Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout04-16-2008 Board of Appeal and Equalization Packet � I AGENDA 2008 LOCAL BOARD OF APPEAL AND EQUALIZATION WEDNESDAY, APRIL 16, 2008, 7:00 P.M. . ORONO COUNCIL CHAMBERS 2780 KELLEY PARKWAY ORONO, MINNESOTA ROLL CALL APPEALS Appeals will be heard in the order persons amve and sign in at the Council Chambers When property owner's name is called please approach the Board and give the following information: • Name • Address of property(Mailing address if different) � The property identification number (PID number of the property being appealed) • Value of property on 2008 Notice of Valuation • Value you believe is appropriate and why ADJOURNMENT Form No.A.F.4-Notice to Cterk of Meeting ot Board of Review-'Equalization OFFICE OF COUNTY ASSESSOR TO THE CLERK OF THE Ci ty pF Orono HENNEPIN COUNTY, MINNESOTA NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, That the Si xteenth day of Apri 1 at Seven o'clock P• M., has been fixed as the date for the meeting of the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization in your �i ty for said year.This meeting should be held in your office as provided by law. Pursuant to the provisions of the Minnesota Statutes Section 274.03, you are required to give notice of said meeting by publication and posting, not later than ten days prior to the date of said meeting. Given under my hand this El eventh day of February 20 08 . � � ���� ,, County Assessor Hennepin County, Minnesota HC200(1/02) CITY OF ORONO ASSESSMENT NOTICE (LOCAL BOARD OF APPEAL AND EQUALIZATION) NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN,that the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization of the City of Orono in Hennepin County, Minnesota, will meet at the Orono Council Chambers, 2780 Kelley Parkway, in said City of Orono at 7:00 o'clock p.m. on Wednesday, the 16th day of April, 2008, for the purpose of reviewing and correcting the assessment of said city for the year 2008. All persons considering themselves aggrieved by said assessment or who wish to complain that the property of another is assessed too low, are hereby notified to appear at said meeting and show cause for having such assessment corrected. No complaint that another person is assessed too low will be acted upon until the person so assessed, or his agent, shall have been notified of such complaint. Dated this 24th day of March, 2008. /s/ Linda S. Vee City Clerk To be published in the Sun Sailor newspaper on April 3, 2008. Posted at: City Hall Crystal Bay Post Office Long Lake Post Office Navarre Post Office CITY OF ORONO NOTICE OF PUSLIC MEETING RECONVENED LOCAL BOARD OF APPEAL AND EQUALIZATION NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN,that the Reconvened Local Board of Appeal and Equalization of the City of Orono in Hennepin County, Minnesota, will meet at the Orono Council Chambers, 2780 Kelley Parkway, in said City of Orono at 6:30 p.m. on Tuesday, April 29, 2008 for the purpose of reviewing and correcting the assessment of said city for the year 2008. /s/ Linda S. Vee City Clerk Posted at: City Hall Crystal Bay Post Office Long Lake Post Office Navarre Post Office � April 16, 2008 Hennepin County Board of Appeal c/o The Orono Council Chambers Orono City Hall Orono, Minnesota Re: Property Tax Assessment Appeal for Property ID # 36-118-23-31-0013 (280 Wakefield Road, Orono, Minnesota 55391) Dear Property Tax Appeal Board; I have begun the process to better understand the assessed valuation of my property. I am unable to attend the meeting on April 16, 2008 at the Orono Council Chambers. The purpose of this letter is to request your consideration of my desire to keep my appeal option open once I better understand the basis for my 2009 assessed valuation. I have a meeting scheduled with the Assessor on April 17, 2008 at 9am to begin the process. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, � / ; ����. 1 �� Thomas J. Batina� , � 2008 NOTICE OF VALUATION AND CLASSIFICATION - COUNTY OF HENNEPIN FOR TAXES PAYABLE IN 2009- TH/S IS NOT A BILL - Municipality: ORONO Property Identification Number: 3 6-118-2 3 31 0 013 PropertyLocation: 280 WAKEFIELD RD THOMAS J/KATHERINE S BATINA 280 WAKEFIELD RD WAYZATA MN 55391-9697 This form is to notify you of the market value and classification of your property for assessment year 2008. The property taxes you pay in 21 (next year)will be based on this valuation and classification.The prior year data has been included for comparison purposes. Assessment Year 2007 Assessment Year 2008 (For Taxes Payable in 2008) (For Taxes Payable in 2009) Property Classification: RESIDENTIAL RESIDENTIAL HOMESTEAD HOMESTEAD Estimated Market Value: g 1 ,814,0 0 0 Limited Market Value: S 1 ,814,0 0 0 5 1,814,000 S 1 ,814,000 Value of New Improvements: g 269,0 0 0 This Old House Exclusion: $ � S p $ � Taxable Market Value: S 1,814,0 0 0 S 1 ,814,0 0 0 IMPORTANT APPEAL INFORMATION ___ Appealing the Value or Classification of Your Property- Anaeal Ontion 1• Contact Your Assessor If you believe the 2008 estimated market value andlor classification of this property has been determined incorrectly, you have the right to make an appi Inauiries concemino valuation or orooertv class should first be directed to your Assessor's Office.This is an important first step of the appeal process.Many tin questions and concems can be addressed�nformally,pnor to the Local Board meetings.You should contact your assessor at the foltowing phone number: 952 249-4640 Appeal Ootion 2: Boards of Appeal and Equalization or Open Book Meetinas Step 1. Local Board of Appeal and Equalization or Open Book Meeting • Your first step in any appeal,process is to first contact the assessor. If you believe your value or classification is incorrect you may bring your case to the Local Board of Appeal and.Equalization.You may appear in person,by letter,or be represented by an authorized agent.To appear before the Local Board, an application is necessary.Please call vour assessor at least five business days orior to the scheduled meeting date.You must have presented your case to the Local Boar�i of Appeal and Equalizat�on BEFORE going to the Coun Board of A ty ppeal and Equalization(step 2). • If your municipality has opted for an Open Book Meeting(M.S.274.13 subd. 1 c,Altemative Review Option),the Open Book meeting is designed to give you information about sales activity in your area and the opportunity to discuss your property's value and/or class with an assessor. Under this option,there will not be a Local Board meeting and you are not required to attend the Open Book Meeting prior to attending the Hennepin County Board of Appeal and Equalization(step 2). • The Local Board of Appeal and Equalization/Open Book(Step 1)meeting time and place for your city is as follows: __ __ 7:00 PM �� APR 16, 2008 at ORONO COUNCIL CHAMBERS Step 2:Hennepin County Board of Appeal and Equalization � _. • If the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization did not resolve your concems,you may bring your case to the County Board of Appeal and Equalization.The Hennepin County Board of Appeal and Equalization begins on June 16,2008,at the Hennepin County Govemment Center,300 South Sixth St., Minneapolis,MN 55487. Application is required no later than June 4,2008. To appear before the County Board,you must have appeared before the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization. If your city has opted for the Alternative Review method/Open Book, it is not a requirement to have attended the Open Book Meeting prior to scheduling an appointment with the County Board. Phone:(612)348-7050.[T'TY(612)348-3461 teletype] Apneal Ontion 3• State of Minnesota Tax Court For information on the Tax Gourt contact: Minnesota Tax Court,25 Reverend Martin Luther King,Jr.Blvd., Room 245,St. Pau(,MN 55115 Phone:(651)296-2806[TTY Relay 1 (800)627-3529 Teletype] Web site:http:1/www.taxcourt.state.mn.us Small Claims Division You may take your case directly to the Small Claims Division of Tax Court if: • The assessor's estimated market value of your property is less than$300,000;or • The entire parcel is classified as a residential homestead(1 a or 1 b)and the parcel contains no more than one dwelling unit;or • The entire property is classified as an agricultural homestead(2a or ib);or • You are appealing the denial of a current year application for homestead classification of your property. Regular Division • Regardless of your property type or the nature of your claim,you always have the opfion to file directly with the Regular Division of Tax Court. • You have until April 30,2009,to file an appeal with the Small Claims Division or the Regular Division of Tax Court for your 2008 valuation and classification. � 4 Steven Snyder and Sherry Stern 2715 Pence Lane, Orono MN 55331 (952) 471-0646 21 _ � � � _Z3 -3Z � c�o7 Request for Adjustment in 2008 Assessed Va/uation Adjust 2008 City of Orono's Estimated Market Value for 2715 Pence Lane down from $3,650,000 to $3,309,965. This is a 9.3%reduction. Rationa/e • An initial interview with Mr. Davy from the City of Orono indicated that the 2008 Estimated Market Value for 2715 Pence Lane incorporated broad market indicators only. Budgetary constraints precluded a specific comparison group. • Steven Snyder worked with Mr. Davy to arrive at a comparison group. o We identified 22 transactions of over$2 Million in the past year. o We eliminated transactions that were clearly not comparable. o We identified four properties in the $3 Million to $4 Million range that served as a comparison group (420 Tonkawa; 2507 Kelly Ave; 1000 Wilhurst Trail; 2599 Casco Point). • Note that for this group of four properties, the City of Orono 2008 Estimated Market Value (column 3) is significantly less than the Sales Price (column 2). The average 2008 Estimated Market Value for these properties is 78.2% of the Sales Price (see ratio in Column 4). • To adjust for differences between these properties, and to achieve comparability with the Pence Lane property, each property was evaluated using w������.zillow.com (column 5). o While Zillow has its shortcomings, Mr. Davy acknowledged that he knows of no better public source that allows comparisons among properties. o Please note that the Zillow site is not being used for absolute market valuation purposes. It only serves as a basis of comparison. • A ratio of the 2008 Estimated Market Value to Zillow estimate was computed (Column 6). For the comparison group this ratio averaged 93.4%. For 2715 Pence Lane this ratio is 103.0%. Thus,the 2008 Estimated Market Value for 2715 Pence Lane is out of line with all properties in the comparison group. • An Equalization Factor of 93.4% (column 7) was applied to the Estimated Market Value for all properties. This gives an Adjusted 2008 Market Value that is more fairly computed (Column 8). For 2715 Pence, this gives a Fair Assessment of$3,309,965. � Analysis of 2715 Pence Lane -- Using Market Comparable Transactions ' 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 Ratio: City of Equalization City of Orono Ratio: 2008 Orono 2008 Factor:Average Adjusted 2008 2008 Estimated Estimated Market Orono Estimated Market Value Estimated Market Value Zillow Value to Current Market Value to ("Fair" Sale Date Sale Price Market Value to Sale Price Estimate Zillow Estimate Zillow Ratio Assessment) 420 Tonkawa Road May-07 $ 3,525,000 $ 3,000,000 85.1% $ 2,979,500 100.7% 93.4� $ 2,783,528 2507 Kelly Ave Nov-06 $ 3,800,000 $ 2,605,000 68.6% $ 2,711,500 96.1% 93.4i6 $ 2,533,155 1000 Wilhurst Trail Sep-06 $ 3,600,000 $ 2,730,000 75.8% $ 3,225,000 84.7% 93.4% $ 3,012,881 2599 Casco Point Jul-07 $ 3,260,382 $ 2,751,000 84.4% $ 2,950,500 93.2% 93.4� $ 2,756,436 Average $ 3,546,346 $ 2,771,500 78.2� $ 2,966,625 93.49b 93.4ib $ 2,771,500 2715 Pence Lane $ 3,650,000 $ 3,543,000 103.0% 93.49b $ 3,309,965 JRh O1 2000 12: 11RM MRMORTENSON CO 9415911381 p. l �/�� � r� 9sa " � / /" ���� Gity of Orono � ���t' ��"�� 02750 Kelley Parkway Orono, MN 55356 ��G�95� Cs t ve� 7 d f�SS�SSo� • Attention; Assessors Office T��'" � April 10, 2008 Re: 1473 Bay Ridge Road Property ID # 10-117-23 34 0005 I would appreciate yowr review and adjustment to the Estimated Market Value of my property at 1473 Bay Ridge Road for taxes payable in 2009. I realize that the current EMV has not increased since last year although I thought the preti�ious EMV was too high, following 2-3 years of significant increases. I