HomeMy WebLinkAbout#3704 - variances-1996 i. �
� O�
O O
�e � C ITY of OROND
� �
ti
�� G�' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
t�kESH��� NO. e`� f� � � �
A RESO�.II'I'ION GItANTING
VARIANCES TO
MUNICIPAL ZONING CUDE
SECTION h0.22, SUBDI�ISIONS i (B) AND 2;
SECTION 10.55, SUBDIVISION 8; AND
SECTION 10.56, SUBDIVISION 16 (C & L)
FIL� #2063
6'VHE�AS, Gerald R. and Candace E. Rowlette, husband and wife, (hereinafter
"the applicants") ar-e o�vners of tlie property located at 3775 IIayside Road tivithin the City of
Urano (nereinafter "Cily") and legally desc:ibed a� follows:
Refe� to E?chibit A attaci.ea, Hennepin County, Min:ic:sota (hc.r;;inafter "the property");
and
VVH�REAS, the applicants have applied to the City for variances to Municipal
Zoi.ing Code Section 10.22, Subdivisior,s 1 (a) and 2; Sectien 10.55, Subdivision 8; and
Section 10.56, Subdivision 16 (C & L) to per.Ynit the reconstruction of a deck to the lake side
of the e:cisting residence to be installed within the exact footprint of the existing deck located
SQ' fi•om tlie shoreline where a 75' setback is required resulting in 423 s.f. of new hardcover
improvement where no hardcover is allowed.
- NOVV, THEREFORE, BE IT IYESOLVED by the City Ccuncil of Orono,
Minnesota:
FINDINGS
l. Th:s application �vas reviewed as Zoning File #2063.
2. The property is located in the LR-lA, Single Family Lakeshore Residential
Zoning District requiring 2 acres in area. The property consists of 33,960
s.f.
Page 1 of 7
� °�
0 0 �
�b - CITY of ORONO �
a �
�� �'� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
�9kESH�4'� NO. � `� � � ^�
3. "The Orano Pia�uiing Ccnu�iissioiY revie�.ved tr�is applic�:t�on cn Nlarch :8, 1996,
ari�: recornmend:,•d appro:�al of tii� proposed variaiices base�l u�oc� !l�� f:�llowing
unique fin�ings a.i:d h��t�sl�ips:
A. The deck is deteriarating and cannot be used by applic�infs in ils present
condition.
B. The deck will be replaced within the same footprint as the existing deck.
C. In 1976 the applicants received variance a�proval for the existing deck
that was to be ;ocated 2' closer to the lak� than the dec�: that was
constructed.
p, Har�co�;er within t.ie 0-75' �etback area �vill remairi at 4.0��%
E, A lanc�sca_pe area u�lderla�n with plastic lccatec_l ���itYiiri �he County ri�ht-
of-��ay shall be. rem�ved. Tl:is �vill result in ihe �emoval of
approximately 660 s.f. of hardcover.
F. In a 1988 variance application, applicants removed 146 s.f. of cement
patio within the 0-75' setback zone.
G. During heavy rainfalls the property receives major runoff from the
developed properties to the north.
4. The City Council finds that tlie conditions existing on this property are peculiar
to it and do not apply generally to other property in this zoning district; that
granting the variance would not adversely affect traffic conditions, light, air nor
pose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely
serve as a convenience to the applicants, but is necessary to alleviate a
demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is necessary to preserve a substantial
property right of the applicants; and w�uld be in keeping with the spirit and
intent of the Zoning Code and Comprehensive Plan of tlie City.
Page 2 of 7
� °�
0 0 �.
�d - C ITY of ORONO �
.� �
�� G'�' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
��kESH�g'� NO. e� ��,` �.� �
5. The City Council'has considered this application iricluding the findings and
recommer.�a�ions of the Plani�ing Conimission, reports by C�ty� staff, comments
by the applicants acici the effect of the proposed variance on the healih, safety
and welfare of the cenimunitv.
