HomeMy WebLinkAboutAffidavit of property use • i Metropolitan Council � Environmental Services MCES Affidavit-C
; 390 Robert Street North Last Updated: 12/14/2014
! St. Paul, Minnesota 55101-1805
"' � 651.602.1531 �651.602.1030 fax
Sewer Availability Charge(SAC)
2015 AFFIDAVIT OF PROPERTY USE
This Affidavit of Property Use is to verify the demand on this property for SAC purposes for Non-Conforming Credit when there
is no evidence of SAC paid for the existing demand and no documentation can be found for the two types of Non-Conforming
Credit: 1)Grandparent Demand (demand used prior to 1973 when the SAC program began with evidence between 1968-
1978); and 2) Long Continuous Demand (demand for 10 years or more up through 3 years prior to current SAC Determination
Property Address: 3384-3386 Shoreline Drive
Customer Community: Ci of Orono
Parcel Identification Number: 17-117-23 44 0100
Dates of Non-Conforming Credit: 1968 througf 1978
Type of Non-Conforming Credit: � Grandparent Demand ❑ Long Continuous Demand
vve certiry tnat c;ustomer c;ommunity statt nave researcnea tne aaove properry ana touna no written
proof of the existing use on this site. Records researched may have included: dated building plans
associated with a specific permit, building inspection records stating the actual use of the property,
business licenses, and/or building or county assessment records. The records that were researched
include:
City Building Permits and other written communications in City files.
Although we could find no written proof, we believe the demand of this property includes (must be
specific in what was there and, if more than one demand include the amount of square feet for each
specific use):
See attached sheet dated June 29, 2015.
and was used in this manner during the Non-Conforming Credit dates as stated above.
We hereby certify that we have read and understood this affidavit and that the statements are true to our
knowledge and belief. We further understand that the giving of false information in this affidavit constitutes fraud
and is also cause for the immediate redetermination of any charges. We have no conflict of interest in this matter.
Print Name of Community Official: 4��Cw�-v� �ar��t�R�'�"
Co unity uilding/SAC Official
Signature of Community Official: Date: ����/�
Print Name of Community Official: p d► .Q ��V �U�J(�rn�r �cC�2�
Dep ent Head of Bu' ' orS8C•1��+eie4
Signature of Community Official: ` Date: �
DRAFT Attachment to �davit of City of Orono, June 29,2015
The commercial building at 3380-3382-3384-3386 Shoreline Drive in the Navarre district of
Orono was constructed in 1937 based on CounTy records. The building is 100 feet in width and
50 feet deep based on surveys on file at the City offices. I have reviewed City building permits
and other City records for this site. The building in the past was divided into as many as 4
separate spaces, as follows, from east to west:
3380 Shoreline Drive- East 40 feet(40' wide x 50' deep) As of 1965 this space was a
clothing Store(Charlotte's)per 1965 Navarre Tornado photo; in 1969 the space was
converted to a restaurant use (first the Unicorn,then Jimmie's, finally the Narrows) and
has been operated as a restaurant ever since.
3382 Shoreline Drive- Central 20 feet(20' wide x 50' deep plus 13'x20' restroom
annex added later)per 1965 tornado photo and City building permit records was operated
as a meat market facility known as Axel & Bob's until ca. 1987 at which time that
business was discontinued. Some time after 1987 the restaurant use at 3380 Shoreline
expanded into this space.
3384 Shoreline Drive - West/central 20 feet(20' wide x 50' deep)per 1965 tornado
photo was a furniture and gift store (Braun's), then in 1967 was remodeled to become a
beauty salon(Building Permit No. 1874). Based on�davits of others, the space was
operated as a beauty salon, first as the Magic Mirror Beauty Salon,then Jul Ann's Hair
Fashion, from 1967 until approximately 2005.
3386 Shoreline Drive- West 20 feet(20' wide x 50' deep)per 1965 tornado photo was a
dry cleaning establishment known as "Magic Cleaners". Based on City records and
affidavits of others,the space was operated as a dry cleaning business until at least 1997
and perhaps as late as 2004, with retail space on main floor and dry cleaning facilities in
the basement.
Attached with this affidavit are affidavits of persons familiar with the history of the uses within
this building. The spaces for which Grandparent Demand is requested are the westerly two
spaces, 3384 and 3386 Shoreline Drive. Unfortunately,the City does not have records of water
use for these spaces in this building relative to the period 1968-1978. We do have a water meter
reading record for the space at 3382 for the period 1973-1978 (attached)but it is believed this
pertains to the entire building,not just the Axel &Bob's meat market operation. That document
suggests quarterly water use of 350,000-450,000 gallons.
��"IT i'!D Y..� y,,�v - "J i2
i 5jy�� ��.
. . ! � t'k � f� � � �'�^
� - �� � t6' ..�,��,,, t� � �s �� �%y''"�S-�! ,,�i��w*,.� '' ,i�'s���,��T�?"�* a�f`��£ .,,��� ..N .
..��_�a i>�y�y�x „� � `5• .� ',�. x �i�-,+ s"•. t r l• #,�'S..�� .� �.., '�
����'"`szT .��h :L -� ' *y �.S.� w !GA':,,n��c �. .
