|
HgUOM V. MS IXMtfM pmnit mciilioMa.
<br />i« and !* In 1«2 tlie village by condemimtion ^
<br />icV of tx- cocilingj accluiicd for parlt „ ,)y
<br />x,,r,;n ,1.0 ,o ,1.c of .1.0 ,
<br />. V “ ‘ ■. • . 1 • I .1 *■,■• V ! • •■* ' * '
<br />. ' ’ n ‘ <1 < •
<br />lit
<br />.•.•.<•> t I; i..' ».
<br />... l!.
<br />; -itf
<br />1Vu ! • * "
<br />>1 A 'X •'•.<-•.:.:x
<br />,0 o'C . Min - i >-r ‘.J t ' f ■
<br />V :t.i i« I’ ^
<br />'p ! ‘t Vu ! • \'‘* S , .
<br />• ■» fr. 1- .. .* : !S of .11 oAii.;iS of VC.',I nciil' iv. a • : /; ,,f n..:cii.:ivuii con-
<br />■ ,iio '■o^^1lol^. lot,>•.^,o.llot1.ou^c .••...do,,Jo)•
<br />"•“’ ! ,nc.,t of ,1.0 .il'an.... .isl.,5 p.-vloBOS
<br />Kf ;o«! Z I atcr-.1.o r.^Iroad quhclaimod ... r.gh,.
<br />of way to tlic village.
<br />I ownor of Enough appears from •’'**||!!
<br />L! horo ta- plomomod Vp th. orrf «P
<br />Uwis B»y. .on the srgumcM »
<br />illjin^B^trn ^iVrwft nf iwiunf
<br />•bitformt aociatioa. yitmMf
<br />thereto Cited lot ooner^ nndcrteol^ y^^rhWd _ *—«• A* tk* waM te io onettiono It pfOVMM
<br />.•itlMaUM
<br />-------
<br />•J t (\
<br />$. a
<br />lUun. 7 XOTITU WK.STKHN lUU’OHTKn. ?fl {:!• P.IK3
<br />.■r ., .. ., p
<br />: . • /, c t. \ • ' *j -
<br />f f « *
<br />n,i T.- n n, n.v;.
<br />I f .’UV ..* I f,
<br />.• M. ; V
<br />:* ,-i I-I
<br />, r .
<br />j,-,.,:..r. f-.r ’l.<* : ' i ;-. •>' L'*:
<br />.'ll ' I'ltr V'- 1.1 •' 'U *'IV '. ®!* ' ".
<br />ifiOi t 1 : ''i''> '.Wu:*! • v '1. M I'V ^ ■'''
<br />cVf^nr:Mrc ;;’aO •.i.'‘'iV;:icd il.o i-r,rk?.;;j or
<br />of Tiny horit fiv ’.vatcri rft, t.xct^jit
<br />at liic f’(»cl: owr.c'l :in(l rna ’nt.v.m <l l>y tl>«
<br />vill.'ijc, for which a ^jcinvt coaling two
<br />dollars per boat for a season was required,
<br />ill, upon, or adjacent to the park in ques-
<br />lion or any other lands owned by it.
<br />Defendant as mayor of the village caused
<br />the ordinance and other regulation*, the
<br />l«rcctse nature of which are not made to
<br />appear, to be enforced. He collected the
<br />fees for dodc permits* which he turned over
<br />10 the villH« treasurer. At hit >nst^^
<br />the village narthal prevented platiitift
<br />from docking hie boot ot the vitlage hiM
<br />dodc because ^intitf failed to obtam the
<br />aeemsafy permit to om the
<br />13S feat of bathing beadi m roped o«
<br />•ag boats were otwnd ed from that nr^
<br />It is them acta of dtfondaiii which pla^
<br />tiff daima ooostitnlt an intcrforcuec with
<br />hia ripariaa lidktk
<br />Tht vilhgo it governed bjr
<br />14Sb which an for as here ma^nal in | 21
<br />* _______“ mmnnmo aal
<br />pfWIQCl
<br />*C A
<br />. *is < ^
<br />! .a v>c .•!
