The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About05-16-1983 Planning Packetss PLANNING COMMISSION MEETING COUNCIL CHAMBERS 7:30 P.M. MONDAY, MAY 16, 1983 Council Representative - John Hammerel CALL TO ORDER public HEARINGS 1. 7.3» J; ”‘™' ="»• * #740 - Variance 2. 7:45 P.M. #744 Richard G. Ogle, 2765 Shadywood Road - Subdivision 3. 8:00 P.M. #745 Robert White, 320 Woodhill Road - Subdivision Actions Items 4. #746 Mike Sjeklooha, 1424 Baldur Park Road - Variance 5. #747 R. William Toward, 3460 Birch Lane - Variance 6. #748 Sandra K. George, 3399 Crystal Bay Road - Variance select Planning Commission Member to attend Council meeting of June 13,1983 Approval of Minui-^s ^PP^oval of Planning Conmiission Minutes of April 18, 1983 1-. ■ ’•»! '"1 pr HNISSION MEETING MBERS 7:30 P.M. ^lAY 16, 1983 tunerel r-1 m. It »an, 3525 Shoreline Drive, 2440, 2450. - Subdivision » Variance e, 2765 Shadywood Road - Subdivision 320 Woodhill Road - Subdivision dur Park Road - Variance Birch Lane - Variance rystal Bay Road - Variance to attend Council meeting of June 13, 1983 % inutes of April 18, 1983 i r V -1 I '• ■...‘ ■ ■ ■ . --5 Pi 4 A y /£ . ^f/3 ACE OF OBONO t.««l I • I« ff I • 1 • Amm m * * I ^.v» t m.-Z. -»s »w*. (3^ X— .. • * • .* T X .1 JjOK •»* / \m ' j KL-* ■ ,A1 T^-/ L\a*..•^ '0 % r_J >ji0C '52) i t • CMLf 9.•-WV ^•A—t <♦ , C_ ^ -1 11’ --^<1 <r:.ii__i:T?»;‘Hv\ V t ‘4? w -- \ \ \\ \\ >^ ' •• ... •...••* y. ••'/ «paii*« 1 «*iil ^*»*r .It L' . : m 4 - i ff/3 Q.-J A \ ’ ■ • & t t' • CM.C • PM \i •ritiiPii 1 tfilki % ■ ■}■:• ^c»- w‘,. \ ■mK ■•-t :V imtsm m TO:Planning Commission FROM:Jeanne A. Mabusth DATE:May 12, 1983 SUBJECT: #739 Edward T. Lehman 3525 Shoreline Drive 2440, 2450, 2470 Carman Street - Preliminary Subdivision #740 Edward T. Lehman 2450 Carman Street - Variance List of Exhibits Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Property Owners List Plat Maps Engineer's letter Density - existing vs proposed Preliminary Plans Review of Current Subdivision Proposal 1.Notice of Public Hearing - Legal notice was once again published in the Minnetonka Sun and notices mailed to all property owners within 350' of the boundaries of the subject property. Review the enclosed plat maps and the lists of notified property owners com piled by staff. 2. Proposed Density Lots 1,2 and 3 Lydiard Park have been included in current plat as Lot 1. The subject property was approved for a duplex in December of 1977. Lot 7, Lydiard Park is combined with proposed Lot 3 removing potential building site as combined Lots 7 & 8. Lot 8 remains as the driveway to the Edwards home. A total reduction of 2 potential residential units. Note, density is not a real issue since setback variances and the conditional use permit were issued in 1977 under exactly the same ordinances existing now. The applications expired and must be renewed but denying them now with no change in facts from 1977 would never be upheld in court. Sewer The Lehman house and Edwards' properties are not hooked up to sewer. The septic systems do not conform to any kind of current code because of proximity to the lake. These three properties and the Paul Smith cabin on Dunwoody are the last lakeshore houses in the urban part of Orono that are not connected to sewer. Council has ordered Smith to connect. These two houses (plus the vacant lot of Edwards) were not included in the 1964 Carman Street sewer project because they did not abut the street and because a pump is needed. They should have been included in any number of projects over the years, especially when the rest of Casco Point was done in 1965, but they were not. Cost has been the obvious factor discouraging voluntary participation. SSF * •y/. i 't mm ii A >•hi .4 ' 4‘. r X #739 & #74C May 12, 19£ I have ask€ sewer servi minimize e> were part c tacting my them on the for the rec connect to a result of sale of his individual properties. City plat a ing drivewa route or ch Riparian Is The propose shoreline w 360' feet a lake. Thus averages ou required by Thus, from recommend a whether or the Plannin precedent f What is the Is it t would c to addr Or is i space t so, the should : The Lehman ; property, s« unbuildable by owners o: continue to agencies, i preservatioi houses than we deal wit] wm 5 ion published owners gview the grs coin- plat as December t 3 Lot 8 remains 2 potential and the he same be 1977 would to sewer, because 1 Smith part of mith to t included abut the ncluded in St of Casco obvious #739 & #740 Edward T. Lehman May 12, 1983 Page -2- I have asked the City Engineer to review the plat relative to sanitary sewer service. He recommends that all parties use the same trench to minimize excavation in the area. This would be fine if the Edwards' were part of this plat but they have not shown any interest in con tacting my office as of this writing. Lehman has continued to update them on the status of the subdivision review. I will write a letter for the record advising them that the City will require that they connect to municipal sewer sometime within the next year. Lehman as a result of this subdivision will be required to hook up prior to the sale of his current residence as a condition of plat approval. The individual grinder pumps are the best method for serving all involved properties. They run about $2500.00 each. Cook recommends that the City plat a utility easement of 20' along the south side of the exist ing driveway serving the Edwards house. Lehman may use that connection route or choose one more economical. Riparian Issue The proposed narrow platted corridors to the lagoon obviously require shoreline width variances. But the factual reality is that Lehman owns 360' feet of shoreline on the lagoon, plus another 120 feet on the main lake. Thus, he has 480 total feet of shoreline for four lots. This averages out to be 120 feet per lot, which is more than the 100 feet required by the City or Lake Minnetonka Conservation District. Thus, from staffs' objective position, there is no factual reason to recommend approval or denial of the application. The question of whether or not to approve this averaging is a question of policy for the Planning Commission and Council, not staff, to answer. There is precedent for both. What is the ordinance intent? Is it to regulate overall density on the lake? If so, the averaging would conform to the intent and the variance would be appropriate to address Lehman's unique lagoon situation. Or is it to rigidly specify 100 feet for each and every dock to space them out for maneuverability or appearance or whatever? If so, then the averaging would not conform and the lot width variance should be denied. The Lehman plat of 1977 left many issues unresolved for the subject property, sewer service to existing house, creation of lots with unbuildable building envelopes, potential illegal use of the lagoon by owners of lots not abutting the lagoon - it exists now and will continue to be used through devices that appear conforming to enforcing agencies. Staff would suggest that the intent of Orono's lakeshore preservation goals might better be served by the sewering of these houses than by denying two or three more docks. In every application we deal with there is the element of tradeoff. - ' #739 & #74 May 12, I9 The survey! lots 2 and than it sh( 40' platte< 1 will be : on the tot* Setback Vai Review lasl for this aj since 1977 Commission 2725 sf. Lot 3's har applicant w variance fo variance se McCleary di specified/a; when dealin' Staff recomi To approve setback va 4 and if n following 1. deptf 2. no ch apprc This approva Staff recomm To recommend application < units in the of fact: 1. There i time oJ :o sanitary trench to Edwards' in con- to update a letter : they jehman as Lor to the il. The L involved that the the exist- : connection Ly require Lehman owns on the main :s. This 100 feet :t. reason to Lon of >licy for There is :he averaging >propriate dock to rever? If Ith variance subject with i lagoon id will :o enforcing .akeshore ; these iplication \ - i': •. • ^■>v kiiar- ‘-^i- 12 T. Lehman than it shonlri xs important to Planning Commissi 40' platted corri!?^^*'* problem in approving the original, p^artea corridors with limi<-at-ionc #->n ^ ___<iT_ on the total lineL foo?agrof“shorelinl?''^®’' “^""^tonka based S0tbaclc Varianc©s for^thiapplication #740 - nothing has changed since changes in the factual findingl improvement the addition of lot 7. Plannina 2725 sf!^°" * that the hardcover limitation must be maintained at Proposed hardcover for lot 4 house 1816 sf drive 300 sf 2116 sf Lot 3's hardcover must be maintained at 3175 sf. Lets make «?ure <-ho variance for this lot. Staff wants to incorporate all aoorover in the subdivision resolution, as we did in the ^“ture owner must build acLrding to the whin dealina**wl^h‘^a'^‘’^^'^^"S envelope. We have found this mist hllpful wnen dealing with developed marginal properties. ^ Staff recommendations: ?