HomeMy WebLinkAboutRes 1839 c k r r,,g �,�
" a"3'��:�*� �a,,`f4`�;� ��,:."� �v, ; S �, 4 ; .. . r � , �y <,�.-
�� ��� '_��.;n �^f�� � 1 '�v r - �s ' : ✓ '# �' '� �
.�y � ? `�y��$b �Kk� + �A �. �, � H .� � �
aµ � � �Z e.�
f 'c '���;`"�,Y',��xa17�t`�U rv, `+r `!� �
Y�`..2�7' T nky t�/„�s � �3a� �� ,y,atTrtl�;�'2"y` ertk .} x... ha'4 �5� r .� ,�.f '�97 �' k�� � q ' �� � � T,� �' it �.
1 t�� "� 3 �i r�f,` � '�6� � F y;���` �LR Y sh r rl��. nR'b F .. �a+t, .,��,����r�����. sw� �.
�� ,y
rs.��, �5�,� ��� N ��y.. � i �7��e�' :+; �4 S :;T ' yi<l a�.+ � ���9 {a�f���y,�. �t� t�� `
� ��;W �. �k ���y.. a3a - �tc� °. d� { I�" � r u�a�c uly���d'���y'�`�`, €�� '
ai r �r ��4 �#�y�"$k ,,A x .',� is:� � "ky k "°° a ��,a�` ,' f 4t��; ,��`�
� .'��"t'tii�" � � 1�4�`�1�y� ;. ,L� �.3 Y a�,�"� "�,.A� ? a,�p r ,. O�,� f - � .,� b .�,+.. 9 5 t. .,�F,'k� a rre', �ii �'"F,�-.
" . �, �,a�'.�r.,�'�+i.�fi! �� ¢-�t,rr �1 �" �� �� i S �` 1 � '4 4�� y. v�9 � � � 4i �,cY a�.'�u!i o y���� a+��,�::�.
s " � 7, r,p,y�, �",�t OG .a'� �i < t�. .�'.Y"'p '="�. � t �q° d N-�d49ri� TMl+�t �b�r ,{�a� i � � .,;r
� � �et� g .. a:w Si� :
�� .' � ..�.gt'�L'�� f �x��� t �, '� ♦ � s a�c : � �� t � � ��
4� r�� a t�l t� £ ..3 M �t s '{� L: � �,€kn� 1�' �; d, �i�,.�d FAt�,au� � �iEY „z� .:y ,
\-,. �a t �...� 1Y � s c r �(��a s« 4p .:! w y � ^7''F r� �v. f.R� ��� � K H y .k
�4 °C � §� ^ '4 J t {� P�� ,� '? ��g�'F 4 Y�:r{ ,yM �;` �Y. ♦ t .�€-
, Y, ����u a� �t "`Y r k �'so s ' et fl� �'`Y r j �}' 9�{t� � r�pz+„� r
y� �,�,;����'--1 t,y�jzg u�,�',s e +"�,- r �� i�r, _ a r �tftq, •y�``�h }r% �.�..
��-yv 'i k >Y,�n� t � A b u'" � �:
. } i J. �4. ?,'
,7µ r� h�1 �'�s''r� , _�`�'
� c'�' ��4 f a �": �s.�_�._ -�-
- >,-��� Ca;co �r.
' City ��' �N�71
RESOLUTION Of THE CITY COUNCIL
` �{O. 1 8 39 �
e•1„'.l,,,�'�.i
,r�
{r;,;"i'
A R;:S�3.LT�IOPi DS�I�Y:�G
AH AI�`!F''.R-TfiE-P�'aC,'� VFoi�t�14CE TO -�;
riQMICIPl1L EOliI1TG CODB
SF.I.'TIdM 10.03, SOBDriISIOii 15 (C)
A., AMEPiD�D Jl�i[JARY 28, 1935
FILB i9��
WHEREAS, James I:. Lear (hereinafter "the applicant") is
the owner of the property located at 3127 Casco Circle r+ithin the
City of Orono (hereinafter "City") and legally described as
follows:
Lot 2, Slock l, Colorado Springs (hereinaftex "property");
and
NHS1tBAS, the applicant has applied to the City for an
after-the-fact ��ariance to Municipal Zoning Code Section 10.03,
Surdivision 15 (C) as amended January 28, 1985 to permit a six
f�t high privacy fence that runs parallel with tho resr/street
iot line for a distance of forty feet located approxfmately two
feet off the riqht of way of Casco Circle where only a three and
; half foot hiyh fence is allowed; and
WP8&B1►S, the City Council of Orono (hezeinafter
'Council") has reviewed t�e fir.dings of the Planning Commissfon
an�i the City stnff nnd thc written and oral comments of the
applicant.
