HomeMy WebLinkAbout06-29-1981 Board of Review Reconvened Minutes w �
, ��
2ND RECONVENED MEE'�ING OF THE
1981 ORONO BOARD OF REVIEW
The 2nd reconvened meeting of the Orono Board of Review
was called to order by Mayor Van Nest, June 29 , 1981, at
7: 30 p.m. Councilmembers present were: Paurus and Hannah.
Absent were Councilmembers Hurr and Butler.
Appearing before the Board were:
l. Henry Kingman
1185 Ferndale Road West
Property I.D. 02-117-23 43 0014
02-117-23 43 0017
i4r. Kingman thanked the Board for again giving him
the opportunity to appear before them. He stated he still
felt the land value was too high. Discussion fallowed as
to the lakeshoxe values in other communities. Motion by
Paurus seconded by Hannah to lower the total land value to
$135 ,000 and leave the partial building value at $4 ,000.
Motion passed.
2. Bruce Curtiss
1920 Fagerness Point Road
Property I .D. 17-117-23 23 0014
The Mayor gave the results of the County' s revaluation
to the Curtiss' . The County had recommended $12 , 000 land
and $1,000 building total $13,000 . The Mayor suggested that
this lot be combined with their homestead parcel. Mr. Curtiss
had an appraisal from Century 21. The Mayor cautioned Curtiss
that the lot his house is on is undersized and any building
improvements or additions could be disallowed because of
lack of area. P-Sotion by Van Nest seconded by Paurus to accept
the revaluation by tne County, land $12 ,000 building $1,000
total $13 ,000 or if the lot is combined with the homestead
parcel tomorrow the value of the land would be $6 ,200 and
building $1, 000. The Curtiss rec�uested time to think this
offer over. The Board agreed to table the motion while
the Curtiss ' made up their minds.
The Board proceeded wa.th the following items:
3. Mr. Carpenter
905 Old Crystal Bay Road
Property I.D. 09-117-23 21 0002
09-117-23 21 0003
09-117-23 21 0004
09-117-23 12 0003
,.
1981 2nd Reconvened Meeting
Board of Review
page 2
Motion by Van Nest seconded by Paurus to accent the
reductions made by Hennepin County as follows:
09-117-23 21 0002 reduced to:
Land $400,000 Building $250, 000 = $650 ,000 Total
f rom
Land $409,000 Building $332 , 400 = $741,400 Total
09-117-23 21 0003 reduced to:
Land $40 ,000 Total
from
Land $76 , 000 Total
09-117-23 21 0004 reduced to:
Land $80 , 000 Building $5 ,000 = $85 , 000 Total
from
Land $79 , 000 Building $23,000 = $102 ,500 Total
09-117-23 12 0003
No changes made.
P4otion carried.
4. Herbert J. Powell
3220 Watertown Road
Property I.D. 32-118-23 44 0001
r�otion by Van Nest seconded by Paurus to accept the re-
ductions made by Hennepin County as .follows:
Land $52 , 000 Buildings $1,500 = $53 ,500 Total
from
Land $44 ,200 Buildings $14 ,400 = $58 , 600 Total
Motion carried.
5. Louis R. Smerling
2683 Casco Point Road
Property I .D. 20-117-23 24 0043
Motion by Van Nest seconded by Hannah to accept the
revaluation by Hennepin County as follows :
Land $92 ,000 Building $3, 000 = $95 ,000 Total
from
Land $93, 900 Building $4, 000 = $97 ,900 Total
Motion carried.
•f
1981 2nd Reconvened Meeting
Board of Review
page 3
6. Alvin Nelson
2445 Dunwoody Avenue
Property I.D. 20-117-23 22 0011
Mr. Nelson asked the Board if Hennepin County thinks
the Orono Assessor was too lenient? Paurus told him "we
have been satisified that the increase was not only in
Orono lakeshore. " The Mayor stated they did feel that Orono
lakeshore was low compared to other communities. No action.
7. Dr. Ahmad Nakib
3393 Crystal Bay Road
Property I .D. 17-117-23 44 0020
Motion hy Van Nest seconded by Paurus to accept the
revaluation by Fiennepin County as follou�s:
$115 ,100 from $125, 800
Motion carried.
