Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout#6354-CUP-2013 * � - a.� c�b ���. � �' Doc No A10046028 Certified, filed and/or recorded on Jan 10, 2014 2:00 PM Office of the County Recorder Hennepin County, Minnesota Martin McCormick, County Recorder Mark V. Chapin, County Auditor and Treasurer Deputy 97 Pkg ID 1073770M Doc Name: Conditional Use Permit Document Recording Fee $46.00 Document Total $46.00 i This cover sheet is now a permanent part of the recorded document. � . _ � O� O � O CITY of ORONO � ` �. � RESOLUTION OF T��ITIf COUNCIL �� ��,'� NO. v 4 �kESHOg' A RESOLUTION APPROVING A CONDITIONAL USE PERMIT FOR A COLUMBARIUM WALL, MEMORIAL LANDSCAPE WALL, AND OPEN GAZEBO STRUCTURE PURSUANT TO ORONO CODE SECTION 78-418 FILE NO. 13-3641 WHEREAS, Jerilyn Lowe (hereinafter the "Applicant") has made an application on behalf of Trinity Lutheran Church, the owner (hereinafter the "Owner") of property located at 2060 Sixth Avenue North within the City of Orono (hereinafter the "City") and legally described as follows: See Attached Exhibit A (hereinafter"the Property"); and WHEREQS, the City of Orono is a municipal corporation organized and existing under the laws of the State of Minnesota; and WHEREAS, pursuant to State Statutes 412 et. seq. and 462 et. seq., the City Council of the City of Orono has adopted zoning reguiation for the protection of the public health, safety and general welfare; and WHEREAS, the Property contains an existing church and is located in the RR-1 B one family rural residential district. A church is an allowed use within residential districts by conditional use permit; and WHEREAS, the church on the Property has an existing conditional use permit; and WHEREAS, on October 23, 2013, the Applicant made an application requesting a conditionaf use permit to permit decorative walls and an open sided gazebo structure to be constructed as part of a memoria{ garden on the Property pursuant to City Code Section 78-418 (4); and WHEREQS, on October 23, 2013, the Applicant also made an application requesting a conditional use permit for construction of an above-grade columbarium pursuant to City Code section 78-418(14); and WHEREAS, after due published and mailed notice in accordance with Minnesota Statutes 462.3595 et. seq. and the City of Orono Zoning Codes, on November 18, 2013, the Orono Planning Commission held a public hearing for the application at which time all persons desiring to be heard concerning the application were given the opportunity to speak thereon. Page 1 of 4 .� o,�,. O �� O CITY of ORONO � � ���;-�"� � RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL �t �G� No. 6354 9kESH�4 NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono, Minnesota: FINDINGS 1. This application was reviewed as Zoning File #13-3641. 2. The Property is located in the RR-1 B Rural Residential Zoning District. 3. A church is an allowed conditional use within the RR-1 B Rural Residential Zoning District. 4. Trinity Lutheran Church has existed on the Property since the 1950's and operates under a CUP issued via Resolution No. 2423 Adopted May 9, 1988. 