Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutappraisal , RAY_ �0 �ELL� E�LTY � - Brokerage and Appraisals L, i�_' . (612) 890-2130 F E.B j. � �.�94 July 27 , 1988 Mr. Thomas J. Hunziker Dunkley, Bennett & Christensen, P.A. Suite 1400 701 Fourth Avenue Souttl Niinneapolis, Minnesota 55415 Re : Germ-Tom Partnership Property 3412-3420 Shoreline Drive Orono, Minnesota Dear Mr. Hunziker: Pursuant to your request, I have made an appraisal of the above property for the purpcse of estimating the Fair Market Value as of the date of the take. The property is described in the Ideiltification Section of this report. Fair Market Value is defined as the price the property will bring in a competitive market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, which would result from negotiations between a buyer and seller, each acting prudently, with knowledge and without undue stimulus . The rights of the property appraised are those of fee simple estate only. 12904 Nicollet Avenue • Burnsville , MN 55337 � Mr. Thomas J. Hunziker July 26, 1988 Page 2 , Based upon the information available to me, it is my opinion that the total damages to the subject property are: TWENTY SEVEN THOUSAND TWO HUNDRED SEVENTY ONE DOLLARS ($27, 271.00) Respectfully submitted, , �-� , , �J � ,��.,,,;�, `�f�ay Conne�ly i IDENTIFICATION: The subject property is located at 3412-3420 Shoreline Drive, in the City of Orono, County of Hennepin, State of Minnesota. The legal description is as follows : A permanent easement for highway purposes over all that part of Lot 23, except the West 15 feet thereof and Lots 24, 25 and 26, Block 6, Navarre Heights, according to the duly recorded plat thereof which lies southerly of the following described line: Beginning at a point on the East line of said Lot 26 distant 9 . 30 feet northerly of the Southeast corner thereof; thence run westerly parallel with the South line of said Block 6 for a distance of 134 . 96 feet; thence run southwesterly to a point on the South line of said Lot 23 distant 33. 89 feet west of the Southeast corner thereof and there terminating. INSPECTION: I inspected the subject property in the spring of 1988 . PURPOSE OF THE APPRAISAL: 3 I The purpose of this appraisal is to determine the Fair Market Value of the subject property, as of the date of the take. Fair Market Value is defined as the price which the property will bring in a competitive market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, which would result from negotiations between a buyer and a seller, each acting pruaently, with knowledge and without undue stimulus. Regardless of the exact wording of the definition, Fair Market Value contemplates the consummation of a sale and the passing of full title from seller to buyer by deed, under conditions whereby: 1. Buyer and seller are free of undue stimulus and are motivated by no more than the reactions of typical owners ; 2. Both parties are well informed or well advised and act prudently for what he considers his own best interest; 3. A reasonable time is allowed to test the market; and 4. Payment is made in cash or in accordance with financing terms available in the community for 4 the property type in its locale. AREA AND NEIGHBORHOOD ANALYSIS: The subject property is located in the City of Orono, which is located approximately fifteen miles west of the Minneapolis/Saint Paul downtown area. The 1987 estimated population of the area is 2,153, 533 and the population is increasing. The Twin Cities are located on the Mississippi River, and the metropolitan area encompasses the Minnesota River. Both Minneapolis and Saint Paul have major urban renewal projects in progress . The community is served by an excellent trans- portation system which includes 9 railroads, 12 buslines, and major interstate freeway systems. This area is also served by river barge traffic on the Minnesota River. The Army Corp of Engineers maintains a 9 foot channel for this purpose. This excellent system has aided in establishing the area as the largest distribution and wholesale center in the Upper Midwest. The area is also served by an excellent airport which is one of the largest in the nation. There are 6 national airlines, 10 regional and commuter 5 I air carriers, 10 air cargo airlines and 20 charter airlines serving this area. The airport is easily accessible due to the extensive freeway system. There are many fine colleges and universities in the area, including the University of Minnesota which has an enrollment of over 50 , 000 students. This area is also served by many vocational institutes and community colleges. � The communications system serving the area consists of 2 daily newspapers, with many weekly papers serving the various suburbs and surrounding areas. There are approximately 35 radio stations serving the area with 5 television stations and an extensive cable network. The metropolitan area iiicludes 22 lakes, with many parks which offer a multitude of recreational facilities for the entire family. This area is represented in professional sports by the Minnesota Vikings, Minnesota Twins, North Stars, Monarchs and next year, the Timberwolves. In addition, the area is the cultural center of the Upper Midwest with the Saint Paul Chamber 6 Orchestra, the Minnesota Orchestra, the Walker Art Institute, Minneapolis Institute of Arts , the Tyrone Guthrie Theater (an excellent repertory theater - one of only four resident repertory theaters in the nation) , the new Ordway Music Theater, and many other theaters and museums. Also benefiting this area is Canterbury Downs, the $67 million dollar horseracing tack which opened in June, 1985, and Valley Fair, a 7-Flags type amusement park located in Shakopee. Other attractions include the Minnesota Renaissance Festival which is held in August and September each year and the Chanhassen Dinner Theatre. Also, in Excelsior, is the Old Log Theatre which has been in operation for over twenty years. Orono is located on the north side of Lake Minnetonka and is in the third tier suburbs . The 1987 estimated population for Orono is 7, 212 compared the the 1980 population of 6, 845. The number of households has continually increased. The 1987 estimated number of households is 2,568 compared with 2,291 in 1980 . Hennepin County is growing, with an estimated 1987 7 population of 986,505 compared to the 1980 census of 941, 411. Along with the population growth has come the expansion of business and industry to provide