The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutRe: temp signs � � DATE TIME CITY OF ORONO CALLED IN INSPECTION NOTICE SCHEDULED 2-Z—I PERMIT NO. COMPL�.TED �` � ADDRESS �� Y� �� OWNER TELEPHONE NO. CONTRACTOR � DESCRIPTION � � � ❑ FOOTING ❑ PLUMBI G FINAL ❑ EXCAV/GRADING/FILLING Q ❑ POURED WALL ❑ MECHANICAL RI ❑ LAKESHORE/WETLANDS y ❑ FFiAMING ❑ MECHANICAL FINAL O ❑ TREE REMOVAL Z ❑ INSULATION ❑ WOOD BURNER/FIREPLACE ❑ SITE INSPECTION Q ❑ RADON SLAB ❑ WATER HOOK-UP ❑ PROGRESS � ❑ FINAL ❑ SEWER HOOK-UP ❑ COMPLAINT J ❑ DEMO-SITE ❑ SEPTIC MAINT. ❑ FOILOW-UP _ ❑ DEMO-FINAL ❑ SEPTIC INSTALL ❑ HARD COVER REMOVAL J ❑ PLUMBING RI ❑ SEPTIC FINAL ❑ FOUNDATION/REMOVAL � OWNER/CONTRACTOR TO MEET YOU:_YES_NO � COMMENTS: � �� a - o ��Q� � L��l�!!��-u-? c� � ,� � o I � W � � Q � � - . W � � O � ❑WORKSATISFACTORY:PROCEED ❑ PROJECTCOMPLEfE W ❑CORRECT WORK&PROCEED ❑ ISSUE CERTIFICATE OF OCCUPANCY � ❑CORRECT WORK,CALL FOR REINSPECTION TEMPORARY V BEFORE C�/ERING PERMANENT ❑CORRECTUNSAFECONDITIONWITHIN HOURS. p pHOTOTAKEN INSPECTOR WILL RETURN ❑CITATION ISSUED ❑STOP ORDER POSTED.CALL INSPECTOR ❑tNSPECTION REOUIRED.CALLTOARRANGE ACCESS. Call for the next inspection 24 hours in advance. (952) 249-4600 Owner/Contractor s' Inspector. White Copyllnspector's File Canary CopylSite Notice April 11,2011 ��vC�`� Orono City Hall �P� �� r�� 2750 Kelley Parkway CI7�� .- ` ',�� Orono,MN 55356 City Manager, A couple of weeks ago we wrote the following letter.The "temporary" sign still is there.Questions �--- abound as to why this business is getting special treatment. If the rules have changed shouldn't we all be allowed to have signs outside our businesses? We would hope to see notification on the city web site that temporary signs are now allowed on a several month basis. Or? We see no need to get city council members involved, however we are running out of ideas to solve this issue. Thank you for looking into this matter Orono City Hall 2750 Kelley Parkway Orono,MN 55356 City Manager, Have temporary sign ordinances changed?When applications were submitted in the past we were told no more than 10 days. If they are indeed more lenient please post the new number of days allowed on your website. Navarre Lanes have had their sign up for 3 months. I think all of the businesses should be allowed to do the same. Do not want to cause a bad relationship with a neighboring business so I will withhold our name. Thank you ! � � O� O a+, O �� CITY of ORONO � ,� TW'1-4'- ... � �,r�,�%�'''-�. ,r ,�,� `w � , �� G�ti Municipal Offices .�9 ; �� p, ¢,� Street Address: Mailing Addross: �C'F,+ggO 2150 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 22 p i 011 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323•0066 Barry Tanner 144 Norman Ridge Drive Bloomington, MN 55437 Re: Temporary Sign Permit Application for Navarre Lanes at 3435 Shoreline Drive We have completed our review of the temporary sign permit application for 40 additional temporary signage display days at 3435 Shoreline Drive (Navarre Lanes).This application was received by this office on April 20,2011. In January you applied for and received temporary sign permits for Navarre Lanes from January 15t through February 10, 2011. An additional permit was granted utilizing signage days from Navarre Liquors from February 24th through April 8th. To date,your signage has been displayed for 112 days in the 2011 calendar year;only 80 of which were covered under permits. We have reviewed your request to permit additional temporary signage display days citing the garage spaces as a business use. As the garage spaces are not retail tenants we do not consider them to be a viable business use. In February the City Council allowed Navarre Lanes to utilize temporary signage from one of the other business use tenants in the building with the hope that before the permit's expiration date you would be applying for and constructing permanent signage—wall signage and/or monument signage. To date,we have not received a permanent sign permit application for Navarre Lanes. This letter is your notification that your request for a temporary sign permit is hereby denied and that all temporary signage on the building and the property associated with Navarre Lanes be removed upon receipt of this notice. Signage within Orono is regulated by City Code 78-1466(enclosed). As with any staff determination this denial may be appealed to the City Council. If you wish to appeal this decision, you must make a written request and pay the appeal fee of$100 by April 29 at noon to be heard by the Council at their May 9th meeting. Please feel free to contact me at 952.249.4627 or by email at mcurtis@ci.orono.mn.us if you have any questions. Sincerely, City of Orono _ Melanie Curtis Planning&Zoning Coordinator encl Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us ' ' City of Orono � Temporary Sign Permit Application Mailing Address: Permit number: O�,D,�.O PO Box 66 � Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 Date received: .�, �, Street Address: Received by: �',�, �ti�' 2750 Kelley Parkway Permit Fee: $35.00 L9kESH�4'� Orono,MN 55356 If mailing,add$2.00 Main: 952-249-4600 Fax: 952-249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us This application form must be completed in full and all required information must be submitted. Incomplete applications will be returned. (P/ease print) BUSINESS INFORMATION: � Name: � .; �-=. �-._� Address: 3�t3 � 5"L,, .._\,,�_ \� CitY: �` ,, ZIP: '��3';i Contact Person: i3��.-.-,�—C;,,,�,r_- \ Phone: t � 1-'�.�� L: Email and/or Fax '. � .. � �_;; , - c , APPLICANT(RESPONSIBLE PARTY): E N I E D Name: � , � Mailing Address: Re gQi1 ZIP: Contact Person: Phone: SIGN COMPANY/OWNER(IF NOT SAME AS BUSINESS): Staff Date; Z7� Name: _ �;'l tr.�� ; .S,-;,,� c_ Address: _ �y`� Q� u,� City: � � ZIP: �S 3i"� �''. _ L � -\.� �. � �, o Contact Person: _��_. >>.._�__-.,;,� Phone: 7�'�� 2_3 �-• �-1;�i`-, PROJECT INFORMATION: Type of Sign: Size of Sign: Location of Sign: Dates Sign to be Displayed: �'Portable Reader board L 1 1 � � �- ''r� ��' �' I ► � � � � / ❑ Banner S ��'�\.� '�;' -S / � � �� ❑ A-Frame 3- k�=�� v y�:� ❑ Balloon ❑ Other(specify) For signs not attached to a building, provide/ocation sketch on back of application. APPLICANT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: • Violation of City Ordinances is a misdemeanor. Each day the violation continues in existence shall be deemed a separate violation; • The City may,without notice, remove any temporary sign erected in violation of city,state or federal regulation; • The si n s ,si n su orts or ortable stand must be removed from ublic view at the end of the ermit eriod. Applicant Signature: . �� Date: �t�1�� —� 1 For Multi-Tenant Buildings: Properry Owner or �%� ManagerSignature: '� , j,_�� Date: ��-��_�� `�-.__..__-- Printed Name of Property Owner or Manager: S� ,� � 4�.: '�. , , , Phone Number: �.�L-��"�� •��,, Email and/or Fax Number: �„., . �� .��.�;,,- ' �tl E J v 1 ��J �\.i \_,� ..� y,1 � \`��.'1N� \ai��`�� 1C � �n J J ��^ . , T . � . City of Orono Temporary Sign Permit Application For slgns not attached to a building,make a sketch showing driveways and sidewalks,edge of road and edge of parking area. Indicate distance from sign to edge of roadway. ; �^..J�u',^� �,��v.o s' � .� . I �''� y i t��r+:�. � 0� . „_„__ �. .._..._..� -- f . C_/.r 7`' � i ' .� . .�. � �' � 1�-- J 4 '�'� � �� S ��1��1�n�, JJ�. ��R��,--- �I�J��YI� yr 1�J� 1(appllcaUons)1Temporary Sfen Permit Appllcation.doc 3/30/2009 10:59 AM ALTA � ACSIVI LANI� TITLE SUT�VEY � . � I� 30 0 30, BO 80 Scale 1" = 3�' � ^i/n ��,�tx' `��J ) i Ypgp,N�17 F08 kIIOHII6Y PURPOSiS ,f� �OIA'YD`� � p£R H.GFIfATB!SD HIGH1fAY � r � tpW � 15.YUT N0. 68.P�9 DOC.P0. 2 � 1 5 ' C �0� � � N0. • � �0. m. RD. �oan �r��r}�( �1�—� .��.�, � I BITtTMINO[JS . . 9is.9i re�*.�"a"'�'iOa�6aseY . . f=`puFrosgs rsk noc.No. siaoise� k�gy� �-CONC. CURB NA7'4a�50"E :.•�Yr�.q6^- � i -:�ALg 5.9 =. �'� ppg-LiC YAY _� . I CONC --,,g. . ' • 86 i 315_82 M � . - �:_ . ' ! PI89'21'55"E PdcM ; nR�` �p�`�'�' ,��" � e �d ADlOINQiC PRAPBRfY OfIV6R: Of �i ,��_� ' � � d� � Alec�c c. o.er.� o UPPER ,� LEVEL PARKiNG ARTsA .Q� � o • � � � ' �pOUs : . ----------'• 1 !■7 y.a ' --------^---------- B1T� , � lo ------------ CatiaPY 1PAI.K ,�, � , �• a -------' - Be0_6i '-"'-• - ` � --1,-6.0_ a CONC. oeo.se o : ; o d �� I 152A � se.9 oda.4e �a � � �� 80.1 1.Oir- � � ti� o N� cvx � r"J CV O �oc"�. no"�i1T'�a�'_.__-- � a `4,� � m N ". �� a i—STORY STONfi N � � � �� I � $a 2—ST�RY S'fOIVE o o m w� O.B .� . NO. 3425 p.�� „ ��¢� . N0. 3485 ;,� ��cti •� � "�` '� �� ¢� � � � H c�i V � 0. �X� �'yV � � MA � 'C4.R3 eo y+f .i. � .. ..t . - � "a eo.�or�c. . e�a s.o oza o � ioz.a �.. se.o , CA ."p`�gpgL SfU7�$�'. 1ALL �A �! ,. I 7 �� I ^�--- asa.a — � '; :: if . ———1——— �Tx v�c�art'[BUOIC PAC9449579� � AR� � MA ' � \ ''•:-DEEDs. P�a"E`i3a.noc.1ao- � � w �a ��J^ � /�ft+ �^ �x.T_` -1,---- -'��— �.__---=--i + N + 6�OS#� pp � S— � --`"1-�ooD.33�'•�\ �_�.-�y=�Y so8 nvsRsss �Ectttssp -�L^r�= W PP ----'�— � � ' � � • �� R�GR�lY -� a�a�-ai===----- ---- . — - ------- . -'hoc.xa ii�aesa� ------------ N ' � "'_�_'_'_'�_'� PP � -----�-^---- ARgp . ---i---`-----------'--' LORER G� � �� P�� 31REA - •..anus .C4�' 4`'v � � Aa . � - ' ' 1136 TANNER ENTERPRISES OF MN, INC. DBA NAVARRE LANES �,0,�12„� 3435 SHORELINE DRNE 2�p5gp5477 ORONO,MN 55391 �ate �� iy �2a1� Pay To The �� ,� $ 1t�Q•�`' Order of �/'� . � .. � � +•1 '� e�curiry O � Dollars � """"' � o.wi.on � �.e,a. �p'' a a<k. wa:ceroo eank� Nevada . weNsfm9aca^ M For ��,0 51`�'^ ��'000000 L L36��' �: 3 2 L 27074 2�: 2705805477��' . 