HomeMy WebLinkAbout#3478-variances/site plan-1994 . : ,��,�� ���� ��� ��� ��9 y
�' ��' CITY of ORONO _
O .. O . -� .C 3
��.
�;��T� > RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL � '�---
� Z������ ti r r o. 3 a '� �
'� �'� , `.'� �j~' .
�`�k�E8H�g'�
A RESOLUTION GR.ANTING
VARIANCES TO MUNICIPAL ZONING CODE
SECTION 10.22, SUBDIVISION 2, SECTION 10.41, SUBDIVISION 5 (A),
SECTION 10.41, SUBDIVISION 9 (B), SECTION 10.41, SUBDIVISION 10 (D),
SECTION 10.56, SUBDIYISION 16 (L) AND SECTION 10.41, SUBDIVISION 2
AND APPROVES A SECOND AMENDMENT OF COMNIERCIAL
SITE PLAN FOR SAILORS WORLD, INC.
FTLE #1947
WHEREAS, Gary DeSantis of Sailors World Marina and Yacht Club, Inc., a
Minnesota corporation (hereinafter "the applicant") has an interest in the property located at
1955 Shoreline Drive within the City of Orono (hereinafter "the City") and legally described as
follows:
Exhibit A, attached (hereinafter "the property"); and
`D��.�.
WHEREAS, on S�ep�erfiber 13, 1993 the City council approved Resolution#3371
that granted variances to allow the uistallation of an 8'x20' accessory storage module to be
located within parking stall 34; and
WHEREAS, the applicant has filed an amended variance application that would
seek to relocate the storage module within another acceptable parking stall located out of the
lakeshore protected area that would require approval of the following variances to Municipal
Zoning Code Section 10.22, Subdivision 2, Section 10.56, Subdivision 16(L) and Section 10.41,
Subdivision 10 (D) to permit a change in the nature of existing hardcover in the 75-250' zone
which contains 5,100 s.f. or 83.6% hardcover as approved in Resolution No. 2891 of the City
Council, where only 1,525 s.f. or 25% hardcover would normally be allowed, and for a variance
to Section 10.41, Subdivision 5 (A) to allow a further reduction of one parking stall from the
42 stalls approved in Resolution No. 2891 which granted a variance to the 48 stalls required for
this site, and for a variance to Section 10.41, Subdivision 9 (B) to allow a 10' street yard
setback for a storage structure where a 50' street setback would normally be required (original
Application #1874 proposed 28' setback); and per Section 10.41, Subdivision 2 seeks approval
of an amended commercial site plan to allow the installation of said storage module.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE TT RESOLVED by the City Council of Orono,
Minnesota: .
Page 1 of 9
' F�rm SO05 D�u(
� ��' CITY of ORONO_.
O ..� O � . � ,
�:'�T� RESOLUTION OF THE EITY COUNCIL
�'l� �' � 347 �
'�,+ �� ,�� � NO.
, r�,, Gti►
����, , � g�
�E3II�
FINDINGS
1. This application was reviewed as Zoning File #1947.
2. The Orono City Council granted variances and approved an amended commercial
site plan for the applicant (Zoning Application #1874) per Resolution #3371 on
December 13, 1993. Pursuant to that resolution, the storage module has been
temporarily placed within stall 34 but applicant has received complaints from
property owner to the west noting visual impact upon lake views.
3. The applicant has filed the cunent application in order to seek approval of an
amended variance application with the purpose of relocating the storage module
in another parking stall that would lessen the visual impact upon the lake views
of the property owner to the west.
4. At the Council meeting of August 22, 1994 Council approved the use of either
stalls 37 or 38 because of their alignment behind the principal structure on the
� property. Council's recommendation was based on the following findings:
A. Placement of the structure within either stalls 37 or 38 will minimize
impact upon lake views of residence to the immediate west.
B. Structure will be located out of the lakeshore setback area.
C. Relocation to either stall 37 or 38 will not result in the loss of additional
stalls.