the goods, services, and employment necessary to serve the population. ZONINGs Zoning for the subject property is B-1 Retail Sales. HIGHEST AND BEST USE Highest and Best Use is defined as that use which will tend to produce the highest net return, or that use which will tend to produce the highest present value. It is my opinion that the highest and best use of the subject property is its present use. PROPERTY DESCRIPTION: The subject property consists of 26,900 square feet and is level back from the street and then drops suddenly to the back of the property. DESCRIPTION OF IMPROVEMENTS: Improvements to the subject property consist of 8 a 6,164 square foot, one story building with a walkout to the back of the property. The building is basically a retail strip center with an easement on the west property line. Some of the buildings tenants consist of a pizza shop, movie rental, an interior design studio and yarn and gift shop. APPROACHES TO VALUE: There are three recognized approaches to value; the Sales Comparison, Income, and Cost Approaches. The Cost Approach utilizes estimating the replacement cost now of the improvements deducting for diminished utility of these improvements due to wear and tear and obsolescence, and adding the value of the land. The Income Approach utilizes capitalization of the income stream to obtain an indicated Market Value. The Sales Comparison Approach compares the subject property with similar properties which have recently sold, making adjustments for dissimilarities between the subject and comparable property to obtain an indicated value of the subject property. When reliable sales data is available, this approach is considered very reliable in that it reflects the actions of buyer and seller in the current market place. 9 For purposes of this appraisal, I have used the Sales Comparison (Market) Approach. � COMMENTS AND CONCLUSIONS: I arrived at my opinion of valuation after viewing the subject property and taking into consideration the fact that the building was purchased by the present owners on August 10, 1987. In my opinion, there are really no comparable sales in the area. It is my opinion that the best way to arrive at value is to consider the sale of the subject property. I used the county' s ratio of land and building to arrive at my ratio of the value of land and building . By using the sale price of $360, 000 and 34.3� value of land to building, a land value of $123,480, or $4.19 per square foot is determined. Because only part of the land is being taken, I consider the property next to the street as having a higher value, which is indicated in the � Correlation of Value. To arrive at my opinion of severance damage, I took into consideration the fact that the owners are losing an access point to the property which 10 will change the parking configuration, resulting in the loss of three parking spaces next to the pizza shop. The street will be moved closer to the building which will result in the merchants losing display area and space for their advertising signs. 11 CORRELATION OF VALUE: Before Value $ 360, 000 Value of the Take 1, 496 sq ft x $6.25 per sq ft = $ 9,350. 00 Temporary Easement 655 sq ft x $6.25 per sq ft = $4,093 $4, 093 x 10� = 409. 