Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout1997 - req. info on dock issue ? 1 0\,17 O 40 CITY of ORONO \''a WY''*1:; 4�, ( , ,n G, Municipal Offices t, Street Address: Mailing Address: `9kesuOg' 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 May 22, 1997 David P. Hubert, Attorney At Law 121 West Main Street Suite 200 Waconia, MN 55387-1023 RE: Requested information on Westlake Street dock issue Dear Mr. Hubert: You have requested information regarding the the City's position regarding an easement purportedly granting some form of lake access,and perhaps the right to have a dock,to the owner of Lot 3,Block 2,Hillside Park over Lot 12,Block 1,Hillside Park. Both aforesaid lots abut Westlake Street,a City right-of-way which ends at the shore of Stubbs Bay, Lake Minnetonka. Lot 3 is not riparian since it does not abut the lakeshore, and in fact is located approximately 400' distant from Lot 12 and 400' from the lakeshore. Lots 3 and 12 are within the City's LR-1A, Single Family Lakeshore Residential Zoning District in which "private docks" are an accessory use subject to the City code and other applicable regulations, including boat storage density regulation(Zoning Code Section 10.23, Subd. 5[A]). By definition, "accessory use or structure" is "a use or structure subordinate to and serving the principal use or structure on the same lot and customarily incidental thereto" (Zoning Code Section 10.02). The principal use of Lot 12 is the single family residence existing on Lots 10-12. Any dock on or in the lake adjacent to Lot 12 therefore can only be used by the owners/occupants of Lot 12. Further, the Orono Zoning Code prohibits residential property owners from engaging in the "business of docking,mooring or storing boats",which is defined as'renting or otherwise providing space, including boat buoys,for docking,mooring or storing one or more boats belonging to persons other than the owner or occupant of the property, except when licensed as a joint use', unless a Marina Business License is obtained. Such a license cannot be issued except in the B-2 Marina Business zoning district(Municipal Code Section 5.43, Subd. 1, Subd. 6). The Joint Use regulations are also enclosed. It is my opinion that the City would not issue a joint use dock license for this situation(Section 5.42). Telephone (612) 473-7357 • FAX 473-0510 f f David Hubert May 22, 1997 Page 2 Lots 10-11-12 have an interesting history regarding lake access. As early as 1967 the City was advised of a purported right-of-way easement in favor of Lots 3, 5 and 18, Block 2 (Sept. 13, 1967 letter). The City required the removal of a 7-slip marina on the property in 1979 (see attached letters). In 1984 the City advised a Mr. Bonner that the City does not recognize such old easement rights(letter of Nov. 1, 1984). In 1995 the Building Inspections Department was involved in having the owner of Lot 3, Mr. Perl, remove his dock from the right-of-way (inspection slips of 4/26/95). The situation with Lots 10-11-12 is not necessarily unique. A similar situation in the Navarre area of Orono involves a number of off-lake properties which have an easement for "bathing and boating purposes" over a private lakeshore homestead parcel. Also, other off-lake properties in the Navarre area have similar deeded "bathing and boating" easements over four City-owned vacant parcels between Crystal Bay Road and Lake Minnetonka. The City has taken the position that those off-lake owners do not have the right to construct docks on the lakeshore parcels for the reasons noted above. I would also note that in the second described Navarre situation,the lakeshore parcels owned by the City are vacant,which provides an even greater basis for denial,because no accessory structure may be placed on a parcel of land that does not have a principal structure (Section 10.03, Subd. 9A). Given the above background information,thank you for providing me with a copy of the easement, which appears to have been granted in 1920. It appears to merely grant "an easement and right-of- way...over Lot 12...to the lakeshore of Stubbs Bay..." without specifying any dock rights. It can probably be construed as a walking easement. The City will not recognize this easement as granting to the owner of Lot 3 the right to have a dock extending on or from Lot 12. The City will act to have such a dock removed if one is placed. Also,any easement created