} OIMR NAHi TAXPAYER • itii ,4t i'l»/ . ... ! i: 11 ’c::> TOTAL 6ATCK f ‘ jl. ■ f r»' i!t[ •• t.. f i *' 'i r. !1 l-'V ; V;j\ > f ;*• ■? 1 } r 1; V C 4 - 0 I, - J* II » . , 1 001 00063P-; ■ tp'!i ; • > I ii > i!'. !• '151 ii i - it'''r1: ii ’ ■ ; ' ' t ' !H'r : '< >i > ^ -I *!' r . v * a*' ’ ^ ^ ‘I' ' - ^ •T '^ ■ F i > ' -- i . -' I ? ‘ • 1. • ■. V- 1. I • I b I «• ifjv * L ,■ '•I * ;i r :■ ji-!. " ' ■ 1! ■! !' vi'i‘ii' • '-'i I' i . ''M 38 17-117-23 ^ 0103 02260 BAYVIEH PL JACQUELYNN J ZONTELLI ET AL JACCI SEGNER 2260 BAYVIEH PL HAYZATA HN 55391 82 16-117-23 33 0004 03167 LAFAYETTE RIDGE RO R A A M L FAULKNER ROBERT A FAULKNER 3167 LAFAYETTE RIDGE RD HINNETONKA BEACH MN 55361 82 16-117-23 33 0007 03155 LAFAYETTE RIDGE RD RAG SCHHEIN RICK L A NANCY G SCHHEIN 3155 LAFAY2TTE RIDGE RD HAYZATA HN 55391 REPORT NO. P1435401 PAGE 4 82 16-117-23 32 0024 03128 OLD COUNTY RO EDH STEARNS DONNA HUNTSBERGER 3128 OLD COUNTY RO 15 HAYZATA HN 55391 82 16-117-23 33 0005 03163 LAFAYETTE RIOGE RO SAD SIMPSON STEVEN R A DIANE E SIMPSON 3163 LAFAYETTE RIDGE RD HINNETONKA BEACH HN 55361 82 16-117-23 33 0019 , 00082 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED LAFAYETTE RIDGE HOMEOHNERS LAFAYETTE RIDGE HOMEOHNERS PO BOX 41 HTKA BEACH HN 55361 * \ 1 CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTEL ARE AN ACCURATE AND TRUE REPRESENTATION OF INFORMATION AS IT APPEARS THIS DATE OH THE RECORDS OF THE HENNEPIN COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PROPERTY TAXATIONp TO THE BEST OF HY KNOHLEOGE AND BELIEF. DATE r- « \« j ‘ » liiiriiliiiii iiiMtBih . .V'-0? ♦ V'. V J -^1 CLAIR T. RCX3D / 2215 K£N^vX>D VJAY / WAYZATA, MN 55391-9700 October 9, 1990 Jfo/. SK'i*" ^ •/'m^r « Zity of Orono P. O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN jj. tf *'rr \ .jS ..*3 ** " ■ / ■: Vt::^ rrrr :ra •; 55323 attention; Building and Zoning Administrator fetsii Please accept the attached survey and cross-section showing the finished topography of the pond we propose to dig. *PiP rhe reasons why I am requesting a conditicnal use permit for this new oond are as follows: mmm-m ^ ■■Bill. •• ^mBmm The existing area has been used as a dur>ping site over the past many years and is in need of a .-lean-up. ■■■■ i-:. 2.With clean water and an aerator in a new pond, fish and wildlife could thrive and grow. Through research my understanding is a pond with an aerator keeps the water circulating which in t.irn makes it difficult for mosquitos to breed and hatch. Also algae will not grow when the water is circulatim which means if there is heavy rain, the run off which w-ould drain into Lake Minnetonka would not contain algae, etc. rtlnSy The Army Corps, of Engineers suggest we erect cm errosion barrier to stock pile excess dirt behind. We will haul away the excess dirt as well as the debris which may be buried in this wetland. We estimate hauling away approximately 1,500 cubic yards of excess dirt. mfvWi& h'' Thank you for your consideration.»v" ififcV. - - ••..•it:-: sincerely, T' 4' ■hmi 4 V* nr» lwsg|Miil ■: :.::v ' - «/■:.• ■;> V:' A:''--.t ■;^mm v>v:-r 4 ■i '31VfO 0>' A«i<li 4 «iWi>4-« »<«>•> «• UU . i - .:. -‘ • : P.O. Box 387, Wayzata, Minnesota 55391 MMRO OF MANAGERS: James R. Spensley Pies • Albert L Letiman • Jatm E Thomas ncliaid R. Miner • Robert 0. Erickson • C. Woodrow love • Clarkson linaiey October 22, 1990Permit Anniication No. 90-126 Applicant: Clair RckjcI 2215 Kenwood Way Wayzaia, MiN 55391 Location: City ofOrono, Sec. 17DD Purpose: Dredging to create an open water pond in a wetland and fill and excavation in a floodplain area. Dear Mr. Rood: At the regularly scheduled October 18, 1990 meeting of the Board of Managers, the subject permit applicadon was tabled pending receipt of: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. Calculations showing no net decrease in Lake Minnetonka flood storage capacity. Hydrologic calculations by a professional engineer or qualified hydrologist of the local 100-vear trequency flood elevation. Calculations providing no net decrease in flood storage capacity below the projected local 100-year frequency flood elevation. Erosion control plan prepared by a qualified individual showing proposed methods of retaining waterbourne sediments on site during the period of work and until bare soil surfaces have been covered or revegetated. Delincauon and area of the total watershed area contributing stormwater runoff to the wetland. Area of the existing wetland and classification of the vegetation types present in the basin. Revised plan including proposed elevation ro*..ours for the area of e-\cavation. Revised plan providing maximum slopes of 4:1, Description of and volume computation of material to be removed. Descripdon of equipment which may be used. Construction schedule. Locadon map of the spoil containment area. Erosion control plan for the spoil containment area. Review and approval by the City of Orono. Review and approval by the DNR. These items should be received no later than November 5,1990 to ensure your permit application will be on die agenda for tiie next meeting of the Board of Managers scheduled for November 15, 1990. CITY OP ORONO P. O. Box 66 Crystal Bay# MN 473-7357 ZONING PILB #1604 55323 NOTICE OF PLANNING COMMISSION ACTION Date of Notice: 11/27/90 TO:Clair Rood 2215 Kenwood Way Wayzata, MN 55391 COPIES TO:1 HOP APPLICATION: Variance Conditional Use Permit • DATS OP MEETING: 11/19/90 VOTE: 6 For 0 Against Planning Conmission recononends the following: Tabled for reasons noted below NOTES AND SPECIAL CONDITIONS: Applicant to provide additional information: 1, Invert elevation and condition of tile outlet at Crystal Bay. 2. Submittal to City of all items requested by Minnehaha Creek Watershed District in their letter of 10 —22 —90 (copy attached). Planning Commission tabled all discussion of the brick pillars until the application is again scheduled for review. Applicant's next scheduled meeting is dependent upon receipt of additional information. Deadline for the Tuesday, January 22, 1991 meeting is January 10, 1990. If the applicant has trouble obtaining additional information, please contact the Zoning Department (473-7357). If you desire certified copies of the official Planning Commission minutes, they are available from the City Clerk after review and approval by the Planning Commission. Isv Permil Application No. 90-126 Page Two October 22, 1990 Should you have any questions regarding this matter, please contact me at 473-4224, Sincerely, JAMES M. MONTGOMERY, CONSULTING ENGINEERS, INC. Engineers for the District cc: Board-file Ronald S. Quanbeck, P.E. <^Cuy of Orono DNR i 5- i ^ I f arv "I t 1taRQNC^ CITYof ORONO Post Office Box 66*Crystai Bay, Minnesota 55323• Munidpai OfSeta On the North Shore of Lake Minnetonka September 27, 1990 Clair Rood 2215 Kenwood Way Wayzata, Mn 55391 RE: Proposed Cieanup/Tree Ramoval/Grading Dear Mr. Rood: The general cleanup work which you have commenced in various areas of your property can for the most part be handled via a staff-issued land alteration permit. Our site inspections on September 17th and September 24th verified that your property indeed has been used as a neighborhood dumping ground for decades. The concrete deb'.is, railroad ties, cans, bottles, and old tires, all constitute debris that is not considered clean fiJ.l and by today's standards would not be allowed to be dumped anywhere except a sanitary landfill. While we wish to allow you to proceed with the cleanup, the fact that the areas of concern are very near a City-designated wetland, requires that we proceed with caution. Before we can issue a land alteration permit for you to continue, you must have the boundaries of the wetland defined and staked by a surveyor. Orono's wetland protection ordinances do not allow any filling, grading, dredging, excavation, hardcover or structures, within wetlands or within 26' of the boundary of wetlands (Municipal Code Section 10.55, Subdivision 8). We believe that the ordinary high water mark elevation of this wetland, which appears to be an enclosed basin, is controlled by a culvert that extends northward underneath the railroad tracks. This culvert may be blocked by debris near its inlet, which may be on your property but which also may be on railroad right-of- way. We have recently determined that this culvert runs under the house at 3329 Crystal Bay Read and outlets at the lakeshore. Much of the debris appears to be on railroad right-of-way or on other properties which County records indicate are not under your ownership. While we wholeheartedly support your efforts to clean up the property, we cannot grant you permission to clean up other people's property without their approval. I would also note that the wetlands boundary survey by Gronberg in 1988 suggests that in order to stay out of the wetlands area during debris removal on NilLOING A ZONING - 473.73S7 ASSESSING ADMlNISniATION A FINA.sa; • 473-73SS FAX-47M510 PUBLIC WORKS - 473.7359 Clair Rood September lit 1990 Page 2 -hP ncr-h end, you will have to either cross other prccerties or riavel trough Che wetland, neither cf which are surtable options. An additional issue which needs to be addressed is the height o^ the 2- X 2’ brick and concrete pillars you ha-e erected along tne south and west boundaries of the property. understanding that you had already of thirds of these pillars when chrs work came to ^ the Building Inspections Department. A review of the pertinent code sections suggests that along street lot include Kenwood Way, Navarre Lane, ana tecnnically ^ould al include Hillside Place (an undeveloped road^which may become a road in the future), fences are not allowed to exceed 3 1/2 ^ height. Since you proposed that you would be planting hedges between theH /ostJ^, there is some question whether they fall under the definition of a fence. Also, the code is not such posts can exceed 3 1/2' in height in a side '"“J.^jp, (along Navarre Lane) or a rear street yard (along Hillside Place!. We are still researching this, however, you should be aware that there may be an issue about the niilars, and if it is determined that the maximum height is in fact 3 1/2', your options would be at the appropriate height, or to apply for an a ^er hhi<? variance. We will advise as to a final interpretation on this issue. In order to expedite approval for your intended cleanup work, you should do the following: 1. Have your surveyor determine the inverts of the and outlet of the culvert that crosses the railroad tracks. He should then determine whether that culvert atfects his previous determination of the wetland boundary. 2. Your surveyor should stake the '^ftland boundary approximately every 50', and should likewise stake the 26 wetland setback where no filling, grading, dredging or excavation is allowed. Once a land alteration permit is issued, the following guidelines must be adhered to: 1. In areas within 26* of the wetland boundary, debris removal shall be allowed only to the degree that voids caused by such removal shall be restored to the arade elevations. No vehicular or equipment traffic shall be allowed within the boundary of the wetland in any case, Clair Rccd Sectsmber 271 x?90 Page 3 vegetation. 2. in areas denoted n on ^a^Ys"=re\^vri''w^thfn north end Jiy I^T^fthin properties not under yourrailroad rrght-of-wayj=r-athin p_^^P^ Ipp?ovai for nich'work from those property owners. 3. In Q"Q^g®“c^°in*’a7ea^M° match the surrounding approximately 1,000 s... ^nowed, subject to the use of Ileal? filfo^i^ with such fill not to exceed an amount of 100 cubic yards 4. in Area 43, the concrete ^abris may be re».°'ied and grades restored to match the Jt and gas fcre?p%^="an‘l^lAT^e-c;iratt?.^g1^ structures. To summarire, once Ci^y'^wi i i^^issue a land setback have Are^ "^^n^such oer.it shall !inud\^"p^r^:rsfiol^ ^^ou^^.rUertl property owners to worK withxn their procero/ a. ,, =.4- 171-7357 if you have any questions Please contact me at 47J /is/ Assis^nt Planning & Zoning Administrator cc: Aeanne Mabusth, Building ^ Zoning A^inistrator Lyle Oman, Senior Building Inspector Bruce Vang, Field Inspector MPG/Isv ^ — ■-— rn^M > J.J . J ■; ?. > • i M - 3 ^ -- - -- —.. — ^ - - -SSC. 10.02. DSnUIT-CNS.^ ^A5^Ui5c: - foilowina words and pnrasas sna— -ran: 1. "Ac=s33orv - = « 3 —-;•■'... - =—-crjr? on ni-.s saSordinacs to and aetving -."® ..................... same lot and cusnomariJ.'/ inc--env.a- --------- 4 "Alley" - A public right-of-way which affords a secondary means of access to abutting property. ' Source: Municipal Effective Dare: 9-14-6/ 33. "Lot, corner" - A lor situated at the junction of, and abutting on two or more i.nrersecring street, the •^nint of deflection in alignment or a conr-..uous ------ » interior angle of which does not exceed 135 degrees. 36. "Lot Death" - The mean horizontal disrance between the front lot line and’ the rear lor line of a lot. 37.Lot, Interior" - A lot other than a corner lot. 38. -Loa Line" - f T.TofV%.%7^s^rTnnltc .uL-oa- such \u51ic right-of-way shall be the lot line. •?q "’•ot Line-Front" - That boundary of a lot which abuts an existing* or dedicated public srreer, and in the case or a lot it shall be the shortest dimension on a public st^e--. • • • • • • • -'me'’Sions of a corner lor are equal, rhe irpn^ f® dingnstsd by bhe owner and riled :n r.ne orrrce or t.-.e 3u. —..w Inspector. nn "’•-r u'-o-Rear" - Thar boundary of a lot which is ocDOsibe bhi fr^i^r lot" line. Id the rear lot line is_less fiit in length, or ir i^°"ie„g:.n'wit^^in' t!^^^ lot, p'L\ue1%o?\Vd Tt 5,e";axi™u: drstancs fron.%.he front lot line. 41. "Lot Line-Side" - Any boundary of a lot which is not a front lot line or a rear lot line. 42 "Lot-Through" - A lor which has a pair rt ^a^"cVrn%\“^Ji"t! ‘^n s^fl be front lot lines for applying tne t,oning Chapter. AT "Lot Width" - The maximum horizontal distance between the Side lit linrofflot -asured parallel to t.he front lot Une and at the rear of the required f.ont yard. ______ NSL 67. "Strae'!:'' - A dedica than fifty feer in width whicn a riunning nrocerny. i“sd cub lie richt-of-way not lass fords' a rri.T.ary naans of access no 68, "Stree as a cernianent; rrcnc in width. - n- ocad-^’*'vata” - Any rrivata way sec aside -of-'vayT=r‘v,hi=-.iar accass iiJty ieaa or r.cre fiQ '•st;*-uc*'ure" - Anvehing constructec or erec^ec, 6 9. 5 'aca-*o'" on, below or above the ground, o.. use of wnxen recur-as J ^ ^^^acion on the ground,accached to scsiec.ning hav_.*^ a -uca — U *•ne Source: Municipal Code Effective Dace:■* • _ JT ■,o such wr.roh such loo is locaoac. rscruxetciaOns v-..e -4- Source: Municrra— Effeccive Date: 9-14-o/ /ova TIV Hecuira.nencs'* relate exclusively to witr.in sceci--i.c «o*.—m « 3r3c»wi—^2HkSr*wS areas when suen are requi Source: Ordinance 26, 2nd Serres .^dorced: 7-14-86 tr-onf’ - A vard extending across 77. .2-.-/ -4-cic anr? lv-»na oerween c.ne a lot between Required front yard setbac.k line, street line o- -..e lot a “i„.;..:<ied on both street frontages of which front yaru shal a laheshore loo shall noo be comer lota and doubla ^ -ather shall be cor.siaered rs"S;i'nVa “l Sr.! /frTo sl-Je of the buildi.o, and a rear y«S on tie other side of the bur.dang. 78. "Yard, a/^tW recuirad lakashore ordinary highwazar nar.c on -.ne - setbac.'c line, for tne raxi -..e ^-Lts^on tL'^ street lying between tne street ixne or -he -ot the required rear yard setback -xne. Source: City Code Effective Date: 4-1-84 80. "Yard-Side" - A specified line between the na*^ foVWestrict in which such lot isin the yard regulations for the o-s —icz located. street. 81. -yard-Side Street" - A side yard abutting a side Source: Ordinance 172 Effective Data: 1-1*“'5 •• -1 1 f -- - --- - -■■...-..wrr • ^ ► Sued •AccsssoiTV 3• The f^llcwir.3ubc. L3» jjGn“-ncrcacnrr.e~wS. ro be encrcacr.r.er.c3 on yard raquirer.enrs: c sn3i ^ ^ nc^ i r^-T^-vs, flues, belo courses, leaders, sills, Pilasters, ■cornices, eaves, 1“^:^'= ;aVer-r is herainaftsr 3iore tnan i.ee_, w«- 5> regulated. far.iiy duellings; T-aT-v-*-cr a-eas. ioadi.ng areas or yards -or lights ror il j.uninat-.- , ‘"-oc dec “he direct source of light safety and security turto^sM^,^ riohi-of-uay or adjacent residential rs not v-sible ^£*-^^,-1' five feet of the front lot xine.property may be located to efi.-n-.n te- S5SS. sa;not exceed 6 feet above tne 1.=-^,.*- -- --- ^, ?L-races, steps ”=tovVgVou^T of which do ^ g.^-*a„Q -o a discance of nor less tnan 2the pnncrpax ou-xding anc ex.—.a feet from any lot line. D In side or rear yards only, bays not to exceed a street parking except for abo orYg^ina 1 -lSrry%-\cc\t “f c3 ?t "reli^ f^^a%\"n=t iitt ”^cn='^eL%V-\la\\^ni\^Ve^?ons-tructed uittin 75 feet of t.he shoreline. Source: Ordinance 9, 2nd Series Adopted; 1-28-85 , 003.. -7.-- onlv? balconies, braezeways, de-ached ourdoor picnic-she-IVers and recraarion^^^^ r-aY'tr’clYsYrthan regulated herei.naitar^ VYtYoYY'aira fence or will constructed 5 fesb from a taa_ -c- “t**" ** 7r»h- o~ 5 -<»*»’■ above oririnax grade, within a rear yarn exceec a neign- o- o- -a-i-,- F. Side yards only; no accessory structure shall oe .=e^irlonn\- ^^eru-tS “e filel^^d en^ee^^ -n^g^-o^ 5 le;ff^cve original grade. Source: Ordinance 9, 2nd Series Adopted: 1—28 —85 16 Tra£*'C Visibility. No fences, structures or Subd. 10. Traix- uf^rVi "■'i" Dist'^ict on corner triangular area <-wa int-“sect’ ng streets, thence •jji; feet from the point of beginning on the other c—a i-ne, the point of beginning. Source: Municipal Code Effective Date: 9-14-67 ' ■ ~rzz. r .ci'v:.,. -—r. ■; : j JL f *• 3a=d. 6. Area, Height, Lot Width and ‘Jard P.equirer.ents. A. Heicnr. scruccure or building shall exceed 1* 2-1/2 scocies or Section 13.75. rhirty fee .. .. w - W o p* o n - as pr 0V Ioec in 3.Lots. The following minimum requirements shall be observed; , Side Yard t' I-.Lot Dot Ar“a Width Front Yard Side *^3rd Rear Yard Adjacent to S t!r0‘S - p i•1/2 acre 100 reet 30 feet 10 feet nW Vj 4- W ^15 feet . - — — . - —. ... •—. . . 1 i • # SEC. 10.75. HEIGHT OP STROCTUHES. Subd 1. Soacial Provisions. The height limitations con'd^^tnal us^pe^rit'by 7o oero^'t" when" apolial ?o thY*-fol* ing' structures : A. Antenna or antenna structures. B. Church spires. CupilaV'and doaes which do not contain nsahla space D. E. H. I. Monuments. F. Water towers. Q. Fire and hose towers. Observation towers. Flag poles, j. Chimneys. L. ’ orr^pe^'^walis extending not more than three feet above height of the building. M. Cooling towers. M. Elevator penthouses. Subd 2 Conditional Use Permits. Heights in excess of Source: Ordinance No. 198 Effective Date: 8-22-77 ___ fl 1 Varda* Additional Provisions. Required yardsSubd. 4. Yards. . gubiect to the followingin the districts specified shall be subject additional requirements: A. Through Lota. Through lota in any diatrlct ahall ha»e a required front yard on each atreet. n _-j "T" Diatricta: Adjacent lota. In hhe -B- and -I* «o’“ee°/oV th“ lot "in qSeaVfon lr°e"\e« or greater than t.he aini-um front yard depth ORONO CC 391 (4-1-84) i , * > • m m • 1.‘•"I • • •••;.*• Subd. 2. Definitions. As used in this Chapter; "Aliev" - A public oc private right-of-way iv*.«—-w*-; • 1 I . • ••• »• I £jjj3irily to sgjtvg sscondsirv (^ccsss to tii0 siQ0 o^. r00ir of those lots whose principal frontage is on some other street i r * *•-- I t • • V • • • • »• ' •• • • ( » «. ‘ 4 3 "Building" - Any structure or any part thereof built foe the silppoct, shelter or enclosure of persons, eniraals, chattels or movable property or any kind. - A lot situated27. "Lot, Corner" - rt »a.uuciu = ^ intersection of two (2) streets, the interior angle intersection not exceeding 135 degrees. at the of such ■1r )8 a*!^j ORONO CC 419 (4-1-84) ■ *...A * ' «»• ^ ^ : ••• :x ’’ * - *’ .X yr. . • -i ..- ,ateSiv#S»4KH-^ij-'r5sS«£^ «* * • *. • *^*e . * * * .•.r*.**’ * '* •• • •r •** V. * t ‘ . .*• • ,*-.v ' . • V- • ..r'> Vi*!-. l>r.A.'.ni''J,Vl V* - -V. - i. c * • ••• ", ■ V'. •'Vvvir:'':; f ^ ..•••• • •. ' • .•/ , • •;.......................‘T ‘ • '*• . ^ V * " ■ ‘ * — . . . ■ • • • — . . . • ■**.. . . rr • » . .........-■ .V- ■ ..........••'•,•••'“• i.. • ■-■•-•■ -I-.*., - .» '.i.v-*,: • •t t * • •• : *•/. *• • • •• *• •• •• V. . ‘ ■' J . . * * .• *1 . . * „ •. V ...1^ ..' - V-r-.- •"* ■-* ** '* Tu.*.:,.**. .. • .-•* * ' • • • . . ..........- • ..................... . —* .* ___ ^ ^ • •' ’f • \ . '< • * •* • A.7AiSr /i»riv;f -i-Mv * ..> •; V- - . •• '••• • *..* '•• • •* • • •* «,y. «i -- . # . 4. •.«. • •• *4... * • •. . .- . ti! •.. , ‘ » .'•• 4.^*. 