'k � O� O..�,, O ��'� � � T CITY of ORONO � �� ;�,� �� .:� � ;y �� Municipal Offices �,� 1 �� G~ Street Address: Mailin� Address: 9 ' '+..�i�,�,'�i $EgHO 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323•0066 April 20, 2011 Barry Tanner 144 Norman Ridge Drive Bloomington, MN 55437 RE: Temporary Signage at 3435 Shoreline Drive Barry, Last week, I reminded you your temporary sign permit expired on April 8, 2011. You indicated you would be submitting another temporary permit application utilizing signage days from another building retail tenant. As of today, I have not received your application. Therefore, the temporary signs for Navarre Lanes must now be removed by Thursday, April 21st. In your discussions with City Council and staff, you stated the reason you were seeking to utilize additional temporary signage days was due to winter soil conditions and the inability to install footings for a new monument sign. It was our understanding that you intended to instatl a monument sign as soon as weather permitted. To date we have not received a Permanent Sign application to install a new monument sign. For your convenience, I have enclosed the Permanent Sign application. Please contact me if you have questions regarding this application. Your property will be re-inspected on or about April 21St for compliance with this letter. Please contact me at cmattsonCa�ci.orono.mn.us or 952-249-4620 if you have any questions. Sincerely, CITY OF ORONO I�.XJ ristine Mattson Planning Assistant Enclosure: Permanent Sign Application Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-461b www.ci.orono.mn.us Melanie Curtis From: Melanie Curtis Sent: Friday, April 22, 2011 3:43 PM To: Lili McMillan (lilim@mac.com) Cc: Jessica Loftus Subject: FW: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Attachments: admin@ci.orono.mn.us_20110422_131320.pdf; 100_0539.jpg; The old Crib Sign 033.jpg Importance: High Lili I want to give you a head's up on a situation with Barry Tanner& Navarre Lanes. I don't know if he will contact you over the weekend or not. But here is an email chain from today— read bottom up also the attached PDF was included in the original email. ***** As you know, Barry more than maxed the allowed temporary signage days for 2010 and then used up the allowed temporary signage for Navarre Lanes at the beginning of the year with a permit from Jan 1 — Feb 10 at which time he made an appeal to the Council and through another tenant was granted 40 additional days. The Council's allowance to utilize additional signage days from another retail tenant in the building was premised upon the installation of permanent signage when weather conditions allowed. We issued another temporary sign permit using days from Navarre Liquors for an expiration of April gtn A ground sign can be installed now as the frost has left the soil. A permanent wall sign could have been installed at any time. We informed Barry that permits will not be issued for additional temporary signage for Navarre Lanes until Jan 1, 2012 as the days for 2011 have been exhausted. He applied for another permit to use temporary sign days from the garage stall spaces in the lower part of the building. We denied the permit based on the fact that his days have been exhausted. I spoke with him and apparently he misunderstood the piece about sharing signage between tenants. He thought he could continue to do so indefinitely. I explained to him that the Code doesn't allow it, but it had been done on occasion in the past so the Council felt comfortable allowing it to help alleviate the issue with winter construction. (As an aside, these spaces are private garages or loading spaces solely for the use of a tenant and are not considered a business or retail tenant— mini-storage is not a permitted use, commercial storage is not a permitted use in the B-1 district nor is the square footage of these garage spaces accounted for in the parking needs of the site as they are not retail spaces.) He made an application before opening last fall in October for 3 '�permanent"signs. One of the signs couldn't be permitted as it was a ground sign that didn't meet the monument standards; one sign was meant to re-face an existing Crib sign on a pole (shown in attached photo); and the 3�d sign was a wall sign. We realize now that the��permanent" wall sign was a banner and is considered temporary. He stated the sign material was vinyl. Our mistake was in assuming he meant rigid vinylas some signs are made with a rigid vinyl material. They do not last as long but we thought it was his attempt to save some money. The vinyl sign is essentially a banner screwed to the wall. We did not and will not penalize him for this as it was something that should have been clarified with the permit application review but he still must remove it and install a permanent wall sign which meets Code. The sign he was proposing as a re-face of an existing pole sign wasn't installed as we permitted. It is now being used as the directional sign he has affixed to the light pole (attached photo) and is considered temporary. The short story is that he needs to install permanent signage. I will be happy to talk with you about this if you have questions. - Melanie Melanie Curtis Planning &Zoning Coordinator City of Orono 2750 Kelley Parkway 1 Orono, MN 55356 Direct Dial: 952.249.4627 Fax: 952.249.4616 Planning &Zoning Office 952.249.4620 Email: mcurtis(cD_ci.orono.mn.us Website: www.ci.orono.mn.us From: Tanner, Barry [mailto:barrytannerCa�edinarealty.com] Sent: Friday, April 22, 2011 1:31 PM To: Christine Mattson Cc: Melanie Curtis Subject: RE: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Importance: High Christine, I told you to contact me with anv issue. I will have a separate business owner in the building contact you to give you permission for the temporary signage. DO NOT return my application and check. Thank you. Barry Tanner Tanner Group Edina Realty 6800 France Ave. S.#230 Edina MN 55435 barrytanner@edinarealtv.com Direct phone 612-916-0223 Direct Fax 612-677-3875 From: Christine Mattson [mailto:CMattson@ci.orono.mn.usl Sent: Friday, April 22, 2011 1:28 PM To: Tanner, Barry Cc: Melanie Curtis Subject: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Barry, Based on your email to me (attached) I understood you wanted me to contact you if your application was not received. We received the application and have processed it. Please see the attached letter regarding your temporary sign request. Christine Mattson Planning Assistant 952-249-4620 2 %��.=o��\ , � � , , /o o��, �� # . ,,� a , �� ;' CITY of ORONO �� y �� Y � t4 �' Municipal Offices �� rKf� �•'� i, 'ti, �i \,��t T w��-� �`r�� Street Address: Mailing Address: ��xE8I;04� 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 22`-7X�ri1�011 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 Barry Tanner 144 Norman Ridge Drive Bloomington, MN 55437 Re: Temporary Sign Permit Application for Navarre Lanes at 3435 Shoreline Drive We have completed our review of the temporary sign permit application for 40 additional temporary signage display days at 3435 Shoreline Drive (Navarre Lanes).This application was received by this office on April 20, 2011. In January you applied for and received temporary sign permits for Navarre Lanes from January 15t through February 10, 2011. An additional permit was granted utilizing signage days from Navarre Liquors from February 24`h through April 8"'. To date,your signage has been displayed for 112 days in the 2011 calendar year; only 80 of which were covered under permits. We have reviewed your request to permit additional temporary signage display days citing the garage spaces as a business use. As the garage spaces are not retail tenants we do not consider them to be a viable business use. In February the City Council allowed Navarre Lanes to utilize temporary signage from one of the other business use tenants in the building with the hope that before the permit's expiration date you would be applying for and constructing permanent signage—wall signage and/or monument signage. To date, we have not received a permanent sign permit application for Navarre Lanes. This letter is your notification that your request for a temporary sign permit is hereby denied and that all temporary signage on the building and the property associated with Navarre Lanes be removed upon receipt of this notice. Signage within Orono is regulated by City Code 78-1466 (enclosed). As with any staff determination this denial may be appealed to the City Council. If you wish to appeal this decision, you must make a written request and pay the appeal fee of$100 by April 29 at noon to be heard by the Council at their May 9`h meeting. Please feel free to contact me at 952.249.4627 or by email at mcurtis@ci.orono.mn.us if you have any questions. Sincerely, City of Orono _ Melanie Curtis Planning& Zoning Coordinator encl Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-461b www.ci.orono.mn.us City of Orono Temporary Sign Permit Application Mailing Address: Permit number: .¢,�� PO Box 66 ('0 Q\�\ Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 Date received: �1,� t �� ,.�� SfreetAddress: Received by: \��'�,�, � '� �titi; 2750 Kelley Parkway Permit Fee: $35.00 \kESH�4�� Orono, MN 55356 �_-=-�'� If mailing,add$2.00 Main: 952-249-4600 Fax: 952-249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us This application form must be completed in full and all required information must be submitted. Incomplete applications will be returned. (Please print) BUSINESS INFORMATION: Name: s'.i�;��.