1ipp, TgERgpORE, B8 IT jtESOLVED that the City Council ot
Orono, Minnesota hereby denies the after-the-fact variance applf-
cation of James H. Lear based on one or more of the fol2owfn9
findinqs:
PIIiDIZ1GS
1. This application was reviewed as Zoning FiI� t944.
2. The property is located in the LR-2C Single Family
Lakeshore Residential Zoning District.
3. The applicant claims that the 6 foot high privacy fence
is needed to deter children frcm running intc+ thrz street
"after a pei, a ball or wnile playing a game". In con- {
sideration of the sloping topography within the rear yard of
the property, a 3 1/2 foot high fence would serve as a
deterrent.
.
Page 1 of 3
f� .»
� }�
h iE�
+n'4?'.T; �
q�- ��'� �� u,� r � '� q,, '* "'i a�'
�, � � ,'�adu � s��F �d j �S'�"` h,� x6'ti t>4�''r� L���. '1
,; � �� � t
M1. �����r� ,-r . .
:� �'x �e7 r ��.: e ` 5'"`,* .
c.. t�, i ,y,�. 1
" � t. �a" '�,� "c�{�� �t i �' .
: . �r�`1'i 'r�4Fa r, i s } i R %
�, �' �ta:i��^.,�ri^6J-':��,f a,5 �'.: �, ' �_� ." ,�:. �t r �.
�1: ,r,, i x t�c .. y I t�3 ' a Yvr•� :.t r
i5
r �„^ � i.. ti,��t.}�i g N#4z' a a . �, � � x� '�Q r � r-,y�. 1 3,� � t �,�
�' s, l.^ �s'r.A*'� t i '�,i�' t t•`n..�''+ �'a �2� ,r 4`} �' °�i+�t:"}"` '� "f'` A,. W's .
, .
s.. .., .: •.
.- .. - t,. , S .
.. . .p . , ;: �a:. ,
. . . i
. ,.. . ; .�. .„... , � . . ,:'.� ,.�
,
'
. „�_.._ 4 M. ,.
�%� S �� � �R�S yr�.�/1 �4S-��y�7 �s Fllti'SKj }i i ' .. ' '.
� ��,��a 'r�r�' . .
��, ���'t .� � �s ��1� `'7-}'y,ex' �'�it;�T�' �zyy,�''�d i� „i�h�A�',� ��sV''��P�'"-� x� S s-�-G,.. � e � � �'v
. � .. _ .�` 3 s - �� , N:� , ,�.,� ,,. . ., �w�a, ��. . . .
#�i �k`C.�' r ��",�,�✓ c��''�C,�y ��7"',�''�R�f��11+! t a '��r t �, , F t '` � *. ��. r.� �'. �� c��.
4t '�O`'�s �a� r�°! :�. � �. �t �,. y° j
� .�� � .� �.3
4 {r�� �� � +� ��'bNl.�� ��� �,�. 4�`a( r ,��v y. f- 1'S �� � .� r��
��_ 8 z5 �� '� !
+ ,v� �3n���' �,F b'��'�,'y�ta �°Y d : "�� ,. N � �.
�-. ��� �,7 4e�:: .. ,�� � r :t "'
,
, > }•' r
. �, ,��^� ,; '�,°��[9,4b s j'�ki�r�'� �xF "' � + ,"�,, �,> n � a � t
.e r �.< �t��,3`Tr r`�. r*".� � 3 � , , �. ' ,�,�k�' ' � + �'s r�y �
'� -.J-`; a !r y t` P � x Y3;. _
�:� Y�fi �y � � �� .� i — � f A�u. �� . 1V y i.�7�.i q Z ,y �.E
�.<�y 1a l ,"r �x�� a �. � r .T 5�..s`' .. � ��� a�#r a �-��;,$� 7� �'�v Y�^,S�"a¢�.