5. The Planning Commission reviewed this application at a public hearing held on October 21, 2013 and voted 7 for and 0 against on a motion to approve the conditional use permit for the columbaria wall as described herein based on the folfowing findings: a) The proposed columbaria wall complies with all setback requirements. b) The proposed open gazebo and memoria� wall comply with all setback requirements. c) The Applicant has provided a landscape plan which provides the required screening. d) The proposed use is consistent with the Community Management Plan; e) The proposed use is compliant with the zoning code, including any conditions imposed on specific uses as required by Article V, Divisions 2 and 3 of the City Code; fl The Property is able to be adequately served by police, fire, roads, and stormwater management; g) The Property is provided with an adequate water supply and sewage disposal system; h) The proposed use is not expected to generate excessive demand for public servicss at public cost; i) The proposed use is compatible with the surrounding area as used both presently and as it is planned to be used in the future; j) The proposed use is consistent with the character of the surrounding area, unless a change of character is called for in the Community Management Plan; k) The proposed use is compatible with the character of buildings and site improvements in the surrounding area, unless a change of character is called for in the Community Management Plan; Page 2 of 4 � � O _V O � O CITY of ORONO � � ,�:'�_ � RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL �t " ��� No. 6 3 5 4 �kESH�g' I) The proposed use is not expected to substantially impair the use and enjoyment of the property in the area or have a materially adverse impact on the property values in the area when compared to the impairment or impact of generally permitted uses; m) The proposed use is provided with screening and buffering adequate to mitigate undesirable views and activities likely to disturb surrounding uses; n) The proposed use will not create a nuisance which generates smoke, noise, glare, vibration, odors, fumes, dust, electrical interference, general unsightliness, or other means; o) The proposed use will not cause excessive non-residential traffic on residential streets, parking needs that cause an inconvenience to adjoining properties, traffic congestion, or unsafe access; p) The site is designed to take into account the natural, scenic, and historic features of the area and to minimize environmental impact; q) All exterior lighting shall be so directed so as not to cast gfare toward or onto the public right-of-way or neighboring residential uses or districts; and r) The proposed use is not detrimental to the public health, public safety, or general welfare. CONCLUSIONS, ORDER AND CONDITIO�lS Based upon one or more of the above findings, the Orono City Council hereby grants a conditional use permit to permit decorative walls and an open sided gazebo structure to be constructed as part of a memorial garden on the Property pursuant to City Code Section 78-418 (4); and a conditional use permit allowing construction of an above-grade columbarium pursuant to City Code section 78-418(14), subject to the following conditions: 1. Council approval is based on the survey/site plan, columbarium pfan, gazebo rendering, landscape pfans submitted by the Applicant and annotated by City staff, attached to this Resolution as Exhibits B, C, D & E (hereinafter the "Plans"). Any amendments to the Plans which are not in conformity with City codes will require further Planning Commission and City Council review. 