�k �}�� � �e c � C �'Y � #:t ..a.�,. �$�p �'�r nl> r � �� ��
�;�ie� 3h} - � �' ..t.:.a..r..,.,:.r� Y" , - ,...�� . , _ „ �,� � '�� ."� ;� ,i
�i � .% ' �� �� s ��''r"Y�+'�j.�x+"-.i}�>� .
•+t`�. c 1 �, . `K+i r� :`.+#,�
�� � � � 1� !� d�ll , _�� .����.x
� ��� � ,�I ,-�y
r
�,'��� y�'i�S��Tti i,+;� . � fsro-�a�i��. . �+r < �'�'��
�:-4 i 'F`��� A. Y��.±,�y�� � �J��� eyy�9 r �-�-.
Y ! `.-.. . 3 h�
������,'y�`t'[� r�•,J * f,+ . ,:# -*'�
K�������r �� -��"'.�DupUe�b �6e�t� tnrnbb.d br Je..pt� G. Peq.rd Ce.� New H� P�rk. N. Y. ,;.�q
� ta S.. q .... � � � ;e.:,
'�,.����3,�� :i Hook u 3/21/73 �
��w� � �1 � ' K' ..'� ��
��T,�:,•,����, ,� p�$MIy� 3382 Shor�lln� Drlw SFC. ' �°
�`s. �"*� E.�'�}�` ,� ^ l � ��_'�a
y ;,�r >� . � lbal 6 Bob� l�Nats �OL , � �=7
Y '� i'4+M.Yi') � Y�' � ��'
'�,r�,� ;f �. k PA1tT 1►�TBBBD ACCT. lOSB � ,`�,
t�� "� s y r �
+
��_.������«Brru � � � LOCATION OF MBTBR � t,p'�'. ° � � ': �t 4�
+l tk'�c��4: �,�=� . - r ����� ��x",.i�>.a
'�.���'�'�t�� �mY wiTH SBAL lro. � t � "'��
i �m
�; `° ��: ,��: ADDITIONAL BLOCXS ADD[TiONAL LOTS S�BT - } ` ` ���'���
�aw�4; ,�, . -Rm,',�,�`,;r,,,.y,
` • w., ,� -�,1 r x:
. � E; ,�
,�, ��}r ri�x S�la; Sc�le Meter No. DLi C�eicr roal daoeb Nit.' '�a ' ;�%
,��, � � 21880Z 24 Mecen Meeees ' - � ' ,,��;
���'° ,,�� R�ad�r • 78711 /4� *""A��,, �'�
5a�
'"`�* ��-,'t�+ � , ,��'� �
a��,F; ." iNDBX , RBMARKS f .""'; " "'
. _ �"R.
ey k+r ^' � z.+.,.. � S
�� - •r+ /� r/`' i i ' � S 1�-�"��
(1�,f,- �►M'' •��7 :f r V l � . ,�p,lt kS.�K�.
... . +'a,. -_
JeY � � .. ' � � rW"f..
I � I �tw'.' � �y T(y� 1 1� ' 4 /� ��:
'� .{' `"s1�; i�: qY i .�! !r � � � . ' .� �
C
. . . � t
!�f �
*�N' �'� �V�. �T..��.tiV.±�'�`
�� . . � ���a�0. '�<:Y4
�^!
��' f� l O d � ��p?+�f
.._ , �.
, ." . V_�� n.�.y.�y���.�f
) i!'' � !� 4 �.� ��+�.5,.,
. I L p� �„�,.�'y�f
�St�� ' � V V � 1koe.���".'M �`T�������.'
C���. f ,�,i$y.� � ��
. � �y f � ► JyG 4�.
k .t .
t'�` t` � O O � S �, `�`y=}�+Tr;��x�"
.��` � I� �''���„
�ax'�. i'r���� k Y1 j � ��:# �'��_
x � ;wJ
�, .
3 ' ` ���
Y-� �.►� { �� s I Y .- c � .
'/a Y+. S �.A� ..
n
-�"`.:�. G � � �;
�
r�r . � �� � �'t'�r
,,;�'r^�' 's"' � ���
i��,. y� "O_. r ,� � - . - ''`r� .� {rat-
.. �' ,� t i�'
l '"4�. �. / . '7 l�ar � O xw Y"v..��$�:t
� '� � �k ��V L ,a� ?��.`.�+'+ �
�I �`tt, �. .. �' � y ,�',, �"
I { �� � , a , ... ' ��.s��,,';:
,� . .,, '�`�,t-t":
� � fi
�
� .�.
�.
_ '"��`
3..
�.
� f� �
�. r���'";�
_ � � � 7L
S
�
''` =�
y
, _-�s,
t.
. , ��
' �� / 7 � +� ` �;�?�'�it
'E"� f. ]'f� ' n ��'"`;:�=
ttr (C 1 "���
.�,�' � � �-�
3 �.
-�,� �j . - ; � ;:�'�
,
� � ����� �
,+.�V' �y 1 '"�. t�. .. � . �`83
i:.s�F��� 2 ��
"�.x§ .�.���.��� ,'�'
,
y� 4
� ..i� . � x`,'��',:.
�s,�
1 � � a' . ' ' y�
#
ti �•;�'�+�?;, �: . � �,
� , .