neglected to contact you last year on a tirnely basis. First, I simply do not believe that my home could be sold for the current Estimated Market Va1ue of$1,044,000 in today's depressed real estate market. I sincerely believe that this amount is at least $lOo,000-150,o�0 too high. This is based on looking at a significant amount of lakeshore property with reducedldepressed values and reflecting that ours is across busy County Road 15 from the lake and therefore less attractivc; then others, The most applicable comparables would be in my imrnediate neighborhood which consists of eight homes on a single,private street. I believe that many of these homes on our s(�eet are also classified too high and that the current real estate market will take a number of years to recover to previous levels and our current value is not reflective of this situation. On our street of eight homes, my current Estimated Matket Value is the second highest, and I do not believe that this is equitable. The property at 1449 is the highest value and is an anomaly, as it is the only cornplete tear down and all new construction of the eight homes. All the other homes are of the late 1950/ early 1960 vintage. The property at 1425 zs valued less than ours and has a similar size, age and type house but is on a large, lot and a half parcel. The property at 1501 is valued $48,000 less than ours and has a similar size, age and quality horne. The property at 1525 was recently completely renovated and has a lower Estimated Market Va1ue. JRN O1 2000 12: 11RM MRMORTENSON CO 9415911381 p. 2 Again, I respectfully request your review of my Esumated Market Value and would be pleased to discuss this with you. For the month of April I can be reached at 239-591- 1381. Sincerely, . �s���� ��� �' Thomas R. McCune April 16, 2008 To the Orono Assessor from the Orono taxpayer: Dear Assessor: Since I didn't ask your name yesterday, my letter will have to be addressed as above. As I stated yesterday, I am having a birthday party at my house — today — April 16t". You suggested that if I wrote a letter stating that the Butterfields would appreciate being considered for a tax reduction, we would not need to be present. You have a copy of our recent appraisal stating a difference of approximately $100,000 less than Orono's assessed value (the house is at 3743 Watertown Road, Maple Plain, Mn. 55359) I.D. #32-118-23-34-0012. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Ned & Lorna Butterfield .�. Butte��teQd Lorna Butterfield 3745 Watertown Rd Maple Plain,MN 55359 � �1� .� �w, � z� Hennepin County Property Map Print Page 1 of 1 . ° �, ��. 1 .� _ _ _ __ Hennepin County Property Map - Tax Year: 2008 �� The data rnntained on this paqe is derived from a wmpilation of records and maps and may contain discrepancies that ran onty be tlisclosed by an accurete survey performed by a IiceMed �, land surveyor.The perimeter anA area(square footage and acres)are approximates and may wntain discrepancies.The Information on Mis page shouW De useA tor rcPorcnce Durposes only. . i Hennepin County does not guarantee the aaurocy of matenal hercin contalned and is not responsible for any misuse or misrepresentatlon of this infortnation or its derivatives. . III . ........ . •5 . �� i� � +�,'���`� �,+.i� ��h�. r���'�'� �f��` ���'���':��� � ` . i �i ,t„��� ���er�, f ��� f�� ! Ril '�-ia �� � 3� � 's 34A2 � �� a-�'., 4����,a u. �. , ._d< < ..,i�� �. .'i ''-. _ �_ 1: ... . . ., y' . ' '�� 14 � � I . l,, 3ASD � ti � , �o ; � ��_ , r .�� , !y� ,� �� � � � 3460 S� �, Ij /� � � t�� � . � 1440 � ��� � �0$ �* " ' �`I`1� �d 39'b r `,� e, z � �I — � 3490 �' 3470 �SQ�'� ii ' i: I cy � £;• �,,� 3qa�t ii '� - ina4 c� iaaa ��.� 3s 4� �� � � � '� ' Sq' ''y��y ,1 �3i8 � � 7 `� ' '� 'I , � �, 5�,�..� ,.�, ��,�,�, 59, �� ���. � .. 3A58 � i �.N�, ��'� lp � � �r'�� ` � � � � ff� ! � :. /� �4 � �_ �J r , , V � yw 3460 qi�•.. ` -� ' r1 °. '\ �-� --.`� s'- ���'�2a� �` �W. .r'r 3470 � f� t` � � 3480 � 3490 � �`� 3498 ' Tom Bernard, 3470 and Judy Oliverius 3490 Birch Lane _ � Property tax issues for discussion 1. Perceived inequities in Market Value Land evaluation with some neighbor's property. Z. Reasons for our perceptions: a. 50' lake front is better than 40' and 45' lake front. b. Pie Shape lots were laid out to accommodate lake shore corner. c. Undesirable feature in pie shape includes limitations of dock and lift. d. Natural lower water level in area necessitates longer docks. 3. Market value of these 2 lots should be lower than value of some 50' rectangle lots. 4. Request reconsideration of Land value assessment in line with neighbors. Hennepin County Property Map Print Page 1 of 1 �q� � J , Hennepin County Property Map - Tax Year: 2008 , TTie data crontalned on[his page is deNveO from a compilation of recortls and maps and may contain discrepancies that can oNy be d'acbsed by an accurafe suney performeG by a licensed . ' land surveyor.T�e perimeter end arce(square footaqe antl atres)are approxfmates antl may mntain dfscrepancles.The inPormation oo this page should be used fw refercnce purposes onry. I Hennepin County Aoes not guarantee the aauracy of material hereim m�tained antl is not�ponsible for any misuse or misrepresentatlon of this infurmation or i[s AerivatN�. 'i . . . . . . ... .. ... .. . . . . �. � �+ _ . � .... . . � � 1� � i1 I �� f;f � � ! 'i � 14Q4 � ,� 1 f� . r . . . . . . . . �� ti �. v� . � � . . � . . f� , �5�� � }� �� ' � ,�� � ,�, � � , � �( � 1408 �i� Q �i �.J� � � nt� � �� ,_.��. ;; � o � � � ' � r S� `'t� • �� ; - ioiz /� ti`'� ;; I / -� � ���C` ,` s� , i� iaie 0 ,' a� �I /a� � �,� �f � �: ,r �� La2o +� � i _�_�"'f � '� � �•�'� �j � � Sg� � 'Q - � , J :._-�---- r� s 3�y , 1424 � �S - f �� .: � , � ' ' .� ; ��'�9 q � :4z$ , `� S 3 ;� ;��o ' �� ��. � ,�i � � � Q8y3 . :— �[�y� ��o i �, $�.� � 1432 -�...�� �-__,��� * , 3 � ,. ;' U , {�. Sn ")�'' 1436 � !� 3e �' ��' � �`� $'a g� �, .i� �p ' ��.�►. 9s�y ' ���o � , _;�,,, - sg��` gg� 36 ,.._�- � �`�'�� lo� . �"rrt I 1�- ''ra `-� � `v Q�..f�Q j S �':'t �_�� P 144d 3s roq _ _ :_,� , ,� �,. �QZB --_ _ , � � �� �./ 33530 35Z0 Q� , - � Hennepin County Property Map Print Page 1 of 1 . � �q e� 3 Hennepin County Property Map - Tax Year: 2008 i The data containetl on t�is page Is tlerived trom a compilation of records and ma0s and may contain discrepancies that can only be discbsed by an accurate survey Oerfomied by a licensea � ' land surveyor.The perimeur and area(square footage anC acres)are appmximates antl may mntain disaepancks.The information on thls page should be usetl Tor reference purposes anM•� � � Mennepin Counry does not guaran[ee the aauracy of ma[erial hereln contninetl antl is not responsible for any misuse or misreoresen[ation of Nis information or its derivatives. �� I �' 38 �.`. � i� ;i I = > .,<:. _ _:. „ i� I 1376 i� ! �)t 38 �r' � ' ;i �r'/ � i. � � � � � � �.+'� � ; �� �� �� � , ,, � i'. � � 1384 � �Sv� �, !! ; j�� _ �'ss f' F``-� '{� .� ;, � � o , ;� �s so �: I � i S6 ;; , � .� ; � � �r� i I;. n �+��,� / X.� � � j/ 1392 � � � � 1396 u � i � •' � , � O 1400 .�./ � ` _ 1404 ,� �� � � w 1408 � 1 }i � /S D � } :, �t� ��(o � �iaiz � , , ,.�_ + 3, y�g , � � K ;; --,._ ' --,_ � , ��. � � �, �� ' ``,` ` � �3.1a� '�'� �'� SQ, � .� �a � �. ``�� '�--�-___ , � �sa ���6 � _ s�,� �s�. _� L~`�'�-- �rytc��,'�---1 , ,��,�;h sa f � I 38 � � f 38 � E �--��� f 1420 � 38 f� �i 3 8 f � �� 38 ��-"'^�.,� : � { ,S. �,�;�y; x,,,.� � ���At,i+^�'�..J�� �R�.r�"��'�'� N X��;,},p*�AinAifii��.''P R��.�B�e%: �T 5"'f�.^ �b"�.����,`�yYy y �l��'�� } ,^i 0 �._ n.:�3, x�' Fx t i�+.�,K Lgis�. �� �- w"'"`^'m� ��.:�e �¢°�'i:A'�' '�,n�°�". x a^*r�°n,b,� 3,� fT 4 �` `� ��'r`✓�"yn .� '�Sv '"" � '�ree.x� -�a, c � �? sa 5�"' K. % ?r x �� r�v . �a°��` '�e `� �� � �� .� ,� �`� �,a �i �.�s'� �,�,� ����,� r� �-�€ '"` � � ��'r�.`3'�'� a� �`' � � a �'��"'N+�..�� a�T ..�+"'�� . '� `"x',��,"�, -�-�a�``"�'d�- �'�P �� . ' ;..� �'"`'= " �,. �� . x ro�� � „�.�F�, ,��,,. ���..�?,�'� �i r i—�3�'`�°�,�," �,�r� � �S '� ��'�y f'sw »7ro v . §: �. - ,�q a. .� �. �" ���, c�e'-���� m�-�R�a''�.r.rgsq'��'#`qz_�m, =��' `��� 3� " �������`���.�`�� ",u� fi"a � �., ��'� Y. au� :;� y"''e' "�`��S' � �`�'-4 � ��t�- �' <�:�a` .* * :. �� '�,��rrb� £�`e � ���'�� �" «'� . � . > , '. 3 � d iF y� �.s� ,,. 'S..ae p+° ��4��;�.,����.{�t3y,¢� z #" .�' '+��"�.r�� z' "� �.,� °z�:.�.. ur �,..�. ���� .��M��x�#�cp��tt���``'T���'�`��e�R<.� ..4 � ���, .,:'�� . ���. � A�" �a �. w� a�� ��-�..7��" � �5 +x`� b ��.q a}tksw � �"e�§ N�' 'wt '1�.�'�.*�t'�� �; . > � � 2 ro ..._ . .�a, L °uLd'5���.tt!- q�^ S 5� W,'+R � � d .�.Y $ + ,�� � ,. �E�TWi��'l�}��_.S� Y��� .�'i' � � �Y 3 � �@ A 2 � �; , �5� � �` �::- tty�f }� � `�� �� x#. o �+�. q t�- ,� ' � '- � � r � ���i"� .:,� � �y�. <r � •.. a�m.., �-'� ,� '� ,�4 � J i .,�� ��`"� :�; 1 z � � ,. x �� � ��� � }'�. �`„ �;:;$� gG."ra' '-r �c `� ��� . �' .... ge'�a '°}{', .�' ��':�. � . I � .�1�� ; l� �r��. � . 3� , i .iy,. QY �I. §'� „,� „- _ +S. � � � ��r � ����� �� ��� d�it�4 8� ..«vx �._ �.p..;� � �.���-�.� tw . � �� � . r�. � . .�,... , �_ x ;_ . , . � � �� ; . �� � �:*`r.� t ,. . " y, ' ; '�" '.� r `' a x- �' `'�' �,.< �� .. 3>:��^�' .�� � �...i�" � ,��^'� h� F� . '� 'r a „� �,$�8 ` � " ' � �?.'"'� � � � � �; � ,. �' s' �%� �� t �a � #�� �� � ��� . �, �� � a,�� � s., ��� � �"' y�, � + .� ��� ��"� �, � � . ����`� �i f � � �'�^C+ � T b, � �� �� � t x� � � . ��� � �� � y� .� �' � �; 3 ( �`` ��:•' i. � $' � � -t �T ' ` �� s�v', �'e �.'�S� .. � tB' .C� �L����� �� ��r",� y . � � '�, 'k. a � � �q� �q�� ��� ���- � ��� �� .:� !:�� �,,.�. . ' � . s.� b�q � � � `1' `d; a ���4�'� � � - } � i-. '�' �- Y'� � _ . .��� <.._ � � '; .�7 S��" ' �nit r," ,��-� +� �k,� �� � �S.�. §�' '�S ��/"`�\�:,`��' . � -'��f a�� .�, v x� � y � +�tk� �r�a�'; �,�3�`� � . ���''� "`�' � '� ,.� " s� `..a� ��� � �, g �� � �, ������ 4,;�E� ����.�' ,�ur,��fyf�j��{9��i'�,+i,�j�rfZ{ i xa, ,,� . ��� _� i' '�' �.�,n y , ''� •�'�- ���.� �s: ��,��' ; �` �� ,� � � '� �� � ��� ���:� � '� —�.� �-�- �" � �, ,� w� �',� "�'��� '� �����, �. � � �.�::: �,,' �.� ��r.ew�.�~n. . � � � O 0 jJEAGUE oF CONI�IECTING & INNOVATING MINNESOTA sr��cF ,�,3 CITIES Property Tax Statement 101. This guide is intended to help explain the basics of the property tax system to residential taxpayers by "walking through" each section of the property tax statement. Minnesota homeowners receive the tax statenlent for their properry in March. Property taxes are derived from the property assessment, the local government levies and any voter approved referenda. Credits, refiinds and other forms of relief complicate the system. See the "Property Taxation 101" document for a more detailed description of the property tax system and a glossary of ter�ns. The Layout Tax Values & Classification The property tax statement is brief but This section contains infonllation on the contains a lot of information. The market value and classification of the property tax stateinent not only property. communicates the amount due in the current year but provides comparison The estimated market value is with the previoL�s year's valuation, detenlri�ned by an assessor and represents property classification, reductions from an estimate of how much the property state aid and credits and total tax ���ould be wortl� on the open market if amounts. sold. The taxahle lnar�ket vultre is the estiinated market value minus any Layout of the statement may vary excluded property improvements or slightly fi�oui county to counry but the other exclusions. The Caxable market content will generally be the saine. The value accounts for the limited�narltiet front page lists identifying inforination valr�e pro��ision, a limitation on�he about the cotmty auditor, the subject amount a property's value can increase property and the taxpayers. The rest of in any year. The increase is cap�ed 1t 15 the front page, which shows the taxes percent of the previous limited market due, «�ill be discussed in more detail in value or 25 percent of the difference the following sections. bet�veen the current year estimated market value and the previous year The back page of the statement contains limited marl<et value. Enacted in 1993, information about refimd programs this provision is currently being phased available to eligible homeowners. See out and will end by 2010. the"Property Tax Relief 101" docun�ent for a summary of state-paid refund Every parcel is classified based on use programs. A summary table of late and assigned a classificatio�z ��ate. payment penllties also appelrs on the