1 UP FLOWAGE AND CONSERVATION EASEMENT and waiver of damages THIS INDENTURE, made and entered into this , by and between day of and its heirs, S’" s™ors\ “unicipa! colp^rfilon “der"the^\U; o°/°Phe sVate of Minnesota (hereinafter referred to as the Grantee). wTTNESSETHe Grantor(s), for and in consideration of the wum of one Dollar"™?” ) enr:tL°r valuable grant, gif t, quit “ ^uTe the use improvement and I”2?op"J;iit,"l"d:r\^e"o:ndiUons^nd covenants here^^^^ following described Land in the County of Hennepin and State of Minnesot . as follows: - '-r 1. Grantor(s) hereby covenant and agree(s): A No structures shall be constructed, erected, or placed upon, above? or beneath the Land including without li-iftron, fences fireplaces, steps, docks, piers, hardcover teaas whatsoever, or any other structure or improvement inconsisten with the natural state of the Land. B No trees, shrubs or other vegetation shall be destroyed, cut I'z reeled from the Land except as authorized by written consent • of Grantee. C. No earth, loam, peat, gravel, soil or any other material or substance shall be movea or -'emovec there shall be no dredging or excavation o any nat ^ vj-’■‘•ter or any change of the topography of the Land wiuhou^ i.he consent of Grantee. D. NO soil, sand, gravel or other substance “ “ landfill shall be placed, dumoed or stored upon whe Land and no iastl? «fsh or garbage shall'be placed, dumped or stored upon the Land. E. No use shall be made of the Land / will not change or alter the natural concition no use which would tend to change the flood ^ont.. 1^ water conservation, erosion control, soil ^^nd^ wildlife habitat characteristics shalx be made of ..he Land water situated thereon. p. Grantee may enter upon the Land for and inspection and enforcement of the covenants ^ to cause to be removed from the Land witnout any liability^an^ structures, uses, materials, substances, or unnatural ma^ inconsistent with the covenants contained herein and the natural state of the Land. l^m^l •rsi* II I .■v;'?> i’ -■ ..d ‘. Chairman Kelley and Planning Commission Members City Administrator Bernhardson 3 Proms Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator Date: Subject: June 13, 1991 #1644 Larry Hork, 3222 North Shore Drive Appeal of Zoning Administrator's Decision Pertinent Ordinances - Section 10.02, Definition 1 - Accessory use or structure. A use or structure subordinant to and serving the principal use or structure on the same lot and customarily incidential to. Definition 75 - Use - principal. The main use of land or buildings as distinguished from subordinate or accessory uses/structures. A principal use may be either permitted or conditional. Section 10.61, Subdivision 1 - Signs. As accessory use and are permitted in all districts. Section 10.61, Subdivision 3 (A) - Allowed area of signage with.in B-2 zoning district. Allowed = 50 s.f. per single sign Proposed = 32 s.f. Section 10.61, Subdivision 3 (D) - B-2 height standards within the B-2 district. No signs shall extend in height more than 2' above the height of side wall or parapet of any principal building nor shall any sign be located closer than 10' from any property line except than any sign over 10 s.f. may project 2' into any required yard area from the principal building. Please review the enclosed building permit application. The applicant proposes the attaching of a 4'x8' message board sign to the dry stack structure at North Shore Drive Marina. This specific sign had been used previously as a temporary sign for the marina property. The sign is attached to the upper southeast corner of the existing dry stack structure. The zoning staff has refussed to issue a building permit for a permanent sign as the above referenced code section would not allow attaching of a permanent sign to an accessory structure. The code specifically allows attachment only to principal buxldings or structures. Applicant should be encouraged to install a permanent sign with footings that meet the standards of the B-2 signage code, height limited to the height of the principal structure located adjacent to shoreline of Maxwell Bay. Such sign could not exceed 50 square feet in area. The property, at approximately 140' in width, would be allowed a total of 140 s.f. of signage. The total signage would include signage installed along shoreline of marina. i Zoning File #1644 June 13, 1991 Page 2 of 2 Please note there has been no fee charged with this appeals application. If applicant wishes to proceed further with an appeal of the Planning Commission recommendation before the Council, we must ask that the $100.00 fee be paid. We are also aware that the applicant has questioned the use of interior signage within windows of another adjacent marina. This type of interior advertising signage is done throughout the City. The City has not required permits nor does the code suggest that such signs require permits. Staff would welcome any comments Members may have or further direction regarding their interpretation of Section 10.61 of the code as it deals with signs as accessory uses. Options of Action - To approve Zoning Administrator's interpretation of the code and requires the immediate removal of the sign. To direct staff to issue penalty building permit for permanent sign installed on property. 1 ^4 Total Fee: $ Entered By: Ji CITY OP ORONO - BUILDING PERMIT APPLICATION _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Date Received: Date Approved: Permit#:-f :g>f V r.‘ ! • ^;• •r ALL INFORMATION "MOST EfE* iSOBMITTED IN FULL BEFORE PLAN REVIEW WILL BE STARTED THE APPLICANT IS: (circle one)OWNER ji>r CONTRACTOR JOB SITE ADDRESS: 3-22^. c,-ra. hjnJ ZIPs ^ /- - - s ^ — / (work) fi, NAME OF OWNER: I.c.rr-/ o t PHONE:(home) HAILING ADDRESS: ?^^_2 CITY: rn ZIP: tm .s-»~3 CONTRACTOR: j PHONE; MAILING ADDRESS: v! S'Am. ILa_ _ _ _ _ CITY; a yr^ctf^fBt^ovUZZ'?^ / TYPE OP WORK Demo New Addition Remodel/Alteration Accessory Structure )C Move Renovate Land Alteration PROPOSED WORK (describe in detail): a ft at P Sty^t 'm JLckK'f-' dar n -JLr /"S'/•/W P^.^. _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ STORIES : ^ SQ. FEET OP EACH FLOOR; NO. OF BEDROOMS:GARAGE STALLS ATT.^^^ PET, ESTIMATED CONSTRUCTION VALUATION (excluding land): $ I hereby apply for a building permit and I acknowledge that the informati above is complete and accurate; that the work will be in conformance with t ordinances and codes of the City and with the State Building Code; that understand this is not a permit and work is not to start without a permit; a that the work will be in accordance with the approved plan. APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE: (Please fi DATE: everse side of this form) \i Lr •jcfr^:^v7 i)R0N05 CITY of ORON( Post Ornce Box 66•Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 •Municipal Offi( On the North Shore of Lake Minnetonka DATA PRIVACY ADVISORY In accordance with M.S. 15.165, "Rights of subjects of data", we would like to inform you that your request for a permit or license from the City of Orono or any of its departments may require you to furnish certain private or confidential information. You are notified that: 1. The information you furnish will be used to determine your qualification for the permit or license requested. 2. You may refuse to supply data, but refusal may require that the City deny the permit or license. 3. The information may be shared with other local, state or federal agencies to the extent necessary to process the permit or license. 4, If your requested permit or license requires Council action to approve, some information may become public. 5. You have certain rights under M.S. 15.165 to review private data on yourself. 6. Your full name, and date of birth are required to process this application or permit. V7/ ' Phone I understand my rights as stated above. Signi-ture BUILDINC k ZONING - 473-7357 ASSESSING ADMINISTRADON A RNANCE - 473-7358 PUBLIC WORKS - 473-7359 I \ iKirth .urn Atym j j hi To;Mayor Petersen & Orono Council Members Planning Commission Chairman Kelley Orono Planning Commission Members City Administrator Bernhardson From:Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator Date June 12, 1991 Subject: #1646 Trinity Lutheran Church - 2060 Sixth Avenue North - Conditional Use Permit - Public Hearing Pertinent Ordinance- Section 10.28, Subdivision 3 (A) - Conditional Use Permit required for church use and other related structures associated with the principal use. Applicant proposes installation of a detached garage, 28' x 34', at a maximum height of 14' to be installed to the northwest of the existing church structures. Required setback Proposed = 90' 50' Section 10.03, Subdivision 9 (B) - Height restrictions. No accessory building in the R district shall exceed height of principal building nor a height of 30'. Proposed building is at a 14' maximum height. Section 10.03, Subdivision 9 (E) - Accessory structures in excess of 750 s. f. footprint area shall be located at least 15' from any lot line. Proposed detached structure is at 952 s.f., less than 1000 s.f.. and must meet a 15' setback from any lot line. The closest lot line to the proposed structure is the west lot line at 90'. List of Exhibits Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Exhibit P Exhibit G Exhibit H Exhibit I Application Property Owners List Plat Map Site Plan Survey Elevations Profile Floor Plan Septic Map Review of Current Application - Trinity Lutheran Church has applied for a conditional use permit to install a detached accessory structure, 28' x 34', with a total footprint area of 952 s.f. The structure is not considered an oversized accessory structure and, therefore, area ; i ''t Zoning File #1646 June 12, 1991 Page 2 considerations are not necessary. The only setback standards applicable are those for church use at 50' and for an accessory structure in excess of 750 s.f. requiring a 15' setback. Review Exhibits D and E. The proposed plan meets all required setbacks. The detached structure shall be used as a garage and for the storage of maintenance equipment. In review of Exhibit I, the septic drainfield area is located 100 + ' to the south. The map indicates sewer lines within the area of the proposed structure and yet in a recent inspection for the removal of an underground fuel tank at a 13 foot depth, there was no sign of the lines. The structure is to be placed over the excavated site for the fuel tank removal. Staff can confirm no problem with the proposed location. It is imperative that all construction vehicles access the site via the north side of the church structure in order to protect the existing drainfield area. The City has received no comments from the most affected neighbor to the west. The applicant seeks no variances as all standards of the pertinent code sections have been met. Staff recommends approval of the conditional use permit for Trinity Lutheran Church located at 2060 Sixth Avenue North that would allow the installation of an accessory structure, 28' x M • A _ ±__ ^ ^ __ _ __ _ ^to serve as a garage and maintenance structure for theJ "t f UW DCJL V ^ -- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - exclusive use of the church finding *:hat all standards of pertinent code sections have been satisfied. This approval is subject to the following conditions; 1.Upon the approval of the Council and the execution of a resolution approving the conditional use permit by applicant, applicant shall apply for a building permit for the accessory structure. 2.All construction vehicles shall entrance site along the north side of the church. Applicant must provide protection of existing drainfield within southwest yard of church. Isv liMueMMiktliriiM r CITY OP ORCNO - GENERAL LAND USE APPLICA•■tST ‘J . V o i .‘JW U t. PROPERTY LOCATION Site Address Zo(pQ 'Slv'f\A VlO, Property Identification Number (P.I.D.) —^^p"2— ^ttacb 1 ecT-"?"" ■' ■ 3cr^ct2>on to appj.rcatxon xf not xncXuded on required survf. APPLXCAN Name nz-t tJ.TrV C2vVu^U phone (work) — Address 2/^(^ t:>/ xrTbi Aog ^VAo City - - Zip OWNER (if different than applicant) Name _ _ _ __^__^___ Address Phone (home) Phone _ _ _ _ City _ _ _ ZXD Date Property Acquired (month/year) I (do) (do not) also own the adjacent parcels of land PEES - CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS - Renewal Fee - 1/2 Current Fee After-the-Fact Fee - Double Current Applxcatxon Fee $ 50.00 For each variance request with CUP application $125.00 Residential accessory Use ^ $150.00 Institutional (church, school, etc.) $150.00 Guest House/Guest Apartments $150.00 Duplex Credit/Bldg \ > i $250.00 Commercial/Industrial Use $200.00 Land Alteration Grading and filling - designated wetland or Grading and filling - 101 cu. yd. or more Grading, seawall, retaining walls within 75' CITY OF QUeSQ FlHYiNCE OFFICE rJI’0200000 01 QEh ‘ 150.00 CHECK TL 150.00 heceift -th ^kk you B'>12S00 cool ROl TlUC 05/16/9floodplaxn of lakeshore PRD/PID - see fee schedule OTHER APPLICATIONS $200.00 $250.00 $175.00 $ 50.00 $250.00 Commercial Site Plan Review (+ consultant fees) Vacation Easement Vacation Easement Vacation with Subdivision Rezoning (PUD - refer to fee schedule) Appeals$100.00 ” Other - see fee schedule iMiai PRESENT DSE OP PROPERTY Present Zoning District Present Use of Property Residential_ _ — otner (scecify) DESCRIPTION OP REQUEST . T3 /v Describe request in detail: REQUIRED SUBMITTALS '• C«^dfied p'?oVer\1°V^n ”; List of owners within 350' (you can obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Government Center 348-3271). 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. Plat Map. Certificate of survey (signed by a licensed surveyor). ,.«?•* j Topographic survey (existing and proposed contours) i- xan alterations involve changes in elevation (grades). Construction plan, if applicable (see stafr for requirements). As an addendum to this application, please attach a separate ..ist of any other persons you wish notified of this application. YOU ARE REQUIRED TO SUPPLY 30 COPIES OF LARGE DOCUMENTS OR A WORKING COPY (ll* X 17■ OR SMALLER) FOR ALL DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED The applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. remember that your application is not complete if the above information has not been included. Certification by Clerical Department that Land Use Application is complete. Initials of Clerical Staff:_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _Date_— - - - - - - - - APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE The applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay additional fees (staff time not covered by original fee payment) and/or unusual expenses incurred /in review of this application, and certifies that the information supplied is true and correct to the best of _hijp/her knowledge. Applicant's signature _ _ _ Date o I (OmiBRS SIGNATURE . , . a The owner hereby acJcnowledges and agrees to this application and further jf tfATi Q.f t^hls i;0quest:# kinvestigation and vejfificati' Owner's signature Applicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 Planning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission Meetings ®^®_ third Monday of each month. Applicants must be present at all scheduled review meetings of the Planning Commission and Council. If an applicant is unable to attend a scheduled meeting, please make arrangements to have an authorized agent attend in your place and advise the Building s Zoning Office of this change prior to the meeting. ^ T • $ RUN DATE 05/09/91 BATCH 001 . a •ii HE^MEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY ONNERS LIST PROP AODR ONNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR J ; t*% f PROP AODR CMCR NAME TAXPAYER I NAME/ADDR j i ■- i • » • » I » tM’ * PROP ADOR .. ONNER NAME : TAXPAYER \ i NAME/ADDR J* J PROP AODR* CM«R NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR 1 • \ i! PROP AODR ‘f: ONNER NAME ITAXPAYER NAME/ADDR • ) * i 38 27-118-23 31 0002 02060 SIXTH AVE N TRINITY ENG EVAN LUTH CH TRINITY LUTHERAN CmJRCH 2060 6TH AVE N LONG LAKE ff4 55356 INC ♦ j 38 27-118-23 31 0016 02165 SIXTH AVE N DANIEL 6 I RUTH 6 MCPHERSON DANIEL 6 A RUTH G MCPHERSON 2165 6TH AVE N LONG LAKE MN 55356 r. i • 1 I'l '■ ; 56 27-116-25 31 0020 01095 BftO»M RO N RICHARD 0 A KAREN ZIHINSKI RICHARD D A KAREN ZIHINSKI 1006 COLONIAL OR NEHTONN PA 18940 'ii58 27-116-25 4E 0006 ,01960 LAKEVIEN TER : • EVELYN E ROSS EVELYN E HALLER 1960 LAKEVIEN TER . LONG LAKE HN 55356 60 27-116-23 13 0001 00060 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED DEPT or NATURAL RESOURCES DEPT OF NATURAL RESOURCES! 1200 NARNER RD ST PAUL Him 55106 •! PROP AODR QMCR NAHE TAXPAYER I . NAHE/AODR' 80 27-116-23 24 0005 01250 PHILLIPS DR NARY » PHILLIPS . HARY 6 PHILLIPS BOX 765 ; y LONG LAKE m 55556 ^- I . r. t ; ■M' J • • 38 27>118-23 31 0005 02135 SIXTH AVE N RICHARD C VALITON ET AL RICHARD I SALLY VALITON 2135 COUNTY ROAD 6 LONG LAKE MN 55356 38 27-118-23 31 0018 02160 SIXTH AVE N PAUL R PHILLIPS PAUL R PHILLIPS BOX 520 LONG LAKE MN 55356 38 27-118-23 62 0003 01960 SIXTH AVE N BRADLEY HANSEN BRADLEY HANSEN 1960 COUNTY RD NO 6 LONG LAKE MN 55356 38 27-118-23 62 0007 01960 LAKEVIEN TER EVELYN E ROSS EVELYN E VOLBY 1960 LAKEVIEN TER LONG LAKE MN 55356 80 27-118-23 26 0001 00080 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED DEPT OF NATURAL RESOURCES DEPT OF NATURAL RESOURCES 1200 NARNER RD ST PAUL MINN 55106 TOTAL BATCH 001 00016 REPORT NO. PI635601 PAGE 1 Hj 38 27-118-23 31 0009 02100 SIXTH AVE N ORONO NOODLANOS INC ORONO NOOOLANDS INC 2160 6TH AVE N LONG LAKE MN 55356 38 27-118-23 31 0019 02085 SIXTH AVE N J R MARESH a D J MARESH JOHN R A DIANE J MARESH 2085 CO RD 6 ORONO MN 55356 38 27-118-23 62 0006 01980 SIXTH AVE N DANIEL A BERGERON DANIEL A BERGERON 1980 6TH AVE N LONG LAKE MN 55356 38 27-118-23 62 0013 01080 DRONN RD N HAROLD F BONER ETAL HAROLD F BONER 1080 N BRONN RO LONG LAKE MN 55356 60 27-118-23 26 0006 02160 SIXTH AVE N PAUL R PHILLIPS PAUL R PHILLIPS BOX 755 LONS LAKE MN . 55356 ij ca ■ Vi n It .•i II tfM I■ RUN DATE 06/0V91 BATCH 001 I. ; , .•^■ )w • . ' • • 'i* j ■{ r. -:¥■ ... ^ . i-: ' U' ‘ t . ' .>t! ••-'■'-■ • f l'\. I j ..■••. .• •■- V .:' \\ 1:. I . / *r l\» » V ■i •i !• [ ' i-i’ v'i' i:’-i: ? i.:ir j;::. ; - I . •»•.,!; • • ’ •; Of. ?•: i 1 I * ! •> . ^ / V •• . • . * • ; l- / ♦» < * ■N V! •■ •}> • I I. ^M- t I ‘A jl : ! i '! ■ • I •• M; . \ f t’ i. • • . • « 1 j* 1 !• • i « * I 4 i • t ♦ f ! .» •l^u !' f* -'M*/. ■ ;■ I ,• j;. .. ‘ 4* . I n .'v; » . r I * ^ I. •; ♦ ' « • ■ ^ \ .: : • t »I i » V ■ ■ ‘ • ■ 1*^ •ii ' • ■ :■ • ' * ' ' : ■ ] •'■ •■■ ■ ■■ ■'•■'■ “ •, .1 -l: ;■ .f.„ ' ‘ -C • r? r : ' .f; • i » . m- . I’ji-if 1-. . I / 4 . O M -C ' .f; • i' ‘ 1 ‘ * I ‘ ‘ -t ‘ ' i ■^ :i -.•I.: • .. '•. I? • HEttCPIN COUKTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY OHNERS LIST ■ • fr *. .* • •■ •' ’I <■ M T • '» i .*• ••' .'• ••.’• i-H •••: ’ .'s''. sVr t ' • 'r.-U •. • j .^S.\v II I * t .•$' . T ' ' V ♦ ♦, RERORT NO. PI4S5401 PAGE 2 =ti= >35S2iL 5 •"v t CD I CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTED ARE AN ACCURATE AND TRUE REPRESENTATION OF INFOR^UTION AS IT APPEARS THIS DATE ON THE RECORDS OF THE HENNEPIN COUNTY DEPARTMENT OF PROPERTY TAXATION# Tf THE BEST OF MY KNOHLEDGE AND BELIEF DATE .1 \ ———Maiiintp 1 1 ~Tn lT i tinirim ii-iaii TittHll iSJKi' '.T ’ •- *•MHMiDiffift . —- —iiiiiiiilii'ftaiiiiliitlirfi ...................-..... jt3 ■ *k Si ,.•',3 i M taAi I•r f Vv] fcST VA 5\UKC,LP.^ N\/>s-rcH UXt-^-T\UC=» \*s*^ reuT >/r.PLS'A/oc>t> -t-»PS TVu WTi: ZA'' ‘^'c IXZ « >x6 C.ePML T? s vfc Ciso^ti- ‘So»*i'n v.^ NV-vjv\ sov^rrr m'&yatij “r-u\ F\\3 ?_>^A <;-TUP*'> A.v^ C.fr.TL'PUOO'^, A. ^ T^Vi<vrc-v 4' CON C •>'-<‘>15 • V«J \LO'^ 1 '>'< ' J £< 6' 0 1cr \ X4, CoP-> *>r- \:^X\^>T' Gr* CWV2.CV4- Liy \G'0 ? 5'. Planning Corjr.issicn Chairman Kelley Orono Planning Ccmmission Members City Administrator Bernhardscn From:Michael P. Gaffron, Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator Date:June 13, 1991 Subject: #1647 Gerald Benoit - 3403 Eastlake St. - Variance Public Hearing Applicant has requested tabling till further notice. m^mm .5 - V • ■v'v ' '■m- To;Chairmar. Kelley and Planning Commission Mem.3ers City Administrator Bernhardson L Fron: Michael P. Gaffron, Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator Date:June 1, 1991 Subject: #1648 Ronald and Julie Prineas, 1920 Shoreline Drive - Renewal Variance - Public Hearing Zoning District - LR-IA, single family lakeshore residential, 2 acre, unsewered. Application - Request for renewal of lot width variance granted in 1989 and previously renewed in 1990. List of Exhibits - A - Application B - Plat Map C - Property Owners List D - Survey E - Resolution #2650 F - Resolution #2829 Pertinent Facts - 1.This is merely a renewal of the variance granted by the City in 1989 for this long and narrow lakeshore lot. 2.Conditions of City Council approval included no variance to required LR-IA setbacks, specifications of the building envelope, and no variance to hardcover requirements. The lot was approved for access via a separate driveway to County Road 15. Discussion - Please review the findings and conditions of the previous resolutions which are attached. The applicants propose no changes from the original application. Staff Recommendation - Staff recommends approval of the renewal lot width variance request for Ronald and Julie Prineas per the findings and conditions outlined within Resolution #2829. - 1 .i OP OPOKQ - VARIAWC3 APPLlCAttOH* 4 1 j ?:aiti»l ftppUe»tlon ftt 5175.00 ___ (150.00 per each additional, variance) Renewal variance Pee $100.00 yy (no change from original application) A£ter-th«-?aet Pees (Doubla application fee) X, •» ■) %« j:-' •. > vv PPOP8RTY LOCATZOH Site Addreai Shofe^hncJ^f'iv-t'^ 4. V -ICc . . • ;:rv - V* VV .