£'"SS“ following fillllls IIHIrdlliplf i°t 3 based on the depth of lots in relation to lagoon Ippllliril"l977^“®^ findings since variance application This approval is subject to the following conditions: 1. Deck to be relocated to south sidf» of __ _ __ _ , '■ Ti7s\T"^ harlllvir ^111^1100*'!^® ^2725 If^*^ "'aintain allowed hardcover allowance of 3. Access location to be reviewed by Public Works Coordinator Staff recommendation I|pnilS‘'o?‘’EZ|d llhnll l°^l-^>^e-rrangement subdivisionu|?„ i. “• '■ tSsj'ofthriiJrnM!;,;!;; “;si! (miw ..a,«th. #739 & #74 May 12, 19 The impr Ripa the appr Lots 2 Lots 2 2. Lot 1 3. Lots 3 Lot 3 Lot 4 4. Applic public 5. Applic final At pre the Ci future ripari 5e of both >nunission iginal tlip. Lot onka based s changed indings ning ntained at ure the newed ved n the to the Bt helpful . a street ' for lot m the Lon n lot 4. ator on al dings h: •? mi #739 & #740 Edward T. Lehman May 12, 1983 Page -4- 2. The applicant has added additional land and has greatly improved the proposal from the original subdivision. Riparian use for 4 lots of the subdivision is based on the total 480' of lineal shoreline footage and hereby approve a shoreline width variance of 60' for lots ^and3- 4. Sewer is available to the property. Approval is subject to the following conditions: 1.Lots 2 and 3 are to share a single dock located in Outlet B or Lots 2 and 3 will each be permitted a dock with one slip at the 40' wide shoreline. 2. Lot 1 is not riparian to Lake Minnetonka 3. Lots 3 & 4 must maintain allowed hardcover allowance as follows: Lot 3 - 3175 sf Lot 4 - 2725 sf 4. Applicant to quit claim deed Outlet A to the City as part of the public waters. 5. Applicant/owner of Lot 5 must hook up to City sewer prior to final plat approval. At present the lagoon is navigable and the approval of this plat by the City does not permanetly vest each approved riparian lot with future boat navigation to the main lake but does encourage general riparian uses. ■ i-1 :ly >n and Lot B or Lp at the s follows: art of the ior to this plat by an lot with rage general '.wi'wirnnwiiinii f-4 O lAm rA >r •-« M CL • lii O H < a q: oa LU Ck: H UJ (A >- 0) o M V— < K r: tn cr o -i u. Z (A M cr UJ >- r— ••cr o UJ CL >- o »- CL q: CL UJ CL>- o H cc T. CL Do u M CL UJ UJz (O \ Cxi V. Kl O < o flOo o I X o CO o o o < H UJ CJ r-t lA CM I rH rH I o CM cno o: tA < o i< a o < UJ zi C j <C UJ CM lA inu\ CO Kl o o CL* cr •»c < Kl O o o CM lA rH < X h- UJ UJ ^ Kl CM I rH rH I O •»cr - < CJ d : CM o o o CJ rH Kl CJ I rH r-l I O CM »- •« O «c < CO fO ocr <3 O lu O U K u; <t < o Nl N. r< >- Q <r < UJ CJ 3 croo < 111 t: q: lUo. o fru. o I-ti cr CJ or CJ UJ < >- \ < Uf CL X X* < r ,r=.. .4J fA rH O o CM rH CM rH Kl CJ I rH 5: a* 111 cru lA UJ CO I o CJ a U CO CO >H cr CL* LTI UJ CO n in •A CJ <r u in in <0 lA lA UJ <r o <r <c CJ CL liJ U •I d: lO «4« Xo < o 71 rH hH in o UJ CJ rH O O UJu. I-H >- 3 CJ (A rH «4 Kl CM In. rH rH I O CM < UJ rH Ch lA in I- in UJ in cr D << < u UJ D Z 3 rH Kl X CO CM < Kl O UJ 3 < o: u ZZ rH -J »A < ^ “J f J < h- < Kl rH u a 3 X a I < -A o u CJ Kl X Z rH UJ UJ rA ^ 3 0 rH CO CJ c( < r CJ•As^: <c Kl < 3 3 CO O 3 lU 3 111 •t CL 3 rj o 't N UJa ...o z X *t u; :< n z O rH O O J- C^J lA rH Z nO o Kl CJ I K* rH rH I O CJ • : X 3 7 CJ o CO (A <C Z -J Ul O -J .") UJ O X o C* X o Cftl in rH O O I- cj in rH ♦A < CJ X I 3 < rH U UJ U) U) < ro h- ►- UJ to lA •< CO o CM CO Kl in ino CM O < < o o o o \ <rH sT-J r:rH 0~i< X O o h* UJ rH O rH o UJ -J O h-a-i-Kl CM lA Kl CM lA rH Z <in rH O O in r-J O'•X ^h-in lA lA K-U*l i-lA i: 3*lA Kl <3 n:(A Kl lA lA inX o CM Am Ul UJ CJ X ill inUi ^1 d;O o 1 rr m •« •iJ -J o <:r>.<UJ UJ A ZZ f'-<• •lA rH U O I- X rH 3 UJ 3 X I u. CO < Xo u CJ U O O >7 X *-i U n T CO CJ c>: '7 Kl O 3 UJ CJ o o: O UJ 3 X a An r. A. 3 UJa o 3 UJ >- -C CL X o: a Cl \ Ui m • •C xi^iHxa 3 :< < 3 U I- o <7 3 \ 3 O U < Ul X 3 UJ 3 O cj : 3 3 UJ < 3 X < 3 O O -'t \ Ul lA >7* UJ iu HI LA 0 0 0 Kl 0 rH 0 rH in UJ 3 0 O' in CJ 0 rA CM LA Kl rH M in rH * .T mUJin7*<r-Ul rA UJ 0 ■~r A.rA lA•ir CJ 3 HH CM 7* 1 0 ►H «J 1 3 Ul IJ f>.X Cl UJ •<-t UJ rH lA **r c:% •rH U »- • AmXrHHJ<0 rH H •-3 <1 -J 3*-t 1 <<-J 0 lA ui h-0 (2 0 U K CM in o <<CM 0 3 0.<n c J X in N <•t 0 N ^ •in 0 CM >-^7 -r >- 0 en rA X in <CO CJ 0 C.I •7 rA 0 i-lA 3 lA 0 UJ Ul CM 3 lU CO CM U. rH CM <7rA00 2Kl0CJ0 rH in K lA lA K.CK <vi O' in CM <A 0 n CJ rA CJ rA rH 3 3 rH LA rH A •Yf inX<x *;LA <h-in rA Z %'lA X lA CO « •CM X 0 0 b CJ 0 1 3 UJ LU UJ 1 Ui G <j <•.» A.K-<z 3 rH U <<in ».r-l Am X 0 rH rH rH i-h-3 0 LH 1 0 0 UJ 1 << U3 10 0 u:3 0 3 0 0 0 U 1-.J CM 0 « ^<3 3 CJ 3 ti:<rH u CO zn 0 Klu<r u U >->“1 • •>- H-X CO CM ►H ►H 1-<CO a 0 >7 •X 3 UJ rA 0 3 3 U Z Kl UJ UJ CJ 2 s7 lU K.LA rH u. CJ in ^7 ►H 0 0 0 UJ 0 > CM <■A.CJ rH • •rH A.(A lA K-«l rA Q 0 lA 5.T rA CJ 3 3 c:3 CJ M*1 <rj <1 UJ K*7T 2 2;3 mJ rH 0 0 77 rH rH Ul Ul UJ to rH r- 1 -J IH 1 0 UJ UJ u r)0 0 CM 0 CJ 3 0 0 lA mJ <( D'3 •7 ~r CO <in 1-CO 0rAV 3 2 ro «A rA UJ rH lA Z LA A I- in X lA Ui X <ri 3 o u 3 Cl UJ o *7 CJ < K •t Kl X A X 3 O O < UJ * #o: UJ ao ft 3 3 Ilf :c o < CL >: 3 tJ O •I N lU X A V r- ■; in rH O O O 03o o Xu < to < I-'o h- CJ -{ Ui 3 X n A 3 Z Ul >- 3 •f 3 Ul CL Z - i :: A r. u nt o o *i s Ul oou r ■;-JK L ! ir''! K'^- ■ Edward T. Lehman 2470 Carman St. Wayzata* NN 55391 Karen A. Pederson 2413 Carman St. Wayzata, MN 55391 W & C Frommes Bruno Betsch 2447 Carman St. Wayzata, MN 55391 Ward E. Edwards 3545 Clenhurst A\ St. Louis Park, ^ Jalmar E. Aune 2431 Carman St. Wayzata, MN 5539! Donna L. Bassett RT 1 Box 608 Excelsior, MN 55 Richard A. Edwar< CTY Rd. 15 Box 1 Navarre, MN 5539 Grace R. Besner 7510 Cahill Rd. Edina, MN 55435 Helen B. Lytle Douglas B. Demal Box 97 Long Lake, MN 55 Stephen Skorc 2428 Casco Pt Wayzata, MN f t A • - J A.iVSi^ ‘1L. i • ‘ ■•VSv;-> ,.•V!s^ lA r-lf O Oo o o o Xo < U3 O h- ai nt i: cjOr o Z «’ < >- X at »f yj tti u :; y X -I -t zu r ■v‘ -v#. vi; :«;4 4'^S- ■>: i. V i iKv S< I V •v Ml K;..' Edward T. Lehman 2A70 Carman St. Wayzata» MN 55391 Karen A. Pederson 2413 Carman St. Wayzata, MN 55391 W & C Frommes Bruno Betsch 2447 Carman St. Wayzata, MN 55391 Ward E. Edwards 3545 Clenhurst Ave. St. Louis Park, MN 55416 Jalmar E. Aune 2431 Carman St. Wayzata, MN 55391 Donna L. Bassett RT 1 Box 608 Excelsior, MN 55331 Richard A. Edwards CTY Rd. 15 Box 127 Navarre, MN 55392 Grace R. Besner 7510 Cahill Rd. HU Edina, MN 55435 Helen B. Lytle Douglas B. Demalignon Box 97 Long Lake, MN 55356 Stephen Skoro 2428 Casco Pt. Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 exhibit Henn. County-Right of T & D Lind Thomas A. Lind 3525 Shoreline Dr. Wayzata, MN 55391 ^^^way Section 320 Washington Ave. S Hopkins, MN 55343 Alec G. Overson RR 2 Box 33 A Chaska, MN 55318 Mpls., MN 55410 Wilbur F. Anderson 3555 Fredrick St. Wayzata, MN 55391 James K. Lindsay Mt/) 2058 Shoreline Dr. -p Wayzata, MN 55391 Michael L. Walman 3565 Fredrick St Wayzata, MN 55391 Kevin Paul O'Brien 2505 Kelly Ave. Wayzata, MN 55391 (J3-> Francis S. Lightly 3585 Fredrick St Wayzata, MN 55391 David Bie 1910 Shadywood Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 Cortlen Cloutier 2480 Casco Pt. Rd.:^^^ Wayzata, MN 55391 George F. Piper 3470 Shoreline Dr. Wayzata, MN 55391 Bruce 0. Newton 3580 Fredrick St. Wayzata, MN 55391 Bishop Trust Co. LTD 140 S. King St. Honalulu, Hawaii 96822 Lyle A. Buerkle 2474 Casco Pt. Rd. ClX Wayzata, MN 55391 State Land Dept. Clarence H. Schmidt 2454 Casco Pt. Rd. LV Wayzata, MN 55391 Margaret Olson 3465 Lyric Ave. Wayzata, MN 55391 Bradley J. Stannard 2408 Casco Pt. Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 Current Resident 3473 Lyric Ave. Wayzata, MN 55391 Marjorie M. Gr< 2156 Cardinal ; Mound, MN 5536 Ruby L. Undbti 3505 ly/ttc Ave. (Uayzata, MW 55: bim, F, VotdtK 35/3 LyA-cc Ave, blayzata, MW 55i R^chaA.d Lee 3525 lyK4,c. Ave Wayzata, MW 55 Vonna M. M^cffe/ 354/ Lyfi>ic Ave. Wayzata, MW 553 Joanne V, PZumt 355/ iyn.J,e Ave. biayzata, MW 553 ktheKt L. VeAA.y 3559 LyfL4.e Ave, Wayzata, MW 553 Eveaaad Geyen 2939 Hazelwood ^hoand, MW 55364 Guy E, Butler Me-tfe U. Stone 3574 ShoKeltne Wayzata, MW 553 Caaol E, Beimel 4603 Sunny^tde Edtna, MW 55424 ity-Right of 3n igton Ave. S• m 55343 verson ell Ave. S. 55410 Lindsay eline Dr. m 55?91 il O'Brien Ly Ave. MN 55391 iywood Rd. MN 55391 . Piper reline Dr. MN 55391 ’rust Co. LfD ^ing St. i, Hawaii 96822 smd Dept. t Olson ric Ave. , MN 55391 Resident ric Ave. , MN 55391 it-'-- Marjorie M. Greg 2156 Cardinal Lane Mound, MN 55364 ^uby I, L^lndbtad 3505 lyKlc. Aue, iiiayzata, MW 55391 Wm, F, VotdzK 3513 LyA^c Ave. (L'ayzata, MW 55 39 7 RickaKd lee 3525 Lyfi^c Ave, iHayzata, MW 5539 7 Vonna M. Mltlzn. 3541 Lyfiic Ave. fitayzata, MW 5539 7 Joanm V, Ptumb 3551 l(//L/CC Ave. (Hayzata, MW 55397 Albzxt L, Ve/LA,y 3559 LyA^cc Ave, Wayzata, MW 55397 EveAaAd Geycn 2939 Hazelwood Lane Mound, MN 55364 Guy E, ButleA MeAte I/. Stone 3574 ShoAettne Va, Wayzata, MN 55397 CaAot E, BeAmet 4603 Sunnytlde Rd, Edtna, MN 55424 mrnr I David S, PeteA6on 7775 SteAllng Da, Mound, MN 55364 exhibit Golden Valley State Bank S210 Golden Valley Rd, Golden Valley, MN 55427 • -7^am * K'k A ’■i<v-^'w ■»i- ,i i W j: i21 m a; rfV.-.s I .t;:;j( •'?'' ' Ro4U4iAoa, /?