D. Less visual impact upon users of adjacent County Road as only 8' side
would be exposed to roadway.
E. There will be no sighting problems at intersection.
5. Noted in the earlier review for Application#1874, in order to compensate for the
loss of the single parking stall which reduces the number of spaces to 41 where .
42 were approved, the applicant has provided a letter from the Minnetonka Art
Center located approximately 1/4 miles west of the marina for overflow parking
use. �
Page 2 of 9
f�<��„�;.
� ��' CITY of ORONO
O -., O . -.
��'��T� RESOLUI'ION OF TI� CITY COUNCIL .
� �',r � � No. 3 4 7"8
i :�°'�'� ti .
"�� r � ' ' G'�'
�
�9�ES80g�
6. The proposed relocation for storage module within either parkin� stalls 37 or 38
will place the structure out of the lakeshore setback zones of both the City of
Orono and the DNR.
7. The location of the storage module at 10' from the County Road 15 right-of-way
where a 50' setback is normally required, is a location that is extremely visible
from said roadway and therefore visual screening of the module by use of
evergreen type vegetation is imperative to reduce the negative visual impacts.
8. Based on the intent of Municipal Code Section 10.41, Subdivision 7 (B) required
landscape areas shall not be used for the storage of boats, equipment, or
materials. The proposed storage module will provide storage such that none of
the landscape areas per the approved site plan for this facility need not be
encumbered with storage of any kind. .
9. The City Council has considered this application including the fmdings and
recommendations of the Planning Commission, reports by City staff, comments
by the applicant and the effect of the proposed variance on the health, safety and
welfare of the community.
10. The City Council finds that the conditions eacisting on this properry are peculiar
to it and do not apply generally to other property in this zoning district;..that
granting the variance would not adversely affect tra�c conditions, light, air nor
pose a fire hazard or other danger to neighboring property; would not merely
serve as a convenience to the applicant, but is necessary to alleviate a
demonstrable hardship or difficulty; is necessary to preserve a substantial properry
right of the applicant; and would be in keeping with the spirit and intent of the
Zoni.ng Code and Comprehensive Plan of the City.
CONCLUSIONS, ORDER AND CONDTTIONS
Based upon one or more of the findings noted above, the Orono City Council
hereby grants the variances as set forth above and approves the proposed amendment of
Resolution #3371 that approved the placement of an 8'x8'x20' storage module within parlcing
sta1134 and now grants a variance that would allow the relocation of said storage module within
either stalls 37 or 38, subject to the following conditions:
Page 3 of 9
Fmn SCOS O�u Cr
� ��' CITY of ORO
O . . O NO-.-. .
�� :���, .
a ���., ,�, � RESOLUTION OF THE G�TTY COUNCIL
,�, � :��'� ti rro. � 4 7 8 .
. , ti
��9�� ' Og�G �
EsH
1. �Cine 8'x8'x20' storage module may be relocated within either parking stalls 37
or 38 per the site plan attached to this resolution as page number 8. The City
Council reserves the right to reconsider and revise this approval at a future time
if the storage module becomes a nuisance.
2. The storage module shall be free standing and shall have no foundation in order
to preserve its mobility.
3. The storage module shall be screened from street view by an integrated landscape
plan, page 9 of this resolution, and that shall include evergreen plantings of a size
and spacing to provide at least a 50% screening of the module in the first year,
with potential in three years to be 100% screened along the County Road 15 side
(west) and the north side. Screening shall not be allowed to interfere with
required sighting distance for vehicles entering and exiting the property.
4. The module shall remain on the site only as long as an off-street parking
agreement with the Art Center or other entity remains in effect.
5. In conjunction with the approval of this storage module, no storage of materials,
equipment, or boats shall occur in any of the non-hardcover landscape areas
indicated on the site plan. �
6. Violation of or non-compliance with any of the terms and conditions of this
resolution shall constitute a violation of the zoning code, shall automatically
terminate any authoriry granted herein,�and shall be punishable as a misdemeanor.