*r“ Property identification Humber (P.I.O.) 10'^ 1(1^23^7, Attach legal deeoriptlon to application if not included on required aurvey. - . . ^ « vv y -“- 'w. -OJ I -■'.■J * . •i •‘i'i Ti-ii' 1 Jhone (home) 3 OS' 6 3 2. ^Ok'2. Phone (work) ^^5"7 ^llQ. APPLZCAirr I name pRlhJlrHS^ g/)NyoL0 4 TMuigNMu- XddrmMBt /?o(-. _ Citvtflidnu Zip? ?,L(^.(2 ferent than applicant)Phone (hO! Phene (work) Addresai quirad .Zip? Date Prope^ X CdoT (do not) aliO own the adjacent parcels of lah (aonth/year} PRBSaiT 081 07 PA0PBI7T Preeent Zoning 'Utrict i^esiDirhJnnL - RL fresant 0$e of Property No c<^ir -Residential Otl^er (specify) Lot Area a/ Lot Width fetback Variances (____Front Hardcover Side ____Hear) Other ‘ Nt.Z(,iOj F<leH lUl^ , adoj^i^ tw, C.)^ ^ dun* li, /<in.Cl'iu/ Ui’(;cztu,l ^ /ffo I ! rmCRZPTZON 07 RSQQBST Describe request in detail: EA^imAtifta conox:xuacd.on ^ IVIDTH l^n fClTMliVVfl L • . VARZARCB8 BBQOZBBD • iescribi andua hardanip cr praocical diriicuicy r^iuii-r.g drcsi acric;; anforcemen^ of zoning regulations _ ___ _—-- - - - - - - -- BSCStlJTJOll OP mroSDAl. PROPSRW C0NDITICN3 Oascrib* unusual proparty conditions preventing ccr'.oliar.cs with Zoning Coda RaquiramentflI BQ0ZJU30 SOBMlOTAtS , Compltted Application Form . CartiSiad Property Owners List or owners within 130' (yeu'in:\uat obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Financa A-603 Govt Center 341*3271)* • Plat Map (obtained with property owners list). Certificate of survey (signed by a licensed surveyor) to include hardcover oalculations as required (provide one (1) copy 8ij ”xll" for reproduction)* i. Topographic survey (axisting and proposed elevations) if any changes in existing grade are proposed (provide one copy aH^xll”). I* 8)<etches or plans of floor a elevation views (provide 1 copy ah"xil"). f. As an addendum to this applicationr please attach a separate list of any other persona you wish notified of this application. I. Additional items as may be requested by city staff. rhe Applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please remembec that vour varfance applicatloa is not eoarelete if the _abova [afon^tion has not been included. MLICA]IT*S SIGRATDB2 )he applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator^ agrees to pay additional fees (staff time net covered by original fee payment) and/or oonaultant expenses Lnourzed in review of this applicationf and certifies that the information rapplied ie true and corraot to the beat of his/her knowledge. Applicant's Signature Date SmiBRS 8ZGHATDRB Phe owner hereby ackovledgea and agrees to this application and further luthorisea reasonable entry onto the property by City staffs oonsultants/ iqtntsr Commission membersr and Council members for purposes of investiga* tion and verifleation of this request^^.^ pWBer’s Signature Data r/ii I ti tolioant must hh^a all submittals into the City offices 2S days before the Pldttaing Commission Meeting. Planning commission Meetings are held on the ^hizd Monday of each month. Applicants mast be presant at all scheduled rewlew meetlnga of the Planning Coitteiaaion and Council, Zf an applicant is Uiable to attend a schedulad meeting/ please make arrangements to have an inithoriied agent attend in your place and no advise the Building a zoning Bffiee of this change prior to the meeting. • ) — 4 • - ^ • m* W' * I \. y.\X f* 'll* * • // - - / **BAVV ...^V -:; £ ♦ i_;> See.DfL t4 :: -1^-i- /V->^ iC" t \W • I »'%•< / •'i,'h i C* f f J*. i*i ^ Se\t^e k^sicr 3. l<'?.< - . I . i>. c k . ^« :i *Xji ^ t /1 (’‘','••11 :^/V/= , _•> e . :i.rwTKAf^ p .' /}&y- •! i ^ 01 ' ii'i a7'I®',;*9 ^ ' * /.“ >5iV / .,. / -iry ' ’ ♦ ^s A - — - *7 --I ^- \% ^_f V \ 3 -V — r* V J V - /V 2 X X X I \ /n"' AVC V v/ ^ " '"'"V► f // '/ V* c*^-. / Xs X-. •.•?<’ ■.. # /• / *y 6i7 2t AND \ 5T.M •r\'V 1.V ■<> ^ ,r<:^ • / - A, 342; . /"'ft ,f / ^ («.3c?'fe M60 (v). N r -4 »: r %no UW/ •T' '>••> * «. ' « .; / 'i\C -A Ai r«' 0f ----------------------------- >05 -A \r5 L * A\3.;v.-. /J iifitfljfaytiiil ........ I I r Property Owenrs List for Application #1648 10-117-23 42 0006 Jeunes Wright 1980 Heritage Drive Wayzata, MN 55391 10-117-23 42 0019 W. Gregory Coward 1950 Heritage Drive Wayzata, MN 55391 10-117-23 42 0005 Robert & Patricia Stierna 1930 Shoreline Drive Wayzata, MN 55391 10-117-23 42 0007 Alan & Anne Nettles 1940 Shoreline Drive Wayzata, MN 55391 10-117-23 42 0018 Morris & Jackie Nelson 1900 Shoreline Drive Wayzata, MN 55391 11IV r-'‘ City of OROiV O CITY QF QRONCr RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 25 50_ _ _ _ _ A RESOLUTION GRANTING A VARIANCE TO MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE SECTION 10.23r SUBDIVISION 6(B) PILE #1410 WHEREAS, Ronald and Julie Frineas | applicants") are owners of the property legally Drive within the City of Orono (hereina.wer City ) and legally described as follows: Per Exhibit "A" attached (hereinafter "the property")? and WHEREAS, the applicants have applied tc the Ciry variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 10.23, bubcivision 6(B) to permit the construction of a single 20^ is of defined width 30' where a definea lot width of 200 normally required. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono, Minnesota; FINDINGS This application was reviewed as Zoning File tl410. 2. The property is located in the LR-IA Single Family Lakeshore Residential Zoning District. ^n „?y^r l°9aV;^"/d""re ‘;r:^ln1rd a^^^rv^/l c/th^'^Vo'p^l variance based upon the following findings. a) The lot area exceeds the minimiim 2.0 dry buiidable acre requirement. tfested and approved for use. Page 1 of 5 ( ) 1 4 ■*./ • • 'r. • 1 \t City of OROrSO CITY OF ORONCr If ■’ / Md RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 2550 _________ c) The hardship to the property lies in its extreme narrowness at the point where the defined lot width is measured. Furthermore, there is no available for purchase that would increase the defined lot width to the 200' minimum standard. 4. The Hennepin County Department of Public verified that the County will approve a private driveway accGSS onto County Road 15. 5. Although the property contains a feasible building site, that site is limited by narrowness of the lot and by thethat site IS iiir.iweu w ------- . , designated drainfield sites, hence careful site planning will be required in develo_ping the propertyWill oe xeuuiicu — £-----sr-----I j is appropriate that a diagram of the building envelope and drainfield sites be filed with this resolution to make future potential buyers of the property aware of the site lim.itations . 6. The City Council has considered this^ application including the findings and recommendations of the Planning Commission, reports by City staff, comments by the applicant and the effect of the proposed variance on the healtn, safety and welfare of the community. 7 The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this property are peculiar to it and do not apply generally to other property in this zoning district; that granting e variance would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor pose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely ® convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate a demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is necessary to preserve a substantial property right of the applicant, ana would be in keeping with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan of the City. CONCLDSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS Based upon the above findings, the Orono City Council single family residence, subject to the following conditions. Page 2 of 5 L ibIMliim I >|'~j I >'»4. ■'• % K { '1♦*J CITY OF QRONCTT Cltv of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. _________ .,n,ed residence must meet the required minimum 1. Any P=^°P°=®f. “//or the LR-IA 2°hi setbacks establis ____setbacks from xm r%A*j rr—^K -^nr “the LR**iA zoning district/ and must i:«hefmU^tir^qulred setbacks frcm drainfield srtes. n __ ^ t_ u nir^ina envslops and 2. A diagram of the bu this resolution as wjf w— -- district. wa-r-lances for development of this 4. No other zoning variances property will be granted. V. j ----------------- - • 1 ^ access for the property is a sing :,. The approved access driveway at County Road 15* .. ^ nark fee Shall be collected by the City at6. The standard park fee s • the time a building permit is issued. V* ^un with ths 7. Authorities ^ gant^^bur are permissive only and property not with ®PP^^?^"Vtion for a building permit roust be exercised ^ council approvals or this 8. Violation of or non-complia^^^^^ ctntti\"ute"'a t?oJatTon"of conditions \^f^g„ton,atically terminate any authority the zoning code, punishable as a misdemeanor, granted herein, and shall oe pu « ________—A. ^ ^ 'CeU ----- 9. The undersigned Vesouftion and on behalfh«eby agree to the terms of thrs resol^ assigns, and °herfbrrgi:;^o1hrrecording of this resolution rn the chain of title of the property. ..M i 1 City of ORONO CITY OF ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 2650_________ Adopted by the Orono City Council on this 26th day of June, *1989. ATTh5T: /j X. / ^c^othy Hallin, CityCity Clerk^James R. GrabeicT^Iaycu^ /Z o C7 perty Owner(s) V 'ATE OF MINNESOTA) )ss. COUNTY OF HENNEPIN) The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this 26th day of June, 1989, by James R. Grabek and Hallin, Mayor and City Clerk of the City of Orono, a Minnesota municipal corporation and said instrument was executed on behalf of the City. / /auk.iA Notary LAURIE «f! ifcHEEfLE* HOTAiTcr-. ir;; hennepin co'jnh < My commiwlso *• f. . . ^ .A My CommitsS10ff'"l!X^ires >1^ , ■ & W Page 4 of 5 III! I itniTii I ii~r i^r*^n ■r-*<T M u-aMli City of OROiNO CITY OF ORONa RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. ^^50 _________ /-LCnbrl STATE' OF MiJeWSCTA COUNTY OF ) ss. On this •+Lt dav of - ■■_______________________ - before me-^ Notary Public within and for s^id «unry, ^personally appsared n r 198 1 known to me to be the person(sJ aescriDea hJ r-hev) executed the same asinstrument, and acknowleaged that he (uheyj execur— -un« his (their) free act and deed. /V NOTARY /PUBLIC , ____ r.crrji. notary f»4n« my COMMISSION EXPIRES fUfi 11 STATE OF ) )ss. COUNTY OF fiSSIRBI^ ) On this ;r«.day of a Notary Public within and for /^IIauUT^ _ _ _ _ _ _ _r 1985f before me said County, personally appeared known to me to be the person(s) described in and who and acknowledged that he (t (their) free act and deed. iVliWWAA ---------------------- execiIFed the foregoing instnament, hey) executed the same as hxs xJ^J^ ./yLcrtrr^— OTARY /PUBLIC .‘♦OTArjY PUBLIC. STATE CF FLCRIO/s. ?iY CO;.|.MlSj!ON EAHN£o:CCT. Ca. I»it> MONOCO TMHU NOrAHr PUBLIC UttCLHVI tUf MY COMMISSION EXPIRES Page 5 of 5 1 r*T. . ' .1 'r, I't EXHIBIT A RESOLUTION NO. 2650 Description: Tracts A and B, Registered Land Survey No. 96, Files of Registrar of Titles, Countv of Henneoin lying Southwesterly of a line drawn across said lot parallel to and 105 feet Northeasterly froir the Soutliwesterly line of said lot. Auditor's Subdivision Number 356, Hennepin Coun*-y, * o.^ota, according to the map or plat thereof on file and of record in the Office of **Tor of Titles of Hennepin County, Minnesota. Together with an easement for road purposes u,^er the Westerly 20 feet of Lot 5, Auditor's Subdivision Number Hennepin County, Minnesota. fe-' ■« •te. HiOl ¥■: m RITm .U B^AILL'ARLC ,?Df eAi»/6Lope l—-£_ |\ 0 0 Aj PaiMAA^ t>&AI»fleit. Sire CwowAjt,'^ ScAL.e l"-/0o' r«>M -siAtuev sv CAeL/Meice A^jor.^^- “ /<^Soc.iATI'S, b^■mI^ \\ If ^e^0<jLiT7OAj A^o. 2^SO -^Kctcw OF BMiLbA&ue fAJUriope- ANb I>RA,„riEi.b 2-a?-S') 11W IT 11 CITX QF QRQNaI City of OR-ONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO.2 329 A RBSOLOTION GRANTING A RENEWAL VARIANCE TO MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE SECTION 10.23, SUBDIVISION 6 (B) PILE #1540 WHEREAS, Ronald and Julie Prineas (hereinafter "the ;,rr 1 icants") are ^the owners of the property located at 1920 Shoreline Drive within the City of Orono (hereinafter "City") and legally described as follows: Per Exhibit "A",attached (hereinafter "the property"); and WHEREAS, the acplicants have applied to the City for a renewal of variances granted in 1989 per Resolution #2650 to width 30' where a -defined lot width of 200 is normally require . NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono, Minnesota: FINDINGS 1, This application was reviewed as Zoning File -1540. 2. The property is located in the LR-IA Single Family Lakeshore Residential Zoning District. 3. The Orono Planning Commission originally reviewed this application #1410 on May 15, 1989, and recoimnended approval of the proposed variance based upon the following findings. A) The lot area exceeds the minimum 2.0 dry buildable acre requirement. B) A feasible building envelope exists in addition to primary and alternate drainfield sites which have been tested and approved for use. C) The hardship to the property lies in its extreme narrowness at the point where the defined lot width is measured. Furthermore, there is no adjacent land available for purchase that would increase the defined lot width to the 200' minimum standard. Page 1 of 5 1 cire QF aRQNCt City of OROINO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO.2329 4. The Kennenin County Department of Public Works has verified that the County will approve a private driveway access onto County Road 15. 5. Although the property contains a feasible building site, that site is limited by narrowness of the lot and by the designated drainfield sites, hence careful site planning will be required in developing the property. Therefore, it is approcriate that a diagram of the building envelope and drainfie^ld sites be filed with this resolution to make future potential buyers of the property aware of the site limitations . 6. The City Council originally granted this variance in 1989 per Resolution #2650 and finds no changes from the original findings and conditions of that resolution. 7. The City Council has considered this application including the" findings and recommendations of the Planning Commission, reports by City staff, comments by the applicants and the effect of the proposed variance on the health, safety and welfare of the community. 8. The City Council finds that the conditions existing on this property are peculiar tc it and do not apply generally to other property in this zoning district; that granting the variance would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor pose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely serve as a convenience to the applicants, but is necessary to alleviate a demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is necessary to preserve a substantial property right of the applicants; and would be in keeping with the spirit and intent of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan of the City. CONCLOSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIONS Based upon one or more of the findings noted above, the Orono City Council hereby grants a renewal variance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 10.23, Subdivision 6 (B) to permit the construction of a single family residence on this lot of defined width 30' where a 200' defined lot width is normally required for construction of a single family residence, subject to the following conditions: Page 2 of 5 .t i I r (• t 11 clty : fORONa rP Citv of ORONO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO.2 329 1. Any proposed residence must meet the required niinimum Lfin^Iefa' = ^ 2 A diagram of the building envelope and approved arainfleia’sites shall be ^ttachea to this resolution Exhibit "B”, to advise future potential buyers of the property of the building site limitations. district. 4. No other zoning variances for development of this property will be granted. 5. The approved access for the property is a single drive way at County Road 15. 6. The standard park fee shall be collected by the City at the time a building permit is issued. ssSiSSiaSS variance will expire on that date (July 9, 1991). 8. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this variance shall constitute a g^nted^hlrein!' and^sLl I'^hTpuniLLirara mis^meanor. 9 The undersigned applicants have read, understood and agree to the recording of this resolution in the chain of title of ,the property. Page 3 of 5 r cirvr QF [ORQNCP City of OROIVO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 2329_________ The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this 9th day of July, 1990, by James R. Grabek & Dorothy M. Kallin; Mayor & City Clerk of the City of ^rono, a Minnesota municipal cLporaticn and said instrument was executed on behal of the City. V \ Cr Notary Public hotary rubuc state cf ^csioa uv rPMMlSSICti lX?« bonded thru general ins. UNO. Page 4 of 5 1 S.J Citv of OROrVO IL - CLtY RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO.^ O O C QRana STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF DADE ) ss. On this tri.day of 199 r before me a Notary Public within and^for sa;^ county, p^sonal^ - - -, known to me to be theappeared Ronald James Prineas» ~]oint owner person(s) described in and who executed the foregoing in-itrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free act and deed. -V NOTARY PUBLIC notary public state Cr rLORIuA MV CCr'HISSlON EXP.BCriCEO THRU GENERAL INS. UNO. STATE OF FLORIDA COUNTY OF DADE }ss. On this day of _ _ _ _ _/ 199^, before me a Notary Public within and for >said'County/ personally appeared Julienne (Julie) Prineas, joint owner known to me to be the person(s) described in and who executed the foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free act and deed. O •V, ^ 4 NOTARY PUBLIC NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF FLORIDA HY COWISSION EXP. AUG.31,1993 BONDED THRU GENERAL INS. UNO. Page 5 of 5 i n-'^Nj III! •» • '1,.! ■\\\''"•!i •• •. ni1 ' -I ) ! I •r, » ORONO REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING HELD JULY S, 199G ZONING FILE J1538-30RN CONTINUED the information regarding this application. hardcover that would result fron the criveway. xt was then .haw I v/as advised that the deck had not been approvea. Mabusth provided pictures shewing ^ that all landscaping has been completed on the property. of the Councilmember Goetten believed that the stairs are necessary, but that she could not approve a deck. It was moved by Councilmember Goetren. seconded by Callahan, to aoorove the stairs and landing and the additional hardcover within the 75-250 foot setback area resulting from the relov-atio of the driveway as required by Hennepin County. Motion, yes- , Nays-0. Motion passed. »1539 DAVID FILKINS 3905 SHORELINE DRIVE VARIANCE RESOLUTION #2828 Hr. Filkins was present for this matter. Bernhardson reviewed the information pertaining^ to this application (see Michael Gaffron’s memo aated Juiy 1..90). Gaffron noted that the Planning Commission had recommended approval of applicant's plan #1. Councilmember Goetten asked whether the Planning CoiTinission had recommended that the concrete walkways oe removed. Gaffron showed the areas of hardcover that are proposec for removal. It v/as moved by Councilmember Goetten, seconded by Councilmember Callahan, to adopt Resolution setback variances to relocate an existing garage. i.otion, Ayes-3, Nays-0. Motion passed. #1540 RONALD ft JULIE PRINEAS 1920 SHORELINE DRIVE VARIANCE RENEWAL RESOLUTION #2829* It was moved by - 7 - I i1 r yf ORONO REGULAR COUNCIL MEETING HELD JULY 9, 1990 ZONING FILE *1540-PRINEAS CONTINUED Ayes-3, Mays-0. Motion passed. *1541 DR. ROBY & JANE THOMPSON 1520 TANGLEWOOD ROAD VARIANCE RESOLUTION *2830 Dr. Roby and Jane Thompson were present. Citv Administrator Bernhardson ^rin'rnemo presented regarding this application (see Michael Gat.ron s nemo dat6d July 2t 1990). <5e^back variance to construct aaditions i.o the e.xiSt.*nu r-si^enc It'l?20 ^angtewood Road. Motion, Ayes-3. Nays-0. Motion passec. *1543 RICHARD C. REED 1000 OLD LONG LAKE ROAD VARIxANCE Mr. Reed was present. Bernhardson reviev/ed the information relating to Mr. Raec's application It was moved by Mayor Grabek, seconded by Councilnenber Goetten to aporovo the after-the-fact height variance tor entrance nonume'kts at the Richard C Reed asked whether it v/ould be appropriate tor the C^t, .o P^^sue whatever irnecessary to make Old Long Lake Road a public road M,:»hii«5th Stated that it is unknown how platting the^ road woul the abutting property owners with torrens ana registered ^fnf Barretf staled tLt 'the City could condemn the property Mayor Grabek asked how wide the road woula have to be ix. J publL rtad. Gerhardson replied that the toad woulc have to be 66 feet wide. Motion, Ayes-3, Nays-0. Motion passed. *1544 ROGER AND BECKY BERRY 1392 BALDUR PARK ROAD VARIANCE RENEWAL RESOLUTION ^*283^^^^^^ by Councilmember Callahan. seconded by Councilmember Goetten. to adopt Resolution *2831. granting tha the-variances approved in Resolution #258/ be renewed. Motion, Ayes-3, Nays-0. Motion passed. *1546 SCOTT PROCHNOW 4075 HIGHWOOD ROAD VARIANCE RENEWAL RESOLOTION^*^^^^^ by Councilmember Callahan, seconded by - 8 - J n To:Chairman Kelley and Planning Commission Members City Administrator Bernhardson From: Michael P. Gaffron, Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator Date;June 13, 1991 Subject: #1649 Elaine Peterson, 1921 Eagerness Point Road - Variance - Public Hearing Zonlr.