after April 1984 would have required City approval(Code Section 11.03 Subd. 2.66, Definition of Class I Subdivision). Since the easement in question was apparently granted prior to 1984, that requirement may not apply. Any new or replacement easement would require City subdivision approval. I hope this clearly defines for you the City's position. If you have further questions, please feel free to contact me at 473-7357. Sincerely, Michael P. Gaffron Asst. Planning & Zoning Administrator encl. cc: Liz Van Zomeren, Building & Zoning Administrator Thomas Radio, City Attorney MELCHERT, HUBERT, SJODIN & WILLEMSSEN a professional limited liability partnership PAUL A.MELCHERT ATTORNEYS AT LAW LUKE MELCHERT CHASKA OFFICE DAVID P.HUBERT (612)448-3121 KEITH E.SJODIN 121 WEST MAIN STREET Fax(612)448.6262 MAC R.WILLEMSSEN R.LAWRENCE HARRIS SUITE 200 TIMOTHY J.LOOBY WACONIA,MINNESOTA 55387-1023 BRADLEY W.SOLHEIM J.MICHAEL MELCHERT WATERTOWN OFFICE CAROL ANN EIDEN TELEPHONE(612)442-5155 G CITY OF (612)955-1404 Finn Administrator FACSIMILE(612)442-6166 QRONQ CHERYL L.PTACEK May 14, 1997 MAY 1 5 1997 Mr. Michael Gaffron , „ City of Orono P.O. Box 66 Crystal Bay, MN 55323 RE: Request for Information Pertaining to Installation of Docks on Stubbs Bay Dear Mr. Gaffron: Thank you very much for our phone conversation yesterday in regard to some questions that I had pertaining to the installation of docks on Stubbs Bay of Lake Minnetonka. Our office represents Mr. and Mrs. Jay Jasper of Waconia, who are the owners of Lots 10, 11 and 12, Block 1, Hillside Park, in Orono. A copy of the Certificate of Title for this property is enclosed for your information. This property is for sale and there is a prospective purchaser. However, the purchaser does not wish to purchase the property unless the "blanket" right-of-way that presently exists across this property as shown on the Certificate of Title can be removed. It is my understanding that the owner of this existing right-of-way is not willing to simply relinquish his interest. However, it is my understanding that he would consider the relinquishment of the interest if, in exchange, he could have the right to install a dock off of the southwest corner of Lot 12 of Block 1, with a very limited restriction of access to the dock over this property. It is my understanding the proposed purchaser of this property would remove the existing buildings and construct a completely new dwelling. Obviously, it would be of help to all parties if this blanket right-of-way could be released and redevelopment of this property could occur. Therefore, we would like to investigate the possibility of obtaining permission from the City of Orono to grant the right to allow an additional dock to be installed in approximately the location indicated, which right would be made legally appurtenant to the owner of Lot 3, Block 2, of Hillside Park,through an easement or other type of document. For your further Mr. Michael Gaffron May 14, 1997 Page Two information, I am enclosing herewith copies of Hennepin County Half Section Plats showing this area and the proposed approximate location of the docks. As of the moment of writing this letter, I do not have a copy of the deed recorded in Book 926 of Deeds, page 188, which sets forth the right-of-way that we would like to have released. If you need a copy of this document, please let me know and I will try to get you one as soon as possible. We would appreciate your earliest response. Thank you very much for your cooperation. If you have any questions,please give me a call. Ors very truly, David P. (b-111 de DPH/j ek Enclosures Cc: Jay M. Jasper • .Cid 1171..1_01 . . .- . .• . ...: ... • - ._ 188,.,:''1)7:'*-1":•:-.,''':•,."';' ,' ,1.',,, ,-..„7.:4:1.:5 ;ei'-A.Ltekt,:•, 7 7 .•7 .1'''fi.1,i''':g7..,?t1.41.1!,' „ .4r.r-rtk7q,.-4'....i7Olt, .,.;;.r,4...;1;414'.-.7t:-..'f''',F-t'it.'.‘,....''',4....' r 117•-•',C''!-', ,i':'•';!•,•714k,TV''.",'1,4f,';' ,„„64`.,;...77•V'Z''''f:•.:".T...“'t•:!e.1:41:-,- ...":`1:.:,?,;,-.;,,s,.r..',,r,,..--..:r':::70!:',te4"1., . '•...'."04 *'°riz.7a34" -.,,....,--,:*Fr-,nie,k,..`..-1,r,.--.4x., ./....A. c .e..i_t...,r1-4:. ...sid.a4s,.:52,,,,-.....-„ lf. ;4>., ' - . .1"44L-,,.4'.'201-14,t,(44. - . • .040.i.;•..' :!7-'4'",'I'litis kdoiteit; ei",'.-•' :•:., •.: '• •;/-'•:2.;,:i4!-.•*'-"'"';•7'aiitt';ge,OAXW7oabil „-':,4a4-.41atto .610111'1:k Oh* , I ‘,... zsii.: WOO ithidie4'••• - •'.: • 1 j 2. ,...A.494:7e' . i''' •4•' '. ,• •,• . , .r ,;----,; •,• -7•• - . 