,��y{�� • z . "' , . - =
�'� s.4'xf�.' k '" ..�� � r,.,�y,�.►,• S � .4 ( . ' _ . '+ ' _� . . `�-{\s
� . �, tt: ��r�* 1fJbt�-" �� �% .+�'� 1°.�r�"+i�ir�+Y�• .;.
�� ���,y . . . �. . : ". , . �
r r ."5'
�'4s��t� ''+1� -� 't ��,1 ' « •sY
!�p�� .,y �f]�, ls..t �� s - , � ; •,-
;�, . �����" }S 4 _T . � .. :
r_ Y.
��'1��'�t�i�•�'g�' - ��.* ..Es,�,.��ta�', f���; ;, ��%-�� �}� yo,== � '
Y'•' ,LS�L�'i�a'�.,, ;:,,.»:
� �
%�4 tp �..� �
�'�Y�'1t„bA',���-�,�'.T4X.: {�
� k.
..�%'. ,a'P
d +
h
�
'�i
3,"
��'a '
�
'�,
�ly„
�`4�
N ni
��
-�.
�:'
�...: .. . . .. .. .:. . :
�n.
Auto damage was extensive at Navarre crossroads
�
;%
�
z .
.;
R
�
�.
s
;.
f
�'
r`, �
�
�:,
� '�
.��;y.
�,�
���_
CF.' Wf` .
}� ��
f
$ 1' �,
A. ,
� . A' i / . . . . . , . .
MapleDrive�ln � 4,: ".
- 41
Sewer Availability Charge (SAC)
2015 Affidavit of Property Use
This Affidavit of Use is to verify the demand on this property for SAC purposes for the
Non-Conforming Credit when there is no evidence of SAC paid for the existing demand
and no public documentation can be found for the two types of Non-Conforming Credit:
1) Grandparent Demand (demand used prior to 1973 when the SAC program began
with evidence between 1968 — 1978); and 2) Long Continuous Demand (demand for 10
years or more up through 3 years prior to current SAC Determination or permit
issuance)
Property Address: 3382 Shoreline Boulevard, Orono, MN. (Building)
Customer Community:
Parcel Identification Number: 17-117-23-44-0100
Dates of Non-Conforming Credit: through
Type of Non-Conforming Credit: _Grandparent Demand; , Long Continuous Demand
Affidavit of James D. Anderst
The undersigned certifies:
I am the owner of the Building and I currently operate a bar and restaurant (the Narrows
Saloon) in the easterly three fifths of the main floor of the Building. In 1999, I acquired
the restaurant business and leased a portion of the existing restaurant premises when it
occupied the easterly two fifths of the Building. In 2000, I remodeled additional space
within the Building and expanded the restaurant to encompass the easterly three fifths
of the Building. The expansion space had previously been occupied by the Axel and
Bob's Meat Market during the late 1960's.
I bought the building from Donald and Dana McCarville in 2004 and at the time of my
purchase, they were operating the Magic Cleaners (a dry cleaning business) in the
westerly one fifth of the building (3386 Shoreline). The McCarvilles had operated the
Magic Mirror business at that location continuously since 1990. Don McCarville advised
' me that the Magic Mirror business had been located at that location since about 1950
and was previously operated by Dick McCurdy, who operated the dry cleaning
equipment full time. According to Don McCarville, the dry cleaning equipment utilized a
'/z" water supply line that was running at full capacity whenever the dry cleaning
equipment was in operation.
From 1999 through 2005, Julie Kreslins operated the Jul Ann hair salon in a rental
space in the Building located immediately east of the Magic Cleaners. The salon
normally functioned with three or more stations for cutting and styling hair and occupied
approximately one fifth of the Building's main floor. Between 2000 and 2005, the Jul
Ann Hair Salon occupied the leased space between my restaurant and the Magic
Cleaners
were familiar with the use of the Building during that period, including Julie Kreslins�
L$roy Koehnen, and Lana Putt. Their Affidavits are submitted herewith. Based upon
tf�eir testimonv. I am of the belief that the tenants that occupied the space now bein�
remodeled for restaurant use between 1968 and 1978 were the Magic Cleaners (an on-
site dry cleaning and laundry business), and the Magic Mirror {a hair salon that normally
operated five or six hair stylinq stations). Upon information and belief, those historical
uses establish "Grandoarent DemandA that began prior to 1968 and continued until at
least 1978. Said demand was equal to, or gr�eater than, the demand that wili be
s�ssnciated with the nc�w r�staurAnt.
I certify that I have read and understand this Affidavit and that the statements are true
acoording to my knowledge and belief. I further understand that the giving of false
information in this affidavit cxmstitutes fraud and is also c�usA for immPciiatc�
redetermination of any charges. I have no confli�t of i rest in this matter.
Dated:
j �
.
James D.Anderst
S�ibscribPd and svim tn .fc��P e
thi d y ne,
��aazaaaa�e�r
NO blic pETER W.JOHNSON
NOTARY PUBUC-MINI�SdiA
- MY Can^ietlo"E�Ye�J�n.31,�
�
,.