00 $360, 000 Before Value - 9,759 Take & Easement 350, 241 After Value Severance Damage $350,241 x 5$ = 17,512. 00 Total Damages $ 27,271.00 12 -- � . .. 1 , �- _ -, __ � , �"` . __ _ _ _ _ ,_ _� _ , _ ._ �. � , __,__�,_ - - � -- -=``=-�� ��. - - - -----_----_----__ -__� -- , �n�j_ �.�"�I ����,,,,.,� i '��=— _-� :''r.��%r_ �r,e� ,• —. _ �..,,_�'� ,�..�� _ _ ;.. ...— ,_ 1 � _•.-�,� .., �. �� ;.; , . - .-_,,,�..�r-. .- . -.�. . �� T�r�� >c..�.��,�`� Vf' _._.t ..,:� , , � -- . -'_,'_ ,,,� . �� ,;, --" - -..., -'ii"^�'�,,,,,,�,�'Z�,�,� . ....�.-,� ,..� . . �; _ . � „� .� j... . . :�-- .� ��:+ :s.i , . . :s S �r• P�°' -a. ,r: . . *# - f�r y��a �rz°i.,. , . - - . . . . ,� � �. . ��� .,, .. �s , , �..��rj.;:. .. . . ... _..., . ��- awv 'L@'F . �}. .. . � , t -:.�+- --- .,+� t� .�� 'eL'�' � ' �;� . ... , .;s r � � ���i 4 ' . ' _ l yisS . E; � �:ny���� A�';� �.:. Y� - ,��„y�F� ' c�'l. • � • • � ' � � . . � . ' ;�F.�I , . ,� � % � ,__� �y.�..R� I�T11P ��✓u�, _ , � / __� ,� , � _� _. _ , . -��„_�.__ _ _ --- _,.. _ _ _, . -___ _ --__ , . �� `- _``— � - j (f L' ,�;f . � , �� . - - _ � _ � _ .. _- ..o..st--, � �....-._ � . '• r . . �1 1 . ._ .:�.��._ .. ... . -, _ �. . �� . :'.s����r:"o-i�C..._ r 'y .. � � . .. '_ _ .. - ' / � ,�.. ' ,.�.' ''".yet}r ' "'"'��� .`�f}gt,- � .. �Slt'�^�+�s."'��„'„ _ . �.ft'ns. �� - .y.,�,�_ `yl.:...�t�C',^ _ '� . C���� � !!-��r_ � - __ - -��a ,; ,,,, � .._.. . __—y � ,. � t +-t�.,�.� .; ���---'�_ _'__ � - ' ,';t�. G T' . . 3�'� ' .y.�r : .. ••aq' .�y .cC. _r� � .1,_�;_ - . . ;ti�-' . . � � � � � ' � • � . , , �� ` �^ —� � '�- =;- , � , --''�-_� -�_�� � +' �'����� ` .�_- :.i. —+.�_:�_ ` �y.. ' ',.�_ +.,'.. _ 1� ' ��'},�a,' � , �S�� t-- ,,�„ ��:,-s�,;, ;i ` ; 1 .�-� """"� �-,.v , �� f.�v:; sa " IV - � � �'..,""'�'a =n s����' � s . "•"'- � z�s,aT�. " r,y� � � _ h r��"�' ���;�<N r.,... � . . ,�� � �, � ��,� 7 j�, � �'\C'' f . r t� �� . N".i�'!�'"'� `r� y�< ; €.� 1 ya��''.' � y a• E�w-'-. z F � ��- s.- u"� � ..� v��-`'� � �•'� y��'` �.-�. � F�� -,lut'.. .. �x,.�w. _L- 1Y � � � � • . � �i� �� ' r� mr. movies � . / �R - ��•�� �� � . �- . ; _ � � �---��� - __...�:. � � -- _�: � � . � . . . _ .. - �► _ _ - � u11,�tij _, .: . — -- � ; � � � I ' .. � 'A � � � � � i - _t_� � `_ }. � �� ��, ,. � ��g� - ..._ ..i111,�,1_.1�.�:l.i �-+..:+`�ir:.: � 'a � �) 1� 'i'M� �r L ��r �� - _- �����' �� � �����.'-i ���� �--� ����`� -- - _._ '. . '. ., l 4a �.� ��1 � � . . . .� ... �`.�^�^�.. ^ .t � � _ . ., :�1��� . . ��Y '� +•: I�it6Yw r --.��..'R �` LL " . . .-�."' �����A����I��f�.T�"I S _. ,'��.+ , s, •-r ._. - �� � �^. f�.� . .. �.pM�`_a� �. Y�.,r .;�`�„ � i � � • � � � 1 - �� � / - _- � �/ ' a ` '��yiT�� ■ � — I ; '� . ,^'• ..�..-r '�..- `r;"_s' ' � � i ' � , ` ' r�� w�, IB;�F F� � '� � I ,. . . �i �ii �� `�:.' . 1.:: ��I.'� t �p� � . '•{N: `�$� - I . � .�.... �..,�__ .�i'.,��� � ��1 r ��.u...,.:��1�L�a " «�:fi��r:��a�'y4,���s ;i�w:,#�;;� _ ,i��;� � 3S :ri:W7�_�_i;;__ � � • Y r , .�.�E'{� T.w'�._.i \�•'�(� ! �'�,' r � ' ►`ty� ���� �— �� �w �+1,.,.�. ,w,� ��''�� . � _ �,, , . _� i ,�41 � . / ��I •`'�` � % ,*L!'��'-��' :��.��'... �P'. � _ — � �..��.w�.-- .---�-�-=, -r ,�� .Y: - �✓ ,__ . �� - L�, �.b. � � . • � � � � -. ./ . � ./. � � � � : A. � T _ � j . :�� 1� i P '� � ��. Y� � <,,,. _ _` . =�,, " ��. <.y_ �.