77""", . , .... • . .., pattedoaot the bet part.end-,....—__ 'I r -' "All'il the Coen/,• .- • and Stitt . . ..4,:i part" 41.11 the tectetri panel l'' ,,,. .,',',...••,-- wITytass ,'met the mid paterma,nt the Amt part,'far rad Le ennildtrailen.ed tha'inn at.-- -,:,.:„.----,4,.. • ••. . -;• i-;;;.; ;.. ......---.....,.....,...4....:;,a... .,;-,... . ;---,:,-,-,------------.--------.-. :-.4.-DOIXARS, ....:7''egvieZtrool",4,....__It bud paid by thu maid per"iond it,,*mead at".the Elbei t wh'Ivel is hen.hz."oltn4wiedvd.ti"-1--c•-f--&-ty- -‘ . ,- amige.itereette.$eti end Cagivey%tutu the said patal4ht the Jecolti pa * „..,-...heiti and avalvta.Portent ill... . .. ,.'.. ,r+ :' • tract- or panel of land lying and being le tet Conag of flantepl,and Beate of Mtneavoto.deteriPed as follows,orwitt ' • ., , , . . ••.... : T• _:?-71„4„,,...„4,,,,e,_,...,A.,,, ...,e1474.&44..4.e._,,e0e,t ,vv.01,,,,,.., , ..-e2.44-44.44.4e- .24,1e.-44.1-4...a,. -•i-. ,. . 4. lyteye.4...D.Le.,e4/tX4,.,4`refor.44,„..410-‘4..-tet..L.1-41.4.47'4 -444ist.....44,44,:eL4P-A.v.., i, 7._.....,,,eLt_;ile.4.4.„.eli,i,;1_,44;,!1.,__ ,agt,..,5,./...r........ e;i.. ,..7e_44.4_,40,44..t....„-„ . .-„,...,..4.. „elleL.4...,47e 00.p.e.4„„ortc.44-• ,...7 ..:,,,.... f. - • — . 4. - .-4--%-ti.,-44(. .4.4,,e.,,,-7:!". :-.4.2434,4.4...,,,,. .......—A C4-k4... *.z;,_ . 1: ._.._...• .. . , ,• -l'• , . .........„.,.. .. .. .. . ___. _....... .... . ... .,_..... ....•. . ..•_•__ • ..-- _. ... .......... .., ,... .......... , - .. • . -----------•—• •----••----..-----••-•—- • -- • •• -- --. • ' • ----- " ' " --• •--- - - •-" ----- •"---- "- • • • ._.........., ,.. -,'.: i .. .. .. . . • ,;. ,,,_ ___ . . - - ... •— • - ._____.___. .... . • •• " , -• ... . , . ... . . , . . . . .. „ . . _ .. , •. . -- •' - "• _ .._,:.,_ .: .„......... ..... ... , .•:,,, • - • 1-1I 1 1 To ei.oms Alm To sent_in./len gamy.Tosethee mit all the hereditament"and rhotteltnanemt(hereunto belonettg or in toy- -4 *t0 0/1&d Park:000f the wood pa „ . --hake and etaistta.FOREVER. And the told-- ...--, • • ^ . _ —..—„,...4.4__... ......_pennoe. of the Ant part,hae-ttetml.st-LatAtiseitmittei.k.hels".Ititeellitsee and ..' weeinfetrerem do.,-covenant with the said partZse of the Krona part.ettete4.4..i.... .1-hetes and assign*,titut4tota.i"....narre,.... well aaliad In Sae of the hods 04 ptetubee atoteseith sod itartngood right CO Ml t"otel wive.,the MIR!In=anew and tom alonsiald.mut that ' . _. . . . . . .• ...... . , ,.. . • ,,, . . , .„. ... ......... and dis abort bargained and granted luadi and preentsee.In the quIvt anti pmentabts poMesoient of the mild Nati-ante the wend part : - .2,441.1.4..lbdit sod nape,sprout all pawns lawfully claiming or to claim the whole or any pert thereof.On old pan;Atr.,et the ttrai '1, • pat wilt WARRANT and DEFEND, ..• 111TwortiMetatY WHERROP‘Thu saki plot the Aral wart ha.et..-Itttiustio ert..alier....--. ....hande-and aratettito day ,. •, ' ' • and pit ant above written. c2atdatt.(2206i.+. ,Ateut_ , ,;, ,. . . . . 1 f,, --. •' Iftwit.Soled and Delivered Is Presents of . .• . .--..---.—.01tail .. •, abziszott•d,iik-....12241.446.1.L._,_,...1 . . • . , ,. '.: •,';';'. ..,.,•7;35:a.,Altwitio&V,4.41.1.,........-.... .71,-,--.. • , . "121,4"4-7/0"ailat."-*---'"'""---"'-` 45°4) i ,• le------,..-.......(8•41) 1 .• ._ . -. RTATE 011.22144101:14.444:26...-,-.... - ......... ., -- '- kerianr9ten.0 ', • er, • • . mim4146.4.4111.444.4.4•46. 41•441444..........-4.4 i . f. . -1!. • , t',- ON ak‘.—,6444_...L . * - - _iwi,....e „,. -- 1).19 --.'ottor. -• -- .1. 4.-. :;,..e ,, . mot for Catuoty.pereatudtt 4.4047monair ' .." -- . • .- " agutotior---- ,i' .... • ,4 .. 0,..1.110 agg Wooten hi the pariah"1"essilki In sod we .4 the OetterIng44.-,- —hrarrunent.sed acknowledged thnt I .., • hefetiO4 64 NM0 IV idol...Mee MI sott 4 1 114 .'•.,:..., ,;,, , 7.,1,.,,.,,,.:,,,,, ,„,,,,,, • • „ • '-'1;i .-'• ‘•il ro,''',` :;'•','•, •• • .'`,15'.1.''''' ''1‘k " • . i- ' " ''••0. '14's":,,.141.„'!-,i' (42.14;:toi;;‘,,,,,,e414,:;:?4444) , ,. • ..,..4...f.,'• W .„.... - . -h.1`...., . •• .?..• •r'it.; - '' ' .-V-1, ' ' ,:e.''14"1,,,-i:,;•ie,',:ki,,..,:,','„)..•,•'s ',,.•AC', • .-• - 1, Ti; ;'?' ". /'..P. '' 4 V4ri;- ''. '+4'':. ..41....,- '4 ;1,1'''•'..'' , Ne V-r•-•;••••iime......,._•'N.';.,'' '..''''.1.f:'•••' '' •,. .. , ; ....: .: - • • , EO'd nTSALL.r# 0± ail mu-I .J.iNnaD HIdENN3H NII TO: T- )6F-J-F7-,1.17.ilJ ' ' ' . - ' ' ' • - . , • - ,......: .