Sewet Avsitat�iHty C�at�e{SA�}
2015 Af�i�av�t a�Prope� Use
This Af�ti�vi# of Us� is io verifiy the dem�nd on this proper�y for ��AC pu;posss fot the
Nor+-CQt�#�ing �redit wt3en tfi�e�'e is na evidenoe �f SA� �aid for the �x�ting demarrd
BTi� �O �?U�314C dCt�i�i8�'li�i(�Tl C�('i ��0U11d��"1� �VJO�j/�7BS {� �Qf��.fl�OftTii� ��1�;
� �1@�YiS� �t��i�l'� US� f 3T�Of �O '���:� ��i � $�Ci �`�f8T11 ��1'1
1) Grandpar�r► � �
wit� evidetme be�n 1� -- "i 97�); ar� �� �ong Contir►�us pemaand {demand for '!0
years o�r more up #hrvu� 3 ye�rs prior to cument SAC Determic��i�ora Qr parm�t
�ssuar�c�e)
Prop�tty Adclress: 3382�Sha�eline B�ulevsrd, �rono, Mt�. t8uildl�g}
Cust�mer Community: �
R_ar+c�i Itientfica#ion Nurr�er; '�7-i 17-23-44-�04t10
l��s of Non-Cor�c�imir►g G�redit: �� .
Type t�f' i�onKCo�fonmin�Credit: �rar�i�ere��#[;�mar+d; L�r�C�ondn�s I�e�rr+and
A�idavit a�Lar�a�'utt
The unders�gned c�erti�es:
I am a t�air sty�is� and I wark$d as a �rtist�at the N�a�i�Nlir►�or salor��rom spprox+�y
�t�,�'7 '1�85 ttuoWgh 'i 9y8. Thrcxl,ghout ihat p$riod the I��c Mirror Sai�n was lac��� it�
leaseci sparce m the Bu�ldir�g at 3382 Shp�reline Dr+v►e ir��rvrx�, ��se of mY�ndl
inrrotver�en#wi#h the sat�n tausiness, i �me tanliiliar w�t#�the salon bt���ess ar�d�e
oiher bt�s��es that w�te tocat� in ihe 8uitdir�g. �n� �prox�r�tei�r #9�throu�h
2D�05, the salon busir��ss was oper�teal c�inuously at its h�as�ed bcatism in t#�a
Building, Tl�+�s��m normafty��t�t�#oned with�ive ot mot$ �t�ticiras#tx'c�t�inQ'a�d�stytin9
hai�. The s�on +accupied c��re #�atf ofi tt� sp��ece�naw beEr�g r,�modeied for u�e as a
roximatel one �th of the �uildin�'� main t�oor). Th� heir .sakn�
resiaurant {aRp Y
c�ntint�o�sly o�ied that spac�wit�n the buitdir�� �niit it�rwved to a d�fferer�i lo:c2�ion
in�UQ5,
��#�� �
Frflm e�d afte� #�, 1 wes z�ware af t�e businesses thet apQra►ted with'sn th� B�ildir�g.
Irnt��distely west c�the saion's lo�etion in tf�e Bu[I��n�, ther�wss�a �pac� o�c�p��d by
the �Ma+goc Cleaners�. a d�► c�ear�ng business kn+c�+'� to rn� to be o�►►ned end o�erated
b�y pit�t McCurdy {33gfi Sht�reiirte�. 'T�e M�g�c Cleaner� had a re��i1 (oca�ion on t#�e
m�in floQr and did a1M of i#'s�clean�n� of laundry in the basement leire! o�f � b�iidir�g.
8ased on my knowled�ie and �ec�ltecc�ion, the Ma�iG Gleaners �t�p�e�l epp�xir�tel�r
one hat� vf the sp�ace r�ow being r+emodeied �s a res#aurant �one fi#�h af#h�e basement
and r�r�e ftft� af #he r�nair� floor of ti�e Building. Ri�it M�Ct�rdy operated t�e Magi�
Gleaners untii he sold t�se b�siness to [3onald �nd �ana McCarvili�e. It is my betfe# ttxat �
ihe Magic Cleaners operat��! continuously �t 336� $hor�line �3rive �t�m 19�i8 thro�gt�
�g73_
From anti a�fer i�7'i, ihe s��ce within the 8uildiRg �nd immedi�#e!y east of the salon's
location, ther� was a space �cupied by "Hxe1 �nd Ba#�'� fV#eai Maricet`, a r�tail butct3er
shop b�rsiness. t3382 Sht�retine). It �s my be�ief tha�t the Axe1 and Bob"� �Ileat Market
ope�ated contir�c�ousty at 33�2 ��nrekne Drive fram �968 #hrough '!573.
0
, :�
Located eas� vfi the butc�`sht� in 1971, there v�ra� e bar'�nd resiatuani th�i Ove�'the
year� was o�erated as the l�nicdm, an� leEer�s: .13m�ties Lounge. �v+�r�tually th�t b�r
and restaurant beca�e the tdarrows �ai�n, a� it tot�k o�rer ihe �pave that h�d
previously ��� the mest mari{et. That bar resta�rant has been in c�inu�us
opera�cx� sinc� at le�s# 19��.
i c�rtif�r tt�at I have read end underst�nd this AfiFidavit and t�t the sfatemertts are tru�
accorsiin� to may knowl�ge �ntt beti�. I fu�ther undt�rst�nd that the giving 9f �Ise
irif'orma#ion in �his a#fitlavii oonstit�'tss fraud and is �tso cause tor immedi�te
r�e�iete�minativn of any d�ar�es. 1 heve n�conflid vi' er�stin ` �atter-
.
