The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About04-29-2008 Board of Appeal and Equalization Reconvened Packet ,•�..�,�az�/ AGENDA RECONVENED 2008 LOCAL BOARD OF APPEAL AND EQUALIZATION TUESDAY,APRIL 29, 2008, 6:30 P.M. ORONO COUNCIL CHAMBERS 2780 KELLEY PARKWAY ORONO, MINNESOTA 1. Roll Call 2. Approval of Minutes - April 16, 2008 3. Council Action on Assessor's Recommendations 4. Adjournment • • E Daniel and Sharon Regan 3410 North Shore Drive DFRegan@msn.com Wayzata,MN 55391 952-471-9318 Lin Vee,City Clerk May 18,2008 City of Orono 2750 Kelly Parkway ��,�,,.,,,�,�� Oronq MN 55356 '�'�� Lin, r;;-�?� C�� e��t� When I received the attached letter I was surprised and disappointed. C�TYO��:��,,� I strongly disagree with the Appraised Market Value of$893,000 and will gladly sell the property for a mere$800,000 and make the purchaser$93,000 richer... anybody interested??? I disagree with the appraisal on three issues: 1�IARK�T VALUE We have lived in this house for more than thirty years and know that our house wouid never sell for $893,000 even when prices were higher than they are today. The public meeting of The Local Board of Appeal indicated that Market Value was based on"comparable sales data." Is"comparable sales data"available to the public? I would like to see how our Market Value was deternuned based on specific"comparable sales data." FAIRNESS The second issue is based on the premise that every property is valued at close to 100%of Market Value resulring in every property owner paying their Fair Share. If properties are valued at more than ]00%they pay more than a fair share and if properties are valued at less than 100%they are paying less than a fair share. Of course it is impossible to value all properties at 100%but the intent is to value all properties close to 100%. I downloaded property tax information from Hennepin County, for three properties in my neighborhood which indicate that my property is overvalued by a great deal. All three properties are on two acre lots(estimated)while our properiy is only a half acre,or 25%of theirs. All three properties have at least 200 feet(estimated)of lakeshore while our property is only 90 feet wide. All three houses were built in the last 10 years while ours is over 50 years old. Their houses are at least twice the size(Mac Mansions)of our 2,000 square foot home. The three properties face North therefore they have sandy beaches while our south facing property has a soft mucky bottom due to the prevailing Southerly winds. One of the houses sold for$2,100,000 in October of 2005 but is only valued at$1,709,000. T'he explanation given to me at the meeting was that"sometimes people pay too much"for a property. In this instance"actual sales data"was ignored in favor of"comparable sales data." If"actual sales data"is ignored or found to be unreliable the appraiser must be making subjective appraisals based on their opinion of Market Value. The appraiser is making subjective decisions as to which properties should be used or not used to determine"comparable sales data." In my experience appraisals and estimates are wrong by definition. Appraisals are a guess by an informed individual based on their experience and interpretation of the available information. The available information is"comparable sales data"as used and interpreted by the appraiser. Another Fairness issue may be the desire to encourage new construction by keeping property taxes low during construction and then for a several years after the house is completed. That policy makes it difficult to raise taxes all at once on these expensive houses. This policy is unfair to existing homeowners! Hennepin County Road 51 Our half acre lot is not really lakeshore property because County Road 51 is between our house and the lake. The Highway diminishes Market Value for the following reasons: T'he highway is three lanes wide in front of our house and grass will not grow close to the road because of all the salt used by the County during the winter. I estimate that the lighway-aad the damaged�-ass is at least 50 feet wide. It is dangerous for adults,children and grandchildren to cross the highway or play near the highway. The speed limit is 35 mph but most cars are going faster. The highway also encourages people from the Maxwell Bay Public Landing to trespass by fishing along our shoreline or from our docks. Trespassers also use our docks to pick up and drop off friends that have parked at the landing: it is too far for boats to go to Maxwell Bay through the channels. This trespassing causes damage to property and diminishes our Market Value. In addition to the soft and mucky lake bottom caused by the prevailing Southerly winds the Highway Department used rip-rap to protect the Highway from erosion. This rip-rap is probably 5 feet wide above the lakeshore and extends another 5-10 feet underwater. The rip-rap,the Southerly winds, and DNR regulations prevent us from having a sandy beach. Other Issues I have looked at several other properties for sale around the lake and although the market is soft right now I have not seen half acre lots selling for anyway near$893,000. At the height of the market our property may have sold for$600,000. I would like to see the"comparable sales data"used to value our property if it is available. Cur Esti�nated Markei Vaiue has increased irom$64's,�0u in 2u06,to$746,OU0 in 2007 and$893,U00 in 2008,a 38.88%increase. These increases caused us to pay more than our"fair share"and based on the above information we will continue to pay more than our"fair share"unless our Estimated Market Value is brought in line with all other properties. Based on my neighbors Estimated Market Value of$1,709,000 our property should be valued at no more than$450,000 based on a ratio of 25%. This is enough of a difference to pursue this further. i � 1 .. �'�) /lit�� . / ' � �'�(/ �' ✓ „ .� 0,�. O O ,� ,� CITY of ORONO �'' Gti Municipal Offices ��,9x 0,�� Street Address: Mailing Address: ESTrI 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 May 6, 2008 Daniel Regan 3410 North Shore Dr. Wayzata, MN 55391 RE: PID: 08-117-23-43-0017 Address: 3410 North Shore Drive Dear Mr. Regan: The Local Board of Appeal and Equalization for the City of Orono has considered your appeal and has taken the following action: Original 2008 Estimated Market Value: $893,000 Estimated Market Value as determined by the Local Board: No Change The Assessor's files are being updated as necessary. If you have any questions, please call me at 952-249-4600 or Bill Davy, Senior Appraiser at 952-249-4640. Sincerely, �� Lin Vee City Clerk Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us - - ., --------.....,,.,.,��.,��.�r�� rage 1 of 1 Hennepin County, MN ,�w. � . .�,s ��.-�,,.�,� Property Information Search Result The Hennepin County Property Tax web database is updated daily(Monday-Friday)at approximately 9:15 p.m. (CST) ��• Parcel Data for Taxes Payable 2008 __ _.__ . ,_ ,. _ �; � , � Clicle'Here=:for the 2008��tete��oPL��c��Yti'�i^�'r3g�ir�e�OOT"!�t-.T�R�ate�Refu�rf '�� r "„ t �Print � �ii��'� �Z�ii��ii1� .�� t�rr+�� ADDRE5� ;. _ � � __ _ - � T�is p,��.��ro ed;�n the=Direct De6it program araa�h�'t�xes,.�n1I��;ut�tmaticatly d�fur��?�t�e�tu��ia�s�� , Property ID: 08-117-23-42-0012 � � Address: 1315 TONKAWA RD i��i��; Municipality: ORONO -- - School Dist: 278 Construction year: 1998 Watershed: 3 Approx. Parcel Size: SE 95X268X112X309 HOUSE or BUILDING Sewer Dist: #: 1315 OW�er Name: LISA A FERRIS Taxpayer Name LISA A FERRIS STREET NAME: &Address: (at least first 3 1315 TONKAWA RD characters) ORONO MN 55391 Tonkawa UNIT# (if applicable) Most Current Sales Information � Sales prices are reported as listed on the Certificate of Real Estate Vaiue and are not warranted to represent arms-length transactions. Search Clear Sale Date: October, 2005 Sale Price: $2,100,000 20 records per page Transaction Type: Warranty Deed Tax Parcel Description Addition Name: TONKAWA SHORES 2ND ADDN Lot: 003 Block: 001 Metes&Bounds. Abstract or Torrens: ABSTRACT Value and Tax Summary for Taxes Payable 2008 Values Established by Assessor as of January 2, 2007 Estimated Market Value: $1,709,000 Limited Market Value: $1,533,500 Taxable Market Value: $1,533,500 Total Improvement Amount: Total Net Tax: $14,820.28 Total Special Assessments Solid Waste Fee: $242.90 Total Tax: m,c��a ,$ I""-------y w_ , ...,.. �� Property Information Detail for Taxes Payable 2008 Values Established by Assessor as of January 2, 2007 Values: Land Market $998,000 Building Market $711,000 Machinery Market Total Market: $1,709,000 Land Limited $895,500 Building Limited $638,000 Total Limited: $1,533,500 Qualifying Improvements Classifications: Property Type RESIDENTIAL LAKE SHORE Homestead Status HOMESTEAO Relative Homestead Agricultural http://www 16.co.hennepin.mn.us/pins/addrresult.j sp 4/1/2008 . . ---- -------- �, .,�.�..�.,...,�� wu,�Ya�,c Page 1 of� Hennepin County� MN w�.1,�,. .� . .�5 � Property Information Search Resuit The Hennepin County Property Tax web database is updated daily(Monday-Friday)at approximately 9:15 p.m. (CST) � � Parcel Data for Taxes Payable 2008 �— -_ . �, ,_ ., _. � Cts;�c;tf�re For t�lie"2l1,O�i,�,�ate�'ppY,ta;.�..,�". hY��.igl�g�i'6�2��1,�f?!t St�fe Refund �' "�a.a. "7�11��: .::` �_._, :. ;�,Print f!�`j3� �... ..iir.i"'�t ��Yiirhiif:�.. �� i�iiYiL+"'iYi::�i" AbDRE55 � � __a... .... � - --- -......- - Property ID: 08-117-23-42-0011 — -- , . . Address: 1335 TONKAWA RD '��''' Municipality: ORONO � - � School Dist: 2�8 Construction year: 2004 `� �- � - �~� �� Watershed: 3 � Approx. Parcel Size: SE147X231X141X268 Sewer Dist: HOUSE or BUILDING Owner Name: JAMES D RENDER #: 1335 Taxpayer Name JAMES D RENDER &Address: 5120 EDINA INDUSTRIAL BLVD STREET NAME: EDINA MN 55439 (at least Frst 3 characters) Tonkawa UNIT# ra licable) Most Current Sales Infarrnation �� pP Sales prices are reported as listed on the Certificate of Real Estate Value and are�ot warranted to represent arms-length transactions. NO SALE INFORMATION ON FILE FOR THIS PROPERTY. Search Clear 20 records per page Tax Parcei Description Addition Name: TONKAWA SHORES 2ND ADDN Lot: 002 Block: 001 Metes&Bounds: Abstract or Torrens: ABSTRACT Value and Tax Summary for Taxes Payable 2008 Values Established by Assessor as of 7anuary 2, 2007 Estimated Market Value: $2,543,000 Limited Market Va�ue: $2,463,30D Taxable Market Value: $2,463,300 Total Improvement Amount: Total Net Tax: $24,358.94 Total Special Assessments: Solid Waste Fee: $390.18 Total Tax: $24,749.12 � Presperiry Ynformaiion Deiai� for Taxes Payable 2008 Values Established by Assessor as of]anuary 2, 2007 Values: Land Market $1,200,000 Building Market $1,343,000 Machinery Market Total Market: $2,543,000 Land Limited $1,162,400 Building Limited $1,300,900 Total Limited: $2,463,300 Qualifying Improvements Classifications: Property Type RESIDENTIAL LAKE SHORE Homestead Status HOMESTEAD Relative Homestead Agricultural Exempt Status http://www 16.co.hennepin.mn.us/pins/addrresult.j sp 4/1/2008 - - � --------_�......, _..,.,�.�r�b� rage 1 oi 1 . Hennepin Coun�,jr, MN www. .� . ,. .: .us �.: Property Information Search Result _.._...._.._._.___.__....._____------.