^ Dxstrlct - LR-lC, single family lakeshore residential, acre, sewered Application - Request for side setback and hardcover variances to construct a detached garage. List of Exhibits *■ A - Application B - Letter of Request C - P3at Map D - Property Owners List E - Neighbor Acknowledgements P - Survey G “ Hardcover Calculations Pertinent Code Sections - Section 10.22, Subdivision 2 - Hardcover regulations. 2. Section 10.03, Subdivision 15 (F) - Accessory structures require 10* side setback. Pertinent Facts - 1.Applicants' property currently has no garage. Applicants propose to construct a detached 20'x22' garage. In order to keep that garage in line with the existing driveway and to avoid distrupting existing retaining walls, they request a 5.5’ side setback variance, allowing a 4.5' side setback for the garage. 2.Existing 75-250' hardcover is 34.9%. Applicants' proposed hardcover removals in conjunction with the garage construction, reduce this to 30.9%. A small portion of the rear of the lot is in the 250-500' zone. Removal of an existing shed will reduce the existing 35.5% down to 6.0% in the 250-500' zone. Discussion - Applicants propose to remove all rock/plastic hardcover, in addition to reducing portions of gravel parking area which will no longer be needed, and will be removing an existing shed structure in poor condition. Zoning File #1649 June 13, 1991 Page 2 of 2 The proposed garage will be 45* from the neighboring residence. It is interesting to note from the survey that applicants' retaining walls already extend into the neighboring property. While this is potentially an issue for the property owners to resolve amoung themselves, it could be argued that replacing the garage as proposed would perhaps limit the possibilities for a future elimination of the retaining wall encroachment. On the other hand, forcing the garage to meet the 10' setback would leave a somewhat less functional angle of approach to the left garage door, and would result in the need to possibly rebuild the opposite side retaining walls. Applicants have not provided a garage plan. However, they have stated that the garage is intended, to be a Menards or similar kit garage, 20*x22', two stalls, standard 8' walls with a 4:12 pitched roof, and peak height of approximately 12'. In the context of the proposed location, this garage probably will not have a significant visual luipact on the neighborhood. Staff Recoamendation - If Planning Commission feels that applicants have provided sufficient hardships and justification for granting of the 5.5' side setback variance, then a recommendation for approval would be appropriate. Likewise, if Planning Commission determines that the proposed removals of hardcover are acceptable, then a similar recommendation for approval would be appropriate. 1 \'/;0 * CITY OP ORONO - VARIANCE APPLICATION y4 4 - jJ #« Initial Application Fee $175.0'^ ($50.00 per each additional variance) Renewal Variance Fee $100.00 (no change from original application) After-the-Fact Fees (Double application fee) . • II J 'WfTl.* *• I ; 1*. . - 4VC a/ . f * 7“ Tk' ■ -* • i' V' *w 7 :1 \ •• PROPERTY LOCATION 4 • V.* • VV a;;;* yr:,—• vw V*f rr. •c*. * ‘ 'V' Site Address v^a f.v dAg Property Identification Number (P.I.D.) ^\*» Attach legal description to application if not included on required survey. Phone (heme) m ^ \ _ _ __ Name S-_Ia.sv^&. _______________ Phone (work) m b • w>r 3hh Address: V.^X\ ^Ac-»<Lry\g_s*> City ; u._______ Zip; OWNER (if different than applicant) Phone (home)__________________ Name _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _Phone (work) _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Address; _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _——_ City:- - - - - - - - - -.2ips_- - - - - - Date Property Acquired '‘nXM \c\SVj_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ (month/year) I (do) ni^) also own the adjacent parcels of land. PRESENT USE OP PROPERTY Present Zoning District __ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Present Use of Property *S‘. ^ _ Residenrial _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Other (specify) _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ DESCRIPTION OF REQUEST Estimated Construction Cost $ S'dcc.qp Describe request in detail; v^ewJ c^er-c^e^ . A ■■■ - ■■ ,,1. —— ^ ——~ ■■ •• •• •• mm mm mm VARIANCES REQUIRED _ _ _ Lot Area _ _ _ Lot Width ^ Hardcover Setback Variances (_ _ _ Front Side - - - Rear) Other _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ___ _ _ • « • • ^ - . ‘ • n I# H' ■ ■■ k HARDSHIP Describe undue hardship or practical difficulty resulting from strict enforcement of zoning regulations: ^V\ \yx_ rci^)^ a -V ^\>c ___CfL-SAjlM—^ C-C >>i t V t n'l^- S>^V~t'\cVi- DESCRIPTION OP DNDSDAL PROPERTY CONDITIONS Describe unusual property conditions preventing compliance with Zoning Code Requirements: v>;^ « sV\\pt \ (VTv o <- 'Oo> \ X ! rtf C«^ tp«*v; Ui ■ rv - - - - - - - - - - - UIRED SUBMITTALS % 5. 6. 7. 8. Completed Application Form Certified Property Owners List of owners within 150' (you must obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Govt Center 348-3271). ^lat Map (obtained with property owners list). Certificate of survey (signed by a licensed sui,eyor) to include tiardcover calculations as required. Topographic survey (existing and proposed elevations) if any changes in existing grade are proposed. Sketches or plans of floor and elevation views. As an addendum to this application, please attach a^ separate list of any other persons you wish notified of this application. Additional items as may be requested by City staff. YOU ARB REQUIRED TO SUPPLY 30 COPIES OF LARGE DOCUMENTS OP A WORKING COPY (ll* X 17" OR SMALLER) FOR ALL DOCUMENTS SUBMITTED. The Applicant and Property Owner must sign this application- Please remember that your variance application is not coriiplete if the above infomation has not been included. Certification by Clerical Department that Variance Application is complete. Initialed by Clerical Staff:_ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _Date_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE The applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay additional fees (staff time not covered by original fee pa^Tnent) and/or consultant expenses incurred in review of this application, and certifies that the information supplied is true and correct to the best of his/her knowledge. Applicant ' s Signature \ Wlvic . r\. Q Data OWNERS SIGNATURE ^ ^ ^ ^ The owner hereby ackowledges and agrees to this application and further authorizes reasonable entry onto the property by City staff, consultants, agents, Commission members, and Council members for purposes of investiga tion and verification of this request. Owner's Signature ^^Date i^plicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 days before the Planning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission Meetings are held on vhe third Monday of each month. Applicants must be present at all scheduled review meetings of the Planning Commission and Council. If an applicant is unable to attend a scheduled meeting, please make arrangements to have an imthorized agent attend in your place and to advise the Building & Zoning Office of this change prior to the meeting. i ¥;: ':}ftrvv-< '-z^r ’ *-!• • -.- '" :^v-. : v;f"’;;V;^^n Life./WMBmMmmmim ■■\ A-'v* *.• : :■ "v / ■ •V »■ >, mW: ^i*'-''''ij;." ?•'"5>>.-/.. •'■>. • •V • * V,': i';‘' SfcV^^vr.-u ;:;!.< - • . • • ;. v.^ t.w«| r% To O /I - r iv'' ■•’■ '•*•• tiOmisr^ *^4 ta-ioi v/' . ► .* -...,:,-AV>*^ vj\ 3-CVJ^ '•XJ^^T'3 ‘ ■-! ■ C" •'■■‘'\::X' '■^■■■'' .r\- *>k--4w4 n^':«V ■/•>/•'•■• » . 'i-. •-. t«i? ■ ;!* . ■ ' ■• • -•’ '•-"'W- -ijf ■■M '.iv if-t O ; -'^A/V<w»X X J W^xSlA. .^«r.. . vva/ Xo- .rv^ - ^c^v» Xo- ^ '-NjaX ' ^ ,j‘\iif« jc/'OkiL o-^ \\ijfKy ^s^M. o-^ ;. /VA.^ ^Vvj^ '^Qi^a,5- «Vv O*^ TN\«. vxj^Ailc^ X.'C 0-- O''-^ . -JaxTt>.sc^^w^va. "Xe-. ‘ .' ■;' ■ :y:| ,.......... mM: ■ . ; ‘»f' Af.:;''^>fe.;i;':.! . ••:f. f..,: .. ■- i' mi l"Am •mi ■WtfA jC>iJCO»w. life:. T3... ■y'i il *»# : . vm oJ^ ^SvX .iLArit^ Tfcrt>\A«, ,\AT«-v»ibik '\>C J\Anrtv^0V«A^ ’i^b^rts. ^'fj-^j;^y^ .:• r?;:.,':r Ai-idipA' myi: ■>'. ;v':. >' 4?* •» mim • V... life.? 3m# i,'s,9*a.!5«JulL r>^------^-------------- -S^!Vw».C^ ^ V-C-'JwJ^ 'Xv..<x sJIaX;*. '^ 'tsjui. ‘'A/ry-jJL'^ JSA.^lXclaJuIL. >a/9"^* ,^-»,--5.-' AiAu. tw ..v\»Auaj. anvA. '.«vX»VA. '*S^fe-r.r <rrX^ WsL %va..' • »ta* ....... »a \ Vaa*C -%<aSKjgW»0 •.-^rvCr>^KO^fl ^ . /vA<S«yNXMnriNi<^ 0KU :f'' # *•«»*••** V#:.; ... ^ ew^- c^ >iVwa.- .«aJ& .«««. .®^._.. SAlf - Ji^ ■SH}» •WS.MUN, ,7;oo f *«?•»■“.1'’ i^K,..!'...:! ■ . , - ■■':'.r'M i; ■ ^ ■- ^ ■ r • v*,. I mA^myy ■. ’'\VartOlu- yj|rvw fe ^ O^I^A)#rw .4.^.f>^'cwiair>VJ *.wi%‘A» wX’**.• .‘^^SSiT^^ .'ft :fJO)■ •> tn N 105 i '.29)*.'’ A ^9! % ^ 23)?i • > »/ 1 22 ^#1 *5 V r*‘fo / ' Lil^ ^• *'•.V* ' V A \ V—isJ^ I' ti V..'f .•'M : ::':|RUN DAT! OS/OS/fl . f i • .iv- P Pvi '-v . > ;,.?•( •; . :ri.rUi {•-.{mtchooi. : ■ rv- HEItCPIN • ■■**■■■» •s'.iVPftOPAOM / 4 : -I'S-v liM'S'?!' iMCR NAME TAXPAYER NAHE/AOOR i - iV'‘ I?'.: >••;{,fi '>f ■i t . • f V » ' *' ' L36 ‘ 17-li7-« 23 0006^ ,01920 CONCOODlil ST JOHN E NEIST ETAL JOHN E ICIS7 * !. ,1920 CONCOHOIA AVI > NAYZATA MN » B5591 ■ti »■ '. i;‘ . V!; !'(• ■; V f I A ' ' JV PROP AOOR ; ^ ONNER NANS I *« TAXPAYER ! : : .NAHE/ADOR f- :C!‘ .u- • ; ^r; V!r36 17-117-23 23 0009 01913 • FAfiERNESS POINT RO •? • >I-'. DAVID L StAVIK A NIFF / OAVID L SLAVIK ^ i 1913 FA6ERNESS PT RO ^' NAYZATA HN ; 55391 f .■ • t ‘f r-,tf ‘;r.- !' ’ •: I, >■ j^pROP AOOR OltCRNAHE * TAXPAYER ’ p NAHE/AODR * i\ {36 17-117-23 23 0012 *01937 FAGERNESS; POIKI RO N L KLITZKE A B J KLIT2KE COtUTTE H KAERCNFR ' 1937 EAGERNESS POINT RO NAYZATA m 55391 ;'V Si ! (« *4 V PROP AOOR I COtCR NAME 4 TAXPAYER : NAIf/^AODR ;v Vr '36/ 17-117-23 23 0017 01990 . CONCORDIA ST SUSAN C PETERSON SUSAN C PETERSON 11990 CONCORDIA ' NAYZATA HN 55391 t I ^ i;’■f j-iv. »I .♦1V r PROP AOOR' N ONNER NAHE TAXPAYER . MHE/AOOR « • < f . *'36 V. 17-117-23 23 0022 01690 CONCORDIA ST ROGER COOK ETAL .'ij CAROL COOK it- rwim il690 CONCORDIA ST • «NAYZATA HN 55391 ;* ; •;» ^ ' j* ♦ 's Hi < •V r/ COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY CMIERS LIST 38 17-117-23 23 0007 00036 ADDRESS UNASSIGNEO LLOYD H DRAPER LLOYD H DRAPER 6015 GIRARD AVE SO MPLS MN 55919 38 17-117-23 23 0010 01921 FA6ERNESS POINT RD D L PETERSON I E M PETERSON DARRYL L PETERSON 1921 EAGERNESS POINT RD S NAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 23 0015 01932 EAGERNESS POINT RO HARK R PLATT MARK R PLATT 1932 EAGERNESS POINT RD NAYZATA MN 55391 38 17-117-23 23 0018 01995 EAGERNESS POINT RD R 6ENAR1 I 6 NISKANEN-GENARI R GENARl A G NISKANEN-GENARI 1995 EAGERNESS POINT RD NAYZATA m 55391 38 17-117-23 23 0031 01920 EAGERNESS POINT BRUCE I CAMILLE CURTISS BRUCE i CAMILLE CURTISS 1920 EAGERNESS POINT RO NAYZATA m 55391 REPORT NO. PI935901 ; PAGE 1 38 17-117-23 23 0006 01905 EAGERNESS POINT RD NILLIAH A HIBBS NILLIAH A HIBBS 1905 EAGERNESS POINT RD NAYZATA MN 55391 1 38 17-117-23 23 0011 01929 EAGERNESS POINT RO LLOYD DRAPER LlOYD H DRAPER 6015 GIRARD AVE SO ) MPLS MN 55919 38 17-117-23 23 0016 01926 EAGERNESS POINT RO K A J DAHLEN EBS MORTGAGE CORP 2610 UNIVERSITY AVE N ST PAUL MN 55119 38 17-117-23 23 0021 01899 EAGERNESS POINT RO LAN KARPINEN LAURI M KARPINEN 1899 EAGERNESS POINT RO S NAYZATA MN 55391 TOTAL BATCH 001 00019 .1 I OD . PV t » %. l: •v I • • \ kMq - —^ -- - H-r J J r r-'o77 Ok,C'C,f^c-v^AjLC?j:y I M •r Y :js: rj •:i /*>« «<c V si,> <« 4 f4^ « *-Vx CV\2 Y“^ ^C\»VjlC*( I r -7>jx •:A ■ . : r Adjacent Property Oiraets•/Acknowledgement Form' ' %:A / I (we) T) ^ 1/) n L. ^ 1/ ' /<^ [print name(s). of / <? f '-e‘ ,-:3 ^ d . [print address] have reviewed the plans for the proposed improvement or proposed use of the property located at also referred to as Land Use Application No ^^^(we) understand that in executing this acknowledgement^^^ am (are) not asked to declare approval or disapproval of the property or use but merely to confirm for the City Council that(2(we) am (are) aware of the improvement plans and that the proposed neighbor's project or use requires Council approval f] '7)^ .7- f 1/ f Piit>perty Owner Date Property Owner Date If you have any information that nay assist the City in the review of this Land Use Application, please submit your comments to the Building & zoning office at least 10 days prior to the scheduled meeting date. L 1 1I XM JLK^JTXjL ^<J Xt/ *'03M Preparec for’. ^ i ' ! i u t ^tAnv\ri / -/"=2o' I I . • • •^ V-* ~r y V- vcr. --------viijn KUA.wt.^-. 5E ”uAc:-: ::;;=: (c:.".c-_h :::=' C-75' u..\tSi li»Q r».#wwi—.* ••! — « r\ • 'Jp • •y X //. / L-; t j i .. V X WIDTH //■ o ^2-05 ____/«?. 7 C^/AU^(Y STJa/' . % uAnAGc y. ? X r-7 » •tv ZQ_X s/ S.r. / c. Driveway .. HHO '■V -PSS' X D., Sidewalk i£HIIiL =/imi€ xo^ s!f. S.F.V^?/5 4-3>o X S • r • /P c/r C, PAT-k^/^ De X igD ECX / 7. 5 . X /2.7 2 2^./ Af^/y/tyf L • " r 1 ivnyrAr-" 7 y X V •- • ytffSAS ,3^. S X 77 tffTOCRLA IN 221 X c?. 5 "• -//«r- irzAmc / 7 X /•/7 SHEwNG X /(T tl.S ^/c J X'2.5-•7. J C*.Ml 1X. .f s /<?, •/ 0 Other • ^ X 2 3 ’* Total Hardcover in Zone Total P roperty Area in Zone X|__y_£2£_.-r[l • 'i820 s.F. A I // 7 9 5'S.F . /7. 7?y X 100 » ^ >• •« ••••• |0^ ci> is^ BIS’ 30 o.F^ s.JU^ S.F.W s.r^ .T.S s.F.y S.F.''_L.l:: I / / 1 r;-, ^- ■U . r: V-/, ■■ '*.. /" w w/t-'/- t: / \ * • '•••♦ •,“••''1! ».;r,r’'C'JirtrT Mni\JLJ»C.‘\ A^.-.L«»wL.n I iU4t jlUU»\w..w-.i / •—^/ * ^ ! ““ - - U J • t p • • I • ■ LE.’iGTH WIDTH :<i. r I S//ea //X /D. «7 s... X S.F. X S • F • 3. Garage s.r I (J/fWt/f i- c. D riveway X S.F. D.. SfDE W-AfcX- _ Cc/ao^-> S.F.,e <-r X S.F. • £. pATrer Cy»V X / <:?. -5" ? y S.F. y\> C, t^'■ '>'f-^ 3^ w w *v X S.F. F. Landscape ___ AREAS UNDERLAIN .. .... 3Y , ______ PLASTIC SHEETING ■I • #r» * _ S.F. __ S.F. X X = ..!• • • S.F. S.F. : fTlUTiillrlfltt'^ - ' f To;Chairman Kelley and Planning Commission Members Mayor Peterson and City Council City Administrator Bernhardson From; Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator Date: Subject; June 12, 1991 #1650 Hennepin County Department of Transportation Intersection of County Roads 15 and 51 - Conditional Use Permit/Variance - Public Hearing Pertinent Ordinances - Section 10,03, Subdivision 19 - Conditional use permit required for land alterations in excess of 100 cubic yards. Section 10.55, Subdivision 8 - No land alterations are permitted within the lakeshore protected area. Application involves storm sewer improvements within the 75* setback area. List of Exhibits - A - Application B C D E F G Addendum Plat Map Property Owners List MCWD Permit Site Plan Elevation/Spec Sheet Review of 7UEter-the~fact Application - The Hennepin County Department of Transportation was asked to file an after-the-fact application involving the installation of turn lane at the intersection of County l-v'ads 15 and 51 and much needed storm sewer improvements ar that intersection. Rather than delay the project, the City asked the County to file an application and proceed with the improvement. The storm sewer project involves the installation of underground tiles and a series of catch basins to handle run-off that comes from the west along County Road 51. The current stoirm sewer system is inadequate. The current system involves a simple underground tile and catch basin that runs along the west side of County Road 15 and then drains eventually into the lake further south. The inadequacies of the limited system have resulted in major washouts in the area during heavy storms. Review Exhibit E, the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District has already approved a permit for the project. The Public Works Department has reviewed the plans and also concurs with the permit from the MCWD. f fiatiHliUtlr Zoning File #1650 June 12, 1991 Page 2 of 2 Staff made an inspection of the storm sewer facility on June 6th. It appears to be complete except for the placement of rip rap at the manhole that empties directly into the lake on the east side of County Road 15. As of that inspection, the turn lanes have yet to be defined by striping. r- staff recommends approval of the after-the-fact conditional use permit/variance application f'.'r the Hennepin County Department of Transportation for storr^ sewer improvements within the lakeshore protected area located at the intersection of County Roads 15 and 51 based on the following findings: 1. The proposed improvement plans have met the standards of the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District - permit issued April 22, 1991. 2. The storm sewer plan satisfies all pertinent standards of Section 10.55 of the zoning code. .v =■;r -hh / / & CITY OP ORONO - GENERAL LAND USE APPLICATION Ml M» «« •• •• •• wmm mm mm mm mm mm ^m % m ^ mm mm ^m «» m PROPERTY LOCATION Site Address Tnt.pr«;prt.inn of C^AH 15 and SI ad-ac°nt to Lake Minnetonka Property Identification Number (P.I.D.) __ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Please attach legal description to application if not included on required survey. APPLICANT ■^^I^^-^c.^Phone (home)--------------------------------- Wayne Matsumoto Phone (wor)c) P30-2584 Address 320 Washington Avenue South City Hopkins zio 55343 OWNER (if different than applicant) N£une Phone (home) ^ Phone Address Citv Zip Date Prooertv Acauired (month/year) I (do) (do not) also own the adjacent parcels of land. PEES - CONDITIONAL USE PERMITS - Renewal Fee - 1/2 Current Fee After-the-Fact Fee - Double Current Application Fee $ 50.00 For each variance request with CUP application _ _ _ $125.00 Residential accessory Use _ _ _ $150.00 Institutional (church, school, etc.) _ _ _ $150.00 Guest Housc/Guest Apartments _______ $150.00 Duplex Credit/Bldg _ _ _ $250.00 Commercial/Industrial Use $200.00 Land Alteration Grading and filling - designated wetland or floodplain Grading and filling ■“ 101 c'l. yd. or more Grading, seawall, retaining walls within 75' of lakeshore PRD/PID - see fee schedule OTHER APPLICATIONS _ _ _ _ $200.00 $250.00 $175.00 $ 50.00 $250.00 $100.00 Commercial Site Plan Review (+ consultant fees) Vacation Easement Vacation Easement Vacation With Subdivision Rezonir.g (PUD - refer to fee schedule) Appeals Other *- see fee schedule 7K HENNEPIN ‘r ■mm-r. DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC WORKS 320 Washingtcn Avenue South Hopkins, Minnesota 55343-8468 PHONE; FAX TDD: (612) (612) 03C-2513 (612) 030-2696 May 22. 1991 Ms. Jeanne A. Mabusth Building and Zoning Administrator City of Orono Box 66 Crystal Bay, Minnesota 55323 CSAH 15 AND 51 SAFETY IMPROVEMENT CONSTRUCTION CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT APPLICATION Dear Ms. Mabusth: As you are aware, our Operations Division is doing safety improvement construction at the intersection of CSAH 15 and 51. The construction consists of the addition of a left turn lane on CSAH 15 and storm sewer work. Enclosed is a Conditional Use Permit Application. Copies of the construction plan and the Minnehaha Creek Watershed District Permit are also enclosed for your Information. There is no change in elevations on the roadway or adjacent land with this construction. Should you have any questions, please call Marcel Kulas at 930-2577. Road & Bridge Dperations Engineer JEA:mak Enclosure HENNEPIN COUNTY an equal opportunity employer $1f2 $!i€. f§ r. H If g. ontasao-^is UtLlsrOH - r ? r '/ ■ ?i>.. D. '5 CERTIFICATE OF MAILING STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) SS. ) CITY OF ORONO ) Property Owners List for Application #1650 10-117-23 31 0002 John Spence 2040 North Shore Drive Wayzata, MN 55391 10-117-23 31 0003 Lyle Godfrey 2060 North Shore Drive Wayzata, MN 55391 10-117-23 31 0001 George Rovegno 2010 Shoreline Drive Wayzata, MI'l 5 5391 10-117-23 34 0001/2 Vernon McCoy 1425 Bay Ridge Road Wayzata, MN 55391 D i I iVIISMIMEHAHA lIS^ErK jtfATEHSHED OISTRIC: P.O. Box 387. Wayzata. Minnesota 55391 /' <•. ' BOARD OF MANAGERS; James ft Soenstey Pres. • Jonn E, Thomas • flicnam R. MJIer Rodert 0. Ef.cKson • C *Vbocrow LOve • Clarkson unaiev • Tdonas Macte. jr. LAKE MINNfTOKXA I i April 22. 