Inconze-producing properties generally back page. The back page may also have higher class rates. These rates are contlin other tax related notices. set by the legislatt�re and are uot tax rates but a weighting system. In other 145 UN[VERSITY AVE. WEST eNONe:(651)281-1200 Enx:(651)281-1299 ST. PAUL, MN S$lO3-ZO4'} TOLL FRCL (F�OO)9ZS-1112 WGB:�NWW.LMC.ORG r. words, if two properties had equal credits comprise the total tax bill for a market vah�es but clifferent class rates, property. the property with the higher class rate would have a higher tax capacity. The Taxes payable for the current year and property tax statement may show the previous year are listed at the top of the abbrevi�ted classification name, such as tax detail section on the statement. These Res. Hmstd. (residential homestead). amotmts do not inchide any special assessments and are used to deternline The Mechanics of Taxes eligibility for refund programs. The market value and classification is used to determine the�roperty tax bill. State Aid Reductions Most property taxes are levied against The statement must contain a section the parcel's tax capacity and some are that details how 1n individl�al's taxes levied against the taxable market value. have been reduced by state aid and credit programs. The tax amount without any • The tax capacity of a parcel is aid or credits applied is shown first, with determined by multiplying the deductions for aid and credits itemized parcel's market vahie by its separately. classification rate. For exainple, a l�ome witl�ai� assessed market vah�e All state aid amounts that cities may of$250,000 has a class rate of 1.0 receive are certified by July. Aid helps percent, which equals a tax capaciry close the gap between a ciry's of$2,500. expenditure needs and its abiliry to raise revenues through property taxes, fees, Property taxes that are levied against tax charges and other sources of revenue. capacity are calculated using tax See the "Local Government Aid 101" capacity rates. These rates are cloctunent for more inforination on LGA, detenilined by dividing the tax capacity the largest state aid prograin. levy by the total tax capacity of a jurisdiction. The suin of all tax capacity An individual property tax bill may be rates, the total local tax r�te, is reduced by�pplicable credits, such as miiltiplied by a parcel's tax capacit��to the homestead market vali�e credit determine the tax capacity portion of the (MVHC). This credit provides a tax bill. reduction in property taxes of 0.4 percent of the homestead's market value Voter-approved referenda levies are up to a maximum of�304 dollars applied to a parcel's taxable market Homesteads valued at �413,778 and o��er ��alue instead of the tax capacity. The do not recei��e credit. Local jurisdictions market value rate is found by dividing are reimbursed by the state for the total the nzarket value levy by the total market amount of credits given to homeowners. value. Mi�ltiplying the market value rat�e Agricultural homestead properties may by the parcel's taxable inarket vah�e benefit from the Agriculrival Market results in the market value portion of Value Credit program which works property taxes. The tax capaciry portion silnilarly to MVHC. See the "Market plus the market value portion less airy Value Hoinestead 101" document for further details on these credits. 2 The taconite tax relief program is taxpayers who pay property taxes along available ro taconite relief areas on the with their mortgage payinents. Iron Range. The value of the credit is dependent on characteristics such as the Half of the total tax payment is di�e ���hie of iron ore in the jurisdiction and M1y 15 with the remaining half due the proximiry to mines. OcC. 1_5. A penalry fee is assessed for late payments. The back of the statement Property Tax by Jurisdiction explains how to calculate penalties. The The tax statement itemizes tax amounts payment amounts must be paid in full for each taxing,jlirisdiction and any even if the taxpayer is eligible for a ��oter-appro`�ed referenda levies. All of refund. the different levies are summed, showing the total pro�erty tax amount before City, county and school district web sites special assessments. oftei7 have additional infonnation on budgets, spending priorities, etc. The An individl�al parcel is typically in League of Minnesota Cities web site several taxing jurisdictions: cit�y, county, offers a calculator tool to compare tlxes school district and any special property on properties in different cities and in taxing districts, such as a watershed different years. district. Each jurisdiction levies a tax aud there is a different tax rate for each Timeline and Additional Information jurisdiction. Jurisdictions do not set the The entire process for assessing, tax rate; rather it is a function of the calculating, imposing and collecting jurisdiction's levy and total tax base. property taxes actually takes two full [le�y] / [tax base] _ [tax rate] years 1nd is aduiinistered by counties. Taxpayers receive two documents prior Each taxing,jurisdiction lnust establish to the tax statement. the preliminary propc�rry tax levy by mid Septeinber. The final levy can be less but Assessors detennine market values by not more than the preliminary ainount. Jan. 2 of the year before taxes are In very simple terins, the levy is payable. In other words, market values detennined by the following calculation: for taxes payable in 2008 were set in Januaiy 2007. Property owners receive [budget] — [all non-property tax notice of the market vafie from the revenues) _ [levy] assessor in March of each year. An appeals process is established for Special Assessment property o��-ners who disagree with the Any special lssessments on the property assessed valuation. are listed by type of assessment. The sum of any assessi7lents owed is then Truth-in-taxation (TNT) notices are added to the property tax subtotal. mailed to propeirty o���ners in November and show the tax burden under the Pay Stubs proposed le�y. The notice lists both The bottom of the statement contains actual taxes paid in the previous year pay stubs showing the lmount and date and proposed taxes. Tlxpayers can see dl�e that are to be submitted with each what flctors contribl�ted to change in the payment. The pay stubs are not used by 3 �. property taxes due (i.e., changes in fi�ture referendums, legal.judgments, spending by one or more jurisdictions, natural disasters or special assessments. classification changes, assessed value A jurisdiction's final le�y inust be change, etc.). Locations and dates for certified by Dec. 28. hearings on the proposed taxes are listed on the bottoin of the notice. The levy may change as a result of these hearings, . Resources League of Minnesota Cities w�vw.lmc.ar�/ResearchAn�lvsislAnalysisB�pic.cfn� • Local Government Aid 101 • Market Value Homestead Credit 101 • Froperry Tax 101 • Property Tax Relief 1 U 1 Minnesota Department of Revenue • Sample TNT Notices http:/%�v�vv��.ta�.es.state.rnn.uslpro,�erty ta� ad�ninistrators/other sup��ortin� conCent/ti�120O 8 main.shtml • Sample Property Tax Stateinent http://www.t�xes.stlte.mn.us/pco��rtv tax 3dministrators/other su�ortin� conlent/pro�,t axstateil�ent 2008.shtml House Research http://��•w���.house.leg.stat�e.rnn.us,!hrdlhrd.h�m . Classification rates . Limited Market Vallie Brief 4 HC586(2/02) � . . CERTIFICATION OF POSTING OF ASSESSMENT NOTICE State of Minnesota COUNTY OF HENNEPIN ss. City OF Orono � - , I, Linda S. Vee , Clerk of the City of Orono insaid County for the year 20 08do hereby certify that on the 24th day of March , 20 08 , in conformity with requirements of law, I posted notices in each of three of the most public places in said c i ty ten days before the time of ineeting therein named, and also caused such notice to be published in a legal newspaper, of which the following is a true copy,to-wit: ASSESSMENT NOTICE NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN, That the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization of the �1 ty of 0 ro n o in H e n n ep i n co,�ty,Minnesota,will meet at the office of'the �1^0110 Clerk in said Orono , at Seven o'clock P_• M., on Wednesday ,the Si xteenth day of Apri l , 20 ��'or the purpose of reviewing and correcting the assessment of said �►"0110 for the year 20 �g. ' All persons considering themselves aggrieved by said assessment, or who wish to complain that the property of an- other is assessed too low, are hereby notified to appear at said meeting and show cause for having such assessment corrected. No complaint that another person is assessed too low will be acted upon until the person so•assessed, or his agent, shall have been notified of such complaint. Dated the 24th day of March 20 08 . , Clerk of the f.j t� of Or�no /� h Given under my hand this /((J� day of �XI(': t 20��. � _�,.' - �� / __��� , - G ��' , Clerk. State of Minnesota, COL7NTI'OF HENNEPIN ss. � City of Orono We, the undersigned, Local Board of Appeal and Equalization, of the �1 ty o f Orono in said County, do hereby ceriify ihat we, and each of us, aitended at the office of the OY'0110 Clerk of said�_�_on the day set forth in the notice given by the Clerk of said �Y'On0 , and that we then and there remained in session the whole of said day as a Local Board of Appeal and Equalization. Witness our hands this day oi 20_ Chairman NOTICE TO ASSESSOR Assessor rnust m¢ke the necessdry footings at bottom of e¢ch p¢ge¢nd c¢rry th.em forward to the "Tabular,S`t¢te�nent" form, and in so doing use all possible care. Minnesota Statutes, Section 274.04. Tlae¢ssessor sh¢Zl foot e¢ch column in his¢ssessment book, and m¢ke in each book, under proper h,eadings, d tabular st¢tem.ent showing the footings of the sever¢l columns upon e¢ch p¢ge.He shall also foot the total amounts of the several columns under the respective h,eadings. �`'�`* Such return shall be verifced by his af�dauit subst¢ntially in the following form: ASSESSOR'S RETURN OATH . To Be Signed By County Assessor I, Jill Alverson Auditor of the County of Hennepin,Minnesot¢. State of Minnesota County of Hennepin ss. I Thomas May , CountyAssessor , of the County of H211t12p111 do solerrcnly swear th¢t tlze book to whiclz this is att¢ched cont¢ins a correct ¢nd full list of all Real ¢nd Personal Property subject to assessment and t¢xation in tfce �1 ty of Orono for tlze ye¢r 20 �$ so far as I h,ave been able to ascert¢in the s¢me, and that the m¢rket value, except as Zimited by statute, and the assessed value, except as li�nited by st¢tute, set down in the property � column, opposite the several kinds and descriptions of property, is in e¢ch case the market ualue, except ¢s.limited by statute,and assessed value, except as limited by st¢tute,of such property, to the best of my knowledge and belief, incZuding all changes made by the Orono Local Board of Appeal and Equalization;and that the footings of th,e seuerdl columns in said book a�ul the t¢bular statements returned herewith are correct, as I verily believe. County Assessor Subscribed and sworn to before me this day of ,20 . Auditor of Hennepin County CERTIFICATION OF NOTICE ON INCREASED VALUATIONS State of Minnesota County of Hennepin ss. City of Orono Thomas May Hennepin j , County Assessor of County, Nfinnesota, do solemnly swear th¢t th.e owner or occup¢nt of each description of re¢l property which was subjected to dn increase in m¢rket v¢?ue over the preceding ye¢r's ¢ssessment w¢s given official notice of the amount of such incre¢ses. I further certify th¢t¢ZZ suclz notices were sent through the course of ordin¢ry m¢il not less th¢n ten ddys prior to Apri 1 16, 2008 on which the C1 t,� Month Day Ye¢r of Orono Loc¢l Bo¢rd of Appe¢Z ¢nd Equ¢lization duly convened or. on ten d¢ys prior to the offici¢l adjournment thereof. Month D¢�� Ye¢r Date Sig�z¢ture: City of Orono (Offlcial Publlcatlon) CITY OF ORONO ASSESSMENT NOTICE � � � (LOCAL BOARD OF APPEAL AND E�UALIZATION) ^ — NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN,that the Local Board of — ---- - — -- p - - ` Appeal and Equalization of the City of Orono in Hennepin �1�/��spape���7 County,Minnesota,will meet at the Orono Council Cham- bers,2780 Kelley Parkway. in said City of Orono at 7:00 o'clock p.m.on Wednesday, the 16th day of April,2008, AFFIDAVIT OF PUBLICATION for the purpose of reviewing and correcting tne assess- ment of said city for the year 2008. All persons consider- STATE OF MINNESOTA ) �ng