I�steti: �,,,�.�..� _ _
Lar►a�Put#
Su anc��v►►om to e me
thi tie , 1
N� ie
��
Sewer Ava�abil�y Ct�a�e(SA�)
2015 A�dav�t<af�,roperty tise
�IS �4,�Id8Y11 8f �5�.'. IS i0 V6Ti�}► � C�et�tld �il t�'i1S jaJ'O�BF�I ��JI' .5"�'1�i {JUf�OS65 �DI �
�ton-Confo�min� Cr�ec3it wtterr t�er+� �s na evid�� v#SAC peid tr�r the exisiit�g demand
and no pLblic docurnentation r�en be fioL+rui f�r the twv type� of h4an-�anfaming �redit_
'i) Gtariripsr�nt Demand (derr+and used ;pri�r tv 1973 r�n �e SA�, pTogr�m began
wit#� evi�en[� �tween 'i968— 1978j; and�) Lt�g Ct�ntinuous I�ems�ttd (dem�r�d fot'1t�
y�aa� o� mc�re up t�xo�gh 3 year� prit�r to .c�,+crent ��►C C?ete�r»ina�on flr permit
iss�,ance}
Prt�perty Address: 3382 Shvret':ne Baulevart�, �3rono. C�N. �Building)
Custcx�er Comrnun'�r:
Parc�l �de�tfi�tion Number. i 7-1 i 7=��-�1 t'�
Da��ofi�1an-Cor�arm�ng Crscin: th��gh
Typ�c�f Nvn-Cor�#orming Credit: Gran�p�nt t3emarad; tAr�g Contirnwus I)er�artd
Affidavlt of Julie Kreslins
T�e undet'si�ned t�arti�ies:
I a� a s:vsrr�t�fo�ist a�^xi I be�a� rn�rking es a hai� s#yl'rst at the Ma� Mi�mr�abn in
1�71. � i�n to wc�rk at th�N�gic AAittor Se�m�t was lo�cated Vvitfiin the �uiidir�
(3384 S�o�e�ir�}, anA ihr'augh �ny worit t#�er�e, i became f�t�ll'ter w�th�e s�n l�simess
ar��d �,s histcc�y. In 197� I ecquire�i t�e sek�r� �s�ne���or� �eat�ae A�ries. At the thme
ofi imy pcltchase. � was aware #�at the �aion had tieeTi opereiit�i� et tt� iot�et�on �in�e
�pr��am�tely 1965_ C3ne of the stylists that con��nc�s to work�r my business (Lar�a
p�tt� har� wotked at the Magic:tV�irtor salcan sit�e '196� at � I�as+ed io�ti�r� in t�+e
Building. From i4ppr�o�rimaisly 19�5 thr�u�h �5; tt��e ssak�n �usiness w�s oper�tsd
c�#inuo�tsly � its�ea:sed foc�ation in�he �u�ldi�, Bec:�use of my persor�ai ir+volvem�nt
with the salc� k�sinass, ( k�atn� fatnili� with � sei+a� #wsiness and t�e other
businesses tt�sf wer+e loc�ted in the Building. `i'he salon rt�rrally fc�3iori�ed wit��five or
m�ore sislions f�r�n� ar� styling h�eir. 1�e salo� oa�pieci;one haft of i!��pac�e�t
is rja�w beir�g ren�odef for use as a res#aurant (apPm�arri�t�ly one ft#th c�f the Bu�ldir�g`s
mait� �loor), `Th�ha�r �lor� c�ntin�ausiy �x:upied thal spava-within the build�r�ftom at
l�as� 19fi� unt�l I mt�veci the business to �different I�ocatum in�45.
Frarn ar�d after 1977. t was awer� of the v�her businesses _that aperated wit�in the
Bu�lding �mmedea�ety west �f t!� s�lvr�`s k�cation in ihe Buitding, ther�e was a sp�c�e
oc�p�+�d by t� "tJlagic Cleaners!'. � dry deaninp bus�ness knc�rn to me to be c�wned
and �rperated by �ick Nlc�Curdy t3386 S#�oreiine). The N�agic Cle�n�ers had a r�tail
iocation an the main �oor and did a11 �# iYs cleaning oi�aundry in the basement level of
th� bullding, Sased on my Imvwle�lge 8�d �1le�titx�, th� Magic Cleaner� o�cupied
approximately !he other half of t�e spat:e now bein� remodele�fcx �as� ss a restaurant.