CONCLUSIONS, 012DER AND CONDITIONS
Based upon one or more of the above findings, the Orono City Council hereby
grants variances to Municipal Zoning Code Section 10.22, Subuivisions 1 (L) and 2; Section
10.�5, Subdi��ision 8; an� Section 10.56, Suhdivision 16 (C & L) to permit the construction
of a deck within the same foot�ririt as the existir.g deck and grants a 17' or 22.G°a lalceshore
s�tback ��ar;an��e alid h�rdcover variance �vitiiin the 0-75 setback area uf 4.0=�%, subject to the
foflovv'lilb conditions:
1. Applicants shall remove landscape area tuiderlain �vith plastic at 660 s.i. in area
located within the County right-of-way as shcwn on Page 7 of this resolution.
2. Applicants are advised that if they plan to install a 1' high berm within the
County right-of-way that such improvement plans will rec�uire approval and a
permit from the Hennepin County Department of Transportation.
3. Authorities grarrted by this variance run with the property not with the
applicants, but are permissive only and must be exercised by application for a
-- building permit within one year of the date of Council approval, or this variance
will expire on that date (March 25, 1997).
4. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this
resolution shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically
terminate any authority granted herein, and shall be punishable as a
misdemeanor.
Page 3 of 7
� o�
0 0
�e _� C ITY of ORONO �
� �
'� RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
��9kESH���G NO. � r� `'� � _�
5. "I'he urid:,rsigned a��,l'tcarits have c�ead, utiderstooil ��d hereby agree t<� tl�z terms
of this resol.�ition �and on behalf of themselves, their heirs, suc�essors and
assigns, hereby agree to the recording �f L�11S Ie501Ut1G11 lil tillE C�lt14i1 Ol 1111C 0�
the property.
Adopted by the Orono City Council on this 25th day of March, 1996.
AT ,F.,ST':
� �
. �
, �c...
Uorotl�y I�1. II� liri, City Clerk Ed�varcl J. Call� an, Jr., N?ayor
�-C�it?GK� � � -��'`"'�"Q'�" ---
Properry O�vner(s)
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
)ss.
COLJNTY OF HENNEPIN )
'The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before l.ie ou this 25th day of
March, 1996, by Edtivard J. Callahan, Jr. & Dorothy M. Hallin, Mayor & City Clerk of the
City of Orono, a Minnesota rnunicipal corporation and said instrument was erecuted on behalf
of the City.
j �.��-G�--
JAMIE L.BOSMA Notary P lic
NOTARY PUBLIC-MINNESOTA
t�, e�' HEN\'EPIN COUNTY
,,, ��� My Conm�ssion Expires Jan.31,2000
.. -_,.__._..�..�s."�`�'�;��.W��r,ce;:�?:,:�.
Page 4 of 7
� o�
0 0
�e - CITY of ORONO
� �
�� �,'�' RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
L9kESH�g'� NO. i3 r� � �
STATE (�F MIN?�TESUTA )
) ss.
COTu'N"I'Y OF HENNEPIN )
+
On this 'S day of �}Q�; � , 199(� before me a Notary Public within
and for said county, personally appeared L'q n d a c e � �ou�% � �h��r'�G'�
l:r.own to me to be the person(s) described in and who executed the foregoing instrument, and
acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free act and deed.
�
, ���.: LINDA S.VEE 1i12c�ic% �• �/��
NOTARYPUBLIC-��INNESOTA N T��r pLJBi,1C
e..;;� .,,-o' HENNEPIN COUNTY
My Commission Expires Jan.31,2000
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this a�D day of , n , 199� before me a Notary Public witlun
and for said county, personally app ared .�x- ��' ' �
known to me to be the person(s) described in and who executed the fore�oing instrument, and
acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free act and deed.