- -- k ,,.�r" , `� .y��/� ..^�rM��• _� -•� . .�� . ` . . ',�,Y � ' ,� ,��� ���_�� ,�M'h - �' .. _ � .i b�' »�� . . .. .. _. - . �f _„ 11 l�i . . "� , , � '.+� . . . . . �'i.. � .. . . F . . � . ' . ' y :� � - ... . � . . ���. ;� � - :�.� �y r .� - .�.. .. .. . � .A - . � . � .1 -. ��'-'-� t - � . ' � . ,."'y'�`� � :.'.:G �'^ T.: ` �K _ � . . . '�� ' . . . M...yyM.��?�.''� � t- , , � ' / ' /``,` � ' �� �.� i \ ' ,_ty � � _ t . . � . • � � '�� �_ : � ,� `�s�.-s.� .� ° ' � :c� �. . . � Ra.j�� . . } 1 .,' 1 ""'i a •-�-. �, --�_ y��'I �� ��`:i� _�- — � ����x���� \ -� -�. � � "'°_� c�r � _5 � � .� : . `` �"' - ^C"' :4,.s, .. ,ii� L v.e- ':.. ,"'G7* 'W , .... t ... ..� .1"' .� q ,. 3 _ .•y ���. b r�>y � + ,{� . s __ . ..- s=`� � t� __f�"� ^f�g��- u ; �� �r?.:�� (R + €' " -�' ,;w',S..- r� . t ,,�. � _� , �� � - "��'. l'#��,r � r.,,�44� �, '� � �4 ,y . - . _ �5�'�Y , � ' "��Y ''�a!�lT� _ � .. _ .. 1 � �k f,{2�.�,�, .�M� • _ � . . .. • ..�i 1�'?�r��l�;��-��• . �^'� � p � �ah c-.• � <..�... . � _ .,'< . .. `c . ,.. b � � / � � � � • , . - • . �. '. ', � ' � '.tL%': . . '„ , ' . , ' . . �.� �yl . ,,y � • : • � t• � , . - - . , . . . . , , . . . .r.�' ' ,.'! . ti:i. • t �� . r.. . L. - � • . •��... ' •^,...,'r.•: ,' � . . . -: .- • - .t , s � r ; � •. � �ittii"tJ� � ��. : R ' . . . . . . . 1 . � f�, e� r :,���bw F� ��d�4r�., � ,1 '� �' r � t� r i.•' ' � .. ' . - . • � . .. 1 !' . .'.��j� t i��1 �h.../ � ' .� • • '� ' � ' � . . • � ' . . • , . . • .:i� . . . .t .r•..� , . .. . . • � ,�•• .! - , ,F•t� . ��. ' ' EGAN� i=1 ELU � NOWAK� � . ' _ . . . supvevoAs � .' � . . . . . . '.� ,, � . . � �»w+u�..� ��u�� � ����B Pu► M���'an �.MIMN ' ' . . • ' .. . ' - . ••_ . ' . . N � � • , � . , • : . . �.,:: � . .: . . . � . . . '�"`" �� - J0' CERTIFI�ATE .aF BVRYEY �. � •' � . � : � • - � � STaN Et*IUNI� . ' . _ , ,• . :,'}• ' . '. , !�r ... .....�.� • � • - . , -.�' `;'. . • . . ; • • '• r,�.d,a�«.b.�l�t , .. .. ,�.� r, • - �0�.0�' " !: H�rt�.�•►o��.�•• e.�•�� . � . .. .. , .. :---�.......-•�.�f _ .._._ .... _---rr:►-'.�•�s�s{it��7a;'-t':?jTa.nr}�:'�1 : •� ; '/S� I • : ' . ��� u. • , .. �. � , . '' � . . �j :j.. � �i . 1�.1,5 � �w• ..i ' � � � � � . � , ��i � 111. L'�J�� � � r . ^ . � � , � " � . S►.r.t 1•.� uwSN � �� �� r , i.o•t - �;' . � . I ' " . j'' • . � -- , �� • ' I • . . ...... . .d�' v 70 O' �. �...,'. , • .. • • . • � � I '• . '�„ •". t' • i ;:..w+ ,:�; ;. ,� . i 1 r' a'.. . I. � •:• � I . . �. , '� � � . .. . i,�� -:tr�• In ; . .. . . . 1 �r ^ ' �/ .. ' �� . �t � �..� _ . . . . I• . . . . . , n �,A • ' ' . � .� . ^ � �. �� ' . .. .: ' � I .. � � I • � ^ �y--��t-��_•�'.�'IY� {��"'r.� "• _I 11 • . . • � £ , .�' .t:,.•.. --- � +%�N� : . ' l0'1.92.' ° fi M�'�.e•-� �. � . .. � � .�---__�___ �- � � •- , �r .,� . -= -t9.SS� . ; .. . _ I � . . H . �, . . ,. . I:� � a . " �-:••�-3'1� � � }o r F�1��� I f • ':•;i- �� � �' :; ' � :: �� W ,,. I J y '� . � � . tt. ' . . • �• . � . 1� ' . • �'�:;."�`' ( ' , t��• .� � . ' ; . I .. . ' � ' , � ��- ' ,, .. . �,� � , ..: � �z-�ia� ', ' .b (4� , � � � -------• , .,� � . . . �'� ���Y. . � �.• ,c �1 �_ 'W a.l l� L.« +•------= � ».9 1.•�. '. ' . ' ;,_._ . V,. � —.*. ' ' I " � S��N , � � . , } . •• btZ �� _i , •. .. z�0•�� - �' ' `. .