2. The Plans submitted for permit will be reviewed to ensure compliance with the City's regulations. 3. Authorities granted by this resolution run with the Property not with the Applicant or Owner, but are permissive only and must be exercised by obtaining a building permit for the new construction within one year of the date of Council approval, or the conditional use permit will expire on that date (December 9, 2014). Page 3 of 4 � , � O� O � O CITY of �RONO � � �;�:.. � RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL �� ��� No. 6 3 5 4 �kESH�4 4. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this resolution shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically terminate any authority granted herein, and shall be punishable as a rnisdemeanor. 5. The undersigned Owner has read, understands and hereby agrees to the terms of this resolution and on behalf of the Owner and the Owner's heirs, successors and assigns, hereby agrees to the recording of this resolution in the chain of title of the Property. Adopted by the Orono City Council on the 9th day of Qecember, 2013. ATTEST: C�,c .�i.� ���, �� :�, rrJ� l� • Rachel Dodge, City Clerk Lili Tod McMillan, Mayor � �--'f Property Owner(s) STATE OF MINNESOTA COUNTY OF HENNEPIN This instrument was acknowledged before me this _�day of���If1e►� , 20�3on behalf of the Owner, Trinity Lutheran Church, by Melanie DeLuca its Councif President. r.p.ar.i". l�' Y1/Wl� :r y�� MONICAA.FADNESS ' ... NOTARYPUBLIC-MINNESOTA Nota PUbIIC � `�,'�'PJ Commission Ex ires Jan.31,2017 ".�a,n��?`s �Y P ���' Page4of4 � Resolution Exhibit A b354 _ LEGAL DESCRIPTION OF PREMISES : That part of the Eost 550.00 feet of the Southwest Quarter of Section 27, Township 118 North, Range 23 West of the 5th Principal Meridian, lyin north of the northerly right—of—woy line of Hennepin County State Aid Highway No. 6. ALSO, that part of Hennepin County State Aid Highway Number 6, Plat 5, as (isted in document number 5455483, described as follows: the East 550.00 feet of the Northeast Quarter of the Southwest Quarter of Section 27- 1 18-23, which lies southerly of the Nortn line of said County State Aid Highway No. 6, plat 5, and northerly of a line drawn parallel with and distant 33.�0 feet southerly of said North line. �– CERTIFICATE OF SURVEY FOR PCExhibltB � ��- ��"� — �— � � i i i ' ' i' � �� �� � �� i � ITRINITY LUTHERAN CHURCH �;3� ,.��oex-- s 8��,6• ,2�� E, , 1 I I � � // � � --�` �� � � I i / l.l „ I �M�6���� 550.19 � 1N THE SW 1/4 OF SEC. 27-118-23 F�� — � / I � ���, � .--... I �.aa U��. �� � � / � I � � � � � � � H E N N E P I N C O U N T Y, M[N N E 5 0 T A ,�»-��.-v M��'�/1 �/ /� / / �;/ I J � r , , � �= �� ��VOODED AREA � -- ���Z � ��w'� ` / WQ6DED A j�A; / � /� / ����/�i���/�.Cy � �....... i / / �� �, �, C 1 � � ...�............../.....�..i.... � � � °��'o� _� i _ _..