7. The undersigned applicant has read, understood and hereby agrees to the terms
of this amended resolution and on behalf of himself, his heirs, successors and
assigns, hereby agrees to the recording of this resolution in the Chai.n of Title of
the properry.
Page 4 of 9
r�soas o���
M w► �
� ��' CITY of ORONO
O ,,. O
�:�,�� � RESOLUTION OF TF� CITY COUNCIL
� �,�,,��'� ti rro. � 4 '7 $ -
� �
t��9� f og�G .
ESS
Adopted by the City Council of the City of Orono, Minnesota at a regular meeting
held on the lOth day of October, 1994.
A T:
.
,
y M. a i ity lerk w J. Callaha r., Mayor
,;
Pro erty w r (s)
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
The foregoing instrument was acknowledged before me on this lOth day of
October, 1994 by Edward J. Callahan, Jr. and Dorothy M. Hallin, Mayor and City Clerk of the
City of Orono, a Minnesota municipal corporation and said instrument was executed on behalf
of the City.
l�i� � v�''�
' Notary Public
� L7NDA S. VEE
NOTARY PUBUC- MINNESOTA
HEIVNEPIN COUNTY
�:. My comrr,isston expires&12-98
Page 5 of 9 �
fam 5005 DisM 0�
. . . 1r' , r
� ��' CITY of ORONO
O_� O
�:��.�� � � RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COUNCIL
� ���� � rro. . 4 '7 R -.
� �� ti
,�, � . Gti
�9xE3II�g�
\
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this 9 � day of lJ e c e m h e� , 199 � before me a Notary
Public within and for said county,persona l ly appeared �a ✓ �� S�n-h�s So/e D u�her'
known to me to be the perso (s) described in and who executed
the foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free
act and deed.
-- E G�`� iC! � (/ie�-i
LINDA S. VE
"'�'"� NOTAP.Y PUBUC - MINNESOTA NOTARY PUBLIC
�``'��' HE�INEPIN COUNT'r
�''i.;,I My comRi9slon axpires 8-12-96
STATE OF MINNESOTA ) ,
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this day of , 199 before me a Notary
Public within and for said county,personally appeared
known to me to be the person(s) described in and who executed
the foregoing instrument, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free
act and deed.
� NOTARY PUBLIC
Page 6 of 9 �
Form 5005 DisN 0��.
� ��' CITY of ORONO _.
O _.,. O : - . � .
�:�T� x�soLv�riorr oF � errY covlvcII.
� '�`��°�� �" rro. 3 4 '7 R �.
;, .. �ti
r '
'�'�9x�, � og�G
ES?rI
\
STATE OF NIINNESOTA ) �
) ss.
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this 9 � day of �J e�e m h e� , 199 � before me a Notary
Public within and for said county,personally appeare d —a D e S��-h�s Sa�e o wner'
known to me to be the perso (s) described in and who executed
the foregoing instniment, and acknowledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free
act and deed.
--- � (/��
c+''�;•.,. LINDA S. VEE G���/
1'"� NOTAP.Y PUBLIC - MINN°SOTA
:�-'�.- NOTARY PUBLIC
HEyNEPIN COUN7'f
��►� My comrrisston expires 8-12-98
STATE OF MINNESOTA )
) ss. '
COUNTY OF HENNEPIN )
On this day of , 199 before me a Notary
Public within and for said county,personally appeared
known to me to be the person(s) described in and who executed
the foregoing insmiment, and acl�owledged that he (they) executed the same as his (their) free
act and deed.
NOTARY PUBLIC
Page 6 of 9 �
►o�soas o��c•
,� , . � ,
h
• � 4 �' � .