memselves aggrieved by said assessment or who wish to complain that the property of another is assessed � SS. too low,are hereby notified to appear at said meeting and COUNTY OF HENNEPIN � show cause for having such assessment corrected. No complaint that another person is assessed too low Richard Hendrickson, being duly sworn on Wiil be acted upon until the person so assessed, or his agent,shall have been notified of such complaint. an oath,states or affirms that he is the Chief Dated this 24th day of March,2008. Financial Officer of the newspaper(s)known dS /s/ Linda S.Vee,City Clerk Plymouth, Wayzata, Orono Sun-Sai/or Published in the Sun Sailoron April 3,2008. (Apr. 3,2008)a2-BOR 041608 and has full knowledge of the facts stated below: (A)The newspaper has complied with all of the requirements constituting qualifica- tion as a qualified newspaper as provid- ed by Minn. Stat. §331A.02, §331A.07, and other applicable laws as amended. (B)The printed public notice that is attached was published in said newspaper(s) once each week, for one successive week(s); it was first published on Thurs- day,the 3 day of April 2008, and was thereafter printed and published on every Thursday to and in- cluding Thursday, the day of .2008;and printed below is a copy of the lower case alpha- bet from A to Z, both inclusive, which is hereby acknowledged as being the size and kind of type used in the composition and publication of the notice: abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz BY: � � �. CFO Subscribed and sworn to or affirmed before me on this 3 day of April , 2008. c/_Z/� 1 C-z Notary Public MARY ANN CARLSON NOTARY PUBLIC-MINNESOTA MY COMMISSION EXPIRES 1�1-09 S ��� �._.. �,� emo � � . �� ftecyckd Paper To: Orono Mayor and Council FYom: Bill Davy Date: March 25,2008 Re: 2008 Assessment Local Board of Review The 2008 Orono Local Board of Review has been scheduled for Wednesday, April 16`h. As preparation for the Local Board of Review, please find the enclosed data to help you. There is a summary of Local Board duties and responsibilities, a chart listing the amount of assessment growth for Lake Minnetonka communities, and a book of sales with photos and characteristics from a sample of sales throughout the city. ' Summarv of the 2008 Assessment Each year estimated market values are analyzed along with data from the market. Adjustments, as appropriate for each type of property are made. The results of those adjustments for the 2008 assessment are as fellows: • Residential Lakeshore+ 0.8% • Residential Off Lake - 0.6% There are 3,919 taa{able parcels in the city with a total market value of approximately $3,099,625,000. This value includes $33,428,000 in new construction improvements. The overall value increase for the City of Orono is 0.2 %. Prior to the meeting if you should have any questions or concerns, please feel free to call me at, 612 348-6833. � LOCAL BOARD OF APPEAL AND EQUALIZATION SUMMARY OF DUTIES AND RESPONSIBILITIES Most of the responsibilities listed under the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization are statutory,primarily found in Minnesota Statutes 274.01. • The first responsibility is attendance. The Local Board of Appeal and Equalization is an official public meeting similar to a Ciry Council meeting and can not convene without a quorum. In addition to the local assessor, the county assessor, or one of his/her assistants is required to attend. • At least one member must be present at each meeting of the Local Board of Appeals and Equalization (beginning in 2006) that has attended an appeals and equalization course as developed and approved by the Commissioner of Revenue. • The valuation notices shall be in writing and be sent by ordinary mail at least ten calendar days before the meeting of the board. The valuation notice will include the dates, places and times set for the meetings of the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization as well as the Hennepin County Board of Appeal and Equalization. • The meetings must be held between April 1 and May 31 each year. The County Assessor shall fix a day and time when the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization shall meet. The board must complete its work and adjourn within 20 days from the time of convening stated in the notice of the clerk, i.e., calendar days -- original night is day one. • The clerk shall give published and posted notice of the meeting at least ten days before the date of the meeting. • Local Boards of Appeal and Equalization must see that all taxable property is properly assessed, valued, and classified for all current assessments. The board may consider both real and personal property. • If any property has been omitted, the board must correct the assessment by adding it to the list of assessments along with its market value. • The board may not increase or decrease by percentage all assessments in a district of a given class of property. Changes in the aggregate to assessments are by class and are made by the county board of equalization. • Although the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization has the authority to increase or decrease individual assessments, the total of such adjustments must not reduce the aggregate assessment by more than one percent. If the total reductions would lower the aggregate assessments by more than one percent, none of the adjustments may be made. The assessar shall correct any clerical errors or double assessments discovered by the board without regard to the one percent limitation. • The local board does not have the authority to reopen former assessments on which taxes are due and payable. The board only considers assessments in the current year. • The board may find instances of undervalued properties. The board must notify the owner of the property that the value is going to be raised. The property owner may then appear before the board if they so wish. • It is the primary duty of each local board to examine the assessment record to see that all taxable property in the assessment district has been properly placed upon the list and valued by the assessor. The local boards do not have the authority to address exemption issues. Only the county assessor has the authority to exempt property. • A taxpayer may appear in person, by council, or written communication to present his or her objection to the board. The focus of the appeal must center on the factors influencing the estimated market value or classification placed on the property. • All changes will be entered into the assessment books by the county assessor's office. • Before adjourning, the local board should prepare an official list of the changes. The law requires that the changes be listed on a separate form. All assessments that have been increased or decreased should be shown as prescribed on the form along with their market values. The record must be signed and dated by the members of the Local Board of Appeal and Equalization. • The Hennepin County Board of Appeal and Equalization begins meeting on: June 16, 2008 • All appointments must be scheduled no later than Wednesday June 4, 2008 by calling the Hennepin County Taxpayer Services Office at: (612) 348-7050 2008 ASSESSMENT GROWTH RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES CITY OFF LAKE LAKE SHORE DEEPHAVEN -5.5% -0.3% EXCELSIOR -4.7% 0.7% GREENWOOD -5.9% 1.1% MINNETONKA BEACH 0.0% -0.1% MINNETONKA -1 .8% -0.4% MINNETRISTA -1.2% -3.9% MOUND -3.4% 3.1% ORONO -0.6% 0.8% SHOREWOOD -0.5% 1.6% SPRING PARK 4.8% 2.8% TONKA BAY 0.8% 1.3% WAYZATA 0.1% 0.1% WOODLAND -0.8% -0.2% 1`� Ci. �' � . `A � r '�� � w.,, ';� �'�~t� 7 �TM f` r V � ~4""�� '� ,� � � � � � � � � � � ' ; l $ �i . '{ 1 �-� 4� � _�. � � ~� �� � �� _; �--�,�- � � � � .�� , �-� i� �� � _.___.. " �.� r ��,` � �,... � _ ,.. "^'SCa . _ f � �� � ■t� sl f�'� w�{� � — ��'�F;� f � �� �� ��a;# '�-..r. ���� �� �� r�1 .�. � E;� � ,_ �._� � .�r��.��:�.:�>�;��,,,,;.,..._,,, ""�;,"�"`.—'--�-.•»--�.....�..�:.,�.�,�,.«,.,,e �,,., � �,,,,� ... , . ' ' _ " � ,. ,. �.r<. , , . :� , � �. . — - r-w�.,. . - ..�f. . .. .. . s-��3.-�a.sr... .;.. .� .....«:. ,.:.:w,�...�«.s .. ...::�..�'�'-��s....ab.�..�:-%.�`�� ,.�;;..,. '� . _.. . � �`:.. ADDRESS: 3670 -TOGO RD PID#: (38) 17-117-23-31-0032 Sale Date: 07/2007 Sale Price: $148,000 2008EMV:$141,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1920 Ground Floor Area: 600 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 600 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 0% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 0 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 282 Garage#1: 242 Type: Detached Garage #2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 8,091 Sq.Ft. 0.19 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 50 Comments: � - - ►�• � `, .w'��'� �'� �� rt ':�• { � , �' �" , '�'. w��i 'a:;,,,qi,+4�. ,t � i`_�' �� �,� ��+� •��r�+�ww4 a' � � ••..,��. � ��.��"�•„. .. . �.`p,�R Ffi, '+ ..� - ...��� �� - � ri ���., h 1�L '� � J � 1 � wy�, .'�� �t �� II rlllll.illlllllll�w���, ,��� _. � � -,r. � _ �, ... .�, , . � _ � � ����� ""`�,'� � „�:���;�:,��.��, , �.�� �<��.��, � . �.�,� ''� �� x.t :.,itz�,y�t�:..."»+�w�.. �..= ���: ,� �� 9.:�€a�r�i�t�:���t�� « '����.��..�.st��. ADDRESS: 2195 - PROSPECT AVE PID#: (38) 10-117-23-31-0058 Sale Date: 06/2007 Sale Price: $177,700 2008EMV:$171,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1900 Ground Floor Area: 616 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 616 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 40°/a Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 � Open: 0 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 320 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 3,957 Sq.Ft. 0.09 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 75 Comments: � � �� �I �'�i ~���V��� i I .s �s fj�yr.��',.� � �T', 4 /'1` �` '�`:!��i � :*� � � � � � � < r,�;.�; � ;� �+� ' � .� � ,.j�. . .w.......-,. _"" F�S;: i�& C � ' � � y�, � : � a pr ' � '`��" .� .... I,:.: u .w . : . � �t�.`, � .p � !& .' M�ln✓ $i"�`a* - .N. .. . : . � . �g �� C £" NM1�� 34�aE .. �� �32y� �z;�y P4S::.' � � "�"" �+ �� . , " , .�. a x:. � � �. �� �s � p��� � • * � } ` ,,..;� � � ���,�� �d .��;� .�' "kj��%� ..J'r� . 6.�'� ,� . ,=P:r�"^. . �a�,+a��:-� .<.7`-'.m. . . - : ADDRESS: 2794 - CASCO POINT RD PID#: (38) 20-117-23-32-0018 Sale Date: 11I2007 Sale Price: $199,900 2008EMV:$199,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1941 Ground Floor Area: 848 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 848 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 80% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 192 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 112 Garage#1: 480 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 12,671 Sq.Ft. 0.29 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 65 Comments: 3 �'� ���' �,�,�. .r * Y� � ,� � ��-�+I�R •t t+��� , `�:+''°` ` '�..� '�' �w�-_•��..�" � / p w �� r . �.c {.3�..�°.�,y �T v t'��t � ��A—e r"'� A�°- .�#?':°��.iq4Z` S . Y r �^ ��g�_� � �f y�.' 'r '"`� N� � + �+.a. }�.� , Y ,�, � `�'�„�� � � � ;,g"'�G � �4S �^� ' t } "� ,� �R r ,,� �,� � ,� �, �° tF.� , ��•Y�� 4 W�A �`' � n � . � .s � � �� ��Y�} \'�! � �'�: � � , _ I s•, « w°a . 'f .,i* � 1 � ;:_. . t�3 l'.`x 1 '��'.. .. .. _. , . _ . : vk. � t ,.. �: L { a . -� _� � , p�'� . � ; �a��r� , `f$ ' '? a�� x!F'� a I I ��� ��f�� ..��.�P�-� fj �'� � . � � � j/' �".+.�.�' ,:%:_ �,.� �'�..c � .,t9 . � �% ��'' _ �' �� ; �,� � - _ � t �� ,� '"� �.. � � � ���-. ' 1: `£�} �..' � �` � . . "`" <��.,� " t ! �.,,,.. �,,.. , .<, , � - �4. � � 1„' ��' a � .... — �. ���`, �„ �" � ,'r�..�- i � . � - � ADDRESS: 3950 - NORTH SHORE DR PID#: (38) 08-117-23-33-0067 Sale Date: 06/2007 Sale Price: $220,000 2008EMV:$221,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1978 Ground Floor Area: 960 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 960 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50% Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 240 Type: Tuckunder Garage#2: 438 Type: Detached Lot Size: 20,319 Sq.Ft. 0.47 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 100 Comments: � ! �',;, '�`. _���,•».� f�i�z ;y i a: d" + - -,t.�„ a . {�� ' f��,.; n,r'' , ��+ � � > . { � . .� �.� �.,��,,,,,ya.<"'" ��".. � } �;= � • �ra tr� r < k �I 1� �� �� .. ��. a�� . � �� .�,'L [���' 3*,�� ¢�� y ; . 4T��A/"� aY � i 4 '8 .� .iY' :rsY '� �0-2���3�,.l:'�� �t,�'.5 ���/ ...—•,�•i l�. � � ��,. -"r M � � ` 7 �:' � c . z t �...