______. .•-:)...:_..._.....1.,_._......,...,._.:..,....L,..,..._....1L_____, 1. i;".=-_-.."-----,...f '...r'.- ..: .11 .: : . ,.„. .. ,. :.„ -,, ; . ; . ' . . _ ••, ." .,,7277:7 ,',-7.""":. i "7.7,7 r: . , '• '. . z ... „ •• ,. . .' ...t. oP •-•• 4...•.,-r,1,t • .., •43 p 1 4;:. 9,...).. ...t.• ••if V u. .• .) •. It•..... •r ::_.: . ??,,t, " ';,•• 4; - /. .4% ‘A ..... .'; ' - •. •:: ... . _ ,..11111 15 *--sie 3 7re. TA „, •-' .1.. - s• III IS WESTLAKE 8 kz•-*--: „... ... . /LAT to FA 93 5:3 33 50 52 53 9) 52 1 •.'9. g t: i • P A _ zi _ ( 0 - .,,,, ,,, •-....ii 3/11)3 Mil•17 I l'i t 635.I I Mr IP I le( .... / : --5 :: 2 ...... ii 6..• .71 rt•iii''''i;'72'72 i'l 4 4 / 13 9 x ..,..- ,..3 CT,1 ,.. - -2._ z_ ...-.-..,-i :. , ,..... ..:. - \ ......c ,., , A '11 ,,,-- 2',- -' -"'- ..' .,.-„,t --- ----.-- . .. : .•'4 Priv i ". - . ., - - : ' -'.:.3 “ 1 -.1 ,"...?. ii „ - ,,, iiitirre 7.- t. .', 44:49CD :I --LI ‘•: 4 ,, / ‘ t' .9? -• .4 4. t e1 - .., \ q./4 t. • 000 5 / • . ..,22 _1 '•••• • .., 1--.- t.' ' • '-??.# A ' Serafiv o • l. - no .4 S'• •-13 ,(4.1 4- i ‘ OAS/SIDE , -- A„T„, ., daCie 3he 1•41. I 0 ' . Ina.GO 14* 01L AND INC a --...• -1,71, --,_,. .,t ,..I '-' 4 8 v. c• ... TA'14 -- ‘....'.. .t•',,,,„ 4.'"' NV 55'11-6 ..0 / . 7-• 7,. .-.: .94, : P. 3 ' • " t• -• Ti 5 *it, ...y.....,4 ... • 1, ,,,, ;. ..e, % r7..a. a.•‘. i„ .. :•' . ... =:. ri:e!i''.; § .t: \_ ,, , 151.74 (LANDMARK DR) .,4',:. :.', '4;9 .../•. .. •I`' t '', 0111101 A ..."!`-' ''''''''',,,,14' \.:: ,...&'"..4 .1r 9.i,44.il..,,'51.96 M./A ,'•.> 00.09 '_y,,„ ,...,_.. :,.. ,„ _____ .0 . __ ______\-• -.,,,,,NM1/4.1 ,, r 5,\`',,2•-.'\\ . ,'., 119 I 9.! Nv•i I./V F I.51 -- u, 110.II'?VI g: . . .40. 4 .,.• 'I ..0,\.--; '....•‘, :-: .4/•:V• Cf:?" / 47, -. .f.: 3> g., ' ‘7..,''... „,8 t•4,, .1,6' .., •,;,2 ., t. Itit, !.-_,,,4 `'.: 'QC A' ..) ., E.' '.. '' ,..' .-.-.7. ''' 19 .; g .•-•. : -...:-..... v :-...-.. , :•*a • \ r. ::2"..k 6' ,,,, T... . eso•17..11.(670,.. r: "''' ' . -1:-71C.'-....- •,-, 1 t 6 1. ' .. .. 4et• ., ti-____ ,. ...... o , ......3 . •;.. .1?4 LI s a S• VO % / I • • '. I;fl N., '-'-9 , et . 69 76 .•I. II. Ise7.:) •-'a- ____..-2----. e ,-• ,-, -g_ 10,Li S s ... •••:..-.1,4„_ • . Z ••_.,_ • . % 5 ... •- ,::, , Z.: F:• 6 ..*L..•'`.. 6-...';i:'' 1 :Li i i 40 . cPP CP . . 5'. ' '-'1 ..'...•.. .••• .;_. .•• - ---,..s 1 t .,.1 4/ 6 - .#- .?.i CO • • i'...!....... CO .. . 1 -4 ..2.' 64 C. ,..,. ''•• .1 .1 i ...,„ . _ 464.43 50.054r. •z!c \ .."."137j4.er 1.0.05111 .ftilliseptil. ( ) ‘° :-,) 292.01 . 191 2#7 • 200 ..' • i: .,..7... -' -P.,: .r ._.. . c . ... -i, :-.. ;37.1,i C> : • 1 ) 't ...0 d a- . • .. . .; - , • ...,^ . . ill ,E--.1 , .. • _.. _ i,....-... ,... -....... I- i ... ,,, s 7„, sg,4 . 1E --- I! f•'___----Irric-I 73 i ' IN . 10.2 270,.5 • If, i. [ 0 • 64 ...: :a •!•' Vi ,.. o 1, ni PARK ST .t!.. -1; i l' :' i 0 -2.1.11:131 a 0 ii '''T S 1--.4 At I •S . n e„ s i Cep. C---3 '10 _ ..1., :1 •,,. -.'!-- .;"-.i..? ;.- a".3-,I . .: z .tt.-;•.,,-,-. ',I.' -<-,- (--. 0 !. , oir I'43 it, 7. - tV .' "s 4 I 154'.? - - . ;:- ...-.. ,4 r.•,,,„ ' . r. z, lb.': N rri 1 -- ..4:! •41.- .. --,,2. i o °'.4. • . 'C ' -- .. ,t.s!. ' '7-' "-'----: f'7..k..•:7 7.7,:---7:•-• ....a .- .'-', ---,.; .-X ..,.. •3P• ....„ .. / . u at, w N• & / ,,' 1 FI - -- •.... - -F,1. Ei '' " '''. '''' .:'':- .: --f ' - i • „ .. ..•.... " 1_ , 0, • . 1 /1 r• ..' • : • ___27:...,_ a .,0 i5 , ,,... w . • .' _,' -1 ' : • . _.... ___ - OAK 5 ,.,t''' .:r 3.1 .. 1••i 2 -7--7:7 - --...' ,''---11 1-c'''"" --,STUBBS-- T- B (:Tr%RO- !LS-, -', ‘...T , ... • pct. su NO0111 261.73 • ' 14;111. •, - .. __ .. e4,11.. .....:, ?:11" „......., .7.7. 4 .......,...:..,4. _ . .,„, .p, ,:...,.., , ...i....- ___ , :. . / _ '''' .... . •- •.--• V/ -I 7. V 404 ••• , :4430.0 / , ,, •-, ,',,•' 4 .-. z A - _, '" 5' ni ...,, .,z. • . • , • >.i... \ .t ..••••••• :--1 •., , • : - -4.4.1.VI_--- - kl - 4-- 7..... , 1.S PIO-I"- -----r 3:11 ..i wa 1...•• ,. •• i :•.' ''• i' / .. • ,..., Dik).- .-- i ,„. ..,- ... i•,,L*,. . 1 .7.•..'.•',. i,.4Y t ..1 '''' N r...-------- ,7-F6--- '.'. ; '''. ,., ,. •.. ,,'11 _Y.^ '4" ; - Vii ,I1 •<, . -- .,‘' .4:,;'•,, „ . '.I.1 .----,t,tf.I^ •• 1 1 ,.!:. ''„, ,-; , 2: i 74 X •-• ',.K....... f?..7:: it I 5 1 5.1•.114 * :)... '• ; --- ., e 4-- ..1 g.. I 4 136 ell - CD „ • / ....• < ' •st- C:0 1.,. k ___i (1_ 0 i 492.19 h3........