�,xxzBZT �
' C�ntral Avenue
Commencing at the intersection °f rit of�athlineeof County P.oad No. 7
o wi�h Easterly rig y � � feet to actual
extended East_rly 42 degrees 15 minutes East 1--�-0 �ast 29.04 feet
thence Northeas�erly 57 aegr�es 45 �ninut_s
point of beginning �henc� Sou`n �
�
'- 130 feet to �he in�ersec�iog
=�es 50 minute�s��ona�d Easterly �hence Nvrth
thence North 37 deg venue qZ Qegrees 1�
oF North line of Grand A
Totions,� "�� pAP.K"
degrees 95 minutes West 18 fe innlnenincluding a�er y
131 .5 feet t° beg g riinnesota, (hereinafter "the
minutes West � „ gennepin County, .
pN LAKE MINrJ�TONKA � .
property" ) ; and
Page 7 of 9
� . .
�...-y;�"l\ �/ / .
�•yv '�"� /�l�':,,� �� .• �- l,i� �����1 ���� • , •' !r-f ,/ / •)
��'�/ ,.�� .� - :�-. ,jr_ c �. {/6�!) a:
. �Jt .�1 �,�I�� . .l .i> �� 1 �� ' . .. . � �J f{ . �)
�. NV� 1.� �� ' - 'i � � �i• '1• � '��1 .`. ,���' .. --......a /
� i .�) ��: � - `% �. ' -•��� �� . . � � _ / i
;,o� � . .: �,: ��`�,., � �c� y� :,� _ . • 4 ; �,� �
~ � f ��f�,. _ � _�>`i` � T t•`'\ .� I \ ' � y. I
��;� . n�.� t '; ; , ,�� . �, 'S� ��J� /,1l�y.�� S � ^'� _ \ 1 \��-�'��Itt.�� , ���
4:�` � ' "��� . . . . �j� •i /r,�� ' 1 1�� � / 1 r•~ �
•�?t, f �� ;.. ;�' . . .t • ,,� 1��-�L'r� �-'J' / ��?� � _ _-...,. ! �����r��.,� fJ_ �.
'I J��� t �J t � �• ;•' � w _,�
�..� � i � :• ' • � �� > >=-=..�:: .�---•---- _ -
.•.J`�1'''3��,1��F ''.j�:'",' . . • -. i �- ���'�.h 'S� /irlr[:S j�z-«Nuv,�l��lv w t� ` �
��• _: , • �u4 . . 3 ..f ( " -`" '' 2 ` 4� . _ �' ;� i
l�/ �'�� •• . `;� �:�'''� . � I o z � x� _ � �� � �� � '
Ll� .I':1!/ -c �r (' , 'f -Y ' w _ x i ��`;r J � P
�'�/ •.�"'t• U3.i�'�.uni✓] 3 / � i ll ; < � � �� - ----_ •, •r 1��`� \ �-
� � o S:� ✓f .)v��. �' � . �
� � 'f` �•<. ~ . .� .�$1.:UH�I �Q.1 �� .._--S-- - •---- --- } ;n � :i 'r 3°, ur�i��r� L °�� +i� j, C
�I �� ' •.� S . ••u :�:?Jq. ti Sa hV( U.�YY�l7 Li:1�10'J.II -� U �� � O]ff*iO1J ���+2 j � V
`` :.;. � `� ` � ann v�,un 4 � � � 1 l ' .� ��_ � _ �., :` �
� �. �i � �'>1'�ZI 11)i�14o1�'� � � • ' �
_ � - 4 � • � v- l��/ t ��'• �
� ' J w .,' a /�� .. .���� / , . . •� . _. .r.'�-. �/ �� �
�` -:� .1.�'�l� � � �d(15.�1\�151v'd1�Nt-ti1 _ �,- _ , �.� o _ r-' `i .,`
_ l Q-j :•, •_ 1 �.� • ��'�--�.1_� . , �J� :�N411?1S�O-.i� -�-, '- . � � !. . `,3 2
�; `� . _ �' � � ' �.I�7�?.7:�J1� . � __ -- _. . , �r . �j ' w
� G..•' �', � � �1��= � ' `� -1�._.. ti �-�,l / 1-� �\ � � �
� t � l � �-..
e` ` • �j � � / / �` ` b'i• 9a� � U� u
. . f� ). /� /,/:/// ' / " � � �,1 � —�G: ' �}'�' a� ,U O
; �. Y � ` . � / ;/�//j� �• --�;----' — –�– , . _ - _ ; �.� . `;5�:
` _ i- � /�/ j / S•�rti15 O�• _ �s ��n � u. �.�� •�L�! O� c
I . ; ; :-', �� � �„�.:�+,. .I _^_ —� =�
�� `� � ��` � -�� ._ j",Z.��L,.O.��� � -�u�rl V�.u�i ^- --- . � - \ r� .'