�� �.�. ��� 'f � `�,�Y J `�?��+'x � ��° �#z ��y: t � -t dY�`" ,'.*�+�,�` �'��.,!s�'��. 5.x •-� a �cd. <,( ��: .� � ,{� �4� ��'��� �' � _ ��� �' — � -- �; � _ � � f Y� ��:� � '� ��' i , - . ._, . �:; �- - � ,,,_ �� ,„ �. .�, e �, � I - �:.�.���� _ � _._1� _� _____-- �,� . � _ —.� � �B�If� �'9".�z�s^*'""r� y .,�_-�" , , x , .:�.�t 5h�4 fi I . z�� ...�� �Y - � LJ...�q . � '„�'� . .;at µ ..R�. S� SCFa+.�d � .h � ,.f:. � _' . �. , .. .- •ss;t�s - .:�: �e �` _ .,. k .. -sr .»....sya ... _, ADDRESS: 3680 -TOGO RD PID#: (38) 17-117-23-31-0029 Sale Date: 1012006 Sale Price: $226,700 2008EMV:$224,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1950 Ground Floor Area: 832 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 832 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50% Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 130 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 356 Garage#1: 308 Type: Attached Garage#2: 672 Type: Detached Lot Size: 15,681 Sq.Ft. 0.36 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 90 Comments: � ,.;.... . , . � r _ _� _i�? � , ` �. �,,�; �,� �� � _�� �"'.". - ��� �� .���3 � � 's'" � ' t ;s� �f � � �' "' ' 1 � x «.� �{� '' p I ��� � J a i . .�., }. �j ¢ '`t-. •,` ' �^�'[ �'?�',�.�Y.r �� �'�+:'.. � � '� � ��� < , . „ �. � , .� . r"` +L !"' ,'i �.. I " �H�� ' 4 � � �� �. _..._.�. � �- ... . _ � " .:...,......._.... 'Ty'�� � . '�^b''.,.,.. � .�; ...,,,�.. �.._, .�� �P � '_ �ffi-.V ..,...Y'�a? '"ea'"'�:i+.� -�� 4 ;�Ir i/ _ ADDRESS: 2413 -CARMAN ST PID#: (38) 20-117-23-12-0011 Sale Date: 09/2007 Sale Price: $237,000 2008EMV:$232,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1910 Ground Floor Area: 892 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 892 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 192 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 256 Garage#1: 1,036 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 21,113 Sq.Ft. 0.48 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 150 Comments: � ; � ,y:��` ��;���}� �{ p � Yiidy!. A t �' ,j '!� t� �Y1 � � ��:�ti�4�,y ��Y a � 1 4.i V. � �. y e��� . �e� }�,.•,�., /��. �� + �. . � �;�►` � i� � �i ! F �#��� � � �� � �"Y�'a,. M� f,v�� �, N6. �.�e�`a# -�..'w `���wry . �� .�., , � j �'4' � 'e a�1 � ..�.,�.._. -- - _ .. � � ---- � „� �,v �� �� ' ;� ��r� ,�� ,� ,. �° . .�.�• _. ,�Y �p� ��� � � . — �h � � 'If� �...� � �. � I I I I��� ~.�,....�.".. .. . F� . �• V n. ✓y�+a..« ��. u . . 1i .AS)1 ��� �f�� � ` � . : •��"��"��g rta�� t��'��s ;.6 pF' �'s..'�R�„� yyr► � � �:.*. .� . � , i�..w*Yrp��`,^� ��., ._. � ,w._.�� �-s` :"'�d��M"���`�"��'�7't,. � ~f� � � .� � . .. , N' . ��:„'�..h�n.: ... . .. ADDRESS: 4108 - HIGHWOOD RD PID#: (38) 07-117-23-44-0089 Sale Date: 10/2006 Sale Price: $305,000 2008EMV:$282,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1920 Ground Floor Area: 1,121 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,121 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 40% Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 220 Garage#1: 660 Type: Tuckunder Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 13,030 Sq.Ft. 0.30 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 50 Comments: 7 {v � ' � � * + . � � �.4.,• l }�:��+5 �t ��. � �`. �� ��� � � �,�1 �Y�Y �Afg�'Y(� � ?�*3 �\\'\}�� _ ,�� ., 3 i. .. ��(� �`��V \` J �y � � S � � ' �! , 'r , � , +' � ; ,���. . ,�;� �•�� � ' � �`� j >'��� ' -` � �� /"T�.� ' '� � � �� � � �� `� �.', , ��;:��.�`:�;.�. � , �, '� x r.�:��.��- �` � �.. �;`.���-�W �� ,� ��'�>�`'�� �.�.,, �' - ;.. , , = � . � _. ,n_..,�� _ � ��- `���:� �_.� �-L ��`4 �� . . _ � � ' �' � , ;°. � � � �� ~ � _ . � �� �- _ �.- _� ....-� -- � �� f , �� �.� _ � n�- ; �,�� , _,�_, , - �_ � r �u� . . ti � - s .._ - � � ^c" .z "�.� .`.�i��, , ADDRESS: 1365 - REST POINT RD PID#: (38) 07-117-23-32-0034 Sale Date: 06/2007 Sale Price: $320,000 2008EMV:$320,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1957 Ground Floor Area: 918 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 918 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 60°/a Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 0 3/4: 2 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 1300 Garage#1: 576 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 26,036 Sq.Ft. 0.60 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 130 Comments: 8 ���M � �1 fi� �, � : ,. :z .��tf _ x�,` ... � �� j' �� �`�'��".:Y��'•�. �"� �. � �4` � < . ti�, .i' }.N r� -� �.!'. �. " '� �¢` 'a+� < r ' ;w- � ..'" ,��;. �.... t:�,;���',• �° x� ��� . _ : ..•e. .. � C,.. , i '' ,.ti'.: . . ^ �'�/�� . �._'—''.�7 i�_.__��,�...� _ ._.'_ ' �� . ._�. � . ..._.._.._.._..__ � �r, --.`r .ro:v- , �� �'r� � ��� �.�. � . � .. � y' rY�i<� � . . y r�a ,�:�3 � .biat^ . a 5 _ �r� -�i���"��''S �� . . ,d g'k.3, ,, t zj': �. ADDRESS: 1261 -WILDHURST TR PID#: (38) 07-117-23-31-0038 Sale Date: 02/2007 Sale Price: $326,000 2008EMV:$324,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1949 Ground Floor Area: 1,164 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,164 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 36 Deck: 336 Garage#1: 672 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 45,804 Sq.Ft. 1.05 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 155 Comments: � Z J *.` " �7, t#. � � x k � ��'; � ��4� � � f�z4* �� �.,��``',�;y, � �s. � , ��, � '' �Ji'�.���„� � � � �� y=� � '� �� � g�$ ,�• {� .�� �r y� .��� �'-� �� �;��'�„ �,',*��:..�i�� � _ � �,.� �, ��a � �� 4 � ''�'� `-'`�. � ,;,,� �.,.,��,� � ,�� ;� ��ea ;� �i�,* �: ��="''"'� v�., .;-���' �� �' :" �„i., . -s,, ' , " ,�.. _ ..+�. 4 M � .. .,. # �" "!, �a` n 4. �.�. . .� . b,.. , . s; yr�« � �,,� _ . . . �..,�s�� $� ��}� ADDRESS: 1368 - NORTH ARM DR PID #: (38) 07-117-23-41-0054 Sale Date: 06/2007 Sale Price: $412,000 2008EMV:$351,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1950 Ground Floor Area: 2,144 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,144 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 60% Finished Bsmt. Area: 20% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 24 Deck: 1268 Garage#1: 778 Type: Tuckunder Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 10,478 Sq.Ft. 0.24 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 50 Comments: lo � '" � ..----...;�^"�' ' _"`�_ ' , ���.�.• , � t{��,;„,rai,,,y�,,.�:',��,,,..�;_, , �,•, ,� ����qf i� "S E �w.l..r�.=.,....v_isa 4�_^ �� �1�y���'°4���% '�<�� �..g4.�. s ii tjf� s� . �P .� � R. ^...r .:,� '��. '� ` :�A '�'i«`,�.� � t"�' g' _ t r 4a� �1 / r � F' # t Ft d�,f 4�,�1.� c ,,J 1,-���,� ���, �' � �-��t� t € jr✓ � �°�" .� � �.�` � �:' � � - �� i �� - ,���•�'�._ • �l _� � .� ��,. � �' }. � �, � '� � �_�: ,�� � � � � , . � � •.��� _ �� � � �. �} r�� . ........--.-- _ -° -- . _.� �. , ; � �I �; - �`_ , i ; � �, � , _ -_ - �,., _ „ ,.. : . . � --.-.- - - . .. _� _ . .., . �; �� _ .�-.�� � _ �� � �� _ � ADDRESS: 795 - FERNDALE RD N PID#: (38) 36-118-23-12-0014 Sale Date: 05/2007 Sale Price: $1,150,000 2008EMV:$993,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1962 Ground Floor Area: 1,938 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,938 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 90% Finished Bsmt. Area: 80% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 1004 Garage#1: 780 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 123,068 Sq.Ft. 2.83 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: l� ' � � , , � � � � _ .� �_ ',�,.m� �� � °�� .�.. � � �� , �. �.,, �t � � ���;�� -�; y� � , � � �� ,��,�. ?N.$� 4� �A p'y' ' �� k �,-� yar , .. o �����' y��`v...ln. i �.�'- ^_} � a3'�€'� �i d�' r� ,g, ,74 t'!r g �.� ba$ f 4.* ��i ..... .� h� �� ,- Y ': �^�'" � `l� 'y Y � �� �E '�Bfy, t„ � �g� f'4 �y% .%�:9d t���a :-yl� ' ' �Y� �� � '�Y� � ..��.. �, '�y-y_ 't .�-d C _ s,�",- = �-a v �,�?X`.�« mL$a�^� ' � ,, ��> . 3 p . • i . _ ' - .� . � .��. _ .,� . � .���� . �.� ��p ��I� .,x._ . . �� � 4 �'�J�' '. C" +rR�' =e<a- � 'a,y � - �"v�> f ,. . �' y:t. 1�1i:# :i.kL �f ,�' i�.. ,. P'�".. , , y ,. � i. �. � �. ,:.W. �. .G::.�M.M.,. . . . .. .... �r ��� � ��.B�W:�,,.�� �� A Y�� � . -� . _„�0 ) ,.. ;e4,o,v.✓�._. ... 3 -.., x --a._.,3sS�Az^=i-.,��._ �...>,,.a.�k�E ��.s,'h,...,..,, . ADDRESS: 1795 -SHADYWOOD RD PID#: (38) 17-117-23-21-0008 Sale Date: 07/2007 Sale Price: $405,000 2008EMV:$382,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Split Entry Age: 1978 Ground Floor Area: 1,568 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,568 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 80% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 0 3/4: 2 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 180 Garage#1: 832 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 30,899 Sq.Ft. 0.71 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 13 - 91 Effective Frontage: 125 Comments: 1,� .., y�,, . � . ��� K�� t��� .:Y / �. i r�r ti ~a �y.4 t'� ��.� �'��y «g,�� - � �,i�"' J,�" ' +�_„ ' . `�'�{� ��. �'1 " :+� �j �t �n h •.� � �d�'. �r. r q� ,�.� 'Ea t,a7.' "4� �v ....1....7+�.+�,z( w+ � . . , , 7 ��,�'i ���� r � ���`�,+�� � ►...� " . � r�w'�p»� -;� ! i 0 Y�° .> /'� r 3. � � � � � � � Ri �— ----�'"����k i��" �� ��C� �. `""'�_ _.` � _ _ . �. � .� �,;�� �, ' a,�'�:� �� ��''�ti w��� w ,�� ,��.. n ^�.sYn.r� � . ��� t.�W" . . � w y ++� �a�� �p '�,rsu �,s�s�5'xaR..%, �X ADDRESS: 2640 - FOX ST PID#: (38) 04-117-23-42-0008 Sale Date: 05/2007 Sale Price: $565,000 2008EMV:$537,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Split Entry Age: 1970 Ground Floor Area: 1,196 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,196 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100°/a Finished Bsmt. Area: 30% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 230 Deck: 140 Garage#1: 528 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 146,135 Sq.Ft. 3.35 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 450 Comments: �3 �" ��' II �, r. , _ ' z;, _,,, �; _ �_ - �3',` ;a �r"�y?h _ . _1- ':•y ar' ..�+'S1 � . ' . 3�d� . .�, �e ��7 .. " ' � b -i. . .., .�.�� 4-''1. ' <m.+.+�� �. :`{� _ �`Y � � _ ;l�. � ,w � t l .� ..� �X.e...y : n- .::.: .Y� ADDRESS: 50 - LANDMARK DR PID#: (38) 05-117-23-21-0019 Sale Date: 11/2006 Sale Price: $815,000 2008EMV:$776,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Split Entry Age: 1994 Ground Floor Area: 1,833 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,833 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 80% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 0 3/4: 2 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 336 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 600 Garage#1: 546 Type: Tuckunder Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 103,231 Sq.Ft. 2.37 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: � � �� � �� � ✓ :�� ��� `� :r� ""�i"^"'et��..�*�� �$�t#r��� ,�;a "'+-s t,�1� �j�[4 J' . ' 1 p � �' . tr (� 'N ,: � � r � � ''!'j>r u �;_`. 4� ; s�=t i �t'. f �. - -s st -. .! '�, �"�� . '.�.._. . �,.� � , '"' �. ,, . � �- � ��� . . F � a ��1 I � � �t� -0. � ;,�,�,'. .� �����I ����� � il � � " «^. �� � , ' � _�.;, 3 rt� l .. yq .. - c -t�.� � .._�� ¢4 �� r . �.��k �..�T ..'��'*.a..s E`=� �`_ '!�` '� � �+'��°.�m+x� ..a aCfs W ,.. 'rMP' > � � �, � m` ����r����, �S�.�y�, . � -�y�� y�i� y, t. �� "�E ','�" - �� ,R � ����� �� T� � .,,. � ., .��� ��� }�.:.` ?� ��E ," �,,,«w. �� °"a"' . . '� � ^� �t: �>��ii�C��aJ����..�:'L�"4s:�r��.a.r�_.Y`an: `xta.� �� _ �i.�avn�`W.,.,„.�..p�, ��Y ADDRESS: 2160 - PROSPECT AVE PID #: (38) 10-117-23-31-0017 Sale Date: 08/2007 Sale Price: $150,000 2008EMV:$134,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.50 Story Age: 1900 Ground Floor Area: 560 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 840 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 20% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 80 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 0 Type: Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 6,440 Sq.Ft. 0.15 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 50 Comments: l� ` � - � � � ��..� � Y � �'. �� ��h�Y ♦� � i �j 4 �,'�r' ,�;,,, _ `,.,-y,�,,,,.+�,�.,�.���,Y_,`W�,�, ^1 w°��"°`r�"� �"�. S .� �`� _ � � � � - � � � .'� »��'� ,.: � � F ,�,:~ '�:.+�r.p�''� � *»�a ��y, � ''�. -M" '�^ ' � �' .,J✓ �k- .9� rf �+�.. 4S= � �� + �' JR��� ��� ��`� ,V .:i } ' �i�'.F � � � �. ~�a� t�, � �. '� '`=,����. .. .... y�. ;� � F��'�'x�� �s v�.��^d� � m� �� �q,.-.�ti�:�rA � `i}`��'.�k.rx-.�?k .ri 3; � .�� ��t;35c��x��.... .. ' � ^ ., . , . .