( 233S lO. *J*mmk St. P»mI, MS5tf3 Pimm*: 6f2-636-ii600 MN.W*iU f-300-622-6. May 10, 1983 City of Orono Box 66 Crystal Bay, Attn: Ms. Jea Re: File No. Lehman Su Dear Jeanne, We have revie Itary sewer s grinder pumps The sanitary pate that the tlon below th can also be b struct their area. The five lots we would not • The benefit t' nance problem If you have a: Yours very tri BONESTROO, RO! Glenn R. Cook GRC:11 Ro4%€4iM4^f R mbha , AnJU^lih & Auooiaiti,, 9hc , Qt>MiMiiiM<f CttadM^a^i 2335 W. 36 &. P»Mt. MimmM^U 55113 Pi^. 612-636-41600 MHWuu 1-300-622-6513 May 10, 1983 City of Orono Box 66 Crystal Bay, Mn. 55323 Attn: Ms* Jeanne Mabusth Re: File No. 139-739 Lehman Subdivision exhibit Otto it, BontunHi, §\E. Rohrn M*. BosriH\ P.L\ Jnxeph C. Atu/rritk, P,E. Brud/onI A. Lrmhcru, P.E, Btvhard L. Turner, P,l. Jamn C. Ohan, P.C. W {■1 Li@[iDW@ MAY I 2 1983 5 (Tv/ r /**• • '( >“ f I - 'mj i. !r^' C/rnn ft. Cmri, P.E* Eeith A. Cordon, P.l\ Thomus f. Soyci, P.t\ ftH'hard M*. foxier, P.L. Bobrrt C. Schunivht, P. E. Marx in L. Sorxata, P,E. ihtnatd C. Burfprdt, P.E. Jerry A. Bourdon, P.E. Mark A. tUnum, P.E Jedh held, P.E. Muhael T. Bautmann, P.E Bother! B. P/efJerh. P.E. Char lex A. Ernixon I Alt .M. Pauvtxkt' liar tun M. Olxtot Dear Jeanne, We have reviewed the Lehman Subdivision and adjacent property relative to san itary sewer service and feel that the area can best be served with private grinder pumps. The sanitary sewer line on Carman Street Is quite shallow and we would antici pate that the basements north of the channel will be constructed at an eleva tion below the sanitary sewer line. The existing homes south of the channel can also be best served Individually but It may be beneficial for them to con struct their service lines In the same trench to minimize excavation In the area. The five lots In question could all be served by one public grinder pump but we would not anticipate a significant cost savings for the property owners* The benefit to the property owners would be the elimination of a pump mainte nance problem. If you have any questions, please contact this office* Yours very truly. BONESTROO, ROSENE, ANDERLIK & ASSOCIATES, INC. Glenn R. Cook GRC:11 4795b m SCALE -u::' <' V . Cilrwii R. CcmM, /•. f.‘. kttih A. Canhn, P.t. Thifmas F .Vou's. P,F. Rnitatd M. / iiwrr. P,L\ Rohrri G. Si'hytui'ht, P.l\ hfurx'tti L. 5iir%-0to. Pi,. DvnaktC. Burf^ordt, P.E. Jern A. Btmrdtm, P.F. Mori A. fUnsum, P.F 7fd A FteM. P.F. hlnhaet T. Bout maun, PF. Both^ft B PfrffrrB. PF. i 'horirx A. Fruiutn t ti* M /\»**W%Ar H Of tan \t. tUuMt e to 8an~ Lvate i antlcl-* n eleva- channel B to con- Ln the trap but inter 8. ttainte- ^■4 m ktTs mm 0- m Mm,r: r>. c ale- 200 / INCH 0 200 400 Xm 200 FEET scale ..... . * •.•... f... ; ; •• • • feel HIBIT ( GO - RO-NO 15 )1761 42 TfiiLCD ti 'i li : :•. :xi^\ fri^: ^ ?fi 'Ll ''■ 3" •••■. ___ •!__k 0 ------2^ — ___.tv s -•■■■ ■ m 1 ' 9 ^ . • • ■w, ■e, ■ ^ llo'oS r- ... 125 V '•'!) r, i f -v'-wri' ‘ • «4f • A , « N 87" 4 3*50”l IB4.68 ■M fie 5 oo Nee* i> NAVAR [i ^J• • .* •*L ‘o u e ? . p, /tit C »'r.o.L A •" —• •• Shcfc; line oe ptr IS 7| Aeud Photo A L; l<c 0^ -Unjer * *• *■• . ART OF WIWSHIP'S SUBDIVISION loti, SPRING PARK 2ND DIVISION ; V ■>v. •v.j> 1C -■• e TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Zoning D Area - 2 Applicat Ogle pro off Shad necessar easily s Parcel B The p€ Ogle, the nc on the City V the rna Staff Re To appro combinat of the L capacity 1. Appl o«ne 2. All TO: FROM: DATE: Planning Commission Members May 12, 1983 SUBJECT: Zoning District - LR-lB Area - 2.64 acres Application - Subdivision - Metes & Bounds - common ownership of General E. f Jeanne A. Mabusth, Zoning Administrator #744 Richard G. Ogle, 2765 Shadywood Road - Subdivision Lots or tracts held under W. Rawlings Ogle proposes the division/combination of General Rawlings' properties off Shadywood Road. Each of the combined tracts or parcels contain the necessary area of one acre. The required lot width along the shoreline is easily satisfied by the total lineal footage on both sides of each lot. Parcel B satisfies the 140' width standard at the building site. The permanent dock that straddles the shared lot line will be owned by Ogle, the future owner of Parcel B. This decision was made based on the narrow or restrictive channel width along the shoreline of Parcel B on the lagoon. Parcel A will have its own dock on the lagoon side. The City would prefer that both docks remain on lagoon side rather than on the main lake so close to the Narrows bridge channel. Staff Recommendations: To approve the subdivision application of a metes & bounds division/ combination of General E. W. Rawlings' property finding all standards of the LR-IB zoning district have been satisfied and adequate sewer capacity for the additional sewer unit subject to the following conditions: 1. Applicant submit copy of easement agreement granting existing dock ownership to Parcel B. 2. All future docks to be placed on lagoon side of Parcels A & B.} M M cn O O 0^ ^ Ul ilJ fH 21 M o <0 «n o I < -i ^ 3 r^XKo:>- iH in < < Q tt u u < o M u u S in CM in -J m «j -J in ui D D tn o 9 CM < < X ^ O CL a CM Ul rH CM CM I •H •H I•H CM Of Ul X K U UJ < X X U X-o q: < o X Min in lA Ulu X CM Ul CM < UJ fH Kl fA O lA CL lA CM I fH IfH CM >• >- UJ UJ in in < COtn in in < < r X o o X X H H- Ooo z 3 X >- O CL< oX Min in lA Ul CO u X CM Ul lAo o fH H>fH CO lA O <f O 3 -i rA O 3 lAo <lA o « 8 !u O lA 3 lA <M CM O3 X Z O lA P O O O CM tA < z> XCM Ir^ r4 (H CM X X -Jo o >- z o o in oU U Z h-z e>O O UJ Z CL Mo oM M o o X CM OfH q o •J CO CD tto QC Oa oUl << >- N3 < Ul CL UJ IL XO S ?S SDC 3 < ZE o H J « UJ 3 tt X O O < 3 Q < >• N3 < UJ 3 ui a X 11?^ fH -I X < OI UJ X MfH o o in in CM o 3 -J -JO < O UJCO X z o u CO CM O CO XlA O 3 3 CM UJ 3 OQ X Ul 3 O 3 O \Ul3 < a UJ 3 X o z X < 3 Sc < Z 3 o H >*PA lA Ul fH o O in fA ooOfAou3&A lA H CM Cl O PA >*olAin Ul o PA CM in 3 X CM 1 HI <X 1Nu>- fH >-o 3 fH UJ -)<o 1 in X M 1 fH < in in in fH CM ‘'S -j CM lA Ul o <0 uCOXX CO lA H H CM Ul PA X UlHin >•in inXu.o oMmJ H CM Ul CM < H ^ O o fH OX in o 3 3 PA 3 M O PA oO -J o o o lAu.^ o in 3 lA fH X in CM O "> u.PA M 3 3 o OUlPA >-HI ^o PA >• S CM O UJ o X CMH 3 1 <in o 3 X 13 O X U. 3 >-N Ul fH in o o 3 fHrH IiH CM COfA Ul iH U.CO^ O •H fC lA O 3 3 PA O O PA ooHIO lA^ o 3 lA CM O Z Z CM3Ul UJ OPA >.3 3 O PA CM O O 19 o Z CM 1 <-J -J 3 £1XX X >- fH in < <O 3 fHfH< O fH 1 in in X M 1fH^ in fH CM O X X CM CO 3 3 O UlA-O O CO U CO CM •> -1 X COPA O CD tfJ CM Ul PA K> -1 *** O O < O 2 H fO O 0 fOoo in «H O £ 2: 2 in0 q: q: 2 <r < oK> >. X X o CM o o 2 I < M M a c1 2 2 >- •H 0 2 IH 2 2 < O I X Mr4 lu \u in tn CM lA O (D ^ 2 2 &n UJo o ^ u CO CM uj uj X Kl O o O CM k&J in Xlu li. to O 2 <•J omOo <o in o 2 O 0 2 in •H O 0 2u.m o O C3 2 2 O o —#n >-0 o UI O 2 CM o 0 oO 2 £1 << 2 2 >-N X > O 2 rH 0 2 O X < O M < X M a in in 1 H-J .J CM in 2 in < O 0 o-0 inZoo0< O' O 0 X 0 CM O 2 CM 0 to O 2 2 CM o tn < Kl O lA CO cn 2 in O CO 2X0 •H M O -J -J o 2 2 2 2 £ < < >• 2 2 0 2 2 2 X M CO CO •T * M l-l U1 UJ 2 2 M> Uo o X Ui Ui CM Ui =tfc CM •Ho o sH < 0 ►-O H 2 O Ol O 8! lAi OC £ D <20 2 lAi < > \ 2 < 0 lii 2 £ 2 X < S ZO H Z 0 2 < 2 UJ < 2 liJ Ui O 2 2 2 <22 J J J m' f.' »««s:Wir';/V^ .: ■.' • ■'; ■ • • '■; ^ ^ URV£Y GeNeoBL RAWLINGS may - S1983 |,|TY OF 0^ Zoning Dis Area 9+ ac Applicatio List of Ex _...ii Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Mr. White Lots 1 & : the estate (50* righi RLS 1098. 1981. Whj date with to make th White has 1 be includee was always tied in wii I am not ai plat, there asked him \ decision. He has advj he has beer the public TO: FROM: DATE: Planning Commission Members Jeanne A. Mabusth, Zoining Administrator May 12, 1983 SUBJECT:#745 Robert White - 320 Woodhill Road - Preliminary Subdivisioi Zoning District RR-lB Area 9+ acres Application - Subdivision - Plat three-lot plat - possible lot line rearrangement or List of Exhibits Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Application Property Owners List Plat Map Plat of Edgewood Place Current Survey Mr. White’s original proposal was to realign the lot lines between Lots 1 & 2 so that the existing driveway would be located within Lot 2, the^estate house lot and provide access to Lot 1 via Edgewood Hills Road (50' right of way - private access easement - 24' wide road) and Tract 1, RLS 1098. Edgewood Place plat was approved by Council on August 24, 1981. White has been trying to sell the estate house since that approval date with no luck. This current subdivision application is an attempt to make the house more saleable. White has been advised that a plat would be required and that Tract 1 must be included in the plat as new access to Lot 1 must be shown. Tract 1 was always to be sold with Lot 2 - Tract 1 is substandard and should be tied in with larger land parcel with this subdivision. I am not an expert on the sale of estates but if the applicant must plat, there are several options now available to the applicant. I have asked him to consult with "experts" in the field and come back with his decision. He has advised that he will be unable to attend the public hearing because he has been called out of town. Planning Commission should move to keep the public hearing open until the meeting of June 20, 1983. #745 - Rot May 12, 19 Page 2 Neighbors 1. Lot li Hills 2. Create 3. Withdr iminary Subdivisio angement or between (Within Lot 2, aod Hills Road 3) and Tract 1, August 24, 2 that approval 5 an attempt lat Tract 1 must »fn. Tract 1 ind should be :ant must :ant. I have Dack with his hearing because 1 move to keep #745 - Robert White May 12, 1983 Page 2 Neighbors in attendance may be advised of the options available to White. ^ access to Lot 1 via Edgewood 2. Create additional residential lot - total three-lot plat 3. Withdraw current application I-/.