-4 R. , .,c1-. iv-_ _i_.....,.!..) • .:•.i I al •,"x' - ) 1--- • - r „ 7:-?, " 0 i --110 647... ) -._2 .52 i - iV.. rc-- / Fl g N .ii'•-1-.1-.•i..-.i-' 1`;'1,"1#4•1•9'.1:•7,1V3-•'1:0,/,7''' ,c,"2 4,.,-,'..:'7 -.',-.,.:1 .-. -• 1•1- \ •'D4..P..(.- iI 1•",:. N1 •...- .-. .. ,.-:•,„••..t.1,N.,',ti.I 1 13 S_,.._...'_;.•..•.',t4...,.. »I r3 - -\ - _ ^ 1151 ti,A''AII IRII 2 ' -._.--- Cgt.5.•i, 57 .. ..5". /••9 •a',0 ii- ...t)V-5.!_•?. T i , qft,, i I. 1 123,33 1•. --. 44. 0, . 1:1 I 3 £1 Crt s'' 4' • ••• 4... A.- •••••. ,..... G4 ,- •••• r i • .1. ,. ., .414.,..1 I ,b..0. 1!6 14 V .. 4-'4...4•-'e 1"I;,4 •,:t••:, ,.:,.r:.•- „ ... :,-, - 4`' - ,' , 0 .T.I •tsk '•• . -.,7 g'"' " - -. ii." " LS' ''''' ..I' t.' : • i 4. ..... ._;\il..... i r.„ w ! . etti-113.4. 3t3,31. ••----.............. 10 .. ..• an- k, --w--5•5" s s) .n :0 m sa so a) - P; ... .0. 8 l' O.' ' a TONKA ° AVE / ,..i ,74 - 4.0. 50.f 50 50 10 .0 35 9) FA .J/ 50 50 53 11 .3. W•ft.• :: 4- ...t 1 t •• , ± ..- _ , . • . W.- Z...2.• Z.. •r- :..CY' '-... .. ;_. '.... =fr.. .....'' -. ..... . ........ , ... 4.. ........,..4 OP.• • •-• l'. ... ,.....• ... *. .4. ...V ,,,i,(fr ...., .a. --. „ ..... .. r.. .10•••• ..... „ pa .... ,,.., .4 It ....b. i . m 1 - , „, •-.. 53 ,A, 52__53_.-23--51.--D-6 - ..-T----1)- 5' P-m-r17V.-n-71 . . . . . - 'it RAI SI DE ADDE(5 PO LAKE WI VI ilt TUNKA. ! -i. . .;•-' *0 -4 .6 ,^- - .. a . i-s- -5I--Y FA-T :,-; - ;-, -... z ----•.., -5\ iln .--. - ..,,,,-' ,..z.--.. , - ,17:;)%Z.' L's'g-12'."1 S'.1.. .,,V- ,,t, 10.5 977 . 93 31 So Al 92 91 92 .9., 51 92 91 9/ 91 91, 51 91 .4 45 ' E .. . 34.5 CRESTVIEW '. AVE A .. . /„ _t> •-• i ''... :NE, 9/.9 50 50 ;51 53 95 1 M 95 , 95 95 9) 9./ 9) 50 50 a, 5 / \ . _r_l, - - .. . ....... . ... fit - . r.' - 6 - t.t..1.2.3‘ ;‘,• - " 1:F.: 3-5'15-:-...---z-:,./,. ,-..... .-. -E .... .. - . - ...-.1.. rc: - QP -- --- 7-ii-- ,.... ,,,0 3, % I 95 69 '''. .7.=713 , 93 92 93 91 9/ DJ 92 0 3/11 97 1J '0 . 2.../11' ! !I 1 ... j __ I. - J .-. Cr) Et.''' .... C1 41' .... ..•'. • < 33 4 297 NO•13.39,1 TV 4 4-- 4. CD _, -i i", 4 < 730- g - ..14,,,y,., 40 4,„'' •. -1 ..,,,, ) - A - ZI 3 '1.4.. afg - ,..)):7 1'., 0 /' .... 79? 50413'3011 9-0 :4. --4 / _I , - • . . . . • • • . . ' • . ., ,. .„, . , . • • . .. ' . ...•, . -- . '''''''' ' '' ''. ..'- .•- - ' 0•.r.4•71.51-1------ • ____-:,........,,,)`-,,--;-:-..r..1_,....:•••-•::;?*;•zoi I-4,1-....----rn•---, _, R. .-•- 75.66 1113.11 an . r-,-:-::,..:-..---",i-:-i- •:•=--:-77:::" r-.7. .1.:.,----.7. .c.r: .`"7",7"7' ''':Ctiet.# ,Ra-#M-••••,-•••••!.% .„..., • ,•:". 71.6.Si 21241114 • 14rt.."' i il „, 70 • 4 Os '5. .-Ja r.i 4 a ''''•11, I =' •dji. •.4 ';;,'. R6;',..,,, I.-'; *•:: n ive 7--; I ••.. ... 1 3r A. t II) 53 Fa1 / .. ... '• ••• > ..*. - If ,_, . . ..• ic , , , r.„ 33 1 ... 77f,.Al i, ---I / -----------\ 1 A : MI 1 I. .. .4 1 I CO CA '••••,. 0 is-..... 1- Ci. • MC ot.,v 'A D-4 / P• Ot,, 1 ), / Ug 7D --i T __tr.L1 it_ • ::. , F; 4.. fi . CP ','-' F1 ii , •-.1. .., h:' .•-• 6 1 . - 7_,- 4, IP* •i.ii' to- ",,' - 41-4' . , . Z.. 1 7 ... • • '• ( • kiV) •/ , • /4'..4.• ,ig . .„, 't' i - l.,''''; - .- / •5... Zi- K'. / \ / 'titqS ft. •. ,421.S. Il ........1-4"....'". 1 .1. ..-...? . \ -- i ''. .tse!• .>7 I / .. ',) , ‘..>4,44,7.,z.4,,,,:.• '''... ''''- ..t. , , , : ,:eo, ''..• .•• , •b s 'S 'r'i";`, • I ! . • .. .. . / ,... . . 4,' ••• .• ,,, ' E; '''-' .•dt - . . C_-... •/;) ,. , ..... ,'. \ °1 ,.-.. .2.-.• e •• . ..• 4, , A,...WIR - ,.:•••,., •,' •, INA) •'' 1 ,,,, .., \J"-s,, ,7„,- i ',, •A%., 1.*,:`fi'' .., rn . .), .-.... . cl..• . gn •-. ‘, i ,, \' - ` i f \ "; N'‘, .•• - ,.., ...' s's•,.6 .44' ':,......... ,,, , I. % '> 17 \.!.•• i .2,..___ ,„ _• • .- .. . AI S. ..• -....:..-C;i•;-. ,i ; ., ? •., % \ \1-.' ''' • .......• , - S I i 4Z) ss,. Ct. '!, l'o,...• c,P.A, '...: - t V 01' \ •,•Y,'",' . . . ..••••• .. !, 1 :::44 .09 42--) t,.,.,. :„• \CY° 6' ,..•' , , , \-...., ' •-' .. ..•., : ',. ---,;,.- ,',.`,:' • :' • , ,,- - , IN44•4111%:. • 4 o *.;-• i•-• • ..• .0 '1,71. Zt;l'•, .4.' (t1. • 4% •• -• o 1• .j, c,•.• Phi . 4.1. .•6 N.;" .4, ‘.7.. ' 6":„(\ 0 • (..":.<•\ .:-. < I's , •••,. ...... u Cr.1.1 : - ..... ..... ,-...„ , ........ ... ............. --I ...... .- . .....i I •--..„. ..'. .•••• i 265 13 .b.. A 41' *• .. ---.,, "1, .'.. Z;;: ---..., CI .:.,.,. _ .._. ,.. I ‘f_.•.,,-,, ...4, • -4 (A.., .;••. -0 , i.:. XI t. .., .., •-4 a: I ...„... = .- ....,. „ . T tif.fil , 17 2SC : I ----"--......,............y .47,.. 34 0 4.75 . ., . , , : cV•q!':'.......' p • .