___._._. The Hennepin County Property Tax web database is updated daily(Monday-Friday)at approximately 9:15 p.m. (CST) �� Parcel Data for Taxes Payable 2008 p� --__... my. ,_ . � „ ■� tT�a ,�*�� IeCIc.H�re f0."r Phe'ZOt1$;state:'Co�ry tp�7��i3rl��r�'f1l,i�9�rc'.Lt��2G��J`�N"1PR Stat`e"�lte�'�nt! ".- 'T.,"_` _ �Print � . _ �' • !< ,�' �.�I�[ �i ADDAE55 z � , . ,.., , _ _- ---�---�'' Property ID: 08-117-23-42-0010 ��,�}'��, Address: 1355 TONKAWA RD �-- --�--•~� Municipality: ORONO ��=��I• School Dist: 278 Construction year. 2001 - ` —'"' Watershed: 3 Approx.Partel Size: IRREGULAR Sewer Dist: HOUSE or BUILDING Owner Name: MICHAEL C&ELLEN I FASCHING #: 1355 Taxpayer Name MICHAEL C&ELLEN I FASCHING &Address: 1355 TONKAWA RD STREET NAME: WAYZATA MN 55391 (at least first 3 charecters) Tonkawa UNIT# if a Most Current Sales Information ( ppiicable) Sates priees ere reported as listed on the Certificate of Real Estate Value and are not warranted to represent arms-length transactions. Sale Date: July, 2000 Search Clear Sale Price: $684,000 Transaction Type: Vacant Land 20 records per page Tax Parcel Description Addition Name: TONKAWA SHORES 2ND ADDN Lot: 001 Block: 001 Metes&Bounds: Abstract or Torrens: ABSTRACT Value and Tax Summary for Taxes Payable 2008 Values Established by Assessor as of January 2, 2007 Estimated Market Value: $2,282,000 Limited Market Value: $2,260,900 Taxable Market Value: $2,260,900 Total Improvement Amount: Total Net Tax: $22,282,46 Total Special Assessments Sotid Waste Fee: $358.12 Total Tax: $22,640.58 �! � ��. Property Information Detail for Taxes Payable 2008 Values Established by Assessor as of 7anuary 2, 2007 Values: Land Market $1,290,000 Building Market $992,000 Machinery Market �� - Total Market: $2,282,000 � Land Limited $1,278,100 Building Limited $982,800 Total Limited: $2,260,900 Qualifying Improvements � �> : : Classifications: Property Type RESIDENTIAL LAKE SHORE Homestead Status HOMESTEa,D Relative Homestead Agricu�tural Exempt Status http://www 16.co.hennepin.mn.us/pins/addrresult.j sp 4/1/2008 Lin Vee From: Rob Wiens [rob@luggagepros.com] Sent: Friday, May 09, 2008 1:40 PM To: BiII.Davy@co.hennepin.mn.us; Lin Vee Subject: RE: FW: land value- 10-117-23-34-0017 Mr. Davy and Ms. Lin, If the city of Orono would allow me to subdived my property, I would agree with Mr. Davy, the value of the 110ft of land without lakeshore is $495, 000 . Unfortunaetly, this land is not subdividble and does not add $495, 000 in value. Lin, I have received your letter, dated May 6th, and would ask the local board to reivew this information and make an adjustment to my land value. If needed, please let me know what further information you will need to make the land value adjustment. Thank you, Rob Wiens -----Original Message----- From: Bill.Davy@co.hennepin.mn.us [mailto:Bill.Davy@co.hennepin.mn.us] Sent: Friday, May 02, 2008 11:27 AM To: Rob Wiens Subject: Re: FW: land value- 10-117-23-34-0017 Mr. Wiens, I 'am aware that you have 100 feet of lakeshore. The land breakdown for land calculation is as follows: Your lot is 210 feet wide with 100 feet of lakeshore and 110 feet without lakeshore. The 100 feet of lakeshore is at $7, 500 per front foot, for $750, 000. The 110 feet without lakeshore is at $4, 500 per front foot, for $495, 000. The total value is $1,245, 000 . Due to the negative influences of being on the corner with traffic as well as the walking trail to the rear, there is a minus 30% to the value of $1, 245, 000 for $871, 500 ($872, 000) rounded. It is my opinion that we are treating your land value fairly and that the total value for the property of $1, 032, 000 is correct and will not change. Disclaimer: Information in this message or an attachment may be government data and thereby subject to the Minnesota Government Data Practices Act, Minnesota Statutes, Chapter 13, may be subject to attorney-client or work product privilege, may be confidential, privileged, proprietary, or otherwise protected, and the unauthorized review, copying, retransmission, or other use or disclosure of the information is strictly prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient of this message, please immediately notify the sender of the transmission error and then promptly delete this message from your computer system. NOD32 2693 (20071129) Information This message was checked by NOD32 antivirus system. 1 ,/�_-.___.--_'_....._.... �� O \\ / � � '-�� O�. o \ ��l� , ��.��, 10 CITY of ORONO V, t,�� _ D,u,'j �1;`�+� ti/� Municipal Offices � � '� � / r ��« �� ',��r�,`;�p,uri"�� G ,/,. �� Street Address: Mailing Address: �`�$'Egg,O�'i% 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Boz 66 -- � Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 May 6, 2008 Robert Wiens 1425 Bay Ridge Rd. Wayzata, MN 55391 RE: PID: 10-117-23-34-0017 Address: 1425 Bay Ridge Road Dear Mr. Wiens: The Local Board of Appeal and Equalization for the City of Orono has considered your appeal and has taken the following action: Origina12008 Estimated Market Value: $1,032,000 Estimated Market Value as determined by the Local Board: No Change The Assessor's files are being updated as necessary. If you have any questions, please call me at 952-249-4600 or Bill Davy, Senior Appraiser at 952-249-4640. Sincerely, U.��— Lin Vee City Clerk Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us Hennepin County Assessor Department - - . A-2103 Government Center www.co.hennepin.mn.us 300 South Sixth Street Minneapolis,MN 55487-0213 April 28, 2008 Local Board of Review City of Orono Dear Board Members: As you requested, we have reviewed the 2008 Estimated Market Value on several properties in Orono. Those properties are listed below with their original 2008 EMV and a recommendation based on the review appraisal. Original Local Board 2008 EMV Recommendation Action 1 Jonn & Cheryl Uran 120 Big Island 23-117-23-22-0018 $700,000 $650,000 2 John Weist 1920 Concordia St. 17-117-23-23-0006 $285,000 $262,000 3 Ted Capra 3534 Ivy PI. 20-117-23-42-0019 $1,200,000 No Change 4 John Quam 3760 Northern Ave. 17-117-23-34-0051 $298,000 $242,000 5 Dan O'Donoghue 1770 Shadywood Rd. 17-117-23-21-0023 $992,000 No Action 6 Tom Bernard 3470 Birch Ln. 08-117-23-43-0001 $798,000 $755,000 1c i�?t�aiCip�ortunity�r�f�tcyer ��; Original Recommendation Local Board 2008 EMV Action 7 Judith Oliverius 3490 Birch Ln. 08-117-23-43-0002 $860,000 $785,000 8 Robert Wiens 1425 Bay Ridge Rd. 10-117-23-34-0017 $1,032,000 No Change 9 Daniel Regan 3410 North Shore Dr. 08-117-23-43-0017 $893,000 No Change 10 John Hollander 200 Hollander Rd. 25-118-23-44-0015 $362,000 No Change 11 Jule Hannaford 1220 Bracketts Pt. Rd. 11-117-23-32-0018 $2,475,000 No Change 12 Diane Erichsen 4225 Watertown Rd. 31-118-23-13-0015 $765,000 $682,000 13 Bill Wyatt 4235 N. 6 th Ave. 31-118-23-12-0013 $595,000 No Change 14 Don Kielley 1670 Shadywood Rd. 17-117-23-21-0015 $956,000 $934,000 15 Charles Ballard 3315 Crystal Bay RD. 17-117-23-41-0017 $790,000 No Action 16 David Dalvey 1270 Wildhurst Tr. 07-117-23-31-0015 $1,618,000 No Change Original Recommendation Local Board Action 2008 EMV 17 Richard Crosby 2705 Walters Port Ln. 21-117-23-31-0015 $924,000 No Change 18 Mary Jane Price 3393 Crystal Bay Rd. 17-117-23-44-0020 $848,000 $780,000 19 Ed Garlock 1179 Elmwood Ave. 07-117-23-14-0030 $809,000 No Change 20 Sheryl Morrison 1525 6 th Ave. N 26-118-23-33-0033 $787,000 No Change 21 Kevin Dulin 1785 Concordia St. 17-117-23-22-0015 $1,599,000 No Change 22 Richard Rohrer 1424 Boulder Park Rd. 08-117-23-34-0013 $781,000 No Change 23 Steven Snyder 2715 Pence Ln. 21-117-23-32-0007 $3,650,000 No Change 24 Cathy Lee 1965 Fagerness Point Rd. 18-117-23-14-0009 $901,000 Still working on 25 Sean Hendrickson 1580 Long Lake Blvd. 26-118-23-33-0031 $438,000 No Change 26 John Waldron 1951 Concordia St. 18-117-23-14-0011 $975,000 No Change Original Recommendation Local Board 2008 EMV Action 27 Gerry Clark 870 Windjammer Ln. 07-117-23-11-0012 $1,041,000 No Action 28 Thomas Rangaard 2965 Shadywood Rd. 21-117-23-24-0060 $1,351,000 No Change 29 Richard Cherla 1340 Vine PI. 07-117-23-42-0030 $641, 000 No Change 07-117-23-42-0031 $1,024,000 $975,000 30 Robert Hanning 4220 6 TH Ave, N. 31-118-23-12-0015 $780,000 No Change 31 Alan Kozicky 1720 Shadywood Rd. 17-117-23-21-0019 $1,151,000 Still working on 32 Thomas McCune 1473 Bay Ridge Rd. 10-117-23-34-0005 $1,044,000 No Action 33 Lorna Butterfield 3743 Watertown Rd. 32-118-23-34-0012 $661,000 $595,000 34 Thomas Batina 280 Wakefield Rd. 36-1 1 823-31-001 3 $1,654,000 No Action Sincerely, , � �� William Davy, SAMA Senior Appraise� �f Nathan Stulc, AMA Appraiser � , Hennepin County Assessor Department - . A-2103 Government Center www.co.hennepin.mn.us 300 South Sixth Street Minneapolis,MN 55487-0213 (� ��; J�.�� ;�j.��-��:) �� 01` `�� G ��' �:5�33� April 28, 2008 Local Board of Review City of Orono Dear Board Members: As you requested, we have reviewed the 2008 Estimated Market Value on several properties in Orono. Those properties are listed below with their original 2008 EMV and a recommendation based on the review appraisal. Original Local Board 2008 EMV Recommendation Action 1 Jonn & Cheryl Uran 120 Big Island 23-117-23-22-0018 $700,000 $650,000 2 John Weist 1920 Concordia St. 17-117-23-23-0006 $285,000 $262,000 3 Ted Capra 3534 Ivy PI. 20-117-23-42-0019 $1,200,000 No Change 4 John Quam 3760 Northern Ave. 17-117-23-34-0051 $298,000 $242,000 5 Dan O'Donoghue 1770 Shadywood Rd. 17-117-23-21-0023 $992,000 $961,000 6 Tom Bernard 3470 Birch Ln. 08-117-23-43-0001 $798,000 $755,000 t"�n 1,�ua�Ot,;�c r ur?ri; �>t;lcyer F'��{yr t�c ',r.�r � � Original Recommendation Local Board 2008 EMV Action 7 Judith Oliverius 3490 Birch Ln. 08-117-23-43-0002 $860,000 $785,000 8 Robert W iens 1425 Bay Ridge Rd. 10-117-23-34-0017 $1,032,000 No Change 9 Daniel Regan 3410 North Shore Dr. 08-117-23-43-0017 $893,000 No Change 10 John Hollander 200 Hollander Rd. 25-118-23-44-0015 $362,000 No Change 11 Jule Hannaford 1220 Bracketts Pt. Rd. 11-117-23-32-0018 $2,475,000 No Change 12 Diane Erichsen 4225 Watertown Rd. 31-118-23-13-0015 $765,000 $682,000 13 Bill Wyatt 4235 N. 6 th Ave. 31-118-23-12-0013 $595,000 No Change 14 Don Kielley 1670 Shadywood Rd. 17-117-23-21-0015 $956,000 $934,000 15 Charles Ballard 3315 Crystal Bay RD. 17-117-23-41-0017 $790,000 No Action 16 David Dalvey 1270 Wildhurst Tr. 07-117-23-31-0015 $1,618,000 No Change . , Original Recommendation Local Board Action 2008 EMV 17 Richard Crosby 2705 Walters Port Ln. 21-117-23-31-0015 $924,000 No Change 18 Mary Jane Price 3393 Crystal Bay Rd. 17-117-23-44-0020 $848,000 $780,000 19 Ed Garlock 1179 Elmwood Ave. 07-117-23-14-0030 $809,000 No Change 20 Sheryl Morrison 1525 6 th Ave. N 26-118-23-33-0033 $787,000 No Change 21 Kevin Dulin 1785 Concordia St. 17-117-23-22-0015 $1,599,000 No Change 1 22 Richard Rohrer �,��\� 1424 BetrtLter Park Rd. 08-117-23-34-0013 $781,000 No Change 23 Steven Snyder 2715 Pence Ln. 21-117-23-32-0007 $3,650,000 No Change 24 Cathy Lee 1965 Fagerness Point Rd. 18-117-23-14-0009 $901,000 $825,000 25 Sean Hendrickson 1580 Long Lake Blvd. 26-118-23-33-0031 $438,000 No Change 26 John Waldron 1951 Concordia St. 18-117-23-14-0011 $975,000 No Change Original Recommendation Local Board 2008 EMV Action 27 Gerry Clark 870 Windjammer Ln. 07-117-23-11-0012 $1,041,000 $795,000 28 Thomas Rangaard ,�•�laS 296�Shadywood Rd. 21-117-23-24-0060 $1,351,000 No Change 29 Richard Cherba 1340 Vine PI. 07-117-23-42-0030 $641, 000 No Change 07-117-23-42-0031 $1,024,000 $975,000 30 Robert Hanning 4220 6 TH Ave, N. 31-118-23-12-0015 $780,000 No Change 31 Alan Kozicky 1720 Shadywood Rd. 17-117-23-21-0019 $1,151,000 No Change 32 Thomas McCune 1473 Bay Ridge Rd. 10-117-23-34-0005 $1,044,000 No Action 33 Lorna Butterfield 3743 Watertown Rd. 32-118-23-34-0012 $661,000 $595,000 34 Thomas Batina 280 Wakefield Rd. 36-11823-31-0013 $1,654,000 No Action Sincerely, ` � �.,�.