�
�z /'���_
�`��'�` NOTARY PUBLIC
`; JAMIE L.BOSMA
NOTARY PUBLIC-MINNESOTA
�' HENNEPIN COUNTY
`-•� My Cammission Expires Jan.31,2000
Paje 5 of 7
• �3
, , \ \
' k� f� � � � \ -
ti r-' L '" e+ 'p L. t+' �7^ \
D C: t � G� C �{7 v ��7 � �` � ^ � 4+ �+ O [n �Gy � � O r�`�
� 0 �.. FZ m � 0 � �� �* < = I"'' � ,�
m *` .. C) e,*'.'a � � c'` � L� D O j � � G .3^.� e� ` c. `� O CJ ^ c9 V+ O \ 4
= N TfS � m � � p m O CG ' C "�'i "'� "'� � C O '7 .. N 7 n '-S � 7 c�* t �
� m K �h�1 ro � '-� � rn O cD r-� r* 3 c' .-' N � ��-
. C�� � a O O � �C laJ C "� "i J cf O � � � p D =� c* 7 c'� � e'r e� >`9 F+ ;'� � i i
0'7 � G !J J t C'f �' t"f 'Y " �-�- � T. r-'�. (: .T, � " �" = \
"'f � =r-�j r h �' ? � � � p � � D O 'S [J G � w -• � � � � ��!�i
� •r`-' o m f* e+� p � �i "� � j a. e" � � �,.� � N O c n O r-' � ^� �3 e'+ 41 `� _
� n,c o � '� r-� - ;, � µ .. o � c� � r��
ro r� o r-� O cr -e e+ o r* � ... e� ri � r � c� � r- --� co � o j.
o ^ '� �+ � o�r� �
`� o � d r � � � o � ° '� .�- c�* �' � � o �. � o � � K � � o r — � � �` �_
�..� � � � ` � [J f� "'� � � hr .r. C'7 � - f+ � � ��„ r, , G. CJ r: � _ / 'y ""�-�-.
� t'* G. v' D m '< � � _'�-' -
w.- � c- = " t �.. � N < :, c �-I X � �.
� � �+ o �' m T _ � c- :,� o + � �� n � � o a r a o . �
� ;�. -w ..., m ._— .n � o 0 0 �,, .. -� •, a c+ _,;:..•_ . -
' � � rr„' �. �~.. o � fi� � o r+ :- 'S y o - ,� �, � �� o T a.c� � ID � � / �.
� y � m � � -r µ S -� � rs o � r ,� r c� o - r` _ —
� m o P .:J y r+ � '01 � S T� r rr � n c� rn+, y S :J c* � � n [n � S ` .
S 'C - ;� r ^ � � D ^ � �
� ...� � �, O O n "� � � W p C' = O "S O ^' r r-'�G n � S b � :. 7 � "' - � �
- "'� '� � � � N - .-, C '7 � `5 , .... � � m O..7 ? O < � t
n � � m o� c► �i n m � O r� e= _ � �` � c r-� r' � F'' �r,� '-` r�- � ^� � � I
� �C � o fl t+ m m � •3. ... '� a. 'i r O '2 � O �.� m C "S _ � I
Lr rl f''' `+- f+ !� "i '�3 [* m -� � G r.. � G: ✓ � �+ r ,� ., �� �` � 61 - � "f
D .� "f A `� .^." ..'�i *') 1-'= � t' � p '..�.. �; c-r C : ? � � � "" ' -� .. v > '� '-` i . .
:A m � -r ^ C7 � 'i 3 ^ Q n p r� 'i � J "R L: '-� c� =� ' -- . � �'.
� �
S J �
. c} c ? � � c� � � � �* �' y ' ' c. � o � c� o ^ .�.�e � .r � � n r c c� n y Y D _ ....... I . ' .--
� t•c o o a x r�.,. ^! o _ � _ =- � � �` c� ci G :� , � � i ��p .. �
� ., r � µ...s � ` rr F c* '7 r = � _.. x :� � ;, u. � � n 7 f- :: L:
� � � � � a v, o c O � cr t-'- � t � }'- '-'. ;� y �' � � y p D u '� � � � ;;, � � � �
m m�t p �. �t a � � ^� 'C r � v, � � m S �. r' m 7 � r � c�+� � -' tn O 7 �+ e�► i
C - � 4 �
G � 7 � � e-' � O
�, rs e+t� �. m r. o � � �,, `* cs w a ci •�^r �� � o _ � � --� ~� -� � � � _ I
�, J-� � � C v m _ �, �..D c�_�_ _ � � o N � � � c� 9 h -' o � o�
c+tiG *` � �' o �` � � y '< -� o � • r o o � � t � .� o �n -s
� D ' c�*n cy* �-! � � L� .3 � �. �: ..�i t t: � 0 `� � '^ n r� --> � �`.� � � r = _ I .