- �� / / jr J/..�. r..........-s�so.00............................................ .���........�- in .................... � � v.. �\ \ ,�........... � C7 � i �� / / / �; � 1 � � �, \ ' ��� �/�ooe'�// i / // /�� � I ` �� ` \�\y °& � '� a� i S\ �Q��� // � ' ' \.,` �� ���J ` \\ \ �-+�� � �� q �/ '..� / i �� + ��` �� '4 \ � � � p'S � / / / � �' \\ a� ,e c i i i � /'°� �� �� ��� :—-�C:� ��� �'.., tio� ��� \ �h � i ,� i i / —�'`;� \ � .' � �� lP / /� / �� "^` \ �'B�MfAIs wK�¢...�... \ � � �i�v°I — / / / ���_� `` \� , \ \ \ \ SF11hf] — � � /�/� ��� ���s,F,,"_�� /� --��� w � �I \�\�_ � – h��IX .........� . ....----r/� � • .�� _ _�..% I �.�,r,� t � � , � _� � /I �� �w p y t � I �\\� LECAL DESCMPTqN Of flEM5E5: � 4�� �,. 7�n � � � I Thal pat oi lM Emt 550.00/eet ol!ha SwlAwut Oumtv 1 Seelion 27. . ��- _ y � I \ \ Tf the�iPwr�thul�Yr,htRol9w Y,I'me�ol�FWu+eyM�Coudy Stater�Aid�•{pl�yfnqy Noh e. �' �0�4. ti.�� I ALSO,thot part �Heme�1n Canty Stala AiA Mgtnq Nrtber 8,Fbt�S,o Yfled U _� � tb"' C Z N � I M 0ocumn[mnber 3455{E7,deaulDeA fob�s:tha Eaat 550.00 leel 1 lhe w Nwihemt quortrc 1 lM Seuthwest Gumt�r f SecNm 27-118-1],which Nas � �—/�,a,-i�� � EXISTI NG "� � "�o� � L,� � .o�enniy o�«r�.w un�ai.�a ce�niy sio�.Ald F49�woy No.B,plat 5, � � ond nwUrrty ol a Iro trawn paMd rllM1 ond dislml 7J.00 leet eaulheAy p. � ' BUILDING �� I or.wa wam e�.. ' l , � v �'—�� /� �. � Azoeo , �ca s�+"s �\ o: e�i..to��k�r � � � O: danole�HemeO����^�Y R�9�'��–ol–woy mo-ker y ��i wr I I�� � ........._ f .._"'....................are......................... .......... .. � /�- ",. ; � ��� •,wy �4 �� 3 (voe�): duwts��rhlMq+pel Nevotiw�mean seo tevel dalum ... .- w I w� � �� � . �: danole�OraOoasd spat elevollen.mam aeo Ie.M dotum '� � O \ � ! t � 1 �e w \1 \� I \ � —on—: d�ml�e�dalMp conta+Ane.mean sao Ievat datum ��yp � a � ...��� ..�;.. � � a --�: e.�ot.. e�a,��r e.,�m..a b.a aai�.,� eyupl 0 6 ..�w .o..� a wwo.. �� . L��� .�y,+ sa'"r / i O � �e��.�..iro.�,a..ea.�e wo�w,o.nm.e eata,,. ��F99 � I�.sa ` _'� f ca�� / ( i4M � Z / � �� �,u �„u�� �.�y•m� � $ A $ / s j \` � ' � �. I � � �1` � TMs avra�y tnlend�to eMw Ne�ound>lea af lha o6ore deacriDed properly, �y $ i ' .. I �j 1• _,.� : �/ .P...., .'' \ a, lh bcotl n of tro exiatx�bWMing;�Idexolk�,bilvrino�n kinq arso � (� B � �' � . ', ..•�'� .....�'/ �, KirAon-s-��r / � � mafor tree�,�and vdleybd eourle.seplic nwude,vie�le u�iilies,o� �bi° E � :. 1 .•"i�, �T�����: { a�o.�m.rro.�' locoled by Capha State One Cd,and Ihe aoposed beolion al o aopoeed • I „�� �:' — ——� �� —��"1�——�——��� � __4. . w�•l�Orame ts�O�nC�enll.lhlraan I(dOef rol pupat lo[b� �a.E'O� . � --==�� .`� _/� �— ' � a. .e� ���j N _-- � _ � ,�,.... �egs 6 � ���� s ) ��� ! � p=20°33'26" R=1317.39 .. �,/ ,� �ien�}e, 1' 1�472.67 U � �_� � , �: / ;.... w,F.���a i .... 83. 53,. W. S��e� I � "� �iENNEPIN COUNTY STATE AID HIGHWAY N0: 6 � (6TH AVENUE NORTH) � -� o �o Bo 90 � �i I �—� � ' !�NI I 5 C A L E 1 N i E E T � ;m — z�z RECEIVED �� olQ �� � ncT 23 z013 �� U"�� � �, � � �' � rn1[� CITY ClF�rtnnin ,�- m �' � � � o c� v` c �. = � o' � W � _ �^. / . j�...... /- / / �� : /av��c i �/ � / � � �/ � / � ,� � �� ��' Resolution � ! � � ��� � � �� Exhibit B Z �- � � / / i � 6,. Pvc–� _– � i �i i � � �— �.