„.. ei . P A ..., ,:.; , .•• •R! 21 3 • ... .. . ..: - i -.. ... , 143.41 . -412- - • , . . --- -4 •••.. A It' - - i T- 4' _____ •• . 27,.74 RES • ..Rt k ''''• nr97 '. I111111111140 -----------..._ -------.................Nice . 4.;. 4:. , 13 dr-.--. • A ......., ---. fi..... 'a. •". 1 0 %I •.•?„ .. ‘6-• 7.', *A 4k. I \ . • ,. •'. •'• 44.- •i. ‘, L 44. ... ,•.,...RP'23 , .,, 1\ \ 't* d;•• %6.3A 4..... I .7 -I- e • It I \ fl (°' 114.4',"e •C.! '... -147 \ , ,.........,.., \ \ •ti. - ...r•-• ., •,,•- •;, , 1 , ILO %it.•' :i; "-.% , \ \ ? i.(2'•--*;0-tt°(3 ','• .tk' G) C:f .-, < 1 \ 1 I A -- -S.. Z'.. . --- ••' •, , .. , ., ..-,•,'1,-,.. •. •:3. . - .i's ...q, 1 ••,ar••• ., 1 ,. 0,...... 1 1 . T, . ... ''. ••• : •.. ..., , ',Z:D : I \ :4 • r• 6, '•, •• '•,._ , . • • . . ! ;' - ....., \ .• ::,;' ,Iff. f9. ,; _ , '•'''',. N).,,. 3'4:2b. 4V a71(4,, i 4,41: 1 /-4. ; •,. r: , s•td El„ -,_, a s ir, -". V! N ----5:. Lig: 61 I, I \ , ..6., . 3,r 4. .6.: •, .• •3 -1 Is:• 4... 0. - ,•• • ';-' ,., . a :3 ". /6 ,. \ . 1 2 46 , e,1 TM - - Irros 0.< 1 ..,-6, .....-. 40_ •'''-- -4..,..7%- '''12 ; 2 ^ ts,..,,,' 21,- -- li v •- , •-,,,.._ . 121.v- .-. g) x T5I iii9 - ""a 1 I t _ , 9 t;* ..., '..•e;`.. ' r'••• - El ...6 •,.., ..,6 - -‘2 . 11. M AS I. ,,>:,„--,.... V • F,.. i 1 in r- 8 \ 4,,D -2 `. . r- x, :b. t .., 0 CO 3 7.•- v \ 7 • - INA 6. Q.91) ,c - P \ 'i rki2' 0 -1' -:L, -- '3 g • • .s Fir '4 .-.; t"'a - .... . a \ ,:' I .1.•!* . • ,.• '? - Crn tir=b 5'5- ., II - '.... ci• . 170.1 , - , ---•4=-4-' 1 03 52' , • t & 5 % ),- 1 v•C $11'•04;:k,').. ‘5'. 4,..,„ *. •Ii.ti• '44,4!, **--r_. lr, al? . . ... 05.69 1 '''' tt tom ••• - '...,,. . ,. .1. • ••I'' ! tlf.eg i •N.ga. 1 e 0 • • N0•14.:1•11 1 ! .. 44./6 co -1 I 21.,-- • ''..4 0 oockir tro9y3"111 14' : RD Il•.' I' . - -') i/ ,.., ......• ..: ie..4. t OKORD I RE2' " 0 I , 1 4.6% 1., ...T.... .t s i 2 ' --..„.....„....1•,, - t......... ' • ' 1 q• : .4. 333 „ .13 -I oLl IF, .... ' ' `I 1 •42. .464..t. 224, ;3. '' ., C,,.• Tgil -- t;-••1‘ 7h i --I LAKE MINNETONKA CONSERVATION DISTRICT REQUEST FOR REVIEW AND COMMENTS MINNESOTA DNR GENERAL PERMIT APPLICATION NUMBER: 97-6098 DATE OF REQUEST: February 13, 2006 RESPONSES DUE BY: February 24, 2006 (Note: Comments on this application are due 10 days from receipt of this notice. Return to: L.M.C.D.; 18338 Minnetonka Blvd.; Deephaven,MN 55391) FROM: Judd J. Harper PHONE: (952) 745-0789 Administrative Technician E-MAIL:jharper@lmcd.org TO: X DNR Area Hydrologist: Ms. Julie Ekman, MN DNR, 1200 Warner Road St. Paul, MN 55106-6793 X DNR Area Fisheries Manager: Mr. Daryl Ellison, MN DNR, 9925 Valley View Rd. Eden Prairie, MN 55344 X Municipality: Mr. Mike Gaffron, City of Orono, P.O. Box 66 Orono, MN 55323 Other PROPOSAL INFORMATION Name of Applicant: Bob Erickson Bay: Stubbs Bay Address of Project: 372 Westlake Street, Orono, MN Project Description: The applicant has submitted a permanent non-multiple dock license application for a site,on Stubbs Bay. The applicant has approximately 310' of 929.4' NGVD shoreline. The proposed dock appears to be contained within the authorized dock use area for this site for dock length and side setback requirements. The applicant does not propose to de-ice at this site. COMMENTS ON PROPOSAL Comments on Project by Reviewer (attach separate sheet if needed): Recommendation of Reviewer: Name of Reviewer: Title: Date: r IstiNt ,r PERMANENT NON-MULTIPLE DOCK LICENSE APPLICATION Lake Minnetonka Conservation District 18338 Minnetonka Blvd. 1/1 ;,.W4.: Deephaven, MN 55391 �°�ar1c ` Phone (952) 745-0789 LMCD Receipt# le yb l In accordance with Sec.2.06 of the LMCD Code,the following application for a permanent Dock License shall be completed in all respects and submitted to the District office. No person may locate,construct, install or maintain a new permanent dock on the lake without first securing a license providing that no such license shall be required of docks requiring a license under sec 2.03 of the LMCD Code.A new license is required whenever the size,type, location,or configuration of the dock is changed. No new license is required for repair or replacement of a previously permitted dock where such repair or replacement does not alter the size,type, location,or configuration of the dock. Because this form is to be copied,please use black ink or type. The person completing this form is the authorized agent or property owner(circle one). Applicant: /Vl/Met-onkr,L tea1j/e. Dre(11%l19 Address: 6-01.; !tJei± Li L. STY,, ' City, State, Zip: -, i /Si.0 r� /)'/tI f.533) Phone: %SZ- 74-9t/ y Fax: y5Z-V7`/--&-7/ 2— Property Property Owner(if different from applicant):, h Fye C KSU�l Address .372 4'uest LukE at. City, State, Zip: Q/2 /4O / /-7//V Phone: ei.5-2 `Y7[- -5-5e9 Fax: ?c2 V75-- 74') Documents listed below are required; and must accompany this application: ❑Locator Map ❑Scaled drawing of docks on abutting properties hO n ❑County Plat Map ❑Proposed facility site plan ❑Certified Land Survey, Legal Description ❑Existing facility site plan Absence of significant requested data, could result in a processing delay. 1. Type of facility ()$private () multiple dwelling () commercial () other(explain) 2. Intended use of dock facility ASh/'ny (end eeU{i`itY) /720604 Ifyia ova jt— 3. Abutting property owners at the lakeshore: North or West M/:v MSS ei,k)/N 6-4&� .r642. 7 %11a/,9 PD, O�•ff/I�O,Hf�1 ssas"� name and address South or East /9 ' 4 clof EL f' SN rOa>5 55.75' Ht:is•rpvg• Ag. Oiec<„r, Mn; , name and address Other affected parties name and address 1 of2 JAN 9 Gtia• Permanent Non-Multiple Dock License Application 4. Site lake frontage:, feet; distance of dock into the lake: feet. 5. All setbacks for the dock use area have been observed ( )yes ( ) no. 6.All required permits, licenses and approvals have been obtained from the city in which the permanent dock is located, and from the DNR: ( ) yes ( ) no Explain: 7. Application Fee $150.00 After-the-fact application fee $150.00 Total Fee enclosed $ I certify that the information provided herein and the attachments hereto are true and correct; I understand that any license issued may be revoked by the District for violation of the LMCD Code. I agree to reimburse the District for any legal, surveying, engineering, inspection, maintenance or other expenses incurred by the District in excess of the amount of the application fee. I consent to permitting officers and agents of the District to enter the premises at all reasonable times to investigate and to determine whether or not the Code of the District is being complied with. I agree to submit . -rtified, as-built survey upon completion of the docks. /—/?— Autborized Signa ure Date r eller a( i2lungyv Title //�� Lel°CVY4C1' V Return this application,attachments and fee to: Relationship to Owner Lake Minnetonka Conservation District 18338 Minnetonka Blvd. Deephaven, MN 55391-3232 Fax: (952) 745-9085 2 of 2 r1I VI n CO N � - v y 1 ° o 8- so (II 4% �x � ¢a p O ® a r O 2 -_ 'V pl - witl Orchard Park Road W� anl�0 2 c O ie c„ ..., .07,, y„ L eo _ ... ,. ,J`° ..se 6P°O„' _ ., ._ �n0 _ f 'D G--''e,....._ J ® mc., 0�1�+"+' ..Q8 -as n �` 7 N + 4i ' _: 4/ Stubbs Bay Road : z / • - A , a, + 0,,.. . / ri y o aT A r 7 o • J o 0 " �, 1,, ` t w \e\J.JI leaf s; Street Z a w › r N s O �Yi+1� y SAO e' N + L>l f + O ..c. O A w. N __� m 01 a + o �' r^ o 41 Z G Q + _. - \ t-P-'-' Old Crystal Bay Road 'OrBe O o �ai1i® 02 i O Ka O m i G@ Z I I`W D J, O Z �� �( To oar o r— @�, 4.'.,--,-.':-- .4„........_____________/'o ,�po1 p� ''y j ye% i 7.1„...,_ a 7O n I D � +.t., ® ` Willow Drive Willow Drive xi Westpoint Road , en `\� A O a CIO :A r• O = 3 n* om. _ a D 7 N - 4. en .l. L r ill -` + 14111115, Brown Road L Brown Road /1 1...- o A w N 1� + ++4- , ® - x t....(7). ( .,,,,—,of a / 2 \ N A o o J / Itifl 0 vei if Z + o room O ,?;C1 "fly o' + ^' .0 ++...• fi ) 9---) O 5 ` ' 1 (\ A g \ -,, ,0 //',7.1a 1....,„,,,_________,„:______)___ -______-----..__.--__..I—A---"'\ •+‘5„.„Jth +,:: N + + 'rti vQ' n MapQuest: Maps Page 1 of 1 Mots . : 372 W Lake St Orono MN 55356-9757 US Notes: wkA� iE"S � 01 ,300m 900tt T:, Luce jJte Rd Irr, U rW High to Reef)Sf �. f jy I. 3 rP;y {•A Vtd ion ig 1 '5'"'"4-- p m � ` � -� C? 71 � � 4':::',::,::-iii.;:-.k., c 9,s s,.#�s' �r } y.�,n�,. c�� � 'fir 1� _.b._. , +"sem "^' � E .1151 20 06 MapQues#,111c, . . „x�. . __.. t±1 s All rights reserved. Use Subject to License/Copyright This map is informational only. No representation is made or warranty given as to its content. User assumes all risk of use. MapQuest and its suppliers assume no responsibility for any loss or delay resulting from such use. http://www.mapquest.com/maps/print.adp?mapdata=%252bKZmeiIh6N9bj efR82ic075fSx... 1/18/2006 Page l of 1 Hennepin County Property Map Print Page Robert Erickson, 372 Westlake Street, Orono •./.., + 4 '� ` r 8 ;349 + P ` . 