<br />/!y : .M,
<br />>Tooentmi and protect the pafo
<br />• • • porka • • •
<br />_ k___
<br />diacontimii aama). * *
<br />if SSiSL
<br />A ’ ^ ^ t \
<br />! • . ‘J u
<br />:.-*t * » ' * ‘-
<br />- .v; V.,^ ! V-.,
<br />; ■■■/ To iCi' d ; .'I d
<br />!•*!. v;-.l or i’jTn. n !'."Vi ; ..d.
<br />fcii'.il to 1 crijoyu by p , ••ous k
<br />iiitcrcsl in the i>* Ijijii;;’! ):p;ui.'U c-tJ'.fc, *■’*_*-
<br />Ihoul.haw V. Duluth To.pcvi.d Mill Co., .'2
<br />Miim. S9, 53 N.W. mG; Cilb-rt v. Hl-
<br />diidgc, 47 Minn. 710, 49 N.W. 679, 13^ L.
<br />R..-\. 411; Miller v. ^^c•.Klcnhnll, 43 Minn.
<br />95, 44 N.W. 1141, 8 L.R.A. 89, 19 Am.St.
<br />Rep. 219: Hanford v. St. Paul & Duluth
<br />R. Co., 43 Minn. 104, 42 N.W. 596, 44 NAV,
<br />1144, 7 L.R.A. 722 (on rcargumenp. We
<br />shall assume also^ without deciding, die
<br />question that plaintiff may mainum this
<br />action separately against defendant for
<br />aett done by him aa mayor of the viHagc.
<br />(2-41 I. Navigability and nonnav^-
<br />bOity mark the distinction between pi^
<br />He and private waters. The state, in ita
<br />aover eign capadty, as tmstco for ^
<br />pie, holds an navigable waters and the tends
<br />them for public use. PubUeuseco^
<br />prdicnds not only navigation by watercraft
<br />lor oommcrcial purpose^ but ^ nso^
<br />for Iht ordinary pnrposca •( hfo such at
<br />boatiim. fowiiiig, Aatimr. hathmfc taking
<br />^oomMic or agnAnral pur-
<br />ootck and cutting ioc. Snhbom v. Feo-
<br />'^lea Co!ttSinn.43^fftRW.Ml. 51
<br />^JUL t29, tl Am.St.lle^ 4W;
<br />State, » Minn. ISI, S3 N.W. H3t. IS
<br />LJLA. 67tk 38 Aln.St.lU^ S41; Docmd v.
<br />W Ml Wia. 22S, 193 N.W. 393* 31 AX.
<br />%9»i 41 CJ. Navgtt.
<br />rS-9] A ripnrian •wncr’t ri|^ f
<br />qBaKM rtstrieied, and sahordiMU lo^
<br />puramonnt rights of foe phMte. Asagamst
<br />the state, a riparian owner can cKeremo^
<br />gominimi or maho n valid gram of ngiM
<br />in watcra adjacent to riparian iMda or in
<br />the sohgmrgcd
<br />^I^CKcrcisc of the stalefo pai
<br />nSSS% riparian owner not os ‘may build
<br />teSJfowTTdit United Statmm ol
<br />„ paftienfor or
<br />State V. Xorror,
<br />817. MMb UtA.19MC;
<br />!
<br />V,i?.A. -Ml, •..•••a
<br />:• Mut’i '7. 'M., •
<br />' *. 4 b ../. n
<br />. V. 'A ,.t. Ill
<br />llh, 8 f . bA. 8C
<br />ii4 P.v’.^
<br />Ji.-rysfcrs only ri
<br />ics u'H led,. vtud
<br />rnoynt rights of.t
<br />thcl't.ate’s public i
<br />iiplrian owner r
<br />rcgdlatcs and lio
<br />ingl ligliM. Ifc
<br />Dttlbth Impenal
<br />N.W. 106^ wPf-
<br />nppication of the
<br />the Hparian owm
<br />on Lite
<br />i
<br />' .r- v;
|