1991Permit Anniicatinn No. 91-52 Applicant: Hennepin County Dept of Public Works 320 Washington Avc. S. Hopkins, MN 55343 Location: City of Orono, Sec. lOCD. Smith Bay, Lake Minnetonka Purpose: Stormwater management plan for a 500 foot long widenmg of County Rd. 15 south of County Rd. 51 and construction of a storm sewer outfall. Dear Mr. Aulu Receipt is acknowledged for the following which you have submined as part of the above permit application: 1. Revised plan received April 22,1991. Ihis plan is in accordance with the action taken by the Board of Managers on April 18, 1991 in reference to the above permiL This lener is your permit from the Minnehaha Qeek Watershed DistricL Permit approval is based upon the following exhibits: 1. Permit Application 91 -52 received April 8,1991. 2. Letter from the applicant to the District dated April 8. 1991. 3. Construction plan received April 8,1991. 4. Letter from the District to the applicant dated April 19,1991 informing him of the Board action on April 18,1991. 5. Revised plan received April 22,1991 . The Board approved the permit application with the following condition: 1.The owner has the responsibility to operate and maintain the approved stormwater management facilities which were designed in accordance with Rule B of the Rules. This permit is valid for one (1) year from the date of approval noted above. If construction is not complete by April 18,19^ an extension must be requested. Please contact the Distria at 473- 4224 when the project is about to commence so an inspector may view the work in progress JAMES M. MONTGOMERY, CONSULTING ENGINEERS, INC. EngipMrs for the District , y James J.Ma^ / AFR2".1391 > ;:R?jcrji csEnr /T/ £?f. Gf A<?r Date ot Issue ‘f-f/ / I &I1 ikf ULjr^. kikirtfvf ii > r ..i r lyM - I HAfO ^t-^cs 0 filfHAf, COiJS ac .. = 2 c.Y, pen Mw/P«T 5Tn*’0'^*P p(Aif 31 >4 6 '5f>eci4ic3T«iu. eefe-AtfP<'<* 3fooO if'xl’ (S<i4*/«x///ff 1. MP MfMU f/t* ■ l-S/4* ■», t M4l*^ j. IMCMll6Hi SEE CAP DETAIL tJL fVt 24" titlO C.^-t \ ttJiTH 8»A^^ i-' Ao^ C.M.P. /e'x6'^'?.+'^ V"’ ^27.S • --f-/ -9/ ••• —J » X 935.22. '^2. 9^7.70 9^1.22 q35.2X J .5“X/2/>-' C.M.P." ' r 9?6.4fe 940.n<> ;.0%___ 9J6.«4 92>l,22 . ..k 1 irwti[i"i^ irtiarnf ^1" III ,4 ... . Planning Coranission Chairman Kelley Crono Planning Commissicn Members City Administrator Bernhardson <?. From: Date: Michael P. Gaffron, Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator June 10, 1991 Subject: #1652 Daniel and Barbara Fleischman, 500 Hanlon Ave. - Variance - Public Hearing Zoning District - RR-IB, Single family rural residential, 2 acre, unsewered Application - Request for side and rear setback variances to construct deck List of Exhibits Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Exhibit F Exhibit G Application Plat Map Property Owners List Description of Request Survey Deck Plans Assessor's Sketch Pertinent Facts 1. 2. 3. 4. Lot area is 6,475 s.f. The property is not subject to hardcover regulations. Lot coverage: Existing = 17%; Proposed * 22% (15% allowed). Setbacks: Front (E.) Proposed 72' Required 50' Variance Left side (S.)22'30'8' Right Side (N.) (side street)11.3'50'38.7' Rear (W.)28'50'22' Discussion The applicants previously had a deck in the same location as that proposed, but slightly smaller (see Exhibit G, Assessor's Sketch). The applicants removed this deck because it was rotting, then applied for a permit and found that variances would be needed to replace it. The new deck will be squared off with the house, plus a 4* x 10' platform and stairway leading to the parking area. Because the railing of this deck will be more than 6' above grade, the deck is calculated in lot coverage. Allowed lot coverage by structures is 15%. With the addition of this deck, lot coverage will increase from 17% to 22%. Ike f ■ ■ Zoning File #1652 June 10, 1991 Page 2 Please review the applicants description of request and hardship statements, and the note from the Miller's next door. The deck will encroach no closer to the side street let line than the original deck, and the only portion being closer to the alley will be the 4' x 4' platform and stairway. Your visit to the site will confirm that 2 of the 3 entrances to this residence would be made accessible by this deck. Adjacent Lot History Applicant's property has no garage, and a small metal shed across the alley to the west appears to be associated with this property. The lot west of the alley was once owned in common with applicant's lot, but went tax forfeit a number of years ago, and is available for sale only to adjacent landowners. While it may take Council approval, applicants property could be considered as adjacent and, therefore, should be eligible to purchase that lot. Also note that when sewer was brought to applicants property, the assessment was split between applicants lot and the lot across the alley. The City has never recovered that half of the assessment, and would expect to recover that as part of the sale of this lot (it is staff's understanding that the tax forfeit status of the westerly lot occurred prior to Fleischman's purchase). At any rate, although it is somewhat unrelated to the variance request, applicants are advised that the shed should be moved onto their own property or they should make arrangements to purchase the vacant lot and combine it with their homestead lot. Note that acquisition of the lot would likely provide a place ^ where a garage could conceivably be constructed in the future. Staff Recommendation If the Planning Commission finds that there is sufficient hardship for allowing construction of the replacement deck, then a recommendation for approval of setback and lot coverage variances would be in order. The Planning Commission should specifically define the hardships supporting approval. Isv i. I OF ORONO - VARIANCE APPLICATION Application Fee $175.00 ($30.00 per each additicnal variance) Renewal Variance Fee $100.00 (no change from original application) After-the-Fact Fees (Double application / 'rjsh J J. sa.-- ] i t. : ^ . A V *• V .• ./ OrVlaVTU * . f,ss) PROPERTY LOCATION Site Address property Identification Number »V ”7 . ^ T “ r* ’ * ~ w/ / a f I vt r r.irrrrc •V I AUU Attach leoal description to application ir not included on ^ ^ “ ♦ 1 /«. »vvrequired survey. - 175.;; f -rw «Tc M.• HlS-'5=.S^OAPPLICAST pt^icMtyXr\ Jhone (home) Name 'PL-.I hrJiKTXai^ Phone (work) gU.- 1^ vrw-MU I u u • v.*t r/.. wa • a V' • : SDD l4-AffJlT^ City: lA.^A-yz.A-7~>^ _ Zip: 6 Phone (home)_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ __ Address OWNER (if different than applicant) Name _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ____Phone (work) Address;City:Zip: Date Property Acquired (month/year) I (do) (do not) also own the adjacent parcels of land. PRESENT USE OF PROPERTY Describe request in detail: VARIANCES REQUIRED Lot Area Lot Width Setback Variances ( Other _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Front _ _ Hardcover Side X Rear) t ^ HARDSHIP ‘ Describe undue hardsi.ip or cracticaJ. difficulty resulting from srrict enforcement ot zoning regulations: C^Ot^ tb lA3\dg ■ hrvc.^yygl it'innpCSgibU “fc> ^Qp-f>lc>cx. tin<[PTI0N^FCrHTODALPR0P^TYC0NDITI0NSO|v>v^C-U<wt^ ^ 6^DESCRIPTION __ _ _ Describe unusual property conditions preventing compliance with Zoning Code Reauxrements; Lw-fh U>icix-» ^- -1* 2. r;3. REQUIRED SUBMITTALS 1. Completed Application Form Certified Property Owners List of owners within 150' (you must obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A—603 Govt Center 348-3271). Plat Map (obtained with property owners list). Certificate of survey (signed by a licensed surveyor) to include hardcover calculations as recuired (provide one (1) copy 8Ji"xll" for reproduction). Topographic survey (existing and proposed elevations) if any changes in existing grade are proposed (provide one copy 8J;"xll"). Sketches or plans of floor & elevation views (provide 1 copy 8%’’xll"). As an addendum to this application, please attach a separate list of any other persons you wish notified of this application. Additional items as may be requested by City staff. 5. 7. 8. The Applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please remember that your variance application is not complete if the above infonaation has not been included. APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE Th»» applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay additional fees (staff time not covered by original fee payment) and/or consultant expenses incurred in review of this application, and certifies that the information supplied is true and correct to the best of his/her knowledge. Applicant's Signature Date 5'- ?/ ONNERS SIGNATURE The owner hereby ackowledges and agrees to this application and further authorizes reasonable entry onto the property by City staff, consultants, agents. Commission members, and Council members for purposes of investiga tion and verif? cation of this request. Owner's Signatiire Date Applicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 days before the Planning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission Meetings are held on the third Monday of each month. Applicants must be present at all scheduled meetings of the Planning Commission and Coun cil. If an applicant is unable, to attend a scheduled meeting, please make arrangements to have an authorized agent attend in your place and to advise the Building & Zoning Office of this change prior to the meeting. \ \ • j J .* 4* :4 c V ' 1 164 1 ? .•*’ 3 S ^ 17 * »• 5 IV 04s S l'\ IS4 07 \L0T 15, ao 3 UI^»€TCM(A S ..i r*o 8 C « \ / <• Ul ^ IIS 7 sr N6a*Sl*IO*| \ <^*^*** Ml :m T (2) iL DICKENSON VAC ll-A-i. c:i Cl cirt cr -: Cl O o WB ^ W v'V' *1 hi) "1 fi ^ ^ 71 .. /it ,sV « " "...5 ‘ > ‘r'•6 t S 16) ® i“s* (7) ‘ b" '• ! (in c ^ * C * “’"J i ^ 10 iT*' s ■* (lor.^I " If 1 t91j, n ^6 n'ViZLZJ—T '* S1 t/r 75 B •' LU cd cd CD a^st^1 lit 4# ^ N ' * »— •' k( M) *“ (•») 1 (27) *41 ’ S •* K » LU i__t'i V *1 i 1 ••' 4 1 (i wJLid ra ’ • ft LU — Z2L 4) LU - » It >»'•M « (S) 1 4 j ^LU it: _ B '““ (rj)N » « O _l B '*" (35) ■T i ft fi IT " (2^) \ • a ( 16) ^c ® cS) ‘(A) »“ ^L >« " (21)(17) ^« '* (30L ^ Q *5 (20)N *0 s B "(1^1 ‘ B '*N 19)'• " 6 ••(Ifll " B^ ”” IJ« M i '* t175 25 ftO lA 4»u II it 0ri - 314.-^ I % . .RUN DATe.05/24/n r** »• ». * .4 T ‘t«. : 9 « « i ■r : BATCH 004v;• V ■»«.r* • • yr » . r> * :*• ^> i i J ‘ * . w♦ i\HEKNEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY OHNERS LIST r ; 'I ; ‘ : 1 ! . ‘/ so' 0E-117-E5 SI OOlS PROP AODR ( 00500 HANLON AVE I *.»• K /# . • t .. \ . OlfCR NAME ‘ I A M BER6SA6EL::taxpayer ' NAME/ADDR,1 , 'DANIEL H FLEISCHHAN '.A'’ '500 HANLON AVE ! il - • ,, I . ♦ I : j HAYZATA MN 55S91 11 I' ,***t - ■ i..PROP AODIl . OHNER NAME ^ TAXPAYER HAME/ADDR ♦ ^ f sa 02-117-2S SI 0028 .005S9 KEENE AVE ’0 HARALD ERIKSEN 0 KARALO ERIKSEN . 6219 ZEALAND AVE N 1 ,1 *•. 1I I- • t•» if •1;f MPLS MN 55426 Si :{ \ * 9 . : V' •; r • • ; IHIOP ADDR ONNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/AODR *; • ;• \ i - * t • •; %' . j •? 3« 02-117-25 51 0059 -t 01295 iilCKENSON ST ; HE SCHHIDT A K H SCHHIOT ' HILLIAM A KARRINE SCHHIOT' 1295 DICKENSON ST HAYZATA MN 55S9I . t » « '» PROP AODR CRfCR NAME TAXPAYER NAM£/AODR i - ’ , I ' 1 . • A • » • ' ys TOTAL BATCH • *I *• ‘' 11 ’ :#r I Uv r*>t ,1 * , r T ^,:r A 1 r> .f ‘ t i . >> I ♦} I: % I »• » • I- il. 'j,;! ■>■• ii' r: ‘:v'! ■• li 'lf'.r-;: ! > , > ' • V • ‘ ' "i ■ 'f! I * 1 * i $ ■ _1 .f ' j; if ' !i j . ;«i 1; •. IM 't •• » < " f-J ■#'’--f.} i>v i''if,ri -.i ' ;1''' { f'vi c’t: ■ .’S$••V fC' ^ -f ■' ff- •: ■'*•■■'/ ;• * V'l;' i '‘i 38 02-117-25 31 0014 00521 HANLON AVE RICK S HILLER ET AL RICK S HILLER AND KATHRYN E STENSO HILLER 521 HANLON AVE HAYZATA HN 55391 38 02-117-23 31 0037 00530 HANLON AVE HA'. THIES 8ILL A LUCY THIES 530 HANLON AVE HAYZATA HN 65391 38 02-117-23 31 0046 00540 8ARRETT AVE D H JAFFRAY A H 8 JAFFRAY DRAPER H JAFFRAY £40 BARRETT AVE HAYZATA MN 55391 REPORT NO. PI435401 PAGE 15 38 02-117-23 51 0015 00537 HANLON AVE R V A H E KOEHNEN ROBERT A HICHEL KOEHNEN 537 HANLON AVE HAYZATA W 55391 38 02-117-23 31 0038 00520 HANLON AVE RAHONA H SLEOZ GERHARD 0 TAN6ER 10043 PILLSBURY AVE BLOOMI^K>TON FM 55420 38 02-117-23 31 0047 00450 ORONO ORCHARD RD S EOHARD H HAHH EDHARD H HAHH 408 ST PETER ST ST PAUL 55102 V-,, 1 CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTED ARE AN ACCURATE AM) TRUE REPRESENTATION OF INFORHATION AS IT APPEARS THIS DATE ON THE RECORDS OF THE HENT<EPIN COUNTY OEPARTHENT OF PROPERTY TAXATION. TO THE BEST OF MY KNOHLEDGE AND BELIEF. „„E „Ml//). b.f AA.a ^ 1^ iffirniHi i Z^k.r^A r>■«*** < r F P i^o i::>^.c/c /f\ a X/?^^ t^.^.’/ /-^yxyi U&^ O^. __ijti.uloS_ : * i^rwl Jr/) A I-^aA^/is 7^ .J^j'l /_ ._4<_. 7^'/>^<- Q/\/ir-L^¥ /yt^<^>w /j/i.^ //?-^ 7^ ^ Zf/A/Z w__^ h -H]■d /r/oc/5> __^I/\Sitc7^/~:<r^^ _____(jJ/ r^6f/C p> //f/j2 jJ h? •_____home -. / , h-ct (^h"!'^i /-^ ■ hiche^J- /^’(/e/_____ .‘•l 7^ A)^d •...* } ■»»*r,J 1/ .--------------^ i'l 6 rv-_ _v(ic:p:> o>^Mo //^ 2 cr/Q^^-5 N /V y nimi Detf-K. -f (/ ^ 6 o vn ns ciic^. i 1 rajTriPw^y^AiM Iw il... ■ c $ r*^ •r /.w* < • 1 *l 1 ‘ I t i j liu=3 i^=> »—• ^ ---- cT Wu. ^'i''< y?'?^i V <d .bt A A<kf'^CC^i<^^ AJbJ Abco'^ ^ 'Z/bH<^^ Z^tyiyx.^ ^ U>£ZAZ'^ iZ'f\ycPt Jy%PC'}\/^C .'^C) /U'^C^y(. J A Ajb-b^iyf^ . CC^h^. ....5 ‘yO^AA^-'km\^cAj^ _^/uZiK. tt) M'lodA^A (^'Tid Alui M wC/w t (/ *\y\J DS^’Ci'Sy^^y^ f Cf\^,jzX> Ubii do dxZ ^ ..ytM• fn».»^ ■» k • V I C-<. ‘bo K|4^; LEGAL OESCIUPTION ■^ippipr fc<3' n A >- <i: 2 5 <i: X fM-AJ /''--20' i KkUBBlB •i roo • • ' .r * W • /I / • u •'»* • »W ••* •• .:y:^...;f ,. •7 p‘*, '! f •7^* ^4. .. i •' ' • *r. . • .if - ' .*• »" * % »v '.^ m- •- •i**» * .'•> t, • ••. • ,* . .•• ...,- #• •♦. . » » • . - AA ... .• .• ••.•,“* ' *• A • *r .* ♦♦ % „ •• —A, . • ■ / ' ' - .•-« , •* , ' \r> so • ■ * w• ^ # •I/e \ i%.—a!^ ■ ' • *- ynf ' •• »«• • . ^ -* * i 1** ^ > . f*>A ' ' /i> • <** ,* • .« - - *c. r • . fc •» ^ ’•'• >» •/ ••if V * •' • ' ' • AIWA - •» , *■ -** • •', * :'!M AiP' T»AW*gl Jc*'. ^ ' ! r*; ^ % , • - ^ '.'V* y* v> f'*' *. • ^ t», •Vi v/.w-?^'?l Sfe:S!: F' >os ' - "lMPeCT»0*l OATl.:; ».*.*•/. . . • •- . • • • • • ^• ••., '• • • ♦♦* •• .• • • • i^ • " . • • • I * '■»* ..........~ • .. . '4." - V iva*^>a?ir>^: ;. • i,'-i'-^• ■ ,- •-<'5- ■-•- •.^ >_'•*• j*WVjfc ..J<r;..-^*AIWUaAtO‘‘*-- ................ -^V /' * *» > ■ ■ *• ••’*>----------------- ................................ ;•HI // TVfe - • •< . • * ■ ■ , ' I. ’ IMmOVCMENTS • . « , •. ■ • # 4*» * • . * ' • .# . . *<if ‘ *• ' . - . '••Tir'. ^ >- t::.\ ' '. •: •••;... • .r- • ::• ________-—^— ■■ — K- ' t-.lAS»CHOJ?E __£2L x-JLH - /^-x X X X X 5CL PT. ^ro .• vAUii •. v:.fj'.,r.iaiAU-t?^ f/fG r* .*^* _ ■••.. 'l-. total AOIICMM - lALOOWIEl • OTHER 9UQfii ^------ ■ X------------------------ ______________________X_______ • J- 1» . •*. '**f' - ■ '■'. •'*' --/T' ’•/;‘'l-.^* iw ..,.. . # / A. QAAACC f ( xV«».X X HM • **. UtTNAt omvrwAV *• - , 1234867 -,* 1 23 4 867' • • nSliT m- 1 23 4 867 .' ' 1 234867 ■**. _4^ •! iiuniMr.1234967 ^ - ALUMBtNC 1 234667 1234867 1234967 * «iar»iAce 1 23496 7 1^/n n^frr 1234967 BUILT i4^a 1234967 ^/AlU TFr 'FIL 1 2 34 96 7 TOlU 1 234967 . . CFNTnAL / •«1 23496 7 PATIQ Oa^jTAB 1234967 Ff^CCS 1234997 1234997 1 234 9< 7 .• *'V- -:» 9 • ... Vi. ^ • • ^ rifeili <1^ ‘ • .-.^ ' • • -V' • - • .... \ . -.*•• •< -. < ■■■■■• • , , m ^S'*. *••*•■ -r . *A. •«• /O'^ m ■ ^► Vi ' • * • tl 1*^ •» •< /^o TOTAL VALUE /Joo JiC>7Cm * ■ i4^ !* r To:Chairman Kelley and Planning Commission Members Mayor Peterson and City Council City Administrator Bernhardson JO- Prom:Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building s Zoning Administrator Date: Subject: June 13, 1991 #1654 Dean Terry, 2710 Pence Lane Variance - Public Hearing Pertinent Ordinances - Section 10.22, Subdivision 1 (B) - Structure placed within 0-75' setback area. Applicant is replacing deck/access stair structure within lakeshore bank area. Section 10.22, Subdivision 2 - Hardcover in the 0-75' setback area. Replacement of a structure that does not meet the City standards; 4' width stair, 4'x4' landings requires variance approvals. 0-75' setback area = 22,000 s.f. Existing Hardcover = 1,84" s.f. Proposed = 1,731 s.f. or 7.86% Review of hardcover within other setback areas; 75-250' setback area = 39,200 s.f. Allowed hardcover = 9,800 s.f. or 25% Existing hardcover = 15,525 s.f. or 39.6% Variance =* 5,725 s.f. or 14.6% 250-500' setback area = 114,600 s.f. Allowed hardcover = 34,380 s.f. or 30% Existing hardcover = 19,740 s.f. or 17.23% H) - hardcoverOpen space easement (review Exhibit limitations for the total property; Total area » 175,800 s.f. or 4.03 acres Allowed = 33,000 s.f. Existing » 37,118 s.f. Proposed = 37,002 s.f. List of Exhibits - A - Application B - Property Owners List C - Plat Map D - Site Plan - Variance Application Approved 11/81 E - Preliminary Survey - Carman Bay Heights F - Resolution #1335 - Approving Hardcover Variance 75-250' G - Resolution #1393 - Approval of Plat 7/26/82 H - Open Space Easement I - Hardcover Fact Sheets J - Plan of Access/Stair Structure - Before K - Plan of Access/Stair Structure - After L - Property Owners' Acknowledgement M - Blunt Letter N - Current Survey of Property and Existing Hardcover mnnir -I ni' rHiftll Zoning File #1654 June 13, 1991 Page 2 of 4 Review of Application - On April 26th a Stop Work Order was issued against the property because an access stair structure was being constructed on the property without the benefit of a permit review. The owner has met with staff and has advised that the total project will consist of the removal of one of the existing access stairs (review Exhibits J and N). The stair to be removed totals 100 s.f. of hardcover. Applicant proposes the reinstallation of an access stairs similar to the previously installed one (review Exhibits K & L). Hardcover with the reconstruction will be reduced an additional 16 s.f. The former one was at 282 s.f.; the proposed at 266 s.f. The overall reduction of hardcover in the 0-75' zone will be at 116 s.f. Before we continue with the review of the application, it is necessary to review the history of this unique property and the land use applications previously filed against this property. In 1981, the City granted extensive hardcover variances within the 75-250' setback area based on the applicant completing removal of certain existing improvements (i.e. boat house within lakeshore yard - review Exhibits D and E; and a loop driveway section - review Condition 1, Resolution #1335 - Exhibit F and site plan Exhibit D). Another condition of that variance approval required the former owner to file a subdivision application as owner had acquired lands to the east. The resulting 2 lot subdivision was filed and finally approved in July of 1982. The former property was increased from 1+ acres to 4.03 acres. A condition of that subdivision approval required that the owner execute an open space easement limiting all hardcover on the total property to 33,000 s.f. (review Exhibit H). The open space easement is filed against the chain of title. Please review the total hardcover facts cited above. It would appear that the site contains approximately 4,118 s.f. of excessive hardcover and in violation of the City's Open Space Easement filed against the property in 1982. In reviewing the file for the variance application. Resolution #1335 - Exhibit F, the boat house structure at 300 s.f. was to be removed and all substructure removed out of the 0-75' setback area. In comparing the location of the boat house structure on that former survey (Exhibit D) with the current survey (Exhibit N) it would appear that the substructure of the boat house may have been retained as the lower deck area of the access stair structure. Review Finding #5 of Resolution #1335. Condition #1 of that same resolution would have required the redesign of the access drive by removing approximately 3,000 to 3,500 s.f. of hardcover. Applicant was not to have a looped design road but a single lane drive approach to residence. Applicant's surveyor has also advised staff that many of the items now included in the hard cover inventory were not considered hardcover back in 1981-82 and have now been included in the hardcover inventory. ,4 f . I HP lih I \ Zoning File #1654 June 13, 1991 Page 3 of 4 The excess of some 4,000 s.f. of hardcover on the property must be addressed by the City as a part of this current review. As for the replacement of the former deck/access stair structure within the lakeshore yard, applicant's application notes the topography of the lakeshore bank necessitates a structure to assist in access to the lake. The existing structure was structurally unsafe and required immediate replacement. It may be that the former owner never altered the original stair structure at the time of the removal of the boat house. In addition the improvements will result in a reduction of approximately 116 s.f. of hardcover within the 0-75' setback area. In discussions with the applicant, we reviewed the trials and tribulations of many residents who have gazebos and similar structures within their lakeshore yards and of staff's advise to provide regular maintenance of these structures. Simple maintenance functions each season rather than total replacement. Total replacement of structures that do not meet the City's informal standards (4' stair width and 4'x4' landings) do require variance approval of the City. Issues to be addressed in your considerations and recommendation: 1. now shall the Planning Commission address the excess amount of hardcover controlled with the open space easement? There is nothing in the files that suggest any later approvals that would have allowed the loop configuration to remain for the access drive. The lower level of the access stair structure certainly appears to be the remnants of the sub structure from the old boat house on the property, which was supposed to be removed in the first variance review. You may ask applicant to select the areas of existing improvements to be removed so that the 33,000 s.f. is retained on total property. 