� '`µ � T� �yA"�^��(���3$ � d�31Z " 1 h . a.+, .�x ,�4,�1 r�1.� a�y,)�,4F�'�1 ����'�:� b �.F � �''Y2'`�"�F'�"t'rx'"�i.
t ��;�(� {�'+�; '^ r� �""'�i' 'a Y �"g F,,1 t-t'� ,�,�a�.� r },��'�;a � ��yK �
�' �� l`� ��� i'���;fr'��$��1$� ..�J l Tw'! �i :S � �''r ". 1 ti � rr���h e,,��;��ir t �,`�y' e�� `t�w`�"� 'ta�
� . � f''},,'�,���lf �,'� � � '�x°z. �%N,y#�.Ys�rykt:'. �'��r 4� N�v��'T'Rf'��7,��°���'}��d� r�'"'Y�i*`�*Y'R° '�s.::
i� 5,�
,� � $ ��'�a'� ���� � y � p � 3� �rM � Sb� k'y�� r �',�t`a !F'P + ,si 'Q}��"��� '���
k
J'{ t��1 �� �° �fi� �* A,-. t . . � , a9y�a ';�� ..a" 5 r'� 9' � x�
�, '��� �- {�1 t"�` �:i.� �r�°FtC� a �. y�Y� �� � � . �y�. R�S.�� f���,y�:��N�' °�� r ��, � x � �.
5 i 4�.;.7'v,y �wY: �g.,. 'd :N t'� t.,f r I'" �g. r }��.:
�IQ' t'"'.-S`�u. , 5,
' f.
. . �F Y'��I�'� V ;���liv:�� 1`�{+^'^;T�. .N�.
� Y
r
'+ �tg� Of ORC�I�O I
RFSOlUT10N OF THE Ctl"Y CO�JNCIL
� (yp, 2 839
♦.:; :.-.. �.
^`:►',a '`l``�
�„.;..�:.�'
4. The applicant clai.ms a 6 foot high privacy fc�nce fs
needed to block the vfew of the 'unkept" park acraas the
stzeet fraa his property. The Casco Circle Park vas deeded
to the City of Orono with specific direction that the pazk
be maintained in a natural state. The park exista today as
it did when the applicant purchased the property.
5. The applicant claims the fence providos to protection �
for his home and surroundinq improvements fzom vandalism. A
forty foot lenqth fence alonq the street lot line dces not
o:fer protection for a residence but may, in fact, serve to
hide vandals from t'�e view of adjacent neighbors and the
police.
6. A forty foot lenqth fence does not provide aecurity.
The fence is an inteqral part of the landscapfnq p13n and
ornamental in function nnd use.
7. 2he applicant has been advised that he may trim 2 1/2
feet off the height of r,he existing fence and mafntain a
leqal 3 1/2 foot high fence, two fcet ofY tl�e road riqht-ot-
+��ay but has refused to comply.
8. The applicant hns beun adviaed that he may move the
fence 30 feet from the atreet/rear Iot lina and maintain th6
f.:nce at the six foot heiqht but he has refused to comply.
9. Par Section 10.07, Subdivision 6 of the Municipal Zoning
Code.
"Zt is unlawful for any person to hereafter erect oz
structurally alter a btructure until a bui2ding pazrait
shall have been issued indicating that the existinq or
proposed structure and the use of the land comply with
this Zoning Chapter."
The applicant's contractor failed to obtain the required
bu:ldinq permit and as a result was never advised of the
zoninq standazds for fence constructioa.
10. The plight of the a�plicant is due tc cirrumstances
created by the ap�licant or agents of applicant.
11. If variances are granted to oermit a new fence 6 feet
in hQight, two feat off the road riqht-of-way, such action
would astablish a negative precedent in the review of
simiiar applications.
Page 2 of 3
. ,
.�4 k�4�t n$r ;aRi.E �`�.� �, "'F�c,k" .�5����',�qW �,
'7��F� y .X� ��'aj �" �,�h ..�,�,e�y} ,
„ # � , .. � ,�.
p ��m� �� J M
� b�� � �C . ?N ��'4.��F n �, �v.