-� � � _�� ,�� �� � __--�=��b: ���4 � � / �— / - — — // // /// / /�' '�''���//` :4' APPLE J / / / /� �_i"-' '�/ � /� //;i=,�\ 4" APPLE _ _ _ — �� � /�/, � � i � /�'i�� . �� _ _.._--_-_���""_--...88 �.....__._ ��� �_ N��-�-ti}{}F-P,�- _ .. o�.. ._/_. ./.__r,� yF.2 .�uM� , Zo��X2o•� / EXISTING � �1 COTTONWOOD � BASKETBAL / / � � I ,, GARAGE"' HooP � � ��'S�/B,� � .o N FLOOR IEVEL � ��� k\��� BOX / I �O =�1025.4) g0.3 � : �'��� ELDER 341 FLOOR N � �� � LEVEL 5•�c ;.... _—�—" `"' � E �, 106.24�\ e��S 55058' 3a+s �(�ozs.o) � °�'o '--1-020� ��/avcT�c . W� -...., �pO �- � p �� �, � � � �'••.SEPTIC••' PP�� � E �:,i' pgt. / MANHOLE i�"' � 5�' O � '/ ,�// B x ,/�EJQSTWGO �/ •� S�T�EPS� �_ RETA�N 5, E X I S T 1 / �� t 2�.0�W 11/ 9��1 �� �� �—�/ � �� 030.7) ��p,�� � 16" $p�,� + 3 1 i � � / 6ti � l _� / / `0'L ,^,�' ' �� r0 0� 1�CF{ ��y� � m� �/ �/ 1 i_�,n . ' ��—�� � y�/ � �� ��� '"i�G h �u''�C"CpP1�C. 3:1 . SROPOSED � �,� � ,�� �� � a/ '�� � 0� I/ J � , ,m PAD #,. FENCE �. � � Q� ��` � °' � a, � � �� / �/ � ����r.. � �� I/ 1 ;� `t � �� w P�OPOSED �/ !� Q/ � � �.o �L., �'n ,'!A, � �' ' / 1 / � � I ��� '��,� rw., �" ROOFED 1 � �� �. ,,, LARGE �� / . � � CROSS N r, � STRUCTURE �� ) '\� o� '�C�, t � •..... 56.2� . . _� �`�%/�r a`�`C`' l Waoo ►u� 1,�� � 3 . P05ED PATIO F G��� y� � i,^N��Pp � 35 � PR ��� 'Yp.� �7o�z t 4•:�SP � � � O Q ; �/� � o�r �ti'� � �%ii,u S CONC. c a9.5 � Y 3' ./ � / � � pR� _ WALK O Q> i : ��j/����°�sEn �\\P ED � E ` R►,M � m� � � �'`�H� �� � / WING �; TRU55 SFRNlKLE � � � p WALL ', OLD N �� FRO WEII � ��l / �x � _� � N WATER ` , '\ t � WELL O i � l / � r �m I � TOP OF � � , .�/� �.{�/ z �� O�� � I� WELL� � 1` 1 /—�rf�' / � �I �� SAND (1036.5) 1 ' 1 C�CRETE � C0 / � -' � � VOLLEYBALL ur�Rc,�ouH� ` p��AR W�� // � yl rn COURT NATt�tAL GAS� � �oss °.� a+ � ' � .� � � �, �m � 1 � :o � z 'o �s���.�, \ �� r i � E i � �' t o • ..��� •BITUMI� I � � `• /� :t. I � `�vrri.,, 6/ , � � � / I 8" JACK PWE .- �I %ii.1a�`' ��- �i�t�.��._ � —� �r \ �� �--' ��- ` t � � � ��� i _�—� �; �� I i� '•L�— � r ��''�� I ''+�Il�" �f PP�f,..• �� 20" � F� � , I SILVER �� / � ' � A1APLy� � _. r, r^ , � Resolution �� Exhibit B3 b354 as z �� �� / � �J i / /c� / �� � � ��� , �e . ��� � % / O ;�� ''�,.���\ ��_.�--� Z / / / � �>'' � �— / �� � � / \�\ ,/-1 = Inl /f� � �J `� �.� � _ /— � �x� '; � o Q � W � L���i�' � f--- ` _,' 1�i��� �!T � ` � j4.!.� � I� � _ � ^` 9K . z � , ,t� ' I �4 u�S��q� r�, 0 �� � � ��,;-•�y z m P�- O ? ���;_ rr.•.�,..�'� t— � �. � � �f O`'J' — � w � U z � %� W z > � \ �� J Q — \ � ,--. �.: �3-� �k, � � � . � l � � z � � � �" � co � ��� �-' � ,� Z i '`` o N s '� .�n ��� W % �-�. �� 9��s ��; Z ~ 26 a � . �� 7`;� � .. ��� � �....._-�� � e,ii° 'S p Ca[ •�,�� � _ � / � �q p �O! �E �' �ex S �� � � 6.2., . � '� � v' ' �� 8 ki� 1 _ __._j3 - .. Z , �d N ,8�� 6� , M .,0£,b .LO \ ` ` � ;:. . ... . . - .:,�., �... .. - - � - _ „�,, � �-� �;�s�'�-� ..''� .y` � 3 , ��=x � �-; `�-� �., �.: �' , ,..�...� - ( � Trinity Lutheran Church t�1jCKH�F Long Lake, MN __....