-:'/' 4 ff' ■ - 4 » ■'* i| I i ;="J t ■ I T r , i UF ORONO R^cCi^d of For Fund Obj B^aS^j* '.1m:»^3- !....>. - .... •^..' ' .’^v^'-'1 i,V-. ■■ / -:.c;.v>^-*'V'»-*^ _^m.m'v^l Liable to White. L via Edgewood Lat ■WWwfS^!^* lllllllliiiiiiii iilillP^ '■‘ IORONO ik J CITY OF ORONO P.O. BOX 66 CRYSTAL BAY. MN 55323 TELEPHONE: 473-7358 GENERAL RECEIPT N9. y 13753 ,/ For_______________—------------------ Fund Object Program Div.Amount 72yJU. » W0. 7 ■ ••* .r. ^ % > m .• T .__^^_________- M wmmw ■« Woodhill Coui 200 Woodhill Wayzata, MN 1 John S. Pillj 315 Woodhill Wayzata, MN ! Robert F. Wh 320 Woodhill Wayzata, MN Current Resi' 1050 Edgeood Wayzata. MN Current Resi< 985 Edgewood Wayzata, MN Freda C. Kei P.O. Box 246 Wayzata, MN ; D. Eldridge i 1055 Edgewoo< Wayzata, MN ! Current Resi< 450 Woodhill Wayzata, MN ! Current Resi< 1000 Edgewoo< Wayzata, MN ! Current Resi< 325 Woodhill Wayzata, MN ! i9. y 13753 r ^p a DOLLARS |: :#d . 'L^ A \ •. 'J W «• 1 ;f. ■. r 'Ml ^-1 ,v-:vr* •V r. i ^1: ' Woodhill Country Club 200 Woodhill Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 John S. Pillsbury Jr. 315 Woodhill Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 Robert F. White 320 Woodhill Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 Current Resident 1050 Edgeood Hills Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 Current Resident 985 Edgewood Hill Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 Freda C. Keith P.O. Box 246 Wayzata, MN 55391 D. Eldridge Jackson III 1055 Edgewood Hills Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391. Current Resident 450 Woodhill Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 Current Resident 1000 Edgewood Hills Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 Current Resident 325 Woodhill Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 #745 MAY - 51983 ' CITY OF OROf •■.Vi.- • "f ; I lif.r. i 4. -i-- 12 N 39^/3 £ ^ k* w A Vi,. W. w • tni9 unu con of a survey c ^ *< •• o *• ^ Hennepin, .-.nc Scale : Date : 0 : 1" = r* > ^ I Iron 4 ^ i \ or '%r’,. '•«;3JSi' 1^ ■jm Cortificata of* Survoy for Robert F, white of Tract A, aecistered Land Survey Kc. 1098 Hennepin County, Kinr.esota Xlm r<*j *Sr*th r r sy // S Z*^C,rfi 7 V // 'jv,: £ ?c ■<//'<.»€ X • ' \ A f rcpo-:^ cJ di^tdincj y\/ r" y / c>cc * ,f\ /'• s'"'''? V S 59 • ----K i'2 32SOO- ■••/.' S9‘’/5 £Z<Ul 00 T 4*-»r ^Vkj- f- I* <5 • 1.,^ L,w. vf!*:. li \ a true an;: correct re^re ?ent.Htion of u survey cf th-; toui.d-m : „<5 o:’ Tract .i, :-.c.r •■a f'k. • ? IIi j . , ' • - ^ I ^ . . ./ -t r CJ. 4.1 • Uo*17lovri0nn«:ji.r.i .-.riu t*ri6 pro^osorf oT .a 1 ” = 1G0» 7-.^2-S0 Iron marker Gordon n. Cor'fir. 60^4 r*inu f;arv?yc.r and Planner lyOHL /t ko , Kinne s o ta t .ii.1 '^E a : ■> i- •• • ^• iv. HBrtB'L I- Scale: 1" - loc Date : 5-10-83 ,0 fc 4 • • • ^uounLv L’iZ’-. 60H Tuer S ;-‘Jv' ;i-v .-oti \i'm ■Sr. Proposed Lot-division Sketcii for liobcrt F. White in Lots 1 and ?, Block 1, £dr;evood Place Hennepin County, Minnesota Scale: Date : 1" - 100' 5-10-83 \ GORDON R. COFFIN CO., INC, Land Surveyors and Planners Long Lake, Minnesota 'M m r s rr’v fV-iM\ ** .* . ’* ^ . • ¥ ■ :x -i.:-. * . —»• •J X:XXX^:X:s // ■ ''u si :.-j 4 TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Zoning Dis Applicatio; a) 0-75’ . Allowei Exist!] 75'-25i Allowei Exist!) Exist!) Propose Proposi List of Exl Exhibit A Exhibit B Exhibit C Exhibit D Exhibit E Exhibit F The applies home for ac consists o) the second of the exij garage in 1 The existii two-car gai 189.9 or 1< the curreni there is ar laca Hi :o., INC. i Plannars 3ta s«! TO; FROM; DATE: SUBJECT; Planning Commission Members Jeanne A. Mabusth, Zoning Administrator May 12, 1983 #746 Mike Sjeklocha, 1424 Baldur Park Road - Variance Zoning District - LR-IC Application - Hardcover Variance (Ordinance 34.510) a) 0-75* area = 3,750 sq. ft. Allowed hardcover = 0 Existing hardcover = 299 or 8% sq. ft. total - 154 sq. ft. screen house - 145 sq. ft. portion of house 75*-250’ area = 4,650 sq. ft. Allowed hardcover 25% = 1,163 sq. ft. Existing hardcover = 1,295.4 sq. ft. - garage 338.1 sq. ft. - house 957. 3 sq. ft. Existing variance = 132.4 sq. ft. or 3% Proposed additional hardcover 375 sq. ft. Proposed hardcover variance 507.4 sq. ft. or 8% or 11% List of Exhibits Exhibit A - Application Exhibit B - Property Owners List Exhibit C - Plat Map Exhibit D - Survey Exhibit E - Elevations Exhibit F - Section The applicant proposes a two-story rear addition to his recently remodeled home for additional living area for his growing family. The addition consists of a family room on the first floor and a bedroom and bath on the second. My concern in this current proposal is the age and condition of the existing garage. Although the applicant does not include a new garage in the proposal, our review must include the inevitable request. The existing garage is 24.15' X 14' or 338.1 sq. ft. A minimum sized two-car garage at 22' X 24' equals 528 sq. ft. in area for an increase of 189.9 or 190 sq. ft. of hardcover. A 4% increase in hardcover and with the current proposal, a total hardcover variance increase of 12% (remember there is an existing 3% excess of hardcover). 'v'ji; m 1! ■P V- i 'la: '- m 4 #746 Mike May 12, ; Page 2 The Plani structure certainl; A new ga] Planning if doors street s< Staff Re< to appro’ addition approve i variance Side setl Street s< Approval 1. Impr< 2. No a< 3. No d( 4. Cont. Approval 1. Remo’ of 11 2. No f 1 3. Per i on h< “ Variance 'i % ecently remodeled The addition m and bath on ge and condition t include a new table request, nimum sized r an increase of cover and with e of 12% (remember •j ' »/■ V,.? M'ifi 0^': * m r i 0 >- ■'•i .4^; 4 #746 Mike Sjeklocha May 12, 1983 Page 2 The Planning Commission may ask for trade-offs - removal of screened structure in front yard - reduce size of addition —. The proposal is certainly consistent with the recently improved lots on Baldur Park. A new garage will also require approval of garage setback variance. Planning Commission may recommend approval of the following variances if doors face away from street. Side yard 3' setback = variance 7', street setback 5'-10' = variance of 25' or 20'. Staff Recommendation: to approve Mike Sjeklocha's hardcover variance application for a 15' X 25' addition creating a hardcover variance increase of 8% and to further approve a future 22' X 24' two-car garage with an additional hardcover variance of 4%, with setback variances as follows: Side setback variance of 7' Street setback variance of 20' Approval is based on following findings: 1. Improvements consistent with other properties on Baldur Park 2. No additional land available 3. No detrimental effects to the public health, safety and welfare 4. Continue to improve property values in the neighborhood Approval is based on the following conditions: 1. Removal of non-conforming structure in 0-75' setback area - removal of 154 sq. ft. of hardcover for total 145 sq. ft. or 3.8%. 2. No future variances granted to this property. 3. Per City ordinance and Uniform Building Code place address numbers on house E screened proposal is Ldur Park, variance. j variances riance 7', l&J iu M 1 for a 15' to further al hardcover o o q;«c oe <IU rH in q:CO a •H O H >h-o o 3 3 rH IU M CO o o o IU o o q:O IU Ck IU o o:r-f o DC .u o rH o ck IU IU oZ<IU o -J c^O u uto a Kl to X IU IU IU m m X IU IU IU d:c in CO u.u.in ^ CO M M Ck q:H ft IU <<in o o o in CL CL O UJ z lO 5 5^H CL K»X o o X to X M M X >-CM O Z CM H oo CO CM h“•-H COorIU1 •J <3 1 d:iO o 1 Ck H h- Zu UJ z>< H s z o X z o IU lu XMoa•H CD _Z o •H z CO CO H*c -1 z CL CL H CL <q:»H 3 O •H ot:rH Ck 10 u IU 1 o <<1 H K o <1 Ck Ck O <D CO z d:CD h-«H z h-CO zXC3To o oo <o o IU lU <o o CO CO lA D ^ o U)o fsl rH VC q:o Kl IU IU o3CMCDd:>-in IU IU •H >-in X X ^ O O'mJ CO «H o q:<CO m >>in <CO Kl << in UJ <ro o o X r-l 3 to o IU IU m 3 to o -> Kl c Park i welfare e3 ress numbers rea - removal .8%. • « 1^ .'W It L=. 25qPoo<c-r*=:;:29^«/5 «/) ;5 u _ 2Ci'-*9juZO<‘"OOa «®iii< .|a««s8c “OI>.«S = o“2,,£ a< =^“-._- (r 2«/)UjbrOCS<Q.Q ‘r<5S>5oO = 5?:i? 2hPk2zw®582o ow<2iiii“ll§*i,. H y O CD <a*33*^§S|!;<5£ h- ‘5flc ^opo^ ui>*0*^*P ouj V IdKZoSssfI SeDUi<Zu.(AU>MX$2 A , fr»*-r ■m ’’X' eicji^ vjgmT I' • iV iV; -?i Tzsp iK-rn Fi'-r-n exhibit ~ ^ ‘Z’-x-iz. glicciQ'c- Fg\H1|t_Y 'Z'xjo _ie;iis.p: -a S^ol'eafc. *.*•« *-»• ^ • •-^*n '<4=> ’LJ Vs// SCly*-:.