�-- `�- William Davy, SAMA Senior Appr iser � Nathan Stulc, AMA Appraiser Y Y<. �Y �i �� .�..KIn� { . ( \}j� � � .. Xs�'YV' �� '°�� y Y �� f � y�.�, �y� $ y`�1Y�`� �fi�„�'��"(`�"y 4�s ,�t.ci . h �� Y �!� �A '.� f : �r, �ey s, ,&- �*. � � � y�}`�S. �� '+� ��y��,�� ,� � �� '�� ?x� ��71� � r, �� ,. 1 �� p �y*., � '� `�p` � � {�'�•. > � y�' .t � g�`�n .. AA1�r '0��p j.�ku l-� �C��,� X��y�� F . � ��.� Y�. �_(, �.Y ,R��1� �..:- ,y � �a.�N�� .� { �•�i "�.:. £�, �Y .� + � , 4. ^�L �t�-� �� t,�. �' W . ��^�'•.� �j �i� F . + . �; �� .. � �� k �.,, � +. 3q�.. , q-� .... }k -� ` ,�-.., � . . .� ,.,,� �.",� t��''.; ,}.� t s° � ��" � ��' . ,� ' � � �� ' �� .,"�e ,�y, t � i3'� �� y�. �..� -{ � �-. � A �� ..F � - �'�, '1i., �.a '7 `y� L�x .� t� i wP� .. ..f� � � �. > . « �_ _ . »f ` .. � �..r3 . .E4.�i ':. -3�. �,�- , , fi` ..�.. , .- � . t-.�+.�...�'� �,;+'.` - t J'r,;1'. y�.�� „�Fpy./��5' '� � ,� " e+l��im-ry.rg,. �: .f��A ��A. . � � ��.n µ:e� .., y. . .��p�, h; a��x � ' ' � �,:. �'� #z a^ ��' ,�i5`�., ��,� �� &-- SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME John &Cheryl Uran ADDRESS 120 Bi�Island PID# 23-117-23-22-0018 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1978 STORY HGT. 1 '/4 Story BSMT. FINISHING LOT SIZE sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 600 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 480 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 1/2 DECK 320 S. F. TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 1 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR WALKOUT LAKESHORE 345 F.F. MISC. COMMENTS: Reduction was made to land value due to location. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COLTNCIL ACTION LAND $650,000 $650,000 $600,000 BUILDING $50,000 $50,000 $50,000 TOTAL $700,000 $700,000 $650,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 1 �;r �r �}I` '1�"9•1'• ` ° �r; J �Sr�:s� ✓. . . �rr,j,�� ,�'�r� .r I .�, A ti� . p�1- � ;.i `�, . Y• K},_ � ��j,�. �� ,7�w�. . " �y�.r�` i ,�`� � y� . -\� j t 7 .^�-,.- �,3+��'��i ', �'�:a�� }'��.'� r 1i, �yY°" ,'.tf `. ^." ..�' � fif'.p' 'i� t� vt r�� , ��'r''�.� °' �.��:� ",d � L+�,�t�il� '!�r' t 7..�!/F' r' �.�'a�'' ,'� a, ^ :r7�f' �� A.��^". <�.�i 4 �� .1�-. � ' r � r ='��'� i►. � ,}y,A-: "r a,/ * � '�,.� r p;. `�" j 1 �"'+�C y;/ � � �� .�� a. M��,, �. C, `-AI" c :4,r ., r I 1 4,�,� ��.�1 5� �I� : q; ""'`�''.i!r �_ � � �� ;i��,1r�"�.�i� �irt�,�34 ,� :,tr� ,,. }� ,a�k y";,�;��h �'��° �� ' �� .��ti i e(yj` , r" '��'`41�r. �, � ,. � � ° �� .M�a�" �� N . �" �,^ `�''-----�.�.�.�,�,�;�'�`��. �.^'� q wl 1 w;'.r L �, '�?rt: ,;�s-�« »4.:W ^+�tr r�� &r�� t�=:#�� +. �`..�� '�� . .,._ i ._ . . ��:a. � �+` th i.: I ... � ��,j � �*J F'"' �°'!�l '.t� :�� ' � �,�, H a „� �s.,�r+. � k � y p t � �G "+�� u�a�. ,�,'• � y�. R F�;��`�.ti � � ,. _ ,.as:.«r+-'.. � ` � R ` �G 4 <* � t��' � . �� w�¢ . `�r '�. 3,� ' `r . � �� w�-� � � � � .� � �8 � t 1i � �d.�` � ��'" �� "�cy;4 � � � "� .� y . '� � : u ��` « y� �',*��*'�'r�;. 7� ..y� � v��r}',� A �t '`,� �� z��_�h[�y �i kr#�.."" v"S"� *.,.,,*�- ti ., ��; 4, f �P q�,�`�x � � �3.:`7 5+' '�'r� ��p � �,'� �'�`�,�, �� ',� r ro�' ;�a�a`*'� t� �� x'�r�-xt �� t�� *j we �, �„� �r�sr€ � � ! w � :t b J%� ��fi i x`:r rt� �q s � ., ro.w.,�.mq 4mdr�,�.€.�: .. .��.,a.�r t.�sru n.an�.,+,��a�.o . �^�a.�� + .ea.d�,a�._. .'.' SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME John Weist ADDRESS 1920 Concordia St PID# 17-117-23-23-0006 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1973 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 50% LOT SIZE 15,967 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1040 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1040 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 484 sq ft 3/4 OPEN DET. 1/2 1 DECK 168 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE MISC. COMMENTS• An interior inspection was completed and a reduction of the building value was made due to the condition. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $150,000 $150,000 $150,000 BUILDING $135,000 $135,000 $112,000 TOTAL $285,000 $285,000 $262,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 2 , � � � �� k � � � ��'��` ` , , �� W;- �'�', � ��'��'` �*��. �� --�� i y� � � � � �.-. 1 � � ` '�z � �� ,��.: �:�, f 1��. '.�'� �A'� ,NV'-•, t .a .�./ }� - � - � �"�. � '� � � _ � ,+�-,�; �' _.'� i � - �� , �. �� . � � e��"� �� #��.'��v�a, s- . � . ��,, � ','��' �,� . °4� r �` '1 . .,.. ,� �v ��. �•� }1.tl . �^�MI'Si�. I � � �� .. 4� .. ..�u i� ; P �"'^t � '¢.'}4� �..�:L{�'hay +'fi • � . �T � P� i .� �` .� � y . � f.^a�... � '"� �. �"+i'i "�""w�,p�3..��` �� y ,u. .�,�a "'+e'�� ,i�.'� Y� - - t ; � �l�f+^Yls� � ' .. .s,.....�».� -+. �`� W. 4 „ . ,�:, � � �,. � ,t ... , :. .. � � � � _ _ s, f.y'.k s` {. - �: } ry ;,'_ � ," • . ,=. , ., . .�. . 4� �tS .- �. .s. .... ...��.,. ,..�.._.r.. .3.,...,-_..,e ,..v,.._,,. ,,,u....,...e_'t �-4w,aunM��+L.��<�&�.. SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Ted Capra ADDRESS 3534 Ivy Pl PID#20-117-23-42-0019 PROPERTY TYPE LL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT STORY HGT. BSMT. FINISHING LOT SIZE 24,021 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA FULL SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 1/2 DECK TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS #OF FIREPLACES CENTRAL AIR WALKOUT LAKESHORE 100 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Sales of vacant lakeshore support the current value. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $1,200,000 $1,200,000 BUILDING $0 $0 TOTAL $1,200,000 $1,200,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 3 � 1l� �_r _.:..:'.,....- .�/_..".. ,�. 4,�� Y M r�� \ .- / �I lT A � t 7�_ '�'�' - i � � Y C �� 1�J �� - �, I �' �� ,' �,.�K'� ` � .� � ,h .� r,�i �.''` i �� :�.o,� �'>, '�� '�€ � ..b-� �i`� � � �. v�� J + �'� r y �< < � ,I� `��j � .f !ru �� '' � -'y'�� ti� ��4,M�ti �,.: �4 � �, •"�^'� �� s,,', d� � �e y� � ..esw�',+w`"�«° =� — - �„' _� �t, � ,ti-w,w..,xa.. +:� -,-��.. }�� '.' , � � 1'•- ��'•"" �'�j�'' t d i.�- . - �-,,,, ;�f. t?. � .. � ��. - .,-,^�:`- ,-_ ' '.,.�. . . . ��. �-s�� »z a� �- �. .r:�,� � . � �' a,w�-`�;��c � �2r-'' �� ,�� .�. :�#:`.b '�,n'"w,a,.�.,..r .'%:�}',.�� +�' �c.' ��s . r� + � . � ``�,�4�" ,»�^ '� � r a'�;`y� � .�' �„P� :.� .a, '�.r .��»�-�5�.�'r . Y��-�,�� +�� ;i "'�-,�' �"� T' � . ftt �t�� w ,..;7 ; , £, �� ~�`.`� . ,p � �* �, "�'�° +'r }4R M,�' r ��: 'd v ,+ ' ' �1�k,� G�' ,c�„ �.r�' ��e �' � J �r' u� r'�,rts r 3� • �,a�`bbY�i...�""��+,'a�.X.r�.it.::��ma,,..x. .,..5,.,. .._�,.;�:.�,.,.M,a�„�,>'x.,w. .-*'��'d.x.r..,..�.,,.H. . . . ,.t'�,`<,.�� _P, b-M,.;� as�: . SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME John Quam ADDRESS 3760 Northern Ave PID# 17-117-23-34-0051 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1986 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 21,214 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1380 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROLJND FLR. AREA 1380 FULL 2 SCREENED 192 sqft GAR.AGE - ATT. 576 sq ft 3/4 OPEN DET. 1/2 1 DECK 160 sq ft TUCKUNDER # OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE MISC. COMMENTS: An interior inspection was completed a reduction was made to the building value for condition and the land was reduced for equalization. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $120,000 $120,000 $100,000 BUILDING $178,000 $178,000 $142,000 TOTAL $298,000 $298,000 $242,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 4 ';� 1-'- q�dy � �e. � Li T ��Ln� t,Y * � �� ;, ; �; , �„ �;, � , ta�:=., v+ �,+�_ 3� ` � r ,� �i�-'x� {'-��'! ' �� 4i� < �— ��`�� . � �, � � �, ... �� - �� . �, . . . _ .,�,. , �. , - r a , �� . :,.,� .x,� _T .v, .. . , v.. .p� �. ��; �� v . q �- - ..:�... .. � � � .. ._.....__ � «' �F � ��, �� . _ _ ¢ _ � . � , • . � ��1 il-, " + M u .. ..s,,,�a �, ,.. � .. ..... �.. .��:z y 2' .az. �� 3 � ~ y a T f � '� �. - w �qx �� ' f �. .! V ��7 sa. . .. � �'�� 7 +n Mh. � , i — � rw. . .'. • �F. . �, . � ' 4 t.. �y 3.....a z.� ��. . T4'� � �, ti WFGr�°. : ,...._�,�..... . `;`�.,`..;.-.. .. . .. �"� � �. � � . � �� x . s � #�. �� r '�t ,. .,'s e ?�� . "�- . `k�;;: h y5 ,{ :. '�... , �<b � "h � � €�.' A�� . ,..r�Y" �...,�� .�,�.�xie_�.s�c.,-r.i�.�*s7-Acm.r��...a&.u'�� ..,�' 'b5�'.�.�..a��,s'��us*�f's�»"�..,��.6� SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Dan O'Donoghue ADDRESS 1770 Shad�wood Rd PID# 17-117-23-21-0023 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1929 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 11,281 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 3236 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED 91 sqft GROUND FLR. AREA 1868 FULL 2 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 400 sq ft 1/2 1 DECK 546 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 # OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE 60 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Interior inspection was done on the property adjustments were made to the building due to qualitX VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $576,000 $684,000 $684,000 BUILDING $308,000 $308,000 $277,000 TOTAL $884,000 $992,000 $961,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 5 .�,�� Y�1 ,��I�^`�,-u f�%er' � ..� ,.. �� ''ss--��.— -.�'1%"�;� �"; ��:,��" 9;, ,•. �� ;� � � .s ✓ .s'n� +� ��'� .�� ,"f!^ � ,j, i::.� x3r�"� , �_ �- �r f� �" �� `� '� -� �"�a'� '��.�'d .r u+r � '� . S�%. i+'. .-J' ,�.��` ��_ , ,� p�1� rj . � �, �r f Yia' . «i��'� : .,�,.^^^ '��a.9ss+ r S�!N'j�� I� i� h �� , �� t �p, �. 54�a� � '�-` �� { ,�!f r f''��j� � � ` ,,,jH( 1 ,�r�f :� - .r n. t�� `+ . i "4:�� 'a! .. .�'_��~ � ,Ti*� "i �r� A�. "" i «3�� .._ �� . ,�:,-,^. f�'�?"'. .. � . ._,-� .. _ -.,x �� a.a ...w �,�.m...z _'�'s......_,.s`� �.,._...... ..a.,»> _._...�.. .,^,..�.� .-;.m,��c ..�._... - *�wP.w..,4,. _ .��.�c. ._ ._ ._�. �.- -�-._ -,� »"' � �, �;,c'�",-�-s�`��;:"._ � „� ��r- i` '3 �_�.�. ,.s�';�� r ��. a ..rr+t a � �; � �a � � ��`� �� a 1 � �q��^t� �w, '� �s, ".=s=��."".� ,� � • ..,..,e. SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME Tom Bernard ADDRESS 3470 Birch Ln PID#08-117-23-43-0001 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1950 STORY HGT. One 1/2 Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 12,958 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2181 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1629 FULL 1 SCREENED 250 sqft GARAGE - ATT. 600 sq ft 3/4 OPEN DET. 1/2 1 DECK 80 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 2 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR WALKOUT LAKESHORE 55 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: A review of land values was done and a reduction was made to the land. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $608,000 $608,000 $565,000 BUILDING $190,000 $190,000 $190,000 TOTAL $798,000 $798,000 $755,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 6 ..' i "n 4'Y �� .�C.C'f'L� �. � +3�ffi �k�, . �� (1��ti�^ f�-_1��'�,,+y`�� . } . 'y� Z�{} Y 4 �i^ � �j Y't ��ry� � A.� ;. P �g�.� /,1��♦ r.�.i� �r+ k��'ti�w[ �� y t`�T' ��t� `Y t� � t/u i A y�� i„�4�� • �°�' 6 � r�' l�{ � _ � � K * (tl 7�`:� .�..'�4.iM�y. ��r?,. r��a ��4"s'.�`�b t � ' A j :. a��p4�� '�N'i��',ik�" �.{✓3'Ea 9 � �� !� �'f ��"... ��'�a�l� *'h� ��+ `{d�r}�iY��t �.1y .. r� �s v � �'� _� � � 1- Z`IE`� ;s.�, � .i�� '�y5��: ,,(t ,�y� � , �"r �A,£t, �`b. � � t�TxYY��tRtt�4 `s,r't'�.t4� L-yR�F t!"' . S'm�:� � r .,�„y�° �" { ;�;t -�°k �., ��' �.',f i.i��l�1 �.tt b�{� , .� � � �' � L � * �'� � � t ��+� � ;-�- � '- ��1* y:r `.� ��, , � � . � .q.� � � "�� r�� -� s,�Y��r � S'�� '� �S. .- y,�,a«�"✓``� , �f �.� y�, '�s-�`k' .� t .� �'''w � ��p'3 A � � �: �� , .� . �,,, � Fir . �.� ^� � , . �....w+�p ;"^�. ,��... < - � � . r' +�+� `',� ��; • ' �. ��4�rrr� 't'f""5 " s' _ �;`T rat�•,�o� ..e ��{R i3,d��'�� .ia� C�I . . MY�'.�' ��t�fl�}��i ... : .... . - ,.x._.,. ,...�r�:.mi$,.• � �..,s;. '4 . �^"' " aw.�$"ar,t-� `�� "`v'.. ,.. . ..c `A `5,4+,�r-�� $k ,,,� .. � � ...�.m^ ; .. t.� �a.t,.�N $.`r�'�i�,.�� 7�,II��' g�,�d, , -.....,, s, .a�m �. .; �.�..r'�`�n�ac.��'� r .tl�� _ _ T Y !'§w{y . . "�.k.^u. _ ''a- _..'w"e�• � ' � '� �. +�t r� �' � � � '. , , ��:� �� ,�r�, � �,�`�`� � � �.=a'� � `6 �d �,,�P.�� x^ " � s m��a a�,�,.m.��.,tr3 ' � � � ...,� " .a - ' ,,.,.,-. , � . =.n -'�, d,.� ., , �.., -- . ro - , r - .s�"'°i9�Rr�m I =.v.:- .s�.��"�s. - _ - _ _ SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Judith Oliverius ADDRESS 3490 Birch Ln PID#08-117-23-43-0002 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE $779,900 SALE DATE 09/2005 YEAR BUILT 1995 STORY HGT. One 1/2 Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 14,174 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1618 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1088 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 1 OPEN 96 sqft DET. 576 sq ft 1/2 DECK 300 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE 55 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: A review of land values was done and a reduction was made to the land. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $640,000 $640,000 $565,000 BUILDING $220,000 $220,000 $220,000 TOTAL $860,000 $860,000 $785,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 7 I Y .�..,�f . ... p��,s�^h�S:d r}R:"��""''"``;°`+"�'��" � vt . r,.-...-�r � r� .� x d�� .a��'�r . �'" .:. �� >,�� i r' . . � �:. , "�. i Y ,�, � � V'"'ye 1 z , - J a ry `l �Zf} �le 4d f .rA '� _ � 1+d 'd �� F !-� r . t � i n b k � �� _..,f � . � . �' ';�.jC s'� ,_ a°+ �. r � �:�� -,.... � -. ,..r . +� AL s F '� c ��{SY-�'�-' _ r- _ .7t,Sti P}�� -��..� �Y q x `-' „ ��^�'F�` `« Y ... -i �7 i `1 + �i ri � � ._�-d� .7.�Lw'.�` . { r ,.�A°�'+�`=--`,(�':Jf,- �,.w ��s � � '�,`-..rfi!�', i r� .. . , _ _i. 5 � _� y,� _ ..i �� '�'�'�' � <<�` � �^ � � ,�a : ��p�,y . � _ - �.•.0 , .Y r"�t'R'r rr11T:'1C��ftY3h , � "�.�{ �� i � Pi�., 1 . 4 '�� .�g __..--...-=�a , . �, �w� .� . . ._. . . rv . . . _ .,'. - � .. -� � ,- ., - . - - 1 �r� ;z�.A s 4�. ....."'"` �".�°�.e., ;`i` �_, 4�. SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Robert Wiens ADDRESS 1425 Bav Rid�e Rd PID# 10-117-23-34-0017 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE $830,000 SALE DATE 07/2002 YEAR BUILT 1959 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 80% LOT SIZE 101,366 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 3005 BATH - DELUXE PORCH- GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 3005 FULL 4 SCREENED GAR.AGE - ATT. 805 sq ft 3/4 OPEN 76 sqft DET. 1/2 DECK 399 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 4 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE 210 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Land value was looked at, in comparison to other properties along Shoreline Dr, and the value was determined to be correct. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $872,000 $872,000 BUILDING $160,000 $160,000 TOTAL $1,032,000 $1,032,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 8 � � � � �'*-`f�� . .� ,"k' ,� . - � � �,#� �� '�� , a �° �� $,,, .��y "� �� '��z �..'�'�'{ � J' 11'r t - � ' _ s y„yC ,t -,-. � 1 � i � #F 41n �� s�� ... ra�+ � , _ - .-....-., �.� .... v . � � ,�'a: '�:.;.-�� , � � _ �--�T,, �. b --�,,,,N,.. � , T �.�. ..:�� - <<. � �� _,, � � ; _ � � � . � :._._... � - � ' . "��` '`°�. +� .� �:,`��,��;'�°��,; ,� �. �� , �� -� �� ",� ° . �.�„ � �� ""'�� . �_:. ��*. „�n �; .z.� _, � . � �„u�€i� ��° �"� �Et,.+ . . , r. �"` �' . �. ,.< vt . �h� sz €n u �, *�� w � ��,#s�^� .� � g�� s � � �� L'.r"c�� f r �i��`�'�r� �r ^ ' u � .b.. ..,> .M..,..:a�w-.�...»...�.,.�.:�r.�a.w.. '� � ,.l��`-�`, �;��- �` .�a.�,.�, ,�. SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Daniel Regan ADDRESS 3410 North Shore Dr PID#08-117-23-43-0017 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1952 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 50% LOT SIZE 23,719 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2164 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1300 FULL 2 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 528 sq ft 3/4 OPEN DET. 1/2 DECK 1127 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 4 #OF FIREPLACES CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE 95 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Interior inspection was done on the property concerned with his land value versus the land values of the lar�properties behind him land values were looked at and verified VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $695,000 $695,000 BUILDING $198,000 $198,000 TOTAL $893,000 $893,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 9 ��` � � � . .�.�` .•.: pu i! � �� 1i��4 ^ �I� �s �--. �� + ;R�� '� �� fi� , � =;� ~, � � �� "� `� `_ ... .��j�� k.-r � .� �- - !.� y tz�.1�i,� � a t ,�� ,�\„ ��ti � �,�.y�td � -� :.� �`; a � . , .+`r,y�, ',°". � 3 _ - }" � � � ��.�,� ".,y,�::+Y'�r. �'� � � � ,.r.,: y�x`,.�,"t ""� r� ,.3a%�� `�ro; a st� ' �P� �'� �' '� �� -.F �4. �r.;;y *��1�d { .±Y:; �' � ,,,,;'�z� '� p' 'ar. z�a° ; � 3 pk� 's� SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME John Hollander ADDRESS 200 Hollander Rd PID#25-118-23-44-0015 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1900 STORY HGT. One 1/2 Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 86,863 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1300 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 932 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 672 sq ft 1/2 DECK TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 2 #OF FIREPLACES CENTRAL AIR WALKOUT LAKESHORE MISC. COMMENTS: Homeowners a�praisal was reviewed along with the building value; building value be adjusted for the 2009 assessment year. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $360,000 $360,000 BUILDING $2,000 $2,000 TOTAL $362,000 $362,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 10 � t1 � N 1 --' � � �k i�� . � � � ��t �� ( ' ,,� y �'1 a� � yF � ,� '� � � � acr4' - �•�r �+'� ��j t � � � , �v� ��,,,n,.., �� ,�:"�, 'fi.� L � .�f ��, . µ r � � �i+ t A j AS ,� � ;a .'�� ia+ 3 g` ��?,f` ' � ! . "�,"'. � .. , � � k � � � . xh M �� _ � � � . } ��S } ��4 x ��• � � IIC(.:' .� � -4�s.�.}Y�.�., �vvu �5"� ' f•.,�. 4� � - - �, �'�' � �s {p � � } "�- ry,. 5 :�,z �� . i 1 �5's� 2�-.� P'� � .m` . rn �� x Aq�� f" /. 's;?�'r..��•n=�:. -_._ ..._ i .;w m,M1,. , r ��.. � � .�.,.,�'-m ry�"�.'�,�I i�' - .T _. ... „ . �� ,,. .- .r� - . .. r„ '��a��na�- . ..��-- � .. �+,. ' a„ s'' �„�, ,G��.e..,-:�,••,.-"."" `.� �` � �� ✓ � - �.� �S � .. w"��,2' _- � ��i+ -, �� t'�. . "."� �?t$.5 w . _�� t...�:-�.- �. . ,t;, a' ' ..' �,�.„�-q, , � �v. � � �a;a�' � �.s�� ; '„'.� �m �'. __., - . .-....__... ... . . � ,�`�.. ,.. ,,..a.-k�.v:T SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Jule Hannaford ADDRESS 1220 Bracketts Pt Rd PID# 11-117-23-32-0018 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1910 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 50,391 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 4692 BATH - DELUXE 1 PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 2784 FULL 2 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 930 sq ft 3/4 2 OPEN 78 sqft DET. 1/2 1 DECK 1026 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 5 #OF FIREPLACES 6 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE 250 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Discussed market value with homeowner, did not wish to pursue further. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COLJNCIL ACTION LAND $1,755,000 $1,885,000 BUILDING $587,000 $590,000 TOTAL $2,342,000 $2,475,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 11 ..'�'f�"�}i � .:�.fi f d �t �ti+ii � � Y . ... p n� t _.�.a.y-t �.. � f . . �:.�..�.. . r p�i �4 � h- , �`5 ��' � � , �" �� s. �v ., �r� ' "�l�+s.. � � � Fg��"�� '� __ _ - ��"'t��.y �`,��;_„, ;a: :� ��,� ��r�oy�,,� � � �dt r� � s � �.t �,.�." . �. � � t .,5�Y a N.� �7,y a�� ' -a SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Diane Erichsen ADDRESS 4225 Watertown Rd PID#31-118-23-13-0015 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1990 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 50% LOT SIZE 245,448 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1740 BATH- DELUXE 1 PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1740 FULL SCREENED 168 sqft GARAGE - ATT. 744 sq ft 3/4 1 OPEN 80 sqft DET. 1/2 1 DECK 160 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT Yes LAKESHORE MISC. COMMENTS: A review of land values was done and a reduction was made to the land due to low areas. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $473,000 $473,000 $390,000 BUILDING $292,000 $292,000 $292,000 TOTAL $765,000 $765,000 $682,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 12 , , '}�;�� ' ,�t '��''"� ' � �;.� � � � ., �� - , . r�'� �.,�a,x. � �' ^r��: g � �""' >:� ^;ti #..� �.,>��,-:;�w, .;..-,da�,.� ��' � ' � ...�`� :�"�" ^��•, —� F �«�� ,.j �.'�� s�*� � � « —�m � ' _. F � ...,..,��,� � �, �, ':.'^ �.�'�'�`a y� � ,2m—.�.�., �?.T.,. �_;,�,,,� .� '' �' ��...,....,�, "' k� �� ,�,.�.a�: � � �,�„,�� , .. ,. 6 � ;s.. �� ,�a«.>x.,,„ ..�� .il� rt�� II� ..�� R li� �':d �� :,� �C . `' � ' ,...��.�.�»�. . ;� , � � � :'� �:��, .�..� ��<��-��' �_a SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Bill Wyatt ADDRESS 4235 6th Ave N PID#31-118-23-12-0013 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1981 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 70% LOT SIZE 219,995 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2083 BATH - DELUXE 1 PORCH - GLAZED 279 sqft GROUND FLR. AREA 1315 FULL 2 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 616 sq ft 3/4 OPEN 36 sqft DET. 1/2 1 DECK 348 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT Yes LAKESHORE MISC. COMMENTS: Reduction was made prior to the board VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $368,000 $308,000 BUILDING $270,000 $287,000 TOTAL $638,000 $595,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 13 � �. � ,��4 �.. � '( , � � '� �� -�-. �� x t - Fr �� ,�� ,f ��- � �� .. 