2.Will you allow two decks/landings for the access stair structure? If upper substructure is removed, there may be serious impact to the upper portions of the lakeshore bank. Would you require additional removals of hardcover within the 0-75' setback area to allow the 266 s.f. of new access stair structure (note overall reduction of 116 s.f. of hardcover within 0-75'). The thrust of the open space easement was to consider this property as a whole. Review Exhibit N, drainage has been defined. Note portions of 0- 75' setback area and the remaining 4 acres drain to retention area within property - away from lake. In fact this property receives major drainage from east, north and west. How does this affect your consideration of the access/stair structures? f Zoning File #1654 June 13, 1991 Page 4 of 4 Options of Action - A. To table the entire application until applicant has provided a plan showing the removal of excessive cimounts of hardcover on the 4.03 acre parcel; or B. To advise the applicant to file a separate variance application to consider the violation of the open space easement limiting total hardcover to 33,000 s.f. and to act separately on the current application which seeks approval of the access stair structure. If you are to act on the access stair structure, you may adopt the findings and hardships set forth by the applicant in addition to any cited by staff or by applicant at the meeting. Such approval must be conditioned on the removal of the most northern access stair structure and any other removals cr changes in proposed structure deemed appropriate by Planning Commission. CITY OP ORONO - VARIANC2 APPLICATION Initial «p?lica-icn Fee S175.0C ($50.00 per each additional variance, - Renewal Variance Fee $100.00 ^ (no change from original applrcacicn; _ A£ter-the-Fact Fees (Double applrcarrcn ---i h . \ ■’w ’d TV v-r.wr. . ' 1. . 1 w . • f ^ r mm wm .«••••■• • 4 - —k-' t V V property location Site 2710 Pence Lan^-Orono . I’ *r ^:J'*/V v,-:» •J .A'* • • - • Property Identification Tf''nc\''Lncruil ^n Attach legal description to applicau-on required survey. _ _ _ _ _ ___ ___ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ “ rhone Thorne) 471 -0900-------- applicant Phone (wcrx) 47"^-5266 Name Dpan R. Terry Address ■ 2710 Pence__T^ene_ _ _ _ OHNZR (if different than applicant) Phone (home)_ Name ____________________________________ Zip; 55331 Phone (work) Address :City;Zip; Date Property Acquired (mcnth/year) I (do) (do not) also own the adjacent parcels of land._ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ PRESENT USE OF PROPERTY Present Zoning District Residential Present Use of Property Single Family Residential NA other (specify) description op request Estimated Construction Cost $_5200.00. Describe request in detail:,, To replace and also reducing total hardcover- - - - to per drawiaft VARIANCES REQUIRED Lot Area Lot Width X Hardcover Setback Variances (Front Side Rear) Other T.akeshore setback k. t ^ YU iM* ^ Tm T inr^^riTr^fTT—f “ .-i<mr ^nrnrr i.' tl\RD5H!I? . * t e“r:-;t*enro=- o lH. unsafe steps and only reo lscir.a one set, also.reducing.total haracover in._t±e----^ r2SCMPTI0N OP DNDSUAL PROPERTY CONDITIONS ^ Describe unusual property condmcr.s preventmc ocir.p--.ance ,w--n .jO**-.., Code Requirements : - - - - -—- - - - - - - - - - - - --—-- - - --- - - j / ^ m « • 3. 4. 2EQUIRED SUBMITTALS certified p|^S‘cwnerT List of owners within 150' (you must obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Gcvt Center 348-3271). ^ Plat Map (obtained with property owners list). ^ certificate of survey (signed by a iicensed surveyor) to_include hardcover calculations as required (provide one (i) copy 8H xll for reproduction). . , . . Topographic survey (e.xisting and proposed elevations ir any cnanges in existing grade are proposed (provide one copy 8 . x-1 ). Sketches or plans of floor & elevation views (provice 1 copy 8% xll ). As an addendum to this application,^ please attach a separate is o any other persons you wish notified of this application. Additional items as may be requested by City staff. 5. 6. 7. 3. ■twfnrTHatioD has not been included. incurred in review of this applicanonf and cer ies tha u v«.* supplied is true and correct'.to the best of his/her knowledge. Applicant's Signature /—Date May 23 , 1 991 / lion and verification of this request. )wner's Signature Date May 23, 1991 oplicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 days ianning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission :hird Monday of each month. Applicants must be present a __-iicant is veview meetings of the Planning Commission and Council. nable to attend a scheduled meeting, please Zoning luthorized agent attend in your place and to advise the Building & ffice of this change prior to the meeting ! : f • -i I £f II i I ! ii •J •qq RUN DATE 05/22/91 BATCH 009 PROP ADDR OHNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADOR OHNER warn TAXPAYER NANE/ADDR PROP ADDR OHNER HME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADDR OHNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADOR OHNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR PROP ADOR OHNER NAME TAXPAYER NAME/ADDR 38 21-117-23 23 0011 02665 PHEASAN1 RO D J DONEFF I D L DONEFF BRYAN A DARCI DONEFF 2685 PHEASANT RD EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 23 0029 02725 PHEASANT RO LILLIAN K ECKLUND NM K t L B HHITHORTH 2725 PHEASANT RD EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 23 0029 02701 PENCE LA M A ARBISl A S J ARBISI MICHAEL A SUSAN J ARBISI 2701 PENCE t . EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 23 0092 02703 HALTERS PORT LA HILLIAM H REESE JR A HIFE HILLIAM H REESE JR 2703 HALIERS PORT LANE EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 23 0095 02709 HALTERS PORT LA H H A S K DUNKLEY HILLIAM M A SUSAN K DUNKLEY 2709 HALTERS PORT LANE EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 23 0098 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING INC ENVIRONMENTAL PLANNING INC 9530 IDS CENTER MPLS MN 55902 HEft4EPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATIOf4 SYSTEM PROPERTY Olt4ERS LIST 38 21-117-23 23 0012 02695 PHEASANT RD BAB REUOICK BRADFORD H REDDICK 2695 PHEASA14T RD EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 23 0025 02765 PHEASANT RO STEPHEN L BAKKE ETAL STEPHEN L BAKKE 2765 PHEASAflT RO EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-25 23 0039 02702 HALTERS PORT LA A J MCDERMOTT III ET AL ANOREH J MCDERMOTT III AT4D JEROME L SKIFTER 2702 HALTERS PORT LA EXCELSIOR MT4 55331 38 21-117-23 23 0093 02705 HALTERS PORT LA DONALD H NELSON ETAL DOT4ALD H NELSON 18305 MINr4ETONKA BLVD STE A HAYZATA MN 55391 38 21-117-23 23 0096 02710 PENCE LA DEAN E TERRY DEAN E TERRY 2710 PErCE LAME EXCELSIOR MT4 55331 38 21-117-23 23 0099 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED DAL UPHOFF DARYL L A LUCY S UPHOFF 2699 KELLY AVE EXCELSIOR m 55331 . J'- J! : ..V 5,, ' 1: REPORT NO. PI435901^ : PAGE • i27 * Ii ivr 5fl 21-117-25 25 0015 02705 PHEASANT RO G « K JOHNSTON G P « K A JOHNSTON 2705 PHEASANT RD S EXCELSIOR m 55551 v.t' f M ■ • «. f S I *. V i. M "V'l ■■'ii • 4|'-. ’ V;|.> • ^ J 38 21-117-23 23 0028 02795 KELLY AVE. RAJ STEHART ' ^ RONALD C A JEAN C STEHART 2795 KELLY AVE EXCELSIOR MN 55331 t 58 21-117-25 25 0040 02701 KELLY AVE C E GARRITY A A 6ARR1TY CHARLES E GARRITY 2701 KELLY AVE EXCELSIOR ttl 55551 58 21-117-25 25 0044 02707 HALTERS PORT I A HUOERT 0 BLUNT ETAL HUBERT D BLUNT 2707 NALTERS PORT LN EXCELSIOR MN 55551 58 21-117-25 25 0047 ” 00058 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED A J HCDERHOTT III ET AL ANOREH J MCOERHOTT 111 AND JEROME L SKIFTER 2702 NALTERS PORT i A EXCELSIOR MN 55551 58 21-117-25 25 0051 02710 PENCE LA < DEAN E TERRY DEAN E TERRY . • 2710 PENCE LANE EXCELSIOR ttl 55551 ■ i ;V-:' 1: if- K > .{«• - XI ■ I!'.! ■ 1) I; f \ i: > • f ID * \ ■ . - i.! • • 4 • ■*. ;r .4. . • ;.J • -1 jwI } !' ‘ \ I . ’» . • ' ‘I ' I . <‘f t • • t i - I .. «• * 1^’ ‘ t 5: i ' ‘ «' * •) . S ‘ 4 1 ' W ^.[ i. • * *1 I. '•/ • i:; •^ V ! V 'V‘ DirtaMr lin BTAVKAiii ' . iRUN DATE 05/22/91 BATCH 009 • i * PROP ADDR ONNER NAHE TAXPAYER NAT^/ADDR PROP AODR ONNER NAME TAXPAYER NAHE/ADDR , . ( . j HENNEPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY ONNERS LIST SB 21-117-2S S2 0001 02791 PHEASANT RO. L N A L C SUNOET LELAND N SUNDET 2791 PHEASANT RD EXCELSIOR HN 55SS1 TOTAL BATCH 009 00021 ^ » 1. ■ : 1: \ 1 mui REPORT NO. P24S54D1 PAGE 2B I? t > 36 21-117-25 32 0005 02789 PHEASANT RD PAUL L POHLE ETAL PAUL L POHLE 2769 PHEASANT RD RR 2 EXCELSIOR MN 55531 38 21-117-2S 32 0007 02715 PENCE LA MICHAEL HALLEY HOMES INC MICHAEL HALLEY HOMES INC 7431 BUSH LAKE RD •i:: T- V EDINA MN 55439 « \ .1?' ■ >• i . ‘•1 ^ ’ f.' ‘I *• • • r-i f * ‘‘ ‘‘ iN•: i :i ' ! ; j -' I • * >-i 4 •l^u I- ^v'4Ixl ' ^y- U .1 V.» V -.4 ■ lie) i % * ■ 'A •!. •' • ♦ j • II t. I •• . <. * ...i ■ ' f 'M!‘■h• ft* • I f ; V • t. • i -:i ii: 0, r ♦ • 4 * <•% • r * I CERTIFY THAT THE FACTS REPRESENTED ARE AN ACCURATE AND TRUE REPRESENTATION OF INFORMATION AS IT APPEARS THIS DATE ON THE RECORDS OF THE HE^#^EPIN COUNTY PEPARfF^NT pf PROPERTY TAXATION* TOLTHE BEST. OF HY KNOHLEDGE AND BELIEF. I • i 1'«*«***■■.» •! t v: .4.1 '• I ; • • * i, .-i-u <1 •. T" -l; U' Ml •» -i. t i •• J ' . ' I • ■*> ii I 4 V Is -ffe- *• ■ f<! • i I • i. M ■ 1 • ’ i. ' . ' * » ; :• ^ u «< • '■ • y f I v,; : rX : • ♦ I ‘ J. . I A • • • •• I V’. y r‘ . .4 • t f • t. U-Mh ' ; >*% CITY OF OHONCL£ " ‘ lio :j*'^.'^i hAi: 5it.iCity of ORONCr RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. _X, ^ ^ ^ RECOLU'T’IOM approving a hardcoltr variance APPLICATION FOR MICHAEL PLUHM ON PROPERTY LOCATED A.T 2710 'WALTERS PORT LADIE WHEREAS, the City of Orono is a Municipal Corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of Minnesota; and WHEREAS, oursuant to State Statute 412 et. seq. ana e • . ' ^he Cit-/ Council of'the City of Orono has adopted zoning regulations .or the protection of the public health, sarety and welrare; anc Hennepin County, Minnesota, hereinarter rererred to as the properu%, and WHEREAS, the City Council has reviewed the application, the recommendations of staff and the Planning Commission, ^ comr.ants of the neighbors and tne letters anc ccnttents mace by the app^ican-. NOW 'T’H''=*REF0RE 3E IT RESOL*.that the City Council of the City 0-ono hereby'aporoves the hardcover variance application o. Micnae.L Pluhrn to permit construction of an addition to his ras:dence basea on one or more of the following rindings o- rac W • 1 - T — 3 - The property is located in the LR-13 .’.')ning d:si'rict requiring a minimum of 43,560 sf in ai«a; ti.e area of the Pluhrn property is 59,000 sf. 870 sf of hardcover exists within the 0 - 75' laxeshore setback area in which none is allowed. The applicant will remove 300 sf of existing hardcover leaving a total of 570 sf of hardcover consisting of a portion of a patio and pool house. 13,288 sf of hardcover exists within the 75' - 250' lakeshore setback area in which 9000 sf ..s allowed. The new construction will call for an adcitional 543 sf of hardcover leaving a total of 13,831 sf with an excess of 4,831. 4 -22,250 sf or 38% of the total lot area of 59,000 sf is located within the 0-75* lakeshore setback area and is excluded from the building enve.lope. ir~IMIII I I in»^T.i»i i i?3.ge *. 71-1 T - I L CITY I I^OHocm city of ORONO. , .: ^ T* ^ i.J . \ V *0 ” »<m . i RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO.t -j ■> c Urn ^ ^ fMT • D - 6 - The actual hardcover increase tor the t.tal prooertv is 24 3 sf based on the siituli-aniwUS removal"of the boat house floor and substructure consisting of 300 st of hardcover. The exterior design of the house and the location of the house on the property will only additional constraction within the 75’ - -dC lakeshcre setback area. 7 - a - 9 - The integrity of the interior design of the house pj-QYgnts the construction of a second sto..y. The aopiicant and William Mernic.k, owner o- -he land to the immediate east of the Pluhm property. Lot 2 Auditors Subdivision Mo. 344, have filed a subdivision application with the City or Orono on October 5, 1981. The subdivision will give Plu.nm an additional 3 acres of land resulting in a 4.05 acre lot. 10 - 11 - 1 5 - The acguisition of the additional acreage will increase t.ne lakasnore setcack a.-eas located within 75' and 500’ from the main lake and lagoon areas. Upon completion of the subdivision the applicant v/iii be required to enter into an open space easement with the City that will limit all future improvements on the 4.05 acre site to an upgrading of the diiveway and a future tennis court. Upon completion of the subdivision the applicant will construct a new access to his residence and close off the existing access onto Walters Port Lane. 13 -Upon completion of the subdivision the applicant will be required to submit a drainage plan for the rear or north portion of his property that would deal with the following areas of concern: a) landscaping amd grading of access area at Walters Port Road b) landscaping amd grading to effect the redirection of drainage from rear of lot to the east and thence north to wetland on Pluhm property. iiliilliiiTifiiiiiHi r ........ I'lce* 1*j.'f •• • .V ^ a If_____CITY QF OHON^ City of OROIN O » ^• j • RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO.: T : 14 - 15 - Council finds tsn-^re ivai-srs Por- will benefit by the proposed subdivision in eliminating another residential building site in an area already troubled with surtace drainage problems. The special conditions applying to this property are peculiar to such and do not apply generally to other land in the district in which this property is located. 16 -The granting of this variance is necessary tor tne preservation and enjoyment of a substantial property right of the applicant. 17 -The granting of the proposed variance will not in any way impair the public health/ safety/ comfort/ morals or general welfare. 18 -The granting of thio variance will not merely seem as a convenience to the applicant/ but is necessary to alleviate demonstrated hardships and difficulties. FURTHERI-IORE, 3E IT .RESOLVED t.hat based upon the foregoing findings/ the City Council approves the hardcover variance of an additional 543 sf of hardcover to permit construction of an addition to the Michael Pluhm residence subject to the complete rem.oval of the boat house g'vithin the 0 “ 75' laiceshore setcaclc area/ sue., removal be completed prior to a footing inspection for the new addition, stafr review the issue of the pilings at the time of that removal. .JIND/ FURTHERMORE BE IT RESOLVED that in the event the above refej^sneed subdivision has not been finalised Ly February 1, 1982, Council in granting approval of this variance ac'plication and permitting the immediate construction of the addition will require the following additional improvements to be completed by March 31/ 1982/ on the lot legally described as Lot 5, Block 3 Walters-Port-. 1 - The removal of the "loop** section of the driveway consisting of approximately 3,000 sf to 3,500 sf of hardcover./ 2 -Applicant must submit a drainage plaji for the rear portion of his property to be reviewed by staff. Additional landscaping or grading may be required to alleviate the drainage concerns along the northern boundary of lot. L J ?aaa 4 i City of OROINO CLTV L.QE . ORONGt RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO.1335 Adopted by the City Council of the City of OronO/ Minnesota at a regular meeting held o-t.» VUIlian 3. Van Nest, Mayor ATTEST: Alberta M. Strom, City Cler.k Adiuiiafiiiiitti A • I L OF Iqroimo^ City of OROIVO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO.— i J. J D I have read and understood the above resolution and agree on behalf of myself, successors, and assigns that the use of the above described property may be so regulated by the City of Orono and agree to the filing of a copy of this resolution in the chain of title to the property. A A " ^ la Michael Pluhm STATE OF MINNESOTA ) } S3. COUNTY OF HENEPIN ) The foregoing instrument was ac.knowledged before me this day o , 1981, by -tvc-L- NotaryJPublic JUDITH NOTARY PUBLIC HENNEPIN My C«mmisji*n tjipires 0*c. 1.198J ^ L. KAMERUO C JLIC-MINNESOTAC •IN COUNTV g City of OnOINO RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCl L caw NO.139 .n RESOLUTIO'T A?PROVi:iG THE CAR:-!A:; bay heights T OF ri WHEREAS, the City of Orono is a municipal corporation organizea and existing under the laws of the State of Minnesota; and of land within the City; ant WHEREAS, the City Council has considered the application for a subdivision plat by Michael G. Pluhm and William Z. Merni.v, the subdividers; and WHEREAS, the subdividers have completed ail requirements of the platting regulations oi the City, inducing; 1) Dedication on the plat of drainage and utility easements. 2) Dedication on the plat of utility easements for Municipal sewer and water lines that interest the subject property. Dedication to the City of 4 drainage easement providing for limitations on f.y wetlands and/or drainageways described therein and •-5. /U the plat as drainage easements'*. 4> The execution of an ooen space easement limiting the total ' square footage of hardcover for Lot 1, Carman Bay Heighcs, to 33,000 square feet, such hardcover shall conrorm to all applicable ordinances of the city of Orono. 5) Payment to the City of $75.00 for legal fees for reviewing and recording the final subdivision and all documents related thereto. 6) Execution of a Subdivider's Agreement providing for installation of the following improvements; a) New driveway connection for Lot 1, Carman Bay Heights at Kelly Avenue to be completed and existing connection at Walters Port Lane removed, not later than January 1,^ 1984. Upon completion of new driveway connection Lot I's address shall be changed from Walters Pott Lane to Kelly Avenue with adequate identification provided at Kelly Avenue for both residences on Lots 1 and 2. Existing driveway "ramp” and connection to Walters Port Lane to be removed, fegraded and landscaped within 30 days after completion of new driveway connection. b) Water stub to serve existing house on Lot 2 oust be extended to the lot line of Lot 2 by November 1, 1 Ofl? . I. k City of onors ’o CffV RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL NO. 1393_________ Utr i OHONCr NOW, THEREFORE, 3E IT RESOLVED, that the City Council of the City of Orono hereby approves the plat of CARMAN BAY HEIGHTS, Hennepin County, Minnesota; subject to the following conditions: 1) Owner of Lot 1 shall provide private easements for driveway, utilities, ingress and egress over Lot 1 in favor of Lot 2. 2) The aforesaid plat shall be filed by the City of Orono with Hennepin County Recorder's Office on or before January 26, 1983, together with a certified original copy of this Resolution and executed copies of the documents noted above. The approval granted by this Resolution shall expire if the plat has not been filed by the date specified above. In that event, it will be necessary to file a new application with the City of Orono for subdivision review. Dates this 26th day of July 1982. ATTEST: Alberta M. Strom,City Clerk Page 2 of 2 in • . .. • V ' iC* >• t y . ^%L. .» J .• - ^ ? . * * » 4 ' '-N ' ^ r r.* V •^ •# V H • v«^r OPEN SPACE EASEMENT . > W *>* , f .*r - 2V. 7 •• '** *• • •* i - i H 0 • ^ A*- > -■ •* • :• r •q • 19thTHIS INDENTURE, m*d« and entered into this _ day of May, 1982, by and between MICHAEL G. PLUHM and SUSANNE PLUHM, husband end wife, their heirs, successors and assigns (hereinafter collectively referred to as the Grantors) and the CITY OF OEONO, Its successors and assigns, a municipal corporation under the laws of Che State of Minnesota (hereinafter referred to as the Grantee). WITNESSETHI Grantors, for and in consideration of the sum of One Dollar ($1.00) and other valuable consideration, hereby covenant, grant, quit claim and convey to Grantee the right to rescricc and Grantors agree to limit and precluda the use, improvement and development, under the conditions and covenants herein contained, the following described Land in the County of Hennepin and State of Minnesota: Lot 1, Carman Bay Heights as follows! 