-OF ex.cx-_-c r’L^veei p-fw%jv4 e'A K(r^)C. .............................. iFco-r V/ iiKjr/^ig.l 'ffei 4h «• * ■> e:iC4ic:> !K zc:>'^'i cr: ^ m A. \-0-4 ■j - ■>v ' i rV, An?, 1 1 J- #; TO: FROM; DATE; SUBJECT; | Zoning Dis Area - App Applicatic a) sett side regu Prop vari stre requ prop vari Hard 75' - Allows Exist! Exist! Propos Propos *1 House = paving shed - Total *2 Garage removal of Total 21 Toward pro principal as additio overuse an- a matching Commission to be used the drive . Staff Recoi To approve and hardco’ following ; 1.P] n( -- iWSH Planning Commission Jeanne A. Mabusth May 11, 1983 SUBJECT; #747 R. William Toward, 3460 Birch Lane - Variance Zoning District - LR-IC Area - Approximately 16,739 sq Application - Variance a) setback variance side setback required 10* Proposed 3* variance 7* or 70* street setback required 30* proposed 10* variance 20* or 66% Hardcover Variance 75* - 250* area = 9259.5 sq Allowed H - 2315sq or 25% Existing H - 5239 sq *1 or 56.5% Existing H. variance = 2924sq or 31.5% Proposed H. = 5453.2 sf*2 or*58.8% Proposed H increase = 214.2sf or 2.3% *1 House = paving shed = Total 2276.2 sf = 2880 sf 82.8 s£ 5239 sf *2 Garage = 440 sf removal of paved area and shed - 225.8 sf Total 214.2sf Toward proposed the construction of a 2 stall garage to serve as the principal garage. The existing attached garage will probably serve as additional storage area. The property is a sad example of the overuse and abuses of paving. I would suggest you ask for at least a matching removal of hardcover to be specific 214 sf more. Planning Commission may ask for more. Check to see if the existing garage is to be used for yard maintenance equipment and storage, if so ask that the drive area in front of attached garage be removed. Staff Recommendations To approve R. William Toward*s variance application for setback variances and hardcover variance within the 75* - 250* setback area based on the following findings: 1. Proposed application is very consistent with pattern of neighborhood development. mm ."a Pa« #747 1 3460 Bi: 2. Approve 1. 2. :ve as the >ly serve of the at least Planning garage is so ask that :back variances >ased on the :ern of • *. Tt. i.;t Page -2- #747 William Toward 3460 Birch Lane 2. The location and use of the proposed structure will have no adverse effect on the surrounding properties. Approval is subject to the following conditions: 1. Applicant must remove sf of additional paving. 2. The City will approve no future variance involving additional hardcover for this property. < . ! !V .• i • »-4 O in•A »H Sf M CL • Ul o o = 2 Hn:o Q. UJ CL OS•A r-i N. Vf O III , ■ • ' ■ r-4 Oo lA CL oo ^ O CL < K> CL •<r rA S CM o I -Ir«» <•H CD fH I <0 ^ O CO CO 2 K» O <I— III Ul Ul c>u ^z Ui UJ rr.K li5c « < -I o 10 r-4 III > m < in X►-o rH < < O <0 CM -J fH a in £ CMo o <HrA < Ul ^ 2 XlA X Ul UJ CM U I a < < ?•rH flO S 5C •H_ _ _• £ £ CO O O V >• <^ CL CL ^ CL CL CO tA < < lA O X X H O* •A Ul in X in 3 Xu M < CO h- < O isl C^ >- 'T < lA 3 o o tA < ^ -i tA X CM U I CL M rH CO fH CO CO lA tA O M M CO CO CL CL O O UJ Ul CO CO fH in ^ fH <r in a in CL o o < < 2 5 o o o o o O 10 in -J ^ a•H £ fH O O ocoo Ul 5 z 5 a oCLCL CL Ul CL O CL O Ul < >- \ < Ula £ X << z H J J J oo tA CL ^ Ul Ul H CL H Cl Ul X lO ^ Ul lA X D CM H O I CL CL N O CO iH Z I P < €0 o o o -J f-* oCL rA < O X Ul h- CL H O ^ Ul^ UJ tA -J rr in Ul o in gg cixs PtA O o M a' > <'t < X tA 3 Oin CLo o X O CL < tA a tA 5 CM O I -I < •H CO fH I Po o <0 rH tA O O CL rH Ui C^ X X tA z CL in UJ < < in X H CL < 3 3 o Q Z CLo oO CO CLO CL CO £ D 2 a £ < < CD H <C o tg <r >• g- <c iH 3 O sr a o o O CL . —*tA CL < g’ h* tA B ^ CM O - UJ IL £ o s o z < CL CL Ul O Z CL rikCL a CLaCL O UJ < >- \ < UJa £ X << zH J CLin o oo Ul CL O lA X <r lo tA X CM ►- I CLo fH Z rH I to o to O' g- CO tA lA O O 5? Z UJ tA o n: in 10 o in O CL CO CO < _^0X2 CL H £< X CL'CJ o < o o < t- CO tg ca z O" >- UJ ^ < £ X lA 3 OCO 3g* oiH O UJo tr. c tA X g CO CL -J < < uH Ul ^ tA X CM h- I CLo fH Z fH I Po o O' <r to tA lA O z UJ o z CO < M CL O UJ >M CL “o! UJ rA CL in o in X CO CJ «9 X X z z o o CLo ui ui X X €0 O' glA <t- <rg >- << 3 3 Ul atA o oo tA g- Ul CL O rA CM IK fH fH I too Xr- o:o u -J < < £ H -J UJ -J Ul 3 H* UJ CO Xu < £-J o•J o -J < Ui X H* CO «4 CL O rH <7* Ui lA 3 Uto in XCO cOtA o CO g*tA o CO CO M M CL 3 O Oa o 3C Z I- £ O < o tg CO >-<r < lA 3 UJ 3 £ O < O Z < 3 3 UJ O Z 3 3 3 O 3 O 3 O UJ < >• \ < UJ 3 £ X << z J 3 CM O CM O UJ O 3 -J CJ < tA X h* g* CO UJ 3o tA X Ul CM I- -J • 3 CD 1^ O Z fH Z Ui fH I U. Po g* o sr >- g* o«0 r A -I tA o lu UJ rH o: <^O tAX in CO in n X< I- CO 3 S O £ 3: 2: ^ 3 OUl g* z CO g* o o g* 3 •A tA o 3fH o CM O UJ O 3 O tA Xg CO z UJ tA X O CM I- a I 3 Or- o fH z u rH I £ €0 <€> O M in -I gcn to iH tA o 3 3z o lU Q Ul O 3o o fH OrA inin U CO £ o << Z HM < «J O N -J in >- IH g <c 3 rn 3 o CM O o tA g tA CM I •H rH I P O < < -J h- Ul 3^ sC^ Ul tA 3 if\o in CJ >- 3 < M 3 CD ~) CO tA O O -J g ^ g 3 t«l UJ O CD >- CO < H £ “A 3o < 3==!; < CM tg 3 g >- UJ g < CD tA X UJ 3 £ o < o z < 3 3 UJ o z3 S 3 O 3 O 3 O UJ < >• \ < Ul 3 £ X < < 2 t- 3in o CM O Ul O 3otA X g 10 tA CM X H t 3 O fH Z fH t to O P in g to fA tA o rH tA tA 2 2 m < < _ m £ £ < 3 3 -J UJ Ui _ SHSi ^ ^ X 3 ^ ^ U O 3 M CO 10 O CO ^ -J £ £ rH Ui O O tA U X X X I- H CM UJ rH O O 3 g oCJ O Ul O 3o tA X g CO 3 U tA X CM t- I 3 OrH Z rH I CO o to g g CO rA tA O 3Ui >- 3 3 Ul <-J £ Ul rH 3 O tAX in CO in £ CO UJ HI £ < •A “A ss g o g 3 tA o tA CM Oo tA g tA X CM U I 3 M fH CD rH I too o in g OD tA tA O U. •J 3 < £ h- Ul Ul X rH tA Ul in z in lU <o. UJ z X o < >- < 3 3 U £ 3 M - g < tA z UJ CL 3 £ OO < 3 O O 2 Ui < < >• N3 < UJ 3 UJ 3 £ O ? X <E S 2 ^3 O H Ut-<c CD oH -I CM < O H O Ul tA < g -J tA X CM U I 3 M rH CO rH I P O O%o g P tA tA o o 3 3 < < n z o ot- t- rH O' tA inin i £ £ < < M M U £ 3 _ M < CD H ►H M 3 3 0 3 3 o tg p >• g <•A 3 *V i 3 P O CM O UJ 0 3-1 O < r A X t- g p UJ tA X CM h- • 3o rH 2 rH IPO O PgP lA tA O C)P 2 -J O P P 2 -J Ui CD fH C^ 3 tA O P PUJ 3OX zU> £ 2 2 X Xo o o < •- < O N P >- g <KI 3 %U 3 3 £ OO < 3 O O 2 P < Ht >• N 3 < P3 P 3 £ O S X < 3 ft < 2 3 O t- - Carl for in Lot 19, • Hennepj f- m ;• 1- f' V. I hereby a true at: tion of a of all tr "Lydiard' lying Nor of fcirch Northerly stra ight the locat tnereon. other imp For purpo has been across sa Hennepin i section s Scale Date 1" U- Ir Ir '-r'‘>41? r4 Oo oo u I- <m •I o IV «l <\J < O H> O UJ to < ^ -J to X CM U I d: 1-4 rH CO rH I COo o M) '4' « K> Kl O o o CK d: < < rr 3 o o 55 M M M M 3 3 3 o: M O' lO lA 5i M < o3 3 tt O O CM O Uio q: ^ o <m X h- ^ CO UJ X X CM K o I O' to Xrv o -J o r-C X UJ to rH Z I UJ «> O Z o o X Z _ X X CO to o O tA o -I -> l-l Ch DC to O lA lA Ui ft O ml o < z »- < O Kl M> >-<r < Kl 3 UI K DC X O O i o: Q O Z ^ < o. S a r O H w£ I m^:■iiflni ^1 •V V' l\ ; ; ''IP ..i' "V.- V- Certificate of Survey for R, William Toward in Lot 19, "lydiard's Park" Lake Minnetonka Hennepin County, Minnesota #747 Of <>/ I hereby certify that this is a true and correct representa tion of a survey of the boundaries of all tnat pert of Lot ic, "Lydiard's Park" Lake MinnetonKa, lying Northerly of the Northerly line of birch Lane in"Baldur Park" if said Northerly line were extended in a straight line across said Lot 19, and the location of all existing buiLiings tnereon* It does not purport to show other improve.-nents or encroachments. For purposes of tnis plat, birch Lane has been assumed to have teen opened across said Lot 19 (as shown on tne Hennepin County Surveyor's half section sheet). GORDON P.. COFFIN CO., INC. Scale: Date : 1" • ho* U-10-d3 Iron marker found Iron marker set Mark S. Gronberg P.eg, No.l?75i; Land Surveyors and Planners Long Lake, Minnesota '^06U l?75ii rt‘ s.f- # TTfr -' . ^r._^ .................... ^. - r*^ r::);=^".Tr~T ti:' r- '.•■ at; Ki :d 91. % ■ * t»f t' c0 Il t-''iS^' ■y:r • S |*-lv 1.4 ^•'-•rrffriittiiia^ni ^1 ■ ;>. A JHg .(‘i #t-v. I -' l'* ■s '.^ 4 Zoning Disi Area - appi Applicatioi a) Side s( Requirt Existii Propost Variant Hardco\ 75'-25( Allowec Existir Existir Propose Propose *1 Existir Gr ave1 Existir Propose New red way List of Exh Exhibit A - Exhibit B - Exhibit C - Exhibit D - Exhibit E - Exhibit F - Exhibit G - Exhibit H - A mir,!S U 76 ih TO: FROM: DATE: SUBJECT: Planning Commission Members Jeanne A. Mabusth, Zoning Administrator May 12, 1983 #748 Sandra K. George, 3399 Crystal Bay Road - Variance Zoning District - LR-IC Area - approximately 15,128 sq. Application - Variance a) Side setback variance Required - 10' Existing - 11* Proposed - 8' Variance - 2' or 20% ft. Hardcover variance 75'-250' setback area = 9,120 sq. ft. Allowed hardcover 25% = 2,280 sq. ft. Existing hardcover = 2,758 sq. ft.*l Existing hardcover variance = 478 sq. ft. or 5% Proposed hardcover = 3,295 sq. ft.