Di��c Mc��rdy aper�ted the Magic Clear�ers un#i! he sold t�e b�siness to aoriald and
Dana McCarville in abaui 199�_ It is my belief that the Ma�ic C��ane�rs oper,�ied
c�or,l�n�sously at 338� Shorel,ne Dnve from 19E8 thr�gh '�973_
From and aft�r '�J�'�, the space within tfi�e 6uiidir�g and imm�diatety wes# a�th� saion's
�oca�ion, there was a spac� oc���ed by ''AueO �nd Bob"s Meat hAarket=. a reta�i bui�er
shv� busine�s. �33$2 Sharslit�e�. !t is my be�ie#.ihat the Axel �nd �ob's Meat Mar�cet
opet�ted c�rt�nuou�ly�t 3�2 $hore�ine Drive from 196�#i�ro+�g� 1 J73_
lo�atec� +east of the �utcher shop in 19?1,. t�ere v�ras a b�r an� r�es�aurant that over th�
ye�rs r�►as operated �s ttae Unicom, and 1�ier a� Jimmies Lbun�Q, Evsnt�ally th�at bar
and resiaur�mi be�ame ti�� �la�r'aws Saloon an�i iook�ver the speoe thst had previously
hausetl the mea��arket� Tt�t bar resiaurant has b�n in cx�ntinuoc�s dperat�or��ince at
ieast ���t� , and was in bvsiness tt�rougit�oui th� �'iod frorri 9"9S8
thto�gfi i 9?3,
t cet�if�r �#�a� ! hav$ read a�►d understand this Aifdav�! and #h�t t!� sit��ements are frue
ec�or�#ing to my knowletlge and beiief, 1 furt�3er �nders#end that � �n►inp af false
in#arr�stio� Im t��s �davit constitutes #rauci and is aiso �use for immediate
r�determinat�or� of any char�es. 1 have na ict caf int��est in this marier.
Dated: (�?'"ll`
�� �
Juti+a lins
5ub� ' �r�d sxn+om o for me
�"Il e;
(1jp� iC
�rlw7iil/�I���. .
�.�.a�
Iid�li11k1ri��C•�
#I�rO����»�
.
. .
S��er Aw►�Y C#�ar9e'�5AC)
2015 Affldavit o�`Propelrty Use
T#►�Af�d�+rit of Use is #� vet�y the de�at�d on tt�is proper#y!�r Si4C purpt�sres ior�e
Non-�r+tc�rr�irr�Cr�vrherr lf�r►e � r�ev�der�oe��iC�id k��e��
�nd rro o�docum�vn �an be faund�or�h+e t+�tvDes:�'f M�n�r�mir�t �red�
1� Cra�t+ent t3em�md ��d t�d p�or to 1973 v�ett t�e � �og�n t�e8an
�M����� ��� `�J�V�' W Af �� �O� ��YVYP DY1,�W M,�����Q
y@if5 Ot f1101'@ l�3 thft�U�1h 3 '1/@��$ p?�0� t0 GUf�'t� �:+ �l�ii[iB�iOt'� Qr p�
�SU81'tGe)
�f�00��'ZY J�f�SB: �2�hOT�8�16�OUIBVBR�. Qt101'10. ��. (St���14�
��01i'iP.f�;O�NN1�1j/:
• W\YR���an/f� I�W,�7W. �l�"����i�`�V�� *
�$�@$!�NOf1 _��:t�l��: � .
T�+fl��011-��t�T1tD�1r11fi,� ��I� !�f�l�p�; LW1g CO�i�tliOtl��}�id
/�l�Gf�.$�CIY iCfl�B!'11i@11 '
7�@ untl�gt� G@tti�es:
i a� � t�►e ov�r�et �nd a�era�'t�f 1h� �s#$�a �vi� �a#bn I�d a� �60
�ho�ine C�riv�, i�r ,cwnr�nt be�ess i� d�y �t to the � at �
Stio�'� Iki��(#h� "&��. p�vkiusly i t�wr�ed ar� +o� a �ervive sta�vn ��
tl�e con� of K►B�eY Av�ue � S�Orei`n�a �1yd. "�#�at loc.�fivn vaas $txoss Sfi�
�livti.�n �li#r. _
�"� 8�ding, t bec�n��r w� tt� bus�ss�s.acr�upyiap fhe
�9 ��8 � I'�d.fnorrr� 1g88 �o�h #��`8 �ause � �9�t �i�rivd, 1 tn�s
w�ft� t!�►r �t .the servi�e � � S�c� � fivm .the �,, Ftam
�ma�Y f965� 2�� tt�r sa�� �s � oo�t�y�rt�s
i� i�oc�ftrc�n a� tt�e �t#�ng �# �t M�ic �ir�ra', � a� .h�f � 1�a� fia�or�.
1'h� sekNt oc�d�p�d a�rr�e�ly on� h�of the s�c� rr�w tiet� �ethodei�cl .as �
restaturaM{one�Ah�1`itie�'s m�n flco�� _
From '1.96�U�ot�t► 1fl78. 1 t+u�s a�o awane tyf the o�r bus�#ha1��ed v�n
ttie Bc�d�. �� v� �1' tne sabrY� �tior� in t� �► t� �s a
�� � bY� "�c C�ea�te�s". � c�y d�8qrdr�g #�ir�s � #� m�e� �e
owned a� oper�f by t�k McCt�rd�r f3� Shore�nel. Ti�e M�ic C�n�ers had a
r�� lo�tion on the rr� Aoor an�3 did a� af�t's � t�feunc�t in !!�� b�
level of U�e bu��g. �as�d on my ia�+�dge a� rec�i�ec�n. �he !►� C��s
occxipied appr�ox�natelv �alf of the spat�e now bei�p r�ernodeled as a r+estaurent. t�dc
McCsn� oper�tesi tfie Magic �ie�e� t�trt� he �d the b�s �o► [3or� �d.i��na
McCar�pe. It � my be�ef #hat tt�e lU�agic Cleaners apers�d cx�r+bi�tro�sly att 3�86
�honeline �r�ive irom 19fi8 throeivh 487B.