� L.�.��5 Address: �i3� 5' �- , p;�,v�• Cit : C��, o ZIP: S." � Contact Person: �-. T� �, - Phone: ��1- ��.-� c�2.. Email and/or Fax ��a-.- �c� r�,- . � APPLICANT(RESPONSIBLE PARTY): E N - IED Name: �c�r,�,� �, c�l•,a;;Y, Mailing Address: Re sd31 ZIP: Contact Person: Phone: SIGN COMPANY/OWNER(IF NOT SAME AS BUSINESS): StBff Dete:� Name: (`"1��r', � S � C;,- Address: 2yv1 P1�^,..��z.� C,.,�� CitY: �..� t � o ZIP: S�.S' i� Contact Person: �'�Q p.�<\�;s�,� Phone: 7 C.3-t3`�-�R`�� PROJECT INFORMATION: Type of Sign: Size of Sign: Location of Sign: Dates Sign to be Displayed: �Portable Reader board � ' 7� `� ' L�`��" dC` �� ❑ Banner S��•� �C�'. -S / � � � --�—r ❑ A-Frame � k�� . ❑ Balloon ❑ Other(specify) For signs not attached to a building, provide location sketch on back of application. APPLICANT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: . Violation of City Ordinances is a misdemeanor. Each day the violation continues in existence shall be deemed a separate violation; • The City may,without notice,remove any temporary sign erected in violation of city,state or federal regulation; • The si n s ,si n su orts or ortable stand must be removed from ublic view at the end of the ermit eriod. Applicant Signature: �.,j �,�--- Date: �i`��—�� For Multi-Tenant Buildings: Property Owner or Manager Signature: �� Date: �--�l.�t� Printed Name of Property Owner or Manager: S��a�'� P:��,. Phone Number: �+2-�"�0��`� Email and/or Fax Number; 5��,j:.,��?, �.�\_��r- ''"'Y"'F �'V> �S+14 �C/" ��cf`� \g!�i'�a,r" � ��•ls'�4— � �5,.� J �! � ' � ; City of Orono Temporary Sign Permit Application For signs not attached to a buildinp, make a sketch showing driveways and sidewaiks,edge of road and edge of parking area. Indicate distance from s�gn to edge of roadway. _.._.�__._..__.._..--- -'_.�' --- : �+J a,r�� ;�c��y"�� ! `�r 1 � ��f.�.. � f t � � i a� --_�______—,_,,,_________.____�_.._..__.-----......._ �,y . � � . i vy ' ..� .�- . �.. � �- ,�._._. .�,y„ ;: _._. S �.�� -� 1 ti��•� �''. _------- -�- `�P�- �,-��;� �� \�applicaWns)1Tsmporary 3ign Permlt Applica�on.dx 3/30l2009 10:59 AM A�TA/A C S M LAND TITLE �URVE�' 90 0 30, BO 90 Scale 1" = 30' ^'/n �� ( ) t�se�rt ►os��eT�ArYr�s.�R �� ,rV`� �s�, eui no.ee� noc.t+ m � N0. - 15 iS IO� ��,�p C0. ;. RD. ROAD ��f�y�p(-I�( �1 r M1—' .,��,�.,� . � BIT�MINOU5 . � "�°'Y . 915.82 .::��jip.elaoia6� •-CONC. CURS NAT43�5��'$ a.g � :.! �tav � i :�� CO� g �_ ' � � 315.82 M o . 86 � N89'21'55"E P�ell ; t�BY.� �`�LR'' �g'!�" • t �� ` t i , «+ AD)WNfNC PROPBR!'Y OT17BR: :a �j �g.�� `�a � 1 :m i �uaek a o.asen � UPPER 1.EVEL PARKINC �� ¢� �d o . ous � � , � uu�r - ----•-----. ` �, � er� � ' . ---•-••---'--CLNOPY AA1X !0 --•--"'•'-' �-� • � -- �i` ' " --'---"---"-'-- '-- 9E0_ t . , �i COI'IC. '"_�"'4.0 OA0.30 O : : �ar S � 15E.0 '� O �E, 36.9 Y60.4! p ' S �N �w 80.1 Lo�- � �d 'n o cv�t cv� .7 p .. �0�� -----" y Z�C'J • . `�� C�o m Q� �_ � � � a `. m I 1-STORY S'fONB N � °D 2-STOAY STOPIE�� o�� 0.8 .� NO. 842fi �y0'�� o �v � N0. 3485 e� $�cti � � � � N� a o. �� z -- •�� m �� : : . ,.� 80:CUNC. . WI% 6.0 028 0 N 102.4 w 99.0 � .-•Y_L6Y6L 3I07��T' 1AIJ. �A r. j % T R61x } � I . � •�� . _- —� . . � ' , • -�__ Q -p ; : _ 1f . �_�--- /O� ---�__��\��-�:,�_�P^a�r s�x��a�_ _ �o - r,__—_J`_�____' +��r�� PP .OSdcT� PP �:— � ---=��-�p — — ------=�sL`_a-� � 1 _ 1f ' --�---1- 9Sdc�' ----'--- - � -_.`1-eoo`n.-�T-wNa:.-- ' �-�- - _ '-SS-`- - ��_��__. 8 -- --- � N � ' '-- � . v�acuRN'1'BOS tNGRBSS lt FARBS _'_�"__ �- . � �a�-.a�—^----- ----- � PPN T� �---- '��boc.xa isveess�-------------- - . __r------------- ---- _ _�_�-------- ARSA LORER G� �L v�' PARKING �� '� � aa � { � _ ...a�t1S 0 � � CITY 0 0 of �RON(J Mrxniclpal Offices �! ,'�v Street Address: Mailing Address: �',� G,�,�' 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 � ,� Orono,MN 55356 Crystal Bay,MN 55323-0066 �k'E$�I��" August 8, 2a11 Barry Tanner 144 Norman Ridge Drive Bloomington, MN 55347 RE: Temporary Signage . 3435 Shorefine Drive This letter is to follow up regarding the temporary signage at 3435 ShoreEine Drive. You were not9fied by staff the temporary signage was to be remaved in Aprif and May of this year. As discussed, temporary signage includes the banner above the door and the dir�c#ional sign on the pole, located in the right of way. Both of these signs are temporary, According to city cade 78-1466(8}, (copy attached) ...banners or batloons...are temporary signage. Upon review of sign permit 2010-01057 (copy attached), the sign type listed for the sign above the door (sign #1) indicates the material is vinyl. Staff interpreted `vinyl' as rigid vinyl, not a banner. A banner is considered temporary. Afong with permit 2010-09057, a sign (sign #3} was approved to re-face the existing sign which read Bowl& The Crib, utilizing the 6' rod and pole at the comer of the entrance driveway and Kelly Ave. The permit is still open as this sign has not been completed. Are you stilf planning to install this sign? You afso inquired about amending the sign code. I have attached the Conditional Use Permit and Other Land Use Applications, which covers amending the zoning cade. The application fee for this application is $700, plus legal fees and requires a pre-applica#ion meefiing with staff. The nex� deadline far the September Planning Commission agsnda is August 17th at noon. The temporary signs must be removed by Wednesday, August 97 by noon, unless an application is received to amend the zoning code. If you have any ques#ions, I can be reached at cmattsan(c�ci.orono.mn.us or af 952-248-4620. Sincerely, C[TY OF ORONO � I`�-� ristine attson Planning Assis#ant Enclosures: City Code Section 78-1466 Permit#2410-01057 Telephone(452)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-461b www.ci.orono.mn.us _ _ ��-� -- � _ •_ : � �;.r. � � ' - • ` . I M�FMV1 W, i � � ��y _ i _.� . _ i �� '�� . .._ �, �I J � . � b. � -- - �, �,�� - � ' �� , ��`i = �� ' �'� .- , � � i: �� `� '��{ ti� ! . �""� ,�,' �� . ._ . � ;;� � �_ ; ;; , � u : � � � ' �' ` ;i� � � ----�_=---=--__� ; �, - � , . �;�� .� �� r � - �� 6 � z .,�. � �m - �� r . � '��^�a �� , �� , I . l s � � . .'(. ,� E �ti � �.ct • ' . � a,4 0. , .c. Vi' _- Sr1��. �' �al� . �� +�f�s� '� �� ,{f t � -. ' " �, t ' � �� , p ��` n �' . ��, �� #.�� ,i#� . ' �r� ��i'. Y• � ��r � „ � a� ?� "� ! : ,�� `� '4;� . „�..�' �r I 1 ��" r .- , �P.,. „ ^ ,. � ,.., ,ir'- - � ,,.. t> �: �>, —— . ,,�,� t —` -- _�. . . • � f h +- � � %2"� . . ; � . � � � .,. � . . � �'�!'. ..E�� -_. . .. �; � F - , _• _`� � �1� . . r,_._.. � ... ( ....- . k.: �� p � �.�-_�:�"> ,t � � � � �� _ �� . � . '� �. � . �- � �lc� � �� Q�Q ��''x � c°, . �� v� � LL a �. -a QC � � �W � �'"'�' � �x �0 � � � �_:_ ,�; � Y :Q„r i�, ��. - - �, � Cr � ,� °' � _ � �' _" .;�- ;T � � , ��. � �� _, � � . , o , ,- � -;--.�.,.-., � .� _ -�- � .,;� , , �,. � m ,�- �� L cn � •��""""�""".i"""'...,r,,,�� .�_ _ �. � � ��., �r�. r'� ra� �, � ,� -� - - -�:_ _�,,,� _ � � _ . � - _, - , r � � . � � � � � � ,.,...�--_ � . . . . - - _ � � � � �F � ��{� � _ ' . . . ,. � :� . _. * t.' b �' i t. . � � , ,. .� a+�`.x . r � o� O ` p CITY of ORONO �.= Municipal Offices ��'z _� r� �� `' � Street Address: Mailing Address: b�' `,... "�''� � �'� G,�,�' 2750 Kelley Parkway P.O.Box 66 � ,� Orono,MN 55356 Crystal Bay,MN 55323-0066 `�kESHog' August 8, 2011 Barry Tanner 144 Norman Ridge Drive Bloomington, MN 55347 RE: Temporary Signage 3435 Shoreline Drive This letter is to foltow up regarding the temporary signage at 3435 Shoreline Drive. You were notified by staff the temporary signage was to be removed in April and May of this year. As discussed, temporary signage includes the banner above the door and the directional sign on the pole, located in the right of way. Both of these signs are temporary. According to city code 78-1466(8), (copy attached) ...banners or balloons...are temporary signage. Upon review of sign permit 2010-01057 (copy attached), the sign type listed for the sign above the door (sign #1) indicates the material is vinyl. Staff interpreted `vinyl' as rigid vinyl, not a banner. A banner is considered temporary. Along with permit 2010-01057, a sign (sign #3) was approved to re-face the existing sign which read Bowl& The Crib, utilizing the 6' rod and pole at the corner of the entrance driveway and Kelly Ave. The permit is still open as this sign has not been completed. Are you still planning to install this sign? You also inquired about amending the sign code. I have attached the Conditional Use Permit and Other Land Use Applications, which covers amending the zoning code. The application fee for this application is $700, plus legal fees and requires a pre-application meeting with staff. The next deadline for the September Planning Commission agenda is August 17th at noon. The temporary signs must be removed by Wednesday, August 17 by noon, unless an application is received to amend the zoning code. If you have any questions, I can be reached at cmattsonCc�ci.orono.mn.us or at 952-249-4620. Sincerely, CITY OF ORONO � I`1-� ristine Mattson Planning Assistant Enclosures: City Code Section 78-1466 Permit#2010-01057 Telephone(952)249-4600 •Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us � �� f� ��: ' h, r�` � -1 �.irC ,ys:�`�. . � ,� .'�. . � �t �`�. ,� '£ ' � �` . -"--'. � � 1^�S �� ,�: � `�r�., j,,k. Y�8,q��lF�4'l I'. "I � R f�� ':� �' `� � .. � � _ .: h,�.s;�. �'� :�, � `,. i�� t'+ M!�■ �"�fi �:. ..Vs 'rr �y'� !\�■ . x • tl\/■ " !Mlli■ � :w��yx, h:-`� ,�'w . . . �-- �f!■ . � R`r� � � � � � � � � � r:��.J � �� , _ " I � ��.� � �,,.� ��I�Ll_i� �+x r!�^e.- y w � � � � .:+, . . � . _ .. , � � _ !'� -;� D �( �._� , � :C."