10-10-2005 Council Packet - Laserfiche WebLink

Home Browse Search

MINUTES or TR£ OAONO FLANNING COMMISSION MltTlNG Moaday.Jttly 1S.2MS 6:00 o'docli |i.n. (MS4121 Nat r«wi Siloaa, CtallaMtf) Mhtim» SuNInfbniw! Oitm Uitl tMy «mM Umg IM rcvi«d ptona b«dr bdbfv IlM nmint OamnMfln prior lo proaaading with tha parldng itudy. KjIm iaqiiirad wMiar there wara any public oonwen ta conotming thia applicatioru Mania rmo^ 2914 Oaaco Foint Road, indieolad 4ia doca raaida in diii araa and raiaed a oonoom ngaidiiig the aafely ofpoople in On ana. iha noiaa gonaraled from the bar and trafTic, and the houn of adian aleotiol wtMld be aerved. Prccae tiaicd in her opinion the me morandum (him Police Chief Good ahould be givon more eonaidofation aa part of (hia appliealion Freoao oonmanlod it it importanl dial expanaion of Oiia buatneaa fin in with what the f«t of the oommoiiity wairta and noljuat Oie palrona of ihe buiiiien. Loia Hufflow, 3431 Lyrie Auaruia, alaled in har opinion the type of fence being propoaed for die rear aeadag ana doaaaotaiie gMaial>i deal wiOi her concoma regarding the noiae. IIimHow atMad aha would Uka to an fewar acaOng afeaa in the back pobo area, which could parhapa ba incieaaad over time. San Marfiald, 3453 North Shore Drive, indicated ha it a lortg-iinia reaideiil of hfevarra and ancouragad iha Ptamiing Commiaaion not to ndta an oppoituniiy to faiveal in Ow conenareial dialikl of Navarre. Marfidd aolcd Oda butinaai hia exfelad in Oiia area fer a adbNaadal nunibar of yaaif md Aould not be rcdiHfid to road aO On toning raqubaniMU Ibat now txifl ainet it axiaiad prior to ihoaa requiramenta being in affect Autoin Evana. 2497 Kolty Avenue, ftoiM ha ittidai in iha hooat Oiat to loeatod the doiCit ID Oiia buaineaa, and pointod out that iMa aria to mad aaieiailfeirvioehiiiinaia and not commarciat Ovana in thia area diould ba buabiaaaaf primaHly that providi icryicci lo fhe aurroundiito Evana nolad a conditional uae permit could ba grantod but that the fenowing feidinfi muto ba made: One, that it to not detrimentel to the pebNe Iwallh, toftty, or welfere of the aurrounding retodenta. Evai alaled tha report feom tha polioo chief ahowa thto tha buaineaa to dohirocntol to ihe reaidento aroiaid it Two, a ianot otoiarially ipjuriouo to proportica or improvcwaiito in tha vicinity. Evana iodieaiad he it uneble to open his windows during the cummertime due to the none from motoreyclos and other voMcks the! ptoroniac (hit busmen. Evans atotod the Planoing Gofnmiotion should cxemine (he overall bitotit ofOiia ^toriet, notiito diet Iho preposad bowling alley for ihto area htol been denied Evans ttolcd in hia view whot is beat fer Navwic ia a compnheiittve plan end (hot approval oflhisappikalion may impede feturedevdopmeot in Navi re. Evane puintod out the ieeunreiating to the need fee a coBHpie heniive plan and inadequate perking were previouity diacuand in 2003. rAoi? MlNUTRSOPTflE ORONO PLANNING COMMISSION MCITING Monday, July 18,2005 6:00 o'clock p.m. (•05-3121 Narrewf Saloon, Coa(Iaoed) Evana Mated this expansion is not necessary as an tmenily lo Ihc community and that it is pooible a targe number of potions to this busincu do not reside in Navarre. Evans stated (here it an organization called Neighbors for a Better Navaire that would like to ace a moratorium for this area and a comprehensive plan created that would allow for development that it more amenable to Navarre. Evans requestad lha Planning Commiation deny this application. Rcbeeca Lowe, 3295 Ctrman Road, staled currenUy the area is not pedestrian friendly and expressed concern that the expsnston of the busincia is not kid friendly. Lowe encouraged the City to make this area more pedestrian friendly. Valerie Coykendall, 2344 Olive Avenue, echoed the concerns ra»cd regarding the noise snd safety of children in the area. Brad 2507 Kelly Aveiue. tadiceted he sent a letter to the City end Ifwnlnl Mi1ce Oiffron for responding to (he issues he raised in hit letter. Hoyt expreaed a conoem that this project may ncpiivtly htipaei the other deveJopinent in die area. Hoyt staled the aeating m the front may not be possible given Oie doee proximity of (be street Mid (hat it may be difficult, if not impossible, to grow trees along the front of the building. Qiartee Nedkr, 2509 Kelly Avenue, indicated he has already aubmstted severil letters regarding this project, but noted he ie here to present a petition to the PUrnnmg Committion opposing this expansion pmject of the applicants. NMIcr tndicatod lha peUtion ilatoa that no outdoor seating should be approved by the city The June 20. 2005 memo from PoUee Chief Good is ample evidence that the owner has been unable to contain either (he none ineide die reatiufant or the notaes mode by the moiorcyclea of the customeis aa well as hie inability to keep motoccyclet from parking on the tidewatk. The me mo goes on to raiie additional public aaftty tiMiea with regards lo the outdoor seating. Any outdoor seating would require meny conditions, ^ as ifand when liquor would be permitted outoide, what hourt the patio would be doted, and othcri. just to name a few. Nadicr staled the owner hai a poor track record regarding his ibility to abide by the laws and matnet iona and that enfbamnent probteme will tncrcaia. Nkdler staled it is poor public policy lo sllow any outdoor aaaling under any circumaiancea. PACK! Sylvia Bertognoli, 2499 Kelly Avenue, staled she is in support of what Evans is attempting to secomplish. BertagnoH raised conoems rcgaidmg the safety of children and other citizens in the vicmily of the Narrows Saloon, eepectally wiih the propoaed outdoor seating in the front Phyllii O'Malley, 2740 Kelly Avenue, indiealed she hu resided in this sree for e number of years and relocatod here from New York. O'Malley ataled the owners ofthisbustncaa do Mve a right to expand but that there needa to be aome type of eap on the expansion. O'MiU^ staled the eovirooiiient of this area wee more conducive to raictng children than what cutreaUy exists wid will ba further imputed nc^uvely Ity thii expansiort