� 5c� :.. , °� ADDRESS: 3596 - LIVINGSTON AVE PID#: (38) 17-117-23-43-0034 Sale Date: 11/2006 Sale Price: $197,725 2008EMV:$186,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.75 Story Age: 1945 Ground Floor Area: 768 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,344 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 360 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 12,635 Sq.Ft. 0.29 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 100 Comments: l�% ,-,�,�-�-,`.� �' �` - � .} ' -� ..���� �' � _ ' � '.� ,_:�� ,`�, .,-,"r ' C ������ ', � `i � , '�, � � � . _ �.� 4 � � � . __ ', � ,_ l � ; tl � � ' � Y��� � � ■� �� �� �� � «� 5 �ytp� "_ _�. v'�.,.„r d r a . .� y.r3�t3 i"'��"'_ �« pc*--_:. � .....'�."'�i.�'�� 5 Sdr'�- �f �� 0 _ �' # � i .. � �t� �,.'� �i�'; #Ci�.� s,�. � > � � �� n�}yii{e„ , ,. z � ; �� ..` .� i 4!i�' t .����. � k� �� i! �A�� - �� � a ,'! �; r ,�'��� �� � "..�a-""" � 4 ' ` ^ 1 • � *;�^" , x k;. �- ..,:._ . ; - _--a. � � w t..'�'��� �`t; L� ' � �M <.. -� . �, _ ADDRESS: 2431 - CARMAN ST PID#: (38) 20-117-23-12-0012 Sale Date: 08/2007 Sale Price: $230,000 2008EMV:$214,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.75 Story Age: 1910 Ground Floor Area: 1,180 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,380 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 60% Finished Bsmt. Area: 20% Fireplaces: 0 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 176 Deck: 98 Garage#1: 264 Type: Tuckunder Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 8,501 Sq.Ft. 0.20 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 65 Comments: l � .t � I,.._hi.�" ...«R. yR , • ft�.r* ,���` . '� ., ., MJ JF���fX��� F � ' 3 +� ,. � . �� � {� '' F 7vt� � � `� '� ' h " �3�. ti� Y ",� '� �� yl .. +tll. ''I� II� ���" `��� r�r� �• � J �P�� ..i"�� �,.".� ��~4 _..y� j �.,,. a ... d y_ t7iF'' � �V 1 � � k�C�� - �� � ✓�f"+�*`�a ;',1.1 . .~�a, �. e.� r. - jJ"�.�� `1 .{' �i• �,.'*{. . ' �Y 4 �. Y' i}� ,_, + !'�� 'A � I,���� �I� � w-�,'•���� i , � �� ���r � tA.. �-s � � -i� r--�„ . ..�. - _ �,�-- , . � , � ___ � :- q y� .,: ..� .. � — � , _ � ,_ � ��. * � � ����� �� '`� `� � v��.�.._"__ �9'yt� >�x, G� ���� � ¢� ��;��, _ , . � r.. �,.. = -��,�- " ; , , . r. � _ �m- . . . :�� ,. , �-, � _ : � �- „� 9, - .,�� _ �_ , ADDRESS: 4495 - BAYSIDE RD PID#: (38) 06-117-23-21-0004 Sale Date: 08/2007 Sale Price: $256,000 2008EMV:$245,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.25 Story Age: 1900 Ground Floor Area: 840 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,032 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 0% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 500 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 84,287 Sq.Ft. 1.93 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 165 Comments: �� f �F �� � „���'lg.. �� �� � . .. �t F � �. . � . . . � -.,. '�' � ! � - �, j ti�" ^ '� � � <' �f. � 1��:rv � "��� '�'� T�� � ` ::� . �' ,� �,,� ���, � .` � �.:t ADDRESS: 585 -STUBBS BAY RD N PID#: (38) 32-118-23-24-0006 Sale Date: 09/2007 Sale Price: $460,000 2008EMV:$428,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.50 Story Age: 1900 Ground Floor Area: 1,082 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,258 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 60% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 144 Garage#1: 680 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 213,582 Sq.Ft. 4.90 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: t' 9 _ _ -- -y '—� . nY:'. -�v;;� :;+t.ti ;. .-� � � , ,• . F � , -..�� � , , � }, _ '`� . ,� _ , , �v �`C -� `� � + �,r,� � � X _' ``�•=;w�'�`t , ," r,�t �""t t �,J ,� ��� ��� � �� _ ; � ` A. 4'" �"��'F g Rt.s. Pr ' '� � 4 � ,.�;' �- � ��.�..� .�., '� "�'`� '� ° � ._ ' •� "� i - r�� �� . ,;.�'�.ar 1� y� `'���'�� :X.. a y.r N' t�. . � . F. n.,- �_ '�� t „ '. r�1•y { + i�� �5*. ��r �N. 'il ��r �4�: °'�'� "� x'�t¢f'�=.':.� � II d}�"jV_ ' _ � x .„¢,. {i�" ,� -i' y s K'3k �r��✓.r ± ;•'h ,,,sY :� .' ,`>.'U 9ti+*"� .:n �^ a 5 a +�f: =x rf -X., ��'�w,e j �. .�,4����,�..�� ��r�� � ��t�'�.. 4� ��.,���� ..��- �� � k d`� z , . r .. - ,<;:.. �' ' x� , .,.,. . ... . ADDRESS: 4355 -CHIPPEWA LA PID#: (38) 31-118-23-42-0020 Sale Date: 03/2007 Sale Price: $595,000 2008EMV:$581,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.50 Story Age: 1910 Ground Floor Area: 1,240 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,552 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00°/a Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 60 Garage#1: 352 Type: Detached Garage#2: 972 Type: Detached Lot Size: 224,020 Sq.Ft. 5.14 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 370 Comments: �� .��q ']4,7;. J. Y�' . '_��j�r�'1=� i; �, ��'Az3�f f � 4 w j} �- � �� rrt� � �h `�� 1 vc � � } � yC`y�`(4't? I I , ..al _ 4 l-e Pi•k w�� q����t` /� iP' 'F �`�.� �'i. � $ `;���� .�`; �` . :,�:��..� ,� ;�x'. „s.;,:� � ::� :!S 7 L:Z::: n� {� . u 1. ;�". "" Y;r �, ; �; n'��."% ,� . �y -� �,� . , ' .. `� ��. „ _, v- �..„.;� . , . ,, �` , � � . :� .� ,__.. �, �-, ,,�..�. ,�-. � ���„ ._�_ -_��. ��� �� �� � ������ .�..��,'�j�.,��y,,, „».}»�i�' ; .. ,Z�a. .n..��r ADDRESS: 3940 -WATERTOWN RD PID#: (38) 32-118-23-32-0001 Sale Date: 01/2007 Sale Price: $735,000 2008EMV:$658,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.75 Story Age: 1898 Ground Floor Area: 1,004 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,652 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100°/a Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% _ Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Fuli: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 332 Screened: 0 Open: 32 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 0 Type: Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 337,317 Sq.Ft. 7.74 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 550 Comments: �-l e� .f _ ���" ��c'x,' . .,..�i �: . , . .. ��3.'���.>. . a. ' . � � , � � t � � � � �e ', ,r� �� �� �3* f +' .e��� . 'k � t � I r , s .���, -'��` y �,y- $ - . a . � ���'� �� � �_.M .�� ��„�. �. _��� `�'��tt "� � fl �. ' ' .,,���.H .-_�+. �n k � � ADDRESS: 1080 - KNOLL MANOR RD PID#: (38) 26-118-23-31-0013 Sale Date: 07/2007 Sale Price: $770,000 2008EMV:$725,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.75 Story Age: 1989 Ground Floor Area: 2,399 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 3,707 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 120% Finished Bsmt. Area: 10% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 57 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 818 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 87,267 Sq.Ft. 2.00 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: vC-� +f. .� �` . i�y� 1�� f,�t t . . � .i . 1-{' �'. . ... 'N C Lil y .� ►. . ' , . . , .;- � ' ` 'x ' t . I �.� y: . ��. - . ���� �`� nr P�- i .� . r� . � � ������, � ��f°���A � I � � ,* ,_...,t;,. . � ���r _�� f � ��� i'�{�,��� � � �� `�, f,y� § . �.—�_•. �.., _ "'�" �`. ..-0�.... •ss�* ;,�� �:aw � �:�.�����r ,�::. �$$�.,' t, � .��� : � � �� � �� ;;.�.a `=" '°�'�.*��� ,.,...,��:��v� .�-._ �"`" �, ,��,. �'.,os�,s� � _� �.,. .,�,,.�...a� _ � ."'-'F"� . '"E? . . . . f � � % �..E<#�*-f..5<`.u _.a.. �. _ ri'� ..@ M.. sr`.Y k a,kw�t � ._.. _..._..,.. ..d.:.�.a ,�..£�'£«.�.a.�rNaa.� ADDRESS: 165 - LUCE LINE RIDGE PID#: (38) 31-118-23-34-0008 Sale Date: 06/2007 Sale Price: $830,000 2008EMV:$783,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.75 Story Age: 1987 Ground Floor Area: 2,460 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 3,330 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 80% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 40 Deck: 346 Garage#1: 1,176 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 109,824 Sq.Ft. 2.52 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: �3 . ' � � ,� * � i�� L w . � 1 .. �i.,� t 1 � .1.f . . r� . d�v.� ,r4 i ._ -� . .. - .3.,�s � . . . , x � �� . . 3 � � � �i'��'� 9 ' �.:��Y.. � 4t �� y �` Y d• t . � . f d. � f �� � i:�; , � ; ! - . . �- ,� �Y ,�,�•.� '�, � `«� .1 � � �� _-::�� r� �� � �` '�. .: �. :Y:. � � _ �T-.��.�. __ '� � , , ..� :.z _ '�.. - - `��.''�+�'.� �► ...�.�. , ADDRESS: 4240 - NORTH SHORE DR PID#: (38) 07-117-23-43-0014 Sale Date: 04/2007 Sale Price: $380,500 2008EMV:$367,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1925 Ground Floor Area: 1,672 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,277 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 30% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 130 Deck: 280 Garage#1: 660 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 29,881 Sq.Ft. 0.69 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: ,�-y ��. �t;�'�t' �` ��{ 1 t �'".�� /'� �� � � t . _ / � t _` t `r J' I � �,,� � \� r i � �' � .�.. _ �';> ,,�j,i. t ,v�: r.:... � �, - � �� �.,. � ' .;^- .t � _ :.,`'_ �a^ � ' �i. ,Y„� ppp� `� ���ro t! i° 1 . �' � �.� i�� J �.' a � � #.�< ---,m� � t�� � ` %f ��� �` ," - :.. ' s 0 .,:=a �`��� , � w`�* �- ,�`, a i��'� — „�„ ADDRESS: 1450 -TANGLEWOOD RD PID#: (38) 26-118-23-32-0015 Sale Date: 12/2006 Sale Price: $655,000 2008EMV:$655,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1988 Ground Floor Area: 2,006 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 3,418 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 70% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 168 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 674 Garage#1: 726 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 86,762 Sq.Ft. 1.99 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 310 Comments: �� �,........,�, ;�c — . .,�r.iy_ - ..�:., ,�i �.." �V �,, ' <. � a�. �yy r �` ,�s y �' g *"°°`�. .t_ K.�° d`' .. ���� ��� 4 ��� � } tn =-�. - �:=�- :°.y �,� �-»�=��_� <� � �i�e `'�. _ . _,._, ,--. . � � _ - , � �• _. _ `� �, _ �____- .=�-: _` , ' - � . . �-:•�- , � �.a �� �� �� y i. �,. �', �;� ..,'�. A���) ��� ..' '_ rn: ..{Htif�s �_ �--�:.� —..,. � ,�'"`'^.r"X..,tl,'r{�- � � ���3Fzce�� �,,.� +�� r" '�� �a���i «� ��;��. ADDRESS: 1995 - FOX RIDGE RD PID#: (38) 03-117-23-13-0005 Sale Date: 08/2007 Sale Price: $674,900 2008EMV:$623,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1968 Ground Floor Area: 1,554 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,842 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 90% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 468 Garage#1: 576 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 44,233 Sq.Ft. 1.02 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: ��> � .�� z` �� e �� 14 '. � � � i �, � ���� � � � _ . �1 ji r� � '�„r�` K� ``\� t * ��3.� ����� \� - ... � �i '. S . � �;-' `_ D e4 t -.... ,er t r� �- '}= � . .� , '��.��,, � � � t �__ �� � � � �' �� � ! �l ^� n- i :�a �4 .�r-:� � �.. � �$ .. .., "'t '<�, �; �^ S� ' ' 3 � � � -.:^.':�,�� ��� �s"' . . ADDRESS: 2140 -SALEM CT PID#: (38) 27-118-23-31-0012 Sale Date: 03/2007 Sale Price: $680,000 2008EMV:$653,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1986 Ground Floor Area: 1,736 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 3,192 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 60% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 168 Screened: 0 Open: 56 Deck: 248 Garage#1: 768 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 89,546 Sq.Ft. 2.06 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: � � .� y�,.�'�t'` [��' � � v� �JI � r� M{ e{ �� {� '} y, i*� � � r � r� t f��k ;a v. 't` �:L ` �� � 1 `� � ' �+� �; t r•. ��� � y. r .+r t Y! �• ' -�.t. ,+"Y +. s 'I �� IN� rs,, — •,,- , +:, .�`..'_."..y ,e��" 1'^ �','� � ���-�k,� '—� _ . � r � 1, �_� k �. ^��IJ'w r� „ ,1'••.!; '+f` ✓ :�. +�e ,�+�i�'�„�' -� �,���;y�^ 4 i �1-. ��1��'I}�i%Vo' `' .'' �� '�.� t A ..�. ; tr!�,�A ?Yl'� � Y Za t:�" �t't'r-� �' jE 'X� 4;� t e ,'a�r�'r�'�'�; �f;��''�' S:.~�4 y �y�Lti.� � ��� rr.« ,:..�= �y'..,�� ��a, •, ` .14t ���:�;�- �'��'r`-w �J1W.�..�''a' r ��� ��''�.+. *t 51t'�Y a';�,G°�! ,�}"��('yi �"y'�� ���' �^�; � ��� �*� n w� � ��� 1`�.r ;iY��'',�I'"�1'l .,�'Vr Ni �t� � r�:.,... ... . ..;. �r p,t ,ir i. ;f ,q, � f i�{�, ,�, �� • '-Y, � � 4 ��� t r•�i ��� �t +�. y";.,�,r�. .,(p. •�M. 1 � i [. {a�,-�r�4� ,Y. w. ! 1r�"1.�". ��l � �f��� � ��! �/R ���� �"�F i�,r'.y� _yya+�'•f.R � `�` � :.g��l',��' a1V4:�+a ?/'f; �Y'+`L+V:A' a:� -'"T +�'at 1 �,� ' 's'��'#.fAH..1t�� ���. :Ni..` a: t� :'!� .V�.... � ��� �'�s'��� . �"`:S �"��.���� ..