�
! +
�� ��k ���g����¢ if i +. �..�� �"' �'*�:' `x�� ,Fa'�"r,_
� �4 . � R�,�Y "��� h � ° N�� �,�t'� •z,,,�t� � *� s �t,�
t� �j x a � ''���.� w1t i r�+�t� ' �' ,
#�} � '•y .�,��,.$�5 >.��u ,�`i 5�:�,� ��k""��� �.p�,�p����i' ,+v.w� �'�i ���y y'4m�t-z� ... i ? m,;��,.z� �� 'i F •t.
� � �
4y� �, i � ���: .� rU $�+ ns z ��t�^�;'� �r y, �"�y(� �%pt t� . ,. .,. .
�'.d!''i�� 4 k.:.; �`3.��" S4�` i':�.G�''r f r$�, �tx ,,�'' rt 1� �C-" ,� � `1 -'t�1 ��. �a�l st�u�i��;�'f 4 ,,�.� e �
"�� 5:. ^tr ; t� "'�i�'k3' n L�1 r5k' j,,,�p+. .t ��'� T'�'� '�.�v .,�,�.
- � - '� . q v M� \ � 2 }��� ^y� k qli.+
y�',fzr'�'4�3�'�31*`��'-u:-r�sr�k����.�y, �,�;;� a,„���s�:��.-'��������,'�`�h�.`�. +c'S`."y4Fs'N�' `:f5r""��'d'�� "y�`.�a '" �, �`g'� �"s*' �-_ t
5' f
. . .. . .. . ac3�- . _. , �. �,e. � I .. . . . n, .�..<��i�� 5... ., .. . .
.:,,.. !`� K' —[ ��:�,� ��`.I m �^ ' i`2z +,:'� �`'�`z,� .d" wJi� a,s� n �:^:. '§ h,. , . .f. . 4.�, 5
� ��� �r�"� ff � �r � r s'� -- �y�'"�'���'��t`N� ��v 1�.� �� �� ;�rr ' Y�,, . �" .
"� r ,F �y�� r' �� �t �` '� .
�4 + fi d' ��4��ry�h' �� !�'��� �� h�` �� ��' f� �d _ �yL .
r� �3 '" � ,,�, ��;�-t �� g�r .� x°` �*.���' "<�''�,�` ,,� .` '
�� �......,�...�_...Y.. - � ��
��� 9
'�� C��� �Df ��$.�No ' ..
�' -`��
RESGlUT10N OF THE CITY COUNCIL � ' "`'
.,t�1
- � �. IE34
,^,
' �4
��_
,'`,����T� 14
i�$
!
pOlttH$EMORE, �8 IT RESOLYED that the Council hereby � ��
denie� the after—the—fact variance epplication of JamasH. Lear aa� I
propused subject to �he condition that the applicant must zemove i
or malce the necessary al�erations to the existing privacy fence
in order to bring the structure into compliance with the zoing
code by September 30, 1985. Violation of or non-cocnplinnce with
this condition of denial shall con�titute a violation of the
�oni.nq code and shall be pur►ishable as a misdemcanor.
Adopted by the Orono City Council on this 26th day of t
Augu , 1985. �,
I
ATT T: _ ,
.
�`�(�.'�� \��\�
thy M. lin, City Clerk Mary C. $?�41er, Mayor i
�)
;
�
I
�
�
�
(
�
I
f
�
�
,
�
;
�
I
��:�
�
�a�,y�.�,
,. ,..;;,;.
Pagc 3 of 3 " t� '� E''
�� W:"-c�";
�
,,
u t,'� �+a;' '
r� }��'��
t � �,����
.a�.. .c A :'•Sr�.."4"�rnr.,� r �r� r. �,�a. +Y ' `n t:� ..-:�'x t ;. ta � ��„ '`� �'
`:k l a,h;�'�y�Y• t 4 �'k�"' ��.n 1"� ,, � �!'.&.��t:�`� e� e'��� ,,�y 1�.. r t G a s .� '���,,, .�xx s�
�rv � �a� �?-r�r,�p,,+� 0.�x` Ez�'�t i,��,�:h ;yy�,�� ���#�'���'. �y' ��" s`G�41s.t�t�?;r��cy„w �p�,}�7�'j.� �y�'�.�"�� Y���ri."�3i,�" r:'N�..