1. Grantors hereby covenant and agree A. For the purpose of this easement hardcover is defined as follows: Any strxicture, blacktop or other material which Interferas with the direct absorption of rainfall into the ground. B. The total square footage of hardcover allowed on the property legally described above shall not exceed 33,000 square feet such hardcover shall conform to all applicable ordinances of the City of Orono. C. Building structures and other imovovements governed by these hardcover limitations which may be constructed upon :hi .. . . . . . . . . . the premises described herein shall be limited to: 1) Principal residence with amenities, including but not limited to garage, swimming pool, driveway and access roadways. 2) Tennis court. 3) Accessory building to tennis court not to exceed 80.) square feet of hardcover. ••.•SI A) Guest house and/or servants quarters which shall be constructed in the northerly 220 feet of the premises herein described which together with any garage and/or driveway shall not exceed 3,300 square feet of hardcover. -.i ..-A * «««l D. Any conscruccion concemplaced by chis easement shall be subject to municipal codes, ordinances and applicable permit requirements. 2. Grantors agree that no further subdivision of lot described herein will be made. 3. All buildings and improvement of the premises described herein, as may be allowed by this Open Space Easement, shall comply with building codes and buildings ordinances of the City of Orono. 4. This Open Space Easement or any provision contained herein may be released by Grantee, but only by adoption of a resolution to that effect by the City Council. In addition to any other remedy the Grantees may have, the covenants and restrictions contained h*'rein may be enforced by injunction. 5. Granto'- i do not intend that the public saould have any interest in the above land by virtue of this indenture or otherwise. 6. The Grantors certify that the Land described herein is free and clear of all encumbrances. All of the provisions hereof shall run with the land and shall extend to and bind the heirs, ..uccessors, representatives, grantees or assigns of the respective parties hereto'. . cVW This Agreement was prepared by the City of Orono, Orono, Minnesota Michael G. Pluhm i:1 busanne Pluhm STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ) On this... _ _ day of May, 1982, before me, a notary public within and for said County and State, personally appe.»red Michael C. Pluhm and Susanne Pluhm, husband and wife, known to me to be the persons described in and who executed the foregoings^instrument, and acknow ledged that they executed said instr'ument/as their ovm free act and deed. j ' NOTARY PlTB V /iil'.i'AV'fVi' %%%% *• . '' 11 4 HARDCOVER CALCUL^TIQM WORKSHEET 9/ SETBACK ZONE: (CIRCLE CNE)(o^ 73-250'25;0-300' 500-1000' E xisting Hardcover in Zone. • # • ..... ft ft • A i'l 0 1J 31 'ZSC ■ S.F. . LENGTH • • . WIDTH « • •• . • • •0 X s ft ft « • .. S.F, « . ••X = - • .«»• . ft. * ft •• • • • ft .ft - ♦' . S • F ••m • • . ^•ft. .ft« •*•«•.«%« m «« ft* ft • •• X s S.F. • . ft X , • • •• ft •« ft • S.F. # ;.. • *, w •*R. Garage ............- • • X • ft s ( w»* < •• . • • S.F. • c. D riveway • X • 4^ • • ft « # ft 0 •• ft • ■ ......................... S.F. ^ m • ft X • • S.h. •• • n. Sidewalk 'X _S.F.' •X * ♦ • S.F. • • •X mmrn~ « .a* . • ■ • •S.F. £.C ^ATI0Z^^^//fif)•• • • <ft • Deck ^ X —J'T'C? s p...................... O • r • • • p.Iandscape X __ .s • S.e.- AREAS UNDERLAIN RY - *.--------------- • •X • • •• • • • . S.F. PLASTIC - ... SHEETING • X ft . .ft* « •• .ft ^ * * • • . m . • S.F. Jrcf>r m • ••>c?o. Cc/oa.? r/^^s X sz S.F. Uf£fai> u>AUr ' 7y G. Other X o. Z5 3-7 /<7 O S.F. • • »•• Total Hardcover • IN Zone • •. / i97 S.F. • • • ^ Total Property A rea in Zone • • •Zz,^e>o S.F. . .ft • • •• •A .A. B 1 .5C • Tnn » • .fc..«.*«ftftft * * • • *■' * * ft m ft • -»t •• •• .• •• *. I • mt • % • • yt/fc*y <^<-<0 ar//e/ au) s‘re'*s .... - ^ J. ? ro '=’ O' <’/v<rr •'Tf,^(,/o — '' ^ -/rVr ..£ jyyTT^a^ •: 1 r [; '*>■ \-(L >', K- I i"’ -i''- i ^;;r -,''»? ■fif' if 'r: ■% »• *»»U 7~'f HARDCOVER CALCUU\TIOfl WORKSHEET SETBACK zcMG: (CIRCLE'ome) 0-75' (75-250^ 250-500' 500-1000' XISTING Hardcover in Zone • • A. ■ House ' x • • » $ ^ S O -s. p. . LENGTH . WIDTH• •• . • • X — S ■ P.X•••«•• • • • , • « m • • • • ♦• X .Q". c • • • • • ’ • • •• • « •• • X s « -3% Garage * • , -•i» . ^ • •• ■• ••• •* • c. Driveway • x ' ' •• s.P. • « » X • • . p.• C^^C.• •••• • «. D,. Sidewalk • x a • '^OO.....^.e.* %• • ■ X _=3 • ' S. F. X ... E. ^ATIO/ — teCK- X % • - ■•----------S . F . • • • F. Landscape ‘ x • • • S.F.- AREAS UNDERLAIN BY *.------------- • • X •5? . P.PLASTIC - .. . SHEETING • • •• m ** a« • *»^ • • • -■ .. . •- X a • . ^ r'ACfxr 7 */a ^ o. is % • • • s.p. ' 2.Z O S G. Other ’ x / / o • i « tt • - S.F. • * • Total Hardcover in KZ'\ ; # • • . 9 ~ /Sy 72 S S.F. • T.otal P roperty A rea in Zone • • «s-.P.B /r FZS -> ful X 100 — - S9. €o % v./.V .- ,,«l »,». •• • • M • . •• • ..«•••« 4P,** !>•%/■ ^ ••• £ /1 •t • • <* •• »’ . • • 9 • • • • < mtaa^--- > HEIf . HARDCOVER CALCULATION WORKSHEET SETBACK zone: Cc-rcls ome) 0-75’ 75-250- 500-1000' Existing Hardcover in Zone A.House X =5 S.F. . LENGTH • • . WIDTH • • • •X • mmrn ■ S.F. • xrr/* dr SMO X • • » I ... S.fV S^AQ . /I X • • // 7<vua//J CMfTT' ^ o X /Zo • •9 :7ZOO S.F. •fi. # •*. • •. « Garage -• ■X • «• S.F. C. • Driveway X • • • /Z, /OO s.p. X ' • • * - . •____ .S.F. • D..: • Sidewalk 'X • • ' 'S.F.' • • * •X S.F. •«. .. . .• •X S-* ♦ ' S • FI E.^ATIO/ Deck •X • • m m* m 9 m9 • ____ ■ S.F.• • • F. Landscape X • W •* • •• _ ' -'S.F.- AREAS UNDERLAIN BY ■■ --------------------- •X • • • • S.F. PLASTIC SHEETING « X 37 • . • ..**«•. . • • • * • wm m * ____7y ^ S.F. ^Ayr^4^ce / <T/rfTjtU4<t •X %•• ' _ S.F. G. Other X " ^......S.F. N. Total Hardcover IN • Zone /y. 7yr-s.F. V » Total Property Area in Zone - " —//^ s;f. • • • >«• « •' . • //V. X lO'O ^3" r A ■TT" 3 % • *. • » »• »* ••, •• f • W «• *0 .i • t -t- •• *• . . • r h Kr-t liilrttnflitJi 1*1 1 tiltiiiMiiiliw filial r tff* Steps 4o It ?£f Wed m sf BEFORE Hardcover 362 sf T*‘ /;'s* 0 r: ?«' .i 11 ;ri-:r:iib’~ Pl> n VI fc *' Sfcfi be ftfwed nci rcF-ioxed IOC s( fS* - yo ’ I ij^* yV Plak) ViC>« I' •• .)V- .. i^/ ■ • EV . ? •. j t I' •' L .--iJir [» TERRY residence ' « •< 2*t fc*b C%e*« 2•^6 w(i»fu /• iu Tn/inc 3dai> - #i ft* K.*m N/»i'j* AFTER Hardcover 266 sf ii;L-rm . T ’.-T -mx » » I I • I I I ■ iLAv» »* - I fiC I ■V — ir.vt H- - VC' t.\3.-T=r i-T* S ^1'C^ c-tcfii ti* ■•iiil. V«».k !• . 'a ^ \ II • k fc - . « J ( .1. •1 4 Ten ft.* Rl-SkCK|i4iL liwi r»vi—T—S^2:Z.£U----- V^auma * Bu>to \ —jn •»•* -1 — - -•■ .?•«. ittittlifaiiai '*'------------- if>s. • • • t I (we)-^ Adjacanz Jropexzy C-rfr.ex2- ac.'.r.cwisz=a=«nz .-orzi TC'-I ■'■■'k* ■ *1 ' i.iW'lilz-d rin - nar.e ( 3 ) ] or (t \,\\a \ W-*- ^ 1 r f r“ddrass •U >v. ^ 3^sv —swsd tJis plsns - property located at^ I j. . _•• cr orcocsed use cf > p .*▲ W Vl. „v> ^ ~ L(T* Ialso referred to as Land Use Application No. ^ -’-a* -fn e.xecuting this acknowledgement, I (we) an I (we) a-oroval or disacoroval cf the property cr use (are) V'ty Council that I (we) an (are) aware of but nerexy to con.i-n proposed neighbor's project or use the imorovement plans and ^hat t.ne ^ require's Council approval. vv V Va"^aA.\ Property Owner Oaue !T ml Property Owner I (we) . -V. ,.ll [print nane(s)l (print address] have reviewed the plans for the proposed to "as^Lanl Us': property located at —-------- Aoolication No. I (we) understand that in (are) not as)ced <:°^‘:«=-“^PP-°^ y ^ I (we) an (are) aware of but merely to con^irri ^o- ‘ orooosed neighbor's project or use the improvement pi.ins ana t.nar me . requires Council approval./ y A‘ 7T ' ^ S iva»» an Property Owner Date Property owner Date If you have My ‘^b^it y“”:o^:nt*s''to^"thi’Building S IMrn^*0«i°le :i"least 1? da^ys prior to the scheduled meeting date. i •" */H^ rWTlKWr..rt :->: .■ ;r>f "M ill & -my-^-• ■■ i '«>■; -. r,^■'•■•■'‘v';*. .• bi -^> * V-^-'- ■■■■ ■ SlSPsiSStfivinip tiih K- -«i ■ / A • n ”i < ^;^?SV-' ;:';: ..:■¥;,x. ^?V , ,,., .. . hV'rlannina r*.-iTin i33ior I’itinsn.tion s- Mix*il;3 3r feriCr','-j-' i''>■•€■_-■■ ■-.:.- **9 t1i5 . riobua - "• - 12 /• V*i ♦ » Oar response is to Item #9 (1654) on tne June 17 acend* with regard to Mr. Dean Terry's request for a variance ro iroconstruct an access scair and deck structure that ran t i y •i - ^ 1 ^ h ^Itik sshora pr-3^r'ra , .« • -i ■ .• *: tliis i.3 Ltic?— r; * - .*t: • J t.j-rtCr .-,J or.i -._ ---------------------- - lake, where cne cannot encroach upon,w„th any narc cover* fSiS ^'i-■ I u 'Vi- ft©11 are very strcngly opposed to allowing -.nycr.a to navo right to build upon these areas now or in the future. i:V Just to cite an instance, our neighbor , Jean Nelscn, build a patio area n-onb to. . . .she app 1^00 rcr a variance x,q h home , would encroach on this 75 foot area and the ms.Council" turned her down -for a good reason tha“ thcs srdiance ►iirigi^as created for the punonss of oreserving tivis area ferV;“&vv;.^®fe , . . ■ f ■ V:vymyxmcm p^^^Viithroughout the iai-.s area .Ilil'iSiii ■hi mm auditiorisl harccover on this proparty Another r'eason we -are nc c 'aati3"^iau i.n permi LCing j, is that »iihSi*i chs -i •r.: rV iM|VV|Vi .i previous owner built on the property and ianriscaped cna a- sa ip^ii^fea: ■•.nn --r> mnnh hardcover was gr-anted ;«c Lr; no ziicught vw.cii. ■ .*;? kfs;pM«ia vv:;ri«piii§r wmimSSSfei'' _______ __________________ _____ ' ke^fsctrit might have cn a neaqi-bor. Our property is di^ectiy. ^;;:|i|||||||g|| North of lir. Terry's and we have had far to much runot. s ;S--*;--‘y sr. across iour yard and has prevented us from having a gcoo yard.I 9-7 ■ •■■ ynmmmisvk’ iwipliviyy^ that while this hardcover may not have any ilMfiyon our property, w* must still say: Stick with ths laws that. ;j:|5.5j|Q|S ii»y;oy.rn Sur propirtias ifeii^KV': 'Miy A ’B» very careful when you vote on this matter and think yvy.A.y:f;-rAr;f ; m i^het might happen in the future to our homes on the lake ,,.- ■ ,.-;,.'’.VS Thank you.y^rySmrnmmm, mmsi y/'. ■ V T..,..' ,, . VAv.. : ,. A'V V. ■ A Ay>: rniil - Dean Blunt 2707 Walters Port Lane I .: ■ • ^.- .iv. •r'.iy-v'vJVvt yV-v-^ • i:-.-- ; • A. 'V'V'ti m saC'.;^, ■,:VSKy;.*«Slaj .. 'tlfcA'rf#* '■'■ .k;yyv;;yAyA-A M.My r [i To:Mayor Peterson & Orono Council Members Planning Commission Chairman Kelley Orono Planning Commission Members City Administrator Bernhardson //. From: Date: Michael P. Gaffron, Asst Planning & Zoning Administrator June 13, 1991 Subject: #1655 Elaine Pagonis - 2740 Shadywood Road - Variance *" Public Hearing Zoning District - LR-IB, Single family lakeshore residential, 1 acre, sewered 1 Application - Request for hardcover variance to construct decks List of Exhibits Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Exhibit F Exhibit G Exhibit H Exhibit I Application Plat Map Property Owners List Letter of Request Surveys Hardcover Worksheet Deck Elevation Views 12-13-90 Inspection Notice Remodeling Hardcover Approval Packet Pertinent Facts 1. * As recalculated by applicants surveyor ** Does not include half-built decki n1o75-250'Total A, Zone Area 23,384 s.f 14,601*— — B. Allowed Hardcover 0 s.f.6,150 s.f.6,150 s.f. C. Original HC prior to remodeling 455 s.f. (1.95%) 7,400 s.f.+ (30% +) 7,855 s.f.+ D. HC approved with April 1990 remodeling permit 419 s.f. (1.79%) 5,138 s.f. (21.18%) 5,557 s.f. E, HC existing on April 25, 1991 220 s.f. (0.94%) 6,024 s.f.** (24.49%) 6,244 s.f. F. Proposed hardcover 220 s.f. (0.94%) 6,448 s.f. (26.2%) 6,668 s.f. 6,668-6,150 = 518 s.f. variance request Zoning File #1655 June 13, 1991 Page 2 2.The applicant purchased this property approxiir.ately 1-1/2 years ago and in April 1990 hired a contractor to remodel the residence. At that time, hardcover exceeded the 25% limit. The contractor submitted a plan for hardcover removals that would yield conformance with the hardcover requirements and a letter from the property owner agreeing to the removals. The permit was issued, the removals occurred prior to the footing inspection and all seemed to be in order. 3.During the course of the project, the contractor and the property owner apparently did not see eye to eye on a number of issues, and the contractor ceased involvement with the project in midstream. 4.Last fall, the property owner, now acting as general contractor, had a new driveway and entrywalk constructed, with no review by the City. When the Building Inspectors discovered this work, the property owner was notified that the hardcover now exeeded the limits agreed to previously. The property owner was surprised and indicated she was unaware of any previously agreed to hardcover limitations, and when presented with the original Letter of Agreement, suggested that her contractor may have submitted that on her behalf without her knowledge in order to speed approval of the project. She agreed to present a plan for hardcover removals to meet the code requirements. 5.After a number of attempts to come up wiuh a plan that would leave a functional driveway, allow for decks on the lakeside of the house, and would not result in the need to remove the fairly elaborate front entry sidewalks, applicant determined that the only way to accomplish this would be to request a hardcover variance. Discussion This request is for 518 s.f. hardcover excess on a lot of about 48,000 s.f. Hardcover on the property has been significantly reduced from the original 7,855 s.f. overall, to 6,668 s.f. with this current proposal. It is possible that had the property owner had more involvement in the original hardcover discussions, the extensive front sidewalk may not have been built, or a variance application might have been commenced before the remodeling project got started. At any rate, applicant finds herself in a position of having to either remove driveway to a point where it may be only marginally functional, or remove a fairly complex sidewalk system in order to have decksr xf r.o variance is granted. There were decks on the originally approved remodeling plan amounting to about 350 s.f. The current deck proposal is 524 s.f. Please review the applicant's Letter of Request and the attached exhibits. t 1 ife:Zoning File #1655 June 13, 1991 Page 3 Staff Recommendation If Planning Commission determines that the circumstances of this project and the resultant decrease jn hardcover on the property in both 0-75' and 75-250' zones is justification for granting of a hardcover variance, then recommendation for variance approval would be appropriate. Isv ■Vi it. t". * » 'M •; 1 fe'i / . ^ 'Q 'p CITY OP ORONO - VARIANCE APPLICATION Initial Application Fee $175.00 ($50.00 per each additional variance) Renewal Variance Fee $100.00 (no change from original application) After-the-Fact Fees (Double application fee) #1 . • U. TV • . — • • . «• • • «» « « ' w k. i J -. uv ; .ui. PROPERTY LOCATION Site Address ^2^ TVi . z. jO .,^ii Pc rh,^.. rA : ru %M t• V V i Property Identification Number (P.I.D.) (ypCS". Attach legal description to application if not included on required survey. vw.' -f • APPLICANT Phone (home) Name //1 O Phone (work) C ~^CGO Address; J2. ^ VO Sl\cic2uujOAr^ I^^Jl City:__^^^070 Zip; PSS332 OWNER (if different than applicant)Phone (home) Name Phone (work) Address;City;Zip; Date Property Acquired (month/year) I (do) (do not) also own the adjacent parcels of land. PRESENT USE OF PROPERTY Present Zoning District L Present Use of Property CLResidential Other (specify) DESCRIPTION OP REQUEST Estimated Construction Cost $ Describe request in detail; _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ VARIANCES REQUIRED Lot Area Lot Width Setback Variances (Front X Hardcover Side Rear) Other -*5 BARDSHXP Describe undue hardship or practical difficulty resulting from strict enforcement of zoning regulations: - - - - - - - - - - - - DESCRIPTION OF UNUSUAL PROPERTY CONDITIONS Describe unusual property conditions preventing compliance with Zoning Code Requirements: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ 2. 3. 4. REQUIRED SUBMITTALS 1. Completed Application Form Certified Property Owners List of owners within 150' (you must obtain this list from Hennepin County Department of Finance A-603 Govt Center 348-3271). Plat Map (obtained with property owners list). Certificate of survey (signed by a licensed surveyor) to include hardcover calculations as required (provide one (1) copy 8ij"xll" for reproduction). Topographic survey (existing and proposed elevations) if any changes in existing grade are proposed (provide one copy 8J5"xll"). Sketches or plans of floor & elevation vi» ^s (provide 1 copy 8%"xll"). As an addendum to t^'is application, please attach a separate list of any other persons you wish notified of this application. Additional items as may be requested by City staff. 5. 6. 7. 8. The Applicant and Property Owner must sign this application. Please remember that your variance application is not complete if the __above Information has not been included. APPLICANT'S SIGNATURE The applicant hereby agrees to provide all information required or requested by the Zoning Administrator, agrees to pay additional fees (staff time not covered by original fee payment) and/or consultant expenses incurred in review of this applicatioji,-^nd certifies that the information supplied is true and corr^ip^ to the^^^est ^f his/her knowledge. Applicant's Signature Date d/J V/fl / / ONNERS SIGNATURE The owner hereby ackowledges and agrees to this application and further authorizes reasonable entry onto the property by City staff, consultants, agents, Commission members, and Couiroil members for purposes of investiga—agents, Commission members, and couiroil m< tion and verification^ this request^ Owner's J■ J Date y/ / J. /• Applicant must have all submittals into the City offices 25 days before the Planning Commission Meeting. Planning Commission Meetings are held on the third Monday of each month. Applicants must be present at all scheduled review meetings of the Planning Commission and Coiincil. If an applicant is unable to attend a scheduled meeting, pi «ase make arrangements to have an authorized agent attend in your place and to advise the Building & Zoning Office of this change prior to the meeting. I 4M •! A 'xS ■f1 V wi \ ^ - IJJP :;J^- »r (T)X ^ - w Sfra»IS ul » Hl i ^•t 7 R AVP. tX/^5 MINNETONKA ,4ii (>*'•' “ci of tht it •.tl5 ? ^! ... •-“' V. .' , .i i ^ “ •.«». ■ HUK DATE 12/12/90 f.. • \•4 • < T Vbatch bos . i ! * ♦ • Kr t' 1^ HEH4EPIN COUNTY PROPERTY INFORMATION SYSTEM PROPERTY OHNERS LIST VPMP ADDR ' S8 21-117-23 24 0005 02735 . 8HADYN000 RO I 1 , i’roltCA NAHE ; PAUL C CARLSON ETAL t . , TAXPAYER PAUL C CARLSON . ’ ; ' » ; MttMiy«nnB • j/SS SHADYHOOO RO ‘ ,i J EXCELSIOR m 55S3I' ..NAHE/AOOA ; i ■ ‘ •* • 4 *t. • 1 ‘.;i■' .H i -u ■ i ■ • ’prop aodr ! I OMCR NAME ,' li; tax { •, MAI i { -i. . TAXPAYER NANE/AOOR t •J J*j|. j» , •. • , • ' ; ? ‘ I; - { PROP AOOR ' ' OlOCR NAHE r-[ * TAXPAYER ? i .NAHE/AODR i U’ I » ; ' . ^ PROP ADOR ,• OHNER NAHE ; > TAXPAYER ’ NAHE/AOOR. j vwnc I.4 PROP AODR . i QNNER NAHE . TAXPAYER . \ . NAHE/AODR •• ft \ i • I 'ii-r i'/ .-i; f I PROP AOOR OMNER NAHE j|-TAXPAYER i .NAHE/AOOR •« <t ,♦ I ^ ■• » r ■ IJ - :‘'K ^ *. f ■f 1 ♦.r r. SO 21-117-2S 2A 0021 ooosa AOORESS UNASSI6NE0 J A H FLEISCHHACKER JOSEPH F FLEISCHHACKER 2775 SHAOYNOOO RO EXCELSIOR HN >,55351 I ♦ SO 21-1I7-2S 24 OOSl 02700 SHAOYNOOO RO H H NICHOLLS ETAL NILLIAH H NICHOLLS ;; 2700 SHAOYNOOO ROAO !Excelsior mn ssssi I I < so 21-117-2S 24 0041 02700 SHAOYNOOO RO JANES H NOLAN ALICE L BROCK 2700 SHAOYNOOO RO ■ i I EXCELSIOR m 55S31 SO . 21-117-n 24 0061 OOOSO AOL.V iSS UNASSIGNEO JOHN P THIMHESH JOHN P THIHHESH S430 FLORIDA AVE N , CRYSTAL m 55427 > S9 21-117-2S 24 0064 027S0 ’ SHAOYNOOO RD JOHN L FIEBELKORN ET AL JOHN L FIEBELKORN ANO NANCY L FIELBELKORN 27S0 SHAOYNOOO RO EXCELSIOR HN 553S1 i 'I i ';:;5 t I.■’ 1 ’t'--1 t;'i* '■!' V, i ♦ V*; . 