4� - :�'� '; " :s < . . ; -�' . �. �,�� z� � -i � �g �4� � , < ,� , � � � � � ��f ��. �� ;�#,s . � � � �� ; x �.,Y a �� .:F�: Pu_,_,.,,, 1 � .�'�,.; �,«� �� - H� ��w � �J. '� ��'", � � r�`�'�:'�. ��.t.r �� 1�11 i� ��. �'��`� , �„�,� ,.�...._�..� .�,�.��.�«. �, .�� .. � �� :; �� , . � � ��,:� � �. � �_ w .; ��:� v�� t; r � .. �� . � �. �� ,� .,�-� ,.�" � � � ,�.�`'�`��, `,�' `",��`�`��-.``��'� � � ��: w�;.�*�c`�',� "�a:�'''.��,,;�,;,�� ..'"'� ��`�� ,� � ,��,.. �. ,,r4 �.' �� " „�� "..'"�r � wj°�ii� �� . xi,� , � � � °'" ��f �� , ; . . ... ::,.�:€'i: SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Don Kielley ADDRESS 1670 Shadywood Rd PID# 17-117-23-21-0015 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1940 STORY HGT. One 3/4 Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 15,524 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2417 BATH- DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1724 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 792 sq ft 3/4 2 OPEN 108 sqft DET. 1/2 DECK 144 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 4 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE 60 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Interior inspection was completed on house, adjustment was made to land value due to effective front foota eg chan� VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $658,000 $782,000 $760,000 BUILDING $174,000 $174,000 $174,000 TOTAL $832,000 $956,000 $934,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 14 �, o ry� � ��, f� x;�[d�("��i � � sg� � � ��N "�I �' �� r �� , � i . , �%� � ��.�x�€� ��r� �', w � � } � �,k�� i s�., �'� � � � �, k p r ! � ri�'��"A � '� � t .�'�i $;u � ,� a(,:u . '�. � ,i "` �'� �. s a. . ��r�ss � � �. t �, � - ,st,,r,r,��,r . ,a �s, � � �,�,�p.� -��" �." y�. � �� ,�,• r `�� :a '� ��''"� � w �- �;., '"� y� � rl„ ' s,. � y � 3�� .k,4G- �x #� i�� .- A�, . �•' � .. s�� k �i < !��:w ^'A - ,rf. Y .�y,4`�$ S _.. R �v��Yg ,W .r' ( q �.#� �, �;� �u&�- � .. , �,.. � r �?� � J� �� r ; ��' �� r ��*� .�t �� +� �„ ��. �� ''" .,:� ( � '`�� .:� .� � �� r,' �� • � � i�E � �. "� � � . � : � ��!' �;°� ,,, ��" �_ �; .,.- w , -�1� �� .� ., ..�„- , x. . . .� . - � � - -f �- � � ' 4 ^ " .y,, a. .fi 0`c. . - - . � '.� �. . . ;� � '�r'!J`„� � � ,�». _ ... ,.. �£ 't�.�c�.3 �' . . �tr.— � - . , '�� p�..�.Za.,�'.�A� ..,�r�,.' ae,,��-.�'�.rdw�+ �.....-�. ,�,z��. .-'9% j �3w.r'"�~ ..�� .. . _.»W+»�... . ... . - ,... �y� < e �...- ��._ .. ,� . . , .. ._ v ..- ,-_„_.��--�^ . . .-:..--•k...::,...,�:--�-. , .d.»,. . . .... .. - .»,r„ ..��.. . — -. � ._.....» .. .�.-�..,,.a�..� .,�<. - . „ -. _ . .__. ...,...... ._ . . .. _ . '�*`"� . . � � . ,'��.?� .r� e Q"t��`�r ��., � �.$.�� ,: , � , �3�' + �h y+� r . .d . i'a . . n �. �?�Gw ,.,_�. , r - �,t� ' t,v *�..�.,,a...., ,... w� �s SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Charles Ballard ADDRESS 3315 Crvstal Bay Rd PID# 17-117-23-41-0017 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE 02/2007 SALE DATE $799,000 YEAR BUILT 1920 STORY HGT. One 1/2 Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 16,777 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1118 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 910 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 324 sq ft 1/2 1 DECK 555 sq ft TUCKUNDER # OF BEDROOMS 2 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT LAKESHORE . 150 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Unable to set up interior inspection with homeowner. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $980,000 $780,000 BUILDING $1,000 $10,000 TOTAL $981,000 $790,000 No Action ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 15 :; �� _.�. 4n. �R y� �'�+ a ��aa:'k' f '��.$;'/,,. �7��y'e. '� . �y��,� .. �. -'-?w � "�' �y"�-� �� 1� � ��.t:� 3v �°.. 3.. i. �-'' � �{�5 e .f g� a�}r. it �� + ',4 �.�> �' �„� ..; � . , � , . '� _ : . q . . , �..�, a '" .� � ��.°„ ► � �- � , �. �, � _ � � , —__._ , � �_�_ �. .- � : - ; .. .,�.*,,., �t � S�° �:' ..�+o��,��*� .��'`�"'�`�`�.�"'�. ,� * � , r� �Z- � TS�d m� ' � � .�a. :.�"" ��„�.- '�",�•�. �,:.v 3� r � ' � k�� u% �°� w m�.�.�� ,�K � ,�i �a.�,�- r e ��*#"_.,, � - . ��, �,�;�� ' ��t ; t, � � �� a � � � �� y �h y �� '' "� �t '` �` t,,,,=z��+y:�:�a..�e��,�A.mn M..,,e..... k..4,a�i�.�.�.�.,a..�......,,a,.�.E..,..<._...a.».t.x� e'��`..�.`+�.�ru:,.+.Yr.�.mstau.a� ��....a.��a,. SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME David Dalvey ADDRESS 1270 Wildhurst Tr PID# 07-117-23-31-0015 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE $1,516,000 SALE DATE 04/2005 YEAR BLTILT 1981 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 80% LOT SIZE 49,513 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 3546 BATH - DELUXE 1 PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 2094 FULL 1 SCREENED 144 sqft GARAGE - ATT. 792 sq ft 3/4 1 OPEN 72 sqft DET. 1/2 1 DECK 264 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 5 # OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT Yes LAKESHORE 135 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Interior was inspected information on current listings of other properties was reviewed. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $1,139,000 $1,139,000 BUILDING $479,000 $479,000 TOTAL $1,618,000 $1,618,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 16 � ,� �� : <jl+< ��.f t �'t_ _ 1 N ��,�� , i'j` �zt. \�.�y - `0 R ]� Y t �` i ,r� ` � �' r''� y`.j, r �� - s �j, � ' , r� � �, � � � ��t� ,�""� � �t �. �,. » uy..� � } '�� + f� ��.i � .� . _,. _� bsaa�� . � � -��'� ,� - :� ,. .r �� -== ,. . �� ,' �� ,z :�� ,,� f io'T_�s', �:� ,+.� a ��p' � � ,(. :.,�.. • t .;�}'�� f c �. � �'Y i ^a. '�� : ., a� ! .T; ��1�: �,. �.� ., 1 - :� �i �a - _�, h � ��' ��°" '� ` : �" ��, � _ R �S � - , � ��.a� .��" ` ,_ � ., �t �'., . i � 1��y � � � s,, ,�€-.,•,��,.h., �.�,.� i.,=a_ s'. SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME Richard Crosby ADDRESS 2705 Walters Port Ln PID#21-117-23-23-0043 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE $899,900 SALE DATE Jan. 2005 YEAR BUILT 1970 . STORY HGT. 2-Stoty BSMT. FINISHING 0% LOT SIZE 25,303 GROSS BLDG. AREA 3294 BATH - DELUXE 1 PORCH - GLAZED 0 GROtJND FLR. AREA 1716 FULL 1 SCREENED 169 sqft GARAGE - ATT. 642 sq ft 3/4 1 OPEN 140 sqft ATT. 340 sq ft 1/2 1 DECK 300 TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 4 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT No LAKESHORE Access MISC. COMMENTS: Properiy was inspected last year for the board. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $550,000 $550,000 BUILDING $374,000 $374,000 TOTAL $924,000 $924,000 No Chan�e ASSESSOR : Bill Davy DATE : April 29, 2008 17 �,_�� ' :l 1 , . .. _ � k �i �� p }��'. � f v � � _ / � � � �.'yj„ E �l K � '7 � y� +,� }� � � � ��Y ,� � � {� 3� { , r °� �,,.=��"' � 1 t � �� Yrl� " �� r � � �,`-� � '�' �� ,,,,� b yly �� r� ,��'�_ �` ��, v �, b 5 J - � ' � .�_ ..r.v�� :..� � �� .,�{��,'` _ .. I .��` �`p'i I � 4:x i �� ' � ��-i. � � �, , "�. ,�+ � _ �.--.-�' � �},��,�,� �7,. r 'E`� / �� 'riw�^+�.-'�.` ��.�� `...�m.'"'.�'�-.S- a� . �� " t�� y x .�t�s � �;i'a:,��•r > � �� •,� � � � 11. � �� ;� �<�p� �� ;`i -^�i�� `�' �- ,� x �µ � � �� p' � � ,�� ,�j � - � 1t ��7r� i j� �� -�K*-.�. �m e_ ��4 �I �''. � 9 ' '..,,.,,...,,,,�,,.,r^�m^s . "'� ro ' �mE,n,. >�> .� .1�� Ei• �t ; , � � �' �,� :.a � I t��, ',`�,,+4,I� ',, � ; , � � � .�� :f � „ � 1 �, , „ . . '"__.. .._ . � �. . . . . . - . ... �, ..._ '° � } � .� - � �,� � ,��`'y°'F+i -"� a� � -,....,�„�a nc"+.ye+-,, # , . � r, � w'*.��'y4':' ��. i��-e.� y� "�3 �.- . �, ' a� > ;3�.� �� g�# ^��" }`�,y� ,. #w.. �`9'.�, st��!�ru+�'�� i 4��"�t�fi '+vys�ra .� i '. ,�. ,. b'r',.�Ayts��,y,yy„ .�, '� s . . .� �� s �7 ''�94�&a.'k'�"y, . t•. �#�&.." "�a�w4c �r.¥' �# �- r"y�.E,w}y�N,. ��gY =' r�.w, .w.��r»tt-tV.�"AAY'i"x�,�s`'�'�„e�-��_'"�. .�+ ,",i. �a �t�. u-a wW ., �``�&_.a�q"�' � .�. w.�,� -r.ic+�«+ro.,.,....;�..,_,... ,�.a •�,uy,. SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Mary Jane Price ADDRESS 3393 Crvstal Bav Rd PID#.17-117-23-14-0020 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1973 STORY HGT. One 1/2 Story BSMT. FINISHING 30% LOT SIZE 11,644 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1500 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED 160 sqft GROUND FLR. AREA 1200 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 1 OPEN DET. 1/2 DECK 446 sq ft TUCKUNDER 600 sq ft #OF BEDROOMS 4 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT Yes LAKESHORE 60 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: An interior inspection was done on the property A reduction was made to the site value for depth and to the buildin�for condition VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $680,000 $660,000 $600,000 BUILDING $188,000 $188,000 $180,000 TOTAL $868,000 $848,000 $780,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 18 �� '' �.�-� _ � �+t ;r� r,,. � � .. . t Y_�" F� 1 �� I � � , �� °, �'�� _ �� : , � .r. �� , � , � ..�, r�i � ��. �� . ,x.'� :, '1 , ��' `� _` _ � �� ,�� __. "`'r` . � � � � r �� , > s � . ,4 r. a. � - ,� ` ,� '�� ..� �-�`. �� d,1` �� tr � y ,- . .... . : � . . . , �i ��",�� ' , � ; � ; , ' � - .' � �� _ � .,-+ s � � ,t:�! .� : . ' . �'t'':._i -,,...,,:'Y ...�� i . �: � . i �; . ,� } "`. r � _,, �� ''"adr', �� r � � �r � t � . �'.. .P �`'�.. .. „ .— F� TTi. .� .. .. ._ - �Yh � �.em �I P .,,'�F`�`�� ra •'�P' � '� . � .: "''-�---- � „u� ��'� � �n p�f �� N e � - -� �_� � � x � . ur��, .."F' .,, ; �' � �� ., � ., � �'44 � �' ,AE�. . . P � «e ` s,.ti�' . ,• : ' . . 4 : 5��. . � �� ., �� •q � e �r lt i �.'-.� � , ... � ��. � ` � o : �� t a ,:�^r �` �� .. X- � �. „N,,,n,... . ' - �,�, � e+r�.r�+y�g^;3N'i.t x,- ' � A�s� r�" r. 7� � s-.� �.7��.-�'aaf��:: . � ..� x -k � } ,.,a+Sa,c,P ��"'Wd.'_ ��'�� ' � ,3 . �P . .. F `� b d � �.`� i. . . " .��' ' - 5 „ _ „ .' .-,_ .,.... -- . .�^ �g_ � ,.,.-..» :,•. � .. " ,. �� . . . � . y� . � �e , , � ;, . ., . . . , _ ;: � ,,. . . �a�. ., � , .. �,•� .. . �� , �9,� F . ,�, t,�'' . a ', ,. ., v' . . , ,. �„ a,�,. , ,,,,as, ./`v�` .� � �" ,: _,. � +�.a.- � „ y �� .��'r� �� . �, _ SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Ed Garlock ADDRESS 1179 Elmwood Ave PID#07-117-23-14-0030 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1951 STORY HGT. One 1/2 Story BSMT. FINISHING 20% LOT SIZE 21,708 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1054 BATH - DELUXE PORCH- GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 886 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 330 sq ft 3/4 OPEN DET. 1/2 DECK TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT No LAKESHORE 150 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: An interior inspection was done on the property Discussion over Limited Market Value increases. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $770,000 $770,000 BUILDING $39,000 $39,000 TOTAL $809,000 $809,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 19 .,:'�- � � � 1 Y ' ' *� �� }'r d"..' .. ��/� / ��'f� .. b 7 .. +� , (', r �.,.�� - ,d z'" :!" � , � ,�T. �.,.,.—M..«..:�«..,.......a. '� "� ., � ''t � � ,��., - «:�ri +. I,J ,�� °� '.'t�'��.... '� - � �`�� ..