.., e�. , '-� . � w � � �� W' � �� �d �i� �fi�+a� �`� � ^` ^%}v�r��t�= ,,�SY�,s�,..,�
�"tH '.x+��A �r�y�a�z ,'� }�"'� #� a�,�s ,,.� ��'1'�cF �9"'���as�`�� �s��r �+ y, � v 4
iy,+ �;� t� ,� u•� s'�t�4 �$�j'{ x Ar�'w', ry� f }�� �',
�"� ;�1�+T.�,. .�/l,�'ri•'��':'�n�1(�"�.�l�S.a{u)tt�s�? p^l�°::R t,�,r� �,`,�� µ•��r k t�,�T^CF��iV��a•�.��y�+"i��'[+� � �� ,+K,� ^v.� �x4'�r�t k1}����� 1.S r
k°'�'' k�� .L 4 f Z� C Y'4 r "��. r � j �t�a � , s �
� �:� -� ��A� y� ��""x��' ,:'�.�,�t„`��*y'��'-� �i"�4'��f'� �.r s� �e 'f� ''ti_.,�r k�, l.�, t,�r��. '�,� +, � �� �,g -�.
7 y .���„�,� �� a �� ,s,, S 4 x i, r`+ r �r� ti, �+ �,��� � `� �
� � ,. yy � ,��, n `�*k�-a��. �� �'�,.°�y � +�r� u x r �`,' S'�- �� x 9�� �' �� �y��'.
. e �C _ � �, � � t, 1 �u` � t �' �� i �� �r�� `��� k�' r� � u��p� t�"�
>t'y, e�3h' ,� :yl �.. ;.�;R 5Y��r a ��i ��'.�.s t n`,s' '}P�� 'X' +
1F� �'�' s�' tk$��y� i «r�wa��.�F$�s� ���5 ��r� �.���ia�`��> � $�i.�i" a ns' ,4"� " �
,t� °' � r
. � tv . � ,c� � '���k3�t'� ���'�'��c �� ���' {,+ �f r� �� i � �ai , t h ry�.r s° � ,�*.
�{'iy sii r �s4,��+4. �"ti�'�p, � t }S k'.`����s 0.v A,fa+, ah^�"'K x e. ��ry� l ,�� �k P' .-
� +�'� 1✓ ':�^;' x ti 'h1-f , .fi* '� �`, �'�9'p����C'��'+,a 7 t-�: v., pA- o `a„'�p .
� i ` dy�; °�'�;'``�'���'�v'A'�T�*E �r"rS�,p`(a ��������^� Rs �r?Y.rA �io-w'���' . i�t���� �.i}tT � a�. � r�.
'� , l.C � L �Y'',y,g �rf',`�ri� p�7' � �!� l.�:,2 � 'S • y"=." �.
r,�, , p ,.''�' t'�E, e �,f�y�e�i F � �' i,� Yt �? �Y ;��. �"`< e" .'f�s.� -^� �.. g�p.�C�.
�� � '$���,�i �'�' ���� � ;,�';
R '� � . `�r ���'� �t T�t �t �`. *, � �.+ar;:
•- a � z w�, "�,. ^'� ��. 'k . �. � . .. ,� A�` e
, '3� � '' f r'� S':. �;�t,t� � u �t �,b� r ���'@v 7 ""- � ��. ��. + :
�� V p�•y, �-��' '� � � � � p 3 9• 1�t,•,�.
. Y _'j q�,,�y
'� .. � .j.. �'', z� � y , ,
. , k *iecfi r , .�{`!4 �� � r«$� �i���� ��� ,t ''' _r:�� �� r x� �et�� .wJ'�,c
�.�' ' i� . ., . .. . �� ... . . . , . . . . . . . . .v'.. .(:.
�Wi �{�, v t �.r,w,�t�;�a
�4 �A^'���7'. `tl' al y ,� °4'aa�'�Ivi9 t, A 9�°. d `•. C
�3± F.:
. , � . , �� . �. . .. 3 .T ..�„�� �r� _ _�.� . r,. . , _ r: ,.,a . � a, ra .,. ,