� ��:. ,..;�,i�e`,�6Y���� ADDRESS: 3505 -WATERTOWN RD PID #: (38) 32-118-23-43-0007 Sale Date: 05/2007 Sale Price: $835,000 2008EMV:$810,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1956 Ground Floor Area: 1,236 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,303 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 80% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 336 Open: 182 Deck: 420 Garage#1: 624 Type: Detached Garage#2: 624 Type: Detached Lot Size; 118,810 Sq.Ft. 2.73 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 320 Comments: �� � � � „: �$_ � , � , � - � t ...�; �� �`1�I i'' '�"�, � � 4, � a ' � � � ���, � , � �� ►�. �:: ��' �, �� � � ^� � :�� �t �� -�- � . � ..�..'_ ��� �� � :��,� " ���.�� ;, � �}-�;� ��� �n�` , ��'�"� F .�,,.... ` �� � ' . � � # , : .�y. :.;x _F 'rs�.U ��b""*�,�� � s �'i�..�-a a`"t' �,;�'v 'd�*+� � ADDRESS: 950 -WILLOW VIEW DR PID#: (38) 28-118-23-44-0017 Sale Date: 11/2007 Sale Price: $960,000 2008EMV:$870,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 2001 Ground Floor Area: 1,642 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,849 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50°/a Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 192 Open: 224 Deck: 156 Garage#1: 888 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 50,433 Sq.Ft. 1.16 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 175 Comments: �9 ��$ �� ,.;i�� r, �,;�� ` . �. � � �Y,. ra�;�.��- , _,Q ...,, f ,.. ' ,; . . . � �s,... .. ,., � '� ;'�m. ` v�.: r; s A y � s '45�,,, . � � � d�k '�,� „� A 'j � � x � ° _ s � �� ;�"v."".� � � �.'�' -£�f� 1��, _ ' . Y�_ � i ADDRESS: 2735 - COUNTRYSIDE DR W PID#: (38) 04-117-23-12-0018 Sale Date: 04/2007 Sale Price: $1,055,000 2008EMV:$987,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1995 Ground Floor Area: 2,453 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 3,968 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 70% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 224 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 503 Garage#1: 840 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 107,872 Sq.Ft. 2.48 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: �c7 �,. -;k�. ���` '�� .�� re n ^'f ti , ' -�r.;... �'C -.,.} . . �i� �'„'�,� :w^,� �� .,�. � ��' � _� � '� '� , : � �� � �:.;� � .,�� .r. �� . � .:,�.. � .. �v� .�. � ;'r � � . ... *. .` � " � .."" . . , . .-. � � � {, � � �� ������ �� ;t � �H ��+ �`����� r_`� � � � ..�� �� ° :� � � ; � : # �f,r�� � �.: ���,,; ,s��.� "�� ��� s '� �.:a F E i'^�3. =�3 . : �- �. � � •`. -.�a' _ � _._�� ��a _„�. .�. . •�r. ... _ . �, ._, „ .�.�,. _ . _ . � a , � .��w+a�ww.w�+�"� '..,"""'.."�""` ��^....r.-..-.a._ � .+,.wr•��.n"�^^-^:.,.,,�.�,,.,. „r�v> » s,s, .e .,.�.�^�'°' � ?.,.,,*Mw.. . . � .wa..,. � �, ..� ` �--" -...� ,., .�., .. .. ....->..A..w. -�' ' ' _ , +� �< • '� .-:aW.HW . . - .. «._.."'�.+�..... . �'e. � . _ _,ys+: _ , , . � . '� _. _.. � . . �"� ` .z x a .. �.y+": . . `a[ ; � . . .: � *,+. ' ,rv s`� . . . _ ,�-.r " . x�.:, . ..... ' s...Pa*�Ar, , , _, .�� � ..� .:.t. ` .�.z���m.Y�.^" . . �..±'. e: ... . _... s , , ..-. .... . � .... . . ,. ..� . ' .. ' � ... ADDRESS: 259 - HOLLANDER RD PID#: (38) 25-118-23-43-0017 Sale Date: 11/2006 Sale Price: $1,085,000 2008EMV:$970,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1983 Ground Floor Area: 2,782 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 4,210 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 60% Finished Bsmt. Area: 60% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 256 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 60 Garage#1: 816 Type: Attached Garage#2: 1,680 Type: Attached Lot Size: 89,430 Sq.Ft. 2.05 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 204 Comments: �7 l 3 ��� �F i y� �" �'� � y �3 .:r�`'� � wr .�� .° � �� � * � � � � � � ,�, �� � i i -� - � i � ,� , , �._ ADDRESS: 20 -CRYSTAL CREEK RD PID#: (38) 33-118-23-33-0007 Sale Date: 05/2007 Sale Price: $1,115,000 2008EMV:$1,032,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1999 Ground Floor Area: 1,872 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 3,726 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 80% Firepiaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 221 Open: 45 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 895 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 110,996 Sq.Ft. 2.55 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: 3v� , i.. :-� : - .,K � � � �� %� ` ; ` � +,. � �� i �t'�x f�� 'i. r � �< `. � � tS t 1 ;�,. 1 ���.,R'. �° - ���+�,,.� �, ,,��; -•. . �,/ � �4i` i��. � .} � . ��� Ef«;�- ,( •� rac;' 'ot _,��' . ��- . �� � ` � � '� : � ',�,��.,��-' 4_ , �, .�,%'' �� .9���'� b �., � �� � i�y_ _ �.e�� ...+wt,. +�t�. . .., . .. .,.. . ,� . „�:'..: . ..� '�' x � ���� : a 4�. � ;,� � � �� ., . . . . „�.j ��w�� ��.N�, . � Y�' Bt�-r�„4....5.."� ... ... �....w '�f�....,� ... . ,. ,,...�o.awesef . ADDRESS: 2005 -SUGARWOOD DR PID#: (38) 34-118-23-21-0011 Sale Date: 10/2007 Sale Price: $1,264,250 2008EMV:$1,085,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1996 Ground Floor Area: 2,370 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 3,335 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 160 Open: 63 Deck: 154 Garage#1: 936 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 36,640 Sq.Ft. 0.84 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: 33 �r '}�^�"�� .F;N . . . . � � . t i J��� � . <' � ~`4+�.ry. T eb �'�� �ri�i.� � � �y�"M � 4� \lf ,. � Y ,�. � a��R�. ���. ,�' �' t �. '+. �-..:n.: .. ks �� .o-� ;,.t'r ADDRESS: 1260 - FRENCH CREEK DR PID#: (38) 10-117-23-32-0012 Sale Date: 06/2007 Sale Price: $1,330,000 2008EMV:$1,245,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1988 Ground Floor Area: 2,342 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 4,044 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50% Fireplaces: 3 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 145 Open: 48 Deck: 544 Garage#1: 1,236 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 71,325 Sq.Ft. 1.64 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: .�r �-� �� � � - E. k ��1�' ' - z �� �;� �� - � ��. � � � � , ,: _ , y r ; , ; , . �_, � .�- r ., . . :! ' '' 4 - J 4 .� .:\ ��: i rr _ �r E , � ��� y� � ,:L � ;� i �► r � � �t �' �� � , r - k, f ...:.se.:�- ::- _:>+�i..`awiir: �, � �.d a _- _ ,� _�. - �t �� - .� ADDRESS: 430 -STUBBS BAY RD N PID#: (38) 32-118-23-13-0005 Sale Date: 06/2007 Sale Price: $1,770,000 2008EMV:$1,706,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 2006 Ground Floor Area: 3,122 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 4,744 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 70% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths- Deluxe: 1 Full: 2 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 253 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 533 Garage#1: 1,402 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 0 Sq.Ft. 0.00 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: �� t � � r�;��„ I �,� =�.� .��:.b� ;.^ .a.. � �+� � � - k r J-.« p�:, ��� � �� ���;� t�-j�7�p ,. ,y �»' �� � T ��• � � ,1, �,4', A ,-� �'.'�'�.. �p -� - �,�:uiU:<I . 4� � .� , - _-� � .��" - ���� ,E�" .,- T ,r _ _ _,,_ ,-., � , <- . , ,.> ,..� �*;�, ' <�: <. . , . . , - „ . ,. , ,.� ADDRESS: 2845 -WATERTOWN RD PID#: (38) 04-117-23-21-0003 Sale Date: 07/2007 Sale Price: $2,700,000 2008EMV:$2,452,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 2005 Ground Floor Area: 6,219 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 9,863 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 0% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 3 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 2 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 2 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 105 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 1,215 Type: Attached Garage#2: 1,056 Type: Attached Lot Size: 107,405 Sq.Ft. 2.47 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: �� �f� i � �. � �- . . . .;,3,,-,�_�� w '-� � .._ 6 .,,„�,.- . ... ,.., .....� . _ ._.� ... :-wr-- -- — _.�..�.-- ; _ �+�� .::.,.�-�� �� � �. „�3., , � . t,f� � �'�" �`� ���'�. � '�.�':,�. �.� T •, ~� ,����y�����:I �."' �r~` - f'-'�+�.�..:_.: ..� � `� `� �i :�+w„�,�,�+.,,,�,.� ..�+er�' �-:.�wr. ''`� +�„� �� � . ��r� .�. i�„" v �,�;,. y +3, F � S� ^�i� 's �� �:b� w��"��� xi�r. N• rr R-f- .��N `,.� .. . .� ' � ..� . �w`- �� ;waL� .g ,��' r ,- ',�.i��,� :�` ,�w.. i .. �, ' " '� , � �, ..,r.,��t .,�.r .��. �...,ae�".s` �'�-m�asa� +�.xs ADDRESS: 3675 - NORTH SHORE DR PID #: (38) 08-117-23-34-0052 Sale Date: 05/2007 Sale Price: $643,975 2008EMV:$601,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1972 Ground Floor Area: 1,344 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,344 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 0% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 256 Garage#1: 528 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 8,618 Sq.Ft. 0.20 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 9 - 9 Effective Frontage: 50 Comments: Crystal Bay 37 � � ,�-� � '•x �, _ r � � _ �""�"' ; �r '�' a �*i ��� ,�:� � f� ,�' '�'`� :� .- � � f'" lt , t'. � , � � `i , � i � �, � �� ��,.. , � -_a ,��< .��.. �' �� ' .� 't �, �� �� � . _ — a e , ..a.,..� � t ,. . .. � .f r 1+':"' �� ` . . ����*�... � A� �� �, �'�'�`,J�:.:�. �� ' ,. �+ils+�.y�s;�S%+��:.�szr 'n. �i+n, ���'„' r e, i. ^•• ..�� �.t �4 ,..����� a,.._._� "r�� �;:>� ��� �4�'�z .._..�,...�,�..,..�'� ,�*x. F..,,..���`*� ADDRESS: 2785 -SHADYWOOD RD PID#: (38) 21-117-23-24-0054 Sale Date: 10/2006 Sale Price: $1,400,000 2008EMV:$1,415,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1980 Ground Floor Area: 2,256 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,256 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 0% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 148 Open: 0 Deck: 1175 Garage#1: 1,232 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 28,814 Sq.Ft. 0.66 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 28 - 5 Effective Frontage: 100 Comments: Upper Main Lake .�� �,�� �.' +�; � �'� ,����''" I � n i` f'� '` �� J .+y9 ti �'� * Fua, ;� r.' �� �J � �$;*i. '��+��� �i„��. ��I �� r ..,� � b� ,�' �� � "�.iy � � ��� � ��' �I.�l� y` �`,� ��'.�., . . �, t � '".�,.. i`� ,;,.i . . � � i .._.._.._. __, .�aT''^'.� :�. � .� � —_ � .�� �"" � �I'� H'��p ���� � .,.:.'.7, - 3.7 �.Mn` �,. s x ✓ � M�y i v � I� .� ' ;r4.NK-.1r�'. . . � � , , n t . . �, s._„ �k� �' ��.. . � .-: eµ .r. ,_.. ... e� � 'a'';t-3��'- .y. � l. Y a+, ,. ,.�'S ._ . � ,`. .e� . '��'�e`. ^ . . ,.,1• . , r r� . .,. ����d ���'�" �� ADDRESS: 2515 - NORTH SHORE DR PID#: (38) 09-117-23-41-0002 Sale Date: 07/2007 Sale Price: $1,700,000 2008EMV:$1,628,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 1958 Ground Floor Area: 1,984 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,984 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 382 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 588 Type: Tuckunder Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 62,316 Sq.Ft. 1.43 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 9 - 5 Effective Frontage: 140 Comments: Crystal Bay �J �a �.,� �� ; # �� :�; � `�� ,�� ., ; , �� ��•�.'� _ , �, , 3 �} � + � � ������� _ r.�t ,� ��� , �� � r-.�'�` �� �,� t��'� �N. � -�. z, � r/' �" � k' ' ''�7t�y ' �i ..�ir k� ' �. R. F'� � ,.� s`�,.��,�. >a��„ � i ��9 i ii � � _� ._....._ - . .�^..- 1 � ` . , - ,,,�, , x�:.:��� r"' �r'�r..:..e. , ,_. � ..�E�»kd"�� . � �^c��'`�2� � ,�''�::C- tt` . >;� � � � rr " � _ ,�,.; �;;�; � _ ~� � .. x�a�_�`� t , . r�,.: ,-c . g�� �. 7� � r. - � �v��f.�i j �'�';. �t` ��l � .x z . '� . - - ; r Sc .k �-.L: /` `er_�..,.. ��4 q{�, k ,��yt d'�, �_. w � .�;.. �.� . � � t�'�-' }..� t,'���� � 'j`-= n }�J, .w .�"S. � ' � ,7' ' f������ � ��; >.2 �� ��� ,. � �� . ✓a ` -- :.r,:.r'ti...� � '`F `^'-�«„E, , . .. � �� �� � � — ,` � � . �.�n vc M1,i: P ,�� a.."r':,'��' ` x4...:�.t, -}#...$_ �."` . ;.r � ,�!;= .-,_,,, '.i , . . .. . . .. ,x..yk._,_, � ..r- �,, ��� � �.- �......- .: _'". -»$"'�, ' __....... ___ � - o-�,.3, `�x,�.% " ,.' , a^f' io ., .. �- ....-_- .:�. �Y�g ' '"'�'„k" . ; qY� s-0 - �" T�� � �'"�e�� _ �,� �"� � —��." ' « �,: � ; �; _:_' �_� _•+:�T .,� .� .� � � `� �'��:�.