� . FI�M .r�� -�»�u , '.. . r F��«r 4i� .. . . , C O � t��c y . �o Av t�J�O:� ;; . � . � . � . � �� NLdCNIPtIW�.•4s�• 2!. 2�, 2b. � ?fi. li�ec� C, NAVAMRE F[1':M13. � ,�• . • . - 1 . . . I �. . , ._. . '. . . � . . .. . . , � ws t+ereDr tr�tll� thel Inlr '1s s trur and torrecl repree�ntsilon ol s survr ��1 ' � ; �nt bOu�derles ol Ine Isn�i ���uve descrlbrd enA ul� tt�• lo��floM ul sll Uulld�n9h ' � � il unY, fhe�e�n, e�d sll �� ,i01e encroachmAhla, If a�y, lrom o� un seld IsnJ. • � ; Qef�d IA16 2�rN dev ol �Mu�• IUe;.! . •�. , • • • ' • , . iGAH, I'IEI� d NCY►AK � '� 5urvrrnri . • � � i'_N.. .IiM1� I�ook+ho ��.IG28.JOr pr �; r�' ' • .' �" � • .._.. . . • .. � � . . • .. , . . � � . • � . . ' . �,' .. . , . . . . . � . . , �� . SITE �SURVEY . .. � �, . .. _� � . �. . • � , , . � � . . . � SHENEHON-GOODLUND- . � � �� � TAYLOEi-FRUEN, INC. � � ' . . . . . � .. ' 1 , • r��,,�, G . ..._...s.a..�.��...�..r. •..o.. ,•nue►« r.N.�ws.►��:�n�:.•:'a•ay'..'t�'v...ri��i:..r:r.a-�.��r�:au.'e'�ROf1::.:lI�11�fl4►R����..�r.,w, r�:1'� . - �Wr'� _-_��. _ ���.� .. . .. ��.. �� �. .. �L. ��� . i HENNE�IN � STA. 145•50 LT. � CONG STEPS � REt�OvE a: if I,� ~ I _p.- i , � Q . � ( �, , � cn ; � � co � 1 -$-gR 8 BLK. _: .� � � -- - � � ► . �, . L , � _ . i ' ! , ,_--- , i I s2 , -fi . i 2'S'�- , ' - . � � � , I ' i. � S-R ` Pl BG. ; � � 1 -S-BR. 8 K. � I J II�Ru� ; 8 NTG. 1 ' BI p � 60 � ` ; 61 61 .� ► "�' i ' i ' � ts � Q--�---� �_ ►- , _T --- --_--=- -- --� =-- - ------ ` • M/�M/�I�/.�M��M�N�M�./�i/�M.�rr►+��+�M�.'I../.nI J I.aI i I+ .��Ii� �"��'I.I IV�r M�r�/+��Arn�N�1 M/�.�M�11II�1µ�r��/I I./IJ bM�A�.'.r AA��N��M�✓� � I C. S. A. H. N0. 15 I 1 .��Nd ♦ �����r�t/1/ J IM�JMI�Iw�+M/`^�II.�/�I�I1I�`�'��M��/1I1/�ir�I�/"���IL✓�r.�r1VI�^�I�/y��I+A, M� � ~� � pna• II'f�r��/`I�1�� /./�* /� —__ V J � � - _ V v ,� �= ���♦ /-I `_ - --- - - .; �r\�� � ' --� � , � i r� SE �SE � ' �f ' 67 —�BUS SHELTER S ; 67 � ', ; : J , II BI T. CUR B �_- � � -----L------- �I � BIT. - , � , . -, � � i �� � t � I �------- ' • � i � ------------- � + : • � �--- ----------------------------------- I J � � � 1 � � i � .� � � 1 � i � � I � KEAvENY U. S. POST LI�UOR � ' � � � .K. ; ` DRUGS OFFICE S70RE ' � � � � � �� � � � � I �il i � � S. A. P. 27 -615- 14 ' RIGH- ) . 15 PROJ . N0 . 8024 , SHEET 5 � �\ �%1�� I_ _._• � \/ '.yA�O,r •J J --_ ��' 6ClQV' \t � U \y� � v�� l� .�� ---- \ �'�. . r� �ti �Y74Iq o..�.. �x '��� Qy/� 12 � e(VQ � � �� � ... r.c ■ �o P ' ' �,�oN w� RR•16 ' �� f��[��/� f .F ■ `l1/� � �i �`h r.n �._:.-.�\ � y � _ � �s ��� WAYZATA . � > � _ . = n, 9 � \� f � � 0� M/GT2ATA BOY . . s 'rruc.� � A�KE R Baoin4 Ber (`_. ■ ..a�s ' �" ,#' �R' � `,�. N • � '" m � � � «<.y � . —.��,a. � eR" ■ . s �ri.4 �D � I � ��� � � ' ,� a ' Official Zoning Map � N �„� � � � City of Orono, Minnesota . � m ' R•1A a»c.�r n..+a.�ur a.vM ��.. . n.n�nn rar! LR'1A R�B on�F.mwrn..�ewnwwnnn �rtia+ • y�1A QM FMMy l�k�Mon MdOMMId D41rk1 t�C�N ' 'e � ! LR 1B a»F.�r�a..n«.n.es.���a.nM �k.. � �•�C ar v.muy►.►..no.•n..ia.Mw aa.�n vt�a. •..w r4 � LR4C 1 a»F.�.,,.....�..R�4OMIul SusMHrlc� 1/IAen RR•1A OM frnil�Ni/N RwWwNW WNtlel sk... • 1 RR•16 a»r.mar�n..�a.�nr a.�Nn :�.. :. �O t ` ■ � ' RR'�B 1 On�Family Nw�l R��IMnlhl fWdbkM t/�cns ,{ ; LAKE NR�t�ETONKA (�S Swwaal rtetreational 6 ncns � 'r � * � ' B� IMIW SaM�lu�Mn DNMkI '� O � � B•2 �wr,a.e�.ti,...aa.k� . ` � �� �� � B•3 snovvtiv e.ro.,s�wuu dn.m . � B'4 a��c.