� �i �;'y 3��< >JT` � - - � � � ' �� Jp2 n 9 'I 1 � .ia.` . ��n yt 5�?- �., ' � NCT -:NO- � .} ��...I � ��NOZA � N i,II�If'� a '____' --'. � �+' t � t _ � , �t . N ' aYL � �� ' !'i ��. �' a � �; t i ,�,�`' �. I �. � , � f' � I x � �' .. i ' �* � I '�� ,� s� �L. � i � r w � � � . � �� wY I �� ..� � �� _ �� ... . . .. ' I� 4 � k i�^ ��, �.� '�:� ; �- <. u �� g � � �� ' � � �s.X �� - "z� 7�`"��, ..'s . ;.;/ � �i��! �1 j� � �< � I �� _� - �� -� � ``�� . , �� I 1l��Tl�i '�,��,� � � � � �..0 �� , � �� ! �--1 > �- � y�ry�,y, �� ,�� '}'[(�"'". *�- ''Y �" � � " .. q jG v 1 I *� F, �#_' ,�„� � �� . �. ( ��I . .iro - � � ,g� �r I t � "� � ��.�, � �� I I � ��. � \�..., I ��.r�' - .,.r'h-.s" . . . � _ .'�3 ��y� i � r � \ , . ■ I r ;.,: ., .. � T o , �' '�� SiT� � � � t �� _ � �� r��^ �� i 4 � �'� ,?-.. ; �,�� `� ��,. :�� ,. � �� ,�� ... .�, . � ' �y��.��.4� �y� i ...1 . � . . . 7�} '� �r�. .,� j. � � � � . ' - . � , � ¢��.'� � . ' � . � � . " i � � ' "M1'� y ,,„ ''~� ��R��' . � . .. ; . I , .. 1 ` C �� '� �� 'j � . �� ti�. �' " : _ 9�,'� r�,-,��..� , _. , � � _` '..""`,� l` �� ` ' - �•, � ��" , , � • - � � �'-� ° C� . a�; " - � � � �� 'r - � � � ` e� � �. � t ■ - • �,� �,. � � ' �fk.,• ' F _ _ � .,,,o � �,,, . � � r t� :� - - y � � �. B� � r i A � � � V �- ! � � �' � " ► r�� ' � . �• � . � 'r. —� _ �. i . .---._.._. � pp„ � __.. _� —.i____ .. __ �- t �}��•7I a -- ' � �� d4 . , . � � r x i+ � . t 1 . �� S �Vµ {WF �., ..�� . � . �� ' � . ... ... . ��J � �� , <, i ( , � t �� • �e'" ' _ �y{ f��°e� " ^'-�"1f►.5.� . i Yk""� w� � , ' � (. � Pl'!�� y..tif �+✓�.�,.r z , . �;�� 3em_' _� ,WF:_ , < � , � . • .� �� ' . ,C� �.. , • i� ..,. . �.�°t--��S•.'�"?�]�r�4�L`_.. :. .. � ..l_-li: . il_:. q+-, .-Y_'T�'� ti!�_'.." .' . . � � I '� r y l ,'� � ± •.� 3 ' i . . . �;r � � � 3 � �r a � � j �1� � . �.-� � � � � 3 � E I � -, � s�� yR,, i � . - I --- � �� '; Il �, �i - � �, .•• .. �� -�.� / 1 ti _ ' � . �, ..: ,� �'. . ,. �... � _ - ,'� � 1 , ,q : � Y \. �. � . V �... .. .._ � xh�"Y 4L', ) �� .r.�' � � , �. a�j , �_T ,� ��>,� . � �� , ��y �� ,� � � h� a1`^� r ��(j� , t ( � '.:�� D •� . �� `�4i ��GF � �� . \�. �� f.�.�f.��1�:, � `s . � �� },� � ��,Y .y. } �� - �1 ; \ t ;� �,' � ti . � � ..x .. 4:.�.- � ' �� . . � �y�_ (��r.'�l i/. ��- �. rY� �f L , � �� u1 .. . . M�r� � � � _ .. a �► _ _ ".3`�_- _ � 4 , : ! � . �t� � �a.�`'t5�`.'4��'.�1�� .-�� 't� aE� �.•t s t f x :� L °I�=�� a � , .� _ ._ 3 �� - - � - ;�o �0�, ,� � � �`�'— �-�-� ,� _ _ � 1 � r 0 �-a 7o C :�� - b, ,� ; ,.. ��,�� _ � :, �o:� � �� 'J�a ��F� �. , �y ; A � ��C Cprn(n� �.po�' � � 6 .x r �" N� �� Y, � : _ (� N = , ,�� --" �� 1 C+�� N _ ; , . ,� _� �.� � Z� �� " , ;;,� �' � , " ��` n,� ,�' '� • � �(/a u�i � � - . �� ; � � � �k�� r�� ... , yy ',�� .�.d,.,. ;' i ,� ' t. �P .� � . . . \ �'. ' � 'Y '_.. '� � � - _ �_ _.. . .... . �� ,�� + ')� A� T."� f' I� 1 I f $ �F �'�'i��,4�..��. � � 3 j � �1I - � �, �"!y :. .� � 1�' ;�� ep g � ,pi � i i�,. �� t �.L A��'��1�-`� ��iti.'. . ...,`: •` �� ,....�i�A t � . �. Christine Mattson From: Tanner, Barry [barrytanner@edinarealty.com] Sent: Friday, April 22, 2011 1:31 PM To: Christine Mattson Cc: Melanie Curtis Subject: RE: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Importance: High Christine, I told you to contact me with anv issue. I will have a separate business owner in the building contact you to give you permission for the temporary signage. DO NOT return my application and check. Thank you. Barry Tanner Tanner Group Edina Realty 6800 France Ave. S.#230 Edina MN 55435 barrvtanner@edinarealtv.com Direct phone 612-916-0223 Direct Fax 612-677-3875 From: Christine Mattson fmailto:CMattsonCa�ci.orono.mn.us] Sent: Friday, April 22, 2011 1:28 PM To: Tanner, Barry Cc: Melanie Curtis Subject: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Barry, Based on your email to me (attached) I understood you wanted me to contact you if your application was not received. We received the application and have processed it. Please see the attached letter regarding your temporary sign request. Christine Mattson Planning Assistant 952-249-4620 i � O� � O O,.��. �� CITY of ORONO r��;�y � �' :� �°�� S Municipal O�ces �'� '�',Y , t�� G ,�9 ,��¢,� Street Address: Mailing Address: �C'EggO 2150 Kelley Parkway P.O. Box 66 Orono, MN 55356 Crystal Bay, MN 55323-0066 April 20, 2011 Barry Tanner 144 Norman Ridge Drive Bloomington, MN 55437 RE: Temporary Signage at 3435 Shoreline Drive Barry, Last week, I reminded you your temporary sign permit expired on April 8, 2011. You indicated you would be submitting another temporary permit application utilizing signage days from another building retail tenant. As of today, I have not received your application. Therefore, the temporary signs for Navarre Lanes must now be removed by Thursday, April 218t. In your discussions with City Council and staff, you stated the reason you were seeking to utilize additional temporary signage days was due to winter soil conditions and the inability to install footings for a new monument sign. It was our understanding that you intended to install a monument sign as soon as weather permitted. To date we have not received a Permanent Sign application to install a new monument sign. For your convenience, I have enctosed the Permanent Sign application. Please contact me if you have questions regarding this application. Your property will be re-inspected on or about April 215t for compliance with this letter. Please contact me at cmattsonCa�ci.orono.mn.us or 952-249-4620 if you have any questions. Sincerely, CITY OF ORONO II�.J ristine Mattson Planning Assistant Enclosure: Permanent Sign Application Telephone(952)249-4600 • Fax(952)249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us Christine Mattson From: Tanner, Barry[barrytanner@edinarealty.com] Sent: Wednesday, April 20, 2011 12:55 PM To: Christine Mattson Subject: RE: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Christine, And to clarify on the permanent sign, the landlord is having the tenants share a sign under the O'Reilly's permanent sign application. Barry Tanner Tanner Group Edina Realty 6800 France Ave. S. #230 Edina MN 55435 barrvtanner(a�edinarealtv.com Direct phone 612-916-0223 Direct Fax 612-677-3875 -----Original Message----- From: Christine Mattson jmailto:CMattsonCc�ci.orono.mn.usl Sent: Wednesday, April 20, 2011 9:44 AM To: Tanner, Barry Subject: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Hi Barry, I am mailing the originals to you day, but am providing you an email copy as well. Let me know if you have any questions. Christine Mattson 952-249-4620 1 Christine Mattson From: Tanner, Barry [barrytanner@edinarealty.com] Sent: Wednesday, April 20, 2011 12:41 PM To: Christine Mattson Subject: RE: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Christine, The renewal of the temp sign permit was mailed from my work office last Thursday. Let me know if you do not have it in the mail today, I will drop off a new copy in person tomorrow. It was mailed to the PO Box that is listed on the temp application. Barry Tanner Tanner Group Edina Realty 6800 France Ave. S. #230 Edina MN 55435 barrytanner(a�edinarealtv.com Direct phone 612-916-0223 Direct Fax 612-677-3875 -----Original Message----- From: Christine Mattson [mailto:CMattson(a�ci.orono.mn.usl Sent: Wednesday, April 20, 2011 9:44 AM To: Tanner, Barry Subject: Temporary Signage for 3435 Shoreline Drive Hi Barry, I am mailing the originals to you day, but am providing you an email copy as well. Let me know if you have any questions. Christine Mattson 952-249-4620 i � �� MINUTES OF THE ORONO CITY COUNCIL Monday,February 14,2011 7:00 0' clock p.m. (7. #11-3496 CITY OF ORONO,AMEND CITY CODE 78-71,NONCONFORMING STRU URESAND USES, Continued) Bremer aske whether other cities are adopting similar measures to deal with the Suprem ourt ruling. Mattick indicate ere are a number of cities that have passed similar ordinances. ttick stated House Bi1152 as currently oposed received the most opposition from car dealers since � contained language that would allow cities grant a variance and then attach conditions to the va � ce. The car dealers would prefer that languag not be contained in the legislation. McMillan asked whether this inance amendment will provide the C' flexibility in dealing with hardcover. Curtis indicated it would give the Cit e�bility and that it wo d allow someone to improve their property if it results in less hardcover an is a reasonable ap oach to the situation. Bremer asked whether Staff will still be com able wi this ordinance a year or two from now. Curtis indicated they will be. The ordinance allow for some flexibility on the part of the City to make a lot more confonning as long as the hardcover is ot ' reased. McMillan asked whether the wn club wou also have so flexibility if they wanted to construct a new building or make other improvements. Curtis noted they did speak with r esentatives of the gun club. that they would be allowed to rebuild their existing structure. Mattick stated he is unsur hether the b n club physically has room to a additional structures but that they would be allowed replace what exists. Sremer moved, anchot seconded,to adopt ORDINANCE NO. 85, Third Se 'es, an Ordinance Amending th rono City Code Regarding Nonconformi�ies. VOTE: Ayes 4, s 0. Bremer oved,Franchot seconded,to adopt SUNIMARY ORDINANCE NO.85,an dinance Ame ing the Orono City Code Regarding Nonconformities. VOTE: Ayes 4,Nays 0. 