�=' �}f�� il �, r� j f' #x1�'x""�.^f��+�f .y„� ,r "'� '+'��'r � ),� �,�� a � r t'.• i. . ' �r`�'� �� ! � - �t � . � � �. :� .^,��k�;".'$ ;�. ' ; � �y�.� c � ,� , ,� ke;'` .'"�� '. "i f� � .� �u �..r �7' �� .�, , ,a�g,'g4 , n' �:`,. �. ''' � �3" , � ,`� ; , , y,� •` „ • ' ; f � —�'u �1/1� � � (��. .iM MK�1� ` , . ��'. � .� �� `. � ,'"� �. .� � � . � � . . , , . ..:� . . _.. � :. 4 � ,.�._ t�• _ vv', .... , � , . ., . , , ..., .�f SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME Sheryl Morrison ADDRESS 1525 6`h Ave N PID# 26-118-23-33-0033 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1997 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 70% LOT SIZE 116,737 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 3646 BATH - DELUXE 1 PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 2183 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 1613 sq ft 3/4 3 OPEN 70 sqft DET. 1/2 1 DECK 2342 sq ft TUCKUNDER # OF BEDROOMS 5 #OF FIREPLACES 4 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT Yes LAKESHORE MISC. COMMENTS: Prior to the Board a standard Hennepin Countv building reduction due to water intrusion was made. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COLJNCIL ACTION LAND $298,000 $280,000 BUILDING $627,000 $507,000 TOTAL $925,000 $787,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 20 � . •_'.- .7&"-rs :� �� ,� �z� �i�F •��,"-� �•t� •4.J, rr,i ,k�-- ~�� .��' �f.LT "..' � ��' G '��R�k V�'�t �r:i:'�.'�:-".,fi^��b�'�y.r.�' e„m��.—,. , 'eF- �� . :.. .... �' y� •--- . ikl� �'�' '�`'. .�.f � �.7 t' � ��t � #_�.M. � �'�� t.w..w= �. . � � tr.�� ' "2� � �� `a§'�.'�"� . � �e,�^'<, Y�.' . � �� ,t��. �_ A . , ^e� �."4�^RF"� bPs`=� ,qg�.�t .�. 3"' } d..�nr . ��'x. F° S�S s�''"°` '�wW` •" �3 . 'r t�S. '<s�W �` � �.: . � � ' a, w`p'., %+�.�".Yc.. �"�e ..��: �`L�.9i`dW.. �s u, _-.... y's. .�.�. ..z�,- - . �'_ ., � ::na 4� .ri . _� � _.. � ,. . _ . ,,,�-.. ,.� . �. � � IU � v .w . y ` . > ,* ' � . ,�-..._ , _ k �yr �"�. _. � +d S � �,�"arv . . . . ��.: ,5� � �� (r4iVJ�� N �,y, �� '� SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Kevin Dulin ADDRESS 1785 Concordia St PID# 17-117-23-22-0016 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1934 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 44,209 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 4100 BATH - DELUXE PORCH- GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 2436 FULL 2 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 1012 sq ft 3/4 2 OPEN 105 sqft DET. 1/2 DECK 401 sq ft TUCKUNDER # OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE 135 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Interior was inspected recent sales on West Arm Bay support the current value. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $1,140,000 $1,275,000 BUILDING $324,000 $324,000 TOTAL $1,464,000 $1,599,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 21 � ;fi s ` r. dv 'r� ''��w .� �� j� , ,;� }� r �� ...r's a.. � • � ..� � �,..�• . Y.ta'" ��.'' i�,.s.y � .� �, �.1�r�.;,�,�.. .4- �w � �, w } N � _ r.. '� �:,�• �, d ,� ;, »;�;. � �I �, � .zr 'a �.y #t;�;i „�;t� � �X •,�y, t- �� ;,�y P�? r,��- �` ��•. � ti R� �� . rt� � . _ t �--_ , � ��v µ� �� --�� . ;� � � "� .. � � � � �� '"..,.�..��- _��x��.*r��, , � ��e .�:�, �> .:_ ..�+" �s■�;�,� �, � � °� � t � �i�. ��,4 ��;:� � �� x �t.�.�' �` k�ses�.n; � ��,° � ,Y}"-� 1 � *. � �' '� -wMie�€ ' ,r.,w,�.-�.a, se � y� � r t,-�"" �.. � � � ��, x �� ; ��a��y� '� � � ��,� �, �i � -� � .�,�^` _ �`�. " ��,,�,.,,�'` '�.: s.� ,°�'' � _ a .r i.ii �- a��^�t" ��»;,. 7 �-"'�°.,.q,^+ � p,.,�+� s�,.. ��g� rr�i_�� '�m � . I . .. .... . . ,. � .. �.._. r „� .,�e.f'�'��.� ✓e. ��. � ` , � E •.- '� ...;+s -r � `: , � s � ;a ,�y' d''t �� + +F .i r,�+ 1 �� , ry•'•� � �.�e�� tJ . i�^�S�i.+�$ �k-.y0� 7�,�`�� ^�s _ ,.�,� ."�� ti' ` `S�'Fe... ^"�,:: -w°.k�'.��1 .',lr, ^'1 �� lilN ,�� SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME Richard Rohrer ADDRESS 1424 Baldur Park Rd PID#08-117-23-34-0013 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1920 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 9,843 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2444 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROLTND FLR. AREA 1460 FULL 3 SCREENED 132 sqft GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 529 sq ft 1/2 DECK 322 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE 50 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Discussion with homeowner on Limited Market Values VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COLINCIL ACTION LAND $550,000 $550,000 BUILDING $231,000 $231,000 TOTAL $781,000 $781,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 22 ��, ...,. ... .. .. x� :.,�'. .. , ..:.i .. � , � '.. �� /1 s: ' �e1•'� .. �. . ��- — f #�, ��•^a(•� . . � . _�'='� . . ' .. _ � ��— 1\ __ �Y� t � � ,'� �/ � � / . � f �. /� � t . ,.. `'t, r � ,_ < �'�' ,�' ,,K , ti �{� � t'>� ,.a`�, � � �,, ,� �r} � ,�,- . >..✓: �� ;: a .Y. i'„ ��r t � ` l:. � „- h�: ,u�"�': u � „,.....,,�. , ' '.� � a � '�`' '�� .�: � � � �t� ; � �� '�<. =� r�s�-"ti� ,.��u.'. ` '��i as,�� `� .r,.�. � ��:,1� � ,.^� �tk. 7. ��.�� ,� � ,,,t' ','�.,,."'.,,;w+.�y '�^' y ." � .� . ...; � � � bn._ ��i�' i � i+� '� ¢�".. �d£�t � � .. ��y � .�� s- ,�'.��"3da�,� � ' �� : �-a'"'"�� v . $ y� . - � � �iH �^� .� �. �,,w� , � ,� �-. -. � � � � ��-� �� .�.. �4 lym � �� k�S ' � � � �# �"�4 �3Ft+ g�Y.. �.. ��n � �� " '�cbi � t.. .,�;"�is�p .��•.. �°'„ - � .�„`�� €$ ;�; � r . �, , ..�, . :, .. � � ;: . .. ^ ` .< . . '� . : � �� , - " , .� z� � � � ,"� ,,��a..�...._._,.��:�.�:,��e��-a>� r' „ ,� � SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Steven Snyder ADDRESS 2715 Pence Ln PID#21-117-23-32-0007 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE 10/2001 SALE DATE $2,775,000 YEAR BUILT 1988 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 90% LOT SIZE 43,755 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 4610 BATH - DELUXE 2 PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 3680 FULL 3 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 786 sq ft 3/4 2 OPEN 96 sqft DET. 1/2 1 DECK 364 sq ft TUCKUNDER # OF BEDROOMS 5 #OF FIREPLACES 6 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT Yes LAKESHORE 175 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Interior inspection was completed and analvsis was done on homeowners comparables/information. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $1,825,000 $1,825,000 BUILDING $1,825,000 $1,825,000 TOTAL $3,650,000 $3,650,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 23 FTAP� ' ? i��q. ��QX� �� 1". � F�'tt Li � `T �yy'' M p ."��. � .�'".t `!'-�S _3✓§ �I" �- �: {+ . # � * a��' r ° , ��',`��'„'��"' l� `--�; ::� �;,� � "��. �. . , -� K Y"` �. ''°"` � +. '4^ �,Y�"`�L.rs'+:.,y�7•� . �'�``� 1�' � - . ^ :� �;.�� p� �� J4°��,�� t � v, ,4d' a K.�,, �� '�t�� 4� ^' «w�a9�� $�� Ra� � ', ��a.�r -..mg"`_� � x � "��, - � ,��. � . g a_' . �' ,��J,; � .�^� �.��-� �" �R� � �.., � ��, .��'�� , - ".` .. �.�.; � �'�. � }: �� 'ak�r� '`��"�'� r `�� `� � ' �! � '�.» � e �� „�, , �, � .�,+a.. ��.� �"� ,� � - .. �� . ' �. ��°��2 ...�� . '�� :....«..�... k ..... •--_ � .. , ,�. �y . ` � rc b. . ., ,n m; :�r �i 2 3�� ',.�� "�€ � � � � ��,y� y�,� _ �i� a ,,F�sC"�°�''! e-• . r � 1$'� ,1 t _ � '�' _ �.*�-. �� '�y !£ �` „�,. �( ` ��' rz_„ � Y �J,:^iT � �i 'N i�. ; �i a. .-�? {.� � �•:$ . !b ' Y s� �L...". +{ " �. ,�-�'+,r.r'd �Ra a �� . ��. �� ,: . � �� _ 'k+ + -�'��- '°'�., ��y�[''} � '� '' � '�«'�. .,�`s x ��" � � .ri'M',y � �� ud�f�Md�' �"'�'� 3'w � A� M� . u � : � -�„��^^^"'s+ $ � �� rio $ a+ '- � bsL*. , �aa� . o .' e�,...�' ,. , +� �• ,�„�¢........ ' ' � .... . ...=,-.zw'a-" �`a«z.iw' " _ .. . � �... �... .,�. ..ti ��.a.e.�,_:....,.... . � ... .'.. ...._. .' i ��prt&��` � � ' . �vY�� ,r � �,' � g 1 + ��P/�A ,. r�L,�^$ e� �``�� ` "' ''�"` ' s e _ . . ., . _.s�� . ��...��_' , ,.��b �:�.,. � _ � .. _ . .. . _�. . . .. . ._.w.,.�..�r...... ., „��.= , SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Cathy Lee ADDRESS 1965 Fagerness Point Rd PID# 18-117-23-14-0009 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1950 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 16,943 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1970 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1970 FULL 2 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 660 sq ft 1/2 DECK 856 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR None WALKOUT None LAKESHORE 75 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: An interior inspection was completed on the property buildin� value was reduced due to bein� an under improvement for the area and the land was reduced for elevation VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $760,000 $831,000 $800,000 BUILDING $70,000 $70,000 $25,000 TOTAL $830,000 $901,000 $825,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 24 ,� : �� : �^� �.n� .; r�r�� ,,�� J- � �� , 4 f"• � ��l.y�s`�. � �� . 2 `:;�`,,�x �,= , ;4 # : ,� ti �r f,i �a�`�,.` t*��" .��;; � � 1 � ... r �.:� ' u �p _� '� �� ..z...y�.� �,��.. !t7�� ; ,., �. ' �"7 r �, � - � . ��r � � � � � �� `' ��k� 'I il'u�n� n � � � '� � � �. - ,, ' � � �a„a� 1 III��I �fl�j� ,:� �� _,� �� _ �� '�� ~ ��.�_ �'' I� _._ . rc � . � �� _ ., . � ; ., � � � ; � My�� - � � �;. � � ,.,..A�-w r� _�� : I �.,.., ... � « � �'_�� ,�'* �:. 1' . j ��,i � ��'.� . �',.` � `°6.`.r'o- ��.. .:. *,e t A�,",' �:.. ao- _ .� Q, . " � ' �rw�w„• ^.". �^µ sa.: . : .��` � � :s. �i�.-�,�„sr s�'"�'G"«'.�,"'r°`� �. -rt'*` - . . "� � �^ i"'`t r ,,�-t�,h `a'+rk"-�rr w+."°�16s�. �v. `�'`S ��a. ,� ,:,t�. i�a�.N�y.��".�``��"� � -A . � � ' . 4��`�{�� 4 �'� �k�� Y� �z��;�3 '�� ^� p�'/� .t,! 4r�. .. �r1� ...... .. ... � . ,� t��•, tt R� v.'t' �-._y..::1t.......n.1 ._. . . ... �� .A+' SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Sean Hendrickson ADDRESS 1580 Lon�Lake Blvd PID#26-118-23-33-0031 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 2007 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 10,051 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2560 BATH- DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1500 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 400 sq ft 3/4 1 OPEN DET. 1/2 1 DECK 40 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE MISC. COMMENTS: Questions on value of new house and increase in value VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $149,000 $149,000 BUILDING $115,000 $289,000 TOTAL $264,000 $438,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 25 1 � 'm�� r�Rw. b V � r+ y � � '&i� p� �� _ � ��a� 3 tz'� � �'�?4 :." ,a`r"�',�, ��, ;� �• Y,'� �. .�, �., _,� �,� .t..;,s§ �:'-1 ��t+�c;. �"��`-��'�,:'� '�a ..., .. .� ,� � ,� s �,,.� �� "e` k g"», s ' ��R,�, r� � - ' ��.. i :;'.�,f. 'a j y�, a� ` , n � „ r� :.. � -_,� ` �wwr .r� «�� ...�.� � 't M '"'E a� aN '� w �z +r " rv � �f .�> ��.. : -- .. � °k . ♦ , 4' . , . ' ^ �' ,� .r. ,,., 4 ... _ _ .._. n. r- . .. ...e"�'ew'::iw�a� .��x�;2;":Nz:u:..,:r�+�w+—.� "' ' __' ' _ ' ' " --�{ �� 4°nq, � �T il�"'� & * � '� .. � . f 'M'W .r". s�'�^ +� . �, ' #.� " ,e"'�^ � `er».. f f, �� k. �i� �F "�1 � �,Y:. p�P�Y R _ � � �9t� �� ;#Z �Po �� ' -s �. .N..�� ''� � . ........ .. � .. .