6+ o fi � •^J � ? c* f+• � � � � � � � � �� � r•� C> � � ..� C�0 0 � v� --j ^ �'" �' -�- �
O p O. � � � T �, � C9 c-�-' N p � � �. CL ' e^* r o µ 0 � ��,,, --- !� W .O a � �r ..�'. � N r�j .� '
: � S O %� t� � _ � � }.. c �-1 G ;.� _ y rr ^i � c* ^f .. C� � c�* �
CC F-' � � '� �„ + m O ^ " � ❑ c} � t �« C�.� "J � ►J_• � � ',� r K O. G� '� C L' � � � _ I
i5 � Qa O c+ .. td m c'F G O C� ... II..r. Y• � O O �.:� y �wj, c� r :J �'' � :'� � O c* O �- O � _. ? ?� y
3 :7 ID I+ '1 !,` C � t � f!� :^ � � � � -- �G • C) � . X
� O O 1-'' =) ?—
ic+ a r. � :l� n �, G � c* �. � c '� � .� y � r+ � cr � 'V � r, — y p h � �.. rJ � �s • r� �"" G � .
`--, � � :-� o � _ � � ,`�.,. o ` � � = o c �'� � --, :� c� µ c+ -�.c. �. c � _ µ � ., ' r ..�_
. !� � � µ � •� �„.� � � ^' � ... � ~ '� "~J `, T•� � t-` r = � " p � 'i � "� � .'�'� L• ^' � .-. -i' � J < >
� c �56+ ^� � O ~ � � ^ � � � � r . O ✓� .C -� O � � y =. 0 y tn � � � �-I c�+ i+ -r � c+ �' � �
' 7 cr � � � h�+ "'� e�? £ i-� :n �' � n >J -- .� y � � � � C � = r-'_. �,, J ... �,
�. � c �c* e�* Y � � � : .r �., tv "'r r.. r- r tu ^ 5� ^ .: p r� 3 ' tn � � r- L`� c� n �.
F'� A = � � L.t j � � � � D O cy* O � n. ^ � ;? :+. D � = L: :..'�.7 � "S v'� � �
j ^ .^_. �� m 7 Y ? `tD � � '� � G � .,, . �� G � [', =� '7 '-�'G .... J � ,,,,, f n = r � c+ 0 " d
- !�s G _ a � C� � �-�- o v, � t� � ... �: n � n a� '�'' � y � C•_• :�' �x„ � c.; 'o o = o . - � � ,. � p. � � c�
� ~ o �S O .... � _, T• - cD •.; -s � ^� •i �3 -i � � � t F r �-• � ,� c� � .. � :� �._ o c m
� fr,,,,� p c+.. r�- � � � r a. h� ' µ O � - � � � T ; - � "J "�
, m � � � � � r, _" ry � � = -� `r £ � W ro •: � i� '� p n � :-i n f* +-- 'o-� � T� ? � _ _' � w � '� �' "� ``
1 � r (D IL O m � ��$ �S .� 7 v C� �J Gr V �� �. � � W� �..f �' V.) .L ��� � �.y �. n.s �V) ('T � 7 _ �� �r � F�� f+
[5 : [: `9 f�'` ;� n � �= � ` ') 1�- `., j_..„ J '� C� �
I .�. .. p � C* � � tc '7. r3 � T � � � � � v � Y .�+- � t-' � -� � � v` j � G `t, i� C ;� ' `7 p 7 F� � "D'1
� , � �r �. 7' '� = � � '`'f t� F+ lJ :) ^ ... �r Y. O �`� 7 J. n � ~ ` �` , L: O � � c* `i ^! r-' r-' � T�''� .`�' `c*.. � ^-
1.+� -"�+ f" 0 E , � � � �� �i c~!',� n �* - C � 7 :C a �h , .�r t � t F� �. � � '�
- � � `�.'r .� y � � �G r� c � n' � � � ? c� c: � c� �� -s � � .. � �s = � �- ,�b; ; o � � '� � r � r� � t � `
. � r.+. K C h' c'� � G O O 'S c` �'' �' ` r p .. . � � 7 S " p, :y ' y ; ! f �-. � V+ �'.