8. BARRY TANNER,3435 SHORELINE DRIVE—APPEAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE DECISION Curtis stated Navarre Lanes opened for business in the multi-tenant building at 3423 Shoreline Drive in December of 2010. Winter weather conditions and frost have not allowed for construction of a new monument sign. In order to draw customers to the newly opened bowling alley, Mr.Tanner placed temporary signage on the property. Per City Code, four 10-day pemuts are allowed for temporary signage per calendar year. These permits may be lumped together into one 40-day time period. Mr. Tanner applied for and received temporary sign permits for the dates December 3`�through December 31 S`. Additionally, Mr.Tanner applied for and received temporary sign permits from January 1 through February 10, 2011. -------- ----------- Page 7 of 18 : ' ' MINUTES OF THE ORONO CITY COUNCIL Monday,February 14, 2011 7:00 0' clock p.m. (8. BARRY TANNER, 3435 SHORELINE DRIVE—APPEAL OFADMINISTRATIVE DECISION, Continued) The recently issued sign permits utilize all of the available 40 days for 2011. Mr.Tanner requested a vasiance be granted to allow additional days for the display of temporary signage. Staff denied this request based on the limitation within the code. On January 19, 2011, the City received an appeal of the Staff decision to allow additional signage days. Staff recommends that Council deny the appeal for additional si�,nage days. Mr.Tanner could explore an agreement with another tenant in the buildinb. Curtis noted that Mr. Tanner has brought some pictures of his temporary sib age. Barry Tanner,Navarre Lanes, stated to his knowledge they have not had any complaints regarding their temporary signage. Navarre Lanes is located in the basement of the building and the temporary signage is necessary to direct patrons to their location. Due to current weather conditions,he is not able to construct the monument sign. Tanner stated if they were not allowed the signage, it would be a huge detriment to his business. Bremer asked whether Mr. Tanner has discussed the possibility of using other tenants'temporary signage allotment. Tanner indicated he was not aware of that option until this evening and that he is requesting a 90-day extension. Franchot asked whether Staffs recommendation to deny is based on the variance issue. Curtis indicated it is. Franchot noted due to the Supreme Court ruling regarding variances, the Council is unable at this time to b ant a variance. Mattick noted in order for the Council to grant a variance, they would need to make a finding that he would not have reasonable use of his property without the signage. McMillan asked whether this is a variance or a permitting issue. Mattick stated the idea was that he could not apply for a variance, but by asking to extend the 40 days, that would be considered a variance. Mr. Tanner could approach other tenants in the building to see if he could utilize their temporary signage days. The City Council will need to decide whether that is an acceptable approach,but Staff would require conf`umation by the other tenants that that is acceptable to them. Bremer stated the Council is currently looking at different ways to deal with the Supreme Court ruling, which greatly Iimits the Council's ability to b ant a variance. The Council does have the ability to allow him to utilize other tenants'temporary signage allotment. --- ----------- Page 8 of 18 — ------------------ ,, � ' MINUTES OF THE ORONO CITY COUNCIL Monday,February 14,2011 7:00 0' clock p.m. (8. BARRY TANNER, 3435 SHORELINE DRIVE—APPEAL OF ADMINISTRATIVE DECISION, Continued) Tanner commented he wish he would have been provided this information from the start. Tanner indicated he could speak with the other tenants tomorrow but that he is not sure how quickly he will get the authorization. Mattick noted Staff would prefer to have that confirmation submitted in writing. Printup indicated he is comfortable with Mr. Tanner speaking with the other tenants and asked how much time Mr. Tanner would require. Tanner stated he would need to get approval from at least two tenants since he will not be able to construct a permanent sign until the springtime. Tanner stated he would make some calls tomorrow but would Iikely need a few days to get the confirmation from the tenants. Tanner asked whether the same permit fees would apply. Curtis indicated they would. McMillan asked whether this is a similar situation to the sandwich board signs in Navarre. Curtis indicated it is not since those business owners did not apply for a permit and the sandwich boards were only utilized during the day. Franchot recommended Mr. Tanner be allowed a week to speak to the other tenants and submit the required information. Mattick commented it would not be uncommon for the City to grant a property owner 10 days to correct a particular noncompliance issue. Franchot moved,Printup seconded,to allow Mr. Tanner ten days from today's date to obtain confirmation from the other tenants that they will allow him to utilize their temporary signage allotment. VOTE: Ayes 4,Nays 0. *9. URCAASE OF 2009 AERIAL PHOTOS Franchot moved,Prin econded,to authorize the purchase of 2009 aer' otos from Hennepin County for appro�mately$3, ith the funds being allocated o the Improvement Equipment Outlay Fund. VOTE: Ayes , a s 0. (The Orono City Counc' essed from 8:13 p.m. to 8:15 p.m.to c ene the HItA meeting) —---------------------.._..---------- Page 9 of 18 � g Feb 14, 2011 Appeal Staff Decision Denying Additional Temporary Sign Permit Days Barry Tanner— Navarre Lanes at 3435 Shoreline Drive Application Summary: Navarre Lanes opened for business in December of 2010. Winter weather conditions and frost have not allowed for construction of a new monument sign for the existing multi-tenant building. In order to draw customers to the newly opened bowling alley, Mr. Tanner placed temporary signage on the property. City Code allows four 10-day permits for temporary signage per calendar year. These permits may be lumped together into one 40-day time period. Mr. Tanner applied for and received temporary sign permits for the dates December 3 through December 31, 2010. Additionally, Mr. Tanner applied for and received temporary sign permits from January 1 through February 10, 2011. These recently issued sign permits utilize all of the available �days for 2011. Mr. Tanner requested additional signage days. Additional days would be considered a variance. Staff denied this request based on the limitation within the code. On January 19, 2011, the City received Mr. Tanner's appeal. The code is not specific when dealing with multi-tenant buildings, but in the past, Staff has allowed 40 days per tenant each year. In the Otten Bros. building some of the businesses do not have a need to display temporary signage and have coordinated or shared their temporary signage days with another tenant. This could be a solution for Mr. Tanner; however staff recommends that only occupied spaces' signage days be available for use. The downside of this is that it may result in what appears to be continual display of temporary signage for one business. In closing, Staff recommends Council deny Mr. Tanner's appeal for additional signage days. If the Council feels it is appropriate Mr. Tanner could be directed to explore an agreement with another tenant in the building to use some of their allotted temporary sign permit days. Ti+�hP.Y' GU�3 yZ�� _� �dv� �j�+''�- . \�GLe �,�,,� ��d �� J �r�� ' �,�f�o�� 'r�n;�,c� Q�d�'� �D � �l� ;R��r � 2� � �-c� � � �� Cit�y of Orono . 2750 Kelley Parkway ��4�� Ororw M�i 5535b Receipt No: 3.044018 Jan 19, ZO11 Barry Tann�^ Plarmin and Ioning ppp��1 �o T� Sign Ord 104•4U 101-3�230 Filing fees-elections/plats Total: 140.00 Check Check No: 1043 100.00 Ba�. rry�Tarmer 100.00 Total Rpplied: Change Tendered° �—'00 O1/19/11 Q3:51PM REQUEST FOR COUNCIL ACTION Date: 7 Febryary 2011 Item No. �� Department Approval:�� Administrator Approval: Agenda Section: Name: Melanie Curtis Title: Planning & Zoning Coordinator Item Description: Appeal Staff Decision Denying Additional Temporary Sign Permit Days Barry Tanner— Navarre Lanes at 3435 Shoreline Drive Zoning District: B-1, Retail Sales Business District List of Exhibits: Exhibit A- Navarre Lanes Appeal Request Exhibit B - Temporary Sign Permits 2010 Exhibit C - Temporary Sign Permits 2011 Exhibit D - City Code 78-1466 Application Summary: Navarre Lanes opened for business in the multi-tenant building at 3423 Shoreline Drive in December of 2010. Winter weather conditions and frost have not allowed for construction of a new monument sign. In order to draw customers to the newly opened bowling alley, Mr. Tanner placed temporary signage on the property. Per City Code four 10-day permits are allowed for temporary signage per calendar year. These permits may be lumped together into one 40-day time period. Mr. Tanner applied for and received temporary sign permits for the dates December 3 through December 31, 2010. Additionally, Mr. Tanner applied for and received temporary sign permits from January 1 through February 10, 2011. The recently issued sign permits utilize all of the available 40 days for 2011. Mr. Tanner requested an exception, or variance, be granted to allow additional days for the display of temporary signage. Staff denied this request based on the limitation within the code. On January 19, 2011, the City received an appeal of the staff decision to allow additional signage days. Staff Recommendation The code is not specific when dealing with multi-tenant buildings. Staff has in the past allowed each tenant to utilize 40 days per year. In the past in the Otten Bros. building some of the businesses do not have a need to display temporary signage