�ns na...�ww su.�..�a.ak� `�'� � ' � ,� �rj ��T��•a N•�anao.�eee s.un•u on�ne� •` ' • ydyNrlM Dbtrlet w�IK�� � � , ' �eople y r n�nce «.eer 19. 19/� �1 �y,W�u � Il/�ftl�! •]Muary 1.11)S '� R S ay we�aea e�: 0.01nMce 195.Jw 1�. 197� Or0 wan<• 2�6 D.�.�.0.• !09 38: ��A�,p .wr �, � oro��..�<�ro.w+..e�.rr. �vrc o.o�a... :•s, a .i. aa, ,�c��n aa��.�ce ro�.ac�oa. �t.nrr o.r�.... :w� �.h �� �--s .y,� ' . ae��.Me ta..trw..�f.ivs o.a�...c. �s. Ne.on ao.nar aa+�.�ce xu,a�eeer S, H7! ♦ � � Ga�..nce il�,bvweer 1�, 197e �` O.�M�w<�12�.f�Mwr1 11.1��0 B�G ISIAPD '� Z a.��.e�tes.,Nw�rt 't�isu ♦ • r ` • — J � lR_lC �.R'R.`"� l - fn ♦ � . �M , � . . SIiOFiELII� B-5 , ` `������������ �� 8-1 R" 8-1 8-3 LR-1C � _4 LR-� . LR-IC-I B-5 & . �O INSERT ' NAVARRE AREA DETAIL MAP ISBERG ' RIESENBERG CHELSETH and ' �_ o � �o s000��. _ �°� ASSOCIATES , � � ��,nt �mi Rp1'tf1 .�....,m.. INC. • gpNESTR00, ROSENE, ANDERIlK i ASSOC,INC. R EY I S E D: Ca1SULTMC ENGM�EERS NOV. I� 1980 JUNE 30, 1986 , �'y�' M�� FEB. 15,1981 JULY i3, 1987 SEP?.IS,1983 AuG. 28,1984 GENERAL LIMITING CONDITIONS 1. The appraiser will not be required to give testimony or appear in court because of having made this . appraisal, with reference to the property in question, unless arrangements have been previously made therefor. 2. Possession of this report, or a copy thereof, does not carry with it the right of publication. It may not be used for any purpose by any person other than the party to whom it is addressed without the written consent of the appraiser, and in any event only with proper written qualification and only in its entirety. 3. The distribution of the total valuation in this report between land and improvements applies only under the reported highest and best use of this property. The allocations of value for land and improvements must not be used in conjunction with any other appraisal and are invalid if so used. 4. No environmental impact studies were either " requested or made in conjunction with this appraisal, and the appraiser hereby reserves the right to alter, amend, revise or rescind any of the value opinions based upon any subsequent environmental impact studies, research or investigation. 5. Neither all or any part of the contents of this report, or copy thereof, shall be conveyed to the public through advertising, public relations, news, sales or any other media without written consent and approval of the appraiser. Nor shall the appraiser, firm or professional organization of which the appraiser is a member be identified without written consent of the appraiser. 6. Acceptance of and/or use of this appraisal report constitutes acceptance of the foregoing general assumptions and general limiting conditivns. 