*2 Proposed hardcover variance = 1,015 sq. ft. or 11% for an increase of 6% hardcover Existing house = 1,378 Gravel driveway = 1,380 2,758 sq. ft. Existing house = 1,378 Proposed addition 707 New reduced drive way 1,210 3,295 sq. ft. List of Exhibits Exhibit Exhibit Exhibit Exhibit Exhibit Exhibit Exhibit Exhibit A - Application B - Plat Map - Property owners list - Plat of variance 1972 - Planning Commission Minutes - 1972 “ Council Minutes - 1972 - Survey Current Application - Elevations C D E F G H ■Mi 4 ■A ^ T 4 j n #748 - Si May 12, ; Page 2 George p: Lot 18. with gari of the 1. and park, and seed< The appl 5’ of lo need for wanted t< lots, th< is 11' f; review o: Lot 18 a] The foun< structure hardcove; hardcove: Commissi* existing Staff Re To appro’ of 8' an* of an ad* 1.The cons, in 1* 2. The ] hood 3. The; Approval 1. Redu* 2. The ; comp. 3. No f 1 - Variance an increase of ■■‘TH v‘3 im /'■ ■_y ... >. 1 r-v’ i;/-'-:- •di.v I #748 - Sandra George May 12, 1983 Page 2 George proposes extensive remodeling for the existing structure on Lot 18. The structure will be jacked and a new foundation installed with garage and walkout basement living area. There will be an expansion of the livingroom on the second level (18* X 10’)• The gravel drive and parking area on the west side and rear of the house will be removed and seeded. The applicant's hardship claim is that the City requested an additional 5' of lot width from Lot 18 back in 1972 on the east side creating the need for the variance. Please review Exhibits D, E, & F. The owner wanted to sell off his adjacent lot and to be consistent with surrounding lots, the City asked for the additional 5’ for Lot 17. The home on Lot 17 is 11' from the subject lot line. The hardship claim is not vaild in review of Lot 18's history. In fact, note the enclosed piat map. Exhibit B. Lot 18 appears to have had 10' removed on the west side. The foundation must be replaced as the original footings for the old structure were never deep enough. The applicant is adding 707 sq. ft. of hardcover with the house addition and removing 170 sq. ft. of driveway hardcover for a total hardcover increase of 537 sq. ft. or 6%. Planning Commission may ask for a reduction in the proposed size of additions to existing structure. Staff Recommendations; To approve Sandra George's variance application for a side yard setback of 8' and hardcover variance increase of 6, 5, 4% to permit the construction of an addition of _ _ _ _ _sq. ft. based on the following findings: 1. The level or degree of variances approved for the property are consistent with the past divisions of Lot 18 reducing a total of 15' in lot width and approximately 2,835 sq. ft. in area. 2. The proposed, as amended, is consistent with the pattern of neighbor hood development. 3.There is no additional land available. Approval is subject to the following conditions: 1. Reduce proposed addition to sq. ft. of hardcover. 2. The seeding of gravel drive on west side of house and in rear yardii completed prior to issuance of certificate of occupancy. 3. No future variances approved for this property. ■ 5’ "81 ::ture on installed be an expansion avel drive 11 be removed an additional creating the The owner ith surrounding e home on Lot 17 ot vaild in at map, Exhibit B. or the old 707 sq. ft. of of driveway 6%. Planning additions to yard setback t the construction ’ ndings: erty are a total of 15' ern of neighbor- Vi er.A in rear yardti I -.V \ - -1 » '**' ,*o •01 -\z 1 frcr r ^ f '*' |i HI % Ur<. fer' \ 01 . »\ 7 If HI ill “ St -mmii! >8*''__L aS* ■r fi?.s1_L_8“S.* »• •A '9, c w — 1 • 01 k/24i•• - - K. ^ •r* ^ y 11 • \« \ * c^vcy • 'r ■ * ( : -N \*” _ •• - ‘ •8 l' : ifil !• • yh I r € i? r-l 11 r-l O u> HI r4 M Q. • lUo o K OCo CL lAl DC Ul H- 01 U> § M jshr (o DC M O -J IL Z 01 M DC 141 DC O I4l CL >- O 1- DC DC CL Ul >.S z M CL Ui HI « V lA CM O N rH HI HI CM • iH r-l Ih* rC O O DC DC O O 14. U. O O CO HI ii O O H H 01 O M> DC rH rH >• O < CO HI HI h* CM 01 I >• DC rH U rH I h* rH U 1-4 z CO HI HI O U O OC 01 Ul •J U >- 0 •-« < z Z CD u 01 01 >- UJ OC h- U UJ 01 (0 o o sf DC Z HI lA o HI HI CM I iH iH • IS. rH 6 O DC OC O O 14. U.o o 01 HI ii O O h- H 141 H- < O O < (O Ul aDC r c O < DC C o Z Ul ^ < >- Na < u. a Ui 0. r gS<2 CL O H a-.: • i .. R. -V-ii'■; . . . * ^ o <^ tt f4 CO :J-i oc - IH<c o^ in h-o incM in •J in 1 >-HI < h* 3 -J H •H U 3 3 in _ fH < >“ S1u in 3 zh-Ul u »o «(i < CO OCO ro X ro am o u u HI O aCO oc *H O >- o < to ^ ^ < < lij H> Hcvi cn o: I >- UJN oc cn r-l o M r4 UJ I ^ 1^ iH to CD m >- CO K> < m o “1 o* s!<h >- m < in CO m “ d in H z M cn c UJ >* ^ QC < O H C3 < in M >- >-< m < -) Kl I£ o CO QC iH •H >-0 <c z CO < tn r ^ -I cc < Ul K> H Z CM <n z 1 >• M 1^ a N iH U f-4 X I h* H «H in q: r-l UJ Sf CD CO lO o Kl O OC o Z oc rC <C CHz >• m oc < in Ul CO in z Z -i M < -Si K U H o: < Ul in N (D »H >- O ^ < OC in 3 Ul q: Z o < o Z < q: Q. Ul Si OL O cco K O UJ < >- \ < Ulo. z o CM QC CM O >-o < CO in 2 CM cn I >•oc rH U rH I iH in o CO in m o < H ui 19 19 Z Z M M -J -I QC OC < < O O UJ O O -> 1 o <o “5! >- in < in CD in in z < in N o >• ^ < in 3 Q *H QC CM O >- O < CD < in ►- CM in I >•oc iH u rH I r-l CH CHm CO in in o h- M !:•- HZ o < o z in H M U.i° UJ H H I- < O H u in in Ul o > -J X CD < 2 W _ H 5^ M < CM X -i ^ z in “ 3 z ^ o z a UJ z oc o M) in o in -J ^ a X in z i in o z O 3 X _ CM O Z O >• -> O o < in CD < Z ^ X^ in o < -1 m H •• CM in M I >- Z DC |V QC O UJ iH u in X •-4 z in rl E-, rH m -> CH -J in u a €0 in < m o ^ ^ o a r-l >- in < in CO in 3 ^ U H < in fsj <H >- m < in 3 ( . fvhibit O CM COo O -J 3 5a Ul in M CM > • >• h* < iH CD r-l I r-l O o CM CO CM in o ^ •J < < H H UJ UJ Z Z O O in in H H UJ UJ -J ^ < < o o Ul r-i U <c in -i in Q. m 3 Ul 5i < < CD H O N O >- CM < CM 3 in CM o o -J CL S 3 Ul m M CM > I >- < •H CD iH I r-l in o CM CO CM m o •J Ul < 3 h- CL UJ CL M -• in Ul -1 3 CL ID M in HI z z o o Ul iHu < in -J in a in 3 UJ 5i < < o >- CM 3 in CM Oo m CM Ir- r-l rH I h- r-l COin O Oz z o o 3 3 O O U. U.o o iio o H H CM r^ O O o r-l O o u < ID H O I- Ul 3 Ul 3 UJ 3 3 Z O0^30 3 Zo <O 3 a 3 Z O0< 3 O o Z UJ < < >- \ o z < UJ < >• N O Z UJ < < >- N 3 < Ul 3 < UJ 3 < UJ 3 UJ a z 3 UJ 3 Z 3 Ul 3 Z O Z X <O Z X <O Z X < 3 3 < Z 3 3 < z 3 3 < Z 3 O K 3 O H 3 O H WILEY’S PA block pvwiBIT PLAT >0 accompany APPLICATION FOR VARIcNCE LOT 17- Wallace's Addition to Minnetonka Beach, Scott Whitnah, Owner CRYSTAL BAY tONKA BEACH LOT 2 WILEY’S PARK block 1 Crystol Bay Road ei-'.v' HUTCHINSON BRAN BURLINGTON Nd .7 Northwesterly Part of Lot 5 BLOCK 3 BLOCK 2 PROPERTY OWNuRS Lots 1 & 2, Wiley's Park- J.D. Darling 3 •• t.B. Bren Lot 18 Wolloces Add. Mtka Beach- West 20 '- Boy View Place East of W. 20 '- Scott Whitnoh Lot 16 Wallace's Addition to Mtka Beach ’ Robertson 15 " •• •• •• J.B. Koiser Lot 14 •' « mm > w. Dahima Lot 2p Bl. 2 ^ Bl. 3Lot II •• " David Sippreli * D.M. Motsotsor f ?• f 1^.= i...¥i I-' F H- rlNOTES OF A 1. Searles • have to have application i 2* The shop] but still W01 building pen 3. Members this, his pi no landscapi Mr. Wear her interested i on the plan. Southworth m approval for recommended requirements Nays (0). Scott V/hitna for lot size V/allaces Add 1, He was ]: the lot to n 2. He felt neighborhooc depriving hi residences c out that the or over on 1 50' with SOI built up anc future cn ti 3. He was t retain this 4, There w; the lot 5. Tiiat he wished to *n that the abi tnis usage. Gasen moved the above. Ayes (R) - C. Steve Ku advised by before the Council bef Island with three perma informed by that lie siio fINUTES OF A REGULAR MEETING HELD AUGUST 21, 1972 1. Searles - The apartment building would have to have a separate conditional use application and be judged on its own merits. 2» The shopping center was a permitted use, but still would have to have approval for a building permit from the Village Council. 3. Members felt that for a complex such as this, his plans were inadequate and sliowed no landscaping whatsoever." Mr. Wear here stated that for now he was only interested in the gasoline island as presented on the plan. Soutlworth moved, Ryerse seconded, t»iat approval for the gasoline concept only be recommended conditioned on all zoning requirements being met. Motion, Ayes (8) Nays (0). Scott V/hitnah represented himself in a petition for lot size and width variance on Lot 17, Wallaces Addition to Shady\vood. Rrought out: 1. He was placing another 5* on the front of the lot to make it 50* 2. He felt he was in conformity v/ith tiie neighborhood and to make liim keep^ tA*/o lous was depriving him of equal rights wita tiie otiier residences on taat street. (Gascii here brought out that there were only two other lots of 100’ or over on tliis street, all others being mostly so* with some 60'; also, the area was entirely built up and no precedent could be set for the future on that street). 