and have coordinated or shared their temporary signage days with another tenant. The downside of this is that often times it may result in what appears to be continual display of temporary signage at a property. This could be a solution for Mr. Tanner; however staff recommends that only occupied spaces' signage days be available for use. COUNCIL ACTION REQUESTED Staff recommends that Council deny the appeal. Should the Council find it is appropriate to allow sharing of signage days between tenants, Mr. Tanner could be directed to explore an agreement with another tenant in the building to use some of their allotted temporary sign permit days. �— Council Exhibit A Navarre Lanes January l Oth,2011 RECE jV��. Mayor&City Council JAN � 9 Z�1� City of Orono C�j'y. 2750 Kelly Parkway �F�RONp Orono,MN 55356 Dear Mayor&City Council: Thank you for again for your help and support of my dream of re-opening Navarre Lanes. We have currently run into an issue that I hope we can work together to resolve with our signage. Per city code we need to have a monument sign on the frontage of Shoreline Drive 8c Kelly Ave. We are working on plans to have a permanent`Monument Sign',but current weather(snow)and ground frost conditions would make it impossible for us to have the sign constructed properly,with footings,until sometime in May 2011 after the frost is out of the ground. I am requesting an appeal to the city code ta allow us to continue to use the`Temporary Sign'until weather conditions will allow us to build the`Permanent Sign' in May of 2011. I feel we will suffer business loss if we cannot have some type of signage on the Shoreline Dr.frontage for the ne�ct few months. We currently,per city guidelines,have a temporary sign on the corner of Kelly&Shoreline Drive to help customers lmow that we are now open and point them in the direction of our pazking lot. Per city code,we aze only allowed to have the `Temporary Sign' for the duration of 40 days. (If you are not familiar with our location,we are located in the basement of a strip mall and access to our parking lot is off of Kelly Ave. Without the current`temporary signage',it would be almost impossible for new customers to find our location.) Please feel free to contact me with any questions or concerns. Thank you. Sincerel , � � .! �`—�� Barry Tanner/Navarre Lanes 3435 Shoreline Drive•Navarre MN 55391 •Phone:612.916.0223•btrace3�msn.com CITY OF ORONO PERMIT NO.: 2010-01174 2750 KELLEY PARKWAY ORONO, MN 55356- DATE IssuEn: 12/03/2010 952 249-4600 FAX: 952 249-4616 Council ADDRESS : 3423 SHORELINE DR Exhibit B�1 PIN : 20-117-23-12-0034 LEGAL DESC : REG.LAND SURVEY NO. 1422 : LOT 000 BLOCK 000 PERMIT TYPE : SIGN � PROPERTY TYPE : COMMERCIAL-BUSINESS � CONSTRUCTION TYPE : SIGN-TEMPORARY NOTE: TEMPORARY SIGN PERMIT FOR NAVARRE LANES-LOCATION ON THE CORNER OF SHORELINE DRIVE AND KELLY AVENUE. DATES TO BE DISPLAYED: 12/03/2010- 12/]0/2010(WEEK 1) 12/1 I/2010- 12/17/2010(WEEK 2), 12/18/2010- 12/24/2010(WEEK 3) AND 12/25/2010- 12/3 U2010(WEEK 4) ADDITIONAL FEE IS FOR THE THREE ADDITIONAL WEEKS FOR TEMPORARY SIGNAGE. APPLICANT SIGN TEMPORARY 35.00 TANNER,BARRY MISC FEE 105.00 144 NORMAN RIDGE DR TOTAL 140.00 BLOOMINGTON, MN 55431- OWNER TANNER,BARRY 144 NORMAN RIDGE DR BLOOMINGTON,MN 55431- AGREEMENT AND SWORN STATEMENT The work for which this permit is issued shall be performed according to the approved plans and specifications,applicable City approvals,and the State Building Code. This permit is for only the work described and does not grant permission for additional or related work which requires separate permits. All provisions of laws and ordinances governing this type of work shall be compied with whether or not specified herein.This permit will expire and become null and void if construction authorized is not commenced within 180 days of the date of issuance,or if construction is suspended for a period of 180 days at any time after work has commenced. The applicant is responsible for assuring all required inspections are � requested in conformance with the State Building Code.This permit may be revok at any time for due use. / � 03� /o i o��o Applicant Permitee ' ature Date Issu y Signature ate SEPARATE PERMITS REQUIRED FOR WORK OTHER THAN DESCRIBED ABOVE. �� City of Orono Temporary Sign Permit Application MailingAddress: Permit num6er. ' �/D" L�/' 0..�O,�.O PO Box 66 Crystal Bay,MN 55323-0066 Date received: .Z.- l> � �, Sfreet Address: Received by: titi 2750 Kelley Parkway pe��F�; $35.00 �y 'Cqx�x�4,��' Orono,MN 55356 Jf maifing,add$2.00 Main: 952-249-4600 Fax: 952-249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us This application form must be completed in full and all required information must be submitted. IZ� Incomplete applications will be returned. (Please prinf) �,,�r ' BUSINESS INFORMATION: c� r� Name: �1Q\l^�.��'e_ l G�,.�.s Address: 3�► S � '• r Ci : � ZIP: S 2 Contact Person: ,. f '�'�r��— Phone: �1-g�'6-��-�- Email and/or Fax � �Qr.�3�rr.sr c �r� APPLICANT(RESPONSIBLE PARTY): Name: � \ Mailing Address: 1 �-; �� Ci : � ZIP: �sy Contact Person: Phone: �� —�►�-c'Zz3 SIGN COMPANY/OWNER(IF NOT SAME AS BUSINESS): Name: �1 �` 'e C , Address: 1 �i� w, s. �^ Ci : ZIP: S i 3) Contact Person: J o�, b,..; mv. Phone: 7�.�-2 1—�� `1 PROJECT INFORMATION: Type of Sign: Size of Sign: Location of Sign: Dates Sign to be Displayed: �Portable Reader board �� X � � <��r�� o� �� 't� �2�� ❑ Banner 51.�ra\y+� ��- i'�1' �\ � 1'2—�7 ❑ A-Frame :s- �a�� J�, `1Z 1� � y2 Z� ❑ Balloon �1-�,S �� '3 j ❑ Other(specify) For signs not aftached to a building, provide/ocation sketch on back of application. APPLICANT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: • Violation of Ciry Ordinances is a misdemeanor. Each day the violation continues in existence shall be deemed a separate violation; • The City may,without notice,remove any temporary sign erected in violation of city,state or federal regulation; • The si n s ,si n su rts or ortable stand must be removed from ublic view at the end of the ermit riod. Applicant Signature: �J� Date: �2�1C� For Multi-Tenant Buildings: Property Owner or �--- Manager Signature: ,�� -' � Date: ��1"\� Printed Name of Property Owner or Manager: Sc,4.�� Phone Number: ��1�+q�� >>�` Email andlor Fax Number: S��n�C� `��-C3't`' City of Orono Temporary Sign Permit Application For signs not attached to a building, make a sketch showing driveways and sidewalks,edge of road and edge of parking area. Indicate distance from sign to edge of roadway. i ; �,eJ�:"� �� t��'� �� o� � -; � � i _� .� � 'a�� S ,� ,�' �' �� -�� C', -� `�Q-- �, �� \(applications)\Temporary Sign Permit Application.doc 3/30/2009 10:59 AM ALTA ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY � 00 0 30 80 90 Scale 1 " = 30' _ W��- sur� EASEM6NT POR H1Gti11AY PURPOSES ��1 ��l �oar� - � � PER H.C.STATE.AID H1GH1fAY NUDIBLR '/11 1 17■ .!/\�/\.A/• � ` c0 l5, PLAT N0. BB� DOC. N0. 18$booz . 1 5 � . tD No. • �S l0' ,p CO. � RD. ROAD �mi�p r7l[ ,� �1'� , ,.�f.�� I BITUMINOUS 3t5.sz P$RYANENT EASENSN'1' FOR H1691�AY � ""pUItPOSES P6� DOC. NU.�21901AB 16�-�] __.�� -GONC. CURH N87"43'50'E-�:-'}� ' ' _-� P�uc neY �Ueu eS.'�Y"- � I ;NALK 15.9 :_ CONC. .,,8.9� I 315.8w M � 86 N89'21'55"E P&M ARE►+ ��ij�� 4i�� Ad v�� 1 � d O I ADJOINING PROPERTY O1fNER: ',C� u�'�; 1�h�t� ' � d . � �" Aleck G. O�er�on p� �� i �C m UPPER LEVEL PARKING AREA ;ae z � � BYfUM ��S i � � � o tN � ' E- ' --------- -- -------- , 10 ' ------'-- --•-----•'-------- -•----•- �OPY 1fAI.K , ; ;�p`� �n �� .�...- - 9E0.51 � ; �� W�: CONC. ~$'� 9e0.59 o� � i o a > 38.9 eeo.4e 152.0 q� I 80.1 -- -�1� � � �o �H A (� t.o�- ��'� �n a N� cv,a DOC�NO�78077EY�-'--•---- � o � G4J� � m � -, . 0 � �� ` ��t� I 1-STORY STONE n z� 2-STORY STONE�� m od � N0. 3425 ,� N0. 3465 �� cy �� TR6R �0'�� , ��„A� �i� � o o "� �' �� w eu , ,.a z� �y � -CLR3 e° �eoi,� ` MH I 80.0 z -- o N 39_0 ' ` ; ; " _ , B.0 0 102.4 �` .. �p ..-.E-LEVEL STOti� I�BT. �ALL �A � 1 �.. coNC. . r� .�23.0 xnuc I . . .9 0 � � 7 � — �' . � 0... . � �__ . -- �. . � -------- -F--- --- ss 3z p j �T � �'�_,UTIWTY EABEM$NT BOOK 2429 ,q . � � v /QSp, o \a , Dg6US, PAGE�182, DOC. N0. 344� W �_-- -- c?;_S�_AREA . MH � -�--w=,— �_e�_ \� -- �—� +;--- T___ GA OE�F pp I _ w .—� �'• _ --_� ---- — — --- - b , __ _ �pp � —;5�=_a - � PP '-SS— / -----1-eooD RET eeu.---- MH ,__ — _------- � I � _ . 4E8G�'� �-=———-�—�� ` EA56YBNT FOR INGRS�B h EGRE99 ----L----- �--- � PP a . ,-'Uoc. No. ii�sese�7 ----------------- � I � -1-^------"_- ----- --�----------------------- AREA LOWER G`� LEVEL v5� PARKING AREA _.m. 1N� US '�" 4. Rfi \ I CITY OF ORONO PERMIT NO.: 2010-01213 2750 KELLEY PARKWAY ORONO,MN 55356- DATE ISSUED: Ol/03/2011 952 249-4600 FAX: 952 249-4616 Council ADDRESS : 3423 SHORELINE DR Exhibit C PIN : 20-117-23-12-0034 LEGAL DESC : REG.LAND SURVEY NO. 1422 : LOT 000 BLOCK 000 PERMIT TYPE : SIGN PROPERTY TYPE : COMMERCIAL-BUSINESS CONSTRUCTION TYPE : SIGN-TEMPORARY NOTE: DATES TEMPORARY SIGN WILL BE DISPLAYED: OU01/2011 THROUGH 02/10/2011 APPLICANT SIGN TEMPORARY 35.00 TANNER,BARRY MISC FEE 105.00 144 NORMAN RIDGE DR TOTAL 140.00 BLOOMINGTON,MN 55431- OWNER TANNER,BARRY 144 NORMAN RIDGE DR BLOOMINGTON,MN 55431- AGREEMENT AND SWORN STATEMENT The work for which this permit is issued shall be performed according to the approved plans and specifications,applicable City approvals,and the State Building Code. This permit is for only the work described and does not grant permission for additional or related work which requires sepazate permits. All provisions of laws and ordinances goveming this type of work shall be compied with whether or not specified herein.This permit will expire and become null and void if construction authorized is not commenced within 180 days of the date of issuance,or if construction is suspended for a period of 180 days at any time aRer work has commenced. The applicant is responsible for assuring all required inspections aze requested in conformance with the State Building Code.This permit may be revok�at any time for due c se. � � D�i l.