��. b;. -, . . . �" r �� - .,: � ... . �..._. �.;- �, ,, ., i♦ �.. � k s "' �s.�`� ' .�. x c x �` � ',� v � � j�'+F �,� � ;� � � �e�$ � s� �=` � %' �; -�• a,�� ' _ �; � '"� ��`, ��,„�p��,;�� ` w� f�, �'� .: . g�,:if � �, � .� ��,� �,�.,�� g,. �' ' ? � � �' � �' ,`° � '� � �� .��' r� ��-K ,. � � � �r "� � � � � � �..„.,�t,, ��„,�."'� �� "V ,� �5�..:..�i�.—h��. ��:'�.�..��a>.,�«y�a�. SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME John Waldron ADDRESS 1951 Concordia St PID# 18-117-23-14-0011 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1950 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 60% LOT SIZE 15,377 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1610 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1610 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 632 sq ft 1/2 1 DECK 260 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE 75 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Buildin�value reduced prior to the board VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $800,000 $875,000 BUILDING $145,000 $100,000 TOTAL $945,000 $975,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 26 - � ' f."t 'll r ..t _ �, �{ � 4� r� x 1� �E..;.-e .` � � i. .., _ . , n _ --` ��,r.w --, , � � . a � - { `: n� '+�" ( ! �t� 7 •��' 1 r t�`'�. . . .. � ..- �� ""��`�_ :}! Y ?��_�� ',-�-�"' "I ,:F §��-, t�- - .. '�-"'_'•.^,.__._�i7� i ) 7: ',l-� 1j� � �2�'?+�'�Y_ f� �} .i i j t z' ,. , ,. ; r. <r- •> j `� :� _ � � g� � i, t �� . _ {� �.�� - ,� rt` � ��°�� ;�� . . � �x. �r ? ��.� _ rr efr i� ' � . � .: ,� . i.�.R"��,� � ,��'r; t af."�i��' � . � �g �� _ �„� �,�'� � �� s' � '� � � �g, R'f'�� v. � � t�,'�,4.�F�� ^� � �� '�i.�'` Pr�`.s. � �' .,�t"' ��^,�-.��*"^'� - �"''z � s j � " ��.,^ 'v`,� �R-�'�`��N: �, '� �.:�Z �a�r'P S�,s �a.�+ v., .mm '�'�-'�"'`�',�='�,_`�' ��t. �� 1' x�$c r e 4n ,��%�.a�+. � ' � � �� v, ' �.��r r 1 el"'� �: . . -,r�,� �d-i��,,a:'�� tr ��' a '�� „ke"= �„s' � . �,as, s ;�.� ;ka _ i:... .� . . . ... . . . . .. .. . ,r , . ,. .� . . > �. . .-,...,.�� SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME Gerry Clark ADDRESS 870 Windjammer Ln PID#07-117-23-11-0012 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1972 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 80% LOT SIZE 45,712 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1614 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROLIND FLR. AREA 1614 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 528 sq ft 3/4 2 OPEN 250 sqft DET. 1/2 DECK 844 sq ft TUCKUNDER # OF BEDROOMS 3 # OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT Yes LAKESHORE 140 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: An interior inspection was completed — buildin� value reduced due to condition and the land was reduced due to the lakeshore ualit� VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $688,000 $768,000 $700,000 BUILDING $273,000 $273,000 $95,000 TOTAL $961,000 $1,041,000 $795,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 27 '" :^" �,T`., � P� � *�� r . ' 7 �: ,,.f, _� � ' r � � S�f . l{ • ,..1 � �i I�•+t� ��.' �� (.. �a ', T� � 1��.„� �� - � t .....�, '�":..�. � . , .., , ` '�" - 3� � �} , 't'� � � � ��" ^` . :�j� .� ..'� .�`, e n.n ��.` � !g��,�� ,al � �`4 � ��.Fq' �� s ��"i�M'~�^^s��' �•'f4 t t �§"`f� , 4fe...1�� yti t t, � a: � .., � �' � �..�. r�q' a °�., �� t'#��; �r,i s E p� � �� i�. ,�..#y.k,�•'�M��t��,� ��6, � �� *� �� at Y a"' � er �,.�, �� t r � - �� m �f'a��'$% "`�� , t q 4 _a 4 z �s,.z= Y.',. i.�^ ;fi �y? • 3 �,�.t'�' �b �#�' . A� .€ �N 1 .� € ��5�.' '�R �' � � � *k�-,. . '` " ".� '�` �; 5^�� . < z i '� -�.r..�'4 �t t. �S�s�� , ^�L ^c' a. � r"�.,�a�a d, �� {g�cg, �d" �� "�''� .�" . :. .rk � �r � C &� e 4 � � �� - d` #3 � ks'a.,�w S.. , ,l„�•�, z �sp kx.h �,; t��y ... � a,v4. txk _ f &a J 6.ww,.T��t�"�� 1�� y��i��'"�.s�+ 's's �v �:' � ." :,, 4 � '.. J,t ` " g� p "''� �.x s ��. � � 46!- kt# �� 't r�� `�.��''J�' ,� ,;,,� ,' �f' ' S �� f .Mo f 2. �- �' f`"1 Y I�€d� E%"�� -4 . �"`.,r�s �.i� r�",� «� � r � .� � �'� � ''� • `��f. ?w�� ^ � ,�,��.,�,�g" .x�+j�.�y� �t a �`g ,^""3 .,�.i.�a -r�� , . . �i a�;. '.r"^c. t^4 x» A' �-�"�,� #� �4's+,� y 4� �.�'�t"`" ,..+��1''!„r�ey� $"t '�� p„ �� n � _ �sM+�s,�tF p�. ��s,"z�'��,'�'�8��'`'� �4 "� ,. y, ti ;� �t� � w°�� • '�'�Y��'�s:� 6.�� '� `.r, �' .'x,�#+� �" "� '�"# t -'�s P � t� +g .�,Y v � �$`,� ^A} {:a�S:r�r �t»z �+ ,a �.c�r,..,, ay, x.«,,. ,r' � „ � s�y;f� fb�.-+',e� 'y+� r} q ._. t ✓ �..0 �,t�,� � s 1y,'^ a ��wV L `� � 7 �n�� ^£ r,:t 4 ,� .,� . _i�D .�:. w x �. ,.M •4`„+ ... .. r�,w,�..a.> a.��:�;�'� �..m �� ..,s.#cs- .v:�'r_ .. -t�� SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Thomas Rangaard ADDRESS 2765 Shadvwood Rd PID#21-117-23-24-0060 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1955 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 60,099 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2864 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED 170 sqft GROUND FLR. AREA 2864 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 616 sq ft 3/4 2 OPEN DET. 1/2 DECK 280 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE 160 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Land value was reviewed VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COLTNCIL ACTION LAND $1,290,000 $1,290,000 BUILDING $61,000 $61,000 TOTAL $1,351,000 $1,351,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 28 i � � ��,,,,..� � . ; � , �� - �_ r n�1��' i � ��. , � y , . , , _. } .��``�,. _. . �, � ,, j.— ,�... �,�_- �. � � '�'� � � � , '�=-'�'" _ "�`�:.,��r , `�n, �� ¢ �� m�` ;.v.� i ` �., 4r �*'�.., i"'s��°'� �:P ' ,h< ;3 rto-" .�. �'�" _ As . }r,g;: � � � � t� � . � �.� q �� ,�. �a��?s"�1�' ��v��.�;' �� . �� .- s ■rrrnrirrrr� �` ,rs5`�tv,�� - � �� Y�� nr��'i .��.:: —- ��,.. �r,Aa�: � �. ,.,,� J:�ii �.�aR �: +��.��_ ' '� r;�,' '�`''' µ �'�"�+ �,�, � v�,� �, ,.,��,,� �.�^'�"y�,�•m�,�, �. .?y, ;y4_�' "T�;.., , R � , ' !'�� „��-. ��d ;. � a �r.�{" �r ` a'. . #' � �y, �.f�'. � _ � r.� 1!�"�l'�m�-' Y' d � �° S5 :..r"M�..n." _ ""Y 9� s� '"'S z '��`»5 �� "`� 1;J'ef 6 /k, ,�� SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME Richard Cherba ADDRESS 1340 Vine Pl PID#07-117-23-42-0031 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1938 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 25,520 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2988 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 2300 FULL 2 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 OPEN DET. 720 sq ft 1/2 1 DECK 999 sq ft TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 4 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE 120 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: Also appealed 1350 Vine Pl which was inspected and recommendin�no chanQe. 1340 Vine Pl was inspected and a reduction was made to the buildin�due to condition and l�out. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COLJNCIL ACTION LAND $782,000 $782,000 $782,000 BUILDING $242,000 $242,000 $193,000 TOTAL $1,024,000 $1,024,000 $975,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 29 .� �� : � � A �� l r � ",� �. :Y 1 � -4 ��.(b+g »�»` i _ C�`' s , �- ^ . � . . � 4� #�� .'Y , j .. .j� .�t^ � .>�`�'l. ` •'"�«,. n '� �' �e � �, �,�.�;,., �,._ .+ � �� t'�' � .,. . ._ �sy� �� :� ��`l - �: .� � � � �. *��` �� . �: '� � � ,�� ,�. .� � �> � ,�°�`" -,�� x� ` � -�,; , � ��.� �, , , ,� ��N `� �� , «r�. �;�� "'�, :,,..,.-*,�-�•.' � �-� � n., �,� � e *�"""'"'�°' ... r �._� �� A� i � 9 �f 3 ��* f t ��.�� i I �`>� 5� � � ' � lM,�' . � - �� '�•� �,+ � �_ � � i �r µ- �- •°••�,��i ��AwLL�' f �..� .. �,r �t •v'1 ,� i. 1+ y:�S"J— "'r+�G -w�{�. ..�"+ '� w;. :. �w+ SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME Robert HanninQ Jr. ADDRESS 4220 6th Ave N PID#31-118-23-12-0015 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1907 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 20% LOT SIZE 513,790 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 1802 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROLIND FLR. AREA 1066 FULL 1 SCREENED 216 sqft GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 1 OPEN 43 sq ft DET. 1/2 DECK TUCKLINDER 216 sq ft #OF BEDROOMS 3 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR None WALKOUT None LAKESHORE MISC. COMMENTS: Reviewed land values and sales nrior to Board land sales along 6th Ave N support the value for over 11.5 acres. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COLTNCIL ACTION LAND $578,000 $578,000 BUILDING $203,000 $202,000 TOTAL $781,000 �780,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 30 �� R� pi�B��`` � " z "�'Y�� ."� �i �, ''�r ky � ��,� ,,•.�.t gr c•;� a� ' _ �' � �r� : +�'i y'; , xo�� r��'�� 4�a� .v ��^ ��,+.8��',� �r �;- � � � _�. � � �� _ � ��`� . � ��w�� ".� . ; � , � �� ,� � � < �� ,�� ,E %. & .I" � �1+�'w{`�°Y E ,_r� ..... ____._. _._,.__ _ a,aw '.�',�., { ;� �..�+.w�. � - � _ � � «�, � � * f i � � �,�� .�, � ' ;'� � �:'' �� q �. . F �� t �. �. , �� .r� � � � ��;�� ;' �" � x��'�` �" �� F t. s� m.�..� ' � � +� �� J .t. _ � it �r$ �� E''�" P .' '�..s � �.it`w�av { �... o,�w � � � ' 1 ��. , 4 rT+� �iG _f a t. �i . ,—�`��y,.�, ��; � ��,r`�„,. a*.r�y�'n"sa'� .`s'�:yt�i`sL".*A5,. '�.w.,�`" ,��,ri ��'�� g� .,��-y� �r� x � �r . e^ry .� �.c.r" : ., • � � - �«r .. _ � � \., � �..�Y1�'��.a9� . (' J'.. .�.. �,�n.. � w^ � ./�. i e � .. ' � • . � p....y � ,f�. � � ,+�` � »� , l . � h �r��_(, � � vy .l..,:�� _ P�� l� -�v :' . �. ' �� N'� s��r t ��m }i"t��1.( g'� p . y `•.wy�.�i �...,,�."-4.�...,1 �'�_�'6 ��- t a .,r�°...rd� . ,j�,rrd.,r%�'�i.s�.wa`-�..«�'*.jF� ��'�`#-€ �'�� .,� ,� �,r � ,...�l� - .. � 3 ... "'^A�i `"�%.,� .r_ �,�. ' „' t� SUBJECT 1NFORMATION SHEET NAME Alan Kozicky ADDRESS 1720 Shadywood Rd PID# 17-117-23-21-0019 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1963 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 13,072 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2928 BATH - DELUXE PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1812 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 1 OPEN 40 sq ft DET. 546 sq ft 1/2 DECK 384 sq ft TUCKUNDER # OF BEDROOMS 4 # OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE 75 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: An interior inspection was completed on the property — recent sales along Shadywood Rd, support the value.. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $775,000 $925,000 BUILDING $226,000 $226,000 TOTAL $1,001,000 $1,151,000 No Change ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 31 , . . f� �'�L i��T r^v �wr,�^f �� ,� ,� �.� .y,�:r��`'4ra`�i�"�`1�! � �_�r� {� t�;� F� �� ' � � ..?` �r�a�*'�s-r•+lrt +w�(�r I�„N!'"'.'r`'` �rr � r F ��,� � +¢ r� o � .+��" '� e aa�r�""�"u � ..`�`� ,t` ;�� '+� �; , �,,�,��"��"�``'��'��r`:� � . , �F 4 i� .'�i 1 �1 �� a� �+,�,�yi9�! ` � .1� . ,„ � �` � Fyi' Kyp.'.�. � � �, I ' '�.� �&.,�._�1`� p,�r�``Y� 1r"a} y," I 1 � q , � A"Mfi�� .Fwr ,q}5'.s.a�1/« Y�yt�9�$�V'� t'�� *,.,i ( �ij ; . ` � Y 4�Y ..�F��"•� '^�+",� G ,�a�E�'i � �fa� ..�� .r R t� a�;a�� '4`�,,,� ''8,�,.�1`f �'� ��, {�'�v�,,'+ 1�I�y a�.W` } .�'+ �e�C+':,-gtg�!��.ta. ��1�..� �.' .` � sai°t, � �, , � � 'S�e� r��`��'��''Z`'�...�rr.� �"r' a�' r� �� J" . �" r,, �ty�;. '�` ,�,. �, �` t �"�.+, � / '1� 1Ik� �.,� f .fM��i}wy�.,,.tw�ti�,� ..,�t��P/Z �M��C��.