3. He was economically or physically unable retain this large a parcel 4. There was a sewer unit charge placed on the lot 5. That he now had a buyer for the lot who wished to *place a beautiful home on it and that the abutting neighbors were in favor of this usage. Gascn moved, Searles seconded, that due to the above, approval be recommended. Motion, Ayes (8) - Nays (0). C. Steve Kuehl appeared saying lie had been advised by the Building Inspector to appear before the Planning Commission and Village Council before purchasing 7 acres on Big Island with views to construct two or perhaps three permanent iiomes on Big Island, lie was informed by members and Councilman Massengale that he should be aware of certain factors (Continued! Page 3 BUILDING PERMIT (Continued) mm LOT SIZE ft WIDTH VARIANCE 3399 Crystal Bay Road 1 RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION Big Island -kiv '..V. ■r % Regular M August 28 The Villa with the Oberhause Massengal Dorn move' Minutes o 1972, be , Nays (0). The divis 2225 Sixti Tiie reque: heard froj The final Street an< referred i presentinj next meet] Tne final North aiid Village El Planning C Butler mov of Joan ICc and widtii of the Vil Ayes (4) - The reques from Ordin additional Dayton’s c The Villag William We informatio Massengale request of Road for a accordnace Planning C Ayes (4) - Tne report speed limi 1 h ..5^’ Page 3 .ding permit itinued) k'- SIZE ft WIDTH VARIANCE ) Crystal Bay Road • v'lV V 5 . SIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION g Island 4 •m ! mim ^ ■ 4 JA v.,.r/y —-.i % 2 VILLAGE OF ORONO Regular Meeting of the Village Council. August 28. 1972 The^ Village Council met on the above date witn the following members present: ilayor Oberhauser, Councilinen Butler, Dorn, and Massengale. Councilman McCartny absent. Dorn moved, Massengale seconded, tliat the Minutes of tiie Regular Meeting of August 14, 1972, be approved. Motion, Ayes (3) - Nays (0). Councilman Butler abstained. The division-combination of Lewis Cox, 2225 Sixth Avenue Worth, was studied. The request will be withdrawn if he is not heard from by October 1, 1972. s The final plat for Archibald Spencer, Fox Street and Old Crystal Bay Road South, wa referred to tlie Village Engineer before presenting to tiie Planning Commission at tlieir next meeting for final approval. Tiie final plat for Robert McKee, Sixtli Avenue North and iVatertown Road, was referred to the Village Engineer before presenting to tiie Planning Commission for their final approval. Butier moved, Dorn seconded, tiiat tiie request of Jonn Keller, Elmwood Avenue, for a lot size and width variance, subject to tiie approval of tne Village F gineer, be approved. Motion Ayes (4) - Nays (u). Tiie request of Bruce Dayton for a variance from Ordinance Mo, 125 be tabled pending additional information from Ron Bowen Dayton's caretaker. * The Village Attorney v/as requested to v/rite William Wear concerning additional necessary information before referring to the Planner. Massengale moved, Butler seconded, that the request of Scott Wiiitnah, 3399 Crystal Bay Road for a lot size and widtn variance, in accordnace with tlie recommendations of tlie Planning Commission, be approved. Motion Ayes (4) - Nays (0). ‘ * Tiie report from tiie Ciiief of Police concerning speed limits on Sixtli Avenue Nortli was accepted. 7:30 P.M, FXHIBIT ■?: S' MINUTES DIVISION-CO; IBINATION 2225 Sixth Avenue North FINAL PLAT Fox Street fi Old Crystal Bay Road South \ FINAL PLAT Sixth Avenue North § V/a ter town Road VARIANCE Elmwood Avenue VARIANCE-ORDINANCE NO.125 900 Old Long Lake Road k BUILDING PERMIT 2100 Wayzata Boulevard VARIANCE 3399 Crystal Bay Road SPEED LIMIT - Sixth Ave.N. A JS..*Ww mmmrnm ..^ies «*1“- %j^mm {• • •’. •-• -!^•r* \H •t •t • •V..-; •;•■ .*' -‘» exhibit *I" A ■■'• ‘ -\ •.< • t*St^nUJUj: .' ...I ; •Shorelin^JfsLit Cbrtificato of Survey for Scott Whitnah estate in Zx>t 18, UalUca*s Addition to the Village of Xinnetonka Boach ■'*’ Hennopin County, Minnesota % •• • ■-» 4^ ■'V. L u: I hereby certify that this is a true and : correct representation of a survey of tho ' boundaries of all that part of Lot 18 lyin^T Cast of the West 10 feet thereof, except t!iat part of said Lot 18 lying Northeasterly of a line described as beginning at the most Easterly corner of said Lot 18; thence Northwesterly through a point described as follows: Comtvsneing at said most ISusterly corner; thence Northwesterly along the Northeasterly lino of said Lot 18 a distance of 175 foot; thence dofloctlng loft 90° a distance of 5 feet to said point, Wallace's Addition to the Yillago of Minne tonka Beach, and the location of all oxistlng buildings thereon. ► It does not purport to show ^ other improvements or encroach ments except a road and a wall. in wail Scales 1" = 30* Date : 11-17-82 o I Iron marker Gordon R. Coffin Re{/' No. 60f>4 Land Surveyor and Planner Long Lake, Minnesota tim ■M 'ir- km 1 1 f I A - « • w 3|:M ’ I ■c-1 r*rE^h- i M I I • > li n •j =i ^ 1 i! V - t ! * I < a true and ■ lorvey of tho' 5f Lot 18 . ; L>t thereof, t 18 lying eribad as erly corner •. rthwestorly as follows: Easterly erly along of said Lot ot; thence distance of Wallace's go of Minno- locntlon of kgs thereon, to show or encroach- { and a wall. ,lI ‘^■A^fcV'‘ 'w i- ^mm '• "••'• V.’ ■ '•■t *••• >vl v< ^ir • •t ■ H; ^ M . •• a ■*■: >'l ,if- ■ :1k' ■^^1.3 it t :■•:■> P/: I- I' a V ■I-.. I?.-' t«2 JVr:-;,H- JS. .■i>i CITY OF ORONO 7:30 P.M. Regular Meeting of the Orono Planning Conunission, April 18. 1983. PUBLIC HEARING 420 Brown Road South #735 - Larry Bader Final Subdivision PUBLIC HEARING 1170 Lyman Avenue #736 - Donald Mogen Subdivision The Orono Planning Commission met on the above date with the following members present: Chairman Rovegno, Planning Commission Members Adams, Callahan, Goetten, Kelley, McDonald, and Sime. Also present: James Grabek Councilmember, Zoning Administrator Mabusth, and Deputy Clerk Woytcke. Chairman Rovegno announced that now was the time and place for the public hearing concerning the final subdivision request of Larry Bader, 420 Brown Road South. Zoning Administrator Mabusth presented the Affidavit of Publication. Mr. Larry Bader was present to review chis application with the Planning Commission. No persons from the public were in nr tendance regarding this application. Chairman Rovegno closed the public hearing at 7:40 P.M. Member Sime moved. Member Callahan seconded, to approve the preliminary and final subdivision of Mr. Larry Bader at 420 Brown Road South. Motion, Ayes (7) Nays (0), Chairman Rovegno announced that now was the time and place for the public hearing concerning the subdivision request of Donald Mogen at 1170 Lyman Avenue. Zoning Administrator Mabusth presented the Affidavit of Publication. Mrs. Donald Mogen was present to represent Mr. Mogen. No persons from the public were in attendance regarding this application. Chaiman Rovegno closed the public hearing at 7:50 P.M Member Sime moved. Member Callahan seconded, to approve the subdivision request of Donald Mogen, 1170 Lyman Avenue based on the following conditions: Application cannot be scheduled for Council action until the owner/applicant resolves issue of encroaching septic system and staff is in receipt of alternate septic test information for lot with existing house. If applicant decides to go with the staff recommendation. ! a -X, VH : I) I’ • 1 PUBLIC HEARING 3155 Jamestown Roi in37 - Robert Schi Subdivision re date with igno. Planning Kelley, McDonald, Llmember, Zoning time and place subdivision . Zoning t of Publication. pplication with e public were in t 7:40 P.M. to approve the ry Bader at s (0). time and place rision request ig Administrator Lon. Ir. Mogen. No regarding this t 7:50 P.M. , to approve the irman Avenue based icil action until icroaching septic nate septic test . If applicant tion, mi Sm.'rn. PAGE -2- the City must receive revised preliminary plans prior to Council meeting. Payment of park fee of $200.00 - per current fee schedule #1 lot 0 $200.00. ■ Owner of lot with existing house grant access easement in favor of newly created lot. Per Septic consultant's recommendation - revise septic design per Gaffron's report dated 4-12-83 Revised preliminary plan to include a portion of a cul- de-sac to be dedicated to the City of Orono. Motion, Ayes (7) - Nays (0). Chairman Rovegno announced that now was the time and place for the public hearing concerning the subdivision request of Robert Schneck, 3155 Jamestown Road. Zoning Administrator Mabusth presented the Affidavit of Publication. Mr. Robert Schneck was present. Several neighbors were oresent and did have comments regarding this application. The ueighbors were opposed to Mr. Schneck*s subdivision because the were under the understanding that the property in their area was to maximum density and that it could not be subdivided. The neighbors were told bv the Commission that there was no such document on record with the County or City and that there was no legal reason to not grant this subdivision. Chairman Rovegno moved, Member McDonald seconded to approve the subdivision request of Robert Schneck, 3155 Jamestown Rd. based on the following conditions: 1. Payment of Park Fee in the amount of $200.00 per current fee schedule ifl two acre lot 0 $200.00. 2. Access construction to Lot 2 must be reviewed by City staff at time building permit is issued. 