�--i// D/l D l /l App lican t Permi tee Signa ture Da te Issu By Signature Date SEPARATE PERMITS REQUIRED FOR WORK OTHER THAN DESCRIBED ABOVE. � Cit of Orono �' `1� .y . . . c� Temporary Sign Permit Application Mailing Address: Permit number. a D�b - 6 � O�,�,j�.O PO Box 66 C rystal Ba y, MN 55323-0066 Date received: �3 l�I 0 a �, Street Address: Received by: �',�, �ti�' 2750 Kelley Parkway Permit Fee: $35.00 '�9gE$H�g'�' Orono, MN 55356 If mailing, add$2:00 Main: 952-249-4600 Fax: 952-249-4616 www.ci.orono.mn.us This application form must be completed in full and all required information must be submitted. Incomplete applications will be returned. (Please print) BUSINESS INFORMATION: Name: �� L�.�.�s Address: S D�• Cit : �r ZIP: SS �� Contact Person: �„� '�o,,,,,e,. Phone: (o�2- t�-� 2� Email and/or Fax �.,,,.��R,.�,�,..c��d�nasQQ� _ _o�... APPLICANT(RESPONSIBLE PARTY): Name: $� Mailing Address: �yy e3o�,.�„�; R�dv� �,� City:`$1,�,,.;,,,,,�, �. ZIP: .5"sy�'9 Contact Person: _„�� '�a,,.� Phone: f�1'2-g��-��t3 SIGN COMPANY/OWNER (IF NOT SAME AS BUSINESS): Name: � S, Address: 2L1�� piu..,�c�� C;�\� City: 3�,.. a o ZIP: 55313 Contact Person: v�.Q,. �,:ta;,-co�-, Phone: 7�3-232 y��"� PROJECT INFORMATION: Type of Sign: Size of Sign: Location of Sign: Dates Sign to be Displayed: : c�a � �Portable Reader board � � d Lc�c�r�r a� -'�' � ❑ Banner �ar+��cx '�'- "' • 1 � ❑ A-Frame ��.`�1 1 �� ❑ Balloon �� Z��' ❑ Other(specify) � I- I '20�I -1� 2"10 Z.�l ! For signs nof attached to a building, provide location sketch on back of application. APPLICANT ACKNOWLEDGEMENT: • Violation of City Ordinances is a misdemeanor. Each day the violation continues in existence shall be deemed a separate violation; . The City may,without notice, remove any temporary sign erected in violation of city,state or federal regulation; • The si n s ,si n su orts or ortable stand must be removed from ublic view at the end of the ermit eriod. Applicant Signature: ��-��.s-� Date: �2 3��i For Multi-Tenant Buildings: Property Owner or Manager Signature: Date: 92 3�-1� Printed Name of Property Owner or Manager: s��i.�;,c�� Phone Number. �+i��`�d"'``►L1 Email and/or Fax Number: �n,a,��i �'��.w� • � -l/ City of Orono Temporary Sign Permit Application For signs not attached to a building, make a sketch showing driveways and sidewalks, edge of road and edge of parking area. Indicate distance from sign to edge of roadway. � i_ _._�_ _._._�____-__---_..______ _.� ! i ' ��,��.<'^` `,�c�.�s i � ; �c- ; ' ; ` , � l�'.��.:. f � � I �� I __ � f - ------ _. . � � � � � ,� - � - t- �,�-- 'J �s:i1 i� S �'J' -t�`.��<.` tL/��, `�x---- .fJ`,-��K;..�I� ��I�� -� I \(applications)\Temporary Sign Permit Application.doc 3/30/2009 10:59 AM ALTA ACSM LAND TITLE SURVEY � 30 0 30 80 90 Scale 1 " = 30' �� Surc� EASEHEN7 FOR HIGH�AY PURPOSE3 �/)n� (�f Y Ioa,rV_ C.��/� V,! � PER H.C.STATL AID H1GH11AY NUYBCR � t5. PLAT N0. 6� DOC. N0. IBS6002 ' i � '� 10 1 /' � � (_� N0. 1 �'U ��p CO. � RD. ROAD �rf�tnp�"� �� 11'�-�' "�.�a . � BITUMINOUS 315.32 PgR1lpNENT EA9EMBN1' F�R R�a�AY �-CONC. CURb NB7'43'50�E L PURPoses Psa Doc. No. z�solae� � ACCEs9 To -''"A�'cEs9"'f6^ ,� 3 A�15.9 = _'"\ PUBUC IIAY . � � • PVBUC 11AY CONC. ,._.8.9ry I 315.82 M o 66 NB9°21`55'�E P&M AR�A �p�`AR'' �,��'��" � �i � w � o I ADJOININC PROPBRTY OIfN6R: 1w �� 11,� • a � �i a Aleck C. O�enac pi � 4 m UPPER �� LEVEL PARKING AREA �,QR z � � � � , � ' atTv�'NOUS � � w ; ' � --------- -- -------- � ' � 10 � - �-------------- -----• - �dOPY 11AI,K 1 � � . --- -----•- •-------------� - 9Eo.51 ,�, � ' . aa -- ` �� d CONC. ~-e.o 152.0 eeo.s9 4.0 � � o d� �S� I 38.9 eeo.~e 0 ; t e�o � 80.1 �� t.0�• � � o N� cvC pARTY R�!,t, AGRSEYENf __ ..- -- •�7 � c�i o .�; DOC. N0. ►17eo77�� - - � o J o o �4 .a, � (n w o �� ^�� . � 1-STORY STONE � ` ��C�' a � ¢� 2-STORY STONE o o m � W o,�g THER N0. 3425 �p��` �v �� N0. 3465 co a � u' : �� z'�'i �+�� I � � N� V � 0, ��a G� $a MH m �x 80.0 z -' -��3 � ` 39.0 ``� .2=LEVE1. STONB I�ET. 11AI1. �A 1/ � / ` o c� CONC. na�.�c B.0 023.0 102.4 �� GA . - I 60. � `7 � —— � a• C. . . ----- 950. 2 ; �� W . ----�--- --�--- a .; ��, � EA " �`�__UTIWTY EASEMEN7` BOOK 2423 �?, W � �H /O� � \� .�TDS, PACE�1B2. DOC. N0. 344� -- — — —--��?��5�_AR__ p __ +;--- f y GA OEdc`P' PP � � --_� - P =_=--- — �L -a f Pp I _ 1/ _ ; _�_ _ � ;� �--------- �H �. � _. . ,� - ��5�"— — . "—SS'— . : '-—'7—� 1100D. R6L�11ALU--. �——-c�..... � N �_——�._ � 1 N Q�J�"' 1=——————'��— � EASEYENT POR INGREBS h SGRE93 ------L----- t--- � I � N . �'�bOC. N0. 1178�3'S� ______---- PP ----------- -�------------------------�-^------- AREA LOWER G� LEVEL,yS� PARKING AREA 44�` 4' �� . 1 _ ..anUs `C Council Exhibit D DIVISION 4. SIGNS Sec. 78-1466. Signs as accessory use. Signs are a permitted accessory use in all districts subject to the following regulations: (1) On right-of-way. Private signs are prohibited within the public right-of-way or easements, except that the council may grant a conditional use permit to locate signs and decorations on or within the right-of-way under their jurisdiction for a specified time not to exceed 90 days. No conditional use permit for such a sign shall be issued by the council if a conditional use permit or temporary sign permit had been issued in the previous 24 months to that property. (2) F/ashing. Illuminated flashing signs shall not be permitted in any district. (3) Beams. Illuminated signs or devices giving off an intermittent, steady or rotating beam consisting of a collection or concentration of rays of light shall not be permitted in any district. (4) Sales signs. For purpose of selling, renting or leasing property, a sign not in excess of ten square feet per surface may be placed within the front yard of such property to be sold or leased. Such signs shall not be less than 15 feet from the right-of-way line unless flat against the structure. For the purpose of selling or promoting a residential project of six or more dwelling units, one sign not to exceed 48 square feet; a commercial area of three acres or more, or an industrial area of ten acres or more, one sign not to exceed 96 feet of advertising surface, may be erected upon the project site. Such sign shall not remain after 90 percent of the project is developed. (5) Existing signs. Signs existing on September 14, 1967, which do not conform to the regulations are a nonconforming use. (6) Traffic interference. No sign may be erected that, by reason of position, shape or color, would interfere in any way with the proper functioning or purpose of a traffic sign or signal. (7) Building wall signs. Signs shall not be painted directly on the outside wall of the building. Signs shall not be painted on a fence, rocks or similar structure or feature in any district. Paper and similar signs shall not be permanently attached directly to a building wall by an adhesive or similar means (temporary use of such signs is permitted per standards set forth in subsection (8) of this section). Signs shall be considered as a structure or fastened to another structure. (8) Temporary signs. a. There shall be no more than four temporary business signs issued per calendar year, and for a period of not more than ten days per time or of the duration of the event promoted by the sign message, whichever is less. The sign (including banners or balloons), sign supports or portable stand shall be removed from public view at the end of the period. Total area of the sign shall not exceed 32 square feet per surface (64 square feet total signage allowed for two-sided portable sign). Advertising balloons are not subject to area restrictions but must meet all applicable federal and state standards. b. There shall be no more than one temporary sign in any required yard area, and, if separate multiple signs are proposed, the total area of the signs shall not exceed 32 square feet. Temporary business signs require a building permit from the city. No such permit shall be issued by the city if a conditional use permit under section 78- 1467(1)c has been issued to a residential property. No temporary sign shall be allowed in residential zones unless permitted as election or sale signs under this section. Multitenant buildings shall be considered as a single property for purposes of subsection (8) of this section; and the use of the single temporary business sign by tenants on the property shall be the responsibility of the property owner or designated manager, who shall endorse in writing all applications for sign permits. c. The owner or manager of the sign and the owner of the property shall be equally responsible for the proper location, maintenance and removal of the sign. All temporary signs shall be located on a property so that they do not impede safety by obstructing vision of pedestrians or motor vehicle operators. d. The city may, without notice, remove any temporary sign erected in violation of this section or any other federal, state, or local law or ordinance. Any signs not claimed within 30 days after removal may be destroyed by the city. (9) Election signs. Election signs are permitted on private property in any district, provided such signs are removed within ten days following the election as