�w...e ` .. . F� — - ADDRESS: 2545 - DUNWOODY AVE PID#: (38) 20-117-23-21-0030 Sale Date: 0512007 Sale Price: $1,550,000 2008EMV:$1,519,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Split Level Age: 1959 Ground Floor Area: 2,364 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,364 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 50% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 168 Screened: 0 Open: 60 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 693 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 38,286 Sq.Ft. 0.88 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 20 - 2 Effective Frontage: 125 Comments: Spring Park Bay �� .�° '' *� �� �`—� x �� — `"���` ��` ` � -�. � � ',..e��4 ", �e �a�S�x� '�.i '"�'i r ' ���g�.'� sa��� y�� � ra�f • •�.{ � r�:f��f, _ `"� ;� , . � , . y -" , d` �* �r �"•�a�, � :�°p �; ' � � � ��" a� � _ I --r-+� _ nfi ���*� - ��' ."�`'. � �y ; + - � � �.j �� t� X��� �l •, , _ ;, _r .. . . , �""�m*^�.�yw. . �� r r . .. _,;.. , .�..7��� „y,�,r� _�..- } .. � - ,� , 4�'... «� � '4`lF+�..a,�,�'� �� � ,� t.:a,.w,,._,,,,,. -r--""" - - .�.. " -.r. - w �. � �N, �� � �--��'�„�,� "'�.'`< - ._.--..-,—�."""" _ � � _r �r_ �,o_ -„_._... �. _ ` _.,._;__.,_.. _.�,,,�.,,.,..*�,. _ � �._ > ,-. .w „���. .m� �_�,_ ADDRESS: 3315 -CRYSTAL BAY RD PID#: (38) 17-117-23-41-0017 Sale Date: 02/2007 Sale Price: $799,000 2008EMV:$790,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.50 Story Age: 1920 Ground Floor Area: 910 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,118 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 50% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 555 Garage#1: 324 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 16,777 Sq.Ft. 0.39 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 9 - 2 Effective Frontage: 150 Comments: Crystal Bay "/ ���-- � � . �. .� � ���.�,- .a •, , I y �,,,._�; . ` , �`� :i y� � ` �W.�' .. �� l: :� A -� "�... r� r,,,.:;" . .'�. � . ' ,�-r�—. .,:�. � - gr- . ��+r .,-..h � - . .. ... . � �'�",� .f, . i�y�t S�,,_ � ' ��.};�� r �� ' '�t' �,ry,'. �'� �t,��� �� ir . ,4 ; ,.",�k�� � � :.� �, .. �., ' .,. '�� � .�.a-- -- -' � �`� � . . � s . � . ; _ __ _� „� b .� _ . _ -,�-� ,� ������.tN Ji� i'. f �� � 1 � ��.�t I'il�eer �.. g`,- ;� .4,�^ — •l.y(w.s �„- • �r �.•,�1' � '.Y �"' }� �. . ,.,��:Kd ADDRESS: 2184 -SHADYWOOD RD PID #: (38) 17-117-23-42-0008 Sale Date: 06/2007 Sale Price: $925,000 2008EMV:$802,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.75 Story Age: 1920 Ground Floor Area: 1,016 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,358 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 80% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 0 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 423 Garage#1: 832 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 17,134 Sq.Ft. 0.39 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 9 - 1 Effective Frontage: 50 Comments: Crystal Bay �� �� �1 � �„ f' y�v� { � '�#'.. "� i�,� ,/���°�, !��� r- yri I r' j�, � f ' F �. `�� � , tU/ +'daT' I` F Y , , �� �� �, -�- � .� � ,� r�.;��- � , �� �� _ , �' %.� �, � , � � � �� `�� ,,_'� } \ \`�S. ��A � .. - • x � ! r r 4." j .� � � , � �* ' ' � ....., �` ..,Y'���� l.�S, r� k. � �� r � � y Ji�. � , � r_......�,,.-_"^' �:+;� �`�°�'' i '� ,^+..�,,��- �� f�`t-* � �d �� �����, E�- ' j � � ��� r �� �; � . � , ,a,�.,�w _ _ � , � � _._ � , ,. - � ,,.� h ;. , �. y _ - e -- �� ,i �� '�- `"`�' � �`�a.-<�� `d ',i y 4 ��','' ��'� � � �� ...:�-,, '- «�...5=:�'.�..., - # '�`� �� .;���,.�...� ,«�_.. �t� i.� ADDRESS: 2172 -SHADYWOOD RD PID#: (38) 17-117-23-42-0010 Sale Date: 01/2007 Sale Price: $975,000 2008EMV:$920,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.25 Story Age: 1920 Ground Floor Area: 889 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,067 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 0% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 288 Open: 0 Deck: 462 Garage#1: 672 Type: Detached Garage#2: 315 Type: Detached Lot Size: 21,094 Sq.Ft. 0.48 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 9 - 1 Effective Frontage: 70 Comments: Crystal Bay "/ � ��ti�. H �� � � � ��4 ��r �/� Y, _.. tt� I���! ��� � ��' \! .1 /�j �.;�.... � X � £ i j �){ � r- '�i,�� ..t�.'y��.. ✓ � i-. � i . � �� �.�, . -,c�.�-:,• � .,::��'!I!! t��, S.�`_--���� 'x � - ��, � r '�"� j j,- �,\`... . `e.. , �.c� .} � . i "-�� x��3: , �. ..-. . .� � �� . . .�`��.�. �4 � � �.. ,,. '�^-=,�4� ,. .��. . � . , , -� ri ,,... �_� '��.�. . vh. .. ��;� - . . . .. ....� %„���F :. � _����a.e�C"�� � .. , � -*:: � _ � �� ` �¢���"���}��u � * s� � g , � ,� - �as'" ° ;�+._� �_, :c�:� ADDRESS: 4315 - NORTH SHORE DR PID#: (38) 07-117-23-43-0028 Sale Date: 11/2007 Sale Price: $1,725,000 2008EMV:$1,650,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: 1.75 Story Age: 1862 Ground Floor Area: 1,076 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,796 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 20% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00°/a Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: No Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 660 Screened: 280 Open: 125 Deck: 0 Garage#1: 896 Type: Detached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 78,215 Sq.Ft. 1.80 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 13 - 4 Effective Frontage: 190 Comments: West Arm '%--� .�r . } � .o s l� ��~� . ... . 4�{�. �x��'�� . . :��� ` y��f A�.. _ ��r f ����ti.: .� y�a+�-- - �:�'�`�-..,:._ � i`; t���'•.tY' � h y . � � t=. , �����"�~ •l+'. , �r`.�.�*�'`�.,�"� � (� ' ;' 4,�- �;� '�;� �"` _ � `� ��''' i'; `� `� �� � �'`�'� ::��� � ,,�Y r ��---. ,y�,,.,"*' ,,_ � * .._..,.. _, � - . �� � :C' "_` . , � � � � - �, . . �,:. . � � '� -��! �, �;,�+r.` , � �.... ...�`�" �-:,.. --- - - ,,,y _.:-.,,p� ._. .. .f�,..�,,,.,�. ' :-�.,„ . „�«»�..*..a.,.wr..,�w.�,� � � � . - -,u . . _-�� �c.b �.k. ... �^ ' � �, � " �.4 .-+i'°`w.ts... ' ' � .:,- . . �.e .... . _ -. '""` , . ��,R, s�' �,.x,,4�����'r".'`.�,r�we. � �' ADDRESS: 835 -WINDJAMMER LA PID#: (38) 07-117-23-11-0008 Sale Date: 10/2006 Sale Price: $719,250 2008EMV:$700,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1969 Ground Floor Area: 2,058 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,599 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 80°/a Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 2 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 160 Open: 72 Deck: 999 Garage#1: 512 Type: Attached Garage#2: 380 Type: Tuckunder Lot Size: 43,316 Sq.Ft. 0.99 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 12 - 81 Effective Frontage: 175 Comments: North Arm Bay Deeded Access 7 � .b�.� ..�t � � w ���d ��F } ��- r!!. '}�, �t.s� il�.���e.�J.. �� f�, .Y��1 �..��.k� ��fl T r���� : _.. _.....,_ ... _. �.�,. �' ��' ,. '��. .._��S!Pb✓� .. �� �. ;.,��� �w r,. , � .., � ,.�,f" .ew__'_"_ . .E �,., _ .�� �... � �"e ' t�,��#.?"a r`�ya , {:^.,. k �,/�P`�,'� « s 1�� 'r�s'€ � � ° t �''' �I, I�IIV �! ' � � ��.�i�'� ���� �����,�I,N, -�; � , ADDRESS: 3026 -CASCO POINT RD PID#: (38) 20-117-23-34-0026 Sale Date: 08/2007 Sale Price: $970,000 2008EMV:$930,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1994 Ground Floor Area: 1,421 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,368 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 90% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 3 3/4: 0 1/2: 0 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 394 Garage#1: 792 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 28,416 Sq.Ft. 0.65 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 21 - 50 Effective Frontage: 90 Comments: Carmens Bay Channel �� ( •i..�. y i� ' �l ��y�f _ ' ^Y r� . ;� t �t�. t _ � � � i � !.>_,' ' �_ ,� � i � �i � � � � '�f�r� d� t....---:y'n-•;' ' �`�„��`a, «,, �� �s�'„�" 4��x►� � �� �:�F� � r��`�* , �.*� .+�+' 1 ' ti a' � ,�°�r�„�`,��"` :;� r ..�,� �� �z�y� ',�y.__ ``:t-!' 1 , � J . ��yl[n� rA� I I �* � �� � ,�.• �i=�.� � � '�p� ��`��-t„�"�,� � r��$` "� �. � �,�;�':%�' � .,,...,,_� ��.� R;- � .� , � �-��;� �- �, , `'� �:; �r _ �.� � :' '�b �: � .� ,� �, �� � � � ���-'—q� .�. � 9 �.� _..� _ -- .�, . � o-��rn,_.�,. _ r_ ADDRESS: 1027 - LINDEN LA PID#: (38) 07-117-23-13-0094 Sale Date: 11/2006 Sale Price: $1,067,500 2008EMV:$968,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1984 Ground Floor Area: 1,330 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,372 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100°/a Finished Bsmt. Area: 40% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 168 Screened: 0 Open: 410 Deck: 156 Garage#1: 576 Type: Attached Garage#2: 352 Type: Detached Lot Size: 20,052 Sq.Ft. 0.46 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 15 - 4 Effective Frontage: 50 Comments: Forest Lake �f� � t�� , , �` �� � � y _ .} � .�,��_,� " ,.- ', ..a_;L,._� < � � �! r��{� t 4� 1 �I ... - '�, -�- %r�' .�.�;; N�. - _,�✓ .r �_ y� . ��`�� - -3''' r . "�'"_'.�e►-��` ��� ,'x:„�"° � ' ; .,;;�, '�. ���y�` �;���.:p r .�� , s `u IT`i� �— ' � �-- ' �Il�kym�w. _, . - ^. , -- -� ; � � � �+�ce-s<,:�,r=,.r=:.�.-- .�r.«,:�� - _. �`°�:,�"�.� -,'�'«+",'� *�a�'""�'��`�.:�=�� f�� .,_r,� .� �,�.�R �r��;:s� >:� '� ADDRESS: 996 - NORTH ARM DR PID#: (38) 07-117-23-11-0017 Sale Date: 05I2007 Sale Price: $1,350,000 2008EMV:$1,269,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 1973 Ground Floor Area: 2,112 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 3,414 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 60% Finished Bsmt. Area: 70°/a Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 2 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 155 Deck: 606 Garage#1: 508 Type: Attached Garage#2: 864 Type: Detached Lot Size: 43,794 Sq.Ft. 1.01 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 1 - 12 - 7 Effective Frontage: 130 Comments: North Arm '7 � _ :��� �. '� �,, *�**�..,.,,,,�,, �� = �"'`' ��� � � y�� . .:�� � ;r� _ p'"i�, ,� w., � - �tr ��� '�m-rn�-� ,__:�_ <n iw ; �� = � � �°'_� � � i ¢� � �! + �' CI{�.q,.,� ;�� Y .., . . ( it��.n �1C,.;. ■ . r�r`.-�rr..��-,.;.--� I_^'_ - —�__..'` . � �f -----�-�-: �., . .. � �,.� � , a"`� �.„� � ��' _ , ,��r�� �..._'`�'-"�,�w ADDRESS: 3749 - LIVINGSTON CT PID#: (38) 17-117-23-34-0081 Sale Date: 05/2007 Sale Price: $208,000 2008EMV:$195,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 2002 Ground Floor Area: 788 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 1,508 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 90% Finished Bsmt. Area: 30% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 0 Full: 1 3/4: 1 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 0 Deck: 212 Garage#1: 480 Type: Tuckunder Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 1,280 Sq.Ft. 0.03 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 20 Comments: Minnetonka Woods Townhouse �G �. ;. h �� �� � � Sf kr�_� , ,. �,� �� �:a. � ��: ., �- ��°. :�� ���.��- � � . - . � '' �j .{�r Ft"4Id��y " � i�a . .',� _�. ,� � , ` , ��-� � � e�; � � - `�� r�; �E � �in � P� �r: � � , �,.�;,�,��illilil�lllil(fllillilllll(1(fl��� � ';,�'.��� .�.�� � � ,�. � �- � � � � � � �. . . 1 �_ �w_ • -'�.r� "�--_-_.._. • _� � ����, r� a. _,�.. �_ s� � ' ,, —���� _� � �aYD . �:.:..��ir..�.� ai�ahAw�F�......�:. ...� ..._.__ .:_.�..._ ,t,�.,,9!'�,V ADDRESS: 651 -SANDSTONE CIR PID#: (38) 33-118-23-11-0030 Sale Date: 10/2007 Sale Price: $390,000 2008EMV:$336,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Two Story Age: 2003 Ground Floor Area: 1,069 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,138 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 00% Fireplaces: 1 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 182 Deck: 144 Garage#1: 600 Type: Tuckunder Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 0 Sq.Ft. 0.00 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: Stonebay �� - " ' .. .. r ,5 `�"�'�'�.��y ... ... . . . ,t_ .�- �rs , i'u.�ir4^ ."."°' - .,�'.,�. , _ ., . , � ;� ,, V �,.: _..:. . �a-,.. _� .,.. ,f� - ,;. ° �a� $ �11�� a �g i. � ,,, ': ',�-1 _ �.,� ._. .. �; � �� * �. :tti � � ���h�y;���T q ti ... »,�w"a;�as+�„r. ' .. :�,�„"",�..�y.^"^T'��r1Fld�+r<^'}'lbai�,�`.�'+,�� ��'�+�it '�r`�.,,.?a'.' �- a;"" ,`#�.'�'".F ri .. .s..�z;:'� `�.�: _a;-::�t� .. ADDRESS: 2538 -SANDSTONE LA PID#: (38) 33-118-23-11-0017 Sale Date: 10/2007 Sale Price: $700,000 2008EMV:$612,000 Sale Date: Sale Price: Style and Story Height: Rambler Age: 2006 Ground Floor Area: 2,035 Sq.Ft. Above Grade Area: 2,035 Sq.Ft. Bsmt. Area: 100% Finished Bsmt. Area: 80% Fireplaces: 2 Central Air Conditioning: Yes Baths - Deluxe: 1 Full: 1 3/4: 0 1/2: 1 Porches - Glazed: 0 Screened: 0 Open: 122 Deck: 102 Garage#1: 470 Type: Attached Garage#2: 0 Type: Lot Size: 0 Sq.Ft. 0.00 Acres Lake/Bay/Rating: 0 - 0 - 0 Effective Frontage: 0 Comments: Stonebay ���