3. New owner of Lot 2 must now participate in the upkeep and maintenance of Jamestown Road - developer must draft revised documents to assure this is done. Copies should be submitted to the City. 4. Wetlands to be designated as drainage easements and described with angles and bearings. Conservation and flowage easement to be filed with new plat. PUBLIC HEARING 3525 Shoreline D: 2440, 2450, 2470 //739 Edward T. L( Subdivision //711 - RAYMOND KL 3775 Togo Road Final Subdivision //738 - Kip Nelson 4580 Watertown Roj Conditional Use P< m. ‘Sif.:: PAGE -2- ary plans Lirrent fee schedule access easement in - revise septic -83 portion of a cul- Orono. time and place vision request ning Administrator ion. sighbors were oresent :ation. i subdivision because >roperty in their area >t be subdivided. :hat there was no such and that there was Lon. ponded to approve 3133 Jamestown Rd. 200.00 per current eviewed by City e in the upkeep and must draft revised should be submitted easements and described d flowage easement to ■'Si I IH1 ■ V ■: \ , .• V I U;;' 3. Applicant to review drainage problem with owner of Lot 1, Block 1, Liberty Acres - resolution of problem prior to final plat approval. PUBLIC HEARING 3323 Shoreline Drive 2AA0, 2A30, 2A70 Carman Street #739 Edward T. Lehman Subdivision //711 - RAYMOND KLOSS 3773 Togo Road Final Subdivision #738 - Kip Nelson A380 Watertown Road Conditional Use Permit Chairman Rovegno announced that now was the time and place for the public hearing concerning the subdivision request of Edward Lehman, 3323 Shoreline Drive. Zoning Administrator Mabusth presented the Affidavit of Publication. No members of the public were present regarding this applica tion. Mr. Lehman was informed by the Planning Commission at this time that all the information was not correct and therefore this public hearing had to be closed and tabled until such time the staff was presented the correct information. Public Hearing closed 8:30 P.M. Member McDonald moved. Member Sime seconded, to approve the Plat of Southview Estates of Mr. Raymond Kloss at 3773 Togo Road based on the following conditions: 1. At the time a building permit is issued for Lots 2 and 3, Block 1, Southview Estates the following fees must be paid. Lot 2, Block 1 *= $290.00, 1/2 water unit Lot 3, Block 1 = $290.00, 1/2 water unit 2. Access to Lots 2 and 3, Block 1, Southview Estates must be from Northern Avenue. 3. The aforesaid plat shall be filed by the City of Orono with the Hennepin County Recorder’s Office on or before October 23, 1983. Motion, Ayes (7) - Nays (0). Zoning Administrator Mabusth reviewed this application with the Planning Commission. Mr. Nelson was present. Member Callahan moved. Member GoetLen seconded to deny this Conditional Use application based on the following fli-dings: 1. Applicant does not have required area to permit a second residential unit. i [.*• - 'I •I i V' f. ■>. #7A0 - EDWARD T. 2A30 Carman Stree Variance #7A1 - WILLIAM S 1360 Cherry Placi Variance + Condli #7A2 - CRAIG OLSO 1960 Shoreline Dr Conditional Use Pi ■ >• ; _ _ ju • -j ■ ‘ ■ HV -^.r. ■ = •• /t ^ * A _tfrW.7-i wv i PAGE-3- th owner of problem time and place /ision request ling Administrator Lon. ling this applica- nission at this :t and therefore >led until such formation. , to approve the 3ss at 3775 Togo for Lots 2 ai.d 3, >s must be paid, jnit jnit Lew Estates 2 City of Orono 5n or before ipplication with •sent. led to deny this .lowing fividings? ) permit a second ■ ■ • -n>s im ■ y .'vVi: ... - J*mm //740 - EDWARD T. LEHMAN 2450 Carman Street Variance //741 - WILLIAM SINCLAIR 1360 Cherry Place Variance + Conditional Use //742 - CRAIG OLSON 1960 Shoreline Drive Conditional Use Permit 2. Rental of second unit ceased in 1978. The rental of the second unit cannot be permitted per Ord. 31.105. 3. Guest house use cannot be approved because lot standards of the RR-IA Zoning District cannot be met. 4. State Statute prohibits the City from approving a second residence on the property ~ municipalities cannot issue use variances. Staff must determine the necessary structural modifications in the subject structure to remove classification of residence. Motion, Ayes (7) - Nays (0). Member Goetten moved. Member McDonald seconded, to table f.ne application for a Variance for Mr. Edward Lehman at 3525 Shoreline Drive regarding 2440, 2450, 2470 Carman Street. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0). Mr. Sinclair and Mr. Ted Rozenboom were present regarding this application. Member Goetten moved, Member Adams seconded, to approve the Variance and Conditional Use Permit subject to the following conditions: 1. Applicant must follow temporary erosion control method setforth in City Engineer's letter dated 4-18-83. 2. Alteration of lakeshore yard shall be done in 2 stages. (First Stage - foundation work ) Second Stage - Alteration of lakeshore bank) the work to be completed within 24-48 hour period. Motion, Ayes (6) - Nays (1) McDonald Voting Nay McDonald stated her reasons for voting nay are as follows: 1. A negative precedence setting for a 75' setback standard. 2. The foundation could be repaired without causing major land alterations. 3. The 60 dump truck loads of earth to be removed are excessive. 4. No erosion problems of the bank, no obvious erosion problems of the existing lakeshore bank. 5. You would nullify the Intent of the existing ordinance. 6. No visible hardships. Member Adams moved. Member Callahan seconded, to approve the Craig Olson at 1960 Shoreline Drive subject to the following conditions: REPRESENTATIVE TO //743 - WILLOW PRO! 350 Willow Drive Subdivision MINUTES ADJOURNMENT RESPECTFULLY SUBMl M. SANDI WOYTCKE DEPUTY CLERK lot »e met. iving a es cannot necessary re to remove to table ehman at Carman L-r- . ; approve to the trol method Ln 2 stages. Alteration thin 24-48 IS follows: >ack standard. ■sing major ed are excessive, erosion problems ; ordinance. approve the horeline Drive •r.J; Iff PAGE -5- REPRESENTATIVE TO COUNCIL 1. To allow expansion of auto repair to include transmission and engine removal and replacement of parts. 2. Repairs on trucks limited to vehicles of 1 ton capacity or less (light truck) 3. All repairs are to be conducted within the existing build ing. 4. Operation limited to parking of 10 cars and/or light trucks for maintenance/repair. 5. No storage of boats on property. 6. Building Inspector to inspect tanks prior to operation. Motion, Ayes (7) - Nays (0). Chairman George Rovegno will be the representative for the May 9, 1983 Council Meeting. //743 - WILLOW PROPERTIES, INC. 350 Willow Drive Subdivision MINUTES ADJOURNMENT Zoning Administrator Mabusth reviewed this application with the Planning Commission. Mr. Gary Peterson was present regard ing this application. After Planning Commission discussion, the following items and infcrmation must be submitted to the City before a Public Hearing can be called: 1. Preliminary plan designating the following: a) lot areas (amount of dry and wet) b) road outlot 50' in width c) 200* of width at road and building site d) Building envelope 50' front and rear setback 30' side yard, 50' if side yard abutts a street e) Wetlands should be designated as drainage easement with angles and bearings noted - all wetlands should be included within defined lot lines. 2. Additional Parcel to be included in plat - originally held under common ownership by K. Mix. 3. Septic tests for each lot. 4. Property owners list (350' radius) and addressed stamped envelopes. Member McDonald moved. Chairman Rovegno seconded, to approve the amended minutes of the March 21, 1983 meeting. Amending the wording of the Molly's Corner motion. Motion, Ayes (5) - Nays (0). •y Itember McDonald moved. Member Sime seconded to adjourn the » meeting at 10:30 P.M. ^ RESPECTFULLY SUBMITTED M. SANDI WOYTCKE DEPUTY CLERK ir V,-. PAGE -5- de transmission ton capacity or existing build- d/or light trucks to operation. itive for the ilication with is present regard Lowing items and >re a Public :back 1 street ;e easement elands should - originally Iressed led, to approve ting. Amending 0 adjourn the mm t.. ■ 'ij l:> Uii- \%' :4 .r .-'.ii WmM 9 ^ Cl CT</ ^ ✓' s' s /n— FROM I , L < ^ 3 - 2) L/STS' Di^ (p-1 Zi O^ 1 SUBJECT R.U/' Tfi OuSlri l^arf^ KC^DATE //I In P1 (/C-e^vC>- ^>^y ^^ ”9."C (1 ^ Or o p-^ ^ D < g.c /-/ /. ^ Ci>i^f>3 irrCc- kicprd> p y tk li ^^ ~Tou^^rj<; ^rc p^^k.y_ I <^X -Whe /s rt> XI wi rt t y y /-t- c^vi 6-g “b uj —- . » ' 7^ .7 I - / ^Ih oi \rc>'B ^-c5-/ a<Tc i- iMy 3-‘4c / lol^M^S u//'6k. s c/^/^rvig^ 4^ IT i Ue' V/O'_____________4 k iou/dtrJ^ to r-f> bUcr rc>•(::c* r (r*> p/ale</ —!; lb ly Ii3i/rv^g r ^ lola-^k \’c p^^J. ^ Q.lso frU-e.____/^ f>ry'ch %Via I'f nci- he^ ai ^ 1 p9^rk/>i>) ^/?BC'^ •Mirv*'* I SIGN ED 72(lMXyU<.^n^-----0M£/ SEND MRTS 1 AND S WITH CARBON INTACT. - RA k T 3 Will BE RETURNED WITH REPIV. R«di^rmo 4S 472 Poly Pok (50 sets) 4P472 a.uc ocu. I f ,1.11/,n.c.,j,•irnuiM r«xwt~i« MC ?O.T»r»jJ ft m i 0) CO =»fe PNVMtO fUMIVWM»m lOMMo T. UiNMAII or un ?. M.OCR I. MMMMC. AW LOTS t -«. fcOCA I. ttllWII ACQITmi r <■ I. ft,. « OOUNTV 110*0 MO IS m fr ¥' =»l 1! H{l t •’ .1! il^l 111i'i ' rM| 4ii (4< 11 ii|5 M f I i ^ ‘f. is » ; I f 111 ^ iiJ I'lli: i'i| i 1 liii'ii 0 5 u I ll- |’"'|''|'-* S'*"! tVii'irfruirit j -,t .'i;; tmmitiMwr* f i'i;^ E * ■* * >^v^...___k.r^i ,:*S| > :'i m