related to the signs. No election sign shall be permitted in any district sooner than 46 days before the state primary for any state general election, and no sooner than two months prior to the election for an election other than a state general election. (10) Pylon sign. A sign supported by a post or posts so that the sign and supports are finished to grade by encasing the posts in a material consistent with the sign and where the base width dimension is a minimum of ten percent up to and including 50 percent of the greatest width of the sign. (11) Monument signs. One monument sign, limited to two faces is allowed per frontage per property, with a maximum of finro. The areas of sign base, the supporting background structure, and the sign copy shall be combined for determining the total square footage and the height of the monument sign. a. The total allowable square footage shall not exceed 100 square feet per side. The base and supporting material shall constitute at least 25 percent of the total square footage. b. The base width dimension is 50 percent or more of the greatest width of the sign. c. The sign copy area shall have a minimum clearance of 20 inches above ground level. d. The sign copy area shall be completely enclosed within the monument materials. e. No portion of the sign or sign structure shall exceed ten feet above ground level. f. The monument sign base shall be constructed of materials similar in appearance to those of the principal structure and shall consist of brick, natural stone, stucco, textured cast stone, or integrally colored concrete masonry units. The structure surrounding the face of the sign from the base to the top of the sign must be solid, continuous, and consist of the base materials or complementary materials that match the appearance and color of the principal building. g. The 200 square feet of ground area around the base of the monument sign shall be landscaped with shrubs or perennials. (Code 1984, § 10.61(1); Ord. No. 97 2nd series, §§2, 3, 8-26-1991; Ord. No. 6 3rd series, § 1, 4-26-2004; Ord. No. 35 3rd series, §§ 1, 2, 11-13-2006; Ord. No. 70 3rd series, § 1, 4-26-2010) Sec. 78-1467. Signs in R districts. Within R districts, the following signs are permitted: (1) Nameplates. a. One nameplate sign for each dwelling, and such sign shall not exceed two square feet in area per surface, and no sign shall be so constructed as to have more than two surtaces. b. One nameplate sign for each dwelling group of six or more units, and such sign shall not exceed six square feet in area per surface, and no sign shall be so constructed as to have more than two surfaces. c. One nameplate sign for each permitted use or use by conditional permit other than residential, and such sign shall not exceed 12 square feet in area per surface. (2) lllumination. Symbols, statues, sculptures and integrated architectural features on nonresidential buildings may be illuminated by floodlights provided the direct source of light is not visible from the public right-of-way or adjacent residential district. (3) Setbacks. Any sign over one-half square foot shall be set back at least five feet from any property line. No sign shall exceed eight feet in height above the average grade level. Signs may be illuminated, but such lighting shall be diffused or indirect. (4) Home occupations. One nameplate sign containing name and address but not to contain business name or type of business, and such sign shall not exceed two square feet in area per surface, nor contain more than two surfaces. (Code 1984, § 10.61(2); Ord. No. 221 2nd series, § 5, 9-23-2002) Sec. 78-1468. Signs in B and I districts. Within the B and I districts, wall and monument signs are permitted subject to the following regulations: (1) 8-1, B-2 and 8-4:size. Within the B-1, B-2 and B-4 districts, the aggregate square footage of sign space per lot shall not exceed the sum of one square foot for each front foot of building, plus one square foot for each front foot of lot not occupied by a building. No individual sign shall exceed 50 square feet. (2) 8-3:size. Within the B-3 district, the aggregate square footage of sign space per lot shall not exceed the sum of four square feet per front foot of building, plus one square foot per front foot of property not occupied by a building. No individual sign surface shall exceed 100 square feet. (3) 1:Within the I District, signs shall be permitted according to the regulations in section 78-832. (4) 8-1, 8-2 and 8-4:height. Within the B-1, B-2 and B-4 districts, no sign shall extend in height more than two feet above the highest outside wall or parapet of any principal building, nor shall any sign be located closer than ten feet from any property line; except that any sign over ten square feet may project two feet into any required yard area from the principal building. (5) B-3 and 1:height. Within any B-3 or l district, no sign shall extend in height more than six feet in height above the highest outside wall or parapet of any principal building. No sign shall be located closer than ten feet from any property line, except that any sign exceeding ten square feet may project only finro feet into the yard area from any building. (Code 1984, § 10.61(3); Ord. No. 6 3rd series, §2, 4-26-2004; Ord. No. 32 3rd series, § 5, 3-27-2006) Secs.78-1469--78-1490. Reserved. , ► Navarre Lanes J�u�-y 1 oth,ao i i R��EjVE� Mayor&City Council `�A� � 9 2u 11 City of Orono Cl� 2750 Kelly Parkway �F�RONp Orono,MN 55356 Dear Mayor&City Council: T'hank you for again for your help and support of my dream of re-opening Navarre Lanes. We have currently run into an issue that I hope we can work together to resolve with our signage. Per city code we need to have a monument sign on the frontage of Shoreline Drive&Kelly Ave. We are working on plans to have a permanent `Monument Sign',but current weather(snow)and ground frost conditions would make it impossible for us to have the sign constructed properly,with footings,until sometime in May 201 l after the frost is out of the ground. I am requesting an appeal to the city code to allow us to continue to use the`Temporary Sign' until weather conditions will allow us to build the `Permanent Sign' in May of 201 l. I feel we wili suffer business loss if we cannot have some type of signage on the Shoreline Dr.frontage for the next few months. We currently,per city guidelines,have a temporary sign on the corner of Kelly& Shoreline Drive to help customers know that we are now open and point them in the direction of our parking lot. Per city code,we are only allowed to have the `Temporary Sign' for the duration of 40 days. (If you are not familiar with our location,we are located in the basement of a strip mall and access to our pazking lot is off of Kelly Ave. Without the current`temporary signage',it would be almost impossible for new customers to find our location.) Please feel free to contact me with any questions or concerns. T'hank you. Sincere� i .j t.------�� Barry Tanner/Navarre Lanes 3435 Shoreline Drive= Navarre MN 55391 ^ Phone:612.916.0223�btrace3�msn.com � , . Hennepin County Property Map Print Hennepin County Property Map - Tax Year: 2011 The data conWined on this page is derived from a compilation of records and maps and may contain dlscrepancies that can only be disdosed by an accurete survey performed by a licensed land surveyoc The penmeter and area(square footage and acres)are approzimates and may contain discrepancies.The information on this page should be used for reference purposes only. Hennepin County does not guarantee the accuracy of material hereim m�tained and is not responsible for any misuse or misrepresentation of[his informaYion or its deriva[ives. � ;�,;��.,, � f � .. . `� - �y � � � �:+;�� '� I ,r - _l:l, :lUG .;G2 � 3�ib� �. _11U 3d ;�;�► ��-. , � w� � _ - , i,; !^ � �.�.' �' � I' . � SHORELINE DR . . � . j�� . .i }.::- . . . . . � 'e` � • � .y � . . .. � '4#..F ` . . ., T#. v��: � + , A '�-" .�.'� �1 ,, �� - � �� : � ti �. �. , E; . , ,.r.., . , , �: � � .. � , - - ; , �� `' �i _ ' �� 'LL , —��'i � � 51�� . �r`��. ( ( 1 _ . � \ � " I� r •,: � i �' � _- .��n._n�.�� ir�.. ,��'� . � _ 'j '�� N y+�+`^ � � �i ,^y ':�� , � ; � �3. s � , • �� i.�� l' � ' — : '' , ': �, �, y� . ,� , ,.� _ � � ' ,� i ; 'wr,�.. `�',� �, �� ..;,: '�r., � ''t , , - i�.t �� y� +-� � �� ;y ,'� tt.' �, . �,��'"��, ��'��. � � . _ �. �..:�� . �. � �: . ,� , �. F,�,�: � . � ,_ ;, - _. __ - � ��,�, � � s�.,, "� �4'. ��' '� ��' .r , ,.. *�4: �- S y�( y`{,� �g� 11� .£i' ��"�, ' '*� .�» �+. n�.� � £ _ "� � .. .i 4�� i's �i�� ' ,:��t� • � � ��j � ' . �� t •t • . . 3!t,� 'i�, ' � �'�.{�g� F•�T�� I��.'�k � ��` ,� �Z e � � i. , �• r./y�`yy, ..�"'`?� 'a �R. -�f _ , ..� � � � �. 'X' L4 (� �y,} j . � �� .�� . �. T . .:v` .`�'; � � ��` s � x ,�'��f'\� �`1s1��'� I -' k. '` ��, t.i;�' `: �s1 �. i . � ,. . w� � 'k ' y � } �}�. � $�+� �. ,1 `�`+� � x'� � � � � � w ��[�"h�� +�. � � R i +� ,� ` -- {��"!f� •'�t J I ��' .�_ � t r..,y�� ; �L, � �y . � ,�•' J ��,c� � � +.c . � . ,�� ^ �i � �� _ ,ii=� � r� . Y �� ,. - ._ . l� .� .. . . . �.�\, . ..�' Selected Parcel Data Date Printed:9/1/2011 9:47:54 AM �', Parcel ID: 20-117-23-12-0034 Current Parcel Date: 8/3/2011 � Owner Name: BROOK INVESTMENT GROUP LLC I'. I' Parcel Address: 3423 SHORELINE DR,ORONO,MN 55391 i Property Type:COMMERCIAL-PREF Sale Price: $1,700,000.00 � Homestead: NON-HOMESTEAD Sale Date: 11/2007 Area (sqft): 69879 Sale Code: WARRANTY DEED ;'� Area (acres): 1.60 ; A-T-B:TORRENS i Market Total: $760,000.00 ;; Tax Total: $23,500.20 i' I:.. http://gi s.co.hennepin.mn.us/HCPropertyMap/Locator.aspx