«�9 (.t ,M��ff rr �� ... � i y,� �+. �'a�-l0.A. A +r ` 4 F rS4,x``" ..r<„i`� �,�. � le�'Y- �� '�",.. „ �� .t� � y�. �..�. ,�°�'I �� ..� .t� �� "�� a-t �� F8;!g f` ,)'Yn.�-F 1. . " ri �� d#. t'1�'� Wr� ,� �Ti� ^�M�r '4"�" Sd�N,� it�.b �l� "i'��R� ..*:�`. . f s F,� ' r � .. j r I �, � �_,� �.,�,,+_� � -� � �.e � � � v i;v� � J ,� ,r .,,�....�� r��. „�,. . � �y �, e..a.� _ , .,«r.�.-�G�,.�:_». w..Ae i � ' � a „��' fa ��rY,� .�'�� r� r.s � - . � , - " M t�.i<.sj s�* r,"+a.�.�.�n ._ ,.. -� ,�'��T'- ' �� '�.:. . � ... . . .. . . , ;: " .�. �..,«,a,e�. . , , � - � � � � :��,p�i � . '` . . �� i ��,"�`"� � .� . � � �.r� �� hiv.''`,� p � . �'�'�l+ �� ,�� . -4 a �pJ �� #.�� q� r fi . � p � rV 2 '��. � 'a�°$��,�aB � 9� ��S � qy*��r �1� z E � -.,�r x L ' . " .::a �+ �� ;�,��.. � `� � � a �r�' � -�-.. y .�.�'� �. �� . { »f � f *�� ''i�.}�{' �� m�.�l�.1s�� .rw- . ��Yu` . ..s�.� . .�..' n u... . ' n a. �Y� .. �`1�� SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Thomas McCune ADDRESS 1473 Bav Rid�e Rd PID# 10-117-23-34-0005 PROPERTY TYPE RL SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1959 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 90% LOT SIZE 41,329 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2556 BATH - DELUXE 1 PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 2556 FULL 1 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 3/4 1 OPEN 54 sq ft DET. 684 sq ft 1/2 DECK 680 sq ft TUCKUNDER # OF BEDROOMS 4 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE 100 Eff MISC. COMMENTS: He is in Florida until May ls` unable to inspectpropert� VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $750,000 $750,000 BUILDING $294,000 $294,000 TOTAL $1,044,000 $1,044,000 No Action ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 32 �� _ �.. � r � "� �` � , �. . �� ` � �� .� � ��. �+ �'�,�•.,-� �,�, ,� t,��, �" � �� P ��: �� "�. � " ;,, � �,; , � � � ci� 'i f�, �� '�� . �"*' .��4 y N>:�� W � �� t+�' I�� iV�f�� I i�l.ii Ill � . � �d ,p � p �� :� � ` �� i� IIII � i �t} tl:11�. •�.+t�kt�.r�'�` F�. ��;�a\g. .�� y - . ... . a'33�+ .iw�..;+er«.A�.. '�_� . ' _ .+.,�-,d.. _ .�r � .:� �r. �.�,. . . � . . "��,� � � \. p�.i � 7 sK �� . �"�'e�e� . . � � .. �.,.,., � ..� � . ..�� .}...�... ., .�. . . . . � __ y� .�s . . � 'ti� . '. - u ' ",. ry ' . �...'i` - - - _ i � � _ �� d:� . I . � � , . � .....� � � � M . _ J � � �� 4 �t�� .�_ .t ..�.. ,.� f ..,�, . � �� ,�. . -"`��,_ _ � _._-- -_. �,....x_._ SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Lorna Butterfield ADDRESS 3743 Watertown Rd ' PID# 36-118-23-34-0012 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE SALE DATE YEAR BUILT 1989 STORY HGT. Two Story BSMT. FINISHING 0 LOT SIZE 210,740 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 2452 BATH - DELUXE PORCH- GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 1312 FULL 2 SCREENED GARAGE - ATT. 576 sq ft 3/4 OPEN DET. 1/2 1 DECK TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 4 #OF FIREPLACES 1 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT None LAKESHORE N/A MISC. COMMENTS: Adiustment made to the site due to size terrain and lack of landscapin� VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $380,000 $380,000 $314,000 BUILDING $281,000 $281,000 $281,000 TOTAL $661,000 $661,000 $595,000 ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 33 , � � � .,�. _ �.; X 1 1 � � � �. .. .. .L ', � F / t�.. .1... � f � *a�. ¢ 11' ��r � � ��; � �� .• � � ' y`.��° � s ' � ;�» . '�� a z ' r� `� G '�'�" `�,a�- ; � a �'�� f } � '°�, F r � :z ,�.,��. �w :_... � �� „'`^t�c,.'.��y �.`�� ffi�' � _ .`�` ��r+`� ` � ' � 1 _r" � ' � �� 4 S `�'� ' �.� d ; � �{ f� .,r �'�� 'S � �. �` a.� a "k � � "'>, �, x � ��, } � ��"� "�" t ``r Fri �.. �� `�� ri E. ��'I � � . � , p r ,��iw�l �� Y�I�tr�'.�;� ��'I� � � �:}mS -. z+.��. ��e-�: �i: r � - yh ' 2�, ' **� . - � - ' �. �. • . , e y y �1 � .t.«. r�� '��. { ��I' 1 _V u . ".. - ; �Y�� t� � � k � � �� .�'t k r�: .. ..2 �.�1 � �,�. 4 . r� ��- -'�•��•-3�.wy.: �it. . _. }�� ews.s't.}�e tS=' Y � 9 . "`� ;��.syx^��> -fi'�ai� �W"' ., ^\s {` ..T� Y4,+_'L _,y_. h N�1u,�. F '. "jP� q ¢�� C f}+ ., �{ " 1'd "q y+,�.a.a.^ 2 4r� '�K� ��''6 ^w'� . . .. � . '.f�_ •� ��.> . " � �c�i.....T�� .+5��6• ..� ... , `t..ls . _ ., �.,�. � ,�„ . � � 1w#A�h ...,��.. .. . � '_ '�4- �-... . 'A-+' _":K..= p�. SUBJECT INFORMATION SHEET NAME Tom Batina ADDRESS 280 Wakefield Rd PID#36-118-23-31-0013 PROPERTY TYPE R SALE PRICE 08/2000 SALE DATE $930,000 YEAR BUILT 1982 STORY HGT. One Story BSMT. FINISHING 80% LOT SIZE 110,982 sq ft GROSS BLDG. AREA 4450 BATH - DELUXE 2 PORCH - GLAZED GROUND FLR. AREA 4450 FULL 1 SCREEI�ED 264sq ft GARAGE - ATT. 936 sq ft 3/4 1 OPEN 21 sq ft DET. 1/2 2 DECK TUCKUNDER #OF BEDROOMS 5 #OF FIREPLACES 2 CENTRAL AIR Yes WALKOUT Yes LAKESHORE N/A MISC. COMMENTS: Reduction was made prior to the Board• he is reservin his ri ng t to eo to the County Board. VALUATION 2007 PAY 2008 2008 PAY 2009 RECOMMEND COUNCIL ACTION LAND $618,000 $618,000 BUILDING $1,196,000 $1,036,000 TOTAL $1,814,000 $1,654,000 No Action ASSESSOR: Bill Davy DATE: 4/29/08 34 May 6, 2008 «First Name» «Last Name» «AddressMailing» «City», «State» «ZIP_Code» RE: PID: «PID» Address: «Property_Address» Dear «Title» «Last Name»: The Local Board of Appeal and Equalization for the City of Orono has considered your appeal and has taken the following action: Original 2008 Estimated Market Value: «Original_Value» Estimated Market Value as determined by the Local Board: «Recommendation» The Assessor's files are being updated as necessary. If you have any questions, please call me at 952-249-4600 or Bill Davy, Senior Appraiser at 952-249-4640. Sincerely, Lin Vee City Clerk 2008 Address List First Name Last Name Address-Mailing City State ZIP Code Original Value Recommendtion PID Property Address John Weist 1920 Concordia St. Wayzata MN 55391 $285,000 $262,000 17-117-23-23-0006 1920 Concordia St. Ted Capra 3534 Ivy Place Wayzata MN 55391 $1,200,000 No Change 20-117-23-42-0019 3534 Ivy Place John Quam 3760 Northern Ave. Wayzata MN 55391 $298,000 $242,000 17-117-23-34-0051 3760 Northern Avenue Dan O'Donoghue 1770 Shadywood Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $992,000 $961,000 17-117-23-21-0023 1770 Shadywood Road Tom Bernard 3470 Birch Lane Wayzata MN 55391 $798,000 $755,000 08-117-23-43-0001 3470 Birch Lane Judith Oliverius 3490 Birch Lane Wayzata MN 55391 $860,000 $785,000 08-117-23-43-0002 3490 Birch Lane Robert Wiens 1425 Bay Ridge Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $1,032,000 No Change 10-117-23-34-0017 1425 Bay Ridge Road Daniel Regan 3410 North Shore Dr. Wayzata MN 55391 $893,000 No Change 08-117-23-43-0017 3410 North Shore Drive John Hollander 200 Hollander Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $362,000 No Change 25-118-23-44-0015 200 Hollander Road Jule Hannaford 1220 Bracketts Point Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $2,475,000 No Change 11-117-23-32-0018 1220 Bracketts Point Road Diane Erichsen 4225 Watertown Rd. Maple Plain MN 55359 $765,000 $682,000 31-118-23-13-0015 4225 Watertown Road Bill Wyatt 4235 Sixth Ave.N. Long Lake MN 55356 $595,000 No Change 31-118-23-12-0013 4235 Sixth Avenue North Don Kielley 1670 Shadywood Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $956,000 $934,000 17-117-23-32-0015 1670 Shadywood Road Charles Ballard 3315 Crystal Bay Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $790,000 No Action 17-117-23-41-0017 3315 Crystal Bay Road David Dalvey 1270 Wildhurst Tr. Mound MN 55364 $1,618,000 No Change 07-117-23-31-0015 1270 Wildhurst Trail Richard Crosby 2705 Walters Port Ln. Excelsior MN 55331 $924,000 No Change 21-117-23-31-0015 2705 Walters Port Lane Mary Jane Price 3393 Crystal Bay Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $848,000 $780,000 17-117-23-44-0020 3393 Crystal Bay Road Ed Garlock 1179 Elmwood Ave. Mound MN 55364 $809,000 No Change 07-117-23-14-0030 1179 Elmwood Avenue Sheryl Morrison 1525 Sixth Ave. N. Long Lake MN 55356 $787,000 No Change 26-118-23-33-0033 1525 Sixth Avenue North Kevin Dulin 1785 Concordia St. Wayzata MN 55391 $1,599,000 No Change 17-117-23-22-0015 1785 Concordia Street .. „a� ��,�=. E,: . . .._ .. „ ,. Wednesday,�May 07,2008 page�of.2 First Nanze Last Name Address-Mailing City State ZIP Code Original Value Recommendtion PID Property Address Richard Rohrer 1424 Baldur Park Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $781,000 No Change 08-117-23-34-0043 1424 Baldur Park Road Steven Snyder 2715 Pence Ln. Excelsior MN 55331 $3,650,000 No Change 21-117-23-32-0007 2715 Pence Lane Cathy Lee 1965 Fagerness Point Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $901,000 $825,000 18-117-23-14-0009 1965 Fagerness Point Road Sean Hendrickson 1580 Long Lake Blvd. Long Lake MN 55356 $438,000 No Change 26-118-23-33-0031 1580 Long Lake Boulevard John Waldron 1951 Concordia St. Wayzata MN 55391 $975,000 No Change 18-117-23-14-0011 1951 Concordia Street Gerry Clark 870 Windjammer Ln. Mound MN 55364 $1,041,000 $795,000 07-117-23-11-0012 870 Windjammer Lane Thomas Rangaard 2765 Shadywood Rd Excelsior MN 55331 $1,351,000 No Change 21-117-23-24-0060 2765 Shadywood Road Richard Cherba 1340 Vine Place Mound MN 55364 $1,024,000 $975,000 07-117-23-42-0031 1340 Vine Place Richard Cherba 1350 Vine Piace Mound MN 55364 $641,000 No Change 07-117-23-42-0030 1350 Vine Place Robert Hanning 4220 Sixth Ave. N. Long Lake MN 55356 $780,000 No Change 31-118-23-12-0015 4220 Sixth Avenue North Alan Kozicky 1720 Shadywood Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $1,151,000 No Change 17-117-23-21-0019 1720 Shadywood Road Thomas McCune 1473 Bay Ridge Rd. Wayzata MN 55391 $1,044,000 No Action 10-117-23-34-0005 1473 Bay Ridge Road Lorna Butterfield 3743 Watertown Rd. Maple Plain MN 55359 $661,000 $595,000 32-118-23-34-0012 3743 Watertown Road Thomas Batina 280 Wakefield Road Wayzata MN 55391 $1,654,000 No Action 36-118-23-31-0013 280 Wakefield Road Jonn&Cheryl Uran P.O. Box 290 Excelsior MN 55331 $700,000 $650,000 23-117-23-22-0018 120 Big Island _. � :7��. � . .�E �ti f _ � . ._ . ,..��.�.��,.� . _ � . _ . �.� . e . � Wediiesday,May 07,2008 Page 2 of 2 � °� � 0 0 .� � r;.� , ,� C ITY of ORONO w� �' ti MunicipalOffices � - ,\ � �,�� ¢.�G Street Address: Mailing Address: _-$'EggO 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 May 6, 2008 Jonn & Cheryl Uran P.O. Box 290 �,�;w. =�� a. ��:� �;��.�trca�� z� Excelsior, MN 55331 ��,��,�,�►� -r� '��`��'�=�' ��-r �a��.,,x��te� �,.� s�ri��rost.r.� �..3►a�a�t_t:: P�`� �-x.��,��a�� RE: PID: 23-117-23-22-0018 � �;_�, ,�,�h�� z%�-�i`��"--�'`7--`�� c: . �;.� c. ! ` Address: 120 Big Island { t ` { �, ji �{ , t ll�i{}314�31'v1�11S1}H�Slli I'.�'�`131i�fi'i!i1zi��ili�li?�i313 Dear Mr. &Mrs. Uran: The Local Board of Appeal and Equalization far the City of Orono has considered your appeal and has taken the following action: Origina12008 Estimated Market Value: $700,000 Estimated Market Value as determined by the Local Board: $650,000 The Assessor's files are being updated as necessary. If you have any questions, please call me at 952-249-4600 or Bill Davy, Senior Appraiser at 952-249-4640. Sincerely, �y�v" �/-�_ Lin Vee City Clerk Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us