Afso dt�ng th� y�ears 19fi8 Uu�ugh 7 97�, in the spaoe w�t�hin �e Bu�ding and
imrnediatety e�t5! of#he selon's �oaa#i�n, the�was a spac�e oc�pied by f+�'a s�rti�icartt
Deriad bv "A� arxi Bob's Meai M�rket`. a r+etaii butc�er sh� busirress. t3382
S#�o�e#ine). � � nty belief t�at #he A�ce� and B�b's AAea#Msrket vv�s c�rig�r cfperated
b�y 8ob Rudh snd Don Ufrich. it �n+as later#aken over bv SYan�ru� Ron Drahas.
� ,
l�ot�ed east of the butcher st�p, the�e w�s a � �d � !t� a�#he yesrs
w�s +o��d 8s the Ur�ioom, a�d la�` as� Lou�e. Etr�11�►� b��nd
rest�urar�t be�arn�#he Natrr� �aloon, and it�o1c ov+�the spaoe ih�#t'+ad pr+evk+uslv
housed�he mest rn�fcet. T�at t��a�s�at�ant ha��in oo�t�6 0���at
iR��f 1 f1R+�
1 Celr��►t�at I h�Ve [+e�d a�ct tir�dB�s,t�r�d �is A�av��:�nd tl�at the�iemenl� � �B
a� to rny lanov�g$ and � I ii�t�' unde�nd �hat the.+� o� �se
ir+finrnu�ti�r► �n ttii� �f�v1t t�ne�t�hrl�±a f�i�t! Ar� �e a1�tn r���aaa► #�r i�r�+e1i�
�f�AtlOtf t�8�t�/i�18f�S. 1�Y+� �f '�U'�S�T.
aa�: �--.�--�-p � 5_
'��► �.-� ��1-'�`G���
�`�
��'h�i�r�rf�wnm t�t�fnr� nw
� � � ��
�- ��.. _
!'�t�BtY - � ��RIN.�MN�OM
N�1EtPtI�C-�t�A
�Ira��Mi��3i��i.�
Karon Cappaert
Technical Specialist MCES Finance
� SACproQram(�metc.state.mn.us
FAX 651.602.1030
[�hETRUPULlT�N 390 North Robert Street � St. Paul, MN � 55101 � metrocouncil.orq
C Q � N G i � Please visit our SAC website by clicking: SAC Proqram for copies of
applications and forms. Electronic submittals are preferred
From: SACProgram
Sent: Tuesday, December 23, 2014 10:04 AM
To: 'rdodge@ci.orono.mn.us'
Subject: Affidavit D for 3384 Shoreline Dr.
Rachel,
We received your Affidavit D form but it does not have the necessary 2 signatures. In addition there is no detail for the
square footage of the space in question.
Also please verify the address as the only recent determination I can find that this might apply to was for Graze at 3382.
Please resubmit with the requested information.
SAC Program
MCES Finance
� SACproqramCa�metc.state.mn.us
FAX 651.602.1030
M�TRC�C'ULlTAN 390 North Robert Street � St. Paul, MN � 55101 � metrocouncil.org
c n � �u c i �
Please visit our SAC website by clicking: SAC Proqram for copies of applications and forms.
Electronic submittals are preferred.
z
Lyle Oman
From: SACProgram [SACProgram@metc.state.mn.us]
Sent: Thursday, January 15, 2015 8:29 AM
To: Lyle Oman
Subject: FW: Affidavit D for 3384 Shoreline Dr.
Please see below.
Karon Cappaert
Technical Specialist MCES Finance
� SACproqram(c�metc.state.mn.us
FAX 651.602.1030
NiETRUPUL(TAN 390 North Robert Street � St. Paul, MN � 55101 � metrocouncil.orq
,� � ,L� ,� � � � Please visit our SAC website by clicking: SAC Proqram for copies of
applications and forms. Electronic submittals are preferred
From: Rachel Dodge [mailto:RDodge@ci.orono.mn.us]
Sent: Wednesday, January 14, 2015 2:20 PM
To: SACProgram
Subject: RE: Affidavit D for 3384 Shoreline Dr.
This was requested by Lyle Oman, please contact him. loman@ci.orono.mn.us
Thanks,
Rachel
From: SACProgram [mailto:SACProgramCa�metc.state.mn.us]
Sent: Wednesday, January 14, 2015 12:07 PM
To: Rachel Dodge
Subject: FW: Affidavit D for 3384 Shoreline Dr.