;� C O .� ^ �
� '.D C � n7 `- r Z SS �� L� ... � := c�+ 'v�
� ^ � � � � � � �''� �" G 'J ""S t- � C G � "i � � �' G � p � ►+ 3 C'� ►'.� � .'�-f � L' O ~' y'" �
m � O 2 „'� ''S L '� � ¢ t� -► = r � � y � � G,.. .y tn ':� '�' � � 'S " � n ` � r -n p e+ G�
Z o'� a p� «� Lp "! O �'' � � c� �" y �� ^ Q c�'r "' ♦ ^ L }� � G � O O t� : ^ '"` - � '< e��C ��
-oi e^� c�+� � � � "� � o� v o � � o L � � � .�. ;s o �, ? :s r� � ,� r �c -� c_ = r : - � J � �.. .
7' . c* O= G '-` LL: � C: .• � t�-' � �: �* C c� F, � � r`' y � _ � � � ,J• D .� � ""_ � . �:
o � � — o m a � � y � � � r�s � r o � � � . -_ c« � c � �
a � m K o` ao �'c+ � ;�- � r-,^ �- � � � r�-,� r= o ►roo c c o � � _+ Qa. a � � c -: � G o � N '��
m w o K e o o �" . = :.� r � �•., .. c. o C ... J � o w n 'c o ; ~• �- - � .. (
� �^ � � .. � K `' •' - -
� „i Q � ..5 � m n � r°, Ge* G ,` � U o� � �. r�-� � n �^ � ^ � � O � C " r � 4 c J' � � � � � �
F� ""� c't
: `,C c* U � p O r-h � � .� c' :� � G � C c^ 7 � � � n-�rr •- O �. % � ';: � 'r r. `' ^ �," � � � �
i+ II fl r t-' � p ��-� W � v^ � . .�.7• G. D G _' -. � ' ..._ :J
� ' � ¢3 O O. ft t� I ^ F~+ O 7 G. P � t* � '� y� � .J+; 03 C'1 !, �' O 'FJ �� �' ^ " � � ' N a 'T
W� m � � � _ � � � � � � 7 O G 4'� �..'� f�• �* � � C � e'+ ,,, � e� +- ►�+. � ~
'r
� C7 � � '7 D a� • D � ` � p
_ _ n r- < � .,
n c* r+ � � ►'' r ^s ,q .. � -��s o '� � o� r - c 3 � o r� v ^ c. .
� o � � r
T G h� i.. O A ,> . � C �� tL � f,,, •.s ,r� ca N � v t
. m m� J U V r+ � "'�'y D �: � � = C1i "S G �J �"S Cr � .S Cr �_/ • � � O O
r '-"' � f� � � — 7 � � � p ^ � O C a e�► r-+
� Oi O O � G.� O � i"' a t :A � � � r+- p. O �' �' `� � � � .. O �' % • ..CS V- � � "'�
� i� � ^� V � .^.. L: � r G c� , .
~ � � ?. �. [c c* � � �" t � K cr O (^ "� 'f T ::. = r' : �" a n
� � Lo W m '7 � .�g G, m ►.'' e� p �. C €' 'y � O O �" IJ G� � O � O, p � -- '" G `t t' ��..i e'•
. o .... °' � e* �.z'• � ry � c o ►�� � �
r' �
� .�-� m o � � c+ ^ � p �` ►.+ c ,� `= � '
• � w ts. ''v O `� "'j = � p c* � � m � � m
� � G. m e"r "'S ,,,�r m "' iD . .
• _O 7� � i . • . , •
c'► "
Page 6 of 7 '
I� - - -- _ __._ _ �'7�:'� �' � i'�`�'� .
�`� ';c:_� �» .
�,- ... � , _ . '_ .;�. .
' . \ � �� � F:'„L'r;y.'}J ..••1•;n4{41:
` � , ' 1ylrTf�I�f,F`!'�:•' '�•�''
I 7 .�'�-�1 �:1�. .
�u �� .`.{:i rl r ��..:�,���.+i r
,I _ •.:• ' O �I ;� 1'� � .'n��,..�
� :,. N 'r�S.���� ? �t�,�,i.:
' w y, ,���i, ,yt`.< <.r.;.