� "•+_�; - oy . e � � ��i•''.�./�j --� � �r � ���� .• . ` . . ��r!� � w�. [�
; cv' p �% ' ../ / r ,r-:ctdt�t'JItoJ: � - `i. '_' ., o` t` l y�` -
• - �- � 1. ^ , ` �� ) `
� . a�i �� �7'J(1:%1T�.1 Ll I M.�vdC �s. \ �U�L�"/� 1 �,y 21_. 'r 1� , . L`� � �� •� �
� = \ J'S� 1 -'-^ -- � -a! .___..f� _� 1.. . . , � S' �J ' .
� T I j' �. .
n � � __.__ �/i 1 � � 1� � � .
�S � � � . �7� �,!G lt� ;j, ' S N,� n �.I.�-�� .1�' �� � �1 'i- �= � p.= �„ � - "
_.,-;.
2 � 1~ ! /' 1.� "�Y •� ��..y� � '\ �� .n ,9� 1 �
v , `` r �y 1 � _�. '
o 'r -- ?- :`�d'Jdl•�u11�5�1� Ull,l ' � tl '— � . . / •��,�� �
t: �� 1l1 ~ �� �� � •1[ � ' i . � '�.. �I'�� `- � � i
o ��. �p Y l �3'S�o)-�33J ��Iittt��ll,l r 1 2�`� � .�,,,/
`� � "' dt t! �c
l� i•�o ,'Fs 1'R ��"�: ldi UU.Y.Y.J'+� �' �!� �_" __ �, ' •. i7 p� 3 . .
. •� •,yj�� L` � / L3 _'fn��f►G:� i, �C� �• 1� t]]r_ . �,�_!vUY:.wPCJ �(�' p��Ji� .j� •%.,
u / O � - — --".� ,.+- � \- � � � � P �� 0� ��'\ J �^ �
�\ �� .. � '�' ��. � - - - -- - � �•'�' � 1'� 2 / , 09 � / ',
1� V • __ �� � �'" o. tr ��e• � � ''�ti�/7, .r�� � ,,- � `_� .�� '`':;1
4 '� Y-)v L 'J l. 1)fJ✓/l i. 1n �Zf�"r�i,.� � '�t •'�}� ��l:l`� `��•
��� a• �f ��- � Q -- � �'��__ �\I — �'1�C.'y0/\` ' ��� � ��.� � �� \.
�.� •� t(� � �-+ , '�/1✓-t�l 1!�� J�.� ' �
�_" \ � \�� I f l --.1.1/.lu ti � � .�
► . 1''_-3n iLU--� � - ���( It ��� 1���� u�st.tu.l! l _ U�'D{l . � ....
• '-� 1 U�TSO..V YJ , . .. " l {�' .� ....
(- -t'O�1C1 • �__ � ' l �� 't
- � . -ti'S'tSZ-•- -_..... �� . ---� ._..- ._._ 1
�I'. ,�,.l ��?o`� � 1 S i 7y 7 (1�'���� ��U?�j,� ������oiJ��ij— _.....___.. �' ao 5i;i..K _.....�. . . � � 1 . . . //` �
� a �, � c� . : i
1 � ,.� ../
� � • �u:�i .:t�l fo :v�t���u» i�jir.� l���c:��d p��rJa 1se� iv� (C �'!1;�4 t �f�)�,� IP
!. \ (-----' --.__..----:'�-==y`=--=---��'--"�_�-�----��, ' ,� `� , ' � .