7. The comparable sales data utilized in the report is compiled from what is believed to be reliable sources, and is believed to be reasonably accurate. The appraiser has made a reasonable effort in securing general condition, finishing and construction quality on each of the comparable sales. This effort may also utilize the appraiser's past experiences of similar properties and may or may not include exterior � , inspection of each comparable sale, as deemed necessary - � by the appraiser. UNDERLYING ASSUMPTIONS AND CONTINGENT CONDITIONS The property has been considered as though it were - free and clear of any indebtedness, liens, or encumbrance; and that the title is good and marketable and competent management is assumed, unless otherwise stated herein. No responsibility is assumed by the appraiser for matters which are legal in nature. No survey has been made and it is assumed that the improvements are located within the legally described property and that the buildings comply with all ordinances. Any sketches and pictures in this report are included to assist the reader in visualizing the property. I believe to be reliable the information identified in this report as being furnished to me by others but I assume no responsiblity for its accuracy. Possession of this report, a copy thereof, or any part thereof, does not carry with it the right of publication, nor may it be used for any purpose by anyone but the applicant or by previous written consent of the appraiser and the applicant and in any event, only with property qualifications. The appraiser herein shall not be required to appear in court or before any governmental body by the reason of the completion of this assignment without predetermined arrangements and agreements. The distribution of the total valuation in this report between land and improvements, if any, applies only under the existing plan of utilization. Neither all nor any part of the contents of this report shall be conveyed to the public through advertising, public relations, news, sales or other media, without the written consent and approval of the author, particularly as to valuation conclusions, the identity of the appraiser or firm with which he is connected. QUALIFICATIONS OF RAY CONNELLY General Experience in Real Estate and Appraisal Business Twenty four years as licensed real estate person. Nineteen years as owner of Ray Connelly Realty, with offices in Burnsville. Specializes . in property sales in Dakota and Scott Counties. . Memberships Dakota County Board of Realtors Minnesota Association of Realtors National Association of Realtors Burnsville Chamber of Commerce (President 1972, Businessman of the Year, 1979 ) Savage Chamber of Commerce (Director, 1986) Eagan Chamber of Commerce Appraisal Assessments Approved as expert witness for court in Dakota, Hennepin, Scott, and Goodhue Counties . Appointed Commissioner in eminent domain proceedings by District Court, First Judicial District. Independent School District 191 Probate Court of Dakota County City of Apple Valley City of Burnsville City of Eagan City of Savage County of Dakota - ' AMCON Construction Company Ames Construction Company Meadowood, Inc. Fab-con, Inc. Fischer Construction Company Howard Dahlgren & Associates Kraus-Anderson . MEPC American Properties � M. G. Astleford Company Metram Properties Company Minnegasco �, . Power Cooperative of Minnesota Richard Rnutson, Inc. Richards Oil Company Edward Rraemer & Sons Larkin, Hoffman, Daly & Lindgren, Ltd. McMenomy & Severson � Glacier Company � Numerous other law firms, companies and property owners in both eminent domain proceedings and 'other appr�isal needs.