4�t M`• `r 1 . " � ii T 3. .�, , , . m. t w'"#. 356 Ft .._ 4. .„ . . ..., ,:tii. _.4014,, ,,,f.10, ,,..., . , ..„:„... _ ......._--„, _..„..,.. ..., .4,r........,,...... . ,,, . . ..... ,,,..--".7, 4:tc„.....,..,...„..,.....7N ..,...4"., ---- - -- e°4 .1 A --- am i} «7 '4V, Z $ 7r 372 ` j z ri .* ,. i - n Orono .r.A. R "4'4 .' ,4��� l ` � _ ` _ .+. .:.,. rim a .4 fw fX.,-.4-...-,,r, nLgv. 1; 1• '> '§kk y«•-� r � Y}4� 420 e a ♦ 1 4110,010, rf AYf r READ IMPORTANT DISCLAIMER INFORMATION Property ID Approximate Property Perimeter Approximate Property Area 05-117-23-23-0044 965 ft. 55,641 sq.ft. =1.28 acres Property Address Market Value Total Tax(2005) 372 WESTLAKE ST ORONO, MN 55356 $1,799,000 $13,861.98 The data contained on this page is derived from a compilation of records and maps and may contain discrepancies that can only be disclosed by an accurate survey performed by a licensed land surveyor.The perimeter and area (square footage and acres) are approximates and may contain discrepancies.The information on this page should be used for reference purposes only. Hennepin County does not guarantee the accuracy of material herein contained and is not responsible for any misuse or misrepresentation of this information or its derivatives. Provided by Hennepin County Taxpayer Services Department. JAN 1 9 2.006 p://wwwl 3.co.hennepin.mn.us/publicparcelimage/Print.aspx?CHID=INIT&IMAGEURL=http://www 13.... 1/19/2006 PROPOSED U , , Nous u in giT ______ 307.00 DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY SURVEYED o --1-0- N89°57'07"E 284. 10 ._______ z - -- NORTH LINE OF LOT 10 - That part of Lots 10, 11 and 12, Block I, HILLSIDE ,n PARK, according to the recorded plat thereof; in together with that part of the vacated Alley x, , `n `r' adjoining said Lot 12 per Document No. 271 1665, Hennepin County, Minnesota, lying west of a line 1— ‘i-) N1($/ CORNER OF LOT 10 BITUMINOUS o --] 1\n, described as commencing at the northwest corner — V J /0 o PROPOSED DRAINAGE & UTLITY EASEMENT of said Lot 10; thence on an assumed bearing of m 5 5North 89 degrees 57 minutes 07 seconds East, _-_-_ i rm along the north line of said Lot 10, a distance of 1i ' -\ = R=40.00 — — — I �J t 307.00 feet to the point of beginning of said line W — — / — to be described; thence on a bearingof South to 10 L=34.44 /// �30 FT. SETBACK LIN1�/` the shoreline of Lake Minnetonka and said line there=49° �40�� terminating. Except that part of said Lot 10, lying 1', j % I\ \ northwesterly of a curve concave to the west having (f, /// / a radius of 40 feet. Said curve passes through the z 112 // r') j northwest corner of Lot 9, said Block I, HILLSIDE J / v PARK and passes through a point on the westerly Y _GARAGE HOUSE / i line of said Lot 10 distant 74.16 feet south from CO said northwest corner of Lot 9. The cener of said tr m curve is on the center line of Westlake Street as Ili /////////////////////"/ % i dedicated in said plat. Q l DECK & STEPS -- — — — CI O O O OIq We hereby certify that this sketch, plan or report was — — — 1 i _ prepared by me or under my instruction and that I am 75 FT. LAKESHORE SETBACK LINE 1 1 = a duly Registered Land Surveyor under the laws of the W (FROM ORDINARY HIGH WATER LINE) State of Minnesota. k Q V) Dated this 18th day of January, 2006 N t' SUNDE LAND RV/YING, n 1 ;i,,,_ PROPOSED DRAINAGE & UTLITY EASEMENT t V By. ii. /' \ ORDINARY HIGH WATER LINE John ,:arnes, R.L.S. Minn. Reg. No. 16456 AS ESTABLISHED BY SURVEY I -J PRIOR TO PLACEMENT OF RIPRAP d Survey originally dated February 14, 2002 (SURVEY LINE r) _�__ 1 -- — —L N88°45'56"W 1 L 42750 I 10- °20 % t L• 307.79 �' , _ I 1 VACA ED ALLEY PER DOC. NO. 2711665 ilk • • • • •il 4i���� ���G•••i ����i=i=�=�— �_�_ _� --- ~ JAN 1 9 200E _��• • • •����������i�iA�••�•�r•�•�•�•�•�•�•� �•��_�_� 60 ■� —o VACATED ALLEY PER DOC. NO. 2711665� _ SHORE LINE —�•�•�14� • • • ..."-`----1"--- -- SHORE ROCK RIPRAP 1 6 1 —��•�I ROCKS ALONG SHORE 2 L 0 1I ir LAKE MINNETONKA W - -1 ( Revision By Date I wIv, Drawing Title:(STUoB ' S BAY) lol 16 ffl I 161 a 1 1 DOCK LOCA770N SKETCH FOR: I1 1 1 1 ROBERT ERICKSON 1 1 1-..-16.5-.--I 1 26.5—+-1 � 1 �-la-� I t co L:,3— J Sunde Date: ///8/2006 cr) Project: 98-248—A Land Surveying, LLC. Drawing: 9001 East Bloomington Freeway (35W)• Suite 118 98248A00/.dwg Bloomington, Minnesota 55420-3435 Business: 1 98-248-A 484/05 T.117, R.23, S.05 98248A001.dwg BMS 952-881-2455• FAX: 952-888-9526 Sheet: / Of 1