`� � .� �� �'}7� Cl ("" i�' "��' � J .� ��'• (S1 0;!�(,y u� ;n u..par i.rii) W
�, � �1 �� � V � i� �1` 1pi l%) � <_> L v►t he�«;f�ll 1,�.,�,� Jo ',1�
}' �J - o - '--'..__ .— • __ � '_.�^'^..1'j °y _
`�� � �I ��` f_ --- -.. �I��/��- -------.- -1- J��.; .(:��`��4�=`s- . �-
.�. ��1 �'�__._._ _. .____..--��--� ._�.�.. ��y --- �--__.__ �-� +=
) . �
_`..;�S _ .�r�••.'f:�:'�T:���_� �f� ��w�'z ,�_�,::,�� � t��- � � _ � •...q.r y�t' � '• L e}�'-'. �s"�'. r:���f.��`7
.::�.t .ti ,� F =`3.�� Y 'i t t� ti :�+ • • '� •; �_�..'�:: ` �{`'7T��E�
��.. .�_�- { . �.-X'r'� -��y, � t 7- � ! .�' ��: s . � -. . � . ��' �t.: � � �'�-t>'ts.o:"'t.'
•. 7�' f . ,ir+,-a c-�-� .i _ :.... � '�� .`� _ . y. >.:. ..� a , �3..h�-�`.�fi
f JS�+C� f ' -i- '�b . s .�.p' i�b. ..Y.t�:
.. Zs ��.1;� tr�� ! r`��`F �iv ; � .. - . _ - -_ . _ .
.♦
t,. .r r iP..'.. -�::,k.Ti' ' . �. '•�%�^"�:.. ' ! ' 'd.-� � . � • � � .r �J »,� � y .�
X- . .�' 1� :a. �.� _n� . l+,'. �.:}:�i'!.��"" . . .. `°...j`a� .;. :� �� -y.: ' `sr, :. y' r.� •� jl_�
��r
. ' ' � ' Y� r . . � �. , _ a . � .` �' `' y".
. .�.;��+•J,��•-��� � r�`' it,{X• '1��r`„ t � t.�, {.�� - i .,; t_ � `. � -r � � r���
� �r � ��,,�r� ♦'v ti. 1 �.. 1. � . .. . .
� :� �.,-L � _. ���{ F.,�:a:
`_�. �� .,�'r+� ��. xt•� � .'+ ,t�... � 'r.vs� ` • ., . . �y � .. - � '*. � ..1� j }'.
•��b � 4" 1. ! � � f. .1 Y . . . .. '., � � •�••
�i�. �S}`�`.'-t Y � ;':'G,�'`'�f'.�'�� � ` ;:y `'. . � � . .� : �� . . - � � . - �r� ��-�'.V- '� ` ' `�`;
. •�t '.dl�l'�}y�. . . . .. ..
. ' - � . 'l� : ~ , : . • - • _ • .. . '� ' _ � '
� .4 '.�;•,�. -t' 'f� .. • � '
wJ►#��-�- . .�- _ ,� �� =- ��. . -. - ` � . . � ...-
�- .y °:'- �l ?�ll ��
. _'. . � '�.: � �'I , ,- ..•� , . . . . <• _ ' . . -. ' .
.•�. .' � '•� ' � J ` � . . !� . . '. .. .��_ '. . � .
� ,• . ... . . _�C� . ._
. . . . • . . _ .. <. • - . �
��� �'� • .. - . . . , '
� ` � . - ��' `y � �Z � . - . . . .
- . ; . . . � � �"� ��-��- � ' � .
� ' � .. . . j - . .
; � �
, t
. \� � .
� � � ;- .
_ \,;
� ��.
. � � ��. � ��3� � , + ��J , 'Le � � i
� _ � . , ..- - • _ .
\y�
\
' � �� ��
..lr_�e0�1� -��E �—'nt-�'�^
�'� '
�+�� .�},r� �c,s��ib- -���'��''' . . �
,• oacla Q nf 9 . . ,