Rachel,
The below email was from Deborah Bauknight who no longer works at MCES. I just found the A�davit D that
was sent 12/23/14 by fax and I want to add to what Deborah statement below. The Affidavit is asking for
Grandparent credit but only supply information form 1995. Graze was given grandparent credit on the letter
but if there is information that this location was different than retail in 1972 and there is proof showing this and
it is dated from between 1968 and 1978 then we can review the determination. The information supplied on
the Affidavit will not change the determination.
i
TRANSMISSION VERIFICATION REPORT
TIME : 12123/2014 �9:28
NAME : CITY OF ORONO
FAX : 9522494616
TEL : 9522494600
SER.# : BROL2J412094
DATE,TIME 12123 �9:26
FAX NO.INAME 6516021030
DURAT I ON 0�:01:42
PAGE(S} 08
RESULT OK
MODE STANDARD
ECM
Metropolitsn Gounal � Environmental Senrices MCES,Af'fida�it-D
390 Robe�t SYreet North � tast uvdated:12M�12413
St. Paul, Mlnnesota 55101-180�
Bb1.602.1429 (651,802.1030 f�Ix
Sev�r Availabiliry Charge(SAC}
2814 AFFI ,AVIT OF PRGPERTY USE
This Affidavit of Property Use is to�erify the dems�nd n this property for SAC purposes for IVon-Conforrning Credit when there is
no evidenCe of SAG pald fo�the existing demand,�nd no documen'ta�ion can be found foP the two types o�F Non-Conforming
Credit: 1) Grandparent Demand(demand used prior�01973 when the SAC program began with evidence be#w�en 19f8,1978};
and 2)Long Cor�Pnuous bemand(demand for 10 yea�rs or mare up through 3 years pnor to current SAC determination or permit
issuance ,
ProperLy Address: '—� �S �2G��N� Q/�
Customer Community: ��,��
Parcel IdentPfrcation Number 1�,���_��_ yN _ b i aa
Dates of Nan�Canforming Credit: �_��_ ��9� through 7- l-�r j
Type of Non-Conforming Credit: Gr�ndparent Demand � Long Continuous Demand
I certify tha# Customer Community staff has r�s�arched th� above property and have f�und none of the
i#ems listed beiow for ae#nrity at this address:
- Dated Building Plan(s) assaciated wit a buiiding permit
- Building Inspection record(s) stafiing #�e a�tuai use af the proper#y
- Business Lic�nse(s}
- Building or County Assessment Reco�d(s)
Aithough no wri##en proof exists, I believe the aemand of this property includes (must be specifc in what
was there and, if mcre than one demand inclu�de the amount of square feet for�ach specific use):
r7' S �r1 c.� �� U 5�c� �.S � �2 Go�v ,�,� ,r-f r�oN.S
n'�` � `� '.'u 2� � Lv � 1 r fM9-5
/G. "i"'�� 1�'Y-�
Lyle Oman
From: SACProgram [SACProgram@metc.state.mn.us]
Sent: Thursday, January 15, 2015 8:29 AM
To: Lyle Oman
Subject: FW: Affidavit D for 3384 Shoreline Dr.
Please see below.
Karon Cappaert
Technical Specialist MCES Finance
SACproqram(a�metc.state.mn.us
FAX 651.602.1030
MLTRtJPULITAN 390 North Robert Street � St. Paul, MN � 55101 � metrocouncil.orq
� � � ,� � � � Please visit our SAC website by clicking: SAC Proqram for copies of
applications and forms. Electronic submittals are preferred
From: Rachel Dodge [mailto:RDodge@ci.orono.mn.us]
Sent: Wednesday, January 14, 2015 2:20 PM
To: SACProgram
Subject: RE: Affidavit D for 3384 Shoreline Dr.
This was requested by Lyle Oman, please contact him. Loman@ci.orono.mn.us
Thanks,
Rachel
From: SACProgram [mailto:SACProgram@metc.state.mn.us]
Sent: Wednesday, January 14, 2015 12:07 PM
To: Rachel Dodge
Subject: FW: Affidavit D for 3384 Shoreline Dr.
Rachel,
The below email was from Deborah Bauknight who no longer works at MCES. I just found the Affidavit D that
was sent 12/23/14 by fax and I want to add to what Deborah statement below. The Affidavit is asking for
Grandparent credit but only supply information form 1995. Graze was given grandparent credit on the letter
but if there is information that this location was different than retail in 1972 and there is proof showing this and
it is dated from between 1968 and 1978 then we can review the determination. The information supplied on
the Affidavit will not change the determination.
i
Karon Cappaert
Technical Specialist MCES Finance
� SACproqram(a�metc.state.mn.us
FAX 651.602.1030
METRUPC?LITAN 390 North Robert Street � St. Paul, MN � 55101 � metrocouncil.orq
� Q � N � � L Please visit our SAC website by clicking: SAC Proqram for copies of
applications and forms. Electronic submittals are preferred
From: SACProgram
Sent: Tuesday, December 23, 2014 10:04 AM
To: 'rdodge@ci.orono.mn.us'
Subject: Affidavit D for 3384 Shoreline Dr.
Rachel,
We received your Affidavit D form but it does not have the necessary 2 signatures. In addition there is no detail for the
square footage of the space in question.
Also please verify the address as the only recent determination I can find that this might apply to was for Graze at 3382.
Please resubmit with the requested information.
SAC Program
MCES Finance
� SACproqram(c�metc.state.mn.us
FAX 651.602.1030
METRt�P�3LiTAN 390 North Robert Street � St. Paul, MN � 55101 � metrocouncil.org
:: L7 � !N G I �_
Please visit our SAC website by clicking: SAC Proqram for copies of applications and forms.
Electronic submittals are preferred.
2