1 * * ^ 38 21-117-23 24 0016 00038 ADDRESS UNASSI^D DAVID C COOK DAVID C COOK 680 H HILLSIDE DR NAYZATA m 55391 38 21-117-23 24 0028 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNEO JAMES 0 GINTHER ET AL JAMES 0 GINTHER 3131 DARTMOUTH AVE EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 24 0032 02720 SHAOYHOOD RO J & B KVAM J0Hr4 C A BEVERLEE A KVAM 2720 SHAOYNOOO RD EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 24 0045 00038 ADDRESS Ur4ASSIGNED D0r4AlD A LAYMAN ETAL LYMAN LUMBER CO 337 ►UTER ST EXCELSIOR MN 55331 38 21-117-23 24 0062 0003P ADDRESS UrUSSIGNED PAUL R NUTT FRED C EODOHES 2748 LAMPHERF DR NEH MOPE MN 55427 38 21-117-23 24 0065 02740 SHADYHOOO RO ELAINE T PAGONIS ELAINE T PAGONIS 2740 SHAOYHOOD RO ORONO MN 55331 REPORT NO. PI435401 PAGE 6 38 21-117-23 24 0020 00038 ADDRESS UNASSIGNED THOMAS J CASEY ETAL t , i • THOMAS J CASEY 2785 SHADYIKX)D RD EXCELSIOR MN 553il i * • 38 21-117-23 24 003C 00038 AOORESS UNASSIGNEO THOMAS P LONE ET AL CG-TRUSTEES TRUST REAL ESTATE NH NATL BK 6TH A MARQUETTE MPLS MN 55480 36 21-117-23 24 0040 02760 SHAOYHOOD RO HILLIAM A A»40ERS0N HILLIAM A ANDERSON 2760 SHADYHOOO RD EXCELSIOR MN 55331 10 I's f' ) 38 21-117-23 24 0059 02771 SHADYHOOO RD R G A r* J OGLE RICHARD G A MARLYS J 2922 OAKLAND AVE SO MPLS ffi 55407 C >. //' InZQV ti.y OGLE 38 21-117-23 24 0063 00038 AOORESS UNASSIGNEO JOHN P THIMMESH JERRY C CLIFFORD 10516 CAVELL AVE S BLOOMirK^TON MN 55438 % TOTAL BATCH 003 00017 . •• . ~ -- Elaine T. ^agonis P7do Shaclvwood Poad 55331Orono, Mu December 27, 1990 City of Orono Post Office Box B6 Crystal Bay, MM 55323 // ? ;• JL W I- 0 Dear City of Orono, In reoards to the property of Shadywood Road, Orono, a few unique situtations exist that would constitute a hardship and/or hardships. Access of the driveway must remain as is because it is city right of way. The addition of a third garace stall has increased the driveway dimensions. The length of the driveway is perpendicular to the garage stalls, therefore, it is essential that the driveway remains as it is in order to have the car wheels remaining on pavement while making the ninety degree turn to get into the garage stalls. In order to decrease the varying elevation proolem that exists near the entry way, the entry way is designed with alternating forty-five degree directions. The entry way was designed this way for safety reasons. My comprehensive plan requests -6.5^ square feet of hardcover or to exit on the property. * 0 •'7S l'5-2ro' * Approximately 1,700 square feet of the original TRACK 0 property is now city right of way to service Hwy. 19. i r i i 1 r y •% •> / / / 4 / ••• m f r,tt4 3 -v-^-------__ / « .8*37 w 1040 Plot ------- ^/ 4 ,20 > P»l N / A / /• / / /• /•*1^ a’: .1‘‘ / i"., -V.IjIjNS jl. '>• ‘Px;.- /-V X \ X X J\ V' fiRi^ \ Vfc,•«i 'v'^^ t \ x'X' * . *» >y^.'’ V \ \ \ \ . '7t '\ jy"^/ .‘f ‘■>f .5 I •v l^X ■•v> \X X \ ?>\ \ X I'l*.' ‘/‘x ^X V"\ 5p£-^;v^ ^—r-H«»" i-\ ‘l>>S,\ X 4 €t porctt oufMw 73 f »eioock % X r ^X *24.401 IQUD't fMl \ \ X* •'U..A ^ ^x\.k XiilOX •«0l« «ore »w«tKt <• 25% \ \ .'2<'i^ • ,25»*i.i5D lo^t twf \ A •‘..M V' N \ \ -X ■X*; •. . * .i %/ s. rv •r. ^\ X x..«=* \ • ’V:- ' - O *=.\ X X V t . • tK4f »• IM| 1,4 •*»lrrt ImiI • ^ .X« - •* f (.*«^ «• • 1 %5^ X .•»• .^* X X X X ■'S X ifx<' X N n. X ./*X >.X X V N/ >» •■ \ . • n.-. \,• * • • ^•l * ••-* • 'm rinAijCj/cn -p.--«u.i I ♦ Cl .iC . ..%w. 2HT3Ac:< zone: Cc :?.cl * :n £) 0-/ E<i3TiNti Hardcdve ?. in Zcne House V<v LENGTH X X Bi Garage c. Driveway X D. Sidewalk E. Patio / Deck X J cr' B F.Landscape AREAS UNDERLAIN ru^suc - SHEETING Trt^n©^^ ; 'Pn/tr HooSS 6-7^ ^ G. Other ^ ^ I ••• « . I •• ^ ^ s« ^ vj = ;^y^5 a • r t WIDTH S •.“ t I •; / S.F.'v 1 ■ • : / • 'AS..; 'O' S • r • S • r. • f m'^ S.F.----------- 9 S • FI i i -I S.F. = 49^?S.F, S.F. jH‘ =. -4/e- S.F. 2^6? - S.F. S« F« S.F. S.F.0"' Total Hardcover in Zone ___ S.F. tpSn^ S.F. Total Property Area in Zone 2^/, GO 1 S.F A B & « •% •Km,I I ri X 100 « •. 9o ^ T- (awsriNt. =6 2VV ii : 25.V % • »• V.* ‘.J* f9J 7tf • t x(^ ;zr <-^'^’> ■'-• * __•'■* ••*- •"" . .— •8 r • 1 • 4 ■ : *•• ‘-i* 'Jt • '' i ■ j L. •- . _ . .w*i|. 7. ..,7..^ . ... ., - -kt* . •*- *.►'• <- i* ... Mfv fi^’Hdrcrir> 1^ T* TT.':S‘^i!^ '■'. Mri;' • • -.• •*<V«V ■ i I*•* • UL .V-•*r^ •* *'* * I CITY OF ORONO INSPECTION NOTICE PERMIT NO_______ CALLED IN SCHEDULED COMPLETED DATE 12L iJJL z2.0 /.2~=-L2-Z1L0: TI^•E y :^o •• V- . i ADDRESS__________ OWNER CONTR. « .•• - •! TELEPHONE NO. .....! g DESCRlFnON J^A^^I>CO'J(:^ U.4 tLS ft *' • 01 FCX)TINQ 02 FRAMING 03 INSULATION 04 WALL BO. 05 FINAL 07 DEMO-SITE 07 DEMO-RNAL 09 PLUMBING R1 10 PLUMBING FINAL 11 MECHANICAL Rl 16 WEU TEST PUMP 11 MECHANICAL FINAL 18 EXCAV/GRADING/FILLING 24/25 WOOD BURNER/FIREPLACE 19 LAKESHOREA/VETLANDS 12 WATER HOOK-UP 13 METER SETn^URN ON 14 SEWER HOOK-UP 27 SEPTIC MAINT 15 SEPTIC INSTALL 23 SEPTIC FINAL 34.TREE REMOVAL Cj^jTE INSPECTION 06 PROGRESS 21 COMPLAINT 22 FOLLOW-UP •? ~4-:V 2 Li Q: i q: 5o UJcc Ul § imORK SATISFACTORT PROCEED t CORRECT WORK & PROCEED D CORRECT WORK. CAU FOR RBNSPECTION BEFORE COVERING C CORRECT UNSAFE CONDITION WITHIN_____HOURS. INSPECTOR Wia RETURN 2 PROJECT COMPLETE C ISSUE CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY ________TEMPORARY ________PERMANENT 2 PHOTOTAKEN O STOP ORDER POSTED. CAU INSPECTOR Q INSPECTION REOUIREO CALL TO ARRANGE ACCESS. 2 CITATION ISSUED • Call for the next Inspection 24 hours in advance. 473*7357 • - .- » Owner/Conti^ori ttjsHe: inspector White Co^flAP«Ci|M*t I CiifUry Copy^ta Notice fluftiiitiai i.r; '*• *;?t. V-3S. ' Tv ?-t— AS. Ahr/ Cor/yer ^O. IM57 ‘’47'W 200 0 Plot - of 7rocf D, JCL^ ROAD 19 r 1 • • . > IS f. • . J v.-r: •. » . * • * • • i/' • y ;..** • .»■ ! I • • - • ' * 1 I » • . . . ? * • V* < • •V' . i:• •• • ••• • • •• L ///4/€DC0l/^ 2V70 ^ftA^yo^^ l 2.yr^*7 3 4.4, “2V0 i4'. <--v^Ck o;:" S<sArvoMj‘tf" /,tS3S /^OLr> S jl. A-rtSf^ 1’^' P^if^ /j£Tt^ ! ;V . • •• •• ; •»•• 33 V .r . I • • J. •:• -i •• . . • •».• .-• * ^ ••.. :i .- •• . • >*. 2.o^-‘e^ c4t-CW4-4r&c> /S/ 2iMAJt£Y<^<^Ar. /Ct^visir^ X 2 0-^ SSr. J=2^7,2^/// s..-?. ^7^' //AO^coi/tr^ /7>rz0 .e(ur;to^!rs' /^^ttoaJ ■*■ 70‘>^9yL. /’-3«c77o.u <D/=- ^ S>T2:r' '■^y^c~ 2-VO T i .0, p^f'OieD IS'Z^' (^p/CO/’os.ek (2) CI> (£> CD (S>_ .. (3^ CC>^iC. l-JArUH 0> ........... -^T^/u^ fi-te^ uiA^C i* •. p/^IO B>Loct^ u->/^e<MAAJC» -7*/, /5-X5.0,/ /0.9 <»<'/3.^r »-20 "i j r* rr ;j3 > 2, >r C»Sk J 2.yx/?.r •720 - -7^ A r>*2^ i y /oo - 7 X >?o / S-O / '2'A/ * • • • • •♦ .* •■ •. •*. S*. .V' J ; *»• I t • - . \ J • .*•*•* i • • • % • » • • \ • • •• ••.•' • • • •• • ! 1 ' •*.*• • • iJ- - • 7°as- ......nf,|: y-’ r 7*'.*: •?, I • '. W 9 —— . >«., c,Kcrr V .....iiriiiirtrlil r i iJihintniMiitii • • •»« I • • V. • »• * •; • .* i : •* •.».. r .i •! » 1' r I • « t •• iv! i- i«. •^*. • 1 i i *f ** *►. ^^ ;••••• V .V. ' • ^ f. . •. : tv ; > t . t ■ I •• • • ••k* ; . W '• :«!r.».* . • ' ' •;» j / .*« i/ • » • * » ‘ .••• ■ .* ' •/ .»* •• • : •:1 ■•. '•« • * ’•.,! • i-• •?«. »:• *.'»«« • •S-:• :f• • • w • ' . •: ♦ • • * /•• •■■irr,.1 •. :J y: •• ’■ * •. Stf |d^ywj>i/eO ^ V*. i^Loc^ PlllUfwW ^2. ...... .» ' ••• J *. ^*•V t» I •%: ;?..i •>.■•••.*• ^ • s , •? : -V. : 'rr.s '■ • * " — f. ..v‘ 7':- »:• y i ■’M t •f • V'.-. » V »•; r V. ;./ V A* V r. * ^ i. V "^Cs» s rr.£ -rjJTAt- r7 9 “i* ^ ■ V-is'^rvr>f^<^ Aier*7 “ ir - 3C« i-f. W I"733 ' / 7 “? 74‘7/^33, 3 sv t. I u. *:: I -7r'2.ST?' '-.t. = -y^77 »— |^e->'>-ov//V<,l III -• /J£T jr ^/SS f •' •V*, ^ ‘ - i r ' ; • . . . ^ , ^ '> 5” j< 2. V *2.^ I» / ■* ^ 5 5 1^..yjTTVt- ■2-7,2. / ■ « ,7DTM- f^fJLtKCMO^. f^i2o?oseX:> — 5’/3>S*+‘V/? - . ^:ST’Z < *v. .•%•i-:an• * •* * • ^ • A* '• '! J ■[•.•;• is‘-'t•vw: ^. ••• .iVir.;r !>4 4-1 ; ’*•:• ^• <.• \• * ft • y ■: ■ *’5* • .'• •: •'#-T'• J/ &08 pifi. _________g ...... ‘3- ■•I-'•■ ».»■ ^spil5y .j7 . ,-. ^ ■ ■ >■ :A I. « 1 tfrfmmrwfti «• *r. 1<1 > <s -% V LiftjiferfcM. ;/ iz. Kv.■■ C •+U ) A ('■. / "^ ,/Z \ .f/''i'V, '?,'!?''-J ____ V .‘?W '^.^ A Mr A.W A 4T> ^ 'V i-'A •C *v \ •51 A \ -^Q ■^<\ ^5>-n: > <V. V. / V S. / I irniigl r Chairman Kelley and Planning Commission Members Mayor Peterson and City Council City Administrator Bernhardson 4?. Frcm:Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator Date: Subject: June 12, 1991 #1657 Nick Simonds, 2007 Sugarwood Drive - Request to Vary From Development Standards for Sugar V7cods PRD List of Exhibits - A - Applicant's Addendum B - Plan for Proposed Driveway Alteration C - riardcover Fact Sheet Approved with Building Permit Application D - Hardcover Fact Sheet Amended by Current Proposal E “ Site Plan Approved with Building Permit F - Letter From Property Owner to the IiTunediate West - Rebers Cons^. ruction The request involves the following: 1. Request to vary from standard that would require a straight alignment of the drive within the front 50' setback area. 2. Request to encroach in the required 30' side yard setback area with realigned driveway; required = 30', proposed *19. Staff Cooiments - Planning Commissicn Members are advised that the following special requests of residents of Sugar Woods are not charged a fee by the City. Because of this applicants are asked to provide all the necessary information and present their special requests to the Planning Commission directly. Please review Mr. Simonds' addendum (Exhibit A), that notes the reasons or hardship that create need to vary from the Sugar Woods development standards. 7 i Tr t! 4 Nick and Nanne Simond 2007 Sugar Vv’oods Dr. Long Lake, MN 5535^ [line 6, 1991 s J\3M -1 To; Orono Plan Commission Re: Request for Variance of Driveway Placement - 2007 Sugar Woods Dr. We are asking that the Orono City Plan Commission approve a variance in the placement of the drive^A^y from the plan originally submitted and approved last fall prior to construction of our home located at 2007 Sugar Woods Dr. The attached survey shows both the original drive’//ay location (shaded) and the proposed new location (dashed). This new location was established at the time of excavation and was chosen by the excavator so as to preserve several mature trees which are located directly in the path of the original driveway location. These trees are identified on the survey. There are several reasons we are requesting this variance; The trees shown would be preserved. These trees provide natural screening for the house and have been incorporated in our landscape plan. The slight curvature of the proposed driveway is a more attractive setting. The back turnaround area west of the garage is slightly larger providing the ability to get into and out of the garage more easily. The original driveway location would require several turning maneuvers when entering and leaving the garage. The property immediately to the west, nearest to the proposed driveway location, is owned by Mr. Sidney Rebers. Mr. Rebers has reviewed the landscape plan showmg the proposed driveway location and h'. approved this plan. A copy of a letter from Mr. Rebers so stating his ap.noval is attached. r XL -1 / ^ 77 • -t ^ I . 7 / -I ■V- ^ / J We are submitting this request through the office of Ms. Jean Mabusth and will attend the Plan Commission meeting on June 17,1991. If you need to contact us prior to that date our phone numbers are: Home - 449-0163 Office - 670-5955 Fax - 670-3997 We would appreciate very much being granted this variance. Thank you very much for your consideration. Respectfully, hu • « Nick and Nanne Simonds pectfullv, /) •/ ^ m suRvr FOR: ^rewe/^ ^ koppclma/^ ' m \__ / 363B ^OOOS Cone. Qurb Offive i i HABDCOVER CALCy5:*JVT10N WORKSHEET A Proposed HardcovoP " a. House X 9 . f • length wiatn /cr^ B • *• • o»f. 0 • ^ • 8.ft fa. Garage n 1 ‘01 f t c. Driveway .3-'^7_o m ^m m Z (include area wirhin front setback area) o.f. d. Sidewalk X X 4‘n a. f * B . f t C)e.d^ Patio/ Deck/PooT7 Pond _ t. Landaoape areas underlain X X X X X • a. • s.r. fl • ^ a S ‘l \a ^D • 4. • with pervious or TmperviouB sheeting/_ _ _ _ _ _ x _ _ _ _ fabric X g. Other a.f. B . f . 9 . f . St£. a.f# B. f t TOTAL HARDCOVER er^ U (A) Building Satback Area (B) Total Lot Area - (C) Building Pad m f: - a.ft*Area ______ s.r. -------------- V.a.f. (C) Building Pad Area I \ > Q?. O'f* b.£« Allowed Hardcover 1 ,'L - - I • • m HARDCOVER CAI.CUrJ^'rlON WORKSHEET (yJ2^.,acX -for Proposed Hardcoveg " a. (A) House X « — r- *1»••length width X -fl • 2! V X S.f. X a.f. X m 9 • f • Garaae X s«f * Driveway X a .s. f . (include area within front setback area) X m s. £ • Sidewalk X •St:::'i.f. X •s. f . X o s.f. Patio/X m s.f. Deck/Pool/ Pond X 8 a a Landscape X •\s.f. areas underlain X ■s.£. with pervious aheetincr/ or Impervious X s.f* fabric X mi Safi other X s*£ X ^ Ji-f- S. f. 7 rJ I . {/k ®s3 TOTAL HARDCOVER o,4''t7c Building Setback Area (B) Total Lot Area - (C) Building Pad Area __ _ _ " - -- - - - -a, f. (C) Building Pad Area i\ noo b«£> X 80' “ s.f« Allowed Hardcover • • • • • — • i^V* 4- , fe^ocies: Z-vj-^C<50^ X- I rtk. iHfcir6w**t'Mainithi#rfiinafcn*^^**‘-^« r « i Sidney Bernhard Rebers, Master Builder «C8£RS CONSTRUCTION COMPANY • 3 5 2 5 WEBSTER AVE. • ST. LOUIS PARK. Ml.VNESQTA ;5«15 •" TELEPHONE 320.6986 May 28, 1991 r To: 61291.1 Chairman Kelley and Planning Commission Members Mayor Peterson and City Council City Administrator Bernhardson 15. From Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator Date: Subject June 12, 1991 Proposed Ordinance Amendment - Antennas - Request for Additional Direction From Planning Commission Update on Review - Since the May meeting of the Planning Commission, staff received a telephone call from C. John Uban, consultant for U.S. West concerning the status of the City's moratorium and proposed ordinance amendment dealing with antennas. Mr. Uban was advised that the City held a public hearing/work session for the benefit of staff and the Planning Commission to consider the existing ordinances as they relate to free-standing and attached antennas for all zoning districts and to determine if it was appropriate to amend the code based on preliminary directives of the City Council and the opinions of the Planning Commission Members. Mr. Uban voiced concern that neither he nor his client received notice of the public hearing. Staff apologized and advised that once again this was merely a work session and that Mr. Uban would be given the opportunity to attend the meeting at which time the proposed ordinance would be presented for Planning Commission's review and comment. Mr. Uban has also suggested that if staff concurred, he would have a member of their staff who specializes in such matters review the ordinances enclosed within your packets and make any recommendations as to other municipal ordinances we may wish to consider now that we have defined the scope of an ordinance amendment whereby only an attached antenna would be considered. The staff will schedule a public hearing at a future Planning Commission meeting when the draft amendment is prepared. Request: for Additional Direction - At the May work session, the Planning Commission directed staff to develop an ordinance amendment that would allow attached antennas on structures at a specified height within the B-6/PUD Highway 12 zoning districts. Once again, attached antennas are only allowed as subordinant or accessory to principal uses within all zoning districts. J Proposed Ordinance Amendment - Antennas June 12, 1991 Page 2 of 2 This kind of an ordinance amendment would prohibit the use of the watertower in Navarre located within a residential zone. The Planning Commission is also asked to consider if an industrial or commercial permitted use was to install a tower on their property, as long as that tower met the minimum required height deemed necessary by the amendment, would Members have a problem with another user installing an antenna on an existing tower? Under the current Planning Commission directive, these users would not be allowed. It may be more appropriate for the City to draft an ordinance similar to the proposed ordinance amendment for Minnetonka included in your May packets that deals with the attaching of antennas in zoning districts where there already exists a legal structure adaptabx.j for the attaching of antennas. The ordinance would have to exclude such use for residentially used or residentially developed properties whereby a ham radio operator installs a tower for private residential use. The ordinance shall specifically exclude all commercial use of residential/hobby use tower structures. Will the Planning Commission amend it's original directives to staff and expand the scope of the ordinance amendment to include attaching of antennas to approved structures at a minimum 60' height as long as those structures are located within industrial, commercial or non-residential used but residential ly zoned properties. This will allow the use of the Navarre watertower and if the City was to install a watertower along Highway 12 outside of the B-6 PUD zoning district. 1 iMiii To: 61291.2 Chairman Kelley and Planning Commission Members Mayor Peterson and City Council City Administrator Bernhardson Frcaas Jeanne A. Mabusth, Building & Zoning Administrator Date:June 12, 1991 Subject: The Use of Geotechnic Fabric as it Relates to Hardcover Council had asked to reconsider the use of weed control fabric as it relates to hardcover at their May 28th meeting. The Council voted unanimously to approve the use of geotechnic non- woven fabric as an acceptable method of controling weeds as opposed to the use of chemicals and that such fabric as long as it is of the un-woven type would not be considered hardcover. Planning Commission may now offer this as an option to applicants in dealing with properties with excessive hardcover where underlying plastic has been used. m ¥ * m pp ps^:;?Si. \i '1 mi ciff St smjmi___ ruamn oubwmiob mwrzm MMDUT, JttM 17, im 7ia«137J ■ma Bw Kwri - cnaco. cjaani coBKii unmamnn - dimiii OMtua MianuKi {ST* !.«. -ill — »»*" “ “ «*>—1- »»*“« ’'T“;?io« ci.1T a». - »1.Varlanc - »< »»*11» I~»iM J. .1.44 urrr lar. I«rt. Ori« .«i«- - »» *-«*> »>-" * i.p^.1. - ruTlie *• SiiiU--Ju/irJiir- * I. .1.47 0.r.ld lM.lt - 1481 iMtl.*. »t- - TarlucM - r-llle iMTlnf • *“*• s::i;i‘7«ii:s*-'5i:rc ‘ -.TIMM - »»*UC IMTIM ,r. fl.lKl— • !»• *8^ **** * TMll. IMTIM .1.14 DM. T«rrr ' *v«xL«Ac«« - r»*lie .1.11 ll.lM T4-M1.. 1748 M^T-m8 IMd - TUlaiM - PMil. iMTUa *« -dltl..1 41IM«1M ____JMU m laj m. imTlT flaalM cmMmIm m»»»»-1 •* “ 7 u rl.».M CM.1..1M t. ..IM. . TMT....t..l« t. r \ ifi ’ . « »•«** . . DETAIL SHEET ,,Ki r tjo*-,c fcA,r s -li - coK# 4-fV-4.. MWtr MO*JL,r«CWT A^t» C^1|4U »*:J 1. ■! ! . *.!■' ' • % Saslft V ! fi' ii :--F\f - -<'-v -, * •* ------«>——A . ^ ^ J .J^ ill !•... . f ' "y ’• ; •* £:-tgA^-n<3n ^ t4.*« I'-O*r .■;.:!• ■f I . -i' amm -. • AT t-Mf MM. K jA mT c-r-fc' I Ik i'lihiiiiiiiaiiiifc fu9 [# • -.* • .jH^’ “r •« «ikMr4 4.IMI '*"•> ■»• • ........................... ».li« ».«. ,,„, Ill < 1^ . *<•>•<■»• i-lk*, ^ . I I »V /.' o\‘ V® 0. ■'zap? ■ ;. \\ Wellaiuf, locali,,,, ...-""2-.;: ■opyAt V.; \ 'OyRtlNQTON \ , I," pvt i»« » . » \ V .>' tte'C S 'V-o /^r»c zc. i « .15^ jjiicn J* j»«»*l5i« "S-M Ovn *:.0»'*' *,T lilwCCr I 0----------- -.0 -------------• - • ~G u*% VI^ sTa.-.«*t. ^4. "rv4\s %^v^c i>=uoo>^ Ti? ^cn 600.0 L.' a n't O ov4 r»a. P^>-KN TRINUTY LUTER^M CW^CVA / BCH SCQUX GAvRAvGE I : ■ ••' •.•-•= -V- ^/,. »:• :^-- / ■#} • *• . ,S ; . V '■. J /- r t 1m f Ufa 1■k f^Hl:^ . r % A ft. • -r.7S’(,ti' ' T,8*7*21 *e T3 fBt Wo'(^ ‘ / I / N f / ^ /« 1 r, i !. -V rAMMimJI * AMOCXJkTIS. no. «)4i.)on L«nO fv Mm mirU. m SSS44 CnttKorte M Surv«y far 1980 Hfttltao* Drlv« Orono M89113 #1410 liM Loti Daacrlptlon i Tract* A and B, Roqlatarffd Land Survey Mo. 96, rilaa of Reqiatrar of Tit las. County of Hennepin, and that pirt of Lot Six (6) lylnq Southwesterly of a line drawn across said lot parallel to and 106 (eat Northeasterly from the Southwesterly line of said lot. Auditor'a Subdivision IAiaa>*r 156, Hennepin County. Hlnnepota, accordlnq to the aiap or plot thereof on file and of record In the Office of the Reqiatrar of Titles of Hennepin County. Minnesota. Toqether with an saseMot for road purposes over the Meatorly 20 feet of Lot 5, Auditor's Subdivision Murt>ei P Hennepin County, Minnesota. of the boundaries of above described property Hennepin County, Minnesota, and of the location of all bulldlnqs thereon, and all visible encroachawnts. If any. from or M Raid land. Surveyed by aie this 37th of March 19?^. ^ J A by C,. _dey of Ma rch CAROARELLS S associates, INC. Rhonei (612) 941-3011 statri;^ " ■ .' \ ± . ■' ■ ft>i' -:' ® -:Wm.it m ... .m LEGAL DESCHTPTIOH LOT 1, BLOCK 14, MINNETONKA BLUrra This survey shows the l(3ca^inn of .in existinq house- in to the hounclsries of the above described property. It i purport to show any other improvemwitB or encroachments I hereby certify that this survey was prepared by no or direct supervision and that I ais a duly reqistered Civt Bnqineer ami Uind Surveyor under thi- laws of the State corriH fc r.RoNtu'.Hc., Mark S. Oronberq MN. I,lc. No. 1275*. Enqineern, Ijind Surveyors, Planners Lonq Lake, Minnesota r>ate ! S-IS-**! Scale: 1*«J0' • : Iron Marker Pound o I Iron Marker Set Bearinqs shown are based ufion an assuned datun. -r T t»r« I r ~ ##l«t t. 1. C*rwJ’'i,y HMftMiR CSK*>^* NilWttMAtR #16S4 lltiS lot t» RiiKli t. C#nk«fl H«r MUflitli. >R4| R*t I 'F,.f - .yn l*»- •' Rp! pnrp^ri »o JIfly 9\k0* rr ffnr rn^f'.m^n* % . Mr# 9\k0 • r##»|fy l!i4. tRij ««r»#r M« pr»pt^pi hf IM M«1f# mf 4't9tt \ r #« • 'tuu #• »P9 !«''# #Mf ts#t 1»R<1 '»*»fv#*#T iHi-4^r St«t» ft' ^iiui««#1i«. MpPt ■•ai a' tR# :orrj\ A l^c. LOR9 \ tt* , ’ ; I'M •«'*•>' OliOtIB COPY ^ V<9 LAKESHOPE & WETLA^-!?S RI c '-! L A T I 0 N 3 Uj-L. ,.J OqDiNA,\CS ?=5Ch;e t3 tx^ jAr:oN. fi:.l:ng. TRc£ P.EVrVAi ;q’ - - ._•. .~,L'C i .C"» Zi~ Ai j ^ V\f7H.JV 73 FT CF .A^)y i-w ■.: c: ' ^“J 26 FT CF M,';v '.Vc''- i'- - ! PEA'.iiTs Apc srq" Cu'CKS. SEAv-VA^l3 CITY CFO?,CNO y ii''Z PlAi C'lCii-C '•Jy-'i. - ,-c-jv^r ^/, M4*»co*0tn (CfflMovAci 4 s /^DICATTU Aiw rft^swT 2. SMMt- Ptf /3C/OA TO /WM/kl. ftwC ftoUitJMC CF fcan*^ «BieTW« /4*>0»Tt0A». *'u«r»-*r' / /«r *7