8. James Fullerton, Jr.
3400 Fox Street
Property I .D. 05-117-23 43 0004
05-117-23 44 0002
05-117-23 44 0005
Motion by Van Nest seconded by Hannah to accept Hennepin
County' s revaluation as follows:
05-117-23 43 0004 reduced to:
Land $530, 000 Building $350 ,000 = $800,000 Total
05-117-23 44 0002 reduced to:
Land $78 ,000
05-117-23 44 0005 reduced to:
Land $100
James Fullerton, III
3350 Fox Street
Property I .D. 05-117-23 44 0001
No change.
rlotion carried.
Mr. and Mrs. Curtiss appeared before the Board and said
they would sign a request for combination.
.,
.
1981 2nd Reconvened A�eeting
Board of Review
page 4
Motion by Van P1est seconded by Paurus to lower the
market value of Property I .D. 17-117-23 23 0014 to:
Land $6 ,200 Building $1, 000 = $7 ,200 Total if combination is
done by June 30 , 1981. �4otion carried.
Curtiss' said they would go to the City Administration
office after the meeting tonight and sign the combination
request.
Motion b_y Van Nest seconded by Hannah to ad�ourn at
� 8 : 30 p.m. Motion carried.
r.
,�� , r�, ., +, ...
� �..1� '�\. �.,.1�,�. �l ` , .
William $_� Van Nest, Mayor
/� �l 1 �
Attest: / /.�f� G�-�LLv✓ �.�7 i GcT�'w
��berta M. Strom, City Clerk
�r
♦ . .
f
. �
June 29 � 19 81
�
V r.�R 1�'ON T. HOPPS
FINIINCE DIVISION DIRECTGFt
llb COIIRTHOUSE
MI NNEIIPOLI 5, MI hT1ESOTA 55415
DF.AR SIR;
I Hr..Zt r.BY MAKS R�UEST FCR A ���T���'rrY CQ�'iBIN�.D) ASSESSMENT ON THE
FOLIA4JI NG DESCRi BED LAND:
17-117-23 23 0013 and
17-117-23 23 0014 �
TC14�iV, VI LLAGE Cfft DI STRI CT 3� - Orono
,
�—'�i l�F� �"� �„� i .�t��,v.�!t���c L��-c�
SI GP1AT UR E OF FLE a,l NER
�/ i� � _r_— � ,�l ri��l.�'d
,�A; ..` �
NAMa OF TAX PAYFR
FCEt 19II2 Tt�C YF.�1R {� �
//��O f"/��,�-tie�SY /c..�i /C �/.
TAX PAYF�t�5 ADI�RESS .
CQ�fBINED CIkZRENT VALUES
H OR TOTAL FULL TaT/IL
N.R. A� �P• �D BUILDING MACHINE f�IdD TRUE ASSESSID
' ,
�
�
JUN 2 919�1
BRUCE CURTISS APPRAISAL _ _
O i�v.r o
f7 � //]'- 1. 3 - L3 - ovl �
Sale #1
Location: Orchard Beach Road
Sale Date: 7/80 12/80
Sale Price: �4,000 $15,000
Size: 75' x 100'
Comments : Unbuildable.
Sale #2
Location: Casco Point
Sale Date: 7/79
Sale Price: $6,000
Size: 60' x 200' + 45' x 45'
Comments : Sale of 1/2 Interest. Unbuildable.
(See Sale #3 for other 1/2 of sale)
Sale #3
Location: Casco Point
Sale Date: 7/79
Sale Price: $6,000
Size: 60' x 200' + 45' x 45'
Corr�ments : Sale of 1/2 Interest. Unbuildable.
(See Sale #2 for other 1/2 of sale}
.
, . , -�
r
Sale #4
Location: Southeast of Pheasant Lawn
Sale Date: 9/80
Sale Price: $22,000
Size: 20' x 120' (mostly water)
Cor�nents : Existing Dock. Unbuildable.
Subject:
Location: Fagerness Point
Size: 210' on Road; 310' on Lake; 70' Average Depth
Comments : Unbuildable. Part of Existing Homestead.
See Attached City Report.
COfJCLUSION:
After analyzing the above Lot Sales , it is my opinion
that a Fair and Reasonable Market Value of the
subject is :
Land $12,000
Building 1 ,000
Total $13,000
—�. ���e`-�cJ .
,� `