,.°`•"' '�r'f, ti',:d� � !�'t
� � "�.sc, i ?1"� `�'�'.
A �s� �Eiv :��,.���,��j �;.i
• e � � ;>t;� =%`�r� :{{{f',
. ` I{D�` •k�� �( JJJ�nn�}f((,.>'{
� •A \ � - ;���� ].' I� .
��J r, . � O ` �,.1���� ` /�''
•� , � • .. ✓'/ j,• ��1`�� �.
jCA.. I�� ,j �;L}���' ,` :�(�.: •
/' � � �`\' .. �'O� \ {����K�1{• !1`V. :'L'�:{ .
1 S� 1
' : I �' �-�� �11'�7l f ���,r.(���`j�`r �
�.`� '
b I �"' � i' '\ `� f. ^ ~ �' il,'�'i�Y�'�.�1� .
• y �, i; , , � _ ► ;,�' � 6
I W rit �7,�- .i1,t�"� . •��,sl�' ��t�?�.�! .
; , • l . •,klif� ���^�;tita.
•1 . J 't � , 4 � .\ .. ��j� -�.�YC
' ,. � 'r,�` "� � 5 �'���
.\ . "'' � �., .�s'',.� '1`'"t
, F � � � ;j � ::;3',
� � �� �•, ., �;
�. .. ._.._.... _.....__ --- � ` x � •� r ,j�.
L ._._.. . . .k�oa ----� . � 'r • , . _ . �f E'�`
J .t j �. ., �-;
, :� :;
� `. . .�
• ; � � .� . ; ,
� '� �
r� � ' f�'� r b � .t �i � I�,
�' ``� � . �; 'fr. ��';:
A ( � � �� .�'` .'��:'.
e• �'��: •' b � I _ I� I �`� „�K`:�.. .
,� \ ' �^^, r r I C � � I :.�-1 S!�..!.
, � • 1 � ' , ::i�'�'�'` ���'"• �� ?,x'�',ti A., �Yi,`.`� �;,?�j \
'� 7 D ,,I�f�•'l' X
\ ��... ^�{���; �1 4wy �t � +fd���1
�p'�+y � I Y ' <�1'� '�-�
. . . 't ��� o y . 'i��� ,'4� �i1 � ` is.
, d � I y, � � F �� ����
EZ�'�� vJ�f.�'' ;,�:'.
. .'° _ ` � ,i'�'! ^�'' n� ` ;ti R"'
D �l :i" y f� �n :
, � , a�t •, ;x: �.i"�:1'r
;. �. �.
f � `�a
� ,, ���i
. I ; ��,:
. , �,
, �
��� �
` I �.
I ' ���r
�\ I A �V.
I \ I 1 � �r�.:�.�:
i . � r. x1 :'• ,.i.)'.
I ` .. 1 � .. . Vti': �\.
� . . I � �` L . "
'1 ,a �,::1�,..i.
�� � i ..� � e i V� ��µI,(`.t��.i
_ ..' • �� � • .. `�I �� Y"T�j • .
� � . w 1i ��%�T'...
` J 1 `1 _i ' � ��T=�j.r
• �'t ' i ^� o� .`:�� i k;�ijT
. I � �� �. :�,�>�;�; .
. . ln • � ' '`� f^'�
� . � �� ����,'`.
i �", �'.
� � _i ' � `.;' � ;4- f ��:
� ' v- . �:L' ~��': .
. . �� .. ��� '��1
p � . .„; Yi1:-��k
• • . � , � � i ? ���� �,�1�-��i��'r
.1� t T .477<< `
I�y
.,�•- ` yx`��'�
r� � � � J;S,'',_
I �;:L;
. • �� I 1�: ::.�5:
•, . , •���;,
.._. •' \ I ... �� ��r}�a�i
'Lb �� � '';�''4j ` � ,
- ,o � . �' ';i�� :; s����
\� �J ! a:�` , ,��.
,.� • I \ �:.(��' •; • r4
� ' • � 7
J� � �� �'�`i1
' + c° . '. ,����
� .:.^;� t�r,,��c;. C
i � � ' . � `:� �':�'`L�t � i:-r 1 `
' ' , Paae 7 of 7 .�. . ;��:,��f;�'�,,,jrM1,4' I