----------- --- C O L U M B A R 1 A 1 N C 160- 8"x8"Companion Niches ForPermenencedBeeuty Finished with a Limestone Cap and Mahogany Granite Niche fronts x � L`opyright C 2010 E�ckhof Cofumbana Inc. �► � 0 1-800.2530457 � � � �� � � � Resofution � Exhibit Cy , � 6 54 � Examvle Serpenhne Columbarium - Free-Standing,Wall � This columbarium features the use of capstone aachors along with base r anc6or brackets. A►!so see pages 28 -31 for details. ; RY EN�S 1ER9 - - EACH COYPANION N[CHE RItL HOLD Niches set back to back� " 2 - 51/2' XSI/2" X7' URNS `; sharing the same capstone and i� 7•-0• rs�ncua • Fece foundation. � OF NICHE FRONTS � '2" RADIU9 • * NICHE FRONTS CHANGE OF RADIUS .i� :� MASONRY ENOS !'� BY OTHERS i• l B'-8' RADIUS • FACE ♦� ' Of NICHE FRONtS �.. ' i , _ - J � ;`:;... PLAN VIEW � - ,�.. _ . .._____ . -� io'-u i/z' wwws • :;�>. FA[E OF NICHE FRONTS �°�� ;kxy> 1 x: 1' Z ';. � •.:L'���'� �CAPSTONE 33"� �I _ i� "�-e; THICK CAPSTONE � �} _ DRIP EDGE ' ' ' 3/4" SEITING SPACE ' 'U'��;'- 12 1 2' . ( �i' ��;s � � � tis:r: DEPTH � Numbers denote hardware �_; f details. See page 9 for � � `��:_�-� C DU BONNET � ' ti;�.' GNITE(N1CHE ° columbarium details. `"; .ONTS PO[13HED) RANITE NICHE z ,:::' FRONTS - 2 1/2" a ;I ;��;;; FR011 FACE p OF CABINET E. TO FACE OF STONE � �1�� 41CK SURRO(1NDS �' =- t OTHERS a 'i. �' � 24'�l/2"• 'I� � OF FOUNDATION � • I P BE S1lOOTH. ALL RE-BAR YUST BE HELD DOMN �� , AND LEVEL 3 1/Z" FROA1 TNE TOP OF CONCRETE I 'PTH IS REQUIRED BASE THIS NILL lNSURE THAT ME iiAVE E'1'E BASE THAT 15 ��5" NO 08STRUCTIONS WHEN DRIILINC � ,�� 's FAS`t'ENED TO TOTAL DEPTH 30 �N OUR 3' [ANC SLEEVE ANCHORS , ',I��HOF i� � ,, - COLUMBARIA INC � -- Copydyl+t O 2009 Eickhof Cohunb�rL Iac � '; SECTION I-800-253-0457 ' � �i��aQ �; Resolution ' ' Exhibit D Melanie Curtis From: Jerilyn �j 3 'cj Q Sent: Thursday, November 07, 2013 1:28 PM To: Melanie Curtis Subject: Gazebo example Melanie, This is an example of the gazebo. The idea is a 4 pole roofed open structure to be used as a shelter from the elements and of course compfiment the garden. 15' x 10 ish. Thank you, Jeri ,, ; , � �� �r--<:;�ur'�_:� ���' �: r. .:'r'• �,. . -.:,...:,'._, ._�..�.. :� �Y � . ... _.,<.: . ;_. . _ a:�"'F'"' _ a - 1 Resolution � ' ' � f Exhibit E � � 6354 � � � . . . � � �� � - � II � �� , �$ } } � � v� � 4 't , � � a � —�, . � � . � , ` . 3 , � ,� ,. � � � � � � � , �. � , �: . , � . ��" . - �_,.,.• �� � . . �. ��� � . . - p' Z � � . � " � 1 J � � r • -� � 'L ` � � .i 1 : � � ' - � � �= � � � f � � � � � � i • � � ' � ` � � � Z � Z Z 11� � � � - � � � � � a � � � � �� � � � � . � � 3 ` � � _ �� � � � �� � � - ,� .� � � . 'i • . � STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ) ss COUNTY OF HENNEPiN ) The undersigned, being duly qualified and appointed City Clerk of the City of Orono, Minnesota, certifies that I compared the foregoing resolution adopted at the meeting of the Orono City Council on December 9, 2013, with the original thereof on file in my office, and the same is a correct transcription thereof. WITNESS my hand officially as such CiTy Clerk and the corporate seal of the City this�day of t�.t , 2014. ���:. ti �.-�_....(' /Jo �=�: City Clerk �� ,�� , � _ :, t , ,._ . `, � '��. ,� '' ;;. � � � �a � �� a 6 � �� � r�f °�� � '. ��,f�}' J i -f P 6l . . r _! h/'"'� .. r?n A+ ,i ..✓4 3 .-e .�,,�.e4����"���rM > �7 Y•, '� `" f� �.y:..°+. s ++„��